snpupr aiilsg nagpur city level workshop...

1

} } } } } } } } } } } } } } } } } } } } }

}

}

Report No. SNPUPR/AIILSG/Nagpur1

Report on

City Level RAY Workshop Nagpur

15th, 16th May 2012

Raj

iv A

was

Yo

jna

for S

lum

Fre

e C

itie

s

All India Institute of Local Self-Government, Mumbai

Submitted by

Submitted to

Support to National Policies for Urban Poverty Reduction

(Strengthening National Resource Centres)

2

Report on

City Level RAY Workshop at Nagpur

15th, 16th May 2012

Venue: Vanamati, VIP Road, Civil Lines- Dharampeth, Nagpur

Name of the Organizers: All India Institute of Local Self-Government + SNPUPR Team + Nagpur Municipal Corporation, + Slum Rehabilitation Authority,

The objectives of the Programme were:

· To set the premise and explain the guidelines of the Rajiv Awas Yojana. · To provide platform to share the information and to discuss the issues and · To facilitate future plan of action

The workshop for the elected representatives (ERs) was designed to inform about RAY. It also aimed to make the Elected Representatives aware about their role in the implementation of the scheme. The workshop with the NMC officials was designed to discuss the status of implementation of the RAY and evolve plan of action for future.

Participant Profile

The workshop for Elected Representatives brought together elected representatives of the corporation and officials of agencies involved in planning. There were about 119 participants who actively took part in the discussion and presented their views that eminently added to the context set for the workshop. Total 59 men and 64 women participated in the workshop. (List is enclosed as Annexure). A significant feature was high degree of participation from women elected representatives, with 64 women elected representatives participating.

The Workshop for the officials also included participants from Nodal Agency i.e. MHADA, SRA Nagpur. It was tailored to sensitize them of their crucial role vis-à-vis RAY and synergizing efforts of all stakeholders for effective implementation of RAY. This workshop on 16th May with the NMC officials was attended by 63 officials

3

Thematic Details

Capacity Building Workshop for Elected Representatives on 15th May 2012

Inauguration & Introduction

The programme was inaugurated by Mr. Anil Sole, Mayor, Nagpur Municipal Corporation. Mayor Mr. Anil Sole urged the participants in his inaugural address to proactively participate in this intervention.

The morning session began with a brief introduction of RAY and the policies by Dr. (Prof) Sneha Palnitkar, Director, RCUES, Mumbai, welcoming the participants

for the day long workshop.

Followed by deliberation by Mr. Balakrishna, on main objectives of RAY that clearly stated to make India ‘slum free’ in next 5

years, further discussing the initiatives and the support that is being received under SNUPUPR by the Pilot Cities.

Rajiv Awas Yojna – Overview

The urban scenario was portrayed by Dr. Sudha Kashelikar. The topics of slums, the urban growth and sprawl, lack of infrastructure and other environmental issues were highlighted.

4

The comprehensive explanation of Rajiv Awas Yojana was presented. The vision & the approach were discussed in detail. Approach of the RAY was highlighted with the processes of SFCPA. Role of elected representatives as an individual and as a member of corporation was discussed at length.

The subsequent presentation was made by Dr. (Prof.) Sneha Palnitkar on RAY guidelines and its aspects. This was followed by a presentation on slum-dwellers, their expansion and the importance of night shelters. While speaking of the strategic interventions and an inclusive approach to deal with slum settlements, she also emphasized on the need to engage the slum communities voluntarily, to ensure smooth operation and implementation of the

designed programme. Operations of ‘Night Shelters’, systematic survey of the homeless and maintenance and management of shelters were also an integral part of this presentation.

After the basic premise was set, SRA Secretary Mr. Ajay Ramteke gave a comprehensive background on the ground realities highlighting challenges faced in implementation of BSUP. He narrated the journey from in-situ redevelopment

to in-situ up-gradation. He highlighted the salient features of RAY in Nagpur context terming it as an opportunity for the pilot city of Nagpur. He also stated the vital role of the elected representatives and quoted the following -

– “Elected representatives are the link between the govt. & Slum Dwellers.”

Dr. (Prof.) Sneha Palnitkar touched upon the topic of housing for urban poor. The present scenario of slums was put forth and the analysis portrayed a low affordability resulting in supply side constraints. Status of various infrastructural aspects like potable water, sanitation, roads & lack of it were also put forth.

Dr. Mukesh Kanaskar discussed the need of community participation at each and every stage of Rajiv Awas Yojana. He highlighted the high degree of flexibility imparted to cities under RAY. He also, through plenary participatory discussion, generated perspectives about role of various stakeholders. He then synthesized these to bring clarity and emphasize synergy of these roles to enable better housing for the slum dwellers.

The workshop concluded by Mr. Sanjeev Jaiswal, IAS, Commissioner, Nagpur Municipal Corporation. The end note by commissioner- “We are artisans of the future” – concluded .

He highlighted the power of women leaders and urged the participants to prioritize needs and work beyond politithe workshop on an inspirational note.

5

Capacity Building Workshop for Officials on 16th May 2012

On day 2 i.e. on 16th May 2012 the workshop was for the officials of the Nagpur Municipal Corporation. The Workshop had a group of administrators, multi-stakeholders including representatives from NIT, representatives from MHADA, rrepresentatives from SRA, Zonal Commissioners – 10 zones, Non Government Organizations, Project Management Consultants etc. The Workshop was inaugurated by Mr. Pravin Darade, IAS, Chairman, Nagpur Improvement Trust, Nagpur. In his inaugural Speech he expressed his pleasure that the Nagpur city has got the opportunity to bring the urban poor in a formal system. He said that the opportunity must be utilised to its fullest. This needs coordinated efforts.

The first presentation was made by Dr. (Prof.) Sneha Palnitkar Director AIILSG Mumbai on RAY guidelines and its aspects. She spoke on slum-dwellers, their expansion and the importance of night shelters. While speaking of the strategic interventions and an inclusive approach to deal with slum settlements, she also emphasized on the need to engage with the slum communities voluntarily, to ensure smooth operation and implementation of the designed programme. Operations of ‘Night Shelters’, systematic survey of the homeless and maintenance and management of shelters were also covered in this presentation.

Mr. Balakrishna Prasad, Regional Coordinator - West, SNPUPR, narrated the objectives of the City Level Workshops and the SNPUPR context to the workshops. He talked about the main objectives of RAY, he also informed about Support to National Policies for Urban Poverty Reduction (SNPUPR) and its role in capacity building of the selected cities for planning and implementation of RAY. Further he explained the initiatives and the support that is being received by the pilot cities under SNPUPR.

The urban scenario was portrayed by Dr. Sudha Kashelikar and the proliferation of slums, the urban growth & sprawl, lack of infrastructure & other environmental issues were highlighted. The Government efforts in poverty alleviation and provisions under the Rajiv Awas Yojana were further explained in detail. The vision & the approach were discussed in detail. Process for preparation of Slum Free City Plan of Action and role of each stakeholder was explained. After the basic premise was set, Mr. Ajay Ramteke, Secretary Slum Redevelopment Authority gave a comprehensive background on the ground realities highlighting the experiences of BSUP. Mentioning the journey from in-situ redevelopment to in-situ up gradation he referred to the challenge of accommodating around 10 lac slum dweller population in Nagpur. He highlighted the features of RAY, terming it as an opportunity for

6

the pilot city of Nagpur. He also stated the role of the stakeholders and the benefits that they will be reaping from this intervention. A social angle to it was also put forth which brought much clarity in the minds of the stakeholder on what, why and how? He highlighted the features of RAY, terming it as an opportunity for the pilot city of Nagpur. He also stated the role of the stakeholders and the benefits that they will be reaping from this intervention.

Mr. S. D. Balvir, Chief Officer, Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Authority, (MHADA), Nagpur Board mentioned that in implementing earlier JNNURM scheme the board has rendered every help. He committed that in the implementation of RAY too, the Board will play positive role and extend all the necessary cooperation.

Mr. Anand Khobragade, Scientist, MRSAC spoke on application of Geographical Information System (GIS) in planning for RAY for the Nagpur city. His presentation mainly depicted mapping technique using GIS. He explained in detail about how to integrate MIS and GIS and develop web enabled GIS based maps. The visuals gave an excellent idea to the stake holders regarding the process and how it can help in implementation.

Dr. Mukesh Kanaskar discussed the need of community participation at each and every stage of Rajiv Awas Yojana. The Endorsement of Community at each step of planning and implementation was highlighted by him. Moreover, thought for community participation in Management & Maintenance of Tenements should be imbibed right from the earlier stages. He also, through plenary participatory discussion, generated perspectives about role of various stakeholders. He then synthesized these to bring clarity and emphasize synergy of these roles to enable better housing for the slum dwellers, he expressed.

Salient points from the workshop deliberations are:

· Following dignitaries participated in the workshops: o Honorable Mayor Mr. Anil Sole (Inauguration on 15th May) o Honorable Dy Mayor Mr. Sandeep Jadhav o Commissioner Mr. Sanjeev Jaiswal , IAS, Nagpur Municipal Corporation,(concluding

on 15th May, concluding on 16th May) o Mr. Pravin Darade, IAS, Chairman, , Nagpur Improvement Trust, (NIT)( Inauguration

on 16th May) o Mr. S. D. Balvir, Chief Officer, Maharashtra Housing and Area Development

Authority (MHADA), Nagpur Board o Mr. Ajay Ramteke, Secretary, Slum Rehabilitation Authority, (SRA), Nagpur

· Realization of severe lack of knowledge about RAY especially in elected representatives o Strong IEC needed

· Overcoming the misconcept of the community and some stakeholders: houses will be destroyed and slum dwellers will be moved away

· In-situ upgradation model to be predominantly adopted:

7

o Kuchcha and semi-pucca to be taken on priority o Pucca structures may not be touched

· Elected representatives and officials from other places (such as Pimpri Chinchwad Municipal Corporation) where slum rehabilitation has been effectively done to be invited in the next phase of workshops

· Need for change in the mind set strongly put forth · A key issue: more than 65% of existing tenements of the higher size (average 500 to 600 sft)

than those proposed under RAY (was one of the hindrance in BSUP progress too) o High degree of flexibility, in city-specific decision making, in-built in RAY emphasized

· Getting ‘patta’ is the topmost priority for the community · Secretary, SRA- Nagpur presented the status on RAY in the context of the challenges and

learnings generated through the implementation of BSUP and the earlier programs. · 9 NGOs already deputed for socio-economic survey. · Balakrishna Prasad took a dedicated meeting with them to understand the progress and

related aspects. On the subject of the sufficiency of the funds for carrying out the survey work, the NGOs were advised to provide a financial analysis based on the work done till now.

· A key thrust area emerged through the workshop was to build ownership among the zonal officials and other stakeholders in the process.

· Importance of the role of various stakeholders was highlighted. · Future Directions:

o Taking RAY process further for discussion & decision making in NMC o Awareness generation campaign with the communities whose DPR is ready o Wide scale IEC in Nagpur to convey correct message about RAY & address the

concerns among the stakeholders o Next workshop to include sessions by elected representatives and officials from case

studies of effective implementation of slum development programmes.

· The point of non-notified slums was emphasized with a view that the present number of non-notified slums needs to be revisited during field assessment.

· Greater awareness needs to be created in the wider stakeholders, very importantly the elected representatives and the community. This will need intense efforts on the IEC front.

Critical Insights Gained:

} Brief mention of critical insights, which can include the following :

◦ Lessons Learnt } Persistent efforts for ensuring participation of the elected

representatives in the workshop yield results. Moreover, keeping explicit emphasis along with the above on inviting participation by women elected representatives enable their high degree of participation.

8

} Involvement of elected representatives needs to be encouraged and hence follow up meeting need to be accordingly planned.

} Process should not halt at the end of the workshop. Subsequently meetings of stake holders should be organized for preparation of action plan, development of its implementation strategy and implementation

◦ Key Achievements:

} The workshops objectives were successfully met.

} The importance and need of holistic approach and community participation appears to have well taken by the participants

} Need for developing future perspective for preventing mushrooming slums was inculcated.

} High degree of participation of women elected representatives.

◦ Follow-up plans:

} Apart from the frequent follow-ups telephonically and through emails, it was decided that need-specific visits will be made by the SNPUPR & NRC Team Members as per requirement of the NMC.

Annexures enclosed:

◦ Design of the event ◦ List of Participants ◦ List of Learning Materials ◦ Evaluation Report: Analysis of the Evaluation format filled by the participants ◦ Handout of Power point presentations

9

ANNEXURE I City Level Workshop on Rajiv Awas Yojana

Municipal Corporation, Nagpur 15th-16th March, 2012

Venue: Vanamati, VIP Road, Civil Lines- Dharampeth, Nagpur

Session Topic Speakers/ Moderators

Elected Representatives, Municipal Corporation, Nagpur

15th May, 2012

14.00-14.15 Registration

14.15-14.30 Welcome Dr. (Prof.) Sneha Palnitkar

Director, RCUES, AIILSG, Mumbai

14.30-14.50 Introduction to the workshop Mr. Balakrishna Prasad,

Regional Programme Coordinator- West, SNPUPR

14.50-15.05 Opening Remarks Mr. Sanjay Jaiswal, IAS

Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Nagpur

15.05-15.20 Inaugural Speech Mr. Anil Sole

Hon’ble Mayor, Municipal Corporation, Nagpur

15.20- 15.50 Over-view of Rajiv Awas

Yojana

Dr. Sudha Kashelikar

Sr. Research Officer, RCUES, AIILSG, Mumbai

15.50-16.20 RAY in Nagpur Mr. Ajay Ramteke

Secretary, SRA (Nodal Agency) &

Nodal Officer, RAY, Nagpur

16.20-16.40 Community Participation &

Inclusive Development- Role

of Key Stakeholders

Dr. Mukesh Kanaskar,

Additional Director, RCUES, AIILSG

16.40- 17.00 Discussion & Concluding

Dr. (Prof.) Sneha Palnitkar


10

City Level Workshop on Rajiv Awas Yojana Municipal Corporation, Nagpur

15th-16th March, 2012 Venue: Vanamati, VIP Road, Civil Lines- Dharampeth, Nagpur

Time Subject Speaker/ Moderator Officials, Municipal Corporation, Nagpur: 16th May, 2012

10.00-10.30 Registration 10.30 – 10.45 Welcome Mr. Pravin Darade, IAS

Chairman, Nagpur Improvement Trust, Nagpur

10.45 – 11.00 Opening Remarks Dr. (Prof.) Sneha Palnitkar


11.00-11.30 About SNPUPR, Introduction to the Workshop

Mr. Balakrishna Prasad, Regional Coordinator, SNPUPR

11.30- 12.00 RAY Overview, Slum Free City Planning and guidelines

Dr. Sudha Kashelikar

Sr. Research Officer, RCUES, AIILSG, Mumbai

12.00 – 12.15 Tea Break 12.15-1.15 Nagpur City and its Slum

Profile Mr. Ajay Ramteke

Secretary, SRA (Nodal Agency) & Nodal Officer, RAY, Nagpur

& Team Status of RAY in Nagpur + Slum Free City Plan + DPR

1.15 – 1.30 S.D. Balvir, Chief Officer, Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Authority, (MHADA), Nagpur Board.

1.30- 2.30 Lunch 2.30- 3.30 GIS Mr. Anand Khobragade

Scientist, MRSAC

3.30- 4.00 Community Participation &

Inclusive Development- Role of

Key Stakeholders

Dr. Mukesh Kanaskar,

Additional Director, RCUES, AIILSG

4.00-4.15 Tea Break 4.15- 4.45 Issues & Challenges: Plenary

discussion Mr. Ajay Ramteke

Secretary, SRA (Nodal Agency) & Nodal Officer, RAY, Nagpur

& Team RAY Nagpur Plan of Action

4.45 – 5.00 Concluding Remarks Mr. Sanjay Jaiswal, IAS

Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Nagpur

11

ANNEXURE II

ALL INDIA INSTITUTE OF LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT, MUMBAI

City Level Workshop on Rajiv Awas Yojana

(Elected Representatives, Municipal Corporation, Nagpur)

Under support from Support to National Policies for Urban Poverty Reduction [SNPUPR]

Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation, Government of India Nagpur Municipal Corporation,

Slum Redevelopment Authority, Nagpur List of Participants for Workshop on 15th May, 2012 at Nagpur (Maharashtra)

Representatives of Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation, Government of India

Sr. No.

Name & Designation Mobile No. / E-mail ID

1 Mr. M. Balakrishna Prasad Programme Coordinator

9908662327

Representatives of All India Institute of local Self Government, Mumbai

Sr. No.


1 Dr. (Prof) Sneha Palnitkar Director, AIILSG, Mumbai.

9820105098

2 Dr. Mukesh Kanaskar Additional Director, AIILSG

9823013440

3 Dr. Sudha Kashelikar Sr. Research Officer, RCUES of AIILSG, Mumbai.

9594865673

List of Participants (Elected Members)

Sr. No.

Name & Designation Municipal Body

Mobile No. / E-mail ID

1 Mr. Anilji Sole, Hon’ble Mayor

Nagpur

2 Mr. Sandeep Jadhav, Hon’ble Dy. Mayor

Nagpur

3 Mr. Dayashankar Tiwari, Chairman, Standing Committee

Nagpur

4 Mr. Praveen Datake, Leading Party Leader

Nagpur

5 Mr. Vikas Thakre, Opposition Party Leader

Nagpur

6 Mr. Prasanna Sadashiv Borkar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

7 Mr. Kishor C. Gajbhiye, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

12

8 Mr. Satish Hole, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

9 Mr. Purushottam Hajare, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

10 Mr. Rajesh Ghodpage, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

11 Mr. Sudhakar V. Kohale, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

12 Mr. Ajay Dange, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

13 Mr. Gopal Bolu, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

14 Mr. Raju Lokhande, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

15 Mr. Jagatram Sinha, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

16 Mr. Prafulla Gudhade, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

17 Mr. Parinay Fuke, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

18 Mr. M. K. Ansari, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

19 Mr. Devendar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

20 Mr. Sanjay Mahakalkar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

21 Mr. Khan Aslam Khan Rashid Khan, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

22 Mr. Ramesh Punekar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

23 Adv. Sanjay Kumar Balpande, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

24 Mr. Duneshawar Pethe, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

25 Mr. Raju Wasudeorao Thorat, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

26 Mr. Amanulla Khan, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

27 Mr. Prashant Chopra, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

28 Mr. Sandeep Joshi, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

29 Mr. Ishrat Kawsae, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9325872170

30 Mr. Sagar Damodhar Lokhande, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9637330186

31 Mr. Raju Bhaurao Nagulwar Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9422147409

32 Mr. Rahul Telang, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9923751713

13

33 Mr. Suresh D. Talwekar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9923493575

34 Mr. Gautam S. Patil, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9881575966

35 Mr. Wasudeo Natthuji Dhoke, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9823887710 / 9923800299

36 Mr. Harish S. Dikondwar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9823659343

37 Mr. Jagdish Shivdas Galbansi, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9823187909

38 Mr. Sagar R. Uiney, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9637298193

39 Mr. Purushottam S. Lonare, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9373576793

40 Mr. Murli K. Meshram, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9372305239

41 Mr. Mahendra Jairam Borkar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9371636090

42 Mr. Suresh Jagyasi, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9822702035

43 Mr. Shrawan T. Khapekar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9028518402

44 Mr. Kalpak S. Bhanarkar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 8624946727

45 Mr. Murlidhar K. Meshram, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9372305239

46 Mr. Abhishek B. Shambharkar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9881142177 [email protected]

47 Mr. Ramdas P. Gudadhe, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9371344447

48 Mr. Pradeep V. Pohane, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9823098938

49 Mr. Ravindra Dolas, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9923598201

50 Mr. Munna Yadav, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9823100148

51 Mr. Bhushan K. Shingne, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9822160539

52 Mr. Avinash Nilkanth Thakre, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9049009123

53 Mr. Vinod Nanaji Kove, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9272601342

54 Mr. Gopichand Krushnarao Kumre, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 8087101171

55 Dr. Ravindra P. Bhoyar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9423076034

56 Mr. Ramesh M. Singare, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9881164150

57 Mr. Pravin Gulabrao Narad, Nagpur 9923757388

14

Municipal Elected Member 58 Ms. Sheetal Gharat,

Municipal Elected Member Nagpur

59 Mrs. Rajashree S. Pannase, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

60 Mrs. Usha Gajanan Nishitkar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

61 Ms. Padma Vikey, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

62 Mrs. Sumitra Jadhav, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

63 Ms. Ashwini Jijkar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

64 Ms. Seema Sunil Raut, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

65 Ms. Priya Vikas Khobragade, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

66 Mrs. Neeta Thakre, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

69 Ms. Pragati Patil, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

68 Ms. Chetna Raju Panle, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

69 Ms. Anita Pradeep Wankhede, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

70 Ms. Sarita Ishwar Kaware, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

71 Ms. Pallavi A. Shamkule, Municipal Elected Member


72 Ms. Varsha Jayant Thakre, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9422808326

73 Ms. Sangita Deepak Githe, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9272801889

74 Ms. Manisha D. Ghodeshwar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9890768616

75 Mrs. Sheela Dinesh Tarale, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9970800101

76 Ms. Nimisha D. Shirke, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 8600456456

77 Ms. Satyabhama Ramesh Lokhande, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9689786777

78 Mrs. Bhavana Prashant Dhakne, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9823022688

79 Mrs. Kumudini S. Kaikade, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9921194898

80 Mrs. Vidya P. Lonare, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9373576793

81 Mrs. Bhavna Santosh Lonare, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9175346985

15

82 Mrs. Sumitra Santosh Lonare, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9689299437

83 Mrs. Sarika Sunil Nandurkar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9371648982

84 Ms. Vandana Vinod Ingole, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9822363012

85 Ms. Lalita Girish Patil, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9420248056

86 Mrs. Manisha Sunil Kodhe, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9422444364

87 Mrs. Meena Govind Tidake, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9371952623

88 Ms. Shabana Jamal, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9371186159

89 Ms. A. Nisa, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9325676840

90 Mrs. Jayshree Mohanrao Wadibhasme, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9657661228

91 Ms. Sarita Sanjay Tiwari, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9823384444

92 Dr. Uma Trimbak Gathibandhe, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9373286678

93 Mrs. Lata Vinod Yadav, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9373984330

94 Mrs. Sangita Gopal Kalamkar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9637766330

95 Mrs. Usha Gajanan Nishitkar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9423936915

96 Ms. Kanta R. Rarokar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9011962530

97 Ms. Saraswati V. Salave, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9422109566

98 Ms. Sheela Sanjay Mohod, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9371092848

99 Mrs. Maya Ivanate, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9923596001

100 Mrs. Sadhana N. Barde, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9765390732

101 Ms. Sushma Sanjay Chaudhari, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9921213274

102 Mrs. Sulochana Vinod Kove, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9272601342

103 Ms. Sidhu Ramaji Uyanke, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9923600651

104 Mrs. Vishakha Maind Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9823199843

105 Ms. Kiran Premkumar Rodage (Patankar) Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9325797928

106 Dr. Safalta Ambatkar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9421777136 safaltaambatkar@g

16

mail.com 107 Mrs. Divya Deepak Dhurde,

Municipal Elected Member Nagpur 9373259393

108 Mrs. Prabha R. Zagnade, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9096073768

109 Ms. Saroj Raju Bahadure, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9860827849

110 Mrs. Malu Vatave, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur

111 Adv. Rekha V. Barhate, Municipal Elected Member


112 Ms. Yashashree Deoram Nandanwar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9422332769

113 Mrs. Nayna Sanjay Zade, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9370463863

114 Ms. Harshala M. Sawle, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9881292002

115 Ms. Pushpa N. Nimje, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9372308656

116 Mrs. Swati Chandrakant Aakhatkar, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9372840189

117 Ms. Mangla Prashantrao Gawre, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9326545321

118 Mrs. Rita Ashok Mule, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9673776690 9823184590

119 Mrs. Sujata Vitthalrao Kombade, Municipal Elected Member

Nagpur 9823094308

17

ANNEXURE III

ALL INDIA INSTITUTE OF LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT, MUMBAI

City Level Workshop on Rajiv Awas Yojana (Officials, Municipal Corporation, Nagpur)

Under support from

Support to National Policies for Urban Poverty Reduction [SNPUPR] Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation, Government of India

Nagpur Municipal Corporation, Slum Redevelopment Authority, Nagpur

16th May, 2012 at Nagpur (Maharashtra)

Representatives of Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation, Government of India

Sr.No.


1. Mr. M. Balakrishna Prasad, Programme Coordinator 9908662327

Representatives of All India Institute of Local Self Government, Mumbai

Sr.No.


1. Dr. (Prof.) Sneha Palnitkar, Director, A.I.I.L.S.G., Mumbai 9820105098 2. Dr. Mukesh Kanaskar, Additional Director, A.I.I.L.S.G. 9823013440 3. Dr. Sudha Kashelikar, Sr. Research Officer, RCUES of A.I.I.L.S.G., Mumbai 9594865673

List of Participants from MHADA

Sr.No.


1. Mr. Anil Ankalfi, Executive Engineer 9422103926 [email protected]

2. S. D. Balveer, Chief Officer 9158883615 3 D. K. Ajwani, Asst. Engineer 7588746484

[email protected]

List of Participants from NHRRDA, Nagpur

18

Sr.No.


1 Ms. Lalita Gaikwad 9326204504 2 Ms. Jyoti N. Shegoker, Laxmi Nagar 9011940072 3 Mrs. Neeta C. Gotmare, Hanuman Nagar 9881333365 4 Ms. Arati G. Jumede, Dharampeth, Zone No.7 9673549195 5 Ms. Mamta Mishra, C.O., Kishor Chiddam Architect &

Planner Nagpur 9975046615 [email protected]

6 Ms. Shubhangi Padole, Centre for Sustainable Development

9403342539 [email protected]

7 Mr. Anmol Tembhurne, NHRRDA, Nagpur 9422103926 [email protected]

8 Mr. Mahendra S. Lonare, NHRRDA, Nagpur 7385699181 [email protected]

List of Participants from SRA

Sr.No.


1 Ms. Bobby R. Meshram 9975058071 [email protected]

2 R. G. Rahate, Dy. Engineer, SRA, 9823095903 [email protected]

3 K. T. Pelts, SRA 9923858530 4 Bhaywandin Patel, SRA 5 R. K. Khatke, Exeuctive Engineer, SRA 9923110148

[email protected] 6 Mr. Anil R. Pandhare 9767445344

List of Participants from NIT

Sr.No.


1 Ms. Suneeta P. Aloni, Asstt. Director, Town Planning 9823323670 2 Ms. Sujata Kadu, Dy. Director, Town Planning 9422104409

[email protected] 3 A. K. Gour,E.E. 9923596201 4 Mr. Ravindra Jaubandhu, Executive Engineer 9923596209

[email protected]

List of Participants from DIT

Sr.No.


1 S. P. Paseband, E.E. (HQ) 9823326953

19

List of Participants from Other Organisations

Sr.No.


1 Mr. Ravi R. Singh, Monarch Surveyors & Engineering Consultants Pvt. Ltd.

9373217630 [email protected] [email protected]

2 Mr. Gunvant Wanghade, Indian Institute of Youth Welfare, Shivajinagar, Nagpur


3 Mr. Gautam Patil, M. M. Project Consultants Pvt. Ltd. 9503774168 [email protected]

4 Mr. Satish, V. K. Associates 9766310249 5 Mr. Kewal Bausal, PMC M/s. V. KA 9765552378

[email protected]

List of Participants from Nagpur Municipal Corporation Sr.No.


1 Ms. Bhavana Yadav, Social Welfare Dept. 9325871488 [email protected]

2 Ms. Chandrakanta U. Gaidhane, C. O., Neharu Nagar, Zone 05, Social Welfare Dept.,

9552288986

3 Ms. Jyotsna J. Deshmukh, C. O., Hanuman Nagar, Zone 03, Social Welfare Dept.,

9370940283

4 Ms. Sarika S. Urey, C. O., Mangalwari, Zone 10, Social Welfare Dept.,

9890209819

5 G. M. Rathod, Asstt. Municipal Commissioner 9823128275 6 Mr. S. M. Juideo, Asstt. Municipal Commissioner 9823128268 7 Mr. Prashant S. Waghmare, Jr. Engineer, Mangalwari, Zone

No.10 9890239494

8 M. L. Mroney, Dharanpur 9823330931 9 C. S. Zade, Town Planner, Laxmi Nagar 9823148256

10 V. M. Kolte, C.E.A. Town Planner, Dharampeth 9923388355 11 P. D. Bambode, Zonal Officer 9823350145 12 D. M. Kalode, Zonal Officer 9823245673 13 R. G. Bhujade, Sanitary Inspector 9823313130 14 S. K. Gore, Zonal Officer 9823245671 15 Mr. Vijay Humane, Asstt. Municipal Commissioner 9673009102

[email protected] 16 Mr. Ashok Patil, Asstt. Municipal Commissioner 9823159373

[email protected] 17 Mr. Pankaj Sarju Mendhe, Social Welfare Dept. 9049898682

[email protected] 18 Mr. Shashi Haridas Fulzele, Social Welfare Dept., 9049670381 19 Mr. Mahesh Gupta, OSD to Municipal Commissioner, SSDE

Town Planning 9823167153 [email protected]

20

20 Mr. Shekhar P. Kolte, Dharampeth, Zone No.2 9823940914 [email protected]

21 Mr. Dilip Patil 9823022718 [email protected]

22 M. R. Gupta, OSD to Municipal Commissioner, SOE Town Planning Dept.


23 M. R. Gupta, OSD to Municipal Commissioner, SOE Town Planning Dept.


24 Y. S. Pingle, J. C., District Project Office, Collectorate Office, 7304245595 25 Mr. Mahesh Dhamecha, Asstt. Municipal Commissioner 9823330937

[email protected] 26 U. V. Dhanvijay, J.E., Aari Nagar, Zone No.9 9923196002

[email protected] 27 K. S. Chavan, J. E., Zone-II 9823010329

[email protected] 28 Mr. Vijay D. Gurbaxoni 9823090126

[email protected] 29 Mr. Sarang A. Pimpalkar 9923423441

[email protected]

30 Mr. Ramchandra R. Hatwar 9850357074 31 Mr. Raju Bhivgade, Asstt. Municipal Commissioner 9823059357

[email protected] 32 Mr. Suresh Chaudhari, Shri Ganesh Gramin Vikas Sanstha,


33 Mr. Vijay P. Nandagawli, Research Officer, BSUP-PIU 9766824993 [email protected]

21

ANNEXURE IV List of Learning Materials:

· Rajiv Awas Yojana Guidelines · Guidelines for GIS Mapping, MIS development and Integration of GIS with

MIS · National Housing and Habitat Policy · Maharashtra State Housing Policy · Draft Property Rights to Slum Dwellers Act, 2011 · Note on strategy to prevent New Slums · Guidelines on Community Participation, 2011 · Formats and Guidelines for Survey and Preparation of Slum, Household and

Livelihood Profiles of Cities/Towns · Training Manual/Instructions for Field Staff for Survey and Preparation of

Slum, Household and Livelihood Profiles of Cities/Towns

22

ANNEXURE V

All India Institute of Local Self Government, Mumbai City Level Workshop

On Rajiv Awas Yojana

(Elected Representatives, Municipal Corporation, Nagpur) 15th May, 2012.

No. Session Score 1 2 3 4 5 1 Overview of Rajiv Awas Yojana 5 8 7 16 15 2 RAY in Nagpur 4 6 21 15 5 3 Community Participation and inclusive

Development – Role of Key Stakeholders. 5 8 18 14 6

5

8

7

16

15

Overview of Rajiv Awas Yojana

1

2

3

4

5

Rank4

6

21

15

5

RAY in Nagpur

1

2

3

4

5

Rank

5

8

18

14

6

Community Participation and inclusive Development

Role of Key Stakeholders

5 48 67

2116 1515

5

05

101520253035404550

Overview of Rajiv Awas

Yojana

RAY in Nagpur

Sessions

Scor

e

23

Community Participation and inclusive Development

Role of Key Stakeholders

1

2

3

4

5

Rank

14 (10%)

22 (14%)

46 (30%)

45 (29%)

26 (17%)

Number and % of respondents for Overall Programme

5

148

2218

46

14

45

6

26

RAY in Nagpur Community Participation and inclusive

Development –Role of Key

Stakeholders.

Number and % of respondents

for Overall Programme

Rank 1

Rank 2

Rank 3

Rank 4

Rank 5

Number and % of respondents

1

2

3

4

5

Rank

24

All India Institute of Local Self Government, Mumbai City Level Workshop

On Rajiv Awas Yojana

(Elected Representatives, Municipal Corporation, Nagpur) 16th May, 2012.

No. Session Score 1 2 3 4 5 1 RAY Overview, Slum Free City Planning and

Guidelines 0 1 11 9 7

2 Nagpur City and its Slum Profile. Status of RAY in Nagpur + Slum Free City Plan + DPR

0 1 4 14 7

3 GIS 4 3 7 9 4 4 Community Participation and inclusive

Development – Role of Key Stakeholders. 1 1 6 13 4

5 Issues & Challenges: Plenary Discussions. RAY Nagpur Plan of Action.

1 3 1 13 6

25

1

11

9

7

RAY Overview, Slum Free City Planning and Guidelines

1

2

3

4

5

Rank

14

14

7

Status of RAY in Nagpur, SFCP & DPR

1

2

3

4

5

Rank

4

3

79

4

GIS

12345

Rank

1 1

6

13

4

Community Participation and Inclusive Development – Role of Key

Stakeholders

1

2

3

4

5

Rank

13

1

13

6

Issues & Challenges: RAY Nagpur Plan of Action

Rank

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

Sessio

Scor

e

26

1

2

3

4

5

Rank6

9

29

58

28

Number and % of respondents for Overall Programme

1

2

3

4

5

Rank

Sessions

Rank 1

Rank 2

Rank 3

Rank 4

Rank 5

snpupr aiilsg nagpur city level workshop...

Documents