skills of a globally dexterous leader presentationb - aimwa version - dclrevs311013
TRANSCRIPT
Skills of a globally dexterous leader
David Landers General Manager, East Asian Growth Markets
AIMWA, Perth
31st
October 2013
Australia Unlimited
Topics
•
Austrade’s value•
The globally dexterous leader
•
Comparing different societies to Australia•
Leading in different cultural settings
•
Business ethics and culture
Australia Unlimited
Who we are
•80 offices in 48 countries, with 44 of those offices in 15 markets in Asia.
•An ‘inverted pyramid’
–
more than 60 per cent of our 1,000 people are offshore, and 60 per cent of those are in Asia.
•More than 400 of our staff have one or more Asian languages.
•Of the people we send overseas, and our executive officers, two-thirds have experience working in the private sector
•Work at the ‘market & firm-specific’
level, not the lead on trade policy & negotiation
Australia Unlimited
Where we are
Australia Unlimited
What we doOur
role is to advance Australia’s international trade, investment
and education interests. Specifically, we:
•Assist Australian companies to grow business in international markets, including through administration of the Export Market Development Grants scheme and the TradeStart program.
•Provide coordinated government assistance to attract productive foreign direct investment (FDI) into Australia.
•Promote the Australian education sector
in international markets and assist Australian education providers with market information and services.
•Provide advice to the Australian Government on its trade and investment policy agenda.
•Deliver Australian consular, passport and other government services in 16 designated overseas locations.
•Manage the building Brand Australia program to enhance awareness of contemporary Australian skills and capability, and to enrich Australia’s global reputation.
Australia Unlimited
Our great strength --
sustained on-the-ground presence in offshore markets
•
We identify opportunities in market
•
We can interpret the business climate and local commercial practice, and provide language support as well
•
We can brief you in-depth on the market and the companies involved
•
We can refer you to potential customers in market
•
We can develop a visit/contact program for you
•
We can set up, and direct you to your appointments•
We can provide ongoing
in market assistance to assist in
establishing your business presence.
The globally dexterous leader
Australia Unlimited
“You have to know how to motivate people who speak different languages, who have different cultural contexts, who have different sensitivities and habits. You have to get prepared to deal with teams who are multicultural, to work with people who do not all think the same way you do.”
-
Carlos Ghosn
Why?
Australia Unlimited
The globally dexterous leader –
Carlos Ghosn
Image sources: Mercopress, Wikipedia, ahchen.wordpress.com
Australia Unlimited
Competencies of a culturally dexterous leader according to Ghosn
•
Thirst for learning
•
Sense of humbleness (arrogance is the antithesis of cultural dexterity)
•
‘Common’
sense (building a shared basis for understanding as in ‘common ground)
Australia Unlimited
So what is culture?
A definition of culture:
“The learned beliefs, values, rules, norms, symbols, and traditions that are common to a group of people.”
Australia Unlimited
How Germans and Chinese perceive each other
Source: Yang Liu (2007), Oft trifft West (East meets West)
Australia Unlimited
Ideal of beauty
Source: Yang Liu (2007), Oft trifft West (East meets West)
Australia Unlimited
“The Boss”
Source: Yang Liu (2007), Oft trifft West (East meets West)
Australia Unlimited
Problem solving approach
Source: Yang Liu (2007), Oft trifft West (East meets West)
Australia Unlimited
Australia Unlimited
Connections and contacts
Source: Yang Liu (2007), Oft trifft West (East meets West)
Australia Unlimited
Complexity of self expression
Source: Yang Liu (2007), Oft trifft West (East meets West)
Australia Unlimited
At a party
Source: Yang Liu (2007), Oft trifft West (East meets West)
Comparing different societies to Australia
Australia Unlimited
How to measure culture?•
Work started by Hofstede’s global study of IBM in the 70’s
•
Continued and modernised by the GLOBE study–
17,300 middle managers interviewed
–
951 organizations worldwide–
62 cultures
–
Focused on leadership, not just culture
•
Why is it useful?–
Objective
comparisons
–
Adapt strategy
Australia Unlimited
GLOBE’s cultural measures of society
Performance orientationUncertainty avoidance
Humane orientation Institutional collectivism
In-Group collectivismAssertiveness
Gender egalitarianismFuture orientation
Power distance
Australia Unlimited
Society: Power distance
The degree to which members of a collective expect power to be distributed equally.
Normative statement: Followers are (should be) expected to obey their leaders without question.
TOP THREE: BOTTOM THREE: MoroccoNigeriaEl Salvador
NetherlandsDenmarkCzech Republic
Australia Unlimited
Society: Institutional
collectivism
The degree to which organizational and societal institutional practices encourage and reward collective distribution of resources and collective action
Normative statement: Leaders encourage (should encourage) group loyalty even if individual goals suffer.
TOP THREE: BOTTOM THREE:
SwedenSouth KoreaJapan
HungaryGreeceCzech Republic
Australia Unlimited
Society: Assertiveness
The degree to which individuals are assertive, dominant & demanding in their relationships with others.
Normative statement: People are (should be) generally dominant.
TOP THREE: BOTTOM THREE:
AlbaniaNigeriaHungary
SwedenNew ZealandSwitzerland
Australia Unlimited
Society: Future orientation
The extent to which a collective encourages future-
oriented behaviors such as delaying gratification, planning & investing in the future.
Normative statement: More people live (should live) for the present than for the future.
TOP THREE: BOTTOM THREE:
SingaporeSwitzerlandNetherlands
PolandArgentinaRussia
Australia Unlimited
Example: What is remarkable about this picture?
This picture generated 40,000 reposts and thousands of comments on Sina Weibo. Why?
"This is something unbelievable in China," said Tang, a Chinese-American citizen. "Even for low-ranking officials,
we don't do things for ourselves. Someone goes to buy the coffee for
them. Someone carries their bags for them.“
Q: What does this say about the differences between US and Chinese culture?
American Ambassador to China Gary Locke, ordering coffee in Seattle Airport.
Source: ChinaSmack.com
Leading in different cultural settings
Australia Unlimited
“The Jack Welch of the future cannot be like me. I spent my entire career in the United States. The next head of General Electric will be somebody who spent time in Bombay, in Hong Kong, in Buenos Aires.”
-
Jack Welch
Australia Unlimited
Question?
How would you describe a good Australian leader?
Australia Unlimited
Do different cultures really prefer different leaders?Able to anticipate Administratively skilledAmbitious AsocialAutonomousCautious Class conscious CommunicativeCompassionate Confidence builderCoordinatorCunningDecisiveDependableDictatorialDomineeringDynamic
Effective bargainerEgocentricElitist EncouragingEnthusiasticEvasive Excellence orientedForesightFormal HabitualHonestIndependent Indirect IndividualisticInformedIntelligentIntra-group competitor
Intra-group conflict avoider Intuitive IrritableJustLogical LonerMicro-managerMotivationalMotive arouserNoncooperativeNonexplicitOrderly Plans aheadPositiveProcedural Provocateur Risk taker
RulerRuthlessSelf-effacing Self-sacrificial Sensitive SincereStatus-consciousSubdued TrustworthyTeam builderUniqueWillful Win-win problem solverWorldly
Australia Unlimited
Example: Leadership styles and cultural differences
Second lowest world rank for modesty
among leaders
Third highest rank for institutional collectivism in
society
Image sources: CNN/Getty.
Australia Unlimited
The globally dexterous leader –
Carlos Ghosn
Image sources: Mercopress, Wikipedia, ahchen.wordpress.com
Australia Unlimited
What the study says about Australian leaders
Australia Unlimited
Australia vs QatarMost important leadership attributes to QatarisHuman orientation
Inspirational
Team integrator
Least important leadership attributes to QatarisAutocratic
Self centred
Malevolent
Australia Qatar
Australia Unlimited
Australia vs IndiaMost important leadership attributes to IndiansVisionary
Team integrator
Administratively competentLeast important leadership attributes to IndiansAutocratic
Self centred
Malevolent
Australia India
Australia Unlimited
Australia vs IndonesiaMost important leadership attributes to IndonesiansPerformance oriented
Team integrator
Inspirational
Least important attributes leadership to IndonesiansAutocratic
Self centred
Malevolent
Australia Indonesia
Australia Unlimited
Australia vs ChinaMost important leadership attributes to ChineseTeam integrator
Inspirational
Administratively competentLeast important leadership attributes to ChineseAutocratic
Self centred
Malevolent
Australia China
Australia Unlimited
Another take on Australia vs China
Source: ClarkMorgan Ltd (www.clarkmorgan.com)
Australia Unlimited
Which cultures are similar?
Source: Project GLOBE.
Australia Unlimited
Be aware of culturally specific sensitivities
Thailand Royal Family; touching the head, tempers…..
China Loss of face, direct criticism….
Indonesia Tempers, gender practices, the color red
Middle-East Invitations, contact with left hand, expose bottom of foot
India Avoid pointing…
Japan Impatience, loss of face….
South Korea Deference to superiors, personal image…
Business ethics and culture
Australia Unlimited
Business ethics issues
Issue Cultural explanation
Nepotism Collectivism = obligations to close relations
Graft High power distance = less accountability
Bribery Low future orientation = motivation linked to immediate rewards
Australia Unlimited
Global corruption risks
Source: Transparency International
Australia Unlimited
For organisations and individuals
•Fines for organisation•Fines and prison for employees
and officers
•Incurring substantial legal and professional fees•Reputational damage
For countries and communities
•Lack of money for communities and on-going poverty•Destruction of industry•Reduced Foreign Direct Investment•Loss of faith in public officials and institutions•Civil unrest and political instability
Bribery and its consequences
Australia Unlimited
Elements of Bribery under Australian law Under Section 70 of the Criminal Code 1995Amendment (Bribery of Foreign Public Officials) Act 1999
Bribery involves:
• Providing, offering or arranging a benefit
• The benefit is not legitimately due
•With an intention to influence a Foreign Public Official (FPO) in their official duties
• With the motive to gain or retain business or a business advantage
Australia Unlimited
Application of Australian law
It is also an offence to:
• Attempt to offer a bribe
• Help any person to offer a bribe
• Get another person to offer a bribe
• Encourage/urge another person to offer a bribe
• Conspire/secretly plan with another person to offer a bribe
Australia Unlimited
Other forms of bribery –
are they ok?•
Gifts
•
Hospitality•
Lavish entertainment
•
Travel•
Supporting a favoured cause
•
Employment •
Donation to a political party
•
Education for family members
Conclusion
Australia Unlimited
My guidance…•
Remember above all else that good leadership is almost universal
•
Myth vs. reality --
be intellectually vigilant & robust in your judgement of cross-cultural situations
•
Remember Ghosn’s competencies:–
Curious
–
humble–
‘common’
sense
•
Be authentic–
get comfortable with being uncomfortable
–
avoid unforced errors•
Proactively seek out international projects and assignments
•
Join the Asialink
programme•
Hire an international business student intern
•
Talk with Austrade in market
Australia Unlimited
“But the key point is to get people out of their comfort zone, learn new languages, travel to different countries, go to places where you don’t understand the culture, and expose yourself to situations where you have to deal with uncertainty. All of this helps put yourself in the shoes of people who are different from you.”
-
Carlos Ghosn
Australia Unlimited
Recommended reading and websites
•
GLOBE study homepage: http://business.nmsu.edu/programs-centers/globe
•
Book: Yang Liu (2007), Oft trifft West (East meets West) •
Book: Trompenaars and Hampden-Turner (1998), Riding the Waves of International Culture, Second Edition
•
Book: Thomas Sowell (1997), Migrations and Culture: A World View
•
Blogs: Russiaslam; Indoboom, Chinasmack, Koreabang, Japancrush offer English translations of local scandals and user comments
•
ASIALINK Leaders Program and events: http://asialink.unimelb.edu.au
•
Trainers: Beasley Intercultural, Clark Morgan
Questions
With credit to:
Brent MooreExecutive Officer –
East Asian Growth Markets