selecting a research proposal topic, spring 2012

13

Upload: utepgrad

Post on 22-Apr-2015

25.620 views

Category:

Technology


3 download

DESCRIPTION

Presentation given by Dr. Martha Ovando February 8, 2012 at the University of Texas at El Paso.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012
Page 2: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012

ü  Conducting research is a complex, demanding and challenging process.

ü  One can be familiar with different paradigms of inquiry but not know how to actually undertake the task of planning and effectively proposing an investigation (Locke, Spirduso & Silverman, 1987).

ü  Given the challenge, complexity and rigor of conducting research, selecting a dissertation research topic becomes one of the most critical steps in the process of conducting research (Ovando, 2010).

ü  Aspiring scholars can be successful by initially completing certain activities to identify a research topic (Ovando, 2010).

Page 3: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012

•  Read extensively focusing on the general area of your research study.

•  Select those pieces, “articles or chapters,” that relate to your research topic.

•  Pay close attention to suggestions/implications for further research.

•  Identify potential questions/problems related to your topic.

Page 4: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012

•  Complete selective (close-up) reading:

þ  Complete additional reading with a focus on the specific research gaps.

þ  Locate a void in the area of your research topic. What gaps exist in previous research?

þ  Develop a graphic organizer that includes the above, if possible.

þ  Methodology (research design, sampling, respondents, limitations, delimitations).

þ  Purpose & questions.

þ  Review of the literature/theoretical background.

Page 5: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012

Characterization of Your Topic Keep in mind that your research idea might…

Ø  Be only one piece of a larger puzzle.

Ø  Address a specific gap in the area of your interest.

Ø  Raise additional questions and/or highlight new problems.

Ø  Contribute to knowledge/practice/development.

Ø  Enhance/expand/contradict/confirm/advance a new perspective.

Ø  Have a historical development/historical background.

Ø  Not necessarily be new.

Page 6: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012

Research as a Puzzle

Page 7: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012

Pulling the puzzle together

(Ovando, M.N., 2002)

Page 8: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012

Finding a Valid Research Problem 1)  Review existing literature to determine “what is already

known” and “what is not known.”

2)  See if your research will:

ü  Challenge research findings that fly in the face of what you know or believe to be true.

ü  Explore unexpected or contradictory findings in previous research.

ü  Apply an existing perspective or explanation to a new situation.

(Neuman, 1994)

ü  Observe how various subpopulations might behave differently in the same situation.

ü  Replicate a study in a different setting or with a different population.

ü  Address suggestions for further inquiry.

Page 9: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012

3)  Attend professional conferences to learn what is hot and what is not in a specific field, and talk to researchers who are working in your area of interest.

The statement of a problem should lead to the purpose of your study and specific research questions.

4)  Scan conference programs to see what others are investigating and what additional questions may be asked.

5)  Ask questions like:

(Leedy & Ormrod, 2001)

ü  What previous research findings don’t make sense?

ü  What burning questions are still there?

ü  What needs to be done?

Page 10: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012

2.  The Process question: How does it work?

1.  The causal question: Does it work?

Asking Research Questions Does the intervention being considered “cause” a particular outcome to change.

What are the processes or interactions that mediate the causal relationship? This may require “thick descriptions” of a phenomenon.

3.  The usability question: Will it work for me?

4.  The evaluation question: Is it working for me?

How is it doing? Does it make sense to modify, sustain or expand the program/intervention?

Is the intervention/program doing what it is supposed to be doing?

Source: McEwan, E. K. & McEwan, P. J. (2003). Making sense of research: What’s good, what’s not, and how to tell the difference. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press, Inc.

What are the context variables of the studies, and is generalization possible?

Page 11: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012

Ø  Verify all the requirements and stages/steps from proposal to graduation.

Ø  Prepare a time line according to the year/semester you wish to graduate.

Ø  Verify both University and department calendars and deadlines.

Ø  Schedule time for every activity related to your time line.

Ø  Be disciplined in following your timeline.

Page 12: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012

June July August

Work on Proposal

Draft

Schedule Proposal Meeting

Before Proposal Meeting * At least 3 weeks before the meeting, your Chair should approve the 3 chapters of your proposal. * At least 2 weeks before proposal date, distribute copies to all your Committee Members.

Final Oral Defense

(at least 1 week prior to May

deadline)

Spring Deadline

Chair must Approve

Dissertation Report Draft

Schedule Final

Defense (2 weeks

prior to date)

Advancement to

Candidacy (online application)

Deadline (August)

Submit Advancement to Candidacy

Application

Enroll in Dissertation

Hours

Two Semesters

Present Proposal to Committee

May Graduation!!

GSC (September)

Approves Candidacy

Apply to graduate earlier

in the spring semester

Page 13: Selecting a Research Proposal Topic, Spring 2012