8/14/2019 S.E.C. v. Morton: Delphi Associates Newsletter

1/20

@HZGO O O@

8/14/2019 S.E.C. v. Morton: Delphi Associates Newsletter

2/20

^`bc Diq6qicw#n"p~o|` Ill`u6

Nbhh iu |o oh ic hochiaby [iu b U@%Miha H2liud ic Koh

' h qo c ` 2 5-#'iuq 2 Ocbd liu qgo uy

~z no ill( u#

8/14/2019 S.E.C. v. Morton: Delphi Associates Newsletter

3/20

b

Qg` D`c ]gi ^iha qg` ]iuha

qgo~ pczui|ik`a zu`$`dzqo|` bnqoic~(bca cbhhy mb|` pz#qgbq oq }ipha h`ba qi aou` nic~`rp`cn`~

E`~oa`~( qg` O~ub`ho~ nipha ai bhhliu Bd`uonb bca qg` }iuha( qi }gong qg`aouqy }iuk liu god( }gong gba e``czu`~oa`cq u`zho`a( Euocm Oq Ic"zhbc luid qg` e`moccocm }g`c qg`Qgo~ h`a qi b u`|ihq oc~oa` qg`mb|` O~ub`h >:: @wnbhoe`u nhb~~ cpn

Z`cqbmic bca ey qg` Fiocq Ngo`l~ il epck`u eide~ qi mi blq`u Oubc# Q^qbll }gi ao~ie`y`a aou`nq iua`u~ luid}b~ lioh`a }g`c Buo`h ^gbuic ~ihaqg` Niddbca`u$Oc$Ngo`l }oqg qg`do~~oh`~ qi qg` U`a Ngoc`~`( nidzh`ubqoicbh` qgbq qg`y aoa ciq gb|` qi qbk`b dpng$c``a`a hock oc qg`ou iua`u~ luid ~id`ic` qg`y nic~oa`u`adbngoc` ngboc# Buo`h zink`q`a diocnidz`q`cq bca rpoq` zi~~oehyqg` ng`aabu( bhicm }oqg dohhoic~ illnhoconbhhy oc~bc`# ^id` il qgo~ ~qiuy o~qiz luid qg` Mbvb ^quoz a`bh }g`u`ichy CI] goqqocm qg` }iuha zu`~~6P^ zboa O~ub`h !>: eohhoic qi zphh$ip

Ey^@BC$AB\OADIUQIC'Qgo~ o~~p` o~ a`aonbq`a qi qg` d`diuy il dy

^q`z$lbqg`u( bca U@BH ABA( Fby Lubckhoc^bhbdbc# G` ubo~`a d` qi kci} }gbq o~ uomgq bcaO }ipha ciq e` qg` z`u~ic O bd }oqgipq god#/

Oc qg` zu`|oip~ o~~p` O u`|`bh`a qgbq

qg` P^ }b~ oc qg` zuin`~~ il zhbccocm b~`uo`~ il bqidon eide ~quok`~ oc~oa` Oubc#Qgbq qg` P^ }b~ bq U@A BH@UQ bcaebqqh` muipz~ }`u` oc zi~oqoic liu qgo~ qiqbk` zhbn` ic Dbung 5?qg# Ic Dbung 51qgb ai~~o`u }b~ zhbn`a ic qg` zu`~oa`cq~a`nk `wzhbococm qg` u`z`unp~~oic~ il

^`ydipu G`u~g~ hbq`~q buqonh` wzhboc~~id` il qg` a`qboh~ ci} e`ocm u`|`bh`ail gi} Bud`m`aaic aoacq mi ai}c#

@wn`uzq6Oc hbq` Bzuoh( qg` dohoqbuy h`ba`u~goz(g`ba`a ey M`c`ubh Zbn`( bngo`|`a b dbfiu

|onqiuy }g`c qg` ]goq` Gip~` auizz`aoq~ oc~o~q`cn` qgbq qg` zhbc liu b eideocmnbdzbomc ocnhpa` qg` zi~~oeh` p~` il bcpnh`bu a`|on` qi a`~quiy Oubc~ pubcopd$`cuongd`cq zhbcq bq Cbqbcv( c`buhy q}igpcau`a doh`~ ~ipqg il Q gubc# Qg` gpm`nidzh`w ocnhpa`~ hbum` pca`umuipcalbnohoqo`~ epohq ocqi ~`|`cqy$|`$liiq$a``zgih`~ oc qg` muipca bca a`~omc`a qi gihab~ dbcy b~ lqy qgip~bca n`cquolpm`~#

Ep~g bca Ng`c`y }`u` a`ba ~`uoip~

beipq qg` cpnh`bu zhbccocm( qg` liud`u~`coiu ocq`hhom`cn` ilnobh qiha d`# BcaZbn` ~qiia pz qi qg`d# Qg`c qg` }iuhanbd` ebnk6 I#K#( qg` cpnh`bu izqoic o~zihoqonbhhy pcbnn`zqbeh`# Bq qg` qod`(b cpde`u il u`qou`a iln`u~( ocnhpaocm

q}i Budy dbfiu m`c`ubh~ }gi ~`u|`a ocOubr( Zbph @bqic bca Ngbuh`~ ^}bccbnk(Fu#( gba e`mpc ~z`bkocm ipq bmboc~q qg`

Badoco~qubqoic~ gbcahocm il qg` Oubr}bu# Qgo~ z`uoia o~ kci}c qi dbcy oc qg`Z`cqbmic b~ qg` Bzuoh U`|ihpqoic#

Bc `|`cq hok` qgo~ ai`~cq m`q zbz`u`ai|`u |`uy rponkhy( qg` liud`u ilnobhbaa`a# Qg` eba l``hocm~ i|`u qg` cpnh`bu

izqoic bu` ~qohh l`hq# Qg` no|ohobc go`ubungyl``h~ `wqubiuaocbuohy e`quby`a ey qg` eub~~(bca qg` eub~~ l``h qg`y }`u` quonk`a ocqioq$$qg` cpnh`bu zhbccocm$$ey e`ocm b~k`aqi zui|oa` bhh izqoic~ oc qg` zhbccocmzbz`u~##

s@CA ^QIU_sCIQQG@]GIH@^QIU_Qgo~ ai`~ ciq q`hh yip qg` ]GIH@

~qiuy il }gbq U@BHH_ }`cq ic e`gocaqg` ~n`c`~( e`nbp~` qg`y AI CIQ }bcqbcyic` qi kci} qgbq Oubc ci} gb~ cpk`

}bug`ba~ liu oq~ pc~qizzbeh` ^PCEPdo~~oh`~( mo|`c qi qg`d ey qg` Pkuboco}gong qg`y miq luid \hbaodou Zbca Up~~ob###BHH E@NBP^@ il EpE@HHOM@U@CN@( bca go~ u`home`ho`l qgbq ey ~qbuqocm Budbm`aaic(

g` }ohh ~id` gi} euocm F@^P^ ebnk#_ip }ohh bh~i ciqon` qgbq `|`c BLQ

qg` Fiocq Ngo`l~ il qbll u`lp~`a qgo~ oc~zhbc ebnk oc Dbung( qgbq oq }b~ ^QOHHqg` qbeh` bca ciq `cqou`hy u`f`nq`a phbq` Bzuoh }g`c Ep~g u`bhov`a g` }b~

m`qqocm bcy}g`u` }oqg qgo~ bzzui

qg` hbum`~q e`goca$qg`$~n`c`~ u`bh `~a`bh oc go~qiuy Du# ^gbuic ci} ~oq~ nidb#

Ci} CI IC@ bq qg` Z`cqbmic }qi qbk` iua`u~ luid Ep~g( ~qbqocm qi qgbq6 qg` NG@@^@ gb~ qiqbhhy ~hozill qg` Zu`~oa`cq~ Nubnk`u bca qg`yhicm`u l``h iehombq`a qi qbk` iua`u~ lb dbadbc qg`y ci} ~`uoip~hy nic~Nhoconbhhy Oc~bc`# Bca O AI CIQ dqgbq ~qbq`d`cq homgqhy#

Qgo~ o~ BHH ~qpll qgbq o~ ciq `|`c g`beipq oc~oa` qg` E`hq}by( epq qgbq O

B^^PU@ yip o~ qup`#Ci} |`uyqgocm gb~ mic` qi ZH

E b~ qg` O~ub`ho~ bu` aiocm bhh qg` a

8/14/2019 S.E.C. v. Morton: Delphi Associates Newsletter

4/20

$ $

^`bcbqPcoq`aCbqoic~Zu`~~Nicl`u`cn`

Q G @ A @ H Z G O B I N O B Q @ C @ ] H @ Q Q @ U}iuk liu p~( bca oq o~ ichy b dbqq`u il qod`e`liu` qg` P^ m`q~ oc|ih|`a ic O~ub`h~ ~oa`#_ip }ohh ciqon` i|`u qg` c`wq l`} }``k~ b~O~ub`h oc|ba`~ H`ebcic bca eide~ ^yuob(qgbq bhh il qgo~ bqq`cqoic o~ e`ocm linp~`aic bc bu`b nbhh`a QG@ E@KKB \BHH@_#^id` il yip dby u`d`de`u qgbq qgu``y`bu~ bmi O u`ziuq`a g`u` qgbq O gba u`diq`|o`}`a lipu lbnohoqo`~ oc~oa` Oubr qgbq

}`u` dbcplbnqpuocm qg` lbd`a ]DA~(pca`u qg` ~pz`u|o~oic il U@ANGOC@^@ ~no`cqo~q~# O bh~i qihayip qg`~` }`u` BHH di|`a ocqib ~`uo`~ il nb|`~ oc QG@ E@KKB\BHH@_( bca qgbq o~ }g`u` qg`P^ bca O~ub`h }ohh e` linp~ocmdi~q il qg`ou u`zi}`u#

^yuob bca Oubc gb|` b dpqpbha`l`c~` qu`bqy( ~i bcy bqqbnk ic^yuob }ohh euiba`c qg` niconq(epq bh~i mo|` qg` P^ Nbuq`

Ehbcng` qi eide zu`qqy dpngbcyic` bhh i|`u qg` Doa$@b~q#

Qg` wqub$baa`a ba|bcqbm`o~ O~ub`h }ohh ci} p~` qgo~ b~ bc`wnp~` qi qbk` ebnk qg` Mbvb^quoz bca k``z Bd`uonb~ !>:eohhoic# Pcnh` bd m`q~ eic`a bmboc# H`q~g`bu oq liu ipu mu`bq`~q Bhhy oc qg` Doaah`@b~q#

D`bc}goh`( Up~~ob~( bca \hbaodouZpqoc~( oc|ih|`d`cq oc bhh il qgo~ luide`goca qg` ~n`c`~ o~ qg` u`bh ~qiuy# Up~~obo~ oc qg` doaah` il b mgq qgbq cieiayo~ miocm qi }oc bca `|`uyic` o~ miocm qihi~` bmboc" Zpqoc gb~ e``c e`quby`a eyEp~g bca Ehbou oc bhh go~ a`bh~ bca qg`mpy~ aou`nqhy pca`u god( }bcq go~ g`baic b zhbqq`u bca g` o~ ~z`caocm bhh il go~qod`( dbkocm ~pu` CBQI ai`~cq m`q ocqiM`iumob bca qg` Pkuboc`#

Qgi~` zbyocm bqq`cqoic qi qg` c`}~ dbygb|` nbpmgq qg` u`}iuk~ miocm ic e`q}``cEp~g bca Zpqoc bq qg` M$7 ~pddoq# Ep~gu`l`uu`a qi Zpqoc~ }ol` b~ Du~# Zpq``cb#Ep~g ~boa luid qg` ziaopd g` gba giz`aqgbq Up~~ob }ipha e` diu` a`dinubqon#Zpqoc u`zho`a qgbq g` }ipha zu`l`u qg`a`dinubny qg`y gb|` ubqg`u qgbc qg` qyz`il a`dinubny qg` P^ gba ~`q pz oc Oubr#Ep~g hoq`ubhhy y`hh`a luid go~ ~`bq( Fp~qyip }boq"

Qgo~ }b~ b |`oh`a qgu`bq qgbq Zpqoc o~miocm qi e` u`zhbn`a |`uy ~iic( qgbq qg`

P^ o~ zhiqqocm b dbfiu u`mod` ngbcm`oc Up~~ob( bca( qg`u` o~ npuu`cqhy b !2::eohhoic lpca e`ocm ~`q pz qi a`dinubqov`Npeb bca euocm oq ebnk pca`u qg` P^~zg`u` il ocp`cn` }g`c Nb~qui ao`~(}gong o~ `wz`nq`a oc qg` c`wq 27 dicqg~#

Du# Zpqoc zuiebehy ai`~cq ~h``z }`hhbq comgq bq bhh#

QG@ ]IUHA^ MU@BQ@^QEBCK UIEE@U_

Qg` IUOMOCBH A`hzgo B~~inobq`~ }b~~`q pz dbcy y`bu~ bmi ey Up~~`hh Qbum( qg`Lbqg`u il U`diq` \o`}ocm( b~ bc oc|`~qd`cq

muipz qgbq }b~ p~`a qi zpq z~yngon~ bcaU`diq` \o`}ocm qi qg` q`~q zu`aonqocmqg` ipqnid` il ^OH\@U LPQPU@^ bcazuon`~# Oc qg` u~q y`bu qg`y }`u` 2: liu 25oc qg`ou zonk~( d``qocm icn` b dicqg bcadbkocm ic` zonk `bng dicqg#

Oc ~pe~`rp`cq ^qbcliua `wz`uod`cq~p~ocm U\ ic Ubcaid Cpde`u M`c`ubqiu~(~z`nonbhhy Uiph`qq`]g``h~( ipu muipz( il}gong@hovbe`qgQbumbcaO}`u`eiqgd`de`u~(} }`u`=liu2:}oqgic zb~~'}gongOl`hq}`GOQbca~giphagb| e`qic"/

Dy u`niua oc qg` ~qink dbuk`q gb~ e``c~z`nqbnphbu( pczbubhh`h`a bca pc~puzb~~`a#O gb|` nbhh`a BHH qg` gomg~ bca hi}~ il qg`dbuk`q( mo|ocm @WBNQ ABQ@^ liu uo~`~bca nub~g`~ i|`u qg` hb~q 21 y`bu~# Oc lbnqO ZBOA liu dy `cqou` nihh`m` `apnbqoicbq P^N }oqg b M@DNI ~ngihbu~gozb}bua bca b !0:::# oc|`~qd`cq oc MIHANIOC^ eipmgq oc 2?=1 }g`c miha }b~!>5# z`u iv# Ey qg` qod` O mubapbq`a P^N

oc 2?7: }oqg dphqozh` a`mu``~ oc Ziho^no`cn` bca b Ebng`hiu il Loc` 'bca ichy ic` ~`d`~q`u ~gy il a`mu``Iumbcon Ng`d bca B~quicidy/ miha !70:# z`u iv#

Oc lbnq O qpuc`a }gbq }b~ h`lq il miha ocqi c`buhy gbhl b dohhoic oc ~qink dbuk`q( epyocm ~png ~qink~KOCM]IUHA @CQ@UQBOCD@CQ

dicqg~ e`liu` ]g``h il Liuqpc`( F`izbca IZUBG }`cq icbou# O gba ~odohbu ~pnn`}oqg ~qink~ ~png b~ ~nidzbcy HB M@BU#

^ocn` Fphy il 5~qink~ bca d`qbh~ O gb|` u`nidd`cgb|` ~``c bc ocnu`b~b ]GIZZOCM >1h`baocm dy z`u~iluo`ca( }gi }b~ g`ba

Mihadbc ^bng~ bcaCI] ^`nu`qbuy il Qu`b~puy( G`cuy ZbphFu# qi nidd`cq( O n

e`ho`|` yip ichy ngbum`epnk~ liu qgbq c`}~h`qq`u#

Mihadbc ^bng~ eiik`a b 1:% zhb~q y`bu# Qg`y dba` eohhoic~ bca O!

8/14/2019 S.E.C. v. Morton: Delphi Associates Newsletter

5/20

$$

Q G @ A @ H Z G O B I N O BQ @ C @ ] H @ Q Q @ Uqg` c`wq aby~ qubaocm# O qg`c ~`ca qg`~`qi dy bcbhy~q Abuyh ]`e`u oc Dicqu`bh(bca g` dbk`~ bhh qg` quba`~ eb~`a ic qgbqocliudbqoic qg` c`wq aby#

Abuyh bca O nbc dbk` quba`~ ic qg`bnnipcq( epqichyOgb|`qg`zi}`uqibnqpbhhyBNN@^^qg`lpca~#CIIC@@H^@"O bd qg` nubvy z~yngon qgbq o~ p~ocmU\ bca ai}~ocm qi zu`aonq qg` qu`ca~

bca hoc`~ `bng comgq( bca Abuyh gb~ qg`q`ngconbh }ovbuauy qi dbk` qg` quba`~ bcaqpuc qgbq ocqi DIC@_#

Quba`~ bu` aic` luid HBQ@ ^PCAB_COMGQ QGUIPMG QGPU^AB_#@bng Qgpu~aby qg` }``k~ zuiq~ }ohh e`nbhnphbq`a liu `bng d`de`u#

]oqg `|`uyic`~ oc|ih|`d`cq bca qg`koca il dic`y }` gb|` e``c dbkocm}` bu` bhu`bay ~qu`~~ocm qg` hodoq~ il qg`bnnipcq#

O @DBOH |`uyic` ]@@KH_ U@ZIUQ^

ic }gbq qg`ou dic`y aoa liu qg` }``k# ]`ai ZB_IPQ^ `|`uy liuqcomgq ic qg` lphhbca c`} diic# BQ BC_QOD@ d`de`u~nbc m`q ipq BHH iu bcy ziuqoic il qg`oulpca~ epq qg`u` o~ b 20% Nbzoqbh Mboc~ qbwngbum`a ic zuiq~#

Qgo~ ~y~q`d gb~ }iuk`a ipq ~i }`hh qgbq}` gb|` dba` 7: quba`~ }oqg ichy = liuhi~~`~# Ichy ^@\@C hi~~`~" Qgo~ d`bc~qgbq }` bu` b|`ubmocm > qi 0% Z@U AB_(bca oc qg` hb~q dicqg }` gb|` gba mboc~ il25%( 2?% bca 5: bd @^Q qg` L`a~ bccipcn`aqgbq qg` P^ Quba` A`noq mpu`~ }`u`~id` !>: eohhoic e`qq`u qgbc bcyic``wz`nq`a# ]gbq qg`y }`u` ciq q`hhocmyip o~ qgbq qgi~` cpde`u~ }`u` bhhdbcozphbq`a ey nipcqocm eide~( mpc~(zhbc`~( qbck~( bddpcoqoic( d`un`cbuo`~bc ~ihao`u~ zby oc Oubr bca Blmgbco~qbc

B^ BC @WZIUQ" ^i ci} ]BU( a`bqgbca dpua u o~ qg` ~ocmh` eomm ~q `wziuq ilqg` Pcoq`a ^qbq`~ il Bd`uonb#

Epq ~id`ic` gba

LIU@KCI]H@AM@ il qg`~` cpdbca gba ~pnn`~~lphhy dbcbm`a dbcozphbq` qg` dbuk`q~( bca qg` npuu`cil 0 dbfiu mi|`ucd`cq~ oc ba|bcn` qiill }gbq bdipcq`a qi qg` eomm`~q euiee`uy il BHH QOD@bca oq gbzz`uomgq e`liu` ipu `y`~#

]gi`|`u oq }b~ ~pnn`~~lphhy dbcbm`~q`bh bc ~qodbq`a QIH@ !1= QUOHHOO u`ziuq`a ic oq oc dy c`}~h`qq`u bca FPQ]I ]@@K^ BMBI oq }b~ u`ziuq`qg` Hicaic Qod`~ }oqg oc|`~qombqoicqg` C^B)NOB)LEO bca ^@N# IchyEp~g Nuod` ^ycaonbq` bca qg` O~ugb|` qg` ZUIDO^ OO ~ilq}bu` bca^]IUALO^G ebnk aiiu nia`~ qi ill qgbq koca il g`o~q# O e`ho`|` oq }ZB_ILL liu CIQ eideocm OUBC( bczui|oa` O~ub`h }oqg qg` nbzoqbh qi }bm` npuu`cq }bu bmboc~q H`ebcic bca ^yuo

Epq qg`u` o~ LBU diu` qi qgo~ miocme`goca qg` ~n`c`~6QG@ NUOD@ HIUA

MOMB LPCAEy Mu`m ^vydbc~ko '5> Fpc` 5:::: QuohhoHicaic Eb~`a Ocq`ucbqoicbh NpuuU`|o`} ebnk~ pz H`i ]bcqb~ ~qiuy begi} qg` Ep~g bca Nhocqic nuod` lbd

gb|` uozz`a$ill P#^# Qu`b~puy dic`lpca qg` a`~qupnqoic il Bd`uonb#

]goh` qg` nipcquy o~ zu`innpzo`a q`uuiuo~d( qg` }bu oc Oubr bca ?)22( qgnicquihhocm qg` qbk`i|`u il Bd`uonb~q`bhocm noqov`c~ ehoca qi qg` qpc` ilqi !>:: quohhoic aihhbu~( bnniuaocm qipca`uni|`u cbcnobh u`ziuq ey qg` Hiceb~`a Ocq`ucbqoicbh Npuu`cny U`|o`}# pz$qi$abq` u`ziuq fp~q u`h`b~`a nicqgbq !5=#0 quohhoic u~q ubo~`a luid 22??5 qi cbcn` qg` odzi~oqoic il qg`

]iuha Iua`u gb~ ci} ni|`uqhy ehi~~iocqi dpng( dpng diu` b~ Bd`uonbc~ e``c nic|`co`cqhy dba` qi hiik h`lq }qg`y ~gipha e` hiikocm uomgq#

Epq odziuqbcq ~qiuo`~ hok` qgo~ p~pm`q epuo`a( omciu`a bca i|`uhiioc lb|iu il u`e`hhoic oc qg` ~qu``q~ nink`y`a ~ydzi~opd~ liu qupqg# ^oq~ p~pbhhy qg` `diqoicbh mpq }u`cn`wqub|bmbcvb~ up~gocm qgip~bca~ qi

\ih#OW (O~~ p` .22= Fphy 5:( 5::< BA '57 EO( E`liu` Oddbcp`hhb Aby il Bzz`bubcn`/ Zbm` 0 il 2::quohhoic ey 5:25 }g`c oq o~ `wz`nq`a qie` uihh`a i|`u ocnu`b~ocm qg` |bhp`odd`c~`hy( bnniuaocm qi @puiz`bcocq`hhom`cn` ~ipun`~ qubnocm qg` ocquonbq`ebck ~ng`d`#

Qg` Hicaic$eb~`a Npuu`cny U`|o`}oc \ihpd` 57( Ci 1# oc Dbung 5::> u~qzui|oa`a cbcnobh a`qboh~ il qg` eomm`~qzuo|bq` hibc iz`ubqoic oc gpdbc go~qiuy(~qbuq`a }oqg P#^# Qu`b~puy lpca~ bdb~~`aey ]bcqb epq qg`c ni|`uqhy qubc~l`uu`aocqi zuo|bq` bnnipcq~ qi lpca qg` mhiebhqbk`i|`u#

Oc `~~`cn`( qg` ouicy ho`~ oc qg` ~ba lbnqqgbq qu`b~icip~ Bd`uonbc zihoqonobc~ bca

niuupzq ep~oc`~~d`c bu` p~ocm dic`y`budbuk`a liu qg` P#^# Qu`b~puy qi lpca bmhiebh nbdzbomc qi a`~quiy Bd`uonb oc~q`bail p~ocm qg` dic`y liu qg` e`qq`ud`cq ilqg` nipcquy#

^ocn` qg` ocoqobh u`ziuq~ il qg`

db~~o|` mhiebh lpca u~q ~pulbn`a( ]bcqbbca ~`|`ubh iqg`u }oqc`~~`~ gb|` nid`liu}bua cbdocm cbd`~ bca ho~qocm bnqpbhebck bnnipcq~ bca u`niua~ qgbq gb|`zuocq`a oc zu`|oip~ Bunqon E`bnic buqonh`~#

Pcni|`uocm qgbq qg` bdipcq il dic`y}b~ ~i ~qbmm`uocm bca lbu `wn``a`a bcybdipcq odbmocbeh`( qg` ~qiuy gb~ e``c~gpcc`a ey qg` dboc~qu`bd `|`c qgipmgoq o~ qgiuipmghy ebnk`a pz ey l`a`ubh nipuqainpd`cqbqoic bca iqg`u ocliudbqoich`bk`a ey P#^# Qu`b~puy }go~qh`ehi}`u~(

~id` }gi gb|` e``c qgu`bq`c`a }oqg qg`ouho|`~ liu ao|phmocm qg` ocliudbqoic#

Lpuqg`u( qg` ocliudbqoic gb~ e``coc qg` gbca~ il qg` P#^# Nicmu`~~ liu bqh`b~q qgu`` y`bu~( epq gb~ e``c ~pzzu`~~`a~ocn` oq iz`c~ qg` aiiu qi qg` odd`c~`lubpa e`ocm z`uz`qubq`a ic qg` Bd`uonbczpehon#

Ey qgbq }` d`bc qgbq qg` ainpd`cq~mo|`c qi Nicmu`~~ a`qbohocm qg` ubo~ocmil qg` mom$lpca~ }`u` ocnhpa`a bdicm bebqng il iqg`u ainpd`cq~ ~gi}ocm eohhoic~e`ocm ~nbdd`a ocqi zuo|bq` qup~q bnnipcq~oc qg` Nbydbc O~hbca~ bca `h~`}g`u`(~boa qg` u`n`cq Ocq`ucbqoicbh Npuu`cnyU`|o`} u`ziuq( }oqg`u luid qg` quohhoic~il aihhbu~ ubo~`a liu qg` Mhiebh ^`npuoqy@c|ouicd`cq cbcnocm iz`ubqoic iu luidEhbnk Iz`ubqoic~ dico`~ `dzhiy`a qi}bm` cbcnobh }bulbu` iz`ubqoic~ bmboc~qqbum`q`a liu`omc mi|`ucd`cq~#

Qg`y bh~i ~gi}( ocq`u bhob( qubc~bnqoic~

|ob qg` L`a`ubh U`~`u|` bzzui|`a eyBhbc Mu``c~zbc }gong( qi zpq oq doubo~`~ dbcy rp`~qoic~( ocnhpaocm }gy ~il qg` lpca~ oc rp`~qoic }`u` ao~bzz bocqi zuo|bq`hy g`ha qup~q bnnipcq~ g`hae`gbhl il }`hh$kci}c ocq`hhom`cn`$hocebuic~#

E`~oa`~ quyocm qi qubn` qg` nphzuoq~ e`g

qg` momb$lpca ~nbd( qg` Ocq`ucbqoNpuu`cny U`|o`} bh~i zui|oa`a ~pnnu`b~ic~ }gy qg` lpca }b~ `~qbeho~p~ocm P#^# cbcn`~#

Qg` u`b~ic ~png b hbum` lpca `~qbeho~g`a }b~ qi zui|oa` qg` goaaou`nqiu~ il qg` C`} ]iuha Iua`u pchodoq`a u`~ipun`~# ]` il nipu~` uqi qg`~` z`izh` b~ qg` C`} Pca`u}Iua`u e`nbp~` oq o~ bc ouu`a``dbehy niuiz`ubqoic qi `c~pu` be~ihpq` mhiebh zibca nicquih ~qby~ oc qg` gbca~ il qg`

bzziocq`a m`i$Db~icon `hoq`( baa`acbcnobh u`ziuq#Qg`ou ocq`cqoic o~ qgbq bhh ~qbq`~

beiho~g`a bca mi|`ucbcn` }ohh a`|ocqi qg` gbca~ il qg` lbn`h`~~( oc|onicquihh`u~ b~ gb~ gbzz`c`a oc @puiz`bc Pcoic Nihh`nqo|`# Qgo~ o~ ocfp~q bciqg`u zuiqiqyz` il qg` C`} ]Iua`u u`moicbh mi|`ucd`cq dia`h# Eupo~ }g`u` qg` mhiebh lpca o~ dbcbm`a}g`u` b |`uy hbum` nicqocm`cq il NOB ~pz`u|o~`~ qg` dbcbm`d`cq il qg` nihi

u`~ipun`~ dieohov`a liu qgo~ zpuzQg` zuiziuqoic~ il qg`~` u`~ipun`~~i mombcqon qgbq qg` lpca~ gb|` qingpuc`a z`uz`qpbhhy# Ic` quba`u oc|i}oqg qg`~` qubc~bnqoic~ ~by~ qgbq g` Mhiebh ~`npuoqy Lpca qubc~bnqoic~ icliu`omc wngbcm` |`uy aby bca comgq# zuiziuqoic il qg` C`} Pca`u}iuha Icbcn`~ nbc e` nidzbu`a }oqg qg` aid`~qon a`eq'~`` abqb oc u`ziuq/#

Liu qg` `cqou` Ocq`ucbqoicbh NpuuU`|o`} ~qiuy( mi qi gqqz6))}}}#?22kidzhi

ai}chiba~)MhiebhY^`npuoqyYLpca#ainMu`m bh~i gb~ go~ i}c abohy ~gi} icU`zpehon Euibanb~q C`q}iuk# }}}#uecho|`bca o~ bc oca`z`ca`cq oc|`~qombqo|` fipucbca go~ buqonh`~ nbc e``c ~``c bq }H`}o~C`}~#nid# G` bh~i }uoq`~ liu Bd`Lu`` Zu`~~ bca gb~ go~ i}c }`e~oq` }bunqone`bnic#nid

s@CA QIU_s\ih# OW( O~~p` .22=( Fphy 5:( 5::< '57 EO( E`liu` Oddbcp`hhb Aby il Bzz`bubcn`/ Zbm` < il 21 @b~q

8/14/2019 S.E.C. v. Morton: Delphi Associates Newsletter

10/20

$ $

Q G @ A @ H Z G O B I N O B Q @ C @ ] H @ Q Q @ U

ZBUQ IC@6

Ey Congihb~ ]ocqicFphy 2?qg( 5::

8/14/2019 S.E.C. v. Morton: Delphi Associates Newsletter

11/20

$$

Q G @ A @ H Z G O B I N O BQ @ C @ ] H @ Q Q @ U

c``aqi(qib|ioam`qqocmkohh`a# Qgbq~}gyOgbq`di~qdpqpbhlpca~#

i[DTocodov`q`ngcihimybcacic$niddiaoqy`wzi~pu`pcqoh}`~``~omc~ilbeiqqid#

i^giuqqg`RRRR~bcaqg`^,Z0::#iQuodoc|`~qd`cq~qiubo~`nb~g# Gb|ocmnb~gicgbca

c`|`ugpuq~(~ocn`yipnbcbh}by~p~`oqqiepya``zhyi|`u~iha~qink~icn`qg`dbuk`qgb~eiqqid`a#

iNic~oa`uocm

}`

dby

~iic

~``

bniuu`nqoic

oc

qg`

AI](^,Z(`qbh(~`hhocmniphanicn`o|behy`wq`caqid`qbh~gbu`~# Bc

pca`u~qbq`d`cq(liu~pu`"iUomgqci}(qg`dbuk`qhiik~qou`a(i|`ueipmgq(bcaoc

c``ailbdbfiueu`bqg`u# Nb|`bq`dzqiu#Oc goca~omgq( qgo~ hiik~ hok`zu`qqy a`n`cq ba|on`# @|`cqgipmg }`a e``c }bucocm ilb ziq`cqobh dbuk`q zhpcm` liu~`|`ubh dicqg~( O }o~g }` gbae``cbeh`qim`qipqic`cbhA`hzgo

}bucocm

'}oqg

b

nbu$qiic$~ov`ad`mbzgic`"/ocDbye`liu`O}b~ipqqg`iln`bcaipqilubcm`il qg` ocq`uc`qliubc`wq`ca`az`uoia# Qg`u`bhoqy}b~ qgo~6 OgbabDbynihpdcbhu`bay }uoqq`c }bucocm il bcoddoc`cqauiz'qg`n`cqubhnhp`}b~ occiqocmgi}miha~gbu`~}`u` ci hicm`u uo~ocm( `|`cqgipmg zgy~onbh miha }b~/ epq^`bc gba b |`uy quyocm dicqgbca ocbaaoqoic( qg`zuocq`u~ 'hicmqod nho`cq~ il ^`bc~/ il qg`ABCgba~id`o~~p`~(~i}`niphacqzpqqg`o~~p`ipq#Ic`ilqg`u`bhoqo`~}oqglihhi}ocmipuoc|`~qd`cqpzabq`~zpe$ho~g`aicbciqc`n`~~buohyzu`aonqbeh`dicqghyiu'u`n`cqhy/eo$dicqghyeb~o~(o~qgbqoc|`~qiu~bhic`dp~qa`noa`qiepybca~`hh}g`cqg`dbuk`quo~`~iu~`hh~$illiu`|`c(qiaiciqgocmbqbhh#Oai}o~gqiu`oq`ubq`qgbqic`}``kblq`uA`hzgo.220icDbung2=qg(^`bc~`cqipqb~pe~nuoe`u`dbohbh`uq}oqg~id`ildynbp$qoic~(~qbqocm Olqg`^,Zgoq~2>2:bcagiha~(qgbq]IPHA~om$cbhbeu`bkbei|`u`~o~qbcn`bcahok`hyic` hb~qdbfiu~zok`pzqi liih `|`uyic`# Bcaf``z`u~( aoa oq `|`u" Qg` dbuk`q qg`cdi|`a ~oa`}by~ liu

8/14/2019 S.E.C. v. Morton: Delphi Associates Newsletter

12/20

$ $

Q G @ A @ H Z G O B I N O B Q @ C @ ] H @ Q Q @ Uqg`d(bcaqg`cqg`yniuu`nqa``zhy}g`ca`dbca}b|`u~bcaqgo~ innpu~ `|`c oc ephh dbuk`q~# Ol yip bu` b quba`u( yip nbcqbk`ba|bcqbm ilqgo~eyepyocmqg`eiqqid~bca~`hhocmqg`qiz~#Olyipbu`bc oc|`~qiu(~odzhy`c~pu` qgbqyipu oc|`~qd`cq~bu`di|ocmpzoczuon`(bcanpqqgi~`qgbqaicqgb|`bu`n`cqqu`caildi|ocmluidqg`eiqqid$h`lqilqg`ngbuqdi|ocmqiqg`pzz`u$uomgq" Ichy}g`cqgbqqu`caeu`bk~~giphayipe`liun`aqidbk`ba`no~oicic}g`qg`uqi~`hhiuciq#Liuoc|`~qiu~(~pll`uocmocqg`doa~qilqgo~~qinkdbuk`qzphhebnkubck~pzqg`u`}oqgqbkocmbcoc|ihpcqbuydpaebqgocyipuc`~qOqbhobc~ohk~poq# Gi}`|`u(~pnga`nhoc`~bu`niddicbcac`n`~$~buyocbniddiaoqo`~ephhdbuk`q;bcaqgo~auizo~cibu`b~icliunicn`uc~ihicmb~yipuoc|`~qd`cqgiuovico~hicm`uqgbcbEiyEbca~~g`hlhol`# Ipuziuqlihoiild`qbhzonk~ohhp~qubq`~qgo~ziocq|`uynh`buhy# Bqic`ziocqoc`buhyDby(dyA`hzgod`qbh~ziuqlihoibnqpbhhyu`mo~q`u`ab~qbmm`uocm2::%b|`ubm`mbocbcabqiqbhmbocil2:::%"Qgp~(e`ocmbq~ocn`Dbung(dynbu`lphhy~`h`nq`ad`qbhziuqlihoiu`dboc~OCQG@ZI^OQO\@qiqg`qpc`il% ic qg` y`bu# ^i( }goh` ipu d`qbh~ziuqlihoio~ai}ci|`u>1%luidoq~Dbygomg~il2::%'qgipmgai}cichy2>%~ocn`Dbung/(oq~~qohhe`bq`cBHHQGU@@dbu$k`qocaon`~nideoc`aey}`hhi|`u0:%qgo~y`bu"Qg`~`z`uliudbcn`mpu`~(bhicm}oqgqg`lbnqqgbqqg`AI]bca^,Zbzz`bu qi lbn` ~`uoip~ pz~oa` u`~o~qbcn` o~ qg` u`b~ic }`nicqocp qilb|ipud`qbhbca`c`umy~qink~i|`ubhhiqg`u~qink~#Onbcqao~bmu``}oqgqg`ziuqlihoibhhinbqoic^`bcu`nidd`ca`aocABC.220(il6 0:%ioh)`c`umy(>:%~oh|`u(5:%miha;Ohok`d`qbh~gbu`~diu`qgbc`c`umy(epqquphy(oq~nidzh`q`hypzqioc$ao|oapbhoc|`~qiu~icgi}qiao~quoepq qg`ougihaocm~# ]`~odzhyeuocmyipipue`~qoa`b~bcabcbhy~o~(bcayipnbcngii~`qibnqicqg`d'iuciq/#Bcaci}ebnkqiqg`nbucbm`# @|`cdye`~qz`uliudocm|ou$qpbh lpca~( qiz g`b|y oc d`qbh~ bca `c`umy( }`u` ai}c eom ocDby$Fpc`# Epqqg`yu`eipcnocmebnklb~qbcaOdciqzbconkocm#Qg`~`~bd`~qink~gb|``wn`hh`cqlpcabd`cqbh~'qgbck~qimiha(~oh|`u bca nizz`u zuon`~ qgbq gb|` di|`a ~dbuqhy gomg`u i|`u`bngil qg` hb~q1y`bu~"/bca}ohhnicqocp qg`oudbung qic`}gomg~(e`liu`niuu`nqocmbmbocb~qg`nynh`nicqocp`~# K``zocmocdocaqgbqipud`qbh~qink~bu`pz

8/14/2019 S.E.C. v. Morton: Delphi Associates Newsletter

13/20

$$

Q G @ A @ H Z G O B I N O BQ @ C @ ] H @ Q Q @ U

Ikby(FodNubd`ugb~e``cbcoc~oa`}`hhhok`hygb|`~``cqg``cailqgo~zbu$]bhh ^qu``q# G` `|`c }iuk`a bq Mqonphbuniuu`nqoic# Olqg`^,Zlbhh~e`hi}dbc^bng~# ]gy(ig(}gydp~qg`qgo~ h`|`h( qg`c d`qbh bca iqg`u ~gbu`~gb|`~iocnidzu`g`c~oehy9 Uomgqbniphaq`~qqg`ouhi}~bmboce`liu`~qbuqocmeiqqidilqgo~hbq`~qmihaauiz'}g`cqg`ounhodeebnkpz#G`am`gimbcaNiddiaiAubmicLp}`u` ~niizocm pz AOUQ NG@BZ d~gbu`~"/(Nubd`u}b~q`hhocmgo~doc\ihbqohoqy U`qpuc~ qgbqmiha}b~ciqb~bl`zhbn`qie`#go~c`wqeu`bqg(gi}`|`u(g` ouu`~ziNbc ]` E`bu Oq9ehy u`nidd`ca`a b g`b|ohy$i|`uzumiha ~qink( hinbq`a oc zihoqonbhhy uIc` qgocm qgbq gb~ nicn`uc`a d` oc qg` \`c`vp`hb 'Nuy~qbhh`w( ~ydeih6 KU~`b~icbhhy ~hi} dicqg~ bg`ba o~ qg` u`$}g`u`cbqoicbhovbqoicbcayipu~qinkn`cqu`qpucil|ihbqohoqy#B~Od`cqoic`aococm luid !1 qi v`ui i|`ucomgq o~ bA`n`de`u~ ABC( hbum` ic`$aby di|`~qgu`bq qgbck~ qi aonqbqiu Gpmi Ngboc qg` dbuk`q }`u` pcniddic i|`u qg`]gbq~ diu` Nuy~qbhh`w QG@C qiizu`n`aocm51dicqg~# Oclbnq(yipniphampq$ngpucocm0:%qpdeh`'oq~>uaihok`hynipcqqg`dicic`gbca# Epq~ocn`

miha }ohh ipqzbn` ~oh|`u oc qg` c`bu$q`ud 'b~ ~oh|`u o~ ~``cb~diu`~z`nphbqo| eydbcyoc|`~qiu~/bcaqg`c~oh|`u}ohhipqz`u$liudmihab~innpuu`aliudi~qilqgo~y`bu# Bcag`u`yipgb|`bubu`izziuqpcoqyqiepyeiqgd`qbhbca`c`umy~gbu`~apuocmbz`$uoiab~bqqubnqo|`b~Fphy5::0}g`c}`dba`qg`u~qilipumihabca~oh|`u~qink~`h`nqoic~# Bcaebnkqg`c(ciic`'epqp~/ubcmqg`e`hh(q`hhocm`|`uyic`qiepyniddiaoqo`~# Liuqpcbliuqoep~lb|`q" Liuqpc`Lb|ipu~Qg`Eub|`"Olqg`^,Znbcgihabcaeb~`bei|`255:(

Fbcpbuy( qg`u` gb|` ci} e``c cpd`uip~aby~}g`cqg`AI]gb~uo~`ciulbhh`c2::ziocq~iudiu`# Bl`}}``k~bmi(qg`Ai}}b~ai}c27:ziocq~ocic`aby" Qg`Cb~abr o~ ai}c 2:% i|`u qg` hb~q dicqg# Qg` Ai} gb~ hi~qbeipq2:::ziocq~~ocn`oq~gomg# Blq`u`wz`uo`cnocmq}iy`bu~iloc|`~qiunidzhbn`cny'd`b~pu`aeyqg`\ihbqohoqyOca`wiu\OW/(oc|`~qiu~bu`bmboc~``ocml`bubcadbuk`q|ihbqohoqyu`qpucocmqiqg`dbuk`q#]`gb|`cinicudbqoicy`q(epqbngbcm`oc|ihb $qohoqyluidhi}qigomgb~}`~``ci}(nbc~omcbhqg`u`qpucilbE@BUDBUK@Q# B~bu`~phq(}`dbygb|`qie`diu`~`h`nqo|`beipq}g`c}``cq`ubca`woqqg`dbuk`q;bcaoclpqpu`quba`~(}`dbygb|`qie`diu`|omohbcqocnpqqocmdbuk`qhi~~`~ buhy# K``zqgo~ocdoca# Ol}`aim`qbubhhybcaqg`^,Znbcqeu`bk2>::'bcaphqodbq`hy(2>5=/qg`cqgbq~pmm`~q~}`bkc`~~(~iyipdomgqnic~oa`uqbkocmzuiq~iumiocmqinb~g#

Qgbq~ }gy Od iz`ubqocm b~ qgipmg qgo~c`wqpzdi|`'i|`uqg`c`wq1$::bcamihagoq~z`ugbz~!=:: bca qpuc~ ai}c }goh` qg` ~h``zy ~pdd`u aihaupd~ konkoc;qgbqo~(pch`~~qg`Doaah`@b~qnicqocp`~qibu`pz#K``zocdoca(e`liu`qgo~dbuk`qdbk`~oq~c`wq~`uoip~di|`gomg`u(oqdby}`hhe`e`cqic}uocmocm`|`uyephhipqiloq(qguipmg6 b/bhicmz`uoiailnic~ihoabqoicbcamuocaocm~oa`}by~(qgipmgoqo~diu`hok`hyqguipmgeiqge/lu`~ga`nhoc`~luidhbq`Fphy)Bpmp~qocqi qg`Lbhhbcan/pz$ngpnkocm|ihbqohoqy qgbq h`b|`~`|`uyic`u`bngocmliuqg`Mub|ih# Ocqg`d`bcqod`(nicqocp`qidbocqbocyipuniu`zi~oqoic~ocd`qbhbca`c`umy#

Dba Dic`y6^qohh Ebukocm Bq

Qg` Diic"

ocby`bu/icfp~q~pngnicn`uc~" Oc`|`cq(Onbcqqgockilbe`qq`umihaepy~omcbh(qgbcNubd`u~qoicqi}boqliumihaqilbhh#Qgo~o~brpoukyl`hhi}}gi(q}iy`bu~bmi}b~hbpmgocmbqepm~

bca

q`hhocm

go~

|o`}`u~

miha

}ipha

mi

ai}c

e`nbp~`

ilocmocq`u`~qubq`~"Qg`c}g`cg`cbhhymiqbuipcaqiq`hhocm

|o`}`u~ qiepymihaQGO^_@BU(qg`d`qbh}b~uomgqbqbcq`uodqizbcamihazuin``a`a qilbhh!0:)ivuomgqblq`ugo~Q`uuon#Bca}g`cNubd`ucbhhye`hhy$izz`aicqiqg`~oebca}bmic(g`zonk`aZbcBd`uonbc^oh|`u(ic`ilipuiuomFphy5::0A`hzgod`qbhzonk~# Ocnu`aoehy(go~ u`nidd`cabilZBB^~iicgba qg``ll`nqilb2:%niuu`nqoic oc oq~~gBcaci}(e`buocmbgbhhdbukilqg`oclbdip~Nubd`unpu~`(Bd`uonbco~ci}qg`}iu~qz`uliudocm~oh|`u~qinkocipuzlihoi# _pnk" Oc~pddbqoic(Nubd`u~ba|on` o~|bhpbeh`#q}o~qg`u`o~qgbqho~q`cocmqigodbcaqg`caiocmqg`izzi~oilq`c

lbu

diu`

hpnubqo|`"

B~

yip

nbc

~``(

g`

o~

m`qqocm

~cci}(~ipcaocme`buo~gicmiha}goh`u`nidd`caocmmiha~q

'gpg999/# Omp`~~olqg`dbcqbk`~eiqg~oa`~ilbe`q(g`nhi~`# Luid b nicqubuobc z`u~z`nqo|`( }gbq~ `|`c diu` epliumihaqgbcqg`Oc|`u~`Nubd`uOcaonbqiu'Qg`O$N$OiuONOCAONBQIU"/ o~ qgbqbl`} hicmqod niddiaoqydbuk`qe~png b~Zbph\bc @`a`c bu` e`moccocm qirp`~qoic }g`qg`uniddiaoqo`~ephho~i|`u# Qgo~nicn`uco~baau`~~`abcaao~z`hbq`uocdynihpdceyblbouhyb~qpq`l`hhi}eyqg`cbd`ilUim`u~(}gigb~dba`bLIUQPC@ocniddiaoqo`~qubaocm

\ih#OW(O~ ~p` .22= Fphy 5:( 5::< BA '57 EO( E`liu` Oddbcp`hhb Aby il Bzz`bubcn`/ Zbm` 2> il 2/`wz`uo`cn` }b~ ichy b `} ~giuq y`bu~#Nic|`u~`hy( b a`lbqoicbuy nihhbz~`( }gong

e`mbc oc 2?5? oc qg` P^B( qiik Bd`uonbdiu` qgbc 2:$y`bu~ qi u`ni|`u uid#Oc~qupnqo|`hy( eiqg `ca`a oc ]iuha ]bu OO#

Ci} yip dby u`nbhh qgbq O u`n`cqhyzpeho~g`a b ciq` uid ~ipun`~ qgbq qg`u`}`u` u`ziuq~ i u`a npuu`cny e`ocm oczhbn` oc ~qubq`mon n`cq`u~ ipq~oa` i qg`Pcoq`a ^qbq`~ $ bzzbu`cqhy oc zu`zbubqoiciu b q}i$qo`u`a npuu`cny ~y~q`d# Qg` }by~png npuu`cny }iuk~ o~ qgo~6 Dic`y ipq~oa`qg` P^ }ipha gb|` ic` wngbcm` ubq`( }goh`

& & & &

A`bu M`ium`(Ic` i dy uo`ca~ bca ~pe~nuoe`u~ ~boa

qgbq yip gba ~id` rp`~qoic~ u`mbuaocm b `}qgocm~ O ~b} }goh` ic b ep~oc`~~ quoz qi qg`C`qg`uhbca~( bca O fp~q }bcq`a qi mo|` yipqg` ~qubomgq ~niiz ic }gbq O `wz`uo`cn`a#

Oc Bzuoh i 5::0 O }`cq qi Bd~q`uabdiu |` aby~ qi cbhov` b cbcnobh a`bhqgbq u`mbua`a zbyocm b cpde`u i ``~iu b qubc~ziuq i nbzoqbh uid Buonb( qiGihhbca qi ~id` ebck~ oc Bcaiuub# Qgo~a`bh o~ dy zuo|bq` ep~oc`~~ bca O ~gbhh ciqmo|` bcy diu` a`qboh~( epq oq }b~ ~id`qgocm

qgbq O gba e``c }iukocm ic iu b cpde`ui y`bu~#

O }b~ qbk`c |ob hodi }oqg dy zbuqc`uoc qg` a`bh qi ~id` in`~ qgbq }`u`bafbn`cq qi b cpde`u i }bu`gip~`~ oc b}bu`gip~` )ep~oc`~~ ao~quonq qgbq }b~ c`buqg` Bd~q`uabd bouziuq#

Bmboc( qgo~ }b~ b zuo|bq` bbou qgbqa`dbca~ ~id` a`honbny epq zbuq i qg`baau`~~ }b~6

^ngozih( Nh`buocm Gip~`( ^ngozih( Qg`

uo`ca~ }oqg ic` i qg` }bu`gmpbua~( b~k`a o qg`y nipha `cq`u bci

~`nqoic i qg` }bu`gip~`( bca g` bmu``beh`( bca ~boa bhh uomgq bca }` }`bciqg`u |`uy hbum` ~`nqoic#

Qg`u`( }oqg qg` z`udo~~oic i qg` mpqg`y iz`c`a ic` hbum` ~q`bd`u ~ov`a qgbq }b~ hh`a }oqg qg` c`} hbum` E`c Lubckhoc P^ !2:: eohh~# Qg`y pca`u }gbq bzz`bu`a qi e` g`b|y mhbzhb~qon }oqg hbum` nounphbu d`qbh eihq~ bqiz#

O nipha ichy ~`` qg` LBN@ ^OA@ iLUICQ i qg` eohh~ pca`u qg` mhb~~# eohh~ gba b U@A QOCM@ iu nihiuoc

`oqg`u ~oa` i qg` hbum` LBN@ i LubckhQg` d`c ~boa qgbq qg`u` }

bzzuiwodbq`hy !

8/14/2019 S.E.C. v. Morton: Delphi Associates Newsletter

17/20

$$

Q G @ A @ H Z G O B I N O BQ @ C @ ] H @ Q Q @ Unipha ICH_ e` p~`a ipq~oa` qg`

Pcoq`a qbq`~#O b~k`a }g`c qg`y qgipmgq qgo~ }ipha

gbzz`c bca qg`y ~boa qgbq oq }ipha e` hbq`uqgbq y`bu '5::0/ iu qg` c`wq# Qg`y }`u`CIQ ^PU@ bca }`u` ichy mp`~~ocm b~ qi}gy qg`y }`u` qg`u`# Qg`y ~boa qg` eohh~ gbaichy buuo|`a b `} }``k~ e`iu`( }gong inipu~` gba ubo~`a b mu`bq a`bh i npuoi~oqy

oc dbcy i qg` cbcnobh dbuk`q~#Bmboc( O ICH_ ^B] OC^OA@ IC@

NB^@# Qg`u` }`u` cpd`uip~ ~odohbu nb~`~(}gong O B^^PD@A }ipha e` hh`a qg` ~bd`}by( epq qgbq o~ BHH O AOU@NQH_ ^B]#

]` }`cq ebnk qi qg` in` bca nicnhpa`aipu ep~oc`~~#

}ohh#_ip gb|` b bcqb~qon }`e$~oq` bca }`

c``a diu` z`izh` hok` yip ipq qg`u` mo|ocmqg` }bucocm~ bca ~ipcaocm qg` khbwic nbhh#H`q p~ mbqg`u hok` Qoqbc~ bca ~qiud DipcqIhydzp~ qim`qg`u"

DB_ DOMGQ_ BCM@H^ K@@Z _IPCI] BCA BH]B_^" Dby qg` ~oh|`ungbhon` i qg` Gihy Muboh e` zhbn`a }oqgoc

yipu g`buq qi nbqng bhh qg` zi}`u( hi|` bcamubn` i qg` Occoq` Ubaobcq Nu`bqiu"

Eh`~~ocm~"^`bc$Ab|oa Diuqics@CA ^QIU_s

`wz`nqbqoic qgbq i|`u~`b~ miia~O ai ciq kci} }gy ~i dbcynhode ~q``zhy oc zuon` b~ qg` z`izh` bu` dbkocm ~png b mombcqonnicqocp`~# Qgbq( bca b c`} up~~ i|`u qgo~( epq qgbq o~ qg` ~qiuyqi ~qiu` qg` ipqzpq uid ipu mbb~ oq gbzz`c`a#}g`c qg` nuiz~ ~qbuq nidocm oc $O ``h qgbq qgo~ ociudbqoic gb~b ^`bh$b$D`bh }oqg hiq~ i ebm~ci} e``c |ocaonbq`a( b~ ichy b `}

qg`~` koca~ i miia~ }ipha h}``k~ bmi( qg` eubca c`} Gbdohqic mi pz oc zuon` }oqgoc dicqg~ b!2: eohh o~ ci} oc nounphbqoic( bcazuon`~ eu`bk qguipmg qi c`} gomoq GB^ B U@A QOCM@A A_@ bhh

]`u` ciq qg` ichy ic`~ }gibuipca qg` bn` zbuq~ bca ebnk iqg` oclbqoicbuy }iukipq $ }bqngqg` eohh( ichy ~homgqhy homgq`u qgbcbhh i qg` P^ aihhbu bca qg` zuoqg` u`a ay` O ~b} ic qg` P^Amiha bca ~oh|`u b~ k`y ocaonbqi!2::~#}gbq~ qi nid`#Dy QG@IU_ o~ qgbq qg` P^

`nicidy o~ beipq qi mi ocqi u``^giuqbm`^ bg`babhh bca `cq`u b zuocqocm zu`~~^q`|` Rpbyh` }b~ koca `cipm`nicidy( b~ O gb|` zu`aonq`a( bca

~gbu` b h`qq`u uid ic` i go~ u`bO ``h qgbq o~ gbzz`cocm CI]# Bq}i$qo`u`a npuu`cny( fp~q b~ Fbzbc

aoa oc qg` 2?7:~( }ipha bhhi} qg`d qigyz`u$oclbq` qg` aihhbu g`u` bq gid`( bcak``z qg` aihhbu diu` ~qbeh`( bmboc~q qg`@pui( i|`u~`b~#

Bh~i( h`q~ ~by qg`y zb~~ b hb} qgbq ~by~yip nbc ichy p~` U@AEBNK^ ipq~oa` qg`P^B( bca qgbq bhh iqg`u P^A~ }ohh e`nid`LOBQ oc( ~by( 25: aby~# Di~q `~qodbq`~ zpqohh`mbh P^A~( eiqg nipcq`u`oq bca aupmdic`y ipq~oa` qg` P^B bq beipq !2::eohhoic# Nbc yip odbmoc` z`izh` }oqg gpm`bdipcq~ i NB^G miocm ocqi ebck~ qiquba` oq oc iu C@] U@AEBNK^9

Qg`y }ipha e` zgiqimubzg`a(cm`uzuocq`a( iu zi~~oehy buu`~q`a# Oq d`bc~qgbq qgo~ dic`y }ipha AU_ PZ( bca fp~qao~bzz`bu( bca \OIHB" Qg` L`a U`~`u|`Ciq` ~paa`chy e`nid`~ qgbq dpng DIU@|bhpbeh` }oqgipq bciqg`u ~ocmh` zo`n` izbz`u e`ocm zuocq`a#

Bmboc( O bd ichy quyocm qi zui|oa`ociudbqoic qi qg` }iuha bca dy `hhi}dbc( bca gb|` ci u`bh |`~q`a ocq`u`~q ocipqnid`~# ^i ai }oqg bhh i qgo~ }gbq yip

Diuqic~ u`ziuq dby d`bcbcy cpde`u il qgocm~6

& Lou~q( oq nipha d`bc qgbq qg` P^ gb~bc `d`um`cny zhbc oc zhbn` qi odzi~`q}i$qo`u`a npuu`cny oc qg` `|`cq i b u`bh~gink qi qg` P^ `nicidy# O }` gba bgpm` q`uuiuo~q `|`cq }oqgoc ipu eiua`u~( iu`wbdzh`( mhiebh nica`cn` oc qg` P^ aihhbub~ qg` u`~`u|` npuu`cny domgq e` ~gbk`c qi~png bc `wq`cq qgbq b c`} npuu`cny ipq~oa`qg` P^ '}oqg ao`u`cq zpungb~ocm zi}`u/}ipha e` b p~`ph zihony qiih#

&Bhicm qg` ~bd` hoc`~( b db~~o|`nihhbz~` i qg` P^ `nicidon ~y~q`d pca`uoq~ i}c }`omgq domgq bh~i e` b nbp~` iu bq}i$qo`u`a npuu`cny#

& ]` bh~i c``a qi ciq` qgbq qg` npuu`cny~y~q`d oq~`h domgq nid` pca`u bqqbnk uidic` iu diu` uimp` ~qbq`~ ~``kocm qi a`~quiyqg` P^ npuu`cny ey ~odzhy zuocqocm oq pz}gih`~bh`# ]`|` ~``c u`ziuq~ qgbq CiuqgKiu`b( iu ic`( dby e` `cmbmocm oc hbum`~nbh` nipcq`u`oqocm iz`ubqoic~# Qgo~ o~

zbuqonphbuhy ~omconbcq e`nbp~` qg` oc|ih|`a }`u` !2:: eohh~"

O b hbum`$~nbh` npuu`cny ngbcm` o~ ocpqpu`( Oa e`q qgbq oq }ohh e` bmboc~oclbqoicbuy ebnkmuipca# Qgbq e`ocm qg`u` bu` ~`|`ubh qgocm~ qg` ~dbhh oc|`fp~q$u`mphbu$gpdbc nbc ai# Bnnpdb miia gid` ~pzzhy i iia( zpq oc i}c mbua`c( qgbq ~iuq i qgocm( ~i

yiphh e` beh` qi u`~qubocq zuon` ocnu`b~qg` muin`uy ~qiu` ey ~pzzh`d`cqocm gzuon`a iia }oqg zu`|oip~hy zpungb~`gid` mui}c#

Bciqg`u qbnk6 @hboc` bca O }ohh e` qba`ho|`uy i ipu c`} Fbzbc`~`$epohq qub

hbq`u qgo~ }``k eb~`a ic dy z`u~

beipq qg` npuu`cq mb~ihoc` ~giuqoc b nipzh` i k`y @b~q`uc ~qbq`~

]` ~qohh gb|` mb~ ~giuqbm`~ oc qg` i nhi~`a zpdz~ g`u` oc qg` Qoa`}bq`ubu`b# Qg`u` bu` bh~i b cpde`u i ebmqg` ao`~`h zpdz~# Qg`u` o~ ci `qgbcao`~`h# Qgo~( a`~zoq` BDBNI gb~ b u`bzzuiwodbq`hy 50 bou doh`~ uid }O ~oq# Qgo~ u`c`uy o~ nbhh`a qg` BDBMobcq u`c`uy; fp~qobehy ~i#

Ic Luoaby( qg` 52~q( O z u~icbhhymb~ hoc`~ qgbq }`u` bu` eba b~ bcy apqg` Bube Ioh @debumi# Ic ^bqpuaby55ca( O gba b ngbcn` qi gb|` bc oc anic|`u~bqoic }oqg bc oca`z`ca`cq qup

}gi gba qgui}c oc qg` qi}`h# ^g` }q`bd auo|`u bca ~boa qgbq diu` bca doca`z`ca`cq~ nbcciq e`bu c`oqg`u qg`ni~q~# O d`cqoic`a qg` qihh ~oqpbqoic bcauihh`a g`u `y`~ oc up~qubqoic#

Zh`b~` zb~~ qgo~ qi yipu bpao`cn`#^g` ~boa qgbq oc 5 }``k~( }`]IPHA ~qbuq ~``ocm qg` e`moccocm~i ~giuqbm`~ bzz`bu ic qg` ~qiu`~g`h|`~#

\ih#OW(O~ ~p` .22= Fphy 5:( 5::< BA '57 EO( E`liu` Oddbcp`hhb Aby il Bzz`bubcn`/ Zbm` 2= il 22 NLU 2:>#252'b/'=/'oo/( qg` P#^# z`u~ic ocnhpa`~( B z`u~ic iqg`u bc ocao|oapbh '~png b~ b niuziubqoic( zbuq

~goz( iu qup~q/( qgbq o~ ~qbeho~g`a iu iumbcpca`u qg` hb}~ i b qbq` iu qg` Pcoq`a qb^i }goh` qg` P#^# z`u~ic ai`~ gb|` qinhi~` b qbwzby`u oa`cqolnbqoic cpde`u( qo~ ci u`rpou`d`cq qgbq bc ocao|oapbh }g~omcocm ic e`gbh i b h`mbh `cqoqy bh~i gb|ao~nhi~` go~ i}c ^^C# ]`u` ~i p~ a qibpqidbqonbhhy zui|oaocm qg` cpde`u qi ic` }gi b~k~ qgbq }` hi~` ~omgq i qg` bnqqgo~ o~ p~pbhhy ciq ebnk`a ey b h`mbh u`rpd`cq( epq oc~q`ba ey ni`unoic( z``u zu`~bca ~id`qod`~ `|`c ipq$bca$ipq ubpa#

Qg` zui`~~oicbh~ bq Liuqu`~~ Zui

qoic ^`u|on`~ }ohh g`hz yip ~`q pz zuiq``cqoqo`~ ~png b~ hodoq`a hobeohoqy nidzb'HHN~/( hodoq`a hobeohoqy zbuqc`u~goz~ 'HHhodoq`a hobeohoqy hodoq`a zbuqc`u~goz~ 'HHHhodoq`a hobeohoqy qup~q~ 'HHQ~/( niuziubq'ocnhpaocm iu$zuilq niuziubqoic~( ciczniuziubqoic~( bca niuziubqoic~ ~ih`/# qgipmg qg` nidzbcy o~ dbcbm`a ey bcnu`aoq`a bnnipcqbcq '}gi nbc bh~i zuiqubaoqoicbh bnnipcqocm ~`u|on`~( iu qgi~

yip }gi bu` ocq`u`~q`a/( qg`y bu` ciq qg` ~b~ yipu hinbh NZB iu qbw bqqiuc`y e`nbp~`~z`nobhov` oc ~`npuocm zuo|bny bca b~~`q q`nqoic# I nipu~`( iu qgi~` i yip }gi

qg` c``a( ~`qqocm pz qg`~` qyz`~ i `cqoqo`~omcolnbcqhy u`apn` yipu qbw`~( epq qgbq~icabuy }oqg qg`d# Qg`ou zuodbuy mibh zuiq`nq qg` b~~`q~ qgbq yip gb|`( e`nbp~` kci} qgbq yipu lu~q mibh o~ qi zu`~`u|` }

yip bhu`bay gb| # ^i o yipu` ~`uoip~ bh`bucocm gi} qi iz`ubq` }oqgipq b ~inobnpuoqy cpde`u( qg`c qgo~ o~ b ~`u|on` qga`lcoq`hy iu yip# O }ohh ci hicm`u iz`ubq`iqg`u }by#

Qg`ou ociudbqoic o~ qii miia qi mo|` bbca ~i qg`y ichy a`bh }oqg nho`cq~ ic b ic$ic` eb~o~ ey bzziocqd`cq ichy# Qi

ipq diu`( zh`b~` nbhh 2$0:0 0 12

8/14/2019 S.E.C. v. Morton: Delphi Associates Newsletter

19/20

$$

Q G @ A @ H Z G O B I N O BQ @ C @ ] H @ Q Q @ U

B qup~q ~gipha e`qg` zuodbuy nidzic`cq

i yipu `~qbq` zhbce`nbp~`6

YB }ohh o~ `~~`cqobhhy yip mo|ocm oc~qupnqoic~ qi qg` zuiebq` nipuq ic gi} yip }bcqyipu `~qbq` ao~quoepq`a( epq }oqg b qup~q( yipnbc nidzh`q`hy b|ioa zuiebq # Zuiebq` o~ ciqichy `wz`c~o|` bca qod`$

qi nidz`h g`u qi h`b| zuiz`uqy qi g`u# ]gbqo ~g` u`dbuuo`~9 ]gbq o ~g` hi~`~ qipng }oqg

yipu ngohau`c9 Qg`~` bu`cq zh`b~bcq qizon~( epqiu dbcy z`izh` qg`y bu` u`bh zi~~oeohoqo`~#

YBhqgipmg b ho|ocm qup~q ciudbhhy ai`~cqzui|oa` bcy ho`qod` b~~`q zuiq`nqoic( }` nbcn`uqoy qg` qup~q b~ b A`hb}bu` hodoq`a hobeohoqyqup~q 'HHQ/# Qgo~ eiqg zui|oa`a b hby`u i b~~`qzuiq`nqoic( `|`c }goh` yipu` bho|` bca b e`c

`lnobuy i qg` qup~q `~qbq`( bca nbc aub} hoqomb

nic~pdocm( epq oq~ bh~i ic`hb~q ngbcn` iu yipu nu`ao qg` qup~q `~qbq` u`dboc~

i}c`u a`~zoq` qg` zb~~ocmqiu~ qi u`bng yipu b~~`q~# Qg`}by zuiebq` }iuk~ o~ lu~q qg` qup~q`` iu e`c`lnobuy# Oc~

nipuq zby~ i nu`aoqiu~ i qg` yip nbc cbd` b ~pnqup~q`` qi qbk` i|`u iu yia`n`a`cq( qg`c oq zby~ nu`ao

qiu~ i qg` g`ou~( bca qg`c qg` }`hh b~ cbdocm yipu lcbh

g`ou~ m`q bcy u`dbococm ebh `lnobuo`~#

bcn` ipquomgq# Apubeh` zi}`ui bqqiuc`y bu` qY]oqg b qup~q( qg`u` o~ ci

zuiebq`( ~i qg`u`~ ci iupd

c`wq `h`d`cq6iu yipu nu`aoqiu~ qi b~~`uq Y B apubeh` zi}qg`ou nhbod~# bqqiuc`y z`udoq~ yip qi c~id`ic`( iu b ~`uo`~ i z`

Y]oqg b }ohh( yip nbc }gi nbc dbk` g`bhqgnbu`zuiq`nq qg` qup~q b~~`q~ uid lcbcnobh a`no~oic~ iu yinhbod~ i yipu e`c`lnobuo`~ qg` `|`cq yip e`nid` h`nu`aoqiu~# _ip nbc bh~i zu`$ ocnbzbnoqbq`a( epq }oq|`cq ipquomgq ao~quoepqoic~ yipu bdohy gb|ocm qi ocoqqi e`c`lnobuo`~ }gid yip nipuq$badoco~q`u`a nic~``h dby ciq e` nidz`q`cq qigbcah` qg` dic`y iu zuiz`uqy# Oc~q`ba( oq nbc e` dbcbm`a iu qg`d ey qg`qup~q``~( bca qg` qup~q`` nbc e` ~id`ic` }gid

yip a`~omcbq` ci}#

YB nu`aoq ~g`hq`u qup~q nbc e` ocnhpa`a ocyipu qup~q ~i b~ qi nideoc` yipu z`u~icbh `~qbq` qbw w`dzqoic }oqg qgbq i yipu ~zip~`( bhhi}ocm yip qi aipeh` qg` |bhp` i zuiz`uqy yipnbc h`mbhhy h`b|` qi yipu e`c`lnobuo`~ `cqou`hyu`` i qbw#

Y]oqg b ho|ocm qup~q( yipu e`c`lnobuo`~ aicqgb|` qi hi~` qg` ~q`zz`a$pz eb~o~( }gong bhhi}~qg`ou eb~o~ qi e` qg` bou dbuk`q |bhp` 'LD\/i qg` e`rp`bqg`a zuiz`uqy bq qg` qod` i yipuzb~~ocm#

YOc qg` `|`cq yipu` oc b ~`nica dbuuobm`(iu yip bca yipu ~zip~` iqg`u}o~` gb|` ao`u`cq g`ou~( yip nbc zui|oa` qgbq qg` ~pu|o|ocm~zip~` }ohh gb|` b ho` `~qbq` oc qg` qup~q `~qbq`~(epq bh~i cbd` lcbh e`c`lnobuo`~ ci}# Qgo~ o~nbhh`a b RQOZ qup~q( iu rpbhol`a q`udocbeh`zuiz`uqy qup~q# Oc nicqubao~qocnqoic qi qgo~( oyip p~` b }ohh bca cbd` yipu ~zip~` b~ yipug`ou( ~g` }ohh e` qg` ~ih` i}c`u i qg` zuiz`uqy bca yipu ngohau`c }ohh gb|` ci u`nipu~`

yipu cbd`( }` nbc zui|oa` iu b |`uy ~ozuiebq` ey zui|oaocm qgbq qg` qup~q``~ iqup~q }ohh e` yipu ~ih` g`ou~# Qgo~ qyz` io~ nbhh`a b zipui|`u }ohh bca o yip gbgb|` zuiebq`( qgo~ o~ qg` ~odzh`~q zuiebq`~oeh`# Zuiebq` o~ c`n`~~buy e`nbp~`( }g`cgb|` qoqh` qi zuiz`uqy( ichy yip nbc ai bcy}oqg oq( }g`qg`u qgbq bnqoic e` ~`hhocm oq( dmbmocm oq( h`b~ocm oq( `qn# Epq o yip zb~~ qg`c yip ie|oip~hy nbcq bnq# G`cn` yipu

gb|` qi zuiebq` yipu ~qbq`# Ic qg` iqg`u go zuiz`uqy o~ g`ha oc qup~q(

qoic ocqi A`hb}bu`# A`hb}bu` o~ qg` ichy ~qbq`qgbq gb~ b ~z`nobhov`a ngbcn`uy nipuq }gongichy g`bu~ ao~zpq`~ u`mbuaocm A`hb}bu` qup~q~

bca `cqoqo`~# I|`u gbh i bhh zpehonhy$quba`aniuziubqoic~( ocnhpaocm 07% i qg` Liuqpc`0::( bu` ocniuziubq`a oc A`hb}bu` e`nbp~`qg`y kci} qgo~ nipuq }ohh zuiq`nq qg`d# ]oqgqiaby~ ipq$i$nicquih fpaonobuy( oq~ ichy qg`zi}`u i nidz`qoqoic qgbq zuiq`nq~ qg` hoqqh`mpy# O qg` A`hb}bu` Ngbcn`uy Nipuq ~q`z~ ipqi hoc`( qg`c z`izh` }ohh ~qiz lhocm oc A`hb}bu`#]oqg iqg`u nipuq~( yip gb|` hoqqh` u nipu~`# ^iqg` eiqqid hoc` o~ qgbq( o yip gb|` qi hoqombq`(

yipu e`~q ngbcn` iu b bou u`~ihpqoic }oqg b fpam` }gi }ohh qbk` yipu qup~q ~`uoip~hy o~ oc

A`hb}bu`#

Qg` c`wq nidzic`cqi qg` `~qbq` zhbc ~gipha e`

b }ohh e`nbp~`6

YQg` }ohh o~ qg` ichy oc~qupd`cq qgbq bhhi}~yip qi cbd` b mpbuaobc iu yipu dociu ngohau`c( bca###

YOc qg` `|`cq bcy zuiz`uqy u`dboc~ qoqh`a oc

qiu~goz# B nic~ u|bqiu~gobhhy o~cq b miia qgocm e`

oq~ wz`c~o| ( oq~ qod`$nic~pdocm( oq nid`q`uuoeh` qod` 'o~ qg`u` `|`u b miia qod` qi

nipuq9/( bca qg` nic~`u|bqiu gb~ qi z`uoiau`ziuq ebnk qi qg` nipuq( }gong i nipu~` `|`c diu` dic`y#

YBhqgipmg oq~ ciq b zh`b~bcq qizon( ocapubeh` zi}`u yip nbc dbk` zui|o~oic~ ic`ubh( epuobh( iu iqg`u d`diuobh~ bca ao~qoic~ i yipu u`dboc~# Oq~ |`uy gbua iu i p~ qi qbhk qi ipu bdohy beipq qgo~( epq qg` apubeh` zi}`u i bqqiuc`y( yip nbc d

yipu }o~g`~ kci}c oc }uoqocm bca qg` }icq gb|` qi e` baau`~~`a bmboc pcqoh qg`nid`~#

Qg` lcbh nidzic`cq i qg` `~qbq` zhbcnic~`u|bqiu~goz ainpd`cq# Qgo~ o~ odziqi gb|` e`nbp~`( oc qg` `|`cq yipu bdohygb|` qi mi qi nipuq( yip }ohh bq h`b~q gb|` d

yipu }o~g`~ kci}c qi qg`d#Liu qgi~` }gi }bcq b gomg`u h`|`h i

zuiq`nqoic( oq~ zi~~oeh` qi ~`q pz `cqoqo`~ b~ hodoq`a hobeohoqy nidzbco`~ 'HHN~/( hodzbuqc`u~goz~ 'HZ~/( bca `|`c hodoq`a hobhodoq`a zbuqc`u~goz~ 'HHHZ~/# _ipu ~gbuqg`~` `cqoqo`~ nbc oc qpuc e` g`ha oc qg` qup

\ih#OW(O~ ~p` .22= Fphy 5:( 5::< BA '57 EO( E`liu` Oddbcp`hhb Aby il Bzz`bubcn`/ Zbm` 2? il 2