search for dark matter axions with madmax · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes lsw a d m x...

48
Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX Dark Side of the Universe, Buenos Aires 15-19/07/19 Christian Strandhagen

Upload: others

Post on 25-Apr-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAXDark Side of the Universe, Buenos Aires 15-19/07/19

Christian Strandhagen

Page 2: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

2

Dark Matter Candidates

FUZZYDark Matter

10-24 10-18

adapted from xkcd.com/2035

2

Page 3: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

3

Dark Matter Candidates

FUZZYDark Matter

10-24 10-18

adapted from xkcd.com/2035

gravitinos

2

Page 4: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

4

Dark Matter Candidates

FUZZYDark Matter

10-24 10-18

adapted from xkcd.com/2035

gravitinos

2

Page 5: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

5

Dark Matter Candidates

FUZZYDark Matter

10-24 10-18

adapted from xkcd.com/2035

gravitinos

2

Page 6: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

6

Page 7: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

7

The QCD AxionThe QCD Lagrangian contains a CP-violating term

→ violates T and P and thus CP→ induces electric dipole moment (EDM) of neutron

experimentally: →

Why is θ so small? → Strong CP problem

4

Page 8: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

8

The QCD AxionThe solution: make θ a dynamical parameter by introducing a scalar field by adding a new U(1)PQ symmetry (Peccei-Quinn)

U(1)PQ spontaneously broken at high energy scale fa

θ minimum is degenerate→ arbitrary value chosen

G. Raffelt

5

Page 9: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

9

The QCD AxionThe solution: make θ a dynamical parameter by introducing a scalar field by adding a new U(1)PQ symmetry (Peccei-Quinn)

potential gets tilted duringQCD phase transition (T < 1 GeV)

field starts oscillating→ axion acquires mass

G. Raffelt

6

Page 10: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

10

The QCD AxionThe solution: make θ a dynamical parameter by introducing a scalar field by adding a new U(1)PQ symmetry (Peccei-Quinn)

potential gets tilted duringQCD phase transition (T < 1 GeV)

field starts oscillating→ axion acquires mass

G. Raffelt

6

Page 11: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

11

QCD Axion Dark Matter

Axions created in early universe through initial misalignment are good candidate for cold dark matter

7

Page 12: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

12

QCD Axion Dark Matter

Axions created in early universe through initial misalignment are good candidate for cold dark matter

7

Page 13: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

13

QCD Axion Dark Matter

Axions created in early universe through initial misalignment are good candidate for cold dark matter

astrophysical bounds

7

Page 14: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

14

QCD Axion Dark Matter

Axions created in early universe through initial misalignment are good candidate for cold dark matter

too much dark matter* astrophysical bounds*depends on the actual cosmology

7

Page 15: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

15

QCD Axion Dark Matter

Axions created in early universe through initial misalignment are good candidate for cold dark matter

too much dark matter* astrophysical bounds*depends on the actual cosmology

axion dark matter

7

Page 16: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

16

Axion Landscape

coup

ling

stre

ngth

(to

phot

ons)

gith

ub.c

om/c

ajoh

are/

Axio

nLim

its

Page 17: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

17

Axion Landscape

coup

ling

stre

ngth

(to

phot

ons)

QCD axion gith

ub.c

om/c

ajoh

are/

Axio

nLim

its

Axion-Like Particles ALPs

Page 18: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

18

Axion Landscape

coup

ling

stre

ngth

(to

phot

ons)

limits from

cosmology

gith

ub.c

om/c

ajoh

are/

Axio

nLim

its

QCD axion

Page 19: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

19

Axion Landscape

coup

ling

stre

ngth

(to

phot

ons)

limits from

cosmology

stellar evolution

astro-physics

gith

ub.c

om/c

ajoh

are/

Axio

nLim

its

QCD axion

Page 20: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

20

Axion Landscape

coup

ling

stre

ngth

(to

phot

ons)

limits from

cosmology

stellar evolution

astro-physics

helioscopes

LSW

gith

ub.c

om/c

ajoh

are/

Axio

nLim

its

QCD axion

Page 21: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

21

Axion Landscape

coup

ling

stre

ngth

(to

phot

ons)

limits from

cosmology

stellar evolution

astro-physics

helioscopes

LSW

AD

MX C

avit

y E

xp.

gith

ub.c

om/c

ajoh

are/

Axio

nLim

its

QCD axion

Page 22: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

22

Axion Landscape

coup

ling

stre

ngth

(to

phot

ons)

limits from

cosmology

stellar evolution

astro-physics

helioscopes

LSW

AD

MX

pro

ject

ed

gith

ub.c

om/c

ajoh

are/

Axio

nLim

its

QCD axion

Page 23: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

23

Axion Landscape

coup

ling

stre

ngth

(to

phot

ons)

limits from

cosmology

stellar evolution

astro-physics

helioscopes

LSW

AD

MX

pro

ject

ed

MA

DM

AX

p

roje

cte

d

gith

ub.c

om/c

ajoh

are/

Axio

nLim

its

QCD axion

Page 24: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

24

How to Detect Axions● axions are pseudo-scalar bosons (like pions)

and have a 2-photon-coupling:

● their de Broglie wavelength is large (O(m))→ we can treat them as classical wave→ axions appear as a source term in Maxwell’s equations

9

Page 25: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

25

How to Detect Axions

axion-induced electric field:

In an external B field Be the axion field a(t) sources an oscillating E field Ea

10

Page 26: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

26

Dielectric Haloscope

power emitted from single interface:

In an external B field Be the axion field a(t) sources an oscillating E field Ea

Ea is different in materials with different ε

At the surface, E|| must be continuous → emission of electromagnetic waves

Phys

. Rev

. D 8

8, 1

1500

2 (2

013)

11

Page 27: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

27

Dielectric Haloscope

power emitted from all interfaces:

● boost emitted power through– coherent emission from

multiple interfaces– resonance effects

● power boost factor

PRL

118,

091

801

(201

7)

12

Page 28: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

28

Dielectric Haloscope● |β|2 > 104 achievable with

80 disks and ε = 24

● non-uniform disk spacing of ~ λ/2 can achieve “broadband” response

● precision required for disk spacing < 10 µm

JCAP 061 (2017); arXiv:1612.07057

13

Page 29: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

29

Boost Factorfrequency is tuned by adjusting

disk spacings

area law: → broad-band scan for search → narrow-band to check signal candidates

14

Page 30: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

30

Proof of Principle SetupTest setup at MPP Munich

● up to 20 disks (Ø = 20 cm, ε ≈ 9)● reproducibility of positioning ~ µm

15

Page 31: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

31

Proof of Principle SetupTest setup at MPP Munich

● up to 20 disks (Ø = 20 cm, ε ≈ 9)● reproducibility of positioning ~ µm● compare reflectivity measurements

to model calculations

15

Page 32: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

32

Proof of Principle SetupTest setup at MPP Munich

● up to 20 disks (Ø = 20 cm, ε ≈ 9)● reproducibility of positioning ~ µm● compare reflectivity measurements

to model calculations● boost factor reproducible within

few MHz for 5 disks

15

Page 33: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

33

The MADMAX Collaboration

16

Page 34: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

34

MADMAXMAgnetized Disk and Mirror Axion EXperiment

EPJ C 79, 186 (2019) madmax.mpp.mpg.de

17

Page 35: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

35

MADMAX Timeline2017 – 2019

Design

EPJ

C 79

, 186

(201

9)

18

Page 36: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

36

Magnet

● design and construction of magnet drives time scale of project● peak field ~ 9 T, homogeneity < 20 %● dimensions of bore: length ~ 1 m, diameter ~ 1.5 m

block design with NbTi superconductor

19

Page 37: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

37

Magnet

● design and construction of magnet drives time scale of project● peak field ~ 9 T, homogeneity < 20 %● dimensions of bore: length ~ 1 m, diameter ~ 1.5 m

block design with NbTi superconductor

FoM = B2A = 100 T2 m2

has never been done before!

19

Page 38: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

38

Disks● requirements: high ε, low loss (tan δ)

→ candidate materials:– LaAlO3 (ε ≈ 24, tan δ ≈ few 10-5)– Sapphire (ε ≈ 9, tan δ ≈ 10-5)

● Ø = 1.25 m needed for 100 T2 m2

→ tiling necessary

● characterisation of dielectric properties @ 4K, f = 10-15 GHz ongoing

20

Page 39: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

39

Booster Simulation StudiesStudy achievable boost factor using different simulation methods to optimize design

● 3D effects (diffraction)● coupling to antenna

(beam shape)● dielectric loss● inaccuracies

(positioning, surface roughness, thickness)

● effects due to tiling● ...

→ ~30% loss (combined)

21

- idealized 1D model- 3D model with diffraction- 3D power coupled to antenna

Page 40: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

40

Booster Simulation StudiesStudy achievable boost factor using different simulation methods to optimize design

● 3D effects (diffraction)● coupling to antenna

(beam shape)● dielectric loss● inaccuracies

(positioning, surface roughness, thickness)

● effects due to tiling● ...

→ ~30% loss (combined)

→ small for tan δ < 10-4

21

Page 41: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

41

Booster Simulation StudiesStudy achievable boost factor using different simulation methods to optimize design

● 3D effects (diffraction)● coupling to antenna

(beam shape)● dielectric loss● inaccuracies

(positioning, surface roughness, thickness)

● effects due to tiling● ...

→ ~30% loss (combined)

→ small for tan δ < 10-4

→ tilt < 0.1 mrad thickness ± 5 µm sourface roughness < 10 µm positioning < 10 µm

21

Page 42: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

42

Booster Simulation StudiesStudy achievable boost factor using different simulation methods to optimize design

● 3D effects (diffraction)● coupling to antenna

(beam shape)● dielectric loss● inaccuracies

(positioning, surface roughness, thickness)

● effects due to tiling● ...

→ ~30% loss (combined)

→ small for tan δ < 10-4

→ tilt < 0.1 mrad thickness ± 5 µm sourface roughness < 10 µm positioning < 10 µm

More on the methods: arXiv:1906.02677

21

Page 43: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

43

MADMAX Timeline2017 – 2019

Design2019 – 2022Prototype

first steps:● build an intermediate-scale

prototype of booster to test mechanics, receiver, …

● put it in an existing magnet● do some physics

EPJ

C 79

, 186

(201

9)

22

Page 44: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

44

Prototype Sensitivity - ALPs

MADMAXPrototype

Axion-like Particle Search:with less and smaller disks and lower B-field (~ 3T)→ don’t reach QCD axion sensitivitybutexplore new parameter space for ALPs

EPJ

C 79

, 186

(201

9)

23

Page 45: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

45

Sensitivity – Hidden Photons

MADMAXPrototype

Hidden photon searchhidden photon mixes with normal photon→ conversion doesn’t require magnetic field

EPJ

C 79

, 186

(201

9)

24

Page 46: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

46

MADMAX Timeline2017 – 2019

Design2019 – 2022Prototype

2022 – 2025Construction

2025 – 2035Data taking

EPJ

C 79

, 186

(201

9)

25

Page 47: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

47

Experimental Siteplanned to be built at DESY in HERA Hall North→ use existing cryogenic infrastructure→ option to re-use H1 yoke to shield magnet

26

Page 48: Search for Dark Matter Axions with MADMAX · 2019. 7. 19. · astro-physics helioscopes LSW A D M X p r o j e c t e d M A D M A X p r o j e c t e d g i t h u b. c o m / c a j o h

48

Projected Sensitivity

MADMAX

EPJ

C (2

019)

79:

186

27

CAPP projection