se ) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u jo aql puadap (uqq 0...

8
t I#!M (,I alqe,~ u! S E) aa!oqa s!qjo a m p aqi ie % p u e “u ‘sJaldops sno+d JO Jaqtunu aql uodn puadap (uqq 0) a[qe1!t?At? d%olouq3a, aq)~o UO!SJaA 2~ J O an[eA ,uasaJd &Xl aql) ,U>& he hq pXX[I?X 8 J O v 8U!SOOq3 01 SUJI,]aJ 2~. )Eq] %U$NW liq SXB3 XaqJ apII[ZW! 1 ‘~UIZlSUO3 9JE SUJl-i)aJ J!aqJ - uoydop; Aq pW-ta~l3Un aJt? Sa$OlOUq3al WJOS pUV 'alqt?l!nS SSal pile Ja3JIeM aWOJ1Q;' Sa)!SUIepSE l([JSO3 aJOUJ SaUlO3aq ‘a~dwlexaJO~‘JaMod >!Jl>ala-OJp,iH *uo!ldo@; Luedmox>e suJnlaJ iiu!qs!u!uup ieql OS aD!Jd u! pJeMdn p!q are qndu! JOI+ saw!~awO~ wogdope q,!M SuJn)aJ ~+?~.JNJ! AOfua sa!%[Ouq3al 11" JON t ( *su yadop$ aJn)nJAq pa~~a~eos[eaJes~~ol(ed aJaqMaswsuo!lei~adxaaql au!uulexa~ Jalqf^l *XBo~ouq~al uasoqr, s!q JO suopdopa wed 6q @IO paw&e s! &oXed s!q letp, OS ‘a3!oq3Jo aury s!q ie uB!sap u! U~ZOJJ ~0 paxy s! sasooq3 lua& q3wg~of JO uo!sJaA aqL .aD!oqs J!aql lnd II!M daql q>!qM 01 asn aqllo asnwaq sdaq& 'sa3uaJaJaJd .r!ayJ u! Bu!JJ~,JJ!~ inq a3!oq350 saw!1 aqj~o luapuadapu! Sadhlot& aqi ‘qzwa II! sJaqwnu pznba ql!M's pur! 21 'sadh OMIJO aJe swa%y S'JalJaaJd uo!sJaA srqi sasn aq pue !g XBolouq3al Jo v Gh~ouq3ai Jaql!a jo uo& lsaiel aql sasooq:, aq atug s!ql le 1'1 at.u!i v2 ialJr?iu aql oiu! sawo3! iua8v *tuaqlJo sraddpA+ s e r([lDaJ!pu! J o &ta.up 138 oqM sa@o[ouqw aq~ JO sJawnsuo3 aldu+s ?JE siua8v *[pz 01 uado aJe Laql !tuJy he ,iq palelnd!usw I(~le$a~aJis~o ~WNIO& IOU ala sa!8o[ouq3al aqL wua%? 3$uouona JO Jaqwnu aSJe[ e hq uoydopa JOT la~adwo~, ‘8 pur? y 'sa!8olouq3al Mau OM) leql [apow aldlu!s 'ley!u! UB u! auxnsse put? s!ql a~ysase3 UIOJJ )3eJ)sqt? 1 *sa!~o~ouqsaluo3!~!s-snoqdJomeJo uo3!1!s-augle)sdJ3 dq pawJauai3 aq ue3 GIJaua ~elos 5JoI3eaJ paIoo3-uuu~J0 ‘Ja~eM-~A~aq~o‘pa~oo3-se~Jo‘Ja~sm-~q8!~ Aq paieJaua8aq ue:,JaModJeaI3n~ 7aaon ZildHllS v .I d ~~ldo~ouq331 JO!J?jU! lIEJO I(~odouom aql 0) ‘SlU3A~ leJ!Jolslq, r(q ui-paq3q . . . . . . . aUlO3aCl ,l~i+JJ kUOUO3;, dql q.NqM 1apUn S~3u1!1SlUtl.~J!.) aql 0) put! !~1!3!?0&~ pue ‘Al!I!q!xalj 'r(;>ua!.,yfa '/(,![!qewpaJtl ,JJ.Ijl! SIIJIIlJJ Awq 0 1 UO!lU?ll~ le!Dads sAed 11 'suJn)aJ )ut?)suo3 p u a Idu!qs!u!~u!~) 'Idu!sed~3u! JO suo!l!puoo Japun csaJeqs iaqJvw, sa@olouq3al J O sn!luaukp aq, SISBJIUO~ Jaded s!qL ' *awo3ino ay3 apr3ap r(etu I(aqi-s+ueuAp aq1 4 ~IJCWO8JOJ, put? r(VMt? pa%?JaAE )OU dJe ,SIUaAl ~[W.lS, [E3!JOlSfi 1eq1 U! li~~~~pofl’sHlou pue !‘ u! pal301, aJow dldA!swJYoJd sawo3aq i! a8Jawaol su$iaq (kiolouq3a) lueu!luope) awo3ino ue a.~uowql u! h?~l,~~!xa&z:SapJadoJd Mau OMI d n iu!od asp? iqP!w qJeoJdde ~!un:ui(p \r *la!iuawd unJ-Suol Jo!JaJu! seq lleql ,@olouq3al e ihqdopAapo$u! ss.woJd uo!ldope aql aA!Jplq+u LIX NJ-X301 CINV S3IOO-IONH3lI.I. :)NI.L3dR03 [6861 HDaVJ’&j MnlaJ h!seaJ3uy moq pue .‘ aUJo3ln0la$Jam, aql WpaJd 01 aBy.Jns IOU At?ur ag![!q!sSod ,sa@olouq331 atg pua sa3JaJajaJd ‘sJa,dope J O a8paIMOu~ I]UD-x3 Eflql os'a3eId aqel suogdopearauaAa azweqa AJ$~LI 0133~ suJnlaJ 8u!seamy fiooq :inoqe auJo3 hcwfn@uj pyu& pue fi(tpqDKywd-uou JO SagJadoJd sumi .%u!s"aJ~u!~le!1!~'90~3 aql moq IeaAaJos~a lq%!w 11 .Jaqloue spJem0~ ~!aApp 01 SJaqlo ‘3tUO31nO ~l~qS-~3~leUJ au0 SpJEMol ssaDoJd aql aA!Jp 0) alapNun3 II&U ,sluaAa le~!Jorqq, wopu~J~ocn3s awes moq atuo3lno aqljo ,uo!Va1aS, Wanyu! asaql MOq aU!UJEXa lq@IJJ l! 'uoydopv @Jnp 8U!JJn330 ,SluaAa ,u~opue.l,~o kl!I!q!swd aq) 8u!~olle kg 'aJ0I.u des 01 a[qe aq jq%!w qzn?oJdde 'qu~zul(p v *cpa13*3s,aq ll!M au0 pym sn llal louue:, l! dllensn inq ‘eyqg!nba ,Idppw asaql alwol @D!dh uw s!sLlaue 3!1els .aJaq Jeadde plnoqs ou1o3)no ald!qnw ,eq~ %+!JdJnS IOU s! I! OS pue ‘e!Jqg!nba aldgntu l!q!qxa 01 pua$ suJnlaJ %U~S?KWU! qa!~ SwalqoJd uopwo~p? wq, UMOU~ IlaM s! 11 : *saruowno pzguaaod aldglnw aAeq Leu.~ sa$iolouqzw uaaMwq suo!~padtu~ t %twu~ux~p 01 auxo3 OI lucw.I~AoJdm! put? uogdope luapyjns aAa!qzie lqii!m '#01ouq3al 1uaJagp e - e33uewutn3q3 ~a3pqod ‘sJado(aAap AfJea J O EW!Z(M k&oloJd J O awauuo~ad aq, u! sassa33ns pa)Dadxaun --,swaAa ~~a~y!u%~ -u!, waJaJ!p Japun ‘agIno JO *Ino pay301 Bu!luo2aq sa@olouq3a1 Jaq30 ql qJ!M ‘slaldopa la!lU~Wd~O ,l?y~JeuJ aql JaUJO:), ~l~"nlUaA3 ~t3LU uo!ldope UI peal dlJea UB sup8 +utq3 Aq aeql r(8olouq3a, e snq& *paAoJduI! JaqaJnJ &a paldopeJaq]JnJawoB?q aJoJaJaq1 Xau111 waldope le!lualodlo uo!lJodoJd ~2pp!meol l"adde~eurl!os'slaqloaq) ueqlaJowaAoJdw!uaql~em k%[OUqaal s!qL*suo!,dopa u! a%vweApa la!~!u! ue waqlJoauo aA!% aDuvq3 r(q ketu SwaAa ~uez1y!u4!su! %Jaldope [epunod~o~ iaq.n?w ,e~oj'uaq, 6a3adwo3,sa!8010uq3al UJnlaJ-8U!SV?al3U! a.tou1 J o oM3 uaqM ;paAoJdtu! aJe kaql aJouI aql put? 'may1 ql!M pau@ s! a3uyJ3dxa ~JOUI aql 'paldope JJI? daql 3JoLu aql leql u! uo!ldopv 01 suJnaaJ %U!~KLI~U! I(aldsyp ua]Jo s@o~ouq3at xalduroa ‘uJapoH .uo!ldopt? JOJ &1!aadu103 sa!80~0Uq331 UaaMJaq Pu!sooq3 Slua8e :AllaJnleu as!Je suJnWJ Bu!saaJ3u! aJ3qM 1xaluo3 S u! suJwaJ Bu!saaJw! Japun uopwo~p? JO s~!urwAp aql SaJoldxa Jaded S!q.L e &.LN3h3 ?V3I~O~LSIH AB NI-X301 tINV ‘SNlIII.LYX 3NISV2IX3NI ‘S3IIWIONH33LL 3NI,L:4Jl’lO03

Upload: doduong

Post on 12-Jul-2019

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SE ) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u JO aql puadap (uqq 0 ...blackout.gmu.edu/archive/pdf/arthur89.pdf · t I#!M (,I alqe,~ u! SE) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u ‘ sJaldops

t

I#!M (,I alqe,~ u! S E) aa!oqa s!qjo a m p aqi ie % p u e “u ‘sJaldops sno+dJO Jaqtunu aql u o d n puadap (uqq 0) a[qe1!t?At? d%olouq3a, aq)~o UO!SJaA 2~

J O an[eA ,uasaJd &Xl aql) ,U>& he hq pXX[I?X 8 J O v 8U!SOOq3 01 SUJI,]aJ 2~.

)Eq] %U$NW liq SXB3 XaqJ apII[ZW! 1 ‘~UIZlSUO3 9JE SUJl-i)aJ J!aqJ - uoydop;Aq pW-ta~l3Un aJt? Sa$OlOUq3al WJOS pUV 'alqt?l!nS SSal pile Ja3JIeM aWOJ1Q;'Sa)!SUIepSE l([JSO3 aJOUJ SaUlO3aq ‘a~dwlexaJO~‘JaMod >!Jl>ala-OJp,iH *uo!ldo@;Luedmox>e suJnlaJ iiu!qs!u!uup ieql OS aD!Jd u! pJeMdn p!q a r e qndu! JOI+

saw!~awO~ wogdope q,!M SuJn)aJ ~+?~.JNJ! AOfua sa!%[Ouq3al 11" JON t( *su yadop$

aJn)nJAq pa~~a~eos[eaJes~~ol(ed aJaqMaswsuo!lei~adxaaql au!uulexa~ Jalqf^l

*XBo~ouq~al uasoqr, s!q JO s u o p d o p a w e d 6q @IO paw&e s! &oXed s!q letp,OS ‘a3!oq3Jo aury s!q ie uB!sap u! U~ZOJJ ~0 p a x y s! sasooq3 lua& q3wg~ofJ O uo!sJaA aqL .aD!oqs J!aql lnd II!M daql q>!qM 01 asn aqllo asnwaq sdaq&'sa3uaJaJaJd .r!ayJ u! Bu!JJ~,JJ!~ inq a3!oq350 saw!1 aqj~o luapuadapu! Sadhlot&aqi ‘qzwa II! sJaqwnu pznba ql!M's pur! 21 'sadh OMIJO aJe swa%y S'JalJaaJduo!sJaA srqi s a s n aq p u e !g XBolouq3al J o v Gh~ouq3ai Jaql!a j o uo&lsaiel aql sasooq:, aq atug s!ql le 1'1 at.u!i v2 ialJr?iu aql oiu! sawo3! iua8v

*tuaqlJo sraddpA+s e r([lDaJ!pu! J o &ta.up 138 oqM sa@o[ouqw aq~ JO sJawnsuo3 aldu+s ?JEsiua8v *[pz 01 u a d o aJe Laql !tuJy he ,iq palelnd!usw I(~le$a~aJis~o ~WNIO&IOU ala sa!8o[ouq3al aqL wua%? 3$uouona JO Jaqwnu aSJe[ e hq uoydopaJOT la~adwo~, ‘8 pur? y 'sa!8olouq3al Mau OM) leql [apow aldlu!s 'ley!u! UBu! auxnsse put? s!ql a~ysase3 UIOJJ )3eJ)sqt? 1 *sa!~o~ouqsaluo3!~!s-snoqdJomeJouo3!1!s-augle)sdJ3 dq pawJauai3 aq ue3 GIJaua ~elos 5JoI3eaJ paIoo3-uuu~J0‘Ja~eM-~A~aq~o‘pa~oo3-se~Jo‘Ja~sm-~q8!~ Aq paieJaua8aq ue:,JaModJeaI3n~

7aaon ZildHllS v .I

d~~ldo~ouq331 JO!J?jU! lIEJO I(~odouom aql 0) ‘SlU3A~ leJ!Jolslq, r(q ui-paq3q. . . . . . .

aUlO3aCl ,l~i+JJ kUOUO3;, dql q.NqM 1apUn S~3u1!1SlUtl.~J!.) aql 0) put! !~1!3!?0&~pue ‘Al!I!q!xalj 'r(;>ua!.,yfa '/(,![!qewpaJtl ,JJ.Ijl! SIIJIIlJJ Awq 0 1 UO!lU?ll~le!Dads sAed 11 'suJn)aJ )ut?)suo3 p u a Idu!qs!u!~u!~) 'Idu!sed~3u! JO suo!l!puooJapun csaJeqs iaqJvw, ‘sa@olouq3al J O sn!luaukp aq, SISBJIUO~ Jaded s!qL '

*awo3ino ay3 apr3ap r(etu I(aqi-s+ueuApaq1 4 ~IJCWO8JOJ, put? r(VMt? pa%?JaAE )OU dJe ,SIUaAl ~[W.lS, [E3!JOlSfi1eq1 U! li~~~~pofl’sHlou pue !‘u! pal301, aJow dldA!swJYoJd sawo3aq i! a8Jawaolsu$iaq (kiolouq3a) lueu!luope) awo3ino ue a.~uowql u! h?~l,~~!xa&z:SapJadoJdMau OMI d n iu!od asp? iqP!w qJeoJdde ~!un:ui(p \r *la!iuawd unJ-SuolJo!JaJu! seq lleql ,@olouq3al e ihqdopAapo$u! ss.woJd uo!ldope aql aA!Jplq+u

LIX NJ-X301 CINV S3IOO-IONH3lI.I. :)NI.L3dR03 [6861 HDaVJ’&j

MnlaJ h!seaJ3uy moq pue .‘‘ aUJo3ln0la$Jam, aql WpaJd 0 1 aBy.Jns I O U At?urag![!q!sSod ,sa@olouq331 atg p u a sa3JaJajaJd ‘sJa,dope J O a8paIMOu~ I]UD-x3

Eflql os'a3eId aqel suogdopearauaAa azweqa AJ$~LI 0133~ suJnlaJ 8u!seamyfiooq :inoqe auJo3 hcwfn@uj pyu& pue fi(tpqDKywd-uou JO SagJadoJd sumi.%u!s"aJ~u!~le!1!~'90~3 aql moq IeaAaJos~a lq%!w 11 .Jaqloue spJem0~ ~!aApp01 SJaqlo ‘3tUO31nO ~l~qS-~3~leUJ au0 SpJEMol ssaDoJd aql aA!Jp 0) alapNun3II&U ,sluaAa le~!Jorqq, wopu~J~ocn3s awes moq atuo3lno aqljo ,uo!Va1aS,Wanyu! asaql MOq aU!UJEXa lq@IJJ l! 'uoydopv @Jnp 8U!JJn330 ,SluaAa,u~opue.l,~o kl!I!q!swd aq) 8u!~olle kg 'aJ0I.u des 01 a[qe aq jq%!w qzn?oJdde'qu~zul(p v *cpa13*3s,aq ll!M au0 pym sn llal louue:, l! dllensn inq ‘eyqg!nba,Idppw a s a q l alwol @D!dh uw s!sLlaue 3!1els .aJaq J e a d d e plnoqsou1o3)no ald!qnw ,eq~ %+!JdJnS IOU s! I! O S p u e ‘e!Jqg!nba aldgntu l!q!qxa01 pua$ suJnlaJ %U~S?KWU! qa!~ SwalqoJd uopwo~p? wq, UMOU~ IlaM s! 11: *saruowno pzguaaod aldglnw aAeq Leu.~ sa$iolouqzw uaaMwq suo!~padtu~t%twu~ux~p 01 auxo3 OI lucw.I~AoJdm! put? uogdope luapyjns aAa!qzie lqii!m'#01ouq3al 1uaJagp e - e33uewutn3q3 ~a3pqod ‘sJado(aAap AfJea J O EW!Z(Mk&oloJd J O awauuo~ad aq, u! sassa33ns pa)Dadxaun --,swaAa ~~a~y!u%~-u!, waJaJ!p Japun ‘agIno JO *Ino pay301 Bu!luo2aq sa@olouq3a1 Jaq30ql qJ!M ‘slaldopa la!lU~Wd~O ,l?y~JeuJ aql JaUJO:), ~l~"nlUaA3 ~t3LU uo!ldopeUI peal dlJea UB sup8 +utq3 Aq aeql r(8olouq3a, e snq& *paAoJduI! JaqaJnJ&a paldopeJaq]JnJawoB?q aJoJaJaq1 Xau111 waldope le!lualodlo uo!lJodoJd~2pp!meol l"adde~eurl!os'slaqloaq) ueqlaJowaAoJdw!uaql~em k%[OUqaals!qL*suo!,dopa u! a%vweApa la!~!u! ue waqlJoauo aA!% aDuvq3 r(q ketu SwaAa~uez1y!u4!su! %Jaldope [epunod~o~ iaq.n?w ,e~oj'uaq, 6a3adwo3,sa!8010uq3alUJnlaJ-8U!SV?al3U! a.tou1 J o oM3 uaqM ;paAoJdtu! aJe kaql aJouI aql put?'may1 ql!M pau@ s! a3uyJ3dxa ~JOUI aql 'paldope JJI? daql 3JoLu aql leql u!uo!ldopv 01 suJnaaJ %U!~KLI~U! I(aldsyp ua]Jo s@o~ouq3at xalduroa ‘uJapoH

.uo!ldopt? JOJ &1!aadu103 sa!80~0Uq331UaaMJaq Pu!sooq3 Slua8e :AllaJnleu as!Je suJnWJ Bu!saaJ3u! aJ3qM 1xaluo3S u! suJwaJ Bu!saaJw! Japun uopwo~p? JO s~!urwAp aql SaJoldxa J a d e d S!q.L

e

&.LN3h3 ?V3I~O~LSIHAB NI-X301 tINV ‘SNlIII.LYX 3NISV2IX3NI

‘S3IIWIONH33LL 3NI,L:4Jl’lO03

Page 2: SE ) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u JO aql puadap (uqq 0 ...blackout.gmu.edu/archive/pdf/arthur89.pdf · t I#!M (,I alqe,~ u! SE) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u ‘ sJaldops

uaqfi ‘u aikls 1~ VJO aJeqs 1a~Jeu.1 aql ‘“Y Aq ssaDoJd aqi aq!JDsap ue3 a~ ‘apa@’u a a q aheq Isi01 u! sa3!oq3 u uaqM ‘I(IaAp3adsaJ g pur! y J O saa!oqD JO Jaquu&aql a q (u)“u p u t ! (u)“u iaI pue 'as83 suJniaJ-iuwsu03 aqi qi!m u!Bq *,s)u3rulIet.us, [e+o~s!q J O uogou a w o s apnpu! 01 s n SMO~~E slua%e J O sadA 0~1 JOawanbas-aD!oqD umouzfun aq] aJaqM ‘]saiaiu!Jo asw aq] 01 uJn]ai on 1aI MON

*a3!oq3 JopaJu! ~1101 ‘ u!-pa?aoI , dI%+saaJ~u! sawoaaq 1alJew aql f aJaq 1uasaJd I O U s! AqI!q!xaajwx!od Ou!~~lels aql w g 01 suJwas aql pua y 01 suJnlaJ aql uaaM)aq da8 av asor”Ja8uoI o u ue3 8 01 % luauusn[pe-l(p!sqns uar\@ e ‘qiinoua ~9 au08 rn3q ~~330~~~aqi J! ina ‘suJnlaJ Jaq%q paJar\!Iap aAreq p[nom g J O u o p d o p e iuaIeA!nba ‘plaJe qa!qMJo IIe ‘ssa3oJd u o p d o p e aqi u! saD!oqa r(iJ!ql iaiJe afw sg UI *SMMO~

c aIqeL s e ‘lua!Dgau!-qled atuoaaq r(I!sea Aw.u ssa3oJd uopdopa aqa ‘~31~waJa#!p le aseaiw! suJniaJ J! wqi qSnoq3 33!ioN ‘alw awes aql it! as9 suJnl31J! ,uapyla-qled p u e ‘aIqewpald XII~+JS s! awo3ino s!qL *papnIsxa s! g pur, iaq=uJ aqi sJauJo3, y ieqi s! 1InsaJ pua aqL ., paiJ~is Bupla% , JO aIqedleDu! 8pua ‘auqi q3ea uasoq2 y ql!M ‘sanupuo3 s!qA ‘001 y sasooqs ~o!;Ao@ lua8e 1x3~aqL ‘v Bugdople 01 suJwaJ aql sawequa s!qL *Aes y ‘ASoIouq3al alqe"noAyaJou1 aqi sasooq3 iuaSe wy aqJ *anss! ut2 iou s! dl!Xpo8Ja ieql os a3uaJag!p ou3Teu.t uw siuaha umou?un pua ! a-86 aql IIe aie slush !Jailetu lou saop JaproaD!oqD aJaH *(c aIqeL) AIuo adh a u o J O aJe swa8a aJaqM suzuaAhx!sreaJau!qi!~ aIdmaxa p.?!~!Jl a u! unJ pInoM s~!unzul(p a q l MOM le yool 01 a~px~~le~s! l! ‘ppow iuah s p u a u in0 u! sa3!oq3 Jo amosino aqi &++uaxa a~oj38

(.x!puaddv aql u! aspard apew aJe suo!l!uyap IwuJo~u! asaqA) ;Jallaq40 p!vd aAeq I O U pIno,++ uo!ldopa u! pwqaq s! wql ABolouqDal aq,Jo (uopdopuI e n b a ) iuaurdoIahap I e n b a sauql IIe ie J! ~u~~~gli-y~DQ s! ssawJd aql leqh pue uo!Jal!J:, ,ia~8ar-ou, e ldopa [[!M 1 ‘StuaIqoJd aa!oqa-Ieyuanbas Jaqloyl!m au![ u! pule ‘@I!~Jo~~v waldopce ia)t?I Aq paliaJ8ai a q Aalu ieql au0inq ‘uraqi JOJ iq@J s! ieqi qaed 1uarudoIaAap a OIUO ssaword aqi 8uuaais XIq!ssod

611 N I - 3 3 0 - I (INV S313010NH33.L ONI.LXdHO3 E%@

ualdopa AIJea qi!~ ‘, padoIa~ap, Jo paldope amo3aq ieql suo!s~ah AsoIouqXw8p u e -y JO awanbas Jo ‘ qed, e wyap sas!oqa waIqoJd uogewIIe s!ql UI *au0hlg!qeqoJd qi!M auIo3ino la+wuI auws aql 01 pEa1 slwha p?yols!qJo sawanbasluaiaB!pJt (luapuadap-qwd IOU) 32283 f sayoq5 1aq.n~ arrwy a3uanyu! dempue3 sJ.tniaJ ,sq8oIouq3a1 aq1 ~0 au0 01 iuawisnfpe xel J o I(p!sqns e J! 314!x@!unJ-8uoI aq) u! ~IaleJn33a SaJaqs la3pw au!mJalap-ald 03 uopeu~~o~u! q%nouaRq JaAJasqo aqi laql 0s , ABM= sa%Jar\a, u! iI!nq hu!wJa3un J O aaJ8ap ~IEUJS$ql j! olqvtg?pz4 : s! ssamJd atg ietp Aes II!M 1 *sagJadoJd awes paau II!M aM

*saJaqs uo!ldope 01 awaJaJ!p e a?mu aanpollu!uuaha lpxus a s a q l ma3!oq3 J o Jap10 a q l u! suo!lvnwnu aql iaqlaqm p u ebuJniaJBu!sleaJcm! pue‘%u!q~u~ur!p'~ua~suo~josaS~?~ iuaJag!paqi u! awo3lnouaqs-uogdope a~ s! wJaw! JO -33!oq3 .r!aqi ayew siuah aqi q3!qM u!ww~bas aql au!walap leql svJaAa Iaayols!q JO las aql s! wql puv ‘uado 1~31 s!iuamap [pxus au0 Xluo *(X1p33!3selau! l!un au0 spuewap lua8e q3ea) puewapaqi s! w ‘UMOU)( aJ8 euopmry (suiniai J O) Qddns aq& 'satuo3 auqi s!q u a q m3Aptx~alla pauaJaJd sty %u~sooq~ luaS?e qaea ‘8 p u e v uaawaq asooq3 slushp sadA 0~1 aJaqM lapom uoywo~[e p?3!sse13oau a[dw!s I? ahaq M O U aM

YIeq auo hg!qeqoJdQ~M ‘s! iaqi ‘pooq!Iaq!I I a n b a qi!M au!I uopdopr? aql u! qw saw03 s ue J o gb aeq, AlJadoJd aq, qiIM ~adddl s pur! ~30 azwanbas hU!q B SI? J a p i o 331093kj~ ‘ saxi, snqi iahl3sqo aqL *s)u%a aqi J O (‘1) a3!oq:, p u a hua J O wu!i aqlc?u!mJaiapreq3 6iuaAa~owaql lda~xa'suo!lmnj suin3aJ p u e suo~~~puo3aq~ IIe10 aBp3pwou4 IInJ sv2q oqm JaA.sasqo ue awnssa sn Ial ‘~3pot.u in0 03 ulnia1 0L

*uoyenl!s aql jo uop3allsq~ JO , Iapow ,wq J O JaMod %u!~IosaJ aqi puokq - latuasqo aql ~0 aBpaIfiou3I WV-x1 aq3gp!sino a.rtz itzqi suopfpuo:, JO 61uar23 asoqi aq 03 , S2lmA3 (p?LuS ~03!JOlS!q, auyap?JojaJaqi I .atuowIoJo hu!uualapu! asn83 hu ‘41n13590 l!a!Idru! ue~o JaModSuyuJamp pal!uxg aql dIas!DaJd aJow J o ‘iahwd Su!uJaxxp payuuI in0 ileqlaprqw03 ut?3 3~ *awahpe u! alqwyw~aiap a q AIqvwnsaJd pInow I(BoIouq3aly3ea Aq pa@ amqc-aalJatu uogdople J o auwxno a q l - sihqlaaw r(alle suo~nap ~~KWJWO~ JO Bu!tup &adoIaAap J O aX.+adxa Jo!Jd aql ‘slsaJalu!la3pgod - sayoq3 tiolouqw waga 1qSy ieqi sa3uelsmn3~p p u e swamJO aBpaI,wouq loud pa1plap Lp~!uyu! aAeq 01 aM aJaM -,swa~a 1eyols!q, JO‘ameq3,Aq uaatu 1 it?qM &aJa:, auyap ollure~ I ‘lapom s!ql alaIdwo3OL

-8 JOJ a3uaJajaJ.d@Jnlau le aAt?q auaSe-g p u e ‘y JOJ awaJaJaJd IeJweu e aneq slua%-y wql06 ‘9 > 60 pue Yq < vu 3uuwn3 oqv 1 ‘0Jaz Jo ‘ah@au ‘ahp!sod kIsnoauelInw!sz pun 1 Aq ua~~ uogdope 01 suJnlaJ NIBWUO~ J o ‘%+qs!u!w!p ‘Su!oeaJv

HmxVYY] ?VN?IInOf OIPION033 3 H . L

Page 3: SE ) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u JO aql puadap (uqq 0 ...blackout.gmu.edu/archive/pdf/arthur89.pdf · t I#!M (,I alqe,~ u! SE) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u ‘ sJaldops
Page 4: SE ) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u JO aql puadap (uqq 0 ...blackout.gmu.edu/archive/pdf/arthur89.pdf · t I#!M (,I alqe,~ u! SE) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u ‘ sJaldops
Page 5: SE ) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u JO aql puadap (uqq 0 ...blackout.gmu.edu/archive/pdf/arthur89.pdf · t I#!M (,I alqe,~ u! SE) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u ‘ sJaldops
Page 6: SE ) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u JO aql puadap (uqq 0 ...blackout.gmu.edu/archive/pdf/arthur89.pdf · t I#!M (,I alqe,~ u! SE) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u ‘ sJaldops
Page 7: SE ) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u JO aql puadap (uqq 0 ...blackout.gmu.edu/archive/pdf/arthur89.pdf · t I#!M (,I alqe,~ u! SE) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u ‘ sJaldops

I-s :;”

'%U!l[LJ["J-J13S aUIO3i3q II'-'1301 kl")!UlJap {I'M g JO y )tZql EJa!lqup.?%e asw s!ql u! 'oJaz aJe J pur! J 1oq1 O S ‘a)3duw3 spJ-epuels %u!AoJdy-uou UaqM ‘~IJE[!lU!S 'OJaZ 01 MOJJWl SJa!JJt?q h!qJOSqE? aql put3 %U!/[yly-Jlas amo3aq suo!mDadxa asaq& ‘g 01 J O v 01 u!-l~o( Alal!uyap II!M wa&aq) wqi suo!vmadxa ploq slua%e~! XIampaum! Jn330 II!M %U~~I!MS leql hi*(5) put? ($) u"qL*;Li > SD- ‘q pue ;II > ar9-nv 1eq1 MOU asoddns *(!!)osvg

Tun!Jqq!nba SUO!)W2dXa [WO!)r?J B aq Il!M llt?M UlOpUeJ S!q)puv‘pa(lyIn~ aq lp~s~aqaq asaqi‘(l) pue (9) I(q WA!% ~v‘~vsJa!JJeq %u!qJocqrql!M lp?M luopue~ e s! ssa3oJd uo!ldope aql aA:Nlaq S)Ua%E J! SnqA ‘8 J~J&S)Ua%t?-S pUE ‘V JaJaJd S)ud%e-2( Waq) U!ql!M )t?ql pue g 01 Jo y 0) U! ~3'1~paapu! s! ssa3oJd p3we a q l sJa!JJaq a s a q l puoliaq wql m~yuo:, 03 dma S!JI _,

(L) ‘S/(,!U -QJ.-“4) = au-“u = sv

,iq uaA!% uo!l!sod r(J8punoq ]e v oi q31!Ms sadi(l-$ A[~tqy!s ;

(9) 'l/(%U -"q---'v) - = Mu- "u = n'v

kq WA!% Ja!JJ"q pa)E!BOSSI! q)!M

3+%+“9 = “ul+~vwqi q3ns au pue$

amq aM pue alay OJaz asp? s! d ‘pal[yInJ s! ssa3oJd paiaadxa aql J! laq) OS !iwqoJaz s! v 01 U!-~DO[JO .h![!qaqoJd p?nim aq& ‘uo uaqi LUOJJ g asooq:, sadAt qiog*lenba amomq suo!ssaJdxa OMJ asaqi leql qms aJe @u p u e “u uaqM 8 01 q31!MtII!M sadAl- ssa3oJd p?tw~ aqi UI 'r(l~t?l!w!s WI)!JM aq I(ew sBohd ad,@

(9

P)

$J[(“U ‘“U)d- I] +“tu+%/

cl1 (“U ‘“U)d + “Ul + ‘I?

:r+aA!13ads& ‘ant! 61 JO V %U!SOOq3 JOJ S&Otiadpalaadxa ad&y ‘SJaqaq asaq) Japun *(‘U ‘“U)d- I ‘g 03 I+-~301 pW ('U ‘"U)d‘y 0 ) u!-~301 J O sa!)!$qeqoJd pa~e!3ossa ql!M ‘:V ‘yv le sJa!JJeq uo!ldmqrqJ!M 0 ‘I[~M UIOpUEJ e S! ssa3oJd uoydope aql ,eql SJa![aq aAt!q Sadri,-$pueg 1eq1 put?;u <Sv-Sqpue;~< nq- +laq~ ~llep!u!asoddns.(!)~sa3

2aymm aqi u! sa3uamJard ~adl!aua%omlaq J O aaJ%ap a q l 01 %u!puodsaJJo3 ‘sase3 0~1 qs!n%u!ls!p ua3 aM

'0 E (a)~ u a q m ‘s! wql ‘ssawJdpalDadxa aql lno smaq I! uaqM ssa3old uquqy~nba suopv~~a~,Ixa pmo?lv~ e s! stamdIaniDa s!qL ‘(Q)J SsamoJd aql MOIIOJ suo!ldope 1wwe ~ql O S ‘suopaaadx;asayl J a p u n I(lleuope~ asooqs AaqL 'u ssa3oJd 3!lsf?q3ols 8 ~0110~ suopdoprleqj sJa!laq JO suo!lElaadxa arzeq Aaq) laql pue %u!sooq:, uaqM (“u ‘“11) mpeua q l J O aleis aql MOU)I siua%a ieql awnssv (*aJoy3q s e uopdopa ql!M aAoidursa!%olouqJaL) ‘:u ‘LD aA!aaa.i s)ua%a-$ @el!tu!s !+?)3adSaJ g JO pr ‘33!Oq:Jfaqi 0) u!-s~30[ ssa3oJd a q l j! 6;~ ‘gn J O s)yauaq l a u leuo!irppe a+332slua%e-8 1t?q1 lapocu Ja!lJea JIIO u! aurnsesv 'sa3!oq3 wed se 1Iaw se sa3!oq3wtln,Aq pal3aJ-l" ale sJa)dopa aJaqM asea sp~apuais %u!wdwoD a q i aJaq Jap!suq

621 NI-X30-I aNV S3I13010NH33.L 3NIl3dYY03

%~Kw)

*au0th.t!%%~l aqi ~0 y p u a A8010uq3ai %urpt?al aqi ~0 sa3!oq.) sno!AaJd tu u a a q amqmqi aJaqh4 ‘244 3 F> y JOJ {(,()~~}'~a~ < (ur)"~ ieq3 q3ns up3maJ ~1 suJnlaJI! sploq Xwa!3yla-qlad ‘s! )eqL wo!ldope JOJ alqel!e,te put ! padolaAap u a a q4aqi p~q aJow paJaA!lapaAaq?ou p~noM~I(%o~ouqw~ %u!%%tqaqijo suo!sJaA'wik[OUq3al paldope-aJotu aql sasooq3 wa%a UB JaAauzqM 'J! ~u~~n&ivd (A ! )

: 00 cu St? 'au0 I()!l!ql!qoJd ql!M ‘0 + (“X---xl"3q) ‘{TX} PUT? {"X} sqwd-awp %U!pUOdSaJJO3 q)!M '(!]} put? ('I) ‘SlUahaI~~!Jo)s!~ alq!SsodJo l a s scwuasqo aqi WOJJ saIdrues (JMI uah!% 3! ?lpoG (m)

fsa3!oq3 aJninj Jnleum sumlaJ ,sa!%010uq3a1 aq1 03 B luawlsnfpe pm!%~mu uaA!% vJ! 119,mf (n)

!cn fu s e ‘au0 hg!qt?qoJd ql!M ‘o~~~x-~x~ leql bJadoJd aql ql!M(:x) amanbas %u!lsa3aJoJ B 13nJlsuo3 I~UV-x3 ut33 JaAJasqo aql J! 11qv13,zpd (!)

:s! ssa3oJd uo!ie3o[p? ar[J, “‘x s e sm!oqn u Jalp? y10 a~leris la?Jeul aql a]ouaa *aAoqe pasn sa!lJadold +I k[as!3aJd auyap I aJaH

sayladold aqi so wqzu$a~ ‘v

XICINXddV

*aJnlnJ 3!urouo3aX[I J O kiy!qt!wpaJd aql 01 ‘sat10 p?gX?rd se (IaM sv ‘si$u!~ pD!iaJoaq) aq Peru313ql laql SW%&Is s!qJ 'bU!e)J~~Jo aaJ%ap HUE ql!M SaJEqs )aqJauI iD!paJd 0 1grssoduq auro3aq ~eU~l!‘ppou~ s,Jahlasqo UEJO uo!lnlosaJ aq) qwauaq QuaAail&s uodn spuadap huouosa aq1 Jo i&aludolaAap lt?.$fo1ouq3al aqi wq$ aaJ%apsql OL w?JJ0dUl! sawo3aq ‘hO)S!H, 11 *+aua% u! Izql 0) upp2 ws!uaq3atu.13aBa Japunq~, t? ql!M ‘Jal3weq3 hauopn[oAa ure u o saqel - saf%olouq3a) 36~3s!ql u! - swa[qo 3!uIouo3a uaaM)aq uo!Jpadwo3 ‘suJn]a~ %u!sr?aJ+ Japun

~a3uaApeu! alqela!paJd klaqlua IOU pus ‘paJalIe lil!sva 1011 ‘saA!leuJalle 01 JopadnsQ.wssa3au IOU awo3lno ua 0) u!Jlasl! 130101 +npeJ% houo3a aql asne3 tn.3STiJtI)C9J %U!SI?aJDU! ‘,+!UlI?Uhp MOq SMOqS )I '6S)UaA2 lC'!JOlS!q, WOpUeJ pullQ~SJOJ ywouo3a J O uo!rmraw! aql Isq ‘sawp!pue3 dld!ilntu WOJJ wn!Jqq!nbaut! ‘ si3aIas, lt?ql sS3mJd @3!we~r(p aql %u!u!LUEX~ dq SlualqoJd SuJnlaJ-hirr~s~~J~u!~o s!s,Q,we spals lensn aq) puohq 0% 01 paldmalla seq J a d e d s!ql

NOISfl?3N03 'AI

‘(&6i ‘uI?Mo~]) su!auraJ )uawdopAapp asJno3 aIqe,)aJ%aJ a u!-%u!q301 Qq!ssod J O wa(qoJd leluawepunJ aq&'sap!1!q!Ssod Jaqlojo JnoA8J u! r(Bo1ouq3a1 s!ql uopueqr: 0) r(lleuo!leJ 1(1)3apad

H32IVHI-j ‘IVNlIInOf 3IHON033 3H.L 8’5’

Page 8: SE ) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u JO aql puadap (uqq 0 ...blackout.gmu.edu/archive/pdf/arthur89.pdf · t I#!M (,I alqe,~ u! SE) aa!oqa s!qjo amp aqi ie % pue “u ‘ sJaldops

. .I

*(0861) 'ID 11 II!Jj JO S!S+Ut? )UEh[a aIj1 LQS kJWJO!W C/ li)!M Z E X3ql ‘od ‘(9.4361) f?SAOjUEx put? Aa![O”i~ ‘Jn~lJV II! S]UaUJalW! WOpW!Ji!un-uou 01 pue d suo~3.m~ snonu!iuo3-uou 01 papualxa s! wa~oaqi aq~,

4 uo!imnj Ilu!ipug 3q1 JO wood p a x y alqeis150 auo 01 auo Q!qaqo.xd q11~ scGixamo~ ssamold aq~ ‘pal[yp-y ale suo!vpuo:,o q e aqi J! ‘s! wq~ 4 uo~3ury Bun!mq aqi JOJ ploq siuau~aieis amqe 3q3

,_ IjL ‘OJaZ 01 SdJaAUO:, U/I UEql JaWVJ 4 UO!)Xlnj kh!l!W!l B 01 SakaAUO3 (“4pnbas aqj pue ‘IA 3uxg q)!ht h~ uo!~ppf? JO sa!l!l!qeqoJd asoddns (A! )i, *‘og!qeqo-‘d a+!sod Ij,!M z 0) a8laAU03$ouum ssmord aql uaq~ *~JO au!od a{qeisun xal~a~-uou e s! z a s o d d n s (u!)

.hq!qeqold aA.p!sod ql!M I ,u!od~ruq say ssa3oJd aql uaq~ .(ht ~ItWO!lUaAU03 aql u! pauyap SE) lu!od a[qe)s eri z leqi p u e ‘JILW! OJU! xaldw!s i!un aql J O JO!J~~U! aql sdew 4 asoddns (u)

*luauodwoa p~1w1uo~ a J O ~ap~oq aq, 01 JO ‘8 s,u!od p a x y J O IJS aq, u! I,u!od le 01 ‘auo hI!qvqoJd q)!M ‘83813AUO3 {‘lx} suo!,mdoJdJo JO133A aq, u3qL*swauodwoa pa~~suuo~ J O ~Ix(umu a~~uy e seq (X = (x)d :x) = g ‘JJO s~~!odpaxy~o ias aqi wql6sle asoddns *(a~!dau (2 ‘[x- (x)4} vnpoJd lauu! ql!Mn

uogmnj aIqE!!iua.m&!p-a3!M ‘a~p!sod e ‘s! wq$) uo!wnJ AoundeAl t? sassassodr-(x)4 uo!wmJ aql a s o d d n s pm ‘snonu!luo:, s! ,,.s+-,,s :d a s o d d n s (!)

(9861 ‘i&61) ynowy pun '~Iayouq 'mytly 'w3xOaHL

* **.“x “x “x suoyrodoJd JO SJO)31A aql p[‘$ 01p~e~aa! s! sszmd aq~ (*,,s m!i!l!qW+JJdJO xaldw!s ,!un aqi oiu! ,,fg suo!mdoJd

JS xaldw!s )!un aq) sdaw d uoyxmj p.q aqJ>) ‘X~aA!l.~adsaJ ‘[(r)‘d ‘**“(x)‘d‘(x)+J’J = d s+vI!cgeqoJd qa!hi ‘x’ qfdnoAq1 I fi~!~okw~ arll JO au0 01 p”pp* *!

~!un e wq-1uaAa q3ta )v y q%WJql I ‘s3!Jo~a183 y ql u! “q sl!un JO JOWAiI$l!U! Ut I,Jl!M Sl.IZl8 )eqJ ssmoJd D!lWqWlS lU1w(3J3U!-lU3pU~d3p E J3p!SUw

~WAO~J- r7W+UOllS lUapUl&(7-~fDd qJ '3

*Xl!I!qtmu! )a~leur pmmcuapun~ aq1 aieqJa3exa AaqL wywunoq 8u!qYMS q

1~) asdtzllo3 JO MOlIBU ~3ql!3 SUO~ltWdX~ ‘J?+Ol (!!) pUe (!) SaSa., BU!l(aL .,

AD1VII-J -lVNZTfIOf 3IRON03X 3H.L OS1d

,