science to policy: is there a risk? · risk is all about predicting the future in terms of...

10
www.jrc.ec.europa.eu Serving society Stimulating innovation Supporting legislation Joint Research Centre The European Commission’s in- house science service Dr. Stephan Lechner Director Institute for the Protection and Security of the Citizen Science to Policy: Is there a risk?

Upload: others

Post on 23-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Science to Policy: Is there a risk? · Risk is all about predicting the future in terms of probabilities • Scientists need to express themselves accurately, i.e. mathematically

www.jrc.ec.europa.eu

Serving society Stimulating innovation Supporting legislation

Joint Research Centre The European Commission’s in-house science service

Dr. Stephan Lechner Director Institute for the Protection and Security of the Citizen

Science to Policy: Is there a risk?

Page 2: Science to Policy: Is there a risk? · Risk is all about predicting the future in terms of probabilities • Scientists need to express themselves accurately, i.e. mathematically

Risk is all about predicting the future in terms of probabilities

• Scientists need to express themselves accurately, i.e. mathematically.

• Mathematics are not understood very well by the general public

June 2014 2

Communicating science to laypersons might result in misinterpretation

Page 3: Science to Policy: Is there a risk? · Risk is all about predicting the future in terms of probabilities • Scientists need to express themselves accurately, i.e. mathematically

Taking Science to Policy…

June 2014 3

Page 4: Science to Policy: Is there a risk? · Risk is all about predicting the future in terms of probabilities • Scientists need to express themselves accurately, i.e. mathematically

4

Science: Structural Assessment

Page 5: Science to Policy: Is there a risk? · Risk is all about predicting the future in terms of probabilities • Scientists need to express themselves accurately, i.e. mathematically

5

Policy: EUROCODES • EUROCODES have replaced

27 national standards in 2010

• 15 years of development

• Collaboration of policy makers, researchers and standardisation organisations

• Protecting the European Citizen

• Interest in Russia and China

Page 6: Science to Policy: Is there a risk? · Risk is all about predicting the future in terms of probabilities • Scientists need to express themselves accurately, i.e. mathematically

Risk: Real Earthquake

6

L'Aquila, Italy, April 2009 • 308 killed • 1500 wounded

• 30.000 homeless

Page 7: Science to Policy: Is there a risk? · Risk is all about predicting the future in terms of probabilities • Scientists need to express themselves accurately, i.e. mathematically

7

L'Aquila, Italy, April 2009 • 308 killed • 1500 wounded

• 30.000 homeless • Scientists sentenced!

Risk: Real Earthquake

Page 8: Science to Policy: Is there a risk? · Risk is all about predicting the future in terms of probabilities • Scientists need to express themselves accurately, i.e. mathematically

Space Weather: Risk of power blackouts due to solar storms

8

Financial Crisis: Systemic Risk of banks "too big to fail"

Cyber Security: Risk of a successful cyber attack

Maritime Cargo Containers: Risk Assessment by automated itinerary analysis

More examples? Tsunami modeling: Risk for coastal areas

Page 9: Science to Policy: Is there a risk? · Risk is all about predicting the future in terms of probabilities • Scientists need to express themselves accurately, i.e. mathematically

Yet more … • Food Authenticity • Pandemics Spread • Flood Prediction • Nuclear Safety • Chemical incidents • Food contact materials • Nano particles • Shale gas fracking • …

9

Page 10: Science to Policy: Is there a risk? · Risk is all about predicting the future in terms of probabilities • Scientists need to express themselves accurately, i.e. mathematically

Conclusions • Yes, there is a risk!

• Refrain from "zero risk" statements!

• Listen well to the next presentations…

http://alphonsuspeck.wordpress.com/category/articles/

10