sc decision on boc computerization project

7/23/2019 SC decision on BOC computerization project

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sc-decision-on-boc-computerization-project 1/5

Sirs/Mesdames:

< ~ J P . R O . O F

S ~ R l l C l i

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES

SUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

NOTICE

Please take notice that the Court, Second Division, issued a Resolution

dated

23

November

2015

which reads as follows:

G.R. No. 220832

(Bureau of Customs

{BOC]

represented by

Commissioner Alberto

D.

Lina, and Department

of

Budget and Management

Procurement Service [DBM-PS], represented by Executive Director Jose Tomas

C. Syquia

vs.

·Hon. Paulino Q. Gallegos, in his capacity

as

Presiding Judge,

Regional Trial Court, Br.

47

Manila, and the purported Joint Venture of

Omniprime Marketing, Inc. and Intrasoft International, Inc., represented

by

Annabelle A. Margaroli).- After deliberating on the petition for certiorari with

prayer for the issuance of a temporary restraining order assailing the Omnibus

Order dated

4

August 2015

of

the Regional Trial Court {RTC), Br. 47, Manila, in

Civil Case No. 15-134333, which, among others, granted herein

r e s p o n d e n ~

·

application for the issuance

of

a writ of preliminary injunction and the issuance of

an injunctive writ [enjoining all the petitioners from implementing both the (a) 6

May 2015 letter of petitioner Lina aborting the competitive bidding of the PNSW /

2 Project and the (b) 7 May 2015 Cancellation Notice of petitioner Syquia in the .

_

meantime that the case is heard upon its merit, and all the petitioners from

initiating any other procurement, sourcing

of

funds and conducting any other

procurement whether thru public bidding or negotiation to replace or up-grade the

present customs systems subject matter of this bid], the Court, without necessarily

giving due course thereto, resolves to

REQUIRE

respondents to

COMMENT

(not to file a motion to dismiss) on the petition, within ten (10) days from notice,

and hereby

ISSUES

a TEMPOR RY

RESTRAINING ORDER,

effective

immediately and continuing until further orders from this Court, enjoining and ·

restraining the respondents, the RTC, Br. 47, Manila, their representatives, agents

or other persons acting on their behalf

1

from enforcing and implementing

the·

assailed Omnibus Order dated

4

August 2015. Carpio,

J.

on official leave;

Velasco, Jr.,

J.

designated acting member

per S.

0

No.

2282.

Very truly yours,

M A D ~ ~ ~ o

3

more

(226)adv/cc



(_J

•P.AOE2

.

_ A F ~ I C E

OF

THE SOLICITOR GENBRAL(x)

134

Amorsolo

Street

1229 ~ 8 f t S p i

Village

Ma.J<ati City .

AOQUE

ANO

BUTIJYAN L,A

C o u ~ s e l

for

P r i v ~ u ,

R esponcte

·

1904

A:ntel

20QQ

Corporate C

121

ValerQ Streot Salcedo Vi11'a:o

.1200

Makati City

HON. ALBERTO D, LINA(x)

Coftlmissioner

Bureau of Cust9ms

·Pround

Floor,

OCOM ~ ~ i l d i n g

Port Area, Manila

· ·

' ' '

J

AoN. JOSE TQMAS c. SYQUIA ex)

;

Executive

D i r e ~ o r . ..

: D B M " P r o c u r e ~ n t S e r v i ~ ·

PS.

, C o q i p l e ~ C ~ t o b a l

St.

Paco, Manil *

a:oN; PRBSlDINQ JUDGE

(x).

l\fgional

Trial Court,

llranoh

41

Manila

·

Civil

Case

No. 1 5 ~ 1 3 4 3 3 3

Pl .e

notify tl e Court o/ ny :hangt inypur address.

GR220837. J / 2 3 / I S 2 2 6 ) a d v ~ ~ .... · ·

'

I

'

;,

1/

l1

~

a :::

~

-

:J I

c::>

'

r:'

::;

~

Ri

j f\ j)

J.7»

- - ~

~ ~ ;

:::: :. ... m m

P. ~

~

cJ1

:? r

N ~

'

. I ~

OED

4 D

C'15i:iM8=48:27

I

I

.:i,

I

I

i

I



..

1 .

. ... ·

(J

· ~ A £ 2 ...

.

OFFICE OF THE SOLICITOR

oeNERAL(x}

134

Amol flolo Street

1229

Legaspi Villaga

MakatiCitY

ROQU2 ANO BUTUYAN I,AWOFFICES (x)

Couqsel

for

P r i v ~ t e

R.osponclent . ·

1904 Antel ~ O O Q Corp0rate C e n ~ r

121

V d e r ~ Street Safoedo

Village··

l,200

Makati City

.

~ N

ALSBRTO D, LINA (x)

•Colllm.issiOI)er

1Bureau of

Cust9ms

Pround Floor, 9coM at;lilding

Port

Area,

Manila

. J . ' .

; H O N ~

JOSE

T ~

C. SYQUIA (x)

Executive Dirof;Jor .

P B M ~ P r o c u r e ~ n t

S e r v i ~

·

PS C o q t p l e ~

Cjilstobal St.

P a c o ~ Manila

. I

10N

PRESlDINQ WoOE·(x) ·

· .RtgionaITrial Court,: :aronQh

47

?;A- 'I

·.

·.. .

_,.

. . .

~ Y : a n 1 a , . .. ·· . . · . ; . .

~ C i v i l

Case No;is;.134333·

. : . . . .. . . .

:

. '. ' ' . , . . : . . . ' .. .· . . . .

Wlft14e

noti 1

' '

Courtli/qny

h a n g f In

YPHf addra1

. . GlU20837. J 1 2 3 / i S . ( 2 2 . 6 ) ~ d v J f f

113

..

1

1.

:. .

I-:

.

:i

'

I

·

:;

i

I·

)

.i

·

i .

·

I.

.

..

,

l·

'.

;

J.

..· i ·

·i

'

f ' ' '

t

ii

'·. .

t. .. ·

: ;

·.

'-··----------

RECEIVED

OFFICE Of Thi C O M M I S S l ~ N r

1

BUREAU

Of

CUSTOMS

O

i

DEC

2015

j

I

:

''

I

i

·

:

\

i

r

.l

I

I i

I

,-·,;



~ )

l

•

EPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES

SUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

BUREAU OF CUSTOMS (BOC), REP. BY

COMMISSIONER ALBERTO D. LINA,

G R No. 220832

AND DEPARTMENT OF BUDGET

AND

MANAGEMENT-PROCUREMENT

S R V I ~

(DBM-PS), REP. BY.EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR

JOSE TOMAS C. SYQUIA,

Petitioners,

•

-versus -

TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER

HON. PAULINO Q. GALLEGOS, IN HIS

CAPACITY AS PRESIDING JUDGE, REGIONAL

TRIAL COURT, BR 47, MANILA, AND TIIE

PURPORTED JOINT VENTURE OF OMNIPRIME

MARKETING, INC. AND INTRASOFT INTER

NATIONAL, INC., REP.

BY

ANNABELLE A.

MARGAROLI,

Respondents.

} -------------------------------------------------------------}(

TO: THE PRESIDING JUDGE

x)

Regional Trial Court, Branch 47

Manila

Civil Case No. 15-134333)

ROQUE AND·BUTUYAN

L W

OFFICES

x)

Counsel for Private Respondent

1904 Antel 2000 Corporate Center

2 Valero Street, Salcedo Village

1200 Makati City

GREETINGS

WHEREAS, the Supreme Court on 23 November 2015 promulgated a

resolution in the above-entitled case, the dispositive of which reads:

- more -

~ U l



.

<

page

G.R. No. 220832

(Bureau of Customs [BOC], represented

by

Commissioner Alberto

D.

Lina,

and

Department of Budget

and

•

Management-Procurement Service [DBM-PS], represented

by

Execu'live Director Jose Tomas

C.

Syquia vs. Hon. Paulino

Q.

Gallegos,

in his

capacity as Presiding Judge, Regional Trial Court,

Manila, Br. 47 and the

purported

Joint Venture of

·

Omniprime

Marketing, Inc. and lntrasoft International, Inc., represented

by

Annabelle A. Margaroli).-

After deliberating on the petition for certiorari

with prayer for the issuance of a temporary restraining order assailing the

Omnibus Order dated

24

August 2015 of the Regional Trial Court (RTC),

Br.

47,

Manila, in Civil Case

No.

15-134333, which, among others,

granted herein respondents' application for the issuance of a writ of

preliminary injunction and the issuance of

an

injunctive writ (enjoining all

the petitioners from implementing both the

a)

6 May 2015 letter of

petitioner Lina aborting the competitive bidding of the PNSW 2 Project

and the (b) 7 May 2015 Cancellation Notice of petitioner Syquia

in

the

meantime that the case is heard upon its merit, and all the petitioners

from initiating any other procurement, sourcing of funds and conducting

any other procurement whether thru public bidding or negotiation to

replace or up-grade the present customs systems subject matter of this

bid], the Court, without necessarily giving due course thereto, resolves to

REQUIRE respondents to COMMENT (not to file a motion to dismiss)

on

the petition, within ten (10) days from notice, and hereby ISSUES a

TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER, effective immediately and

continuing until further orders from this Court, enjoining and restraining

the respondents, the RTC, Br. 47, Manila, their representatives, agents or

other persons acting on their behalf from enforcing and implementing the

assailed Omnibus Order dated 24 August 2015. Carpio, J. on official

leave; Velasco, Jr.,

J.

designated acting member

per

S.O. No. 2282.

N O ~ THEREFORE effective immediately and continuing until further

orders from this Court You the RTC Br. 47 Manila the respondents your

agents representatives and all other persons acting on your behalf are hereby

RESTRAINED from enforcing and implementing the assailed Omnibus Order

dated 24 August 2015.

GIVEN by the

HONORABLE

A SSOCIATE JUSTICE ARTURO D.

BRION Acting Chairperson of the Second Division of the Supreme Court of the

Philippines on

23

November 2015.

Copy furnished:

OFFICE OF THE SOLICITOR GENERAL (x)

134 Amorsolo Street

· 1229 Legaspi Village

Makati

City

A

Very truly yours

M A L ~ ~ C T O

Division Clerk o ~ ~ u r t

sc decision on boc computerization project

Documents