sarah jones v. dirty world - opening appellate brief
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
1/75
GINGRAS LAW OFFICE, PLLCGINGRAS LAW OFFICE, PLLCGINGRAS LAW OFFICE, PLLCGINGRAS LAW OFFICE, PLLC
12, 2013
A B: D . G, E.
, 1,420 J
.D. CC A. L , I . F , I .
B , D 2009, J, FL C B, D , LLC ( .D.).
D D 2009, . , K $11 .
H CD A CDA, (// ). A I ,
F.
K , , CDA (I 40 ). , CDA. ( & D).
E: I & D
J , .
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
2/75
, . , $33,000 . ($3,000/.) .
, , . , .
, (11) . , .. , .
, ( ) , , .
, . . , ( ).
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
3/75
? C. .
? B , CDA
K . CDA , .
I , CDA .I , CDA . , ; 100% .
, . F, C . CDA . I , CDA , . . I , .
C ,
. I , $338,000 ( ).
H C , CDA . I , , , C . .. C
1%.
, C, ., ILL .. C , . CDA 1996, C .
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
4/75
, ? D 16, 2013, 17 J2, 2014.
A, C . I , C A C /
. , F, A.
A , ( ). , .
FIAL CE ,
J . D H . , I , .
. I . , ( ) .
, .D. . , ; . I, .
I , : @.
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
5/75
AAH JE,
/,
.
DI D EEAIE ECDIG, C, .,
/.
AEA F HE IED AE DIIC CEAE DIIC F KECK
CAE.2:09C219BH.IIA .BEEA
D . G, E. A C. , E.G , C A B. , E.
4802 E , #23271 H B, , A 85044 855 C A, 301
: (480) 2641400 A, K 41105
F: (480) 2483196 .: (606) 3298771
E: @. F: (606) 3244651@.@.
DI D,CADIK AAICHIE
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 1
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
6/75
. . . . 26.1, / ,
: , ,
10% .
: 12, 2013 // .
. , . ,
4802 , #23271, 85044
: (480) 2641400
: (480) 2483196
: .
,
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 2
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
7/75
JIDICIA AEE ..........................................................................1
1. A A B A A
3. A A B A
1. D C A F
2. E A ,
.
IE EEED F EIE .......................................................................2
AEE F HE CAE..................................................................................3
2. A A
AEE F FAC ........................................................................................4
A F AGE.............................................................................. 12
AGE.......................................................................................................... 14
I. AEA AE EIED CDA II.......................... 14
A. D ...........................................................14
B. H A B CDA ...............................................15
C. G F A CDA................................25
I C ...................................................26
I ..........................................................................28
I C ...................................................28
D. D C CDA A E ...........................30
D..........................................................................31
J..........................................................................................43
3. A I I .............................454. A C ...............................................................56
CCI....................................................................................................... 60
DESIGNATION OF DOCUMENTS .....................................................................61
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 3
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
8/75
. ,
F..2 , 2013 5420973 (.D... 2013)..................................... 52
. ., .,
456 F.3 1316 (11C. 2006)................................................................ 15, 17, 25
, . .,
842 F..2 450 (E.D... 2011) ............................................................ 27, 49
. ,449 F.3 709 (6C. 2006)................................................................................ 16
. !, .,
570 F.3 1096 (9C. 2009).................................................................. 17, 29, 51
. ,40 C.433, 146 .3 510 (C. 2006)........................................................ 22, 23
. .,2013 2355512 (D.. 2013) ...................................................................... 27
B , , , . . .,
206 F.3 980 (10C. 2000)........................................................................ 17, 56
', . . ,2008 4182827 (D.A. 2008)...................................................................... 41
. , .,
2010 3222147 (.D.C. 2010) ................................................................... 54
. ,992 F.. 44 (D.D.C. 1998) ............................................................................ 23
. ., .,339 F.3 1119 (9C. 2003)........................................................................ 17, 51
. , . . , .,
519 F.3 666 (7C. 2008).......................................................................... 17, 36
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 4
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
9/75
. .,703 F..2 862 (.D.I. 2010) ................................................................... 47
, . . , .,
776 F. . 135 (.D... 1991)................................................................ 18, 19
. , .,665 F..2 961 (.D.I. 2009) ..................................................................... 36
. ,
433 F..2 523 (E.D.. 2006) ......................................................... 24, 51, 56
.. . , ,2012 3335284 (.D.. 2012) ............................................................ 49, 53
. , .,783 .2 1010 (F. 2001)................................................................................. 51
. .,
347 F.3 655 (7C. 2003)................................................................................ 17
. .,551 F.3 412 (6C. 2008)................................................................................ 16
. ,
374 .J.. 475, 865 A.2 711 (.J. 2005)............................................. 24, 28
. ., ,
521 F.3 1157 (9C. 2008).......................................................................
. ., ,666 F.3 1216 (9C. 2012).............................................................................. 37
. .,
438 .. 726, 98 .C. 3026, 57 .E.2 1073 (1978)....................................... 41
. ,99 C.A.4816, 121 C..2 703 (C.A. 4D. 2002) .................. 28
. ,
76 .3 1100 (F. 3 D. 2011)..................................................................... 42
, . . , ,
544 F..2 929 (D.A. 2008) ......................................................... 26, 42, 49
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 5
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
10/75
. , .,318 F.3 465 (3C. 2003)................................................................................ 17
. , .,
727 .E.2 550 (.C.A. 2012)........................................................................ 17
. ,614 F.3 785 (8C. 2010).................................................................... 15, 17, 25
. , ,
F..2 , 2013 4068780 (E.D.K. 2013)................................
. , ,840 F..2 1008 (E.D.K. 2012) ...........................................................
. !, .,2011 5079526 (.D.C. 2011) ................................................................... 56
.. . , ,
809 F..2 1041 (E.D.. 2011).................................................................. 51
. ,311 ..3 210 (.A. 2010)................................................................... 59, 60
. , .,
2013 664231 (E.D.. 2013) ....................................................................... 54
. ,.,
528 F.3 415 (5C. 2008).......................................................................... 17, 30
, . . ., .,591 F.3 250 (4C. 2009).......................................................................... 17, 59
. ., .,
391 F.3 715 (6C. 2004)................................................................................ 15
. .,40 .3 582, 966 ...2 843 (..C C. C. 2013) ........................... 29
. ,
774 F..2 310 (D.D.C. 2011) ................................................................ 58, 59
10, . . , ,
488 F.3 1102 (9C. 2007)........................................................................ 17, 22
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 6
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
11/75
. ,182 C.A.4323, 105 C..3 791 (C.A. 3D. 2010) ................ 57
. , ,
F.3 , 2013 4525870 (6C. 2013) ............................................ 17, 52
. , .,952 .E.2 1011, 17 ..3 281 (.. 2011)............................................
. ,
407 F.A. 918 (6C. 2011) ...................................................................... 16
, . . ., .,1995 323710 (.. . C. 1995).................................................. 18, 20, 21
. ,491 .. 397, 109 .C. 2533, 105 .E.2 342 (1989)..................................... 41
. ., .,
352 F.3 1017 (6C. 2003).............................................................................. 15
. ., . . , .,478 F.3 413 (1C. 2007).................................................................... 17, 25, 27
. , .,
129 F.3 327 (4C. 1997).............................................................. 17, 23, 25, 56
. ,
2012 6725588 (D.D.C. 2012) ...................................................................... 27
28 ..C. 1291........................................................................................................1
28 ..C. 1332........................................................................................................1
47 ..C. 230................................................................................................
47 ..C. 230()(3) ........................................................................................ 13, 32
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 7
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
12/75
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
13/75
()()() ()
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 9
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
14/75
1
A , S A C,
D. #22, P/A S J (M. J) K.
D/A D W, LLC (D W) D L
L C A.
D/A N LR (M. R) S
C, M. J A. T S
A C $75,000. T
28 U.S.C. 1332.
F , J 11, 2013
M. J. D. #208. A N A
J 15, 2013. D. #209.
T C A 28 U.S.C. 1291.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 10
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
15/75
2
1. A A C DA, 47 U.S.C. 230()(1)?
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 11
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
16/75
3
T
A
.TD.. I , M. J ,
,
, M. J .
I
A . I
A. I
, M. R
, , W ?
A M. J
,
C D A, 47 U.S.C. 230()(1) (
CDA). T , A
. T
M. R
.
F M. J, A
.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 12
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
17/75
4
T A
CDA. A , A
J 10, 2012 .
. , , 840 F.S.2 1008
(E.D.K. 2012).
A
. T C M 9, 2012,
.
D ,
A CDA (D. #177)
R 50() ,
. .
, , F.S.2 , 2013 WL 4068780 (E.D.K.
2013). A , M. J
. H,
A CDA
,
.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 13
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
18/75
5
D W, LLC .TD..
A N LR (R A.) 1, ECF D. #642 P ID
#478. T 2007 .DS.,
S, A. M. R . .
DS. M. R
S . R A. 2
4; P ID #47879. M. R
. W
, DS. ,
50 U.S. 20 C
18 . R A. 67; P ID #47980. I ,
.TD.
M. R ( )
.
A , . A , M.
R . R A. 8; P ID #480. R,
( T D A)
, ,
, .
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 14
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
19/75
6
T (ECF D. #642 P ID #50405)
100% ; ,
. T
: T . R W, W, W, W,
W. R A. 12; P ID #481.
A S 2011,
.TD. 90,000 .
A 18 , A M 7,
2013, .TD. 121,863
900 . I , 3,182,200
. D. #1771 1, 3; P ID #2696. M
,
. O ,
, , ,
, . R A. 11()(); P ID #48081.
U ;
. D. #1771 2, 4; P ID
#2697. A M. R, ( )
, , I
, I . .
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 15
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
20/75
7
A ,
,
. S,
C, C, C . R A. 13; P ID
#481. I ,
40 : I HAVE NO IDEA,
B, N, S B . R A. 14; P ID #481.
A , M. R / ,
/, , ,
M. R . R A. 15; P ID #48182.
F, , M. R ,
, M.
R , ,
, . .
A M. J C ( S A
C; D. #22) D 7, 2009,
. T ,
M. R E J (ECF D. 642, P ID #507)
O 27, 2009 : G D I A.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 16
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
21/75
8
T M. J (
C B) B
S G. T
:
N, S J, C B C. S SG. S BF . T !! Y G N!
M. R , .
R A. 1619; P ID #48283. M. R
;
. . P ,
M. R M. J,
. R A. 20; P ID #483.
I , M. R
B
, E C S A. I
R R
. . R A. 21; P ID #483. N
M. R M. J .
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 17
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
22/75
9
T , M. R
E K (ECF P ID #509), D
7, 2009. R A. 16. T
M. J 2007 BG
. T :
N, S J, B.. M S AND .. .. .. H
N.. 50 4 .. C I G.. I S .. .. .. DIXIE H.
A ,
. M. R
, . R A. 1619.
A , , M. R
: W ? .
R A. 22; P ID #483. T
M. J ,
M. R ..,
. R A. 23; P ID #483.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 18
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
23/75
10
O D 9, 2009, M. J
B C B. A
M. R E L, P ID #511. T
M. J :
N, B/ N. P . O .
A ,
; A
, . R A. 1619.
O , M. R : C
. F I
, . . R A. 24, P ID #483.
A , M. J
D 23, 2009. D. #1. R D W, LLC M.
R, M. J C D
W E R LLC
.TD.. T C
.TD., D W, LLC, M. R. R A.
26; P ID #484.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 19
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
24/75
11
D M. J NFL ,
.
R A. 27; P ID #484. F ,
.TD. M. J, B
. R A. 28; P ID #484. H, M. J
. R,
O 27, 2009 ( M. J
B ) D 7, 2009 (
M. J , STD,
M. J ).
A ,
, M. R M.
J. R A. 30; P ID #485.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 20
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
25/75
12
A : .
? T ,
.
U CDA
ICP. T ICP
47 U.S.C. 230()(3) :
T , , I . ( )
B ,
. A
.
I , M. J A
. E ,
.
I, M. J A
CDA . T .
T
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 21
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
26/75
13
C CDA. U
,
CDA . F ,
.
I, C
. S,
. T
, , ,
,
(.., )
. E
C , .
U , A
,
M. J CDA. A ,
A.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 22
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
27/75
14
. . I , A CDA
, R 50 M
J M L. T
A 12, 2013 .
. , , F.S.2 , 2013 WL
4068780 (E.D.K. A 12, 2013). A R 50
. . ., ., 391 F.3 715, 720 (6C.
2004) (W
.) (
. ., ., 352 F.3 1017, 1022 (6
C. 2003)).
I , CDA ;
. . , 614 F.3 785, 791 (8 C. 2010)
(, T CDA
.) (
. ., ., 456 F.3 1316, 1321 (11 C. 2006));
, 840 F.S.2 1010 (, S 230 CDA
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 23
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
28/75
15
.)
B A CDA ,
; C
, . . , 407
F.A. 918, 927 (6C. 2011) ( . , 449 F.3 709, 714 (6
C. 2006)).
F , .
. T C
CDA . . .,
551 F.3 412 (6
C. 2008).1
H,
CDA .
, 551 F.3 16. T .
A ,
C . R, S, D.C.
1 T C CDA .
, , F.3 , 2013 WL 4525870, *4 .8 (6C. 2013) ( TA C D A, 47 U.S.C. 230()(1).)
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 24
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
29/75
16
F , CDA
( N C) .2
I , CDA
. , .., D S. A,
: 230
, 43 LOY.L.A.L.REV. 373 (2010) ( 184
CDA ); . , ., 727 S.E.2 550, 558
(N.C.A. 2012) (, A ,
300
47 U.S.C. 230 . A
.)
2 . ., . . , .,478 F.3 413 (1C. 2007); . , ., 318 F.3 465 (3C. 2003); . ,
., 129 F.3 327 (4C. 1997); , . . .,., 591 F.3 250 (4C. 2009); . , 528 F.3 413 (5C. 2008); . ., 347 F.3 655 (7C. 2003); , . . , ., 519 F.3 666 (7
C. 2008);
. , 614 F.3 785 (8C. 2010); . , 333 F.3 1018 (9
C. 2003); . .. ., 339 F.3 1119 (9
C. 2003); 10, . . , , 488 F.3 1102 (9 C. 2007); . ., , 521 F.3 1157 (9
C.
2008) ( ); . !, ., 570 F.3 1096 (9C. 2009); , & . . , ., 206 F.3 980 (10C. 2000);... .
., 570 F.3 1187 (10C. 2009); . ., ., 456F.3 1316 (11C. 2006).
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 25
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
30/75
17
B CDA ,
, .
, ., 129 F.3 327 (4C. 1997),
. H,
CDA
. F , CDA
, . T
,
C CDA 17 .
T CDA N Y , .
. , ., 776 F. S. 135 (S.D.N.Y. 1991) ,
. . ., ., 1995 WL 323710 (N.Y. S. C. 1995). T ,
, R USA.
, 775 F.S. 13738. T , CS,
,
CS . .
I, R .
A R
, C. . 138. I , C CS
. C ;
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 26
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
31/75
18
O,
. . 139. T
M. J .
CS
R ,
. T
,
. . 141.
A , CS :
T . A , CS , , . G F A , CS R .
. 14041.
F ,
CS R . A ,
. . 144.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 27
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
32/75
19
F 1995, .
. I , , (P)
.
, 1995 WL 323710, *1. H, CS
, P
.
A , P
,
, PRODIGY
. 1995 WL 323710, *2. P
. .
B
, PRODIGY
,
. . G ,
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 28
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
33/75
20
CS, P ,
:
T CS P .F, P . S,P , G B L . B , , P , .T
, P . B , C P ,P .
, 1995 WL 323710, *4 ( ).
B P /
,
; P ,
, CS
. . *5 ( ).
H, ;
C
C D A . .
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 29
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
34/75
21
V ,
CDA ,
( CS)
. O ,
( P)
.
E C
CDA . I, ; O
S 230 .
. ,333 F.3 1029 ( S.REP.NO.
104230, 194 (1996)) ( , W
S 230(),
,
.); H.R. CONF. REP. N. 104458, 194 (1996)); .
, 40 C.433, 5054, 146 P.3 510, 52023 (C. 2006) (
CDA).
A , C CDA
,
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 30
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
35/75
22
, , ;
I
, C
I I
,
. . , 992 F.S. 44, 52 (D.D.C. 1998);
, 129 F.3 330 (; I , 230
.);, 40 C.4 53, 146 P.3 522
(, B 230()(1) R
C
.)
T . I
.
R, CDA ,
;
, ;
. , 333 F.3
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 31
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
36/75
23
1031; , 521 F.3 1163, 1169 (, I
230, C
.); . , 433 F.S.2 523, 530
(E.D.P. 2006) (, C 230
. T,
.), , 248 F.A. 208 (3 C. 2007);
. , 374 N.J.S. 475, 865 A.2 711 (N.J. 2005) (
CDA
, .)
H,
CDA . A
I . ,333 F.3 1027. T
F C :
S 230 , , I , , .
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 32
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
37/75
24
T . I
. F , . C .
, 129 F.3 330. T , S 230
I. ,
333 F.3 1028; , 521 F.3 1175 (, W
,
. S 230
,
.) ( ).
T CDA C , T
CDA
. , 614 F.3 791
( , 456 F.3 1321); . ., 478 F.3 418
(
S 230 .); , . . ,
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 33
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
38/75
25
, 544 F.S.2 929, 931 (D.A. 2008) (, I C
, CDA .)
A , CDA
. T
, CDA
, ,
; I
C, A
. , 2013 WL 4068780, *3
( ).
T , , . T
A CDA
. T .
. P ,
26 , 47 U.S.C. 230()(1):
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 34
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
39/75
26
N .
G ,
CDA ::
1.) I ?
2.) D ?
A :
3.) W ?
. ., 478 F.3 418 ( );
. ., 2013 WL 2355512, *3 (D.N. 2013) ( ).
A , A .
1.
T ,
CDA; C
. , 2012 WL 6725588, *3 (,
. ., 842 F.S.2 450, 473 (E.D.N.Y. 2011) (
F, F, N C)); , 570 F.3 1195.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 35
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
40/75
27
T M. R
.TD. . I
, M. R . T
CDA ; 230()(1)
,
. , 333 F.3 1030.
T, M. R ,
; T
. T
. , 374 N.J.S. 490, 865 A.2 720;
. , 99 C.A.4 816, 833 .11, 121 C.R.2 703, 717 .11
(C.A. 4D. 2002) (, I
;
. T
.).
B M. R D W
, YES.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 36
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
41/75
28
2.
T
. H,
. D.
#207 ( ). D
CDA .
. .,40 M.3 582, 586, 966 N.Y.S.2 843, 846 (N.Y.C C.
C. 2013) (, CDA
,
,
CDA.); , 570 F.3 1101 (, T
230 .)
M. J A /
. A , YES.
3.
T
; .., . I ,
A
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 37
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
42/75
29
. , 528 F.3 419 (, S
,
.)
H, M. R
M. J :
19. T I P, I . I , ,
, . I , I P. A .
ECF D. 642; P ID #483.
W M. J ? N. I ,
, CDA
, M. J M.
R M.
R TV D. P MG M. J
. D. #66, 67. H,
M. R .
T
M. J B
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 38
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
43/75
30
STD
A
. G , M.
J ; T
230 . , 521 F.3
1174.
O , . A ,
.
. A A
M. J, , . T
CDA .
A ,
S 230()(1). A
,
47 U.S.C. 230()(3) :
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 39
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
44/75
31
T , , I . ( )
I ,
CDA
, CDA . P
, CDA
; ..,
. T,
, .
M. J A
, .
I,
A . T
,
.
1.
H,
. O
, :
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 40
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
45/75
32
:
. , 840 F.S.2 1011 ( )
( , 570 F.3 1199). A ,
,
. T
.
, . I,
.A.
. , 570 F.3 1191. A ,
, ,
, I P.
. S A
T A
. . 1192. T F T C
A .
A ,
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 41
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
46/75
33
A . B T
C ,
.
K A
: A
, ,
,
. , 570 F.3 1201 ( ).
U , CDA
,
230, . . 1200
( ) (, 521 F.3 1168).
I ,
( ). I,
A A. T
A . T, A
.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 42
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
47/75
34
N . A
M. J. R, M.
R , A
100% . U ,
.TD. .
A ,
, . F,
A T S (D. #1771 ECF P ID # 278889)
; C
, , .
E ,
A ; O
,
. A
.
., 519 F.3 671. T
A A ;
S 230()(1)
. . , ., 665 F.S.2 961, 969 (N.D.I. 2009).
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 43
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
48/75
35
I ( N
C )
. H,
.
(
) , F H
A, , ,
. 521 F.3 116162. T
CDA .3
T, ,
; R
230 CDA
. , 521 F.3 1165. I , N
C :
3 F CDA
, N C . .
., , 666 F.3 1216 (9 C. 2012). T .
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 44
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
49/75
36
, . I
, ,
230,
. . 116768 ( ). T N C
;
N
. . 1169
( ).
T
. U
, A
, , ( )
M. J . A
. D. #642 6, 19; P ID #483.
A, . A
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 45
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
50/75
37
,
A C . T N C
, CDA
:
T C A C
; , C , ,R . B , . S 230 , .
, 521 F.3 1174 ( ).
T , :
I , , .H, 230.
. 1174 .38.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 46
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
51/75
38
U, N C
A C ,
:
R . I , . R , , , R. W , R
. N R . T
230 .
521 F.3 117374 ( ).
A ,
; ..,
4 .
4A , ; I F A,
. . , 491 U.S. 397, 414, 109 S.C. 2533, 105 L.E.2342 (1989). O , T . I, ,
. . ., 438 U.S. 726, 745, 98 S.C. 3026, 3038, 57L.E.2 1073 (1978).
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 47
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
52/75
39
O . F , , . .
, 2008 WL 4182827 (D.A. 2008), ( )
. T CDA
. T
:
P BWI F CDA
. B . BWI BWI. T C . B , F CDA .
.*10 ( ) (, 521 F.3 117374).
I , .RR.
; I R R
. H,
, ,
. , 544
F.S.2 933. . , 76 S.3 1100 (F.3 D. 2011)
().
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 48
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
53/75
40
T N Y C A
. , ., 952 N.E.2
1011, 17 N.Y.3 281 (N.Y. 2011), .
I , ,
,
. ,
17 N.Y.3 25886, 952 N.E.2 101415. L ,
: 1.)
S K
T J; 2.)
,
3.) .
L M. J,
. I
, ,
CDA :
A , ; . A
. W S
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 49
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
54/75
41
N Y C . C 230 .
, 17 N.Y.3 29091, 952 N.E.2 1018 ( ).
T C :
T , , . I ., ,
, . H, , ,
. T ., TA . T
.
. ( ) ( ).
T
A ( ),
A
M. J (
). I ,
.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 50
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
55/75
42
T
S
K T J,
CDA; T ,
... . T
, ,
S . N, ,
CDA. , 17 N.Y.3 29293, 952 N.E.2 1020.
I , A
. D , ,
.
, 840 F.S.2 1013 .5. I ,
M. J CDA.
A , ,
, ,
. S
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 51
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
56/75
43
230
. , 521 F.3 1167.
I,
,
.
U ,
. T M.
J M. R
, M. R , ,
. A, M. R
A , , CDA.
2. , , .
A , CDA
. F ,
M. J .
H,
, . T
A
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 52
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
57/75
44
M. J. . .,
703 F.S.2 862, 879 (N.D.I. 2010) (
, CDA
.) ( ).
S,
, A
M. J:
1.) T A ; .TD.;F,
, . ,840 F.S.2 1012.
2.) T M. R ; H . I , . I R
. .
3.) M. R O C; M , R , . I , D A. H
..
T ,
.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 53
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
58/75
45
. W ,
A .TD.
,
. , 840 F.S.2 1012.
T , , T .
. . 1011. T
.
F, ,
. F , K
, M
A .. . , , 2012
WL 3335284 (W.D.M. 2012). I ,
A ; CDA
. . *5 (
) ( , ,544 F.S.2 933); , .
., 842 F.S.2 450, 473 (E.D.N.Y. 2011) (
.. CDA
); , , 952 N.E.2 1011, 17 N.Y.3 281, 2011 WL 2313818
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 54
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
59/75
46
(N.Y. 2011) ( ..
CDA ).
T C A
, CDA
. O , C
230 . , 952 N.E.2 1018, 17 N.Y.3 29091.
T M. J
: ..,
://.. CDA .
T
. R, , .
T, CDA
. F ,
, CDA
( ).
T C
, , A
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 55
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
60/75
47
.5 S
CDA ,
.T. .A.
.TD.. N CDA
.
F,
, I . ,
433 F.S.2 533 (,S I
. S I ,
, , , ,
, . B
.) F ,
, .
, ..,, , 339 F.3 1120 (
5F , : .PPDCASJ..
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 56
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
61/75
48
,
..);, 570 F.3 1098 (, T
, ,
.. );
.. . , , 809 F.S.2 1041, 1043 (E.D.M. 2011)
( , ,
..
); . , ., 783 S.2 1010 (F. 2001) ( CDA
; ..).
A , ,
. T,
CDA .
H, CDA
, .
T . ,
,
. E
;
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 57
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
62/75
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
63/75
50
. T ,
D W ,
, , . .., 2012 WL 3335284. T
. F ,
CDA A .
. ..
T
.TD. . O , : R
.
H . H . I
, . , 840
F.S.2 1012.6 B , M. R
.
6T : I R .,840 F.S.2 1012. T . D. #642 8, 30. H, CDA
. . , ., 2013 WL 664231, *3 (E.D.P. 2013) (G .); ., ., 2010 WL 3222147, *3 (N.D.C. 2010) (); ( .
, 2012 WL 97632, *8 (D.C. 2012) (); , 54F.S.2 93132 ().
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 59
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
64/75
51
T
CDA 1996 . I
, , M. R
C
.
O , ,
M. R CDA
/, ,
, , . D. #642 4, 15. I , M. R
2009, 2,200
. D. 1771 4, 1012, P ID #2699.
S CDA 1996,
. O ,
( )
C
CDA;
230. , 521 F.3 1171; , 129 F.3 330 (,
, ,
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 60
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
65/75
52
.); , , , . .
., 206 F.3 980, 986 (10
C. 2000) (, C
230
.)
M. R
CDA. , 433
F.S.2 530 (
; I
, 230
C .);
. !, ., 2011 WL 5079526 (N.D.C. 2011).
A , M. R
.
. . T
?
M. R .
2013 WL 4068780, *4. Y ,
.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 61
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
66/75
53
F,
. M. R
. M. R
, I
.
I, M. R
;
. I
, CDA .
. , 182 C.A.4323, 328, 105 C.R.3 791, 795 (C.A.
3 D. 2010) ( CDA
;
,
. T ,
. N
.); , 333 F.3 1022.
T . M. R
. T
. U
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 62
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
67/75
54
, M. R
. T, M. R
, CDA .
L, CDA,
. O ,
.
F , . , 774 F.S.2 310 (D.D.C. 2011)
. A (
BAM BAM)
, BAM CDA
. T :
P CDA BAM . H, . I, CDA, I,
.
, 774 F.S.2 316 ( ) ( , 591 F.3
253 ( 47 U.S.C. 230()(2)).
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 63
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
68/75
55
S, . , 311 S.W.3 210 (T.A. 2010),
( )
. T
: . I
. O .
, 311 S.W.3 216. B ,
,
. .
T T ,
,
G B . .
F , CDA
. . 217. A ,
CDA
.
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 64
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
69/75
56
. A , CDA ,
M. R
,
. A , A
.
H, M. R
M. J . S,
, M.
R : I D A .
I , O
( D
A): I D A . , 840 F.S.2
101213. I , M. R
M. J.
T , ,
M. J (
B ) O 27, 2009,
M. J M. R
. A, M. R
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 65
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
70/75
57
,
, M. J
M. R .
U,
. S, CDA ,
:
R , : I DIRTY ARMY
; N DIRTY ARMY; Y S. F , J 9, 2010, B F
. (D. 642 30).
, 2013 WL 4068780, *5 ( ).
T . T
J 2010; O 27,
2009 M. R .
T . T
M. J B
O 27, 2009.
A (ECF D. #642, P ID #507)
J 9, 2010,
, .
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 66
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
71/75
58
T 1 M. R
:
T P O27, 2009 G D I A. T J 9, 2010 I . O , O 27, 2009 J 9, 2010 .B , O 27, 2009 (.., J 9, 2010 ) .
D. #642 5, P ID #482.
A, M. J M. R
. T, M. J
B O 27, 2009,
M. R (
M. J ) D 19, 2009
. ECF D. #642 P ID #519.
G ,
M. R
. T,
M. R
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 67
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
72/75
59
M. J,
.
.
F ,
A.
D: N 12, 2013 // D S. GD S. G, E.
G L O, PLLC4802 E R R, #23271P, A 85044T: (480) 2641400E: D@GL.
A C. W, E.A B. M, E.H B, LLP855 C A, S 301A, KY 41105T.: (606) 3298771F: (606) 3244651@.@.
D W, LLC N LR
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 68
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
73/75
60
1. T F. R. A.P. 32()(7)(B) 13,976 ,
F. R. A. P. 32()(7)(B)().
2. T F. R. A. P.32()(5) F. R. A. P. 32()(6)
M W
T N R .
D: N 12, 2013 // D S. GD S. G, E.G L O, PLLC4802 E R R, #23271
P, A 85044T: (480) 2641400F: (480) 2483196E: D@GL.
D W, LLC N LR
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 69
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
74/75
61
(6C. R 30()(1))
. #
#1 12/23/2009 C W J D 17
20 8/27/2010 M L A 6163
22 8/31/2010 S A C 7481
641 9/21/2011 D M F S J 442477
642 9/21/2011 A O N LR I S OD M F S J
478519
68 10/12/2011 P M C DM T D 804814
70 10/26/2011 R I S D M FS J 818830
76 1/10/2012 O D D M FS J 845855
177 3/07/2013 D R M F SJ 26762695
1771 3/07/2013 A N LR I S OD R M F S
J
26962789
186 4/01/2013 P M C DM F S J 29933001
187 4/11/2013 R I S O D RM F S J 30023022
188 4/18/2013 O D D R MF S J 30233024
192 5/18/2013 D P J I 30333054
207 7/11/20132 J I (A G) 31163133
208 7/11/2013 F J 3134
209 7/15/2013 N O A 31353137
210 8/12/2013M O D DM F J A A M O L
31383149
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 70
-
8/14/2019 Sarah Jones v. Dirty World - Opening Appellate Brief
75/75
U.S. C A D N: 135946
I I C C U S C A S C CM/ECF N 12, 2013.
//D S. G
Case: 13-5946 Document: 006111880224 Filed: 11/12/2013 Page: 71