rta supplement to austroads part 2 - 2006 design considerations

16
RTA Supplement Guide to R  __________________________________________________________________ oad Design Part 2 (Austroads)  ____________________________ RTA Austroads Guide Supplements Publication Number: RTA/Pub. 11.091 Publication date: 3 March 2011 Supersedes : Nil RTA Supplement to AUSTROADS GUIDE TO ROAD DESIGN PART 2 (2006): DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS General Austroads has released the Guide to Road Design Part 2 – Design Considerations and all road agencies across Australasia have agreed to adopt the Austroads guides to provide a level of consistency and harmonisation across all jurisdictions. This agreement means that the new Austroads guides and the Australian Standards, which are referenced in them, will become the primary technical references for use within the Authority. This supplement is issued to clarify, add to, or modify the Austroads Guide to Road Design Part 2 – Design Considerations. The RTA NSW accepts the principles in the Austroads Guide to Road Design Part 2: Design Considerations with variations documented in this supplement. These variations fall into two categories:  RTA Complementary Material: RTA Design Reference Documents reference material that complements the Austroads Guides. These documents include RTA Manuals, Technical Directions and/or other reference material and are to be read in conjunction with the Austroads Guides.  RTA Departures: RTA road design practices that depart from the Austroads Guides. See also the RTA Supplements for the other parts to the Austroads  Guide to Road Design Series and the RTA Supplements to the other Austroads Series. All Reference Documents mentioned in this part should be checked against the RTA Design Reference Documents. UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 1 (16 pages)

Upload: neodisciple-rego6719

Post on 18-Oct-2015

24 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

RTA Supplement to Austroads Part 2 - 2006 Design Considerations

TRANSCRIPT

  • RTA Supplement Guide to R__________________________________________________________________

    oad Design Part 2 (Austroads) ____________________________

    RTA Austroads Guide Supplements

    Publication Number: RTA/Pub. 11.091

    Publication date: 3 March 2011 Supersedes : Nil

    RTA Supplement to

    AUSTROADS GUIDE TO ROAD DESIGN

    PART 2 (2006): DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS

    General Austroads has released the Guide to Road Design Part 2 Design Considerations and all road agencies across Australasia have agreed to adopt the Austroads guides to provide a level of consistency and harmonisation across all jurisdictions. This agreement means that the new Austroads guides and the Australian Standards, which are referenced in them, will become the primary technical references for use within the Authority. This supplement is issued to clarify, add to, or modify the Austroads Guide to Road Design Part 2 Design Considerations. The RTA NSW accepts the principles in the Austroads Guide to Road Design Part 2: Design Considerations with variations documented in this supplement. These variations fall into two categories:

    RTA Complementary Material: RTA Design Reference Documents reference

    material that complements the Austroads Guides. These documents include RTA Manuals, Technical Directions and/or other reference material and are to be read in conjunction with the Austroads Guides.

    RTA Departures: RTA road design practices that depart from the Austroads Guides.

    See also the RTA Supplements for the other parts to the Austroads Guide to Road Design Series and the RTA Supplements to the other Austroads Series. All Reference Documents mentioned in this part should be checked against the RTA Design Reference Documents.

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 1 (16 pages)

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    Document Information Title: RTA Supplement to

    AUSTROADS GUIDE TO Part 2 (2006) : Design Considerations

    Branch / Section: Road Design Engineering / Technology Standards (Road) Author: TechnologyStandards(Road)Contributors: TechnologyStandards(Road)Endorsed by: PrincipalRoadDesignEngineer,PatKenny Approved by: ChairofAustroadsReferenceGroup,ChrisHarrison Date of approval and Effect:

    3 March 2011

    Audience: Public Next Review Date: 17/3/2012 Publication Number: RTA/Pub.11.091 Keywords: Supplement, Austroads, Part 2, Design Considerations,

    Road Design.

    Document History Version Date Reason for Amendment Page No. Editor 1.0 17/3/2011 Published All Technology

    Standards (Road)

    For enquiries and further issues to be added to this supplement email Austroads Supplements

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 2 (16 pages)

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    ReferenceSection

    RTAEnhancedPractice,ComplementaryMaterial,orDepartures

    Date

    General RTApracticeforActsRTA

    ,RegulationsandRules.role/purpose:

    TransportAdministrationAct1988RoadClassification/RoadAuthorityPowers: RoadsAct1993 RoadsRegulation2008Ro mentpowers:adRules/enforce RoadRules2008 RoadTransport(General)Regulation2005

    RTAcomplementarymaterial:DesignReferenceDocuments

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 3 (16 pages)

    ReferenceSection

    RTAEnhancedPractice,ComplementaryMaterial,orresDepartu

    Date

    CONTENPgii

    TS Delete:1.1Introduction....................................................................................................11.2Strategicfit.................................................................................................11.3Natureandmagnitudeoftransportdemand..............................21.4Safety...........................................................................................................31.4.1Safetyobjectives............................................................................. 31.4.2Designingforsafety.......................................................................31.5Communityexpectations...................................................................51.6Reducedtraveltimeandcostsincludingfreightcosts..........51.7Reducedfreightcosts..........................................................................61.8Improvedpublictransport................................................................6

    Provisionforcyclistsandpedestrians.......................................61.9

    CONTENPgii

    TS Insert:2.5BelowDesignDomain...........................................................16after

    2.4.3Speedparameters.............................................................16and

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 4 (16 pages)

    before3DESIGNCONSIDERATIONS....................................................17

    Section1 Deletesections1.1Introductionto1.9ProvisionforcyclistsandpedestriansandtheircontentsandInsertafter1DESIGNOBJECTIVESandbefore2CONTEXTSENSITIVEDESIGNthefollowing:TheplanningapproachadoptedforinfrastructurecontrolledbyNSWRTAissetoutintheNetworkandCorridorPlanningPracticeNotes(RTA2008).NSWRTAundertakesnetworkandcorridorplanningtoidentifyexistingandanticipatedperformanceissues,determinerelative

    erprioritiesanddevelopappropriatestrategiestoaddresstheseovthelongerterm.Theoverallframeworkisdescribedfromnetworklevelthroughcorridor,routeandprojectlevel.Atthenetworklevel,theplanningobjectivesincludefourareas:transportdemand,asset,safetyandenvironment.Theroadclassificationisdescribedandthelinkagebetweenmeasuresandobjectivesisillustrated.Forcorridorplanning,eightthemesareusedandthesearedescribedinNetworkandCorridorPlanningPracticeNotes(November2008).Attheroutelevel,asetofmeasuresandtargetstomeetthenetworklevelplanningobjectivesoftransportdemand,asset,safetyandenvironmentaredescribedinthe'NetworkPerformanceMeasuresandNetworkPlanningTargets'(RTA2010).

    TherelationshipbetweenNetworkDemandandNetworkSupplyisalsodescribedwithanexpandeddiscussionofmeasuresoverandabovethosedetailedinRTA2008.ItshouldbenotedthatthereisadifferencebetweenmeasuresandtargetsandPerformanceMeasuresareusedtorefertoperformancelevelswhentheroadcarriestrafficwhilePlanningTargetsaredesirablelevelsofaphysicalcharacteristicsuchaslanewidthtobeachievedoveraperiodoftime.Deficienciesonarouteinrelationtostandardsforeachphysicalroadcharacteristicarealsoexplainedandillustrated.Thepriorityroadcharacteristics,thatis,thephysicalcharacteristicsofaroad,havebeenderivedfromalistofperformancemeasuresinlinewithkeyresultareasoftransport,asset,safetyandenvironmentandspecifictargetsforeachofthesecharacteristicsaregiven.Forurbanprojects,againattheroutelevel,asetofmeasuresand

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 5 (16 pages)

    targetstomeetplanningobjectivesoftransportdemand,asset,afetyandenvironmentaredescribedinthe'NetworkPerformancesMeasuresandNetworkPlanningTargets'(RTA2010).ThetargetsforpriorityroadcharacteristicssetoutinRTA2009andRTA2010arecriticalconsiderationsinthedesignofprojectsandintheabsenceofprojectorroutespecificvaluesaretobetakenasthefundamentaldesignobjectivesfortheproject.Itshouldbenotedthatastargetstheydonotexcludestagedimprovementsworkingtowardtherequiredultimatevalues.

    ForroadcharacteristicsnotaddressedinprojectorroutespecificdocumentsorinRTA2009andRTA2010,thevaluessetoutinthisdocumentaretobeadoptedinthefirstinstance.

    Insomesituationsincludingtransitioningbetweenoldandnewwork,itmaybenecessarytomodifythesevalues.WherethesetargetsorstandardscannotbemetandtheRTAhasgivenermission,thenthecontextsensitivedesignapproachmaybep

    exercised.Thisapproachisdescribedbelow.TheRTAiscommittedtoasafeworkingenvironmentforitsworkers.

    Agooddesignconsiderssafeconstruction,maintenance,operationanddemolition.

    Itisthereforedesirablethattheplanningprocesstakeintoaccountoccupationalhealthandsafety(OHS)issuestoprovideguidanceandalsoallowsufficientflexibilityforthedesignprocesstoproduce'safedesign'.

    TheRTAisreviewingitsproceduresforincorporatingOHSissuesintoitsplanningprocess.

    TheRTAalsorequiresthataProjectOHSDevelopmentPlaniscompletedateveryphaseofthedesignofanindividualproject.Theprojectmanagermayrequirethedesignertobeinvolvedinthe

    theProjectOHSDevelopmentPlanseePart8.realisationofParagraph2DeleteToquoteFHWA,undated)aftertheproject.andbefore

    e.Thechalleng

    Section2

    Paragraph3Deletesafetyafterenvironmentalimpactsandbeforelossofconsistencyandinsertusersafetygenerallythroughtheappropriateapplicationofroaddesignstandards.

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 6 (16 pages)

    Paragrasert

    ph3In

    theprojectincludingperationanddemolition

    Workersafetyoverthelifeofconstruction,maintenance,o

    andbeforelossof.aftersafetyParagrasert

    ph3In

    Trafficcapacityspecificcommunityissues

    set,suchasthe factorsthatmayaffectthelifeoftheasallowablemaximumvehicleloading

    constructabilityandmaintainabilityratingcosts)andbeforeaesthetics.afterope

    Paragraph3eendproducttheInsertafteraesthetics.andbeforeTh

    following:CSDisusedforthefollowingreasons:

    o ueItrequiresdesignerstorecognisethecommercialvalofanexistingroad.

    o forItreducesusageofthescarceresourcesrequiredpavements.

    o Ittakesintoaccounttheprivateandcommunityinfrastructurethathasbuiltuparoundanexistingroad

    hcorridorandthepotentialdisruptionassociatedwitchangestotheexistingalignment.

    o Thelandscapebenefitsassociatedwithearlierroadlocationpracticesareoftenbetterthanthedominationofthelandformthatcanresultfromnew,highspeedalignments.

    AnimportantpartofCSDapproachistherelationshipbetweentravelspeedandtheexistinggeometricalignment.Thisinvolvesestablishingrealisticexpectationsaboutthenatureofthealignmentonanarterialroutesectorfortheforeseeablefuture.Itbuildsonthedesignmethodsusedtodeliverselfenforcingdriveroperatingspeeds.Paragraph3InsertAfurtheroptionistodefervariouselementsoftheultimatedesignuntilalaterstage,refertoCommentaryK[seeCommentaryK]afteraesthetics.andbeforeTheendproduct.

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 7 (16 pages)

    Paragraph3DeletetheFigureoccurringafterofeachselection.andbeforeFigure2.1:TheDesignandinsertthefollowingFigure:

    Section2.1

    Paragraph4Insertafterdesignelementsinvolved.andbeforeUsingthisconceptthefollowing:Routetargetsaretobeusedinthefirstinstancebecausetheyshouldalreadyhavebothextendeddesigndomainandbelowthedesigndomainconsiderationsincluded.Alternatively,normaldesigndomainvaluesintheabsenceofaroutestandardfortheparticularparameter,shouldbeadopted.TheuseofExtendedDesignDomainisfurtherqualifiedinPart8.BelowtheDesignDomainvaluesareonlytobeusedwherestrictadherencetodomainvalueswouldresultinadesignoutcome

    chwhichisnotviableandwheretheRTAhasallowedtheuseofsuvalues.TheuseofvaluesthatwouldconstituteeitherExtendedDesign

    tenDomainorBelowtheDesignDomainrequirethepriorwritconcurrenceofthePrincipalRoadDesignEngineer.'RoadGeometryAnalyst'isacomputersoftwareavailabletodesignerstoassisttheminidentifyingdeficienciesonexistingroads.Whereverpossible,itshouldbeusedinconjunctionwithclientbriefinformationsuchasaccidentdata,todevelopdesignsonanexistingalignment.TheuseofvaluesthatwouldconstitutetheExtendedDesignDomainrequiresthepriorwrittenconcurrenceofthePrincipalRoadDesignEngineer.Theuseofvaluesthatwouldconstitute

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 8 (16 pages)

    BelowtheDesignDomainrequiresthePrincipalRoadDesignngineertobeconsulted.E

    Paragraph5

    afterasit:isandbeforedirectlyrelatedtoDeletemoreParagraph6InsertIntheabsenceofaroutestandardandafterare

    ndbeforeAsageneralimportant.aParagraph6Deletemoreimportantandinsertclass46afterdesigningand

    .beforeroadsParagraph7Insertintheabsenceofaroutestandard,afterSimilarly,and

    sinthe.beforevalueParagraph8InsertRefertoPart8,4.7.2DesignDepartures/Exceptionsfordetailsofwhendesignexceptionsshouldnotbeusedafterand

    oreFigure2.2.risks.andbefParagraph10Delete:

    eeringcommunityvalues.afterwillberequired.Tosomeextent

    Theseenginandbeforeandinsert:Wherethesevaluesareoutsideofthedesigndomain(bothnormalandextended),thisthenbecomesa"BelowtheDesignDomain"decisionandisnotnormallytakenbythedesignerbutbytheProjectManagerutilisingadvicefromthedesigner.Furtherinformationonthe"BelowtheDesignDomain"conceptisgivenin2.5.Paragraph11

    Insertafterapproachtodesign.andbeforeFigure2.2.thefollowing:ForfurtherdetailofDesignDepartures/ExceptionsrefertoAustroadsProcessandDocumentationPart8Section4.7.2.ArecordofallDesignDepartures/ExceptionsmustbeincludedintheDesignReporttogetherwiththeappropriateroadauthoritysignoffforeach.

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 9 (16 pages)

    Paragraph2Delete11.2ofGuidetotheGeometricDesignofRuralRoads(Austraods,2003)afterreferSectionandbeforeInsomecasesandinsert4.2.6ofGuidetoRoadDesignPart3:

    adDesign(Austroads,2009).GeometricRoParagraph2InsertRefertoPart1forRTAsOrderofPrecedenceafterabove

    eforeThepractical.3.0m).andbParagraph3Delete3.0occurringafterruralroadisandbeforem(refer

    dinsert3.1.Sectionan

    Section2.2

    Paragraph3Delete11.2,Austroads,2003occurringafterreferSectionandbefore).Asageneralandinsert4.2.6ofGuidetoRoadDesign

    etricRoadDesign,Austroads,2009.Part3:Geom

    Paragraph3DeleteAustroadshasdefined(Table2.2).andinsertRTAhasdefinedasystemoffunctionalclassificationforruralandurban

    TA2010).roads(referR

    Section2.4.1

    Paragraph4DeleteInruralareastrafficfunction.whichincludesTables2.2and2.3.

    Section2.4.3 AfterParagraph2Insertafterurbanroads.andbefore3DESIGN

    CONSIDERATIONSthefollowing:2.5BelowDesignDomain(BDD)Itmustberecognisedthatnotallroadworksrequireplansorgeometricdesign.Manymaintenanceworksfallintothiscategory,includingactivitiessuchasresealing(withoutimprovementinwidth),shoulderresheeting(withoutimprovementinwidth),relinemarkingandpavementrepairs.Otheractivitiesincludingasphaltoverlays,granularoverlaysorwideningandorsealingofpartoralloftheshouldersmaynotaffectthehorizontalorverticalalignmentandmayhavedrawingstofacilitateminorshapecorrections.However,theseactivitiesmayalsoproduceanettresultsuchthattheoveralldesignstandardhasbeeneffectivelyreducedandaBelowtheDesignDomainsituationexists.ThereforeadvicefromRoadDesignEngineeringmustbesoughttoidentifyandcorrectanyissuesdirectlyrelatedtochanges

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 10 (16 pages)

    suchaslevels,roadsidefurniture,drainage,frictionfactorsetc.anditisexpectedthatthiswouldincludeanassessmentofthepotentialimpactondriverbehaviour(includingtheeffectonoperatingspeed)andappropriatedesigntocorrectanydeficienciesbroughtaboutbythis.

    Thelevelofgeometricdesignappliedtotheseworkswillbedrivenbyfactorsoutsidethedesignerscontrol,inparticular,theleveloffundingavailabletoroadauthoritiesundertheseprogrammes.

    ItcanbeseenfromFigure2.1thatcostsandbenefitscontinuetodecreaseforvaluesofdesignparametersbelowtheDesignDomain,buttheremaystillbenettsafetybenefitsbydoingworkinthisareaknownasBelowtheDesignDomain.ThetopofthisrangeisdefinedbythebottomoftheEDD,thepreferablelowerlimitforrestorationworks.Generally,valuesintheBDDrangecannotbesupportedonengineeringgroundsbut,nevertheless,theremaybecircumstancesinwhichdesignersareobligedtoproduceDrawingsusingvaluesinthisareaandmayachieveaddedsafetyvaluebycontributingdesignadvice.

    Roaddesignerscanaddvalueinthefollowingareas:

    hintheidentifyinginconsistentgeometricelementswitprojectlength

    identifyinginconsistentgeometricelementsonimmediatelyadjoininglengthsofroadwherea

    nsubstandardgeometricelementistoberetainedexaminingtherecordedcrashesattheparticularlocatio

    providingadviceontheuseoftrafficmanagementdevicesthatprovidewarningtoapproachingmotorists

    eandmaymitigatetheriskassociatedwithadoptingthlowervalue.

    TheRTAhasestablisheda"DesignMatrixshowingthetypesofinvestigationrequiredwhenundertakingvarioustypesofmaintenance/rehabilitation/reconstructionactivities"(seeRTASupplementtoPart1Clause3.2.2)

    TheRTAhasestablishedvaluesforvariousroaddesignparametersbasedonNDD,EDDandBDDandthesearespecifiedinthedraftRTARuralNetworkPlanningTargets(RTA,2009)andRTAUrbanNetworkPlanningTargets(RTA,2010).

    iskfactorsforBrownfieldssitesarediscussedinCommentaryV.R

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 11 (16 pages)

    Paragraph3Insertafterforfurtherguidance.andbeforeTable3.1:Checklistthefollowing:Onallprojects,eveniftheyarereasonablysimple,recordsmustbekeptanddocumentationprovidedofallprojectdecisionmakingmatters.Forsmallerprojects,thismayjustbeashortsectionintheDesignReport.Forlargerprojectsitwillinvolveacompletestudywithaacilitatoranddetailedreportingofoutcomes,whichwillthenfbecomepartoftheprojectrecords.Thereportmustshowthatalltheissueshavebeenfullyconsideredandthatappropriateremedialmeasureshavebeendeterminedwhererequired.Thesedocumentsmustbeavailableforfutureaccessifrequired,andtheprocessmustbefullytransparent.Anyopportunitiestoprovidecostsavingsbydeferringunnecessaryworksmustbepursued.Thismaymeanthatsomeformationwidening,sealingorotherimprovementsaredonewhilepavementstructuralworkisdeferred(ifpracticable)untillater.Forexample,iftheremaininglifeofthepavementandotherperformancemeasuresaresatisfactory,thepavementstructuraloverlayandstrengtheningmaybeabletobelefttothenextincrementalimprovementreview,whichcouldbeupto10yearsinthefuture.Ontheotherhand,potentialbudgetshortfallsforriskreducingorotherworksshouldbeaddressedandmustbediscussedandapprovedbythedelegationsasoutlinedinheRTA'sNetworkPlanningTargets.tTable3.1ChecklistfordesignconsiderationsCONSTRUCTIONFACTORSInsert,REHABILITATION&RECONSTRUCTIONafterCONSTRUCTIONandbeforeFACTORS.Delete[seeCommentaryK]afterproposalsandbeforeTrafficmanagement.

    Section3.1

    MAINTENANCEFACTORSertafterfacilitydesignandbeforeINDUSTRIALFACTORSthelowi

    Insfol

    ng: designdetailsincludingparkingbaysforaccess sealingunderbarriersetctominimiseworkerexposure

    locationofroadsidefurnituretomaximiseworkersaccessandminimiserisk

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    COMMENTARYA

    DeletecontentandinsertNotUsed.

    COMMENTARYB

    DeletecontentandinsertNotUsed.

    COMMENTARYC

    DeletecontentandinsertNotUsed.

    COMMENTARYD

    DeletecontentandinsertNotUsed.

    Paragraph3sionafterandwiththeandbeforeofthepublic.Deleteinclu

    Paragraph4Delete

    ex.htmefore

    http://www.kytc.state.ky.us/design/designmanual/indafterhttp://www.tfhrc.gov/focus/oct02/02.htmandb

    d/context/index.htm.http://www.dot.ca.gov/hq/oppFigureF.1:Conceptualdiagram

    aftervalueforaandbeforeroadDeletenewParagraph7Deletebecomeincreasinglycapability.afterbecausetheyandbeforeAnydecisionandinsertcannotbesupportedonpurely

    unds.technicalgroParagraph8Deletecrashaftersupportedbyandbeforeanalysisandinsert

    .appropriateParagraph8DeleteItmustalsoofcrashes.aftercrashanalysis.andbefore

    evices.MitigatingdParagraph9

    eNewZealand(TNZ,1998).Deleteorth

    COMMENTARYE

    Paragraph9InsertAmajorconsiderationintheuseofmitigatingdevicessuchassignpostingistheresponsetimetoeffectrepairsshoulddamageoccur.afterhazards,etc.andbeforeCOMMENTARYG.

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 12 (16 pages)

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 13 (16 pages)

    Paragraph1DeleteorLandTransportNewZealand(LTNZ)after

    teAustroadsandbeforestandardvehicle.appropriaParagraph1InsertfortheDesignVehicleandfortheCheckingVehicle.afteradoptedandbefore(referto.TableG1:DesignvehiclesAustraliaDeleteTableG1:DesignVehiclesAustraliaanditscontentsand

    SEDinsertNOTUParagraph1Deletethetablesbelowafter(refertoandbeforeTableG1:andinsertPart3:GeometricDesign2.2.5DesignVehicleandPart4Intersections5.2and5.3..TableG2:DesignVehiclesNewZealandDeleteTableG2:DesignVehiclesNewZealand.anditscontents

    OTUSED.andinsertNParagraph2Insertdesignedandafterdesignshouldbeandbeforecheckedfor.

    COMMENTARYG

    Paragraph2Deleteforthelargesttheroad,afterbecheckedandbefore

    stroads.usingtheAu

    COMMENTARYH

    Paragraph1Insertafter..andfillsarerequired.andbeforeCOMMENTARYI,thefollowing:Thecostpenaltyforincreasingthedesignspeedfrom60km/hto80km/h,70km/hto90km/h,or80km/hto100km/hinundulating,andhillyterrainmaybeinthevicinityofbetween2to3timesthecostsofthelowerspeedalignment.Thiswillincreasefurtherwhenmountaincountryisencountered.Infactinmostcasesitwouldbeimpossibletoeconomicallyandpracticallyobtainadesignof100km/hinmostmountainrelatedterrainsduetohorizontalandverticalalignmentrestrictions.Hence,contextsenstivedesignbasedonanoperatingspeedapproachwillbenecessarytodeliveranppropriateengineeredoutcomea

    COMMENTARY Paragraph2

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 14 (16 pages)

    K Insertafterfuturesignalisation.andbeforeCOMMENTARYL,thefollowing:Fromanassetperspective,retrofitting,replacementorupgradingoftheexistingroadnetworkisamajorissueandthereisalimittotheamountoffundsavailable.Asaresult,theRTAhastakenalongtermviewandadoptedabestfornetwork,routeandroadapproachintryingtomaintainwhilealsoupgradingthestateroadsystem.Thisinvolvesifnecessaryadoptingastagedorincrementalapproachtoworkpriorities.Thebasisoftheincrementalapproachistotryandachievethewidestsealsandshoulderwidthspossiblewithinexistingformationstomeetdemandinacosteffectiveway.Alternativelyiffundspermit,provideforthefinaldesignformationwidth,wherethisisnotalreadyavailable.Thiscanthenbeusedtoachievefuturefullpavementandsealedshoulderwidths,drainage,clearzoneandbetterverticalalignmentwhichareabletobeprogressivelyimprovedduringanyfutureupgrades.

    COMMENTARYM

    Insertafterbudgetfunding.andbeforeCOMMENTARYNthefollowing:WhenundertakingeconomicanalysistheRTAreliesonawholeoflifeandbenefit/costanalysisindeterminingthebestoption.Oftenthemajorcostisnottheinitialcost,itistheongoinglifecycleostwhichincludesannualandperiodic,usingeitherrecurrentorapitalfunding.cc

    COMMENTARYN

    Insertafterstandardunaffordable.andbeforeCOMMENTARYOthefollowing:ItisimportantthatdesignersandprojectmanagersunderstandwhytheyaredoingorarenotdoingcertainthingsinrelationtoproDec

    jects.isionsthatimpactaretakeninsuchareasas:thepriorities,policiesandgoalsoftheStateGovernment, includingStateTreasurypoliciessuchasTotalAsset

    sportpolicy ManagementGuidelinesmeetingTransportNSWdirectionsforoveralltranmeetingtheRTAscorporateplanningobjectives

    COMMENTARYQ

    Insertlightrail/afterorbetterandbeforetramstops.

    COMMENTARY Paragraph4

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 15 (16 pages)

    T DeleteThesemeasuresaresummarisedspeedincludingTableT1anditscontentsafterofeffectiveness.andbeforeAnumberofconditions.

    COMMENTARYV

    InsertafterthisGuidetoRoadDesign.thefollowing:COMMENTARYVRiskManagementtechniquescanbeappliedatalloperationallevels,fromthestrategiclevel(suchasRegionalRouteStandards)tothedeliveryoflocalprojects.Followingareaseriesofriskissuesthatcouldbeusedasachecklist,orconsideworks:

    redforimplementationonprogrammedpavement /ortheratechangesintheprogrammingoftheworksand

    offundingcostproblemsthatleadtoabudgetoverrun

    changesinthenumberofESAcarriedbythenewwork,leadingtoasignificantreductionindesignlifeforthepavement

    geunknownenvironmentalissuessuchasaburiedheritaitemnotfounduntilexcavated

    errorsintheassumptionsaboutthepavementdesigne)

    (especiallyregardingthestrengthofthesubgradsafetytargets(bothstrategicandlocal)notbeingmet

    incidentsoccurringduringtheprojectthatdrawattentiontoproblemsthatwerenotpreviouslyevident

    notexpectationsofstakeholders(especiallytheRAM)beingmetbythefinishedwork

    emergenceofanunrecognisedstakeholderwhoseexpectationsareimportanttotheprojectoutcomes

    workprogramsrequiringadjustmentduetoproblemsertise,withtheavailabilityofimportantresources(exp

    materials,plant) withdrawaloffundsatcriticaltimesbecauseof

    emergencyissuesatotherlocationsonthenetwork roaduserspeedperceptionissues.Forexample,drivers

    mayperceivethatanewsurfacecreatedfromaroutineresealiscapableofsustaininghigheroperatingspeeds,eventhoughthealignmentandsignpostedlimitsremainunchanged

    problemswiththedrainagesystemduringthecourseofthework

    utilityadjustmentsthataredelayedornotidentifiedinthestrategicprojectplanningstage

    eliveryofincreasesintheunitratesforthesupplyandd

    pavementmaterialsdefective/delayedsuppliesofcriticalmaterialproblemswithsafetyaudits

    StopWorkordersissuedbyauthorisedexternal

  • RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) __________________ ______________________________________________________

    ______________________

    UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 16 (16 pages)

    agencies industrialdisputes

    OH&Sissues adversepublicityfromcommunityrepresentativesthat

    divertsresourcesand/ornecessitatesalterationstotheproject

    communityprotestatlossofbusinessduringworks,orallfinals,interferencewithimportantlocalevents(footb

    localshows)heritageissuesarisingfrompoorinvestigation

    t,vibration,constructionngoftheworksprogram

    publichealthissues(noise,dusructuri

    traffic)thatrequirerest

    unexpectedgroundconditions

    problemswithutilities

    inadequateprovisionsfortraffic

    copeofworks eareas,disposalareas

    projectcreepduetochangesinsproblemswithhaulroutes,stora

    g vandalism/arson/theft/sabotage

    heavyraindamagingtheworks ower,programmingissueswithotheragencies(p

    railway)becomingcriticalwithdrawalofpoliticalsupportforproject

    projectvariationsexceedingavailablefunds postcompletiondefectsthathavebecomecritical.

    Detailsfrompostcompletionreportsarealsoimportantsourcesofinformationwhencarryingoutreviewsofkeyissuesthathavearisenfrompreviousprojects.