rta supplement to austroads part 2 - 2006 design considerations
DESCRIPTION
RTA Supplement to Austroads Part 2 - 2006 Design ConsiderationsTRANSCRIPT
-
RTA Supplement Guide to R__________________________________________________________________
oad Design Part 2 (Austroads) ____________________________
RTA Austroads Guide Supplements
Publication Number: RTA/Pub. 11.091
Publication date: 3 March 2011 Supersedes : Nil
RTA Supplement to
AUSTROADS GUIDE TO ROAD DESIGN
PART 2 (2006): DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS
General Austroads has released the Guide to Road Design Part 2 Design Considerations and all road agencies across Australasia have agreed to adopt the Austroads guides to provide a level of consistency and harmonisation across all jurisdictions. This agreement means that the new Austroads guides and the Australian Standards, which are referenced in them, will become the primary technical references for use within the Authority. This supplement is issued to clarify, add to, or modify the Austroads Guide to Road Design Part 2 Design Considerations. The RTA NSW accepts the principles in the Austroads Guide to Road Design Part 2: Design Considerations with variations documented in this supplement. These variations fall into two categories:
RTA Complementary Material: RTA Design Reference Documents reference
material that complements the Austroads Guides. These documents include RTA Manuals, Technical Directions and/or other reference material and are to be read in conjunction with the Austroads Guides.
RTA Departures: RTA road design practices that depart from the Austroads Guides.
See also the RTA Supplements for the other parts to the Austroads Guide to Road Design Series and the RTA Supplements to the other Austroads Series. All Reference Documents mentioned in this part should be checked against the RTA Design Reference Documents.
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 1 (16 pages)
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
Document Information Title: RTA Supplement to
AUSTROADS GUIDE TO Part 2 (2006) : Design Considerations
Branch / Section: Road Design Engineering / Technology Standards (Road) Author: TechnologyStandards(Road)Contributors: TechnologyStandards(Road)Endorsed by: PrincipalRoadDesignEngineer,PatKenny Approved by: ChairofAustroadsReferenceGroup,ChrisHarrison Date of approval and Effect:
3 March 2011
Audience: Public Next Review Date: 17/3/2012 Publication Number: RTA/Pub.11.091 Keywords: Supplement, Austroads, Part 2, Design Considerations,
Road Design.
Document History Version Date Reason for Amendment Page No. Editor 1.0 17/3/2011 Published All Technology
Standards (Road)
For enquiries and further issues to be added to this supplement email Austroads Supplements
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 2 (16 pages)
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
ReferenceSection
RTAEnhancedPractice,ComplementaryMaterial,orDepartures
Date
General RTApracticeforActsRTA
,RegulationsandRules.role/purpose:
TransportAdministrationAct1988RoadClassification/RoadAuthorityPowers: RoadsAct1993 RoadsRegulation2008Ro mentpowers:adRules/enforce RoadRules2008 RoadTransport(General)Regulation2005
RTAcomplementarymaterial:DesignReferenceDocuments
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 3 (16 pages)
ReferenceSection
RTAEnhancedPractice,ComplementaryMaterial,orresDepartu
Date
CONTENPgii
TS Delete:1.1Introduction....................................................................................................11.2Strategicfit.................................................................................................11.3Natureandmagnitudeoftransportdemand..............................21.4Safety...........................................................................................................31.4.1Safetyobjectives............................................................................. 31.4.2Designingforsafety.......................................................................31.5Communityexpectations...................................................................51.6Reducedtraveltimeandcostsincludingfreightcosts..........51.7Reducedfreightcosts..........................................................................61.8Improvedpublictransport................................................................6
Provisionforcyclistsandpedestrians.......................................61.9
CONTENPgii
TS Insert:2.5BelowDesignDomain...........................................................16after
2.4.3Speedparameters.............................................................16and
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 4 (16 pages)
before3DESIGNCONSIDERATIONS....................................................17
Section1 Deletesections1.1Introductionto1.9ProvisionforcyclistsandpedestriansandtheircontentsandInsertafter1DESIGNOBJECTIVESandbefore2CONTEXTSENSITIVEDESIGNthefollowing:TheplanningapproachadoptedforinfrastructurecontrolledbyNSWRTAissetoutintheNetworkandCorridorPlanningPracticeNotes(RTA2008).NSWRTAundertakesnetworkandcorridorplanningtoidentifyexistingandanticipatedperformanceissues,determinerelative
erprioritiesanddevelopappropriatestrategiestoaddresstheseovthelongerterm.Theoverallframeworkisdescribedfromnetworklevelthroughcorridor,routeandprojectlevel.Atthenetworklevel,theplanningobjectivesincludefourareas:transportdemand,asset,safetyandenvironment.Theroadclassificationisdescribedandthelinkagebetweenmeasuresandobjectivesisillustrated.Forcorridorplanning,eightthemesareusedandthesearedescribedinNetworkandCorridorPlanningPracticeNotes(November2008).Attheroutelevel,asetofmeasuresandtargetstomeetthenetworklevelplanningobjectivesoftransportdemand,asset,safetyandenvironmentaredescribedinthe'NetworkPerformanceMeasuresandNetworkPlanningTargets'(RTA2010).
TherelationshipbetweenNetworkDemandandNetworkSupplyisalsodescribedwithanexpandeddiscussionofmeasuresoverandabovethosedetailedinRTA2008.ItshouldbenotedthatthereisadifferencebetweenmeasuresandtargetsandPerformanceMeasuresareusedtorefertoperformancelevelswhentheroadcarriestrafficwhilePlanningTargetsaredesirablelevelsofaphysicalcharacteristicsuchaslanewidthtobeachievedoveraperiodoftime.Deficienciesonarouteinrelationtostandardsforeachphysicalroadcharacteristicarealsoexplainedandillustrated.Thepriorityroadcharacteristics,thatis,thephysicalcharacteristicsofaroad,havebeenderivedfromalistofperformancemeasuresinlinewithkeyresultareasoftransport,asset,safetyandenvironmentandspecifictargetsforeachofthesecharacteristicsaregiven.Forurbanprojects,againattheroutelevel,asetofmeasuresand
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 5 (16 pages)
targetstomeetplanningobjectivesoftransportdemand,asset,afetyandenvironmentaredescribedinthe'NetworkPerformancesMeasuresandNetworkPlanningTargets'(RTA2010).ThetargetsforpriorityroadcharacteristicssetoutinRTA2009andRTA2010arecriticalconsiderationsinthedesignofprojectsandintheabsenceofprojectorroutespecificvaluesaretobetakenasthefundamentaldesignobjectivesfortheproject.Itshouldbenotedthatastargetstheydonotexcludestagedimprovementsworkingtowardtherequiredultimatevalues.
ForroadcharacteristicsnotaddressedinprojectorroutespecificdocumentsorinRTA2009andRTA2010,thevaluessetoutinthisdocumentaretobeadoptedinthefirstinstance.
Insomesituationsincludingtransitioningbetweenoldandnewwork,itmaybenecessarytomodifythesevalues.WherethesetargetsorstandardscannotbemetandtheRTAhasgivenermission,thenthecontextsensitivedesignapproachmaybep
exercised.Thisapproachisdescribedbelow.TheRTAiscommittedtoasafeworkingenvironmentforitsworkers.
Agooddesignconsiderssafeconstruction,maintenance,operationanddemolition.
Itisthereforedesirablethattheplanningprocesstakeintoaccountoccupationalhealthandsafety(OHS)issuestoprovideguidanceandalsoallowsufficientflexibilityforthedesignprocesstoproduce'safedesign'.
TheRTAisreviewingitsproceduresforincorporatingOHSissuesintoitsplanningprocess.
TheRTAalsorequiresthataProjectOHSDevelopmentPlaniscompletedateveryphaseofthedesignofanindividualproject.Theprojectmanagermayrequirethedesignertobeinvolvedinthe
theProjectOHSDevelopmentPlanseePart8.realisationofParagraph2DeleteToquoteFHWA,undated)aftertheproject.andbefore
e.Thechalleng
Section2
Paragraph3Deletesafetyafterenvironmentalimpactsandbeforelossofconsistencyandinsertusersafetygenerallythroughtheappropriateapplicationofroaddesignstandards.
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 6 (16 pages)
Paragrasert
ph3In
theprojectincludingperationanddemolition
Workersafetyoverthelifeofconstruction,maintenance,o
andbeforelossof.aftersafetyParagrasert
ph3In
Trafficcapacityspecificcommunityissues
set,suchasthe factorsthatmayaffectthelifeoftheasallowablemaximumvehicleloading
constructabilityandmaintainabilityratingcosts)andbeforeaesthetics.afterope
Paragraph3eendproducttheInsertafteraesthetics.andbeforeTh
following:CSDisusedforthefollowingreasons:
o ueItrequiresdesignerstorecognisethecommercialvalofanexistingroad.
o forItreducesusageofthescarceresourcesrequiredpavements.
o Ittakesintoaccounttheprivateandcommunityinfrastructurethathasbuiltuparoundanexistingroad
hcorridorandthepotentialdisruptionassociatedwitchangestotheexistingalignment.
o Thelandscapebenefitsassociatedwithearlierroadlocationpracticesareoftenbetterthanthedominationofthelandformthatcanresultfromnew,highspeedalignments.
AnimportantpartofCSDapproachistherelationshipbetweentravelspeedandtheexistinggeometricalignment.Thisinvolvesestablishingrealisticexpectationsaboutthenatureofthealignmentonanarterialroutesectorfortheforeseeablefuture.Itbuildsonthedesignmethodsusedtodeliverselfenforcingdriveroperatingspeeds.Paragraph3InsertAfurtheroptionistodefervariouselementsoftheultimatedesignuntilalaterstage,refertoCommentaryK[seeCommentaryK]afteraesthetics.andbeforeTheendproduct.
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 7 (16 pages)
Paragraph3DeletetheFigureoccurringafterofeachselection.andbeforeFigure2.1:TheDesignandinsertthefollowingFigure:
Section2.1
Paragraph4Insertafterdesignelementsinvolved.andbeforeUsingthisconceptthefollowing:Routetargetsaretobeusedinthefirstinstancebecausetheyshouldalreadyhavebothextendeddesigndomainandbelowthedesigndomainconsiderationsincluded.Alternatively,normaldesigndomainvaluesintheabsenceofaroutestandardfortheparticularparameter,shouldbeadopted.TheuseofExtendedDesignDomainisfurtherqualifiedinPart8.BelowtheDesignDomainvaluesareonlytobeusedwherestrictadherencetodomainvalueswouldresultinadesignoutcome
chwhichisnotviableandwheretheRTAhasallowedtheuseofsuvalues.TheuseofvaluesthatwouldconstituteeitherExtendedDesign
tenDomainorBelowtheDesignDomainrequirethepriorwritconcurrenceofthePrincipalRoadDesignEngineer.'RoadGeometryAnalyst'isacomputersoftwareavailabletodesignerstoassisttheminidentifyingdeficienciesonexistingroads.Whereverpossible,itshouldbeusedinconjunctionwithclientbriefinformationsuchasaccidentdata,todevelopdesignsonanexistingalignment.TheuseofvaluesthatwouldconstitutetheExtendedDesignDomainrequiresthepriorwrittenconcurrenceofthePrincipalRoadDesignEngineer.Theuseofvaluesthatwouldconstitute
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 8 (16 pages)
BelowtheDesignDomainrequiresthePrincipalRoadDesignngineertobeconsulted.E
Paragraph5
afterasit:isandbeforedirectlyrelatedtoDeletemoreParagraph6InsertIntheabsenceofaroutestandardandafterare
ndbeforeAsageneralimportant.aParagraph6Deletemoreimportantandinsertclass46afterdesigningand
.beforeroadsParagraph7Insertintheabsenceofaroutestandard,afterSimilarly,and
sinthe.beforevalueParagraph8InsertRefertoPart8,4.7.2DesignDepartures/Exceptionsfordetailsofwhendesignexceptionsshouldnotbeusedafterand
oreFigure2.2.risks.andbefParagraph10Delete:
eeringcommunityvalues.afterwillberequired.Tosomeextent
Theseenginandbeforeandinsert:Wherethesevaluesareoutsideofthedesigndomain(bothnormalandextended),thisthenbecomesa"BelowtheDesignDomain"decisionandisnotnormallytakenbythedesignerbutbytheProjectManagerutilisingadvicefromthedesigner.Furtherinformationonthe"BelowtheDesignDomain"conceptisgivenin2.5.Paragraph11
Insertafterapproachtodesign.andbeforeFigure2.2.thefollowing:ForfurtherdetailofDesignDepartures/ExceptionsrefertoAustroadsProcessandDocumentationPart8Section4.7.2.ArecordofallDesignDepartures/ExceptionsmustbeincludedintheDesignReporttogetherwiththeappropriateroadauthoritysignoffforeach.
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 9 (16 pages)
Paragraph2Delete11.2ofGuidetotheGeometricDesignofRuralRoads(Austraods,2003)afterreferSectionandbeforeInsomecasesandinsert4.2.6ofGuidetoRoadDesignPart3:
adDesign(Austroads,2009).GeometricRoParagraph2InsertRefertoPart1forRTAsOrderofPrecedenceafterabove
eforeThepractical.3.0m).andbParagraph3Delete3.0occurringafterruralroadisandbeforem(refer
dinsert3.1.Sectionan
Section2.2
Paragraph3Delete11.2,Austroads,2003occurringafterreferSectionandbefore).Asageneralandinsert4.2.6ofGuidetoRoadDesign
etricRoadDesign,Austroads,2009.Part3:Geom
Paragraph3DeleteAustroadshasdefined(Table2.2).andinsertRTAhasdefinedasystemoffunctionalclassificationforruralandurban
TA2010).roads(referR
Section2.4.1
Paragraph4DeleteInruralareastrafficfunction.whichincludesTables2.2and2.3.
Section2.4.3 AfterParagraph2Insertafterurbanroads.andbefore3DESIGN
CONSIDERATIONSthefollowing:2.5BelowDesignDomain(BDD)Itmustberecognisedthatnotallroadworksrequireplansorgeometricdesign.Manymaintenanceworksfallintothiscategory,includingactivitiessuchasresealing(withoutimprovementinwidth),shoulderresheeting(withoutimprovementinwidth),relinemarkingandpavementrepairs.Otheractivitiesincludingasphaltoverlays,granularoverlaysorwideningandorsealingofpartoralloftheshouldersmaynotaffectthehorizontalorverticalalignmentandmayhavedrawingstofacilitateminorshapecorrections.However,theseactivitiesmayalsoproduceanettresultsuchthattheoveralldesignstandardhasbeeneffectivelyreducedandaBelowtheDesignDomainsituationexists.ThereforeadvicefromRoadDesignEngineeringmustbesoughttoidentifyandcorrectanyissuesdirectlyrelatedtochanges
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 10 (16 pages)
suchaslevels,roadsidefurniture,drainage,frictionfactorsetc.anditisexpectedthatthiswouldincludeanassessmentofthepotentialimpactondriverbehaviour(includingtheeffectonoperatingspeed)andappropriatedesigntocorrectanydeficienciesbroughtaboutbythis.
Thelevelofgeometricdesignappliedtotheseworkswillbedrivenbyfactorsoutsidethedesignerscontrol,inparticular,theleveloffundingavailabletoroadauthoritiesundertheseprogrammes.
ItcanbeseenfromFigure2.1thatcostsandbenefitscontinuetodecreaseforvaluesofdesignparametersbelowtheDesignDomain,buttheremaystillbenettsafetybenefitsbydoingworkinthisareaknownasBelowtheDesignDomain.ThetopofthisrangeisdefinedbythebottomoftheEDD,thepreferablelowerlimitforrestorationworks.Generally,valuesintheBDDrangecannotbesupportedonengineeringgroundsbut,nevertheless,theremaybecircumstancesinwhichdesignersareobligedtoproduceDrawingsusingvaluesinthisareaandmayachieveaddedsafetyvaluebycontributingdesignadvice.
Roaddesignerscanaddvalueinthefollowingareas:
hintheidentifyinginconsistentgeometricelementswitprojectlength
identifyinginconsistentgeometricelementsonimmediatelyadjoininglengthsofroadwherea
nsubstandardgeometricelementistoberetainedexaminingtherecordedcrashesattheparticularlocatio
providingadviceontheuseoftrafficmanagementdevicesthatprovidewarningtoapproachingmotorists
eandmaymitigatetheriskassociatedwithadoptingthlowervalue.
TheRTAhasestablisheda"DesignMatrixshowingthetypesofinvestigationrequiredwhenundertakingvarioustypesofmaintenance/rehabilitation/reconstructionactivities"(seeRTASupplementtoPart1Clause3.2.2)
TheRTAhasestablishedvaluesforvariousroaddesignparametersbasedonNDD,EDDandBDDandthesearespecifiedinthedraftRTARuralNetworkPlanningTargets(RTA,2009)andRTAUrbanNetworkPlanningTargets(RTA,2010).
iskfactorsforBrownfieldssitesarediscussedinCommentaryV.R
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 11 (16 pages)
Paragraph3Insertafterforfurtherguidance.andbeforeTable3.1:Checklistthefollowing:Onallprojects,eveniftheyarereasonablysimple,recordsmustbekeptanddocumentationprovidedofallprojectdecisionmakingmatters.Forsmallerprojects,thismayjustbeashortsectionintheDesignReport.Forlargerprojectsitwillinvolveacompletestudywithaacilitatoranddetailedreportingofoutcomes,whichwillthenfbecomepartoftheprojectrecords.Thereportmustshowthatalltheissueshavebeenfullyconsideredandthatappropriateremedialmeasureshavebeendeterminedwhererequired.Thesedocumentsmustbeavailableforfutureaccessifrequired,andtheprocessmustbefullytransparent.Anyopportunitiestoprovidecostsavingsbydeferringunnecessaryworksmustbepursued.Thismaymeanthatsomeformationwidening,sealingorotherimprovementsaredonewhilepavementstructuralworkisdeferred(ifpracticable)untillater.Forexample,iftheremaininglifeofthepavementandotherperformancemeasuresaresatisfactory,thepavementstructuraloverlayandstrengtheningmaybeabletobelefttothenextincrementalimprovementreview,whichcouldbeupto10yearsinthefuture.Ontheotherhand,potentialbudgetshortfallsforriskreducingorotherworksshouldbeaddressedandmustbediscussedandapprovedbythedelegationsasoutlinedinheRTA'sNetworkPlanningTargets.tTable3.1ChecklistfordesignconsiderationsCONSTRUCTIONFACTORSInsert,REHABILITATION&RECONSTRUCTIONafterCONSTRUCTIONandbeforeFACTORS.Delete[seeCommentaryK]afterproposalsandbeforeTrafficmanagement.
Section3.1
MAINTENANCEFACTORSertafterfacilitydesignandbeforeINDUSTRIALFACTORSthelowi
Insfol
ng: designdetailsincludingparkingbaysforaccess sealingunderbarriersetctominimiseworkerexposure
locationofroadsidefurnituretomaximiseworkersaccessandminimiserisk
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
COMMENTARYA
DeletecontentandinsertNotUsed.
COMMENTARYB
DeletecontentandinsertNotUsed.
COMMENTARYC
DeletecontentandinsertNotUsed.
COMMENTARYD
DeletecontentandinsertNotUsed.
Paragraph3sionafterandwiththeandbeforeofthepublic.Deleteinclu
Paragraph4Delete
ex.htmefore
http://www.kytc.state.ky.us/design/designmanual/indafterhttp://www.tfhrc.gov/focus/oct02/02.htmandb
d/context/index.htm.http://www.dot.ca.gov/hq/oppFigureF.1:Conceptualdiagram
aftervalueforaandbeforeroadDeletenewParagraph7Deletebecomeincreasinglycapability.afterbecausetheyandbeforeAnydecisionandinsertcannotbesupportedonpurely
unds.technicalgroParagraph8Deletecrashaftersupportedbyandbeforeanalysisandinsert
.appropriateParagraph8DeleteItmustalsoofcrashes.aftercrashanalysis.andbefore
evices.MitigatingdParagraph9
eNewZealand(TNZ,1998).Deleteorth
COMMENTARYE
Paragraph9InsertAmajorconsiderationintheuseofmitigatingdevicessuchassignpostingistheresponsetimetoeffectrepairsshoulddamageoccur.afterhazards,etc.andbeforeCOMMENTARYG.
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 12 (16 pages)
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 13 (16 pages)
Paragraph1DeleteorLandTransportNewZealand(LTNZ)after
teAustroadsandbeforestandardvehicle.appropriaParagraph1InsertfortheDesignVehicleandfortheCheckingVehicle.afteradoptedandbefore(referto.TableG1:DesignvehiclesAustraliaDeleteTableG1:DesignVehiclesAustraliaanditscontentsand
SEDinsertNOTUParagraph1Deletethetablesbelowafter(refertoandbeforeTableG1:andinsertPart3:GeometricDesign2.2.5DesignVehicleandPart4Intersections5.2and5.3..TableG2:DesignVehiclesNewZealandDeleteTableG2:DesignVehiclesNewZealand.anditscontents
OTUSED.andinsertNParagraph2Insertdesignedandafterdesignshouldbeandbeforecheckedfor.
COMMENTARYG
Paragraph2Deleteforthelargesttheroad,afterbecheckedandbefore
stroads.usingtheAu
COMMENTARYH
Paragraph1Insertafter..andfillsarerequired.andbeforeCOMMENTARYI,thefollowing:Thecostpenaltyforincreasingthedesignspeedfrom60km/hto80km/h,70km/hto90km/h,or80km/hto100km/hinundulating,andhillyterrainmaybeinthevicinityofbetween2to3timesthecostsofthelowerspeedalignment.Thiswillincreasefurtherwhenmountaincountryisencountered.Infactinmostcasesitwouldbeimpossibletoeconomicallyandpracticallyobtainadesignof100km/hinmostmountainrelatedterrainsduetohorizontalandverticalalignmentrestrictions.Hence,contextsenstivedesignbasedonanoperatingspeedapproachwillbenecessarytodeliveranppropriateengineeredoutcomea
COMMENTARY Paragraph2
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 14 (16 pages)
K Insertafterfuturesignalisation.andbeforeCOMMENTARYL,thefollowing:Fromanassetperspective,retrofitting,replacementorupgradingoftheexistingroadnetworkisamajorissueandthereisalimittotheamountoffundsavailable.Asaresult,theRTAhastakenalongtermviewandadoptedabestfornetwork,routeandroadapproachintryingtomaintainwhilealsoupgradingthestateroadsystem.Thisinvolvesifnecessaryadoptingastagedorincrementalapproachtoworkpriorities.Thebasisoftheincrementalapproachistotryandachievethewidestsealsandshoulderwidthspossiblewithinexistingformationstomeetdemandinacosteffectiveway.Alternativelyiffundspermit,provideforthefinaldesignformationwidth,wherethisisnotalreadyavailable.Thiscanthenbeusedtoachievefuturefullpavementandsealedshoulderwidths,drainage,clearzoneandbetterverticalalignmentwhichareabletobeprogressivelyimprovedduringanyfutureupgrades.
COMMENTARYM
Insertafterbudgetfunding.andbeforeCOMMENTARYNthefollowing:WhenundertakingeconomicanalysistheRTAreliesonawholeoflifeandbenefit/costanalysisindeterminingthebestoption.Oftenthemajorcostisnottheinitialcost,itistheongoinglifecycleostwhichincludesannualandperiodic,usingeitherrecurrentorapitalfunding.cc
COMMENTARYN
Insertafterstandardunaffordable.andbeforeCOMMENTARYOthefollowing:ItisimportantthatdesignersandprojectmanagersunderstandwhytheyaredoingorarenotdoingcertainthingsinrelationtoproDec
jects.isionsthatimpactaretakeninsuchareasas:thepriorities,policiesandgoalsoftheStateGovernment, includingStateTreasurypoliciessuchasTotalAsset
sportpolicy ManagementGuidelinesmeetingTransportNSWdirectionsforoveralltranmeetingtheRTAscorporateplanningobjectives
COMMENTARYQ
Insertlightrail/afterorbetterandbeforetramstops.
COMMENTARY Paragraph4
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) ______________________________________________________________________________________________
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 15 (16 pages)
T DeleteThesemeasuresaresummarisedspeedincludingTableT1anditscontentsafterofeffectiveness.andbeforeAnumberofconditions.
COMMENTARYV
InsertafterthisGuidetoRoadDesign.thefollowing:COMMENTARYVRiskManagementtechniquescanbeappliedatalloperationallevels,fromthestrategiclevel(suchasRegionalRouteStandards)tothedeliveryoflocalprojects.Followingareaseriesofriskissuesthatcouldbeusedasachecklist,orconsideworks:
redforimplementationonprogrammedpavement /ortheratechangesintheprogrammingoftheworksand
offundingcostproblemsthatleadtoabudgetoverrun
changesinthenumberofESAcarriedbythenewwork,leadingtoasignificantreductionindesignlifeforthepavement
geunknownenvironmentalissuessuchasaburiedheritaitemnotfounduntilexcavated
errorsintheassumptionsaboutthepavementdesigne)
(especiallyregardingthestrengthofthesubgradsafetytargets(bothstrategicandlocal)notbeingmet
incidentsoccurringduringtheprojectthatdrawattentiontoproblemsthatwerenotpreviouslyevident
notexpectationsofstakeholders(especiallytheRAM)beingmetbythefinishedwork
emergenceofanunrecognisedstakeholderwhoseexpectationsareimportanttotheprojectoutcomes
workprogramsrequiringadjustmentduetoproblemsertise,withtheavailabilityofimportantresources(exp
materials,plant) withdrawaloffundsatcriticaltimesbecauseof
emergencyissuesatotherlocationsonthenetwork roaduserspeedperceptionissues.Forexample,drivers
mayperceivethatanewsurfacecreatedfromaroutineresealiscapableofsustaininghigheroperatingspeeds,eventhoughthealignmentandsignpostedlimitsremainunchanged
problemswiththedrainagesystemduringthecourseofthework
utilityadjustmentsthataredelayedornotidentifiedinthestrategicprojectplanningstage
eliveryofincreasesintheunitratesforthesupplyandd
pavementmaterialsdefective/delayedsuppliesofcriticalmaterialproblemswithsafetyaudits
StopWorkordersissuedbyauthorisedexternal
-
RTA Supplement Guide to Road Design Part 2 (Austroads) __________________ ______________________________________________________
______________________
UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED 16 (16 pages)
agencies industrialdisputes
OH&Sissues adversepublicityfromcommunityrepresentativesthat
divertsresourcesand/ornecessitatesalterationstotheproject
communityprotestatlossofbusinessduringworks,orallfinals,interferencewithimportantlocalevents(footb
localshows)heritageissuesarisingfrompoorinvestigation
t,vibration,constructionngoftheworksprogram
publichealthissues(noise,dusructuri
traffic)thatrequirerest
unexpectedgroundconditions
problemswithutilities
inadequateprovisionsfortraffic
copeofworks eareas,disposalareas
projectcreepduetochangesinsproblemswithhaulroutes,stora
g vandalism/arson/theft/sabotage
heavyraindamagingtheworks ower,programmingissueswithotheragencies(p
railway)becomingcriticalwithdrawalofpoliticalsupportforproject
projectvariationsexceedingavailablefunds postcompletiondefectsthathavebecomecritical.
Detailsfrompostcompletionreportsarealsoimportantsourcesofinformationwhencarryingoutreviewsofkeyissuesthathavearisenfrompreviousprojects.