rsv vaccine: review and update - novavax

22
RSV Vaccine: Review and Update WVC, Sept 2020 Gregory M. Glenn M.D.

Upload: others

Post on 16-Nov-2021

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

RSV Vaccine: Review and Update

WVC, Sept 2020

Gregory M. Glenn M.D.

Page 2: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

N Engl J Med 2020;383:426-39. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa1908380

Page 3: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

The first Phase 3 investigational vaccine trial in pregnancy

3

Prefusogenic F

Is this a good construct?

The Prepare™

Trial

Results & Lessons

Going forward

Findings in P3 trial?

• Prepare trial: first ever Phase 3

investigational vaccine trial in pregnancy

• Evidence of efficacy despite missing primary

endpoint

• Trial-related factors eroded efficacy, drove

geographic variations in efficacy

• Prevention of most severe, most-clinically

relevant disease observed

Page 4: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

The first Phase 3 investigational vaccine trial in pregnancy

4

Prefusogenic F

Is this a good construct?

The Prepare™

Trial

Results & Lessons

Going forward

Findings in P3 trial?

• Why did the trial fail to meet the primary

endpoints?

• Is the true efficacy 40-50%?

• Is the construct poorly immunogenic?

• Is there a better construct?

Page 5: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

RSV fusion (F) protein is modified through the viral lifecycle

Adapted from Krzyzaniak MA, et al. PLOS Pathog. 2013;9(4):e1003309: Zunlong Ke et al., Viruses. 2018 Aug; 10(8): 446

PrefusogenicF PostfusionFPrefusionF

RSV

Macropinocytes

RSVFcleavage RSVFvirus– cellmembranefusion

RSVRNA

RSV

Fusion Protein

Macropinocytosis

The RSV F protein is essential for viral cell entry and cell

fusion, and undergoes a number of conformational changes

5

Respiratory

Syncytial Virus

Host Cell

Page 6: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

How Novavax engineered a stable, prefusogenic F protein

Mutation to furin cleavage site B • Stabilizes RSV F in prefusogenic form

• Prevents progression to prefusion F

Smith et al. PLOS ONE. 2012 7(11)e50852

6

Native RSV F

furin A furin B

Novavax Prefusogenic RSV-F

NNRARR--p27--KKQKQQ--flgfllgvgsAIASGVA109 136 154

furin A furin B (▲10aa) fusion peptide

Site I Site II

Site I Site II

Page 7: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

Immune responses in recently infected infants recognize p27, indicating the prefusogenic form is present during infection

7

Sandra Fuentes, Elizabeth M. Coyle, Judy

Beeler, Hana Golding, Surender Khurana**

Division of Viral Products, Center for Biologics

Evaluation and Research (CBER), FDA.

PLOS Pathogens 10.1371,2016

p27

Page 8: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

Krueger et al. Structural Characterization and Atomistic Modeling of a

Respiratory Syncytial Virus Fusion Glycoprotein Nanoparticle Vaccine.

(NIST)

Page 9: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

9

The full-length RSV F trimers are purified into a PS80 core forming nanoparticle vaccine and reflect a prefusion 3-D structure

Page 10: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

Patel et al. “Flexible RSV prefusogenic fusion glycoprotein exposes multiple

neutralizing epitopes that may collectively contribute to protective immunity”

BioRxiv

Page 11: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

Relative immunogenicity of RSV F constructs: Prefusogenic F, Prefusion DS, Cav1, and DS-Cav1, and Postfusion F

11

Flexible RSV prefusogenic fusion glycoprotein exposes multiple neutralizing epitopes that may collectively contribute

to protective immunity Nita Patel et al, bioRxiv preprint doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.14.296350.

Page 12: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

12

RSV F prefusogenic and variant F immunogenicity and epitope-specific competing antibodies in cotton rats

Each intervention

may highlight or hide

antigenic structures

DS Cav 1 highlights

Site 0 and V,

minimizes Site II, IV

Prefusogenic

highlights Site II, IV

Page 13: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

Summation of Antigenic Epitopes: RSV A and B neutralization and protection

13

Neutralizing

antibodies

Protection in

challenge, nasal

and lung

Page 14: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

PREPARE (M301) clinical trial results

14

• First ever Phase 3 investigational vaccine trial in pregnancy

• Evidence of efficacy despite missing primary endpoint

• Hypoxemia, hospital and pneumonia

• Trial-related factors eroded efficacy, drove geographic variations in efficacy

Page 15: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

Vaccine Efficacy, Primary and Secondary Endpoints

15

Generally, the ITT, more real-world experience, is less than the PP LBCI.

The primary difference is the use of pulse oximetry from the hospital and site.

FDA defined success: LBCI>30 at the 97.52% CI

Page 16: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

Impact of site and hospital hypoxemia on the primary endpoint

16

Primary endpoint comprised PCR+, LRTI with hypoxemia

Collection of hypoxemia from site only and not hospitalization eliminated the most ill

and ~50% of the cases

• 20 vs 47 cases

Page 17: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

Prevention of hospitalizationTime to RSV LRTI with hospitalization

17

• RSV LRTI with hospitalization

was replaced with hypoxia as

the endpoint during open

discussions of trial design to

create an objective measure of

disease

• VE 44%, (95% CI 19.6, 63.7)

Page 18: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

Driver of indeterminate low US signal

18

Figure 1: Time to First Placebo RSV Positive Illness Episode: US vs South Africa – Per

Protocol Efficacy Population

Source: f_km_p.sas 12Feb2019

US Attack Rate was

very low, especially in

the first 60 days

Eroded overall efficacy,

US efficacy

Campaign for expansion

of %US subjects led to

social distancing?

US Attack Rate

SA Attack Rate

Page 19: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

VE in a high transmission setting

19

Again, the importance of using site and hospital derived hypoxemia is evident.

Table 4: Vaccine Efficacy (95% CI) in South Africa, Through Day 90

Analysis Population MS-LRTI LRTI with Severe Hypoxemia LRTI with Hospitalization

PP, Site Only 42.5 (-1.2, 67.4) 49.4 (-26.9, 79.8) 58.5 (34.3, 73.8)

ITT, Site Only 35.9 (-10.0, 62.7) 43.5 (-38.4, 77.0) 60.7 (39.1, 74.7)

PP, Site and Hospital 57.0 (32.7, 72.5) 75.7 (51.9, 87.7) 59.5 (36.1, 74.4)

ITT, Site and Hospital 56.1 (32.8, 71.3) 73.6 (50.0, 86.1) 61.6 (40.5, 75.2)

Page 20: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

RSV prevention has long term positive consequences on susceptibility to pneumonia

20

From the safety data

All-cause infant pneumonia

• VE 48.9% to day 180

• VE 48.8% to day 364

RSV+, hypoxic pneumonia

• VE 83.6% to day 180

Table 1: Pneumonia Serious Adverse Events

Subject with At Least One Event, Period of Observation*

Safety Populations Apparent Risk Reduction

Placebo

n (%)

N = 1561

Vaccine

n (%)

N = 3008 Point

Estimate 95% CI

Pneumonia SAE, 0 to 180 Days 66 (4.2) 65 (2.2) 48.9% 28.4, 63.5

Pneumonia SAE with Chest X-ray +, 0 to 180

Days

42 (2.7) 34 (1.1) 58.0% 34.2, 73.2

Pneumonia SAE with RSV+*, 0 to 180 Days 38 (2.4) 25 (0.8) 65.9% 43.4, 79.4

Pneumonia SAE with Chest X-ray + & RSV+,

0 to 180 Days

23 (1.5) 12 (0.4) 72.9% 45.7, 86.5

Pneumonia SAE with RSV+ & Tachypnea**

or SpO2 < 95%, 0 to 180 Days

25 (1.6) 10 (0.3) 79.2% 56.9, 90.0

Pneumonia SAE with RSV+ & SpO2 < 92%, 0 to 180 Days

19 (1.2) 6 (0.2) 83.6% 59.1, 93.4

Pneumonia SAE, 181 to 364 Days 18 (1.2) 17 (0.6) 51.0% 5.2, 74.7

Pneumonia SAE with Chest X-ray +,

181 to 364 Days

8 (0.5) 8 (0.3) 48.1% -38.0, 80.5

Pneumonia SAE, 0 to 364 Days 80 (5.1) 79 (2.6) 48.8% 30.5, 62.2

* Based on the SAE start date.

** ≥ 70 bpm 0 to 59 days of age, ≥ 60 bpm at ≥ 60 days of age

Page 21: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

PREPARE trial conclusions

21

Prefusogenic F

Is this a good construct?

The Prepare™

Trial

Results & Lessons

Public Health Impact

Going Forward

• ResVax™ is a prefusogenic RSV F nanoparticle

vaccine

• The immunogenicity of the prefusogenic vaccine is

similar to other well described stabilized F proteins

• ResVax™ is efficacious but trial conduct and design

factors led to less than optimal results

• This pioneering trial result advanced the field

• The multiple learnings have been widely shared

• NVAX intends to develop the vaccine further

Page 22: RSV Vaccine: Review and Update - Novavax

The Prepare investigators

Dhruv Agneshwar Jim Buttery Marci Eck John Houghton Gary Marshall Juan Manuel Nardin Gary Soucie

Khatija Ahmed James Cain Coreen Ellis Naseem Jaffrani Helen Marshall Aftab Naz Thorsten Stanley

Abdulla Al-Khan Samuel Campbell Janet Englund Robert Jeanfreau Marke Martens Terry Nolan Geeta Swamy

Marquita Anderson Cristian Campos Susanna Esposito Chrissie Jones Maria Martinez-Gonzalez Jorge Orezzoli Paresh Thakkar

Olivia Arendse Maria Rosario Capeding Pedro Ferrand Sulbha Joshi Federico Martinon-Torres Ramonde Patientia Alan Tita

Jeffrey Baker Josefina C. Carlos Lisa Foglia Thea Koekemoer Maysseb Masenya Amita Phadnis Adrian Trenholme

Peyman Banooni Alfonso Carmona Leon Fouche Michelle Ann Kominiarek Paul Matherne Pedro A. Piedra Guillermo Valenzuela

Abdullah Baqui Elena Carreras Ariel Fuentes Cathy Laflan Katherine McHugh Alan Rappleye Michael Varner

Sneha Basude Spencer Colby Helena Gandur Ricardo J. Larrain Hugh Miller Michael Rausch Ricardo Velasco

Ashish Bavdekar Mark Cotton Glenn Gardener Conrado Llapur Angel Minguez Peter Richmond Keith Vrbicky

Bradford Brabec Gezila De Beer Salvacion R. Gatchalian Johannes Lombaard Jennifer Meece George Saade Tony Walls

Lulu C. Bravo Joanne N. De Jesus Bernard Gonik Lydia Luna Ismail Mitha Caro-lee Saal Stuart Weprin

Paul L. Beckett Maria De la Calle Gary Gregerson Shabir Madhi Celia Monla Stephen Schmidt John Wideman

Richard H. Beigi Brian Dedinsky Abel Guzman Darvy Mann Barney Montgomery Rachel Scott Karen Wilson

Marshall J. Benbow Joseph Domachowske Laura Hammitt Gonzalo Perez Marc Victor Moreno Adam Secory Shirley Wong

Oleg Bess Claudia Dominguez Paul Heath Gonzalo Luis Mariani Flor Munoz Matthew Snape Heather Zar

We also gratefully acknowledge the contributions of the many sub-investigators, coordinators, and study

staff around the world too numerous to list here.

22