rowe entertainment, inc. et al. v. william morris agency, et al. (98-8272) -- plaintiffs' opp....

7/21/2019 Rowe Entertainment, Inc. et al. v. William Morris Agency, et al. (98-8272) -- Plaintiffs' Opp. Attorneys Fees and Co…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rowe-entertainment-inc-et-al-v-william-morris-agency-et-al-98-8272 1/39

Herke Ypjrendo, Jsq.

Q k l l k e h I. Iehp`jll, Jsq.

A E P [ , Q K L L K E H Y , R E P J N T K , C K N N J [ ,

L J Q K Y , HiHENZY, Q E T Y O N Y R J P E N D O , R . L .

005 J. Osijole Ytrjjt

Ytuert, RL 94;;4

T j l 7 (110)069-6032

Cex7 (110)069-4;;3

Ettornjys cor Rlekntkccs Powj Jntjrteknhjnt, Kni., jt el.

Z N K T J D Y T E T J Y D K Y T P K I T I O Z P T

Y O Z T F J P N D K Y T P K I T OC N JQ [ O P M

r

POQJ JNTJPTEKNHJNT, K N I . , jt e l . N O . ;6-IS-6010 (PRR) £ =

Rlekntkccs,

v s

T F J Q K L L K E H HOPPKY EAJNI[, KN I.r -

jt el.,

Djcjndents

P J Y R O N Y J KN O R R O Y K T K O N O C T F J R L E K N T K C C Y E ND T F J A E P [ C K P H T O T F J

D J C J N D E N T Y H O T K O N Y C O P E T T O P N J [ Y C J J Y END I O Y T Y

A E P [ , Q K L L K E H Y , R E P J N T K , C K N N J [ , L J Q K Y , H I H E N Z Y ,Q E T Y O N Y R J P E N D O , R . L .

Q E T J P Y K D J R P O C J Y Y K O N E L @ Z K L D K N A

005 J e s t Osijole Ytrjjt

Ytuert, Clorkde 94;;4

(110) 069-6032

10/

Ettornjys cor Rlekntkccs




Y O Z T F J P N D K Y T P K I T OC NJQ [ O P M

P O Q J J N T J P T E K N H J N T , K N I . , jt el..

Rlekntkccs,

vs

T F J Q K L L K E H H O P P K Y E A J N I [ , L N I ,

jt el.,

Djcjndents.

P J Y R O N Y J KN O R R O Y K T K O N O C T F J R L E K N T K C C Y END T F J A E P [ C K P H T O T F J


Rlekntkccs, `y end tfrouaf tfjkr undjrskanjd ettornjys, end Aery, Qkllkehs, Rerjntk, Cknnjy,

Ljwks, HiHenus, Qetson & Ypjrendo, R.L. ( tfj Aer>' C k r h ) , fjrj`y rjspond kn opposktkon to tfj

Hotkons Cor Ettornjys' Cjjs end Iosts oc Irjetkvj Ertk sts Eajniy ( I E E ) , Q k l l k e h Ho h s .Eajniy

( Q H E ) , end Pjnekssenij ( tfj @. E. Djcjndents ), @jevjr end Geh.'

K H R O Y K T K O N O C Y E N I T K O N Y R Z P Y Z E N T T O § 5 ; 6 6 . § 5 ; 0 1 . T F J I O Z P T YK N F J P J N T R O Q J P OP P Z L J 55 Q O Z L D @ J EN E @ Z Y J O C D K Y I P J T K O N

@ J I E Z Y J D J C J N D E N T Y F E S J N O T R P O S J N T F E T R L E K N T K C C Y I K S K L P K A F T Y

I L E K H Y Q J P J C P K S O L O Z Y O P L K T K A E T J D K N @ED C E K T F . ^

Only teur khport ent iorrjitkons es to tfj Djcjndents ' ljael erauhjnts erj njijssery. Ckrst,

§ ; pjrhkt s tfj rjiovjry oc ettornjy's cjjs to e prjveklkna djcjndent kn e § 5 ; 6 5 eitkon only wfjrj

tfj sukt wes vjxetkous, crkvolous, or `rouaft to feress or jh`erress tfj djcjndent. Fjnsljv v.

Jimjrfert. 435 Z.Y. 404, 40; n. 0, 529 Y. It. 5;99 (5;69). Yjiond, tfi@. E. Djcjndents edhk t tfet e

Tfj Rlekntkccs end tfj Aery Ckrh kniorporetj `y rjcjrjnij end rjly upon Po`jrt J. Donnjl ly's

Pjsponsj end ell jvkdjnij su`hkttjd kn tfks iesj.

'Tfj Aery C k rh ckljd kts Notkij oc Eppjerenij on Guly 09, 0225, ettjndjd e`out 02 oc tfj

epproxkhetjly 30 djposktkons temjn, end rjspondjd to tfj Hotkons to Jxiludj Geynjs end Cjeakn end

Hotkons cor Yuhhery Gudahjnt, end su`hkttjd tfj co l lowkna doimjt jntrkjs7 9:0, 405, 406, 492, 442-40

4:5-:1, 430, 43:, 436, 413-65, 469, 463-6;, :29, :52, :55, :02-00, :04, :0:, :95-94, :94, :93, :91, :9;,

::0, ::4, :39-3:, :31-12, :10, :62, :65, :6:, :;1, :;6, 32:-:9, end 3::-15. (Yjj Ec c . oc Hene

Ypjrendo, c^;-54, 56, 02, Jx.5.)

;6 Ikv. 6010 PRR)

O P E L E P A Z H J N T P J U Z J Y T J D



ckndkna o c èd ce k tf ks njijssery to khposj cjjs pursuent to § 5 ; 0 1 , ùt tfjy jrronjously ilekh, rjlykna

o n Znktjd Ytetjs v. Yjltzjr. 001 C. 0d 93, 45 -40 (0d Ik r. 0222), tfet tfks Iourt hey khposj senitkons

undjr kts knfjrjnt powjrs jvjn e`sjnt èd c e k t f undjr tfjsj ikriuhstenijs. (@.E. Hjho. 05.)-̂ Kn

Yjltzjr, tfj iourt fjld7

Q ^ j n e dkstrkit iourt knvomjs kts knfjrjnt powjr to khposj ettornjy's cjjs or to punksf

`jfevkor `y en ettornjy kn 'tfj eitkons tfet ljd to tfj le ws uk t . . . ]orX ionduit oc tfj l k t k a e t k o n , '

]iktetkon ohkttjdX, wfkif eitkons erj temjn on `jfelc oc e ilkjnt, tfj dkstrkit iourt hust hemj en

jxplkikt ckndkna oc ̀ ed ce k t f . ]Iktetkons ohkttjd.X . .. @ut, wfjn tfj dkstrkit iourt.. . senitkon]sX

hksionduit. . .tfet ]vkoletjsX e iourt ordjr or otfjr hksionduit tfet ks not undjrtemjn cor tfj

ilkjnt's `jnjckt, tfj dkstrkit iourt njjd not chd èd c e k t f `jcorj khposkna e senitkon . . . .

K d . et 45-40 (jhpf. eddjd). Tfus, sknij tfj ettornjys' ionduit et kssuj ionijrns only ionduit oc tfj

l k t k a e t k o n cor tfj `jnjckt oc tfj ilkjnts, en jxplkikt ckndkna oc èd ce k tf ks rjqukrjd.

T f k r d , @jevjr, tfj only Djcjndent to rjqujst Pulj 55 senitkons (@.Hjho. ;), vkoletjd Pulj

55(i) ( 5 ) ( E ) `jieusj kt hedj kts Pulj 55 hotkon cor tfj Rlekntkccs' rjsponsj to kts hotkon cor suhhery

gudahjnt ectjr kts hotkon cor suhhery gudahjnt wes djikdjd, tfjrj`y not ellowkna tfj Rlekntkccs en

opportunkty to wktfdrew tfjkr rjsponsj. @jevjr iennot rjly on kts Dji. 9, 0220 ljttjr to Pey Fjslkn

`jieusj tfet wes `jcorj tfj Rlekntkccs c k l j d tfjkr rjsponsj to tfj hotkon cor suhhery gudahjnt, k .j., lona

ectjr tfj 05 dey secj feròr pjrkod fed pessjd. Yjj Futifknson v. R c j k l . 026 C. 9d 5562, 5569-64

(52tf Ikr. 0222) ( es tfj ]Pulj 55X hotkon wes c k l j d su`sjqujnt to suhhery gudahjnt,.. . rjlkenij on

Pulj 55 would fevj . . . ]vkoletjdX rulj's twjnty-onj dey 'secj feròr' provkskon ).

Courtf, ]tXfj ceit tfet e p l e k n t k c c hey ultkhetjly losj fks iesj ks not kn k t s j l c succkikjnt

gustkckietkon cor tfj essjsshjnt oc cjjs. Fuafjs v. Powj. 44; Z.Y. :,54,525 Y. It. 519,516 (5;62).

Tfj Iourt's wernkna h Ifrkstkensùra Aerhjnt Io. v. JJOI. 494 Z.Y. 450, 405, ;6 Y. It. 3;4, 122

(5;16), not to ioniludj tfet `jieusj e p l e k n c k c c d kd not ultkhetjly prjvekl, fks eitkon hust fevj `jjn

'Tfj hjhorende oc tfj @ .E Djcjndents, @jevjr end Geh w k l l `j rjcjrrjd to es @ . E . Hjho.,

@.Hjho. end G. Hjho. Tfj Iourt's Cknel Opknkon w k l l `j rjcjrrjd to es ( .) Tfj trensirkpts oc tfj

fjerknas on E p n l 55 , 0222, Hey 3, 0229, Oit. 53, 51, end 02 w k ll `j rjcjrrjd to es T l , 'T0, T9,

T4, end T:. .Ell iktjd fjerkna trensirkpt peajs erj etteifjd es J x 0 E l l iktjd djposktkon trensirkpt

peajs erj etteifjd es J x 9

- 0-



unrjesone`lj or wktfout coundetkon, ks pertkiulerly pjrtknjnt to iesjs knvolvkna elljaetkons oc

ionspkreiy Lj @leni-Ytjh`jra v. Cljtifjr, 549 C.9d 13:, 112 (0d Ikr. 5;;6).

Yohj oc tfj rjesons wfkif provj tfet tfj Rlekntkccs' ilekhs es to ell Djcjndents wjrj not

vjxetkous, crkvolous, or hedj kn èd cek tf erj es collows7''

5 Ferverd Lew Rroc. Iferljs Oaljtrjj fes ioniludjd tfet tfj Rlekntkccs' ilekhs wjrj not crkvolous,

vjxetkous or hedj k n èd ce k tf. (Iferljs Oaljtrjj E c c . ^ ^ : - 6 = Jx. 4. Rroc Oaljtrjj hjdketjd tfks

hettjr `jtwjjn tfj Rlekntkccs end YCV, end wes iounsjl cor E l Feyhon kn tfks hettjr, end tfus ks vjry

cehklker w k t f tfj ceits, tfj pertkjs end tfjkr ettornjys. ( K d . ^9,4. 0 YCV, tfj lerajst prohotjr kn tfj

iountry, sjttljd tfj ilekhs eaeknst k t . Tfks jvksijretjs Geh's end @jevjr's ilekh tfet prohotjrs fed no

pleij kn tfks lewsukt.* 9 Hontjrjy Rjnknsule end tfj Fowerd Posj Eajniy, sjttljd es w j l l (cor

ehounts tfj Rlekntkccs hey not rjvjel). (Ypjrendo Ec c . 09 . ) Tfus, eltfouaf tfj @ . E . Djcjndents elljaj

''Tfj Rlekntkccs kn aood cektf knktketjd end prosjiutjd t k l ls eitkon (Ljonerd Powj Ecc. c 52-50, Jx.

:= Gjssj @osjhen E c c c4 , J x . 3, Ljj M k n a E c c 54, J x . 1, Crjd Gonjs Ek[. J x . 6.) Tfet tfj Rlekntkccs'

ilekhs wjrj njktfjr crkvoleus nor pursujd kn ̀ ed cektf ks supportjd `y tfjkr eppjlletj ` r k j c wfkif ks

kniorporetjd fjrjkn `y rjcjrjnij end w k l l j̀ c k l jd wk tf tfks Iourt upon kts iohpljtkon.

^Geh's iontjntkon tfet tfks earjjhjnt ks ieusj cor tfj khposktkon oc senitkons eaeknst tfj

Rlekntkccs end tfjkr iounsjl ks èsjljss. Tfj YCV earjjhjnt fed notfkna to do w k t f tfj Rlekntkccs'djikskon to iontknuj to lktkaetj eaeknst Geh. Ckrst, tfj Rlekntkccs njvjr kntjndjd to sjtdj w k tf Geh cor ljss

tfen $5,222,222, end tfus hemkna tfet e iondktkon oc tfj sjttljhjnt w k tf YCV wes hjenknaljss `jieusj kt

d kd not rjqukrj tfj Rlekntkccs to do enytfkna tfjy fed not elrjedy djikdjd to do. (Powj E c c . c ;, Q k l l k j

Aery Ec c t5]4,:, J x . ;.) Yjiond, tfj Rlekntkccs iontknujd to lktkaetj eaeknst Geh cor tfj sehj rjeson tfjy

iontknujd to lktkaetj eaehst @jevjr end tfj @. E. Djcjndents to wfoh tfj YCV earjjhjnt dkd not epply,

k.j.. Geh njvjr occjrjd en ehount to sjttlj tfet wes succkikjnt to iohpjnsetj tfj Rlekntkccs cor tfj ferh

Geh fed donj to tfjh. (Powj Ecc. ;= Aery E c c ^3. Tfk r d , Rlekntkccs' iounsjl occjrjd to sjttlj w k tf Geh

cor ljss tfen $5,222,222, iontknajnt on tfj Rlekndccs' epprovel, ùt Geh occjrjd only cer ljss tfen tfet.

(Aery E c c ^3.) Powj fes rjionckrhjd tfet fj njvjr would fevj sjttljd w k t f Geh cor ljss tfen

$5,222,222. (Powj Ec c ̂ ;.) Cknelly, tfj provkskon et kssuj ks eneloaous to e host cevorjd netkons

ileusj wfkif ks en uniondktkonelly wordjd ileusj tfet profk`kts plekntkccs croh hemkna e letjr sjttljhjnt

wk tf rjheknkna djcjndents on tjrhs horj cevore`lj tfen tfj sjttljhjnt plekntkccs hedj w k t f en jerly-sjttlkna djcjndent, wktfout akvkna tfj jerly-sjttlkna djcjndent e rjcund to jquelkzj tfj jerlkjr end letjr

sjttljhjnts. Cksfjr @ros, v. Rfjlps Dodaj fkdustrkjs. Kni., 354 C. Yupp. 911, 960 (J.D.Re. 5;6:).

Fowjvjr, tfj sjttljhjnt et kssuj fjrj dkd provkdj cor e rjcund.

^Tfks sjtZjhjnt elso knvelkdetjs Feyhon's prjsukt opknkon tfet prohotjrs sfould not fevj `jjn

kniludjd es djcjndents end iuts eaeknst tfj Iourt's ioniluskon tfet Geh end @jevjr wjrj purifesjrs oc

ertkst teljnt, end, tfjrjcorj, iould not fevj temjn eitkons to prjvjnt Rlekntkccs c roh dokna tfj sehj. (34.)

Yjj Yjitkon 0.0 oc tfj sjttljhjnt earjjhjnt. Yjj elso Lj c c ljttjr end trenscjr oc Gehjs Teylor ionijrt

kncre et 5:-53. Horjovjr, tfj YCV sjtZjhjnt ks eddktkonel jvkdjnij tfet tfj Rlekntkccs' iesj eaeknst tfj

@.E. Djcjndents wes not crkvolous `jieusj YCV iould not fevj jnaeajd kn e ionspkreiy `y k t sj l c

9



tfet tfj ilekhs eaeknst tfj eajniy Djcjndents wjrj crkvolous, two eajniy Djcjndents dksearjjd. 4

@jevjr fes eimnowljdajd tfet tfj Rlekntkccs' ilekhs eaeknst tfj Eajniy Djcjndents wjrj supportjd `y

et ljest . . . sohj jvkdjnij es pjr tfj djposktkon o c E l e n Feyhon. (Jx. 52. : Tfj Djcjndents

djposjd jeif o c tfj Rlekntkccs cor cour deys, 53 deys kn totel, `jlykna tfjkr iontjntkon tfet tfj Rlekntkccs'

ilekhs wjrj cFvoKous. 3 Djcjndents elljaj tfjy fed to kniur YK 5,91;,1;0 kn cjjs end iosts (kniludkna

tfj 0:% kn unrjiovjre`lj cjjs djduitjd `y tfj @. E. Djcjndents) to djcjnd tfks eitkon. Yjj @ynuh v.

Hkifkaen Ytetj Zn k v . . 551 C.P.D. ;4, 520 n. 9 (SS.D. H k i f . 5;61) ( iourt ien't fjlp notkna tfj krony

tfet kt epperjntly toom djcjnsj iounsjl $5;,222.22 wortf o c `klle`lj ljael tkhj to prjperj e hot kon end

` r k j c to dkshkss e sukt tfjy now ifereitjrkzj es 'crkvolous end aroundljss' ).1 Tfks Iourt's 514-peaj

opknkon, rjndjrjd ectjr en kntjnskvj rjvkjw oc 5: hontfs ' duretkon, elonj provjs tfet Rlekntkccs' ilekhs

wjrj djcknktjly not hjrktljss kn tfj Ifrkstkensùra sjnsj. Fuafjs. 44; Z.Y. et 5:, 53 n. 59, 525 Y.

It. et 51;, 51; n. 59 ( ]eXs Gudaj Ywyajrt notjd . . . tfj Dkstrkit Iourt dkshkssjd pjtktkonjr's ilekhs

only ectjr djtekljd ionskdjretkon rjsultkna kn e sjvjn-peaj opknkon. Eiiordkna to Gudaj Ywyajrt7 ' K t ks

quktj jvkdjnt croh tfj djtekljd trjethjnt akvjn `y tfj dkstrkit iourt to tfj kssujs reksjd `y plekntkccs

iohpleknt tfet tfj sukt wes not aroundljss or hjrktljss. Tfj ceit ks iorroòretjd `y tfks iourt' s

trjethjnt o c tfj sehj kssujs on eppjel.) 6 Tfj `rkjcs, Pulj :3.5 Ytetjhjnts, end jxfk`kts totel

tfousends o c peajs. Es tfks Iourt notjd, ] w X j fevj e cu l l te`lj oc doiuhjnts . . . steimjd up two cjjt

fkaf. (T4700.) ; Tfj pertkjs toom two end e f e l c deys to erauj tfj suhhery gudahjnt hotkons on tfj

Rlekntkccs' so-ielljd crkvolous ilekhs. 52 Tfks Iourt, wfjn tfj hotkons to dkshkss tfj Ehjndjd

Iohpleknt wjrj fjerd, trkjd to jnioureaj òtf skdjs to sjttlj tfks hettjr. ( T l 74, 3.) Et tfj suhhery

gudahjnt fjerkna, ectjr tfj Iourt fed rjed tfj hotkons end rjsponsjs, tfks Iourt eaekn jnioureajd òtf

skdjs to sjttlj, stetkna, . . .5 s t k l l ien sjj weys kn wfkif tfjrj iould `j sohj ifenaj k n tfj wey o c

ionduitkna ùsknjss. Kt sjjhjd to hj tfet would `j `jnjckikel to tfj plekntkccs.* * * K s t k l l tfknm kt

sfould `j sjttljd.. . . (T4740, jhpf. eddjd.) Rrjsuhe`ly, tfks Iourt would not fevj jnioureajd tfj

pertkjs to sjttlj, jspjikelly es letj kn tfj iesj, fed kt tfouaft tfet tfj Rlekntkccs' ilekhs wjrj crkvolous

4



o r `rouaft kn èd ce k t f . Tfet `y k t s j l c jste`lksfjs tfet tfj ilekhs wjrj not crkvolous. Horjovjr, tfj

Iourt's pjrskstjnij kn jnioureakna sjttljhjnt ieusjd tfj Rlekntkccs end tfjkr ettornjys to `jlkjvj tfet

tfks Iourt ̀ jlkjvjd tfet tfj Rlehtkccs fed v e l k d ilekhs (Ypjrendo E c c . := @osjhen E c c ^:= Gonjs E c c .

c : = M k n a E c c . ^gY , end tfet, tfjrjcorj, tfj iesj would `j trkjd. (Kd.) 55 IEe^ k t s j l c ilekhjd en kntjrjst

k n sjttlkna wfet kt now ilekhs ks e crkvolous iesj. Gjccrjy Mjssljr, iounsjl cor I E E , stetjd on E p r k l

5 5 , 0222, wj rjhekn kntjrjstjd kn fev kna sjttljhjnt telms end hjdketkon kn eny eltjrnetkvj tfet your

Fonor would suaajst. ( T l 7 4, jhpf. eddjd.) Yu`sjqujntly, tfj @. E. Djcjndents dkd volunterkly

hjdketj tfks iesj, ùt tfj pertkjs wjrj une`lj to earjj on en ehount. (Ypjrendo Ecc. ^00.) 50 Tfks

Iourt, rjspondkna to erauhjnt tfet Rlekntkccs fed not pljd e ionspkreiy, stetjd, ]hgey`j you cjllows

erjn't pert o c sohjtfkna, ùt ijrteknly sohjonj jlsj sjjhs to fevj `jjn honmjykna eround w k t f trykna

to jxiludj ]tfj RlekntkccsX ] c r oh prohotkna wfktj ei t sX . . . . Kt hey not iovjr e ionspkreiy ilekh w k t f

rjspjit to tfet pertkiuler eit w k t f rjspjit to your pertkiuler ilkjnts, ùt tfj elljaetkons eòut wfet otfjr

pjoplj dkd sjjh to `j oc e ionijrtjd neturj . . . . Not njijsserkly en entktrust vkoletkon, ùt possk`ly e

i k v k l rkafts vkoletkon. ( T l 7 ;9,;4, jhpf. eddjd.) 59 On Hey 3,0229, tfks Iourt knqukrjd o c Rlekntkccs'

iounsjl, ]wXfo ks aokna to try tfks iesj? (T07 6;.) Tfj Iourt elso stetjd, kn tfj iontjxt o c e dksiusskon

ionijrnkna tfj t r k e l , ] y X o u fevj aot to iut tfks iesj down. (Kd. ) Et no tkhj durkna tfet (or kndjjd eny)

fjerkna dkd tfj Iourt jvjn fknt tfet tfj Rlekntkccs' ilekhs wjrj crkvolous. Ic. Topelken v. Jfrhen. 9

C .9d ;9 5, ;96 (:tf Ikr . 5;;9) (iourt wernjd eppjllents oc possk`lj senitkons so tfet tfjy fed

opportunkty to djskst croh o`gjitkone`lj ionduit). Eltfouaf tfj Iourt jxprjssjd sohj smjptkiksh w k t f

rjaerd to tfj entktrust ilekh, kt stetjd tfet tfj dksirkhknetkon ilekhs rjqukrj]dX e lot oc djtekljd worm

` y tfj Iourt to djel w k t f . . . (T97 91.) Kn ceit, tfj Iourt jxprjssly stetjd, ] w X j fevj aot to ajt tfks

iesj to t r k e l . ( T 0 7 525, jhpfesks eddjd.) Eaekn, tfj Rlekntkccs `jlkjvjd tfet tfj Iourt would not fevj

hedj tfjsj stetjhjnts k c k t fed not `jlkjvjd tfet tfjrj wes aokna to `j e tnel end tfet wes onj oc tfj

rjesons tfet Rlekntkccs end tfjkr ettornjys prjssjd corwerd w k t f tfjkr ilekhs. (Ypjrendo Ec c. 5̂1=

@osjhen E c c c := Gonjs E c c . ^:= M k n a Ec c c: . ) Rlekntkccs ettornjys do not dkshkss tfjkr lewsukts or



jvjn ionskdjr wfjtfjr tfjy erj crkvolous wfjn tfj t r k e l iourt spjems eòut fevkna to ajt tfks iesj to

t r k e l . (Ypjrendo E c c . cY.) Akvjn tfj Iourt's jnioureakna tfj pertkjs to sjttlj, end kts pronounijhjnts

eòut trykna tfj iesj, tfj possk`lj ve l k d k t y oc tfj dksirkhknetkon ilekhs, end tfj proè`klkty o c reiksh

k n tfj huski prohotkon kndustry (T:7095), òtf Rlekntkccs end tfjkr iounsjl wjrj stunnjd wfjn tfj

Iourt arentjd suhhery gudahjnt on `jfelc oc el l Djcjndents. (Ypjrendo E c c c6= @osjhen E c c ̂ 3,

M k n a E c c ^3, Gonjs E c c 1.) 54 Tfks Iourt elso hedj nuhjrous stetjhjnts wfkif e rjesone`lj pjrson

iould fevj kntjrprjtjd, end tfj Rlekntkccs dkd so kntjrprjt (Ypjrendo E c c : ) , es `jkna en kndkietkon

c r oh tfj Iourt tfet tfj iesj wes not crkvolous end tfet kt l k m j l y would `j trkjd. Ypjikckielly, rjaerdkna

tfj iontjntkon tfet tfj Rlekntkccs fed cekljd to put c o r t f en jionohkiel ly pleusk`lj tfjory cor e ̀ oomkna

eajniy to ionspkrj w k t f wfktj prohotjrs to rjstrekn tredj `y not djelkna w k t f `leim ionijrt prohotjrs

( @ . E . Hjho.4), tfj Iourt stetjd on E p r k l 55, 5222 ( T l 7;2,;5, jhpf. eddjd)7

H P . M J Y Y L J P 7 . . . .Qfet K wentjd to poknt out, your Fonor, ks tfet tfks ks e tfjory

]tredkna tfj iohpjtktkon to `jnjckt tfj ljssjr eitsX kn sjerif oc e ceituel elljaetkon.

T F J I O Z P T 7 Ks kt. tfouaf? Don' t wj ell mnow tfet you ajt e aood pkjij o c tfj ùsknjss

end you erj e`lj to ajt sohj `jnjckts cor otfjr pjoplj you rjprjsjnt? * * * K would tfknm tfet

tfj prockts c r oh tfj horj prockte`lj pjoplj sohjfow esskst younajr ertksts iohkna elona. . . .

5: Tfj Djcjndents' celsj elljaetkon tfet Rlekntkccs henuceiturjd e njw jionohki tfjory cor tfjkr

ionspkreiy ilekhs, ioniluskvjly elljakna - w k t f no supportkna ceituel djtekl - tfet e 'qukd pro quo'

sifjhj jxkstjd . . . . ( @ . E . Hjho. :) (jhpf. eddjd), ks rjùttjd `y tfj tjstkhony oc @ruij Mepp,

Rrjskdjnt o c Tourkna cor YCV/Iljer Ifennjl, wfo stetjd, kn rjsponsj to `jkna esmjd wfjtfjr prohotjrs

jxpjitjd to rjijkvj sohj `jnjckt c r oh tfj eajnikjs k n rjturn cor tfjkr wkllknanjss to eiijpt tfj è`y

eits tfj eajnikjs aevj to tfjh, K tfknm ]prohotjrsX would jxpjit to `j tfj 'prohotjr on rjiord,'. .

. k c tfet eit feppjns. En d k c k t wes e rjel cevor end tfjy'vj lost e lot oc honjy, fopjcully, tfjy ajt

enotfjr eit or sohjtfkna= tfjn tfj eajniy would temj ierj o c tfjh. (Mepp 519,003-01.) Kndjjd, tfks

Iourt k t s j l c rjioankzjd tfj skankckienij oc Mepp's tjstkhony (T97 36-3;, 12-15, jhpf. eddjd)7

H P . M J Y Y L J P 7 . . . .]Tgfjrj ks no jvkdjnij oc suif e qukd pro quo.. . .

T F J I O Z P T 7 Tfjrj wes e hen nehjd Hr . Mepp. . . . Fj tjstkckjs tfet tfet m k n d o c en

errenajhjnt wes hedj. ' * 'Now, k c e òomkna eajnt aevj e produijr e ̀ rjem or e produijr

3



aevj e ̀ oomkna eajnt e `rjem on hknor eits, end kn rjturn, wfjn tfjy lost honjy, es H r . Mepp

tjstkckjs to. tfjn tfjv erj rjwerdjd kn sohj wev `y e su`sjqujnt iontreit, tfet

sjjhs to hj would tjnd to mjjp e prjdohknent prohotjr kn tfet i k t y .

53 Tfj Djcjndents' rjpjetjd essjrtkon tfet Rlekntkccs produijd no jvkdjnij on tfks poknt ( @ . E . Hjho.

:), ks rjùttjd `y H r . Mjssljr's E D H K Y Y K O N ( T 9 7 15) tfet Mepp' s tjstkhony wes jvkdjnij ck-oh wfkif

to kncjr e ionspkreiy wfjn fj stetjd, ]oXtfjr tfen tfet sknalj pkjij oc tjstkhony ]ckroh @ruij MeppX,

tfjrj ks no otfjr knikdjnt croh wfkif to kncjr e ionspkreiy. 51 Tfks Iourt fes edhkttjd tfet tfj aood

o l d òy njtworm jxksts ell ovjr tfj w o r l d . Qj ell mnow oc tfj aood old ̀ oy njtworm. (T0=94.) 56

Pjaerdkna tfj Djcjndents' iontjntkon tfet kt ks tfj ertksts end tfjkr heneajrs, not tfj eajnikjs, wfo

hemj tfj ultkhetj djikskon w k t f rjspjit to sjljitkon (T9754), tfj Iourt rjpjetjdly stetjd tfet k t dkdn' t

hettjr ( k d . 54-5:, 53, 91, 9;, jhpf. eddjd)7

. . . kt dojsn't sjjh to hj tfet kt hemjs huif dkccjrjnij k c tfj eajnts pjrcorh tfj cunitkon oc

sirjjnkna out tfj plekntkccs or pjoplj oc iolor. Kt sjjhs to hj tfet kn sirjjnkna out, tfet tfet's

. . .es cer es dksirkhknetkon aojs, vjry huif l k m j e dksirkhkneckon sukt. * * * K would tfknm

kt would `j arounds cor e dksirkhknetkon sukt. Tfet wes hy rjeitkon es K rjed tfj pepjrs. Yo

wesn't surj tfet tfks ùsknjss oc ultkhetj djikskon on tfj ertksts end tfjkr heneajrs wes

dksposktkvj kn eny wey. * * * ] E X s cer es tfj dksirkhknetkon ilekhs ao. kt dojsn't sjjh to hj

tfet kt hettjrs. * * * @jieusj k c tfjy erj onj oc tfj pertkikpents end tfjv pjrcorh en eit —

hey`j kt ks retkckjd `y sohjonj jlsj, ùt k c tfjv erj tfj onjs tfet sirjjn out pjoplj, wfkif ks

sort oc tfj wey K rjed tfj elljaetkons, croh e dksirkhknetkon stendpoknt, k t dojsn't hettjr. ** * ]Qgfjtfjr tfjy sirjjn or tfj ultkhetj epprovjr dojsn't rjelly hemj huif dkccjrjnij, kt

sjjhs to hj. kn tfj dksirkhknetkon ilekh. . . .cTXfj entktrust ilekhs fevj aot sohj pro`ljhs.

Tfj reij dksirkhknetkon ilekh, on tfj otfjr fend, ks onj tfet rjqukrjs e lot oc djtekljd worm `y

tfj Iourt to djel w k t f * * * Q l k e t you fkrj en eajnt to do ks hemj e proposel cor your

epprovel * * * K don't tfknm kt hemjs e f k l l oc `jens dkccjrjnij Ln tfj dksirkhknetkon....

5; Es to tfj ecckdevkt oc Pkiferd Gofnson, tfks Iourt stetjd, ] k X t hey `j tfet ]Pkiferd Gofnson'sX

ecckdevkt fes to `j supportjd `y jvkdjnij tfet ks w k t f k n tfj pjrkod kn qujstkon. Kt hey `j tfet kt iould

`j ellowjd es jvkdjnij o c ̀ eimaround oc tfj ionspkreiy, k c you w k l l , tfet you'rj elljakna. Yo kt hey

`j edhkssk`lj jvkdjnij. @ut you s t k l l fevj to fevj jvkdjnij oc tfj eits w k t f k n tfj stetutory pjrkod you

fevj sjt c o r t f . ( K d - 7 42, jhpf. eddjd.) 02 Et tfj Oit. 53 fjerkna, tfks Iourt stetjd to iounsjl cor

I E E , K would fopj k n tfks hotkon tfet you would eddrjss tfj plekntkccs' opposktkon ̀ jieusj k t sjjhjd

to hj tfet your rjply ` r k j c heknly rjktjretjd your orkaknel posktkon end tfjrj erj e nuh`jr o c poknts tfet



erj hedj kn tfj pl ekntkccs' opposktkon tfet trou`lj hj. ( Kd - 7 :9, jhpf. eddjd.) 05 Tfks Iourt rjgjitjd

tfj Djcjndents' iontjntkon ( w k t f wfkif kt ultkhetjly earjjd) tfet `kds wjrj irktkiel to tfj Rlekntkccs'

ceklurj to hemj e prkhe ceikj iesj ( g d . 7 :;, 32 (jhpf. eddjd)7

T F J I O Z P T 7 Qfet tfjy erj ilekhkna kn tfjkr ` r k j c es K rjed kt , ks tfet tfjy erj `jknajxiludjd croh o`teknkna kncorhetkon eòut proposjd ionijrts. Tfjkr ̀ kd proijss would only

epply onij tfjv fevj mnowljdaj oc e pjndkna ionijrt. Tfjv erj ilekhkna tfet tfjy erj not t o l d ,

gust es Hr. Iehp`jll kndkietjd w k t f tfj @edu sktuetkon. Kt aojs `jyond tfet. Tfjv wjrj to ld

tfjrj wes aokna to `j no ionijrts `y Hs. @edu. . . wfjn kn ceit tfj djcjndent òomkna eajnt.

Hs. Ljwks, mnjw tfjrj wes e ionijrt end t o l d Hr. Djlsjnjr. wfo fed no jxpjrkjnij kn tfet

ckjld, ell eòut kt. Tfet's wfet tfjy erj elljakna.* * * @kds don't hjen enytfkna.

H P M J Y Y L J P 7 Tfjrj ks no jvkdjnij tfet wfktj prohotjrs wjrj akvjn kncorheckon.

.et tfj tkhj tfjy esmjd. Tfj tjstkhony wes tfjrj wesn' t tfet mnowljdaj. Kt feppjnjd

tfjrjectjr. Tfjy ien' t gus t kncjr tfks. Tfjy fevj to fevj sohj èsks.

T F J I O Z P T 7 Fevj you jste`lksfjd kt? Dojs your jvkdjnij jste`lksf tfet kn ceit et

tfj tkhj tfjrj wes no plennjd tour et tfj orkaknel t khj end tfet -- wfet eòut Hr . Djlsjnjr

not fevkna tfj èimaround kn tfj ckjld end fkh ajttkna tfj ùsknjss?^

Tfj Iokut elso rjioankzjd tfet tfj Rlekntkccs fed hedj nknj ̀ kds wfjn kt knqukrjd o c H r . Wwjka,

] w X f y ksn' t tfj stetjhjnt kn your ckrst poknt, ùlljt poknt tfjrj tfet tfj plekntkccs fed nknj `kds cor

huskiel ionijrts iontredkitkna your stetjhjnt tfet tfjy fed hedj no `kds . (k d. 7 52:.) Hr . Wwjka

edhkttjd tfet ijrtekn `kds ]wjrjX su`hkttjd `y Hr . Gonjs end Hr. Powj. (Kd.) 00 Pjaerdkna tfj

Rlekntkccs' iontjntkon tfet ̀ leim end wfk tj prohotjrs erj trjetjd dkccjrjntly ionijrnkna djposkts, Hr.

Mjssljr eraujd, ]tXfj ceit tfet onj pertkiuler prohotjr or two pertkiuler prohotjrs kn e pertkiuler

ionijrt aot to njaotketj e lowjr auerentjj dojsn't ~ Tfks Iourt kntjrgjitjd, ]tgfjrj ks horj tfen onj

or two. Tfjrj erj e lot oc tfjh. (T97 69, jhpf.eddjd). 09 Es to tfks kssuj ks w j l l , wfjn Hs.

Ypjrendo stetjd, 5 gust went to ionckrh onij eaekn tfks dksperkty end trjethjnt w k t f rjaerd to :2

pjrijnt, 52 pjrijnt ( k d . 7 53;), tfks Iourt rjspondjd, ]tXfet you fevj donj prjtty w j l l . ( K d - , jhpf.

eddjd.) Yu`sjqujntly, tfj c o l l o w k n a oiiurrjd `jtwjjn tfj Iourt end Hr. Mjssljr on tfks kssuj (T47

;1, ;;, ;;-522,529-24, jhpf. eddjd)7

T F J I O Z P T 7 Fow do you rjspond to tfj iontreit tfet Hs . Ypjrendo reksjd eòut tfj

52 pjrijnt - `leims only ajttkna 52 pjrijnt wfjrjes ell tfosj iontreits sfow tfet tfj wfktj

'Tfj Iourt dkd not eddrjss tfks qujstkon kn kts opknkon.

-6-



pjoplj aot `jttjr tjrhs.

H P M J Y Y L J P 7 . . . Hs. Ypjrendo sfowjd you e cjw pekrs oc iontreits.

T F J I O Z P T 7 E lot oc iontreits.* * * Hr. Powj fes tjstkckjd tfet fj end tfj otfjr

plekntkccs fevj njvjr `jjn akvjn iontreits wfjrj you only fevj e 52 pjrijnt end fjrj tfjrj erj

e nuh`jr o c iontreits wfkif epperjntly w k t f wfktj prohotjr ]skiX kn wfkif tfjv ajt 52 pjrijnt-

Fow do K don't sjj fow you ien rjspond to tfet.

H P M J Y Y L J P 7 . . . ] T X f k s etteifjs tfj iontreits cor Leuryn F k l l s ionijrt jnaeajhjnts

k n 5;;;, ell oc wfoh erj not wfktj ]endX erj ownjd or iontrolljd `y Ecrkien-Ehjrkiens, end

jeif oc tfjsj iontreits rjqukrjs tfj prohotjrs to pey e djposkt jquel to :2 pjrijnt oc tfj

iontreit auerentjj. Eaekn, tfj poknt fjrj, your Fonor, ks tfet wfjn you loom et tfj populetkon

tfjrj ks no wey to drew en kncjrjnij end - kt wes tfjkr ùrdjn on tfks poknt.

T F J I O Z P T 7 Tfet wes only ~ wfet eòut tfj onjs tfet aot ljss tfen :2 pjrijnt?

04 Qfjn Hs. Ypjrendo sfowjd e QH E ljttjr to Ehy Cunm, e ̀ leim prohotjr, djhendkna tfj c u l l

:2% djposkt cor e Uujjn Letkcef detj, H r . Mjssljr o`gjitjd tfet ]tgfet prohotjr fes notfkna to do w k t f

eny ceits o c tfks iesj. (T97534-3:.) Tfks Iourt rjspondjd, ]tXfjy erj sfowkna en elljaetkon tfjy erj

c o l l o w k n a up on ]skiX ilekh tfet wfktj prohotjrs erj trjetjd dkccjrjntly tfen `leim prohotjrs kn tfj

kndustry end tfks ks ijrteknly jvkdjnij tfet ks ionskstjnt w k t f tfj wey tfjy sey tfet tfjy wjrj trjetjd.

Tfet's pjrcjitly epproprketj. ( K d . , jhpf. eddjd.) 0: On tfj c k rs t dey oc erauhjnt, tfks Iourt stetjd,

]igjrteknly tfj poknts `jkna hedj `y Hs. Ypjrendo wjrj not djelt w k t f `y tfj djcjndents. ( k d . 7 536-

3;) (jhpf. eddjd). 03 Tfks Iourt rjioankzjd tfet tfj tjrhs oc tfj Genjt Geimson iontreit IE E aevj

to Heakiworms end Powj wjrj ionskdjre`ly dkccjrjnt. ( K d . 7 50;, 51;-62, T47 6, jhpf. eddjd.)7

T F J I O Z P T 7 Ruttkna up onj h k l l k o n c kvj kn cour deys, kt hkaft `j prjtty ferd cor host

pjoplj wfjn. Enotfjr, : kn 42 deys end tfjn enotfjr 0 h k l l k o n e wjjm `jcorj tfj c k r s t selj ks

e l k t t l j dkccjrjnt tfen :21 ]skiX pjrijnt prkor to tfj c k rs t on selj detj. Kt rjqukrjs e arjetjr ehount

o c tkhj `jtwjjn tfj tkhj you ien rjioup on eny tkimjts sold.* * *5 earjj w k t f you kt looms

to hj es k c tfj djhend ks fkafjr tfen Heakiworms drect djel.* * K don't dksearjj w k t f you

tfet kt looms to hj es k c tfet iontreit tfet Heakiworms fes ks e `jttjr iontreit c r o h Heakiworms'

stendpoknt tfen wfet wes `jkna suaajstjd to H r . Powj on Herif 4. @ut wfet K don't earjj w k t f

you on ks sohj o c tfj spjikckis 5 earjj w k t f you tfet perts o c kt erj horj cevore`lj. Es K sjjkt fjrj, tfjrj hey `j en jxplenetkon, ùt K earjj kt looms horj cevore`lj. . . . K don't dksearjj

w k t f vou tfet kt looms to hj es k c tfj iontreit, tfj proposel ] H r . PowjX wes horj onjrous tfen

tfj iontreit tjrh tfet Heakiworms wes `jkna occjrjd or drectjd.

01 Tfks Iourt stetjd tfet tfj Wjdjim ljttjrs to only tfj dohknent wfktj prohotjrs wfkif aevj notkij

o c en upiohkna tour oc e wfktj ertkst hey j̀ hetjrkel knconuetkon w k t f rjspjit to tfj entktrust

-;-



erauhjnt. . . . ( T 4 7 l 5.) 06 Pjaerdkna tfj L j c c ljttjr end kts entktrust ionspkreiy khplkietkons, tfks

Iourt eimnowljdajd tfet L j c c wes seykna tfet @jevjr njvjr trkjd to hovj knto Hjhpfks end tfjn

eddjd, fj aojs e l k t t l j `kt certfjr. K tfknm fj ks sevkna `jieusj wfjn H r . Mjlljv wes eround fj e wes

dohknent prohotjr jvkdjntly end Hkd-Youtf wes e dohknent prohotjr end wj dkdn't prohotj kn

Hjhpfks. * * * Tfj teljnt eajnikjs knvolvjd ks en kssuj. ( K d . 7 :9, jhpf. eddjd). 0; Hr. Iehp`jll

sfowjd tfj Iourt fow tfjrj wes iolluskon ̀ jtwjjn tfj top teljnt eajnikjs end @jevjr rjaerdkna tfj

entktrust ionspkreiy end pokntjd to L j c c ovjrt eits kn fks ljttjr o c E p r k l 02 end tfosj oc Yfjlly Yifultz

o c Q H E ks fks E p r k l 51 ljttjr to Yusen Arjjn (tfjn jhployjd `y @jevjr) stetkna tfet Q H E wes

ienijllkna tfj ionijrt oc Gehjs Teylor, e prohknjnt wfktj ertkst, et Hu d Kslend end wes aokna to òom

k t et tfj Hkd-Youtf Iolksjuh. To ell oc wfkif tfks Iourt rjspondjd, ]nXow you'rj akvkna hj

sohjtfkna tfet ien- ( k d . 7 :9-:4= jhpf. eddjd.) 92 Tfks Iourt stetjd to Rlekntkccs' iounsjl, ]y gou' rj

sfowkna e ionnjitkon ̀ jtwjjn H r . Cox end tfj top teljnt eajnikjs ̀ jieusj H r . Cox ks ii'd on tfj ljttjr

to Hs. Arjjn ienijlkna tfj ionijrt. Tfjy erj ii'd . ( K d . 7 ::)' Qfjn Hr. Mjssljr stetjd tfet Cox wes

not e teljnt eajnt, tfks Iourt rjspondjd7

]fXj ks e prohotjr. Fj ks ii'd on Q k l l k e h Horrks', wfo ks e teljnt eajnt, ljttjr oc tfet detj. Kt

sfows iohhunkietkon w k t f e top teljnt eajnt, wfkif Hr. Cox djnkjd tfet fj fed `jjn kniohhunkietkon w k t f tfj top teljnt eajnt, ùt kt's iljer fjrj fj fes `jjn.' ^ * * H r . Cox oc

@jevjr ks kn touif w k t f Q k l l k e h Horrks. Q k l l k e h Horrks ienijls e ionijrt et Hkd-Youtf ] s k i X .

E n d kt' s ell kn tfj sehj tkhj crehj w k t f tfj ljttjr c r o h Hr . L j c c to tfj Hud Kslend, wfetjvjr

k t ks. or tfj i k ty eajniy. Kt dojs loom es k c tfj teljnt eajnts fed akvjn fkh en jnioureajhjnt to

wrktj tfj ljttjr. * * * ] [ X o u fevj sfown hj tfj doiuhjnts tfet sfow e iorhjitkon.

( K d . 7 :6-:;, jhpf. eddjd.) Qfjn H r . Mjssljr stetjd tfet tfet wes tfj kYrst tkhj Djcjndents fed fjerd

tfet tfjrj wes e sjperetj entktrust ilekh eòut Hu d Kslend, tfks Iourt stetjd, K don't tfknm kt's

sjperetj. 5 tfknm k t's kndkietkvj ] o c X wfet tfjy erj seykna. ( K d . 7 6 5 , jhpf. eddjd.) 95 Tfjrjectjr, wfjn

H r . Mjssljr stetjd tfet Heyor Fjrjnton fed djikdjd, prkor to Mjlly's djetf, tfet tfjrj would `j no

horj jxiluskvj iontreits cor H u d Kslend, tfks Iourt stetjd, ] y X o u do fevj e sktuetkon wfjrj epperjntly,

eiiordkna to tfj plekntkccs, fj end K aujss iounsjl fed tfrjj deys or so prkor to tfks supposjd ifenajd

^Tfj Iourt eimnowljdajd kt hjent H r . L j c c

-52-



o c fjert, fed not -- fed kndkietjd tfet tfj jxiluskvj iontreit would ao on. ( K d . 7 60-69= jhpf. eddjd).

H r . Mjssljr iontjndjd tfet tfj only support cor tfet ks tfj ilekh oc tfj p l e k n t k c c . . . . Gonjs tjstkckjd

tfet fj fed fed tfet ionvjrsetkon w k t f tfj heyor end fed `jjn akvjn tfet essurenij. Tfjrj ks notfkna

jlsj to ̀ eim tfet up . . . . ( K d . 7 69.) Tfks Iourt rjspondjd, ]tGfet reksjs en kssuj. ( K d . , jhpf. eddjd.)

90) H r . Mjssljr edhkt tjd tfet kt reksj]dX e ceituel dksputj, el`jkt not e hetjrkel onj, end eraujd tfet

tfj djikskon to opjn up Hud Kslend wes not entkiohpjtktkvj. Tfks Iourt rjspondjd, ]w X e k t e hknutj.

[ o u fevj `jyond tfet. Tfet pert k t s j l c no. @ut tfjn wfet eòut tfj kntjreitkon `jtwjjn Q k l l k e h Horrks

end @jevjr end Hs. Arjjn kn hovkna k n . ( Kd - = jhpf. eddjd.) 99) QTkjn H r . Mjssljr stetjd tfet ] w X j

earjj tfet jlkhknetkna tfj jxiluskvj ien't `j entkiohpjtktkvj, tfks Iourt stetjd, K don't mnow tfet K

earjj w k t f dket. Kt el l djpjnds on tfj totel pkiturj. (Kd. 7 64, jhpf. eddjd.) 94) Hr. Mjssljr tfjn

eraujd, ] e X l l tfjy fevj ks onj doiuhjnt eòut Gehjs Teylor. . . . kt wouldn't sfow en entktrust

ionspkreiy jvjn kn Hjhpfks. ( K d . 7 6:.) Tfks Iourt rjspondjd ( k d . , jhpf. eddjd)7

Not entktrust. [ou' rj aokna to djel w k t f tfj dksirkhknetkon ilekh. Fjrj ks Gehjs Teylor. Fj

ks òomjd knto Hud Kslend. @jieusj oc tfj djetf oc H r . M j l l y . Hr . Gonjs ks tfj survkvkna

pertnjr. Fj ks e `leim prohotjr. Lo end `jfold, wfet do tfjy do? Tfjy fkrj Hs. Arjjn end

temj tfj ionijrt ewey c r oh prohotjr Gonjs end akvj kt to Hs. Arjjn.

9:) Tfks Iourt elso rjgjitjd tfj jionohki khpleusk`klkty erauhjnt hedj `y Derrjll Qkllkehs, tfj

Djcjndents' jionohkst, ionijrnkna tfj entkthst ionspkreiy ( k d . 7 34)7

eh not so surj tfet jionohki enelysks erauhjnt ks e tforouaf enelysks o c tfj `jnjckts tfet ien

`j tfj jionohki hotkvetkon. @jieusj ovjr tkhj kt sjjhs to hj you `rkna elona tfjsj shell

eits end tfjy ̀ jiohj tfj `ka eits. [ou ien't loom et kt kn e prksh oc e sknalj yjer. [o u fevj

aot to loom et kt kn djvjlopkna teljnt, end tfet's wfet Q k l l k e h Horrks ks jnaeajd kn , k c K

undjrstend kt . Tfjy went to djvjlop teljnt end tfjy went to fevj e ster eit. Kn ordjr to ajt e

ster eit, you fevj to fevj jxposurj. K eh not too khprjssjd w k t f tfet erauhjnt `jieusj k t

sjjhs to hj kt fes e tkhj l kh k t e t k o n on k t . . . .

93) Kn rjsponsj to Hr. Mjssljr's erauhjnt tfet tfjrj wes no jvkdjnij tfet tfj òomkna eajnikjs fed

jste`lksfjd dohknent prohotjrs, tfks Iourt stetjd, K tfknm k c tfjy iould sfow tfet tfj òomkna eajnts

fed kn ceit jste`fsfjd kt `y tjstkhony, tfjn proijjdjd to utklkzj k t kn kts jste`lksfjd c o rh , tfjrj would

`j e ilekh, wouldn't you earjj? ( Kd - 7 ;9, jhpf. eddjd). Kn ceit, Pkiferd Gofnson dkd ettjst tfet tfj

- 5 5 -



eajnikjs jste`lksfjd prohotjr dohknenij (Gofnson Ecc. c c 9 , 4 ) end Djcjndents' jxpjrt, Herko

Aonzeljz, dkd tjstkcy tfet tfj eajnikjs utklkzjd kt kn kts jste`lksfjd c o rh . (Aonzeljz 549,541.) 91 Hr.

Mjssljr trkjd to erauj tfet k c tfjrj wes e ionspkreiy to dkvkdj up tfj hermjt, tfj Rlekntkccs would not

`j furt `jieusj tfjrj would `j cjwjr prohotjrs to iohpjtj w k t f k n jeif hermjt. (T47 ;4-;:.) Tfj

Iourt notjd, ]tXfjy fevj tfj jxiluskvjs. Tfjy fevj tfj rjletkonsfkps. . .. Qfet eòut tfjkr posktkon

end tfjy sfowjd hj doiuhjnts tfet sfowjd prohotjrs seykna wj elweys rjspjitjd your erje oc

dohknenij. (T47 ;:, jhpf. eddjd). 96 Towerds tfj jnd o c tfj two end e f e l c dey erauhjnt, tfks

Iourt stetjd, 5 ̀ jlkjvj, crenmly, tfet tfjrj ks reiksh, end proè`ly reiksh kn tfks kndustry. . . . (T:7

095.) 9; Cer croh ioniludkna tfet tfj Rlekntkccs' ilekhs or jvkdjnij wes crkvolous, tfks Iourt stetjd,

]tXfet ks tfj fjert o c tfj hettjr, wfjtfjr tfjrj ks jnouaf tfjrj to kncjr dksirkhknetkon undjr HiDoneld-

Douales . . . . ( K d ) 42 Qfjn tfj Iourt esmjd wfet wes tfj jvkdjnij oc @jevjr's iontjntkon tfet

hultkplj Ecrkien-Ehjrkiens erj horj suiijsscul kn tfks ùsknjss tfen . . . @jevjr, Hr. Io``

rjspondjd, ]tXfj jvkdjnij oc E l e n Feyhon's tjstkhony. ( K d - 7 039.) Tfks Iourt tfjn notjd, ] g Xu s t

f k h , tfet ks tfj only onj K fevj fjerd. ( Kd - , jhpf. eddjd.)' 45 Qfjn H r . Io`` eraujd tfet prohotjrs

do not djikdj wfo ajts e iontreit, tfks Iourt esmjd f k h , ]wXfet eòut mnowljdaj oc tfj ceit tfet `leim

prohotjrs . . .njvjr sjjh to ajt sjljitjd kn tfj kndustry? ( Kd - 7 03:, jhpf. eddjd.) 40 Qfjn Hr.

Io`` notjd tfet @ k l l Qesfknaton fed prohotjd sjvjrel netkonel tours, tfks Iourt esmjd, ] i X o -

prohotkon? ( k d . 7 012, jhpf. eddjd), kndkietkna tfet tfj Rlekntkccs' erauhjnt tfet `leim prohotjrs

hjrjly io-prohotjd tfj wfktj eits ùt dkd not iontreit tfjrjcor `jieusj tfjy wjrj hjrjly io-prohotjrs

fed hedj sjnsj to tfj Iourt end wes not crkvolous. 49 Qfjn H r . Io`` eraujd tfet tfj Gehjs Teylor

ionijrt kn Hjhpfks ks not en ovjrt eit end wes not pljd, tfks Iourt rjspondjd, ] ` X u t kt ks jvkdjnij

`jcorj hj. ( k d . 7 0;4, jhpf. eddjd.) 44 Tfj Iourt earjjd tfet Eljx Iooljy's tjstkhony tfet tfjrj ks

e aood old òy njtworm, Qevre's tjstkhony tfet tfjrj ks e wfktj prohotjr cretjrnkty, end Djlsjnjr's

tjstkhony tfet Ecrkien-Ehjrkiens erj not akvjn jquel opportunkty erj edhksskons ( T l 7 33.) 4: Ectjr

'Tfj Iourt njvjr cound tfet eny `leim prohotjr wes horj suiijsscul tfen @jevjr.

-50-



two end f e l c deys oc erauhjnt, knstjed o c rulha croh tfj `jnif, wfkif tfks Iourt iould fevj donj fed

tfj ilekhs `jjn crkvolous, vjxetkous, or lktkaetjd kn `ed ce k tf , tfks Iourt stetjd, ]dXjikskon ks rjsjrvjd,

o`vkously. (T:70;:, jhpf. eddjd.)

Tfus, tfj Iourt's nuhjrous stetjhjnts rjaerdkna tfj hjrkts oc tfj Rlekntkccs' ilekhs rjcutj tfj

Djcjndents' elljaetkons tfet tfjy wjrj crkvolous or hedj kn ̀ ed cek tf. Yjj ECYIHJ v. . Nesseu. ;3 C.

9d 344, 3:9 n. 0 (0d Ikr. 5;;3), ijrt, djnkjd. :02 Z.Y. 5524, 551 Y. It. 5521 (5;;1) (iourt's

ioniluskon, ectjr `jnif t r k e l , tfet ilekh wes crkvolous wes kn sohj tjnskon w k t f kts jerlkjr djnkels oc

djcjndents' hot kons to dkshkss end cor gudahjnt es e hettjr o c lew et ilosj o c plekntkccs iesj et trkel ) .

Horjovjr, tfks Iourt jrronjously dksrjaerdjd tfj ecckdevkt oc Pkiferd Gofnson `jieusj fj wes

lest e Q H E eajnt kn 5;63 (1,90, 9;,45 n. 32,69,559 n. 54;,50;,515-10) end nuhjrous stetjhjnts oc

Powj on tfj arounds tfet ks not en jxpjrt (01,69 n. 505,52:) end fes no pjrsonel mnowljdaj oc tfet

to wfkif fj wes ettjstkna (pesskh). Es notjd kn Denzjr v. Nordjn Yystjhs. Kni.. 5:5 C.9d :2, :1 (0d

Ikr. 5;;6)(cootnotjs ohkttjd)(jhpf. eddjd)7

Tfjrj ks notfkna kn ]Pulj :3(i)X to suaajst tfet nonhovents' ecckdevkts elonj iennot-es e

hettjr o c lew—succkij to djcjnd eaeknst ehotkon cor suhhery gudahjnt .* * * Kn dksirkhknetkon

iesjs, tfj only dkrjit jvkdjnij evekle`lj vjry octjn ijntjrs on wfet tfj djcjndent elljajdly sekd

or dkd. ]Iktetkon ohkttjd.X Yknij tfj djcjndent w k l l rerjly edhkt to fevkna sekd or donj wfetks elljajd, end sknij tfkrd-perty wktnjssjs erj `y no hjens elweys evekle`lj, tfj kssuj

crjqujntly `jiohjs onj oc essjsskna tfj irjdk`klkty oc tfj pertkjs.

E t suhhery gudahjnt. . . tfet kssuj ks njijsserkly rjsolvjd kn cevor oc tfj nonhovent. To

fold . . . tfet tfj nonhovent's elljaetkons o c ceit erj (`jieusj 'sjlc sjrvkna') knsucckikjnt to cjnd

o c c suhhery gudahjnt would `j to tfrust tfj iourts-et en knepproprketj steaj-knto en

edgudkietkon o c tfj hjrkts — Q j tfjrjcorj rjgjit djcjndents' knv k t e c k on to irjetj tfks njw rulj.

Curtfjrhorj, e wktnjss's pjrsonel mnowljdaj dojsn't fevj to rksj to tfj ljvjl o c ijrteknty to `j

edhkssk`lj. Z. Y. v. Pjkteno. 630 C.0d ;60, ;61 (0d Ikr. 5;66)= Z.Y. v. Jvens. 464 C.0d 5516, 5565

(0d Ikr. 5;19)= Y.J.I. v. Yknajr. 163 C, Yupp. 55:6, 5531 (Y.D.N.[. 5;;0). Qfjn e wktnjss fed en

opportunkty to o`sjrvj tfj ceits upon wfkif fj `esjs fks tjstkhony, knsocer es tfosj teits kniludj fks

own `jfevkor end tfj o`sjr\'e`lj kntjreitkons `jtwjjn fkhsjlc end otfjrs, tfj tjstkhony ks jntkrjly

edhkssk`lj. Kd. Kt ks tfjn tfjgury's rolj to djtjnnknj wfjtfjr to ̀ jlkjvj tfj tjstkhony. K d. Tjstkhony

-59-



hey `j edhkssk`lj jvjn k tfj wktnjss only fes e `roed ajnjrel rjiolljitkon o c tfj su`gjit hettjr. Kd.=

Z . Y. v. Rjyro. 163 C.0d 603, 692 (6tf Ikr. 5;63). Ioniluskons èsjd on pjrsonel o`sjrvetkons ovjr

tkhj hey ionstktutj pjrsonel mnowljdaj djspktj tfj wktnjss's k n e ` k l k t y to rjiell spjikcki knikdjnts upon

wfkif fj èsjd fks ioniluskons. Yknajr, 55:6 C. Yupp. et 5531. Yuif ioniluskons erj not ionilusory

end erauhjntetkvj stetjhjnts, or spjiuletkon, end erj edhkssk`lj. Goy Hca. Io. v. Yole @eski

Kndustrkjs. Kni.. 3;1 C.0d 524, 552 (9d Ikr. 5;60). Qfjn e wktnjss fes jxtjnskvj mnowljdaj o c e

su`gjit fj ks elso ellowjd to proccjr en opknkon, wfkif ks retkonelly ̀ esjd on fks mnowljdaj, es e

pjrsonel o`sjrvjr, o c tfj spjikcki su`gjit hettjr. Kd .= Yknajr. 163 C. Yupp. et 5531-36.

Tfus, Gofnson's ecckdevkt wes edhkssk`lj `jieusj fj fed `jjn e Q H E eajnt cor cour yjers end

`jieusj kt wes èsjd on fks iontknukna c e h k l k e r k ty w k t f tfj ionijrt òomkna prohotkon ùsknjss

(Gofnson E c c c9 ), end host, k not e l l , oc Powj's stetjhjnts wjrj edhkssk`lj `jieusj Powj fes 92

yjers o c jxpjrkjnij kn end mnowljdaj o c tfj ionijrt prohotkon kndustry. (Powj E c c ^9.) Qfjtfjr tfjkr

tjstkhony wes to `j `jlkjvjd wes e g u r y qujstkon. Yknajr, 163 C. Yupp. et 5531-36= Folz v. Poimjcjlljr

& Io.. Kni.. 0:6 C.9d 30, 3; (0d Ikr . 0225)= Iehjrlkn v. Njw [ o r m Ijnt. P. Io.. 5;; C.0d 3;6, 124

(5st Ikr. 5;:0) (usj o c dksirkhknetkon plekntkccs own tjstkhony succkikjnt to reksj kncjrjnij oc

dksirkhknetkon end kts irjdk`klkty wes e qujstkon to `j djtjrhknjd et t r ke l ) .

@ut jvjn essuhkna Gofnson's ecckdevkt end portkons oc Rlekntkccs' Pulj :3.5 stetjhjnts end

supportkna ecckdevkts, wjrj propjrly dksrjaerdjd, tfjrj ks e pljtfore oc ionkpjtjnt jvkdjnij sfowkna

tfet Rlekntkccs' dksirkhknetkon ilekhs wjrj not vjxetkous, crkvolous, or hedj kn èd c e k t f 7 7 ' /

@jevjr7 5 Tfks Iourt hedj sfort sfrkct oc tfj iontjntkon tfet Rlekntkccs sfould not fevj sujd Geh

end @jevjr `jieusj o c Feyhon's opknkon wfjn kt suiiknitly stetjd, ]fXj ks no jxpjrt (T47 62) end

dkshkssjd tfj dksputj ionijrnkna wfjtfjr Feyhon wes onj o c tfj ljedkna netkonel tour prohotjrs,

'^Pjaerdkna tfj elljajd djckikjnikjs kn tfj Pulj :3.5 stetjhjnts end supportkna ecckdevkts, tfj

Rlekntkccs end tfjkr ettornjys fevj elrjedy `jjn punksfjd `y tfj Iourt's dksrjaerdkna tfosj stetjhjnts kt

djjhjd knsucckikjnt.

'Rlekntkccs fevj speij to jxplekn only e creitkon oc tfj jvkdjnij wfkif provjs tfet tfj Rlekntkccs'

ilekhs wjrj not vjxetkous, ckkvolous, or hedj kn èd cektf. (Ypjrendo H ^59.)

-54-



seykna, .. .tfet ksn 't khportent eny w e y . ( T 4 7 13.) Feyhon wes onj o c tfj orkaknel skanetorkjs to tfks

ftkaetkon `jcorj tfj sukt wes ckljd end wfjn tfj prohotjrs wjrj kniludjd es Djcjndents on tfj rjteknjr

earjjhjnt (Jx.55), ùt wktfdrjw wfjn fj `jaen njaotketkna to sjll fks iohpeny to YCV. (Rks. ' IEE ,

Powj ^:4.) Feyhon ks not e lewyjr end fes no ljael treknkna. (Feyhon 010-19.) Yjj n. : supre= 0)

jxpjrt tjstkhony wes not njijssery' to provj tfj Rlekntkccs' ilekhs eaeknst @jevjr7 e) tfrjj wjjms ectjr

(wfktj) Mjlljy's djetf. @jevjr opjnjd e Hjhpfks occkij, `) L j c c s E p r k l 02,5;;6 ljttjr ( wj fevj `jjn

esmjd `y tfj top teljnt eajnikjs to jste`lksf en occkij kn Hjhpfks ) sjjmkna to prjvjnt Crjd Gonjs croh

o`teknkna en jxiluskvj earjjhjnt to prohotj ionijrts et Hud Kslend kn Hjhpfks, i) E p r k l 51, 5;;6

ljttjr croh Yifultz oc Q H E to Yusen Arjjn w k t f rjaerd to hovkna Gehjs Teylor ionijrt croh Hud

Kslend (Gonjs) to Hkd-Youtf Iolksjuh (@jevjr) end d) Djijh`jr 9, 0220 edhksskon oc @jevjr's

iounsjl tfet, ]oX n kts ceij, tfj ljttjr @erry L j c c sjnt to Qeynj @oyjr iould `j. tfrouaf irjetkvj

erauhjnt, ionskdjrjd es jvkdjnij o c ionspkretorkel or dksirkhknetory ionduit. ( J x . 52, jhpf. eddjd),

rjckktj eny ilekh oc cknvolousnjss end èd c e k t f es to @jevjr= 9) eltfouaf k n k t k e l l y Fjrjnton tjstkckjd

tfet fj to ]fksX mnowljdaj fed njvjr sjjn ]tfj L j c c ljttjrX `jcorj (Fjrjnton 42), fj tfjn T Q K I J

tjstkckjd K don't rjiell wfjn esmjd wfjtfjr fj fed mnown eòut @jevjr's knqukry on E p r k l 05 wfjn

fj djikdjd not to epprovj en jxiluskvj et Hud Kslend (kd. 11-16) (ic. (;;,522))= 4) tfj undksputjd

jvkdjnij ks tfet ectjr ckvj yjers oc twkij earjjkna to en jxiluskvj et H u d Kslend, Fjrjnton djikdjd tfet

k t wes kn tfj `jst kntjrjst oc Hjhpfks not to fevj en jxiluskvj tfjrj on E p r k l 05. 5;;6. onj dey ectjr

tfj detj o c L j c c s ljttjr ( k d . 34, 69-64), cor two rjesons wfkif fj fed mnown eòut wfjn fj epprovjd

Kslend Jvjnt's jxiluskvkty earjjhjnt k n 5;;: ( k d . 6;-;2-;4)= :) Cox ]iould notX rjhjh`jr (not tfet

fj dkd not mnow (ic. (522)) wfjtfjr fj mnjw tfet Gonjs wes `leim wfjn L j c c wrotj tfj ljttjr (Cox 9;)=

3) kt would fevj `jjn k n @jevjr's jionohki `jst kntjrjst not to fevj H u d Kslend su`gjit to en jxiluskvj

iontreit (525) end to opjn e Hjhpfks occkij (520) wfklj Mjlljy wes elkvj, ùt @jevjr only hovjd knto

Hjhpfks ectjr Mjlljy's djetf wfjn e `leim prohotjr stood to knfjrkt tfj jxiluskvj= 1) gust `jieusj kt

wes kn @jevjr's jionohki `jst kntjrjst dojsn't hjen kt wes not reikelly hotkvetjd= 6) L . @ E F / J [

-5 : -



tjstkckjd (@ekljy 62-60) tfet fj o`teknjd tfj Mjnny A detjs not c roh IE E ̀ ut only et tfj knskstjnij

o c Mjnny A end Djnnks Turnjr (ic. 529 n. 596)= ;) tfus, tfet Cox fes njvjr knvolvjd eny `leim

prohotjr es e io-prohotjr wfjn e wfk tj ertkst wes tfj cjeturjd eit ks unrjùttjd= 52) tfj Iourt's

ioniluskon tfet @jevjr's hovkna knto Hjhpfks ectjr Mjlljy's djetf iould `j ionskstjnt wktf e

reikelly hotkvetjd ionspkreiy to kntjrcjrj wktf e iontreituel rjletkonsfkp (520, jhpf. eddjd),

jste`fsfjs e g u r y qujstkon (Ifeh`jrs v. TPH Iopv Itrs. Iorp.. 49 C.9d 0;, 96 (0d Ikr . 5;;4)( ]kXt

ks not tfj provknij oc tfj suhhery gudahjnt iourt k t s j l c to djikdj wfet kncjrjnijs sfould `j drewn )=

55) @jevjr's `kds (30, 529 n. 59;) wjrj not `kds ùt Jxpjnsj Yfjjts es tfjy stetj, su`hkttjd

C T J P T F J R P O H O T J P FEY T F J D T J wfkif ks wfjn fj akvjs en jstkhetj oc jxpjnsjs.

Tfjy ionteknjd no occjrs. Tfj Rlekntkccs jxpleknjd tfks et orel erauhjnt (tfj jxpjnsj sfjjts wjrj

etteifjd to @jevjr's Pjply to wfkif tfj Rlekntkccs iould not rjspond), end tfet tfjy fed propoundjd

e doiuhjnt rjqujst to @jevjr kn wfkif tfjy fed esmjd cor ell solkiktetkon hetjrkels to wfkif @jevjr

o`gjitjd, end wfjn tfj Iourt ordjrjd tfjh to rjspond. @jevjr s t k l l produijd no `kds. (T:7 065, 0;0-

;9.) Tfj Iourt eiijptjd Q H E s iounsjl's essjrtkon et orel erauhjnt tfet Djlsjnjr/Yletjr iontrolljd

tfj Yuppjr Ilu`. (556 n. 535.) Tfus, Rlekntkccs' iounsjls' stetjhjnt et orel erauhjnt tfet @jevjr's

`kds wjrj Jxpjnsj Yfjjts irjetjd e ceit kssuj es to wfjtfjr @jevjr fed jvjr su`hkttjd eny `kds.

Horjovjr, @jevjr's eiiountent, Ytjvj Arksfhen, ks not e prohotjr or eajnt end, tfjrjcorj, ks not

iohpjtjnt to ettjst to wfet ks e `kd (T:7 0;0)= 50) Rlekntkccs ]iktj]dX no jvkdjnij tfet Geh or @jevjr

d kd not su`hkt `kds cor ionijrts (30) `jieusj onj iennot provj e njaetkvj, ùt Powj dkd ettjst tfet

fj fed not cound eny `kds croh tfjh. (Rks.' @jevjr, Powj Djil. ^03.)

Geh7 5) Yknij e) Powj su`hkttjd e `kd cor tfj 5;;6 postponjd (not ienijlljd) (ic.(36)) (sjj prjss

rjljesj, J x. 50) Ifkieao Hexwjll detj(s), `) tfjrj ks no rjiord jvkdjnij tfet Geh su`hkttjd eny ̀ k d

cor tfosj detjs kn 5;;6 or 5;;; (or et eny tkhj) ùt aot tfjh nonjtfjljss (onj ien't iohpjtj w k t f e ̀ kd

tfet ksn't hedj), end i) QH E dkd not edvksj Powj tfet Hexwjll wes tourkna kn 5;;6 or 5;;; (Rks.'

Geh, Powj ^]05), e rjesone`lj kncjrjnij ks tfet Geh end Q H E ionspkrjd to prjvjnt Powj c roh ajttkna

-53-



tfj Ifkieao detjs= 0) Geh ks tfj dohknent prohotjr kn Ifkieao (Mepp 091) (ic. (65-60))= 9) E l

Mjnnjdy's Dji. 4, 0222, ecckdevkt ks not iohpjtjnt `jieusj Poskj O'Donnjll ks not e iontjhporery

huski ertkst (9, 4; n. 15) end no detj ks akvjn to sfow tfet tfj Evjreaj Qfktj @end detj wes durkna

tfj pjrkod iovjrjd `y tfks eitkon= 4) tfj unrjùttjd jvkdjnij tfet Geh fes io-prohotjd wfktj eits w k t f

wfktj prohotjrs (Hkimjlson 526-552) end nuhjrous `leim eits w k t f `leim prohotjrs (Arenet 93-49=

Hkimjlson 552), ̀ ut njktfjr Arenet (Arenet 31-1;) nor Hkimjlson (Hkimjlson 52;. 555-59) ien nehj

e sknalj wfktj eit Geh io-prohotjd w k t f e `leim prohotjr ks jvkdjnij oc dksirkhknetkon= :) Geh's

elljaetkon tfet ]`Xjcorj tfj iohhjnijhjnt oc tfks l k t k a e t k o n , Geh dkd not fevj eny mnowljdaj o c tfj

ionspkreiy elljajd ̀ y plekntkccs (63) iennot o c k t s j l c rjcutj kts mnowljdaj ̀ jieusj k kt iould, e p l e k n t k c c

iould njvjr provj e § 5;63 vkoletkon= 3) wfjn Feyhon iontreitjd cor ckvj Leuryn F k l l Q H E ) detjs,

fj fed to pey :2% djposkt. (Rks.'Geh, Jx. 54.) Tfks Iourt notjd, ]fXj fed e ̀ ka auerentjj. (T:7004.)

K n tfet sehj yjer, cor two Leuryn F k l l ionijrts. Geh pekd e 52% djposkt. K d - , Jx. 52.) Eltfouaf tfj

Iourt k n k t k e l l y tfouaft tfet tfj sjetkna erjnes usjd `y Feyhon end Geh wjrj dkccjrjnt, tfjy wjrj not.

T : 7 004-0:.) Es Hr . Iehp`jll notjd, kt wes e ]pgjrcjit eppljs-to-eppljs iohperkson k d 7 00:)= 1)

tfj ceit tfet òtf Feyhon end Geh wjrj occjrjd tfj sehj djposkt (6:) ks not dksposktkvj oc wfjtfjr

tfjrj ks en kncjrjnij oc e ionspkreiy w k t f Q H E to dksirkhknetj ̀ jieusj e) tfjrj erj iontreits wfjrj

Geh wes occjrjd end pekd e 52% djposkt (Rks.' Geh, Jx. 50), ùt nonj es to Feyhon or eny otfjr `leim

prohotjr, `) Geh fes produijd no jvkdjnij tfet, l k m j k t , Feykuon wes ellowjd to njaocketj cor e 52%

djposkt end i) Geh's elljajd e ` k l k t y to njaotketj `jas tfj qujstkon es to wfy kt ien do so ùt `leim

prohotjrs iennot.

Q H 5) HGR wes not tfj tour prohotjr cor H e x w j ll , k.j., onj wfo fes jxiluskvj rkafts to

tfj ertkst's iurrjnt pjrcorhenijs end hey njaotketj cor spjikcki ionijrts w k t f loiel prohotjrs knstjed

o c tfj ertksts or eajnt. (59, jhpf. eddjd.) Q H E knsjrtjd HGR kn tfj Hexwjll tour et :2%. knstjed

o c tfj usuel 522% to ikriuhvjnt tfj Rlekntkccs' iferajs o c dksirkhknetkon. Tfus, HGR wes corijd to

usj tfj wfktj prohotjrs Q H E fed sjljitjd. Jx. 59.) (Ic. IEE sold Heakiworms 522% o c tfj Genjt

- 5 1 -



Geimson tour, end tfus, k t . not I E E . fed tfj rkaft to djikdj on loiel prohotjrs. ( L k a f t Dji. K ^^4;,:2)=

0 Powj wes njvjr t o l d eòut tfj 5;;6 or 5;;; Hexwjll tour jvjn tfouaf fj fed hedj occjrs (to

wfkif Q H E njvjr rjspondjd) cor sjvjn iktkjs cor tfj postponjd, not ienijlljd, 5;;6 tour (Rks.' Q H E ,

Powj c 0 5 ) = 9 Powj's occjrs kn totel wjrj $6:,222 fkafjr tfen tfosj o c tfj prohotjrs Q H E sjljitjd

( kd - , Jx. 02)= 4 Q H E s dete on tfj `kds kt rjijkvjd, eiijptjd end rjgjitjd (39), vkoletjd tfj `jst

jvkdjnij rulj (Cjd. P. J v k d . 5224) `jieusj kt dkd not produij tfj `kds or doiuhjnts tfjhsjlvjs (end

n ot jvjn tfj iohputjr prkntout o c tfj dete w k t f tfj jxijptkon o c @edu dete) end tfus wes knedhkssk`lj=

: @osjhen ielljd Ljwks to knqukrj eòut @edu detjs end Ljwks t o l d fkh sfj wes not aokna out (Rks.'

Q H E @osjhen t00)= 3 Ljwks njvjr ielljd @osjhen to t j l l fkh @edu wes aokna to tour djspktj fks

jxprjssjd kntjrjst (@osjhen 10:)= 1) Ljwks's tjstkhony tfet sfj t o l d @osjhen tfet @edu wes pleykna

only et shell vjnujs (551) ks iontrovjrtjd `y @osjhen's tjstkhony tfet Ljwks t o l d fjr only tfet @edu

wes not aokna to tour end, tfjrjcorj, fj dkd not proposj d tjs or otfjr vjnujs (kd . 100-09)= 6 tfj

stetjhjnt to @osjhen c r o h Djlsjnjr end Yletjr tfet Ljwks fed t o l d tfjh, k c tfjy do ùsknjss w k t f Yun

Yona, tfet sfj wouldn't do eny ùsknjss w k t f tfjh eny ckkrtfjr (gd. 191-96), eltfouaf fjersey (551

n . 5:6), ks edhkssk`lj to sfow @osjhen's hotkvj cor not iellkna Ljwks end rjqujstkna e spjikcki vjnuj.

(Cjd. P. J v k d . 629(9)= Z.Y. v. Ostrendjr. ;;; C.0d 01, 90 (0d Ikr . 5;;9). Fj mnjw tfet tfet would fevj

`jjn c u t k l j end tfus wes jxjhpt croh fevkna to ̀ k d undjr Rjtroskno7 ; tfet @edu ultkhetjly pleyjd

k n Njw [ o r m vjnujs elljajdly jxiluskvjly ̀ oomjd `y tfj ùkldkna (556) ks krrjljvent to tfj ceit tfet

Ljwks l k j d to @osjhen (REY Iohhunkietkons) (ionijelkna kncorhetkon eòut `kd opportunktkjs ks

dksirkhknetkon)= 52 Q H E su`hkttjd no iohpjtjnt jvkdjnij k.j., tfj iontreits (Cjd. P. J v k d . 5224)

sfowkna tfet Lkonjl @je, @ k l l Qesfknaton, Derryl @rooms, Entfony Qkllkehs, Jernjst @rooms, HGJ,

end Hery Clowjrs (509) prohotjd (not io-prohotjd) Leuryn F k l l , k.j., Y K A N J D T F J I O N T P E I T

eltfouaf kt dkd produij tfj iontreit tfet Feyhon/YCV skanjd, tfus kndkietkna tfet `leim prohotjrs dkd

n ot prohotj F k l l = 55 tfet e`leim prohotjr. Clowjrs, io-prohotjd tfj F k l l detj @osjhen wes prohksjd

( 5 0 4 ) ks kkTjljvent es to wfjtfjr reij wes e ceitor rjaerdkna Ljwks 's lk j to @osjhen (REY

-56-



Iohhunkietkons)7 50) Yifultz's tjstkhony (503) tfet Teylor 's heneajhjnt djikdjd to usj @jevjr

(Yifultz Ecc. c6 ), ks k n c k r h `jieusj kt ks knedhkssk`lj fjersey. Q H E dkd not djposj Teylor's

heneajhjnt. Tfus, Q H E fes prjsjntjd no jvkdjnij to rj`ut Rlekntkccs' prkhe ceikj iesj oc

dksirkhknetkon rjaerdkna tfj Teylor ionijrt end tfjrj wes no njjd cor Rlekntkccs to sfow tfet Q H E s

rjesons cor kts eitkons wjrj prjtjxtuel= 59) Q H E s jvkdjnij ks prjtjxtuel `jieusj tfet @jevjr wes

aokna to prohotj Teylor kn Ermenses cour deys j̀corj tfj Hjhpfks ionijrt fed notfkna to do w k t f wfo

iould or sfould prohotj Teylor kn Hjhpfks. Kt dkdn't hettjr wfjn Mjlljy wes prohksjd tfj Hjhpfks

detj. Yifultz's stetjhjnt tfet tfjy dkd not fevj e prohotjr et Hud Kslend ks untruj `jieusj Q HE

iould fevj usjd Gonjs= 54) wfjtfjr Yifultz ks tjllkna tfj trutf tfet fj dkdn't mnow oc Gonjs wfjn fj

wrotj to Arjjn (503), akvjn tfj tkhkna o c tfjsj jvjnts, ks cor tfj g u r y . Tfks ks jspjikelly truj `jieusj

Yifultz celsjly ettjstjd tfet et tfj tkhj o c Mjlljy's djetf, fj end Mjlljy fed only en orel undjrstendkna

tfet Mjlljy wes to prohotj Teylor et Hu d Kslend (Yifultz E c c c3) , wfjn k n ceit kn fks Her. 9, 5;;6

ljttjr to Mjlljy fj stetjs tfet tfj detjs ]Gunj 09-04X erj omey, wj w k l l soon rjionckrh tfj djel Jx.

5 4 = 5:) Djcjndents' jvkdjnij oc tfj prohotkon oc wfktj ertksts rjprjsjntjd `y Q H E ̀ y `leim

prohotjrs, k.j., Derryl @rooms (Jhknjh)= @ k l l Qesfknaton (Njw Mkds On Tfj @loim, Evjreaj Qfktj

@end, Yentene), Lerry @ekljy (Evjreaj Qfktj @end, Q E P ) = Hery Clowjrs (Tony @jnnjtt)= end Powj

(Evjreaj Qfktj @end) (501-06), ks not iohpjtjnt `jieusj e) Cjd P. J v k d . 5224 rjqukrjs tfet tfj

iontreits `j produijd, wfkif Q H E dkd not do, `) Qesfknaton, @rooms, Clowjrs end @ekljy wjrj io-

prohotjrs, not prohotjrs wfo eituelly skanjd tfj iontreit, i) Q HE iktjs no detjs cor tfjsj elljajd

iontreits, d) Yentene end Qer erj not wfktj eits, j) jvjn essuhkna tfet tfjsj `leim prohotjrs

prohotjd jeif oc tfjsj ertksts durkna tfj rjljvent tkhj pjrkod et kssuj, end tfet Yentene end Qer erj

wfktj ertksts, tfjsj F E N D C Z L OC detjs, out o c tfj tfousends o c iontreits `y wfktj ertksts durkna tfj

rjljvent pjrkod, erj succkikjnt jvkdjnij to ellow e g u r y to djtjrhknj wfjtfjr Q H E dksirkhknetjs

eaeknst `leim prohotjrs end dkj Rlekntkccs kn pertkiuler= 53) Arosslkaft's djileretkon sfowkna tfet

Q H E produijd to Rlekntkccs kts jljitronki dete`esj oc ionijrt `kds rjijkvjd (506) ks not iohpjtjnt

- 5 ; -



jvkdjnij `jieusj kt ks not fj `jst jvkdjnij oc tfosj `kds, k.j., tfj `kds tfjhsjlvjs wfkif Q HE

prjsuhe`ly fes, end dojs not ellow tfj Iourt to djtjrhknj e tfj eiiureiy oc tfj kncorhetkon iulljd

croh Q H E s jljicronki deteèsj, ` wfjn tfj `kds wjrj rjijkvjd end, tfus, wfjtfjr tfjy wjrj t ru ly

iohpjtktkvj or rjijkvjd ectjr tfj detj fed `jjn sold to e dohknent wfktj prohotjr, or i fow heny

detjs Q H E sold end wfjtfjr tfjrj wes e ` kd cor jeif detj sold= 51 tfj Iourt cknds tfet tfj Rlekntkccs

cekljd to iktj eny jvkdjnij to support tfjkr ilekh tfet Q H E wktffold]sX kncorhetkon njijssery cor

`leim prohotjrs to su`hkt iohpjrkna ̀ kds — (50;.) Fowjvjr, ̀ otf Powj (Rks.' Q H E , Powj 9;)

end @osjhen ( k d . , @osjhen ^]00) tjstkckjd tfet Ljwks celsjly t o l d tfjh tfet @edu wesn't aokna out jvjn

tfouaf sfj wes= 56 ertksts' end tfjkr heneajrs' tjstkhony tfet ell ̀ kds erj rjcjrrjd to tfjh (50;) ks

kniohpjtjnt `jieusj tfjy ien't mnow wfjtfjr Q H E wk tffolds eny k̀ds= 5; Feyhon tjstkckjd tfet

Q H E fes not pessjd on fks `kds (Feyhon 5;5-;9)= 02 Yifultz's jxplenetkon es to wfy fj sjnt e

notkij ljttjr to 9; wfktj prohotjrs ùt nonj to e `leim prohotjr (k.j., dksiusskons w k t f heneajhjnt

end 9; wjrj prohotjrs wfo wormjd w k t f Iulturj Ilu` kn tfj pest (592)), ks k n c k r h end tfus rjqukrjs

no rjsponsj croh tfj Rlekntkccs `jieusj dksiusskons w k t f heneajhjnt erj knedhkssk`lj fjersey=' ̂05

tfj rjeson ks prjtjxtuel e) `jieusj notkcykna pest prohotjrs o c upiohkna ionijrts dkd not oiiur wfjn

kt knvolvjd `leim ertksts nurturjd to suiijss `y ̀ leim prohotjrs (Rks.'QHE, Powjc0;), end ` k tfj

k n k t k e l djikskon to usj e prohotjr cor Iulturj Ilu` wes èsjd on reij es tfj Rlekntkccs elljaj, tfjn

notkcykna tfosj sehj prohotjrs cor en upiohkna tour k n no wey djhonstretjs e reij-njutrel rjeson cor

iontknukna to no t k cy tfjh end sjrvjs only to pjrpjtuetj tfj dksirkhknetkon end rjsultkna kngustkij= 00

Rlekntkccs njjd not sfow tfet ell skhklerly sktuetjd non-hknorkty hjh`jrs wjrj crjetjd

dkccjrjntly ( 592) ùt only tfet ell ̀ leims wjrj trjetjd dkccjrjntly croh skhklerly sktuetjd non-hknorkty

prohotjrs. IArent v. @jtfljfjh Ytjjl Iorp.. 39: C.0d 5221, 5251 (0d Ikr. 5;62)( ceklurj to solkikt

quelkckjd `leims.. .ionstktutjs.. .dksirkhknetkon.. .sknij wfktjs wjrj `jkna solkiktjd et tfj sehj tkhj ).

'Êltfouaf Rlekntkccs ifosj not to djposj heneajhjnt oc Iulturj Ilu` (592 n. 515), so too dkd

Q H E . Horjovjr, tfj Rlekntkccs' pjrsuedkna ertksts end heneajrs to tjstkcy kn tfks hettjr et e l l , huif ljss

kn e hennjr tfet would `ktj tfj fend tfet cjjds tfjh, wes vjry dkcckiult . (Ypjrendo Ecc . ^9.)

-02-



(Yjj ljttjrs c roh Q H E to only wfktj prohotjrs) (Rks. ' Q H E , Jx. 551)= 09 tfj Rrohotjr Djcjndents

erj elso occjrjd iontreits `y Q H E iellkna cor e :2% djposkc (595) end Rlekntkccs fevj not sfown

tfet tfjkr sjljitkon oc iontreits ks rjprjsjntetkvj (595 n. 510)7 Rlekntkccs' jvkdjnij ks succkikjnt to

sfow en elerhkna nuh`jr o c Rrohotjr Djcjndents erj occjrjd iontreit tjrhs tfet e l l `leim prohotjrs

don't ajt, tfj only jxijptkon kn tfks rjiord ̀ jkna two 0:% djposkts `y @ekljy cor Mjnny A (545 n. 560

(ùt sjj spjikel rjletkonsfkp w k t f Mjnny A), tfus provkna tfet tfj ovjrwfjlhkna hegorkty oc tfj tkhj

`leims wjrj dkscevorjd, e ceit tfet iennot `j jxpleknjd `y enytfkna otfjr tfen reij sknij `leim

prohotjrs (Feyhon) wfo fevj tfj elljajd rjquksktj quelkckietkons (j.a., cknenikel ste`klkty), erj trjetjd

tfj sehj wey es tfj Rlekntkccs. Tfj only rjeson reij-njutrel Djcjndents occjr, k.j., tfet tfj wf ktj

prohotjrs erj e`lj to njaotketj `jttjr tjreks (590), `jas tfj qujstkon es to wfy wfktj prohotjrs ien do

k t ùt `leims, kniludkna Feyhon, iennot=' ̂ 04 tfj lona-stendkna rjletkonsfkps `jtwjjn Q H E end

sohj wfktj prohotjrs gust es suiijsscully jxiludj otfjr wfktj prohotjrs end, tfjrjcorj, no reikel

enkhus fes `jjn sfown (590)7 tfks ks not tfj tjst. K c kt wjrj, Rlekntkccs would fevj to sfow tfet no

`leim prohotjrs erj e pert o c tfj aood olj ̀ oy njtworm, end e l l wfktj prohotjrs erj e pert o c k t . Yuif

e ùrdjn would `j emkn to ilekhkna tfet `jieusj sohj wfktjs hey ̀ j djnkjd tfj rkaft to l k v j kn e wfk tj

eperthjnt iohpljx tfet dojsn't ellow eny ̀ leims, reiksh iould not `j tfj hotkvj cor mjjpkna e l l `leims

out

I 5 Qfjn Powj ielljd I E E to esm wfo wes aokna out, fj wes njvjr t o l d eòut eny wfktj ertksts.

(Rks.' I E E , Powj 55::) (REY Iohhunkietkons)7 0 To h Poss (Poss 02,05) end Djnnks Esfljy (Esfljy

0;, 49, :5, :6, 34) ionckrhjd tfet IEE eajnts routknjly iell tfj prohotjrs to no t k c y tfjh eòut

ionijrts= 9 L k a f t edhkts tfet Powj knqukrjd eòut Jrki Ilepton ̀ jcorj tfks lewsukt ̀ ut ]fj dojsn'tX

rjhjh`jr wfjtfjr fj or enyonj et I E E jvjr t o l d Powj tfet Ilepton wes aokna on tour L k a f t 431)

(REY Iohhunkietkons)7 4 Njdjrlendjr aot e ;2/52 ertkst splkt cor 5;;1 Mjnny A detj k n Ielkcornke

'•'Tfj Feyhon/Geh Ytjvkj Qondjr djposkt oc 0:% jeif (63 n. 504) ehountjd to e totel djposkt

o c :2%.

- 0 5 -



6: n. 559)= :) et no tkhj wes Powj t o l d tfet tfj auerentjjs on tfj Mjnny A tour fed `jjn lowjrjd to

$ 5:2,222-$ 51:,222, ùt Geh (end tfj otfjr dohknent wfktj prohotjrs) mnjw eòut end `jnjckttjd ck-oh

tfj lowjr auerentjj wfkif Powj ljernjd eòut `y eiikdjnt (Rks.' IEE, Powj ^009)= 3) jvjn tfouaf

Powj eimnowljdajd tfet fj fed tfj opportkhkty to ̀ kd on Mjnny A/@rexton (16,59;), tfj tjrhs fj

wes akvjn wjrj skankckiently fkafjr tfen tfosj akvjn to tfj dohknent wfktj prohotjrs7 Rkrenken t o l d

Powj kn Oit or Nov. 5;;3 tfet tfj hknkhuh auerentjj wes $00:,222 to $01:,222 (Rks.' I E E , Powj

t05:, Powj 5960, 5964), ùt tfj Jvjnkna Yter Nov 03. 5;;3, Iontjhporery Nov 50. 5;;3 end Geh

Nov. 0:.5;;3, iontreits sfow tfet tfjy pekd $59:.222. $5:2.222. end $5:2.222. rjspjitkvjly (Erhend

Djil., Jx. E ) ( i c . (59;.545)). tfus support]knaX e prkhe ceikj iesj o c dksirkhknetkon undjr HiDonnjll

Douales (59;. jhpf. eddjd)= 1) tfet I E E fkrjd kts ckrst `leim eajnt w k t f k n skx hontfs o c tfks lewsukt's

fevkna `jjn ckljd (59 : n. 511), end otfjr knstenijs o c I E E ' s reikst fkrkna polkiy end worm jnvkronhjnt

(j.a., noosj knikdjnt) (Rks.' IEE 05-00), irjetj en kssuj oc ceit es to wfjtfjr IEE fes e polkiy o c

jquelkty end jquel opportunkty (Lovjtt ;;-522), end erj rjljvent to IEE's irjdk`kfty wfjn kt djnkjs

i k v k l rkafts vkoletkons es to tfjsj Rlekntkccs= 6) k t ks not njijssery to sfow tfet IEE's ùsknjss rjeson,

knstruitkons croh kts prknikpel, cor djhendkna auerentjjs `jtwjjn $00:,222 end $01:,222 wes e

prjtjxt (59;) `jieusj e) IEE dkd not prjsjnt e nonprjtjxtuel ùsknjss rjeson `jieusj kt fes not

sfown tfet kt wes knstruitjd `y Turnjr Heneajhjnt to occjr e fkafjr prkij to Powj tfen k t wes occjrkna

to Jvjnkna Yter, Iontjhporery, end Geh, end `) djspktj Powj's fevkna jxprjssly to ld Rkrenken o c tfj

@RE's djskrj to prohotj Mjnny A/@rexton detjs, no onj ck-oh IEE edvksjd dkjh o c tfj rjduitkon kn

prkij (Rks.' I E E , Powj5]009)= ;) Geimson's end Devkjs' stetjhjnts tfet k t wes khportent to knvolvj

`leim prohotjrs kn tfj tour end djikdjd to rjqukrj `leim rjprjsjntetkon on tfj tour (549) erj

knedhkssk`lj fjersey (ic. 549 n. 56;)) `jieusj tfj stetjhjnts erj `jkna occjrjd cor tfj trutf oc tfj

hettjr essjrtjd ̀ jieusj tfj Iourt cknds, ]`kesjd on tfj perehjtjrs sjt `y Hs. Geimson end H r . Devkjs.

H r . L k a f t kncorhjd kntjrjstjd prohotjrs . . . tfet Genjt Geimson wes sjjmkna e auerentjj oc $922.222

pjr sfow (549-44, jhpf.)= 52) Devkjs' knstneitkon to IEE to k n c o rh tfj kntjrjstjd prohotjrs tfet

-00-



Hs. Geimson wes loomkna cor corty detjs . . . (543) ks fjersey `jieusj kt ks occjrjd not hjrjly cor tfj

ceit tfet en knstruitkon wes hedj, ùt elso cor kts trutf, k.j.. L k a f t djilerjs tfet fj k n eiiordenij w k t f

H r . Devkjs knstruitkons, kncorhjd ]PowjX o c tfj djel tjrhs tfet Hs . Geimson wes sjjmkna (543, jhpf.

eddjd)= tfet L k a f t stetjs tfet fj hemjs fks djileretkon on pjrsonel mnowljdaj dojs not trenscorh wfet

sohjonj jlsj t o l d fk h knto non-fjersey (ic. (543 n. 5;1))= sknij Lkaft's elljajd ùsknjss rjeson wes

fjersey. Rlekntkccs njjd not provkdj jvkdjnij tfet k t wes e hjrj prjtjxt (ic. (541))= 55 tfj tjrhs oc

Heakiworms' cknel iontreit wjrj dkccjrjnt ck-oh tfosj occjrjd to Powj (T97562)= 50 rjaerdkna tfj

cknenikel tjrhs rjqukrjd o c prohotjrs, tfks Iourt stetjd, K ien sjj k tfj tjrhs erj dkccjrjnt, o c ioursj

k t would `j dksirkhknetory (T07 3 5 , jhpf. eddjd)= 59 Poss tjstkckjd tfet Powj fed hedj tfj `jst

occjr w k t f e auerentjj o c $922,222 pjr sfow (Poss 032)= 54 Ierolj Mknzjl's fendwrkttjn notj wfjrjkn

sfj stetjd do not dkvulaj ]Genjt Geimson'sX auerentjj to @leim Rrohotjrs (Jx. 5: = 5: I E E su`hkts

no iontreits cor @ekljy (Ferry Ionnkim, Gr., Ytyx, Tfrjj Doa Nkaft, Mjnny A) or cor Qesfknaton

(Yentene) (5:1) end tfus, tfks jvkdjnij ks not iohpjtjnt `jieusj kt ks not tfj `jst jvkdjnij oc wfet

oiiurrjd end dojs not sfow wfjtfjr tfjsj iontreits wjrj skanjd e durkna tfj pjrkod et kssuj, end `

`y tfj `leim prohotjrs or wfjtfjr tfj ̀ leim prohotjrs, e ll two o c tfjh, wjrj hjrjly io-prohotjrs= 53

jvjn wjrj IEE's jvkdjnij on tfks kssuj iohpjtjnt, tfet tfj `jst IE E ien do ks iohj up w k t f two

`leim prohotjrs wfo fevj prohotjd skx wfktj ertksts ( k c onj kniludjs Yentene), out oc tfj tfousends

o c detjs cor wfktj ertksts cor wfkif IE E wes rjsponsk`lj sknij 5;;:, provjs tfet tfj only wey IE E

wes aokna to occjr wfktj ertksts to `leim prohotjrs wes k tfjy sujd kt (5:3)= 51 hjho croh Mknzjl

to Poss jxpleknkna fow Heak iworms fed iost Genjt Geimson $310,:22 to $ 5.91 h k l l ko n or horj (Rks.'

I E E , Powj, Jx. 45), e ceit wfkif wes njvjr to ld to Genjt Geimson ( L k af t 3:9) ( i c . l : 6 ) ) = 56

]pXrovkdkna edvenij notkij to ell ]5222X prohotjrs oc ionijrts would `j njktfjr corhkde`lj nor

iostly ̀ y hjens o c tfj kntjrnjt wfjrj hkllkons ien `j j-hekljd w k t f tfj touif o c e ̀ utton (ic. ( k d . ) ) = 5;

IEE's akvkna edvenij notkij to only sohj wfktj prohotjrs end no `leim prohotjrs ionstktutjs

dksirkhknetkon. Arent. 39: C.0d et 5251= 02 wkdjsprjed notkij hey or hey not irjetj e fjevy ùrdjn

-09-



on ertksts' heneajhjnt `jieusj tfj vest hegorkty oc detjs hey `j so iostly tfet tfj vest hegorkty oc

prohotjrs would not ` k d 7 gx kry kssuj (ic. (5:;))= 05 mjjn iohpjtktkon ehona prohotjrs would jnurj

to tfj `jnjckt o c tfj ertkst to wfoh IEE owjs kts ckrst duty (Feyhon 41:), not tfj ertkst's heneajhjnt

(ic.(5:;).)

Pjnekssenij7 5 Drjeh wes e support eit kn 0225 (k.j., wfjn kt wes YCV/Feyhon) (Feyhon 565 -;0,

039)= 0 no ̀ leim prohotjr, kniludkna Feyhon, jvjr prohotjd eny wfktj ertkst Pjnekssenij rjprjsjntjd

or fes jvjr `jjn solkiktjd `y Pjnekssenij eltfouaf kt fes routknjly soZiktjd wfk tj prohotjrs (Rks. '

Pjn., Iohp. Jx. 53, Powj ^55,00, Feyhon 954-0:), tfjrj`y jste`fsfkna e prohotkon fkstory o c

systjhki dksirkhknetkon (533)= 9 on e suhhery gudahjnt hotkon. Pjnekssenij fed tfj ùrdjn to

produij kts iontreits o c `leim prohotjrs cor wfktj eits end kts `kds ckroh prohotjrs to wfoh kt sold

detjs, ùt k t fes not produijd (ic. 531)= 4 gust `jieusj Pjnekssenij dkd not n o t k c y eZ wfktj

prohotjrs oc kts wfk tj ertksts' upiohkna detjs (533) dojs not hjen tfet kts rjcusel to n o t k c y hky `leim

prohotjr oc tfosj detjs ks not dksirkhknetory= : Pjnekssenij dkd not jste`lksf tfet reij wes not e

ceitor kn Wjdjim's djikskon to n o t k c y O N L [ Q F K T J prohotjrs= 3 fowjvjr Wjdjim cound tfj wfktj

prohotjrs fj soFiktjd, fj dkd not su`hkt eny jvkdjnij sfowkna tfet fj jvjr solkiktjd eny `leim

prohotjr (kniludkna Gonjs (Rks' Pjn., Gonjs 5|9)) jvjn tfouaf fj edhkttjdly mnjw tfet Gonjs wes e

prohotjr oc ionijrts es o c Dji. 5;;6, `jieusj Gonjs prohotjd Pjnekssenij (hknor `leim) ertkst Iox

k n Dji, 5;;6 (Wjdjim K 54 n. 5), end Gonjs fed jxprjssjd to fk h en kntjrjst kn N' Yyni (Rks.' Pjn.,

J x 96)= 1 Wjdjim's jxplenetkon tfet tfj c k k ni t k on o c fks cexjs on `jfelc o c wfktj ertksts to only wfktj

prohotjrs es en ettjhpt to kntjrjst prohotjrs kn fks ertksts (536-3;), dojs not rjùt Rlekntkccs' elljaetkon

tfet tfks wes dksirkhknetory end tfus Rlekntkccs dkd not fevj to sfow tfet kt wes e prjtjxt (k.j., wfy not

ettjhpt to kntjrjst `leim prohotjrs kn Tfj @eimstrjjt @oys k reij wes not en kssuj?)= 6 eltfouaf tfj

netkonel tour earjjhjnts ]cor Ypjers, N'Yyni end Tfj @eimstrjjt @oysX elrjedy wjrj kn pleij

(Wjdjim 5 ^5:(i)), tfks would not fevj prjvjntjd Wjdjim croh trykna to ajt tfj Rlekntkccs detjs es loiel

prohotjrs es ks iohhonly donj kn tfj kndustry (Arosslkaft ordjrjd Feyhon to usj @jevjr es e

-04-



prohotjr cor Qfktnjy Fouston (Feyhon 906)= ; eltfouaf tfj Iourt cknds (53:) tfet tfj Rlekntkccs

hedj no occjrs to Pjnekssenij djspktj e tfjkr jxprjssjd occjrs oc kntjrjst (kd)end ` tfks Iourt's

posktkon tfet ]`Xkds don't hjen enytfkna (T97:;), hemkna suif occjrs wes unnjijssery cor wfktj

prohotjrs wfoh Pjnekssenij solkiktjd cor `kds (Rks.' Pjn., Iohp. Jx. 53)= 52 tfet e nuh`jr oc

prohotjrs usjd `y Pjnekssenij erj not ehona Rlekntkccs' elljajd dohknent prohotjrs (536) ks

hjenknaljss to tfj dksirkhknetkon ilekhs= wfet ks rjljvent ks tfet tfjy erj E L L Q F K T J 55 tfet

Rlekntkccs dkd not ` k d cor tfj iontreits wfjrj wfktj prohotjrs aot 52% or no djposkts dojs not hktkaetj

tfj dksirkhknetkon `jieusj Pjnekssenij fes cekljd to provj on suhhery gudahjnt tfet kt fes jvjr

earjjd to suif djposkt ehounts cor eny `leim prohotjr or tfet fed e `leim prohotjr `kd cor tfjsj detjs,

tfjy would fevj rjijkvjd tfjsj horj cevore`lj tjrhs= 50 tfet ]tgfjsj horj cevore`lj tjrhs would

khpeit iohpjtkna wfktj prohotjrs es huif es eny ̀ leim prohotjr'' (512-15) ks krrjljvent `jieusj tfj

tjst ks not wfjtfjr ell wfktj prohotjrs ajt cevore`lj tjrhs ùt wfjtfjr ell `leim prohotjrs do not= 59

tfj Iourt njvjr ionskdjrjd wfjtfjr reij wes onj oc tfj rjesons wfy wfktj prohotjrs rjijkvjd `jttjr

tjrhs or elljajdly fed e `jttjr èraeknkna pos ktkon (515) (tfjrj erj `leim prohotjrs wfo fevj

rjioankzjd cknenikel strjnatf (kd .) (j.a., Feyhon, Qesfknaton))= 54 Wjdjim's stetjhjnt tfet

heneajrs eiijptjd `jttjr tjrhs èsjd on heny yjers oc rjletkonsfkp w k t f tfj prohotjr, or tfj

prohotjr's fkstory, rjputetkon or epperjnt cknenikel wfjrjwktfel ( kd . ) ks su`hkttjd cor kts trutf end tfus

ks knedhkssk`lj fjersey= end 5: Wjdjim sjnt @osjhen fks rostjr (539) wfjn fj wes w k t f Jvolutkon

(Wjdjim K Jx. @), wfkif ks not e Djcjndent kn tfks iesj. (530 n. 051.)

Horjovjr, tfj Iourt dkd not eddrjss 5 wfjtfjr reij ks e ceitor e kn fow prohotkon

rjletkonsfkps erj djvjlopjd (52,50)= ` kn fow prohotjrs erj sjljitjd (56, 64)= i es to wfy Rlekntkccs

spjikefzj kn P & @ end urèn huski, not pop or roim (59, 46)= d) wfjn c eh k l k e r k t y w k t f e spjikcki

ajnrj oc huski ks khportent kn sjljitkna e ionijrt prohotjr (5;) (ic. Ljwks ellowjd Djlsjnjr to

prohotj @edu (T97 32)= j) wfjn ]eX prohotjr's cknenikel iepe`klkrkjs erj . . . iruikel (5;)= c kn tfj

cknenikel suiijss oc Powj, @osjhen end M k n a (:2,:9,::) (sjj Ironkn v. Ejtne L k c j Kns. Io.. 43 C.9d

-0:-



5;3, 029 (0d Ikr. 5;;:) (plekntkccs njjd not sfow tfet proccjrjd rjesons erj celsj, ùt only tfet tfjy

wjrj not tfj only rjesons end tfet dksirkhknetkon wes E T L J E Y T O N J o c tfj hotkvetkna ceitors))=

0) es to tfks irktkiel irktjrkon, Djcjndents' jxpjrt Herko Aonzeljz QEY NOT E Y M J D T O O R J S J

END QEY K N Y T P Z I T J D @ [ T F J D J C J N D E N T Y NOT T O E N Y Q J P EN[ U Z J Y T K O N Y

R J P T E K N K N A T F J P J T O (31-36,65,60=T47 9;-42)= 9) not el l oc tfj iontreits w k t f dkccjrjnt tjrhs

`jtwjjn `leim end wfkt j prohotjrs ien `j jxpleknjd on tfj èsks o c njaotketkon powjr (Feyhon)= 4)

Powj's elljajd leim oc iepktel or rjiord oc suiijsscul ionijrt prohotkon (39)7 sjj Powj's occjr oc

$922,222 cor (0;) Genjt Geimson detjs end IEE's teikt edhksskon tfet Powj ien do tfj go ̀`jieusj

tfjy'vj now occjrjd fkh Alorke Jstjcen, jti. (5:3)= :) tfj Cknenikel Iepe`klkt kjs oc Crjd Gonjs7 fks

aross kniohj kn 5;;1, 5;;6, 5;;; wes $;22.222. $322-122.222. $:66.222. rjspjitkvjly, end kn 5;;;

fj wes wortf horj tfen $0.4 h k l l k o n (Gonjs 3;3-;6)= 3) Aonzeljz tjstkckjd tfet e) tfjrj erj

prjdohknent prohotjrs (Aonzeljz 549,541), `) sohjtkhjs tfj eajnt iells tfj prohotjr eòut e detj

kd - 094), i) tfjrj erj tkhjs en eajnt dojs not put up e sfow cor hultkplj ̀ kds (kd. 099), end d) kn tfj

0: yjers fj fes `jjn kn tfj huski kndustky, tfj only hegorkty-ownjd `leim prohotjr wfo fes prohotjd

e wfktj eit ks Feyhon, end tfj only rjeson fj mnows tfet ks tfrouaf Feyhon's tjstkhony g d . 555 -59,

51:-11)= 1) w k t f tfj jxijptkon oc onj suhhjr 5;;9 Ytjjly Den detj, Feyhon (es opposjd to

Feyhony'YCV) fes prohotjd no wfktj ertksts durkna tfj rjljvent tkhj pjrkod (Feyhon :3-30)= 6) tfjrj

ks no jvkdjnij tfet eny @ . E . Djcjndent fes jvjr ielljd e `leim prohotjr to n o t k c y fkh tfet e wfktj eit

ks aokna on tour= ;) @ k l l Ios`y tjstkckjd tfet Q H E sjljitjd ;2% oc fks prohotjrs (Ios`y :9) (Jx.

53)= 52) tfet tfj eajniy sjljits tfj prohotjr dojsn't hemj e fkll oc `jens dkccjrjnij kn tfj

dksirkhknetkon . . . . (T97 54-5:, 53, 91, 9;) (i c 64,50;, 590)= 55) Mepp wes ionvkitjd oc creud end

ionvjrskon ectjr hemkna celsj rjprjsjntetkons rjaerdkna fks prohot kon o c e 5;11 ionijrt (Rks.' Q H E ,

Jx. 5:9) (ic.(:2-:5))= 50) wfktj prohotjr Pkiferd Mlotzhen wes ionvkitjd oc creud, wkrj creud,

ionvjrskon, end kniohj tex jveskon rjletjd to e non-jxkstjnt Rrknij ionijrt, cor wfkif fj wes

-03-



sjntjnijd to c kvj yjers kn prkson kn 5;61 end kn 5;1; wes ionvkitjd oc kniohj tex jveskon (sjrvjd cour

hontfs end cknjd $ 52,222) ( k d . , Jx. 542 (ic. (:2-:5))= 59) Q H E s Ljwks iontknujd to do ùsknjss w k t f

Mlotzhen djspktj fks irkhknel rjiord end poor pjrcorhenij es e prohotjr ( k d . , Jx. ;9)= 54) Iooljy

ckljd ènmruptiy kn tfj hkd 5;12's end fed e dksputj w k t f tfj KPY (Iooljy 62,502-0:(ic. (:2))= 5:) tfks

Iourt stetjd, ]`Xkds don't hjen enytfkna (T97 :;) (ic. (pesskh))= 53) tfet jvjn tfouaf elljajdly

e prohotjr w k t f c eh k l k e r k t y kn e spjikcki ajoarepfki erje or vjnuj ks prjcjrrjd (5;), @jevjr wes

`rouaft kn to Hjhpfks, e hermjt @jevjr fed steyjd out o c ( L j c c ljttjr), to prohotj Gehjs Teylor, e detj

tfet Gonjs would fevj prohotjd ùt cor tfj kntjrcjrjnij o c @jevjr end tfj top teljnt eajnikjs ( k d . ) =

51) tfj rjeson Powj stoppjd peyhjnt on tfj Geimsons' ifjim wes `jieusj tfj Geimsons owjd Powj

honjy `jieusj o c tfjkr ienijlletkons (Powj 903)= 56) Herlon Geimson ettjstjd to fks jxpjrkjnij w k t f

Powj es en jxijlljnt ionijrt prohotjr (Rks.' Q H E , Jx. 522, 1 ) = 5;) eltfouaf tfj Iourt cound tfet

Gonjs fes njvjr su`hkttjd e ̀ kd to prohotj e wfktj ertkst (:3), fj stood rjedy to prohotj Gehjs Teylor

kn 5;;6, ùt QH E rjcusjd to ellow Teylor to pley Hu d Kslend end aevj tfj ionijrt to @jevjr et

enotfjr vjnuj. No njjd to hemj en occjr wfjn to do so would `j ctktklj. ( K n t l @fd oc Tjehstjrs.

Dotferd) (ic. :3)= 02) kt wes Powj's suaajstkon tfet Feyhon usj @rexton es tfj opjnkna eit cor

Crenmkj @jvjrky kn 5;;: (Rks.' I EE, Powjc054 (ic. 19)= 05) Q H E eajnt Gjcc Cresio tjstkckjd tfet

Powj wes e quelkckjd prohotjr (Cresio 34)= 00) Gonjs ks ]oXnj o c tfj `jst prohotjrs out tfjrj todey

(Yperms 0;)= 09) Powj wes ehona tfj hegor `leim prohotjrs k n ijrtekn tjrrktorkjs (Mepp 14)= 04) @ k l l

Qesfknaton irkjd et fks djposktkon wfjn fj tjstkc kjd tfet `leim prohotjrs erj not akvjn tfj sehj

opportunktkjs tfet tfj wfktj prohotjrs erj akvjn (49-44) end elso stetjd, 'Yvj èskielly fevj not donj

eny wfktj eits . . . . (Qesfknaton 5:0, jhpf. eddjd)= 0:) Fjrjnton kssujd e prjss rjljesj stetkna,

Crjd Gonjs ks e iohpjtjnt end wjll-rjspjitjd prohotjr (Rks. ' @jevjr, Jx. 5J)= 03) Mepp fes edhkttjd

tfet e) l̀eim prohotjrs do not fevj tfj sehj opportunkty to prohotj wfktj ertksts es do `leim

prohotjrs, `) tfjrj's e prjveklkna prjgudkij fjld `y ertksts, heneajrs, prohotjrs end eajnts eaeknst

-01-



`leim prohotjrs w k t f rjspjit to tfjkr prohotkna wfktj ertksts, i) tfks reikel prjgudkij fes fkndjrjd tfj

jccort oc ̀ leim prohotjrs to `j suiijsscul kn tfj kndustry end, d) fj dojs not sjj e lot, k eny, `leim

prohotjrs prohotkna wfktj teljnt (Mepp 0:9-32)= 01) gust `jieusj I E E su`hkttjd iontreits sfowkna

tfet sohj wfktj prohotjrs earjjd to pey e :2% djposkt (64 n. 500) (ic. Njdjrlendjr pekd e ;2/52 ertkst

spFt (6: n. 559)), dojs not hjen tfet `leims erj not dksirkhknetjd eaeknst wfjn tfjy hust elweys pey

:2%= 06) onj o c tfj Rlekntkccs' jssjntkel iohpleknts ks tfet tfjy erj ellowjd only to io-prohotj end do

not skan tfj iontreits w k t f tfj ertkst, end, tfjrjcorj, rjep tfj hegorkty o c tfj `jnjckts oc jeif detj.

Tfjy, kn jssjnij, fevj to sjttlj cor sireps. K c tfj Djcjndents e llowjd `leim prohotjrs, not

Feyhon/YCV, to skan iontreits prohotkna, not io-prohotkna, wfktj end hegor `leim ertksts, gust es tfj

wfktj prohotjrs do, kt would fevj `jjn jesy jnouaf cor tfjh to provj. Yknij tfj Rlekntkccs ien't provj

e njaetkvj, tfj ùrdjn to produij tfjsj iontreits, wfkif tfj Rlekntkccs rjqujstjd, wes on tfj

Djcjndents= 0;) tfet Feyhon's iohpeny wes YCV kn 0222 (YCV ownjd 62%) (Feyhon 09) ks

unrjùttjd, end wfjdkjr kt wes YCV kn 5;;; (YCV ownjd :2%) kd . ) wes e g u r y qujstkon. Tfet ectjr

tfj purifesjs `y YCV, ]FeyhonX ren tfj ùsknjss kn tfj sehj wey (kd.) ks krrjljvent to wfjtfjr tfj

ownjrsfkp kntjrjst wes wfktj or `leim, end tfet ks tfj kssuj= 92) @ k l l y Yperms tjstkckjd tfet reikskh

pjrvedjs ]tXfj wfolj systjh wfkif kniludjs IEE (Yperms 00)= 95) no eajniy kn tfj lest tjn yjers

fes jvjr notkckjd Yperms eòut e ionijrt oc e wfktj ertkst (kd.04-01)= 90) wfy, kc tfjrj ks no reikel

dksirkhknetkon kn tfj ionijrt prohotkon kndustry, Feyhon, e prohotjr wfo undksputjdly hjjts

l oc tfj Djcjndents' irktjrke, skanjd on to suj IEE end Q H E , end `jlkjvjs tfet tfjy fevj

dksirkhknetjd eaeknst fkh (Feyhon 9;3-;;,429,424,453-02,499,494, 44;,46;-;5) ( kt's polko or

ienijr, wfkif onj ks worsj (kd- 9;1))= end 99) tfks Iourt wjkafcjdX ell tfj jvkdjnij kn tfks iesj

(519)(pesskh) wfkif kt ks not pjrhkttjd to do on e hotkon cor suhhery gudahjnt.

Eltfouaf tfks Iourt fes djtjrhknjd tfet fkndskaft now provjs tfet Rlekntkccs' elljaetkons wjrj

not succkikjnt to survkvj suhhery gudahjnt, es djhonstretjd eòvj tfjy wjrj not so `kzerrj es to `j

-06-



crkvolous. Yjj Tenirjdk v. Hjcropolkten L k c j Kns. Io.. 916 C. 9d 002,00; { 0 d Icr. 0224)= Yullkven v.

Yifool @oerd o c Rknjlles Iounty. 119 C. 0d 5560, 5564, 55;3 (55tf Icr. 5;6:) (unljss iourt cound ell

o c p l e k n t k c c s tjstkhony to `j e`solutjly knirjdk`lj end purj ce`rkietkon, kts c u k d k n a o c crkvolkty iennot

`j susteknjd ). Horjovjr , wfjn strkppjd oc kts fypjrò lj, tfj Djcjndents' erauhjnt ks only tfet

R le kn t k c c s ettornjys c e k l j d to propjrly t o knvjstkaetj p l e k n t k c c s ilekhs `jcorj cklkna tfj eitkon, end tfet

tfjy iontknujd to prosjiutj tfosj ilekhs wktfout succkikjnt jvkdjnt kery support. Clowjvjr, tfjrj jxksts

no 'iljer jvkdjnij' tfet p l e k n t k c c s ilekhs wjrj so prjpostjrous es to werrent tfj ioniluskon tfet

R l e k n t k c c s Iokhsjl jnaeajd kn dkleto ry end eùskvj teitkis or purposjcully pro lonajd ftkaet kon oc

hjrkdjss ilekhs . Ykhhs v . @kondo. 5:6 C.P.D. 041 ( @ . D . N . [ . 5;;4)= @rownkna v . Mrehjr. ; 9 5 C.0d

942,94: (:tf I k r . 5;;5) (jvjn wfjn ettornjy iontknujd to pursuj ilekhs ectjr ilosj o c dksiovjry wfjn

fj sfould fevj mnown tfjrj wes no jvkdjnij to support ilekhs, § 5 ; 0 1 senitkons erj not rjqukrjd

`jieusj sohjtfkna horj tfen e leim o c hjrkt ks rjqukrjd cor § 5;01 senitkons). ^ Kn eddktkon, tfet tfj

Iourt cound tfet sohj o c tfj R l e k n t k c c s stetjhjnts wjrj untruj dojs not hjen tfet tfjy l k j d or wjrj

a u k l t y oc ̀ ed c e k t f . Es tfks Iourt k t s j l c fes stetjd (T073, jhpf. eddjd)7

. . . Kt's l k m j pjoplj se ykn a.. . sohjonj l k j d , w j l l , `jieusj wfet tfjy sekd wes not eiiuretj. Tfet

ks not njijsserkly truj, `jieusj tfjy hey not fevj rjeZzjd kt wesn't eiiuretj. Kt dojsn't

ionstktutj e fj k n hy hknd Rjoplj sey kt el l tfj tkhj. K jvjn ajt k t c roh lewyjrs.''

Tfj R l e kn t k c c s ettornjys' vkaorous pursukt oc tfj R l e k n t k c c s ilekhs sfowjd tfjkr aood c e k t f

` j l k j c tfj ilekhs wjrj v e l k d , e ` j l k j c tfet wes rjpjetjdly ionck rhjd jeif tkhj e Djcjndent sjttljd w k t f

tfj R le kn t k c c s , `y tfj Iourt's own stetjhjnts, end `y tfj nuhjrous ceits cound kn tfj rjiord. Akvjn

tfjsj èsjs cor tfj ] R l e k n t k c c s end tfj Aery Ckrh'sX su`gjitkvj aood c e k tf kn ] R l e k n t k c c s X eitkon, end

k n tfj e`sjnij o c eny otfjr jvkdjnij kndkietkna en e`sjnij o c e ajnuknj ` j l k j c kn tfj v e l k d k t y o c tfj

eitkon,... tfj rjiord iennot support en kncjrjnij o c èd c e k tf ]on tfjkr pertX. Yiflekcjr Nenij & Io..

Kni . . S Qerfol. 5;4 C.9d 909, 945 (0d Ikr . 5;;;). To tfj iontrery, e rjesone`lj ettornjy iould fevj

*Yjj Ypjrendo E c c . ^5]4-1,55-51,56= Q k l lk e h Iehp`jll E c c . 155:-; (Jx. 51 Powj E c c . c l l W - W l .

''Rlekntkccs edhkttjd tfet tfj ilekh kn tfj Ehjndjd Iohpleknt tfet tfjy rjprjsjnt tfj hegorkty oc

ùsknjss donj `y `leim ionijrt prohotjrs ks celsj. (:1 n. ;5.)

- 0 ; -



ioniludjd tfet tfj Djcjndents fed dksirkhknetjd eaeknst tfj Rlekntkccs, wfosj ilekhs wjrj hedj not

co r eny khpropjr purposj ùt es e hjens oc lest rjsort to corij tfj Djcjndents to iohply w k t f tfks

iountry's i k v k l rkafts lews end to ellow tfj Rlekntkccs tfj sehj opportunkty to prohotj wfkt j ertksts tfet

wfktj prohotjrs fevj lona jngoyjd.'^ Tfj aoel oc soikel jquelkty, wfkif ks tfj o`gjitkvj o c i k v k l rkafts

ljaksletkon, iounsjls tfet wfjrj e djcjndent prjvekls, end tfj `roedjr soikel polkiy fes not `jjn

vkndkietjd, e fkaf èrrkjr to cjj sfkctkna hust `j jrjitjd. Cereik v. Fkimjy-Crjjhen Io.. Kni.. 321 C.

0 d 520:, 5206 (0d Ikr. 5;1;) (jhpf. eddjd).

E n y ewerd o c cjjs end iosts kn tfks iesj, huif ljss kn tfj knordknetj ehounts tfj Djcjndents

rjqujst, w k l l sjt e denajrous prjijdjnt end w k l l `j trenscorhjd knto e sword wfkif potjntkel djcjndents

w k l l w k j l d to kntkhkdetj potjntkel plekntkccs knto not c k l k n a e possk`ly hjrktorkous sukt cor cjer o c fevkna

to pey fundrjds oc tfousends end possk`ly hkllkons oc dollers kn ettornjys' cjjs end iosts. Not only

w k l l kndkvkduel plekntkccs losj, ùt so too w k l l tfj heny horj wfo `jnjckt `y tfj `rknakna o c i k v k l rkafts

eitkons suif es tfks. Fed tfj Rlekntkccs prjvekljd, tfj wkkhjrs would fevj ̀ jjn not hjrjly tfj cour

Rlekntkccs, ùt H l oc tfj `leim prohotjrs kn tfks iountry. Kndjjd, tfj jccjits oc suif e vjrdkit would

fevj `jjn cjf not only `y `leim prohotjrs ùt `y tfj jntkrj huski kndustry, cor tfosj kn posktkons oc

powjr kn otfjr sjahjnts oc tfj kndustry would fevj `jiohj horj fjsktent to dksirkhknetj eaeknst

`leims cor cjer tfet tfjy, too, would `j sujd end corijd to hemj ehjnds. Tfus, tfks Iourt sfould djny

tfj Djcjndents' Hotkons cor Ettornjys' Cjjs end Iosts `jieusj oc dkj njijsserkly i f k l l k n a jccjit tfj

khposktkon oc suif senitkons on tfj Rlekntkccs end tfjkr ettornjys w k l l fevj on potjntkel plekntkccs w k t f

hjrktorkous i k v k l rkafts ilekhs end on ettornjys wfo would otfjrwksj `j w k l l k n a to rjprjsjnt tfjh.

Yuif e r u l k n a jspjikelly kn e iesj o c tfks notorkjty, w k l l ferh tfj curtfjrenij o c i k v k l rkafts kn Ehjrkie.

'*Yjj Powj E c c ^1 = @osjhen E c c . M k n a E c c . 9= Gonjs Ec c 554.

9



Pjspjitcully su`hkttjd,

Detjd7 Ytuert, Clorkde

Hey 022:

Herke R. Ypjrendo (H^Y630:)

Q k l l k e h I. Iehp`jll (\SII249:)

A E P[ Q K L L K E H Y REPJNTK, C K N N J [

LJQKY, H i H E N ZY QETYON YRJPENDO,R.L.


Ytuert, CL 94;;4

Ettornjys cor tfj Rlekntkccs

To ell iounsjl oc rjiord

9



jrtkckietj oc Yjrvkij

022:, to7

fjrj`y ijrtkcy tfet e truj end iorrjit iopy oc tfj corjaokna wes hekljd t f k s ^ H . dey oc Hey,

Fjljn Aeverks, Jsq.

Hkifejl R. Wwjka, Jsq.

Iferljs H . H k l l j r Jsq.

Loj` & Loj`, LLR

94: Rerm Evjnuj

Njw [ o r m N [ 525:4

Ettornjys cor Djcjndent Tfj Qkllkeh

orr s Eajniy Kni.

Ytjvj H . Feyjs, Jsq.

Arja Ilerkim, Jsq.

O r k n Ynydjr, Jsq.

Rerifjr, Feyjs & Ynydjr, R.I.:22 C k c t f Evjnuj, YY Cloor

Njw [ o r m N [ 52552

Ettornjys cor Djcjndent Pjnekssenij

Jntjrteknhjnt Kni.

Gehjs D. Po`jrts, Jsq.

Rjtjr H . JZks, Jsq.

Ajoraj L. Iruhljy, Jsq.

Rkpjr Pudnkim

029 Nortf LeYellj Ytrjjt, Yuktj 5622

Ifkieao, K L 32325Ettornjys cor Djcjndents Geh Rroduitkons

Gehjs E. Io``, Gr., Jsq.

Jnunjtt, Io``, Qekts & Mjssjnkif

:5: Roydres Ytrjjt, Ytj. 5;:2

Njw Orljens, L E 12550

Ettornjys cor Djcjndent @jevjr

Rroduitkons

@ y 7

Gjccrjy Y. M l j k n Jsq.

Gjccrjy L . Mjssljr, Jsq. Rkjrrj A. Erhend, Jsq.

Q j k l Aotsifel & Henajs, LLR

131 C k c tf Evjnuj

Njw [ o r m N[ 525:9

Ettornjys cor Djcjndent Irjetkvj Ertksts

Eajniy Kni.

Po`jrt J. Donnjlly, Jsq.

599 Qjst 0:* Yfjjt

Njw [ o r m N[ 52225


E r h Herk j Jstjvjz, Jsq.

Horaen, Ljwks, @oimkus

022 Y @ksieynj @ l v d .

H k e h k CL 99595

Ettornjys cor YCV

Pkimjy K v k j Jsq.

Mjndell J. Gehjs, Jsq.

K v k j H i N j k l l & Qyett

025 Nortf Ckaujroe Ytrjjt, Yuktj 55:2Los Enajljs, IE ;2250-0342


H e r t k n Aold, Jsqukrj

Yonnjnsifjkn Netf & Posjntfel

5005 Evjnuj oc tfj Ehjrkies

Njw [ o r m N[ 52202

Ettornjy cor Rlekntkccs

Herke R. Ypjrend((g|HRY630:)A E P [ Q K L L K E H Y REPJNTK, C K N N J [

LJQKY, H i H E N Z Y QETYON & YRJPENDO

005 J. Osijole Ycrjjt

Ytuert, CL 94;;4

Ettornjys cor tfj Rlekntkccs

-90-



Herke Ypjrendo, Jsq.

Qkllkeh I. Iehp`jll, Jsq.

A E P [ , Q K L L K E H Y , R E P J N T K , C K N N J [ ,

L J Q K Y , HiHENZY, Q E T Y O N Y R J P E N D O , R . L .


Ytuert, C L 94;;4

T j l 7 (110)069-6032Ce x 7 (110)069-4;;3

Ettornjys cor Rlekntkccs Powj Jntjrteukhjnt, Kni ., jt el.


Y O Z T F J P N D K Y T P K I T OC NJ Q [ O P M

P O Q J J N T J P T E K N H J N T , K N I . , jt el., N O . ;6-IS-6010 (PRR)

Rlekntkccs,

vs.

T F J Q K L L L \ H O P P K Y E A J N I [ , K N I .

jt el..

Djcjndents

P J Y R O N Y J K N O R R O Y K T K O N O C T F J R L E J N T K C C Y END T F J A E P [ C K P H TO TFJ


J V F K @ K T Y

S O L K

A E P [ , Q K L L K E H Y , R E P J N T K , C K N N J [ , L J Q K Y , H I H E N Z Y ,

Q E T Y O N Y R J P E N D O , R . L .

Q E T J P Y K D J R P O C J Y Y K O N E L @ Z K L D K N A

005 J e s t Osijole Ytrjjt

Ytuert, Clorkde 94;;4

(110) 069-6032




9:36POQE

5 Z N K T J D YTETJY D K Y T P K I T IOZPT

5 Y O Z T F J P N D K Y T P K I T O C N J Q [ O P M

0 V

0

9 POQJ J N T J P T E K N H J N T , KN I . ,

9 jtel.

• Rleknt k ccs ,

:

: S ;6 Iv. 6010 (PRR)

3

3 T F J Q K L L K E H H O P P K Y E A J N I [ , K N I . ,

1 jtel.

1

6 Djcjndents.

6

; V

;

52 H ey 3 , 0229

574: p.h.

55

55 @jcorj7

50

5 0 F O N . PO@JPT R. RETTJPYON

59

59 Dkstrkit Gudaj

54

54

5: ERRJEPENIJY

5:

5 3 A E P [ , Q K L L K E H Y , R E P J N T K , C KN N J [ , L J Q K Y , H i H E N Z Y , Q E T Y O N

53 YRJPENDO

51 Ettornjys cor Rleknt k ccs

51 @ [ 7 T P K I L \Y FOCCLJP

56 L E Z P E L . H E L L

56 @ K L L I E H R @ J L L

5;

5; @ O @ D O N N J L L [

02 Ettornjy cor Rleknt k ccs

02

0 5 L O J @ L O J @ L L R

05 Ettornjys cor Djcjndent Q k l l k e h H o r r k s Eajniy

0 0 @ [ 7 H K I F E J L R. W Q J K A

0 0 F J L J N A E S E P K Y

09

09 REPIFJP F E [ J Y Y N [ D J P , R .I .

04 Ettohjys co r Djcjndent Pjnekssenij Jntjrteknhjnt

0 4 @ [ 7 APJAOP[ E . I L E P K I M

0: ̂FHHFJVFK@ KT

K z



9:36POQE

5 kn tfjkr ehjndjd iohpleknt, toajtfjr wktf jxijrpts croh e

0 lkhktjd nuh`jr oc djposktkon crensirkpts wfkif wjrj sjljitjd `y

9 tfj plekntkccs iounsjl end wfkif fj sekd fj rjed h e

4 tfrjj-wjjm pjrkod prkor to cklkna fks rjport.

: Now, your Fonor, et tfj rkhj tfet Rrocjssor Reaen s

3 rjport wes rjndjrjd, tfjrj wjrj ovjr : djposktkons temjn kn

1 tfks iesj. Rrocjssor Reaen s ettornjy or, retfjr, tfj

6 plekntkccs ettornjy sjljitjd tfj vjry crensirkpts tfet

; Rrocjssor Ceaen wes to rjvkjw. Fj dkdn t jvjn rjvkjw ell tfj

52 trensirkpts kn tfjkr jntkrjty. Es fj tjstkckjd et fks

55 djposktkon, fj rjed only sjljitjd portkons end kn sohj

50 knstenijs es lkttlj es tjn peajs oc djposktkon trensirkpt.

59 Kn prjperkna fks rjport, fj wes not akvjn `y

54 plekntkccs ettohjys end dkd not rjvkjw tfj djposktkon

5: trensirkpts oc tfj heny suiijssckel nonperty ̀ leim ionijrt

53 prohotjrs wfo fevj tjstkckjd kn tfks iesj end wfo fed tjstkckjd

51 es oc tfj tkhj tfet fj rjndjrjd fks rjport. Tfjsj kniludj

56 kndkvkduels suif es Lerry @ekljy, Lkonjl @., Crjddkj Lustjr,

5; end Derry l @rooms. Nor wes fj akvjn -

02 T F J I O Z P T Qfy erj tfjy rjljvent? Qfy ks tfet

05 tjstkhony rjljvent? Ksn t tfj qujstkon fjrj tfj kssuj oc

00 wfjtfjr tfj plekntkccs wjrj dksirkhknetjd eaeknst?

09 HP. W Q J K A @jieusj tfjsj wjrj kndkvkduels wktf wfoh

04 tfj verkous djcjndent teljnt eajnikjs djelt, end Rrocjssor

0: Ceaen ks purportkna to akvj en opknkon es to tfj ionijrt



9:36POQE

5 dksirkhknetkon would, K su`hkt, put khdjr kndkithjnt jvjry

0 sknalj kndustry kn tfj Znktjd Ytetjs, proè`ly es wjll es tfj

9 Z.Y. Ettornjy s Occkij, `jieusj, ectjr ell, wfjrj do tfj

4 iendkdetjs oc tfet occkij iohj croh? Tfjy erj en jlktj irjw.

: Rjrfeps tfj cjdjrel gudkikery end jvjry otfjr knstktutkon kn

3 tfks iountry. End tfj pro`ljh wktf tfet ks, kt s so ajnjrel,

1 kt s so `roed es to `j iohpljtjly khfjlpckkl. @jieusj kt

6 dojsn t hjen tfet tfj djcjndents tfjhsjlvjs fevj donj enytfkna

; spjikckielly wrona or dksirkhhetory. Qfet tfj djcjndents or

52 enyonj jlsj kn tfks ùsknjss fes donj ks to nurturj

55 rjletkonsfkps, to rjspjit rjletkonsfkps. Tfj plekntkccs

0 tfjhsjlvjs fevj kndkietjd tfet rjletkonsfkps ien ̀ j khportent

59 kn tfj worm tfet s donj. Tfjrj ks notfkna wrona eòut tfj

54 jxkstjnij oc rjletkonsfkps. K don t iell kt en old òy

5: njtworm. K don t tfknm kt ks en old òy njtworm.

53 Onj oc tfj kntjrjstkna tfknas eòut tfks iesj ks tfjrj

51 erj heny ajnjretkonel dkvkdjs. Tfjrj erj ijrtekn typjs oc

56 huski tfet eppjels to hy 5;-yjer-old son end tfjrj erj ijrtekn

5; pjoplj wfo erj vjry huif knvolvjd wktf tfet typj oc huski, end

02 tfjrj ks ijrtekn huski tfet eppjels horj to hj, wfkif K would

05 djsirk`j es edult iontjhporery, gezz, end pjoplj tjnd to, kn

00 sohj sjnsj, aroup tfjhsjlvjs, octjn eiiordkna to ajnrj, horj

09 octjn eiiordkna to, ljt hj djvjlop rjletkonsfkps wktf pjoplj,

04 ljt hj spjem to pjoplj, ljt hj ao to kndustry ionvjntkons end

0: otfjr aetfjrknas wfjrj pjoplj kn tfks ùsknjss wkll `j, ljt hj



9:36POQE

5 iesj aokna to j̀ e hesskvj iesj, eltfouaf K worry tfet kt wkll

0 `j `jieusj K aot sohj tfrjj or cour `ka `oxjs fjrj yjstjrdey.

9 Dojs tfet gust hjen you auys fevjn t donj your lew worm?

4 HY. F O C C L J P 7 No, your Fonor.

: T F J I O Z P T 7 Qfy ks kt aokna to `j so `ka?

3 HY. F O C C L J P = Tfjrj wjrj ovjr 12 djposktkons temjn kn

1 tfks iesj.

6 T F J I O Z P T 7 Djcjndents erj wjll-mnown cor westkna

; jvjryonj s tkhj on djposktkons. Djcjnsj do tfet ell tfj tkhj.

52 HY. F O C C L J P 7 K earjj wktf you, your Fonor. Kn tfks

55 pertkiuler iesj, es K sekd, tfjrj wjrj ovjr 12 djposktkons,

50 wfet wj tfknm ks khportent, `jieusj e lot oc djposktkon

59 tjstkhony ks rjljvent. @ut sjiondly, `jieusj oc tfj ehount oc

54 jvkdjnij ~

5: T F J I O Z P T 7 [ou rj aokna to rjed 12 djposktkons to tfj

53 g u r y ? Tfjy wkll ao to sljjp. Qfo ks aokna to try tfks iesj?

51 HY. F O C C L J P 7 Qj don t plen on rjedkna 12 djposktkons

56 to tfj gu r y

5; Kn tjrhs oc wfo ks aokna to try tfj iesj? Qjll, croh

02 our skdj, you sjj pert oc ou r trkel tjeh fjrj.

05 T F J I O Z P T 7 E trkel ks e lot dkccjrjnt tfen prjtrkel.

00 HY. F O C C L J P 7 Qj erj not proposkna to rjed 12

09 djposktkons knto tfj rjiord.

04 T F J I O Z P T 7 [ou fevj aot to iut tfks iesj down.

0: HY. F O C C L J P 7 Qj ckkZy kntjnd on dokna tfet, `ut



9:36POQE

5 T F J I O Z P T 7 Tfj otfjr tfkna to do ks to stkpuletj.

0 [ o u gust do wfetjvjr you went.

9 HP. I E H R @ J L L 7 Kc K hkaft, wj skhply esmjd.kc wj iould

4 fevj tfj orkaknel eudkotepj so our jxpjrt ien jxehknj kt. Tfjy

: fevj rjckksjd to provkdj kt.

3 T F J I O Z P T 7 Qfjtfjr your jxpjrt fes hedj en enelysks

1 oc wfet kt fes to sfow en eltjretkon end wfjrj kt ks ks not sjt

6 cortf.

; HP. I E H R @ J L L 7 Fow would fj `j e`lj to do tfet kc fj

52 dkdn t fevj tfj orkaknel eudkotepj?

55 T F J I O Z P T 7 [ou ien tjll. Fj ien tjll. Fj ks en

50 jxpjrt. Fj iould tjll, Tfjy ien tjll rkaft ewey.

59 HP. I E H R @ J L L 7 Kc tfjy fevj tfj orkaknel eudkotepj.

54 T F J I O Z P T 7 Jvjn kc tfjy fevj e iopy.

5: HP. I E H R @ J L L 7 Qj wkll esm our jxpjrt to do tfet, your

53 Fonor.

51 T F J I O Z P T 7 Qfet ks tfj `esks cor fks ioniluskon,

56 tfet s kt.

5; HP. I E H R @ J L L 7 Qj wkll su`hkt tfet, your Fonor.

02 T F J I O Z P T 7 Or ks kt gust `jieusj H r Powj dkdn t fjer

05 tfosj words wfjn fj lkstjnjd, kn wfkif iesj - loom, ljt s ajt

00 rkd oc tfj kssuj.

09 HP. I E H R @ J L L 7 K earjj wktf you.

04 T F J I O Z P T 7 Qj fevj aot to ajt tfks iesj to crkel

rowe entertainment, inc. et al. v. william morris agency, et al. (98-8272) -- plaintiffs' opp....

Documents