ron shandler the babs project 3 … · the babs project introduction my conversation with you me:...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
RONSHANDLER
TheBABSPROJECT3.0
BOOK1
WhyWeNeedaNewSystem
![Page 2: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
1
LastUpdate:January1,2020Copyright2020,TheShandlerCompany,LLCAll rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, resold, distributed, transmitted or displayed for any commercial purpose, including incorporating into a website without the prior permission of the publisher, except for brief excerpts used in reviews. You may not create derivative works based upon the product. This product is intended for entertainment purposes only. Neither the author nor publisher assume any liability beyond the purchase price for any reason. The Shandler Company, LLC Port St. Lucie, FL [email protected]
![Page 3: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
2
BOOK1-CONTENTSIntroduction MyConversationwithYou 4
Chapter1 HowtheStatsareOuttoGetYou 7
Chapter2 HowtheMarketplaceisOuttoGetYou 17
Chapter3 HowYourBrainisOuttoGetYou 24
BOOK2 TheBroadAssessmentBalanceSheet
BOOK3 BABSinPractice
![Page 4: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
3
WhyFantasyBaseballWinnersLoveBABS
"Fantastic,thoughtprovokingstuff,evenforagrizzledveteranof31consecutiveRotoseasons.Isuspectaquarterofacenturyfromnowitisthisstuffthatyouwillberememberedandreveredfor.WhatdidEarlWeaverliketosay?It'swhatyoulearnafteryouknowitallthatisimportant.Thatcouldbeyouraptsubtitle."–J.Morgan"Ijustwanttomakeastatementhereofsimplegratitude:yourthoughtsandsystems—theForecaster,andnowBABS—havegivenmeeffective,analyticaltoolsIcanuseinconstructingmyfantasyteams,whichisaformofintellectualplaythatIfindimmenselyfun.Hugelyfun.So,aresoundingthankyou."–B.Crenshaw"Ithadneverinalltheseseasonsoccurredtometoseethepatternsasthewayplayersaremostlyallalike.Ihadalwayslookedfordifferences.Revolutionarythinking."–D.Emerson"IwanttothankyouandBABSforescortingmetoachampionshipthisyear.Thiswasthe27thyearofourverycompetitiveleague.Ihadfinishedtiedforfirsttwiceovertheyearsbuthadneverwontheleagueoutright.I’manumbersguy,whichiswhyIwasturnedontoyouatHQ,butthatmadeithardtogetcomfortablewithBABS.ButthesystemdefinitelyhelpedandIlookforwardtoitscontinueddevelopment."–B.Wentz"Wow.That.Was.Awesome.I'mcompletelysoldonthesystem,therankingprocessandthespreadsheetthathelpsputitalltogether."–D.Morris
![Page 5: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
4
TheBABSProjectIntroduction
MyConversationwithYouME:Hey,welcome.
YOU:HiRon.Iseeyou'reback.What'sup?AneweditionofTheBABSProject.ThepreviousbookseemedalittledauntingtosomereaderssoI'vedivideditupintothreemini-booksandtriedtostreamlinetheBroadAssessmentBalanceSheet(BABS)programabit.
Istherealotdifferentfromtheoriginalbook?It'ssomewhatthesame,Ithink.I'vesplittheoriginalincarnationintomoreeasilydigestiblesections.ThenIaddedabunchofnewstuff,updatedsomeotherstuffandclarifiedstuffthatwasconfusing.Theclarificationsledmetomakeafewotheradditionsanddeletionstoaidinusability.Hmm…inretrospect,it'snotsomewhatthesame.Itis,butitisn't.
Stillconfusingreaders,Ron.Um,okay.I'lldobetter.InPartOne–"WhyWeNeedANewSystem"–Iamgoingtopresentyouwithlonglistsoffactsabouthowbadweareatpredictingthefutureandhowwearemisusinginformation.Weprobablyknowandacknowledgethesefactsindividually.We'llnodourheadsandsay,"Yeah,projectionsarenotgospel.Igetit."Butno,wereallydon'tgetit.Weknowthatbaseballcultivatesaloveaffairwithstatistics.But,thosenumbersworkbestindescribingwhathasalreadyhappened.Usedcorrectly,theydoaterrificjobofthat.Butwetakeamassiveleapoffaithinproclaimingouraptitudeassoothsayers.Yes,paststatisticscanbemanipulatedtoprojectfutureperformance,butwithinaverywiderangeofoutcomes.Extraordinarilywide.Theproblemis,forourfantasyleagues,weneedfarmoreprecisionthanwecancurrentlyachieve.Yetwecontinuetogointoeachseasonwithmeticulously-craftedrankingslists,playervaluesandtargets. Areyousayingthatallmydraftprepisawasteoftime?It'snotacompletewasteoftime,butweputfartoomucheffortintotheprocessandfartoomuchcredenceintheminutia.Westilllookata40-HRperformance–or40steals,or200strikeouts,etc.etc.–andfixateonthosenumbersasiftheyholdsome
![Page 6: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
5
religioussignificance.Wearestillseducedintomakingimportantdecisionsbasedonthewildallureofsmallsamples.Westilltrytoferretoutpatternsinthestats,evenifwhatwe'relookingatismostlynoise.Westilllookatresearchresultsbasedonaggregatedataanddrawfiniteconclusionsaboutindividualplayers.Andrecencybias?Oh,don'tgetmestarted.Ashardasitistocomprehend,thereisoftennotasignificantdifferencebetweena3rdroundplayerandan8throundplayer,orbetweena$19playeranda$9player.AndyetweagonizeoverADPsandengageinauctionbiddingwars.PartOneisintendedtomakeusawareofthefallibilityofourinformation,whichcreatestheneedforanewdraftpreparationprocessthatgivesusmorecontrol.InPartTwo–"TheBroadAssessmentBalanceSheet"–I'lldescribethenewsystem(BABS)andhowitworkstoresolvetheissuesoutlinedinPartOne.BABSlooksattheprocessofbuildingacompetitivefantasybaseballrosterthroughanunorthodoxlens.Foroverthreedecades,we'vetakenabottom-upapproachtorosterconstruction,focusingonprojectingplayerperformanceandthenbuildingfromthere.BABStakesatop-downapproach,focusingonthestructureoftherosteritself,andthenfillinginthepieces.Afterall,winningisnotaboutnailingprojections;it'saboutweighingskillversusrisk,anduncoveringprofit.Itdoesn'tmatterifyouthinkMikeTroutwillhit48HRs,or38,or28.Youmightberight;you'llprobablybewrong.Itmattershowhisoverallprofilefitsintoawell-constructedroster.OnDraftDay,successfullyreachingstatisticaltargetsprovidesfalsecomfort;howmanypost-draftstandingsprojectionsevercometrue?Butcreatingasolidfoundationandstructure,andthenbuildingitoutbybalancingassetsandliabilitiesprovidesahigher-levelperspectivethatallowsforbetterrostermanagement.Finally,inPartThree–"BABSinPractice"–weputBABStowork.We'lllookathowyoucanusethesystemandadaptittodifferentgameformatsandsituations.Backinthe1990s,thegreatestadvantageyoucouldhavewaspossessingbetterinformation.Theinternetleveledthatplayingfieldandleftuslookingforothercompetitiveedges.Overthepast25years,we'vegonethroughnumerousiterationsinvolvingstatisticalmodeling,newsimpactanalysisandevengametheory,butthegoalwasalwaystogetbetterplayerprojections.Thisisdifferent.That'swhyyouneedBABS.
Geez,itsoundslikeyou'retossingoffalltheyearsofresearchyou'vedoneintheBaseballForecasterandonBaseballHQ.com.
No,notatall.TheBaseballForecasterisstillthebibleoffanalyticsandprobablythemostimportantresourceforsettingbaselinesforplayerperformance.BaseballHQ
![Page 7: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
6
stillprovidesthedeepestfantasy-baseball-relevantinformationanywhereandistheonlyonlinesourceofthiscaliberthatis100percentbaseball,24/7/365.TheyarestillkeyinputstoBABSandtheplacesweneedtogotofindaccurateskillsassessment.That'sthefoundationuponwhichBABSisbuilt.Itisstillimportanttobeabletoevaluateperformanceinitscomponentpartsandunderstandhowthatrelatestothesurfacestatswithwhichweplayourgames.Thedifferencehereisthat,oncewe'vedonethatevaluation,Idon’twanttomaketheleaptoastatisticalprojection.IntheForecaster,wedoallthatevaluationandthenareforcedtocullitdowntoasinglelineofnumbers.I'vealwayshateddoingthat,butweneedthedataforourdraftprepsowekeeppublishingthosenumbers.However,likeIwriteintheConsumerAdvisoryinthefrontofthatbookeachyear,therearefarmoreimportantthingstolookatbeyondthatprojectedstatline.SowithBABSIgettosay,"Sorry,I'mnotgoingtodoit."IfyouabsolutelyneedtoknowhowmanybasesTreaTurnerisgoingtostealsoyoucanplugitintoyourfantasymodel,feelfreetogoelsewhere.Youwon'tfindthatnumberhere.Butifyou'reatleastcuriousabouttryingadifferentway,well,that'swhyyoumustbereadingthisrightnow.
Sorry,butI'mnotgoingtogiveupmystats.SoamIgoingtogetanyuseoutofthisbook?
Youdon'tneedtoabandonyourstatsbutyou'llhavetobewillingtotryrelyingonthemabitless.WithBABS,playersarenotstat-producingmachines;infact,theyarealsoprettyflawedashumanlifeforms.Ratherthanattemptingtofigureoutwhattypeofnumberstheyaregoingtoputup,myfocusisondescribingtheminthemostaccuratenon-statisticalterms,andthenassemblingtheseformlessentitiesintoproductiverosters.
Soundslikeyouaretryingtoreinventhowtowinatfantasybaseball.Thatseemsoverlyambitioustome.
InevershyawayfromachallengewhenIbelievethereisabetterwaytodosomething.AndIdobelievewe'vebeendoingthingswrongforaverylongtime.It'simportanttonotethatTheBABSProjectisintendedtobean"evergreen"referenceresource.Theexamplesandexhibitsarefromtheperiod2015-2019andarepresentedingeneralterms.Thatmeansthisbookdoesnotincludeanyplayerratings,rankingsorcheatsheetsfortheupcomingseason.Allthattime-sensitivedata,forthisyearandallfutureyears,appearsonlineatBABSbaseball.com.
Okay,howdowestart?Let'sstartwithabunchofharshrealitychecks.
![Page 8: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
7
TheBABSProjectChapter1
HowtheStatsareOuttoGetYou"Thisisaverysimplegame.Youthrowtheball,youcatchtheball,youhittheball.Sometimesyouwin,sometimesyoulose,sometimesitrains."NukeLaloosh,BullDurhamThestructureofthegameofbaseballlendsitselftoanalysis.Theresultofeachat-batisanindividualeventthatcanbemeasured.Butthismeasurementisalwaysafterthefact.Wecancounthowmanyhomerunsaplayerhits,butthatisonlyafterhe'shitthem.Theproblemcomeswhenwetrytotakethenextapparentlylogicalstep.Ifaspecificeventchroniclesareal,measurableskillandwecancountitandtrackitstrendsovertime,thencan'twealsopredictit?No,notreally,atleastnotwiththelevelofprecisionnecessarytohavemeaningfulcontroloverbuildingafantasybaseballteam.Buteveryyear,thequestcontinuestocreate,enhanceandfine-tunepredictivemodels.
Again,areyoudissingalltheworkwe'veputintoadvancedbaseballanalysisovertheyears?
No,thereisnothingwrongwithmoreandbetterdata.ThemetricsintheBaseballForecaster,atBaseballHQ.com,now-mainstreamsabermetricgaugeslikeWARandwOBA,advancedgranulardatafromPitchF/X,Statcastandheatmaps–areallvery,veryimportant.Thebetterthatwecandescribetheelementsofperformance,thebetterwecanassessskill.Thenweoftentakethenextstepandtrytousethosemethodstovalidatestatisticaloutput.That'sareasonableexercisetoo.Yes,aplayermighthit40homeruns,butwhenwedeconstructeventsintogranularcomponentssuchascontactrate,exitvelocity,trajectoryandbattedballdistance,wecangetasenseofhow"real"those40HRswere.Wecandeterminewhethertheplayer'sskillsetsupportedthathomerunoutputingeneralterms.That'sstillusableanalysis.Butthenweoftentakeitasteptoofar;wetrytoattachanumbertoit.Weanalyze:"Basedonthecomparableexitvelocityofallotherplayers,heshouldhavehitthreemoreHRs,allthingsbeingequal."Wedrawtheseconclusionsfromthevariancesbetweenexpectationandreality,basedonassumptionswemakeaboutunderlyingskill.Andweexcusethefallacyoftheexercisebyaddingthefauxqualifier,allthingsbeingequal.
![Page 9: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
8
Butallthingsareneverequal.Youcanneverreplicateoneseason'sperformanceinanotherseason.Conditionsarealwaysdifferent.Sowhilethisisaninterestingexercise,itprovideslittleactionableinformationwhenitcomestosubsequentyears.Tellmethattheindicatorspointtoanincreaseordecreaseinskills,showmetheareasofgrowthorerosion,evengooutonalimbandtellmethataplayerisgoingtofalloffacliff–butdon'ttellmethataplayerisgoingtohit37HRs.Don’ttellmeheisgoingtosteal45bases.Don'teventellmethatheisgoingtohaveanERAsomewherebetween3.25and3.50. But,but…weneedthosenumbers.Iknow–weneedthosenumberstoplaythegame.Wemusthaveplayerprojectionsandweneedtoconvertthemintodollarvaluesorrankingpositions.Weneedtobuildbudgetsandrosterplans,andsetstatisticaltargetsbasedonallthisdata.Thatiswhatwe'vealways"needed."Butnomatterhowexhaustiveajobwedoinassemblingourdraftprepmaterials,thenumbersweusetoplanoutourrostersarealwayswrong.Checkitoutyourself.Lookbackatlastseason'sprojectionsoneventhestableplayers.Theyneverhitexactlytheprojectednumber,andoftenit'snotevenclose.AplayerlikeMikeTrout,whohasbeenonthetopoftheleaderboardformostofthepastdecade,haspostedverydifferentnumberseachyear.Evenwitharangetoworkwith,thefinaloutputisalmostaslikelytoendupsomewhereoutsidethatrangeasinsideit.
Yes,noprojectionisgoingtobeexact.Butcan'tweexpectthattheover-projectionsandunder-projectionsaregoingtoevenoutacrossanentireroster?
No,wecan'texpectthatatall.Infact,yourleague'swinnersandloserswillmostlikelybedeterminedbyabasicreportcardofoversandunders.Theteamwiththemostorbiggestover-performerswillalwayshavethebestoddsofwinning,regardlessofhowcloseyourprojectionswereoverall.Truestory:Backinthe2015FSTAexpertsleague,myoveralldraftreportcardwasprettydamning.Ihadfiveon-parpicks,nineprofitablepicksand15outrightlosers,includingsixinthefirsteightrounds.Byallrights,thisteamshouldhavebeenadisaster.Butmyninewinnerswerebigwinners,includingthebreakoutyearsofJakeArrieta(9thround),J.D.Martinez(14),MannyMachado(15),XanderBogaerts(16)andDallasKeuchel(19).Ifinishedonedayandtwopointsshortofatitle,eventhoughmyoverallprognosticatingprowesswasawful.Sowereallycan'trelyontheprojectionsgettingustowhereweneedtogo.Yeteveryspringwegobackthroughthesameprocessalloveragain.
![Page 10: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
9
Well,ofcourse.Whatelsecanwedo?Well,let'sstartbyrecognizingwherewetendtogoastray.Youwouldn'tknowitfromallthisextremeanalysisgoingon,butbaseballisasimplegame.Evenfantasytendstodigfardeeperintotheminutiathanisnecessary.Hereisarundownofmanyofthelessons,truismsandproclamationswe'vemadeovertheyears.Somanyacceptedtruths,somuchofitmisguided.Thesearethecliffswekeepstumblingoff.Therearesomanywaysthatwearelookingatthingsincorrectly.Thefollowingresearchfindingsareallvalid;thecitedauthorsarefromtheBaseballForecaster,BaseballHQ.comandothersources.Ifnoauthoriscited,it'smyownresearch.StatisticalBaselines:AreTheyReal?Withthetoolscurrentlyavailabletous,themaximumprojectiveaccuracywecanhopetoachieveis70percent.Thisisanumberthatwe'vebeenthrowingaroundforalongtime.Butwhatthatmeansis,thebestwecanhopetobeis30percentwrong.Thirtypercentisalot!Itmeansbeingoff,onaverage,bynineHRsfora30-HRhitter,60strikeoutsfora200-Kpitcheror12savesfora40-savecloser.That'sthebestlevelofwrongnesswecanexpecttoachieve.Andfewofuswilleverachieve"best."
Seriously?Isthistrue?
Eh,Idon'tknow.That'sthenumberwe'vebeentossingaroundalltheseyears,andfrankly,Idon'trecallhowtheyarrivedat70percent.It'spossibletherecouldbeasystemthatexceeds70percentbutIdon'tknowthatyou'dbeabletoproveit. Why?Becauseoneseasonrepresentsonlyasingledatapointforanalysis,andthatissimplynotenough.Everyyear,wegainnewknowledgethatcompelsustoimproveandfine-tuneourforecastingmodels.Amodelweusedin2019mightbecompletelyoverhauledby2022.However,that2019modelmighthavebeenmoreaccurateoverafiveor10-yearperiod.Wenevergiveourselvesachancetofindout.What'smore,giventhatthestatisticallandscapeisalwayschanging,we'relikelynevergoingtohavedatathat'sstableenoughtodeemanymodeloptimalanyway.Ifwemadeadjustmentstoa2014modeltoaccommodatethe2015season,oddsareitwouldbeacompletefailuregiventheoffensivesurgethatyear.Andthenifweappropriatelyprojectedregressionfor2016,we'dhavebeenwrongagain.Wherewouldwegofromthere?
![Page 11: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
10
Maybeyoucan'tevaluateanentireseasonofprojectionsonamacrobasis,butwhataboutindividualplayers?That'sallthatmattersforusanyway.
Sure,wecantry.Thereareoverallskillsmetricsthatareconsideredgoodevaluatorsoftalent,likeonbaseplusslugging(OPS).Butlet'ssaythatIprojectaplayertohaveanOPSof.840andheendsupwithanOPSofexactly.840. Um,thatwouldbegreat!Except,this:
2019 HR SB BA OBP Slg OPSAdamEaton 15 15 .279 .365 .427 .792KoleCalhoun 33 4 .232 .325 .467 .792
IfIprojectedCalhounnumbersandheproducedlikeEaton,I'dhardlycallthatasuccessfulprojection.ButOPSthinksso.Therearedozensoftheseeveryyear.Baseballanalystsusevariousstatisticalprocessestocomparetheaccuracyofonesetofmetricstoanother.You'llseethesemethodsusedtomeasuretheaccuracyofplayerprojectionstoo.Therearefrequentstudiesthatinvolveagroupofforecasters,oftencomparedtoacontrolgroup–oftenasimpleage-adjusted,weightedthree-yearaverage(theMarcelMethod)–andtoeachother.Usingtheresultsofthesestudiestodeterminethebestsystemhaslittlevalue.Thetestgroupstypicallycoverhundreds,orthousands,ofplayers.Thevariancebetweenanyonesystemandanotherusuallyamountstopercentagepointsovertheentirestudygroup.It'snotsomethingthat'sgoingtoprovideanybenefitforatinysampleof23playersonafantasyroster.Thereisnowaythatyoucancoveryourriskofvolatilityoverarostersizeofjust23players.ThisisapointIamgoingtocomebacktoseveraltimes.About15yearsago,beforeweweresmarter,aleadingwebsiteoncepublishedacomparativeanalysisofabunchofforecastingsystems,usingthestatisticalmeasuresofcorrelationcoefficient,meanerrorandrootmeansquarederror(don'tworry,you'renotgoingtobetestedonthis).Theirresults: Mean
Correl Error RMSESystemA .690 .067 .084SystemB .694.066.084SystemC .711.064.085SystemD .692.067.085SystemE .683.068.086SystemF .715.064.081SystemG .672.071.091
![Page 12: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
11
Forwhatit'sworth,SystemCwasdeemedmostaccurate,thewinner,theprognosticationchampion!(Theywerealso,coincidentally,thepurveyoroftheanalysis.)Evenwithoutthebias,thereisnowayforyoutoleveragethatminutevarianceinaccuracyoverjust23players,or40,orevenseveralfantasyrosters'worth.Soyoucanpickalmostanysystemandhavejustasgoodofachanceofwinningasanyother.TheTruthAboutVolatilityAccordingtotheresearchofPatrickDavittofBaseballHQ.com,normalproductionvolatilityvarieswidelyoverany150-gamespan.A.300careerhittercanhitanywherefrom.250to.350,a40-HRhitterfrom30-50,anda3.70/1.15pitcherfrom2.60/0.95to6.00/1.55.Alloftheserepresentnormalranges.Soifabatterhits31-.250oneyear,36-.280thenextyearand40-.310thethirdyear,youdon'tknowwhetherthatisgrowthornormalvolatility.Infact,thelow-endand/orhigh-endpointscouldbeisolatedoutliers.Butnearlyeveryonewillseeitasatrendandcallitgrowth.AprojectionforyearNo.4willeithercontinuethisperceivedtrendorshowsomeregression.Andanyoneofthemcouldberight.Orwrong.ItactuallywouldbealoteasierifeveryplayerperformedlikeChrisDavisdidearlierinhiscareer:
Year HR BA OBP Slg R$2012 33 .270 .326 .501 $182013 53 .286 .370 .634 $362014 26 .196 .300 .404 $82015 47 .262 .361 .562 $262016 38 .221 .332 .459 $12
IloveChris.Hedidn'thidehisvolatility.Itwasall-clothes-off,outthereintheBaltimoresun.Hetrumpetedthefactthattherewasnowaytopinhimdown.Washea.220hitterora.270hitter?Couldweexpect30HRsor50HRs?Butwhilethisdatasetwasimpossibletoprojectintothefollowingseason,itwasnearlyconsistentwithinanormalrange.Infact,2014lookslikeaslightoutlierinthisparticularscan,buthissubsequentcareerprovedthatitwasn't.Youprobablycouldn’tconvincemanypeople,butthisisprettymuchthesameplayereveryyear. I'mstartingtopullmyhairout.Completelyunderstandable.Butthere'smore.Researchhasshownthat150games,oraboutthelengthofasinglebaseballseason,isnotenoughofasamplesizetobeareliableindicatorofskillforsomestatistics.
![Page 13: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
12
Forinstance,astatlikebattingaveragedoesn'tprovideareasonableapproximationofaplayer'strueskillleveluntilabout910AB,accordingtoRussellCarleton.Sowedefinitelycan'tdrawconclusionsafteroneseason.Youcan'tlookatabatterwhohits.230oneyearand.270thenextandcallthat"growth."Whatyou'dmorelikelycallthatisa.250hitter.MyfriendChris?Atthepointinhiscareershownabove,hewasyourbasic.240shitter,eventhoughhe'dneveractuallyhadabattingaverageinthe.240s.Butwhatdoes.240meananyway?Or.300?Or.250,or.200?Thelinewedrawinskillsbenchmarksisincrediblygrey.
• We'llchasea.300hitterasbeingsignificantlybetterthana.250hitter,however,over550AB,thedifferenceisaboutahitaweek.
• Thedifferencebetweena.272averageanda.249average–stillperceptivelydifferent–istwohitspermonth,orahiteveryotherweek.
• We'lloptforapitcherwitha3.95ERA,passingoveronewitha4.05ERA.Butwhat'stherealdifference?Apitcherwhoallows5runsin21/3inningswillseeadifferentERAimpactthanonewhoallows9runsin3innings,eventhough,forallintentsandpurposes,bothgotrocked.Thatcouldbeyour0.10varianceinERArightthere.
Thelinewedrawbetweensuccessandfailureisalsoincrediblygrey.
• AbatterwhoseHRoutputdropsmighthavehadaconcurrentincreaseindoublesandtriples.
• ApitcherwhoseERAspikesmayhaveseennodegradationinskillsbutwasbackedbyapoordefenseandabullpenthatallowedmoreinheritedrunnerstoscore.
• AspeedstermayhaveseenhisSBtotalplummetonlybecausehewastradedtoateamthatdidn’trun.
• Aclosermayhavebeenaseffectiveaseverbutlostthe9thinningroleasaresultofatradeoramanagerwithaquickhook.
It'slikenothingisrealanymore.Oh,it'sreal.Theissueishowyouinterprettheserealities.I'mtryingtomakeacasethatourtrusted,comfortablestatisticsarenottheplacetofind"real."Thisbecomesmoreproblematicwhenwetrytoprojectthefuture.Garbagein,garbageout.Andhonestly,beyondthevolatilityinthenumbers,thereistoomuchuncertaintyformanyplayerstopindownastatlineanyway.
![Page 14: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
13
• Howdoyouhandleplayerscomingoffofaninjury-marredseason?• Canyoureasonablypro-rateamid-seasoncall-up'sstatlinetoafullseason?• Islastyear'spitchingbreakoutstarreallynowinthesameclassasthe
game'selite?
Idon’tknow.Youdon'tknow.Nobodyknows.Butsomeoneisgoingtohavetoslapabunchofnumbersontheseguysinorderforyoutodraft,right?
Um,right.Well,won’tthey?Theywill,butyoudon'thavetobuyintoanyofit.HereisafactthatI'vesaidoften:Thetwomostpowerfulforcesknowntomanareregressionandgravity.Ifyou'reeverfacedwiththequestionofwhethertoprojectaplayertoimproveordecline,thebetterpercentageplaywillalwaysbeDECLINE.Butthatrunscountertowhatwewanttoseeinourplayers.That'swhywearesoinfatuatedwithupwardlymobilerookiesandanydatathatevenremotelyhintsatimprovement.Wecravesleepers!Bringmemoresleepers!TheLogicalTruthsAboutPEDsIhatewritingaboutthis,especiallysincethetopiccyclesinandoutoftheheadlineseachyear.Andreally,theperformance-enhancingdrugsthemselvesarenottheissueasmuchastheirimpactonthestatisticsthatdriveourgame.Whilethereremainsdisagreementamonganalystsabouthowrealormeasurablethatimpactis,therearefivelogicaltruthsthataretoughtodeny.1.Peoplearegenerallyhonest,exceptifit'sachoicebetweenhonestyandsurvival.2.Forproathletes,survivaloftenequatestomaintaininganedgetostaygainfullyemployed.3.IfPEDsdidnotimproveorsustainperformanceinordertogiveathletesanedge,whywouldtheyaccepttheriskofusingthem?4.Thedruglaboratorieswillalwaysbeonestepaheadofthedrugtesters.5.Youcan'tdismissthepossibilitythatanyradicalswinginproductivitycouldbecausedbyaplayer'suseordiscontinuanceofPEDs.
Ugh.IhatetalkaboutPEDs.Areyoutryingtosaythatallplayersaremotivatedtocheat?
![Page 15: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
14
No.Butit'syetonemorevariablethatputsthe"realness"ofallstatisticsatrisk.Andunfortunately,it'snaïvetothinkthatthelackofdailyPEDheadlinesmeanstheproblemhasbeencontained.Theabovetruthsdon'tchange;neitherdoestheefforttocoverupPEDuse.
ButwhataboutallthoseminorleaguersthatwereintheMitchellReport?Aren'ttheyproofthatPEDsdon'twork?
ForanyallegedPEDuserswhofellshortofarealMajorLeaguecareer,it'spossiblethattheyneverwouldhavemadeitoutofrookieballwithoutthathelp.Wedon'tknow.TheimpactofPEDsisrelativetoeachplayer'sactualskilllevel.Thatmeansweneedtoquestionthelegitimacyofperformancestatsthroughouteverylevelofproball.Probablycollegeandhighschooltoo. Ithinkmyheadisgoingtoexplode.Trytohangon.There'sonemorestatvariable.I'vesavedthebiggestoneforlast.TheBlackHoleofPlayingTimeYoucandoalltheskillsassessmentyouwant,butthebaneofourexistencehasbecometheblackholeofprojectingplayingtime.It'sanearlyimpossibletask.
Youmakeitsoundlikeit'sanewproblem.Becauseitisarelativelynewproblem.Twentyyearsago,projectingplayingtimewasjustanothervariablepronetosomenormalvolatility.Itwasnomoredifficulttoprojectthanhomersorstrikeouts. So,whatchanged?ContinuallyescalatingMLBplayersalariesandthecrackdownonPEDsreachedatippingpointinthemid-2000s.Theresult?Withteamsbendingoverbackwardstoprotecttheirhigh-pricedinvestmentsandplayersrunningscaredofgettingnailedbydrugtesters,thesafeharbortostashbodiesbecametheDisabled(nowInjured)List.In2007,thenumberofILdaysspikedfrom22,472to28,524.Fiveyearslater,itcracked30,000.Afterafewyearsaround31,000itspikedagainto34,284in2018andthento36,394in2019.EachtimeaplayerhitstheIL,itcreatesanopeningforanotherplayertofillthevoid.MoreILstintsmeanmorenewplayersclaimingapieceoftheplayingtimepie.
Sowhat?Wecan'tbetalkingaboutthatmanynewplayers.
![Page 16: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
15
Well,waybackin1985,about39players,onaverage,wouldappearonasingleteam'srosterduringthecourseofaseason.In2018,thatnumberhit54.Whilethenumberofplayersseeingmajorleagueactioneachyearisrising,thenumberofgameshasremainedthesame.Eachteamstillplays162games,whichgeneratesanearlyfixednumberofoutsandinnings,andaverynarrowrangeofplateappearances.Thesedays,availableplayingtimeisthesamebut15moreplayersperteamarefightingforapieceofit.We'vebeengoingintoour15-teamdraftswithprojectionsallotting6500ABand1450IPofplayingtimeto345players(15teamsx23playersperteam).Butwereallyneedtoallotthosesameat-batsandinningstothenumberwhoareactuallygoingtobeseeingthatplayingtime,whichismanymore.Ifwefailtoaccountforthatreality–andarenotatleastreasonablyaccurateinthateffort–thefalloutishuge:In2018,60percentoftheADP'stop300playerslostplayingtimeduetotheinjuredlist,demotion,suspensionorrelease–arecordforsingleseasonattrition.Sinceplayingtimeisazero-sumproposition,thoselostABandIPhadtogosomewhere,andinfact,morethan70percentofthemostprofitableplayersweredrivenbyunexpectedincreasesinplayingtime.Theopportunityforthoseplayingtimeincreaseswaslargelydependentonexternalevents,virtuallynoneofwhichwerepredictableonDraftDay.Andso,morethan70percentofeachseason'smostprofitableplayerswereunpredictableonDraftDay.Asyouwouldexpect,thesemostprofitableplayershadadisproportionatelylargeimpactonwhowontheirleagues.Researchshowedthat25percentoftheteamsowningoneormoreofthemostprofitableplayerswontheirleagueoutright.Oneoutoffour!Morethan50percentofthoseteamswiththemostprofitableplayersfinishednolowerthanthirdplace.Thebiggestdrivingforcebehindallthat–changesinplayingtime–wasunpredictableonDraftDay.
Wow.So,allinall,areyoutellingmethat,despiteallthemassiveeffortwe'vebeenexpendingtoconstructelaboratesystemstoprojectplayerperformance,noneofthenumberscanbetrusted?
Well,wecanalittle,butnotenoughforittomatter.Backin2010,Iasked12ofthemostprolificfantasychampionsinhighstakesleaguesandnationalexpertscompetitionstoranksixvariablesbasedonhowimportanttheyweretowinningconsistently."Moreaccurateplayerprojections"cameindeadlast.
Whatdidtheysaywerethemostimportantvariablesforwinningconsistently?Hereweretheresults:
![Page 17: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
16
1.Betterin-draftstrategy/tactics2.Bettersenseofvalue3.Betterluck4.Bettergraspofcontextualelementsthataffectplayers5.Betterin-seasonrostermanagement6.MoreaccurateplayerprojectionsTherewasactuallyaseventhvariablebroughtupbyLarrySchechter–betteruseandaccesstotime.Hesaidthatthemoretimeinvestedintheentireprocess,thebettertheresults.Researchsupportsthefactthatbetterdecisionsaremadewhenmoretimeistakentoanalyzetheimportantinputvariables.Larry'strackrecord–sixToutWarstitles–certainlysupportsthat.Buthere'saquestion:Canyoubuildasuccessfulteamwithoutstatisticalplayerprojectionsatall?Givenhowfaultythosenumbersare,itisaquestionweneedtoanswer.Butfirst,weneedtodiscusssomemoreobstaclestosuccess.
![Page 18: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
17
TheBABSProjectChapter2
HowtheMarketplaceisOuttoGetYouImaginethatwehavefiveplayerswiththeexactsameprojection:
AB HR SB BAGeorge 600 25 10 .275Herman 600 25 10 .275Willie 600 25 10 .275Joe 600 25 10 .275Hank 600 25 10 .275
Inthiscase,itwouldn'tmatterwhichplayeryoutook,right?
Well,sure.Iguess.MaybeyoumightdrawadistinctionbasedontheteamWillieplayson,orHank'shomestadium,orsomeothervariable.Andevenifthisdatarepresentedsomestatisticalmeanoutcomeorgeneralconsensusofpotential,thepointremains:atminimum,thesefiveplayersareexpectedtoproduceroughlycomparablenumbers.Butweknowtherearevariablesthataffectperformance,eveniftheyarenotblatantlyreflectedinthenumbers.Thosevariablesoftencomeoutinthemarketvaluesoftheplayers.Oncefantasyleaguersstartearlydraftsorrunningmocks,itwouldnotbeunusualtoseeourfiveplayersrankedlikethis:
ADP R$ AB HR SB BA37 $28 Joe 600 25 10 .27539 $27 Willie 600 25 10 .27543 $25 George 600 25 10 .27559 $20 Hank 600 25 10 .27576 $16 Herman 600 25 10 .275
Nowthemarketplacedetermineswhichplayersarethebetterpicks.Perhaps:
• Joewasaconsistent.250hitterwhohada.350runinSeptember.• Willieisridingsomemajorrookiehypeandhadagreatspring.• Georgeisa30-year-oldveteranwho'sputupthesenumbersconsistently.• Hankhadacareeryearlastseasonandisexpectedtoregress.• Hermanwasa35-HRhittercomingoffofJanuarywristsurgery.
Whenalltheinputsconverge,thenumbersmayenduplookingthesame,butthemarketplacehelpsrevealthenuances.Still,allthatmattersiswhatnumbersthese
![Page 19: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
18
playersaregoingtoaddtoyourbottomline,soifallfivearegoingtoendupinthesameplace,doesitreallymatterwhichoneyoupick?
Well,theywon'tallendupexactlythesame.Thenuancesthatthemarketshowsusareimportanttoseparatethem.
Ifonlythatwastrue.Theproblemis…themarketplaceisgenerallywrong.
• Joe'sSeptembercouldhavenoimpactonhisperformance.• Williecouldbeover-hyped.• Georgecouldbefacingthebeginningofhisdeclinephase.• Hank'scareeryearcouldbethebeginningofanewlevel.• Herman'swristcouldbecompletelyhealed.
Wethinkweknow,butit'sallspeculation.Let'stakealookathowthesedraftrankingscomeaboutinthefirstplace.Itexplainsalot…Itallstartsintheearlyfall,whenagroupofpeopledecidestohavea"waytooearly"mockdraftforthefollowingyear.Sometimesthistakesplaceevenbeforethecurrentseasonends(whichleadsmetobelievethesemightbefolkswhoseteamsarealreadyoutofcontention,whichpotentiallyaddsalayerofbias).Thesearethefirstpioneersofthefutureseason'sAverageDraftPositionrankings.Then,someofthespringannualshaveearlydeadlines(Decemberforsome)andhavetoconducttheirmag'smockdraftaroundThanksgiving.It'smereweeksafterthelastoutoftheWorldSeries,wellbeforetheWinterMeetingsorwhenfreeagentshavestartedtosign.Someofthemagmock'sparticipantsmayusetheresultsofthepioneermocksasaguide;it'stoughtotell.Theseearlymocksandearlymagshavetorelyonsomethingtorankplayers.Thatsomethingistypicallytherecencybiasofthepreviousseasonandspeculationaboutcontextualvariablesthatmightaffectthefollowingseason.Somenationalcompetitionsopentheirdoorstodraftsasearlyasmid-November,maybeaslateastheWinterMeetings,butstillwellbeforeallthefreeagentshavefoundhomes.Thereisstilllittleinformationtoanalyze,sotheADPsgeneratedbythesedraftswilltendtofeedoffthefirstones,usingthemasbenchmarks,especiallyforplayerswhohaveanuncertainfuture.Thatlastpointisanimportantoneastheuncertainplayersareoftentheonesmostlikelytobequestionablypositionedintherankings.Themoreofthesethatarepublishedoverthewinter,themorethattheearlyranksgainafootingandwestartformingopinionsaboutwhereplayersshouldbedrafted.
![Page 20: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
19
Therankingsineachsuccessivedraftbecomeself-perpetuating.Beforeyouknowit,wereachcriticalmass.Therankingsbecamelessaboutrealityandmoreaboutgroup-think.Oncespringcampsopen,ourexpectationsareprettymuchlockedin.So,insummary…TheADPsaredrivenbyearlyspeculatorsplantingstakesinthegroundbasedonincompleteinformation.Andallthisisdoneasearlyassixmonthsbeforeeveryonewillbedraftingforreal.Backinthefallof2015,everyonewasexcitedaboutCarlosCorreaafterhislateseasondebut.Afewpeopledecidedtopushtheenvelopewithafirstroundselectioninearlymockdrafts.ThepickgainedtractionovernumerouswintermocksandCorreaneverfelloutoffirstroundconsiderationafterthat.He'dentertheseasonrankedNo.6overall.He'dfinish2016outsidethetop70.Fouryearslater,hehasyettocrackthefirstroundinearnings.TheextentofthefalloutisdescribedinaresearchpieceIwroteforTheAthletic.comin2019.IlookedathowtheADPs–essentially,themarketplace–faredagainstactualperformancein2018.Itexposedsomehorrifyingrealities.ThenIreranthestudyfor2019,publishedinthe2020BaseballForecaster,withsimilarresults.Thefollowingchartsareallbasedona15-teammixedleague,andshow:
Rounds RoundsorrangeofroundsstudiedPar PctofpicksthatearnedthesamevalueasthedraftroundProfit PctofpicksthatearnedmorevaluethanthedraftroundLoss Pctofpicksthatearned1-3roundsworsethandraftroundBust Pctofpicksthatearnedmorethan3roundsworseDisaster Pctofpickswithearningsoutsidethetop750,essentiallyundraftableina
50-roundleague."Disaster"picksareasubsetof"Bust"picksThesechartsrepresenttheaggregateresultsfrom2018and2019. PERCENTAGES
Round Par Profit Loss Bust Disaster1-5 11% 21% 24% 45% 4%
6-10 7% 26% 18% 49% 5%11-15 1% 31% 7% 61% 21%16-20 2% 34% 7% 57% 26%21-25 2% 39% 4% 54% 30%26-30 2% 39% 3% 55% 34%31-35 0% 25% 1% 75% 63%36-40 1% 23% 1% 75% 67%41-45 1% 28% 2% 69% 67%46-50 0% 31% 3% 67% 66%
![Page 21: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
20
Fromthetopofthedraftboard,thereisasteadydeclinethatquicklydevolvesintoamassiveplummet.Andadifferentperspective: PERCENTAGES
DraftStage Par Profit Loss Bust DisasterActive 5% 30% 13% 53% 17%
Reserve 1% 30% 2% 67% 57%Tryingtonailtheexactroundtodraftaplayerisafool'squest–afivepercentplay.
Wow.Thetruetakeaway:"Intheactiverosterportionofthedraft,athirdofourpicksperformedatparorbetter;twothirdsperformedworsethanwherewedraftedthem.Fullyhalfofthemcouldhavebeenconsideredbusts."
Wowagain.SowhydoweplacesuchimportanceonADPs? Nah…IdraftwhoeverIwant.I'mnotswayedbytheADPs.Maybe.ButI'dwageraguessthatyou'remorelockedinthanyouthink.Let'ssayit'spre-season2019andImakeaveryconvincingargumentthatFreddieFreemanshouldbedraftedaheadofNolanArenado.Youmightconsidermyanalysis,andevenifyouagree,youwillbereluctanttochangeyourexpectationsmuch.Why?BecauseallthepublishedanalyseslistArenadoasa1st-rounderandFreemannot.Shandlerisjustonevoiceinacrowdnomatterhowstrongmyargumentmightbe.Andfrankly,youdon'twanttoriskpublicscornbydraftingFreemantoohigh. ButFreemanisnotafirst-rounder.Whynot?Howdoyouknow?Therearemanyplayerswhoarenotconsideredfirst-roundersbutwhocouldbe.InsteadofFreeman,whatifIhadsaidCodyBellinger?I'llbetyoudon'trememberthatthefollowingplayersoncegeneratedfirstroundearnings:AdamJones,HunterPence,ChaseHeadley,CurtisGrandersonandMarkReynolds. MarkReynolds?C'mon.Hewasthe12thbestplayerinbaseballin2009.Ithappens.
![Page 22: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
21
Ican'tstressenoughabouttherealitiesofgroup-thinkexpectations.Asmuchaswemaydenyit,theADPsdoinfluenceourdraftbehaviorandwehavetobeawareofthat. Still,overallwedoaprettygoodjobpickingourfirst-rounders,right?Notsomuch.FACT:ThesuccessrateofADPrankingscorrectlyidentifyingeachseason’stop15players(inanyorder)isonly33.75percent.Infact,thosetop15playersfinishsomewhereinthetop30only53percentofthetime.(Studyperiod:2004-2019)Sohere'sthetakeaway:Whenyousitdownatthedrafttable(oryourcomputer,whatever)andstartagonizingoverwhoisgoingtofalltoyouinthefirstround,thereisnearlyatwo-in-threechancethatwhoeveryouendupdraftingwillbewrong.About10ofthefirst15playerstakeninyourdraftwillnotearnbacktheirowner'sinvestment.
That'scrazy.Okay,here'salittlequiz.Whatdothefollowing21playershaveincommon?
RyanBraunKrisBryantMadisonBumgarnerCarlosCorreaChrisDavisPrinceFielderCarlosGomezAdrianGonzalezCarlosGonzalezJoshHamiltonBryceHarperFelixHernandezRyanHowardAaronJudgeMattKempEvanLongoriaAndrewMcCutchenChrisSaleGiancarloStantonMarkTeixeiraTroyTulowitzki
Lotsofstarsandsemi-starsthere.It'spossibleallofthemwerefirst-roundersat
onetime,Isuppose.
![Page 23: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
22
Yes,theywere.Allofthemwerefirstrounddraftpickssometimebetween2011and2019.Andall21alsoholdanotherdistinction…everyonefinishedtheseasonatleast100spotslowerthanthatfirst-roundADP.DraftedinRound1;earnedbacknobetterthanRound7.It'sjustfurtherevidenceofthevolatilityofstatistics,evenatthetop.
Isitanybetterinauctionleagues?Nah.TryingtofindsomestabilitywithinRotisseriedollarearningsorAverageAuctionValues(AAVs)isnolessfrustrating.FACT:Playerswhoearn$30inaseasonareonlya34percentbettorepeatorimprovethefollowingseason.(MattCederholm)FACT:Pitcherswhoearnlessthan$24inaseasonretainonly52percentoftheirvaluethefollowingyear.Moreexpensivepitchersdoretain80percentoftheirvalue.(MichaelWeddell)That80percentisnicebutitstillmeansyouracepitcher'svalueisgoingtodecline.FACT:Thereisonlya65%chancethataplayerprojectedforacertaindollarvaluewillfinishtheseasonwithinplus-or-minus$5ofthatprojection.Thatmeans,ifyouprojectaplayerwillearn$25andyouagonizewhenbiddinghits$27,thereisonlyabouta2-in-3shotofhimfinishingsomewherebetween$20and$30. SoIshouldn'tworryaboutthoseextrafewbucks?Inmostcases,no.Butauctionpricingisgoingtobemarket-drivenanyway.So,ifyouareconvincedthataplayerisworth$25andlandhimfor$21,youwillhaveoverpaidiftherestofyourleagueseeshimasnomorethana$19player.Evenifheisreallyworth$30.
Arrrgh!Igiveup.AreyousayingIshouldjustpaywhateverforwhoeverandnotworryaboutbudgetsorbargainsorvalueoranything?!
Youstillneedtofollowthemarketandhavearoughbudget,butingeneral,yes.Forecasterswillgiveyouastatlinethatwillsplitthedifferencebetweenhigh-endandlow-endprobabilities.Theyhavenochoicebuttohedge;thereistoomuchrisktocommittoanyoneendoftheperformancespectrum.Reputationsareatstake!Soifallthetopanalystsdon'tknowwhattheheckeachplayerisgoingtodo,clearlytheotherownersinyourleaguehavenoclueeither.Youneedtodecidewhethera
![Page 24: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
23
playerisworthowningandfitsyourplan,andthenjustfollowthemarket.Mostfantasyleaguersdon'tdraftthatway. Thisisincrediblyfrustrating.Indeed.Ifyouarelookingforvalueretentionorareasonablereturnonyourinvestmentinthisgame,you'replayingthewronggame.
So,thestatisticscan'tbetrustedandthemarketplacecan'tbetrusted.Butwecantrustourownjudgment,right?
Notsofast.
![Page 25: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
24
TheBABSProjectChapter3
HowYourBrainisOuttoGetYouBeyondeverythingI'vewrittensofar,ourbrainalsoplaysitsowntricksonus.Therearecognitivebiases,nefariouslittlebrainflakesthatsurreptitiouslyderaillogicaldecision-makingprocesses.Weusuallydon'tevenknowwhenit'shappening;that'showeviltheyare.Herearesomeofthemostdamagingpsychologicalpitfalls:Webasedecisionsonsmalldatasamples.Timeforafairytale."Onceuponatime,therewasafringeoutfieldprospectintheTampaBayRayssystemnamedJoeyRickard.TheRaysthoughtsohighlyofthisprospect–whohadslammed13HRsin1,237careerminorleagueABs–thattheylefthimunprotectedinthe2015Rule5draft,wherehewasquicklygrabbedupbytheBaltimoreOrioles.Now,theOrioleshadnoshortageoffringeoutfieldtalentthatMarch.ButRickard'sspringtrainingperformancewasHall-of-Fame-worthy–arobust.397/.472/.571slashlinein63at-bats(withonehomerun)againstamixtureofveteransgettingtheirrustoff,marginalmajorleaguersworkingonanewpitch,andminorleaguersplayinglikeminorleaguers.TheO'sweresoimpressedthattheynamedhimtheirOpeningDaystartingleft-fielder.Thankfully,participantsinthenationalexpertsleagueswerenotfooled.Theyknewthat1,237minorleagueat-batsfaroutweighedRickard'squestionable63-ABsmallsampleMarchperformance.SoRickardwentundraftedinnearlyeveryexpertsleague.Butinthefirstweekoftheseason,Rickardposteda.467/.438/.733line(withonehomerun)in15AB.Thatweekend,morethan50expertsacrosssixleaguesplacedfreeagentbidsfortheO'sstartingleft-fielder,withanaveragewinningbidofnearly$150(outofa$1000budget).Isupposeevenexpertscanlosetheirminds.Allthosepreciousfreeagentdollarsweretossedarounddueto15atbats!Andnotjustany15AB.Itwas15ABagainstthepoorMinnesotaandTampaBaypitchingstaffs.ThearmsRickardfacedinthosecoldBaltimoreoutingshadnameslike
![Page 26: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
25
Santana,Fien,Gibson,HughesandArcher,whocollectivelyposteda7.23ERAin18.2IPthatweek.RickardfinishedAprilwitha.280average,twoHRsandoneSB.HefinishedMaywitha.249average,fourHRsandthreeSBs.Hewascutfromnearlyalltheexperts'rostersbymid-June.TheOriolesputhimontheILwithathumbinjuryinJuly,wherehestayedfortherestoftheseason.Andnobodylivedhappilyeverafter."
Fessup,Shandler.Ibetevenyouplacedabid.Sadly,yes.I'lladmitthatIplacedalosingbidof$57inTout-AL.Intoday'sfantasyenvironment,weallthinkweneedtoatleasthaveahorseintherace.Thereisalwaystheslightestchancethataplayercouldsustaintheirperformancelongenoughtohaveapositiveimpactonyourroster.ButRickard'swinningownersinvested15percentoftheirentirefreeagentbudgetsonaspeculationthat78at-batsagainstquestionablecompetitionweremorelegitimatethantheprevious1,237ABs.Thatdecision-makingshowshowyoucanbeblindedbysmalldatasamples.Wetrytoferretoutpatternswithinstatisticalnoise.Humans(includingyouandI)arehard-wiredtotrytofindpatterns.Initsgrandestsense,wedothistosurvive.Theworldisfullofchaos–eveninnon-electionyears–andit'sthewayourbrainsattempttocreateorder.Baseballanalysisissimilarlyallaboutfindingpatternsindata.Weseeabatterhitting8,10and12homerunsinsuccessiveyears,andweimmediatelylabelthatasagrowthtrend.Maybeitis.Butresearchbackin2010byEdDeCariashowedthattheoddsofthenextdatapointinthatseriesbeing14aresmall.Infact,thegreatestoddsarethatthenextpointregressesbackto10,oreven9.AsdescribedinChapter1,sincethatwedon'tevenknowhowreal8,10and12are,it'sdifficulttoconcludethatthereisanytrendatall.That8-HRyearcouldhavebeen13iffiveofhisdoubleshadtraveledanother5feet.That12-HRyearmighthavebeen9ifnotforthosethreenightswhenthewindwasblowingout.Wefantasyleaguersneedtofindpatterns.That'sthestartingpointfortheentireforecastingprocess.Butwhenthedataitselfissuspect–obscuredingreatmeasurebynoise–maybeit'sbetternottobelookingforsomethingthatmightnotexist.Likebettersentencestructure.
![Page 27: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
26
Let'splayalittlegame. Oo,Ilikegames!Good!Hereisashortseriesofdatapointsrepresentingoneplayer'sRotisserieearningsduringhisfirstthreeyearsinthemajors:$7,$15,$18.TellmewhatyouthinkheearnsinyearNo.4.
Well…itseemslikegrowth,butyouwarnedmeagainstassumingthat.I'lltakethebait.I'llsaythatheearns$16inyearNo.4.
That'saveryreasonableguess.Anyof$14,$15or$16wouldtakeanappropriatelevelofregressionintoaccount.InyearNo.4,thisplayeractuallyearned$23. What?Youtrickedme!Ididn'ttrickyou;thisisanactualplayer.Nothingisever100percent.So,nowyou'refacedwithafour-yeartrend:$7,$15,$18,$23.WhatdoesthisplayerearninyearNo.5?
Okay,nowyou'rescrewingwithme.LogicdictatesthatIsay$19or$20,butyou'vealreadyprimedmetoexpecttheunexpected.I'llsay$25.
Anothergoodguess.Mostanalystswouldprobablyhavestuckwithsometypeofregressedvalue,andIcantellyouthattheForecasterprojectedthisplayertoearn$22inyearNo.5.Butheactuallyearned$28.
Ofcourse.Fourstraightyearsofincreasingearnings–isthisarealplayer?ShouldIbelieveyou?
Youcanchoosewhattobelieve.Butlet'skeepgoing.We'renowat$7,$15,$18,$23,$28.WhatdoeshedoinyearNo.6?
Thereisnowaythiscankeepgoing.I'mgoingtosay$24.That'smyfinalanswer.
Andthatisthecorrectplay.Regressionisalwaysthecorrectplay.TheForecasterprojected$26.Butheactuallyearned$32.
You'replayingme.Youclearlypickedanoutlier…ifheactuallyexistsatall.Well,that'sonethingyougotright.Aplayerwiththisconsistentafive-yeartrendisclearlyanoutlier.Doyouwanttokeepgoing? Sure,whynot?It'sonlyaguessinggameatthispoint.
![Page 28: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
27
Okay.$7,$15,$18,$23,$28,$32.What'snext? Regressionisalwaysthecorrectplay…evenwhenitisn't.I'llsay$29.RememberthatMattCederholmsaid,"Playerswhoearn$30inaseasonareonlya34percentbettorepeatorimprovethefollowingseason."Giventhat,itwouldseemthattheoddsofhimcontinuingtoimprove,orevenholdingsteady,arelow.InyearNo.7,heearned…Waitforit…$28. Hooray!Theplanetsfinallyalign!Doesitkeepgoing?Forsure.Let'sdotwomoredatapoints.$7,$15,$18,$23,$28,$32,$28.It’snolesstrickynow.Was$28anoutlier?Doesherebound?Ordoesthedownwardtrendcontinue?
I'dhavetosayhe'sathispeakandwouldprobablybouncearoundabitforafewyears.I'llpeghisearningsat$30.
Yeah,that'sareasonableassumption.But,no.Heonlyearned$19. $19?!Yougottabefreakin'kiddingme.It'sallreal.$7,$15,$18,$23,$28,$32,$28,$19.Forthelastdatapointinthisexercise,I'llgiveyouonehint:hewas30yearsoldthatseason. Ugh.Thiscouldbethebeginningofthedownslope.Buthe'snotthatoldthathe couldstillreboundalittle.I'llsay…$22.Nah,$14.Forecastingisatoughgame. Morelikeasucker'sgame.Whowastheplayer?Washereal?AdamJonesisveryreal.Andasmuchasthisexercisewasfrustrating,alookatJones'careerprovidesaprettyslickbellcurve:$7,$15,$18,$23,$28,$32,$28,$19.$14.Sincethen,heplateauedbetween$17and$19forafewyearsbeforedroppingto$10in2019.Wewouldbesoluckyifeveryplayer'scareerfollowedasfineatrendasthis.They'dbeacinchtoprojecteachyear(oh,theirony!).
Waitaminute.Isanyofthisdatavalid?CanweevenuseRotisserieearningstoevaluateplayers?Isn'tthisthesameargumentyoumadeagainstusingOPS?
![Page 29: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
28
You'reright;nicejob.That'swhyallofthesedatapointsaresuspect.AdamJones'bellcurveisprobablynotnearlyasconsistentasitseems.Still,therearetwoareaswhereRotisseriedollarscanhavesomevalue.1.Iwouldn'tusepastRotoearningstoprojectnextyear'sdollarvalue,buttheydohaveanadvantageoverothermetrics.Thisisbecausethedollarcalculationnormalizesstatisticstothelevelofoffenseandpitchingeachyear.Soa30-HRperformanceinahighoffenseseason(like2019)wouldearnfewerdollarsthanthatsame30-HRperformanceinalowoffenseseason(like2014).Theabovedatasetsarefinetoevaluatewithinthelimitationoftheimpreciseinputs.2.Sharpchangesinperformancearereflectedprettyaccurately,eveniftheprecisedollarvaluesareinexact.Sowecanuserotodollarstosuggestthemagnitudeofabreakoutorbreakdownperformance.Welookatresearchresultsbasedonaggregatedataanddrawfiniteconclusionsaboutindividualplayers.Therehasbeenatonofresearchdoneoverthepast30years.Mostofthisstuffisincrediblyinsightfulandthefindingsreallyhelpusunderstandthecomponentsoftrueskill.Theproblemisthattheseresultsreflecttendenciesonamacrolevel.Noneofthemproduceapercentageplaythat'sgoodenoughtomakemicroplayerdecisionswithanyconfidence.Astandardfantasyrosterwith23playersiswaytoosmallasamplesizeforanyofthistomatter.(There'sthatstatementagain.)Youarenotgoingtobeabletoleverageminisculepercentagedifferenceswithsofewchancestoberightorwrong.Those23playersarejustnotenoughopportunitiestocoveryourrisk.Herearethreewidely-usedvariablesthatarealmostalwaysawasteoftimetoworryabout.Age:Researchshowsthatplayers'skillspeakatacertainage–26,23,28,31–pickanumber,anynumber.Butthosearejustroughaverages.Noteveryplayerisgoingtopeakatagivenage.Sotargeting28-year-oldsinyourdraftmightpayoffonlyifyou'reinabout30leagues.Andeventhen,youmightenduppassingona21-year-oldrookiewhohitsthegroundrunningoradecliningveteranwhohasahugereboundseasonatage39.Thoseerrorsmightcostyouatitle.Withonly23chances,theoddsofrosteringanoutlierarenotmuchdifferentfromtheoddsofrosteringaplayerthatfitsyourtarget.However…thereareafewtimeswhentheoddsarehighenoughtopursue.Eventually,playersageoutofrosterableskills.Thatageisdifferentforeveryplayer,
![Page 30: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
29
buttheoldertheyget,thehighertheodds.So,ifaplayerhasacareeryearinhismid-to-late30s,betagainstarepeat.Ifaplayerhasacrappyyearinhislate30s,betagainstarebound.Thosearehigherpercentageplaysandareprettymuchtheonlyonesworthchasing.Buteventhosearenotabsolutes.Parkeffects:Iknowfromexperiencethatmosttoutsgothroughapainstakingconversionprocesseverytimeaplayerswitchesteams.Iusedtoaswell.ButI'vecometofindtheexerciseofadjustingprojectionsforparkeffectsmostlyawasteoftime.AsoftenasaChristianYelichbreaksoutmovingfromMiamitoMilwaukee,therewillbeanIanDesmondorJonathanLucroywhofailstocapitalizeonamovetoCoorsField.Evenextremeballparkchangesareinconclusivebecausetherearealwaysothervariablesinplay.Thatbringsupabiggerquestion:howdoyouknowthatanincreaseordecreaseinaplayer'soutputisreallypark-related?Ifa30-HRhittermovestoaparkthatincreasespowerby20percent–whichisahugeleap–thenwecouldexpecthimtonowbea33-HRhitter(thepercentageonlyaffectshomegames).Buta3-HRincreaseiswellwithinthelimitsofnormalstatisticalvariance.Howdoweknowthatnormalskillsgrowthdidn'tdrivetheincreaseinhomeruns?Orsimplestatisticalvolatility?Oratrioofwell-timedgustsofwind?It'sevenmorefuzzywithratiogauges.However…ifyouaregoingtouseitatall,focusonthemargins.Thenoticeableimpactsareonlygoingtocomefromahittermovingfromoneofthebesthittersparkstooneoftheworst,orviceversa.Theinversegoesforpitchers,obviously.Ihavegivenupcalculatinganythinginbetween.Teamsupport:Ifyouhavetwoplayersofcomparableskill,butoneplaysonacontenderandtheotherplaysonadoormat,you'llalmostalwaysoptfortheplayeronthebetterclub.Teamenvironmentmatters,right?MorerunsandRBIs,morewinsandsaves.UnlessyouinvestedintheNationalsin2018,ateamthatwassupposedtocontend.OrmaybeyoubetheavilyonthedefendingchampionRoyalstobebetterthana.500clubin2016.Orthe2018championRedSoxtofinishcloserthan19gamesoutin2019.Failuretocorrectlypredictteamenvironmentforthoseclubshadahugeimpact.Evenpickingtherightteamisnoguarantee.In2016,CarlosCarrascoandDannySalazaronthe94-winIndiansonlywon11gamesapiece.Similarly,the89-winBrewersin2019hadonlytwopitcherswithdouble-digitswintotals–BrandonWoodruff(11)andZachDavies(10).The2015Dodgersshouldhavebeenaprimetargetforoffensiveproduction,butnobodybehindAdrianGonzalezamassedmorethan60RBIs.
![Page 31: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
30
Asatie-breakerwheneverythingelseisequal?Sure.ButI'mwillingtobetyoucanfindsomeothervariablethatwillhavemoreofanimpact.Wearelargelydrivenbyrecencybias.Weliveinaworldwherewe'reinundatedininformation.It'sfartoomuchtoprocesssowehavetorelyonsmallerchunksthatareeasiertoremember.Andtheeasiestpiecesofdatatorememberarethoseclosesttothesurfaceofourconsciousness.AskmewhatIhadforbreakfastthismorningbutforgetaboutmerememberingwhatIhadfordinnertwonightsago.("RedcurryatthatThairestaurant."–Wife)Theeffectsofrecencybiasonmanagingourfantasyteamshavegrownovertimeastheamountofinformationwe'vehadtoprocesshasgrown.Partofitisjusttheendlessquesttograbatwhateverwecan.I'vealreadytalkedaboutsmallsamplesizes–that'spartofit–butthesedays,evenapartialseasonofaberrantperformanceoftentrumpsa10-yearcareerofconsistency.Recencybiasdriveseachyear'sADPs.Thequickestwaytoearnafirstroundrankingistopostfirst-roundearningsthepreviousyear.Thesenewriserswhohavesupplantedthevetscouldwellbethenextwaveofstartalent,butarewepassingjudgmentafterjustoneseason?Afterall,outliersrunbothways.It'slikewecompletelyignoreoneoftheveryfirsttenetsofbaseballprognosticating:Don'tprojectaplayerbasedononeseason'sstats.After30years,havewelearnednothing?Thehistoricaltrackrecordshowsthatpitchersearningfirstroundvalueinoneseasonarepoorbetstorepeatthefeatinconsecutiveyears.ClaytonKershawmanagedtodefythisformanyyears–hewastheonlyone!–butevenhecouldn'tescapein2016.Still,therearealwaysseveralarmswhodoearntop15value;it'sjustmostlyadifferentgroupeachyear.Volatilepitchingstatsandthechangingcompositionofthetalentpooldrivethatphenomenon.Butguaranteedthatsomeoflastyear'sdominantarmsarestillgoingtogetdraftedaheadofotherswhohavebeenmorestableandconsistentyearinandyearout.AndassureasCarlosCorreawasoverdraftedin2016,therearealwaysahandfulofsecondhalfsurgerswhowillgetpushedfarforwardintherankingseachyear.AdalbertoMondesiwasoverdraftedin2019;YordanAlvarezlikelyin2020.Thishappenstimeandtimeagain.Whydopeoplekeepdoingthis? Maybewedon'twanttomissout.
![Page 32: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
31
Wemakedecisionsbasedonthefearofmissingout.Igetitthatyoudon'twanttobetheguywhomissesoutonthenextHall-of-Famer.Butareyouabsolutelycertainenoughtoriskthoseall-importantearlypicksthatarealreadysaddledwithinflatedfailurerates?EveryyearbringsanotherexampleofwhathappenswhenyoubuyintotheFearofMissingOut.Evenifaplayerperformsasexpected–likeKrisBryantdidin2015andFranciscoLindorin2016–over-draftingthemofferednobenefit.TheteamsthatwonleaguesthatyearwerenotthosethatownedBryantorLindor,becausetheywerepurchasedatnearlyfullvalue.Therewasnoadvantagetopayingthatmuch;therewasonlytheriskthatanunprovenplayerwouldfail.Whenyoudraftaplayerlikethatasafoundationpiecetoyourroster,thereisfarmoredownsidethanupside.Ifheisfullyproductive,you'vesetaveryhighbarforhimtoreturnparvalue.Perhapshehasahigherfloorthanothers,soyourdownsideismitigated.Butwesimplydon'tknowwhatthatrangeis.Hereismycompletelyunscientifictakeontheoddsforthattypeofplayerasatoppick:
Profit 1%Parvalue 20%Someloss 60%Majorloss 19%
Youcanquibblewiththepercentages,butthegeneralconclusionhastobethesame:whatareyouchasing?Ifyou'reoverpayingforaspeculationatthedraft,you'realsopotentiallypassingupprofitopportunitieslateron,especiallyinauctionleagues.Asmuchasyouthinkyoucanfindprofitineveryplayer,youonlyget23chances,andthereareatleast11otherguysinyourleaguewhoarethinkingthesameway.Thisisparticularlydangerousintheearlyroundswherewe'veshownthatouroveralltrackrecordisterrible.Hereareafewinterestingplayersofnote:
#yearsdraftedin1stRd #yearsearnedPlayer forFearofMissingOut 1stRdvalueTroyTulowitzki 4 0EvanLongoria 3 0CarlosGonzalez 4 1PrinceFielder 4 1BryceHarper 4 1GiancarloStanton 3 1
Talkaboutdoingthesamethingoverandoveragain,andexpectingdifferentresults.Isn'tthatthedefinitionofinsanity?
![Page 33: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
32
WebasedecisionsonNOW.Thereisasubconsciouspartofusthatactuallyagreeswiththefactthatyoucan'tpredictthefuture.Ifourdecision-makingprocesswasfullyconsciousanddeliberate,wemighttakeanobjectivelookateachsituationwithaneyetowardstomorrow.Instead,wetendtotaketheeasywayoutandjustviewwhatishappeningrightnowasafixedreality.Butrealityisnotfixed.Itisfluid.Onedecisionbegetsuncertainoutcomes,whichbegetotherdecisions. English,please.Atleastgivemeanexample.Okay.Here'sanotherfairytale:"Onceuponatime(early2015),therewasacloserfortheSeattleMarinersnamedFernandoRodney.Hehadavolatilecareer–someverygoodyearsandsomeverybadones–anddespitesomequestionabouthisabilitytoholddownacloser'srole,RonShandlerspentfull-pricecloserdollarsforhiminToutWars($16).Shandlerreasonedthat,despiteRodney'serratictrackrecord,hewasthecloserNOW.Asitwouldturnout,itdidn'ttakelongforRodneytoturnintoapumpkin,wipingoutShandler'sinvestment(andrelegatinghimtolastplaceinsavesfortherestoftheseason).WhenCarsonSmithinnocuouslyslidintothecloser'srole,heimmediatelybecametheNOWguy,andfantasyleaguersaroundtheworldproceededtoexhaustasignificantpartoftheirfreeagentacquisitionresourcesonapitcherwithfarbetterskillsthanthedeposedRodney.Because,betterskillsandNOW.TheseNOWinvestmentsalsocomewithanintrinsicexpectationoflongevity–weexpectthepitcherwillholdtherolefortherestoftheyear.Butwhenitcomestoclosers,theyholdthatroleuntiltheydon't,andsometimesthein-seasonshelflifeforthatroleisweeks,ordays.Smith'sninthinning"BestifUsedBy"dateexpiredafterabouttwoandahalfmonths.HestartedlosinggamesandblowingsavesinlateJuly,andwassupplantedbyTomWilhelmsonbymid-August.Wilhelmson'sskillsetpaledincomparisontoSmith's(andonceSmithlosttherole,hedidnotgiveuparunfortherestoftheseason)butthat'snotwhatrealityisabout.WilhelmsonwasnowtheNOWguydrawingwhatevermeagerfreeagentresourceswerestillleft.Aftertheseasonwasover,theMarinersrespondedtoallthisbytossinglastyear'sNOWguystothecurbandstartingoverwithabunchofnewNOWguys.Andtheyalllivedhappilyeverafter.ExceptforShandler."
![Page 34: RON SHANDLER The BABS PROJECT 3 … · The BABS Project Introduction My Conversation with You ME: Hey, welcome. YOU: Hi Ron. I see you're back. What's up? A new edition of The BABS](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022053006/5f0a70fb7e708231d42ba62d/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
33
Thesestoriesdon'tseemtohavehappyendings. Nicestory.Iassumeyoudidn'twinToutWars.Um,no.Buttheexperienceisrepresentative.Hereareotherwaysthatourdecision-makingprocessesareinfluencedbyNOW:Therearesomeplayerswholockdownrolesattheveryendofspringtraining.Theserosterdecisionsaresometimesbasedonjustoneortwogamesoflateperformance,goingintothatlastMarchweekendwithtwoplayersfightingforonespot.WetreatthoseNOWguysasfixedrealities,biddingthemuptofullvalueonDraftDayasif"winningajob"istheonlyprerequisitetofull-seasonsuccess.Thisalsogoesbacktothesmallsamplesizediscussion.YourNo.4startingpitchergetsofftoaridiculouslygoodstart.Despitethefactthathisskillshavenotchangedsubstantiallyandhisrecentsuccessisagainstweakcompetition,yourefusetoentertaintradeoffers,becauseheisdoingwellNOW.Whatifhekeepsitup?AreyoucontractinganacutecaseofFearofMissingOut?Manyofthesepsychologicalpotholesareinterrelated.Theyareallobstaclestosuccess. I'vehadit.Ifyoucan'ttrustthenumbers,themarketplaceorourowndecision-
making,wheredoesthatleaveus?Thereisanotherwayoflookingatit,anotherplacewherewecanputourtrust.Theonlytruthisskill.Wemaynotbeabletotrustprojections,orthemarketplace,orourowncognitivebiases,butwecanstilltrustaplayer'sdemonstratedskills.Fortunatelyforus,theindustry'stopanalystshaveputgreateffortintocreatingaccuratemetricstomeasurethoseskills.Theymaybedescriptivemorethanpredictive,butthat'sjustfine.Wewantdatathatwecancounton.Thenextsteps–thebirthofanewidea–starthere.