roles for mobile technology and self -management in ... · roles for mobile technology and self...
TRANSCRIPT
Rolesformobiletechnologyandself-managementinstrengtheningautonomyinabortioncare
FIAPAC.October2016,Portugal.
DeborahConstant* JaneHarries*KristinaGemzell-Danielsson§CaitlinGerdts#
*Women’sHealthResearchUnit,UniversityofCapeTown,SouthAfrica§KarolinskaInstitutet,Stockholm,Sweden#IbisReproductiveHealth,SanFrancisco,US
Reproductiverightsandabortionlaws@2016
UnitedNationsGeneralCommentNo.22(2016)ontheRighttoSexualandReproductiveHealth:
UNE/C.12/GC/22. 4March2016
Statesarerequiredtotoadoptmeasuresto:
• Liberalizerestrictiveabortionlaws
• Guaranteeaccesstosafeabortionservices
CRR:http://worldabortionlaws.com/map/ Accessed12Sep2016
SA:CTOPA1996
Commonbarrierstoaccesswhereabortionislegal
• Scarcityoftrainedandwillingproviders• Scarcefacilitiesconcentratedinurbancenters
• Over-medicalizationofprocedures– multiplevisits,ultrasoundexaminations
• Lackofinformationandsupportsystemsesp.forpoorer,hardtoreach
women
• Shortagesofhealthcareprofessionalswillworsenincomingyearsesp.inLMICs- tasksharingcomponentsofabortioncare(WHO,2015)
• Wherewomenhaveaccuratesourceofinformation• WherewomenhaveaccesstoaHCPifneeded• Wheremifepristoneandmisoprostolareused• Usingpregnancytestsandchecklists
WHO:Health workerrolesinproviding safeabortion careandpost-abortion contraception. 2015
Tasksharingmedicalabortion:self-management(WHO2015)
Internationalagencies
Users
Businesses(Telecoms)
Healthcareprofessionals
Governmentbodies
Researchers
Mobiletechnologyandhealth:therolepayersmHealth:Theuseofmobiletechnologytosupportmedicalandpublichealthcarepractice
Challenges:coordinationbetweenroleplayerswhosecultures,objectivesandtraditionsaredifferent
FeasibilityofmHealthintheSouthAfricansetting:ThereachofmHealth
Source:GSMAmhealth:mhealth feasibility SouthAfrica2014
2014: Surveyofurbanlow-incomesuburbnearCapeTown(clinicattendees)
• 89%ownaphone
• 49% havesmartphoneoperability
• 75% don’tsharetheirphoneKhayelitsha mobilehealth phoneusesurvey.MSF,2014
mHealthintheSouthAfricansetting:phoneusageandpreferredmodalityforhealthinformation(clinicattendees)
Khayelitsha mobilehealth phoneusesurvey.MSF,2014
Autonomyinsafeabortioncare
How:MA orSA?
IFMA -Where:clinicorhome?
IFMA -Support:
In whatform?
Autonomy:• choice• self-sufficiency
Riskmanagement/supportifwantedorneeded
Healthcareprovider?Helplines?TextMessaging?
mHealthforabortion:self-assessingeligibility
i calculatestudy:Exploredacceptability&usabilityofonlinewebsitetoself-assesseligibilityforMA(gestationalagecalculator+prompts+questions)
Self-assessingeligibility:i calculatestudy
Mainfindings:• MostlyaccuraterecallofLMP,butsomeextremeoutliers
• Calendarpromptswerehelpfulfor43%ofthoseuncertainaboutLMPdate
• Most(91%)foundcalculatoreasytouse
• Most(94%)thoughtwebsitecouldbehelpfulwhenconsideringabortion
2.mHealthforabortion:SMSsupportwhileself-managingMAwithoutprovidersupport
• SouthAfrica(2011/12,2014/15)RCTs13timed,automatedSMSssentover2weeksremindersaboutprocess,S&Sofcomplications-mostlyverywellliked
• Indonesia(2014)IDIs– infavour ofsmartphoneappforinformationonsafeabortionandreminders
• Cambodia(2014/15)RCT- 80%infavour of SMSforsupport,remindersandself-assessment
Hihopeyou'regood.Youmaystillbespotting(abitofbleeding orbrownbits).Ifyou'rebleedinglikeanormalperiodormore,tell yourclinicprovideraboutthis
Day13
Constant etalContraception 2014, Gerdts etalAPHA2014, Gerdts etal(inprep)
SMSsupport(SA;2011/2012RCT)Outcomesatfollow-upclinicvisit
0102030405060708090100
Bleeding Pain Sideeffects Process
InterventionN=197ControlN=184
Interventio
n
Control
%ofwomenverywellpreparedfor:OR:2.9
(1.62to5.07)
OR:1.6
(1.02to2.59)
OR:1.8
(1.07to2.89)
OR:2.7
(1.20to6.04)
“Ialwaysknewwhat isgoingtohappensothatkeptmegoingbecauseifitwasnotfortheSMSsIwouldhavecomebackafter2days.SotheyhelpedmealotbecauseIdidn'tevencalltheclinic.Theyweremyhope.”
“SometimestheSMSscomfortedme.IfelttheSMSsunderstoodwhat Iwasgoingthrough.Feltlikeafriend
“comforted&calmedme&theyalsokeptmealerted”(27yr.old,nopriorMA,1child,unemployed) “theyhelpmetocalmdown,hadnoonetotalk
to”(33yr.old,1priorMA,2children,unemployed)
2014/2015
2011/2012
SMSsupportfeedback(SA;2014/20152011/2012)• 4%: SMSfailurerate• 96%:SMSswerehelpful/veryhelpfulinmanagingMAathome• 25%: Hadconcernaboutphoneprivacy
Othersettings:useofmobileandinformation& communicationtechnologyinstrengtheningautonomyinabortioncare
Remotefollow-upusingphonecalls/textmessagestowomen’smobilephones.UK(RUOK?,2014)RCT:mostpreferphoneFU
Remoteprovisionandfollow-upusingtelemedicine(provisionofMAatadistanceusingICT)
Directtopatient–• WOW- onlineconsultationandhelplineifneeded• Canada,Australia– localscreening,remoteconsultation,drugs/prescriptionmailed• ToberesearchedinUSIowamodel(US)- localscreening,remoteconsultation,drugsprovidedatclinicGrossmanDetal.ObstetricsandGynecology.2011
3.Self-assessingcompletenessofabortionoutcome(supportedbymHealth)Background
2011: Symptomhistoryaloneunreliabletodetectongoingpregnancy
2012– 2016:US,Vietnam,Moldova,Tunisia– Multi-levelurinepregnancytest:somedifficultieswithinterpretationoftest- interpretation?repeatedtest
2012– 2015:Europe,UK,India:Low-sensitivityurinepregnancytest:Simpletest,butoccasionalfalsenegativeresults,one-offtest
2014-2016:SouthAfricanstudyusingnew checkToP® Lowsensitivityurinepregnancytest(LSUPT) Rapidtest,detects≥1000mIU/mLhCGinurine
Studyrationale
Somedifficultiesidentifiedinearlierstudieswithrespecttothemulti-levelandlow-sensitivityurinepregnancytests
StudyQuestions:
• Can/WillwomenattendingpublicsectorprimarylevelabortionfacilitiesinSouthAfricausethetestcorrectly(storage,steps,timing)?
• Canwomeninterpretthetestresults(faintlines?)
• Dowomenwanttoself-assessorreturntoclinic?
Materialsandmethods• Anon-inferiorityRCTin6publicsectorprimarylevelabortionclinics,SA.• Studyarms:Guideddemonstrationvs.instruction-onlyonLSUPT• Inferioritymarginsetat6%.
• Primaryoutcome:Accurateassessmentofmedicalabortionoutcome.IncompleteMA:requiringadditionalmedicalorsurgicalintervention.
• Eligibilitycriteria:18+years,confirmedintra-uterinepregnancyupto63days,willingtoreceiveabortion-relatedtextmessagesontheirphone.
StudyaimToevaluateaccuracyofself-assessmentofmedicalabortionusingthecheckToP® low–sensitivitypregnancytest(LSUPT),combinedwithachecklistandphonetextmessages.
•Baselineinterview
•Standardcare:MedicalabortionIntervention
•AutomatedtimedreminderSMSs•Self-AssessmentwithcheckToP®LSUPTandchecklist
•Standardcare:In-clinicproviderassessment
• Follow-upinterview
Studymethods:procedures
Results:In-clinicproviderassessmentat2wk.followup:DemonstrationvsInstruction-only
91%
1% 3% 5%
91%
1% 4% 4%0%
10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%
100%
Completeabortion
Ongoingpregnancy
Incompleteabortion(MVA)
Incompleteabortion
(misoprostol)
Demonstration
Instruction
Results:PrimaryOutcome:Accurateself-assessmentofMAoutcome
Results:Preferredmethodoffollow-upDemonstrationvsInstruction-only
2%
1%
1%
5%
91%
0%
1%
0%
1%
4%
93%
1%
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
In-clinicassessment
LSUPTONLY*
LSUPT+checklist*
LSUPT+SMSs*
LSUPT+checklist+SMSs*
LSUPT+checklist+SMSs**
Demonstration
Instruction
*AndvisittheclinicifIneedto**AndcalltheclinicifIneedto
Conclusionsandrecommendations
üNon-Inferiorityof instruction comparedtodemonstration isinconclusive.Simulateddemonstrationcanberecommended
ü Carefulcounsellingisneededtoensurenoongoingpregnanciesaremissed.
ü Women’schoiceforassessmentofmedicalabortionistheLSUPT+checklist+SMSs
ü SMSsareanalternativeeffectivewayofsupportingwomenandmanagingriskincaseofcomplicationsorofongoingpregnancy
Whatnow?• EngagementwithSRHNGOsonimplementingmhealthprograms✓✓
• IterativeimprovementofSMSsassupportandriskmanagementplan✓
• Alignmentwithcountrymhealthstrategyforscale-up
• StakeholderengagementtoextendMAbeyond63daysinpublicsector
• StakeholderengagementtoapproveimplementationofLSUPTinpublic
sector
• Acknowledgements:Exelgyn,fieldworkers,participants
• Funding:SAAF,WHO,IPAS