risk characterization, george gray
TRANSCRIPT
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Risk Perception and Communication
George Gray
Center for Risk Science and Public Health Department of Environmental and Occupational Health
Milken Institute School of Public Health
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Risk Communication
• Risk communication is successful only to the extent that it raises the level of understanding of relevant issues or actions and satisfies those involved that they are adequately informed within the limits of available knowledge.
• Risk communication is a component of risk management. Successful risk communication does not guarantee that risk management decisions will maximize general welfare; it only ensures that decision makers will understand what is known about the implications for welfare and the available options.
Source: NRC-NAS (1989) Improving Risk Communication
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Risk Communication
• A risk communication process that disseminates accurate information is not successful unless the potential recipients achieve a sufficient understanding. The recipient of the information must be able to achieve a complete understanding of the information he/she desires.
• Risk communication is more than one-way transmission of expert knowledge to the uninformed. Messages about expert knowledge are necessary to the risk communication process; they are not sufficient, however, for the process to be successful.
Source: NRC-NAS (1989) Improving Risk Communication
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
The Importance of Risk Communication
• Inform people to make sound choices about risk
• Help build understanding for social efforts to manage risks
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Perceptions of Environmental Quality
• Thinking about the nation as a whole, do you believe that America’s air quality is better than, worse than, or about the same as it was in 1970 when the Clean Air Act was enacted? • Better 29% • Worse 38% • About the Same 31% • Don’t Know/Refused 2%
N=1000 Source: Foundation for Clean Air Progress
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Air Quality Trends According data from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency* between 1970 and 2003:
• Nitrogen oxide emissions have declined by 17%
• Sulfur dioxide emissions have declined by 49%
• Lead emissions have declined by 98%
• Carbon monoxide emissions have declined by 41%
• Volatile organic compounds have declined by 48%,
• Particulate emissions from combustion declined by 82%
*Source: http://www.epa.gov/airtrends
In the same period:
• U.S. population grew by 42%, to 291 million
• Overall energy consumption grew by 43%, to 97.351 trillion btu.
• Total U.S. employment grew by 95%, to 138 million.
• The number of registered vehicles grew by 111%, to 235 million
• Annual Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) grew by 151%, to 2.8 trillion miles
• “Real” Gross Domestic Product (GDP) grew by 175%, to $10.381 trillion.
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
What is Your Perception? Q Which has caused more cancer deaths in the last 50
years? Nuclear Radiation
The Sun
A Each year, just in the US, there are 1.3 million cases of skin cancer, almost all from the sun. 7,800 people die of melanoma each year. In 60 years since Hiroshima and Nagasaki about 500 cancer deaths. No other radiation release is linked to increased cancer deaths, including TMI and Chernobyl (although up to 4000 predicted by WHO)
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
What is Your Perception?
Q Which is responsible for a greater proportion of human cancer?
Alcohol consumption
Environmental pollution
A The Harvard Center for Cancer Prevention suggests alcohol responsible for 3% of human cancer versus < 2% for pollution
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Consequences of Misperception of Risk?
• Influences efforts to protect self and family
• Sources of risk compete for attention and resources • Diet • Accidents (smoke detectors) • Environmental risks
• Individuals play role in social decisions about risk
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Factors Influencing Risk Perception
Quantitative Dimensions
How big is the risk? How does it compare to other risks?
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Science Matters
• Sound communication requires good information • Size of a risk • Sources of the risk • Possible risk management options
• Decisions made solely on the basis of perception can increase, rather than decrease, risk
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Communicating Science
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Factors Influencing Risk Perception*
Qualitative Attributes
What else do I know about the risk that influences my perception?
* Throughout this presentation many examples are taken from 1) Kahneman, Slovic and Tversky (1982); 2) Morgan and Henrion (1990) and 3) Ropeik, D. (2010) How Risky Is It, Really?: Why Our Fears Don't Always Match the Facts. McGraw Hill.
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Thinking About Risk
• Biases and Heuristics – Making decisions under uncertainty
• Risk Perception – How do we “feel” about risks?
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Judgments Under Uncertainty
• When faced with uncertainty (risk) people rely on a limited number of “rules of thumb” or heuristics in making judgments
• Judgments under uncertainty may be subject to manipulation through framing effects
• Heuristics often valuable and useful - but sometimes mislead
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Some Heuristics
• Representativeness
• Availability
• Anchoring and adjustment
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Representativeness
• When judging the likelihood that an object (or idea) belongs to a certain class, or is generated by a certain process, people look for the characteristics of the general class in the specific example
• Which is more likely result from 8 flips of a fair coin?
• H T H T T H T H • H H H H T T T T
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Representativeness • Another bias related to representativeness is an insensitivity to sample size.
A town is served by two hospitals. In the larger hospital about 45 babies are born each day, and in the smaller about 15 are born. As you know, about 50% of all babies are girls. However, the exact percentage varies from day to day. For a period of one year, each hospital recorded the days on which more than 60% of babies born were girls. Which hospital do you think recorded more such days?
The Larger Hospital The Smaller Hospital About the Same (within 5% of each other)
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Representativeness
• 95 undergraduates asked the hospital question
The Larger Hospital (21) The Smaller Hospital (21) About the Same (within 5% of each other) (53)
• Here, likelihood of a sample result is often judged by the similarity to the overall population result regardless of the size of the sample
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Availability • Occurs when people judge the probability of an
event by the ease with with they can recall similar events
• Older people may overestimate the probability of heart attacks because they can more easily recall them in their circle of acquaintances
• Younger people may overestimate the probability of car accidents which are more common with less experienced drivers
• Botulism deaths more widely reported than strokes
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Estimation of Annual Fatalities
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Availability Other biases of availability: • salience - stronger memory increases the judged
likelihood or recent events found more available than past
• effectiveness of a search set - people often undertake mental "search" to find relevant information.
"If I sample a random word (>3 letters) in the English language, is it more likely that the word starts with r or has r as the third letter?"
since it is easier to think of words beginning with r, most respondents judge this more likely. It is not.
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Anchoring and Adjustment
• People often form quantitative judgments starting with a first value that is adjusted with supplementary information.
• Anchors are often biased
• Adjustments are often too small
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Anchoring and Adjustment
• People were asked to estimate the number of African nations that are in United Nations.
• First, a wheel of fortune (with numbers from 1 to 100) was spun in the subject's presence. Wheel designed to always stop at either 10 or 65
starting point median estimate 10 25 65 45
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Anchoring in Estimates of Annual Deaths
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Anchoring When Time is Limited
• Please estimate within 5 seconds the result of the following numerical expression:
Sample A 1 x 2 x 3 x 4 x 5 x 6 x 7 x 8
Sample B 8 x 7 x 6 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1
• Median response • Group A 512 • Group B 2,250
Correct answer - 40,320
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
The Classic Perceived-Risk Model Familiarity
High
High
Source: Slovic (1987)
Public Outrage
Dread
Low
Low
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
What Influences Dread?
Fatal Global Impact
Involuntary Uncontrollable
Unfair Catastrophic
Future Generations Increasing Not Easily Reduced
Not Fatal
Not Global Impact
Voluntary
Controllable Fair
Individuals Only Current
Generation
Decreasing
Easily Reduced
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
What Influences Familiarity?
Observable
Known to Exposed
Immediate Effect
Old Risk
Known to Science
Not Observable
Unknown to Exposed
Delayed Effect
New Risk
Unknown to Science
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Other Factors
Man-Made
Children at Risk
Untrustworthy Institutions
Media Focus
Identifiable Victims
Suppressed Data
Natural
Only Adults at Risk
Trustworthy Institutions
Media Neglect
Statistical Victims
Accessible Data
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Probability of Occurrence is Not the Only Concern
not observable unknown to those exposed
effect delayed/ new risk
risks unknown to science
observable known to those exposed
effect immediate old risk
risks known to science
controllable not dread not globally catastrophic consequence not fatal equitable individual low risk to future generations easily reduced risk decreasing voluntary
uncontrollable dread
globally catastrophic consequence fatal
not equitable catastrophic
high risk to future generations not easily reduced
risk increasing involuntary
Slovic, P. Science 236:280-285
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
RISK VS. BENEFIT?
• Vaccinations • Artificial sweeteners • Mammography and diagnostic X rays • Prescription drugs • Skiing
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Lessons
Quantitative Dimensions
Qualitative Attributes
• People have difficulty making judgments under uncertainty and use heuristics to help
• Many factors have been suggested to influence perception but prediction is difficult
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
No Shortage of Risks
Center for Risk Science and Public Health
Why Does This Matter?
• We make judgments about personal risks every day
• Public views on risk influence social risk management decisions
• There are real public health consequences to the “risk perception gap”