richard gardner - opinions of child abuse

8/9/2019 Richard Gardner - Opinions of Child Abuse

1/12

Mjx l{slc {if 4essq?))www*jcbb*i{g)q|kdmhbsmijx)jlwxdlssl{x)|qcbslYpid|flY20Yj|fkl{Y0Y;118*esfd:

\qcbsl & Pid|fl 20$ J|fkl{ 0$ ;118

Qb{ljsbd Bdmljbsmij X}jc{ifl? Webs Q{i`lxxmijbdx Jllc si Njiw

Qb{s 2 i` ;K} L{mnb [mpl{b [bgdbjc2 & Eiql @mldcx;

Mjs{ic|hsmij

^sVel qb{ljsbd bdmljbsmij x}jc{ifl mx b hemdceiic cmxi{cl{ sebs b{mxlx bdfixs luhd|xmpld} mj sel hijslus i`hemdc&h|xsic} cmxq|slx* Msx q{mfb{} fbjm`lxsbsmij mx sel hemdcx hbfqbmgj i` cljmg{bsmij bgbmjxs b qb{ljs$ bhbfqbmgj sebs ebx ji o|x sm mhbsmij* Ms {lx|dsx {if sel hifkmjbsmij i` b q{ig{bf fmjg %k{bmjwbxemjg-qb{ljsx mjcihs{mjbsmijx bjc sel hemdcx iwj hijs{mk|smijx si sel pmdm`mhbsmij i` sel sb{gls qb{ljs* Welj s{|lqb{ljsbd bk|xl bjc)i{ jlgdlhs mx q{lxljs$ sel hemdcx bjmfixms} fb} kl o|xsm`mlc bjc xi sel qb{ljsbdbdmljbsmij x}jc{ifl luqdbjbsmij i{ sel hemdcx eixsmdms} mx jis bqqdmhbkdl*8

Sel dbsl C{* [mheb{c Gb{cjl{$ b hdmjmhbd q{i`lxxi{ i` Qx}hembs{} bs Hid|f kmb \jmpl{xms}$ himjlc Qb{ljsbd BdmljbsmijX}jc{ifl %QBX- mj 2=5


2/12

hbqbkdl i` dljcmjg msxl d` si eb{c cbsb i{ mjhd|xmij mj sel i{sehifmjg CXF&P*Mj xei{s$ QBX mx bj |jslxslc seli{} sebs$ |jhebddljglc$ hbj ebpl b{ &{lbhemjg hijxlr|ljhlx i{ hemdc{lj xllnmjgq{islhsmij bjc dlgbd pmjcmhbsmij mj hi|{sx i` dbw*Q{ixlh|si{x bjc isel{ hemdc bk|xl q{i`lxxmijbdx xei|dc lc|hbsl selfxldplx$ selm{ hiddlbg|lx bjc hdmljsx weljhij`{ijsmjg QBX mj sel dlgbd {lbdf* Qb{s ; i` semx jlwxdlssl{ wmdd bcc{lxx sel hbxl dbw ij semx x|kolhs* @i{ fi{l mj &clqse bjc hifq{leljxmpl s{lbsfljs i` selxl mxx|lx$ hijsbhs sel Jbsmijbd Hljsl{ i{ Q{ixlh|smij i` Hemdc Bk|xl*

2 Xsb`` B ssi{jl}$ Bfl{mhbj Q{ixlh|si{x [lxlb{he Mjxsms|sl$ Jbsmijbd Hljsl{ ì{ Q{ixlh|smij i` Hemdc Bk|xl*; Xsb`` Bssi{jl}$ Bfl{mhbj Q{ixlh|si{x [lxlb{he Mjxsms|sl$ Jbsmijbd Hljsl{ ì{ Q{ixlh|smij i` Hemdc Bk|xl*8 [mheb{c B* Gb{cjl{$ F*C*$ Cilx sel CXFMP Ebpl Lr|mpbdljsx ì{ sel Qb{ljsbd Bdmljbsmij X}jc{ifl %QBX- Cmbgjixmx9

Bfl{mhbj Oi|{jbd i` @bfmd} Sel{bq}$ 82%2-?2;2> bdxi bpbmdbkdl$ essq?))ww w*{gb{cjl{*hif){l`x)b{2;*esfd*3 [mheb{c B* Gb{cjl{$ F*C*$ Sel Qb{ljsbd Bdmljbsmij X}jc{ifl$ bs


3/12

JBSMIJBDCMXS[MHSBSSI[JL]XBXXIHMBSM

IJ

BQ[MEIFL

t Bki|sBQ[MtHijsbhsBQ[M

Xlb{he t Xmsl

Fbq t Lpljsx tLc|hbsmij t

Lfqdi}fljs

\qcbsl & Pid|fl 20$ J|fkl{ 7$ ;118

Qb{ljsbd Bdmljbsmij X}jc{ifl? Webs Q{i`lxxmijbdx

Jllc si Njiw

Qb{s ; i` ;K} Eiql @mldcx2 & L{mnb [mpl{b [bgdbjc;Mjs{ic|hsmijQb{ljsbd Bdmljbsmij X}jc{ifl %QBX- ebx h{lbslc ikx sbhdlx i{ hemdc bk|xlq{ixlh|si{x* Ms mx h{|hmbd i{ hemdc bk|xl q{ixlh|si{x si |jcl{xsbjc selseli{} i` QBX$ bjc njiw eiw si klxs hebddljgl msx dlgmsmfbh} mj hi|{s* Qb{s2 i` semx b{smhdl bcc{lx xlc sel QBX seli{} bjc msx mjel{ljs dbwx*8 Wl jiws|{j si sel hi|{sx bqq{ibhelx si QBX$ bjc q{iqix l b{g|fljsx bjc

flseicx si x|qq{lxx semx |j{ldmbkdl lpmcljhl*Hbxl Dbw Xsbs|xQBX ebx kllj {lhlmplc cm``l{ljsd} k} h{mfmjbd bjc hmpmd hi|{sx* Eiwlpl{$cl`ljcbjsx c{bw {if kise hmpmd bjc h{mfmjbd iqmjmijx mj h{b smjg b{g|fljsx`i{ bcfmssmjg QBX bx xhmljsm`mh lpmcljhl mj hemdc bk|x l hbxlx * Sel{l`i{l$ msmx mf qi{sbjs i{ q{ixlh|si{x si kl bwb{l i` kise h{mfmjbd bjc hmpmd dbw weljq{lqb{mjg b x|qq{lxxmij b{g|fljs* QBX ebx kllj bcc{lxxlc mj b lwh{mfmjbd hbxlx bjc bqq{iumfbsld} m`s} hmpmd hbx lx mj hi|{sx i` {lhi{c*H{mfmjbd Hbxl Dbw3Mj 2==


4/12

Hbdmì{jmb Hi|{s i` Bqqlbdx eldc sebs sel cl`ljcbjs$ hijpmhslc i` xlu|bdbxxb|ds bjc dlwc bjc dbxhmpmi|x bhsx ij b hemdc$ ebc jis kllj clq{mplc ièmx c|l q{ihlx x {mgesx k} sel s{mbd hi|{sx {l`|xbd si bddiw emx luql{s si slx sm }{lgb{cmjg QBX*5 Bfijg sel {lbx ijx i{ b``m{fmjg sel s{mbd hi|{sx clhmx mijwbx sel clsl{fmjbsmij sebs bj |jcl{x sbjcmjg i` sel QBX seli{} wbx jiskl}ijc hiffij luql{mljhl bjc sebs QBX lpmcljhl mx jis xhmljsm`mh lji|gesi flls sel Nldd}&@{}l lpmcljsmb{} xsbjcb{c*Hmpmd Hbxl DbwLpmcljhl i` Qb{ljsbd Bdmljbsmij X}jc{ifl mx bcfm sslc fi{l {lr|ljsd} mjhmpmd hbxlx sebj mj h{mfmjbd hi|{s* QBX lpmcljhl ebx kllj bcfmsslc mj hbxlxmjpidpmjg h|xsic} clsl{fmjbsmijx bjc mx |x |bdd} mjs{ic|hlc mj bj bsslfqs sixeiw sebs ijl qb{ljs$ mj cljmg{bsmjg sel isel{ qb{ljs mj sel q{lxljhl i` selhemdc$ ebx hb|xlc sebs hemdc si luq{lxx cm xsbxsl bjc)i{ ebs{lc i{ sebs isel{

qb{ljs*=Xsbslx bqq{ibhelx si QBX lpmcljhl pb{}* B `lw x sbslx ebpl bddiwlc QBXlpmcljhl si kl bcfmsslc mj hmpmd h|xsic} hbxlx*21 Isel{ hi|{sx$ weljhij`{ijslc wmse QBX$ ebpl cmxh|xx lc ms i{ bddiwlc xif l lpmcljhl i` ms wemdllfqebxmzmjg sebs x|he cmx h|xxmij cmc jis hifq{mxl bj lpbd|bsmij i` seldlgmsmfbh} i` QBX seli{}*22Hebddljgmjg QBX LpmcljhlCb|kl{s2; bjc @{}l28 b{l sel fixs q{ifmjljs hbxlx clbdmjg wmsebcfmxxmkmdms} i` xhmljsm`mh lpmcljhl bjc luql{s slxsmfij}* Wemdl cm``l{ljs

o|{mxcmhsmijx lfqdi} cm` l{ljs bcfmx xmkmdms} xsbjcb{cx$ sel{l b{l b j|fkl{ i``bhsi{x sebs hbj hijs{mk|sl {ldlpbjs mjì{fbsmij si bj} bcf mxx mkmdms}lpbd|bsmij* @m{xs$ lpmcljhl i` b x hmljsm`mh seli{} mx fi{l dmnld} si kl bcfm sslcmj hi|{s m` sel slhejmr|lx |jcl{d}mjg sebs seli{} ebpl kllj slxslc bjc m` bjl{{i{ {bsl ebx kllj clsl{fmjlc* Sel seli{} i` QBX cilx jis lf qdi} bj}bxx lxxbkdl slhejmr|l k|s {bsel{$ bx xsbslc mj sel Qb{s 2 i` semx b{smhdl$ ms mxkbxlc |qij bjlhcisbd lpmcljhl sebs wbx ql{xijbdd} ikxl{plc bjc {lqi{slck} C{* Gb{cjl{* Bx b {lx|d s$ sel bhh|{bh} i` QBX seli{} ebx jis kllj{mgi{i|x d} xs|cmlc bjc pl{m`mlc* Xlhijc$ sel {ldmbkmdm s} i` xhmljsm`mh lpmcljhl

mx fi{l lbxm d} lpbd|bslc welj ms ebx kllj x|kolhs si qll{ {lpmlw* Bxq{lpmi|xd} mjcmhbslc$ Gb{cjl{ q|kdmxelc emx iwj wi{n bjc emx w{msmjgx wl{ljis {lr|ljsd} x|kolhslc si xhmljsm`mh qll{ {lpmlwx *Q{ixlh|si{x x ei|dc cmdmgljsd} r|lx smij bj} hbxl dbw i{ b{smhdl sebs mx hmslcbx x|qqi{smjg QBX seli{}* Xifl Wlk xmslx sebs cmxh|xx QBX {l l{ si hbxldbw bx x|qqi{smjg sel {ldmbkmdms} i` QBX seli{}$ k|s sel iqmjmijx mj selxlhmslc hbxlx b{l i`slj jis bclr|bsld} luqdbmjlc i{ sel} q{ipl si kl dlxxx|qqi{smpl i` QBX seli{} sebj b{g|lc* Q{ixlh|si{x {lpmlwmjg dmsl{bs|{l sebsmx {l`l{ljhlc bx qix msmpl ij QBX xei|dc xh{|smjmzl ms hb{l`|dd}*23Q{ihlc|{bd B{g|fljsxSel xs{ijglx s q{ihlc|{bd b{g|f ljs bgbmjxs bcfmxxmij i` QBX lpmcljhl pmxb pmx luql{s slxsmfij} mx sebs ms mjpbclx sel q{ipmjhl i` sel o|{}* Fixs xsbslxci jis bddiw luql{sx si i``l{ bj iqmjmij ij sel |dsmfbsl mxx |l i` bhs bx siwelsel{ sel xlu|bd bk|xl ebx ihh|{{lc*2< Mj seixl xsbslx$ q{ixlh|si{xxei|dc b{g|l sebs bddiwmjg b QBX luql{s si slxsm`} sebs sel bddlgbsmijx b{ix li|s i` b xi|{ {ldbsmijxemq klswllj qb{ljsx ql{fmsx sebs luql{s si slx sm`} bxsi sel |dsmfbsl mxx|l i` sel hbxl*Q{ixlh|si{x mj o|{mxcmhsmijx sebs ebpl bciqslc sel @lcl{bd [|dlx i`

Lpmcljhl hbj b{g|l i{ luhd|xmij i` QBX lpmcljhl |jcl{ swi {|dlx* @m{xs$|jcl{ {|dl 213%b-$ b s{mbd o|cgl f|x s fbnl b q{ldmfmjb{} bxx lxxfljs i`welsel{ sel {lbxijmjg i{ flseicidig} |jcl{d}mjg sel slxsmfij} mxxhmljsm`mhbdd} pbdmc*20 QBX mx jis kbx lc ij bj lbx md} b{smh|dbkdlflseicidig} sebs hbj kl bx xlx xlc i{ xhmljsm`mh pbdmcms} bjc$ hijxlr|ljsd}$q{ixlh|si{x xei|dc b{g|l sebs ms bmdx lplj si qbx x sel q{ldmfmjb{}bxx lxxfljs i{ pbdmcms}*Xlhijc$ {|dl 318 xsbslx sebs lpmcljhl xei|dc kl luhd|clc welj selq{ikbsmpl pbd|l mx i|swlmgelc k} sel cbjgl{ i` |j`bm{ q{lo|cmhl*27 Sel{l mxb qixxmkmdms} sebs sel o|{} wmdd xll sel hi|{sx bhhlqsbjhl i` cl`ljcbjsx QBXluql{s bx b clsl{f mjbsmij sebs sel slxsmfij} q{lxljslc k} sel luql{s{lq{lxljsx xifl xhmljsm`mh s{|se* Q{ixlh|si{x xei|dc b{g|l sebs ms mx wmsemjsel hiffij luql{mljhl i` o|{i{x si hijslfqdbsl sel qixx mkmdms} sebs sel jij&bhh|xlc qb{ljs qdbjslc mclbx m j sel hemdcx elbc* R|bdm`}mjg bj luql{s sislxsm`} bki|s QBX h{lbslx sel {mxn sebs sel o|{} wmdd qdbhl sii f|he lfqebxmxbjc {ldmbjhl ij QBX lpmcljhl*X|kxsbjsmpl B{g|fljsxB x}jc{ifl mx b g{i|q i` x}fqsifx sebs bqqlb{ si ihh|{ siglsel{*25

Eiwlpl{$ sel hb|x l i` sel x }fqsif x mx i`slj |jnjiwj i{ qii{d}|jcl{x siic$ wemdl sel hb|xl i ` b cmxlbxl$ k} hijs{bxs$ mx |x |bdd} njiwj*2=Ms mx qix xmkdl i{ b x}jc{ifl si mjcmhbsl b x s{ijg {ldbsmijxemq klswllj bhb|xl bjc b x ls i` x}fqsifx$ k|s lbhe x}jc{ifl bddx mj b cm``l{ljs qdbhlbdijg sel hijsmj||f i` hl{sbmjs}* Sel hijsmj||f mx b hijhlqs sebs luqdbmjxsel xs{ljgse bjc {ldmbkmdms} i` sel x|qqixlc {ldbsmijxemq*;1Xifl x}jc{iflx b{l jijcmbgjixsmh$ wemhe flbjx sebs sel} ci jis qimjs siqb{smh|db{ hb|xlx * QBX mx b jijcmbgjixsmh x}jc{ifl*;2 Se|x$ wemdl bjluql{s hbj b{g|l sel dlgmsmfbh} i` sel seli{mlx |jcl{d}mjg QBX$ sel luql{smx jis bkdl si qimjs si b qb{smh|db{ hb|xl i` sel x}jc{ifl wm se hl{sbmjs}*Lplj m` hi|{sx {lolhs b{g|f ljsx {lgb{cmjg |j{ldmbkmdms}$ q{ixlh|si{x xei|dc{lfbmj bh|sld} bwb{l i` eiw sel lpmcljhl mx kl mjg q{lxljslc* M` sel luql{smx i``l{mjg bj iqmjmij {lgb{cmjg sel hb|xl i` sel x}jc{ifl$ q{ixlh|si{xxei|dc ikolhs si sel mfq{iql{ |xl i` sel lpmcljhl*R|mhn Smqx ì{ Hebddljgmjg QBX Lpmcljhl

Sel{l b{l fbj} semjgx sebs q{ix lh|si{x hbj ci si hebddljgl QBX lpmcljhlmj hemdc bk|xl hbxlx ?

\j`mdlc Jislx Qbgl 3


5/12

Hebddljgl |jcl{ Cb|kl{s)@{}l* B{g|l sebs QBX lpmcljhl cilx jisflls sel lpmcljsmb{} xsbjcb{c mj }i|{ o|{mx cmhsmij*

Njiw xsbsmxsmhx bjc xs|cmlx* Xsbsmxsmhx bki|s bdxl {lqi{smjg b{lbpbmdbkdl se{i|ge sel Jbsmijbd Hljsl{ i{ sel Q{ixlh|smij i` HemdcBk|xl %JHQHB- i{ {if sel Jbsmijbd Hdlb{mjgei|xl ij Hemdc Bk|xlbjc Jlgdlhs Mjì{fbsmij bsessq?))jhhbjhe*bh`*eex*gip*

Njiw qx}heidigmhbd c}jbfmhx i` hemdc bk|xl* B{f }i|{xld` wmsemjì{fbsmij bki|s hemdc bk|xl cmxhdix|{lx* Dlb{j sel qx}heidigmhbdq{ihlxx i` cmxhdix|{l$ sel xmgjm`mhbjhl mj sel smfmjg i` cmxhdix|{lx${lhbjsbsmij$ bjc q{iql{ q{ihlc|{lx i{ hijc|hsmjg i{ljxmhmjsl{pmlwx*;;

Xeb{l mjì{fbsmij*Xeb{l }i|{ fismijx $ k{ml`x$ bjc s{bjxh{mqsx wmse

isel{ q{ixlh|si{x * H{lbsl hljs{bd mdlx mj sel i``mhl xi isel{q{ixlh|si{x ci jis ebpl si {lmjpljs sel welld *

W{msl sel BQB* Xljc b dlssl{ si sel Bfl{mhbj Qx}hembs{mhBxxihmbsmij;8 si cmxhi|{bgl mjhd|xmij i` QBX mj sel CXF&P*

Q{lqb{l }i|{ luql{sx* Flls wmse }i|{ luql{sx klì{l s{mbd si q{lqb{lself i{ sel cl`ljxl luql{s bjc webs }i| bjsmhmqbsl emx i{ el{slxsmfij} wmdd kl*

Hijsbhs sel Jbsmijbd Hljsl{ i{ Q{ixlh|smij i` Hemdc Bk|xl%JHQHB-* Hbdd i{ L&fbmd sel JHQHB wmse r|lx smijx bki|s hemdcbk|xl i{ luql{s slxsmfij}*

Hijhd|xmijQBX mx bj |jq{iplj seli{} sebs hbj se{lbslj sel mjslg{ms} i` sel h{mf mjbd

o|x smhl x}xslf bjc sel xb`ls} i` bk|xlc hemdc{lj* Q{ixlh|si{x xei|dclc|hbsl selfxldplx bki|s QBX bjc kl q{lqb{lc si b{g|l bgbmjx s msxbcfmxxmij mj hi|{s* Mj hbxlx wel{l QBX slxsmfij} mx bcf msslc$ ms mx bq{ixlh|si{x {lxqijxmkmdms} si lc|hbsl sel o|cgl bjc o |{} bki|s sel xei{s`bddxi` semx seli{}* Bx fi{l h{mfmjbd hi|{sx {l`|xl si bcfms QBX lpmcljhl$ fi{l

q{islhsmij wmdd kl b` i{clc si pmhsmfx i` xlu|bd bk|xl mj i|{ hi|{s x}xslf*

2 Xsb`` B ssi{jl}$ Bfl{mhbj Q{ixlh|si{x [lxlb{he Mjxsms|sl$ Jbsmijbd Hljsl{ ì{Q{ixlh|smij i` Hemdc Bk|xl*; Xsb`` B ssi{jl}$ Bfl{mhbj Q{ixlh|si{x [lxlb{he Mjxsms|sl$ Jbsmijbd Hljsl{ ì{Q{ixlh|smij i` Hemdc Bk|xl*8 Xll [bgdbjc$ L{mnb bjc @mldcx$ Eiql$ Qb{ljsbd Bdmljbsmij X}jc{ifl? WebsQ{i` lxxmijbdx Jllc si Njiw $ \qcbsl$ Pid* 20$ Ji* Mj {l X*G*$ ;118 Iemi 202> Hbkis p *Hbkis$ 200 Ps* 35< %2==7-> Mj {l Fb{{mbgl i` Xelj$ ;11; Wbxe* Bqq* DLUMX 217Hijcl p* N{|lgl{$ ;118 Wmxh* Bqq* DLUMX 085*22 Xll H*O*D* p* F*W*K*$ ;118 Bdb* Hmp* B qq* DLUMX 211 %w emdl QBX bcfmsslc bss{mbd$ bqqlddbsl hi|{s mjcmhbslc sebs ms fb} ebpl kllj mjbcfmxxmkdl |jcl{ @{}l->Ql{diw p * Kl{gQl{diw$ 520 Xi* ;c ;21 %@db* Cmxs* Hs* Bqq* ;11;- %ikolhsmij sibcfmxxmij i` QBX mj diw l{ hi|{s jis q{lxl{plc i{ bqqlbd-> Mj Mjsl{lxs i` S*F*W*$ Lddmx p* Lddmx$ 531 Xi*;c 510 %Fmxx* ;118-%QBX lp mcljhl bcfmsslc ijd} w mse b dmfmslc cl`mjmsmij-> O*@* p*D*@*$ 0=3 J*]*X*;c


6/12

25 F}l{x$ Oiej L* K* Lpmcljhl mj Hemdc Bk|xl bjc Jlgdlhs Hbxlx$ Sem{c Lcmsmij$Pid* 2* Oiej Wmdl} & Xijx$ Mjh* Jlw ]i{n$ 2==7*2= Mc* bs


7/12

Ipl{pmlw i` C{* [mheb{c Gb{cjl{'x Iqmjmijx

ijQlciqemdmb bjc Hemdc Xlu|bd Bk|xl

[mheb{c B* Gb{cjl{$ F*C*$ mx sel h{lbsi{ i` sel h{lbsi{ bjc fbmj q{iqijljs i{ Qb{ljsbdBdmljbsmij X}jc{ifl %QBX- seli{}* Q{mi{ si emx x|mhmcl$ Gb{cjl{ wbx bj |jqbmc qb{s smflhdmjmhbd q{i`lxxi{ i` hemdc qx}hembs{} bs sel Hiddlgl i` Qe}xmhmbjx bjc X|{glijx bsHid|fkmb \jmpl{xms} * El fbcl emx fijl} fbmjd} bx b `i{ljxmh luql{s*QBX wbx clpldiqlc k} C{ [mheb{c Gb{cjl{ mj 2=5< kbxlc ij emx ql{xijbd ikxl{pbsmijxbjc wi{n bx bj luql{s wmsjlxx$ i`slj ij klebd` i` `bsel{x bhh|xlc i` fidlxsmjg selm{hemdc{lj* Gb{cjl{ bxxl{slc sebs QBX mx pl{} hiffij bjc el xbw fbjm`lxsbsmijx i` semxx}jc{ifl mj ipl{ =1, i` sel h|xsic} hij`dmhsx el lpbd|bslc lplj welj bk|xl bddlgbsmijxb{l jis {bmxlc %Gb{cjl{$ 2=57$ q* 07-*2 Gb{cjl{ %Xlqslfkl{ 0$ 2==8- hdbmflc sebs QBX mx+b cmxi{cl{ i` hemdc{lj$ b{mxmjg bdfixs luhd|xmpld} mj hemdch|xsic} cmxq|slx$ mj wemhe ijlqb{ljs %|x|bdd} sel fisel{- q{ig{bfx sel hemdc si ebsl sel isel{ qb{ljs %|x|bdd} sel`bsel{-*+;Gb{cjl{ 'x seli{} i` QBX ebx ebc b q{i`i|jc l``lhs ij eiw sel hi|{s x}xslfx mj i|{hi|js{} ebjcdl bddlgbsmijx i` hemdc xlu|bd bk|xl$ lxqlhmbdd} c|{mjg cmpi{hl* Gb{cjl{ ebxb|sei{lc fi{l sebj ;


8/12

Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2=50-* Hemdc H|xsic} Dmsmgbsmij? B G|mcl `i{ Qb{ljsx bjc Fljsbd ElbdseQ{i`lxxmijbdx* H{lxxnmdd$ JO? H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx$ %q* =8-

Mj bccmsmij$ Gb{cjl{ q{iqixlx sebs fbj} cm``l{ljs s}qlx i` e|fbj xlu|bd klebpmi{$mjhd|cmjg qlciqemdmb$ xlu|bd xbcmxf$ jlh{iqemdmb %xlu wmse hi{qxlx-$ ziiqemdmb %xluwmse bjmfbdx-$ hiq{iqemdmb %xlu mjpidpmjg cl`lhbsmij-$ hbj kl xllj bx ebpmjg xqlhmlxx|{pmpbd pbd|l bjc se|x ci +jis wb{{bjs klmjg luhd|clc {if sel dmxs i` sel axi hbddlcjbs|{bd `i{fx i` e|fbj xlu|bd klebpmi{*'+

Xll$ Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==;-* S{|l bjc @bdxl Bhh|xbsmijx i` Hemdc Xlu Bk|xl * H{lxxnmdd$JO? H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx* %qq* 258;-

Gb{cjl{ ij sel xlu|bd bgg{lxxmpljlxx i` hemdc{ljGb{cjl { x|gglxsx sebs hemdc{lj wbjs si ebpl xlu wmse bc|dsx bjc fb} xlc|hl self*Xifl hemdc{lj luql{mljhl + emge xlu|bd |{glx mj lb{d} mj`bjh}* + +Sel{l mx giic {lbxijsi kldmlpl sebs fixs$ m` jis bdd$ hemdc{lj ebpl sel hbqbhms} si {lbhe i{gbxf bs sel smfl sel}b{l ki{j*+

Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==;-* S{|l bjc @bdxl Bhh|xbsmijx i` Hemdc Xlu Bk|xl * H{lxxnmdd$ JO?H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx* %q* 2 sel clsl{fmjbjs bx si welsel{ xlu|bd fidlxsbsmijwmdd kl s{b|fbsmh si sel hemdc$ mx sel xihmbd bssms|cl siwb{c selxl ljhi|jsl{x*

Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==;-* S{|l bjc @bdxl Bhh|xbsmijx i` Hemdc Xlu Bk|xl * H{lxxnmdd$ JO?H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx* %qq* 071 72-

Gb{cjl{ ij sel{bq} wmse hemdc{lj wei b{l xlu|bdd} bk|xlc k}selm{ bsel{

Nllq sel hemdc hijjlhslc si sel bk|xl{Xqlhmbd hb{l xei|dc kl sbnlj jis bdmljbsl sel hemdc `{if sel fidlxsmjg qb{ljs* Sel{lfipbd i` b qlciqemdmh qb{ljs `{if sel eifl +xei|dc ijd} kl xl{mi|xd} hijxmcl{lc b`sl{bdd bsslfqsx bs s{lbsfljs i` sel qlciqemdmb bjc {bqq{ihelfljs wmse sel `bfmd} ebpl q{iplj`|smdl*+

Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==;-* S{|l bjc @bdxl Bhh|xbsmijx i` Hemdc Xlu Bk|xl * H{lxxnmdd$ JO?H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx*%q*


9/12

H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx*%q*


10/12

El ebx ebc kbc d|hn wmse {lgb{c si sel qdbhl bjc smfl el wbx ki{j wmse {lgb{c si xihmbdbssms|clx siwb{c qlciqemdmb* Eiwlpl{$ selxl b{l jis {lbxijx si hijclfj emfxld`*

Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==2-* Xlu Bk|xl E}xsl{mb? Xbdlf Wmshe S{mbdx [lpmxmslc * H{lxxnmdd$ JO?H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx* %q* 22=-

Nllq emf mj sel eiflSel {lfipbd i` b qlciqemdmh qb{ljs `{if sel eifl +xei|dc ijd} kl xl{mi|xd} hijxmcl{lcb`sl{ bdd bsslfqsx bs s{lbsfljs i` sel qlciqemdmb bjc {bqq{ihelfljs wmse sel `bfmd} ebplq{iplj |smdl+

Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==2-* Xlu Bk|xl E}xsl{mb? Xbdlf Wmshe S{mbdx [lpmxmslc * H{lxxnmdd$ JO?H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx* %q* 22=-

Eldq emf q{islhs emfxld`+El f|xs dlb{j si hijs{id emfxld` m` el mx si q{islhs emfxld` `{if sel C{bhijmbjq|jmxefljsx flslc i|s si seixl mj i|{ xihmls} wei bhs i|s selm{ qlciqemdmh mfq|dxlx*+

Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==;-* S{|l bjc @bdxl Bhh|xbsmijx i` Hemdc Xlu Bk|xl * H{lxxnmdd $ JO?H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx* %qq*


11/12

Wei mx si Kdbfl ì{ +Hemdc Bk|xl E}xsl{mb+9

Qliqdl wei pimhl jlgbsmpl `lldmjgx bgbmjxs qlciqemdlx+C|{mjg selm{ eb{bjg|lx bgbmjxs sel 'ql{pl{sx' wei b{l sel ikolhsx i` selm{ xhi{j$ sel} i`slj{mxl si b dlpld i` luhmsbsmij sebs hbj {lbcmd} kl xllj bx xlu|bd* * * * Qx}heidigmhbd$ x|hemjcmpmc|bdx b{l lpl{ `mgesmjg si {lq{lxx selm{ iwj |jbhhlqsbkdl qlciqemdmh mfq|dxlx$ wemheb{l hijsmj|bdd} q{lxxmjg i{ {ldlbxl*+

Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==2-* Xlu Bk|xl E}xsl{mb? Xbdlf Wmshe S{mbdx [lpmxmslc * H{lxxnmdd$ JO?H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx %qq* 8182-*

Sel dlgbd x}xslf & mjhd|cmjg o|cglx+Sel{l mx ji r|lxsmij sebs bk|xl hbxlx b{l +s|{j ijx+ ì{ sel wmcl pb{mls} i` mjcmpmc|bdxmjpidplc mj self$ sel bhh|xl{%x-$ sel q{ixlh|si{x$ sel dbw}l{x$ sel o|cglx $ sellpbd|bsi{x$ sel qx}heidigmxsx$ sel {lqi{sl{x$ sel {lbcl{x i` sel jlwxqbql{x$ bjc lpl{}ijlldxl mjpidplc luhlqs i{ sel bdxld} bhh|xlc bjc sel mjjihljs pmhsmf ** Lpl{}ijl mxglssmjg selm{ 'oiddmlx$ *+

Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==2-* Xlu Bk|xl E}xsl{mb? Xbdlf Wmshe S{mbdx [lpmxmslc * H{lxxnmdd$ JO?H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx* %q* 82-*

+O|cglx * sii fb} ebpl {lq{lxxlc qlciqemdmh mfq|dxlx ipl{ wemhe sel{l mx x|qq{lxxmij${lq{lxxmij$ bjc g|mds* Mjr|m{} mjsi sel clsbmdx i` sel hbxl q{ipmclx pi}l|{mxsmh bjc pmhb{mi|xg{bsm`mhbsmijx ** Mjhb{hl{bsmjg sel bddlglc ql{qls{bsi{ fb} xl{pl qx}heidigmhbdd} siikdmsl{bsl sel o|cgl'x iwj q{iolhslc qlciqemdmh mfq|dxlx*+

Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==2-* Xlu Bk|xl E}xsl{mb? Xbdlf Wmshe S{mbdx [lpmxmslc * H{lxxnmdd$ JO?H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx* %q* 217-

Xlu|bdd} mjemkmslc fisel{x+Sel fisel{ * mx * qx}heidigmhbdd} g{bsm`}mjg êl{ iwj xlu|bdd} mjemkmslc jllcxV wmse selpmx|bd mfbgl{} sebs sel xlu bk|xl bddlgbsmij q{ipmclx*+

Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==2-* Xlu Bk|xl E}xsl{mb? Xbdlf Wmshe S{mbdx [lpmxmslc * H{lxxnmdd$ JO?H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx %qq* 8087-*

G{llc} qb{ljsx+Fbj} b{l pmhsmfx i` selm{ g{llc$ wemhe mx xi lji{fi|x sebs sel} kdmjc selfxldplx si selqx}heidigmhbd s{b|fbx sel} b{l x|kolhsmjg selm{ hemdc{lj si mj sel xl{pmhl i` wmjjmjg

dbwx|msx sebs q{ifmxl self lji{fi|x wlbdse*+Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==2-* Xlu Bk|xl E}xsl{mb? Xbdlf Wmshe S{mbdx [lpmxmslc * H{lxxnmdd$ JO?H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx %q 38-*

O|cli&He{mxsmbj q{mjhmqdlx+Ms mx i` mjsl{lxs sebs i` bdd sel bjhmljs qliqdlx ms fb} pl{} wldd kl sebs sel Olwx wl{lsel ijd} ijlx wei wl{l q|jmsmpl siwb{c qlciqemdlx* * I|{ q{lxljs ipl{{lbhsmij siqlciqemdmb {lq{lxljsx bj lubggl{bsmij i` O|cli He{mxsmbj q{mjhmqdlx bjc mx b xmgjm`mhbjs`bhsi{ iql{bsmpl mj Wlxsl{j xihmls}'x bs}qmhbdms} wmse {lgb{c si x|he bhsmpmsmlx

Gb{cjl{$ [*B* %2==;-* S{|l bjc @bdxl Bhh|xbsmijx i` Hemdc Xlu Bk|xl * H{lxxnmdd$ JO?H{lbsmpl Sel{bql|smhx* %qq* 307-*

@i{ fi{l mjì{fbsmij xll?Cbddbf$ X* O* %2==5-* C{* [mheb{c Gb{cjl{? B {lpmlw i` emx seli{mlx bjc iqmjmijx ijbs}qmhbd xlu|bdms}$ qlciqemdmb$ bjc s{lbsfljs mxx|lx* S{lbsmjg Bk|xl Sicb}$ 5%2-$2


12/12

022$ 02; %H{mf* Hs* ;111-* @i{smjwbx b h{mfmjbd xlu bk|xl hbxl mj wemhe C{* Gb{cjl{i``l{lc si slxsm`} ij klebd` i` sel bhh|xlc fidlxsl{ hijhl{jmjg QBX bjc sel h{lcmkmdms} i`sel hifqdbmjmjg wmsjlxx* Sel hi|{s {l`|xlc si ql{fms emx slxsmfij} klhb|xl i` b `bmd|{l silxsbkdmxe gljl{bd bhhlqsbjhl i` QBX wmsemj sel q{i`lxxmijbd hiff|jms}*-

richard gardner - opinions of child abuse

Documents