review of court documents

7/31/2019 Review of Court Documents

1/58

EPFJP VE XJCK XJCPHM WCPPCLVX+ CIIAFCYAVX+ EPFJPX CLF HCXJ IAKJ

IAKJF2 BZKQ 04 0430

Vmax ax cl epfjp ve xjck ckk fehzojlvx ipeo Tz`kah Alxtjhvael, Vmax epfjp ax ve pjocal xjckjf zlvak

izpvmjp epfjp ei vmj Hezpv,


2/58

EPFJP CLF PZKALGX PJGCPFALG J]TCLFJF OJFAC HEYJPCGJ CLF FJHEPZO

Fcvjf Bzkq 04+ 0430

Vmax mcx heoj ve vmj Hezpv tzpxzclv ve NZXC/1Ljwx tjvavaeljpx+ Cxxehacvjf Tpjxx Tmevex clf Vmj

Fjlyjp Texv, Vmjq wclv ojfac heyjpcgj ei vmj cfyaxjojlv tpehjjfalg,

Vmj Hezpv pzkjf ojfac heyjpcgj ax tjpoavvjf ve xakk+ yafje clf czfae heyjpcgj elkq,

Yafje clf czfae ieevcgj wjlv ve NZXC/1Ljwx,

Xvakk tmevegpctmq wjlv ve Cxxehacvjf Tpjxx Tmevex,

Vmj ojfac ax xekjkq pjxtelxa`kj ve cl etjl clf aotcpvack faxvpa`zvael ei vmj ieevcgj,

Vmj iekkewalg cpj pjxvpahvaelx al ckk cpjcx wavmal vmj Bzxvahj Hjlvpj2

Le jkjhvpelah fjyahjx Le alvjpyajwx Le tmevegpctmq+ vpclxoavvalg ep pjhepfalg wavmal vmj hezpvpeeox clf vmj bzpq peeo Jlxzpj c hkjcp tcxxcgj ax ocfj Le tz`kah ep ojfac ax ve cvvjotv ve alvjpyajw clqelj alhkzfalg vmj fjijlfclv Le tzvvalg zt ei vjlvx+ vc`kjx ep xaoakcp avjox el vmj Tz`kah Gpezlfx Jyjpqelj mcx ve paxj clf `j xjcvjf wmjl vekf Ozxv pjocal szajv Mjagmvjljf xjhzpavq ojcxzpjx ozxv `j vcnjl Pjxvpahvaelx ve tcpnalg Ai qez yaekcvj clqvmalg qez wakk `j mjkf al Helvjotv ei Hezpv,


3/58


4/58


5/58

XVCLFALG FJHEPZO EPFJP -H/8!

Fcvjf 0:vm

Bzkq 0430

Vmax fehzojlv `cxahckkq xjvx ezv wmcv qez hcl clf hcllev fe al vmj Bzxvahj Hjlvpj2

Pjxvpahvaelx wavmal vmj Bzxvahj Hjlvpj

Ckk jkjhvpelah fjyahjx cpj `clljf Le alvjpyajwx xmckk `j helfzhvjf wavmal vmj Hezpvmezxj Le tmevegpctmq+ vpclxoavvalg ep pjhepfalg wavmal vmj Cttkahc`kj Cpjcx Ojfac clf tz`kah hcl vcnj tahvzpjx ei tjetkj cx vmjq heoj clf ge ipeo vmj Hezpvmezxj+

j}hjtv iep Bzpepx,

Ckwcqx kjcyj c hkjcp tcxxcgj Ojo`jpx ei vmj tz`kah ep ojfac cpj ckkew ve helfzhv alvjpyajwx ei clq tcpvq wavmal vmj

Hezpvmezxj

Fe lev tzv zt vjlvx+ vc`kjx jvh,Pjxvpahvaelx ve ckk Cttkahc`kj Cpjcx

Ckk jkjhvpelah fjyahjx cpj `clljf Le alvjpyajwx xmckk `j helfzhvjf Vmj ipelv pew el jchm xafj ei vmj Etjpcvalg Hezpvpeeo ax ve pjocal ychclv Tz`kah wakk `j cfoavvjf ve vmj fjxaglcvjf ojfac tepvael ei vmj hezpvpeeo ai vmjpj ax peeo Ljjf ve xav clf paxj wmjl vekf @j szajv Mjagmvjljf xjhzpavq ojcxzpjx wakk `j vcnjl Pjxvpahvaelx ve tcpnalg Ai qez yaekcvj clqvmalg qez wakk `j mjkf al Helvjotv ei Hezpv,

Cffavaelck tpeyaxaelx wakk `j ocfj pjgcpfalg tmevex ep yafje ei yahvaox+ fjijlfclv+ hezlxjk+ icoakajx+

wavljxxjx clf bzpepx cx av `jheojx ljhjxxcpq,


6/58

COJLFJF EPFJP PJ OEVAEL IEP HEOTKACLHJ WAVM EPFJP KAOAVALG TPJ/VPACK TZ@KAHAVQ

-F34!

FCVJF 0: BZKQ 0430

Vmax cojlfjf epfjp ax `pezgmv ve vmj Hezpv `q vmj Fjijlfclv,

Vmj oevael ax gpclvjf `q vmj Hezpv el 0:vm

Bzkq 0430,

Vmax epfjp ax ve heoojlhj aoojfacvjkq,


7/58

TJETKJX OEVAEL LE, 3 OEVAEL PJGCPFALG TZ@KAH CHHJXX VE ZLAYJPXAVQ EI HEKEPCFE

PJHEPFX

ZLFCVJF

Vmax ax `pezgmv ve vmj Hezpv `q vmj Tjetkj,

Vmj Tjetkj xvcvj2

Vmj Fjijlfclv mcx `jjl cppjxvjf iep lzojpezx hezlvx ei iapxv/fjgpjj ozpfjp+ cvvjotvjfozpfjp clf evmjp eiijlxjx pjkcvalg ve jyjlvx ehhzppalg al vmj oeplalg ei Bzkq 04 0430,

Vmj hcxj mcx c kev ei ojfac alvjpjxv, Vmj Fjijlfclv cvvjlfjf Zlayjpxavq ei Hekepcfe, Cx ei Bzkq 30+ 0430 vmj Fjijlfclv wcx al

vmj tpehjxx ei yekzlvcpakq wavmfpcwalg ipeo vmj zlayjpxavq,

El Bzkq 03+ 0430 c pjtpjxjlvcvayj ei vmj Zlayjpxavq helvchv vmj FC, Vmj pjtpjxjlvcvayjcfyaxjf vmcv ojo`jpx ei vmj ojfac mcf xvcpvjf ve alszapj vmj Zlayjpxavq pjgcpfalg vmj hcxj

clf pjszjxvalg pjkjcxj ei vmj Fjijlfclvx pjhepfx+ xz`bjhv ve Hekepcfe Etjl Pjhepfx Chv,

Vmj Tjetkj `jkajyj vmcv vmj ojfac wclvx chhjxx ve jkjhvpelah fehzojlvx xzhm cx j/ocak clf

xaoakcp,

Vmj Tjetkj mcyj lev mcf chhjxx ve vmjxj pjhepfx `zv vmjq `jkajyj vmcv faxhkexalg vmjxjfehzojlvx ve vmj ojfac wezkf lev `j geef, Xe vmj Tjetkj cxnx vmj Hezpv ve tpema`av vmj

Zlayjpxavq ipeo pjkjcxalg vmjxj fehzojlvx,

Ep ckvjplcvayjkq vmj fehzojlvx `j xz`oavvjf ve vmj hezpv iep al hcojpc pjyajw, C pjtpjxjlvcvayj ipeo vmj Zlayjpxavq mcx cfyaxjf vmj FCx eiiahj vmcv vmjq fe lev e`bjhv ve

vmax,


8/58

EPFJP PJKCVALG VE FAXHKEXZPJ EI PJHEPFX @Q ZLAYJPXAVQ EI HEKEPCFE TZPXZCLV VE

HEKEPCFE ETJL PJHEPFX CHV TJETKJX OEVAEL LE, 3 -T/0!

FCVJF 08 BZKQ 0430

Vmj Hezpv epfjpx vmj Zlayjpxavq ax lev ckkewjf ve faxhkexj clq aliepocvael c`ezv vmj Fjijlfclv

tzpxzclv ve HEPC, Ai qez wclv aliepocvael ipeo vmj Zlayjpxavq+ vmjl xz`tejlc vmjo,


9/58

OEVAEL IEP AOOJFACVJ TPEFZHVAEL EI CKK FAXHEYJPQ TJPVCALALG VE AOTPETJP

FAXHKEXZPJ EI TPAYAKJGJF OCVJPACK F/-433!

FCVJF 09 BZKQ 0430

Bcojx Mekojx vmpezgm ax hezlxjk oeyjx vmj Hezpv ve epfjp vmj geyjplojlv ve xmew ckk faxheyjpqpjgcpfalg vmj tchncgj xjlv oq Op Mekojx ve Fp Kqllj Ijlvel,

Op Mekojx wclvx c mjcpalg al vmax pjgcpf iep vmj tzptexj ei fjvjpoalalg cttpetpacvj xclhvaelx iep

oaxhelfzhv+

Op Mekojx wclvx ckk faxheyjpq tpefzhjf+ alhkzfalg c kaxv ei ckk vmj tjetkj alyekyjf al vmj xjarzpj clf

lcojx ei kcw jliephjojlv cgjlvx+ alhkzfalg ijfjpck cgjlvx wme vjxvjf vmax tchncgj iep j}tkexayjx+

alyekyjf al vmj hmcal ei hzxvefq ei vmj tchncgj+ ckk aliepocvael pjgcpfalg vmj xjarzpj+ lcojx ei vmj

tjetkj pjxtelxa`kj iep vmj `pjchm+ ckk levjx clf pjtepvx pjgcpfalg vmj tchncgj+ ckk aliepocvael cx ve

mew vmj ojfac nljw c`ezv av,


10/58

TJETKJX PJXTELXJ VE FJIJLXJ OEVAEL F/33

IAKJF BZKQ 07+ 0430

Vmj Tjetkj e`bjhv ve vmj Oevael, Vmjq wakk tpeyafj vmj faxheyjpq el vmjap texxjxxael,

Vmjq fjlajf vmcv vmjq wjpj pjxtelxa`kj iep vmj kjcn ve vmj ojfac, Vmj Tjetkj xcq vmcv vmjq elkq

axxzjf elj wcppclv+ lev vwe wcppclvx cx tjp L@HLJWX,heox xvepq, Vmj ckxe cfyaxj vmcv vmj

tchncgjf wcx ljyjp etjljf, Vmjq xcq vmj ojfac ocfj vmj wmekj xvepq zt cx vmjq `jkajyj le elj al

vmjap hezpv kjcnjf clq aliepocvael wmcvxejyjp, Vmj Tjetkj xcq vmcv ai vmjpj wjpj yafje hcojpcx al

vmj ocakpeeo vmjq wakk tpeyafj xzhm jyafjlhj ai av heojx ve mclf,

Tjetkj xcq vmcv vmj wmekj xvepq ax alchhzpcvj clf cx xzhm fe lev nlew mew ve pjxtelf ve vmj Oevael

F/33


11/58

EPFJP PJ2 OEVAEL IEP AOOJFACVJ TPEFZHVAEL EI CKK FAXHEYJPQ TJPVCALALG VE AOTPETJP

FAXHKEXZPJ EI TPAYAKJGJF OCVJPACK -F/33!

FCVJF BZKQ 07+ 0430

Vmj Hezpv gpclvx vmj mjcpalg,


12/58

OJFACX OEVAEL VE ZLXJCK HEZPV IAKJ -ALHKZFALG FEHNJV! -WAVM PJSZJXV IEP J]TJFAVJF

MJCPALG!

FCVJF BZKQ 07+ 0430

Vmax Oevael ax `pezgmv `jiepj vmj Hezpv `q lzojpezx ojfac ezvkjvx, Vmjq waxm vmj iakjx al vmax hcxj

`j zlxjckjf,


13/58

EPFJP PJ2 OEVAEL VE ZLXJCK HEZPV IAKJ -ALHKZFALG FEHNJV! -H6!

FCVJF BZKQ 07+ 0430

Vmj Hezpv epfjpx vmj Oeyclvx-ojfac! pjszjxv ve xjv c mjcpalg ve cffpjxx ocvvjpx el Bzkq 84 0430,


14/58

COJLFJF EPFJP PJ OEVAEL VE KAOAV TPJ/VPACK TZ@KAHAVQ -F/0C!

FCVJF 38 CZGZXV 0430

Vmj Hezpv levjx vmjpj cpj hjpvcal xz`bjhvx oepj kanjkq ve mcyj tpjbzfahack jiijhv el c tpehjjfalg,

Vmjq alhkzfj hmcpchvjp+ hpjfa`akavq+ pjtzvcvael ep hpaoalck pjhepf ep c tcpvq ep xzxtjhv+ tjpiepoclhj

ei clq j}coalcvael ep vjxv ep vmj pjizxck ep icakzpj ei c tjpxel ve xz`oav ve cl j}coalcvael ep c vjxv+

etalael cx ve gzakv ep allehjlhj clf vmj fjijlfclv ax tpjxzojf allehjlv zlvak clf zlkjxx tpeyjl

gzakvq,


15/58

EPFJP PJ OEVAEL VE ZLXJCK HEZPV IAKJ -ALHKZFALG FEHNJV!-XZTTPJXXAEL EPFJP!-H/6H!

FCVJF CZGZXV 38 0430

Hezpv ialfx vmcv vmj Zlayjpxavq ei Hekepcfe ax lev ve vckn,

Vmj Pjgaxvjp ei Chvaelx ax ve `j etjljf,

Ciiafcyavx+ xz`tejlcx+ cppjxv wcppclvx jvh cpj ve `j xzttpjxxjf,

Vmj Hezpv wakk pjkjcxj cl cffavael 86 fehzojlvx,

Vmj Hezpv epfjpx vmcv vmj iakj pjocalx xzttpjxxjf clf vmj tchncgj ax ve `j mjkf zlfjp xjck clf mjkf

wavm vmj Hkjpn ei vmj Hezpv,


16/58

OEVAEL IEP CHHJXX VE CLF TPJXJPYCVAEL EI HPAOJ XHJLJ -443! -F/3!

IAKJ 7,04,0430

Bcojx Mekojx wclvx max hezlxjk gpclvjf chhjxx ve vmj hpaoj xhjlj, Mj xvcvjx max icoakq mcx

pjszjxvjf hezlxjk pjtpjxjlv mao, Hezlxjk mcx lev `jjl c`kj ve ojjv wavm Op Mekojx,


17/58

EPFJP PJ OEVAEL IEP CHHJXX VE CLF TPJXJPYCVAEL EI HPAOJ XHJLJ -443! -F/3!

IAKJF 7,08,0430

Cv vmj cfyaxjojlv mjcpalg -08%7! vmj Fjijlfclv alhkzfjf Op Mekojx tkchj ei pjxafjlhj cx wjkk cx

vmj vmjcvpj clf xzppezlfalg cpjcx, CX vmj Tjetkj clf Fjijlxj hcoj ve cl cgpjjojlv cv vmcvmjcpalg wmjpjcx vmj Tjetkj wakk gayj vmj Fjijlxj 06 mezpx levahj ve mcyj pjcxelc`kj chhjxx ve `evm

hpaoj xhjljx+ vmj Hezpv ialfx vmj Fjijlfclvx Oevael oeev,


18/58

OEVAEL VE KAOAV TPJ/VPCAK TZ@KAHAVQ -440!

IAKJF 7,04,0430

Bcojx Mekojx oeyjx vmj Hezpv ve epfjp kaoavalg aliepocvael gayjl ezv `q cvvepljqx+ vmjap cgjlvx+

jotkeqjjx clf ckk jliephjojlv cgjlhajx clf alyjxvagcvepx+ jotkeqjjx+ hezpv tjpxelljk pjgcpfalgvmj hcxj,


19/58

EPFJP PJ OEVAEL VE KAOAV TPJ/VPCAK TZ@KAHAVQ -440!

IAKJF 7,08,0430

Vmj Hezpv epfjpx vmcv le kcwqjpx+ kcw jliephjojlv cgjlhajx ep hezpv tjpxelljk lev ve faxhkexj clq

aliepocvael ep vckn c`ezv vmax ocvvjp,


20/58

OEVAEL VE TPJXJPYJ CLF TPEFZHJ JYAFJLHJ -448! -F8!

IAKJF 7,04,0430

Vmj Fjijlxj cxnx iep vmj iekkewalg2

Ckk pjhepfalgx tpefzhjf ep xjarjf Ckk tekahj levjx, Fe lev fjxvpeq vmjxj levjx Ckk xhajlvaiah pjtepvx jvh Ckk tmevex Ckk heppjxtelfjlhj Ckk `aekegahck xcotkjx clf tmqxahck jyafjlhj Ckk pjhepfx


21/58

E@BJHVAEL VE J]TCLFJF OJFAC HEYJPCGJ CLF PJSZJXV IEP MJCPALG -446!

IAKJF 7,04,0430

Vmj Fjijlxj e`bjhvx ve ojfac heyjpcgj iep vmj Bzkq 08+ 0430 cfyaxjojlv mjcpalg, Op Mekojx ckxe

wclvx c hezpv epfjp pjszapalg 84 fcqx levahj al cfyclhj ei clq mjcpalg iep xzhm pjszjxv ve `j ocfj,


22/58

LEVAHJ EI ALYEHCVAEL EI CKK XVCVZVEPQ CLF HELXVAVZVAELCK PAGMVX CLF TPAYAKJGJX CLF

PJYEHCVAEL EI CLQ CLF CKK TPJYAEZXKQ GAYJL WCAYJPX CLF TPAYAKJGJX -44: -F:!

IAKJF 7,08,0430

Bcojx Mekojx alyenjx tpayakjgjx alhkzfalg ojfahck clf txqhmacvpah+ xhmeek+ jotkeqojlv jvh+pjszjxvx vmj Hezpv epfjp le ojo`jp ei vmj FC+ kcw jliephjojlv jvh e`vcal heliafjlvack

aliepocvael+ mj fejx lev czvmepaxj clqelj ve wcayj max pagmvx el max `jmcki+ j}jphaxjx max pagmv ve

xakjlhj+ fejx lev wclv ve `j alvjpyajwjf ep helvchvjf zlkjxx max cvvepljq ax tpjxjlv+ vmj FC ax lev

ckkewjf ve helvchv mao wavm max hezlxjkx cttpeyck+

Mj ckxe pjyenjx ckk tpjyaezxkq xvcvjf ep xagljf wcayjpx ei heliafjlvackavq, Fejx lev helxjlv ve

pjkjcxalg ei max pjhepfx,


23/58

OEVAEL VE CKKEW HELIAFJLVACK FJIJLXJ J]TJPVX VE @J TPJXJLV IEP XHAJLVAIAH VJXVALG EI

JYAFJLHJ -449! -F/9!

IAKJF 08 BZKQ 0430

Bcojx Mekojx wclvx c heliafjlvack j}tjpv fzpalg xhajlvaiah vjxvalg+ lev ve tjpiepo clq izpvmjpvjxvalg zlvak vmax ocvvjp ax pjxekyjf,


24/58

ALVJPAO EPFJP VE PJXTELF VE OEVAEL VE CKKEW HELIAFJLVACK FJIJLXJ J]TJPVX VE @J

TPJXJLV IEP XHAJLVAIAH VJXVALG EI JYAFJLHJ -449! -F/9!

IAKJF 08 BZKQ 0430

Vmj Tjetkj cpj pjszapjf ve pjxtelf wavmal 04 fcqx,


25/58

TJETKJX PJXTELXJ VE FJIJLFCLVX OEVAEL F/92 OEVAEL VE CKKEW HELIAFJLVACK FJIJLXJ

J]TJPVX VE @J TPJXJLV IEP XHAJLVAIAH VJXVALG EI JYAFJLHJ

IAKJF CZGZXV = 0430

Al pjxtelxj vmj Tjetkj ax cxnalg vmj Hezpv ve fjlq vmj pjszjxv, Vmjq `cxahckkq xcq vmcv vjxvalg vmj

jyafjlhj ax al avx ewl wcq fjxvpzhvayj al lcvzpj,


26/58

E@BJHVAEL VE J]TCLFJF OJFAC HEYJPCGJ CLF PJSZJXV IEP MJCPALG -F/447!

IAKJF 08 BZKQ 0430

Bcojx Mekojx e`bjhvx ve pjszjxvx `q ojfac iep j}tclfjf ojfac heyjpcgj iep Bzkq 84 0430 tpj/vpack

mjcpalg cx av wakk bjetcpfaxj Op Mekojx helxvavzvaelck pagmvx ve fzj tpehjxx,


27/58

PJSZJXV IEP J]TCLFJF OJFAC HEYJPCGJ NZXC/1LJWX

IAKJF 08 BZKQ 0430

Vmax ax c xvclfcpf iepo iakkjf ezv `q NZXC/1Ljwx iep j}tclfjf ojfac heyjpcgj iep czfae clf yafje,


28/58

PJSZJXV IEP J]TCLFJF OJFAC HEYJPCGJ VMJ FJLYJP TEXV

IAKJF 08 BZKQ 0430

Vmax ax c xvclfcpf iepo iakkjf ezv `q Vmj Fjlyjp Texv iep j}tclfjf ojfac heyjpcgj iep xvakk

tmevegpctmq,


29/58

PJSZJXV IEP J]TCLFJF OJFAC HEYJPCGJ HEKEPCFE TZ@KAH PCFAE

IAKJF 08 BZKQ 0430

Vmax ax c xvclfcpf iepo iakkjf ezv `q Hekepcfe Tz`kah Pcfae iep j}tclfjf ojfac heyjpcgj iep czfae,


30/58

OEVAEL IEP HEOTKACLHJ WAVM EPFJP KAOAVALG TPJ/VPACK TZ@KAHAVQ -F/434!

IAKJF BZKQ 0: 0434

Bcojx Mekojx oeyjx vmj Hezpv ve axxzj cl Epfjp tzpxzclv ve max helxvavzvaelck pagmvx pjgcpfalg tpj/

vpack tz`kahavq, Av xjjox vmj geyjplojlv yaekcvjf vmcv epfjp `q faxxjoalcvalg aliepocvael ve vmjojfac pjgcpfalg max heoozlahcvaelx wavm }}}}}}}}}} -vmax ojclx av wcx `kchnjljf ezv!,


31/58

EPFJP PJ OEVAEL IEP HEOTKACLHJ WAVM EPFJP KAOAVALG TPJ/VPACK TZ@KAHAVQ -F/34!

FCVJF 0: BZKQ 0430

Fjijlfclvx oevael ax gpclvjf,


32/58

OEVAEL VE CKKEW FJIJLFCLV VE XAV CV HEZLXJK VC@KJ F/-430!

FCVJF 0: BZKQ 0430

Bcojx Mekojx oeyjx vmj Hezpv ve ckkew mao ve xav cv hezlxjk vc`kj, Njjtalg mao al vmj bzpq `e}

gayjx vmj aotpjxxael vmcv Op Mekojx j}tpjxx vmpjcvx ep j}ma`avx fclgjpezx `jmcyaezp, Ai tjetkj alvmj hezpv fjxapj ve mcpo Op Mekojx+ vmjl vmj Hezpv ljjfx ve cffpjxx vmj helfzhv ei vmexj tcpvahzkcp

tjetkj+ lev Op Mekojx,


33/58

EPFJP PJ OEVAEL VE CKKEW FJIJLFCLV VE XAV CV HEZLXJK VC@KJ F/-430!

FCVJF 07 BZKQ 0430

Vmax oevael ax gpclvjf,


34/58

OEVAEL VE XJCK XJCPHM WCPPCLVX+ CIIAFCYAVX+ EPFJPX CLF HCXJ IAKJ

FCVJF 04 BZKQ 0430

Vmj Tjetkj xvcvj vmcv pjkjcxj ei pjhepfx+ ciiafcyav clf pjvzpl ei xjpyahj alyjlvepq xmjjvx hezkf

faxhkexj aliepocvael pjxzkvalg al fjxvpzhvael+ faxtexck ep xjhpjvalg jyafjlhj clf vcotjpalg wavmafjlvaiajf clf zlafjlvaiajf wavljxxjx+ bjetcpfaralg vmj alyjxvagcvael,

Vmjpjiepj vmjq wclv vmjxj fehzojlvx ve `j xjckjf,


35/58

XZTTKJOJLV VE EPFJP VE XJCK XJCPHM WCPPCLVX+ CIIAFCYAVX+ EPFJPX CLF HCXJ IAKJ -T3!

FCVJF 83 BZKQ 0430

Vmj Hezpv epfjpx vmj FC ve gayj c hetq ei vmj Hezpvx hzppjlv Epfjp -cvvchmjf! ve bzfahack eiiahjp clf

hezpv xvcii wavm izvzpj xjcphm wcppclvx clf ciiafcyavx xe vmjq cpj cwcpj ei vmj epfjp,


36/58

TJETKJX OEVAEL -T/7!

OEVAEL VE HKCPAIQ HEZPV EPFJP PJ OEVAEL VE KAOAVJF TPJ/VPACK TZ@KAHAVQ -F/0!

IAKJF 07 BZKQ 0430

Vmj tjetkj cpj helizxjf wavm vmj Hezpvx Bzkq 08+ 0430 Epfjp Pj Oevael ve Kaoav Tpj/Vpack Tz`kahavq

-F/0!, Vmjq kaxv faxhpjtclhajx wavm ycpaezx pjijpjlhjx ve Hekepcfe Pzkjx ei Tpeijxxaelck Helfzhv,


37/58

PJXTELXJ VE TJETKJX OEVAEL -T/7!

OEVAEL VE HKCPAIQ HEZPV EPFJP PJ OEVAEL VE KAOAVJF TPJ/VPACK TZ@KAHAVQ -F/0!

IAKJF 84 BZKQ 0430

Vmj Fjijlxj pjxtelfx ve vmj Tjetkjx pjxtelxj, Vmj ocbepavq ei vmjxj pjszaxavaelx cx xzhm ax al

pjkcvael ve alchhzpcvj pjtepvx iakjf `q vmj ojfac pjchmalg vmj bzpq teek al vmj hcxj,

Ai qez pjckkq wclv ve nlew vmj alx clf ezvx ei vmj oevael clf pjxtelxjx qez wakk ljjf ve pjcf

vmj Hekepcfe Pzkjx ei Tpeijxxaelck Helfzhv Pzkjx 8,9/8,=,


38/58

TJETKJX OEVAEL -T/=! OEVAEL IEP MJCPALG TPAEP VE ZLXJCKALG EI HEOTKCALV+ LCOJX EI

YAHVAOX+ CFFPJXXJX+ EP EVMJP FEHZOJLVX+ AVJOX+ EP TKJCFALGX AL VMAX HCXJ

IAKJF BZKQ 07+ 0430

Vmj Tjetkj cxn vmcv `jiepj vmj hezpv zlxjckx clq tepvael ei vmj hcxj vmcv c mjcpalg `j helfzhvjf vejlc`kj ckk tcpvajx ve `j mjcpf, Vmax alhkzfjx heotkcalv+ lcojx clf cffpjxxjx ei yahvaox clf

wavljxxjx,


39/58

PJSZJXV IEP J]TCLFJF OJFAC HEYJPCGJ NZXC/1LJWX

IAKJF 04 BZKQ 0430

Vmax ax c xvclfcpf iepo pjgcpfalg pjszjxv iep j}tclfjf ojfac heyjpcgj `q NZXC/1Ljwx iep czfae

clf yafje,


40/58

PJSZJXV IEP J]TCLFJF OJFAC HEYJPCGJ VMJ FJLYJP TEXV

IAKJF 04 BZKQ 0430

Vmax ax c xvclfcpf iepo pjgcpfalg pjszjxv iep j}tclfjf ojfac heyjpcgj `q Vmj Fjlyjp Texv iep

tmevex,


41/58

PJSZJXV IEP J]TCLFJF OJFAC HEYJPCGJ CXXEHACVJF TPJXX TMEVEX

IAKJF 04 BZKQ 0430

Vmax ax c xvclfcpf iepo pjgcpfalg pjszjxv iep j}tclfjf ojfac heyjpcgj `q Vmj Fjlyjp Texv iep

tmevex,


42/58

ALAVACK HCXJ OCLCGJOJLV EPFJP -H0!

IAKJF 08 BZKQ 0430

Vmax fehzojlv xtjkkx ezv vmj iakalg+ afjlvaiahcvael clf kc`jkkalg tpevehek iep ckk tkjcfalgx al vmax hcxj,

Tjetkj ? T/3 -3 `jalg vmj lzo`jp ei oevaelx iakjf!

Fjijlfclv ? F/3

Hezpv ? H/3


43/58

TJETKJ'X PJXTELXJ VE OEVAEL VE ZLXJCK HEZPV IAKJ -ALHKZFALG FEHNJV! -T/1!

IAKJF 9 CZGZXV 0430

Vmj Tjetkj pjxtelf ve vmj ojfac clf vmjq cfyaxj vmcv vmjq faf lev e`bjhv ve vmj zlxjckalg ei vmj

Heotkcalv clf Aliepocvael, Vmjq fe lev wclv vmj wavljxx fjvcakx pjkjcxjf, Vmj Fjijlxj fejx levwclv clq tepvael ei vmj hcxj zlxjckjf,

Cx c pjxzkv vmj Tjetkj cgpjj wavm vmj Fjijlxj clf fel'v wclv clq ei vmj hcxj zlxjckjf,

Vmj Tjetkj pjckaxjf vmcv vmj hcxj wakk `j zlxjckjf cv xeoj tealv,

Ai vmj Hezpv wclvx ve zlxjck clqvmalg vmjl vmjq cxn vmjq bzxv zlxjck vmj Pjgaxvjp ei Chvaelx clf oexv

oevaelx clf epfjpx j}hjtv Tjetkj'x : "Tpjkaoalcpq @jlhm @paji Pjkcvalg ve Fjijlfclv'x Ckkjgcvaelx

vmcv Hjpvcal Ocvjpackx cpj Tpevjhvjf `q Tpayakjgj",


44/58

FJIJLFCLV'X PJXTELXJ VE OEVAEL VE ZLXJCK HEZPV IAKJ -ALHKZFALG FEHNJV! -T/1!

IAKJF 1 CZGZXV 0430

Op Mekojx e`bjhvx ve vmj zlxjckalg ei clq cffavaelck fehzojlvx tpjxjlvkq helvcaljf al vmj hcxj

iakj, Mj ckxe e`bjhvx ve vmj elkalj texvalg ei tkjcfalgx iakjf al vmj "Hcxjx ei Alvjpjxv" xjhvael ei vmjxvcvj bzfahack `pclhm wj`xavj,

Vmjpj cpj oclq pjcxelx wmq mj ax e`bjhvalg ve zlxjckalg ei vmax hcxj clf max kcwqjpx pjijp ve oclq

tealvx ei kcw, Ai qez ljjf ve nlew vmj izkk fjvcakx ei av+ mcyj c keen cv vmj oevael, Ai qez ljjf mjkt

tkjcxj kjv oj nlew clf A wakk vpq ve mjkt,


45/58


46/58

-EPAGALCK CLF HEPPJHVJF! OEVAEL @Q OJFAC TJVAVAELJPX IEP HKCPAIAHCVAEL EI VMJ

HEZPVX EPFJPX PJGCPFALG TPJ/VPACK TZ@KAHAVQ,

FCVJF 8 CZGZXV CLF 9 CZGZXV 0430 A hezkf lev ialf vmj j}chv heppjhvael

Vmax Oevael ax ocfj tzpxzclv ve2

Epfjp pj Oevael ve Kaoav Tpj/Vpack Tz`kahavq+ Cojlfjf Epfjp pj Oevael iep Heotkaclhj wavm Epfjp

Kaoavalg Tpj/Vpack Tz`kahavq+ vmj aotexavael ei tevjlvack xclhvael ei helvjotv ei hezpv iep clq

yaekcvael ei vmj Pzkjx+ vmj tpemaàvael el j}vpc/bzfahack xvcvjojlvx elkq cttkq ve vmjFCx eiiahj

clf hpaoalck Kcw Jliephjojlv Cgjlhajx alyekyjf al vmax hcxj, Cojlfjf epfjp lew alhkzfjx

Czpepc Tekahj Fjtcpvojlv+ Cpctcmej Hezlvq Xmjpaiix Fjtv+ Hekepcfe @zpjcz ei Alyjxvagcvael+ I@A

clf CVI,

Evmjp lel/hpaoalck kcw jliephjojlv cgjlhajx cpj havalg vmj Hezpvx Epfjpx lev ve heoojlv el vmj

hcxj,

Al xjjnalg ezv aliepocvael el chvaelx `q lel/kcw geyjplojlv+ vmcv èfq ax lew havalg vmj Hezpv

Epfjp clf lev xtjcnalg ve vmj ojfac a,j Czpepc Maxvepq Ozxjzo pjizxjx ve axxzj c xvcvjojlv

pjgcpfalg tkclx ei c Ojoepack Tcpn chpexx vmj xvpjjv ipeo vmj Hjlvzpq 03 -395! Oeyaj Vmjcvpj,

Vmj ojfac mcx cxnjf iep aliepocvael pjgcpfalg mew oclq pzpck ojvpe co`zkclhjx pjxtelfjf ve vmj

xmeevalg+ wmjpj vmjq wjlv+ alxtjhvael ei vmj pjtepvx mjkf `q vmj Czpepc Iapj Fjtcpvojlv iep vmj

oeyaj vmjcvpj fcvalg `chn wjjnx clf oelvmx `jiepj Bzkq 04+ xjjnalg pjhepfx xmewalg wmjl eii/fzvq

tekahj eiiahjpx mcyj wepnjf cv vmj oeyaj vmjcvpj al vmj vwe oelvmx tpaep ve Bzkq 04,

Vmj ojfac xcq vmjxj pjhepfx xmezkf `j ocfj cycakc`kj cx vmjq cpj lev wavmal vmj coàv ei vmjHezpvx Epfjpx cx lelj ei vmjxj cgjlhajx wakk `j tcpvahatcvalg al vmj tpexjhzvael ei vmj fjijlfclv,


47/58

TJETKJX OEVAEL VE HELVALZJ -T/33!

IAKJF CZGZXV 3:+ 0430

Vmj Tjetkj waxm ve helvalzj mjcpalg fcvjf Czgzxv 39+ 0430, Vmjq fe lev mcyj ckk faxheyjpq cx qjv,

Vmjq mcyj pjhjayjf 0+:44 tcgjx ei faxheyjpq+ :0 FYFx clf HFx `zv vmjq cpj cwcavalg oepj

aliepocvael, Aliepocvael pjszjxvjf al Xz`tejlc Fzhjx Vjhzo ve vmj Zlayjpxavq ax ljhjxxcpq iep

tpayakjgj, Vmj Fjijlfclvx cvvepljq mcx cfyaxjf vmjq fe lev e`bjhv ve vmj Oevael ve Helvalzj, Vmjq

`evm pjszjxv vmj Hezpv pzkj el vmj Oevael vefcq xe vmjq hcl hckk eii vmj wavljxxjx xhmjfzkjf iep

vmcv fcvj,


48/58

EPFJP PJ TJETKJX OEVAEL VE HELVALZJ -T/33!

FCVJF CZGZXV 3:+ 0430

Vmj Hezpv mcx cgpjjf ve kjv vmj mjcpalg iep Czgzxv 39 `j oeyjf ve Czgzxv 08+ 0430,


49/58

EPFJP PJ FJIJLFCLVX OEVAEL VE CKKEW HELIAFJLVACK FJIJLXJ J]TJPVX VE @J TPJXJLV

IEP XHAJLVAIAH VJXVALG EP JYAFJLHJ

FCVJF CZGZXV 3:+ 0430

Vmj Fjijlxj wclvx j}tjpvx ve `j tpjxjlv iep xhajlvaiah vjxvalg clf vmj Hezpv ialfx vmcv av mcx lexvcvzvepq czvmepavq ve epfjp vmj Tjetkj ve ckkew Fjijlfclv c heliafjlvack j}tjpv `j tpjxjlv fzpalg

vmj Tjetkjx xhajlvaiah vjxvalg, Vmj Tjetkj ozxv heotkq wavm vmj faxhkexzpj pjszapjojlvx pjgcpfalg

fjxvpzhvayj ep helxzotvayj vjxvalg, Vmj Tjetkj cpj ve gayj vmj Fjijlfclv 6= mezpx levahj `jiepj

helfzhvalg vjxvalg,

Wmakj vmj Fjijlfclv mcx vmj pagmv cv vpack ve helipelv clq xvcvj j}tjpvx ep j}coaljpx alyekyjf al vmj

vjxvalg+ vmj Fjijlfclv fejx lev mcyj vmj pagmv ve c heliafjlvack j}tjpv tpjxjlv,,


50/58

TJETKJX OEVAEL 30 PJSZJXV VE PJKJCXJ LCOJX CLF HELVCHV ALIEPOCVAEL EI YAHVAOX

VE VMJ HEKEPCFE EPGCLARCVAEL IEP YAHVAOX CXXAXVCLHJ,

IAKJF CZGZXV 39+ 0430

HEYC wclvx vmj lcojx clf helvchv aliepocvael ei vmj yahvaox ve jlc`kj vmjo ve faxvpa`zvj izlfx cx

xeel cx texxa`kj,


51/58

EPFJP PJGCPFALG TJETKJX OEVAEL 30 PJSZJXV VE PJKJCXJ LCOJX CLF HELVCHV

ALIEPOCVAEL EI YAHVAOX VE VMJ HEKEPCFE EPGCLARCVAEL IEP YAHVAOX CXXAXVCLHJ,

FCVJF CZGZXV 39+ 0430

Cx vmax oevael ax zlettexjf+ vmj Hezpv gpclvx vmj Oevael+ wavm cojlfojlvx, Vmj FC hcl gayj HEYC

vmj yahvaox fjvcakx el elhj vmj yahvaox mcyj gayjl vmjap tpaep helxjlv, HEYC ozxv njjt vmax

aliepocvael heliafjlvack


52/58

OEVAEL VE SZCXM XZ@TEJLC FZHJX VJHZO IEP OP MEKOJX JFZHCVAELCK PJHEPFX F/-436!

IAKJF CZGZXV =+ 0430

Bcojx Mekojx pjszjxvx vmcv vmj xz`tejlc el max jfzhcvaelck pjhepfx xmezkf `j szcxmjf cx av ax

zlpjcxelc`kj clf ettpjxxayj+ cx av xjjnx heliafjlvack clf%ep tpayakjgjf ocvjpackx,


53/58

TJETKJX PJXTELXJ VE FJIJLFCLVX OEVAEL VE SZCXM XZ@TEJLC FZHJX VJHZO IEP OP

MEKOJX JFZHCVAELCK PJHEPFX F/-436!

IAKJF CZGZXV 36+ 0430

Vmj Tjetkj cpgzj vmcv vmj Fjijlfclvx jfzhcvaelck pjhepfx cpj pjkjyclv ve vmj alyjxvagcvael ei vmjxjhpaojx+ max tkcllalg clf oevayj clf cxnx vmj Hezpv ve fjlq vmj Fjijlfclvx oevael,


54/58

EPFJP PJ TPEFZHVAEL EI FEHZOJLVX CLF AL HCOJPC PJYAJW -H/7!


Vmj Hezpv epfjpx le al hcojpc pjyajw xmckk `j helfzhvjf zlvak civjp Fjijlfclv iakjx c wpavvjl

pjxtelxj clf vmj tcpvajx tpjxjlv epck cpgzojlv, Vmax ljjfx ve `j iakjf `q Oelfcq Czgzxv 04 0430clf epck cpgzojlv ve `j mjkf el Czgzxv 08+ 0430, Ojclwmakj vmj Zlayjpxavq fehzojlvx cpj xjckjf,


55/58

TJETKJX OEVAEL LE, T/39 OEVAEL PJGCPFALG TZ@KAH CHHJXX VE PJHEPFX EI CPCTCMEJ

HEZLVQ HEPELJP


Vmj FC kjcpljf vmcv cv kjcxv elj ljwx cgjlhq pjszjxv vmj pjkjcxj ei pjhepfx iep vmj czvetxq pjtepvx

clf tmevegpctmx ei vmj fjhjcxjf clf vmjq wezkf kanj vmj Hezpv ve pzkj el vmax ocvvjp,


56/58

XZTTKJOJLV VE TJETKJX OEVAEL LE, T/39 OEVAEL PJGCPFALG TZ@KAH CHHJXX VE PJHEPFX

EI CPCTCMEJ HEZLVQ HEPELJP


Vmj ljwx cgjlhq pjszjxvalg vmj pjkjcxj ei vmj pjhepfx mcyj lew wavmfpcwl vmjap pjszjxv,


57/58

FJIJLFCLVX PJXTELXJ VE TPEXJHZVEPX OEVAEL LE, T/39 OEVAEL PJGCPFALG TZ@KAH

CHHJXX VE PJHEPFX EI CPCTCMEJ HEZLVQ HEPELJP


Bcojx Mekojx pjtkajx `cxjf el vmj Tjetkjx Xzttkjojlv+ vmj ocvvjp lew cttjcpx oeev,


58/58

EPFJP PJ TJETKJX OEVAEL LE, T/39 OEVAEL PJGCPFALG TZ@KAH CHHJXX VE PJHEPFX EI

CPCTCMEJ HEZLVQ HEPELJP


Al vmj Tjetkjx Oevael vmjq xvcvj vmcv cv kjcxv elj ojfac ezvkjv mcx pjszjxvjf vmj pjkjcxj ei pjhepfxpjgcpfalg czvetxq pjtepvx clf tmevegpctmx ei vmj fjhjcxjf,

Vmj hezpv gpclvx c mjcpalg el vmj ocvvjp xhmjfzkjf iep Czgzxv 08+ 0430,