WirelessVitae-2013

Full Review for #1569737533: Analysis of OFDM Error Floor in IndoorChannels by Stochastic Modeling

The review period for this paper ended on May 15, 2013 23:59:00 EDT and the review can no longer bechanged.

Reviewer Alexandru Vulpe (E); completed; assigned April 30, 2013 01:35:56 America/New_York by Rasmus HjorthNielsen; last reminded April 30, 2013 03:16:22 America/New_York; completed April 30, 2013 04:37:46

America/New_York

Relevance Familiarity Presentation RecommendationModerate importance (3) Familiar with this area of research (2) Needs revision (3) Accept if room (3)

Summary (Please provide a summary of the paper (the contents and contribution of the paper). (1-3sentences))

The paper provides analytical formulas for error floor analysis of OFDM signals in indoor channels using stochastic modeling.

The paper provides a comparison between the derived formulas and Monte Carlo simulations, showing that they are closely matched.

Strengths (What are the most important reasons to accept this paper (e.g., technical depth, novelty,creative solution, importance of topic, etc.)?)

The authors derive a closed form expression for the probability of signal error in OFDM signals, using stochastic modeling.

They validate their results against Monte Carlo simulations and show that they are close

Weaknesses (What are the most important reasons NOT to accept this paper?)The authors do not perform state-of-the-art literature review.

Conclusion section is badly written.

Seems as though sections III and IV have been shortened just in order to fit in the 5-page limit.

Comments to authors (Please provide detailed comments to the authors.)Please move figure 1 to the second page. Please remove text box borders (make them invisible) for figures 1 and 2

Please show how your work differs from that of other authors by performing state-of-the-art literature review.

Please provide more detailed comments of the results obtained.

Please improve conclusion section. Show how your results are relevant,and how you plan to improve them.

EDAS at 72.233.114.26 (Sat, 06 Dec 2014 03:53:15 -0500 EST) [User 829755: 0.095/0.511 s] Request help

Home Register My... Help

Full Review for #1569737533: Analysis of OFDM... https://edas.info/R.php?r=5259523

1 din 1 06.12.2014 10:53