retail market overview hungary - cushman & wakefield/media/reports/hungary/retail market... ·...
TRANSCRIPT
JANUARY 2015
RETAIL MARKET OVERVIEW HUNGARY
A Cushman & Wakefield research publication
YEAR-END 2014
1
OFFICE
MARKET
OVERVIEW 2014
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
ECONOMIC SNAPSHOT Q4 2014
ECONOMIC SUMMARY – DECEMBER 2014
ECONOMIC INDICATORS* 2012 2013 2014F 2015F 2015F
GDP growth -1.5 1.6 3.2 2.5 2.6
Consumer spending -1.9 -0.1 1.5 3.1 2.9
Industrial production -1.4 1.4 7.8 3.7 3.4
Investment -4.2 5.2 14.9 3.5 3.0
Unemployment rate (%) 10.4 9.8 7.6 7.3 7.2
Inflation 5.7 1.7 -0.2 0.7 2.6
HUF/€ (average) 289.3 297.0 308.4 308.6 304.1
HUF/US$ (average) 225.1 223.7 231.8 249.9 251.9
Money market rate (%) 7.0 4.3 2.4 1.9 3.2
Interest rates 10-year (%) 7.9 5.9 4.8 3.9 5.0
MARKET
OUTLOOK
GDP GROWTH is moderate but remain above-average in
2015
INFLATIONIs likely to stay negative until mid 2015
INTEREST RATEcuts are likely in HI 2015
EMPLOYMENTconntinues to improve graduallyTHE HUNGARIAN ECONOMY IS PERFORMING STRONGLY
aided by accommodative monetary policy, low inflation and rising consumer spending. Consumer
confidence is now at levels last seen in 2006, helped by the robust recovery in the labor market, which
has seen the unemployment rate falling.
NOTE: *annual % growth rate unless otherwise indicated. E estimate F forecast
Source: Oxford Economics Ltd. and Consensus Economics Inc
2
OFFICE
MARKET
OVERVIEW 2014
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
FORECAST
FORECASTS FOR THE HUNGARIAN ECONOMY HAVE BEEN
UPGRADED FURTHER,growth of 3.2% is now expected for 2014 (the best performance since 2006) followed by 2.5% in 2015.
THE 2014 PERFORMANCE IS EXPECTED TO EXCEED the Slovakian, the Czech and the Romanian performance.
Given the INCREASINGLY CHALLENGING EXTERNAL CONDITIONS and
a tighter fiscal policy, the consumer sector is anticipated to come to the fore later in 2015.
THE LONG-TERM OUTLOOK FOR THE ECONOMY IS BRIGHT as the
country’s GDP remains below its 2008 peak, implying ample scope for catch-up.
SIGNIFICANT DOWNSIDE RISKS remain, including further anti-business policies and a
resulting erosion in the country’s competitiveness as well as an escalation of the crisis in Ukraine and
sluggish growth in the Eurozone.
CONSUMER
SECTOR GAINS
MOMENTUM
Consumer prices are falling on the
back of a plunge in global oil prices,
sharp falls seen in unemployment and
low interest rates continue to boost
households’ disposable incomes.
Private consumption is estimated to
have grown by 1.5% in 2014 and is set
to accelerate to 3.1% in 2015.
GDP GROWTH
3.4CONSUMER SPENDING
3.1
3.2 1.5
2.3 1.4
3
OFFICE
MARKET
OVERVIEW 2014
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
COUNTRY OVERVIEW
DEMOGRAPHICSHUNGARY with a population of
9.9 million (2013) and a land area of
92,340 sq km, is bordered by
Slovakia to the North, the Ukraine
and Romania to the East, Serbia and
Montenegro and Croatia to the
South and Slovenia and Austria to
the West. The country is situated in
the centre of the CEE region
connecting Western to Eastern
Europe.
BUDAPEST is the economic and
political capital with some 1.7 million
inhabitants. This constitutes 17% of
the country’s population which is
proportionately high compared to
the capitals of Poland (5%), Slovakia
(8%) and the Czech Republic (12%).
Hungary has only nine towns with a
population over 100,000.
TRANSPORTROAD: Hungary is well served by a
Motorway network that is still being
extended, with the M1 leading to the
west of Hungary and on to Vienna,
the M7 to the tourist destination of
Lake Balaton, Croatia and Slovenia.
The M5 leads to the south to Szeged
then Serbia, while the M3 leads to
the east, and Romania and the
Ukraine. The Hungarian motorway
network is Budapest-centred.
AIR: There are two passenger
terminals at Budapest’s Liszt Ferenc
International Airport, which is 16 km
south-east of the capital.
RAILWAY: Budapest is the hub of
the Hungarian railway network, with
three large stations. From Budapest a
7,607 km network radiates through
the country with various connections
to the larger towns. Whilst many
domestic lines are dated,
international connections such as
from Budapest to Vienna are efficient
and comfortable.
COUNTRY DATA
Population 9.9 million (2013)
Top Cities
Budapest 1,700,000
Debrecen 204,000
Miskolc 163,000
Szeged 161,000
Győr 129,000
Currency Forint
VAT - Standard Rate 27%
ECONOMIC & POLITICAL BREAKDOWN
GDP US$ 130.9 billion (2013)
Public sector balance -2.2% of GDP (2013)
Public sector debt 79.2% of GDP (2013)
Current account balance 3.0% of GDP (2013)
ParliamentMajority government of Fidesz and KDNP
President János Áder
Prime Minister Viktor Orbán
Election dates
October 2014 (Municipality)
2017 (Presidential)
2018 (Parliamentary and Municipal)
4
OFFICE
MARKET
OVERVIEW 2014
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
RETAIL SNAPSHOT Q4 2014
-20,0%
-15,0%
-10,0%
-5,0%
0,0%
5,0%
10,0%
15,0%
20,0%
3,00%
4,00%
5,00%
6,00%
7,00%
8,00%
9,00%
dec..04 dec..06 dec..08 dec..10 dec..12 dec..14
AN
NU
AL R
EN
TA
L G
RO
WT
H (y/y)
PR
IME Y
IELD
Rental Growth - Prime Yield - Prime
PRIME RETAIL VALUES - HUNGARY
The outlook for the retail sector is generally stable, albeit there are some concerns over the
potential impact of increased state intervention in recent months.
A new law was passed in December, which forces non-family owned retail stores that are larger than
200 sq m GLA to shut on Sundays, which may dampen investors appetite and cause some
international occupiers to re-consider expansion plans in the country. This is in addition to an already
approved levy of up to 6% on retail activities and a rule that will revoke a trading license if there are
two consecutive years of trading losses.
MARKET
OUTLOOK
PRIME RENTSAre stable with some upward pressure
for Váci utca
PRIME YIELDSForecast to remain unchanged at current
levels in 2015
SUPPLYGood supply in most locations and
limited development pipeline
DEMAND Occupier demand is healthy for prime
locations whereas investment demand to
remain selective
5
OFFICE
MARKET
OVERVIEW 2014
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
RETAIL SNAPSHOT Q4 2014
PRIME RETAIL RENTS – DECEMBER 2014
€ € US$ GROWTH %
HIGH STREET SHOPS SQ.M/MTH SQ.M/YR SQ.FT/YR 1YR 5YR CAGR
Budapest (Váci utca) 95 1,140 128 0.0 -1.0Budapest (Andrássy út) 40 480 54 0.0 -7.8
€ € US$ GROWTH %
RETAIL PARKS SQ.M/MTH SQ.M/YR SQ.FT/YR 1YR 5YR CAGR
Budapest 7.50 90 10.1 7.1 -3.6Budaörs 7.00 84 9.4 0.0 -4.9
PRIME RETAIL YIELDS – DECEMBER 2014
HIGH STREET SHOPS CURRENT LAST LAST 10 YEAR
(FIGURES ARE GROSS, %) QUARTER QUARTER YEAR HIGH LOW
Budapest (Váci utca) 6.75 6.75 7.00 8.50 5.50
Budapest (Andrássy út) 7.00 7.00 7.25 11.00 6.00
RETAIL PARKS CURRENT LAST LAST 10 YEAR
(FIGURES ARE GROSS, %) QUARTER QUARTER YEAR HIGH LOW
Budapest 8.50 8.50 8.50 8.50 6.25
Budaörs 8.50 8.50 8.50 8.50 6.00
SHOPPING CENTRES CURRENT LAST LAST 10 YEAR
(FIGURES ARE GROSS, %) QUARTER QUARTER YEAR HIGH LOW
Hungary 7.25 7.25 7.25 7.50 5.00
With respect to the yield data provided, in light of the lack of recent comparable market evidence in many areas of Europe and the changing nature of the market and the costs
implicit in any transaction, such as financing, these are very much a guide only to indicate the approximate trend and direction of prime initial yield levels and should not be used
as a comparable for any particular property or transaction without regard to the specifics of the property.
MARKET
OUTLOOK
OCCUPIER FOCUSDemand remains healthy, with a growing
number of international mass-market and
luxury operators actively looking for space in
key high street locations and in the best
performing shopping centres.
There is a relatively good supply of retail
units in most locations.
Prime rents are under pressure in Váci
utca to rise further.
INVESTMENT FOCUSInvestment demand for retail assets is
patchy and the majority of deals tend to be
smaller sized lots, with local investors
dominant in this segment.
International investors are typically only
interested in larger shopping centre and
portfolio deals.
Total investment volume were €193 mn in
2014, which is better than in recent years
but still below the peak annual volumes of
€946 mn in 2007.
Prime yields were unchanged across the
country.
HighstreetRetail
7
OFFICE
MARKET
OVERVIEW 2014
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
HIGHSTREET RETAIL
The Main Streets Across the World 2014/2015 Cushman & Wakefield Research Publication identified 31
high street locations in the CEE region. Budapest Váci utca is the third most expensive retail location in
the region, just after Prague downtown areas but outstrips Warsaw and Bratislava high streets.
Source: Main Streets across the World, A Cushman & Wakefield Research Publication http://www.cushmanwakefield.com/en/research-and-insight/
RANK COUNTRY CITY LOCATIONRENT
Sept 2014
RENT
EURO/SQ.M
/YR
RANK COUNTRY CITY LOCATIONRENT Sept
2014
RENT
EURO/SQ.M
/YR
22. Bulgaria Burgas Alexandrovska 25 300 6. Poland Warsaw ul. Chmielna 70 840
22. Bulgaria PlovdivAlexander
Batenberg25 300 11. Poland Warsaw ul. Jerozolimskie 47 564
13. Bulgaria Sofia Vitosha Blvd 44 528 7. Poland Warsawul.
Marszalkowska60 720
18. Bulgaria Varna Kniaz Boris I. 30 360 4. Poland Warsaw ul. Nowy Swiat 85 1 020
6.Czech
RepublicBrno
Ceska Street /
Svobody Square70 840 14. Poland Wroclaw ul. Swidnicka 40 480
1.Czech
RepublicPrague
Na Prikope /
Wenceslas
Square
185 2 220 14. Romania Brasov Strada Republicii 40 480
2.Czech
RepublicPrague Parizska Street 180 2 160 10. Romania Bucharest
Bulevardul
Magheru50 600
14. Hungary Budapest Andrássy út 40 480 12. Romania Bucharest Calea Victorei 45 540
3. Hungary Budapest Váci utca 95 1 140 15. Romania Cluj
Memorandumul
ui, Napoca,
Eroilor
37 444
19. Poland Gdynia ul. Swietojanska 29 348 23. Romania Constanta
Stefan cel Mare,
Rascoala din
1907
20 240
9. Poland Katowice ul. 3 Maja 53 636 23. Romania IasiStefan cel Mare,
Cuza Voda20 240
5. Poland Krakow ul. Florianska 75 900 16. Romania Timisoara Victoriei 35 420
21. Poland Lodz ul. Piotrkowska 26 312 14. Slovakia Bratislava Downtown 40 480
8. Poland Poznan ul. Polwiejska 55 660 8. Slovenia Ljubljana Copova 55 660
17. Poland SzczecinAl.
Niepodleglosci33 396 20. Slovenia Ljubljana Slovenska ulica 27 324
8. Poland Warsaw Trzech Krzyzy 55 660
MOST
EXPENSIVE
LOCATIONS
IN CEE
NA
PRIKOPE &
WENCELA
S SQUARE
€
SQM
/M
€185
PRIME
YIELDS
CURREN
T VALUES
5.00%
PARISKA
STREET
€180 5.00%
VÁCI
UTCA
€95 6.75%
UL.
NOWY
SWIAT
€85 7.50%
8
OFFICE
MARKET
OVERVIEW 2014
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
BUDAPEST
Budapest’s high street shopping area is concentrated in 3
major shopping streets located in the city center.
VÁCI UTCA is the main shopping street of Budapest, attracting most mass market
retailers. The street is pedestrianised, and generates circa 25,000 pedestrian traffic on a
daily basis. Retailers present include H&M, Promod, Zara, Douglas, Mango, Swarovski,
L’Occitane, Salamander, Foot Locker and Deichmann.
FASHION STREET is another shopping destination targetted by middle to high-
end retailers with current tenants Hugo Boss, Furla, Lacoste, Lloyd, Massimo Dutti,
Starbucks, Zara Home and Oysho. This is located in the vicinity of Váci utca, forming an
„L” shape shopping area. Footfall is in the range of circa 15-18,000 people per day.
ANDRÁSSY ÚT (Andrássy Avenue) has become the main destination for luxury
retailers since the opening of Louis Vuitton. The avenue is part of the National Heritage
site, and has excellent potentials. Retailers, such as LV, Burberry, Gucci, Max Mara,
Nespresso, Boggi, and Hublot have already opened their flagship stores, and others are
investigating. Footfall at Andrássy Avenue is in the range of 8.000 – 10.000 people / day.
Petőfi Sándor Street, running parallel Váci utca is an emerging high street destination since
the street was partially pedestrianised. International retailers are not yet concentrating on
this location.
While there are a select number of luxury brands considering expansion in Hungary,
jewellery and fashion segment were the most active in recent years. Newest openings
include Il Bacio di Stile department store and Breitling on Andrássy út; Oysho, Intimissimi,
Subway, and Zara Home on Fashion Street and Desigual, Pylones, Deichmann in Váci utca.
LOOKING AHEAD,
ANDRÁSSY ÚT
IS EXPECTED TO SEE NEW ENTRANTS
AND PRIME RENTS – WHICH ARE
CURRENTLY MUCH LOWER THAN THE
MAIN SHOPPING STREET IN BUDAPEST
AND RANKED ONLY 14 IN CEE
COMPARISON – SHOULD RISE.
9
OFFICE
MARKET
OVERVIEW 2014
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
Shopping Centre Market
11
OFFICE
MARKET
OVERVIEW 2014
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
EVOLUTION OF THE MARKETThe first modern, first generation shopping centres opened in the second half of the 1990’s.
Typical examples include Duna Plaza, Pólus Center and Mammut1.
The second wave of the evolution happened in the early 2000’s when schemes having an
excellent strategic location came on the market. Examples are Westend City Center, Mammut II,
MOM Park, and Árkád Budapest; all of them producing outstanding footfall and turnover figures
since then.
The third wave of the evolution started in November 2007 with the opening of Aréna Plaza, a
scheme of 65,000 sq m GLA. Its retail concept and unique tenant mix fundamentally changed the
dynamics of the Hungarian market. ING’s Allee Shopping Centre, opened in November 2009, is
another prime example where best of class international anchor tenants are present. In Q3 2011,
the locally developed KÖKI Terminal opened with 55,000 sq m GLA, but is currently in
bankruptcy. The second phase of the Árkád Center opened in Q1 2013 (20,000 sq m), and thus
Árkád has become the largest scheme of the country.
In a CEE context, modern retail stock is far the largest in Poland with 9.0 million sq m GLA,
well above the CEE market average of 3.3 million square metres.
Hungary is one of the smallest markets by country comparison with 1.9 million square metres
GLA, but one of the largest markets by capital comparison with 778,000 square metres. Almost
60% of the Hungarian stock is concentrated in Budapest, which is the highest share in the region.
The highest saturation in the region can be found in Prague and Warsaw, followed by Budapest.
SHOPPING CENTRE MARKET
BUDAPEST IS ONE
OF THE LARGEST
MARKETS IN CEE
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Bulgaria / Sofia
Hungary / Budapest
Czech Rep. / Prague
Romania / Bucharest
Poland / Warsaw
SHARE OF MODERN SHOPPING CENTRE SPACE IN
CAPITAL CITIES VS REGIONAL CITIES
GLA open in capital city GLA open in regional cities
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700
Sofia
Budapest
Prague
Bucharest
Warsaw
SHOPPING CENTRE SPACE PER 1,000 POPULATION IN CEE
CAPITAL CITIES
12
OFFICE
MARKET
OVERVIEW 2014
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
STANDARD LEASE TERMS
GENERAL
DOCUMENTATION No standard form of lease contract is
available, whilst most modern leases are corresponding to Western
European standards. Landlords generally provide standard format lease
contracts for multi-tenanted offices and shopping centres.
ENFORCEABILITY OF LEASE Leases are enforceable on court,
but not widely tested.
RESTRICTIVE USER CLAUSES Premises may only be used for the
purpose defined in the lease. Any change will require the landlord’s
prior consent.
LEASE TERMS
DURATION OF LEASE 5-10 years
BREAK OPTIONS Negotiable, albeit generally implies penalty which
amounts to the total gross rent for the remaining lease term.
RENTAL PAYMENTS
RENT PAYMENT AND FREQUENCY Euro per square metre
per month, due monthly or quarterly in advance. In most cases payable
in HUF.
RENT DEPOSIT For retail properties a security deposit equivalent
to three months rent plus service charge is usually required or the
equivalent bank guarantee.
RENT REVIEWS No rent reviews, only indexation is common. For
retail properties a lock-up clause is common whereby turnover rent is
payable if is higher than the base rent.
INDEXATION Rents are indexed annually to HICP 27 or MUICP
index of Eurostat, generally at the start of the calendar year, or at the
anniversary of the lease commencement date.
SECURITY OF TENURE No automatic renewal option is defined
by law, whilst negotiable. Not common in Hungary.
PREMIUM/KEY MONEY Premiums are common in high street
retail only.
TURNOVER RENTS Turnover rents are common and subject to
the actual retail profile. Usually are in the 3-12% range.
SERVICE CHARGES, REPAIRS & INSURANCE
REPAIRS
Tenant Internal repairs only Landlord Structural repairs - charged back to tenant in the
service charge.
INSURANCE
Tenant Internal areas Landlord Main structure
SERVICE CHARGES Typically covers all operating expenses including management fee, security and cleaning costs, maintenance of
common areas, elevators, water / electricity / heating / air conditioning systems, snow clearance, property tax and property insurance.
UTILITIES INCLUDED IN SERVICE CHARGE For common areas only.
TAXATION
LOCAL TAXES
Tenant Local Business Tax - the maximum rate is 2% of gross
sales revenue less cost of goods acquired .
Landlord Property Tax - for buildings is based on GLA
(maximum HUF 1,821/sq m pa), or on the market value
(maximum 3.6%). For land, the tax is based on size (maximum
HUF 331/sq m pa), or on the market value of the land (maximum
3%).
VAT ON RENTS 27%
MEASURING CODE
MEASUREMENT PRACTICEGross Internal Area
LEGISLATION
LEGISLATION IN RELATION TO LEASE CONTRACTS Hungarian Civil Code.
PROSOPECTIVE CHANGES TO LEGISLATION None.
DISPOSAL OF LEASES
ASSIGNMENT AND SUB-LETTING Leases generally do not allow sub-leasing or assignment, but it is negotiable and subject to
the landlord’s written consent. The majority of the office leases allow sub-letting or assignment to an affiliate company.
EARLY TERMINATION Not allowed if the lease is concluded for definite term.
TENANT LIABILITY The tenant is generally responsible for reinstating the premises to their previous state, with the exception of
wear and tear. No further liability after lease expiry.
13
OFFICE
MARKET
OVERVIEW 2014
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
14
OFFICE
MARKET
OVERVIEW 2014
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
SUNDAY TRADING BAN
On 16 December 2014, the Hungarian Government
voted to restrict retail trade on Sundays effective from
15 March 2015. The ban applies to most shops with very
few exceptions such as pharmacies, bakeries, retail at
international airports, railway stations, bus terminals,
hospitals, petrol stations, hotels, entertaining and spa
facilities, shops located within the World Heritage zone,
and family businesses of less than 200 square metres.
In 2015, 38 Sundays will be affected considering the
Advent period (four weekends before Christmas) will
not be banned. which corresponds to a decrease of 10%
in trading hours per annum. If calculating this figure for
the whole year, the decrease in trading hours is
equivalent to 13% per annum, which is almost
three times higher than the loss caused by public
holidays.
Studies of trading liberalisation have confirmed the
presumption that larger retail schemes benefit to a
greater extent from the Sunday trading than their smaller
counterparts or high street retail, therefore with an
opposite regulation one would expect larger shopping
centre schemes and out-of-town retail warehousing
including big boxes, retail parks, outlet schemes will be
more hit.
Studies suggest that Sunday trading is important in fields
where time intensive search has importance. These are
the products where there are high consumer loyalty. We
consider that strong property fundamentals such as in-
city location, public transport links and tenant mix could
counterbalance the loss in trading hours.
Our investigations amongst core retailers reveal
that they are expecting a decrease in turnover
of 7-9% in the short-term. The impact of the new
regulation will be different amongst retailers and some
(e.g. cafes in shopping centres) will likely to be more
dramatic. Those who will likely be less affected will
move to alternative days or e-commerce or will seek to
open for longer hours, although the Government is
restricting retail trade beyond 6 am-10 pm on weekdays.
Studies also suggest that confectionery, tobacco and
drinks being goods with little consumer loyalty to
particular outlets, therefore here the Sunday closing
might have impact that is more significant. The view
however, of a prime FMCG retailer is that the regulation
will not affect the FMCG market, since they sell
“essentials”. Shops with 200 square metres or less GLA,
or those, which are family-owned will only be allowed to
open, meaning that large supermarkets / hypermarkets
will have to shut, losing a strong sales day and sending
customers towards smaller rivals. We consider in
situations like this, alternatives such as e-shopping and
delivery services are likely to be developed further, albeit
the government intends restricting Sunday delivery as
well.
Most retailers
believe that these
measures will not
last – the ICSC is
currently preparing for
the public voting against
the regulation. Main
arguments include the
treat of significant staff
redundancies and lower
revenues through VAT.
The above will definitely
be a hot issue in the
coming months and will
emerge to cause
uncertainty on the
market. We are
continuously talking to
market players and will
keep you posted.
www.cushmanwakefield.com
ORSOLYA HEGEDŰS MRICSRICS Registered Valuer
Head of Research Hungary
Associate Valuation and Advisory