research design - ope rationalization
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
1/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 11
Research designResearch design operationalization ofoperationalization ofvariablesvariables
Chapter 6 in Babbie & Mouton (2001)Chapter 6 in Babbie & Mouton (2001)
The construction of actual, concreteThe construction of actual, concretemeasurement techniques; the creation ofmeasurement techniques; the creation of
operations that will result in the desiredoperations that will result in the desiredmeasurements.measurements.
The development or choice of specificThe development or choice of specific
research procedures (operations) that willresearch procedures (operations) that willresult in representing the concepts ofresult in representing the concepts ofinterest.interest.
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
2/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 22
OperationalizationOperationalization
An operational definition is a procedure forAn operational definition is a procedure forclassifying, ordering, or quantifying somethingclassifying, ordering, or quantifying something
ClassifyingClassifying -- crowded or not crowdedcrowded or not crowded
OrderingOrdering -- uncrowded, mildly crowded, severelyuncrowded, mildly crowded, severelycrowdedcrowded
QuantifyingQuantifying -- measure crowdedness in terms of themeasure crowdedness in terms of thenumber of residents per square kilometrenumber of residents per square kilometre
Focus on questionnairesFocus on questionnaires otherotheroperationalization techniques in section on typesoperationalization techniques in section on typesof research designof research design
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
3/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 33
Choices to be made about operationalizationChoices to be made about operationalization
The range of variationThe range of variation how large should yourhow large should yourcategories be?categories be?
Depends on the purpose of your studyDepends on the purpose of your study pragmaticpragmatic
considerations (considerations (e.g. income)e.g. income) Variation between the extremesVariation between the extremes how fine are thehow fine are the
disctinctions you want to make in your study?disctinctions you want to make in your study?
e.g. agee.g. age
Again, depends on the purpose of your studyAgain, depends on the purpose of your study
(Why research is such a challenging task(Why research is such a challenging task very few recipes)very few recipes)
Single or multiple indicators of variablesSingle or multiple indicators of variables Some straightforward, such as genderSome straightforward, such as gender
But others benefit from multiple indicatorsBut others benefit from multiple indicators
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
4/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 44
Levels of measurementLevels of measurement
Of great concern in psychometricsOf great concern in psychometrics
We look for three elements:We look for three elements:
A zero pointA zero point
Distances between categories equalDistances between categories equal Categories can be rankCategories can be rank--orderedordered
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
5/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 55
Nominal measuresNominal measures
Reflects only categoriesReflects only categories
The variable gender has two attributes,The variable gender has two attributes,
male and femalemale and female They are distinct from one another, butThey are distinct from one another, but
they have no additional structuresthey have no additional structures
Also political party affiliation, birthplace,Also political party affiliation, birthplace,etc.etc.
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
6/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 66
ExampleExample
The next question is on the subject of work. People lookThe next question is on the subject of work. People lookfor different things in a job. Which of the following fivefor different things in a job. Which of the following fivethings would you most prefer in a job?things would you most prefer in a job?
1. work that pays well1. work that pays well
2. work that gives a feeling of accomplishment2. work that gives a feeling of accomplishment
3. work where there is not too much supervision and you make3. work where there is not too much supervision and you makemost decisions yourselfmost decisions yourself
4. work that is pleasant and where the other people are nice to4. work that is pleasant and where the other people are nice towork withwork with
5. work that is steady with little chance of being laid off5. work that is steady with little chance of being laid off
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
7/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 77
Ordinal measuresOrdinal measures
Include the aboveInclude the above
Plus we can logically rankPlus we can logically rank--order theorder the
attributesattributes e.g. social class, prejudicee.g. social class, prejudice
We can rank order people according to theWe can rank order people according to the
amount of education they hadamount of education they had
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
8/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 88
ExampleExample
1. very satisfied1. very satisfied
2. fairly satisfied2. fairly satisfied
3. neither satisfied nor dissatisfied3. neither satisfied nor dissatisfied 4. fairly dissatisfied4. fairly dissatisfied
5. very dissatisfied5. very dissatisfied
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
9/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 99
Interval measuresInterval measures
Include the aboveInclude the above
Plus the intervals between the attributes havePlus the intervals between the attributes havemeaningmeaning
e.g scores on an intelligence teste.g scores on an intelligence test
BUT:BUT:
We cannot say that a person with an IQ of 120 isWe cannot say that a person with an IQ of 120 isTWICE as intelligent as one with an IQ of 60TWICE as intelligent as one with an IQ of 60
And the 5 points difference between 110 and 115,And the 5 points difference between 110 and 115,and 95 and 100?and 95 and 100?
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
10/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 1010
Ratio measuresRatio measures
Include all of the aboveInclude all of the above
Plus they have a true zero pointPlus they have a true zero point
e.g.e.g.
how long you have lived in Cape Town?how long you have lived in Cape Town?
ageage the number of times you were marriedthe number of times you were married
incomeincome
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
11/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 1111
ImplicationsImplications
Mainly for the analysis of data (theMainly for the analysis of data (thestatistics part of the course)statistics part of the course)
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
12/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 1212
Indexes and scalesIndexes and scales
Social scientific concepts have complex and varied meaningsSocial scientific concepts have complex and varied meanings
Often difficult to capture all the dimensions of a conceptOften difficult to capture all the dimensions of a concept
As a result, we normally make multiple observations, and useAs a result, we normally make multiple observations, and usemore than one indicator of a variablemore than one indicator of a variable
Indexes and scales are techniques to combine indicators of aIndexes and scales are techniques to combine indicators of avariable into a single measure of that variablevariable into a single measure of that variable
They are composite measures of variablesThey are composite measures of variables measurementsmeasurementsbased on more than one data itembased on more than one data item
Typically they are ordinal measures of variablesTypically they are ordinal measures of variables
Typical in quantitative researchTypical in quantitative research
Indexes and scales differ through the manner in which scoresIndexes and scales differ through the manner in which scoresare assigned to individual attributesare assigned to individual attributes
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
13/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 1313
IndexesIndexes
Constructed through the simple accumulation ofConstructed through the simple accumulation ofscores assigned to individual attributesscores assigned to individual attributes
e.g. we add the number of items a person agreede.g. we add the number of items a person agreedwith to obtain a total scorewith to obtain a total score
e.g. How politically active are you? We give you sixe.g. How politically active are you? We give you sixstatements of political activities you could have beenstatements of political activities you could have been
involved in, and if you indicate that you have beeninvolved in, and if you indicate that you have beeninvolved in three of them, you will obtain a score of 3involved in three of them, you will obtain a score of 3on our index of political activism.on our index of political activism.
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
14/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 1414
ScalesScales
A scale recognizes that not all responses reflectA scale recognizes that not all responses reflectthe same degree of the presence of a variablethe same degree of the presence of a variable
e.g. women are different from men is a muche.g. women are different from men is a much
weaker statement of the variable sexism thanweaker statement of the variable sexism thanwomen should not be allowed to votewomen should not be allowed to vote
Also, it assigns scores to patterns of responsesAlso, it assigns scores to patterns of responses
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
15/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 1515
Scaling proceduresScaling procedures
Bogardus social distance scaleBogardus social distance scale
Thurstone scalesThurstone scales
Likert scalingLikert scaling
Semantic differentialSemantic differential
Guttman scalingGuttman scaling
The format of the LikertThe format of the Likert--typetype scaling isscaling iscommonly used in questionnaire design todaycommonly used in questionnaire design today
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
16/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 1616
ShopaholicismShopaholicism
1 I enjoy shopping1 I enjoy shopping SAgrSAgr AgrAgr NeitherNeither DisDis SdisSdis
2 I look forward to going shopping2 I look forward to going shopping SAgrSAgr AgrAgr NeitherNeither DisDis SdisSdis
3 I shop whenever I have the opportunity3 I shop whenever I have the opportunity SAgrSAgr AgrAgr NeitherNeither DisDis SdisSdis
4 I avoid shopping if I can4 I avoid shopping if I can SAgrSAgr AgrAgr NeitherNeither DisDis SdisSdis
5 When I visit a town or city I don't know well, I always5 When I visit a town or city I don't know well, I alwayswant to see the shopswant to see the shops SAgrSAgr AgrAgr NeitherNeither DisDis SdisSdis
6 Shopping is a chore that I have to put up with.6 Shopping is a chore that I have to put up with.
SAgrSAgr AgrAgr NeitherNeither DisDis SdisSdis
-
8/3/2019 Research Design - Ope Rationalization
17/17
Research designResearch design -- operationalizationoperationalization 1717
ShopaholicismShopaholicism
ScoringScoring -- note 4 and 6note 4 and 6
Level of measurementLevel of measurement -- ordinal orordinal orinterval/ratiointerval/ratio