res original - wordpress.com · ctj/j v/af-ed tjj-a,1 ol/er1f'e , /j q c/re,u/t courf f ... ca...
TRANSCRIPT
i/S
S'(,,..,1- I / I , -f'u Ti' {J/= /111..{' SI£' SI /J /JI
::z;; •
FILED SEP 26 2016
OFFICE OF THE CLERK SUPREME COURT
iJe l.1/ l.10/Je ~OURTOFAPPEALS
..vo. a01s-f?1:- oos;i 1 - ,e.J; u Res ftJrJ del'J I-
ORIGINAL
Comt.S .A/tJtAI, Pe/--/J/e1/Je.r J)o,v/d "YacKSor1, Prv Se , Q.rJtl // /) / /> 1' I u/Jd mov-eS r/J,'S Cou,./- 1--or a cJ,,-.1 I- or Ce,,-,orar1
?fl )/j /o/1~ Y-- /J1a l<e .r h/s /Jf /-/.J, p;1 /Ju r Suc,11 I- -1-o
/17,'S.J','js//J/J/ Rt..1/e.f' d/:- /).1'/Je/J~ft /Jroc/Jdur~ /1wle J'7{a){3)t).
/J-/} d //J J'u /J/ld ,-r 1 I i"a / J /J e I/ l-,"o/1 cJ ou I J Show ..J--o
J-f;/s JloyJor0ihlt: Col/I,/- -fhtJ .fo//uuv1//1J:
_:n:-',
Th,~ C'ciJ'~ //J valve a Ct111.Fl/.1..u /,~r1Lt I tJrJ/J J .f'f-a /.r_,1/orc;
t,~h/- f-o a~ a/J/Jeal .. #rJd ?he dtJr1,~I 11./ /-he /"tJCorJ
(.J--;1,11-1.fCr//Jf) /r a d/Jn/al o/ ~/Jc,./- r,Jhf,
!h/j ...rub J'/a,1 I-,~ I Cf d-ef' l,~,1 a I /au lJ 1,/c t, /s ol
n r/ I I>/ I d I I lh ,n .::1B/'JBral J,.!3n,:1-,cc,,,1C~ r&qu1t"'e. a ec,'..f,or1 /J<{ e .::iu/Jreme
Cou,/. ff},Y,{'_ Rule S dt /l-/lPe//e, 1-e /l,t1ct1 tlc1rt1, !?ult' 17
(a) (3) (/) I
2016
I
• .
/ ~
l-h1.J' IS
~ /Jo['/-c i);1 V, j; /-/~/I /.rS'ue r Thal- SVJot.1! cl '7(-) dec/dptf
.bf/ ~i/f' courh ne,e. ,~f' /JO courl- flrecflfln I ..f/ic,/
re.J't1f Ve 411 /.J'Stte o./1 /'li/1' YJalurr:1.
1h1~ C1Jurl- haS' fl-a/.td /.--ha//'' fl /Josl-conv/cl,'o;1
re I,& I /J()//l/11/Jt'r /r t!/J J././/e J l-o f.}(}f'l-c tJ'7v/c h~/J d/scover4
to, !J"o d Caufe I'hown tJ P1 l<f /.; /J/f m // //0,1 t,,.//1-h S'l~/Jd-5
..J'unJ/Jary J,'.fm:ss,;t "1 r'/e1>'1,AJ v. .fl-ale, SS 3 So.J.d sos
c;,/ So~, J)e/-/://u/Jt'/" slaks ~haJ .th/s t:1/JPeet I /~
d/J>//,13u/J'lialile /,om F/e/J1//J3,I11 ~/;al Cate F/e1,r1,l,,.5
JJ/e I .gu/1 fY.
-rh11/ !tit1ve.f IAe afJ/Je/!alhf tJ'/1 d/rSci- a/7/lt°al
tJho have /Jee n dt°rv"& ti h/s r,!Jhl- ./,l) C Ir/al
./rcu·1fc r / pl, .17 o rtun e ti <f a J /atJ,
1/Je tA/1,1/-(}d Jlcf&f .I'u/J~tni!- courl held I-Ju; I .,. a d ti t/J/JJc.11 ./ /~ a c r/ rn/11a I ca.f'e 1S e/1 t/.J/e cl -1-o
a. l-ra/JScr//ll d I 1,/_t /, ~ sl l-r,·~J uht/J I-/; e.-
1-rM J>c,/fJI- 1/J' /'Jc#d&d ./ar o,r1 efleol./v~ d~/e;,,Se
cJ,1 CA I/Jea I~ Br ,"f { V, ./\/t1rl-h C01 ,o //rJa I Lf oLf U, S~ :l:J. ~ /
al J.J?.
trl/J'J, L(Jde, ./J11/J. qq-35-101, --9,'~s tJn'I /Je/'.f>OV\
CtJ/J v/af-ed tJJ- a,1 ol/er1f'e , /J q c/re,u/t COurf f-h e
r(Jhl- lo 4/J/Jecl ~tJ J.,/,e .J'uf)reme cou,.f.
lh8 de,1/a/ at t1 Com /Jltk ~cord a,1tl +fat"!SCr/P-r dP'()~
1-Aal r(Jhl,
:rz:, ?eJ///o,1er tJ C, J' C 011v/cl-t>d bf/ 5urr ,/J c~ !,e A/ti I J / h3"
maJ/~011 CourJf</ c/,cu/1- Courl-. /Ll/Jd ,r/- I~ J-;,, flus Ca Se .J-.,h~ / f-h C /-re,,r1.J'cr/ p/ u /J cf d O c u,n t'/1 J.s Q /' l
Sou.3hl-, P/Jd ,j /Jc'CeJ'SCt/'tf rtt d11c,~~ SPec/.1,c /S'Sll11S
#/Jd 1-t? /d&r1l/~o/ .t/Jec/,C,c v/o/a/,~,1S,
;ht CDm /} ffk /.rtMS'Cr/~I- a/lei t"f>C o,d.S tJt rt 110 I /Jre J&1kJ ../---r1 ll1 / J' c~u /'j tJ r1 d/r~cl- a /l/Jea (,
~
j} t' // 1--, dtJu J' ltt /es !-ha I- he lN us. d en /e d e ~ /'e c ././ ve._
c;, .r r/sl-aJ11Ce O /1 Counsel 1'r1 f/Jt;, I C()uf/1.s'el ..J-o/e,c,/&c/J
w,'l-hou /- c r1J11n1-e/lf 1 ,dJ/Jro/?&r a/Jd /Jrelud/ c/0, I Yemc,rk~
/ I / ar1 d fY}tJf,/Jf'J&,'-i' rnS' O/J l,le /Jar!- o / ..Ji1e l-rJC1, JUd!:Je.,.
rr/a! ;udje ardtrerl 'i}e,,rl-S t1I Jhe reco(d ..J.,,o bt
J
Om/ .J 1-ed, 1/Je CotArl: rr /Jo fhe clerk) /-c;/(e
fhQI meSSPt.3e o./1 J) 1/"u/JS'Cr/PI- /J, d 13 ,
Juli/cl, v/ola k d /YJ<f r,'j h .f f-o u//1 e I I f'C I: ve
a /J /Jea /, ,, 1he hue /Jroces-s clause e,1 l/./les ~ /JfrSo,1 lo
Or) /nJ fJ11rl-/a. I c,11 d tl/J>,/J l-ere5-kd ./-I,'l;unti I ,~ bt1Jh ( 11 d ( ( I )) h I _. C1V1 a/l Cr,rr11111a CaS'ef .. mar~ af v, Jerr/co,Tr1c_J
I OtJ S, C j / ~ / 0, a f I /JJ I 3 "
Tire fr,~! ;dd.9~ .f'hdwt3J hof' /-/1/1-lf a,1J
c tJ/J .fe9 ll e IJ 1-1'{ ma de / I , ';,,,i /J .1S' S, I, I e .f!o r iJ e ./{/lo/le r + o
Pm.S/3/11 h/s detm.fe,. .r- £JaS dtJ!l,~d mv ,(5hf +o a .l1a/r Irr~!; /Ile .Jr/al fudse ordered over /G>
ht/JCh d/~Cc/JJ\t7/)J oll' n:>Cdrd.,
1/;e SMl~c,/13 /Jear/r1j ht!d orl ~11t14rCf ;.e-;
/9Cffl/ /:iw/,,~h !ht ./-r/a I :ud!Jt recuJ'ed hlYV1~tf-f
Wei S n (} I made /Ja rl- /J /-) .J,/Je record or1 a /J Pe1t I -;:J,.j -J,/J/s hear!nJ ev/detW 1-haf /he c./legrd
utrll/t,1 fJ,l-tmt/JI tJaS ./a/Jr/caf-gJ_ WuS PaS!'IJ.f~d-
7Z11 -,
Ltl/Jtre. a del&Jtk11t l1?es I-or d,~cl- ct/1/J~q I c;,_
CorYJ JJ!&k record ,l' e..f.t'er,./-,~/,
(r ti /Jo,r..JY S'eek,~!3- re,vtWSq I o./- ll1e. Jud.smMI- o/J
u Jr/of couri PJllSI /Jrrs~J- -1-/;t!...- a,tJ1,t?e//0r:le Ct7urJ...,,
lJ/./h LA record c;dequ0if--e .Jo Show ./-,ha/· t:?n error
of re ve, S, ble /Jr() Po,,..J-/o/7.s' hti·S been comm/I-led
urJ d ..fh4 ~ .f/;e /Jo/,,, .J hla..f' /;e eJ? /Yl'7JC ed' ura I 1 '-1
V,@Jerved.?) Jone.S l/.. S)-/1:;+e/ CJ(p;;. So.2dS7/Uoo6J ...
T/Je eJh/h//S deS/'5(')qfed IAf heCe.f'SCir~ OY1 c;/1/JPaf
IA.le re n&ver to ,LJ a, d--e d -1-o M/s c·ourl ag requ (,,e d
bC/ M/c .f. !lt..1/es /J / J!Jt?t:Jel /ale Pr1 cedar~> Ru le I I
{d) /J) (; / /), Bet:.auf'e ~Ae t v1tl~J-J<f u/1Jt S .Jalir/c~-k I.
W/lh /,Jr au./htJr/.Jy o./ .f/Je Courl Pt>.//l-/o/1Rr
C oa/tl Produce- t> x ('Li I /Ja lore; f //, ti tr> Ce ..lh& I-- W 11u Id
Prave a U-ua I 1/J/J o c t°/J r iJ S'.
:-11111,
711& d12/h~I tJJ! lhe c~m(}J&le l-,ar1SC,//.J/- and !¥'corl I .
t111 d,,c'ct a/J/Jflal tJtJu!d be r"--evBrS/Ji/e error,
iJ/J//fJ v. S la lei/ hos .S. w. ,J d 5 S ~ fi 9 %0 J J (1e xa g). /1/h,£ h /_t fr1aJ11Ja-hJ bl/ Br/11-J ~u/Jra.
::rt:._.
Ptl/),~IJEJr sfa-le.J' Ma/, . -rhtJ c/le.s I~ S'u/J/Jor..J.
ol -!ht Courl- tJI /Jf)f}ea IS d/JPOJ//--/cJt/J a rt_
8u/f fC( /J /ea S, JYJ ~h/1' Cu J'e /J~ J,/t/c1/1er /.r ~//1 //j/&6'
I-a a -traY1 S' c r/ p./ a .I' tJ ./) r (9 h f_ /JtJ J Af, I-- r j h ./- W r;. S
v/olalet:! h Y ..J,!J fl fr/~ I Courl,
::C/1 JIJ~ cou,/.- o? IJ/J/J&al...f rc1!/n.3 J pa.Ee 3, e/.//nj
Fkm,/13J SSJ So. Jd a I so&, rr W,'/h,',-, +-hi' /JC R
c.fJl'eai I
ll,e /Jr/.J'cMtr rnalf /,,,c/,.de /.-he c/c.//Y? .fhcf.
/,/ie de,1/al tJ /! h,J> r't:qoesf- lor lra;1Scr,J?f or '))
{) /lie r ti o cu n1M /-S LAI a .f er!' or. 1 /I/ J ,L/r> r ou,./- f-o n1a k .,a t--fu; /- ...ran1#
jJ fJ f-1 r 1 /J/Je r a__f I< r'lJ/...J L
c/a,~ av,.:ldle /..o Cl /Jr/1w1er .J-,hfl/.- utc.S den/ed
h, 'J> r/.9 h I- .J-,o a co /11 /I le le l-rar1J' er, W a,, J do cu tnM IS
on di rec/. afl/Jt:r, I 1,.,/,,1 C our-/, W ht!'t' he Md'
!J, ~n /,1 etl-e c I/ ve. a S'S/J'/-c, 11ce a/J counJ>ei
olh8, lJ ,Te f.h ere lJ /1 I /J fJ /J o ,Bd ,rl}_S' S. -fto r Ct
J.v /" h h h t d I d. '-,'" r I J O/Je /' W IJ fll V'll f> t7 r> lJ r t:J r1 j Cf /J YI I B VI ~
r(jhl lo an t:J'./t?cl/,N o./J/Jtc.l J,y a,1 ,/Jcoh?/Jlt'k
l-r a~..I'C r / 17../- ..
/tlerfJ .fiote _£' a...Cr lh/~ Courl :/--o g ra/1 y Set,' J.
JJe//l-/0.,1 /Jo,,, t...,tr/1 o/J ce,J-/ort?tr/ J,haf :C mat{
r-Bdr{)SS .the dt?/7,~/ DJ] rYJ '( 0'9hJ ..J-o CIJr71'1/e.f.e
/rt:tJ1JSC/'1~J a/Jd mco~I. 0/1 d/rLJvl-- a/Jl-7tal..
Ile Sfl<tCl/u I Jq Subm, 1./uf,
,tJ~c~
JJav/ci J'acl<SOYI # :J,t;vL/O
~, m.c . .r. P. o, l3ox Jt/19
le0il<tsv/!lf/ mt- JqLf5J
Ce,// //co,. /--e_ /JF Sef'vlce
-r-JII (> ~S /_ In w I ,D
Cc.used l-o b8 nJo,.,'/,!!.tl, v/c u.S. nJc,~'l, /7tJS-la,[:)e_
/Jfc'-Pc,/d., o, I-rue cuJcl ~rrecl Cof7l/ ol -fhe
c.6ov-e O/Jd ~oa~o/r1j le.ft'l/u/1 lor u.Jy/j o/J
C ~' J/or-CA ~/ +o .'
trz/r.f' ... S'u.preme COCA/' I- C /erk
~ 0, JJ qj_ '* </ q . P, (/, Bat ,)_cJ- o
J)o,v/d J o.c~f On
:Jq~'!O Sm. c.,,...r. P, 0, B(/A /lf I q
Lea Ke tv/1 I tJ, mr. 3fCf5/
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF MISSISSIPPI
NO. 2015-CP-00521-COA
DAVID JACKSON AfK/A DAVID DONNELL JACKSON
APPELLANT
v.
STATE OF MISSISSIPPI
DATE OF JUDGMENT: TRIAL JUDGE: COURT FROM WHICH APPEALED: ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANT: ATTORNEY FOR APPELLEE:
NATURE OF THE CASE: TRIAL COURT DISPOSITION:
DISPOSITION: MOTION FOR REHEARING FILED: MANDATE ISSUED:
APPELLEE
03/06/2015 HON. JOHN HUEY EMFINGER MADISON COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT DAVID JACKSON (PRO SE) OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL BY: JEFFREY A. KLINGFUSS CNIL - POSTCONVICTION RELIEF MOTION FOR TRANSCRIPTS AND RECORDS DENIED APPEAL DISMISSED - 05/03/2016
BEFORE GRIFFIS, P.J., CARL TON AND JAMES, JJ.
JAMES, J., FOR THE COURT:
11. David Jackson (pro se) appeals from the circuit court's denial of his motion for
transcripts and records. We dismiss Jackson's appeal for lack of jurisdiction.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL IDSTORY
,r2. On December 11, 1997, Jackson was convicted of possession of cocaine with intent
to distribute. He was sentenced as a habitual offender to thirty years to be served in the
custody of the Mississippi Department of Corrections. His conviction was affirmed on direct
appeal. Jackson v. State, 778 So. 2d 786, 790 (120) (Miss. Ct. App. 2001).
(111'/JMd/ X l'f) q
"
if3. Since then, Jackson has filed numerous postconviction-relief (PCR) motions, and has
received monetary sanctions for his frivolous motions. On August 20, 2014, the Mississippi
Supreme Court entered an order denying Jackson's motion to lift his sanctions. See Jackson
v. State, 2014-M-00623 (Miss. Aug. 20, 2014). In that same order, the court dismissed his
pending PCR motion as both time-barred and a successive writ. The court found that the
issues he raised were not within any exception to the procedural bars. Id. The court also
determined that Jackson's PCR motion was frivolous, and further sanctioned him $200 in
addition to any outstanding sanctions that already had been imposed. Id.
if4. On November 13, 2014, the court dismissed Jackson's "Petition for a Writ of
Production of Documents Pursuant to Miss. R. App. P. 21." See Jackson v. State, 2014-M-
00623 (Miss. Nov. 13, 2014). On December 23, 2014, the court dismissed Jackson's
"Motion for Production of Documents." See Jackson v. State, 2014-M-00623 (Miss. Dec.
23, 2014). The court found that Jackson was "not entitled to a free copy of the record and
transcripts," citing Fleming v. State, 553 So. 2d 505 (Miss. 1989). Id.
,rs. Undeterred, Jackson filed a motion for records and transcripts in circuit court on
February 23, 2015. On March 9, 2015, the circuit court denied Jackson's motion and stated
that he was not entitled to discovery. Jackson timely filed a notice of appeal from the order
denying his motion for records and transcripts.
DISCUSSION
if 6. The Mississippi Supreme Court has strongly emphasized that nothing in the Uniform
Post-Conviction Collateral Relief Act (UPCCRA) or elsewhere gives a prisoner the right to
2 ,o
institute an independent, original action for a free transcript or other documents, and then if
dissatisfied with the circuit court's ruling, to directly appeal that ruling to the supreme court
as a separate and independent action. Haynes v. State, 174 So. 3d 953, 955 c,s) (Miss. Ct.
App. 2015) (citing Fleming, 553 So. 2d at 506). This Court has explained:
Rather, under the UPCCRA, a prisoner who has filed a proper motion, and whose motion has withstood summary dismissal under [Mississippi Code Annotated section] 99-39-11(2) [(Rev. 2015)], may be entitled to trial transcripts or other relevant documents under the discovery provisions of [Mississippi Code Annotated section] 99-39-15 [(Rev. 2015)], upon good cause shown and in the discretion of the trial judge. Fleming, 553 So. 2d at 506. And if the request for documents is denied, and the overall PCR petition is denied, a prisoner may appeal under Mississippi Code Annotated section 99-39-25 [(Rev. 2015)]. Fleming, 553 So. 2d at 506. Within the PCR appeal, the prisoner may include the claim that the denial of his request for transcripts or other documents was error. Id. But there is no independent avenue to fish for a free transcript or other documents and then appeal if denied relief.
Wooten v. State, 127 So. 3d 322, 323 (,7) (Miss. Ct. App. 2013) (internal quotations
omitted).
,1. In Wooten, this Court held: "Since Wooten did not file his request for transcripts or
audio tapes as part of a PCR motion or as part of a direct appeal from his conviction, the
proper recourse is to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction." Id. at (19). In Haynes, this Court
stated: "As in Fleming and Wooten, Haynes filed an independent motion for transcripts and
records unrelated to any pending [PCR] motion, much less one that had withstood summary
dismissal." Haynes, 174 So. 3d at 955-56 c,10). We dismissed Haynes's appeal because a
prisoner has no right to institute such an independent, original action for transcripts and
records. Id.
18. Likewise, because Jackson's independent motion for transcripts and records was
3 l I
unrelated to any pending PCR motion, we must dismiss his appeal for lack of jurisdiction.
,9. THIS APPEAL IS DISMISSED. ALL COSTS OF THIS APPEALARE ASSESSED TO MADISON COUNTY.
LEE, C.J., IRVING AND GRIFFIS, P.JJ., BARNES, ISHEE, CARL TON, FAIR, WILSON AND GREENLEE, JJ., CONCUR.
4
I~
vs
/or a
• t jl /t' Ju~,sa, Cr,/Jr'l,
A/o. ;Jo1s -c-/J-oos;u -co/4
For Rchea.l',a8
-'-,
·•/! 11 /) ,,. /1/0 ·,Or? f-Or 1t?hECir1~j ,.r1
li1 f 5.f'. !?ule .s {] F /J./J/Je ! I a !-(~ (),{) c"&d (.,/ i"C I
(3
•
LJrJu)r/
JI!.
mu/oner /},·~s/- s/q!t, {' I-Ii~/- h/g c,f);Jec. I (
,J
d,~'l-,/JJU,Sf,ai./t,• J~on'J Flrn;-y,:1_q V !.,'/c;ff I s·s~? So.dd .t.ioS
(111SS, /(jfj )J~ .r-J/Jrl HCty/JfS II. .S'/-crlr, I 7</ !;o, 3d Ci.5_"3
(ff!,'S'J'. cl /l/JfJ. o<o1sL Fltm,/13 cu1cl flc-tY/JcS bu!-h /JIN! 3c1//~y
fo /-/,e Cr/n1fS Chc.l'y&J., /
Co rJ v/c le cl bY
1,11 (('(' S' (Jc Ct' -./.- ,· C I~ ..>U -e. ~ ,
JV
JtJ/~ J: Ct1lfp /4/J/J,. tJ9- -3 S -/0 I,
/ i /)
f 91 veJ' uVl1 Persov1
1/JJ".J//ah orJ i'l/'//f'ct l f-a -1-/Je ~·r1/Jr'erl1~ c:aurl-- -
COl1V, < fp cl
.T>-J c/rcu/1- Ccur-1-- Cei..fe 2!&3, t; l-1:11tfV ufJPf:lc.f LJCcS'
=iz-.
Tn F/c1m,~3 J /-/'le CL)urt · /Jc/et! /-,/;4/ Mere Coul.l i:Jt1
tY/,L'un'J.f"'I-C1.PJCBS ,~" [,1,,h/ch Ct dele,,-7cf4p7 I r:n/ihl a/lf'L"al
)he d &r1 ,~ I O I Or frJ o J/ol"J /.-o/' I-, Ot//7 JY r / /JI S c; J?d rl!.c:. 0 rel{;
1~ Me LtJnlexf tJ! h/S d/rec+ Q.f//Jea/_
P!&rJ/r191
S.53 So_cld af 500, fc1~,~5 ~/she, V. S'l-ttk,,
5JJ -.to.clcl 992 },
T7T '
I lJC1S cfc--,, ,8 J my f',jhf S .)-o due /J ro t'eS!} a/J J
equul f)r1Jfecl/or1 oi I-he lau-1' 9uarar1-kd by J,/;~
/</ 1h J:JdJf':,/Jd ;J'Jenl .flJ i6e U. 5. Co/JS/ 11-t_/hd/J ..
Ill/ l-ra,1sa//lk ol' lhe Jr,,;. I/ oaJ all r?J'i,/1,//s
J?/J-e d .J )a_,f p P? CJ/" o / /.1e re I , :,"7 f-ht7 o, ba ve C Ct g e_ we, e
c/e_t/!)r1alecl oS hS/Y13 rlc?Ce.!}50try /o, d/,ecl-- o,/JPt°c,/ ..
Bu/ JrJ()J/o/Jer lJaS .f J/; / d~rJ,~d Ct U1Tl/l!&f-t:
l-rar1.Scr,JJ.f 011J. exh/h/fS. See eth/k/+ l3 all£tch~~
!he ~~nlPnC /rJg h~or/YIJ htJ!t/ tin Jc,1Jary :J 'JI, /ti9 JJ
was !1bl ,~eluded as /Jar! o I I-At: ret:of'd ...
Ulh1L'h J//o/a..//e1y15 d/d OL1 Cur, /JI //,al heao"n!)"
Jhe couY-1 ord12,e-d over It btJnCh
h5
•
·1 { d/S'CLI S.f, DY1 5
lo 6e om/I rel~ lhc: CtJurl-: er f lo J-J,e rlrrk) l-aK e
f-j, c, f fflt' J'.S c, !Ji' 0 ./' /, ) ' Ir a,1 ':,-'C, /JJ I JJ. d ! 3 .
J.A/h/ch
1-/"cdJ Sc r, pf ,.,.
1/J my Cct.f e. {'f'
. ,zu ~
1-o o I a I IJ, e
JA/t> r P _( I- .J-j, /r d t9 c /s// o/J ,.., .,., -1. , '° U/J tlu (_.. /J,oce S'S grau/Jdgi
h v/J/v1 .J /he, I Ifie d~ 1/J /'a I ol a l-1 a,1 { c r /p ! ftJ a__n y
dt?-IP,'Jdu11/. Who df'/n6/JSl-rolL!J~ btJf/1 1/Je t/alut? al -,/-.IJtl
.f..r-arJSCn~I a/Jtl ..J.ie hck o-l Ctva/lalile a!lerr1a l/ve 5'
de/Jr/vtS .. I'uc/, u de.fe11da1Jf t)./ .a /Ju/r 1,/a! .. -i
1
S' Ja 1-e v, c (J ./t kt? , I :2 9 .;1/, If. I 3 -3 (; 9 'i? 7 J, o.) I 3 ? ,
ill 11 . I,..,
TJ,/J' Courl- hc..J' /Jo pre:;cede,,f- I-ha/ alda:S'S' the ,1,.{;lk'1
CfS 1~ mv Ca.ff i Whl',~ ht' /-/'/al Courf f'e!'u~~/ -lo
/Jrov/Jp 1r1ol-;'o,,,t>r tv/f/, Cl. ll'"uv1Sc,r//Jf CJI l!?c [OHJJJ/6¥-e
l-r/e, I iJro Cl" .--c/,'~/)JJ'' lf//,tFJ /1- w Ct s cl et' ,911.:, led~
/JS requ/n d by /cnJ~ /J/JJ Cl>u;/JJc:I lo/led 1-o ma/Cc M/s
Ci rJ /r Su t- LI /J d /r e c /- Cf() /J t! L (" L e IA V /r, g tJ 17 I Y CO f / u I er' e, J
~-0 / f-h"f! COUl"f- -,J tU //v1 ')
I I /1
h 1 , f I f
a S uu,, .sJ, c rtCJ/J,
rr /J Y Plf!ad//19 gu/1 ff Ot/J J h ,, . · J 'JfaS.S,,13 lhe o/JPorfu11,'1Y'
/al' c/rPL+ oppet.il' he f-o,/e/Jed A/s r,9hl h Cl l~ee
/,an J'c, /Pl I 0, s-sum/'/13 he LJ t>, s 1/J t1~3 e11 I a I 1-h e l-/n1 c.J J
llav/J/JJ do11e !/o, ./I /.f' rJol Url na!}tJrJc;blt; C!/J ti
Ce, le ,:/JI v rJ of LA/~{.~ ()f1 f //I u /./o/Ja I , -I- o re9 u/r'f! h,~
f o d P rYJtJ ,-1 _f/ r a l-e S d m e f /J e C / // c rJ r e J bf la !'t
n9u/r /n:J .J--J,e S' it1 /.e or CiJuAIY f-11 h,,,.,,,,'sh h/111
lJ ,'JI, /,c,, c d p/8 s o /' Ir/ a I l'e CD rd J a I- 11,/s <}-/-c;. ~ ,)'}
!-le1Y1/r1J, a I- so'/.
J:'J/7 viCL'o,da/Jce. w/fh /i?,SS. f!ulcS OF #;J/JC(!ok
J),oceit.,,frt, /11.Jle '-lo/a), ,'/- /s 1~ t-ht> tJ/J//J,d,// t:Pfl
-fhe movoi,1f lhf,(f fl,t Lou,! has ovt3r/oaKed !he
Po,/JI ol- r~eed,71
I I d( / /l I/J .f--/,r' L'v,..9/2 Sun JU ,ce , Uhere t--he mo lt'LJAe r -1-/J-ed
/o"" d/rt>Cf. a/JPt1c. !\ /1,,t_ /-rc,,/1.fcr//JI- tt11d ,~car/S Ctrt
e S' .{' &1 /,;,/, r r j:J ,P4r/.y SnK,'r, '} re ve r Sa I o ;J 1-h e .iud!ln'IM I
o /' a 1-r,'. I CtJIAr-1- fl'JUS-1- /Jt"e I'e/1 I I-he t; fJfJ ell" h C our f
wt, 1,/, u r,, u r J ,rrJ e9 c/4 -fc ./--o Sh ocJ lh a I a ,1 err iJ I' of'
n:vers,'l,k p,ttf'df'l/a//S hc.s beM Co,r1n1,1--kJ at'ld Hi~f ?7
f/, e fh,/11 hr,S /;eerl ;1roet>du,al fy /1t1' Servel·
";j' ovie> II. S' Jwfe , tj(p)_ S: o, ;)_ d 5 71 {:; oofo)
muf/,1//u WaS ru,dered /Aetl'ect/ve Gss/.f'fa..1u at { (}UYJ ,1 I' / tJ /J d,' a c j vt fJ pea I, ul J,,'ch Co r1 c; .L: 1-u-f ~ co vi S e
\
lor /1,/s /
,S'Sup
On d/rpc -I o, /J /Jee,/,
d· 1 I ,J>CuS S, tJr1S
/Jol-
Order&d ·1--haf ./he Cof/09uy /Je/·'l<.Jl?h? .J/11: L.'ou,1/->
dc-tt>n.t~ L'du,1Sc>/, a/Jd -lhe SJa!e !u? /-aKct1 of/:
re Co rd. ~ & e ./-rar1 s·c r / /J+ ? a !J t? d I 3 ;
"x I _ .
Ex/1/-b/f J::J al-lcLhPd S'how !--ha! o ..f't>,1Je11c/Y15
hear /Y"i,3 LJtJi S held (J n -::I arJua r y :J fi. J q 9 <J' 1 hu f /!
lJaf never made /Jqr..f- o./ I-he 1t>Co,d O(I aPPeaf ~
ExAtl:i/1 B Sho£J /-.ha! q/J j)c,j}fy_f I lr4nff'rlll~J
and exk/1:,//_s werc des,3nc,led af /Jt>ce<;!;cuy /011
/IPPti4l# Bui all /b,IS ol lie l-nv1_fcr//J+ tJere iltJf Sen/.,
c-X 1,/b,'l- ./J ,S /-wo fj) j]t-i:Je.S' .Jakt°n ./,oM +he
Se cor1d S'ti/J /-&P1c/J/19 he£A r/r13 ,
~ ..
/tJo//1h1tr /s Suh m,''l~-/-/J/19 e yh,'b/1- C lo S/1ocJ ..J-,!Ja+
11.,,,, 1 ~,,.ori~' ,~ 1-i,/s Lo.5e • he ha.S d///gc->nl-ly Sou3hf rn~ LL,
/ It Q_
hY /'hz0
, ) ') 1/Jclt::1det!.. Mt1ani/).3 /Jo t?v/d~/JC.e,
I a.J'k 1--A~ Courl lo, htl/J /j'J /h/..f J'rJc,l/er due, 1-o
1h11 l-1.c.J- fhal J- havt bti~rJ 1//e!Ja.//y de/Jr1v~d
tJI e XCul/Ja. lorv ,- -ev/derJCe -
Tht7 3 - f}e,9e d/scoverY S'e/J/ 1-o me hY 1-/;e clerK' ~
oJ>/>,ce Cor1S/sl ol o Cerl/1/caf-t t:Jf S'e,-i.,tce .. /
Bui I-he cer),"/,'eerk o/1 S'e,v,ct' 1S' 011& /or lht
( J)en'1C111/ /!or ./VO f- /c e LI.) /J //.6/ '1'> n ol /-,hr! d/srovery,,
u!li/ch /r1cl/cale Iha!- docurne/Jls have b eey} deCt:/ll/ve/Y
la.ken out*
'I 777
lhe,&lore mt1vtu1I (),av Iha.I ll,~ Cou,f 9r",,i fa/d
!no l/011 .I-or rY?hr-ctr/J/lJ arJd ,e qu/re I-he SI-ah lo
lurr1/Sh h,m W/ffr /,J,e fr~r1SCr,f./- and /"e co,JS +ha+
/At> )atJ re9u, re, rJ10Vt1i1/.- haJ' defr'1tJl1Sfraft°d a
S/Je c/ 1/c .f1eed. r+ -,~S' c!t1ar- lrom ..fh~ !'eCD,d Iha!
movc,r1 f /s, 1 ',.,,,) oce /JI. Md fhe /,c;FJS'Ch 'flt- ?/11 J· rte urdS are
/JI' (,) X Cul ()q /--(lry,
/JnJ /-he C Our I ha..S no re .f ea rChe,, h It JJr Pct' Jen I
/he,/ e,JdrtSS f/.,e. rJeed J?or /-r/al l---ra/J!/cr//1-- a11tl
/f ' /( u11cor1S1r f-ur,ct);4a /Iv
/t;Jc/ ,;, J//d la hd;/J ol .s.c:.-k /u 1--o r I/ I au!.
"The un//erl s/4.-fe.J' Sapretnf!_ Cour../ ht1!d ../-he.I /}/J1 de-l't>,,,--:JdC,,41-,r I / /' en /./ .f 1-B d ID J-ra"' S'f r ,1;Jf of' , 11 a Lrt rY1 I ,u:d L'CtS fJ I_{' a
h/_{' J/r.{,j 1-,,'al whe/J /--}. e lreir1Scr, f'I- I /Jeedr-d !CJ,,.. 1..f
a l"1 t / f ecJ,' vf clele/JSe 0,1 61Pf ec;i/,
/ -, .r.1 /'YJ y C tJi St?
h ee Y1 a i, I e l-o S houJ /he; f -Phe a JI e 911 I L,1 r/ 1-1-t r,
f' /c, leWJVI /, Uh,c 11 WIA J· ./-/,e ha{/ f ol' lhe S: k le IS
e11.J-/re Cu.Se I bt/c.J l-ahr/e-c,1-t) 1--he dc.Y bs..f-ori
/r/£-1 / Furlht'r /'J'7ort' 1-h/.J" t 1//d~/J{ 12 l,_J1;,J"' Suf}/?IC' !:Sed
bu./ s//11 ct I I OIA,/ l-o .9 o 1--o lhe
The S'lo/e h/l)cl 1--h,~r 4.//c'.!Je,l
(
ha cl !Jo I-le I'? a J/l i --;., c£ :: 1-rYJ t'/! I i bu I d /rt /} a J !( tn aw /J.
S k; /e d tiP1 (l,CAI S' I-ti lcr11 t' /I/- iv1vd' n"Ja d -P o,~ ./-J,e_, ~cet,.,e
u/J//; the tla v he/~a- l-rfetl,
1h12 J'·ltt+e: C (' r /!ou/Jcl !Jul abdul /he O ('e, I _[> la le ff1P1/J ./
Y~S 1-erd t)i.V, ;h e_ - - I l-/-)/:r1 I< ./-i1 r !3 / ~ .J.- o /! 1--h t ore,/
.J'lcrlc,neA ..J /s 11d ffJ1~I' .. r/J/e beCc,u~'e ,' j.. ,J' Coy1 f a,~£'j
,;,lo - ,;, I-lie l-Jr/1-fe~ Sia -k/Y)t/JI-. '.)) rrti/J..{C/J,,P./- /Jvi f!Je
IJ. 3. II-- &J;;;.s a Cor1SfJ,~a.c.y /.-o CO/Iv/;,~_/ a/ t,jff CoS/.
1 he Com /JI e-Fc: nJ c cu-d LJ ct£' , "r1 1--e ~1 /-/o /1 od I v o, 11 ti
//J esa 11 Y w/i-1-, hP Ir!.
/hi' C'orJ.£~/h//d/Jal r/.3h.f -lo equal p,oJ-ecl.1o,,,, t1/
lie l'1wS u11ckr /-At? lourlee/J/ii utYJt1r1dmt!Yl/- 1-o fhe
U/J/kcl Sh-le.r CO/J.f'l//-uJ/c1,1 ha.f bc:'&YJ v,'a/aled,
/Af'lc'/1o,t' -'-- c;i..f'k !--h/-1 C>ou,J- 1-o ..9 rc,1 I Sc,/d mul-,'or1
lo r re h eo.r /r1 J Cl J1 d r equ, 're .J-h ~ sl-c. -/-e -1--o l'r.i m !sh
movaYJI w/tA JA1 en-I/~ record ol +hP above
ca.Se,
;Jr Jeri(£) -12e J'P&c/--lu JI Y ~LI b n'\; +.-+e d,
,O,wifj~
-I)av, ~ 75 o..C I<~ D v1 tl 3 q & 4 o
~ ;r). {'. f,
j}, O, BoY /'!!Cf
Lee/( esv/t If I ms' 3 9'-15/
d-' I ,
1/i/s 1-h e I )
'J /J rd J, r& - Va, 1
fllfo, 11e 'I [; &11 er,;;, I
J!. c?, JJ o X ;J..__J o ;:; c. c 1< s·011 f m >~ 3 c;;) as
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
Motions
BY THE COURT: This is case
number 3163, David Darnell Jackson. Mr.
Jackson is charged by indictment in this
case under count #1, with possession of
cocaine with intent to distribute, and
under count #2, possession o_f a firearm by
a convicted felon. It is my understanding
that this case was tried before a jury
with Judge Richardson presiding, that the
jury returned a verdict of ...
B¥- MR. GANNER: Guilty on the drug
count, Your Honor, however the verdict on
the gun count was directed by the Court at
the close of the government's case, Your
Honor.
BY THE COURT: so Mr. Jackson was .
acquitted under count #2, and convicted
under count #1?
BY MR. GANNER: Yes, Your Honor.
BY THE COURT: And then Judge
Richardson set the matter for sentencing
last Friday ...
BY MR. GANNER: On January 28, 1998,
Your Honor.
BY THE COURT: And it is my
understanding that because he was the
Assistant District Attorney at the time
that some of the prior convictions which
the State intends to use to establish the
273
I .
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
Motions
habitual offender portion of the
indictment he recused himself and asked
that I handle this phase of the proceeding
as well as sentencing. Is that correct?
BY MR. GANNER: Yes, Your Honor.
However there is one issue that I would
like to tak.e up prior to the sentencing,
Your Honor. It will only take a few
moments which I think would in the
interest of judicial economy should be
heard before we proceed on the sentencing.
BY THE COURT: sure.
BY MR. GANNER: Your_Honor 1 earlier I
had filed a motion, it is in the court
file, it is the last document filed in the
court file, is a supplemental motion for
judgement notwithstanding the verdict or
the alternative a new trial. Your Honor,
on January 2 8, 1 9 8; when I appeared here
for sentencing that was the first time I
saw the senten~ing 0rders on David
Jackson 1 s prior felonies. Mr. savant has
those sentencing orders here. They were
never supplied to me in discovery. I did
see the discovery in the case on the
merits. However it was not until January
28, '98, well after the verdict that I saw
these sentencing orders on these prior
felonies. The sentencing orders on his
·1Joou22 ,..,, f)J-f
274
IN TI-Ilt CIRCUIT COURT OF MADISON COUNTY, MISSISSIPPI
DAVID JACKSON
vs.
STATE OF MJSSISSlP >1 \ '
>f\.PPELLANT ··
RESPONDENT
tr·~ l ~ D APR 2 O 1999
CHARLOTTE B. WILLIAMS, CLERK SUPREME COURT
'd M' . . . COURT OF Af PEALS Davi Jackson, by and through counsel, pursuant to 1ss1ss1pp1 Supreme ·court
Rule lO(b)(l), de~igi1aled the following pm1s of the record as being necessary fo be
i 11cl uded on appe<ll:
L All Clerk's papers, trial transcripts, and exhibits filed, taken or offered in
this cause, including but not limited lo the Court's opinion, briefs filed by the parties and
the Order Overruling Motion for New Trial.
1 TH!Sthe~ <layof¥, 1999. •
Lis:t M, Ross Attomey at Law Post Office Box 11264 760 N. West Street Jackson, Mississippi 39283-12(,4 ( 60 l )948-6080 . (601) 948-7744 MSB. No. 9755
Respectfµlly submitted, David Jackson
nv:~ // /kc Lisa M.ic:ss, Attorney for Appellant
l
r I. I
I i
I
I
• ( .
~~~~~i~~~CH1:08~cv-0072.?. Filed: 07/11/2008 pcf~~2<?1~1i j59-4365 (~ii 352-2049
Fax: (601) 859-8555
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
RE:
OFFICE OF
Citteuit Ceenk 06 fft'"™lllt Couuty LEE WESTBROOK, CIRCUIT CLERK
MEMORANDUM
David Jackson
Lee Westbrook Madison County Circuit Clerk
February IS, 2007
Madison County Cause No. 3163 State vs David Donnell Jackson
ln response to your further request, please be advised that the 3-page document supplied to you previously entitled Discovery Provided Pursuant to Rule 9.04 filed in the Circuit Clerk's office on June 10, 1997 has no attachments included.
Please notice that the third page of the document indicates that a copy was mailed to your attorney, Chris N.K. Ganner. Mr. Ganner had previously requested discovery with a document filed in our office on June 6, 1997.
There is no other documentation 1 can provid.
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF MADISON COUNTY, MISSISSIPPI
STA TE OF MISSISSIPPI I F .1· L E D f vs.
DAVID DONELL JACKSON
DISCOVERY P
1. WITNESSES IN CHJEF
Inv. Jim Marlett Dep. Brad Harbour Dep. Tommy Jones Dep. llichard Lawrence Dep .. Joey Ludlow Const. Johnny Sims Madison County Sheriff'_s Office Post Office Box 98 Canton, Mississippi 39046 601/859-2345
Claudette Luckett 457 Church Street Canton, MS 39046
Agent Mo~ca Artis Mississippi Crime Laboratory 1700 East Woodrow Wilson Jackson, MS 39216 601/987-1600.
THIS DAY
JUN 101991 ~
LEE WESTB-ROOK CIRCUIT CLERK
RULE 9.04
CASE N 0. 3163
DEFENDANT
2. RECORDED STATEMENTS OF DEFENDJ..NT TO L/1iW OFFICERS
See attached.
3. CRIMINAL RECORD OF DEFENDANT FOR IMPEACHMENT
See attached.
4. CRIME LAB REPORT/TESTS
See attached.
·"'
5. PHYSICAL EVIDENCE/PHOTOGRAPHS
i::;-. -~dence bag C""'ta1··ru·ng crar-v cr.r-~;np L V 1 Vll. 1 .1 \..JS\. '-./'vl.A...l_l.-,1 .... _
6. EXCULPATORY MATERIAL CONCERNING DEFENDANT
None known to State.
7. OTI--mR.
Miscellaneous papers located in District Attorney's file available for inspection upon 24 hours notice. ·
Respectfully submitted, this ;hefflday o~~ , 1997.
~~~J DA}()O,rrt; ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEY
CERTIFICATE·
This is t.o certify that I "have this day mailed, postage prepaid .. , -a true and correct copy of .. .
--·-·-••••••••••--• ---··-- --·-·---· ________ .. ___ ,______ ------·· ·---- H H ------ - 000 -·· --~- •• :·--·--·-•H - --·-·-H••• •o > • •0•0 0 • -- ~- ••,,••••• -·• • • ,,·,··-:;; -· ,
· the above and foregoing Demand for Notice of Alibi to the attomey~-for. the Defendant:
:Chris N. K. Ganner;.Esquire Attorney at Law· . ·
· 405 Tombigbee Street . Jackson, Mississippi 39201.
JOHN T- KITCHENS, DISTRICT ATTORNEY · OFFICE OF-IBEDISTRICT ATTORNEY Post Office Bo?( ~21 Canton, :Mississippi 3 9046 (601) 859:.783& .
, 1997~.
~~~J7tl MARYL . ~ON · · ASSISTANT ·)?!STRICT AITORNEy
·---·---------------·--·--·--···--·- ..
• . F/f t d :r /} r/J" {j J: F /c {:_, or Tht. CI er K
~U/J!Pn11' Ctlul" I O ~ fYJ /~ s,'s.s/~;;/
rYlur /fJ! 13 .. EI J/s e le rl( I
j)_ (), 73ox .J 4 q
Uac K Son, If/ S. 3 Q ,;1 o5
])ef'A, de r K : Plsci'e t,/J d ,p;1c(dS'tJd lor ./11/n~ -fhe o rfeJ(/l4..•
tJt mer tPtl/J,'P,, Jo, t,Jr/1- o I re,./-,Ort>.r/ w/.fh
a /1/JM d /:,1&s If c,;1 d 8 a f lach-#J J --ro }8 J', "/nl
-r ha/JK' l/ou lo, C/ou r t/m e a11 d, /Ja //e .n c e
fr1 ..f'J,ts h1G lier.
I ,n
f /rJcere ( v\ J
, fJ~v&ffli J)a v/d Ja.cKqon