report on 'samarthya' technical training programme for state

0

Report

on

‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Programme

for

State Technical Resource Teams (STRTs)

MGNREGA Division Department of Rural Development

Ministry of Rural Development Government of India

(October, 2015)

2

Contents

List of Tables: .................................................................................................................................................. 4

List of Images: ................................................................................................................................................. 4

1. Introduction: ............................................................................................................................................ 6

2. Objectives: ............................................................................................................................................... 7

3. ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual: .............................................................................................. 8

3.1. Aspects covered in the Manual: ....................................................................................................... 9

3.2. Contributors: .................................................................................................................................. 12

3.3. Salient Features of SAMARTHYA technical training Manual: ......................................................... 14

4. Creation of State Technical Resource Teams (STRTs): ........................................................................... 15

4.1. Identification/ Selection of STRT Members: .................................................................................. 15

4.2. Schedule of the trainings conducted: ............................................................................................ 15

4.3. Method adopted for training: ........................................................................................................ 18

4.4. Pre and Post Training Assessment of trainees: .............................................................................. 20

4.5. Assessment of satisfaction level of STRT members: ...................................................................... 22

4.6. Impact of STRT Training: ................................................................................................................ 22

5. Feedback/opinions and suggestions from STRTs: ................................................................................. 23

6. Action plan for creation and training of DTRTs and BTRTs: ................................................................... 24

ANNEXURES: ................................................................................................................................................. 25

ANNEXURE - I: STATE WISE DETAILS OF STRT MEMBERS: .................................................................... 25

ANNEXURE - II: QUESTIONNAIRE-1 & MODEL ANSWERS ..................................................................... 57

ANNEXURE - III: QUESTIONNAIRE-2 & MODEL ANSWERS .................................................................... 68

ANNEXURE - IV: EVALUATION OF STRT TRAININGS: ............................................................................ 74

3

ASSESSMENTS BY STRT MEMBERS OF BATCH - 1: ...................................................................... 74







ASSESSMENTS BY STRT MEMBERS OF BATCH - 8: .................................................................... 102

ASSESSMENTS BY STRT MEMBERS OF BATCH - 9: .................................................................... 108

ASSESSMENTS BY STRT MEMBERS OF BATCH - 10:.................................................................. 112

ANNEXURE - V: GLIMPSES OF SAMARTHYA TECHNICAL TRAINING PROGRAMMES FOR STRTs. ....... 117

ANNEXURE - VI: FEEDBACK/ OPINION AND SUGGESTIONS FROM STRTs .......................................... 127

ANNEXURE - VII: FORMAT FOR ACTION PLAN, TO CONDUCT TRAINING OF DTRTS AND BTRTS DOWN

THE LINE IN CONCERNED STATES................................................................................................. 143

ANNEXURE - VIII: ACTION PLAN FOR THE CONDUCT OF DTRT AND BTRT TRAINING PROGRAMMES144

4

List of Tables:

Table 1: Chapters and topics covered in ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA): ............ 10

Table 2: National Technical Team for preparation of ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA):................................................................................................................................................ 12

Table 3: Resource Persons for preparation of ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA): ... 13

Table 4: Schedule for STRT training programmes: ...................................................................................... 16

Table 5: Assessment of trainees in STRT training programmes .................................................................. 21

Table 6: Assessment of STRT training programme by trainees .................................................................. 22

List of Images:

Image 1: Launch of ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA) by the Joint Secretary (MGNREGA) ................................................................................................................................................... 8

Image 2: Members of STRTs of batch -1, Resource persons and officials at the time of launch of ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA) ................................................................................ 8

Image 3: Ms. Aparajita Sarangee JS (MGNREGA) addressing members of STRTs ....................................... 8

Image 4: Shri G N Sharma (National Technical Team Leader) giving presentation .................................... 18

Image 5: Film on Participatory planning ..................................................................................................... 19

Image 6: Film on Watershed principles ...................................................................................................... 19

Image 7: Film on Gabion structure ............................................................................................................. 19

Image 8: Film on Earthen Dam .................................................................................................................... 19

Image 9: Film on Boulder Checks ................................................................................................................ 19

Image 10: Film on Production of CSEB ........................................................................................................ 19

Image 11: Model building constructed using Jack arch roof and 9”brick masonry with non-erodible mud plaster at RTP .............................................................................................................................................. 20

Image 12: Model building constructed using Rat-trap bond masonry wall and filler slab roof at RTP ...... 20

Image 13: Pre training assessment of trainees ........................................................................................... 20

Image 14: Post training assessment of trainees ......................................................................................... 20

6

1. Introduction:

One of the core objectives of the MGNREGA is ‘Strengthening the Livelihood base of the poor’

through creation of productive assets of prescribed quality. To achieve this, Selection of work,

site, design and the execution of each work has to be in a manner as to maximize the

outcomes.

To acquaint and train the MGNREGA technical functionaries for all the permissible works under

MGNREGA, Ministry of Rural Development conducted ten programmes for the training of State

Technical Resource Teams (STRTs) on ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA),

published by the Ministry.

Out of ten training programmes for STRTs, eight were conducted at NIRD&PR, Hyderabad and

two were conducted at North East Regional Centre (NERC) of NIRD&PR, Guwahati. The duration

of each training was of four days. Total numbers of participants trained in the trainings are 260

from 31 States/ Union Territories (UTs). Resource persons for trainings were experts from

Ministry and technical resource persons, working in the field related to MGNREGA works from

different states. These trainings were anchored by the experts from Ministry and facilitated by

the NIRD&PR.

Ms. Aparajita Sarangee, Joint Secretary (MGNREGA) launched “SAMARTHYA” Technical Training

Manual (MGNREGA) and addressed participants on the first day of the first training programme

held from 23rd March to 26th March, 2015 at NIRD&PR, Hyderabad. Shri S. M. Vijayanand, (Sec

PR & DG NIRD-PR) addressed participants on the last day of the ninth training programme held

from 2nd June to 5th June, 2015 at NIRD&PR-NERC, Guwahati.

In these training programmes, out of 32 states/ UTs, 31 states/ UTs participated. Goa did not

participate in any of the training programme.

7

2. Objectives:

The prime objectives of the trainings were:

To develop a cadre of trainers / experts in planning, convergence, execution, and

maintenance of MGNREGA works in respective states at State level (State Technical

Resource Team [STRT]), District level (District Technical Resource Team [DTRT]) and Block

level (Block Technical Resource Team [BTRT]).

To acquaint and train technical functionaries for works allowed under MGNREGA, to

improve quality and durability of the assets being created under MGNREGA.

To acquaint the MGNREGA technical functionaries with all circulars/ guidelines issued from

the Ministry on works and convergence.

8

3. ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual:

To train the MGNREGA technical functionaries on different type of permissible works under MGNREGA,

Ministry has developed ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA) as a training cum

reference manual for technical functionaries. It was launched on 1st day of first batch of training, on 23rd

March, 2015 at NIRD&PR, Hyderabad by Joint secretary (MGNREGA), Ms. Aparajita Sarangee, IAS.

Image 1: Launch of ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA) by the Joint Secretary (MGNREGA)

Image 2: Members of STRTs of batch -1, Resource

persons and officials at the time of launch of

‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA)

Image 3: Ms. Aparajita Sarangee JS (MGNREGA)

addressing members of STRTs

9

3.1. Aspects covered in the Manual:

For creation of productive assets of prescribed quality and durability to strengthen the

livelihood resource base of the rural poor, it is necessary that the engineers/ technical

personnel implementing the programme are clear about the activities which are to be carried

out under different type of works permitted under MGNREGA. Secondly, for quality and

durability, the basic technical input required in selection of work site, surveying, designing,

planning, layout, execution and maintenance of works etc. are well known to the engineers/

technical personnel implementing the programme. Therefore, in this manual all these aspects

have been covered.

Aspects covered in the manual are as follows:

i) Activities which are to be carried out under different type of works permitted under

MGNREGA for:

a) Development of rain fed areas on watershed approach,

b) Development of irrigated areas on command area approach and

c) Development of agriculture & rural infrastructure.

ii) The basic technical input required in selection of work site, surveying, designing, planning,

layout, execution and maintenance of works;

iii) Quality Control & Maintenance of works under MGNREGA;

iv) How convergence of MGNREGS with other ongoing schemes in rain fed areas and command

areas can be carried out for gap filling and value addition;

v) The list of relevant Circulars on MGNREGA works issued by the Ministry and are effective.

On the basis of above, there are 8 chapters in the manual as given below:

10

Table 1: Chapters and topics covered in ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA):

Chapter No Name of the chapters Topics covered

Chapter - 1 Introduction - MGNREGA brief

- List of works permitted under act

- Important instructions issued on MGNREGA works

from Ministry

- The Strategy

Chapter - 2 Watershed development for rain fed areas under MGNREGA

- What is ‘Watershed’

- Why watershed development

- Water budgeting and planning in watershed

development.

- Watershed interventions

Interventions in non-arable/ ridge area

Interventions in on-farm/ and arable areas.

Interventions in drainage lines.

Chapter - 3 Command area development for irrigated areas under MGNREGA

- What is Command Area (CAD)

- Why Command area Development

- Command area interventions:

Water conveyance system,

Surface drainage system,

Land levelling and shaping,

Construction of irrigation and drainage structure,

Engineering survey,

Execution of work.

Dos & Don’ts

Chapter - 4 Afforestation, Tree plantation and Horticulture

- Introduction

- Planning activities

- Types of Plantation

- Raising of Nursery

- Land development and irrigation infrastructure

- Planting techniques

- Convergence

- Schedule of rates

- Do’s & Don’ts

11

Chapter – 5 Agriculture infrastructure under MGNREGA

- Infrastructure for promotion of livestock

- Infrastructure for promotion of fisheries

- Infrastructure for promoting agricultural

productivity.

- Infrastructure for irrigation (Dug wells).

Chapter - 6 Rural infrastructure under MGNREGA

- Rural sanitation

- All-weather rural connectivity

- Construction of play fields

- Disaster preparedness

- Construction of rural buildings

Building wise Guidelines

Appropriate Construction Technologies

Broad Do’s & Don’ts

Standards & specifications - Construction of food grain storage structure

- Production of building materials

Chapter - 7 Quality control and maintenance of works under MGNREGA

- Quality control of MGNREGA works

- Maintenance of works under MGNREGA

Chapter - 8 Convergence of MGNREGS with other schemes in the area

- Why convergence

- Why convergence of MGNREGS with other schemes

- Convergence guidelines issued so far, MGNREGS and

Schemes of line Departments

- Non Negotiable in Convergence

- Steps in implementation of convergence

- Typical Exercise for planning convergence.

12

3.2. Contributors:

National technical team and resource persons working in the fields related to MGNREGA works,

from different states of the country, contributed in preparation of ‘SAMARTHYA’ technical

training manual. According to their subject of expertise, they contributed in development of

different chapters in the manual. List of the contributors is as given below:

Table 2: National Technical Team for preparation of ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual

(MGNREGA):

Sr.

No. Name & Designation Qualification

Experience

Field No of

Years

1 Shri G. N. Sharma, (Team Leader)

Irrigation and Soil Engineering

Expert,

UNDP Consultant, NREGS works,

MGNREGA Dn. MoRD, GOI

B.Tech. (Agri. Engg.),

M. Tech. (Soil and

water cons Engg.),

MBA (Executive)

1) Rain fed and

Command Area

Development

2) Rural

Development

45

2 Shri Biju Abraham,

Project Executive, Horticulture

and Afforestation, UNDP

Consultant, MGNREGA Dn.

MoRD, GOI

M. Sc. Forestry 1) Forestry

2) Watershed

14

3 Shri Pankaj Shrikant Duberkar,

Project Executive, Alternative

Technology, UNDP Consultant,

MGNREGA Dn. MoRD, GOI

B. Arch, M. Arch

(Sustainable

Architecture)

1) Architecture 2

13

Table 3: Resource Persons for preparation of ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA):

Sr.

No. Name & Designation Qualification

Experience

Field No of

Years

1. Shri R Kondala Rao,

Technical Advisor,

PR, RD and RWS & S

Departments, Govt. of Andhra

Pradesh

B.E. (Civil) Administration, Designs &

estimates and overall technical

guidance for construction of

Roads, Bridges, Rural Drinking

Water Supply Schemes,

Buildings, major educational

institutions, residential school

buildings, colleges etc.,

58

2. Shri C.K.S. Parmar,

Retd. Addl. Dir. Eng. (C.E.),

Government of Rajasthan

B.E. Agri. 1) CAD Works,

2) Watershed

3) MIS, RD

44

3. Shri H Kurma Rao,

Centre Head, Centre for

Natural Resources

Management (CNRM), AMR-

AP Academy of Rural

Development (APARD),

Rajendra Nagar, Hyderabad

M. Tech (Soil and

Water Eng.), MBA

1) Water sheds

2) Micro irrigation

3) Training Experience

23

4 Dr. V. Suresh Babu,

Associate Professor,

CWEP, NIRD and PR, Rajendra

Nagar, Hyderabad, Telangana

M.Sc.

(Agriculture),

Ph.D. in

Agronomy

1) NAEB

2) MGNREGA

14

5 Shri Sumer Mathur,

Retd. Executive engineer,

Govt of Rajasthan.

Diploma in Civil

Engg.

1) Watershed 40

6 Shri Rajesh Mit,

Integrator,

PRADAN, Barmesia, B

Deoghar, Jharkhand

B. Tech. (Civil

Engg.)

1) Watershed

2) Social Mobilization

18

7 Shri Narendra Patel,

Samaj Pragati Sahayog,

Bagli, Madhya Pradesh

Diploma Civil

Engg.

1) Watershed 15

14

8 Shri K. Durga Prasad,

Dy. Executive Engineer,

O/o CRD Telangana State,

Hyderabad

M. Tech.

(Structures)

1) Structural engineer 22

9 Ms. T. Satya Kumari,

Dy. Executive Engineer,

O/o The Commissioner, Rural

Development, Andhra Pradesh

M. Tech (Geo-

Technical)

1) Civil Engineer in PRED 36

10 Shri Haridas Eeranna,

Dy. executive engineer,

Panchayati Raj Engineering

Department, Kurnool, AP

B. Tech. (Civil

Engg.)

1) PR Eng. Dept.

2) Rural Water Supply

3) Watershed and MGNREGA

25

11 Ms. M. Mythily,

Assistant Engineer,

O/o The ENC, PRED, TS,

SRTGN Bhawan, Erramanzil,

Hyderabad.

M. Tech (Geo-

Technical)

1) Civil Engineer in PRED 16

12 Shri Abed Abdul Wadood

Khan,

Engineering Consultant,

MGNREGS, Telangana State

B.E. (Civil Engg.) 1) Watershed

2) MGNREGA works

13

Communication Strategist: Shri S Ajai Kumar, Communication and Advocacy Officer, UNDP, (GOALS

Project, MoRD) New Delhi

3.3. Salient Features of SAMARTHYA technical training Manual:

Salient Features of the Manual:

1) All works permitted under MGNREGS are covered in the manual.

2) Ready reckoners for ready reference are provided to reduce time on calculations.

3) Self-explanatory figures and images are provided, where ever required.

4) Illustrations are given, whenever required.

5) Circular and guidelines on works issued by Ministry are referred, where ever required.

6) Typical drawings and estimates are provided where ever required.

7) Do’s and Don’ts for every type of work are given in the manual.

15

4. Creation of State Technical Resource Teams (STRTs):

To convene technical training programme at District level and Block level down the line to train

District Technical Resource Team (DTRT) and Block Technical Resource Team (BTRT) & ensure

quality and durability of MGNREGA works, State Technical Resource Teams (STRTs) from 31

States/ UTs have been trained in 10 training programmes conducted at NIRD&PR, Hyderabad

and NIRD&PR NERC, Guwahati.

The process followed for creation of STRTs is as follows:

4.1. Identification/ Selection of STRT Members:

Engineers directly involved in implementation of MGNREGA at state and district and engineers

from concerned line departments implementing MGNREGS or converging MGNREGS with their

departmental schemes were nominated by the state as STRT members, to participate in the

training.

4.2. Schedule of the trainings conducted:

Duration of each training was of four days. First day was dedicated to introduction on

‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical training manual, pre-assessment of trainees on subject matter,

sessions on watershed development and water budgeting in rain fed areas. After lunch it was

on watershed interventions in Non-arable areas, Arable areas and drainage line. In the evening,

2 hours’ film on watershed shown to the trainees which cleared their concepts and all doubts

on watershed development approach, as intimated by almost all the trainees.

Second day was dedicated on Afforestation, Tree plantation, Horticulture and Command area

development.

Third and fourth days of the training were on Rural and Agriculture infrastructure related

works, Quality control and Convergence of schemes with MGNREGS. On third day visit to Rural

Technology Park (RTP) at NIRD and PR campus was also made to give exposure on different

buildings constructed using different appropriate technologies.

16

The training modules and their facilitators are as given below in the Standard schedule followed

for all the trainings with slight alterations:

Table 4: Schedule for STRT training programmes:

DURATION TOPIC FACILITATORS

DAY-1:

09:30 -10:00 Registration

10:00 -10:45 Introduction Shri G.N. Sharma

10:45 -11:30 Pre- assessment Shri G.N. Sharma/ Shri Biju Abraham

11:30 -12:30 Watershed development & Water

Budgeting

Shri G.N. Sharma

12:30 -13:30 Watershed interventions In Non-arable

Areas,

Shri S. Mathur/ Shri R.P. Agarwal

13:30 -14:30 LUNCH BREAK

14:30 -15:30 Watershed interventions –In Arable Areas, Shri S. Mathur/ Shri G.N. Sharma

15:30-17:00 Watershed interventions –In Drainage Line Shri R.P. Agarwal

17:00-18:00 Film on Watershed

DAY-2:

09:00 -09:30 Recap Shri G.N. Sharma

09:30 -11:00 Planning & Raising of Nursery Shri Biju Abraham/ Shri L.K. Sharma

11:00 -12:30 Plantation Techniques Shri L.K. Sharma

12:30 -13:30 Estimation & Convergence Dr. Suresh Babu/ Shri Biju Abraham


14:30 -16:00 Command Area, Water Conveyance System

& Irrigation Structures

Shri C.K.S. Parmar

16:00-17:30 Drainage System & Drainage Structures &

Land Levelling, Engineering Survey &

Execution of CAD works

Shri C.K.S. Parmar

17:30- 20:30 Local Visit

17

DAY-3:


09:30 -11:00 Rural sanitation related works under

MGNREGA

Ms. Satyakumari /Shri K. Durga Prasad

11:00 -12:00 Rural road connectivity under MGNREGA Shri K. Durga Prasad/ Shri R. Kondala

Rao

12:00 -13:30 Use of different appropriate technologies in

construction of buildings under MGNREGA

Ms. M. Mythily/ Shri R. Kondala Rao

13:30- 14:30 LUNCH BREAK

14:30 -15:30 Construction of different rural buildings

permitted under MGNREGA

Ms. M. Mythily / Shri R. Kondala Rao

15:30 -16:30 Construction of Food Grain storage

structures under MGNREGA

Ms. M. Mythily/ Shri K. Durga Prasad

16:30 -17:30 Convergence of MGNREGS and other

schemes under implementation in the area

Shri R. Kondala Rao /Shri K. Durga

Prasad

17:30 -18:30 Visit to Rural Technological Park (RTP) Ms. M. Mythily/ Shri Pankaj/ Shri Satish

DAY-4:


09:30 -11:00 Quality control & maintenance of works

under MGNREGA

Shri G.N. Sharma

11:00 -12:30 Production of building materials under

MGNREGA

Shri Pankaj S Duberkar/ Shri G.N.

Sharma

12:30 -13:30 Agriculture Infra. -Livestock, Fisheries, Dug

Wells and Agriculture Productivity

Shri Haridas Eeranna/ Shri Abed Abdul

Wadood Khan/ Ms. M. Mythily


14:30 -16:00 Assessment /Action Plan Shri G.N. Sharma/ Shri Pankaj

16:00 -16:30 Valedictory Shri R. Kondala Rao/ Shri G.N.

Sharma/Dr. Suresh Babu/ Shri Pankaj

Note: Tea breaks: 11.30 am and 4.00 pm & Lunch break: 1.30 – 2.30 pm

18

4.3. Method adopted for training:

Different participatory and interactive methods were adopted during the training as given

below.

Power point presentation: Power Point presentation was a primary tool used to impart

training. All power point presentations were validated and edited as required by the technical

team, before being presented. Whenever require white board was also used to show

calculations and draw sketches.

Image 4: Shri G N Sharma (National Technical Team Leader) giving presentation

Audio Visual Presentation: To give clear understanding about the topics, following video

films were shown during the training:

i) Watershed Interventions – Basic Principles

ii) Ridge area Treatment

iii) Boulder checks

iv) Gabion structures

v) Earthen Dams

vi) Production of Compressed Stabilised Earth Blocks (CSEB).

vii) Participatory planning.

19

Image 5: Film on Participatory planning

Image 6: Film on Watershed principles

Image 7: Film on Gabion structure

Image 8: Film on Earthen Dam

Image 9: Film on Boulder Checks

Image 10: Film on Production of CSEB

Field visit: In eight training programmes conducted at NIRD-PR, Hyderabad, field visits were

organized to Rural Technology Park (RTP), on 2nd / 3rd day of the training, to acquaint

participants for different cost effective, appropriate and green construction technologies.

20

Image 11: Model building constructed using Jack arch

roof and 9”brick masonry with non-erodible mud

plaster at RTP

Image 12: Model building constructed using Rat-trap

bond masonry wall and filler slab roof at RTP

Recap session: Recap sessions of half an hour were organized on 2nd, 3rd and 4th day of the

training to discuss queries on training imparted on previous day, after self-study.

4.4. Pre and Post Training Assessment of trainees:

On first day of each training, to gauge the participants’ understanding on works under

MGNREGA a pre training assessment was conducted on topics on which training was to be

conducted. On the fourth day i.e. last day of training, again same (Pre-test) questionnaire was

circulated among the participants for post training assessment.

Image 13: Pre training assessment of trainees

Image 14: Post training assessment of trainees

Questionnaire with model answers used for first 7 and 10th training is provided at Annexure-II

and Questionnaire with model answers used for 8th and 9th training is provided at Annexure-III.

Number of participants for each training programme, average marks in pre-test and post-test is

given below in table-5.

21

Table 5: Assessment of trainees in STRT training programmes

Performance in pre- assessment and post- assessment in the graph below shows that, there is

very much enhancement in knowledge level of trainees on the subjects of training given, after

each training programme.

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

1st Batch 2nd Batch 3rd Batch 4th Batch 5th Batch 6th Batch 7th Batch 8th Batch 9th Batch 10th Batch Average

Mar

ks o

bta

ined

Performance in pre-assessment and post -assessment

Pre-test Post- Test

Programme

No Dates

No of

Participants

Average marks

obtained in pre-

test (Out of 47)

Average marks

obtained in post-

test (Out of 47)

1st Batch 23/03/2015 to 26/03/2015 37 - 18

2nd Batch 07/04/2015 to 10/04/2017 36 7.5 18.9

3rd Batch 14/04/2015 to 17/04/2015 40 8.8 19.2

4th Batch 21/04/2015 to 24/04/2015 23 7.9 21.0

5th Batch 28/04/2015 to 01/05/2015 24 4.9 13.4

6th Batch 05/05/2015 to 08/05/2015 22 8 18.57

7th Batch 12/05/2015 to 15/05/2015 17 6.5 22

8th Batch 26/05/2015 to 29/05/2015 20 5.1 18.1

9th Batch 02/06/2015 to 05/06/2015 21 3.5 17.8

10th Batch 08/09/2015 to 11/09/22015 20 6 16 Average 260 6.5 18.3

22

4.5. Assessment of satisfaction level of STRT members:

At the end of each training, online evaluation was conducted to capture the satisfaction level of the

participants on the training programme; reports on evaluation of all batches are at Annexure-IV. Overall

effectiveness score, of seven training programme out of ten is more than 86% and of remaining three

training programme is more than 80% as given below in Table-6

Table 6: Assessment of STRT training programme by trainees

Batches 1st

Batch

2nd

Batch

3rd

Batch

4th

Batch

5th

Batch

6th

Batch

7th

Batch

8th

Batch

9th

Batch

10th

Batch

Overall Effectiveness

Score (Online

evaluation) ‘ % ’

86 86 82 88 86 88 88 88 80 82

4.6. Impact of STRT Training:

Chhattisgarh STRT was so impressed that after return to their state, they requested

government and got their ‘Chief engineer’ and ‘Superintending engineer’ concerned nominated

to attend this training at Guwahati.

23

5. Feedback/opinions and suggestions from STRTs:

Feedback/ Opinion and suggestions received from State Technical Resource Teams (STRTs) after

each training of ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training programme and comments of National

Technical team on the suggestions received are at Annexure –VI.

24

6. Action plan for creation and training of DTRTs and BTRTs:

Preparation of action plan for creation and training of DTRTs and BTRTs, STRT members

discussed among themselves and with resource persons. On the last day of training, STRTs

submitted action plans for the conduct of DTRTs and BTRTs training programmes down the line

in their states, in the format shared by the Ministry, given at Annexure - VII. Sate wise Action

plans to conduct training programmes for DTRTs and BTRTs is at Annexure - VIII.

25

ANNEXURES:

ANNEXURE - I: STATE WISE DETAILS OF STRT MEMBERS:

Andaman and Nicobar:

Andhra Pradesh

S.

No. Name & Designation of STRT members Phone No. /e-mail id

1. Shri A. Kalyan Chakravarti

JCRD/SPM (T), O/o the Commissioner RD

07095554499

[email protected]

2. Shri N. Krishna Reddy

EE (RD), O/o the Commissioner RD, AD

07095548444

[email protected]

3. Shri K.M.M. Khalandar

PE (Tech), O/o the Commissioner RD

07095557786

[email protected]

4. Shri K. Anjineyulu

Assistant Project Director

O/o Project Director, DWMA, Visakhapatnam

07095539899

[email protected]

5. Shri M. Gowrisankar

EC, Mummidivaram (M), East Godavari District

07095525296

[email protected]

6. Shri K. Sudheer

EC, Attili Mandal, West Godavari District

07095542533

[email protected]

S.


1. Smt. Reshma

Assistant Engineer, MGNREGA, Headquarters

South Andaman District

Port Blair

09474247248

[email protected]

2. Ms. P.P. Prema

Assistant Engineer, MGNREGA, Mayabunder

Block, North & Middle , Andaman District

09476016569

[email protected]

mailto:[email protected]








26

S.


7. Shri M. Shamir Hussain

JE, DWMA, SPS Nellore District

07095538057

[email protected]

8. M. Eswaraiah

EC, Bukkapatnam Mandal, Anantapur District

7095520205

[email protected]

9. Shri M.D. Ahobilam

SQCO, Team Admn., DWMA, Kurnool

07097533397

10. Shri G. Satyam Naidu

SQCO, O/o Project Director, DWMA,

Vizianagaram

09440230784

11. G. Venkateswarlu

TA, Bukkapatnam GP,

Anantapur District

7095520428

12. T. Sikindar Zahapana

TA, Agraharam GP,

Anantapur District

7095520429

13. T. Sreenivasulu

FA, Agraharam GP,

Anantapur District

7095520788

talarisreenivasulusreenivasulu@g

mail.com

14. V. R. Sowmithri

State Coordinator, GIZ, RD Dept.

09848564699

[email protected]

15. P.V. Ramani

PM CB, O/O Commissioner of Rural Dev.,

Hyderabad, AP

9000725935

[email protected]







27

Arunachal Pradesh:

S.


1.

Shri Nani Chatung

APO (T), District Rural Development Agency,

West Kameng District, Bomdila,

Arunachal Pradesh

9436052190 (M)

[email protected]

2. Er. Kipa Gagung

APO (T), Near Bharat Scout and Guide Training

Centre Polo Colony, Naharlagun, Papumpare

District, Arunachal Pradesh

9436041967 (M)

[email protected]

3. Shri Kenmin Nyorak

Asstt. Project Officer (T), District Rural

Development Agency, West Siang District,

Aalo, Arunachal Pradesh

03783222704 (O) / 0360222310 (F)

9436056260 /9191680789 (M)

[email protected]

4. Er. Dongche Baka

APO (RE), District Rural Development Agency,

Kungkumey District, Koloriang,

Aruanchal Pradesh

9436632102 (M)

5. Er. Taku Ligu

APO (Tech.), District Rural Development

Agency, East Kameng District, Seppa,

Arunachal Pradesh

9436051466 (M)

6.

Er. Yumlam Take

APO (Tech.), District Rural Development

Agency, Lower Subansiri District , Ziro,

Arunachal Pradesh

9436055445 (M)




28

Assam:

S.


1.

Shri Wahadur Nobi

Executive Engineer,

District Rural Development Agency

Morigaon District, Morigaon, Assam

9401104043 (M)

2.

Shri Sanjiv Baruah

Junior Engineer (HQ),


Dibrugarh District,

Dibrugarh, Assam

9435155501 (M)

[email protected]

3.

Shri Khandakar Shamsul Alam

Executive Engineer,


Nagaon District, Nagao, Assam

9435022348 (M)

[email protected]

4.

Shri Santosh Brahma

Executive Engineer,


Chirang District,

Kajalgaon, Assam

9435120025 (M)

[email protected]

5.

Shri Jieu Ali Sheikh

Executive Engineer,


Dhubri District, Dhubri, Assam

9435726576 (M)

6.

Shri Balendra Kalita APO (T)

I/c Executive Engineer, District Rural

Development Agency

Darrang District,

Mangaldai, Assam

03713-222192 (O)

9435018594 (M)




29

S.


7.

Shri Prabhat Chandra Borah

Junior Engineer,


Sonitpur District,

Tezpur, Assam

9401602888 (M)

[email protected]

8.

Shri Maneswar Deka

Executive Engineer,


Kamrup (Rural) District,

Amingaon, Assam

9864420003 (M)

[email protected]

Bihar:

S.


1. Mr. Satish Chandra Sharma

Executive Engineer

Buxer

07488023543

2. Mr. Rudra Kumar

Executive Engineer

Rohtas

09304830751

[email protected]

3. Mr. Ravi Shankar Kumar

Executive Engineer

Nalanda

09525226654

[email protected]

4. Mr. Nityanand Choudhary

Executive Engineer

Banka

08863920133, 09771877847

[email protected]

m

5. Mr. Awadh Bihari Singh

Executive Engineer

Bhagalpur

09905071715, 08986024913

[email protected]








30

S.


6. Mr. Suresh Prasad Singh

Executive Engineer

Araria

08252665229

[email protected]

7. Mr. Ajay Kumar Gupta

Executive Engineer

Aurangabad

09905558630

[email protected]

8. Mr. Sanjay Kumar Pandit

Executive Engineer

Gaya

09122163618

[email protected]

[email protected]

9. Mr. Anil Kumar

Executive Engineer

Jahanabad

08986297421

[email protected]

10. Mr. Sanjay Kumar

Executive Engineer

Kaimur

09576719113

[email protected]

om.in

11. Mr. Ashok Kumar Mehta

Executive Engineer

Katihar

09931264360

[email protected]

Chhattisgarh:

S.


1. Shri Narayan Nimje

Superintending Engineer

MGNREGA State Cell Indrawati Bhawan,

Naya Raipur

09893192435

[email protected]

2. Shri Vinay Gupta

Assistant Engineer

MGNEAGA State Cell, Indrawati Bhawan,

New Raipur

07049090401

[email protected]











31

S.


3. Shri Sudhir Tiwari

Executive Engineer

Rural Engineering Services, Dhamtari District

09425214969

[email protected]

4. Shri B.L. Amule

Executive Engineer, Rural Engineering Services

Ambikapur, Surguja District

09753311149

5. Shri Akhilesh Tiwari, Assistant Engineer

Rural Engineering Services,

Manora, Jashpur Dist.

09981756837

[email protected]

6. Shri R. K. Khobragade, Assistant Engineer

Rural Engineering Services

Dharsiwa, Raipur

09977429030

09425584323

[email protected]

7. Shri Prakash Devre, Assistant Engineer

Rural Engineering Services

Keshkal, Kondagaon district

07587266033

09826209696

[email protected]

8. Shri Ashok Dewangan, Assistant Engineer

Rural Engineering Services Dept.

Baloda, Janjgir Champa District

09993775300

[email protected]

9. Shri I P Somankar

SDO-RES / Technical Coordinator

MGNREGA, Kurud Block, Dhamtari

09753672866

09425214682

[email protected]

10. Shri Girish Chandra

Technical Assistant

Gram Panchayat-Nari

09406073782

[email protected]

11. Shri Pradeep Sahu

Technical Assistant

Gram Panchayat-Parkhanda

09691692854

[email protected]









32

S.


12. Shri Shyam Sonkar

Gram Rojgar Sahayak

Gram Panchayat – Parkhanda

09770413123

[email protected]

13 Shri Kapil Dikshit

CFT Coordinator

Kurud Block

09753370916

[email protected]

14. Shri Kumbhaj Lal Verma

Gram Rojgar Sahayak

Gram Panchayat-Jhandatalab

08959374949

[email protected]

15. Ms. Deepshikha Sahu

Technical Assistant

Gram Panchayat, Shiwnikala/Bijanapur

07828141830

[email protected]

16. Shri Ishwar Donode

SDO-RES/Technical Coordinator

MGNREGA, Dongargarh Block, Rajanadgoan

09893140566

[email protected]

17. Ms Namita Mishra

State Coordinator, GIZ, Raipur

09406204520

[email protected]

[email protected]

Gujarat:

S.


1. Shri Indrajeet P. Raval

T.A., DRDA, Mehsana (North Zone)

09913290690/9687650998

[email protected]

2. Shri Abbas A. Mansuri

Works Manager (Dy. Engineer)

DRDA, Patan (North Zone)

08128676822/09925638934

[email protected]

3. Shri Balvant Singh P. Labana

AWM., DRDA, Dahod (Central Zone)

09825278575

[email protected]











33

S.


4. Shri Sunil Patel

Works Manager., DRDA, Dang (South Zone)

09428382408

[email protected]

5. Shri Bhadresh D. Titosa

W.M., DRDA, Amreli (Saurastra)

08128677687/9879123007

6. Shri Sanjay B. Vanavi

A.W.M., DRDA, Junagadh (Saurastra)

09104488630

[email protected]

[email protected]

7. Shri Ramesh M. Bhanusnali

T.A., DRDA, Katch (Kutch Zone)

09737193625

[email protected]

Haryana:

S.


1. Shri Balwan Singh

Superintendent Engineer

Panchayati Raj, Ambala

09729596512

[email protected]

2. Shri Rajinder Hooda

Executive Engineer

Panchayat Raj, Kurushetra

09467780118

[email protected]

3. Shri Sahil Sharma

Sub Divisional Officer

Panchayati Raj, Shehzdpur

Ambala

09896151661

[email protected]

4. Shri Abhishek Nain


Panchayati Raj , Hansi-I, Hisar

09466629211

[email protected]

5. Shri Joginder


Panchayati Raj, Ranis, Sirsa

09416728389

[email protected]










34

S.


6. Shri Gaurav Bhardwaj


Panchayati Raj, Indri, Karnal

09416573103

[email protected]

7. Shri Narender Kumar Gulia


Panchayati Raj, Jatusana, Rewari

09466112077

[email protected]

8. Shri Puran Singh


Panchayati Raj, Shima, Narnaul

09416480481

[email protected]

Himachal Pradesh:

Jammu and Kashmir:

S.


1. Mr. Parvez Malik

Executive Engineer

REW, Jammu (Team Leader)

09419135877

[email protected]

[email protected]

S.


1. Er. K. C. Mastana

A.E., D.R.D.A Hamirpur, Head Quarters

09418107965

[email protected]

2. Shri Onkar Singh Nirala

AE, DRDA, Chamba,

Himachal Pradesh

09418201710

[email protected]

3. Er. Sukh Dev Aur

AE, DRDA, Bilaspur,

Himachal Pradesh

09805274677

[email protected]









35

S.


2. Mr. Daleep Tikoo

AEE, REW, Sub division

Sunderbani

09419280493

[email protected]

3. Mr. Raj Kumar Pandita

AE, REW, Jammu

09596060786

[email protected]

[email protected]

4. Mr. Assadullah Malik

AEE, REW Sub division, Beerwah Khag

09622460517

[email protected]

5. Mr. Quiser Amin

AEE, REW, Sub Division

Beerwah Khag

09419042406

[email protected]

6. Mr. Abdull Qayoom Chalkoo

AEE, REW Sub Division Budgam

09419033132

[email protected]

7. Mr. Nasir Ahmad Hakim

AE, REW Sub Division Pampore

09419077560

[email protected]

Jharkhand:

S.


1.

Shri Santosh Kumar Singh,

Asstt. Engineer, M-24 (Old) , Adityapur – 1,

Jamshedpur – 831013 , Jharkhand

9334625799 (M)

[email protected]

2.

Shri Rajiv Kumar Mahto

Asstt. Engineer, O/o the Block Development

Officer , Simdega Development Block , Simdega

District, Jharkhand - 835223

9939116677 (M)

[email protected]

3.

Shri Praveen Kumar

Asstt. Engineer, O/o the Block Development

Officer , Rajmahal Development Block ,

Sahibganj District, Jharkhand - 816109

9546981250 (M)

[email protected]











36

Karnataka:

S.


1. Sri Chandrashekhar M. Masaguppi Joint Director (Technical) Rural Development, Commissionerate RD & PR Department, Bangalore

09480850066/09448164488 [email protected]

2. Sri M. Thimmanna Asst. Executive Engineer Panchayat Raj Engineering Sub Division, Harapanahalli Tq, Davangere District

09480863118 [email protected]

3. Sri Basayya Hiremath Asst. Executive Engineer Panchayat Raj Engineering Sub Division, Shorapur Tq, Yadgiri District

09343424455 08792560369 [email protected]

4. Sri Ningasetty Asst. Executive Engineer Panchayat Raj Engineering Sub Division, Kollegala, Chamarajanagar District

09448601994 [email protected] [email protected]

5. Sri S.S. Malagi Asst. Executive Engineer Panchayat Raj Engineering Sub Division, Koppal Division , Koppal District


6. Sri B.V. Krishnamurthy Asst. Executive Engineer Panchayat Raj Engineering Sub Division, Chikkaballapura Sub Division, Chikkaballapura District


7. Sri Anand Kumar M Asst. Executive Engineer Panchayat Raj Engineering Sub Division, Chikmagalur, Chikmagalur District


8. Sri B. Harinarayan Asst. Executive Engineer Panchayat Raj Engineering Sub Division, Hosadurga, Chitradurga District











37

S.


9. Sri S.T. Basavarajappa Asst. Executive Engineer Panchayat Raj Engineering Sub Division, Hiriyur, Chitradurga District


10. Sri K.M. Rajashekar Asst. Executive Engineer Panchayat Raj Engineering Sub Division, Belur, Hassan District


11. Sri T.N. Murthy Asst. Executive Engineer Panchayat Raj Engineering Sub Division, Arasikere, Hassan District


12. Sri P.H. Bandi Asst. Executive Engineer Panchayat Raj Engineering Sub Division, B. Bagewadi Tq, Bijapur District


Kerala:

S.


1. Sri Pramod C., Accredited Engineer Nemom Block Panchayat Thiruvananthapuram District


2. Sri Byshak Mohan, Accredited Engineer, Pallom Block Panchayat, Kottayam District


3. Sri Biju Pillai, Accredited Engineer Cheppad Grama Panchayat, Muthukulan Block, Alappuzha District










38

S.


4. Sri Anirudhan K. M Accredited Engineer Mahathma Gandhi NREGS Kollengode Block Panchayat Palakkad District


5. Sri Prasanth M. Accredited Engineer Vengara Block Panchayat Malappuram District


6. Sri Safad Ali M Accredited Engineer Kasaragod Block Panchayat Kasaragod District


Lakshadweep:

Madhya Pradesh

S.


1 Shri M. K. Jain Superintending Engineering MGNREGS H.O., Bhopal


S.


7. Sri F. M. Faizal Junior Engineer Village (Dweep) Panchayat, Kadmat


8. Sri P. Shafeeque Technical Assistant O/o District Programme Coordinator Kavaratti








39

S.


2. Shri R. K. Pandey Divisional Manager Bhopal


3. Shri Mahesh Soni Asst. Engineer NREGS H.O.


4. Shri MPS Bundela Deputy Director (Horticulture), NREGS H.O., Bhopal


5. Shri A. K. Sharma Project Officer (Tech.) Tikamgarh


6. Shri Umesh Sahu Assistant Engineer & Project Officer (Tech.),Sagar


7. Shri Dilip Agrawal Asst. Engineer, Betul


8. Shri Yogendra Kumar Giri Asst. Engineer, MPSEGCHO


9. Shri R. S. Lodhi Asst. Engineer, NREGS H.O.


10. Shri Mukesh Verma Asst. Engineer Jabalpur


11. Shri R.S. Raghuwanshi Asst. Engineer Shajapur


12. Shri B. L. Dangode Asst. Engineer Ujjain













40

S.


13. Shri K. P. Mishra Asst. Engineer Rewa


14. Shri B. K. Banke Asst. Engineer Khargone


15. Shri Rajeev Pandey Asst. Engineer Sheopur


16. Shri A. K. Verma Asst. Engineer Khargone


17. Shri Subodh Agarwal Asst. Engineer Jhabua


18. Shri Arvind Gupta Asst. Engineer,Satna


19. Shri Himanshu Tiwari Asst. Engineer Datiya


Maharashtra:

S.


1. Mr. S.D. Bhagat Joint Commissioner MGNREGS, Nagpur


2. Dr. Uday M. Patil Dy. Comm. Commissionerate MGNREGS, Nagpur


3. Shri Shinde Balasaheb Rajaram Superintending Agriculture Officer (MREGS), Pune Division, Pune

09422554733 020-26361059 [email protected]











41

S.


4. Shri M.J. Naik Executive Engineer Pune Division, Pune

09422544625 020-26361059 [email protected]

5. Shri Vijay Bondre Executive Engineer Division Comm. Office, Nagpur


6. Shri Nilkanth V. Sonune Dy. Engineer Collector Office Washim


7. Shri A.N. Ingole Executive Engineer Divisional Commissioner Office Nashik


8. Shri Sunil Chandrashekhar Rahane Sub divisional Engineer Collector Office Wardha

09423119430 / 07152243249 [email protected] [email protected]

9. Shri Anil Laxmanrao Shirfule Agri. Officer NREGA Cell, 2-P, Nanded


10. Shri A.G. Patil Executive Engineer Commission Office Kokan Bhawan New Bombay

09823377185 [email protected] [email protected]

Manipur

S.


1. Shri Chabungbam Sadananda Meetei

State Level Monitor, State MGNREGA Cell

Manipur Secretariat, North Block, Room No.

205, Babupara, Manipur

9856164895 (M)

[email protected]






mailto:[email protected]%20m





42

S.


2. Shri Longjam Rojendro Singh

Executive Engineer, District Rural Development

Agency, DC, Office, Bishnupur District,

Bishnupur, Manipur

9856268496 (M)

3. Shri Ngangbam Somorendro Singh


Agency, DC Office, Thoubal District, Thoubal,

Manipur

9856183262 (M)

[email protected]

4. Shri L. Ramesh Singh

State Level Monitor, State MGNREGA Cell

Manipur Secretariat, North Block, Room No.

205, Babupara, Manipur

0385-2445820 (O/F)

[email protected]

Meghalaya

S.


1.

Shri R. Lytan


Agency , East Khasi Hills District Shillong,

Meghalaya

9856084368 (M),

[email protected]

2.

Shri Ialumbok Pyngrope

Asstt. Engineer, State Rural Employment

Society, Sympli Building, Dhankheti,

Shillong, Meghalaya

8575785664 (M)

[email protected]

3.

Shri Kerry B. Lyngdoh

Asstt. Engineer, State Rural Employment

Society, Sympli Building, Dhankheti,

Shillong, Meghalaya

9863651659 ( M)

[email protected]

4.

Shri Dominic Susngi


Agency , Ri-Bhoi District, Nongpoh, Meghalaya

9615323725 (M)






43

S.


5.

Shri Parnell Erwin Hynniewta

Executive Engineer,

District Rural Development Agency ,

DC Office, West Garo Hills District,

Tura, Meghalaya

9862098895 (M)

[email protected]

Mizoram:

S.


1. Pu Paul L. Khuma

Under Secretary

R.D. Department

09862397653

[email protected]

2. Pu H. Lalrinpuia

BDO, Bunghmun, Lunglei District

09862927197

[email protected]

3. Pu Zoremthara Ralte

BDO, Champhai, Champhai District

09612617440

[email protected]

4. Pu Vanlaltanpuia

BDO, Sangau, Lawngtlai District

09436375126

[email protected]

Nagaland:

S.


1. Er. Ghoshito Sumi

Executive Engineer

R.D. Department

Nagaland

09436066012

2. Er. Thokphen Phom

Executive Engineer

Nagaland

09436603033






44

S.


3. Er. T.T. Bhutia

Assistant Engineer

Nagaland

08132906697

[email protected]

4. Ms. Melehole Pucho

S.O I

Nagaland

09402679084

[email protected]

5. Ms. Yapanglemla

S.O II, Nagaland

09856882662

[email protected]

Odisha:

S.


1. Shri F.U. Khan

Executive Engineer

DRDA, Dhenkanal

09437209099

[email protected]

2. Shri Bijay Kumar Badu

Executive Engineer, DRDA, Khurda

09437248399

[email protected]

3. Shri Mangaraj Behera

Executive Engineer

DRDA, Bolangir

09556256119

[email protected]

4. Shri Madan Mohan Majhi

Executive Engineer

DRDA, Keonjhar

09438776577

[email protected]

5. Dr. Dasharathi Sabar

Executive Engineer

DRDA, Rayagada

09438255403

[email protected]

[email protected]

6. Shri Rushikesh Dansana

Executive Engineer

DRDA, Kalahandi

07894897095

[email protected]











45

S.


7. Shri Jagannath Bhujabala

Asst. Eng., PR Department

09437183407

[email protected]

8. Shri Santosh Kumar Balabantaray

Asst. Executive Engineer

Banki Dampada Block, DRDA Cuttack

08763533601

[email protected]

9. Shri Amulya Kumar Mohanty

Asst. Executive Engineer

Kolabira Block, DRDA, Jharsuguda

09437539311

[email protected]

10 Shri Ashis Kumar Banerjee

Asst. Engineer, Rairangpur Block

DRDA, Mayurbhanj District

09437379359

[email protected]

11. Shri Rajdeep Ranjan Saha

Asst. Engg., Raikia Block

DRDA, Kandhamal, Odisha

09439069959

[email protected]

12. Shri Pradosh Kumar Das

J.E., P.R. Department, Odisha

09437682250

[email protected]

Puducherry

Punjab:

S.


1. Er. Parkash Singh

S.E, (Panchayati Raj) Circle

PB, S.A.S Nagar, Punjab

08557000073

[email protected]

S.


1. Thiru K.J. Venkatachalapathy

Work Inspector, Block Development Office,

Villianur Block

07639697430

[email protected]




mailto:[email protected]%20n





46

S.


2. Shri Devinder Singh

Sub Divisional Officer, Punjab

08146818685

[email protected]

3. Shri Tarjinder Singh

Asstt. Engineer (Canals)

S.B.S Nagar

09876766480

[email protected]

4. Shri Vijay Kumar

A.E, Zilla Parishad Mansa,

Distt Mansa, Punjab

09878823543

[email protected]

5. Shri Krishan Lal

A.E, Zilla Parishad Mansa,

Distt. Mansa, Punjab

09872879887

[email protected]

6. Shri Devinder Kumar Hans

Executive Engineer

Panchayati Raj, S.A.S Nagar. Punjab

09876514115

[email protected]

7. Er. Janak Raj Grover


Panchayati Raj

Gurdarpur (Punjab) 143521

09646135288

[email protected]

8. Shri Ranjit Singh

A.E, O/o Xen Panchayati Raj

Gurderpur (Punjab)

08872810333

[email protected]

9. Shri Chetan Parkash

B.D.P.O Office, SH. Anandpur Sahib

Distt. Roop Nagar, Punjab

08054468611

[email protected]









47

Rajasthan:

S.


1. Shri N.K. Joshi

Executive Engineer,

EGS cum State Nodal Officer Convergence

State Nodal Officer MoRD-GIZ Project,

MGNREGA HQ, RD & PR Deptt.

Secretariat, Jaipur

09414311492

[email protected]

[email protected]

2. Shri Krishan Tyagi

State Coordinator

GIZ, MGNREGA HQ, Secretariat, Jaipur

09672984720

[email protected]

3. Shri Rajendra Sharma

Assistant Engineer,

Chittorgarh

09414364795

[email protected]

4. Shri Fateh Lal Soni

Assistant Engineer, P.S

Chittorgarh

08769504611

5. Shri Om Prakash Bhambi

Junior Technical Assistant,

Chittorgarh

09929343755

[email protected]

6. Shri Mathura Singh Meena

Junior Technical Assistant

Chittorgarh

08058236174

[email protected]

7. Shri Bharu Lal Meena

Gram Rozgar Shayak

GP-Abhaypur, Chittorgarh

09983780765

8. Shri Raj Kumar Soni

Gram Rozgar Shayak

GP-Sehnwa, Chittorgarh

09680330472







48

S.


9. Shri K.K. Sharma

Assistant Engineer

Kotri, Bhilwara

09460987548

10. Shri Chandra Shekar Sharma


Kotri, Bhilwara

09785717372

11. Shri Prakash Nath Yogi


Kotri, Bhilwara

09571502514

[email protected]

12. Shri Bhagwati Lal

Gram Rozgar Shayak, Kankroliya Ghati GP

Kotri, Bhilwara

09772831420

13. Shri Mukesh Meena

Gram Rozgar Shayak

Nandrai, Kotri, Bhilwara

08094423211

14. Shri Rajiv Ahuja

Technical Expert

MoRD, GIZ Project

09910909111

[email protected]

15. Shri Rakesh Gupta

Executive Engineer

ZP, Alwar

09694096209

16. Shri Suresh Dadhich

ADPC, EGS

ZP, Barmer

09829010297

[email protected]

17. Shri Arvind Saxena

Executive Engineer

MGNREGA HQ, Secretariat, Jaipur

09414238443

[email protected]

18. Shri Inderjeet Nimesh

Executive Engineer

ZP, Bhilwara

09672995495

[email protected]

[email protected]







49

S.


19. Shri Rajesh Mundra

Executive Engineer

ZP, Jhalawar

09828118717

[email protected]

20. Shri Anil Acharya

Executive Engineer

ZP, Udaipur

09414736634 / 08003821056

[email protected]

21. Shri B.L. Gupta

Executive Engineer

ZP, Jaipur

09928660030

[email protected]

22. Shri Nitin Sharma

Assistant Engineer

MGNREGA HQ, RD & PR Deptt.

Secretariat, Jaipur

09829316691

[email protected]

23. Shri O. P. Parihar

Assistant Engineer

ZP, Jodhpur

09928373731

[email protected]

24. Shri Ram Bol Singh

Assistant Engineer

ZP, Dholpur

09414282952

[email protected]

25. Shri Hari Sharma

Assistant Engineer

ZP, Bharatpur

09950422503

[email protected]

Sikkim:

S.


1

Shri Prasoon Pradhan

Asstt. Engineer, Rhenock Gram Vikash Kendra

Aritar, Sikkim 8016879293 (M)

[email protected]









50

2

Shri Mohan Sharma

Junior Engineer, Gram Vikash Kendra

Khamdong, East Sikkim, Sikkim 9725821394 (M)

[email protected]

3

Shri Rinzing Sherpa

Technical Assistant, Gram Vikash Kendra

Dzongu, North Sikkim

Sikkim 8145294933 (M)

[email protected]

Tamil Nadu:

S.


1. Tmt. M. Kavitha

Executive Engineer (RD)

Directorate of Rural Development and

Panchayat Raj, Chennai – 15

09444292527

08012588640

[email protected]

2. Tmt. B. Sharmila Devi

Assistant Engineer



09488949838

07402608914

[email protected]

3. Tmt. S. Senthamarai Selvi

JDO/ Union Overseer



09445803050

09688105222

[email protected]

4. R. Santhanakrishnan

Assistant Engineer

Block Development Office

Parangipettai, Cuddalore District

07402606255

[email protected]

5. R. Krishnakumar

Assistant Engineer


Keerapalayam, Cuddalore District

7402606262

[email protected]








51

S.


6. K. Parimalapriya

Assistant Engineer


Thiruvalangadu, Tiruvallur Dist.

07402606159

[email protected]

7. M. Narasimman

Assistant Engineer


Minjur, Tiruvallur District

07402606141

09444164566

[email protected]

[email protected]

8. A.R. Sivanandan

Union Engineer

Block Development Office, RK pet

Tiruvallur District

07402606171

09443066357

[email protected]

[email protected]

9. V. R. Gomathi

Assistant Engineer


Sholavaram, Tiruvallur District

07402606146

09566513548

[email protected]

10. G. Anbumani

Assistant Engineer

DRDA, Krishnagiri District

07402607011

9488319029

[email protected]

11. N. Sakthi Prahadeesh

Assistant Engineer


Thalavadi, Erode District

07402607152

09894421231

[email protected]

12. S. Umashankar

Assistant Engineer

District Rural Development Agency,

Erode District

07402607094

09894016633

[email protected]










52

S.


13. S. Saravanan

Assistant Engineer

Block Development Office,

Ammapettai, Erode District

07402607119

09043567052

[email protected]

14. R. Ravichandran

Assistant Engineer

Block Development Office,

Thiruvannamalai District

07402606676

[email protected]

15. S. Masilamani

Union Engineer, Block Dev. Office

Kanthili, Vellore District

09443442905

07402606546

[email protected]

Telangana:

S.


1. Shri B. Saidulu Joint Commissioner (EGS&IT) O/o Commissioner RD


2. Shri M. Vishnuvardhan Reddy PM (QC), O/o Commissioner RD


3. Shri P. Kiran Kumar EC, Mudigonda Mandal O/o Project Director, DWMA, Khammam


4. Shri A. Venkateswar Rao Assistant Project Director Ibrahimpatnam Cluster O/o Project Director DWMA, Rangareddy


5. Md. Abed Abdul Wadood Khan EC, O/o Commissioner RD


6. Smt. K. Madhavilatha SPM (CB), O/o Commissioner RD











53

Tripura:

S.


1.

Er. Manoj Majumder

Asstt. Engineer, O/o the Executive Engineer

Bisharmganj R.D. Division Sepahijala, Tripura

0381-2807244 (O/F)

9436122227 (M)

[email protected]

2.

Er. Barun Debbarma

Junior Engineer (Gr. 1), O/o the Block

Development Officer

Dasda R.D. Block, North Tripura

03824267265 (O)

9862312705/9436531010 (M)

[email protected]

3.

Er. Saradindu Sarkar

Junior Engineer (Gr. II), O/o the Block

Development Officer, Dumburnagar RD Block,

Dhalai District, Tripura

03826265344 (O)

9436558677 (M)

[email protected]

4.

Er. Subhayan Debnath

Junior Engineer (Gr. II), O/o the Block

Development Officer

Matabari RD Block , Gomti District, Tripura

03821223520 (O)

9436121182 (M)

[email protected]

Uttar Pradesh

S.


1 Mr. Mukesh Kumar Sharma, Assistant

Engineer, DRDA, Bijnor

09759127447

[email protected]

2 Mr.R.N. Pandey, A.E. DRDA, Gonda

Uttar Pradesh

09415415862

[email protected]

3 Mr. CP Singh, AE, DRDA, Balrampur

Uttar Pradesh

09451629126

[email protected]

4 Shri Ajay Kumar Jain, A.E, DRDA, Bulandshahr,

Uttar Pradesh

09410483952

[email protected]









54

S.


5 Shri S K Priyadarshi, Executive Engineer

SSK-39, Allahabad, Irrigation department,

Govt. of UP

09415122166

[email protected]

6 Shri Kamlesh Srivastava, A.E, DRDA

Jaunpur

07860787042

[email protected]

7 Shri Madhur Mohan Agrawal

AE, DRDA, Bareilly, Uttar Pradesh

09415119156

[email protected]

8 Shri Lav Kush Singh, Executive Engineer,

Sharda Sahayak Khand – 23, Azamgarh

09839440757

[email protected]

9 Shri Arun Kumar Yadav, AE, Minor Irrigation,

Ghazipur

09453585579

[email protected]

10 Shri Sanjeev Kumar, A.E, DRDA

Jhansi, Uttar Pradesh

09450297571

[email protected]

11 Shri S.K. Saraswat, A.E.P.W.D Agra, Uttar

Pradesh

07599001333

[email protected]

12 Shri Mahesh Kumar Gupta, A.E, DRDA,

Chitrakoot

09415182197

[email protected]

13 Shri Pradip Kumar Singh, A.E, DRDA

Basti, Uttar Pradesh

09415163401

14 Shri A.R. Singh, A.E, DRDA

Pratapgarh, Utttar Pradesh

09918874555

15 Shri Anurag Verma, A.E, DRDA

Mahoba, Uttar Pradesh

09415057976

[email protected]

16 Shri Surendra Kumar

A.E, DRDA, Hathras, Uttar Pradesh

09458510430










55

S.


17 Shri R.B. Gupta, A.E, DRDA

Kasganj, Uttar Pradesh

09412226052

[email protected]

Uttarakhand

West Bengal:

S.


1. Shri Anirban Samanta

Technical Assistant, MGNREGA, MGNREGA

Cell, Bankura District, West Bengal

03242253147 (O)

9434253906 (M)

[email protected]

S.


1. Ms. Joiti N. Kharwal

Additional Secretary

Rural Development Department, Uttarakhand

07536888888

[email protected]

2. Shri Pradeep Kumar Pandey

District Development Officer

Janpad, Tihari Gadwal

09412093900

[email protected]

3. Shri Rajendra Singh Bisht

A.E, DRDA, Janpad, Deharadun

09411381751

[email protected]

4. Shri Vivek Upadhyay

District Development Officer, Janpad,

Champavat

09456395231

[email protected]

5. Ms. Sonika

Chief Development Officer

Pauri Garhwal, Uttarakhand

0885999977

[email protected]








56

S.


2. Shri Suraj Kumar Sarkar

Asstt. Engineer, MGNREGA, MGNREGA Cell

Nadia District, West Bengal

9635864798 (M)

[email protected]

3. Shri Sudipta Mistry

Asstt. Engineer, MGNREGA,

O/o the District Magistrate, District MGNREGA

Cell, Jalpaiguri District, West Bengal

03561222334 (O)

9733309192 (M)

[email protected]

4. Shri Debasis Ray Choudhuri

Asstt. Engineer, District MGNREGA Cell

Karnojora, Uttar Dinajpur District, West Bengal

9434682719 (M)

5. Shri Sandip Rana

Technical Assistant, MGNREGA Cell,

Sahid Kshudiram Parikalpana Bhawan

Paschim Medinipur Zilla Parishad, West Bengal

03222269866 (O)

9434989525 (M)

6. Shri Paritosh Chandra Das

Asstt. Engineer, O/o the District Nodal Officer,

Gram Unnayan Bhawan, Malda, West Bengal

03512223815/ 9434300972 (M)

[email protected]

[email protected]

7. Shri Kuntal Biswas

Asstt. Engineer, District MGNREGA Cell

Purulia Zilla Parishad, West Bengal

03252225761 (O)

9732159629 (M)

[email protected]

8. Shri Anupam Maity

Asstt. Engineer, Dist. MGNREGA Cell

Purba Medinipur Dist., West Bengal

03228-263890 (O)

8906146947 (M)

[email protected]







57

ANNEXURE - II: QUESTIONNAIRE-1 & MODEL ANSWERS

ASSESSMENT OF TRAINEES PARTICIPATED IN SAMARTHYA, TECHNICAL TRAINING FOR

CREATION OF SRT UNDER MGNREGA (Pre/post-Test) TIME – 1 hour DATE:

Name: Designation: State

1. Contour Bund can be provided? Tick the right answer

a. Type of land Non arable / Arable

b. Up to what slope 10% / 12%

c. Up to Rain Fall less than 800mm/ more than 800mm

d. Type of soil Permeable / Impermeable

2. What type of activity we should propose for impermeable soil and where rain fall is less

than 800mm. Tick the correct answer

1. Contour Bund 2. Graded Bund

3. In Arable Land what type of works should be proposed? Write the name of Four Works.

1) Contour bund 2) Bench Terrace 3) Graded bund 4) Conservation ditch 5) Farm pond 6) 30 X 40 model 6) Tanka 7) Khadin 8) Grass water way

4. In Drainage line Treatment write the name of Four Works.

1) Loose boulder check dam 2) Gabion Structure 3) Earthen Dam/ Bund 4) Earthen Gully plug 5) Drop spill way 7) Spurs 8) Revetment

5. In Non-Arable area write the name of three works.

1) Diversion Drain 2) Contour trench 3) Loose Boulder Bund 4) Village pond 5) Spring-shed development

6. In which Area Grass Water Way can be constructed?

Arable area/ Cultivable area

7. What is the difference between the Diversion Drain & Grass Water Way?

Diversion drain is constructed across the slope whereas Grass water way is constructed along the slope

58

8. What Formula we will use to calculate break runoff?

Q = (C X I X A) / 360

Where,

Q= Design peak rate of runoff, (m3/s)

C= Runoff coefficient

I= Intensity of rainfall, (mm/hr) for the duration equal to time of concentration (Tc) of watershed

and design RI, and

A=Area of the watershed,(ha)

9. What Formula we will use to calculate velocity?

V = 1/n (R2/3 X S1/2) OR V= Q/A

Where,

V= velocity of flow in the channel (m/sec)

R= hydraulic radius (m)

S= hydraulic Slope (M/m) and

n= The Manning’s roughness coefficient

10. What Formula we will used to calculate waste weir?

Q = 1.711 LH 3/2

Where,

Q = Maximum discharge capacity of weir (including f.b.), m3/s,

L = Crest length of weir, m,

H = Depth of flow over weir crest, m

11. List out the priority in identifying the beneficiaries for providing individual assets:

They are the para 5 household and the priority is:

a) SC, b) ST, c) Nomadic Tribe, d) De-notified tribes, e) Other families below the poverty line, f)

Women- headed household, g) Physically handicapped headed household, h) Beneficiaries of

land reforms, i) The beneficiaries under Indira Awas Yojana, j) Beneficiaries under schedule

tribes and other traditional forest dwellers, k) After exhausting the eligible beneficiaries under

the above categories, on lands of the small or marginal farmers.

12. What is the importance of plantation in MGNREGS:

They are as follows:

1) Soil and moisture conservation

2) Carbon sequestration

3) Enhance livelihood activities

59

4) Reduce pollution (Air, sound and water)

5) Improve biodiversity

6) Convert waste lands in to productive lands.

7) Provision of usufruct rights to para-5 household.

13. What is the importance of convergence in afforestation/Horticulture activities.


1) Funds from other schemes can be utilized for gap filling and value addition to generate

quality assets.

2) It will help in maintaining 60: 40 (Wage: Material) ratio.

14. List out the types of plantations, and which type of plantation will be most suitable in

your District.


1) Bund Plantation,

2) Road side tree plantation.

3) Canal side plantation.

4) Planting trees along the railway tracks.

5) Block plantation.

6) Institutional plantation.

7) Horticulture plantation.

8) Farm forestry.

15. How participatory planning exercise can help in proper planning of plantation activities:

It will help in identification of land, beneficiary and species to be planted in proper and

systematic manner and maintenance of plantation.

16. While undertaking Roadside Tree Plantation who will select the plant species.

The beneficiary will select the plant species from the informed choice of species, if he is given

tree patta, otherwise GP.

17. What parameters you will consider for the selection of a nursery site.


1) Location - Accessibility and close to the plantation site.

2) water availability round the year.

3) Topography and drainage - flat with good drainage.

4) Soil – Sandy loam to loam, having pH 5.5 – 7.5

60

18. Match the following from column A to B:

S. No A Answers B

1 Category A 4B Planting Exercise

2 IPPE 3B Teak, Redsander

3 Category B 5B Planning Exercise

4 Maintenance activities 7B Public works related to Natural Resource

Management

5 Horticulture plants 6B Community Assets or individual assets for

vulnerable sections

6 Coconut, Mango

7 Weeding, manuring, watering

19. What do you mean by month-wise schedule of activities for nursery and tree plantation?

What is its importance?

As tree plantation is a time bound activity, so as to carry out the nursery and tree plantation

activities in time, a month wise schedule of activities for nursery operations and for the conduct

of tree plantation like site clearance , pitting, pit filling, tree plantation, etc. need to be prepared

before the conduct of raising nursery and tree plantation.

The main importance of preparing this schedule of activities is that it becomes easy for

implementing agency to execute the works in time and also for monitoring the works.

20. Mention the criteria adopted while selecting the species to be planted on bunds?


a) Trees which grows straight and have less canopy.

b) It should be farmer friendly.

c) It should not compete with the main agriculture crop for nutrient and water.

d) It should be drought resistant and act as wind break.

21. Write the steps to calculate the peak run of flow for your area for the design of field drain using monographs Figure no. 3.11 to 3.14 (of SAMARTHYA technical Manual) for the rainfall of 10 years recurrence interval.

Following steps will be followed to conduct the peak run off.

Step-1: Calculate the average value of runoff coefficient ‘C’ from table 3.7.

Step-2: Calculate the time of concentration from fig 3.11 for the given

61

Step-3: Calculate 1hr Rainfall in mm per hour for the longitude and latitude of the particular

area for 10 yrs. of recurrence interval from figure 3.12.

Step-4: From fig 3.13 rainfall intensity for the duration equal to time of concentration will be

calculated.

Step-5: Now when we know the area of watershed, average runoff coefficient, the rainfall

intensity in mm/ hr for the duration equal to time of concentration then from the figure 3.14 the

peak rate of run off may be calculated.

Or by Q = CIA/ 360… (Rational formula)

Step-6: Now when we know the Q, then find the velocity of the flow through Manning’s formula

v =( R2/3 X S1/2)/n

Step-7: Find out roughness coefficient from table 3.11 for the soils for which you want to

calculate runoff.

Step- 8: Find out the value of R i.e. Radius of influence

R = A/P

A= Area of cross section of the drain

P= wetted perimeter.

Step-9: If the velocity is within the safer limit i.e. non-scouring then the section is appropriate

provided it can take care of more than the designed discharge.

Step-10: Draw L-section and Cross section (design).

62

22. Design & draw cross section and L-section of a drain of 1.0 meter depth, 0.6 meter bottom width, 1.5:1 side slope with following N.S.L. The designed gradient may be kept 1:1000

Chainage NSL in M

0 m 100.5

100 m 100.8

200 m 100.4

300 m 100.0

400 m 100.7

500 m 100.5

600 m 100.3

700m 99.5

800 m 99.0

900m 98.5

1000m 98.4

It is as given below:

63

23. What are command area and its objectives and why we need it?

Command area is the area which can be irrigated by particular reservoir/ dam. The main

objective of Command Area Development (CAD) programmes are as given below:

a. Minimization of water losses through lining of canals, increasing canal capacity, installation

of control structure and improved techniques for more efficient water usage.

b. The maximization production of grains from water use through on farm development works,

construction of an improved and wider farm road network, improved agriculture techniques

brought by adaptive research and agriculture extension etc.

c. The equitable distribution of water throughout the command area and greater control over

canal system as a whole.

24. Why we need land leveling. Assume average NSL level of a border strip of 30 m wide and 100 m length. Draw L-Sections and calculate earth work by profile method. Draw profile mentioning NSL and designed formation level showing cut and fill also.

Land levelling is the process of preparing or modifying (i.e. Shaping) the land surface to a

planned grade to provide suitable field surface for controlling flow of water, check soil erosion,

provide better and equal distribution of water to the crops, better surface drainage flow, and

ensure uniform application and distribution of water.

64

25. Draw a typical layout plan of a drainage system?

It is as follows:

26. Draw a typical layout plan of irrigation system showing reservoir?

It as follows:

65

27. Mention the factors / variables which affects the design of peak runoff flow of rain water

and the drainage system?

It depends upon the following factors:

(i) Intensity of rainfall.

(ii) Soil characteristic of catchment.

(iii) Size and topography of the catchment.

(iv) Vegetative cover and land use in the catchment.

(v) Cropping pattern, Tolerance of crops regarding flooding in the area to be protected.

28. Draw typical cross-section of earthen water course and levee of water course for 1 cusec capacity?

It is as follows:

29. What do you mean by convergence of schemes in Command Area. Write Manning’s formula?

In Command area the works of construction of water courses, field drains, construction of

Pucca Water Course, Hydraulic structures, farm roads, main drains, land levelling, etc. can be

carried out under MGNREGA and the material procurement if needed may be obtained from the

CAD funds or concerned line Department. In this way convergence can be done.

Manning’s formula is, V = (R2/3 X S 1/2)/ W

Where,

V = Velocity of flow in m/sec.

R = Radius of flow, (m)

S = Slope,

W = Roughness coefficient.

66

30. Mention the works of Command Area which can be done under MGNREGA?

They are as follows: 1) Repair / New construction of Minor 2) Construction of Kachcha water course. 3) Construction of Pucca water course. 4) Construction of surface drainage system. 5) Construction of Sub – surface drainage system. 6) Construction of Hydraulic structures, culverts, etc. 7) Construction of farm roads. 8) Land levelling 31. In conventional method of construction to resist earth quake pressure, RCC Bands to be

provided at plinth/ sill , Lintel and roof levels.

32. Brick layer laid with headers will have beam/ arch action.

33. In Rat trap bond to have concealed electrical conduit & concealed plumbing pre-panning is

required and vertical pipes to be run in cavity.

34. Rat trap can be taken up when good quality bricks are available.

35. Filler slab can be constructed when Manglore tiles or any suitable filler material is

available.

36. Filler material can’t be placed in bands, running of conduits fan hooks are not to be

placed in filler zone.

37. Type of sand to be used for concrete, plastering & cement mortar is coarse, fine & coarse

respectively.

38. To avoid cracks in between basement & superstructure Damp proof course is

recommended.

39. To avoid separation & to have monolithic action to be provided in between top layer of

the super structure while using different materials.

40. Disseminate Technology up to GP (root) level for proper execution.

41. What is the sanitary Mate main responsibility?

Identify the beneficiary with respect to data base of Swachh Bharat Mission (Gramin).

42. Identification of GPs where IHHLs to be taken up under MGNREGA shall be covered in

Database available at SBM (G) and DWM.

43. What items to be charged to NREGA in solid waste Management.

67

Processing and disposal infrastructure

44. What item to be charged to NREGA in Solid and Liquid Waste Management.

Solid waste Management : Infrastructure required for processing and disposal. (Vermi-

compost, NADEP compost pit, dumping yard, etc.)

Liquid waste management: Leach pits, Septic pits, stabilization ponds, drains.

45. What is revised cost of IHHL Rs 12000/- and what are the new provisions to be included in

the design handwashing and how much charges to NREGA funds Rs 12000/-.

46. Minimum formation width for road 7.50 m in plain area & 6.0 m in mountain area.

47. Minimum height of Road formation 0.6 m and above.

68

ANNEXURE - III: QUESTIONNAIRE-2 & MODEL ANSWERS

ASSESSMENT OF TRAINEES PARTICIPATED IN SAMARTHYA, TECHNICAL TRAINING FOR CREATION OF SRT UNDER MGNREGA (Pre-Test) TIME – 1 hour DATE:

Name: Designation: State

1. While planning the contour bund how much deviation is permitted towards down-stream side and upstream side?

Permitted deviation towards down-stream side - 30cm, Permitted deviation towards Up stream side – 15cm

2. What formula is used to get the height of contour bund for 30 cm impounding of water behind the bund?

h = √(Re X VI/50)

Where,

h = Height of bund 30 cm impounding (m).

Re = 24 hrs. Rainfall excess (cm)

VI = Vertical interval (m)

3. By which formula we can calculate the width of bench terrace?

W = (100 X d) / s

Where,

W = Width of terrace (m),

d = Maximum admissible cutting,

s = Slope in %

4. When batter in riser is 1:1, by which formula we can calculate the V.I. (Vertical Interval) in Bench Terrace?

V.I. = W X S/ (100 - s)

Where, W = net width of bench terrace, m S = Slope in %

5. In Contour Trenches, write the formula to work out Horizontal Interval.

H.I. (Horizontal interval) = A/L in m

Where, A = Area from which rainfall is received in sqm,

L = Total length of trench in m.

69

6. In which Area Grass Water Way can be constructed?

Question No 6 of Questionnaire-1 to be referred

7. What is the difference between the Diversion Drain & Grass Water Way?


8. What Formula we will used to calculate runoff?


9. What Formula we will used to calculate velocity?


10. What Formula we will used to calculate waste weir?


11. List out the priority in identifying the beneficiaries for providing individual assets


12. What is the importance of convergence in afforestation/Horticulture activities?


13. List out the types of plantations, and which type of plantation will be most suitable in

your District.


14. How participatory planning exercise can help in proper plantation activities


15. While undertaking Roadside Tree Plantation who will select the plant species.


16. As per the action plan on Roadside Tree Plantation, the maximum number of trees that

can be allotted to a single beneficiary/Household is –

200 trees

17. What parameters you will consider for the selection of a nursery site.


70

18. What is the importance of month-wise schedule of activities for nursery and tree

plantation?


19. Mention the criteria adopted while selecting the species to be planted on bunds?


20. Write the name of the method used for the calculations of peak flow of runoff for an area up to 1300 ha and the steps with formula for the calculations of runoff.


21. How you will design the earthen water course to carry 1 cusec discharge and 1:1000 grade. Do the calculations in detail drawn the cross section of Levee and W.C.

We will design water course of 1 cusec discharge by Manning’s formula.

Q = A X v

Where, v = ( R2/3 X s 1/2)/ n

Q = 1 Cusec

A = Area of cross section of W.C. (m2)

v = Velocity of flow in (m/ sec).

R = Radius of influence (m) = A/P = Area of cross section/ Wetted perimeter of W.C.

S = gradient (1:1000 here)

n = Roughness coefficient.

71

22. How you will design a surface field drain to carry 2 cumec water at an gradient of 1:1000. The bed width of the drain may be kept 0.6m and the side slope 1:1.

We will design velocity of flow of water by Manning’s formula-

V= (R2/3 X S1/2) / n (Assume F. S. D. of drain)

If this velocity is non-scouring then we will design the Q by the formula Q = A X V and if this Q is more than 2 cumec, then this section is OK.

23. Draw a Typical L-Section and cross-section of earthen W.C. constructed on ridge line irrigating both side fields assume all the data required including F.S.C. of parent minor from where the W.C. has been off taken.


24. Mention in brief what is command area development and why we need it for rural upliftment.


25. What do you mean by Land levelling? Mention the steps to be considered for land levelling. Why it is required?

Land levelling is the process of preparing or modifying (i.e. Shaping) the land surface to a planned grade to provide suitable field surface for controlling flow of water, check soil erosion, provide better and equal distribution of water to the crops, better surface drainage flow, moisture and ensure uniform application and distribution of water. Steps: i) Fix temporary bench mark

ii) Fix wooden pegs.

iii) Determine ground elevation with dumpy level.

iv) Draw contour lines.

v) With the help of contour map divide land in to fields and border strips.

vi) With profile method work out cut and fill.

72

26. Draw typical Layout plan of surface drainage system and irrigation system.


27. Write components of CAD works that can be taken under MGNREGA.


28. Write down the formula for the calculation of non-silting and non-eroding velocity of flow.

Vo = 0.3092 y0.5

Vo = Non silting and non-eroding velocity in (m/sec).

y = depth of flowing water (m)

29. What is the time of concentration? How you will calculate it, if length of catchment and gradient is given, mention the formula.

Time of concentration of the water shed is the time required for water to flow from the most remote highest point of watershed to the most remote lowest outlet point, once the soil has become saturated and minor depressions filled up.

Tc =0195L 0.77 X S - 0.385 Where, Tc =Time of concentration (min) L = Length of flow (Maximum) (m) S = Grade of drainage area.

30. Write the formula for calculation of average runoff coefficient, where a Particular catchment have three types of topography in an area. (Area- A1, A2, A3).

Average runoff coefficient (C) = (A1C1 + A2C2 + A3C3) / (A1+ A2+ A3)

31. In conventional method of construction to resist earth quake pressure, RCC bands to be

provided at Plinth/ sill, Lintel and roof level.

32. Brick layer laid with headers will have Beam/ Arch action.

33. No. of bricks required for Construction of 1cum Rat Trap bond is 400 Nos.

34. Savings of concrete in Construction of Filler slab w.r.t. RCC slab is about 20 %.

35. Type of sand to be used for concrete & plastering Coarse & fine respectively.

73

36. Any Six different types of Rural Buildings permitted under MGNREGA.

1) Gram Panchayat (covered area-130 sq. m.)

2) Anganwadi centres (covered area at least -56 sqm)

3) Food Grain Storage Structures

4) Village Haats

5) Crematoria

6) Women self-help groups’ federation

7) Cyclone shelter

8) Common work-sheds for livelihood activities of self-help groups

9) Post harvest facilities including pucca storage facilities for agricultural produce

10) Houses sanctioned under the IAY (minimum built up area at least 20 sq. m.)

37. Rat Protection slabs to be constructed in Food grain storage structure buildings

38. In C/o IAY House 95 / 90 Man-days in Hilly / plain Terrain areas are allowed under

MGNREGA.

39. Identification of IHHLs in GPs covered in Database to be taken up under MGNREGA.

40. For digestion of night soils what action is required?

Aerobic in twin pit system

41. Items that can be charged in solid and liquid waste management

Solid waste Management: Infrastructure required for processing and disposal.

(Vermicompost, NADEP compost pit, dumping yard, etc.)

Liquid waste management: Leach pits, Septic pits, stabilisation ponds, drains.

42. What is the revised cost of IHHL under MGNREGS?

Rs 12,000/-

43. Minimum formation width for road 7.5m in plain area and 6.0m in mountain area.

44. Minimum height of Road formation 0.6m above G.L.

45. Maximum no. of curves allowed per 1km?

6 Nos.

74

ANNEXURE - IV: EVALUATION OF STRT TRAININGS:

ASSESSMENTS BY STRT MEMBERS OF BATCH - 1:

78


82


86


90


94


98


102


108


112


117

ANNEXURE - V: GLIMPSES OF SAMARTHYA TECHNICAL TRAINING PROGRAMMES FOR

STRTs.

STRT TRAINING, BATCH-1: 23/03/2015 TO 26/03/2015:

118


119

STRT TRAINING, BATCH-3: 14/04/2015 TO 17/04/2015

120


121


122


123


124


125


Shri S. M. Vijayanand, (Sec PR & DG NIRD-PR) addressed participants of the ninth training held

from 2nd June to 5th June, 2015 at NIRD&PR-NERC, Guwahati. (Image above on right side

bottom)

126


127

ANNEXURE - VI: FEEDBACK/ OPINION AND SUGGESTIONS FROM STRTs

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

S. No.

Duration of Technical Training

State/ No. of participants

Feedback/ opinion of the STRTs

Suggestions of the STRTs Comments of National Technical Team

1 23rd to 26th

March, 2015

Tamil Nadu/ 15

1) The training was very useful.

2) The Manual is very informative.

3) The watershed concepts are very clear, after the training.

4) The permissible works under MGNREGA is very clear.

1) Field level training may also be included in the STRTs technical training.

1) Advised, 1 to ½ day field visit for District Technical Resource Team (DTRT) and Block Technical Resource Team (BTRT) training.

2 Andhra Pradesh/ 16

1) Very informative, well

designed training

programme.

2) A very good refreshing

course to all the

participants.

1) This training is like a class room teaching. Organize group discussions and maintain more interaction with the participants.

1) After this training, Interaction with the participants was increased.

3 Telangana/ 6

- 1) It will be effective if one or two persons from concerned line department are also trained as STRTs.

2) Field visits of one or two days required during STRT training.

3) Design calculations could have been explained elaborately.

4) Use of black board for sketching and calculations to be preferred.

1) Yes, it will be better if one or two persons from concerned line department are also trained. While preparing action plan for training to DTRT and BTRT the STRT members were advised to include line department persons.

2) Advised to arrange 1 to ½ day field visit for DTRT and BTRT training.

3) Explained with illustrations as and when required.

128

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

4) As and when required, it was made.

4 7th to 11th April, 2015

Madhya Pradesh/ 19

1) ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA) is valuable document to strengthen technical officers implementing MGNREGS.

2) Technical training is very effective due to highly experienced persons being involved as trainers.

3) Overall orientation is very satisfactory.

1) Exposure visit may be included in the training program especially for Watershed and Command Area Development (CAD) works.

2) The technical manual may also be published in Hindi.

3) Self-learning videos on the permitted works.

4) For the Site survey, investigation and preparation of project report, provision of 1% should be made in addition to 6% administrative costs.

5) One day Orientation programme must be organized for DPC and ADPC, to make them aware about different works like watershed, Command area development, etc. and various technical issues.

6) PO must be from the technical background at block level/ Janpad Panchayat level.

7) At block level full time programme officer must be deputed (At present CEO Janpad Panchayat is looking after MGNREGA along with other more than 60-70 programmes.)

8) All maintenance works, there should be provision to issue first

1) Advised to arrange 1 to ½ day field visit for DTRT and BTRT training.

2) Where ever required, it is to be

done by the concerned states. 3) It has already been initiated. 4) It is a policy matter. However, the

suggestion is reasonable. 5) Yes, it is good suggestion.

6) Yes, it is good suggestion & is required.

7) ---------------do-------------- 8) ----------------do-------------

129

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

muster roll after uploading 1st photograph of the site.

9) STRTs technical training programme should be of 1 week instead of 4 days.

10) STRT training programme may be conducted once in a year for sharing of the experiences.

11) GOI may develop software to design various structures.

9) Advised to keep sufficient days for

training of DTRTs & BTRTs 10) Yes it is good suggestion; it

can be short of refresher training of shorter duration.

11) Being taken up.

5 Chhattisgarh/ 17

1) Training was very comprehensive, helpful in our working.

2) ‘SAMARTHYA’ Technical Training Manual (MGNREGA) is very useful.

1) Technical field visits may be arranged during the STRT training.

2) In order to improve proper implementation of MGNREGA as per the “training manual”, the administrative authorities such as DPCs and POs must be given such trainings.

3) The PO should be permanent employee with the Civil engineering degree.

4) Rural Technology Park must be established at SIRD, Nimora, Raipur, for better dissemination of technologies in CG with the help of NIRD.

5) The procedures related to muster roll, MBs, etc. may be simplified considering the huge work load on the field engineers.

6) Trainers of STRT are requested to guide in our DTRT training (at least 1st batch).

1) Advised STRT members to keep provision of 1 to ½ day field visit in the training of DTRTs and BTRTs.

2) Yes, 1-2 day orientation of DPCs and POs will be better.

3) Yes, it will be better if PO (MGNREGA) have Agricultural or Civil Engineering degree.

4) Yes, suggestion is reasonable.

5) It is state to suggest/ take action as

per the existing conditions, rules & MGNREGA.

6) Looking to the availability, state can request National Resource persons as and when required.

130

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

6 14-17th April, 2015

Haryana/ 8 1) Very helpful. 2) Very innovative & useful

for making MGNREGA successful.

1) Visit to successful stories shown in the slides.

2) People should be included from all the departments concerned as MGNREGA includes 60% works incorporating agriculture & allied activities.

3) More emphasis should be given on solid & liquid waste management works as done in Haryana.

4) PO (MGNREGA) at district level should be a technical person.

5) MGNREGA staff including technical & administrative must be separate from the present staff of Panchayat Raj as in the State of Rajasthan to make it successful in Haryana State.

1) Advised, 1 to ½ day field visit in the training of DTRTs and BTRTs.

2) Advised for including one or two persons from concerned line department in the training programme of DTRTs and BTRTs.

3) Yes, it was given from next batch.

4) Yes, it is good suggestion & need of the hour for quality of assets created under MGNREGA.

5) It is State to decide

7 Gujarat/ 7 1) This training is useful for technical persons to increase their knowledge to create durable and needful assets under MGNREGA.

1) PO (MGNREGA) at Block level should be separate for MGNREGA implementation.

2) Assistant PO (MGNREGA) at Block level should be a technical person.

3) A State Level Training for 2 days is required to be organized at SIRD.

4) Training schedule should be extended for one day more.

1) Yes, it is good suggestion & need of the hour.

2) -------------do----------------- 3) It is State to decide.

4) Advised to keep sufficient number

of days in the training programme of DTRTs and BTRTs

131

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

8 Rajasthan/ 25

- 1) For successful convergence, the orientation of line department officials at Block and State level should be organized.

2) For effective implementation, Executive Engineer at district level should be posted as Ex. Eng. Cum ADPC (MGNREGA)

3) At block level Assistant Engineer should be posted as A.Engg. cum PO (MGNREGA)

4) Shelf of projects may be allowed to revise once in a year.

5) For quality control of works there should be testing laboratories at district/ block level.

6) For planning there should be separate wing or outsourced.

7) Labour: material ratio should be maintained at block level.

8) The technical and other staff at GP level should be on regular basis not on contract.

9) Respective Ministries should give direction to their respective departments in the State to incorporate guidelines of convergence in their scheme guidelines.

10) Bush cutting, clearing of drains along the roads should also be permitted under MGNREGA.

11) As per IRC the width of CC &

1) Yes, good suggestion, in the training of DTRT and BTRT it may be taken care of by the states.

2) Yes, it is justified suggestion & need of the hour.

3) -------------do-----------------

4) Informed to STRTs that it is already allowed.

5) Yes, it is justified. Can use existing laboratories of line departments.

6) For quality of assets, planning should be carried out by the person/ agency implementing MGNREGS.

7) Existing system is justified. 8) It is state to decide.

9) The convergence guidelines issued from the Ministry are signed by both the Secretaries of concerned Ministries & sent to the concerned secretaries of the states.

10) It is repetitive work & cannot be allowed under MGNREGA.

11) It was explained to the STRT, that this limit is for village internal

132

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

interlocking block rural roads should be allowed up to 3.75 meter instead 3.0 meter.

12) The time frame of present STRT training schedule is very tight.

13) It is suggested that it is scheduled for 5 days from Monday to Friday to hassle free training & ½ day must be for field visit.

roads & not for roads connecting village to village or village to main roads.

12) Advised to keep sufficient duration of training for DTRTs and BTRTs.

13) Advised that in the training of DTRTs and BTRTs, it may be taken care of.

9 21st to 24th April, 2015

Karnataka/ 12

1) State is thankful for this wonderful book ‘SAMARTHYA’

2) All presentations were to the point and effective.

3) All resource persons were excellent and knowledgeable.

4) Shri. G.N. Sharma, Shri Kondala Rao, Shri Agarwal, Shri Parmar, Shri Biju Abraham and Shri Suresh Babu wonderful in imparting training.

1) All technical staff should be regular and not on out source.

2) State should have technical cell and instructions should come from GOI. (Cell should have 1 chief engineer, 1 super intending engineer and 2 Executive engineer and 5 AEEs )

3) One of the national level resource person should be present for DTRT training for supervision.

4) In maintenance, painting to be included at least once in 3years (For buildings)

1) It is state to decide.

2) It is justified, but it is state to decide.

3) On availability, state can invite the

national resource person.

4) It can be carried out under maintenance work as and when required in public buildings.

133

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

10 Kerala/6 1) ‘SAMARTHYA’ stands as a complete guidance for the successful and efficient executions of Mahatma Gandhi NREGA in our country. ‘SAMARTHYA’ reflects the great effort, knowledge and experience of the master minds behind this project.

2) Got lot of information after the training which was not imagined before the classes.

1) Depending upon our site conditions more photographs and videos may be incorporated.

2) Change contract staff to permanent, depending upon their qualification and experience in MGNREGS.

3) Provide technical Programme Officer (PO) in MGNREGS.

1) In the training of DTRTs and BTRTs state may incorporate in their manual and PPTs.


3) It is justified and need of the hour.

11 Lakshadweep/2

1) Training sessions were informative.

2) Training was not of theory sessions only, but also practice sessions.

3) Site visit with facilitators was helpful (May site visit to RTP).

1) Some of the chapters in training Manual are not applicable in our island local conditions. Hence faculty is requested to visit Lakshadweep, study our local conditions and guide accordingly and also incorporate it in the training manual.

1) Technical team may visit the area.

12 Puducherry/1

1) It is very helpful to know new techniques.

2) Cleared the doubts in executing works.

1) This type of training may be conducted regularly.

1) Good suggestion

134

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

13 Andaman and Nicobar/2

1) We have got much valuable information from this training programme.

2) All the facilitators of STRT training put lot of efforts to train us.

3) Training will help us in proper implementation of MGNREGA.

4) The manual/ other study materials given to us for further training to DTRTs and BTRTs will be very helpful to us.

1) We request the member of resource team to visit Andaman and Nicobar Islands for proper guidance in the field works undertaken under MGNREGA.

2) In MGNREGA, all the staffs including technical staff are on contract basis. At least programme officers and technical staff should be regularized as per their experience.

1) Justified suggestion, technical team should visit the area.


14 28th April to 1st May, 2015

Himachal Pradesh/2

1) Training was very good, useful and knowledge adding.

1) The technical staff working in RDD should be trained.

2) STRT technical training should be for at least 7days.

3) Such type of training should be held yearly, for knowledge refreshment.

4) B.D.O.s/Programme Officers should be trained by this training.

5) An Engineer should be there in every block as APO to get the work done from technical staff as per specifications.

6) Sufficient technical staff should be there in development block i.e. One Junior Engineer in 3 Gram Panchayats and 1 Technical Assistant in each GP.

1) Advised to take care of in the training of DTRTs and BTRTs.

2) Advised to keep sufficient days for training of DTRTs and BTRTs.

3) Yes, it is required.

4) Yes, it is justified.

5) Yes it is justified and need of the hour.


135

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

15 Uttarakhand/ 5

1) The training was very good and Helpful.

1) Field visits on water shed must be part of training.

2) Field visits to MGNREGA work sites.

3) This kind of training to be organized yearly.

4) Power point presentation should be in Hindi also.

5) A.P.O. / D.P.O. should be a technical person.

1) Advised to include in the training of DTRTs and BTRTs.



4) Advised to do it for the training of DTRTs and BTRTs.


16 Jammu and Kashmir/ 7

1) Innovative and informative: with respect to appropriate technologies and their subsequent use.

2) Inclusive: with respect to permission for use of selective/ specific machineries, viz., PRR, Concrete mixer, etc. and convergence.

3) Pragmatic: with respect to various works incorporated that makes MGNREGA more viable and practical.

1) More visuals to be displayed in future training.

2) To avoid or lay minimum emphasis on some chapters / subject which are of academic interest only and not in practice.

1) It was added in the training of next batches. Advised to include in the training of DTRTs and BTRTs.

2) Advised to take care in the training of DTRTs and BTRTs.

136

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

17 Punjab/ 9 1) Innovative presentation about appropriate technologies

1) Presentation requirements for presentation on appropriate technologies may be asked in advance.

2) To explore and train officials from different departments concerned with MGNREGA for better command on various subjects. (i.e. for better implementation of works)

3) Apart from Technical persons other related officials / officers should also be given training.

1) May ask if required, in the training of DTRT and BTRT.

2) Advised to consider it in imparting training to DTRTs & BTRTS.

3) -------------do------------------

18 5th to 8th May, 2015

Odisha/ 12 - 1) Course duration to be increase further by 2 days.

2) Field visit and videos need to be part of training, for better clarity and to understand concept.

3) The line Department officers in charge of execution of items like water shed, rural sanitation and planation, etc. should be included in the STRT training.

4) APOs at Block level and M.C. at district level should be a technical person and should report to technical heads at block level as well as district level respectively.

1) Advised to keep sufficient course duration, in the training of DTRTs and BTRTs.

2) Videos and films were shown in the training programme.

3) Yes, advised to include in the training of DTRTs and BTRTs.

4) Yes, it justified and need of the hour.

19 Maharashtra/ 10

1) Excellent training and training material.

1) One day visit to good works will be useful.

2) Use of video films in the training may be increased.

3) Proper proportion of technical


2) It was increased.

3) It is state to act upon.

137

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

persons at block level from Agriculture, Forest and Engineering background.

4) Pressure on MIS person CDEO is more where numbers of works are more.

5) Proper internet connectivity at GP level for generation of e-Muster.

6) APO should be a technical person to produce good quality work.

4) It is state to act upon.

5) Yes, it is required, state to take action.

6) Yes, it is need of the hour.

20 12th to 15th May, 2015

Uttar Pradesh/ 17

- 1) From each district one technical officer should be included in STRT. So that they can coordinate technical training for DTRT and BTRT in their own districts.

2) STRT technical training should be more frequent and necessary fund should be made available in advance

3) P.O. should be a technical person. 4) Technical cell should be

established at state and district level.


2) Yes, it is required.

3) Yes, it is need of the hour. 4) Yes, it is need of the hour.

21 26th -29th May, 2015

West Bengal / 8

- 1) All the MGNREGA staff should be permanent, so that they will work whole heartedly.


138

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

22 Tripura / 4 1) We hope learning from this training will enrich our activities in the implementation of MGNREGA works more than before.

1) Since MGNREGA works are also implemented by other line departments such as Agriculture, Horticulture, Forest, etc. therefore training may be imparted to officers/ engineers of those departments also.

2) Training may be imparted to Administrative officers concerned.

3) 4 days training is not sufficient, training period may be increased in days.

4) Such training may be arranged in the state, so that more functionaries related with MGNREGA works, can participate.

5) For implementation of innovative projects discussed during the training, skilled masons are not available in states. Therefore NIRD authority may kindly arrange training for the local masons so that such projects can be implemented.

1) Yes, advised to include in DTRT and BTRT.

2) Yes it is justified.

3) Advised to take care in the training of DTRT and BTRT.

4) Advised to take care in the training of DTRT and BTRT.

5) Masons were trained at NIRD,

Hyderabad on Appropriate technologies. However, for the states could not participate in this training, one more training of masons can be arranged at NIRD.

23 Assam / 9 1) We learnt many new ideas about watershed development, plantation, appropriate technologies, convergence of schemes, rural sanitation, etc.

2) It is important that, we

1) State Institution Rural Development (SIRD), may play vital role in conducting the training programmes.

2) Program Officer (PO) should be a technical person, in block level, who may implement various schemes properly.

3) In our state Assam, The power of


2) Yes it is justified and need of the hour.


139

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

should adopt appropriate technologies for construction of rural buildings permitted under MGNREGA.

Technical sanction by EE, should be increased from 5 Lakhs to 20 Lakhs.

24 2nd June to 5th June, 2015

Jharkhand / 3

1) All the resource persons were well experienced and senior in his/ her field. We gained knowledge and learned about new ideas and concepts.

2) This was great opportunity avail to us.

1) The duration of training is very short, it needs to be increased.

1) Advised to keep sufficient duration in the training of DTRTs and BTRTs.

25 Arunachal Pradesh / 6

1) Training imparted to State Technical Resource Teams (STRTs) by the resource persons from MoRD, New Delhi and others was excellent.

2) We acknowledge our gratitude to all the eminent resource persons from different states of India, who shared their knowledge to produce durable assets under MGNREGA and strengthen livelihood support to BPL.

1) MoRD, GOI, New Delhi needs to liaison with State Governments to extend support morally and financially, also extend full cooperation to STRT for carrying out the training activities at state level, District level and block level

2) Sufficient training materials may be provided to STRTs along with cooperation and guidance from central resource persons/ Team.

3) To Successful implementation of MGNREGA works and ensure its quality, it is strongly felt that the project director of DRDA of Arunachal Pradesh be appointed from engineering background.

1) It is being done. 2) Sufficient training materials were

provided. As and when required state may invite resource person for the purpose.

3) Yes it is justified and need of the hour for quality of works.

140

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

4) Preferably assistant project officer (Tech) be given the charge of Project Director. But so far it has been observed that the Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh deputes POs from Admin (Non-technical) background; As a result performance of MGNREGA is very poor.

4) ----------do------------------

26 Sikkim / 3

1) It was a good experience. Lectures were useful

1) Site visits should have been part training.

1) Advised to include in the training programme of DTRTs and BTRTs.

27 Manipur / 4 1) Obtained good knowledge on appropriate technologies.

2) Learn ways to implement in convergence.

3) Training was well defined.

1) Duration of training may be extended.

2) Training material may be forwarded before the training.


2) Advised to forward training material to the concerned before training of DTRTs and BTRTs

28 Meghalaya / 4

1) It was a good experience 1) Practical training should be imparted in the field.

1) Advised to impart required practical training in the training of DTRTs and BTRTs.

29 8th Sept to 11th Sept, 2015

Bihar /11 1) Present STRT training is excellent.

2) The book ‘SAMARTHYA’ as well as ready reckoners in the book are very useful.

3) The presentation in PPT and A.V. are clear and useful.

4)

1) Duration of the training should be more.

2) Field visits to live projects will be useful.

3) Participants should be inform in advance for better preparation.


2)Advised to include in the training programme of DTRTs and BTRTs.

3) Yes

141

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

30 Mizoram /4 1) Informative, well planned which will influence in creation of durable assets.

2) Appropriate technologies which was highlighted not very appropriate for North- Eastern states.

3) Time management (as per schedule)

4) A training has opened to us to a new dimension, in the field of construction of durable assets under MGNREGA, which will go long way, in the better implementation of works under MGNREGA, thereby, achieving the goal for which the scheme was/ is intended.

1) Generalization in creation of durable assets could have been avoided. It could have been region specific.

1) In DTRT & BTRT training this aspect may be taken care of.

31 Nagaland / 5 1) Imparting STRT training to the technical personnel is a new concept for us and is essential for capacity building for implementation of various works under the MGNREGA programme. Through which the goal of MGNREGA can be achieved. We

1) It is suggested that such types of training be continued in the future for strengthening the technical of the department. 2) Apart from STRT training, imparting training to the technical personnel in the District and Block level is essential for capacity building to create of durable assets and successful implementation of scheme.

1) Yes, it is required. 2)Yes, STRT has to train DTRTs & BTRTS in their States.

142

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

acknowledge and grateful to all the resource persons.

143

ANNEXURE - VII: FORMAT FOR ACTION PLAN, TO CONDUCT TRAINING OF DTRTS

AND BTRTS DOWN THE LINE IN CONCERNED STATES

1. State :

2. No. of districts :

3. No. of Blocks :

4. No. of GPs :

5. Rolling out the trainings to District Resource Teams and Block Resource Teams

a. Proposed date for state level strategy meeting for rolling out DRT and BRT

b. Date by which State Manual will be prepared

c. Nodal officer to carry it forward:

i) _____________ ii) _____________

d. No. of technical persons to be trained as DRTs at each district

e. No of technical persons to be trained as BRTs at each block

f. Proposed dates to train DRTs

g. Proposed dates to train BRTs

7. Feedback/ opinion about the present SRTs technical training

8. Suggestions to improve the SRTs technical training

9. Particulars of State technical Officials who prepared the Action Plan

Name Designation Signature

Technical Official-1

Technical Official-2

Technical Offcial-3

Date:

Place:

144

ANNEXURE - VIII: ACTION PLAN FOR THE CONDUCT OF DTRT AND BTRT TRAINING PROGRAMMES

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

SN

Name of the State

Nodal Officers

Date for state level strategy

meeting for rolling out

DTRT & BTRT

Date by which State

manual will be

prepared

DTRTs BTRTs

Number of technical

persons to be trained

Date of Training

Number of technical

persons to be trained

Date of Training

1 Andhra Pradesh

1) Shri. A. Kalyan Chakravarthy, JC (EGS)/ SPM (T) 7095554499, [email protected]

6/4/2015 31 May, 2015

10 Nos X 13 (Districts) = 130 Nos

01/06/2015 - 06/06/2015

4 Nos X 661 (Blocks)= 2644 Nos

15/06/2015 - 30/06/2015

2 Tamil Nadu 1) Ms. M. Kavitha, Executive Engineer (R.D.), 9444292527, 8012588640, [email protected]

1/4/2015 2nd week, May, 2015.

10 to12 Nos X 31 (Districts) = 310 to 372 Nos

2nd week of May to 2nd week of June, 2015; (4-5 batches)

10 to 12 Nos X 385 (Blocks) = 3850 Nos to 4620 Nos

Month of June, 2015

3 Telangana 1) Shri. B. Saidulu, (J. Comm-EGS and IT) 09010510110, [email protected]

6/4/2015 6/6/2015 10 Nos X9 (Districts) = 90Nos

13/07/2015 to 17/07/2015*

4 Nos X 443 (Blocks) = 1772Nos

20/07/2015 to 10/09/2015*

4 Chhattisgarh 1) Shri. Narayan Nimje, Superintending Engineer, MGNREGA State Cell, 9893192435, [email protected]

25/4/2015 15/5/2015 20 Nos X 27 (Districts) = 540 Nos

20/ 05/2015 to 23/05/2015 (Start date)

16 Nos X 146 (Blocks) = 2336 Nos

26/05/2015 to 29/05/2015 (Start date)





145

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

5 Madhya Pradesh

1) Shri. A. K. Choudhary, Chief Engineer, MPSEGC, Bhopal, (0755) 2559314, 9425648824, [email protected]

2) Shri M. K. Jain, Superintending Engineer, MPSEGC, Bhopal. 9425393378, [email protected]

17/4/2015 5/5/2015 20 Nos X 51 (Districts)= 1020 Nos

11/05/2015 to 14/05/2015 & 18/05/2015 to 21/05/2015

25 Nos X 313 (Blocks) = 7825 Nos

25/05/2015 to 28/05/2015, 01/06/2015 to 04/06/2015, 08/06/2015 to 11/06/2015.

6 Gujarat 1) Shri. G.V. Shrotriya, I/c DEE, CRD, Gandhinagar 09426363135, [email protected]

2) Shri. A.A. Mansuri, WM, DRDA, MGNREGA, Patan 08128676822, 09925638934, [email protected]

30/5/2015 30/6/2015 4 Nos x 33 (Districts ) = 132Nos

05/072015 (Start date)

4 Nos x 244 (Blocks) = 976 Nos

25/07/2015 (Start date)





146

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

7 Haryana 1) Shri Ramphal Kundu, Project officer MGNREGA, (0172)2703007/ 2703136, 9417869505, [email protected]

2) Shri Balwan Singh, superintending Engineer, Panchayati Raj, Ambala. 9729596512, [email protected]

7/5/2015 30/05/2015 6 Nos X 21 (Districts) = 126Nos

01/07/2015 to 30/07/2015

5 Nos X 126 (Blocks) = 630Nos

01/08/2015 to 15/09/ 2015

8 Rajasthan 1) Shri Arvind Saxena, Executive Engineer (Hq.), 9414238443, [email protected]

2) Shri N.K. Joshi, Executive Engineer (Hq.), 09414311492, [email protected] , [email protected]

23/4/2015 15/06/2015 4 Nos X 33 (Districts) = 132Nos

10/07/2015 (Start date)

8 to 12Nos X 295 (Blocks) = 2360 to 3540 Nos

20/07/2015 to 30/07/2015







147

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

9 Andaman and Nicobar

1) Shri N.K. Sharma, Secretary RD/ PRI, 09434287790, [email protected]

2) Smti. Reshma, Assistant Engineer, MGNREGA, 09474247248, [email protected] ,

15/5/2015 5/8/2015 9 Nos (i.e. 4 Nos from MGNREGA + 5 Nos from line Deptt) X 3 Districts = 27 Nos

18/08/2015 to 21/08/2015

13 Nos (i.e. 8 Nos from MGNREGA + 5 Nos from line Deptt) X 9 Blocks = 117 Nos.

07/09/2015 to 11/09/2015

10 Karnataka 1) Shri P.C. Rao, IFS Spl. Comm, 9480877777, [email protected] , [email protected]

2) Shri Chandrashekhar M. Masaguppi, 09480850066, [email protected]

4/5/2015 25/07/2015 4 Nos (i.e. 3 Nos from MGNREGA + 1 Nos from Line Department) X 30 District= 120 Members

Start: 28/07/2015 or 29/07/2015. Completion: 4/08/2015 or 5/08/2015

1936 Nos (i.e. 11 Nos X176 Blocks) + 1936 (i.e.11 Nos from Line Deptt X 176 Blocks) = 3872Nos

06/08/2015 to 31/08/2015

11 Kerala 1) Shri P.G. Vijay Kumar, JDC, MGNREGA, Kerala, 9447746163, [email protected]

2) Shri Pramod C., AE (Nemom block, Trivandrum), 09567267990, [email protected]

6/5/2015 (2 DTRT persons will participate in the meeting)

15/05/2015,

9 Nos (i.e. 5 from MGNREGA + 4 from Line Deptt) X 14 (Districts) =126 Nos

20/05/2015 to 5/06/2015

9Nos (i.e. 5 from MGNREGA+ 4 from Line deptt) X 152 (Blocks) = 1368 persons

01/06/ 2015 to 15/06/2015

mailto:09434287790,%[email protected]








mailto:[email protected],%2009480850066

mailto:%209447746163,%[email protected]



mailto:09567267990,%20%[email protected]

mailto:09567267990,%20%[email protected]

148

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

12 Lakshadweep

1) Ashwani Kumar Mehta, Director (RD), Kavaratti, U.T. of Lakshadweep, (04896) 262208, 09953322786, [email protected]

2) Shri Faizal F. M., Junior Engineer, 9447983088, [email protected]

16/9/2015* 17/9/2015* 6 Nos (i.e. 1 from MGNREGA + 5 from Line Deptt) X 1(District) = 6Nos

25/09/2015 – 28/09/2015 *

18Nos (i.e. 9 from MGNREGA + 9 from Line Deptt) X 10(Blocks) = 180 Nos

07/10/2015 to10/10/2015

13 Puducherry 1) Shri P Parthiban, I.A.S., The Project Director, D.R.D.A., Puducherry, 09487879168, [email protected],

2) Thiru K.J. Venkatachalapathy, Work Inspector, 07639697430, [email protected]

14/5/2015 28/5/2015 6 Nos (2 from MGNREGA + 4 from line Department) X 2 (Districts) = 12 Nos.

02/06/2015 to 05/06/2015

10 Nos (6 from MGNREGA + 4 from Line Department) X 3(Blocks) = 30Nos

09/06/2015 to 12/06/2015

mailto:(04896)%20262208,%2009953322786,[email protected]




mailto:09487879168,%[email protected],

mailto:09487879168,%[email protected],


149

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

14 Himachal Pradesh

1) Er. Ajay Gupta, E.E. (R.D.D.), Headquarter, Shimla, H.P. 9418061404, [email protected]

2) Er. Sukh Dev Attri, A.E. (D.R.D.A.), Bilaspur, H.P., 9805274677, [email protected]

3) Er. K.C. Mastana, A.E. (D.R.D.A), Hamirpur, H.P., 9418107965, [email protected]

4) Er. O.S. Nirala, A.E. D.R.D.A., Chamba, H.P., 09418201710 [email protected]

27/6/2015 31/7/2015 12 Nos X 12 (Districts) =144Nos (4 batches)

1/08/2015 to 30/09/2015

5 Nos X 77 (Blocks) = 385 Nos (9 batches)

10/08/2015 to 10/09/2015

15 Jammu and Kashmir

Mr. Parvez Malik, E.E. (REW), Jammu, 09419135877, [email protected] , [email protected]

18/5/ 2015 06/7/2015 805 Nos (695 Nos from RDD + 110 Nos from Line Deptt), 25 batches.

18/07/2015 to 31/08/2015

2507 Nos, 60 Batches

05/08/2015 to 05/12/2015







150

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

16 Punjab 1) Mr. G.S. Ghumman, JDC, MGNREGA, Punjab, (0172) 2231056 ,9781200003, [email protected]

2) Er. Prakash Singh, S.E., Panchayati Raj, Punjab, 8557000073, [email protected]

10/5/2015 10/8/2015 12 Nos (1 Ex.En. from Panchayati Raj + 11 Line Deptt of each District) X 22 (Districts) =264 Nos.

11/08/2015 to 9/10/2015

15 Nos (1 B.D.P.O. + 1 Technical Asst + 1 A.P.O + 12 from Line Deptt) X 146 (Blocks) = 2190Nos.

12/10/2015 to 12/12/2015

17 Uttarakhand 1) Mrs. Jyoti Khairwal (I.A.S.), Add. Sec., RD, 7536888888, [email protected]

2) Mr. Pradeep Pandey, D.D.O., Tehri, 9412093900, [email protected]

3) Mr. Rajendra Singh Bishil, A.E. D.R.D.A.,Dehradun, 9411381751, [email protected]

27/5/2015 30/7/2015 25 Nos (i.e.11 from MGNREGA + 14 from Line Deptt.) X 13 (Districts) = 325Nos, 6 batches.

20/08/2015 to 30/09/2015

25 (i.e. 11 from MGNREGA + 14 from Line Deptt.) X 95 (Blocks) = 2375Nos, 95 batches.

15/09/2015 to 31/10/2015

mailto:(0172)%202231056%20,9781200003,%[email protected]








151

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

18 Maharashtra 1) Shri M. Sankarnarayan, Commissioner, 9422916770, [email protected],

2) Shri Sharadkumar Bhagat, Jt Commissioner, 9923499978, [email protected]

3) Dr. Uday Patil, Dy Commissioner, 9404951032, [email protected]

15/5/2015 31/6/2015 8 Nos (including line Deptt) X 34 (Districts) = 272 Nos, 7 Batches

1/07/2015 to 31/08/2015

8 Nos X 351 (Blocks )= 2808 Nos, 60 Batches.

15/09/2015 to 30/09/2015

19 Odisha 1) Shri Bhumesh Chandra Behera, Joint Secretary MGNREGS, P.R. Deptt, Odisha, 9437154304, [email protected]

2) Er. F.U. Khan, Executive Engineer, DRDA, Dhenkanal, 9437209099, [email protected]

12/5/2015 15/8/2015 10 Nos (including Line Deptt) X 30 (Districts) = 300 Nos, (Average 30 persons in each batch)

20/08/2015 T0 15/ 10/ 2015

10 Nos (including Line Deptt) X 314 (Blocks) = 3140 Nos, (Average 30 Nos. in each batch)

30/08/2015 TO 30/11/2015











152

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

20 Uttar Pradesh

1) Shri Ranvir Prasad, Additional Commissioner, MGNREGA, Luknow, Uttar Pradesh, 09454465222, (0522) 6713418, [email protected]

4th Week of May, 2015

Same manual prepared by Ministry will be used

10 Nos X 75 districts = 750 Nos

01/07/2015 to 15/10/2015

10 Nos X 840 Blocks = 8400 Nos

16/07/2015 to 15/09/2015

21 West Bengal 1) Dibyendu Sarkar, Commissioner MGNREGA, W.B., 08697748383, [email protected]

2)Kuntal Biswas, Assist Engineer, Purulia, W.B., 09732159629, [email protected]

8/6/2015 For DTRT SAMARTHYA manual by MoRD will be used. For BTRT manual will be prepared by 15/7/2015

8 NosX20 Districts=160 Nos at 40 per batch, 4days training for 4 batches

15/06/2015 to 07/07/2015

3349 (GPS) + 4 X 341 Blocks + 2 X 341 Line Dept= 4713 at 40 per batch, 120 batches of 3days' training

18/08/2015 to 30/09/2015

mailto:09454465222,%20(0522)%206713418,%[email protected]%20m






153

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

22 Tripura 1) Mihir Kanti Gope, S.E.R.D., 9436122818, 2) Er. Manoj Majumder Asstt. Engineer, 0381-2807244 (O/F), 9436122227 (M), [email protected] ,

3) Er. Subhayan Debnath, Junior Engineer (Gr. II), 03821223520 (O), 9436121182 (M), [email protected] ,

4) Er. Saradindu Sarkar, Junior Engineer (Gr. II), 03826265344 (O), 9436558677 (M) [email protected]

19/6/2015 15/07/2015 7 (i.e. 2 from R.D.+5 from L.D)X 8 Districts =56

20/07/2015 to 30/07/2015

10 (i.e. 6 from R.D.+4 from L.D)X 58 Blocks =580 Nos, 15 batches, 2days' training

01/07/2015 to 31/08/2015

23 Assam 1) Dr. Krishna Kumar Dwivedi, CPRD, Assam,0361- 2333645, [email protected]

2) Shri Balendra Kalita, APO (T), I/c Executive Engineer, 9435018594 (M), 03713-222192 (O), [email protected]

8/6/2015 15/07/2015 10 (i.e. 5 from MGNREGA+5 from line Dept)X27=270 Nos, 30 per batch, 9 batches

01/08/2015 to 31/08/2015

8 (i.e. 6 from MGNREGA+2 from line Dept) X 219 =1752 Nos, 30 batches, 58 batches

18/09/2015 to 30/09/2015





mailto:0361-%202333645,%[email protected]




154

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

24 Arunachal Pradesh

1) Shri Nani Chatung, APO (Tech), 9436052190 (M), [email protected]

2) Er. Kipa Gagung, APO (Tech), 9436041967 (M), [email protected]

10/6/2015 Manual prepared by MoRD, shall be used for the training of DTRT and BTRT.

15 Nos X 17 Districts = 225 Nos, 8 batches with 3 days training.

15/06/2015 to 15/07/2015

11 Nos X 106 Blocks =1166 Nos, 38 batches with 3 days training

15/07/2015 to 15/09/ 2015

25 Sikkim 1) Dr. Sandeep Tambe, Commissioner MGNREGA, 9474059791, [email protected]

2) Shri Prasoon Pradhan, Asstt. Engineer, 8016879293, [email protected]

17/6/2015 Manual prepared by MoRD, shall be used for the training of DTRT and BTRT.

12 (i.e. 8 from MGNREGA + 4 from line dept.) X 4 Districts = 48 Nos, 2 batches

25/06/2015 to 05/07/2015

7 (i.e. 5 from MGNREGA + 2 from line dept.) X 31 Blocks = 217 Nos, 8 batches

09/07/2015 to 21/07/2015

26 Manipur 1) Shri P. K. Jha, Joint Secretary (RD and PR) Government of Manipur, 0385-2443776

2) Shri L. Ramesh Singh, SLM, 0385-2445820(O/F), 9436027946(M), [email protected]

19/6/2015 25/07/2015 54 Nos (6 from each district), 2 batches.

27/07/2015 to 2/08/2015

252 Nos (6 from each block), 9 batches.

3/08/2015 to 20/08/2015








155

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

27 Meghalaya 1) Shri George B. Lyngdoh, Jt Mission Director, 9612170942, [email protected]

2) Shri R. Lytan , Executive Engineer, 9856084368, [email protected]

22/6/2015 15/07/2015 8 (i.e.4 from MGNREGA + 4 from Line Dept) X 11 Districts = 88 Nos, 3 Batches, 3days training

17/08/2015 to 31/08/ 2015

8 (i.e.4 from MGNREGA+ 4 from Line Dept) X 39 Blocks = 312 Nos, 11 Batches, 3days training

1/08/2015 to 30/08/2015

28 Jharkhand 1) Shri Vijay Kumar Singh, Commissioner MGNREGA, 9431184280

2) Shri Santosh Kumar Singh, Asstt. Engineer, 9334625799, [email protected]

18/6/2015 22/7/2015 10 Nos X 24 Districts = 240 Nos, 8 Batches, 4 days training.

22/07/2015 to 18/08/2015

10 Nos X 260 Blocks = 2600 Nos, 88 Batches, 4 days training.

21/08/2015 to 30/09/2015

29 Bihar 1) Shri Chet Narayan Roy,

O.S.D., R.D.D., Government

of Bihar, Cell: 9471006336

2) Shri Rudra Kumar, E.E.,

D.R.D.A., Rohtas,

Cell: 9304830751,

[email protected]

m

Before 5/12/2015

5/01/2016 45 Nos X 38

Districts =

1710 Nos

Patna: 15/1/201-20/1/2016, Muzaffarpur: 23/1/2016-30/1/2016, South Bihar: 1/2/2016- 10/2/2016, North Bihar: 11/2/2016- 20/2/2016

20 Nos X 534

Blocks =

10680 Nos

South Bihar:

21/2/2016-

29/2/2016,

North Bihar:

1/3/2016-

12/3/2016










156

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

30 Nagaland 1) Shri. Neihesa Nakro, Dy.

Sec. RD, 9615087917,

[email protected]

2) Shri. Ghoshito Sumi, E.E.,

DRDA, Phek, 9436066012

20/10/ 2015 31/10/2015 3 Nos X 11

Districts = 33

Nos (1 batch

and 3 days

training)

3/11/2015 –

5/11/2015

3 Nos X 74 Blocks = 222 Nos (5 batches and 3 days training)

1st Batch:

10/11/2015-

12/11/2015

2nd Batch:

17/11/2015-

19/11/2015

3rd Batch:

24/11/2015-

26/11/2015

4th Batch:

3/12/2015-

5/12/2015

5th Batch:

8/12/2015 –

10/12/2015

31 Mizoram 1) Paul L. Khuma, Under

Secretary, R.D., Cell:

09862397653,

[email protected]

2) H. Saizama, Asst.

Engineer, Aizawl, DRDA,

Cell: 8974843059,

[email protected]

16/09/2015 15/10/2015 (In English)

3 Nos X 8 Districts = 24 Nos (1 Batch)

13/11/2015 –

16/11/2015,

at State

Capital

5 Nos X 26 Blocks = 130 Nos

27/11/2015 –

31/11/2015

(BTRTs will be

trained by

DTRTs)

(*As per revised action plan)




report on 'samarthya' technical training programme for state

Documents