relationships with cmo’s - pqripqri.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/hameister.pdf · relationships...
TRANSCRIPT
Relationships with CMO’s Setting the stage for successful production phase relationships Richard L. Hameister, Genentech, Inc.
Outline
• Understand the relationship you want with your CMO
• Aligning expectations
• Establishing the infrastructure for performance assessment
• Measuring success
• Getting through difficulties together
• Conclusion
2
Is this a Tactical or Strategic Relationship Short term work or long term commitment?
3
Category Tactical Relationship Strategic Relationship
BUSINESS
COMMITMENT
• Generally one product
• Short term
• Minimum commitment
• Multiple products
• Long term
• High level of commitment, including yearly an/or multi year
minimums
SUPPLY CHAIN &
CAPACITY
PLANNING
• 3-12 month firm forecast
• Limited guarantee to capacity beyond firm
forecast
• 1-3 years firm forecast • Ability to substitute products to meet business commitment
• Guaranteed access to capacity above forecast and
represented within internal LRP capacity planning
TECH
TRANSFER/
CAPITAL
EXPENDITURE
• Contract giver bears 100% of tech transfer
costs
• Potential shared tech transfer costs
• Capital investments shared or covered by CMO
Cost
• Focus on negotiating per unit cost
• Lack of measurable Total Cost of Ownership
(TCO)
• TCO measurements utilized to achieve superior financial performance
QUALITY &
REGULATORY
• No quality management on site
• Lesser degree of access/direct involvement
during issue resolution.
• Dedicated Contract Giver quality management resource at
the CMO (Person in Plant (PIP))
• High degree of access to documentation and rapid issue
resolution
OPERATIONAL
PERFORMANCE
• May or may not have aligned metrics, goals,
and decision-making principles
• Aligned goals, metrics, and decision-making principles with
incentives and penalties
Outline
• Understand the relationship you want with your CMO
• Aligning expectations
• Establishing the infrastructure for performance assessment
• Measuring success
• Getting through difficulties together
• Conclusion
4
Aligning Expectations The Supply and Quality Agreements
5
• Supply/Manufacturing Agreement (the contract) A good Supply/Mfg Agreement creates a more productive quality relationship. – Audits – How Many and Who Pays – Person In Plant Allowances/Costs – Material Purchasing Controls – Testing Costs – Routine and Investigative – Key Personnel Requirements – Relationship Governance – Mfg/Release Lead Times
• Possible incentives for reductions – Procedures for Resolving Product Acceptability Conflict
• Latent defect/Complaint investigations – Annual Product Quality Reviews – Costs and Timing Expectations
Aligning Expectations The Supply and Quality Agreements
6
• Quality Agreement Discussion, clarification, and debate is critical to Quality Agreement success. – Health Authority Guidance and Expectations – Quality Responsibilities Matrix
• Deviation Review and Approval • Change Control Notification and Approval • Audits – types, numbers, durations • Release Activities and Sequence
– Quality Systems – Standards and Differences • Validation and Qualification • Utilities and Environmental Controls • Equipment Cleaning and Bioburden Controls
Outline
• Understand the relationship you want with your CMO
• Aligning expectations
• Establishing the infrastructure for performance assessment
• Measuring success
• Getting through difficulties together
• Conclusion
7
Outsourcing Decision
Contract Signed Registration Approved Reliable Supply to Patients Decommissioning Complete
Implement Manage Decommission Select
Governance Structure Installed Right Oversight Applied
Integrated Risk Management
Joint Governance
Category Strategy
Integrates Quality, Operations and Business Management
CMO Lifecycle – Relationship Governance Know how you will work together towards success.
8
Outline
• Understand the relationship you want with your CMO
• Aligning expectations
• Establishing the infrastructure for performance assessment
• Measuring success
• Getting through difficulties together
• Conclusion
9
What Performance Areas to Measure CMO Site Level Metrics – Examples
Supplier Delivery Performance (SDP) Deviations (Mo. & YTD)
Deviations Closed
Batches Dispositioned Deviation Root Cause Batches Rejected Deviation Rate Reject Rate (%) Avg. Release Time from End of Mfg Investigations (Mo. & YTD)
Investigations Closed Product Defect Rates (DP and FP) Investigation Root Cause (Trend)
Investigation Rate Field Issues and Recalls Investigation Free Lots (%)
Complaint Responses Risk Score Complaints Opened and Closed Compliance Risk Score Reduction Complaint Investigation Avg. Lead Time Risk Reduction %
10
Performance Scorecards for Communication Supplier Delivery Performance Example
11
Outline
• Understand the relationship you want with your CMO
• Aligning expectations
• Establishing the infrastructure for performance assessment
• Measuring success
• Getting through difficulties together
• Conclusion
12
• Support without Overtaking - Stay Calm and Respectful – You both want a successful outcome. - Focus on getting to solutions regarding compliance and product quality. - Bring the technical support but value the technical collaboration - Work collaboratively through misalignments in responsibilities or expectations.
• Empower the CMO to be Successful - Process knowledge and information sufficient to “own” the process. - Respect their need to represent their site, their quality systems, your process during inspections
• Collaborate on the CAPA’s - Find the right fit to ensure performance and for CMO internal consistency. - Avoid over-committing the CMO; be cautious with unique requirements.
• Celebrate Your Successes with Your CMO! - A job well done deserves recognition. - Approvals, positive trial outcomes, inspections, milestones.
Managing Through Difficulty Final Thoughts on Maintaining a Good Relationship
13
High-performing CMO relationship
• Successful tactical working relationship
• Excellent CMO performance and alignment of mindset and culture
Ability to commit • Internal willingness and ability to
make a multi-product, multi-year commitment
Mutual desire to grow relationship
• Willingness and ability from both organizations to implement novel arrangements that create mutual value
Reliable, Quality
Product Supply
In Conclusion… Mutually beneficial relationships enable reliable supply
14
Doing now what patients need next