regional enterprise architecture (ea) modeling for systemic development of city's ict

Regional enterprise architecture (EA) modeling for systemic development

of citys ICT(рус Моделирование комплексов городского хозяйства

для системного развития средств ИКТ города)

Kostyrko Artem1 Kudryavtsev Dmitry 23 Grigoriev Lev2 Kislova Valentina2 Zhulin Andrey1 Sinyatullina Leila1 Ermakov Roman4

1 NRU HSE 2 Business Engineering Group 3 NRU SPbSPU 4 КТЕ Labs

NRU HSE Business Engineering Group NRU SPbSPU КТЕ Labs

Agenda

1 The role of regional EA modeling for systemic ICT development

2 Regional EA modeling methodology

3 Decision support reference system for systemic (consistent) ICT development

4 Related work

5 Conclusions


Information city 2011-2016 Program

Development of advertising and

mass media

Program Implementation Management

Building public ICT environment

Creation of the Intelligent City Management System

ICT Development aimed at improving city

inhabitants quality of life and

facilitating business conduct

Quality of life High-level infrastructure

Efficient government


Moscow city strategic goals



Carrying out integrated analysis and assessment of applicability and relevancy of the existing Moscow city information systems and resources

1

Integrated simulation of the processes of implementation of functions of Moscow city authorities and institutions and description of their targeted state

2

Development of the risk management system including development of the package of risk prevention measures

3

KEY FIGURE

DEVELOPMENT OF THE SYSTEMIC PROJECT OF THE PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION

4

bull The share of Moscow city information systems and resources meeting the system project

requirements 100 by 2016

1

Developing requirements to the solution architecture within the framework of the systemic project of the Program implementation

Developing of training methodology and vocational training of state civil officials and employees of Moscow city institutions creating and providing methodological component of the technology training center activity

2

3

Development and execution of public control and technical supervision procedures


Models within systemic project

Process and performance model

Information modelOrganizational structure model

Information system model

Public function

Business area Line of business

City process

Outcome Output

Indicators

Government authorities

Lower organizations

Positions

Information entity

Attributes Domains

Business entity

Information resources (register repository databasehellip)

Information system (IS)

IS functions IS passports

Interfaces

Info

rmat

izat

ion

acti

viti

es

(pro

gram

ldquoIn

form

atio

n ci

tyrdquo)


Systemic project ontology


Онтология для моделирования комплексов городского хозяйства (фрагмент иерархии классов)

7


Онтология для моделирования комплексов городского хозяйства (свойства классов)

8


Decision support Reference system

Portal

Project and performance

management systemIS audit IS

Modeler

Projects and KPIs which are related to government authorities and IS IS passports

Comments and moderation

Semi-automatic amendment

System architecture


Modeler

Ontology-based enterprise model

editorOntology-based

enterprise model

Reporting and query module

Documents

Diagrams (visual svg)

Modeling process wizard

Integration wizard

Diagram editor

Query results

Semi-structured

data

OWL

XML


Structure of the model

Classifier Matrix


Classifier example City processes


Classifier example Information resources


Matrix example Organizational structure - City processes

Matrix examplesbull What processes are controlled by authority (Organizational structure -

City processes)

bull What information resources are used by the process (City processes ndashInformation resources)

bull What information resources are used by the authority(Organizational structure ndash Information resources)


Matrix example Outcomes (Values) ndash City processes


Metamodeling language - ORLAN (ORganizational LANguage)

This language allows to structure represent and query enterprise model

ORLAN = ltTYPES CL MX InferPR D TASKS SPEC gt where

TYPES ndash types descriptions which specify the CLASSES RELATIONSHIPS AND PROPERTIES of enterprise ontology together with their taxonomies

CL ndash classifier the representation format for entities hierarhical relationships between them and values for the properties of entities (including ontological types) Hierarchy is the main feature of classifies and the main relationship types are ldquopart-of rdquo ldquoclass-subclassrdquo ldquobe subordinated tordquo etc

MX ndash matrix (or table) the representation format for relationships between entities from classifiers Example relationship types are ldquoperformrdquo ldquohelp achieverdquo etc

InferMX ndash inference matrix allows to infer implicit knowledge via transitive property of relationships in several matrixes

D ndash modeling domains (activities norms information resources etc)

TASKS ndash enterprise engineering method specification

SPEC ndash views specifications


Classes (metamodel)


Outputs from the model analytical reports

This data is not recorded by any government authority yet

This data is already recorded by another government authority

8


Data is recorded in several information resources

(repositories) by different authorities

9

Outputs from the model diagrams


Portal ndash the tool for final users

Main users bull managers of department of information technologies of Moscow citybull government authorities managers responsible for informatizationFuture Public


Portal examples line of business key activities


Portal examples Public function passport


Portal examples Public function context diagram


Portal examples Faceted search


Related work

Enterprise architecture research and practice

Traditional methodologiesbull NGOSS (англ New Generation Operations Support

System) from TMForumbull FEA mdash Federal enterprise architecture bull Business Systems Planning (BSP)mdash Information

Systems Planning Guide IBM Corporation

Semantic methods and toolsAllemang D Polikoff I Hodgson R Enterprise Architecture Reference

Modeling in OWLRDF International Semantic Web Conference 2005 mdash P 844ndash857


Conclusions

bull Regional enterprise architecture (EA) modeling supports systemic development of citys ICT (explicit link between outcomes city processes and information systems)

bull Currently we are creating regional enterprise architecture models and collecting feedback

bull Work in progress


Publications

1 Моделирование комплексов городского хозяйства для системного развития ИКТ города Костырко А Кудрявцев Д Григорьев Л Кислова В Жулин А Синятуллина Л Ермаков Р Сборник трудов конференции laquoИнженерия знаний и технологии семантического веба -2012raquo 1-9 октября 2012 г Санкт-Петербург Россия СПб СПбГУ ИТМО 2012 ndash С 81-88

2 Административное моделирование на основе онтологий Кудрявцев Д В Григорьев Л Ю Кислова В В Жулин А Б Вопросы государственного и муниципального управления ndash 2009 1 ndash с 157-169

3 Технология наполнения баз знаний онтологического типа Григорьев Л Ю Заблоцкий А А Кудрявцев Д В Журнал laquoНаучно-технические ведомости СПбГПУ Серия laquoИнформатика Телекоммуникации Управлениеraquo 3 2012 ndash С 27ndash36

4 Организационное проектирование на основе онтологий методология и система ОРГ-Мастер Григорьев Л Ю Кудрявцев Д В Журнал laquoНаучно-технические ведомости СПбГПУ Серия laquoИнформатика Телекоммуникации Управлениеraquo 1 2012 ndash С 21ndash28

5 Ontology-based business architecture engineering technology Kudryavtsev D Grigoriev L The 10th International Conference on Intelligent Software Methodologies Tools and Techniques September 28-30 2011 P 233-252

27

Thanks

Questions


1 NRU HSE artemkostgmailcom azhulingmailcom lsinyatullinagmailcom2 laquoBusiness Engineering Groupraquo dmitrykugmailcom griglevgmailcom valyabigspbru3 SPbSPU4 КТЕ Labs romanermakovgmailcom

Regional enterprise architecture (EA) modeling for systemic development of citys ICT (рус Моделирование комплексов городского хозяйства для системного развития средств ИКТ города)

Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions


Agenda

1 The role of regional EA modeling for systemic ICT development

2 Regional EA modeling methodology

3 Decision support reference system for systemic (consistent) ICT development

4 Related work

5 Conclusions




mass media














1


2


3

KEY FIGURE


4



1



2

3







Public function


City process

Outcome Output

Indicators


Lower organizations

Positions

Information entity

Attributes Domains

Business entity




Interfaces

Info

rmat

izat

ion

acti

viti

es

(pro

gram

ldquoIn

form

atio

n ci

tyrdquo)





7



8



Portal



Modeler




System architecture


Modeler



enterprise model


Documents



Integration wizard

Diagram editor

Query results

Semi-structured

data

OWL

XML



Classifier Matrix








City processes)

















Classes (metamodel)





8




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions




mass media














1


2


3

KEY FIGURE


4



1



2

3







Public function


City process

Outcome Output

Indicators


Lower organizations

Positions

Information entity

Attributes Domains

Business entity




Interfaces

Info

rmat

izat

ion

acti

viti

es

(pro

gram

ldquoIn

form

atio

n ci

tyrdquo)





7



8



Portal



Modeler




System architecture


Modeler



enterprise model


Documents



Integration wizard

Diagram editor

Query results

Semi-structured

data

OWL

XML



Classifier Matrix








City processes)

















Classes (metamodel)





8




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions




1


2


3

KEY FIGURE


4



1



2

3







Public function


City process

Outcome Output

Indicators


Lower organizations

Positions

Information entity

Attributes Domains

Business entity




Interfaces

Info

rmat

izat

ion

acti

viti

es

(pro

gram

ldquoIn

form

atio

n ci

tyrdquo)





7



8



Portal



Modeler




System architecture


Modeler



enterprise model


Documents



Integration wizard

Diagram editor

Query results

Semi-structured

data

OWL

XML



Classifier Matrix








City processes)

















Classes (metamodel)





8




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions






Public function


City process

Outcome Output

Indicators


Lower organizations

Positions

Information entity

Attributes Domains

Business entity




Interfaces

Info

rmat

izat

ion

acti

viti

es

(pro

gram

ldquoIn

form

atio

n ci

tyrdquo)





7



8



Portal



Modeler




System architecture


Modeler



enterprise model


Documents



Integration wizard

Diagram editor

Query results

Semi-structured

data

OWL

XML



Classifier Matrix








City processes)

















Classes (metamodel)





8




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions





7



8



Portal



Modeler




System architecture


Modeler



enterprise model


Documents



Integration wizard

Diagram editor

Query results

Semi-structured

data

OWL

XML



Classifier Matrix








City processes)

















Classes (metamodel)





8




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions



8



Portal



Modeler




System architecture


Modeler



enterprise model


Documents



Integration wizard

Diagram editor

Query results

Semi-structured

data

OWL

XML



Classifier Matrix








City processes)

















Classes (metamodel)





8




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions



Portal



Modeler




System architecture


Modeler



enterprise model


Documents



Integration wizard

Diagram editor

Query results

Semi-structured

data

OWL

XML



Classifier Matrix








City processes)

















Classes (metamodel)





8




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions


Modeler



enterprise model


Documents



Integration wizard

Diagram editor

Query results

Semi-structured

data

OWL

XML



Classifier Matrix








City processes)

















Classes (metamodel)





8




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions



Classifier Matrix








City processes)

















Classes (metamodel)





8




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions








City processes)

















Classes (metamodel)





8




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions















Classes (metamodel)





8




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions





8




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions




9














Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions













Related work








Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions


Conclusions





Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions


Publications






27

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions

Thanks

Questions




Agenda







System architecture

Modeler







Classes (metamodel)








Related work

Conclusions

Publications

ThanksQuestions

regional enterprise architecture (ea) modeling for systemic development of city's ict

Business

nru spbspu

business engineering

ermakov roman41 nru

labsinformation city

outcomes values city

processes of implementation

example relationship

types types descriptions