raising capital in 2010 or beg, borrow and steal 403 @ the school of hard knocks also called why i...
DESCRIPTION
Raising Capital in 2010 or Beg, Borrow and Steal 403 @ the School of Hard Knocks also called Why I hate the word “funding”. Getting the Terminology Right. “ Funding ” is what research a project consumes It is a matter of academic curiosity “ Capital ” is what entrepreneurs need and create - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Raising Capital in 2010
or
Beg, Borrow and Steal 403@ the School of Hard Knocks
also called
Why I hate the word “funding”
Getting the Terminology Right
• “Funding” is what research a project consumes– It is a matter of academic curiosity
• “Capital” is what entrepreneurs need and create– It is a matter of business and wealth creation
• “Cash” is what keeps the enterprise alive– It is a matter of life and death
Getting the Thinking Right
• “Debt” is not the same as “Equity”
• “Expenses” are not the same as “Cash Flow”
• A key programming language: “Accounting”
What’s up with Venture Capital?
The V in VC = Vanishing
Getting To Angels
• It’s about “Math” not “Prayers”
• The technical term is “Win-some, Lose some”
• “Rule of 2-6-2”: Out of every 10 investments– 2 die completely– 6 are the undead... Zombies... Cash never exits– 2 generate all of our returns
• Every entrepreneur thinks they are in the right 2
Angels: Time Value of Money
Investors have CHOICES about where to put their money
Assuming average Time to Exit of 5 years, what are our alternatives?
Portfolio Multiple Equivalent Investment Strategy 1x = (1+0%)5 Hoard Cash 1.5x =(1+8%) 5 Secured Debt2.0x =(1+15%)5 Unsecured Debt3.0x =(1+25%)5 Pay day loans4.5x =(1+35%) 5 Other Startups Like You
The Basic Math
1.0X Dead
Zombies
Live
35% Per Year Rate of Return
4.5X
Year 0 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5
Our Expectations = 4.5X
1X
22.5 X
Your Promise = 22.5 X
Entrepreneur MathAverage angel deal looking at 20 X exit, so...
• IF– I want to keep control of my company (66%)
• THEN – 33% of my company needs to be worth > 20X the investment– So 100% needs to be worth > 60X the investment!!
• 80% of companies bought by Google were purchased for less than 100 M$
Angels will do this math, even if you don’t
Corollary: Why are you better than average?
To Close an Angel• Show that our risk is lower than typical
– Better than 20% chance of being in the right 20%– (we won’t believe you, but you get extra points for trying)– Or at least demonstrate that you are keenly aware of risks
• Explain how their exit will be much sooner– Shrink that exponential function, exponentially
• Prove that you understand basic business– Demonstrate a focus on making money for them– Demonstrate knowledge that business is about choices– Connect the dots from cool technology to wealth creation
A good business opportunity will attract investors
Friends and Family Aren’t Like That• They want you to succeed more than they
want to make money
• Or maybe they just aren’t any good at math
Really, they are buying into YOU...
Corollary: If they won’t, who will?
YOU: the most important investor
• “Skin in the Game”... yours first– If you don’t believe, then I won’t either
• “Appetite for Risk”... if you don’t have the stomach, don’t sit at the table
• “Risk” and “Reward” enjoy a Karmic balance
Banks• Banks only provide you cash for the capital you
already have
• They convert “Assets” to “Cash Flow” and vice versa• They don’t share your passion or care about your
ideals
• Banks *ONLY* care about the math
Banks are NOT sources of capital
Financing• Easiest: Product with Gross Margin of 80%
– Customer pays 20% in advance– This is the basis for “just pay S&H” (includes product cost)
• Purchase Order Financing, or “factoring” in lingua banka– Unconditional Purchase order is financeable on *THEIR* credit rating– Conditional purchase order is financeable on YOUR ability to convince
your investors you can meet the conditions
• Services business can be SRED financed– Especially if US sourced revenue
EDC: Export Development Canada
• “Export Express Credit”– $50,000 unsecured loan, repayable over 2 years
• “Export Guarantee”– Provide guarantees to your bank (so your bank will give
you more credit)
• “Supplier Financing” – Purchase your foreign receivables
Government
• It takes work... But in most cases you don’t have to pay it back
• SR&ED Tax Credits• IRAP• OCE• Regional Development Incentives
SR&ED & OITC
• Know this program inside and out
• Simplistic: ~ 40% of 160% of eligible expenditures– There are lots of rules, but they are clear and easy to follow
• You need to actually make the expenditures – You must maintain appropriate records, evidence– Expect to be audited – better safe than sorry
• Note: expenditures and cash flow are not the same thing
IRAP• Most useful program is “Contribution” agreement
– IRAP pays for R&D Salaries (about 60% of project)– Company pays for overheads (about 40%)
• You pay your costs, IRAP reimburses a portion, about 60 days AFTER you spend it and send in proof
• BUT, it can be difficult for many entrepreneurs– It is a finite resource, heavily over-subscribed– Requires a disciplined business management approach– Need to learn how to speak IRAP
• Great program, Fantastic people, Really trying to help– But they are over-worked
• Also provide other useful programs– Market research, mentorship, academic-industrial partnering...
Regional Initiatives• OCRI– Strong and active entrepreneurship program– Sponsors Lead To Win– Various events– Referrals to Provincial programs (OCE, MARS...)
• Grass Roots Initiatives– The Ottawa Network, DemoCamp, TeamCamp...
The Good news: Opportunity Cost trending to $0
Employees
• Slavery was outlawed long ago, but...... Sweat Equity is part of the package
• Innovative “on spec” or “rev-share” deals
• Directors, Executives and Officers are Special
• But... Get appropriate legal advice
Suppliers
• Take As Long As Possible to Pay
• They often have more patience than you think– If you succeed, you’ll buy more– It’s in their interest that you survive
• Cash is our most precious resource – Count cash in terms of Door-Open-Days
Customers
• The only source of capital you don’t eventually have to pay back
• Customers are the folks who pay you– Avoid Whiners (won’t pay)– Differentiate from Users (don’t pay)
• If you can’t find at least one Customer willing to put it in writing, you have to wonder if any exist at all
Summary: Sources of Capital
• Venture Capital • Angel Capital• Friends and Family• Banks• Government• Employees• Suppliers• Customers
Financial Engineering
• A few illustrations in the art of the possible– Makes many simplifying assumptions – Get professional advice (legal, accounting)
• Start with the typical Founder Scenario– Work for a year from your kitchen for no salary– 1 year later... What do you have?
A Tale of Two FoundersA: Works for a year “for free”
B: Personally Begs, Borrows or Steals $100,000– Lends it to their company– Company uses this stash of cash to pay B a salary+benefits of $100,000– Company pays source deductions of about $35,000
• (B takes home about $65,000 after tax, which gets returned to whence it came)– Company eventually receives SRED Tax Credit of $43,000
• (company repays B $43,000 of the $100,000 loan principal, which also goes back to whence it came)
• When The Dust Settles, both A and B have 0 net cash, but– Founder B shows a $57,000 loan to the company (skin in the game!!)
• which can be offset against future income, tax free even if the company fails – Founder B has EI, CPP benefits– Founder B isn’t “unemployed” to the rest of the world
Your Mileage May Vary, Some Restrictions Apply
Three Founders, IRAP+SREDC: Approved for $100,000 IRAP program and begs, borrows or steals $100,000
– Lends it to their company (showing IRAP sufficient cash to execute the program)– Company pays salary+benefits of $100,000– Company pays source deductions of about $35,000
• (C takes home about $65,000, which gets returned to whence it came)– Along the way, IRAP pays the company $60,000
• (company repays C $60K of the $100K oan, $35K goes to retire the loan, leaving $25K free cash)– Eventually receive SRED Tax Credit of about $16K (SRED is reduced by contributions etc.)
• (company repays C another $16K of the loan principal, total $41K free cash)
• When The Dust Settles, C has net $41K after-tax cash – (equivalent to 60K/year salary)– Founder C also holds a $24,000 loan to the company which can be offset against future income, tax free
even if the company fails– Founder C has EI, CPP benefits– Founder C is employed at a better rate than flipping burgers
• Again, Your Mileage May Vary, Some Restrictions Apply
Put it All Together with an Angel Investment
IRAP & SRED & Angel & BankD: Approved for $100K IRAP program, $30K Equity from Angel, $70K Personally
Secured Bank Loan– Company starts with 100K in bank– Company pays salary+benefits of $100K – Company pays source deductions of about $35K
• (D takes home about $65,000)– Along the way, IRAP pays the company $60,000
• (company repays bank $60,000 of the $70,000 loan)– Eventually receive SRED Tax Credit of about $16,000 (SRED is reduced by contributions etc.)
• company repays bank remaining $10,000 of the loan principal• company has $6,000 left over, but it will also owe some interest
• When The Dust Settles, D has taken home a good salary, AND– Angel investor gets $100K worth of work done for $30K investment– Company has established a good credit rating
Add revenue, and even a break-even business is profitable