radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · iaea cn-254 - vienna - 13-17 nov 2017 -...

22
1 IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies P. Finocchiaro , P. Checchia, M. Ripani INFN Laboratori Nazionali del Sud, Catania, Italy INFN Sezione di Padova, Italy INFN Sezione di Genova, Italy Data data storage Data Data

Upload: others

Post on 10-Oct-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

1IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies

P. Finocchiaro, P. Checchia, M. Ripani

INFN Laboratori Nazionali del Sud, Catania, Italy

INFN Sezione di Padova, Italy

INFN Sezione di Genova, Italy

Data

datastorage

Data

Data

Page 2: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

2IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

INFN

National Institute of Nuclear Physics

Medicine

Cultural heritage

Computer science

Electronics

ENERGY: strategic project

Theoretical / experimental

nuclear and subnuclear physicsUniversity

Industry

≈ 30 Sections

+ 4 National Laboratories

Page 3: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

3IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

what why how

www.energy.gov/EM 22

Drum 68660

R16:C4

R17:C5 R15:C5

68660

R16:C4

R15:C5

68660

68660

www.energy.gov/EM 22

Drum 68660

R16:C4

R17:C5 R15:C5

68660

R16:C4

R15:C5

68660

68660

protection of nuclear material and nuclear facilities

Page 4: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

4IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

what

Page 5: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

5IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

storage

what

handling transport

inspection check

security & safety issues:

maintaining the continuity of knowledge (e.g. legacy waste)

checking package integrity

Page 6: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

6IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

why

Page 7: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

7IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

why monitoring? why new tools?

nuclear material lasting hundreds of thousands years

geological repository

but... predisposal & preclosure?

handling, transportation, interim, legacy waste...

inspecting? monitoring?

conventional methods new technologies?

need to prevent, detect and respond to

theft, sabotage, unauthorized access and illegal transfer

or other malicious acts

Page 8: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

8IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

To have a complete and detailed record of the history of each cask

What would be the goal?

individual and continuous online monitoring of casks

to improve safety, security, transparency

why monitoring?

Page 9: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

9IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

www.energy.gov/EM 22

Drum 68660

R16:C4

R17:C5 R15:C5

68660

R16:C4

R15:C5

68660

68660

WIPP

Waste Isolation Pilot Plant

14-Feb-2014 New Mexico

Could individual online

monitoring have prevented

or limited the accident?

Why monitoring?

Page 10: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

10IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

Why (online) monitoring?

Page 11: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

11IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

how

Page 12: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

12IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

low-cost

thermal neutron counterlow-cost linear gamma ray counter

miniature low-cost

gamma ray spectrometer / dosimeter

how

Muon Scattering

Tomography system

Page 13: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

13IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

nuclearmaterial

data acquisition and control

counters

counters

counters

• local wireless and LAN• global WAN

LAN

wireless

local Data Base

control

authorities

organizations

IAEA

remote Data Base

how

in place

in place

transport

Page 14: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

14IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

low voltage (30V)high gain

radiation hard

flexible

robust

reliabile

easily handled

low cost

SiPM

1 mm

1÷2m long

low-cost linear gamma ray counter

how

developed with the support ofAnsaldo Nucleare

Page 15: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

15IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

low-cost linear gamma ray counter

how

tested in collaboration with SOGIN

Page 16: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

16IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

miniature low-cost gamma ray spectrometer / dosimeter

how

developed by Wisnam under INFN license

Page 17: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

17IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

how

compact, robust, manageable

good detection efficiency (5÷ 10%)

optimum gamma discrimination (<10-8)

low-cost thermal neutron counter

solid state (Silicon + 6LiF)

low voltage (25 V)

low cost technology, cheaper than 3He

SiLiF3He tube

partly supported by JRC Ispra

Page 18: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

18IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

how

Muon Scattering Tomography system

provides the 3D density distribution

can detect missing fuel rods

inspection of legacy unknown radwaste

presented at the Consultancy Meeting on

Recent Developments in Muon Radiography

25-29 September 2017, IAEA, Vienna

non-invasive inspection technique

Page 19: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

19IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

neutrons and gamma rays

convey information from the

inside

an unexpected change in

counting rate is an indication

of anomaly

radiological

characterization

storage & monitoring

via a sensor network

= fingerprinting

how

radiation fingerprint, similar to CRC Control Code for computer data

muon

tomography

transport

Page 20: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

20IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

Disposal

nuclear fuel

reactor

temporary

storage

wet

storage

dry

storage treatment

partitioning

(& transmutation)

deep

geological

disposal

intermediate

depth

disposal

direct disposal

ProcessingTemporary

Storage

Nuclear

Power Plant

Interim

Storage

recycled

nuclear fuel

Spent Fuel Management Cycle

transport

monitoringin place

monitoring

Page 21: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

21IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

new technologies provide viable solutions

for full continuity of knowledge

Conclusion

and help preventing and detecting

theft, sabotage, unauthorized access and illegal transfer

or other malicious acts

Page 22: Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new ... · IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

22IAEA CN-254 - Vienna - 13-17 Nov 2017 - Radwaste online monitoring: opportunities from new technologies (ORA-117) P.Finocchiaro

International Conference on Physical Protection of Nuclear Material and Nuclear Facilities

[email protected]

Thank you

Catania and the Etna volcano