québec court of appeal - marcomm.mccarthy.ca€¦ · lortie, jean respondent qc final appeal class...

The French version will be available soon.

Québec Court of AppealAppellate Cases Argued by Active McCarthy Tétrault Lawyers

NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR

REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY

LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS

1. QCCA Groupe d'actiond'investisseurs dansBiosyntech c. Tsang

11/30/16 [2016] Q.J. No.17247, 2016QCCA 1923,2016EXP-3850,J.E. 2016-2152,EYB 2016-273408

Lortie, JeanMathieu,Jean-Philippe

Respondent QC Final appeal Civil procedure - Classaction - Authorization -Conditions precedent -Serious appearance ofright - Corporation law -Directors - Personalliability - Extracontractualliability.

2. QCCA National CommercialBank c. Suleman


Bouchard,Pierre-Jérôme

Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure -Judgment - Revocation -When available - Defaultjudgment - Defence onmerits.

3. QCCA Jasmin c. Sociétédes alcools duQuébec

05/03/16 [2016] J.Q. no4092, 2016 QCCA746

Tremblay,Gérald R.Mathieu,Jean-Philippe

Respondent QC Final Appeal Class action - Civil;procedure - Motion todismiss - Res judicata.

4. QCCA Québec (Procureuregénérale) c. Glass

04/18/16 [2016] J.Q. no3582, 2016 QCCA688

Brabander,Kristian

Respondent QC Final appeal Immigration law -Provincial law - Certificatde sélection du Québec -Waiver of rights -Discontinuance.

5. QCCA Camiré c. R.N. 04/15/16 [2016] J.Q. no3751, 2016 QCCA705, 2016EXP-1485, J.E. 2016-

Cantin,PhilippeLessard,Frédérique

Appellant QC Final Appeal Health law - Physician -Surgeon - Medicalmalpractice - Surgerycompetently performed -



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


809, EYB 2016-265044

Inference of fault.

6. QCCA Charland c. Lessard 03/11/16 [2016] J.Q. no2088, 2016 QCCA452, 2016EXP-1025, J.E. 2016-541

Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Final Appeal Civil procedure - Motionto dismiss the appeal -Abuse of process - Theappeal was a recklessexercise

7. QCCA J.G. c. Nadeau 02/02/16 [2016] J.Q. no635, 2016 QCCA167, 2016EXP-589, J.E. 2016-290, EYB 2016-261643

Chénier,Robert-JeanBélanger,Marie-Ève

Respondent QC Final Appeal Application forleave toappeal filedon 2016-04-04 (docket36924)

Health law - Physician -Medical malpractice -Choice of treatment -Medication - Prematurebirth

8. QCCA Blouin c. Parcséoliens de laSeigneurie deBeaupré 2 et 3,s.e.n.c.

01/21/16 [2016] J.Q. no362, 2016 QCCA77, 2016EXP-458,J.E. 2016-255,EYB 2016-261189

Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Final Appeal Class action - Civilprocedure - Individualproceedings -Composition of the group- Civil liability - Abuse ofright - Neighbourhooddisturbances - Cementplant.

9. QCCA Masella c. TD BankFinancial Group

01/15/16 [2016] J.Q. no143, 2016 QCCA24, 2016EXP-298,J.E. 2016-167,EYB 2016-260905

MasonPoplawÉlisabethBrousseau

Respondent QC Final Appeal Class action - Civilprocedure - Authorization- Burder to demonstartecolour of right

10. QCCA Uber Canada inc. c.Agence du revenu duQuébec

01/07/16 [2016] J.Q. no 5,2016 QCCA 1,2016EXP-219,J.E. 2016-97, EYB2016-260448

NicolasCloutierNicolasChaput

Appellant QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappealdismissed on2016-06-09(docket36882).

Tax - Provincial taxation -Search and seizure -Escrow - Right to accessthings and documentsseized - Civil procedure -Safguard order -Irreparable harm.



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


11. QCCA Université McGill c.McGill UniversityNon Academic

Certified Association(MUNACA)

11/24/15 [2015] J.Q. no12744, 2015QCCA 1943, EYB2015-258949

Baril, André Appellant QC Final appeal Labour law - Collectiveagreement - Industrialaccidents andoccupational diseases -Jurisdiction of thegrievance arbitrator -Insertion of provisionsmore favorable to theworker in the collectiveagreement.

12. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd c.Conseil Québécoissur le tabac et lasanté

10/27/15 [2015] Q.J. No.7413, 2015 QCCA1737, 2015EXP-3171, J.E. 2015-1760, EYB 2015-258069

Potter, SimonV.Bouchard,Pierre-Jérôme

Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure - Securityfor costs - Appellantscondemned to pay over$8 billion in damages -Security orderedfurnished in the amountof $758 million forImperial Tobacco and$226 million forRothmans, payable inquarterly instalments

13. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. c.Québec (Procureuregénérale)

09/28/15 [2015] J.Q. no9382, 2015 QCCA1554,2015EXP-2886, J.E. 2015-1589, EYB 2015-256982


Appellant QC Final Appeal Health law - Public health- Tobacco-relatedDamages - Health CareCosts Recovery - Judicialrights - Burden of proof

14. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. c.Conseil québécoissur le tabac et lasanté

07/23/15 [2015] Q.J. No.6159, 2015 QCCA1224, 2015EXP-2292, J.E. 2015-1283, EYB 2015-254767


Appellant QC Interlocutory Class action - Civilprocedure - Execution ofjudgments - Compulsoryexecution - Provisionalexecution - Production ofevidence - Sealing ofevidence - Confidentialityorder



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


15. QCCA Roy c. Mout 04/23/15 [2015] J.Q. no3390, 2015 QCCA692, 2015EXP-1475, J.E. 2015-814, EYB 2015-251191

Poupart,EmmannuelleDufort-Langlois,Philippe

Respondent QC Final appeal Medical malpractice -Causation - Moraldamages du to thevictim's spouse andchildren

16. QCCA Videotron, s.e.n.c. c.Bell ExpressVu, l.p.

03/06/15 [2015] J.Q. no1742, 2015 QCCA422, 2015EXP-846, J.E. 2015-446, EYB 2015-249113

Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Final appeal Civil liability - Medias -Telecommunication -Televison signal -Inadequate securitysystem - Dammagescaused to competitors

17. QCCA Syndicat desemployées etemployés del'Université deMontréal, sectionlocale 1244 (SCFP-FTQ) c. Université deMontréal

03/04/15 [2015] J.Q. no1612, 2015 QCCA411, 2015EXP-909, 2015EXPT-479, J.E. 2015-487, D.T.E.2015T-197, EYB2015-248878

Baril, André Respondent QC Final appeal Labour law - Grievancearbitration - JudicialReview - Arbitrator'sjurisdiction

18. QCCA Pagé c. Godbout 02/09/15 [2015] J.Q. no664, 2015 QCCA225, 18 C.C.L.T.(4th) 42, 2015CarswellQue 646,2015EXP-667,J.E. 2015-342,EYB 2015-247792

Dberge, DavidEmmanuelufour, Marc

Appellant QC Final appeal Civil liability - Causation -No fault regime - Novusactus interveniens -Transportation law - Caraccident

19. QCCA Taberna PreferredFunding VI Ltd. c.Stichting HomburgBonds

01/16/15 [2015] Q.J. No.161, 2015 QCCA62, 2015EXP-369,J.E. 2015-188,EYB 2015-246975

Poplaw,MasonPerreault,JocelynDeslandrew,Nicolas

Respondent QC Interlocutory Insolvency - Companies’Creditors ArrangementAct - Compromises andarrangements withunsecured creditors -Priority - Directors claim



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


20. QCCA Jasmin c. Sociétédes alcools duQuébec

01/14/15 [2015] J.Q. no 78,2015 QCCA 36,2015EXP-336,J.E. 2015-171,EYB 2015-246823

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Final appeal Consumer protection -Class action -Authorization - Statemonopoly - Wines andliquors

21. QCCA Charland c. Lessard 01/12/15 [2015] J.Q. no 51,2015 QCCA 14,2015EXP-278,J.E. 2015-139,EYB 2015-246657

Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Final appeal Corporate law -Shareholdersagreements - Protectionof minority shareholders -Directors liability

22. QCCA Association desmédecins résidentsde Québec c. Leclerc

12/17/14 [2014] J.Q. no14615, 2014QCCA 2374,2015EXP-256,2015EXPT-129,J.E. 2015-128,D.T.E. 2015T-52,EYB 2014-246254

Cantin,Philippe

Respondent QC Final appeal Labour law -Psychologicalharassment in a hospital- Medical examiner

23. QCCA Deraspe c. Zincélectrolytique duCanada Corporationltée

12/08/14 [2014] J.Q. no13990, 2014QCCA 2266,2015EXP-150,J.E. 2015-76, EYB2014-245560

Gagné,MichelRoberge,DavidEmmanuel

Respondent QC Final appeal Class action -Environmental law -Corporate personality -Alter ego - "Custody" of aplant.

24. QCCA St-Germain c.Benhaim

12/05/14 [2014] J.Q. no13772, 2014QCCA 2207,2014EXP-3922,J.E. 2014-2197,2014 CarswellQue12131, 16C.C.L.T. (4th) 190,EYB 2014-245285

Platts, DavidE.Brousseau,Elisabeth

Respondent QC Final appeal Civil liability - Medicalmalpractice - Diagnosis -Damages.

25. QCCA Groupe Enerstat inc.c. Siemens BuildingTechnologies

11/03/14 [2014] J.Q. no12142, 2014QCCA 2023,

Giroux,François

Respondent QC Final appeal Obligations - Contractbreach - Remedies - Thegoods could not be used



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


(Siemens Canadaltée)

2014EXP-3591,J.E. 2014-2026,EYB 2014-243972

for the purpose for whichthey were intended.

26. QCCA Liu c. Comité dediscipline du Centrede santé et deservices sociauxHaut-Richelieu—Rouville


Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Final appeal Health law - Physicians -Discipline committees inhospitals - Complaint -Deadline for the medicalexaminer tocommunicate isconclusions.

27. QCCA 6926614 Canada inc.(Entreprises Tag)(Arrangement relatifà)


Perreault,Jocelyn

Appellant QC Interlocutory Insolvency - Companies'Creditors ArrangementAct - Leave to appeal -Analysis of the requiredcriteria to appeal ajudgment rendered underthe CCAA.

28. QCCA Simard-BeaudryConstruction inc. c.Constructions Bob-Son inc.

06/10/14 [2014] J.Q. no5616, 2014 QCCA1182

Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Final Appeal Contracts - Contract ofenterprise - Resiliation ofthe contract once thework started -Interpretation of thecontractual documents

29. QCCA Agence du revenu duQuébec c. Potvin

05/15/14 [2014] J.Q. no4541, 2014 QCCA1001

Discepola,Angelo

Respondent QC Final Appeal Tax - Provincial taxation -Notice of assessment -Determination of themoment of the grant ofthe stock options - Intentof the parties.

30. QCCA Fortier c. MeublesLéon ltée

02/04/14 [2014] J.Q. no661, 2014 QCCA195, EYB 2014-232573

Loranger,Julie-Martine

Respondent QC Final Appeal Class action – Consumerprotection – Legal andsupplemental warranties– Seller's liability –Misrepresentation.



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


31. QCCA Banque deMontréal/Bank ofMontreal c. BanquedeNouvelle-Écosse/Bank of NovaScotia

09/12/13 [2013] J.Q. no11447, 2013QCCA 1548

Tremblay,Gérald R.Boodman,Martin

Respondent QC Final Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadapending(Docket35610,12/11/2013)

Banks and financialinstitutions – Civil liability– Customer of a bankengaged in fraudulentactivities (“kiting”) – Dutyof the bank to stop theillegal activities and not tobenefit from the saidactivities

32. QCCA Caron c. Voyer 08/07/13 [2013] J.Q. no9214, 2013 QCCA1335, 2013EXP-2710, J.E. 2013-1466, EYB 2013-225414


Respondent QC Final Appeal Professional liability –Securities dealers –Liability of another –Investment Advisor –Evidence – Similar factevidence in civil matters.

33. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 05/27/13 [2013] J.Q. no5710, 2013 QCCA981

Dufort-Langlois,Philippe

Appellant QC Final Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadapending(Docket35495,26/08/2013)

Medical liability – childborn premature –causation – damagecaused by prematurebirth – discretionarypower of the court toreserve the right of thecreditor to apply foradditional damageswithin three years (art.1615 CCQ)

34. QCCA Lévesque c. Hudon 05/22/13 2013 QCCA 920 Chénier,Robert-JeanRoberge,DavidEmmanuel

Appellant QC Final Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket35485,09/01/2014)

Medical malpractice -Orthopedic surgery -Alleged late diagnosisand treatment - Anteriorcruciate ligament injury -Causation



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


35. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 05/22/13 2013 QCCA 921 Chénier,Robert-JeanRoberge,DavidEmmanuel

Respondent QC Final Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket35486,09/01/2014)

Medical malpractice -Orthopedic surgery -Alleged late diagnosisand treatment - Anteriorcruciate ligament injury -Causation

36. QCCA MacMillan c. AbbottLaboratories

05/15/13 [2013] Q.J. No.5177, 2013 QCCA906

Gagné,MichelPoupart,Emmanuelle

Respondent QC Final Appeal Class action - Medication- Meridia - Authorizationstage - The facts allegeddid not justify theconclusions sought

37. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 03/15/13 [2013] J.Q. no2432, 2013 QCCA486

Roberge,David E.Gagnon,Isabelle

Respondent QC Final Appeal Medical malpractice -Erroneous diagnosis -Extinctive prescription -Moment at whichprescription started

38. QCCA Lorrain c PetroCanada

02/21/13 [2013] J.Q. No.1420, 2013 QCCA332

Poupart,Emmanuelle

Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket35335,19/09/2013)

Class action – Criteria forauthorization –Calibration of gas pumps– Weights and measures

39. QCCA Canada (Procurergénéral) c. ImpérialTobacco Ltd.

11/14/12 [2012] J.Q. no13162, 2012QCCA 2034


Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure –Dismissal of action –Class action againsttobacco companies –Action in warrantyagainst Federal Crown –



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


Federal governmentpolicy – Stare deciss –Public law immunity

40. QCCA Centre commercialLes Rivières ltée c.Jean Bleu inc.

09/19/12 [2012] Q.J. No882, 2012 QCCA1663

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure –Contempt of Court – Oraljudgment – Order toproduct documents –Proof of the actus reusand of mens rea for civilcontempt – Availability ofeither remedies

41. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. C.Conseil québécoissur le tabac et lasanté

09/17/12 [2012] J.Q. no8750, 2012 QCCA1641

Potter, SimonV.

Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure –Production of documents– Survey data – Classction – Tobaccocompanies

42. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 07/11/12 [2012] J.Q. no.6756, 2012 QCCA1288

Chénier,Robert-Jean


Civil procedure – Partiesacting in a quarrelsomemanner – Dismissal ofthe appeal

43. QCCA Bitton c. AppleCanada Inc.

06/01/12 [2012] Q.J. No5120, 2012 QCCA991, 2012EXP-2286, EYB 2012-207251

Potter, SimonV.

Respondent QC Appeal Class action –Authorization –Conditions precedent –Alleged false ormisleading informationconveyed by Apple in themarketing of iPodproducts regarding thememory capacity – Thefacts alleged did not



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


justify the conclusionssought

44. QCCA Brown c. B2B Trust 05/15/12 [2012] J.Q. no4652, 2012 QCCA900, 2012EXP-2035, J.E. 2012-1071, EYB 2012-206680

Loranger,Julie-MartineClavier, Elisa

Respondent QC Appeal Class action –Authorization – Fraud –Real estate investments– Duties and obligationfor directors and officersunder the Trust and LoanCompanies Act –Custodian liability.

45. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 02/29/12 [2012] J.Q. no1610, 2012 QCCA383, 2012EXP-1072, 2012EXPT-533, J.E. 2012-586, D.T.E.2012T-172, EYB2012-202902

Rousse,Jacques

Respondent QC Appeal Labour and employmentlaw – Labour relations –Jurisdiction of grievancearbitrator – Medicalreport – Forcedretirement –Fundamental justice –Procedural safeguards

46. QCCA Watters v. White 02/09/12 [2012] Q.J. No.906, 2012 QCCA257

Platts, David Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket34758,30/08/2012)

Medical liability – rategenetic condition –obligation to inform –duty of confidentiality –patient’s extended family

47. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 01/30/12 [2012] J.Q. no.868, 2012 QCCA249, 2012EXP-726, J.E. 2012-401

Chénier,Robert-JeanHudon, Marc-Alexandre

Respondent QC Appeal Medical liability – medicalmalpractice – anesthetist– Obligation to inform –risks – consent givenorally – no obligation todisclose a very rarecomplication



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


48. QCCA Anvil Mining Ltd. v.Associationcanadienne contrel’impunité

01/24/12 [2012] J.Q. no.368, 2012 QCCA117, 2012EXP-513, J.E. 2012-277, EYB 2012-201106

Lehoux, Jean-FrançoisBouchard,Pierre-Jérôme

Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket34733,01/11/2012)

Class actions – Privateinternational law –international jurisdictionof Québec authorities –personal action – legalperson having anestablishment in Québec– dispute unrelated to thelegal person’s activities inQuébec

49. QCCA OptionConsommateurs v.InfineonTechnologies AG

11/16/11 [2011] Q.J. No.16769, 2011QCCA 2116

Renaud,MadeleineLegendre,Céline

Respondent QC Appeal Appeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket34617,31/10/2013)

Civil procedure — courts— jurisdiction andpowers — territorialjurisdiction — declinatoryexceptions — classaction —- motion forauthorization — damagesuffered in Québec

50. QCCA Valeurs mobilièresDesjardins inc. c.Lepage

10/06/11 [2011] J.Q. no14061, 2011QCCA 1837,2011EXP-3086,J.E. 2011-1725,EYB 2011-196622, [2011]R.J.Q. 1805



Professional liability –Financial advisors –Duties and obligations –Civil liability of aninvestment advisor andhis employer.

51. QCCA Volailles du fermierinc c. Éleveurs devolailles du Québecinc.

09/27/11 [2011] J.Q. no.136362011 QCCA 17722011 EXP-3012J.E. 2011-1686EYB 2011-196351

Vendette,Isabelle

Respondent QC Appeal Obligations —contractual liability(breach of contract) —consent of the parties —fraud — concealment ofvital information



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


52. QCCA Clouâtre c. FactoryMutual InsuranceCompany

09/19/11 [2011] J.Q. no12829, 2011QCCA 1690

Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — legalsubrogation — partialcollapse of a roof —liability of constructioncontractors

53. QCCA Collège desmédecins du Québecc. Genest

09/19/11 [2011] J.Q. no12831, 2011QCCA 1683

Dufour, MarcChamberland,Simon

Respondent QC Appeal Disciplinary law —physicians — re-entry onthe roll of the order ofphysicians after beingprovisionally struck offthe roll

54. QCCA Caisse populaireDesjardins de Côte-des-Neiges c.Banque Toronto-Dominion


Deschamps,MichelPerreault,Jocelyn

Respondent QC Appeal Bills of exchange —fraudulent alteration ofbill — clearing system

55. QCCA Bombardier c.Éleveurs de volaillesdu Québec

06/03/11 [2011] J.Q. no6757, 2011 QCCA1058, EYB 2011-191589

Renaud,Madeleine

Respondent QC Appeal Agri-food — chickenmarketing — regulationsby self-regulationorganization — penalties— jurisdiction of theRégie des marchésagricoles et alimentairesdu Québec

56. QCCA Grenier c. Grenier 05/24/11 [2011] J.Q. no5877, 2011 QCCA964, EYB 2011-191082,2011EXP-1782J.E. 2011-982

Cantin,Philippe

Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability — medicalmalpractice — caraccident — osteotomy

57. QCCA Greenberg c. Capitald'Amérique CDPQinc.

05/20/11 [2011] Q.J. No.5891, 2011 QCCA958, 2011EXP-1807, EYB 2011-191159

Giroux,François

Respondent QC Appeal Commercial — contracts— agreement relating tothe purchase ofshareholdings — pre-contractual document



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


58. QCCA Nechi InvestmentsInc. c. Autorité desmarchés financiers


Bourbonnais,Miguel

Respondent QC Interlocutory Securities — jurisdictionof Court of Québec —freezing orders

59. QCCA Sodexin Financementmercantile inc. c.Sport Maska inc.

01/25/11 [2011] J.Q. no267, 2011 QCCA113

Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency — effects ofthe contract —shareholders —corporate personality

60. QCCA R.K. v. Ackman(Succession d')


Platts, DavidE.Chamberland,Simon

Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadapending(Docket34077,28/01/2011)

Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — duty to inform— disclosure of risks

61. QCCA Domtar Inc. c.Produits Kruger ltée

10/29/10 [2010] J.Q. no10947, 2010QCCA 1934,2010EXP-3603,J.E. 2010-1964EYB 2010-181157

Potter, SimonV.

Respondent QC Appeal Energy — hydroelectricity— sale of a factory —electricity supply to thefactory

62. QCCA Conseil de lamagistrature duQuébec c. Dubois

10/08/10 [2010] J.Q. no10428, 2010QCCA 1864,2010EXP-3409,J.E. 2010-1882EYB 2010-180670

Tremblay,Gérald R.Bélanger,Marie-Eve

Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadapending(Docket33973,

Discipline and ethics —legal professions —judges — inquiry by theConseil de lamagistrature du Québec



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


07/12/2010)

63. QCCA P.L. c. Benchetrit 08/24/10 [2010] J.Q. no8067, 2010 QCCA1505, 2010EXP-2900, J.E. 2010-1600, [2010]R.R.A. 606, [2010]R.J.Q. 1853

Brabander,Kristian

Respondent QC Appeal Professionalresponsibility — medicine— plastic surgery —consent — expertevidence

64. QCCA Apple Canada Inc. c.St-Germain

07/28/10 [2010] J.Q. no7327, 2010 QCCA1376, 2010EXP-2564, J.E. 2010-1430, EYB 2010-177247, [2010]R.J.Q. 1627

Potter, SimonV.

Appellant QC Appeal Copyright — class action— iPod — royalties —proof — admission —necessity to establishthat internal mechanismis a sufficientcompensation

65. QCCA Château Drummondinc. c. 9171-8338Québec inc.

05/20/10 [2010] J.Q. no4746, 2010 QCCA1012

Schenke,Stephen G.

Appellant QC Appeal Property law — servitude— parking lot

66. QCCA Nunez de la TorreRomero c. Lichtblau


Platts, DavidE.

Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —change of attorneys —disqualification — conflictof interest

67. QCCA Forest c. RaymorIndustries inc.

03/24/10 [2010] J.Q. no2439, 2010 QCCA578, 2010EXP-1238, J.E. 2010-673, EYB 2010-171471, 66 C.B.R.(5th) 197, 2010CarswellQue 2474

Tardif, AlainN.Perreault,Jocelyn

Respondent QC Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency — companies'creditors arrangements— reorganization —dismissal of appeal —lack of sufficient legalinterest — mootness



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


68. QCCA Fabrikant c. Swamy 02/16/10 [2010] J.Q. no1352, [2010] Q.J.No. 1352, 2010QCCA 330, EYB2010-170047,2010EXP-896J.E. 2010-492

Lehoux, Jean-François

Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket33675,08/07/2010)

Civil procedure —inherent power ofsuperior court to punishabuse of process — rightto be heard —fundamental right

69. QCCA Richard c. Gougoux 12/03/09 [2009] J.Q. no15088, 2009QCCA 2347

Bélanger,Marie-Eve

Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability —defamation —harassment — civilprocedure — dismissal ofthe appeal

70. QCCA N.L. c. Sabbah 11/19/09 [2009] J.Q. no12092, 2009QCCA 1995

Platts, DavidE.

Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — dismissalof the appeal

71. QCCA Progistix-Solutionsinc. c. Commissiondes normes du travail

10/26/09 [2009] J.Q. no12538, 2009QCCA 2054, EYB2009-165565, J.E.2009-2045, [2009]R.J.D.T. 1103

Gagnon,Nathalie

Appellant QC Appeal Labour — labourstandards — collectiveagreement — differencesin treatment

72. QCCA Interinvest (Bermuda)Ltd. c. Herzog

07/24/09 [2009] J.Q. no7463, 2009 QCCA1428, J.E. 2009-1451, EYB 2009-161934, 179A.C.W.S. (3d)1088

Potter, SimonV.,Brabander,Kristian

Respondent QC Interlocutory International private law— conflicts of jurisdiction— foreign corporation

73. QCCA Gestion Raymor inc.c. Ready PacCanada Co.

04/08/09 [2009] J.Q. no2973, 2009 QCCA679

Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency —nanotechnology —safeguard order —interim receiver —



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


intervention —proposition

74. QCCA Raymor Aerospaceinc. c. Béliveau

04/08/09 [2009] J.Q. no2972, 2009 QCCA678, EYB 2009-157156

Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency —nanotechnology —safeguard order —interim receiver —intervention —proposition

75. QCCA Raymor Industriesinc. v. Ready PacCanada Co.

04/08/09 [2009] Q.J. No.2974, [2009] J.Q.no 2974, 2009QCCA 680, J.E.2009-813

Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Interlocutory Bankruptcy andinsolvency —nanotechnology —safeguard order —interim receiver —intervention —proposition

76. QCCA Raymor Nanotechinc. c. Ready PacCanada Co.

04/08/09 [2009] J.Q. no2971, 2009 QCCA677


77. QCCA Gagné c. Fortin 04/06/09 [2009] J.Q. no2877, 2009 QCCA659, EYB 2009-157100, J.E.2009-747, [2009]R.R.A. 447

Dufour, Marc Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket33197,24/09/2009)

Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — psychiatrists —diagnosis — dismissal ofthe action — prescription



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


78. QCCA AP&C Revêtements& poudres avancéesinc. c. Ready PacCanadaCo.

03/30/09 [2009] J.Q. no2970, 2009 QCCA676


79. QCCA St-Arnaud v. C.L. 01/09/09 [2009] Q.J. No.259, [2009] J.Q.no 259, 2009QCCA 97, [2009]R.J.Q. 239, EYB2009-152692, J.E.2009-284

Chénier,Robert-JeanDufresne,Marie-Eve

Appellant QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket33045,18/06/2009)

Civil procedure —incidental proceedings —provision for costs

80. QCCA OptionConsommateurs c.Bell Mobilité

11/19/08 [2008] J.Q. no11736, 2008QCCA 2201, J.E.2008-2293, EYB2008-150743

Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Appeal Telecommunications —class action —authorization — billing

81. QCCA OptionConsommateurs c.Banque Nationale duCanada

11/12/08 [2008] J.Q. no11343, 2008QCCA 2128

Deschamps,Michel

Respondent QC Appeal Class action —authorization — banks —loan of money —interpretation of contracts

82. QCCA Syndicat national destravailleurs des pâteset papiers de Port-Alfred c. CompagnieAbitibi-Consolidateddu Canada, divisionde Port-Alfred

10/08/08 [2008] J.Q. no9780, 2008 QCCA1887, 72 C.C.P.B.156, 2008CarswellQue 9740

Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Labour — interpretationof a collective agreement— jurisdiction of arbitrator— retirement plan

83. QCCA Autorité des marchésfinanciers v. Panju

05/05/08 [2008] Q.J. No.3642, 2008 QCCA832, EYB 2008-

Legendre,Céline

Respondent QC Interlocutory Securities — civilprocedure — productionof exhibits by



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


132929, J.E.2008-1075, [2008]R.J.Q. 1233, 172A.C.W.S. (3d) 604

respondents —confidentiality —protection of the publicinterest

84. QCCA Ferland c. Ghosn 04/28/08 [2008] J.Q. no3351, 2008 QCCA797, EYB 2008-132464, J.E.2008-987, [2008]R.R.A. 295, 172A.C.W.S. (3d) 788

Bujold,Steeves

Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — duty to inform

85. QCCA Baum c. Mohr 04/18/08 [2008] Q.J. No.2978, 2008 QCCA718, EYB 2008-132239, J.E.2008-937, [2008]R.R.A. 285, 167A.C.W.S. (3d) 813

Platts, DavidE.

Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadiscontinued(Docket32688,09/10/2008)

Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — surgery

86. QCCA Latte des berges inc.(Syndic de)

04/08/08 [2008] J.Q. no2657, 2008 QCCA617, EYB 2008-131952, J.E.2008-858, 172A.C.W.S. (3d) 92

Lortie, Jean Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket33197,04/12/2008)

Contracts — sale ofassets — deposit

87. QCCA ConsortiumPromecan inc.(Syndic de)

12/18/07 [2007] J.Q. no14713, 2007QCCA 1835

Poplaw,Mason

Appellant QC Appeal Affirmed byQuebec(Revenue) v.Caissepopulaire

Insolvency andbankruptcy — taxation —collection of taxes onconsumption — deemedtrust — order of priority



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


Desjardins deMontmagny,2009 SCC 49,[2009] 3S.C.R. 286

88. QCCA Clennet c. Loto-Québec

12/06/07 [2007] J.Q. no13702, 2007QCCA 1690, J.E.2008-99, EYB2007-126944,[2007] C.A.I. 603,167 A.C.W.S. (3d)88

Dufort-Langlois,Philippe

Respondent QC Appeal Statute interpretation —interpretation — accessto information

89. QCCA Canada PostCorporation v. Lépine

08/10/07 [2007] Q.J. No.8498, [2007] J.Q.no 8498, 2007QCCA 1092,[2007] R.J.Q.1920, J.E. 2007-1615, EYB 2007-122903

Lortie, Jean Intervenor QC Appeal Confirmed bySociétécanadiennedes postes c.Lépine, 2009C.S.C. 16,[2009] 1R.C.S. 549

International private law— foreign judgments —recognition procedure —class action — lifetimeInternet service

90. QCCA 9026-9739 Québecinc. (Séquestre de) c.Roy, Métivier,Roberge inc.

04/11/07 [2007] J.Q. no2924, 2007 QCCA526, [2007] R.J.Q.828, J.E. 2007-825, EYB 2007-117894, 164A.C.W.S. (3d) 333

Bélanger,Philippe H.

Respondent QC Appeal Insolvency — bankruptcy— Farm Debt MediationAct — lift of stay

91. QCCA Trudel c. BanqueToronto-Dominion

03/19/07 [2007] J.Q. no2167, 2007 QCCA413, J.E. 2007-701, EYB 2007-116838, 165A.C.W.S. (3d) 987

Giroux,François M.

Respondent QC Appeal Class action —authorization —hypothecs — publicationof rights — acquittance ofa debt



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


92. QCCA Curateur public duQuébec c. Centrehospitalieruniversitaire deQuébec

01/11/07 [2007] J.Q. no 17,2007 QCCA 31

Cantin,Philippe

Respondent QC Appeal Persons — care —integrity of the person —confinement in aninstitution

93. QCCA Sheppard c. RoyalInstitution for theAdvancement ofLearning(McGill University)

01/09/07 [2007] Q.J. No. 77,2007 QCCA 46,J.E. 2007-248,EYB 2007-112066, 165A.C.W.S. (3d) 286

Gagnon,Nathalie

Respondent QC Appeal Labour — dismissal —just cause — contract ofemployment —resiliation

94. QCCA Thibault c.Assurancesgénérales desCaisses Desjardins

12/08/06 [2006] J.Q. no13344, 2006QCCA 1599, EYB2006-111820, 165A.C.W.S. (3d) 347

Cantin,Philippe

Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — insurance ofgoods — exclusionclause — waiver

95. QCCA JetsGo Corporation(Syndic de)

11/27/06 [2006] J.Q. no13607, 2006QCCA 1521, J.E.2006-2336, 163A.C.W.S. (3d)1011, EYB 2006-111320

Poplaw,MasonBourbonnais,Miguel

Appellant QC Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency — trustee —letter of credit — bank

96. QCCA Aubin c. Moumdjian 10/03/06 [2006] J.Q. no12186, [2006] Q.J.No. 12186, 2006QCCA 1264, J.E.2006-2056, [2006]R.R.A. 827, 42C.C.L.T. (3d) 242,EYB 2006-110126, 2006CarswellQue8720, 164A.C.W.S. (3d) 531

Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — neurosurgeon— disc herniation



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


97. QCCA Poupart c. Sécuriténationale, compagnied'assurances

09/12/06 [2006] J.Q. no10309, 2006QCCA 1184, J.E.2006-1895, 152A.C.W.S. (3d) 768,EYB 2006-109729

Cantin,Philippe

Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure —jurisdiction of superiorcourt — arbitration —compromissory clause

98. QCCA Daviault c.Climatisation GR inc.

05/17/06 [2006] J.Q. no4637, 2006 QCCA689, J.E. 2006-1108, 150A.C.W.S. (3d) 293,EYB 2006-105527


Respondent QC Appeal Class action –Authorization – Similar orrelated issues –Assignment of claims –Contracts – Defect ofconsent – Fraud –Liability of financialinstitutions.

99. QCCA Kruger inc. c.Première nation desBetsiamites

04/28/06 [2006] J.Q. no3932, [2006] Q.J.No. 3932, 2006QCCA 569, J.E.2006-1004, [2006]3 C.N.L.R. 19, 149A.C.W.S. (3d) 864

Potter, SimonV.


Aboriginal law — lands— logging — safeguardorder

100. QCCA Québec (Procureurgénéral) c.Première nation deBetsiamites

04/28/06 [2006] J.Q. no3931, [2006] Q.J.No. 3931, 2006QCCA 567

Potter, SimonV.


Aboriginal law — lands— logging — safeguardorder



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


101. QCCA Université deMontréal c.Commissiondes droits de lapersonneet des droits de lajeunesse

04/10/06 [2006] J.Q. no3357, 2006 QCCA508, J.E. 2006-991, 148 A.C.W.S.(3d) 69, EYB2005-103827

Baril, André Appellant QC Appeal Labour — human rights— jurisdiction ofgrievance arbitrator andof Québec Human RightsTribunal

102. QCCA TIP InvestmentAdvisors Ltd. c.Gilbert

02/20/06 [2006] J.Q. no1718, 2006 QCCA275


Respondent QC Appeal Winding up — civilprocedure — safeguardorder

103. QCCA Syndicat national desemployéeset employés duCentre de soinsprolongés Grace Dart(CSN) c. Holligin-Richards

02/07/06 [2006] J.Q. no952, 2006 QCCA158, 147 A.C.W.S.(3d) 721, EYB2006-100971

Gagnon,Nathalie

Respondent QC Appeal Labour — grievancearbitration — dismissal —right to arbitration

104. QCCA Beaupré c. Lavoie 01/12/06 [2006] J.Q. no109, 2006 QCCA36

Baril, André Respondent QC Appeal Labour — grievancearbitration — claim forloss of revenue anddefamation — jurisdictionof arbitrator

105. QCCA Terreault c. Bigras 12/15/05 [2005] J.Q. no18585, 2005QCCA 1243,[2006] R.J.Q. 126J.E. 2006-125,145 A.C.W.S. (3d)166, EYB 2005-99100

Poupart,Emmanuelle

Respondent QC Appeal Legal ethics — feeagreement —cancellation of theagreement — agreementgiving to the legalprofession a profit—seeking or commercialcharacter

106. QCCA Ruffo (Re) 12/09/05 [2005] J.Q. no17953, [2005] Q.J.No. 17953, 2005QCCA 1197,[2006] R.J.Q. 26,J.E. 2006-60, 144

Bélanger,Marie-Eve

Friend of theCourt

QC Report of theCourt ofAppealregarding arequest for theremoval of

Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanada

Discipline and ethics —legal professions —judges — removal of aprovincial court judge



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


A.C.W.S. (3d) 863 Judge Ruffo dismissed(Docket31304,18/05/2006)

107. QCCA Trikon Technologiesinc. c. Panametricsinc.

09/07/05 [2005] J.Q. no13267, 2005QCCA 796

Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure —contract — arbitrationclause

108. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada ltée c.Canada (Procureuregénérale)

08/22/05 [2005] J.Q. no11174, 2005QCCA 725, 142A.C.W.S. (3d) 423

Potter, SimonV.

Appellant QC Appeal Reversed byCanada(AttorneyGeneral) v.JTI-MacdonaldCorp., 2007SCC 30;[2007] 2S.C.R. 610

Constitutional — freedomof expression —advertising andpromotion of tobacco

109. QCCA Rothmans, Benson &Hedges inc. c.Canada (Procureuregénérale)

08/22/05 [2005] J.Q. no11175, 2005QCCA 727, 142A.C.W.S. (3d) 592

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Reversed byCanada(AttorneyGeneral) v.JTI-MacdonaldCorp., 2007SCC 30;[2007] 2S.C.R. 610

Constitutional — freedomof expression —advertising andpromotion of tobacco

110. QCCA Therrien c. Launay 07/06/05 [2005] J.Q. no9043, 2005 QCCA665, J.E. 2005-1345, 141A.C.W.S. (3d) 669


Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket31151,

Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — diagnosis



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


16/02/2006)

111. QCCA Association deschiropraticiens duQuébec c. Office desprofessions duQuébec

02/25/05 [2005] J.Q. no1087, 2005 QCCA189, [2005] R.J.Q.691, J.E. 2005-559, 137 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1236

Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Professions —chiropractors —interpretation of theChiropractic Act —diagnosis

112. QCCA Tecsys inc. c. Sociétéen commandite CDTIde Montréal

12/10/04 [2004] J.Q. no13394, 137A.C.W.S. (3d) 191,2004 CanLII46686

Potter, SimonV.


Lease — interpretation —determination of rights —rent — arrears

113. QCCA Citadelle,Coopérative deproducteurs de siropd'érable c. Régie desmarchés agricoles etalimentaries duQuébec

12/03/04 [2004] J.Q. no13206, J.E. 2005-193, 136 A.C.W.S.(3d) 981

Renaud,Madeleine


Agri-food — maple syrup— marketing control

114. QCCA Produits alimentairesJacques et Fils inc. c.Régie des marchésagricoles etalimentaires duQuébec

12/03/04 [2004] J.Q. no13205, 136A.C.W.S. (3d) 980,REJB 2004-81157

Renaud,Madeleine

Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed

Agri-food — maple syrup— marketing control



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


(Docket30772,30/06/2005)

115. QCCA Chambre de lasécurité financière c.Carciero

11/10/04 [2004] J.Q. no12036


Respondent QC Appeal Disciplinary law –Securities – Statutoryoffenses – Act respectingthe distribution offinancial products andservices.

116. QCCA Banque Amex duCanada c. Procureurgénéral du Québec

09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10130, 135A.C.W.S. (3d) 29

Tremblay,Gérald R.


Class action —authorization — civilprocedure — joinder ofactions — functus officioI

117. QCCA Banque canadienneimpériale decommerce c.Procureur général duQuébec

09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10127, 135A.C.W.S. (3d) 24

Tremblay,Gérald R.



118. QCCA Banque de Montréalc. Procureur généraldu Québec

09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10133, 135A.C.W.S. (3d) 30,REJB 2004-70909

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed




REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


(Docket30645,10/03/2005)

119. QCCA Banque Laurentiennedu Canada c.Procureur général duQuébec

09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10129, 135A.C.W.S. (3d) 26,EYB 2004-70919

Tremblay,Gérald R.


Declaratory judgment —class action — joinder ofactions — right to beheard — adjudicationbeyond the conclusions

120. QCCA Banque MBNACanada c. Procureurgénéral du Québec

09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10134, J.E. 2004-1921, 135A.C.W.S. (3d) 31

Tremblay,Gérald R.



121. QCCA Banque Nationale duCanada c. Procureurgénéral du Québec

09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10128, 135A.C.W.S. (3d) 28

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30648,10/03/2005)


122. QCCA Banque Royale duCanada c. Procureurgénéral du Québec

09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10132, 135A.C.W.S. (3d) 27

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to the

Class action —authorization — civilprocedure — joinder of



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


SupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30649,10/03/2005)

actions — functus officioI

123. QCCA Banque Toronto-Dominion c.Procureur général duQuébec

09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10123, 135A.C.W.S. (3d) 25

Tremblay,Gérald R.



124. QCCA Fédération desproducteursacéricoles du Québecc. Citadelle,coopérative deproducteurs de siropd'érable

07/15/04 [2004] J.Q. no7880, J.E. 2004-1583, 134A.C.W.S. (3d) 5,2004 CanLII 3284

Renaud,Madeleine

Respondent QC Appeal Agri-food — maple syrup— marketing control

125. QCCA Perez c. Bank ofNova Scotia

05/07/04 [2004] J.Q. no6451

Tremblay,Gérald R.Giroux,François M.

Respondent QC Appeal Private international law— declinatory exceptions— defendants' activitiesin Québec

126. QCCA Hrtschan c. Ville deMontréal

03/22/04 [2004] J.Q. no2772,[2004] R.J.Q.1073,J.E. 2004-799,[2004] R.R.A. 329,133 A.C.W.S. (3d)708, REJB 2004-

Arpin, Sophie Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket

Municipal — civil liability— defamation — mayor



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


55545 30354,06/01/2005)

127. QCCA Ville de Montréal c.M.J. Oppenheim

03/22/04 [2004] J.Q. no2773, J.E. 2004-767, [2004] R.R.A.325, 133 A.C.W.S.(3d) 539

Arpin, Sophie Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — insurancepolicy — defamation —civil liability

128. QCCA Ordre des dentistesdu Québec c. Forget

03/10/04 [2004] J.Q. no3437

Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — disciplinecommittee — dentists

129. QCCA Wolofsky c. GestionKenmont inc.

02/03/04 [2004] J.Q. no620, J.E. 2004-385, 133 A.C.W.S.(3d) 364

Poplaw,Mason

Appellant QC Appeal Property law —servitudes — servitudeby destination ofproprietor

130. QCCA Essaris c. Kiriazis 12/19/03 [2003] J.Q. no19212, J.E. 2004-269, 131 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1141

Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Appeal Real estate — leases —publication of rights —cancellation — safeguardorder

131. QCCA SSQ Sociétéd'assurance-vie inc.c. La Société desservices dentaires(A.C.D.Q.) inc.

12/01/03 [2003] J.Q. no17929

Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure —acquiescence in ademand — letterconfirming theunconditional nature ofthe acquiescence

132. QCCA UL Canada inc. c.Procureur général duQuébec

10/01/03 [2003] J.Q. no13505, [2003]R.J.Q. 2729, 234D.L.R. (4th) 398,J.E. 2003-1975,10 Admin. L.R.(4th) 36

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Affirmed byUL CanadaInc. c.Québec(Procureurgénéral),2005 CSC 10,[2005] 1R.C.S. 143

Constitutional —distribution of legislativepowers — colour ofmargarine — freedom ofexpression



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


133. QCCA Dans l'affaire de lafaillite de : Réjean St-Pierre c. RaymondChabot inc.

09/09/03 [2003] J.Q. no11751, J.E. 2003-1712, 127A.C.W.S. (3d) 400

Poplaw,Mason

Respondent QC Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency — proof ofclaim — cattle broker —seizure and sale ofcalves — preferentialpayments

134. QCCA Laforce c. Dumont 05/05/03 [2003] J.Q. no4945, J.E. 2003-959, [2003] R.R.A.422, 125 A.C.W.S.(3d) 911

Platts, DavidE.

Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — vicariousliability — causation


04/28/03 [2003] J.Q. no4362, J.E. 2003-917, [2003] R.R.A.400

Dufour, Marc Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — childbirth —caesarean

136. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 04/17/03 [2003] J.Q. no5510

Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Professions — lawyersand attorneys — security— hypothecs —contracts

137. QCCA Enterprises R & G St-Laurent inc. C.Québec (Procureurgénéral) (Ministèredes Transports duQuébec)

04/17/03 [2003] J.Q. no5450

Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Professions — lawyersand attorneys — security— hypothecs —contracts

138. QCCA Lévesque c. Hudon 04/07/03 [2003] J.Q. no3320, [2003]R.J.Q. 1081, J.E.2003-828, REJB2003-39879, 125A.C.W.S. (3d) 994

Tremblay,Gérald R.Giroux,François M.

Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket

Corporations —oppression remedy —unanimous shareholdersagreement — referral toarbitration



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


29810,09/10/2003)

139. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 03/13/03 [2003] J.Q. no4495, J.E. 2003-747

Dufresne,Marie-Ève

Appellant QC Appeal International private law— declaratory judgment— forum non conveniens— action in damagesfiled in Texas


02/21/03 [2003] J.Q. no984, J.E. 2003-472

Tremblay,Gérald R.Lortie, Jean


Insurance — class action— value of payment ofannual premiums

141. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 02/11/03 [2003] J.Q. no669, J.E. 2003-493

Potter, SimonV.

Respondent QC Appeal Corporations —shareholders —unanimous shareholdersagreement — sale ofshares — dividends


01/23/03 [2003] J.Q. no4024, J.E. 2003-383, [2003] R.R.A.127

Cantin,Philippe

Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — subrogation— exception to theinsurer's subrogatoryclaim

143. QCCA Consultants Aecominc. C. Société duQuébec

12/04/02 [2002] J.Q. no5287

Poplaw,Mason

Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket29567,

Corporations —receiver—manager —oppression — abuse ofright by directors



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


02/10/2003)


12/04/02 [2002] J.Q. no5286

Poplaw,Mason


Corporations —receiver—manager —oppression — abuse ofright by directors


12/04/02 [2002] J.Q. no5282, J.E. 2003-45, 120 A.C.W.S.(3d) 768, REJB2002-36022

Poplaw,Mason


Corporations — receiver— manager —oppression — abuse ofright by directors


11/25/02 [2002] J.Q. no5088, J.E. 2003-32, 119 A.C.W.S.(3d) 260, REJB2002-35845

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Labour — dismissal —senior manager — noticeof termination

147. QCCA Han c. Demers 10/22/02 [2002] J.Q. no4749, 118A.C.W.S. (3d) 57


Appellant QC Appeal Reversed byBanquenationale deParis(Canada) c.165836Canada Inc.,2004 CSC 37;

Obligations —transaction — offer tosettle



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


[2004] 2R.C.S. 45

148. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 10/22/02 [2002] J.Q. no4750


Respondent QC Appeal Reversed byBanquenationale deParis(Canada) c.165836Canada Inc.,2004 CSC 37;[2004] 2R.C.S. 45

Obligations —transaction — offer tosettle

149. QCCA Thibault c. Marina dela Chaudière inc.

09/09/02 [2002] J.Q. no3859, [2002]R.J.Q. 3005, 118A.C.W.S. (3d) 208,REJB 2002-33889, J.E. 2002-1693, 2002 CanLII41226

Tremblay,Gérald R.Potter, SimonV.

Appelant(Tremblay)Respondent(Potter)

QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket29449,12/06/2003)

Contracts — sale ofbusiness — distributionof auto parts —noncompetitionagreement —assessment of damages

150. QCCA Bitton v. AppleCanada Inc.

08/23/02 [2002] J.Q. no3571, [2002]R.R.A. 771

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Real estate — sale ofland — professionalliability — notary

151. QCCA N.F. c. Montréal (Villede)

06/14/02 [2002] J.Q. no3141, REJB 2002-32242

Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — civilprocedure — action inwarranty

152. QCCA Masson c. Centre desanté et de servicessociaux de St-Jérôme(CSSS)

06/04/02 [2002] J.Q. no3086


Appellant QC Appeal Corporate law — value ofshares — interest



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


153. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 05/08/02 [2002] J.Q. no1057, [2002]R.R.A. 296, 116A.C.W.S. (3d) 126,REJB 2002-30304

Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — duty to inform

154. QCCA Matériaux deconstructionOldcastle CanadaInc. c. St-Bruno-de-Montarville (Ville de)

05/08/02 [2002] J.Q. no1056, [2002]R.J.Q. 1262, J.E.2002-937, [2002]R.D.I. 241, [2002]R.R.A. 317, 2002CanLII 41120, 116A.C.W.S. (3d) 131,REJB 2002-31662, REJB2002-34963

Poplaw,Mason

Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — promise ofsale — preference clause— assignment of rights— Paulian Action —damages — extrajudicialfees

155. QCCA Watters v. White 05/08/02 [2002] J.Q. no1058

Poplaw,Mason

Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — promise ofsale — preference clause— assignment of rights— Paulian Action —damages — extrajudicialfees


03/18/02 [2002] J.Q. no 464 Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Municipal — contracts —liability — infrastructureproject

157. QCCA Organisme canadiende réglementation ducommerce desvaleurs mobilières(OCRCVM) c.Beaudouin

03/07/02 [2002] J.Q. no696, J.E. 2002-543, REJB 2002-30825



Insurance — class action— civil procedure —authorization — right ofappeal



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY



02/12/02 [2002] J.Q. no194, [2002] R.J.Q.328, J.E. 2002-402, 112 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1014

Deschamps,Michel


Winding up — funds —loss of legal status


02/05/02 [2002] J.Q. no279, [2002] Q.J.No. 279

Gagnon,Nathalie

Respondent QC Appeal Labour — grievancearbitration — judicialreview

160. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 01/23/02 [2002] J.Q. no 68,J.E. 2002-297,[2002] R.D.I. 36,113 A.C.W.S. (3d)154

Tremblay,Gérald R.Dufour, Marc

Respondent QC Appeal Real estate — contracts— commercial lease —resiliation — assignmentclause


01/17/02 [2002] J.Q. no 28 Poplaw,Mason

Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — lease —eviction of the lessee —transaction

162. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 11/12/01 [2001] J.Q. no5990

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Contracts — obligations— partnerships — lawfirm — partner leaving


11/04/01 [2001] J.Q. no5001

Deschamps,Michel

Appellant QC Appeal Security — contracts —discharge of debtors



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


164. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 10/16/01 [2001] J.Q. no4916, 27 M.P.L.R.(3d) 267

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Constitutional —municipal amalgamations— injunction


10/16/01 [2001] J.Q. no4821, [2001]R.J.Q. 2520, J.E.2001-1961, 27M.P.L.R. (3d) 173,108 A.C.W.S. (3d)980

Tremblay,Gérald R.


Constitutional —municipal amalgamations— injunction

166. QCCA Scotia McLeod Inc. c.Banque de Nouvelle-Écosse

08/28/01 [2001] J.Q. no3815, [2001]R.J.Q. 2099, J.E.2001-1654, 27C.C.P.B. 169, 108A.C.W.S. (3d) 89,REJB 2001-25542


Appellant QC Appeal Confirmed byBank of NovaScotia v.Thibault, 2004SCC 29,[2004] 1 SCR758

Annuities – Self-directedregistered retirementsavings plan – Exemptionfrom seizure – Right towithdraw funds –Alienation of capital.


06/12/01 [2001] J.Q. no2783, J.E. 2001-1273, [2001]R.R.A. 567, REJB2001-24643, 107A.C.W.S. (3d) 694,2001 CanLII20632

Poupart,Emmanuelle

Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — neurosurgeon— diagnosis — medicaltreatment


05/03/01 [2001] J.Q. no2228

Schenke,Stephen G.

Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — contract ofenterprise — awarding ofthe contract — good faith— compliance of bid

169. QCCA Han c. Demers 04/30/01 [2001] J.Q. no1893, [2001]R.R.A. 310, 2001


Appellant QC Appeal Medical — civil liability —medical malpractice —diagnosis



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


CanLII 14425

170. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 04/09/01 [2001] J.Q. no1446, [2001]R.J.Q. 846, J.E.2001-812, [2001]R.R.A. 332, 107A.C.W.S. (3d) 287,REJB 2001-23520

Deschamps,Michel

Appellant QC Appeal Financial institutions —banks — negotiableinstrument — clearingrules

171. QCCA Teixeira c. TetraVision Inc.

03/22/01 [2001] J.Q. no1219, J.E. 2001-747, 2001 CanLII5481, REJB 2001-23492


Respondent QC Appeal Class action – Criteria forauthorization – Leasing –Setting-up of acomputerized system ofadvertising.


02/19/01 [2001] Q.J. No.592, [2001] R.R.A.39

Schenke,Steve G.

Appellant QC Appeal All-risk insurance —claim for insuranceindemnity — constructionproject — faulty design


02/01/01 [2001] J.Q. no258, [2001] R.J.Q.875, 200 D.L.R.(4th) 470, J.E.2001-424, 2001CanLII 17930,104 A.C.W.S. (3d)784

Tremblay,Gérald R.


Professions — lawyers— eligibility for theprofession


01/09/01 [2001] J.Q. no 9,[2001] R.J.D.T. 10,J.E. 2001-259,102 A.C.W.S. (3d)909, REJB 2001-21823

Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Labour — labourstandards — overtime —application of the LabourStandards Act — seniormanager



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY



10/23/00 [2000] J.Q. no3776, J.E. 2000-2005, [2000] R.D.I.563, 48 R.P.R.(3d) 22, 100A.C.W.S. (3d) 890

Deschamps,Michel

Appellant QC Appeal Hypothecs —hypothecary remedies —taking in payment —emphyteusis

176. QCCA McMahon Essaiminc. c. ToulonDevelopment Corp.

06/28/00 [2000] J.Q. no2117


Respondent QC Appeal Contracts and obligations– Suretyship – Paulianaction – Transfer ofmoney – Discharge ofpayment.

177. QCCA Fortier c. Lavoie 06/12/00 [2000] J.Q. no1921, J.E. 2000-1258, 99 A.C.W.S.(3d) 40, REJB2000-18714


Appellant QC Interlocutory Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilprocedure — medicalexamination — fees paidin part by the other party

178. QCCA Watters v. White 05/01/00 [2000] J.Q. no1548, [2000] R.D.I.202, 98 A.C.W.S.(3d) 927

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Contractual obligations— sale and delivery ofimmoveable property —forced execution —permanent injunction —transfer of title

179. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 04/17/00 [2000] J.Q. no1215, [2000]R.J.Q. 1086, J.E.2000-856, 98A.C.W.S. (3d) 809

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Publishing andpublications — legalpublications — access tocourt decisions inQuébec


04/04/00 [2000] J.Q. no1040, J.E. 2000-777, 98 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1108,REJB 2000-17480, 2000CanLII 7400

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket27953,

Extra-contractual liability— prescription — realestate — purchase ofimmoveable — leaseagreement — option torenew



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


25/01/2001)


03/02/00 [2000] J.Q. no6184


Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — post-operativefollow-up

182. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 12/14/99 [1999] J.Q. no5502, [2000]R.J.Q. 58, J.E.2000-126, REJB1999-15659

Poplaw,Mason

Respondent QC Appeal Movable hypothec —hypothecary remedies —sale by judicial authority


10/04/99 [1999] J.Q. no4446, J.E. 99-2033, [1999]R.R.A. 817

Poplaw,Mason

Appellant QC Appeal Reversed inpart byPrévost-Masson v.General Trustof Canada,2001 SCC 87,[2001] 3S.C.R. 882

Contracts — obligations— obligations in solidum— professional liability —chartered accountant

184. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 06/03/99 [1999] J.Q. no1790, J.E. 99-1343, 89 A.C.W.S.(3d) 281, D.T.E.99T-598, REJB1999-12823

Tremblay,Gérald R.Gagnon,Nathalie

Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadiscontinued(Docket27464,10/22/2000)

Labour — dismissal —just cause — seniordirector


03/01/99 [1999] Q.J. No.572

Gagnon,Nathalie

Respondent QC Appeal Labour — wrongfuldismissal — sufficientcause



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY



12/02/98 [1998] J.Q. no3667, J.E. 99-253,[1999] R.J.D.T. 9,84 A.C.W.S. (3d)902

Baril, André Appellant QC Appeal Labour — unions —certification — sale ofundertaking


10/29/98 [1998] J.Q. no3165

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Contract — formationand execution — sale ofland — damages — lossof profits —reimbursement ofexpenses — damage toreputation — evidence —admissions

188. QCCA Han c. Demers 06/15/98 [1998] J.Q. no1944, [1998]R.J.Q. 1722,J.E. 98-1462,82 A.C.W.S. (3d)244

Giroux,François M.

Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure — partialannulment of anarbitration award —service of proceedings

189. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 06/15/98 [1998] J.Q. no1946, [1998]R.J.Q. 1731,J.E. 98-1463,82 A.C.W.S. (3d)282, REJB 1998-06799

Poplaw,Mason


Bankruptcy andinsolvency — civilprocedure — recusal of ajudge — reasonableapprehension of bias


06/05/98 [1998] J.Q. no1866, 80 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1108, J.E. 98-1367, REJB 1998-06604


Appellant QC Appeal Medical — disciplinecommittee — judicialreview — rules of naturaljustice



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY



04/29/98 [1998] J.Q. no1257, [1998]R.R.A. 385

Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — surgery —post-operatory follow-up


02/17/98 [1998] Q.J. No.373, J.E. 98-518,[1998] R.D.F. 183,REJB 1998-04774

Gagnon,Nathalie

Respondent QC Appeal Family law — custodyand access to children —interest of childparamount


12/02/97 [1997] J.Q. no4040

Tremblay,Gérald R.


Evidence — solicitor-client privilege

194. QCCA Watters v. White 11/24/97 [1997] J.Q. no4132, [1998]R.R.A. 1


Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — neurosurgeon

195. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 09/29/97 [1997] J.Q. no3204, [1997]R.J.Q. 2663, 156D.L.R. (4th) 376,J.E. 97-1866

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Successions —administration — trusts— termination of trust —production — annualaccounts


06/09/97 [1997] J.Q. no2125, J.E. 97-1356, 79 C.P.R.(3d) 403, 73A.C.W.S. (3d) 189,REJB 1997-01073, 1997CanLII 10706

Renaud,Madeleine

Intervenor QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket26256,30/04/1998)

Agri-food — hog sale —modification of regulation— jurisdiction of Régiedes marchés agricoles etalimentaires du Québec



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


197. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 05/14/97 [1997] J.Q. no1603, [1997]R.R.A. 310



Civil liability —investments — kiting —financial situation ofcorporations


05/07/97 [1997] J.Q. no1586


Respondent QC Appeal Hypothecs —hypothecary remedies —description of theimmoveable

199. QCCA Lévesque c. Hudon 03/11/97 [1997] J.Q. no 796 Gagné,Michel

Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability —medical malpractice


03/10/97 [1997] Q.J. No.692, J.E. 97-611


Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — dismissalof the action —prescription

201. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 03/10/97 [1997] Q.J. No.693


Respondent QC Appeal Medical malpractice —dismissal of the action —extinctive prescription


02/25/97 [1997] J.Q. no 575 Bélanger,Philippe H.

Appellant QC Appeal Banks — winding up —irrevocable letter of credit


02/21/97 [1997] J.Q. no513, [1997] R.J.Q.816, 148 D.L.R.(4th) 255, J.E. 97-588, 71 A.C.W.S.(3d) 71, 1997

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanada

Elections — contestation— illegal or corruptpractice



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


CanLII 10409 dismissed(Docket25848,16/10/1997)


12/16/96 [1996] J.Q. no4136

Poplaw,Mason

Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — installationof fuel tanks — paving —leak

205. QCCA Han c. Demers 03/06/96 [1996] J.Q. no524, J.E. 96-602,EYB 1996-71808,61 A.C.W.S. (3d)1083

Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Construction — call fortenders — bid depositorysystem — conformity ofbid

206. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 02/21/96 [1996] J.Q. no339, [1996] R.D.J.193

Tardif, AlainN.

Appellant QC Interlocutory Bankruptcy andinsolvency — proposal —commercial leases —rents — stay


02/12/96 [1996] J.Q. no 293 Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Contracts —interpretation — leasingagreement — priceprovision



Appellant QC Appeal Interpretation of contract— fixed lease rate —layman


12/12/95 [1995] J.Q. no1140, J.E. 96-126,[1996] R.R.A. 25

Dufour, Marc Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — duty to inform


12/12/95 [1995] J.Q. no1112, J.E. 96-121,[1996] R.D.J. 62,59 A.C.W.S. (3d)1033

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure —uncontested — judicialauthorizations —executor — request fordismissal — s.885 Codede procédure civile —statutory interpretation



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


211. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 11/22/95 [1995] J.Q. no931, J.E. 96-2,EYB 1995-57702,[1996] R.D.I. 6

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Servitude — perpetuity— immoveable —electricity — transmissionand telephone lines


10/06/95 [1995] J.Q. no727, [1995] R.J.Q.597, [1995] R.D.J.597

Renaud,Madeleine


Labour — work stoppage— essential publicservices — bus service— power of council toorder return to work

213. QCCA Watters v. White 08/28/95 [1995] J.Q. no663, J.E. 95-1727,57 A.C.W.S. (3d)754, EYB 1995-56924

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Securities law —commission fees —public order — validity ofcontracts — jurisdiction— prescription — actionsin warranty

214. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 08/08/95 [1995] J.Q. no529, J.E. 95-1631,[1995] R.D.J. 537,57 A.C.W.S. (3d)738

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Insurance policy —jurisdiction — lis pendens— forum non conveniens— prescription


05/18/95 [1995] J.Q. no445, J.E. 95-1183,[1995] R.R.A. 589,55 A.C.W.S. (3d)432

Deschamps,Michel

Appellant QC Appeal Civil liability —professional liability —auditor


04/21/95 [1995] J.Q. no420, [1995] R.J.Q.1329, J.E. 95-1091, 55 A.C.W.S.(3d) 769

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt of

Canada Election Act —contestation of election— presentation of notice— time frame — statuteinterpretation



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


Canadadismissed(Docket24729,29/06/1995)


02/23/95 [1995] J.Q. no 184 Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Contracts — contract ofadhesion — no legalrelation between theparties

218. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 01/16/95 [1995] J.Q. no 25,[1995] R.J.Q. 63,J.E. 95-222,[1995] R.R.A. 4,52 A.C.W.S. (3d)1013

Tremblay,Gérald R.


Line of credit — security— respondent seizure —loss of profits —prescription


11/28/94 [1994] J.Q. no1000, J.E. 95-19,EYB 1994-55894

Dufour, Marc Respondent QC Appeal Administrative law — realestate assessment —judicial review — powersof superior court

220. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 11/28/94 [1994] J.Q. no999, J.E. 95-87,67 Q.A.C. 1,[1995] R.D.J. 33,51 A.C.W.S. (3d)1075, EYB 1994-28943

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Union grievance —dismissal — arbitration —admissibility of evidence— hearsay — burden ofproof


08/31/94 [1994] J.Q. no611, [1995] R.D.J.118, 49 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1305

Potter, SimonV.

Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —interlocutory injunction —sale of business —noncompetition clause



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY



06/02/94 [1994] J.Q. no458, [1994] R.J.Q.1269, J.E. 94-979,48 A.C.W.S. (3d)292

Tremblay,Gérald R.


Insurance —enforcement of foreignjudgement —executory/final judgment— cross-claim


05/24/94 [1994] J.Q. no447, [1994] R.J.Q.1493, J.E. 94-1074, 48 A.C.W.S.(3d) 907, EYB1994-59173

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure — costs— abuse of procedures— specific orders — legalfees —criteria tocondemn lawyer for costs


01/24/94 [1994] J.Q. no 48,[1994] R.J.Q. 289,J.E. 94-250, 60Q.A.C. 50, 45A.C.W.S. (3d) 673

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Crown immunity —senior civil servant —dismissal — injunction


12/23/93 [1993] J.Q. no2222, [1994]R.J.Q. 29, J.E. 94-88, 61 Q.A.C. 307,44 A.C.W.S. (3d)1020, EYB 1993-64306, 1993CanLII 4401

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure —mandamus — Barreaudu Québec — judicialreview


12/17/93 [1993] J.Q. no2254, J.E. 94-193,60 Q.A.C. 168,[1994] R.D.J. 172,44 A.C.W.S. (3d)1199, EYB 1994-64491

Arpin, Sophie Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —interlocutory —examination on discoveryafter defence



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY



07/30/93 [1993] J.Q. no1204, [1993] Q.J.No. 1204, [1993]R.J.Q. 2070, J.E.93-1420, 58Q.A.C. 161, 42A.C.W.S. (3d) 75

Tremblay,Gérald R.Deschamps,Michel


Winding up — registeredpension plans — depositadministration contracts— priority

228. QCCA Fortier c. Lavoie 07/30/93 [1993] J.Q. no1203, [1993] Q.J.No. 1203, J.E. 93-1419, 58 Q.A.C.211, [1994] R.L.268, 42 A.C.W.S.(3d) 76

Tremblay,Gérald R.Deschamps,Michel

Intervenor QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket23851,10/02/1994)

Winding up — mutual lifeinsurance society —provisional liquidator —priority claim

229. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 07/06/93 [1993] J.Q. no1201, [1994]R.D.J. 13, EYB1993-59194, 41A.C.W.S. (3d) 799

Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —dilatory exceptions —particulars


05/19/93 [1993] J.Q. no632, J.E. 93-874,56 Q.A.C. 215,[1994] R.L. 126,39 A.C.W.S. (3d)1120

Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket23633,23/09/1993)

Contracts — attribution ofa contract by a publicbody — call for tenders— injunction —declaratory judgment



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


231. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 03/11/93 [1993] J.Q. no 436 Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Civil liability — mandate— securitiesmanagement agreement— duty to inform —negligence




Winding up — provisionalexecution of a superiorcourt judgment



Intervenor QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket23851,10/02/1994)

Winding up — motion fordirections — stay —priority claims


02/22/93 [1993] J.Q. no 275 Renaud,Madeleine

Respondent QC Appeal Constitutional —Competition Act —declaratory judgment


01/15/93 [1993] J.Q. no 1,[1993] Q.J. No. 1,[1993] R.J.Q. 375,102 D.L.R. (4th)289, J.E. 93-329,53 Q.A.C. 79,48 C.P.R. (3d)

Potter, SimonV.

Respondent QC Appeal Affirmed byRJR -MacDonaldInc. v.Canada(AttorneyGeneral),

Constitutional — freedomof expression —advertising andpromotion of tobacco —stay — relief fromcompliance withregulations



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


417, 38 A.C.W.S.(3d) 55

[1994] 1S.C.R. 311

236. QCCA Lévesque c. Hudon 03/30/92 [1992] J.Q. no495, [1993] R.L. 4,32 A.C.W.S. (3d)1071

Potter, SimonV.

Appellant QC Appeal Corporations — directorsand officers — right toindemnification

237. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 03/16/92 [1992] J.Q. no447, 95 D.L.R.(4th) 644, J.E. 92-596, 46 Q.A.C. 21,[1992] R.D.J. 333,32 A.C.W.S. (3d)699

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Interlocutory Environmental law —class action — civilprocedure — motion tostrike paragraphs —modification of the natureof the remedy


01/29/92 [1992] J.Q. no 76,J.E. 92-336,[1992] R.D.J. 358,31 A.C.W.S. (3d)539

Poplaw,Mason

Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —cross-demand —connectivity between thecauses of action


12/30/91 [1991] J.Q. no2310, J.E. 92-136,44 Q.A.C. 271,[1992] R.R.A. 3,31 A.C.W.S. (3d)162


Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability —medical malpractice —diagnosis — prescribedmedication


07/30/91 [1991] J.Q. no1264, [1991]R.J.Q. 1852, J.E.91-1270, 40Q.A.C. 200, 28A.C.W.S. (3d) 470

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Interlocutory Expropriation —jurisdiction of Court ofQuébec (expropriationchamber) — assessmentof damages

241. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. C.Conseil québécoissur le tabac et la

06/07/91 [1991] J.Q. no1025, J.E. 91-1034, [1991] R.L.646, 47 C.L.R.

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupreme

Construction — defect —architects — civil liability



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


santé 213, 27 A.C.W.S.(3d) 399

Court ofCanadadismissed(Docket22641,06/02/1992)

242. QCCA Han c. Demers 06/07/91 [1991] J.Q. no1026

Tremblay,Gérald R.


Construction — defect —architects — civil liability

243. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 06/06/91 [1991] J.Q. no1068, [1992]R.D.J. 1, 27,A.C.W.S. (3d) 797,EYB 1991-57899,J.E. 91-1114

Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —incidental proceedings —illegal amendment —extinctive prescription


06/03/91 [1991] J.Q. no1002, J.E. 91-1029, 51 Q.A.C.107, [1991] R.D.J.466, 27 A.C.W.S.(3d) 610

Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket22623,16/01/1992)

Company law — sale ofshares — warranty —claim for sharesownership


04/10/91 [1991] J.Q. no630, J.E. 91-672,EYB 1991-94675

Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Contracts — publiccontracts —infrastructure works —execution on contractual



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


obligations


11/30/90 [1990] J.Q. no2124, J.E. 91-94[1991] R.D.I. 36

Poplaw,Mason

Appellant QC Appeal Real estate — lease —municipal taxation —taxes payable by thelandlord


11/21/90 [1990] J.Q. no2140, J.E. 91-55,[1990] R.D.J. 598,EYB 1990-58105,24 A.C.W.S. (3d)548

Gagné,Michel

Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — extinctiveprescription

248. QCCA Fortier c. Lavoie 11/07/90 [1990] J.Q. no2018

Rousse,Jacques

Respondent QC Appeal Labour — grievancearbitration — discipline —dismissal —reinstatement

249. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 09/21/90 [1990] J.Q. no1662, [1990]R.J.Q. 2498,J.E. 90-1492,32 Q.A.C. 1 ext,23 A.C.W.S. (3d)351

Renaud,Madeleine

Intervenor QC Reference Affirmed byReference reEducation Act(Que.), [1993]2 S.C.R. 511

Constitutional - education- linguistic school boards


06/19/90 [1990] J.Q. no1062, [1990]R.J.Q. 1547, J.E.90-1033

Tremblay,Gérald R.


Bankruptcy andinsolvency — trustee —proof of claim



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


251. QCCA General Accident Cied'assurance duCanada c. Duhaime

06/01/90 [1990] J.Q. no1003

Loranger,Julie-Martines

Respondent QC Appeal Insurance – Subrogatoryremedy.

252. QCCA Sivananda YogaVedanta Centre Inc.c. Val Morin(Municipalité)

03/14/90 [1990] J.Q. no445, J.E. 90-584,[1990] R.L. 204


Appellant QC Appeal Municipal taxation –Property and schooltaxes – Invalidity of theassessment roll.

253. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 03/13/90 [1990] J.Q. no424, [1990] R.D.J.249

Poplaw,Mason

Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —evidence —examinations ondiscovery after defence— communication ofexhibits


02/23/90 [1990] J.Q. no 280 Poplaw,Mason

Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — real estatebroker — sale of animmoveable — promiseof sale


02/22/90 [1990] J.Q. no278, J.E. 90-495,[1990] R.R.A. 268,19 A.C.W.S. (3d)1259


Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability —medical malpractice —diagnosis


02/06/90 [1990] J.Q. no216, [1990] R.J.Q.655, J.E. 90-422,29 Q.A.C. 251, 6C.E.L.R. (N.S.)150, 1990 CanLII3338

Tremblay,Gérald R.


Environment — classaction — air pollution —bauxite — alumina



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY



01/09/90 [1990] J.Q. no 10,[1990] R.J.Q. 121,J.E. 90-132,18 A.C.W.S. (3d)1212

Potter, SimonV.

Respondent QC Appeal Bills of exchange —cheques — banks —negligence

258. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 09/05/89 [1989] J.Q. no1606, [1989]R.J.Q. 2287, J.E.89-1416, 29Q.A.C. 199

Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket21653,01/02/1990)

Suretyship — contract ofpersonal suretyship —liberation of debtor


09/05/89 [1989] J.Q. no1605

Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket21653,01/02/1990)

Suretyship — contract ofpersonal suretyship —liberation of debtor

260. QCCA Cohen c. Hill Samuel& Co.

06/16/89 [1989] J.Q. no1066, [1989]R.J.Q. 2078, J.E.89-1265, 33Q.A.C. 1, 16A.C.W.S. (3d) 117


Respondent QC Appeal International private law –Exemplification of foreignjudgments – Diplomaticcertificate.

261. QCCA Lévesque c. Hudon 04/25/89 [1989] J.Q. no696, [1989] R.D.J.209

Potter, SimonV.

Respondent QC Interlocutory Evidence — testimony —objections — declaratoryremedy — trial judge's



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


discretion

262. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 04/20/89 [1989] J.Q. no680, J.E. 89-1567,[1989] R.D.F.Q.138, [1989] R.L.361, 15 A.C.W.S.(3d) 45

Gagnon, GuyA.

Appellant QC Appeal Tax — appeal of taxassessments — income— commission on sales

263. QCCA Banque canadienneimpériale decommerce c.Carbonneau

04/03/89 [1989] J.Q. no600, [1989] R.J.Q.1091, J.E. 89-721,EYB 1989-63412,22 Q.A.C. 115


Respondent QC Appeal Consumer protection –Annulment of contracts –Lesion between personsof full age - Assignmentof claims.


03/21/89 [1989] Q.J. No.453, J.E. 89-696,21 Q.A.C. 161,[1990] R.L. 128,14 A.C.W.S. (3d)358

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Family law — divorce —accessory measures —compensatory allowance

265. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 03/13/89 [1989] J.Q. no429, [1989] R.J.Q.820, 59 D.L.R.(4th) 743, J.E. 89-628, 25 Q.A.C.201, 42 Admin.L.R. 175, 14A.C.W.S. (3d) 167

Potter, SimonV.


Civil procedure — appeal— conservatoryintervention


02/09/89 [1989] J.Q. no218, [1989] R.J.Q.1101, J.E. 89-723,34 Q.A.C. 36, 14A.C.W.S. (3d) 67

Rousse,Jacques

Appellant QC Appeal Labour — labourstandards — notice —layoffs — differences intreatment



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY



02/01/89 [1989] J.Q. no 200 Lehoux, Jean-François

Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability — securityguards — injuries


09/29/88 [1988] J.Q. no1715

Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Real estate —commercial lease —resiliation of lease

269. QCCA Han c. Demers 09/28/88 [1988] J.Q. no1704, J.E. 88-1270, [1988]R.D.J. 580, 12A.C.W.S. (3d) 53

Tremblay,Gérald R.


Municipal — municipalcouncillors — quowarranto — right ofappeal

270. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 09/15/88 [1988] J.Q. no1650, [1988]R.J.Q. 2605, J.E.88-1229, 28Q.A.C. 228, [1988]R.D.I. 593

Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Property law —application of theconstitution or TenureSystem Act — mobilehome


05/24/88 [1988] J.Q. no896, J.E. 88-831,EYB 1988-58859

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Loans — small loans —class action



Appellant QC Interlocutory Corporations — civilprocedure — evidence —objection — right to beheard


04/29/88 [1988] J.Q. no696, J.E. 88-660,14 Q.A.C. 295,[1988] R.L. 249,

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Tax — tax evasion —prescription



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


[1988] 2 C.T.C.64, 88 D.T.C.6267

274. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 06/11/87 [1987] J.Q. no1032, 8 Q.A.C.283


Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability —transaction — opinion asto the ability to return towork


05/19/87 [1987] J.Q. no836, 8 Q.A.C. 19,[1987] R.L. 388,4 A.C.W.S. (3d)442

Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Tax — retail sales tax —assessments

276. QCCA Watters v. White 05/12/87 [1987] J.Q. no 825 Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure —arbitration —homologation of anaward

277. QCCA Fontaine c. Beique,succession

12/23/86 [1986] J.Q. no2259


Respondent QC Appeal Information not available.

278. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 02/07/86 [1986] J.Q. no 273 Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Interlocutory Oppression remedy —payment of dividends —civil procedure — dilatoryexception — jointconclusions


01/17/86 [1986] J.Q. no2835

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Municipal taxation — realestate assessment —interpretation


11/15/85 [1985] J.Q. no553, J.E. 85-1055

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — lifeinsurance — additionalbenefit in case ofaccidental death —exclusion clause



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY



09/23/85 [1985] J.Q. no592, [1985] R.D.J.608, J.E. 85-960

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —examination on discoveryafter defence — thirdparties

282. QCCA Labranche c. Ciepétrolière impérialeltée Esso


Respondent QC Appeal Competition — consumerprotection — class action— oil companies —price-fixing

283. QCCA Domaine de la rivièreinc. c. Aluminium duCanada ltée

01/25/85 [1985] J.Q. no 96,J.E. 85-249, 1985]R.D.J. 30

Tremblay,Gérald R.

Respondent QC Interlocutory Property law — evidence— right to hear expertevidence and to file anexpert report

284. QCCA Réserves du Nord(1973) Ltée (In re):Hôtel Pilma sur leLac Inc. et Bertrand

09/04/84 [1984] J.Q. no741, J.E. 84-729,[1984] C.A. 500

Tremblay,Gérald R.


Bankruptcy andinsolvency — fraudulenttransaction — settingaside

285. QCCA Gérard Nolin Ltée (Inre): Banquecanadienne nationalec.Bellavance

02/08/79 [1979] J.Q. no317, J.E. 79-235,[1979] C.A. 168

Deschamps,Michel

Appellant QC Appeal Insolvency — bankruptcy— cancellation oftransactions prior tobankruptcy — novation

286. QCCA Bean c. Langlois 12/21/67

[1967] J.Q. no 4,[1968] B.R. 135

Drouin,Richard

Appellant QC Appeal Civil liability — damages— dismissal of appeal

QCCATotalAppeals:286

québec court of appeal - marcomm.mccarthy.ca€¦ · lortie, jean respondent qc final appeal class...

Documents