quarterly report january 2015 - socwa quarterly january 2015.pdf12, 2014. as of that date, only 4 of...
TRANSCRIPT
* Berkley * Beverly Hills * Bingham Farms * Birmingham
* Clawson * Huntington Woods * Lathrup Village * Pleasant Ridge
* Royal Oak * Southfield * Southfield Township
SOCWA 3910 W. Webster Road Royal Oak Michigan 48073 Phone 248.288.5150 Fax 248.435.0310 Email [email protected]
www.socwa.org
Printed on Post Consumer Recycled Content Paper
www.socwa.org
Printed on Post Consumer Recycled Content Paper
QUARTERLY REPORT
JANUARY 2015
F BOARD OF TRUSTEES
Representative Municipality
D. Schueller City of Berkley
C. Wilson Village of Beverly Hills
D. Warren Village of Bingham Farms
P. T. O’Meara City of Birmingham
H. Drinkwine City of Clawson
C. Galed City of Huntington Woods
M. Baumgarten City of Lathrup Village
S. Pietrzak City of Pleasant Ridge
G. Rassel City of Royal Oak
L. Schultz City of Southfield
R. Walsh Township of Southfield
OFFICERS
Chairman: H. Drinkwine
Vice Chairman: G. Rassel
Secretary: C. Galed
Advisory Committee: H. Drinkwine
S. Pietrzak
J. A. McKeen General Manager
R. Jackovich Operations Manager
January 2015
Board of Trustees
Southeastern Oakland County Water Authority
Subject: Quarterly Report - January 2015
Board Members:
Attached is a copy of the Southeastern Oakland County Water Authority's Quarterly Report
covering the first six months operation of the fiscal year 2014/15. The report contains a financial
statement of the Authority's operation and an outline of projects in progress or completed during
the second quarter. The report also contains statistical information and other information of
general interest to the members of this Authority.
FINANCIAL STATEMENT
The total net operating income before depreciation for the first 6 months of 2014/15 was
$225,201.
Actual Compared to Budget
Revenue $11,437,840 - $2,993,560
Expenses $11,197,764 - $1,518,964
Net Income (before depreciation) $ 225,201 - $ 1,474,596
This level of net income is significantly lower than planned and is also significantly lower than
the net income of $710,816 recorded for the same period in the 2013/14 fiscal year. The
decrease in net income reduced our working capital to 14.1%, based on unrestricted assets, as of
December 31, 2014. This is higher than the 8.3% working capital goal approved by the Board
and it is a decrease from the 22.7% working capital as of December 27, 2013.
The decrease in revenue was primarily due to lower than planned water sales to both the member
communities (-$1,250,000) and to Bloomfield Hills and Bloomfield Twp. (-$1,695,000).
Revenue from rentals (-$26,000), grants (-$10,000) and interest (-$9,000) were also below
budget. Water sales were significantly lower than budgeted for the August to October period.
Water sales for the six month period were 6% below the actual water sales for the same period in
2013/14 and 19% below budget.
The decrease in expenses was due largely to reduced costs for water purchased (-$1,258,000),
labor (-$71,000), utilities (-$35,000), maintenance (-$25,000), supplies (-$12,000) and lower
than planned expenses for non-labor Administrative & General (-$119,000).
Capital expenditures for the first six months of the fiscal year totaled $339,962 and were for the
final expenses for the internal painting of the 7.5 million gallon reservoir at Webster Station.
Additional financial detail is attached.
II
The following is the Authority’s record of revenues and expenditures based on the average cost
per 1,000 cu. ft. of water.
2012/13
2013/14
2014/15
Over or
Under
2013/14
Total Sales (MCF) 833,666 716,634 672,438 -44,196
Water Sales $16.53 $16.47 $16.95 +0.48
Other Income .07 .07 .06 -0.01
Total Income $16.60 $16.54 $17.01 +0.47
Water Purchased for Resale 12.69 14.11 15.20 +1.09
Operating Expenses 1.30 1.39 1.45 +0.06
Fixed Charges 0.05 0.04 0.02 -0.02
Total Operating Expenses $14.04 $15.54 $16.67 +$1.13
Available for Debt Service
and Improvements
$2.56 $0.99 $0.34 -$0.65
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT
The following is a comparison of the first six months operation of the current fiscal year with the
same period of the previous fiscal year.
Revenues From the Sale of Water - $399,214
Revenues From Other Sources - 13,597
TOTAL REVENUES - $412,811
Operating Expenses
Water Purchased for Resale + $112,494
Other Operating Expenses - 25,684
Fixed Charges - 14,006
TOTAL EXPENDITURES +$72,804
NET INCOME BEFORE DEPRECIATION -$485,615
The following is the record of water sales to member municipalities for the period July 1 through
December 31. The six month record shows a decrease in water sales of 6.2% during the current
fiscal year compared with the same period of the previous fiscal year. For the six month period,
our sales were 19% lower than budget. The wet weather this summer drastically reduced the
amount of water sold for sprinkling and we are continuing to observe a slow decline in water
sales during the winter months. Water sales will be well below budget for the entire fiscal year.
III
WATER CONSUMPTION – DAILY AVERAGE (MGD)
JULY 1 THROUGH DECEMBER 31
Month
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
Over or
Under
2013
July 34.23 53.25 52.33 35.92 36.61 +0.69
August 36.47 40.61 43.25 38.34 32.91 -5.43
September 28.83 32.13 38.20 32.31 28.27 -4.04
October 21.99 24.90 25.70 24.58 23.09 -1.49
November 19.13 22.35 22.03 21.63 21.76 +0.13
December 19.45 22.39 21.60 21.89 21.24 -0.65
Average 26.71 32.66 33.89 29.13 27.34 -1.79
Variance +4.4% +22.3% +3.8% -14.0% -6.2%
The following is the precipitation record, as recorded at the Webster Station:
PRECIPITATION – INCHES
Month 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
July 1.55 4.95 3.40 3.80 3.00
August 4.00 0.25 3.30 4.30 3.30
September 1.56 2.70 7.80 2.00 2.00
October 2.85 2.20 3.20 1.70 3.10
November 0.20 4.30 5.60 0.72 2.40
December 2.80 0.70 3.10 2.10 3.60
Total: 12.96 15.10 26.40 14.62 17.40
MAJOR PROJECTS
DWSD WATER RATES
DWSD will be announcing the rates for 2015/16 in late February. Preliminary information
provided by DWSD has indicated that the average rate for all water customers (both City of
Detroit and suburban customers) may increase by about 10% for 2015/16. The increase will
likely be significantly larger than in the past several years and is due to increases in DWSD’s
costs combined with significant decreases in the volume of water sold by DWSD. Water sales
are down due to the wet weather discussed above and to the loss of Flint as a DWSD customer.
We will be providing a water rate estimate to the member communities in February of 2014,
after we receive the actual rate increase proposed by DWSD.
DWSD ISSUES
Major changes are taking place at DWSD with the formation of the Great Lakes Water Authority
(GLWA). The GLWA was set up at the end of 2014. The current plan is that the GLWA and
the City of Detroit will negotiate a lease of the DWSD assets that will be used by the GLWA
during the first half of 2015 and that the GLWA will begin operations as of July 1, 2015. This
IV
will probably result in DWSD being split into two organizations, the GLWA and the City of
Detroit retail system. The City of Detroit will become a wholesale water customer of the
GLWA. Between now and June 30, 2015, the Board of Water Commissioners will continue to
be responsible for the operations of DWSD including setting the rates for 2015/16. The Board of
Water Commissioners will probably cease to exist when the GLWA becomes operational.
Great Lakes Water Authority
The GLWA Board held its initial meeting, which was its organizational meeting, on December
12, 2014. As of that date, only 4 of the 6 Board members had been named. The full complement
of 6 Board members has since been named:
Bob Daddow, Interim Chair Oakland County, Deputy County Executive, Oakland
County
Brian Baker Macomb County, Finance Director, Sterling Heights
Joe Nardone Wayne County, Director of Development, Wayne County
Airport Authority
Gary Brown Detroit, Group Executive for Operations, Detroit
Ike McKinnon Detroit, Deputy Mayor, Detroit
Ed Hood State of Michigan, Retired attorney
At their December 12 meeting, the Board took a series of organizational actions, including
having DWSD staff provide interim staff support to the GLWA. The Board will be conducting
at least one meeting and one workshop each month throughout 2015. At their meeting on
January 7, the GLWA Board appointed Sue McCormick as the Interim Executive Director of the
GLWA. This is an extremely important decision that will serve to minimize confusion during
the transition period. The GLWA Board will make a permanent appointment at some point in
the future, likely after the GLWA becomes operational. The Board of Water Commissioners will
continue to meet during this period. Both Boards appear to be taking steps to minimize
confusion that could be caused by having two different Boards active at the same time.
The 200 day period (which will last until mid-June 2015) to develop a lease agreement between
the GLWA and the City of Detroit has begun. Several study groups have been established to
assist with the development of the GLWA including making recommendations as to how the
assets and employees of DWSD will be divided between the GLWA and the Detroit retail
system. I have been asked to serve on both the Finance/Accounting and Operations Study
Groups. At the moment, it appears as if all of the activities of these study groups will be public
except for items subject to future confidentiality orders by Judge Cox or financial or personnel
items that would be subject to a confidentiality agreement which would protect these items from
public disclosure. It is my opinion that very few financial issues and no operational issues would
require confidentiality agreements. Employees of the Oakland County Water Commissioner’s
Office are taking the lead role in the Operations Study Group.
A detailed work plan is being developed to address the many issues that will arise as the GLWA
is established. Central to this work plan is the separation of DWSD into 2 organizations, the
GLWA and a separate organization to manage Detroit’s retail system.
Veolia Water Study
The peer review reports on DWSD and DWSD’s retail services that were conducted by Veolia
Water were released in early January. SOCWA staff will be reviewing these lengthy reports
over the next several weeks.
V
DWSD
In the midst of all of the changes discussed above, DWSD is continuing their long term
organizational improvement plan and they have filled several high level managerial jobs with
external hires. Their total number of employees is continuing to decrease through attrition.
SOCWA staff is continuing to participate in the DWSD Customer Outreach Process. I have been
serving as one of four elected customer co-chairs of the Technical Advisory Committee that
guides this process. I am also serving on a customer group that is working with DWSD to update
their water master plan, which is about 10 years old. This plan was developed with only minor
customer input and a number of key demographic assumptions that need to be updated to reflect
the changes in the region in the last 10 years. This plan will be completed by June 30, 2015.
Significant progress has been made in improving the level of communication and understanding
between DWSD and its customers through this process, which will be a continuing effort.
SOCWA continues to be a strong proponent of DWSD’s customer partnering process.
The City of Flint discontinued the purchase of DWSD water in April of 2014 and they are
running their own water treatment plant using the Flint River as source water. Flint has had a
number of significant water quality issues, including violations of the Safe Water Drinking Act,
as a result. Genesee County is continuing to purchase DWSD water while they are constructing a
new water supply system for Flint and Genesee County using Lake Huron water. DWSD has
offered to resume water supply to Flint at the rates that were proposed for 2014/15.
SALE OF WATER TO BLOOMFIELD TWP.
As part of our water sales contract with Bloomfield Twp., the Township is required to build an
interconnection with the SOCWA system. The Township developed a plan to use our existing
interconnection with Bloomfield Hills to also supply a portion of the Township system. The
construction required by this plan has been completed and SOCWA is directly supplying a
portion of the Bloomfield Twp. and Bloomfield Hills systems. We have completed an
engineering study that determined that this interconnection will have no effect on the SOCWA
supply to Birmingham. We will be adjusting how this interconnection is operated this spring in
order to verify the findings of our engineering study. We have also refurbished an existing meter
vault that supplies Birmingham in order to improve the security of the SOCWA supply to the
Birmingham system.
MAIN DAMAGE SETTLEMENT
We reached a settlement regarding the damage that was done to our 30” concrete water main in
the Birmingham Country Club. The SOCWA main was punctured by a contractor doing work
for Consumers Energy. The settlement ended a lawsuit that SOCWA filed against the contractor.
PENSION FUNDING
The Board took continued additional steps to address the underfunded status of SOCWA’s
pension plan. SOCWA has been contributing the actuarially required amounts to this plan for
many years, however it remains significantly underfunded. The Board approved a five year plan
to make additional funding to the SOCWA pension plan above the actuarially required amount.
VI
The third of the five planned annual contributions was made before the end of 2014. We will
include an additional contribution to this fund in our budget for 2015/16.
ANNUAL AUDIT
The audit report for the 2013/14 fiscal year was completed by our auditors, Plante & Moran and
was reviewed at the November SOCWA Board meeting. This was the fourth audit performed by
Plante & Moran under our five year agreement. For the 2013/14 audit, the financial statements
contained in the audit were prepared by the SOCWA staff and reviewed by the auditors. The
audit found the Authority to be in complete conformity with generally accepted accounting
practices. The auditors concluded that the Authority’s level of working capital has been
maintained above the goal level established by the Board but that the net position of SOCWA
decreased by $219,000 during the year.
Respectfully submitted,
Jeffrey A. McKeen, P.E.
General Manager
SOUTHEASTERN OAKLAND COUNTY WATER AUTHORITY
BUDGET ANALYSIS
JULY 1, 2014 THROUGH DECEMBER 31, 2014
VARIANCES
ESTIMATED ACTUAL OVER OR
REVENUES REVENUES REVENUES UNDER
OPERATION
SALE OF WATER $8,774,000.00 $7,524,368.06 ($1,249,631.94)
SALE OF WATER OTHERS 5,570,000.00 3,875,023.18 (1,694,976.82)
$14,344,000.00 $11,399,391.24 ($2,944,608.76)
OTHER INCOME
RENTALS $52,600.00 $26,235.00 ($26,365.00)
WATER ANALYSIS-LAB & MISC. 4,500.00 1,200.30 (3,299.70)
GRANT REVENUE 9,900.00 0.00 (9,900.00)
INTEREST ON INVESTMENTS 20,400.00 11,013.16 (9,386.84)
$87,400.00 $38,448.46 ($48,951.54)
TOTAL REVENUES $14,431,400.00 $11,437,839.70 ($2,993,560.30)
EXPENSES
WATER PURCHASED FOR RESALE $6,796,000.00 $5,628,215.30 ($1,167,784.70)
WATER PURCHASE IN TRANSIT 4,689,000.00 4,598,468.30 (90,531.70)
POWER, PUMPING & GROUNDS WEBSTER 318,764.08 256,198.53 (62,565.55)
POWER, PUMPING & GROUNDS 143,034.00 82,343.77 (60,690.23)
COMPUTER OPERATIONS 34,100.04 33,306.86 (793.18)
PURIFICATION 32,599.98 43,472.26 10,872.28
METERS & MAINS 60,200.04 63,829.99 3,629.95
ADMINISTRATIVE & GENERAL 643,030.00 491,928.67 (151,101.33)
$12,716,728.14 $11,197,763.68 ($1,518,964.46)
FIXED CHARGES
INTEREST ON BONDS $14,875.00 $14,875.00 $0.00
BOND MATURITIES 0.00 0.00 0.00
$14,875.00 $14,875.00 $0.00
TOTAL EXPENSES $12,731,603.14 $11,212,638.68 ($1,518,964.46)
NET INCOME BEFORE DEPRECIATION $1,699,796.86 $225,201.02 ($1,474,595.84)
-1-
SOUTHEASTERN OAKLAND COUNTY WATER AUTHORITY
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF INCOME
JULY 1, 2014 THROUGH DECEMBER 31, 2014
2014/15 2013/14
AVERAGE AVERAGE
PER 1,000 PER 1,000
AMOUNT CUBIC FEET CUBIC FEET
REVENUES
OPERATION
SALE OF WATER $7,524,368.06 $14.4600 $13.9000
SALE OF WATER OTHERS 3,875,023.18 25.4800 24.5000
$11,399,391.24 $16.9523 $16.4639
OTHER INCOME
RENTALS $26,235.00 $0.0390 $0.0385
LAB & MISCELLANEOUS 1,200.30 0.0018 0.0008
INTEREST ON INVESTMENTS 11,013.16 0.0164 0.0334
$38,448.46 $0.0572 $0.0727
TOTAL REVENUES: $11,437,839.70 $17.0095 $16.5366
EXPENSES
WATER PURCHASED FOR RESALE $5,628,215.30 $8.3699 $7.8909
WATER PURCHASE IN TRANSIT 4,598,468.30 6.8385 6.2226
POWER, PUMPING & GROUNDS WEBSTER 256,198.53 0.3810 0.3730
POWER, PUMPING & GROUNDS 82,343.77 0.1225 0.1407
COMPUTER OPERATIONS 33,306.86 0.0495 0.0482
PURIFICATION 43,472.26 0.0646 0.0542
METERS & MAINS 63,829.99 0.0949 0.0689
ADMINISTRATIVE & GENERAL 491,928.67 0.7316 0.7058
BOND INTEREST 14,875.00 0.0221 0.0403
$11,212,638.68 $16.6746 $15.5446
INC. BEFORE DEPRECIATION $225,201.02 $0.3349 $0.9919
DEPRECIATION $248,885.34 $0.3701 $0.3486
NET INCOME ($23,684.32) ($0.0352) $0.6433
-2-
SOUTHEASTERN OAKLAND COUNTY WATER AUTHORITY
STATEMENT OF REVENUES & EXPENDITURES
COMPARED WITH TOTAL BUDGET
JULY 1, 2014 THROUGH DECEMBER 31, 2014
TOTAL PER CENT
BUDGET ACTUAL REC'D OR
2014/15 6 MONTHS BALANCE EXPENDED
REVENUES
OPERATION
SALE OF WATER $15,756,000.00 $7,524,368.06 $8,231,631.94 47.76%
SALE OF WATER OTHERS 8,790,600.00 3,875,023.18 4,915,576.82 44.08%
$24,546,600.00 $11,399,391.24 $13,147,208.76 46.44%
OTHER INCOME
RENTALS $108,000.00 $26,235.00 $81,765.00 24.29%
LAB & MISCELLANEOUS 10,000.00 1,200.30 8,799.70 12.00%
GRANT REVENUE 20,000.00 0.00 20,000.00 0.00%
INTEREST ON INVESTMENTS 40,000.00 11,013.16 28,986.84 27.53%
$178,000.00 $38,448.46 $139,551.54 21.60%
TOTAL REVENUES: $24,724,600.00 $11,437,839.70 $13,286,760.30 46.26%
EXPENSES
WATER PURCHASED FOR RESALE $21,236,000.00 $5,628,215.30 $15,607,784.70 26.50%
WATER PURCHASE IN TRANSIT 0.00 4,598,468.30 (4,598,468.30) 0.00%
POWER, PUMPING & GROUNDS WEBSTER 622,500.00 256,198.53 366,301.47 41.16%
POWER, PUMPING & GROUNDS 292,200.00 82,343.77 209,856.23 28.18%
COMPUTER OPERATIONS 68,200.00 33,306.86 34,893.14 48.84%
PURIFICATION 85,200.00 43,472.26 41,727.74 51.02%
METERS & MAINS 120,400.00 63,829.99 56,570.01 53.01%
ADMINISTRATIVE & GENERAL 1,033,600.00 491,928.67 541,671.33 47.59%
BOND INTEREST 29,750.00 14,875.00 14,875.00 0.00%
TOTAL EXPENDITURES $23,487,850.00 $11,212,638.68 $12,275,211.32 47.74%
NET INCOME BEFORE DEPRECIATION $1,236,750.00 $225,201.02 $1,011,548.98 18.21%
DEPRECIATION $497,770.58 $248,885.34 $248,885.24 50.00%
-3-
SOUTHEASTERN OAKLAND COUNTY WATER AUTHORITY
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT JULY 1, 2014 THROUGH DECEMBER 31, 2014
2014/15 2013/14 OVER OR (UNDER)
REVENUES
OPERATION
SALE OF WATER $7,524,368.06 $7,551,787.99 ($27,419.93)
SALE OF WATER OTHERS 3,875,023.18 4,246,817.31 (371,794.13)
$11,399,391.24 $11,798,605.30 ($399,214.06)
OTHER INCOME
RENTALS $26,235.00 $27,594.00 ($1,359.00)
LAB & MISCELLANEOUS 1,200.30 550.00 650.30
GRANT REVENUE 0.00 0.00 0.00
INT. ON INVESTMENTS 11,013.16 23,901.63 (12,888.47)
$38,448.46 $52,045.63 ($13,597.17)
TOTAL REVENUES $11,437,839.70 $11,850,650.93 ($412,811.23)
EXPENSES
WATER PURCHASED FOR RESALE $5,628,215.30 $5,654,856.02 ($26,640.72)
WATER PURCHASE IN TRANSIT 4,598,468.30 4,459,333.12 139,135.18
OPERATING EXPENSES 971,080.08 996,764.11 (25,684.03)
FIXED CHARGES 14,875.00 28,881.25 (14,006.25)
TOTAL EXPENSES $11,212,638.68 $11,139,834.50 $72,804.18
NET INCOME $225,201.02 $710,816.43 ($485,615.41)
-4-
SOUTHEASTERN OAKLAND COUNTY WATER AUTHORITY
TOTAL CHARGES JULY 1, 2014 THROUGH DECEMBER 31, 2014
WATER
CONSUMPTION TOTAL WATER
MUNICIPALITY CUBIC FEET CHARGES
BERKLEY 23,282.000 $336,657.72
BEVERLY HILLS 20,006.800 $289,298.33
BINGHAM FARMS 5,459.700 $78,947.26
BIRMINGHAM 59,196.000 $855,974.17
CLAWSON 19,720.500 $285,158.43
HUNTINGTON WOODS 11,431.600 $165,300.94
LATHRUP VILLAGE 8,267.700 $119,550.94
PLEASANT RIDGE 5,530.400 $79,969.58
ROYAL OAK 125,756.700 $1,818,441.91
SOUTHFIELD 233,351.000 $3,374,255.48
DETROIT ZOO & RACKHAM 8,355.000 $120,813.30
MEMBERS 520,357.400 $7,524,368.06
NON-MEMBERS
BLOOMFIELD HILLS 29,827.372 760,001.44
BOOOMFIELD TOWNSHIP 122,253.600 3,115,021.74
152,080.972 3,875,023.18
TOTAL: 672,438.372 $11,399,391.24
-5-
SOUTHEASTERN OAKLAND COUNTY WATER AUTHORITY IMPROVEMENT FUND
JULY 1, 2014 THROUGH DECEMBER 31, 2014
FIXED ASSET EXPENDITURES
Water Meter Project 500.00
Webster Tank Painting 339,461.60
TOTALS: $339,961.60
-6-