Public Administration and Ethics

Week 10

McCallion’s conflict of interest http://www.thestar.com/opinion/editorials/

article/1063908--hazel-s-new-legacy-a-hurricane-of-conflict?bn=1

“Mississauga Mayor Hazel McCallion engaged in a very real conflict of interest when she secretly promoted a land deal that could have put millions of dollars into her son’s pocket. “

Ethics and Public Administration In Canada, and other liberal democracies, the

1970s saw the rise of concerns about public sector ethics.

Ethics and Public AdministrationNew Public Management raises new concerns.

Civil servants responsible for results not process, has led to focus on values rather than rules.

Alternative service delivery raises question of whether private partners share public sector values.

Complex Responsibilities

The public service has many responsibilities and commitments:

to the public to the laws that govern its powers and

management; to the Ministers who are the political heads of

departments.

Conflicting responsibilities

These multiple responsibilities can create tensions between the duty of the public service to serve the government and its ethical obligation to promote the public interest.

Ethical issues

conflicts of interest confidentiality of information political partisanship

How can we, or should we, encourage ethical behaviour in the public service?

Strengthening public sector ethics codes of conduct training and education role models an attentive public (citizens, NGOs, mass

media)

However, it is clear that rules and guidelines about process still will need to play a role.

Tait Report: A Strong FoundationTask Force on Public Service Values and

Ethics, 1996

called for development of public service code of conduct

Values and Ethics Code for the Public ServiceIn 2003 a Values and Ethics Code for the

Public Service was prepared by the Treasury Board, and it came into force on September 1, 2003.

The Code sets out Public Service values as well as Conflict of Interest and Post-Employment Measures.

Values and Ethics Code for the Public Service

Public Service Values Democratic Values Professional Values Ethical Values People Values

http://www.tbs-sct.gc.ca/pubs_pol/hrpubs/tb_851/vec-cve-eng.pdf

IPAC, “A Public Servant’s Commitments”Institute of Public Administration of CanadaA strong Commitment to Personal IntegrityA strong Commitment to Democratic GovernanceA strong Commitment to RespectfulnessA strong Commitment to Continual Learning and

InnovationA strong Commitment to Critical Reflection on Ethics

and Values

Sponsorship Scandal

What was the “sponsorship scandal”?

How was it uncovered?

CBC Archives, May 8, 2002 CBC News In-depth:

Federal Sponsorship Scandal

Sponsorship Scandal

“then former Prime Minister Jean Chrétien, his chief of staff, Jean Pelletier, the deputy minister of public works and government services Canada, Ranald Quail, a hands-on minister of public works and government services Canada (hereafter PWGSC), Alfonso Gagliano, and a middle-level entrepreneurial manager in charge of advertising in that same department, Charles (Chuck) Guité, were all responsible for allowing the sponsorship program to be run irresponsibly and without proper accountability safeguards” (Greene and Shugarman, 2006: 220).

Gomery Final Report

Recommendation: The Government should adopt legislation to entrench into law a Public Service Charter.

statement of the essential values that all public servants could be expected to embrace

a charter of the rights and obligations of public servants and as a symbol of the Government’s undertaking to give new respect to the public service

Federal Ethics Counselor

First appointed 1994 To report to Prime Minister’s Office

Federal Ethics Commissioner

Appointed in 2004 Greater independence from Prime Minister Reported directly to Parliament Bernard Shapiro appointed as first

Commissioner in 2004, resigned in 2007.

Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner Created in 2007, replacing the Ethics

Commissioner created in 2004. Mary Dawson was appointed as the first

Commissioner in 2007. Office administers the Conflict of Interest Act

and the Conflict of Interest Code for Members of the House of Commons.

Conflict of Interest Act Passed in 2006, coming into force in 2007. A summary of the Act for public office holders including

ministers, parliamentary secretaries, ministerial staff and all full-time Governor in Council appointees such as deputy ministers, heads of Crown corporations and members of federal boards.

“Conflict of Interest: public office holders are in a conflict of interest when they exercise an official power, duty or function that provides an opportunity to further their private interests or those of their relatives or friends, or that improperly furthers another person’s private interests.”

Public Servants Disclosure Protection Act Passed in 2005, came into force in 2007. “The Act provides a means for employees in the

federal public sector to disclose information that they believe could show that a wrongdoing has been committed or is about to be committed in the federal public sector, or that they were asked to commit a wrongdoing. The Act protects public servant disclosers against reprisal.”

Created the Office of the Public Sector Integrity Commissioner of Canada (replacing the former Public Service Integrity Officer created in 2001).

Public Sector Integrity Commissioner The Commissioner is an Agent of Parliament

appointed by resolution of the Senate and House of Commons. He/she reports directly to Parliament.

Under investigation by the Auditor General, Public Sector Integrity Commissioner Christiane Ouimet resigned in 2010.

December 2010, AG released her report critical of Integrity Commissioner.

Controversy over the Integrity Commissioner“Former Integrity Commissioner Christiane Ouimet modeled many

of the behaviours that she was charged with driving out of the public service:

abusing her staff, taking reprisals against a former employee, and demonstrating 'reluctance' to find wrongdoing;

failing to do her job. The Auditor General reported that Ouimet failed to fulfill her mandate: in three years she found zero cases of wrongdoing and failed to protect a single whistleblower from reprisals;

when the Auditor General's investigation into her conduct was nearing completion, Ouimet negotiated a $500,000 settlement, including a gag order seemingly designed to protect her (and the government) from criticism or consequences;

displaying a disregard for our democratic institutions by refusing for months to respond to a Parliamentary committee as it tried to summon her to explain her actions.”

http://fairwhistleblower.ca/no-more-ouimets

Protection for whistleblowers? Despite the Public Servants Disclosure Protection Act and the

creation of the Public Sector Integrity Commissioner, many complain that there is still not sufficient protection for whistleblowers in the civil service.

Critics include: FAIR (Federal Accountability Initiative for Reform) Canadians for Accountability

For a critique of the act, see: http://fairwhistleblower.ca/psdpa/psdpa_critique.html

One example of the lack of protection: http://www.thestar.com/opinion/editorialopinion/article/1038934--effectively-silencing-canada-s-whistleblowers

Conservative Government and Ethics http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com/

2010/05/29/harper-lets-the-ethics-slide/

Corruption Rankings

Transparency International – Corruption Perceptions Index

Global Integrity – Global Integrity Reporthttp://www.thestar.com/news/world/article/986663--canada-slips-in-anti-corruption-rankings