From: Lori L. BuchananTo: Cleghorn CIV June N; Angie Westfall; betsy_merritt@nthp.org; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; Faulkner, Kiersten;

Jackson-Retondo, Elaine; jeromey@oha.org; Katie; keolal@oha.org; Louise Brodnitz; kahiwal@cs.com; A. VanHorn Diamond; Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT); aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com;Angienora Rogers; Bill Aila; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Chad K. Baybayan; ChasminSokolovski; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Clive Cabral; Cy Harris; Donna Camvel; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net;Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha; htf@lava.net; kaim@oha.org;Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; keohokalole@hawntel.net; Kunane Aipoalani; Likeke Papa;malamapono@aol.com; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov; mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; Moaikeala Tomasbelsky;Nalani Olds; nalanialua@gmail.com; napua4u@yahoo.com; Nau Kamalii; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov; Rick Ortiz;rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tom Lenchanko; vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org; kaleopaik@yahoo.com;JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; leahkpereira@aim.com; zensea1@gmail.com;mikesbchside@yahoo.com; imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com

Cc: Rasmussen CIV Coral M; George Capt Derek R; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; Tome CIV Steven K; Sibley CIV JamesR; Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Goodfellow CIV Sue; Irvin CIV Carolyn E; Patrick CIV Tiffany L;Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC, EV; Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US); Angela Thompson;Interpretive@iarii.org; walter ritte; colettem@oha.org; hoolehuamoon@gmail.com; ford.fuchigami@hawaii.gov;Kauwila Hanchett; karenh@molokai.org; kdavis@qlcc.org

Subject: RE: FINAL DRAFT PA FOR VERIFICATIONDate: Friday, July 13, 2012 1:31:46 PM

Aloha e June, Section 106 committee, and all participants,

Mahalo to everyone involved and especially to all across Hawaii nei who supported the "no militarytraining actions on Molokai" island. Mahalo for your insight and compassion to the patients of Kalaupapaand the Hawaiian homesteaders of Hoolehua, Molokai. For the record, I continue to petition allsignatories NOT TO SIGN this current and "final" PA until all of the proposed undertakings on Molokaiisland are OMITTED FROM THIS PA. Furthermore, as I stated on the record of the July 5, 2012 finalconsultation meeting, the determination by MCBH and the Navy of "no effect" to the APE proposed"Arming and Refueling Point" in Homestead lands in Hoolehua, Molokai is in error. I stated that therewere cultural sites and I will be forwarding that information to you when I get back to Molokai thisweek. Also, no mitigation exists in the final PA for Kalupapa APE which you determined to be impacted.Continuing a "baseline of training events" impacting significant sites and the patients in Kalaupapa doesnot constitute mitigation for adverse impacts to a significant cultural/spiritual National HistoricalLandmark! AUWE! Bottom line it is clear MCBH/Navy wants a footprint on Molokai no matter the cost.There was never any real alternatives to Molokai which constitutes "stacking".MCBH has the option to move forward with their entire proposed undertakings without Molokai in themix and the only way they will come to that conclusion is if SHPO and all other signatory decline to signthe PA.For the record, as the person being affected by your undertaking, I cannot agree to sign your PA aswritten. For the record, because I cannot agree to sign this final PA does not excuse the Federalgovernment from consulting with myself and other declining signatory for further discussion of yourproposed undertakings on our islands.

Mahalo,

Lori BuchananMolokai Resident

-----Original Message-----From: Cleghorn CIV June N [mailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.mil]Sent: Monday, July 09, 2012 12:07 PMTo: Angie Westfall; betsy_merritt@nthp.org; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; Faulkner, Kiersten; Jackson-Retondo, Elaine; jeromey@oha.org; Katie; keolal@oha.org; Louise Brodnitz; kahiwal@cs.com; A. VanHorn Diamond; Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT); aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com;Angienora Rogers; Bill Aila; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Chad K. Baybayan;Chasmin Sokolovski; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Clive Cabral; Cy Harris; Donna Camvel;ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha;htf@lava.net; kaim@oha.org; Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; keohokalole@hawntel.net; Kunane

mailto:lbuchanan@TNC.ORGmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:angie.r.westfall@hawaii.govmailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.orgmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:htf@lava.netmailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:nalaniolds@yahoo.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:zensea1@gmail.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.orgmailto:rittew@hotmail.commailto:colettem@oha.orgmailto:hoolehuamoon@gmail.commailto:ford.fuchigami@hawaii.govmailto:kauwila2@yahoo.commailto:karenh@molokai.orgmailto:kdavis@qlcc.orgmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.mil

Aipoalani; Likeke Papa; Lori L. Buchanan; malamapono@aol.com; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov;mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; Moaikeala Tomasbelsky; Nalani Olds; nalanialua@gmail.com;napua4u@yahoo.com; Nau Kamalii; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov; Rick Ortiz; rosina@hawaii.rr.com; TomLenchanko; vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org; kaleopaik@yahoo.com; JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com;pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; leahkpereira@aim.com; zensea1@gmail.com; mikesbchside@yahoo.com;imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.comCc: Rasmussen CIV Coral M; George Capt Derek R; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; Tome CIV Steven K; SibleyCIV James R; Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Goodfellow CIV Sue; Irvin CIV Carolyn E; PatrickCIV Tiffany L; Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC, EV; Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US);Angela Thompson; Interpretive@iarii.orgSubject: FINAL DRAFT PA FOR VERIFICATION

Aloha Consulting Parties -

As you requested, please find the revised final draft of the PA showing the changes made per commentsreceived regarding the 2 July version of the PA. We reviewed and addressed, as appropriate, allcomments received in writing by Friday night and all comments received verbally during the morningand evening calls on Thursday.

The purpose of sending out this final draft is so the parties can confirm that we addressed comments aswe stated we would do during the phone conversations. This is not intended to initiate another round ofreview and comment. Please notify us if there is an issue that we didn't address, or if the languageinserted to address a comment needs a minor tweak. We will be sending out the Final PA for signatureby close of business on Wednesday, 11 July, and requesting that signatures be provided by 23 July.

The Final PA will include signature pages for all the consulting parties that have been included in thisSec 106 consultation effort. I have included PA Attachment 15 here (attached), and please note that itis revised to show the addition of recent consulting parties. To reiterate, all consulting parties will berequested to sign the Final PA as either a Signatory, an Invited Signatory, or a Concurring Party. MCBHawaii understands that this is a request only and that not all consulting parties will elect to sign thisPA.

Mahalo,

The MCB Hawaii Sec 106 Consultation Team:Dr. Sue GoodfellowCapt. Derek GeorgeJune CleghornKaren DesiletsCoral Rasmussen

June Noelani CleghornCultural Resources ManagerMarine Corps Base HawaiiEnvironmental Compliance and Protection Dept808-257-7126808-257-2794 (fax)457-7126 (DSN)june.cleghorn@usmc.mil

From: Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govTo: Cleghorn CIV June NCc: ailaw001@hawaii.rr.com; aloha1st@flex.com; aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; angela@masonarch.com;

Angie.R.Westfall@hawaii.gov; antiquarian@hawaii.rr.com; betsy_merritt@nthp.org; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov;Irvin CIV Carolyn E; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; ccabral@hawaii.rr.com; charris002@hawaii.rr.com;chazinhawaii@aol.com; ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.net; Rasmussen CIV Coral M; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov;George Capt Derek R; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.gov; ellyn.goldkind@navy.mil;Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; FredCachola@aol.com; halealoha@wave.hicv.net; htf@lava.net;imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com; Interpretive@iarii.org; iolekaa@hawaii.rr.com; Sibley CIV James R;jeromey@oha.org; JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com; julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.mil; kahiwal@cs.com; kaim@oha.org;kaleopaik@yahoo.com; Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; karen.desilets@navy.mil; Katie@historichawaii.org;kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.org; keohokalole@hawntel.net; keolal@oha.org; Kiersten@historichawaii.org;kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.mil; laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.mil; lbrodnitz@achp.gov; lbuchanan@TNC.ORG;leahkpereira@aim.com; malamapono@aol.com; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov; mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com;mikesbchside@yahoo.com; nalanialua@gmail.com; napua4u@yahoo.com; NKamalii@papaolalokahi.org;ortizr008@hawaii.rr.com; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov;puna_moku@hotmail.com; rangien2010@yahoo.com; rgjpapa@yahoo.com; rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tome CIVSteven K; Goodfellow CIV Sue; Patrick CIV Tiffany L; TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.com; tomasbelsky@gmail.com;vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org; zensea1@gmail.com

Subject: RE: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 AircraftDate: Monday, July 16, 2012 7:08:17 PM

Just wanted to let everyone know that after much deliberation the SHPO signed the PA today.

Pua

-----"Cleghorn CIV June N" wrote: -----

To: From: "Cleghorn CIV June N" Date: 07/16/2012 02:52PM Cc: "Bill Aila" , , ,"Angela Thompson" , "Angie Westfall" , "A.Van Horn Diamond" , ,, "Irvin CIV Carolyn E" , ,"Clive Cabral" , "Cy Harris" , "Chasmin Sokolovski", "Kunane Aipoalani" , "Rasmussen CIV CoralM" , , "George Capt Derek R", , "Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC, EV", , , "Fred Cachola", "Halealoha" , , , , "Donna Camvel" , "SibleyCIV James R" , , ,"Taomia, Julie M CIV (US)" , , ,, , "Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3", "Katie" , "Chad K. Baybayan", , , "Faulkner, Kiersten", "Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT)", "Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US)" , "LouiseBrodnitz" , "Lori L. Buchanan" ,, , ,, , ,, "Nau Kamalii" , "Rick Ortiz", "Ujimori CIV Paulette B" ,, , "Cheryl Lovell-Obatake", "Angienora Rogers" , "Likeke Papa", , "Tome CIV Steven K" ,"Goodfellow CIV Sue" , "Patrick CIV Tiffany L" ,"Tom Lenchanko" , "Moaikeala Tomasbelsky", , Subject: RE: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft

mailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:Angie.R.Westfall@hawaii.govmailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:htf@lava.netmailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.orgmailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.orgmailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:lbuchanan@TNC.ORGmailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:zensea1@gmail.com

From: Lori L. BuchananTo: kaleo paik; Cleghorn CIV June N; Angie Westfall; betsy_merritt@nthp.org; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; Faulkner,

Kiersten; Jackson-Retondo, Elaine; jeromey@oha.org; Katie; keolal@oha.org; Louise Brodnitz;kahiwal@cs.com; A. Van Horn Diamond; Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT; aloha@koolaupokohcc.org;aloha1st@flex.com; Angienora Rogers; Bill Aila; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Chad K.Baybayan; Chasmin Sokolovski; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Clive Cabral; Cy Harris; Donna Camvel;ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha; htf@lava.net;kaim@oha.org; Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; keohokalole@hawntel.net; Kunane Aipoalani; Likeke Papa;malamapono@aol.com; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov; mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; Moaikeala Tomasbelsky;Nalani Olds; nalanialua@gmail.com; napua4u@yahoo.com; Nau Kamalii; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov; Rick Ortiz;rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tom Lenchanko; vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org; kaleopaik@yahoo.com;JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; leahkpereira@aim.com; zensea1@gmail.com;mikesbchside@yahoo.com; imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com; Rasmussen CIV Coral M; George Capt Derek R; UjimoriCIV Paulette B; Tome CIV Steven K; Sibley CIV James R; Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3; GoodfellowCIV Sue; Irvin CIV Carolyn E; Patrick CIV Tiffany L; Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC, EV; Taomia, Julie M CIV(US; Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US; Angela Thompson; Interpretive@iarii.org; walter ritte; colettem@oha.org;hoolehuamoon@gmail.com; ford.fuchigami@hawaii.gov; Kauwila Hanchett; karenh@molokai.org;kdavis@qlcc.org

Cc: Lori L. Buchanan; William J. Aila (william.j.aila@hawaii.gov); Scarlett Ritte; Editor@TheMolokaiDispatch.comSubject: RE: FINAL DRAFT PA FOR VERIFICATIONDate: Tuesday, July 17, 2012 6:59:40 PMAttachments: Kuahu at Hoolehua, Molokai.JPG

Aloha e Kanaka and all section 106 participants,

Aloha from Molokai. Mahalo again to all those who have made it their kuleana to protect our aina and tothe signatories who stand in solidarity with us by choosing NOT TO SIGN the Programmatic Agreement(PA) for the basing of the Navy’s MV22 and H-1 Aircraft elements in Hawaii at Marine Corp Base Hawaii(MCBH) and the associated training throughout the state. Yes, we are disappointed that the StateHistoric Preservation Officer William Aila (SHPO) chose to sign the PA despite strong statewideopposition over several months. It was stated for the record several times not only through thestatewide 106 consultations but also through the DLNR Listening sessions and SHPO Listening sessionon Molokai that the entire island of Molokai is a cultural site and should be treated as such. MCBH, theNavy, SHPO and all other who continue to move forward in support of this PA has left us here onMolokai with no recourse but to erect a visible and tangible representation of our cultural significance tothese lands by way of the placement of an ahu on the proposed MCBH/Navy “Forward Arming andRefueling” site in Hoolehua, Molokai in protest. Please see the attached picture. The building of this ahuwas done following correct cultural protocol and a KAPU has been placed on it. The mana of our peoplehere on Molokai has been given to this ahu. Any attempt to remove this cultural site will be seen asdesecration. MCBH and Navy, do not desecrate this cultural site. The threat of “excommunicating” thosewho do not sign this PA citing federal law is absurd. We state for the record our willingness to continuewith earnest discussion on MCBH and the Navy’s proposed actions on Molokai and throughout the stateof Hawaii and hope that they will do so.

Ma kau kau,

Lori Buchanan and Ohana

Molokai

(808) 336-0625 mobile

From: kaleo paik [mailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.com]Sent: Tuesday, July 17, 2012 11:29 AM

mailto:lbuchanan@TNC.ORGmailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:angie.r.westfall@hawaii.govmailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.orgmailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.orgmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:htf@lava.netmailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:nalaniolds@yahoo.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:zensea1@gmail.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.orgmailto:rittew@hotmail.commailto:colettem@oha.orgmailto:hoolehuamoon@gmail.commailto:ford.fuchigami@hawaii.govmailto:kauwila2@yahoo.commailto:karenh@molokai.orgmailto:kdavis@qlcc.orgmailto:lbuchanan@TNC.ORGmailto:william.j.aila@hawaii.govmailto:kalaekreations@yahoo.commailto:Editor@TheMolokaiDispatch.commailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.com

From: Kiersten FaulknerTo: Cleghorn CIV June N; George Capt Derek RCc: Rasmussen CIV Coral M; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; Tome CIV Steven K; Sibley CIV James R; Desilets, Karen A CIV

NAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Goodfellow CIV Sue; Irvin CIV Carolyn E; Patrick CIV Tiffany L; Goldkind, Ellyn P CIVNAVFAC, EV; Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); Angie Westfall; betsy_merritt@nthp.org; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov;Jackson-Retondo, Elaine; jeromey@oha.org; Katie Kissling; keolal@oha.org; Louise Brodnitz; kahiwal@cs.com;A. Van Horn Diamond; Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT); aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com;Angienora Rogers; Bill Aila; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Chad K. Baybayan; ChasminSokolovski; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Clive Cabral; Cy Harris; Donna Camvel; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net;Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha; htf@lava.net; kaim@oha.org;Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; keohokalole@hawntel.net; Kunane Aipoalani; Likeke Papa; Lori L. Buchanan;malamapono@aol.com; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov; mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; Moaikeala Tomasbelsky;nalanialua@gmail.com; napua4u@yahoo.com; Nau Kamalii; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov; Rick Ortiz;rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tom Lenchanko; vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org; kaleopaik@yahoo.com;JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; leahkpereira@aim.com; zensea1@gmail.com;mikesbchside@yahoo.com; imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com; Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US); Angela Thompson;Interpretive@iarii.org; William Aila (william.j.aila@hawaii.gov); Glenn Mason (gm@masonarch.com); KatieKissling

Subject: RE: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 AircraftDate: Monday, July 23, 2012 2:57:47 PMAttachments: HHFComments_FinalPA_MV22.pdf

Aloha,Historic Hawai'i Foundation has decided not to concur in the final programmatic agreement for theMarine Corps basing of MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft in Hawai'i. Please see attached letter of explanation.

We would like to thank June, Coral, Karen, Captain George, the Marine Corps staff, and all theconsulting parties for the time and effort spent on this very complex and difficult undertaking. We lookforward to participating in the discussion about best practices so that lessons learned may bedocumented and shared for future projects.

Please let me know if you have any questions or would like to discuss any of the items in the attachedletter.

Mahalo,Kiersten

Kiersten Faulkner, AICPExecutive DirectorHistoric Hawaii Foundation680 Iwilei Rd., Ste. 690Honolulu, HI 96817Tel: 808-523-2900FAX: 808-523-0800Email: kiersten@historichawaii.orgWEB: www.historichawaii.org

-----Original Message-----From: Cleghorn CIV June N [mailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.mil]Sent: Saturday, July 21, 2012 8:28 AMTo: Angie Westfall; betsy_merritt@nthp.org; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; Kiersten Faulkner; Jackson-Retondo, Elaine; jeromey@oha.org; Katie Kissling; keolal@oha.org; Louise Brodnitz; kahiwal@cs.com; A.Van Horn Diamond; Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT); aloha@koolaupokohcc.org;aloha1st@flex.com; Angienora Rogers; Bill Aila; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; ChadK. Baybayan; Chasmin Sokolovski; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Clive Cabral; Cy Harris; Donna Camvel;ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha;htf@lava.net; kaim@oha.org; Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; keohokalole@hawntel.net; KunaneAipoalani; Likeke Papa; Lori L. Buchanan; malamapono@aol.com; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov;mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; Moaikeala Tomasbelsky; nalanialua@gmail.com; napua4u@yahoo.com;

mailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.orgmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:angie.r.westfall@hawaii.govmailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:htf@lava.netmailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:lbuchanan@TNC.ORGmailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:zensea1@gmail.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.orgmailto:william.j.aila@hawaii.govmailto:gm@masonarch.commailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.mil

From: Lyn McNuttTo: Kiersten FaulknerCc: Cleghorn CIV June N; George Capt Derek R; Rasmussen CIV Coral M; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; Tome CIV Steven

K; Sibley CIV James R; Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Goodfellow CIV Sue; Irvin CIV Carolyn E;Patrick CIV Tiffany L; Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC, EV; Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); Angie Westfall;betsy_merritt@nthp.org; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; Jackson-Retondo, Elaine; jeromey@oha.org; Katie Kissling;keolal@oha.org; Louise Brodnitz; kahiwal@cs.com; A. Van Horn Diamond; Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRFITT); aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com; Angienora Rogers; Bill Aila; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov;Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Chad K. Baybayan; Chasmin Sokolovski; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Clive Cabral; Cy Harris;Donna Camvel; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola;Halealoha; htf@lava.net; kaim@oha.org; Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; keohokalole@hawntel.net; KunaneAipoalani; Likeke Papa; Lori L. Buchanan; malamapono@aol.com; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov;mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; Moaikeala Tomasbelsky; nalanialua@gmail.com; napua4u@yahoo.com; NauKamalii; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov; Rick Ortiz; rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tom Lenchanko;vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org; kaleopaik@yahoo.com; JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com;leahkpereira@aim.com; mikesbchside@yahoo.com; imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com; Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US);Angela Thompson; Interpretive@iarii.org; William Aila (william.j.aila@hawaii.gov); Glenn Mason(gm@masonarch.com)

Subject: Re: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 AircraftDate: Monday, July 23, 2012 3:40:37 PM

Good for you, Historic Hawaii Foundation. Here on Kauai, our consultation was an afterthought. TheUSMC intends to shoot missles at Kaula Isand, which has a bird sanctuary, and is a location withcultural and biological significance. These actions weren't even included in the EIS, but have been'hidden' by saying that the effects of the take-offs and landings at PMRF are within the PMRF EIS of acouple of years ago, and that the "new" activity of using Kaula for target practice is covered in the USNavy EIS currently under review (I could find no reference to these activities in either of these EISdocuments). My point is, this is not really an EIS for the entire project. Where is the accountability?

People on Kauai do not want helicopters rampaging out of Oahu on a mission to bomb the daylights outof Kauai, and then rampaging back to Oahu. Will they be playing music like in Apocalypse Now?

The training for these helicopters ALREADY takes place in Southern California. This project is a thinlyveiled excuse to station these helicopters here, and to expand the military presence into pristine areas,and use Hawaii as the new Okinawa. Boo. Hiss.

Lyn

On Mon, Jul 23, 2012 at 2:56 PM, Kiersten Faulkner wrote:

Aloha, Historic Hawai'i Foundation has decided not to concur in the final programmatic agreement for theMarine Corps basing of MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft in Hawai'i. Please see attached letter of explanation. We would like to thank June, Coral, Karen, Captain George, the Marine Corps staff, and all theconsulting parties for the time and effort spent on this very complex and difficult undertaking. We lookforward to participating in the discussion about best practices so that lessons learned may bedocumented and shared for future projects. Please let me know if you have any questions or would like to discuss any of the items in theattached letter. Mahalo, Kiersten Kiersten Faulkner, AICP Executive Director Historic Hawaii Foundation

mailto:zensea1@gmail.commailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.orgmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:angie.r.westfall@hawaii.govmailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:htf@lava.netmailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:lbuchanan@tnc.orgmailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.orgmailto:william.j.aila@hawaii.govmailto:gm@masonarch.commailto:gm@masonarch.com

From: Chad Baybayan on behalf of Chad K. BaybayanTo: Cleghorn CIV June NCc: Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.gov; Bill Aila; aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com; Angela Thompson;

Angie Westfall; A. Van Horn Diamond; betsy_merritt@nthp.org; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Irvin CIV Carolyn E;Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Clive Cabral; Cy Harris; Chasmin Sokolovski; Kunane Aipoalani; Rasmussen CIV CoralM; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; George Capt Derek R; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC,EV; Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha; htf@lava.net; imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com; Interpretive@iarii.org; Donna Camvel; Sibley CIV James R; jeromey@oha.org;JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com; Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); kahiwal@cs.com; kaim@oha.org; kaleopaik@yahoo.com;Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Katie; keohokalole@hawntel.net;keolal@oha.org; Faulkner, Kiersten; Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT); Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US); LouiseBrodnitz; Lori L. Buchanan; leahkpereira@aim.com; malamapono@aol.com; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov;mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; mikesbchside@yahoo.com; nalanialua@gmail.com; napua4u@yahoo.com; NauKamalii; Rick Ortiz; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Angienora Rogers; Likeke Papa; rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tome CIV Steven K; Goodfellow CIV Sue;Patrick CIV Tiffany L; Tom Lenchanko; Moaikeala Tomasbelsky; vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org;zensea1@gmail.com

Subject: Re: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 AircraftDate: Monday, July 23, 2012 4:45:41 PM

We are not in agreement with the PA, hence I will not be signing the document.Kālepa BaybayanKahu Kū Mauna Council

Subject MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft Aloha Consulting Parties - Attached, please find the Final PA for signature. Hard copies of the PA, with the attachments on aCD, are being mailed out to you today. The attachments are also available for download from theSharepoint site. We are requesting that everyone that chooses to sign the PA send us the three originalsignature pages (once signed) to us in the mail. Before sending those, if you can scan a copy of onesignature page and email it to June Cleghorn at june.cleghorn@usmc.mil, that would be greatlyappreciated. Once we get all signatures, we will post a version of the PA that includes all signatures onthe Sharepoint site. For those consulting parties that were able to review the verification version of the PA sent out onMonday, thank you for the quick turnaround. For the remaining consulting parties, we hope that the language in the PA also addresses yourconcerns. Thanks again to everyone for their participation in this PA process; we look forward to workingwith you on the Best Practices/Lessons Learned document later this year to document your thoughts onwhat went well and what didn't. Please feel free to contact us with any further questions about the PAor the signature instructions. Mahalo,

mailto:chadkbaybayan@gmail.commailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:angie.r.westfall@hawaii.govmailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:htf@lava.netmailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.orgmailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.orgmailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:lbuchanan@TNC.ORGmailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:zensea1@gmail.com

From: valerie monsonTo: Cleghorn CIV June N; George Capt Derek RCc: Rasmussen CIV Coral M; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; Tome CIV Steven K; Sibley CIV James R; Desilets, Karen A CIV

NAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Goodfellow CIV Sue; Irvin CIV Carolyn E; Patrick CIV Tiffany L; Goldkind, Ellyn P CIVNAVFAC, EV; Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); Angie Westfall; betsy_merritt@nthp.org; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov;Jackson-Retondo, Elaine; jeromey@oha.org; Katie Kissling; keolal@oha.org; Louise Brodnitz; kahiwal@cs.com;A. Van Horn Diamond; Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT); aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com;Angienora Rogers; Bill Aila; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Chad K. Baybayan; ChasminSokolovski; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Clive Cabral; Cy Harris; Donna Camvel; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net;Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha; htf@lava.net; kaim@oha.org;Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; keohokalole@hawntel.net; Kunane Aipoalani; Likeke Papa; Lori L. Buchanan;malamapono@aol.com; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov; mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; Moaikeala Tomasbelsky;nalanialua@gmail.com; napua4u@yahoo.com; Nau Kamalii; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov; Rick Ortiz;rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tom Lenchanko; vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org; kaleopaik@yahoo.com;JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; leahkpereira@aim.com; zensea1@gmail.com;mikesbchside@yahoo.com; imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com; Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US); Angela Thompson;Interpretive@iarii.org; William Aila (william.j.aila@hawaii.gov); Glenn Mason (gm@masonarch.com);Kiersten@historichawaii.org

Subject: Re: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 AircraftDate: Monday, July 23, 2012 5:27:29 PMAttachments: "Ohana PA letter 7-23-12.pdf

To all consulting parties,

The Board of Directors of Ka 'Ohana O Kalaupapa greatly appreciates the Marine Corps' elimination ofany proposed increased military exercises at Kalaupapa, but has decided not to sign the PA because wedo not believe the concerns of other communities, particularly those of the topside Molokai community,have been adequately addressed.

The topside Molokai community stood strong with the 'Ohana against any increase of helicopterlandings at Kalaupapa -- and the 'Ohana Board wants to stand with them. We encourage the Marines tocontinue to work with all communities where issues remain to find resolution.

Our 'Ohana President, Clarence "Boogie" Kahilihiwa, has written a letter to Captain George with anexplanation of our decision which I have attached. The 'Ohana has appreciated being part of thisprocess -- and we thank all the support from the Office of Hawaiian Affairs, State Historic PreservationDivision, National Park Service and many others to keep these additional military exercises out ofKalaupapa.

I apologize for not getting this out earlier today, but I have been having problems with my Kalaupapaemail address so am sending this from my personal email.

Best regards,Valerie Monson, CoordinatorKa 'Ohana O Kalaupapa

mailto:valeriemonson@yahoo.commailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:angie.r.westfall@hawaii.govmailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:htf@lava.netmailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:lbuchanan@TNC.ORGmailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:zensea1@gmail.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.orgmailto:william.j.aila@hawaii.govmailto:gm@masonarch.commailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.org

From: Betsy MerrittTo: Cleghorn CIV June N; Angie Westfall; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; Faulkner, Kiersten; Jackson-Retondo, Elaine;

jeromey@oha.org; Katie; keolal@oha.org; Louise Brodnitz; kahiwal@cs.com; A. Van Horn Diamond; Aipoalani,Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT); aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com; Angienora Rogers; Bill Aila;Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Chad K. Baybayan; Chasmin Sokolovski; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Clive Cabral; Cy Harris; Donna Camvel; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Eric_Brown@nps.gov;Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha; htf@lava.net; kaim@oha.org; Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov;keohokalole@hawntel.net; Kunane Aipoalani; Likeke Papa; Lori L. Buchanan; malamapono@aol.com;Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov; mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; Moaikeala Tomasbelsky; nalanialua@gmail.com;napua4u@yahoo.com; Nau Kamalii; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov; Rick Ortiz; rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tom Lenchanko;vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org; kaleopaik@yahoo.com; JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com;leahkpereira@aim.com; zensea1@gmail.com; mikesbchside@yahoo.com; imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com

Cc: Rasmussen CIV Coral M; George Capt Derek R; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; Tome CIV Steven K; Sibley CIV JamesR; Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Goodfellow CIV Sue; Irvin CIV Carolyn E; Patrick CIV Tiffany L;Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC, EV; Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US); Angela Thompson;Interpretive@iarii.org

Subject: RE: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 AircraftDate: Monday, July 23, 2012 7:17:44 PMAttachments: NTHP ltr to USMC re MV-22 PA July 23 2012.pdf

Thank you for this e-mail notification. We received the copy of the Final Programmatic Agreement bymail on Wednesday July 18.Attached is a letter from the National Trust for Historic Preservation respectfully declining the invitationto sign the PA as a concurring party.

Sincerely,

Elizabeth S. Merritt, Deputy General CounselNational Trust for Historic Preservation1785 Massachusetts Ave. NWWashington, DC 20036(202) 588-6026www.preservationnation.org

Note my new e-mail address:

emerritt@savingplaces.org

________________________________________From: Cleghorn CIV June N [june.cleghorn@usmc.mil]Sent: Thursday, July 12, 2012 1:43 PMTo: Angie Westfall; Betsy Merritt; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; Faulkner, Kiersten; Jackson-Retondo,Elaine; jeromey@oha.org; Katie; keolal@oha.org; Louise Brodnitz; kahiwal@cs.com; A. Van HornDiamond; Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT); aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com;Angienora Rogers; Bill Aila; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Chad K. Baybayan;Chasmin Sokolovski; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Clive Cabral; Cy Harris; Donna Camvel;ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha;htf@lava.net; kaim@oha.org; Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; keohokalole@hawntel.net; KunaneAipoalani; Likeke Papa; Lori L. Buchanan; malamapono@aol.com; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov;mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; Moaikeala Tomasbelsky; nalanialua@gmail.com; napua4u@yahoo.com;Nau Kamalii; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov; Rick Ortiz; rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tom Lenchanko;vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org; kaleopaik@yahoo.com; JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com;pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; leahkpereira@aim.com; zensea1@gmail.com; mikesbchside@yahoo.com;imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.comCc: Rasmussen CIV Coral M; George Capt Derek R; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; Tome CIV Steven K; SibleyCIV James R; Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Goodfellow CIV Sue; Irvin CIV Carolyn E; PatrickCIV Tiffany L; Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC, EV; Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US);Angela Thompson; Interpretive@iarii.orgSubject: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft

mailto:emerritt@savingplaces.orgmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:angie.r.westfall@hawaii.govmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.orgmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:htf@lava.netmailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:lbuchanan@TNC.ORGmailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:zensea1@gmail.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.org

1785 Massachusetts Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20036 E: law@savingplaces.org P: 202.588.6000 F: 202.588.6272 www.Pres ervationNation.org

July 23, 2012 Captain D.R. George Director, Environmental Compliance & Protection Department Marine Corps Base Hawai‘i Box 63002 Kāne‘ohe Bay, HI 96863-3002 Re: Final Programmatic Agreement (PA) for the Basing of MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft in

Support of III Marine Expeditionary Force Elements in Hawai‘i Dear Capt. George, Thank you for the invitation to concur in the Final Programmatic Agreement (PA) Among the U.S. Marine Corps, the Hawai‘i SHPO, and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP) for the Basing of MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft in Support of III Marine Expeditionary Force (MEF) Elements in Hawai‘i. The National Trust for Historic Preservation respectfully declines to endorse the PA as a Concurring Party, in deference to the concerns about the undertaking that have been raised by the Native Hawai‘ian Organizations and the National Park Service, including concerns about the use of Kalaupapa National Historic Park. We have appreciated the opportunity to participate by telephone in the numerous and extensive consultation meetings conducted by the Marine Corps pursuant to Section 106. (In addition, we participated in an on-site consultation meeting in November 2010.) We also appreciate the Marine Corps’ willingness to include the National Trust and Historic Hawai‘i Foundation in follow-up consultation regarding the architectural design for the new buildings that will replace historic properties that are demolished. We intend to participate constructively in that future design review process. Most of all, it has been truly impressive to witness the dedication and commitment and sheer endurance of the other consulting parties, who have provided thoughtful and informed and passionate comments throughout the intensive consultation process, have mastered complex technical issues, and have been tireless in their principled advocacy. We have enormous respect for their views. Sincerely,

Elizabeth S. Merritt Deputy General Counsel cc: Consulting Parties

July 23, 2012

Captain D.R. George

Director, Environmental Compliance & Protection Department

Marine Corps Base Hawai‘i

Box 63002

Kāne‘ohe Bay, HI 96863-3002

1785 Massachusetts Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20036 E: law@savingplaces.org P: 202.588.6000 F: 202.588.6272 www.Pres ervationNation.org

July 23, 2012 Captain D.R. George Director, Environmental Compliance & Protection Department Marine Corps Base Hawai‘i Box 63002 Kāne‘ohe Bay, HI 96863-3002 Re: Final Programmatic Agreement (PA) for the Basing of MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft in

Support of III Marine Expeditionary Force Elements in Hawai‘i Dear Capt. George, Thank you for the invitation to concur in the Final Programmatic Agreement (PA) Among the U.S. Marine Corps, the Hawai‘i SHPO, and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP) for the Basing of MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft in Support of III Marine Expeditionary Force (MEF) Elements in Hawai‘i. The National Trust for Historic Preservation respectfully declines to endorse the PA as a Concurring Party, in deference to the concerns about the undertaking that have been raised by the Native Hawai‘ian Organizations and the National Park Service, including concerns about the use of Kalaupapa National Historic Park. We have appreciated the opportunity to participate by telephone in the numerous and extensive consultation meetings conducted by the Marine Corps pursuant to Section 106. (In addition, we participated in an on-site consultation meeting in November 2010.) We also appreciate the Marine Corps’ willingness to include the National Trust and Historic Hawai‘i Foundation in follow-up consultation regarding the architectural design for the new buildings that will replace historic properties that are demolished. We intend to participate constructively in that future design review process. Most of all, it has been truly impressive to witness the dedication and commitment and sheer endurance of the other consulting parties, who have provided thoughtful and informed and passionate comments throughout the intensive consultation process, have mastered complex technical issues, and have been tireless in their principled advocacy. We have enormous respect for their views. Sincerely,

Elizabeth S. Merritt Deputy General Counsel cc: Consulting Parties

From: kaleo paikTo: Lori L. Buchanan; Chad K. Baybayan; Cleghorn CIV June NCc: Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.gov; Bill Aila; aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com; Angela Thompson;

Angie Westfall; A. Van Horn Diamond; betsy_merritt@nthp.org; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Irvin CIV Carolyn E;Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Clive Cabral; Cy Harris; Chasmin Sokolovski; Kunane Aipoalani; Rasmussen CIV CoralM; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; George Capt Derek R; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC,EV; Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha; htf@lava.net; imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com; Interpretive@iarii.org; Donna Camvel; Sibley CIV James R; jeromey@oha.org;JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com; Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); kahiwal@cs.com; kaim@oha.org;Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Katie; keohokalole@hawntel.net;keolal@oha.org; Faulkner, Kiersten; Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT); Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US); LouiseBrodnitz; leahkpereira@aim.com; malamapono@aol.com; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov;mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; mikesbchside@yahoo.com; nalanialua@gmail.com; napua4u@yahoo.com; NauKamalii; Rick Ortiz; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Angienora Rogers; Likeke Papa; rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tome CIV Steven K; Goodfellow CIV Sue;Patrick CIV Tiffany L; Tom Lenchanko; Moaikeala Tomasbelsky; vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org;zensea1@gmail.com

Subject: Re: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 AircraftDate: Monday, July 23, 2012 8:22:19 PM

Aloha Lori,

I am very happy to see so many coming forward to verbalize their lack of support for the PA. That is atestament to our concerns and true consultation. I have been keeping track of all those who havestated they will not endorse this PA. I also thank the other consulting parties and their ohana for notsigning as well. This speaks volumes to our own SHPO.

Kaleo Paik

________________________________

From: Lori L. Buchanan To: Chad K. Baybayan ; Cleghorn CIV June N

Cc: "Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.gov" ; Bill Aila; "aloha@koolaupokohcc.org" ;"aloha1st@flex.com" ; Angela Thompson ; AngieWestfall ; A. Van Horn Diamond ;"betsy_merritt@nthp.org" ; "Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov"; Irvin CIV Carolyn E ; "Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov"; Clive Cabral ; Cy Harris; Chasmin Sokolovski ; Kunane Aipoalani; Rasmussen CIV Coral M ;"denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov" ; George Capt Derek R; "ekflores@hawaiiantel.net" ; "Goldkind, Ellyn PCIV NAVFAC, EV" ; "Eric_Brown@nps.gov" ;"Erika_Stein@nps.gov" ; Fred Cachola ; Halealoha; "htf@lava.net" ; "imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com" ; "Interpretive@iarii.org" ; Donna Camvel; Sibley CIV James R ; "jeromey@oha.org"; "JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com" ; "Taomia, Julie M CIV(US)" ; "kahiwal@cs.com" ; "kaim@oha.org"; "kaleopaik@yahoo.com" ; "Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov"; "Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3" ;Katie ; "keohokalole@hawntel.net" ;"keolal@oha.org" ; "Faulkner, Kiersten" ; "Aipoalani,Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT)" ; "Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US)"; Louise Brodnitz ; "leahkpereira@aim.com"; "malamapono@aol.com" ;"Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov" ; "mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com"; "mikesbchside@yahoo.com" ;

mailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:lbuchanan@TNC.ORGmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:angie.r.westfall@hawaii.govmailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:htf@lava.netmailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.orgmailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.orgmailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:zensea1@gmail.com

From: tomasbelsky@gmail.comTo: kaleo paikCc: Lori L. Buchanan; Chad K. Baybayan; Cleghorn CIV June N; Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.gov; Bill Aila;

aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com; Angela Thompson; Angie Westfall; A. Van Horn Diamond;betsy_merritt@nthp.org; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Irvin CIV Carolyn E; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Clive Cabral; CyHarris; Chasmin Sokolovski; Kunane Aipoalani; Rasmussen CIV Coral M; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; George CaptDerek R; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC, EV; Eric_Brown@nps.gov;Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha; htf@lava.net; imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com;Interpretive@iarii.org; Donna Camvel; Sibley CIV James R; jeromey@oha.org; JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com;Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); kahiwal@cs.com; kaim@oha.org; Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; Desilets, Karen A CIVNAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Katie; keohokalole@hawntel.net; keolal@oha.org; Faulkner, Kiersten; Aipoalani, Kunane KCONT (PMRF ITT); Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US); Louise Brodnitz; leahkpereira@aim.com; malamapono@aol.com;Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov; mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; mikesbchside@yahoo.com; nalanialua@gmail.com;napua4u@yahoo.com; Nau Kamalii; Rick Ortiz; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com;Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Angienora Rogers; Likeke Papa; rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tome CIVSteven K; Goodfellow CIV Sue; Patrick CIV Tiffany L; Tom Lenchanko; vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org;zensea1@gmail.com

Subject: Re: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 AircraftDate: Monday, July 23, 2012 10:41:40 PM

I have been a party of the conference calls through these past months, and in all clear conscience Icannot be a part of this programmatic agreement. Me ke Aloha pumehana , Moanike'ala Akaka -- Aloha Aina Eduation Center HIlo

On Mon, Jul 23, 2012 at 8:22 PM, kaleo paik wrote:

Aloha Lori,

I am very happy to see so many coming forward to verbalize their lack of support for the PA. That is a testament to our concerns and true consultation. I have been keeping track of all those whohave stated they will not endorse this PA. I also thank the other consulting parties and their ohana fornot signing as well. This speaks volumes to our own SHPO.

Kaleo Paik

________________________________

From: Lori L. Buchanan To: Chad K. Baybayan ; Cleghorn CIV June N

Cc: "Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.gov" ; Bill Aila; "aloha@koolaupokohcc.org" ;"aloha1st@flex.com" ; Angela Thompson ; AngieWestfall ; A. Van Horn Diamond ;"betsy_merritt@nthp.org" ; "Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov"; Irvin CIV Carolyn E ; "Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov"; Clive Cabral ; Cy Harris; Chasmin Sokolovski ; Kunane Aipoalani; Rasmussen CIV Coral M ;"denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov" ; George Capt Derek R; "ekflores@hawaiiantel.net" ; "Goldkind, Ellyn PCIV NAVFAC, EV" ; "Eric_Brown@nps.gov" ;"Erika_Stein@nps.gov" ; Fred Cachola ; Halealoha; "htf@lava.net" ; "imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com" ; "Interpretive@iarii.org" ; Donna Camvel

mailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:lbuchanan@tnc.orgmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:angie.r.westfall@hawaii.govmailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:htf@lava.netmailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.orgmailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.orgmailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:zensea1@gmail.com

From: Terri KekoolaniTo: tomasbelsky@gmail.com; kaleo paikCc: Lori L. Buchanan; Chad K. Baybayan; Cleghorn CIV June N; Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.gov; Bill Aila;

aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com; Angela Thompson; Angie Westfall; A. Van Horn Diamond;betsy_merritt@nthp.org; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Irvin CIV Carolyn E; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Clive Cabral; CyHarris; Chasmin Sokolovski; Kunane Aipoalani; Rasmussen CIV Coral M; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; George CaptDerek R; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC, EV; Eric_Brown@nps.gov;Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha; htf@lava.net; imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com;Interpretive@iarii.org; Donna Camvel; Sibley CIV James R; jeromey@oha.org; JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com;Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); kahiwal@cs.com; kaim@oha.org; Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; Desilets, Karen A CIVNAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Katie; keohokalole@hawntel.net; keolal@oha.org; Faulkner, Kiersten; Aipoalani, Kunane KCONT (PMRF ITT); Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US); Louise Brodnitz; leahkpereira@aim.com; malamapono@aol.com;Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov; mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; mikesbchside@yahoo.com; nalanialua@gmail.com;Nau Kamalii; Rick Ortiz; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Angienora Rogers; Likeke Papa; rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tome CIV Steven K; Goodfellow CIV Sue;Patrick CIV Tiffany L; Tom Lenchanko; vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org; zensea1@gmail.com

Subject: Re: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 AircraftDate: Monday, July 23, 2012 11:52:24 PM

Aloha kakou,

I have a hard copy of the PA dated July 11, 2012 which lists me as Keko'olani Ohana, Terrilee NapuaKeko'olani Raymond. I cannot sign the final PA. There are many issues involved with this plan that havenot been addressed in a manner that has truly incorporated a voice of not only our people the KanakaMaoli, our people specifically called upon to address cultural, historical concerns under Section 106, butalso whole communities of people across ka pae'aina 'o Hawai'i nei who are not native but who trulywant to protect our historic, cultural sites and the environment. This plan, MCB Hawaii MV-22/H-1Aircraft, is being bullied on us all.

Here is a link from Okinawa people who feel and are experiencing the same bullying phenomena aswell. Something is truly wrong with all of this.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/23/japan-osprey-aircraft-protests_n_1694510.html

Regarding Mo'okapu, there are ceded lands at Mo'okapu, national lands. It is not right to say you willnot discuss this as a part of the EIS.

Any plans for new construction that involves digging into areas that have been described as sand dunesof Mo'okapu and thus burial grounds, our Ohana absolutely opposes and warns you to cease and desistany disturbance of our kupuna.

There should be a separate, independent study of the Ethnohistory of Mo'okapu. We do not support theMarines conducting their own study. We hope the Office of Hawaiian Affairs and other Hawaiian civicgroups getting involved to conduct and fund an ethnonistory of Mo'okapu that truly speaks to thehistory, beauty and legacy of this very important wahi pana.

The Marines should stop any further construction at Mo'okapu and should instead work on a plan todecrease their construction and decommission parts o Mo'okapu that can be returned to our peopleimmediately. Work with our people to truly reconcile past harms in a pono way.

Anyone who works in buildings or lives in homes , or drives on the roads, or plays golf on the sanddunes of Mo'okapu should be fully apprised of the existence of human remains on that property andwhy it exists. Any military personnel who sign a lease agreement to live in a house on Mo'okapu shouldbe fully informed in a legal real estate transaction, about the presence of human remains and why it isthere.

Further, my position to NOT sign this PA agreement should not exclude me from consultation. There isharm, adverse impacts, injury on our wahi pana. All Kanaka Maoli, Native Hawaiian organizations mustbe included in any further consultation and kept fully informed about what the Marines, the Navy or theDepartment of Defense intend to continue to do or plan on our wahi pana despite our objections.

mailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:lbuchanan@tnc.orgmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:angie.r.westfall@hawaii.govmailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:htf@lava.netmailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.orgmailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.orgmailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:zensea1@gmail.comhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/23/japan-osprey-aircraft-protests_n_1694510.html

Mahalo to all...hope I met the deadline...

Aloha a hui hou,

Terrilee Napua Keko'olani-Raymond Ohanamai Solomon Leihuanui Kalanimaiheuila Peleiholani

From: "tomasbelsky@gmail.com" To: kaleo paik Cc: Lori L. Buchanan ; Chad K. Baybayan ;Cleghorn CIV June N ; "Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.gov" ; Bill Aila ; "aloha@koolaupokohcc.org"; "aloha1st@flex.com" ; Angela Thompson; Angie Westfall ; A. Van Horn Diamond; "betsy_merritt@nthp.org" ;"Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov" ; Irvin CIV Carolyn E ;"Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov" ; Clive Cabral ; Cy Harris; Chasmin Sokolovski ; Kunane Aipoalani; Rasmussen CIV Coral M ;"denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov" ; George Capt Derek R; "ekflores@hawaiiantel.net" ; "Goldkind, Ellyn PCIV NAVFAC, EV" ; "Eric_Brown@nps.gov" ;"Erika_Stein@nps.gov" ; Fred Cachola ; Halealoha; "htf@lava.net" ; "imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com" ; "Interpretive@iarii.org" ; Donna Camvel; Sibley CIV James R ; "jeromey@oha.org"; "JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com" ; "Taomia, Julie M CIV(US)" ; "kahiwal@cs.com" ; "kaim@oha.org"; "Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov" ; "Desilets, Karen ACIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3" ; Katie ;"keohokalole@hawntel.net" ; "keolal@oha.org" ;"Faulkner, Kiersten" ; "Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT)"; "Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US)" ; LouiseBrodnitz ; "leahkpereira@aim.com" ;"malamapono@aol.com" ; "Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov"; "mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com" ;"mikesbchside@yahoo.com" ; "nalanialua@gmail.com"; "napua4u@yahoo.com" ; Nau Kamalii; Rick Ortiz ; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; "pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com" ;"Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov" ; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake ;Angienora Rogers ; Likeke Papa ;"rosina@hawaii.rr.com" ; Tome CIV Steven K ;Goodfellow CIV Sue ; Patrick CIV Tiffany L ;Tom Lenchanko ; "vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org"; "zensea1@gmail.com" Sent: Monday, July 23, 2012 10:41 PM

From: Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govTo: Lori L. BuchananCc: Bill Aila; aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com; Angela Thompson; Angie Westfall; A. Van Horn

Diamond; betsy_merritt@nthp.org; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Irvin CIV Carolyn E; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; CliveCabral; Cy Harris; Chasmin Sokolovski; Kunane Aipoalani; Rasmussen CIV Coral M; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov;George Capt Derek R; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.gov; Goldkind, Ellyn P CIVNAVFAC, EV; Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola; Halealoha; htf@lava.net; imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com; Interpretive@iarii.org; Donna Camvel; Sibley CIV James R; jeromey@oha.org;JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com; Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); Cleghorn CIV June N; kahiwal@cs.com; kaim@oha.org;kaleo paik; Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Katie; Chad K. Baybayan;keohokalole@hawntel.net; keolal@oha.org; Faulkner, Kiersten; Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT); Lucking,Laurie J CIV (US); Louise Brodnitz; leahkpereira@aim.com; malamapono@aol.com;Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov; mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com; mikesbchside@yahoo.com; nalanialua@gmail.com;napua4u@yahoo.com; Nau Kamalii; Rick Ortiz; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Angienora Rogers; Likeke Papa; rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tome CIV Steven K; Goodfellow CIV Sue;Patrick CIV Tiffany L; Tom Lenchanko; Moaikeala Tomasbelsky; vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org;zensea1@gmail.com

Subject: RE: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 AircraftDate: Tuesday, July 24, 2012 8:32:02 AM

Aloha Lori,

The chair is traveling but I will certainly update him when he gets back and include your request in thebrief.

Pua

RE: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft

Lori L. Buchanan to: kaleo paik, Chad K. Baybayan , Cleghorn CIV June N 07/24/2012 08:12 AM

Cc: "Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.gov", "Bill Aila", "aloha@koolaupokohcc.org" ,"aloha1st@flex.com", "Angela Thompson", Angie Westfall , "A. Van Horn Diamond" ,"betsy_merritt@nthp.org" , "Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov", Irvin CIV Carolyn E,"Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov" , Clive Cabral, Cy Harris , Chasmin Sokolovski, "Kunane Aipoalani",Rasmussen CIV Coral M , "denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov" , George Capt Derek R,"ekflores@hawaiiantel.net", "Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC, EV", "Eric_Brown@nps.gov" ,"Erika_Stein@nps.gov", "Fred Cachola", Halealoha, "htf@lava.net", "imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com" ,"Interpretive@iarii.org" , Donna Camvel, "Sibley CIV James R", "jeromey@oha.org","JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com", "Taomia, Julie M CIV (US)" , "kahiwal@cs.com", "kaim@oha.org","Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov" , "Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3" , Katie,"keohokalole@hawntel.net", "keolal@oha.org" , "Faulkner, Kiersten", "Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT(PMRF ITT)", "Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US)", Louise Brodnitz , "leahkpereira@aim.com","malamapono@aol.com", "Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov" , "mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com" ,"mikesbchside@yahoo.com" , "nalanialua@gmail.com", "napua4u@yahoo.com", Nau Kamalii ,Rick Ortiz, "Ujimori CIV Paulette B", "pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com" , "Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov", "CherylLovell-Obatake", Angienora Rogers , Likeke Papa, "rosina@hawaii.rr.com", Tome CIV Steven K , Goodfellow CIV Sue, "Patrick CIV Tiffany L", Tom Lenchanko , Moaikeala Tomasbelsky,"vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org", "zensea1@gmail.com"

From: "Lori L. Buchanan" To: kaleo paik , "Chad K. Baybayan" ,

mailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:lbuchanan@TNC.ORGmailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:angie.r.westfall@hawaii.govmailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:htf@lava.netmailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.orgmailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:Kiersten@historichawaii.orgmailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:zensea1@gmail.com

From: htf@lava.netTo: Cleghorn CIV June NCc: George Capt Derek R; Rasmussen CIV Coral M; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; Tome CIV Steven K; Sibley CIV James

R; Desilets, Karen A CIV NAVFAC PAC ,EV3; Goodfellow CIV Sue; Irvin CIV Carolyn E; Patrick CIV Tiffany L;Goldkind, Ellyn P CIV NAVFAC, EV; Taomia, Julie M CIV (US); Angie Westfall; National Trust for HistoricPreservation; denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; Jackson-Retondo, Elaine; jeromey@oha.org; Katie Kissling; KeolaLindsey; Louise Brodnitz; kahiwal@cs.com; A. Van Horn Diamond; Aipoalani, Kunane K CONT (PMRF ITT);aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com; Angienora Rogers; Bill Aila; Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov;Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; Chad K. Baybayan; Chasmin Sokolovski; Cheryl Lovell-Obatake; Clive Cabral; Cy Harris;Donna Camvel; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; Fred Cachola;Halealoha; kaim@oha.org; Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; keohokalole@hawntel.net; Kunane Aipoalani; LikekePapa; Lori L. Buchanan; Mahealani Cypher; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov; Creighton & Cathleen Mattoon;Moaikeala Tomasbelsky; nalanialua@gmail.com; napua4u@yahoo.com; Nau Kamalii; Pua Aiu; Rick Ortiz;rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tom Lenchanko; vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org; Kaleo Paik; JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com;pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; leahkpereira@aim.com; zensea1@gmail.com; mikesbchside@yahoo.com; Isaac Harp;Lucking, Laurie J CIV (US); Angela Thompson; Interpretive@iarii.org; William Aila (william.j.aila@hawaii.gov);Glenn Mason (gm@masonarch.com)

Subject: MCB FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 AircraftDate: Tuesday, July 24, 2012 10:42:02 PMAttachments: Military 106 PA agreement 7-23-12.docx

ATT1296981.htm

Aloha, Hawaii's Thousand Friends is unable to sign the Marine Corps Final Programmatic Agreement forbasing MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft in Hawai`i. Letter is attached.

Mahalo,

Donna WongExecutive DirectorHawaii's Thousand FriendsPhone/fax: 808-262-0682www.hawaiis1000friends.org

If the people lead, the leaders will follow. -- Mahatma Gandhi

mailto:htf@lava.netmailto:june.cleghorn@usmc.milmailto:derek.george@usmc.milmailto:coral.rasmussen@usmc.milmailto:paulette.ujimori@usmc.milmailto:steven.tome@usmc.milmailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:james.r.sibley@usmc.milmailto:karen.desilets@navy.milmailto:sue.goodfellow@usmc.milmailto:carolyn.irvin@usmc.milmailto:tiffany.patrick@usmc.milmailto:ellyn.goldkind@navy.milmailto:julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.milmailto:angie.r.westfall@hawaii.govmailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:betsy_merritt@nthp.orgmailto:denoa.naboa@hawaii.govmailto:Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.govmailto:jeromey@oha.orgmailto:Katie@historichawaii.orgmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:keolal@oha.orgmailto:lbrodnitz@achp.govmailto:kahiwal@cs.commailto:antiquarian@hawaii.rr.commailto:kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.milmailto:aloha@koolaupokohcc.orgmailto:aloha1st@flex.commailto:rangien2010@yahoo.commailto:ailaw001@hawaii.rr.commailto:Cari_Kreshak@nps.govmailto:Cathy_Gilbert@nps.govmailto:kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.orgmailto:chazinhawaii@aol.commailto:puna_moku@hotmail.commailto:ccabral@hawaii.rr.commailto:charris002@hawaii.rr.commailto:iolekaa@hawaii.rr.commailto:ekflores@hawaiiantel.netmailto:Eric_Brown@nps.govmailto:Erika_Stein@nps.govmailto:FredCachola@aol.commailto:halealoha@wave.hicv.netmailto:kaim@oha.orgmailto:Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.govmailto:keohokalole@hawntel.netmailto:ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.netmailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:rgjpapa@yahoo.commailto:lbuchanan@TNC.ORGmailto:malamapono@aol.commailto:Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.govmailto:mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.commailto:tomasbelsky@gmail.commailto:nalanialua@gmail.commailto:napua4u@yahoo.commailto:NKamalii@papaolalokahi.orgmailto:Pua.Aiu@hawaii.govmailto:ortizr008@hawaii.rr.commailto:rosina@hawaii.rr.commailto:TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.commailto:vmonson@kalaupapaohana.orgmailto:kaleopaik@yahoo.commailto:JrKeoneakapu@gmail.commailto:pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.commailto:leahkpereira@aim.commailto:zensea1@gmail.commailto:mikesbchside@yahoo.commailto:imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.commailto:laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.milmailto:angela@masonarch.commailto:Interpretive@iarii.orgmailto:william.j.aila@hawaii.govmailto:gm@masonarch.com

July 23, 12

Captain D. R. George

Director, Environmental Compliance & Protection Department

Marine Crops Base Hawai`i

Box 63002

Kaneohe Bay, Hawai`i 96803-3002

RE:Final Programmatic Agreement (PA) for the Basing of MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft in Support of III Marine Expeditionary Force Elements in Hawai`i

Dear Captain George;

Hawaii’s Thousand Friends (HTF) appreciates the opportunity to participate in the National Historic Preservation Act Section 106 process as a consulting party but must decline the request to concur with the Programmatic Agreement.

Particularly troubling was the proposed increased military use of Kalaupapa Airport for training flights. Kalaupapa is a national landmark of spiritual and cultural significance to its residents and the people of Hawai`i nei so we are pleased that the additional training flights at Kalaupapa Airport have been eliminated.

Section 106 requires federal agencies to determine how historic properties might be affected and explore measures to avoid or reduce harm to historic properties.

Yet the PA that we are asked to sign states that the Marine Corps has determined that the effects on historic properties cannot be fully determined before approval of the Undertaking and that some areas have not been adequately inventoried and may require additional identification effort. (Emphasis added)

Under these circumstances it is impossible for Hawaii’s Thousand Friends to sign this PA.

Sincerely,

Donna Wong

Executive Director

July 23, 12 Captain D. R. George Director, Environmental Compliance & Protection Department Marine Crops Base Hawai`i Box 63002 Kaneohe Bay, Hawai`i 96803-3002 RE: Final Programmatic Agreement (PA) for the Basing of MV-22 and H-1 Aircraft in Support of III Marine Expeditionary Force Elements in Hawai`i Dear Captain George; Hawaii’s Thousand Friends (HTF) appreciates the opportunity to participate in the National Historic Preservation Act Section 106 process as a consulting party but must decline the request to concur with the Programmatic Agreement. Particularly troubling was the proposed increased military use of Kalaupapa Airport for training flights. Kalaupapa is a national landmark of spiritual and cultural significance to its residents and the people of Hawai`i nei so we are pleased that the additional training flights at Kalaupapa Airport have been eliminated. Section 106 requires federal agencies to determine how historic properties might be affected and explore measures to avoid or reduce harm to historic properties. Yet the PA that we are asked to sign states that the Marine Corps has determined that the effects on historic properties cannot be fully determined before approval of the Undertaking and that some areas have not been adequately inventoried and may require additional identification effort. (Emphasis added) Under these circumstances it is impossible for Hawaii’s Thousand Friends to sign this PA. Sincerely, Donna Wong Executive Director

From: malamapono@aol.comTo: lbuchanan@TNC.ORG; kaleopaik@yahoo.com; kbaybayan@imiloahawaii.org; Cleghorn CIV June NCc: Elaine_Jackson-Retondo@nps.gov; ailaw001@hawaii.rr.com; aloha@koolaupokohcc.org; aloha1st@flex.com;

angela@masonarch.com; angie.r.westfall@hawaii.gov; antiquarian@hawaii.rr.com; betsy_merritt@nthp.org;Cari_Kreshak@nps.gov; Irvin CIV Carolyn E; Cathy_Gilbert@nps.gov; ccabral@hawaii.rr.com;charris002@hawaii.rr.com; chazinhawaii@aol.com; ckaipoalani@hawaiiantel.net; Rasmussen CIV Coral M;denoa.naboa@hawaii.gov; George Capt Derek R; ekflores@hawaiiantel.net; ellyn.goldkind@navy.mil;Eric_Brown@nps.gov; Erika_Stein@nps.gov; FredCachola@aol.com; halealoha@wave.hicv.net; htf@lava.net;imua-hawaii@hawaii.rr.com; Interpretive@iarii.org; iolekaa@hawaii.rr.com; Sibley CIV James R;jeromey@oha.org; JrKeoneakapu@gmail.com; julie.m.taomia.civ@mail.mil; kahiwal@cs.com; kaim@oha.org;Kaohulani_McGuire@nps.gov; karen.desilets@navy.mil; Katie@historichawaii.org; keohokalole@hawntel.net;keolal@oha.org; Kiersten@historichawaii.org; kunane.aipoalani.ctr@navy.mil; laurie.j.lucking.civ@mail.mil;lbrodnitz@achp.gov; leahkpereira@aim.com; Mary_Jane_Naone@nps.gov; mattoonc001@hawaii.rr.com;mikesbchside@yahoo.com; nalanialua@gmail.com; napua4u@yahoo.com; NKamalii@papaolalokahi.org;ortizr008@hawaii.rr.com; Ujimori CIV Paulette B; pkaleikini@hawaii.rr.com; Pua.Aiu@hawaii.gov;puna_moku@hotmail.com; rangien2010@yahoo.com; rgjpapa@yahoo.com; rosina@hawaii.rr.com; Tome CIVSteven K; Goodfellow CIV Sue; Patrick CIV Tiffany L; TLENCHANKO1@hawaii.rr.com; tomasbelsky@gmail.com;vmonson@kalaupapaohana.org; zensea1@gmail.com

Subject: Re: MCB Hawaii FINAL PA - For Signature - MV-22 and H-1 AircraftDate: Wednesday, July 25, 2012 4:19:14 PM

Aloha mai kakou,

On behalf of the Ko`olaupoko Hawaiian Civic Club, the Ko`olau Foundation, and Kako`o `Oiwi, weregret to inform the U.S. Navy that we will be unable to sign the programmatic agreement for variousreasons already stated in earlier communications but also for this reason:

It is our belief that the plan to expand military operations at various locations in Hawai`i was pre-determined and decided, long before we began these consultations. While we appreciate everyone'sefforts to improve on the plan, we continue to object to the fact that the U.S. government proceedswith its undertakings before 106 consultations or EIS mitigations are adequately completed oraddressed.

It is inappropriate that serious implementation of the proposed expansion and training actually beganbefore our consultations were completed. As was said before, it makes a mockery of the many hours oftime and effort donated by our community advocates and native Hawaiians who came to the table tooffer their suggestions for improving the plan.

Albeit at this late date, we wish, for the record, to repeat some of the earlier concerns we raised:

1) That the proposed flight patterns take your aircraft over land areas where residents and farms arelocated, and we are concerned about chemical drift that may affect our food crops and streams that areimportant to native Hawaiian cultural practices.

2) That the proposed flight patterns take your aircraft over Kane`ohe bay, disturbing culturalpractitioners who are engaged in fishing or other practices in and around the bay.

3) That the times during which your training would take place may disturb Hawaiian cultural activitiesthat require discussions or pule (prayers) that would be interrupted by the loud sounds of aircraftoverhead.

Mahalo for this opportunity to offer our mana`o.

Offered on behalf of:

Alice P. Hewett, Presiden