privileged and confidential - epd.gov.hk · implement the proposed software into the upgraded p ath...

16
Privileged and Confidential Executive Summary Agreement No. CE 27/2007 (EP) Upgrade of a Regional Air Quality Modelling System (PATH) Feasibility Study DRAFT FINAL HK1100066 1 Executive Summary Agreement No. CE 27/2007 (EP) Upgrade of a Regional Air Quality Modelling System (PATH) – Feasibility Study Prepared for: Environmental Protection Department Hong Kong Prepared by: ENVIRON Hong Kong Limited Date: November, 2011 Project Number: HK1100066 Report Reference: R1810_V2.2

Upload: dinhkien

Post on 21-Aug-2019

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

1

E

xec

utiv

e S

um

mary

A

gre

em

ent N

o. C

E 2

7/2

00

7 (E

P) U

pgra

de

of a

R

egio

nal A

ir Quality

Mo

dellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H)

– F

easib

ility S

tud

y

Pre

pare

d fo

r:

En

viro

nm

en

tal P

rote

ctio

n D

ep

artm

en

t H

on

g K

on

g

Pre

pare

d b

y:

EN

VIR

ON

Ho

ng

Ko

ng

Lim

ited

Date

: N

ovem

ber, 2

011

Pro

ject N

um

ber:

HK

1100066

Report R

efe

rence:

R1810_V

2.2

Page 2: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

2

Tab

le o

f Co

nte

nts

1.

INT

RO

DU

CT

ION

.......................................................................................................................... 1

2.

The O

ld m

odellin

g sy

stem

and th

e upgrad

ed m

odellin

g sy

stem

....................................................... 3

3.

Mo

dellin

g D

om

ain

s and G

rid S

tructu

re ........................................................................................... 5

4.

Mo

dellin

g E

piso

des ......................................................................................................................... 9

5.

Syste

m C

om

po

nents ...................................................................................................................... 1

0

5.1

E

missio

ns M

odellin

g S

oftw

are .................................................................................................. 10

5.2

M

eteoro

log

ical M

odelin

g S

yste

m .............................................................................................. 1

1

5.3

C

hem

ical T

ransp

ort M

odellin

g S

oftw

are ................................................................................... 11

5.4

T

ransp

ort D

ata Co

mp

ilation an

d M

odellin

g ............................................................................... 1

2

5.5

D

ata Analy

sis and V

isualisatio

n S

oftw

are ................................................................................. 13

6.

Syste

m O

ptim

izatio

n an

d D

em

onstratio

n....................................................................................... 1

3

7.

Po

st Imp

lem

entatio

n...................................................................................................................... 1

4

8.

Co

nclu

sion .................................................................................................................................... 1

4

Page 3: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

1

1.

INT

RO

DU

CT

ION

In o

rde

r to a

dd

ress th

e co

mp

lica

ted

air q

ua

lity issu

es c

onfro

nte

d b

y Hong

Kon

g, th

e E

nviro

nm

enta

l P

rote

ctio

n D

ep

artm

en

t (EP

D) e

sta

blis

he

d in

200

0 a

co

mp

rehe

nsiv

e n

um

eric

al a

ir qua

lity m

od

ellin

g

syste

m, kn

ow

n a

s P

AT

H (“P

ollu

tan

ts in

the

Atm

osp

he

re a

nd

the

ir Tra

nsp

ort o

ve

r Hon

gko

ng

”). Th

e

PA

TH

mo

de

ling s

yste

m w

as b

ased

on w

ell-d

eve

lope

d c

om

pu

ter m

ode

lling te

chn

olo

gie

s ava

ilab

le

in th

e m

ode

lling

com

mun

ity a

t the tim

e it w

as d

eve

lope

d (A

gre

em

en

t No

. CE

46

/95

). R

ecen

t stu

die

s ca

rried

ou

t by E

PD

ha

ve in

dic

ate

d th

at th

e p

resen

t mo

de

lling

sys

tem

requ

ires a

n

upg

rade

in o

rde

r to b

ette

r und

ers

tand

an

d re

so

lve s

om

e a

ir qu

ality

pro

ble

ms in

Hon

g K

ong

an

d th

e

Pe

arl R

ive

r De

lta R

eg

ion. T

he

up

gra

de

effo

rts inclu

ded

upd

ate

s to

the

me

teo

rolo

gica

l, em

issio

ns

and

che

mic

al tra

nsp

ort m

od

els

. The

ob

jectiv

es o

f the

stud

y in

clu

de

:

• T

o re

pla

ce

the

exis

ting

mo

du

les o

f the

PA

TH

mo

de

lling

syste

m w

ith cu

rren

t sta

te-o

f-the

-art

ope

n so

urc

e so

ftwa

re fo

r pe

rform

ing th

e co

re fu

nctio

ns o

f PA

TH

and

pro

vid

ing e

nric

hed

fun

ctiona

lity;

• T

o d

ete

rmin

e th

e c

om

pu

ting

ha

rdw

are

requ

irem

en

ts for su

pp

ortin

g th

e o

pe

ratio

ns o

f the

pro

po

sed

syste

m in

clu

din

g m

akin

g d

aily

air q

ua

lity fore

castin

g o

pe

ratio

n;

To

pe

rform

sen

sitiv

ity m

ode

l sim

ula

tion

s fo

r de

term

inin

g th

e o

ptim

al c

onfig

ura

tions fo

r ea

ch

co

mp

on

en

t of th

e p

ropo

sed

sys

tem

, an

d

To

revie

w th

e p

erfo

rman

ce o

f the p

ropo

sed

syste

m a

nd

pro

vid

e a

de

velo

pm

en

t road

map

to ca

ter fo

r futu

re te

chno

log

y a

dva

nce

men

t. T

he

ag

ree

men

t ca

lled

for th

e fo

llow

ing

specific

task

s to

be

un

de

rtake

n:

• R

evie

w

the

la

test

de

ve

lop

men

t in

th

e

scie

nce

an

d

techn

olo

gy

of

em

issio

n

mo

de

lling

, m

ete

oro

log

ica

l mo

de

lling

and

reg

ion

al a

ir qu

ality m

od

ellin

g;

Re

vie

w th

e s

tate

-of-th

e-a

rt softw

are

ava

ilab

le to

the

air q

ua

lity m

od

ellin

g co

mm

un

ity;

• R

evie

w th

e c

urre

nt se

tup

and

ope

ratio

n o

f the

PA

TH

mo

de

lling

sys

tem

;

• C

om

pile

tran

spo

rt data

for H

on

g K

on

g a

nd th

e G

uan

gd

on

g P

rovin

ce fo

r the

estim

atio

n o

f ve

hicu

lar e

mis

sio

ns;

Pro

po

se s

tate

-of-th

e-a

rt open

sou

rce s

oftw

are

to re

pla

ce

the

core

mo

du

les in

the P

AT

H

mo

de

lling

syste

m;

• Im

ple

me

nt th

e p

ropo

sed

softw

are

into

the

upg

rade

d P

AT

H m

ode

lling

syste

m;

• Id

en

tify

the

p

ara

me

ters

th

at

ha

ve

sig

nific

an

t im

pa

ct

on

th

e

mod

ellin

g

resu

lts

of

the

upg

rade

d s

yste

m;

Eva

lua

te th

e p

erfo

rman

ce o

f the

upg

rade

d s

yste

m;

• P

rovid

e tra

inin

g to

G

ove

rnm

en

t assig

ned

p

erso

nne

l o

n th

e se

tup an

d op

era

tion of

the

upg

rade

d s

yste

m; a

nd

Page 4: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

2

• R

eco

mm

en

d

furth

er

de

velo

pm

en

t of

the

mode

lling

syste

m

to

cate

r fo

r te

chn

olo

gy

ad

van

cem

en

t.

Page 5: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

3

2.

Th

e O

ld m

od

ellin

g s

yste

m an

d th

e u

pg

rad

ed

m

od

ellin

g

syste

m

A

n

um

eric

al

mo

de

lling

syste

m fo

r a

ir p

ollu

tion

m

ust

de

al

with

th

ree

p

roce

sse

s:

me

teo

rolo

gy,

em

issio

n a

nd

che

mic

al tra

nsfo

rma

tion

. The

de

velo

pm

en

t fram

ew

ork

used

in th

e cu

rrent P

AT

H

syste

m is

sch

em

atica

lly re

pre

sen

ted

in F

igu

re 1

. F

igu

re 1

: Sc

he

ma

tic D

iag

ram

sh

ow

ing

inte

rac

tion

of th

e o

ld P

AT

H C

om

po

ne

nts

T

hre

e typ

es of

atm

osp

he

ric p

rocesse

s a

re nu

me

rica

lly re

pre

sente

d in

th

e o

ld P

AT

H b

y th

ree

dis

tinct s

imu

latio

n m

odu

les:

• M

eso

sca

le M

ode

l Ve

rsio

n 5

(MM

5) fo

r mete

oro

logic

al s

imu

latio

n;

• E

mis

sio

n M

ode

lling

Syste

m (E

MS

-95

) for e

mis

sio

n m

od

ellin

g; a

nd

• S

AR

MA

P A

ir Qu

ality M

od

el (S

AQ

M) fo

r tran

spo

rt and

che

mis

try s

imu

latio

n.

Th

e u

pg

rad

ed

PA

TH

syste

m co

nsis

ts o

f a n

um

be

r of s

ep

ara

te m

odu

les w

hose

execu

tion

flow

is sh

ow

n in

Fig

ure

2. T

he m

ajo

r co

mpo

nen

ts o

f each

syste

m m

od

ule

ba

sed o

n cu

rrent sta

te-o

f-the

-a

rt softw

are

tha

t wa

s s

ele

cted

and

use

d to

up

gra

de

the

curre

nt P

AT

H s

yste

m a

re a

s fo

llow

s:

Page 6: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

4

Fig

ure

2. S

ch

em

atic

Dia

gra

m s

ho

win

g in

tera

ctio

n o

f the

Up

gra

de

d P

AT

H C

om

po

ne

nts

• M

eso

sca

le

Mo

de

l ve

rsio

n

5

(MM

5)

an

d

the

W

eath

er

Re

sea

rch

Fo

reca

st (W

RF

) a

re

me

teo

rolo

gic

al

mo

de

l so

ftwa

re th

at

requ

ires in

pu

t d

ata

a

s 1

) ro

utin

e ob

se

rvatio

ns w

ith

upp

er

air

and

su

rface re

po

rts,

inclu

din

g w

ind,

tem

pe

ratu

re,

rela

tive hu

mid

ity,

sea

-leve

l p

ressu

re, a

nd

sea

su

rface

tem

pe

ratu

re, 2

) glo

ba

l mo

de

l an

d o

the

r reg

ion

al m

ode

l's o

utp

ut

eith

er

as

first

gue

ss

for

ob

jective

a

na

lysis

, o

r a

s la

tera

l bo

un

da

ry

cond

ition

s,

an

d

3)

topo

gra

ph

ic a

nd la

ndu

se

data

. The

MM

5/W

RF

softw

are

gen

era

tes m

ete

oro

log

ical o

utp

ut

da

ta re

qu

ired

by th

e S

MO

KE

, CM

AQ

, an

d C

AM

x m

od

ule

s.

MC

IP is

a d

ata

con

ve

rsio

n u

tility to

con

vert M

M5

/WR

F o

utp

ut to

be u

sed b

y C

MA

Q a

nd

SM

OK

E.

Me

t2C

AM

x is

a d

ata

con

ve

rsio

n u

tility to

con

vert M

M5

/WR

F o

utp

ut to

be u

sed

by C

AM

x

• T

he

S

pa

rse

M

atrix

O

pe

rato

r K

ern

el

Em

issio

ns (S

MO

KE

), th

e C

on

solid

ate

d C

om

mu

nity

Em

issio

ns P

roce

ssin

g T

oo

l (CO

NC

EP

T), th

e M

od

el o

f Em

issio

ns o

f Ga

se

s an

d A

ero

sols

from

Natu

re (M

EG

AN

) and

the

Bio

gen

ic E

mis

sio

n In

ven

tory

Syste

m (B

EIS

) we

re se

lecte

d

as th

e e

mis

sio

n m

od

ellin

g s

yste

ms fo

r the u

pg

rade

d P

AT

H.

• C

om

mu

nity

Mu

ltisca

le

Air

Qua

lity

(CM

AQ

) a

nd

Co

mp

rehe

nsive

A

ir-qua

lity

Mo

de

l w

ith

exte

nsio

ns (C

AM

x) C

he

mic

al T

ranspo

rt Mo

de

ls (C

TM

s) w

ere

sele

cted

for th

e u

pg

rad

ed

PA

TH

syste

m a

s tra

nsp

ort a

nd

che

mis

try s

imu

latio

n. It re

qu

ires m

ete

oro

log

ica

l data

outp

ut

by th

e M

M5

or W

RF

mo

du

le, a

nd

pre

-gen

era

ted

or re

al-tim

e g

ene

rate

d e

mis

sio

ns d

ata

o

utp

ut

by S

MO

KE

, C

ON

CE

PT

, M

EG

AN

a

nd

/or

BE

IS m

odu

les.

The

C

MA

Q a

nd

C

AM

x

gen

era

te a

ir qu

ality

da

ta.

MM

5/W

RF

CA

Mx

Met2

CA

Mx

SM

OK

E

MC

IP

CM

AQ

Page 7: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

5

3.

Mo

dellin

g D

om

ain

s a

nd

Grid

Stru

ctu

re

Th

e o

ld P

AT

H m

ode

ling

syste

m u

sed

a 4

0.5

/13

.5/4

.5/1

.5/0

.5 km

grid

stru

ctu

re.

Th

e m

ode

ling

do

ma

ins

we

re

de

velo

pe

d

a

decad

e

ag

o

and

re

pre

sen

ted

an

ap

pro

pria

te

trad

e-o

ff be

twe

en

co

mp

uta

tiona

l requ

irem

en

ts a

nd

reso

lvin

g e

mis

sio

ns a

nd

air q

ua

lity in

the

hig

hly

de

nse

Hon

g K

on

g

are

a a

t tha

t time

. Th

ere

are

are

as fo

r imp

rovem

en

t in th

e g

rid s

tructu

re to

add

ress th

e c

urre

nt

Ho

ng

Kon

g a

ir qu

ality

and

air q

ua

lity re

late

d p

roble

ms fo

r long

term

ap

plic

atio

ns. B

y s

tud

yin

g th

e

cu

rren

t PA

TH

mo

de

ling

syste

m d

om

ain

defin

ition

s a

nd

takin

g a

dva

nta

ge

of th

e a

dva

nce

men

t in

co

mp

utin

g p

ow

er o

ver th

e la

st d

eca

de

, an

alte

rnativ

e e

xpan

de

d g

rid s

yste

m h

as b

een

se

lecte

d fo

r th

e u

pg

rad

ed

PA

TH

mo

de

ling s

yste

m.

Fo

ur n

este

d m

esh

es w

ith g

rid s

pa

cin

g o

f 27

, 9, 3

an

d 1

km

are

use

d fo

r the

mo

de

ling

do

ma

ins o

f

the m

ete

oro

log

ica

l a

nd

e

mis

sio

ns/C

TM

m

ode

ls.

T

he cha

racte

ristic

s of

the

se d

om

ain

s a

re a

s

follo

ws:

D1

-- Grid

1 (2

7 k

m):

Th

e co

ars

est o

ute

r grid

wou

ld in

clu

de

alm

ost a

ll of C

hin

a a

nd

Japa

n a

s w

ell

as T

aiw

an

, Vie

tna

m, L

ao

s, C

am

bod

ia, T

ha

iland

, etc

. Th

is is m

uch

larg

er

than

th

e

old

P

AT

H

mod

ellin

g

sys

tem

ou

ter

grid

th

at

just

cove

rs S

outh

ea

stern

Ch

ina

, Ta

iwan

and

No

rth V

ietn

am

. D

2 -- G

rid 2

(9 k

m):

Th

e se

con

d g

rid w

ou

ld cove

r S

ou

the

aste

rn C

hin

a in

clu

din

g G

uan

gd

ong

Pro

vin

ce,

Hon

g K

ong an

d M

aca

o.

T

his

is

in co

ntra

st

to th

e o

ld P

AT

H

mo

de

l config

ura

tion

wh

ose

secon

d (1

3.5

km

) grid

co

vers

the

ma

jority

of

Gu

an

gd

on

g P

rovin

ce.

D3

-- Grid

3 (3

km

) : T

he th

ird n

este

d g

rid co

ve

rs mo

st of G

ua

ng

do

ng P

rovin

ce, H

on

g K

ong

and

M

aca

u. T

he o

ld P

AT

H s

yste

m th

ird (4

.5 k

m) g

rid c

ove

rs ma

inly H

on

g K

ong

a

nd

the

PR

D.

D4

-- Grid

4 (1

km

): T

he

fina

l grid

in th

e a

ltern

ative

do

ma

in c

onfig

ura

tion

is fo

cu

sed o

n th

e P

RD

re

gio

n, a

s co

mp

are

d to

just H

ong

Kon

g w

ith th

e o

ld P

AT

H c

onfig

ura

tion.

Fig

ure

s 3

to 6

sho

w th

e h

oriz

onta

l exte

nts

of th

e fo

ur m

ode

ling d

om

ain

s. The

do

ma

ins o

f the

Ch

em

ica

l Tra

nsp

ort M

od

el (C

TM

) and

em

issio

ns m

od

els w

ill be

slig

htly

sm

alle

r and

are

ne

sted

in

the m

ete

oro

log

ical m

od

el d

om

ain

.

Page 8: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

6

F

igu

re 3

. 27

-km

MM

5/W

RF

me

teo

rolo

gic

al m

od

el d

om

ain

with

the

27

-km

CT

M d

om

ain

(red

) a

nd

the

9-k

m M

M5

do

ma

in (b

lue

).

F

igu

re 4

. 27

-km

CT

M d

om

ain

with

the

9-k

m M

M5

do

ma

in (b

lue

) an

d th

e 9

-km

CT

M d

om

ain

(re

d).

-3807

-2943

-2079

-1215

-351

51

3137

7224

13105

-247

0.5

-203

8.5

-160

6.5

-117

4.5

-74

2.5

-31

0.5

12

1.5

55

3.5

98

5.5

141

7.5

184

9.5

228

1.5-2

403

-19

71

-153

9-1

107

-675

-24

31

89

62

11

05

314

85

19

17

23

49

-18

76.5

-16

60.5

-14

44.5

-12

28.5

-10

12.5

-79

6.5

-58

0.5

-36

4.5

-14

8.5

67.5

28

3.5

49

9.5

71

5.5

93

1.5

11

47.5

13

63.5

15

79.5

17

95.5

Page 9: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

7

F

igu

re 5

. 9-k

m C

TM

do

ma

in w

ith th

e 3

-km

MM

5 d

om

ain

(blu

e) a

nd

the

3-k

m C

TM

do

ma

in

(red

).

F

igu

re 6

. 3-k

m C

TM

do

ma

in w

ith th

e 1

-km

MM

5 d

om

ain

(blu

e) a

nd

the

1-k

m C

TM

do

ma

in

(red

)

-522

-46

8-4

14

-360

-30

6-2

52

-198

-144

-90

-36

18

72

12

61

80

23

42

88

34

2-9

67

.5

-913

.5

-859

.5

-805

.5

-751

.5

-697

.5

-643

.5

-589

.5

-535

.5

-481

.5

-427

.5

-373

.5

-319

.5-291

-264

-237

-210

-183

-156

-129

-102

-75

-48

-21

633

60

87

114

141

-754.5

-727.5

-700.5

-673.5

-646.5

-619.5

-592.5

-565.5

-538.5

-511.5

-484.5

-457.5

-430.5

Page 10: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

8

Th

e

CT

M

ve

rtical

stru

ctu

re

is

prim

arily

defin

ed

by

the

ve

rtical

laye

r d

efin

ition

s

used

in

th

e

MM

5/W

RF

m

od

ellin

g.

Th

e

MM

5/W

RF

m

od

el

em

plo

yed

a

terra

in

follo

win

g

coo

rdin

ate

syste

m

defin

ed

by p

ressu

re, u

sin

g 3

8 ve

rtica

l laye

rs th

at e

xte

nd

from

the

su

rface

to th

e 5

0 m

b p

ressu

re

leve

l (a

pp

roxim

ate

ly 20

km

A

GL

). A

la

yer

ave

rag

ing

sch

em

e w

as a

do

pte

d fo

r th

e C

TM

th

at

co

llap

sed th

e 3

8 la

yers

used

in th

e M

M to

26 la

yers

for th

e C

TM

to re

du

ce th

e c

om

puta

tiona

l time

of th

e C

TM

sim

ula

tion

s. T

he

CT

M v

ertic

al la

ye

r stru

ctu

re e

xactly

ma

tche

d th

e M

M m

od

el la

ye

r stru

ctu

re fo

r the

low

est p

ortio

n o

f the

atm

osph

ere

(be

low

app

roxim

ate

ly 1

80

0 m

AG

L) w

ithin

the

Pla

ne

tary

Bou

nd

ary

La

yer (P

BL

) wh

ere

mo

st o

f the

atm

osp

he

ric p

roce

sse

s o

ccu

r tha

t lea

d to

e

levate

d p

ollu

tion

leve

ls in

the

HK

an

d P

RD

reg

ion

s. T

hu

s, th

e C

TM

laye

r stru

ctu

re w

ill ma

tch

the

MM

5 v

ertic

al la

yers

with

no

laye

r colla

psin

g fo

r the

bo

ttom

20

laye

rs in th

e tw

o m

od

els

. Abo

ve th

e

PB

L th

e C

TM

will e

mp

loy la

ye

r colla

psin

g o

f the

MM

laye

rs to

be

mo

re co

mpu

tatio

na

lly e

fficie

nt.

Page 11: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

9

4.

Mo

dellin

g E

pis

od

es

Fo

ur

his

toric

al

mod

ellin

g ep

isod

es w

ere

se

lecte

d b

y th

e H

ong

K

ong

E

nviro

nm

en

tal

Pro

tectio

n

De

pa

rtme

nt (E

PD

) for te

stin

g a

nd

de

mo

nstra

ting

the

upg

rade

d P

AT

H s

yste

m. N

ote

that fo

r ea

ch

ep

isod

e, te

n (1

0) in

itializ

atio

n d

ays w

ere

add

ed

to th

e b

eg

inn

ing o

f the e

pis

od

e fo

r the 2

7 k

m o

ute

r g

rid w

ith s

ho

rter in

itializ

atio

n d

ays fo

r the

sm

alle

r grid

s a

s a

pp

rop

riate

:

• E

pis

od

e 1

: Se

pte

mb

er 1

0 th

rou

gh

Octo

be

r 12

, 200

4;

• E

pis

od

e 2

: No

vem

be

r 2-3

, 200

3;

• E

pis

od

e 3

: July

24

-25

, 200

6; a

nd

• E

pis

od

e 4

: Ma

rch

16

-17

, 200

6.

F

igu

re 7

dis

pla

ys th

e lo

catio

ns a

nd

iden

tifiers

for th

e a

ir qua

lity m

on

itorin

g s

ites w

ithin

the

Hon

g

Ko

ng re

gio

n th

at

we

re u

sed

to

cha

racte

rize

each

of th

e m

ode

lling ep

isod

es

an

d eva

lua

te th

e

CT

Ms.

Fig

ure

7. A

ir Qu

ality

mo

nito

ring

sta

tion

s in

Ho

ng

Ko

ng

YL

ST

CW

MB

EN

TW

KC

TC

SSP

KT

Page 12: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

1

0

5. S

yste

m C

om

po

nen

ts

5.1

E

mis

sio

ns

Mo

de

lling

So

ftwa

re

Th

e S

pa

rse M

atrix

O

pe

rato

r K

ern

el

Em

issio

ns (S

MO

KE

) e

mis

sio

ns m

ode

lling syste

m w

as

the

prim

ary

em

issio

ns m

od

el u

sed in

the

PA

TH

up

gra

de

stud

y fo

r all s

ou

rce

s bu

t bio

ge

nic e

mis

sio

ns

and

on

-road

mob

ile so

urce

em

issio

ns w

ithin

the

Ho

ng

Ko

ng

are

a. S

en

sitiv

ity tests

we

re c

on

du

cte

d

usin

g th

e C

onso

lida

ted

Co

mm

un

ity E

mis

sio

ns P

roce

ssin

g T

oo

l (Co

nC

EP

T) e

mis

sio

ns m

od

ellin

g

syste

m a

s a

n a

ltern

ativ

e e

mis

sio

ns m

ode

l for p

roce

ssin

g p

oin

t, are

a a

nd m

ob

ile so

urce

em

issio

ns.

Th

e C

ON

CE

PT

em

issio

ns m

ode

l pro

du

ced

sim

ilar C

TM

-rea

dy e

mis

sio

ns in

pu

ts a

s S

MO

KE

, but

wa

s s

low

er s

o th

e S

MO

KE

em

issio

ns m

od

el w

as a

dop

ted fo

r the fin

al m

od

ellin

g s

yste

m. T

he

CO

NC

EP

T e

mis

sio

ns m

od

ellin

g s

yste

m w

as a

lso u

sed

with

link-b

ase

d v

eh

icle

activ

ity d

ata

for o

n-

roa

d m

ob

ile s

ou

rce

s in H

ong

Kon

g to

pro

du

ce h

igh

ly re

solv

ed o

n-ro

ad

mo

bile

sou

rce e

mis

sio

ns in

H

on

g K

ong

. The

Mo

de

l for E

mis

sio

ns o

f Ga

s a

nd

Ae

roso

l in N

atu

re (M

EG

AN

) wa

s th

e p

rima

ry

em

issio

ns m

od

el fo

r bio

ge

nic

em

issio

ns, a

lthou

gh

sen

sitiv

ity tests w

ere

als

o c

on

du

cte

d u

sin

g th

e

Bio

ge

nic

Em

issio

ns In

form

atio

n S

yste

m (B

EIS

) bio

ge

nic

em

issio

ns m

od

ellin

g s

yste

m.

SM

OK

E:

Th

e

Sp

arse

M

atrix

O

pe

rato

r K

ern

el

Em

issio

ns

(SM

OK

E)

mo

de

ling

syste

m

is

an

em

issio

ns m

ode

ling

syste

m th

at g

ene

rate

s h

ou

rly g

ridde

d s

pe

cia

ted

em

issio

n in

pu

ts o

f mo

bile

, n

on

-road

, are

a, p

oin

t, fire a

nd

bio

gen

ic e

mis

sio

n s

ou

rces fo

r pho

toche

mic

al g

rid m

ode

ls. A

s with

m

ost ‘e

mis

sio

ns m

ode

ls’, S

MO

KE

is p

rincip

ally

an e

mis

sio

n p

roce

ssin

g s

yste

m a

nd n

ot a

true

em

issio

ns m

ode

ling

syste

m in

wh

ich e

mis

sio

ns e

stima

tes a

re s

imu

late

d fro

m ‘firs

t prin

cip

les’. T

his

me

an

s th

at,

with

th

e e

xcep

tion

of

mo

bile

an

d b

ioge

nic

so

urce

s,

its p

urp

ose

is

to

p

rovid

e an

effic

ien

t, m

od

ern

to

ol fo

r co

nve

rting

an

exis

ting b

ase

em

issio

ns in

vento

ry d

ata

in

to th

e ho

urly

grid

de

d sp

ecia

ted

form

atte

d e

mis

sio

n file

s re

qu

ired

by a

n a

ir qu

ality

sim

ula

tion

mo

de

l. SM

OK

E

wa

s u

sed to

pre

pa

re e

mis

sio

n in

puts

for n

on

-roa

d m

ob

ile, a

rea

, po

int a

nd

no

n-lin

k on

-road

mob

ile

so

urc

es fo

r all m

od

elin

g d

om

ain

s.

CO

NC

EP

T:

T

he

C

on

solid

ate

d

Co

mm

un

ity

Em

issio

ns

Pro

ce

ssin

g

To

ol

(Con

CE

PT

) is

a

n

ew

e

mis

sio

ns m

od

elin

g sy

ste

m th

at w

as u

sed

to g

ene

rate

on

-roa

d m

ob

ile so

urce

em

issio

ns co

ve

red

by th

e lin

k-b

ase

d T

rave

l De

ma

nd

Mo

de

l (TD

M) a

ctiv

ity d

ata

with

in H

on

g K

on

g. T

he

CO

NC

EP

T

on

-roa

d m

ob

ile s

ou

rce

com

po

ne

nt ca

n m

ake

full u

se

of lin

ked

-based

veh

icle

kilo

mete

rs tra

vele

d

(VK

T) d

ata

inclu

din

g te

mpo

ral a

nd

spa

tial v

aria

tion

s in

spe

ed

s a

nd

flee

t dis

tribu

tion

s.

ME

GA

N: B

ioge

nic e

mis

sio

ns a

re m

ode

led

usin

g th

e M

ode

l of E

mis

sio

ns o

f Ga

ses a

nd A

ero

so

ls fro

m N

atu

re (M

EG

AN

). ME

GA

N is th

e la

test b

ioge

nic

em

issio

ns m

od

el d

eve

lope

d b

y re

sea

rche

rs

from

the N

atio

na

l Ce

nte

r for A

tmo

sph

eric R

ese

arc

h (N

CA

R) in

co

rpo

rate

s the fu

ll ran

ge

of o

zon

e

and

PM

pre

cu

rsor s

pe

cie

s. In a

dd

ition

, the la

test v

ers

ion o

f ME

GA

N in

clu

de

s bio

ge

nic s

pe

cie

s no

t fo

un

d in

oth

er b

iog

en

ic e

mis

sio

ns m

od

el th

at a

re u

sed

by th

e la

test C

AM

x s

eco

nd

ary

org

an

ic a

ero

sol (S

OA

) mo

du

le. M

EG

AN

is a

fairly

ne

w b

iog

en

ic e

mis

sio

ns m

od

el s

o b

iog

en

ic e

mis

sio

ns

we

re a

lso g

ene

rate

d u

sin

g th

e B

EIS

alg

orith

ms th

at h

ave b

een

use

d m

ore

exte

nsiv

ely

in th

e p

ast

in a

sensitiv

ity te

st.

BE

IS: B

ioge

nic e

mis

sio

ns a

re a

lso m

od

ele

d u

sin

g v

ers

ion 3

of th

e B

ioge

nic E

mis

sio

n In

ve

nto

ry S

yste

m (B

EIS

3). B

EIS

3 w

as d

eve

lope

d in

200

1 a

nd

is the

late

st ge

ne

ratio

n in

the

BE

IS fa

mily

. All

BE

IS3

ve

rsio

ns

are

d

esig

ne

d

for

use

with

th

e

Spa

rse

M

atrix

O

pe

ratio

na

l K

ern

el

Em

issio

ns

(SM

OK

E) s

yste

m. B

EIS

3.0

9 is c

urre

ntly

the

defa

ult ve

rsio

n in

SM

OK

E. B

EIS

3.1

0 w

as d

eve

lope

d

for th

e 2

002

rele

ase

of th

e C

om

mun

ity M

ultis

ca

le A

ir Qu

ality

(CM

AQ

) mo

de

ling

syste

m. B

EIS

3.1

0

inclu

de

s

a

1-k

m

vege

tatio

n

data

ba

se

tha

t re

solv

es

fore

st

cano

py

cove

rag

e

by

tree

spe

cie

s; e

mis

sio

n fa

cto

rs for 3

4 c

he

mic

als in

clu

din

g 1

4 m

ono

terp

en

es a

nd m

eth

ano

l; a s

oil N

O a

lgo

rithm

d

ep

en

de

nt o

n so

il mo

istu

re, c

rop

cano

py co

ve

rage

, an

d fe

rtilize

r ap

plica

tion

; and

spe

cific

atio

n fo

r th

e C

BIV

, RA

DM

2, a

nd

SA

PR

C99

che

mic

al m

echa

nis

ms. T

he

soil N

O a

lgo

rithm

in B

EIS

3.1

0 h

as

sin

ce b

een

revis

ed

(BE

IS3.1

1) to

bette

r distin

gu

ish

betw

ee

n a

gric

ultu

ral a

nd n

ona

gric

ultu

ral la

nd

,

Page 13: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

1

1

and

to lim

it ad

justm

en

ts from

tem

pe

ratu

re, p

recip

itatio

n, fe

rtilizer a

pp

lica

tion

, an

d c

rop c

an

op

y to

the g

row

ing s

ea

son

and

to a

rea

s o

f ag

ricultu

re. A

leaf sh

ad

ing

alg

orith

m h

as b

een

ad

ded

for

estim

atin

g m

eth

ano

l e

mis

sio

ns fro

m n

on

-fore

sted

a

rea

s.

BE

IS3

.12

w

as re

lea

sed

in

N

ove

mb

er

200

3 a

nd

is th

e m

ost re

cen

t ve

rsio

n o

f BE

IS. It w

as a

sse

mb

led

as a

sta

nd

-alo

ne

mo

du

le to

the

Sp

arse

M

atrix

O

pe

ratio

na

l K

ern

el

Em

issio

ns

(SM

OK

E)

syste

m fo

r g

en

era

ting

g

ridde

d,

ho

urly

em

issio

ns in

a fo

rma

t consis

ten

t for a

ir qua

lity m

od

elin

g.

5.2

M

ete

oro

log

ica

l Mo

de

ling

Sys

tem

Me

so

sca

le M

od

el

ve

rsio

n 5

(M

M5

) th

e W

eath

er

Re

se

arc

h F

ore

cast

(WR

F)

are

u

sed

fo

r th

e

Me

teo

rolo

gic

al

Mo

de

ling

to

d

eve

lop

ho

urly

an

d,

thre

e-d

imen

sio

na

l, m

ulti-s

ca

le

me

teo

rolo

gica

l fie

lds to

supp

ort p

ho

toch

em

ica

l mo

de

ling to

ad

dre

ss H

KE

PD

’s air q

ua

lity an

d a

ir qu

ality re

late

d

pla

nn

ing

activ

ities.

The

M

M5

/WR

F

me

teo

rolo

gic

al

mod

els

w

ere

a

pp

lied

at

the

va

riou

s g

rid

reso

lutio

ns

(27 km

, 9 km

, 3 km

an

d 1 km

) and

the

m

ode

lling re

sults

(e.g

., w

ind

spe

ed

, w

ind

dire

ctio

n, te

mp

era

ture

, etc

.) we

re c

om

pa

red

aga

inst a

vaila

ble

surfa

ce

me

teo

rolo

gica

l ob

se

rvatio

ns

in a

mo

de

l pe

rform

an

ce e

valu

atio

n.

MM

5/W

RF

: Th

e F

ifth-G

en

era

tion

NC

AR

/ Pe

nn

Sta

te M

eso

sca

le M

od

el V

ers

ion

3.7

(MM

5) a

nd

th

e N

CA

R A

dvan

ced

Re

sea

rch W

eath

er R

ese

arch

an

d F

ore

castin

g M

od

el V

ers

ion

3 (W

RF

-AR

W)

we

re se

lecte

d a

s the tw

o m

ete

oro

log

ica

l mod

els im

ple

me

nte

d in

the u

pg

rad

ed

PA

TH

mod

elin

g

syste

m.

Pre

pro

ce

sso

r p

rog

ram

s

of

the

M

M5

m

ode

ling

syste

m

inclu

din

g

terra

in,

RE

GR

ID,

LIT

TL

E_

R,

and

IN

TE

RP

F

we

re

used

to

de

velo

p

mod

el

inpu

ts.

The

cu

rren

t W

RF

softw

are

fra

me

wo

rk su

ppo

rts tw

o d

yna

mica

l so

lvers

(dyn

am

ic c

ore

s): th

e A

dvan

ced

Re

sea

rch

WR

F (A

RW

) a

nd

the

no

nh

yd

rosta

tic M

eso

sca

le M

od

el (N

MM

). Bo

th so

lve

rs a

re fu

lly co

mp

ressib

le, E

ule

rian

, n

on

hyd

rosta

tic an

d

con

se

rvativ

e fo

r sca

lar

va

riab

les.

Co

nsid

erin

g th

at

the W

RF

-AR

W

is

we

ll su

pp

orte

d b

y th

e N

CA

R, th

e la

test re

lea

sed

WR

F-A

RW

Ve

rsio

n 3

for th

e W

RF

mo

de

ling

sys

tem

w

as s

ele

cte

d fo

r imp

lem

en

tatio

n in

the

PA

TH

upgra

de p

roje

ct. T

he

ove

rall W

RF

cod

e (V

ers

ion

3)

inclu

de

s th

e W

RF

Softw

are

Fra

me

wo

rk (W

SF

), the A

dvan

ced

Re

sea

rch

WR

F (A

RW

) dyna

mic

so

lve

r, the

WR

F P

rep

roce

ssin

g S

yste

m (W

PS

), the

WR

F V

aria

tion

al D

ata

Assim

ilatio

n (W

RF

-Va

r) syste

m,

and

nu

me

rou

s

ph

ysic

s

pa

cka

ge

s

contrib

ute

d

by

WR

F

pa

rtne

rs

and

th

e

rese

arc

h

co

mm

un

ity. T

he g

oa

l of th

e M

M5

/WR

F m

od

el e

valu

atio

n w

as to

asse

ss w

he

the

r and

to w

ha

t exte

nt co

nfid

en

ce

ma

y

be

p

lace

d

in

the

m

od

elin

g

sys

tem

to

p

rovid

e

thre

e-d

imen

sio

na

l w

ind

, te

mp

era

ture

a

nd

mo

istu

re to

air q

ua

lity m

od

els

. Th

e b

asis

for th

e a

sse

ssm

en

t is a

co

mpa

rison

of th

e p

red

icte

d

me

teo

rolo

gic

al fie

lds to

ava

ilab

le su

rface

da

ta c

olle

cte

d b

y th

e G

lob

al T

ele

co

mm

un

ica

tion

Syste

m

(GT

S)

and

H

K O

bse

rva

tory

a

uto

ma

tic w

eath

er

sta

tion

s a

roun

d H

K.

T

his

is ca

rried o

ut

bo

th

gra

ph

ica

lly a

nd

sta

tistica

lly.

5.3

C

he

mic

al T

ran

sp

ort M

od

ellin

g S

oftw

are

Th

e

Co

mm

un

ity

Mu

ltisca

le

Air

Qua

lity

(CM

AQ

) a

nd

C

om

pre

hen

siv

e

Air-q

ua

lity

Mo

de

l w

ith

exte

nsio

ns

(CA

Mx)

mo

de

ling

syste

ms

we

re

se

lecte

d

as

the

two

C

he

mic

al

Tra

nspo

rt M

od

els

(CT

Ms) im

ple

me

nte

d in

the u

pg

rad

ed

PA

TH

mo

delin

g s

yste

m.

CM

AQ

: Fo

r mo

re th

an a

de

cad

e, th

e U

nite

d S

tate

s E

nviro

nm

en

tal P

rote

ctio

n A

gen

cy (E

PA

) ha

s b

ee

n d

eve

lop

ing

the M

od

els

-3 C

om

mun

ity M

ultisc

ale

Air Q

ua

lity (C

MA

Q) m

od

ellin

g s

yste

m w

ith

the o

vera

rch

ing a

im o

f pro

du

cin

g a

‘O

ne

-Atm

osp

he

re’ a

ir qu

ality

m

ode

lling syste

m ca

pa

ble

of

add

ressin

g o

zon

e, p

articu

late

matte

r (PM

), vis

ibility

and

acid

de

po

sitio

n w

ithin

a c

om

mon

pla

tform

. T

he

mo

st re

cen

t ed

ition

s are

CM

AQ

Ve

rsio

n 4

.7 (V

4.7

) pub

licly

rele

ase

d in

Octo

be

r 20

08

an

d

Page 14: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

1

2

Ve

rsio

n 4

.7.1

rele

ase

d in

Jun

e 2

01

0, a

ltho

ug

h th

e cu

rrent S

tud

y sta

rted

with

the

CM

AQ

V4.6

tha

t w

as re

lea

sed

in O

ctob

er 2

00

6 a

nd

all th

ree

ve

rsio

ns w

ere

use

d in

the

PA

TH

up

gra

de

stu

dy.

CM

AQ

co

nsis

ts o

f a co

re C

he

mic

al T

ran

spo

rt Mo

de

l (CT

M) a

nd

seve

ral p

re-p

roce

sso

rs in

clu

din

g

the

Me

teo

rolo

gica

l-Ch

em

istry

In

terfa

ce

Pro

cess

or

(MC

IP),

initia

l an

d

bo

un

da

ry

con

ditio

ns

pro

ce

sso

rs (IC

ON

and

BC

ON

) an

d a

ph

oto

lysis

rate

s p

roce

sso

r (JP

RO

C). A

nu

mb

er o

f fea

ture

s in

C

MA

Q’s

th

eo

retic

al

form

ula

tion

an

d te

chn

ical

imp

lem

en

tatio

n

ma

ke

the

m

od

el

we

ll-su

ited

fo

r o

zon

e a

nd

pa

rticula

te m

atte

r (PM

) mo

de

ling.

Th

e C

MA

Q V

ers

ion

4.6

wa

s u

sed

initia

lly in

the

HK

/PR

D m

od

ellin

g. W

e u

pd

ate

d to

the

Octo

be

r 2

00

8 ve

rsio

n of

CM

AQ

(V

4.7

) as p

art

of th

e se

nsitiv

ity te

st

mod

ellin

g.

In p

artic

ula

r, th

e ne

w

Octo

be

r 20

08

V4

.7 o

f CM

AQ

inclu

de

s m

an

y S

OA

pro

ce

sse

s th

at a

re m

issin

g in

the

sta

nd

ard

ve

rsio

n o

f CM

AQ

, wh

ich w

as in

itially

add

resse

d w

ith th

e S

OA

mo

ds e

nha

nce

men

t tha

t wa

s u

sed

e

xte

nsiv

ely fo

r reg

ion

al P

M a

nd v

isib

ility m

ode

lling

in th

e U

.S. T

he fin

al s

yste

m o

ptim

isa

tion a

nd

de

mon

stra

tion

use

d C

MA

Q V

4.7

.1 in

the P

AT

H u

pg

rade

stu

dy.

CA

Mx

: T

he

Co

mp

rehe

nsive

A

ir-qua

lity

Mo

de

l w

ith e

xte

nsio

ns

(CA

Mx)

mo

de

lling

syste

m

is a

pub

licly

ava

ilab

le th

ree

-dim

en

sio

na

l mu

lti-sca

le p

ho

toche

mic

al/a

ero

so

l grid

mo

de

lling

sys

tem

that

ha

s be

en

de

velo

ped

and m

ain

tain

ed b

y E

NV

IRO

N In

tern

atio

na

l Co

rpo

ratio

n. T

he

mo

st c

urre

nt

ve

rsio

n o

f CA

Mx is

Ve

rsio

n 5

.3 re

lea

sed

in D

ece

mb

er 2

01

0, a

lthou

gh

the

PA

TH

up

gra

de

stu

dy

sta

rted

with

CA

Mx V

ers

ion

4.5

1 re

lea

sed

in M

ay 2

008

. T

he

CA

Mx V

4.5

1 w

as e

mp

loye

d a

nd

the m

ode

l wa

s s

et u

p a

nd

exe

rcis

ed

on

the s

am

e 2

7/9

/3/1

km

g

rid a

s C

MA

Q. H

ow

eve

r, in th

e in

itial c

onfig

ura

tion C

AM

x w

as ru

n u

sin

g tw

o-w

ay g

rid n

estin

g o

n

the

27/9

km

do

ma

ins w

ith o

ne

-wa

y n

estin

g e

mp

loye

d b

etw

een

the

9 k

m a

nd

3 k

m a

nd

3 k

m a

nd

1

km

do

ma

ins (C

MA

Q d

oe

s n

ot s

up

po

rt two

-wa

y g

rid n

estin

g). T

he

entire

27

/9/3

/1 k

m g

rid stru

ctu

re

wa

s to

o la

rge

to m

ode

l usin

g tw

o-w

ay g

rid n

estin

g a

mon

g a

ll fou

r do

ma

ins u

sin

g typ

ica

l co

mp

ute

r m

em

ory

. Mo

st s

en

sitiv

ity te

sts

just ve

rified p

ara

me

ters

with

in th

e 3

km

an

d 1

km

do

ma

ins so

p

erfo

rmin

g o

ne

-wa

y g

rid n

estin

g w

as m

ore

co

mp

uta

tion

ally

effic

ien

t. The

ba

sic

config

ura

tion

of

CA

Mx u

se

d 2

6 v

ertica

l laye

rs to

a 5

0 m

b re

gio

n to

p (~

20

km

AG

L) th

at e

xactly

ma

tch th

ose u

sed

by C

MA

Q. T

he

PP

M a

dve

ctio

n so

lve

r wa

s u

sed

alo

ng

with

the

spa

tially

va

ryin

g (S

mag

orin

sky)

ho

rizon

tal

diffu

sio

n ap

pro

ach

. V

ertica

l d

iffusio

n in

C

AM

x w

as

mo

de

led

u

sin

g K

-the

ory

. T

he

Me

t2C

AM

x p

roce

sso

r, wh

ich

is s

imila

r to th

e C

MA

Q M

CIP

3.3

“pa

ss th

rou

gh

” optio

n, w

as u

sed

to

pro

ce

ss th

e M

M5

an

d W

RF

da

ta. F

or th

e in

itial co

nfig

ura

tion

, CA

Mx w

as e

xerc

ised

with

the

CB

05

ga

s-p

ha

se,

RA

DM

aq

ue

ou

s-p

ha

se,

an

d

CM

U/IS

OR

RO

PIA

ae

roso

l ch

em

istry

sche

me

s.

Th

e

upd

ate

d S

OA

P se

con

da

ry o

rga

nic

ae

roso

l sch

em

e w

as u

sed

for th

e b

ase

config

ura

tion

in C

AM

x.

Th

is ve

rsio

n in

clu

de

s up

da

ted tre

atm

en

t for S

OA

from

isop

ren

e a

nd

se

squ

iterp

ene

s. T

he fin

al

op

timiz

atio

n a

nd d

em

onstra

tion

run

s use

d th

e la

test C

AM

x V

5.3

CT

M.

5.4

T

ran

sp

ort D

ata

Co

mp

ilatio

n a

nd

Mo

de

lling

Th

e E

PD

cu

rren

tly u

se

s th

e E

MF

AC

-HK

ve

hic

le e

mis

sio

ns m

od

el fo

r a

ir q

ua

lity p

lann

ing

an

d

rela

ted

activ

ities.

E

MF

AC

-HK

is

no

t re

ad

ily a

da

pta

ble

for

use

w

ithin

C

on

CE

PT

for e

mis

sio

ns

pro

ce

ssin

g, a

ste

p in

clu

ded

in th

e u

pg

rade

of th

e P

AT

H m

od

elin

g s

yste

m. T

he

EM

FA

C-H

K w

as

ada

pte

d fro

m th

e 2

002

EM

FA

C s

oftw

are

use

d in

U.S

. Sta

te o

f Ca

liforn

ia. T

he U

.S. E

PA

MO

BIL

E6

mo

de

l is a

n o

n-ro

ad

em

issio

ns m

ode

l tha

t has b

ee

n u

sed

exte

nsiv

ely fo

r reg

ula

tory

air q

ua

lity

ana

lyse

s in

the

U.S

. for a

ll state

s o

the

r than

Ca

liforn

ia. A

s re

qu

ired

by th

e S

tud

y B

rief, th

e

US

EP

A M

OB

ILE

6 w

as a

dap

ted

for u

se

in e

stima

ting

veh

icle

em

issio

ns in

Ho

ng

Ko

ng

an

d th

e

Stu

dy T

ea

m d

eve

lop

ed

a v

ers

ion

of th

e M

OB

ILE

6 fo

r Hon

g K

on

g.

Page 15: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

1

3

Th

e C

on

CE

PT

MV

em

issio

ns m

od

el w

as u

sed

to c

om

bin

e th

e M

OB

ILE

6-H

K e

mis

sio

n fa

cto

rs w

ith

ve

hic

le k

ilom

ete

rs tra

velle

d (V

KT

) da

ta, b

y ro

ad

wa

y lin

k, to

estim

ate

ove

rall e

mis

sio

ns fo

r on

-road

mo

bile

sou

rce

s in

H

ong

K

ong

. T

he

V

KT

and

sp

ee

ds b

y ro

ad

wa

y lin

k w

ere

ob

tain

ed

from

a

tran

spo

rtatio

n d

em

and

mod

el (T

DM

) de

ve

lop

ed

for u

se in

Ho

ng

Kon

g b

y MV

A H

ong

Ko

ng

Lim

ited

.

Th

e M

VA

mod

el w

as e

xerc

ised

for th

e 2

00

5 b

ase

yea

r. Th

e V

KT

activ

ity da

ta w

ere

pro

jecte

d o

r

ba

ckca

st to

the

oth

er y

ea

rs o

f the

stud

y (2

00

3, 2

00

4, a

nd

20

06

) usin

g fo

reca

st/ba

ckca

st fa

cto

rs

de

velo

ped

from

ana

lysis

of T

ran

spo

rt Dep

artm

en

t an

nu

al tra

ffic co

un

t da

ta. T

he

MO

BIL

E6

-HK

em

issio

ns m

od

el a

nd

the

link-b

ase

d V

KT

da

ta w

ere

use

d in

the

Co

nC

EP

T M

V to

de

velo

p a

hig

hly

reso

lved

, tem

po

rally

and

spa

tially

, on

-roa

d v

eh

icle

em

issio

n in

ven

tory

for H

on

g K

on

g. T

he

grid

ded

tem

pe

ratu

re a

nd h

um

idity fro

m th

e M

M5

an

d W

RF

me

teo

rolo

gica

l mo

de

ling ru

ns w

ere

used

to

imp

lem

ent a

pp

rop

riate

ad

justm

en

ts to th

e M

OB

ILE

6-H

K e

mis

sio

n fa

cto

rs in

Co

nC

EP

T M

V.

5.5

D

ata

An

aly

sis

an

d V

isu

alis

atio

n S

oftw

are

Th

e S

tud

y T

ea

m im

ple

me

nte

d d

ata

ana

lysis

an

d v

isu

alis

atio

n so

ftwa

re fo

r disp

layin

g th

e re

su

lts o

f

the

me

teo

rolo

gica

l, em

issio

ns a

nd

che

mic

al tra

nsp

ort m

ode

lling

. The

da

ta a

na

lysis

too

ls w

ere

cu

sto

mize

d to

pro

cess th

e e

mis

sio

n m

ode

lling

, me

teo

rolo

gic

al m

od

ellin

g a

nd

che

mic

al tra

nspo

rt

mo

de

lling

resu

lts to g

ene

rate

sca

tter p

lots, tim

e se

ries p

lots, m

od

el p

erfo

rman

ce s

tatis

tics, s

pa

tial

ma

ps

an

d

oth

er

gra

ph

ica

l d

isp

lays

of

the

m

od

elin

g

resu

lts.

In

ad

ditio

n,

the

se

to

ols

w

ere

cu

sto

mize

d to

disp

lay th

e in

put a

nd

ou

tpu

t data

from

the

em

issio

ns, m

ete

oro

log

ical a

nd

che

mic

al

tran

spo

rt mo

de

ls a

nd

pro

vid

e in

tera

ctive

2-D

an

d 3

-D v

isu

alisa

tion

fun

ction

s.

6.

Syste

m O

ptim

izatio

n a

nd

Dem

on

stra

tion

Th

e fin

al o

ptim

isatio

n a

nd

de

mon

stra

tion

run

s we

re co

nd

ucte

d u

sin

g th

e ve

ry la

test ve

rsio

ns o

f

CM

AQ

(V

4.7

.1,

Jun

e

20

10

re

lease

) a

nd

C

AM

x

(V5

.3,

De

cem

be

r 20

10

re

lea

se)

CT

Ms

usin

g

me

teo

rolo

gic

al

inpu

ts ba

sed

o

n

the

MM

5

and

WR

F

me

teo

rolo

gica

l m

od

els

for

thre

e

of

the

his

toric

al e

pis

od

es u

sed in

the

testin

g, w

hich

inclu

de

d th

e S

ep

tem

be

r 20

04

, July

200

6 a

nd M

arc

h

200

6 m

od

ellin

g e

piso

de

s. P

rior to

pe

rform

ing

the

fina

l op

timis

atio

n a

nd d

em

on

stra

tion ru

ns, a

fina

l

se

t of se

nsitiv

ity te

sts

we

re co

nd

ucte

d to

add

ress th

e fo

llow

ing

two

issu

es.

1.

Defin

e

the

op

tima

l fin

al

config

ura

tion

fo

r th

e

CT

Ms

in

the

fin

al

op

timis

atio

n

an

d

de

mon

stra

tion

mo

de

l run

s u

sin

g th

e v

ery

late

st v

ers

ion

s o

f the

CM

AQ

and

CA

Mx C

TM

s;

and

2.

Be

tter u

nd

ers

tand

ing

of th

e C

TM

mo

de

l pe

rform

an

ce

for th

e Ju

ly 2

006

ep

isode

(Ep

isod

e 3

)

and

in

pa

rticu

lar

wh

y

the

C

TM

o

zon

e

mode

l p

erfo

rma

nce

is

m

uch

be

tter

usin

g

me

teo

rolo

gic

al in

pu

ts b

ase

d o

n th

e W

RF

tha

n th

e M

M5

me

teo

rolo

gica

l mod

el.

Th

e la

test v

ers

ion

s o

f the

CM

AQ

and

CA

Mx C

TM

s w

ere

su

cce

ssfu

lly a

pp

lied

to th

ree

histo

rica

l

ep

isod

es to

estim

ate

air q

ua

lity w

ithin

the

Hon

g K

ong

are

a a

s w

ell a

s the

gre

ate

r Pea

rl Riv

er D

elta

(PR

D) re

gio

n. N

o p

rob

lem

s we

re e

nco

un

tere

d in

app

lyin

g th

e tw

o C

TM

s a

nd

de

mo

nstra

tion

run

s

we

re m

ad

e u

sin

g m

ete

oro

log

ical in

pu

ts b

ased

on

bo

th th

e M

M5

an

d W

RF

MM

s. T

he

fina

l run

s

de

mon

stra

te th

at th

e tw

o C

TM

s a

re o

pe

ratio

na

l an

d re

ad

y fo

r use in

assis

ting

the

Ho

ng

Ko

ng

EP

D

in m

ana

gin

g th

eir a

ir qua

lity is

sue

s.

Page 16: Privileged and Confidential - epd.gov.hk · Implement the proposed software into the upgraded P ATH modelling system; • Identify the parameters that have significant impact on the

Privile

ged a

nd C

onfid

entia

l

Executiv

e S

um

mary

Ag

ree

men

t No

. CE

27/2

007

(EP

) Up

gra

de o

f a R

eg

ion

al

Air Q

ua

lity M

od

ellin

g S

yste

m (P

AT

H) ––– –

Fe

asib

ility S

tud

y

DR

AF

T F

INA

L

HK

1100066

1

4

7.

Po

st Im

ple

men

tatio

n

On

ce th

e u

pg

rade

d P

AT

H m

od

ellin

g s

yste

ms w

as d

eliv

ere

d to

EP

D, in

stalle

d o

n th

eir co

mpu

ter

syste

m a

nd

EP

D w

as tra

ine

d o

n its

use

, EP

D se

t up

the

mod

ellin

g s

yste

m to

pe

rform

fore

castin

g

of

me

teo

rolo

gica

l a

nd

a

ir qu

ality

co

nd

ition

s in

th

e H

on

g K

on

g an

d su

rroun

din

g a

rea

s, a

P

ost

Imp

lem

en

tatio

n R

evie

w w

as co

nd

ucte

d w

hic

h re

vie

we

d a

nd e

valu

ate

d th

e E

PD

fore

castin

g re

sults

for th

e fo

ur m

on

th p

erio

d o

f Au

gu

st th

roug

h N

ove

mb

er 2

01

0. A

n a

dd

ition

al a

na

lysis o

f the

EP

D’s

MM

5/C

AM

x fo

reca

st d

em

on

stra

tion ru

n fo

r the

entire

ca

lend

ar y

ea

r wa

s do

cum

ente

d in

the

stu

dy’s

fina

l rep

ort.

8.

Co

nclu

sio

n

A n

ew

me

teo

rolo

gica

l, em

issio

ns a

nd a

ir qua

lity m

od

ellin

g s

yste

m h

as b

een

deve

lop

ed a

nd s

etu

p

for th

e H

on

g K

ong

(HK

) an

d P

ea

rl Rive

r De

lta (P

RD

) reg

ion

. Th

e n

ew

mo

de

lling s

yste

m w

as

de

mon

stra

ted

usin

g fo

ur h

isto

rica

l mod

ellin

g e

pis

ode

s fro

m 2

003

-20

06

. Th

e m

ode

lling

syste

m

wa

s d

elive

red

to H

K E

nviro

nm

en

tal P

rote

ctio

n D

ep

artm

en

t (EP

D) a

nd

EP

D w

as tra

ined

on

its u

se.

EP

D h

as a

pp

lied

the

mo

de

lling

syste

m to

ma

ke m

ete

oro

log

ical a

nd a

ir qua

lity fo

reca

sts fo

r the

HK

/PR

D re

gio

n a

nd

the

entire

201

0 ca

len

da

r yea

r.

Du

ring

the

cou

rse o

f the

de

velo

pm

ent o

f the

ne

w a

ir qu

ality

mo

de

lling s

yste

m, th

e s

tudy te

am

ha

s

striv

ed

to

co

ntin

uou

sly

up

da

te th

e m

ode

lling sys

tem

so

th

at

it u

se

s th

e ve

ry la

test

mo

de

lling

co

mp

on

en

ts. T

o th

is en

d,

the

fina

l op

timis

atio

n an

d d

em

on

stra

tion

ru

ns u

sed

th

e ve

ry la

test

ve

rsio

ns o

f the

Co

mm

un

ity M

ultis

ca

le A

ir Qua

lity (CM

AQ

Ve

rsio

n 4

.71

rele

ase

d Ju

ne

20

10

) an

d

Co

mp

reh

en

siv

e A

ir Qua

lity M

od

el w

ith e

xte

nsio

ns (C

AM

x V

ers

ion

5.3

rele

ase

d D

ece

mb

er 2

01

0)

Ch

em

ica

l Tra

nsp

ort M

ode

ls (C

TM

s).

Th

e a

pp

lica

tion o

f the

CT

Ms fo

r the

histo

rica

l ep

isode

s fro

m 2

003

-200

6 a

nd fo

r fore

ca

stin

g fo

r the

201

0 c

ale

nd

ar ye

ar d

em

on

stra

te th

e u

sefu

lne

ss o

f the n

ew

air q

ua

lity mod

ellin

g s

yste

m fo

r air

qua

lity

man

ag

em

en

t p

lan

nin

g

in

the

H

K/P

RD

re

gio

n.

T

he

m

ode

lling

syste

m

is

no

w

fully

ope

ratio

na

l an

d re

ad

y fo

r rou

tine

ap

plica

tion

.