predatory tow flow

1NC 2AC Neg Block 1AR

1

2NR 2AR


1

2NR 2AR


1

2NR 2AR


1

2NR 2AR


1

2NR 2AR


1

2NR 2AR


1

2NR 2AR


1

Neg 6

2NR 2AR

Neg 6

1AC 1NC 2AC Neg Block

1

¯xx

2

¯

3

Out of control poor signage and spotters leads to taking advantage of people

poor signage leads to advantage over residents

they say media overhype but they are indicative of the voice of the people the voices of these people represent the collective body of these bodies

her experience is representative of people who park in downtown ogden with their chillin'

Private parking lots cash cows- they haul a ton of cars not counting other fees. Inflated towing leads to 57% increase

People hire squatters to watch leads to inscrpulous amount

they say current better for local bidnss but

¯

decimate small businesses

4

poo¯

kills consumer protecion

5

mob mentality in argumentation

devorik we must act now because lack of regulation has lead to decade of abuses

they have said regulations don't solve nguyen evidence regs are perfect a comparative advantage with the affirmative

They assume the position of the towing company you argue on the side of businesses. It's about their bottom line and will pad their pockets successfully harass a grandma

¯

6 UDOT doesn't agree with them ¯

plenty of profit no gauging

Ogden sould amend and make it illegal to initiate non-consentiual via contract unless they use Ogden towing

cash only transactions are indicative

Ogden not alone provo, without commission leads to disruptive commission practices

indicates that it is a review and doesn't endorse the idea of rejecting regulations it's just a study

employees on the plow. Amount is capped they put the decision back on property owner

downtown Ogden voter Downtown provo

Provo solves

provo city code

7

¯

xx 14

The creation of the towing industry was a result of the increase of private vehicle use in the city. While initially being a problem for law enforcement, the contracting to 3rd party businesses allow to maintain the efficiency of the streets. Decades of criminological research have indicated the dangers of street congestion in the overall safety of the city. The affirmatives teams caution allows for the reduction of property value for businesses

Ogden Utah not built on privitized vehicle but train as method. Why are streets are so small. Train junction of the west

must use contract right to appeal to owner of property, right to grant appeal, permit and signage

Spotters wait for grandmas to enforce terrible laws

lets be honest--they have yet to prove that grandmas are th largest hurt demographic by predatory towing. The aff is engaging in nothing more than vicious adhom attacks of an industry that continues the efffective and efficient regulation of Utah street.

stepping beyond the boundary of the law leaving your vehicle for a few minutes does not make it legal. Neither does leaving a note saying “Back soon- Please don’t tow!”

Mark Saal companies conitinue to reform--media doesn't report that

modeling provo solves best, proper request includes written provision appeals process and better signage.

8

¯deterence is better than appeasing

9

¯

10

a) written agent lower fees and signage we have struck a delicate balance

Poor signage is the real problem people can't see.

make signs bigger put signs in multiple languages. All of their arguments amount to notihng more than a misdirect

spotters suck- if you have a financial incentive to not tell an individual they are interested in talking advantage

Misplaced blame-seductive fallacy that would have you think you are saving grandmothers- it is no ones obligation but the individual who parks to no park illegally. You would think from the 1ACs lofy rhetoric that the only person not to blame is the one who initiated the law breaking.

Had a "spotter" identified anything else that was detrimental to the overall productivity and efficiency of the city.

They prioritize private companies over individual people

It's not a problem that should be viewed as Resident vs Private business. Their demonization of the towing industry continues the long demonization of a crucial municipal service.

non-consensual is lucrative

Our Omadi Mobile Management argument is devestating to the affirmative teams position

snoow tow is $50 is hard for a company to profit

250-300 we have to move at 50 dollars a pop you cant hire help to do that

if you cap at 175 you are arguably stabbing at a portion of our business.

The aff team has to justify 175 it's what keeps my 100 people emplpoyed. These car notes on my tow truck have to get paid otherwise repossessed

1AR 2NR 2AR

The issue not towing practices but predatory towing and restrictions on access built on padding pockets of hard earned

We have proposed regulation-we do not hurt business we do not trade off with any towing practice we force more responsible business practice

Reeval omadi evidence it's about blogs- it's from a towing companies perspective they have economic incentives predoatory towing is not the problem it takes the problem of companies don't have to deal with price kits

parking is not the rootcause diff parking structures in downtown Ogden. Teleperformance for example companies just pay for spots and the same practices still happen. There's plenty of space people just don't know--we need an increase in signage

Provo model ineffectivity article is bad that aff obivously doesn't entail tat

leads to more crim. Parking structures surve as a hideway for sexual assault and crime. We have them now and they are still not solving. In order to get the money you have to submit a different study and also quite emminent domain claims. Do you really wanna deal with another river parkway situation ie aff ammendment regarding solutions that can happen immediately.

we have cited anecdotal study. They have no evidence or data that indicates $50 hit will decimate hit

Is there any historical sites in the parking strucure?


1

1AR 2NR 2AR


1

1AR 2NR 2AR


1

1AR 2NR 2AR


1

1AR 2NR 2AR


1

1AR 2NR 2AR

Cross-x of the 1AC by 2N Cross-x of the 1NC by 1A Cross-x of the 2AC by 1N

Cross-x of the 2NC by 2A

TeamsTournament

Aff Prep Neg Prep5:00 5:00

Plan 2NR

Adv List 1NC List

JudgeDecisionComments

predatory tow flow

Documents