petro-facts october 2015

Upload: ksamgeorge

Post on 24-Feb-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    1/27

    O

    ctober2015

    Petrofacts

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    2/27

    Petrofacts October2015

    4 Ourrecord ofthe companysnews,activities,newcontractsandagreementsaround theglobe

    8 CountingthegainsofsandHowPetrofachas madeits inroadsintothe Algerianmarket

    14 WhereweworkTherearec ausesfor celebrationontheBerantaifield, offshoreinMalaysia

    16 Iamfascinatedbywhatwedo,andwhatwearecapableofdoingTimWeller,PetrofacsChief FinancialOfficer,talksprospectsand pressures

    20 Inpraiseof thehumblevalveTheunsung componentwhichplays akeyrolein virtuallyallofourprojects

    26 Gas:big markets,bigprojectsA graphicrepresentationof Petrofacscontributionto gassuppliesworldwide

    28 SharjahkeepsgoodcompaniesMeetsomeofthebusinesseswhichmakeour workin Sharjahpossible

    34 ThebigpictureTheSantuarioNorthEastfield,Mexico,wherefirstoilhasjust beenachieved

    36 OpportunityisheadingdownstreamTargeted diversification hass eenPetrofacachievesuccessinrefining

    40 I alwayscarryAsingleitem,carriedtoworkeachday,revealsa lotabouta person

    42 DoublevisionTwogeneralmanagerscomparenotesfromopposite endsof India

    44 Meetsome ofthe Petrofacpeoplearoundtheworld,astheytalkabouttheirprojects,their plans,and somemorepersonalaspects oftheir lives

    GalkynyshgastreatmentplantinTurkmenistan.Photoby PhilSayer

    ontributors Petrofacts

    og

    HelenCampbellJournalist

    Helen,a languagesgraduate,writes onenergy,shippingandtechnology

    LeeHoaglandPhotographer

    TheFTandNewYorkTimeshavepublishedAbuDhabi-basedLee

    elenunneurnalist

    rten years,elenwas BankingorrespondentofeDaily Telegraph

    JayDanielWrightIllustrator

    JaywasborninNottingham,butcurrentlylivesinGlasgow,Scotland

    Featurearti cle:Countingthegrainsof sandSeepage8Algeriais inadynamicstatetoday,saysLeilaMansour

    eatures

    eople

    over

    nside this issue

    ThePetrofac editorialteamis respondingtotheoperatingenvironmentbypublishingtwoeditionsthisyear;contactpetrofacts.editorial@petrofac.comwithcommentsorcontributions.Everyemployee shouldreceivea copy;[email protected] youdliketoreceiveacopy

    EditorLucyAlmond

    Art DirectionEstersonAssociatesPictureEditorsMillieSimpsonAnnWhatleyLucyPinkstoneConsultantEditorPaulKeersPrintedbywww.push-print.com

    Petrofacts October201

    34

    8

    28

    40

    4

    20

    44MexicoSantuarioNorthEastisineffectanew field

    AlgeriaInten years

    Petrofachasachievedspectaculargrowthhere

    SharjahFromthishub,weship toaround25corecountriesforPetrofac

    MumbaiMyown

    lunchboxtravelsto theofficeeachdaybylocal train

    NorthSeaThisistestamenttoourrecordofsustainedoperationsdelivery

    TurkmenistanWealwayswant ourinnovationstobebe provenandcertified

    PerthThisfeelsmorelikea bitowntomethanacityoftwomillion

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    3/27

    Log

    PetrofactsOctober2015

    CONTRACTRENEWALSINTHEUKUNDERPINOPERATIONSarge-scalerenewalof contractsin theUK ContinentalShelf,worth approximately$400million,servesstestamentto ourrecordof sustainedoperationsdeliveryon behalfof customers

    trofacsOffshoreProjectsdOperations(OPO)sinesshas securedntractrenewals forerationsand maintenanceorkworth approximately00milliononthe UKontinentalShelf (UKCS).Thelargestof theseawards

    ortheprovisionoferationsand maintenanceamsfor CNRInternationalrossitsNorthSeaassetsethree platformsin theniancomplex;Murchison;dTiffany forthenexteyears.AlsointheEastIrishSeatrofachas securedao-yearcontractrenewalmEni, coveringoperationsdmaintenanceservicesthe Douglasfixedplatforms;shorestorage installationdPointof Ayrterminal;andtyholder responsibilityforeIrish SeaPioneererationssupport vessel.Thisbuilds onPetrofacsistingportfolioofserviceovisionfor Eni,includingdutyholderoftheHewettldandassetsintheuthernNorth Sea.

    tweerPetroleumin Bahrainsawardeda contracttotrofacsOffshoreProjectsdOperationsbusinesstopplya newgas dehydrationcility Petrofacsfirstprojecthe Kingdom.Thecontractcovers thestallationofa newgashydrationfacility,which isefirstina seriesof plannedscapacity projectsheduledforthenextthreeto

    fiveyears.Witha capacityof500 millionstandardcubic feetofgasaday, i twi l lbeasignificantpartof Tatweerscommitment tosecure thedeliveryof naturalgasneededtomeet thegrowingdemandsofthe Kingdomof Bahrain.Atthe signing,Manivannan

    Rajapathy,Deputy ManagingDirectorof PetrofacsOffshoreProjectsandOperationsbusiness,said:This award

    buildson ourgrowingportfoliotrackrecordin theMiddleEast,wherewevedemonstratedourabilityto safelydeliver projectperformanceand integrity.Wenowlookforwardto

    workingcloselywith TatweerPetroleumand toplaying akeyroleinthesuccessfulfuturesupplyof energyfromtheBahrainoilfield.AndrewH Kershaw,Chief

    ExecutiveOfficerfor Tatweer

    Petroleumadded: Installationofthenewgas processingfacilitywillbea significantmilestoneandis acriticalpieceofBahrainsfuture energystrategy.Signingthis contractisthenextbigstepforTatweerPetroleumin theimplementationofits long-termdevelopmentplanfortheBahrainoilfieldandweareallveryexcitedandproudto beabletomovethisprojectahead.

    PETROFACSECURESFIRSTWININBAHRAIN

    WalterThain,ManagingDirector,PetrofacOffshoreProjectsandOperations,says:Thispackageis greatnewsforthebusinessandforeveryoneinvolved.Inthe

    currentclimate,morethan ever,itis vitalthatoperatorscanhaveconfidencein thesupplychainto continueto generatevaluefor them.This large-scalerenewal ofcontractsthatwe

    haveheldin somecasesformorethana decade istestamentto ourrecord ofsustainedoperationsdeliveryonbehalfofourcustomersrightacrossthe UKCS.

    CNRIsNinianCentralplatform,oneof theNorthSea assetsincludedin thecontractrenewalsCOURTESYOFCNRINTERNATIONAL

    Petrofacts October201

    toredefinetheir portfoliosandreinvestcashin newerprospectselsewhere.Accordingto informationprovider1Derrick, almost$6billionof assetswerefor saleintheUK NorthSeaas atend-April 2015,with aquarteofthat valuecomingontothemarketduring thefirst quarteManyoil majorsanda rangeofsmallerindependentcompanieshave assetsonthemarket.

    Thefloodof assetshascreatedsomethingof abacklog,pushing pricesdowandmakingdeals morelikelyAnewwaveofassetsaleactivityandinfluxofNorthSefirst-timerswould createnewopportunitiesfor Petrofacas

    thecompanysexperiencemakesitwell-placedto winnbusiness,eitheras dutyhold(morecommonlynowservicoperator)or insupportfunctionsduringthetransitionaryphaseas NorthSeaassetschangehands.

    Petrofacpi oneeredoutsourcedasset managemin1997viathecreationofthedutyholder model.Sincethewehave managed19 assettransitionsand enabledsixnentrantoperatorsin theUKC

    ASSETSCHANGEHANDSINNORTHSEA

    6NEWUKCSENTRANTSENABLED

    19ASSETTRANSITIONSSINCE1997

    Petrofacscontract tosupportthenew operatorof theSeangasfieldin theSouthernNorthSeacouldheraldawaveofsimilaropportunitiesfor thecompany,as theoil pricedownturnis leadingmajorstodivestmatureassets.

    Oranje-NassauEnergie(ONE)UK LimitedtookovertheSean operatorshipinJune,followingits purchaseof 50%intheproducingfield fromShellandEssoattheendof2014.InJune,ONEawardeda$45-million,three-yeardutyholdersupportservicescontractto Petrofac,with theoptionoftwo one-year

    extensions.Thecontractsupports

    around40jobs(on-andoffshore)and willsee thecompany provideoperationsandmaintenanceservices totheSean facilities, located68milesoffshore,north-east ofLowestoft.In total,In total,Petrofacemploys4,000 peopleforits UKCSoperations.

    Petrofachas beensupportingnew entrantsintheNorthSeasincethe1990s,whenit pioneeredthe dutyholdermodelof outsourcedassetmanagement.Thisprovedattractiveto smallerindependentoil companiesandthoseenteringtheregionforthefirst time.

    Thesecontractswereoriginallyseenasa lifeoffieldoffering.But intheir matureformtheyhave sometimesactedas abridgingphase,wherecompanieswithoutoperatingequity inthe UKCS

    areableto benefitfromPetrofacs procedures,processesand relationshipswithregulatorsduringtheirtransitionto fulloperatorships.PetrofacsupportedONEthroughoutits preparationsfortransferof operatorshipforSean,includingits interfacewithUK regulators.

    Therecouldbe moresuchagreementson theway.ThesalebyShellandEssoof theirinterestsin Seancame asloweroilprices areleadingthe majorsJA

    MIEJONES

    4,000PEOPLEON-ANDOFFSHORE

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    4/27

    Log

    Petrofacts October2015

    trofachas beenawardedantracttosupport

    aintenancemanagementstem(MMS)implementationBumi Armadasfloating,

    oduction,storageandloading(FPSO), theArmadaakenboundfor theNortha. Theseservices willberformedbyBumi ArmadapportedbyPlant Assetanagement,the asset

    rformancemanagementnsultingbusinesswithintrofac.

    Petrofacwas selectedcauseof theirtrack record

    MMSservicesforFPSOojects.TheArmada Kraken,nvertedfroma Suezmaxice

    asstanker,will bedeployedineEast ShetlandBasin.TheKrakenfieldvelopmentis oneofthe

    biggestheavy-oil fieldprojectscurrentlyunderdevelopmentintheUKCSwithananticipatedproductionlifeofup to25years.

    Thescopeofworkincludesdevelopmentof anintegratedrisk-basedmaintenanceprogramme,associatedrepairandreplacementstrategiesandsparesholdings.Recognisingthe potential

    valueandcostsavingsto beachieved, PlantAssetManagementwill applyitssystematicmethodologytorationalisesparesholdingswiththeexpressaimofensuringeffectivecost controlwhenowning,stockingandmaintainingequipmentsparesforthelifeofthe asset.

    BuildMETM,PlantAssetManagementsproprietary

    assetmanagementprogramme developmentplatform willsupport theproject. Itwill provideacontrolled environmentinwhichtodeveloptheassethierarchy,assignmaintenance,conductthe criticalityassessment andsparesanalysis,andbuild billsofmaterials.

    BusinessManager(Europe)

    ofPlant AssetManagement,JohnMorrison,says: Wearedelightedtohave securedthiswork,which willbe executedanddeliveredby adoptingaclosepartnershipagreementwithour clientthat optimisesthecombined skillsof PlantAssetManagementand BumiArmadapersonnelin KualaLumpurto provideahighquality, costeffectivesolution.

    PETROFACRECOGNISED

    ORSETTINGSTANDARDINSAFETY

    We aredelightedtohavesecuredthiswork,whichwillbe executedanddeliveredbyadopting aclosepartnershipagreementwith

    ourclient

    MANAGINGANDMAINTAININGTHEARMADAKRAKEN

    Theteambehind theUZ750projectalsowon aclientsafety award

    Directorof KOCPipelines,receivedtheaward fromKOCCEOHashemS. Hashem.

    TheteambehindtheZADCOUpper ZakumUZ750Projectalsowon aclient awardasBest ContractorSafetyInitiatives for2014.

    Theteam designed,producedanddelivereda widerangeof corporateand projectHSSEinitiativesto makesure

    thatall employeesandcontractorswho areon siteareengagedandsafeatalltimes.

    TheUZ750projectisa majoroffshorefielddevelopmentinthe UnitedArab Emirates.Itis located80kmoffthecoastofAbuDhabiandis beingconstructedonartificial islandsa hugeonshoreprojectthatrequiresanunusual blendofoffshoreskills.

    Twosafetyawardshavebeensecuredby Petrofacfromclientsfor projectsin KuwaitandAbuDhabi.

    ThecompanysKuwaitOilCompany(KOC)Pipelinesprojectteamwon theKOCCEOsHealthSafetySecurityandthe Environment(HSSE)awardfora secondconsecutiveyear.

    Theawardwas presentedbyHashemS. Hashem,ChiefExecutiveOfficerof KOC.

    TheKOC PipelinesProjectrecentlyclocked15.5 millionmanhours withouta lost-timeincident(LTI),andthisHSSErecognitionfor thesecondsuccessiveyearshowsthe commitmenttosafetybyeveryoneinvolvedinthe project.

    ThePetrofacdelegation,whichincluded AndyNickerson,HSSE DirectorofOnshore EngineeringandConstructionbusiness unit,andMohamedShanan, Project

    Petrofacts October201

    PetroleumDevelopmentOman

    (PDO)has awarded Petrofacanengineeringandprocurementcontracttoprovideservicesfor itsYibalKhuffproject, afield locatedapproximately350 kmsouthwestof Muscatin theSultanateofOman.

    Underthe termsof thefour-and-a-half-yearcontractPetrofacwill beprovidingreimbursabledetailedengineering,and constructionandcommissioningmanagementsupport services

    andprocurementon an

    incentivisedpass-throughbasis.Thiswill extendthroughoutconstructionandduringstart-upof theintegratedoil andsour gasfacility.

    Thetotal contractvalueisexpectedto bearound$900millionwith aroundone quarterofthe revenuesrelatingtoprofessionalservices(engineering,constructionandcommissioningmanagement).

    Developmentof thefield willaddtoPDOsfutureoil

    productionwhilstthe

    associated gaswill beutilisedforpower generationandenhancedoil recoverydevelopments.

    CraigMuir,ManagingDirectorforPetrofacsEngineeringand ConsultingServicesbusiness,says: Thiscontractbuildson theRababHarweelIntegratedProjectwhichwe arealreadyexecutingalongsidePDOand representsafurthermilestoneinthedevelopmentof ourEPCmdeliverystrategy.

    Itreinforcesour presence

    inOmanwherewehaveanumberof projectsandengineeringoffice, andwherthiswill furthercomplementouragenda forincreasingincountryvalue. Wewill contintomaintainastrongfocusonthisaspectof ourdeliverybyaccessingthe localsupplychainand recruitment oflocaresourcesandwe areverymuchlooking forwardtogrowingandstrengtheningtteamworkingalongsidePDOtodeliver thisproject.

    ENGINEERINGANDPROCUREMENTCONTRACTAWARDEDINOMAN

    PETROFACAMBITIONSREWARDEDINKUWAITKuwaitis, andwillcontinuetobe, oneof ourcoremarkets,andis ofstrategicimportanceto Petrofacsambitionsinthe MiddleEast.

    Petrofachas signeda contractwiththe KuwaitOil Company(KOC)fortheir manifoldgrouptrunkline(MGT)system inthenorthof Kuwait.

    Thelump-sum engineering,procurementand construction(EPC)project,valued atapproximately$780 million,isintegralto KOCsplanstoincreaseandmaintaincrudeproductionoverthe nextfive

    years.Threenew gatheringcentres(GCs),which formpartofthe broader project,arealreadyunderconstructionwithPetrofacexecutingtheEPCcontractforGC 29.

    Due forcompletiontowardstheendof2017,theMGTsystemwill providethefeedstockto eachofthegatheringcentres viathreeindependentnetworksof

    intermediatemanifoldsandpipelines.Eachof thegatheringcentreswill becapableof producingaround100,000barrelsof oilperdaytogetherwithassociatedwaterandgas.

    MarwanChedid,ChiefExecutiveof PetrofacsEngineering,Construction,Operationsand Maintenancedivision,said:Wehavea long

    trackrecordin Kuwaitwhichextendsoverthelast15 yeaandthe MGTawardrepreseourtwelfthprojectinthecountry.Kuwaitis, andwillcontinuetobe,oneof ourcomarketsandisof strategicimportancetoPetrofacsambitionsinthe MiddleEastWelook forwardtoworkingwithKOCtodeliverthisprojsafelyand onschedule.

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    5/27

    Petrofacts October2015

    uringthe past 18yearsPetrofachas madesignificantinroads

    to theAlgerianmarket,thanks toits involvement ina numberof

    ajor oiland gasprojects.RobinKnight describeshowitasbeendone andwhatliesahead

    ALGERIA:COUNTINGTHEGAINSOF

    SANDPetrofacts October201

    Locatedina remoteregionAlgerias Sahara Desert,where the terrain consistsinterlockingsanddunes, thElMerkcentralprocessingfacilityoperatesasa keyproductionhub fortheBerkineBasinregion.

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    6/27

    PetrofactsOctober2015

    Grassrootstraining isoneofthemosteective toolsthat thecompanyhas

    AdelHaddadVice President and CountryManager,Algeriasince 2009.JoinedPetrofacin 1998.Amech anical engineerbytraining,he hasworkedmainlyintheoilandgassectorinIndia, Kuwait,GeorgiaandKazakhstan.

    ahamMacMillan

    ce President&Director ofojectsAlgeriafor Onshoregineering& ConstructionEC).JoinedPetrofacin001as asafety studiesanager,and transferredtoojectmanagementin 2007.

    PetrofactsOctober201

    Algeriaisa specialmarketwithitsownenvironmentsof risksand challenges,observesLeilaMansour,PetrofacsLegalRepresentativeand BusinessDevelopmentManager inAlgiers. Despitethis,she says,the companysspectaculargrowthsinceit openeditsfirstofficeinthecapitalin1999has madethenameofPetrofacin hercountry arespectedlabelofseriousnessone renownedfor itsabilitytodeliverhighqualityservicesontimeandtobudget.Successhas nothappenedovernight.

    Thecompanywas firstestablishedinAlgeriain1999,andthefirstcontractawardedin2000 the$660millionOhanetdevelopment.But it wasnot until2007that Petrofacmade itsnextbreakthrough theawardof a$600 millionengineering,procurementandconstruction(EPC)contractto designandinstallcompressionfacilitiesat threegas-producingfieldsatthehugeIn Salahdevelopmentin thecentral Sahararegion.Sincethen, growthhasbeen impressive,

    muchofit linkeddirectlyor indirectlytolargeventuresassociatedwith theAlgerianstate-owned oiland gascompanySonatrach.A furtherfour EPCcontractshavebeensecuredwithacombinedvalueexceeding$5 billion,and thecompanynowhasmorethan800staff(includingover350 expatriates)workingin thecountryat ninesites.ThreemajorEPCprojectsarestill

    ongoinga $1.2billioncontractto developsoutherngasfieldsin theInSalahdevelopment(SFDP); a$ 650million jointventurewiththe Italianfirm Bonattitoextendthelifeofthe AlrargasfieldinsoutheastAlgeria;and a$970 millioncontractfora gastreatmentplantandassociatedflowlines/pipelineattheRegganebasinin theSahara1,500kmsouthwestofAlgiers.Mostrecentlythe companywona

    five-yearcontractwith Sonatrachtoprovidea rangeof engineeringdesign andprocurement(EDP) servicesas wellassigninga contractforthe provisionalundertaking ofa jointventure,also for

    EDPservices.Theobjectiveisto buildlocalcapability andcapacity.Theseagreementsare excellentillustrationsofourstrategyin action,saysCraigMuir,ManagingDirectorof PetrofacsEngineeringandConsultingServices(ECS)business.Theyuseourinternationalcapabilityto maximisein-countryvalue.And theysupport ourlonger-termsustainabilityin Algeria.Thesesuccesses havenot been

    achievedeasily.TheIn SalahSouthernFieldsDevelopment,to giveone example,hasbeen along challengingprojectaccordingtoGrahamMacMillan, VicePresident Operationsand DirectorofProjectsAlgeriafor PetrofacsOnshoreEngineeringandConstruction(OEC)businessunit. Firstgas is scheduledforlaterthis year,withfurther expansionasadditional wellsbecome availableto behookedup.There hasbeen somedelay,heexplains,duetotheknock-oneffectoftheterroristattackattheIn Amenassiteinearly2013,whichresultedinmorethan

    oneyearofstandbyas theclientandPetrofacevacuatedexpatriates.TheIn Amenasincidentapart, Algeria

    hasbeenrelativelystablesincethe turnof

    thecentury.Nevertheless,as Grahamstresses,Wherever wework inthe worwehavetoremainvigilantaboutthespecificsof ouroperatingenvironment.Thats justcommon sense.VedPrakashGupta,the companys

    ProjectManagerat Alrar,adds:Constructionin Algeriahas haditschallengesintermsof logisticsandtheavailabilityof skilledmanpowerandqualifiedcontractors. Alraris noexceptiButwe dounderstandthe operatingenvironment.Indeed,every Petrofacprojectherehas beencompletedsuccessfully, andboth theAlrar andRegganeprojectsareprogressingwellaccordingtoAlgeria CountryManagerAdelHaddad.Resourcestocounter thechallenges

    facingAfricaslargestcountry relyoverwhelminglyon thehydrocarbonsector. Oiland gasrevenuesaccount fo58%of thegovernmentsbudget,98% oAlgerias exportearningsand 28%of itsgrossdomesticproduct.Substantial

    untappedoiland gasreservesdo exist,mainlyin theSahararegion, makingitlikelythatAlgeriawillcontinueto woooutsideinvestors.

    PaulNicholson

    DirectorEngineeringandConsultingServices(ECS)NorthAfrica.JoinedECSin2013. Some25yearsprojectandconstructionmanagement, developmentandimplementationexperiencein theonshoreandoffshoreoiland gasindustry.

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    7/27

    PetrofactsOctober2015

    ForPetrofac, winningthe $2.3billion EPCntractforthe ElMerk centralprocessingcility(CPF) in2009 wasthe differentiatingoject,saysGrahamMac Millan.Wewonatcontractduring theglobal financialwnturn.Itensured stabilityovera periodhenour peersreally struggled.Firstoil atElMerkwas achievedin

    arch,2013andthewholeprojectwasmpletedsix monthslaterin lessthanfivears.Morethan1,000kmof electricalblewaslaidandtodaytheEl MerkCPFeratesasa keyproductionhubfortherkineBasinregion.OneexplanationforPetrofacsuccessoriesinAlgeriasuchas ElMerkhasbeenecompanysfocused andsustainedveto developstronglocal relationships.heyare acutelyimportant,notesRomenah,ProjectManagerat theRegganevelopment.Paul Nicholson,DirectorCSNorth Africa,echoes thesentiment:heyarethe cornerstoneforalloursinessdevelopment andgrowth.JigneshDoshi,Project DirectorontheDP,explains:About 60% ofour labourrcecomesfromlocaltowns.Henceourationshipswith thelocal authoritiesandoplearevery important.Our biggestncernisthatonceourworkstartsperingdown,therewill notbe adequatemploymentina desertcontextlikethisforcalpeople,unless otherprojectvelopmentsfollow.

    prioritybe giventoAlgeriansinrecruitment,suchinitiativeshave emphasisedthatPetrofacis inAlgeria forthe long-term.Theadventof alowoil priceerameans

    thatcompetitionfor businesswill inevitablybecomemoreand morechallenging,acknowledgesAdel Haddad.Andthere isagreementamong Petrofacexecutives

    that,as JigneshDoshiputsit,whiletherearetremendousopportunitiesin Algeria,aswithallourmarkets,it requirestimeandpassiontoget thingsdone.Nevertheless,with thelikelihoodof a

    renewedpoliticalpushfromthetop tofurtherdevelopAlgeriasconsiderableoilandgasassets,andbringthemtomarketwithina morecompetitiveframework,plus southernEuropesongoingneedfor moregas,the overallfutureforoil andgasservicescompaniesinAlgeria appearsencouraging.Petrofac,in particular,looks wellplaced

    tothrive, witha fully operationalengineeringand representativeofficeinAlgiersnow supportingacost-effectivebusinessinthefield allunderpinnedbyastrongtrackrecord.It hastakenus nearlytwodecadestolearnhowto performhere,concludesGrahamMac Millan.Inthelasttwoyearsourpeershavetriedtoenterthismarketbutarefindingit heavygoing.Algeriais notsoeasytoenterasanewcomerbut thoroughly rewardingonceyouarein.

    InAlgiers LeilaMansouradds anotherperspective. InAlgeria relationshipsdevelopthe countryisin adynamicstatetoday. Severalchangescan happenduringthelifeof thesameproject.Thisis acountrywhereyou mustalwaysbeon thealertaschangecanhappenswiftly.Ontheotherhand,as relationshipsdeepen,

    eachprojectcan behandled differently,andbetter,thanthe previousone.ThatsveryrewardingAnotherkeystrategyhas beento invest

    ingrassrootstraining oneof themosteectivetoolsthe company hasaccordingtoAdel,andanimportantweaponinthestruggleto combatunemployment.Inlate-2010Petrofacfundedtheconstructionandoperationof acentre900kmsouthofAlgiersat HassiMessaoud,designed tohelpyounglocalsacquirethe skillstheyneedfortheoilandgasindustry.Over800individualshavegraduatedin fivetechnicaldisciplinesandthe facilityhas beenwidelypraisedatlocal andnationallevel.OtherPetrofacfundshavebeenusedto

    upgradeatrainingcentreintheIn Salahtownship,builda craftcentreatElMerktoimproveskillssuch aswelding andpiping,andfacilitateEnglish languagecoursesforengineersthroughthe BritishCouncil.Also,says PaulNicholson,each memberofourengineeringteamhasafullydefinedtraininganddevelopmentplan.Given arecentlyenactedlaw whichlays downthat

    VedPrakash GuptaProjectManagerAlrargasfieldproject.ElectricalEngineer bytrainingwithbackgroundin thermalandgaspowerplantsin theoilandgas industry.JoinedPetrofac2007 asDeliveryManagerforthe InSalahgasproject.

    RomenShahProjectManagerforthe

    Regganeprojectmanagingengineering,procurementandconstruction.Achemicalengineerbyqualification,hehas 25yearsexperienceinprojectmanagementonvarious types of projects.JoinedPetrofacin 2002.

    JigneshDoshiProjectDirectorSouthern

    FieldsDevelopmentProject,InSalah. JoinedPetrofac2002.A civilengineerbytraining,he workedpreviouslywith BechtelinUAE andIndia.

    PetrofactsOctober2015

    ProfileLeilaMansour,PetrofacLegalRepresentative,Algiers

    AsthefirstAlgerianwomantoworkasan oilfieldengineerinthe AlgeriaSaharadesert,LeilaMansourclearlyhaswhatittakestosurviveandflourish.Itwas anexciting

    experience,she recalls.Iwas involvedinloggingoperationson theoil wells,responsiblefor someveryexpensive andsensitiveequipmentandfor thecrew.Tospendmorethan72hourswithoutmuchsleepwasnothingexceptional.The best

    momentwasgettinganinvoicerelatedto theoperationssigned bytheclientandthengoingbacktothebase office.Workingatthetimefor

    Schlumberger,Leilarealisedfromtheoutsetthatthedesertworkplacewasessentiallyamasculineenvironment.ItmeantthatI avoided

    askingthemenforhelpincaseitwasusedas areasontojustifytheirdelaysor losttimeintheoperation.I justhadtocarryonwithoutcomplaint.Eventuallypeopledidofferme theirhelpwhich,ofcourse,I refused!Thisunabashed,can-do

    attitudehastypified Leilascareer.Born inAlgiers, shegrewup betweenAlgiersandParisbeforeattending

    USTHBAlgiersUniversity,whereshe studiedelectronicengineering.Mynatureis toseeka

    challenge.Atthat timetheelectronicsdisciplineat theuniversityhadthe bestrating,soit becamemychallenge.In1993shegraduatedwithhonours.JoiningSchlumbergerin

    theSahara,the companysubsequentlytransferredhertoParis. Thereshe oversawthecompanysbusinesstieswiththe globalcreditinsurerCoface herfirstmoveawayfromengineering.Itwasveryexcitingtofind

    oneselfdealingwith banks,andnegotiatingbestvaluedatesto allowinvestmenttobeon time,she remembers.LatershejoinedABB

    LummusGlobalNetherlandandwas responsiblefor its

    IntenyearsPetrofachasachievedspectaculargrowthin Algeriaandmadeitsnameknown forthehighqualityofits services.

    businessinAlgeriauntilitsolditsoilandgasinterests.Andshortly after,in 2004,Petrofaccame callingwith anewchallengeto beLegaRepresentativeand SeniorBusinessDevelopmentManagerin Algiers.Leilawashappyto accept.Today,shesays, Idont ha

    aspecific jobframeworkwhlimitsmy orientation.As LegRepresentativeand SeniorBusinessDevelopmentManagerImin contactwithkindsof people,fromthoseithelowestpositionstothosethehighest.Leilaexplainsthat sheis

    mostlyself-taught.It pushemeto learnlegal proceduresandthebestwaytodealwittheauthorities,banks andministries,she adds.Mostofhertime,Leila

    admits,isdedicatedtoher joInten yearsPetrofac hasachievedspectaculargrowtinAlgeriaandmadeits nameknownforthe highqualityofservices.Weareallproudtoworkforthiscompany.It hasbecomepartofmy life.Whathaskepther with

    Petrofac,she reflects,isthetrustinvestedbytopmanagementin people.Lookingahead,she hopestobemore involvedin corporasocialresponsibilityissues.Yetmindfulthat successin

    businesscan neverbe takenforgranted,characteristicalshehasanothergoalinmindInherwords:Inertiaisthemaindangerthreateningthedominantposition ofacompany.MyfocusinPetrofacinthe futurewillbetoconcentrateon avoidingthatdanger.

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    8/27

    PetrofactsJune2014

    WHEREWEWORKJUMPFORJOY

    All those who work orhaveworked ontheBerantaifield offshoreinPeninsularMalaysiahavesomethingto celebrate.Notonly hasthe assetsurpassedtheone millionmanhourmark ofsafeoffshore operationswithout al ost-timeinjury(LTI),but itwasalsoHari Merdeka orMalaysiaDay in August.Thefieldhas operated

    formorethan 961dayssafely,since hittingbothfirstgasandfirstoilinlate2012andearly 2013respectively.

    Thesafetyachievementalsoincludescompletionworkdone bycont ractorsandvendors.

    Petrofacis operatorofthefieldandhasledthedevelopmentunder ariskservicescontract,workingalongsideits partner

    SapuraKencanaPetroleum,onbehalf ofPETRONAS.Hari Merdekameans

    IndependenceDay.It isanationalholidaywhichiscelebratedon31 Augusteveryyear, whenpeoplefromall backgrounds,raceandreligioncelebratetheformationofMalaysia,andits independencefromcolonialrule.Photograph byIanTeh

    Petrofacts June2014

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    9/27

    Petrofacts October2015

    AMFASCINATEDBY WHATWE DO ANDWHAT WEARE CAPABLEOF DOINGcompanysChief FinancialOcerknowsallabout

    xpectations especiallythoseof theCity. HelenDunneeetsTimWeller to talkpressure,prospects andperformance.

    hotographsby JoakimBlockstrom

    s Fridaymorningattheend ofa busyeekfor PetrofacsChiefFinancial OfficermWeller.On Tuesday,the companynounceditsinterim resultsto thearket. AfterbriefingCity analysts,mhas spentthe interveningdayseetingsomeof Petrofacsinstitutionalvestorsand explainingthose resultsintail.Yesterday, forexample,he wasininburghto meeta numberofareholders,includingStandardLife,eof Petrofacslargestexternalinvestors.doverthenextthreeweeks,he willitinvestorsin London,EuropeandorthAmerica,where morethan 20%Petrofacs sharesarenow held.Itsa prettyintensiveperiod,Timncedes.Theinvestorroadshowtakestweenthreeand fourweeks.Theocessisthenrepeatedafterthefullyearsultsareunveiled. Igenerallyvisit theUS

    acoupleoftimesa year,andtheresanannualEuropeanroadshow.Indeed,overthecourseof ayear,Tim,

    togetherwithmembers ofhis investorrelations teamand Petrofacsexecutiveteam,will meetaround300 investors,sometwicea year.WemeetStandardLifetwoorthreetimesayear,headds.Meetinginvestorstoexplain Petrofacs

    storyandhighlightitsprospectsisavitalpartof Timsrole,andone hetakesveryseriously.Quite simply,the investorsownthebusiness.Itis theirmoneythatisatrisk.Manyboughttheirsharesatthetimeof Petrofacsfloatand areloyaltothecompany.ButTimalsohastoexplainthebusiness modelandperformanceto Cityanalystswhorecommend whetherinvestorsbuy,sellor holdsharesin Petrofac.Managingtheinvestorinterfaceis a

    veryimportantpart ofthe CFOsjob.Wearethepeoplewhohavetofacetheinvestorandanalystcommunity,and makesurethat theyvery clearlyunderstandourexpectationsfor thebusiness sothat theycanset realisticgoals.WhenPetrofacslippedout oftheFTSE

    100indexintotheFTSE250,it didnotsufferfrom anexodusof shareholderswhichother companiesinsimilar positionshaveexperienced.Wedid notseea bigshakeout ofour existinginvestors,andactuallyour currentsecondlargestexternalinvestoracquiredtheirstake afterourexit fromthe FTSE100,says Tim,indicatingthatthe loyaltyofthe investmentcommunityreflectsan understandingofPetrofacsstrengths,suchas itsrecordbacklogand significantopportunitieswithinits coreMiddle Easternmarkets.Timadds: Afrequentmistakemade in

    Petrofacts October2015

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    10/27

    PetrofactsOctober2015

    Ifany executiveof alistedcompanysaysthatthey dont look atthesharepriceseveraltimesonthedayofan announcement,they areprobablynottellingthe truth

    executiveleadershipteam,bothon abusinessand personalbasis,and that

    helps,he explains.Itis veryimportantthatwedonotseekto dressup badnews.Wehavetotellitlikeit is.Wehavetoadmitmistakes andexplainthe reasons.

    Toughcall

    Themost significantwarningcameinNovember 2014when Petrofachad toresetmarketexpectationsfor2015 verydramatically,says Tim.We shavedmorethan20% offearnings expectationsand,asa result,thesharepricedroppedbymorethan25% thatday.Itwasthe biggestbadnewsstoryIveeverhadtodeliver.It wasntahappy day.Theanalystscallwastough.As arepresentativeofthecompany,you feelbad forthe investorandanalystcommunitybecause youvedisappointedthem.

    Ironically,there isa Citymantrathatprofitswarningsgenerallycomein threes.Itispartlydueto humannature,explainsTim.The firstwarningusually alertsinvestors thatthereis aproblem,butnobody leastof allthecompany reallybelievesitwillbe quiteas badasit seems.Thesecond warningprovidesanupdate,asthegrimrealitystartstodawn.Andthe

    finalone deliversthe grislytruth.Itis importantforTim andhisteamto

    keepabreastof operationaland financialperformanceacross thewhole companyiftheyaretoensurethattheCitysexpectationsreflect arealistic viewofPetrofacsprospects.Timholds frequentformaland informalmeetingswithhisteam,who haveresponsibilityforallaspectsof thecompanysfinancesincludingbusinessunit anddivisionalfinance,financialcontrol,tax, treasury,IT,internalaudit,mergersand acquisitions,andrisk, aswell asinvestorrelations.

    Theyare expectedtounderstandnotjust Petrofacsb usiness but the sector inwhichit operates.Wearea majorplayerintheindustry,andmyteamandI mustunderstand thatlandscapeand howwe fitintothe broadermarketplace,he explains.Regularsenior-levelinternalmeetingsarekeyopportunitiesforTimand histeamtounderstand developmentsacrossall ofPetrofacsbusinessunits indetail. Onceagain,Timemphasisesthe needforopenness,honestyand transparencyinthis dialogueso thatPetrofacs seniorleadershipteamcan developa detailedandaccurateview ofthe companysperformanceand prospects.

    vestor relationsis toseek as highauationaspossible bytelling areally

    odstorywhichisnotbackedupbyality.But thatis nota sustainablesition. Hebelievesit ismoreportant toget thecompanycorrectlyued.Beingopen, honestandnsparentwith analysts andinvestors

    keytothisprocess.Thegoodstoriesustbetoldalongsidethemoretrickyes,andTim hashadsomedifficult

    oriesto explaininrecent months.Overthe pastyear,Petrofachasliveredthreeprofitswarnings a

    sultoffallingoilprices,a difficultonomicbackground,over-ambitiousecastsfor IntegratedEnergyServicesdsome unforeseenoperationalallengessuchas theadditionalnstruction costsrelatedto ECOMsggan-Tormore project.Youdontgetalot ofsleepthenightforea majorprofitswarning,Timmits.Itiseasyto delivergoodnewstitis veryhardto deliverbadnews.

    s attimessuchasthesethatationshipswith keyinvestorsandalysts comeinto play,reinforcingTimsefor regularcontact.They willhave

    etandwillknowmembersofthe

    Petrofacts October2015

    and,ultimately, in thesaleofthe companytoVodafone.I likebusinessesthat create

    things,explainsTim.At Petrofac,I amfascinatedbywhatwe doandwhatwearecapableofdoingandbelievewecan bereallyproudof ourfeats ofengineering.It isfundamentallyimportantto methateverybody inmy financeteamunderstandsthese thingsand reallygetstoknow ourbusiness.Timis currentlya non-executivedirector

    ofG4Sand TheCarbonTrustandhas hadnon-executiveroles withbusinessessuchasBBC Worldwide andStanleyLeisure inthepast.Iseemynon-execrolesasanopportunitytoget exposuretodifferentbusinessesandmarkets,he explains.Butalsotobringvaluetoeachparticularcompanythroughmy financialexpertiseandbroadercommercialexperience.Forexample,havingworkedfor utilitycompanies,I havedevelopedanunderstandingof theinterfacebetweentheprivateand publicsector,which wasanattributeG4S werelookingfor giventhatgovernmentoutsourcingis amajorbusinessdevelopmentchannelfor thecompany,he says.Asa non-exec,I haveaveryrealresponsibilitytolookaftertheinterestsof acompanysstakeholders

    Itis very importantthatwedo notseektodressup badnews.Wehave to tell it likeitis. Wehavetoadmitmistakesandexplainthereasons

    inthebroadestsenseoftheword.Hebelievesnon-execdirectorscan act

    asimportantchecks andbalancesforbusinesses,and claimsto havelearnalotfrombothperformingtheroleandtpeoplehe hasmetasa result.Hisownexperience hasalso renewedhisrespecforthose whoperform therole atPetrof

    Shareprice

    Despitethetravailsofthepast12 monthPetrofacsshareprice improvedfollowintheresultsannouncementandallbutonCityanalystnow ratesthecompany aseithera buyora hold.WasTimrelieveIfanyexecutiveofa listedcompanysaythattheydontlookatthesharepriceseveraltimeson thedayofan importantannouncement,they areprobablynot tethetruth,Timsays.Buthealsobelievesthat,if acompanysinvestorrelationsactivitiesareeffective,thepriceatwhicsharesultimatelysettleshould notcomeashock.Indeed,he suggeststhatthe toofthe analystsconferencecall, whichtaplaceon themorningofbigfinancialannouncements,providesan indicationofhowthesharesarelikelytoperform.So,Iask,whatsthe sharepricethismorning?Ihaventlooked yet,he laugh

    Careeropportuni ties

    Hisfocus ondetailprobablyhasa lottodo

    withhis engineeringbackground.Indeed,havinggraduatedinthe subject,Timinitiallyaspiredto bean engineer,but therewerelimitedcareer opportunitiesavailable.Ofthe70studentsin myyear,fewerthan10 becameengineers,recallsTim.Therest becameinvestmentbankersoraccountants.Tim joinedKPMG asatraineeaccountant.Heshunnedinvestmentbanking becauseof itslackofa tangibleproduct,adding:It isquitehardfor myinvestmentbankingbuddiestoexplainto theirkidswhattheydoonaday-to-daybasis!Accountancyappealedbecauseof its

    parallelwithengineeringfrom anumeracyperspective.I wasalreadyfinanciallyliterate,he says.Havingbecomea partnerinKPMGs InfrastructureBusiness Unit,heleftin 1997tobecomeaserialChiefFinancialOfficer,first joiningthe GranadaGroup,beforemovingto InnogyHoldings(nowRWE npower), RWEThamesWater,UnitedUtilitiesand enduringa shortperiodwithCable &WirelessWorldwide, wherehealsohadtodeliverthreeverybigprofitswarningswhichculminatedin thedepartureofa numberof seniorexecutives

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    11/27

    PetrofactsOctober2015

    INPRAISEOFTHEHUMBLE

    VALVEIfyouarea fanof comicbook

    characters,youmay beaware ofTheEnforcers,a fearless team

    whoapplythe rules anddirect

    theaction. Sowho, orwhat,isthePetrofacequivalent?At

    Petrofacts, wewouldnominate

    thehumblevalve that unsungcomponentessentialto every

    projectthe companyhasever

    designed,built, maintainedormanaged.PeterHalliday reports

    Petrofacts October2015| 2

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    12/27

    |PetrofactsOctober2015

    astyourmindbackto everyplumbingueyou haveexperiencedathome.inkof theirritatinglittleniggleslikeappingtap,or ashowerthatwontstayat

    eright temperature.Thinkof thebigger,oredisturbingdramas,likeanerflowingcistern, ora badlybehavingiler.Almost allof theseplumbingissuesnbetracedbacktothesamerootcausevalveof onetypeoranotherthatis not

    tinginthe wayitshould.Thethingis, intheoil andgasbusiness,esameprincipleapplies.Exceptonaggerscale.Much, muchbigger.Stripit backtoitsbareessentialsand,t like your domestic plumbing system,eryoil andgasinstallationfroma

    ellhead,toa processingfacility,to apeline,to arefinery ismadeupof aotleycollectionof pipeworkandvalves,thmaybe afew pressurevesselsthrownor goodmeasure.And,becauseit isthevalvesthatcontainostof themovingparts,theytendtobeemost temperamental.Theyare the

    ostlikelypointsof failure.Theycan weart,they canmalfunction and,especially

    heyareincorrectlyspecified,theycanmplyfailto withstandthe rigoursofdaysoiland gasbusiness.Theyrangeinsizefromtinylittleneedleves,togargantuanman-sizedgatelves.Theyrangein weightfroma fewncestomorethan30 tonnes.They

    ngeinpricefroma fewcentstondredsofthousands ofdollars. And,in

    anyways,itis thesevalvesthatarethealworkhorses,or TheEnforcers,of ourdustry startingandstoppingthe flow,gulatingit, sendingit inthe rightdirection,eventingit fromgoingin thewrongection, relievingpressurebuild-ups,andtingasthe lastlineofdefencewheneverngsgo awry.fyouarein anydoubtabouttheroleof

    evalve,considerhowmanyof themareutinelyspecified,procured,fitted,tested,aintainedand,whennecessary,replaced.Overthecourseof 2015,accordingtotimatesfrom theMcIlvaine Company,eoilandgasindustryis settospendahopping$19billionon valves.Ofthat,0.3billionwillgoonnew valves,$6billion

    lbespentonrelatedequipment,and$3lionwillbeeatenupon spareparts.Whysomuch?Well,againaccordingtocIlvaine,evena modestlysizedgasocessingplant,builtata costof50million,wouldrequire a$5 millionvestmentinvalves80% ofwhichwould

    on relatively simpleon/offvalves,and

    Estimated2015 industryspendon valves:

    Overleaf,theGalkynyshgasplantinTurkmenistanisPetrofacslargestEPCprojecttodate.

    Abovea ndright, theBerantaifieldinoffshorePeninsulaMalaysia,operatedbyPetrofaconbehalfof PETRONAS.

    20% onmore sophisticatedcontrol valves.And,of course,Petrofacsown

    experience bearsthis out.Take,forexample,the $1 billionRababHarweelprojectinOman,consistingof sourgasprocessingfacilities, associatedgatheringandinjectionsystems, andexportpipelines.Forthis contractalone,Petrofacspecialistsarespecifying,procuring,testinganddeliveringupwardsof 15,000different valves including14,000 manualvalves,650 actuatedvalves,300 controlvalves,and200 pressuresafetyvalves.

    Thecostofmanyofthesevalvesmayberelativelymodest at,say,$250-to-$500apiece. But,dependingon theirpurpose,valvescan getvery sophisticatedveryquickly,andthe priceescalatesaccordinglyso,for example,it isnotunusualtopay morethan$300,000foralarge emergencyshutdownvalve.

    ToughlifeAvalvehasa toughlife.And,asthe oilandgasindustry evolves,presentingever more

    difficultand demandingconditions, itgetstougherall thetime.

    Dependingon whattheyarefo randwheretheyaresited,manyvalveshavetowithstandawide rangeof demandingconditions. Theyoften haveto contendwitha highlycorrosivemix ofmaterials,fromseawateratthe lowerendof thetoxicityscale,through tothe highlypoisonous,corrosive,flammable,andexplosive propertiesof hydrogen sulphide

    $9bn

    ,

    $MSpendonvalves foronegasprocessingplant:

    Valves involved on theRababHarweel project

    Petrofacts October2015

    atthe other.Theycan experiencepressuresofmorethan300bar(so,theyhaveto bearounda hundredtimestougher thanthevalvesin thetyresof yourcar).Theycanfacetemperaturesofmore than600C(whichis ator approachingthe meltingpointof manyeverydaymetalssuch aszinc,aluminiumandmagnesium).Orinanemergencydepressurisationsituationat agasplant, forexample,temperaturesmaysuddenlyplummetfrom +30Cto -100C.Thevalves controllingthe procedure needtomaintaintheir integritythroughoutitall.

    Inan industrythatwont toleratesafetycompromises,has arelentlessfocus onproductionperformance,treatseven a

    singledropofspiltoilas areportableincident,andhas neverbeenmore costconscious,evermore expectationisloadedontothelotof thehumblevalve.

    Misbehavingvalve

    Itis generallytrueto say,justlikethosedomesticplumbingproblems,in anyoil

    andgas incident,a misbehavingvalve willbeatthe rootof manyissues orwillhavefailedto prevent them.Letstakethe mostnotorious caseimaginable,the DeepwaterHorizonoilspill .Here,thecauseoftheaccidentwastracedbacktotheconspicuousfailureof eightdifferentsafetysystems threeof whichwerevalvesor valvecontrolsystems.

    Consideralsothat, in theUSlegalindustry,there isa dedicatedclassofattorneyscalled valvefailureinjurylawyers.They earntheir moneybyrepresentingoil andgas workers whohavebeenhurtina valvefailure andthefactthatthey evenexistspeaks volumesabout

    theprevalenceof suchincidents.So,clearly,in anyasset integritycampaign, andin everystatutorytestingregime,valvesarealways aprime focus.But,remember,thejobofa valveis notjusttostopthingsfromgoingwrong.Itis alsoaboutenablingthingstogoright.Awholeclassof valves,the so-calledcontrol

    valves,arethere toregulatethe flowthrougheveryfacetofan oilandgasfacility.They thereforehave adirect impontheperformanceof thatfacility.And,tachievethe optimumperformance,all othedifferentvalves needto becorrectlyspecified,sized,situatedand safeguard

    Inrecent years,thequestion ofvalvequalityhas edgedup thePetrofacagendThefactis,thecompanyhadbeguntosufferfrom qualityand integrityissuesnothingonthescaleof amajorincidentbutan on-goingseriesof nigglingissueslikeleakagethroughvalve casings,or thsheeringofvalvestems,allofwhichweradding tocosts andcausing delays.

    Theissues becameso prevalentthatvalveintegritybecamea regularagendaitemof thecompanyssix-monthlymanagementreviewmeetings,and ateaofquality specialists,under theleadershofDr AndrewThomas,QualityDirectorwithOnshoreEngineeringandConstruction,was chargedwithfinding

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    13/27

    | Petrofacts October2015

    lution.A supplierqualitymanagementstemanda bi-monthlyvendor forum

    ereput inplace, bringingcloserrtnershipswith themajor valveppliers,a morescrupulousregime of

    onitoringand testing,anda systematicayof capturingandreportingon any

    atedqualityconcerns.Thismaysoundsimpleintheory,but thealitycan bemore complex.Thevalvedustryis unusuallyfragmented,withndredsofdifferentsuppliers using

    ousandsof different sub-contractors.vena highlyreputablesupplierwith veryphisticatedvalvedesignsmay outsourcemeofitsmanufacturingtoa thirdparty,

    dthatswhere qualityissues canmetimescreepin, explainsAndrew.

    ualityinitiativeotherperspectivecomesfrom Richard

    ng,Vice PresidentofEngineeringandegrityAssuranceatEngineeringand

    onsultingServices.He says:Issueswith

    valvequalitycantakeawhiletocometolight.Oftenthepurchaserisnotthe enduser,which meansthe manufacturermayneverget thefeedbackunless somethinggoesseriouslywrong.

    Althoughsomeissuesdo continuetosurface,andnotalltheinformationisalwayspassedbackdowntheline,thequalityinitiativehas beena definitesuccess somuchso thatvalvequalityisno longera regularagendaitematmanagementmeetings.

    Whenitcomestoactuallyoperatinganoilandgasfacility,it isdifficult tooverstatetherole thatvalveswill play. Practicallyeveryoperationwe everundertake

    involvesa valvein someform oranother,explainsRoyArmishaw,Vice PresidentofOperationsin AsiaPacific,who overseasallof thecompanyscurrentoperationsinMalaysiaandThailand.They arethe focusofour testingandcertificationregimes.Theyarethesubjectof ourupgradecampaigns.Andthey arethe mainreason

    whywe wouldimplementa shutdown.Anadded considerationis thatRoy and

    histeamsrarelygettooperatea shinynewplant.Instead,theyoften inheritan ageingfacility;theirjobis tonurseitbacktofullproduction.The symptomsyou facein anoldplantareexactlythesameasthoseyouwouldfacein anoldhouse.Theplumbingis pastits prime.Youtake thingscautiously.And youprepareyourselfforthefactthatanystopcockor theoilandgasequivalent mayfailjustwhenyouneeditthemost.

    Hethereforeimploresall designerstothinkthroughthe everyday realitiesofoperatinga plant.Youcan neverhavetoo

    manyvalves.We areforeverhavingtoisolateasectionofplant.Anditsanabsolutepainifthedesignerhasgivenyoutoofewvalvestoworkwithorif theyareinthewrong place.

    YetanotherperspectivecomesfromValveEngineerJohn Fowler,who isbasedinthe AberdeenOfficesof Offshore

    Learningaboutvalvesat theINSTEPtrainingacademyinMalaysia,oneof twotrainingfacilitiesthatPetrofacbuilttosupportPETRONAS workforce.

    PetrofactsOctober2015

    ProjectsandOperations,and managestheBPisolation valvescontract.Simplyput,thismeansthat,foritsNorthSeaoperations,BP hasoutsourceditson-goingvalverequirementstoJohn andhissix-strongteam.On anannual basis,theywill specify,procureandtest around1,000differentvalveson behalfof BP.Andthisgivesthemarareinsightintotheinnerworkingsof thevalve business.

    Thebig issueis timing,explainsJohn.Thesearenttypically off-the-shelfitems.Theytendto beone-offs.Sowe areoftenlookingat 50-weekleadtimes. Theproblemsarisewhen a bespoke valveisneededquickly.Then,instead ofcarefullyselectingand negotiatingwith therightmanufacturer,you suddenlyfind yourselfatthemercyofa thirdpartyvendor.

    Theymayhavea similarvalvein stock,whichtheyarewillingtosellyoufor100,000.But it needsto bemodified,whichmay costanother50,000.So,insteadof gettinga custom-madevalve for80,000,you endup payingalmosttwice

    asmuchforsomethingthatsnottothepreferredor optimumspecification.

    Consequentlya bigpart ofJohnsroleisto workverycloselywithBP,understandingand advisingonvalvespecifications,keepingon topofmaintenanceschedules, planningwellaheadfor anyshutdowns,carryingajudiciou s stockof themostfrequentlyuseditems,anddoingafull qualityinspectiononeverysingleitem theyhandle.

    Havingacquiredmorethan 4,000valves,andtrackedthedetailsof eachothem,the teamhas excellentrelationshiwiththe manufacturersand suppliers,aarekeento sharetheirinsightswiththegreater Petrofacorganisation.Valvesawhatwe do.Itsourbreadandbutter.SoanyoneinPetrofacever hasany valve-relatedquestions,wecan usuallyhelp,saysJohn.

    3DprintingAlthoughvalveshave beenaroundforaslongastheoil andgasindustryitself,andstillcontinuetofulfilthesamebasicfunctions,theydo keepon evolving.Allof theleading manufacturerspridethemselvesontheir spiritof innovation.InfactPentair,oneofthelargestmanufacturers,claims tofile around60relatedpatentsevery year.

    Forexample,onehot topicin todaysvalveindustryis thepotentialfor 3Dprinting.Theoretically,thisoffers hugepromise. Highlycomplexdesignsbecom

    easierto manufacture.Short runsofone-offitemsbecome cost-effectivetoproduce.Goodscanalsobe madewhetheyare needed,insteadof wherelaboucostshappentobe low.And oneofthelargervalvemanufacturers,GE Oil& Gahasannouncedthatit isalreadyusing3printingtoproduce controlvalveparts wspecialconfigurations.

    Evenso,there isan understandableindustryreluctanceto adoptcompletelynewor novelmanufacturingtechniquesAsRoyArmishawputsit,Wedo likeinnovation,but wealwayswant ourinnovationsto beprovenand certified.Inour situation,tried-and-testedis goo

    Withsoverymanyvalvesbeingproduced,whichfulfilsucha criticalroleawide rangeof judicious,incrementalinnovationscontinuesto takehold.Throughitssupplier qualitymanagemeprogramme,Petrofachasstruck upa gorelationshipwith amanufacturercalledEmersonProcessManagement.

    RobertHechinger,thecompanysWorldwideQuality Director,providesausefulanalogy:Comparea 1964FordMustangwith abrand newFordMustan

    Theybothdo exactlythesamethinganfromthe outside,theylook quitesimilar.But,belowthesurfaceitis atotallydifferentcar itis morereliable,morecomfortable,more economical,andmucmuchsafer.

    Itmaysoundstrangeto sayso,butvalvesareevolving inmuch thesame w

    Theeffluentwaterand centralseawaterinjectionfacilityinKuwait,a projectforthe KuwaitOilCompany(KOC).

    Numberof valves acquiredforBP NorthSeaoperations:

    4,000Temperature at whichavalve may have to operate:

    600CPressure(bars) whicha valvemayhaveto withstand:

    00

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    14/27

    |PetrofactsMarch2015

    89

    TurkmenistanandKazakhstan2.5%oftotalworldproductionofgas

    Tu sia

    asdru al prb alterm o jectEED/EPC

    yria

    sblagctlantpro

    EPC

    Syria

    Jihardevelopmentroject

    E

    tedKingdomtotalworldoductionofgas

    37

    86

    ria

    aneNorthopmentProject

    ria

    rk centralessingfacility

    Algeria

    Alrargasfielddevelopmentproject

    P

    Tunisia

    Ch ig asp lan ter uIES

    geriaAl

    Salahsouthernfieldsdevelopmentproject

    EPCalahGasIn

    mpressionprojectcCE

    Algeria

    OhanetgasdevelopmentEPC,JV

    audiArabiaS

    ranutilitiesdositesnC

    UnitedKingdom

    gasprocessingplantaggan-TormoreEPC

    TunisiaandAlgeria2.5%totalworldproductionofgas

    on cubicmetres

    Billioncubicmetres

    Billioncubicmetres

    ofachasdecadesof experiencein

    dinggas plantsgas processing

    gassweeteningforexample

    wingfroma strongbaseinthe

    dleEast.Thisgraphicshowsa

    ctionof thecompanysmajorgas

    ectsin keyoperatingregions,

    errecentlycompletedor

    entlybeingbuilt. Theseare

    wnin thecontextofthe totalgas

    ductionforeach region,according

    eBPStat istical Review.

    currentlyinproduction

    ETROFACROJECTS

    Petrofacts March2015

    ialay

    tlopmeBerantaifieldd vE

    66

    Malaysia2%oftotalworldproductionofgas

    Kuwait

    40''gas pipelineEPC

    UAE

    shanssionandBabHaBabComprojectsdevelopmentp r

    EPC

    UAE

    pmentprojectntegratedgas dev lNGL4,Ruwais,iiEPC

    Qatar

    sweeteningfacilitiesasCEP

    388

    SaudiArabia, Kuwait,UAE,OmanandQatar11%oftotalworldproductionofgas

    Oman

    Harweelclusterdevelopmentproject

    EPC

    Oman

    Yibal hu oEPCM

    an

    aut erg s plantanddepletioncompressionEPC

    Oman

    KhazzancentralprocessingfacilityEPC

    Kazakhsta

    Kashaganfie ddevelopment(gas oil)EPCM

    anTurkmeni

    sfieldprojealkynyshgFEED/EPC

    Billioncubicmetres

    BillioncubicmetresRababHarweelIntegratdProject(gas&oil)

    EP

    Kazakhstan

    arachaganak:fourth stabilisationsweeteningtrainEED/EPCM

    BIGMARKETSBIGPROJECTSForecastingagencieshavebeenpredictinga glob

    ageof gasformany years.Technology, market

    forcesandpolicyareall atplay.Developmentssuch

    asthe NorthAmericanshalegas revolution,LNG

    regionaltradedealsandtheroleofgasasa

    transitionfuel todecarbonisationhaveall playeda

    majorrolein positioninggas asthe fuelof thefuture

    Accordingto the BP Statistical Review,natural

    gasisexpectedtocatchupwithoilandcoaland

    emergeasthe mainhydrocarboncomponentofa

    moresustainableenergymix overthe next20 year

    Itis thefastest-growingfossilfuel, mainlyusedfor

    powergeneration,but alsoin homes,offices,shops

    andothercommerciallocationsforheatingandcooling, andas araw materialin theproductionof

    fertilizerand otherchemicals.

    Despitepressureson theindustrytoday

    withgas pricesdownandcapitalinvestmentunder

    pressure longer-termtrendsstill pointtothe

    increasingsignificanceofnaturalgas inthe energy

    mix.Over thepastdecade, theworldhas consume

    around30trillioncubic metresofgas but reserve

    todayare30 trillioncubicmetresmorethan they

    werein2004.

    GAS

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    15/27

    |Petrofacts October2015

    sall aboutdeliveringthe serviceourstomerswant.We listen,we diversify,weliverand,most importantly,we care.Itsearthat SalimKhoury,SeniorManagerperationsfor oneof Petrofacson-siteterers,Abela& Co,isbrimmingwithdefor thecompanythathesbeenwithr25years.nPetrofacs TowerOne cafeteria, helsits story.Abela&Co beganitsjourneyhe UnitedArab Emiratesin 1967,beforeecountrywasformedin itscurrentguise.eywereknown asthe Trucial Statesckthen,hesays.SadlyMr Abelaisnongerwithus,but theethosof hisfamilysinessstillexists today.Salimtalksaboutarecentstaffsurveyhere89% ofthosesurveyedsaidtheyjoyedworkingforthe business.

    OurCEOknowsthenamesof everyoneworkingherewhichis morethan3,000people andheis alsointerestedinhowwe arealldoing.Thatsgreatleadershipinmy book.Everyperson isempoweredto makedecisionsthat impactoursuccess,whichbreedsa senseofbelonging,he adds.Forsure weenjoyourtriumphsbutwe alsoreflect,andreact,whenthingsdontgothewaywewantthem to.Salims energyandpace arewell-known

    evenmoresothanusual today.Its acrazyday,he explains.Weve justwonbackacontract,soI haveto gotoJebelAlitodealwiththesetup. Dependingon themoon,it couldbethelastdayofRamadansotrafficwillbe crazierthanever,andImtryingto geteverythingin orderbeforemy

    summerholiday.Hiswife andthreechildrenarealreadyin Lebanon escapingtheblisteringUAE heat,and itsclear heslookingforwardto joiningthem.Beforeleaving,Salimiskeentopointout

    howthewholeAbela&Co teamplaytheirpartin keepingPetrofacsworkforcefedandwatered.I onlyvisitoncea week,sosuccessisreallydownto theguysontheground.Since wewere awardedthecontractin 2008,we havemadegoodprogress:allourfoodis preparedin oneofourtwocentralkitchensinDubaiandtransportedtoourcustomersquitealogisticsoperation.Lookingathis watch,Salimrattlesoff

    somemore statistics:at Petrofac,8,000mealsa monthareserved, thats96,000mealsa year;in theUAE,Abela&Co

    SHARJAHKEEPSGOODCOMPANIESetrofacemploysmore than6,000peoplein theUAE;000of thosein Sharjah alone.But itdoesnt stop there.

    any companies acrossthe UAE are involvedin keeping

    ewheelsturning locally-owned,locally-managedr internationalcompaniesbasedin the region.

    ayeKrause-Whiteingmeets thepeopleinside thesupply

    hainecosystem.Photographsby LeeHoagland

    OODFORHOUGHT

    orsurewe enjoyouriumphsbut wealsoreflect,ndreact,whenthings dontothewaywewantthemto.

    alimKhoury, Abela &Co

    Petrofacts October2015

    PRINTSAMONGMENAsfor themost interestingjob, its probablythebusinesscards. Lastyearweprinted around140,000.

    Thats a lotof networking.EliasKhoriaty,PioneerPrintingPress

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    16/27

    |Petrofacts October2015

    rvesmorethan 120,000meals adayhichtranslatesto over43 millionmealsear.As Napoleonwouldputit, anarmy

    archingonits stomach.When pressedoutthemostpopulardishtheyserve,limlaughs.Without adoubt, itschickenyani,requestedbyevery nationality!

    an highlyrecommendit,hesays.Withjust0.002%ofAbela& Cossinesscomingfrom Petrofac,Salimpressesthateverycustomer isportant tothem, regardlessof size.Andthan exuberantwave, hedisappearsoutthefrontdoorsintothefiercesunshinedon tohis nextappointment.

    oomserviceeratiobetween expatriatesand localsheUAE isoneof thehighestinthe worldt around80/20 andnotallnewcomers

    anagetosort outtheir accommodationforetheyarrive. Petrofacsemployees

    eno exception,so havingarrangementsthhotelsiscriticaltosmoothrunningforwarrivals.Oneofthosehotelsis theGoldenTulip

    otel overlookingthe KhalidLagoonandMajaz Waterfront justa stonesthrow

    mPetrofacsoffice. Asan apart-hotel,eare anideal property,says Alexherfan,OperationsManager there.

    Wehave264 unitsfromstudiostosuites,short- andlong-stays,singleresidents

    family groups. Atypical Petrofacstay isounda month.Alextakesthe Petrofacaccount veryriously. Didyou know12,000bed

    ghtswereused bynew employeesin14alone?Andinthefirstsixmonthsofsyear,we arerunningclose to7,000.atamountsto revenuerunningintolionsof Dirhams.So yes,Petrofacisimportantclient. Thehospitality

    industrycan beprettycut-throat,and weworkhard inorder tostay competitive.

    Keepingnewarrivalshappy cantalwaysbeeasy?Surehesmiles,itgoeswiththeterritory. Thebiggestchallenge isensuringthatwegiveourguestswhattheywant,andwithintheconfinesofwhatworkscommerciallyfor usas abusiness.

    ManyPetrofacguestsstay forweeks atatime,andtheirstayisthebackdropfortheirfirst impressionsabout theUAE.Weoffera guidinghandinthatinitialperiod,saysAlex.Ourteam takethatresponsibilityvery seriously.Its oftenthesimplethingsthat makethebigdierences,likeimprovinginternetaccess andthenumberof TVchannels available.We havearelationshipbuilt onrespect andtrust.Thatsimportantto me,truly,andis theethosof theentire GoldenTulipbrand.

    Hiseyeslightup whenaskedaboutanyfunnystoriesfrom hiswork inhospitality.Icould probably writea book,helaughs,butheis thenquickto pointout thatconfidentialityis themostprizedpossessioninhistrade,andrefusestonamenames.Wedidhaveoneindividualwho thoughttheirbedroomwas haunted,hesays.

    Naturally,theywere movedintoanotherroomand welooked intothe claims...

    MorningrushSittinginlandfromthehustleofDubaiisMeydan,wellknown forits horseracingandhometotherichestracedayin theworld andalsowhereDHLhas locateditsbrand newfacility.

    Wehad outgrownour previousspaceinDubaiAirportsTerminal2, saysRyanHunter,Vice President ofCommercial,anda realbonusforour driversaretheindoor,air-conditionedloadingbayshere.Withthe UAEssummertemperatures

    reachingthemid-high forties,thisis nottobe underestimated.

    Walkingaroundtheir coolloadingbaymid-morning,the parcelconveyorbelt issilentas theearlymorningrushhasalreadypassed.Notfor longthoughlaughsFadiAbu Touq,NationalCustomerManagerEngineering& Manufacturing.Comefouroclock,itwillbe ahiveofactivityagainas allthevanscomeinfortheevening deliveries.

    Sowhatisa typicalparcel?Well, it snotwhatyou probablythink,saysRyan. Themostcommontype ofshipmentPetrofacsendsthroughDHLiselectricalandengineeringequipmentdestinedforprojectsites.Documents,whilealargepartoftheload,are secondary.From thishub, weshiptoaround 25 corecountriesfor Petrofac.

    Butitcantgo smoothlyallof thetime,andthe morechallengingaspectsofPetrofacsbusiness,Ryan andFadiagree,arethe criticalityandtime sensitivityofallits shipments.

    Withthe companycelebrating25 yearsofbusinesswithPetrofacintheMiddleEastthisyear,bothmen areproudof thelongrelationshipthathas beenestablished

    withthebusiness,andRyaniskeentoadd:Nocustomeristoolargeortoosmallforus andthat verymuch includesPetrofac.

    PressonAreturndrivefromMeydantoSharjahfindsanothercompany meetingPetrofacsneeds.Thistimeitsintheheartof theindustrialarea,ajourneynotforthefaint-hearted.Tankersqueuing toaccessSharjahMunicipalityssewageworksclogupalmosteveryinchof thejam-packedroad.Hundredsof businessesarehere,includingPioneerPrintingPress.

    Pioneerspremisesarein contrast to

    GUARDOFHONOUReingincludedis amajoronsiderationfor ourguys,articularlythosewehaveaced inclientlocations.avidStockton,G4S

    Petrofacts October2015

    IN-FLIGHTSERVICEWehavebeenhandlingthecompanystravelformorethan tenyears;andthenumbersspeakfor themselvesKhalidAlSerkal,EmiratesAirline

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    17/27

    |Petrofacts October2015

    HLs stateof theart facility. Herethesidualaromaof solvents,andtheashesof ink,give someindicationofe30yearsofhistoryin thebuilding.Operatingin theEmiratesince 1982,oneeris a family-runbusiness whichwasughtby GeneralManagerElias Khoriatydhiscousinin1997.Westartedwithewarehouseand todaywe havefive,assays,smiling.Hesnota manforstandingstill ,andis atmeon theshop-floorsurroundedby hisanyprintingpresses.He pausesfrommetotimetopassonadvice,examineantjob oraskhowoneof hisemployeesoing.Ithink themost challengingjobwevenefor Petrofacwas theproductionofmepipinginspection handbooks,heys.Wehadtouse adurablepaperhichwouldntdeterioratewhenused inefield.Thatcausedusa fewproblems.Asforthe mostinterestingjob,itsobablythe businesscardswe producecross allpositions inthe company.Itsscinating.Last yearwe printedaround0,000business cards.Thatsa lotoftworking,he laughs.

    eypersonnelckontothehighwayto Dubaiand intoaazeofroadsto theAl Quozindustrialarea.isisthemainUAEcentreforsecuritympanyG4S,fromwherethe localCEOvidStocktonoversees12,000people.Petrofachas 200G4S contractorsorkinginitsoffices.Wefieldteamsofallesto ourcustomers,explainsDavid.

    Whatwe prideourselvesonfirstandemostis addingsignificantvalue toerydaylife whereverweare working.With42accommodationsitesin arietyofUAE locations,andalmost 100%

    ofthe workforcebeing expatriateandsingle-status,howdo theymanagethis?ItsatopicthatstrikesachordwithDavid.Iam passionateaboutthe welfareofour

    people:we have39 nationalitiesfrom allsortsof backgroundsliving inmore than40accommodationsites,he explains.Howeveryoneintegratescanthrow upchallengesof course,butwe allworkhardatit.Allnew joinersparticipateinacomprehensiveinduction programme.Andof course,thereis specialisedtrainingdependingonthe natureof thecompanytheyaregoingto beworkingfor.Beingincluded isa majorconsideration

    forourguys,particularlythosewehaveplacedin clientlocations;the mannedsecurityand facilitiespersonnelwe haveworkingforPetrofacgenuinelyfeel partoftheculture. Sinceour relationshipbegan in2004,theresbeenvery littlechurn ofpeoplewe haveplaced.And thatspeaksvolumesabouttheworkplaceenvironment.

    International carrierAfew dayslaterits theenormouscorporateheadquartersof EmiratesAirlineswhich loomslarge.The worlds

    biggestinternationalcarrier,it isalso theairlinewhich fliesthousandsof Petrofacsemployees aroundthe worldfor bothbusinessand pleasure.Itis animpressivefacility:twohuge

    buildings,its ownmetrostation,and alargeatriumbathedin sunshineandfullofshops,restaurantsand otherconveniences.Andat10 oclockin themorning,theplaceis absolutelybuzzing.Butthen, asKhalid AlSerkal,District

    Managerfor Sharjahandthe NorthernEmiratessays,Theairportis 24/7,so ourHQnever sleepseither.Itsour maincentreinthe UAEsomost

    ofour 84,000employees areeitherbasedhere orpassingthrough. Itsa greatfacility,dont youthink?Heis quickto praiseEmiratesasa

    greatemployerandbrand. Butnot foronemomentdoanyof uslosesightoftheimportanceof ourcustomers,hesays,seriously.Sohow doesPetrofac fitinto Khalids

    clientportfolio?It isrewardingtoserve allourloyalclients,and Petrofacis oneofthem,he says.Wehavebeen handlingthecompanystravelfor morethanten years;ourbusinessrelationshipisexcellentandthenumbersspeak forthemselves.During2014,almost 10,000Emirates

    ticketswereissued andused byPetrofacsSharjahoffice withmostfrequentvisitstoChennai,London andShanghai.Khalidis amanwhohas allthefactsat

    hisfingertips.Ive beenwith Emiratesfor15years,andhadthe opportunitytoliveandworkina numberofcountries,hesays.Such experiencesare enriching;dealingwith different environmentsandcultures.It keepsyour mindopen.AndwithEmirates,there isalways

    somethingnewto learn.I liketothinkthat

    helpsme addvalueto theclientsthatIworkwith.Onthatnote,our timewasupandwitha

    heartyhandshakeanda promiseof coffeesoon,Khaliddisappearedinto thethrongoftheatrium.Aftermakingthe shortjourneyfrom

    Dubaiback toPetrofacs SharjahHQ,itspleasingtosee theG4S guysstewardingvehiclesatthefrontofthebuildings,threeofwhicharefromDHL,PioneerandTheGoldenTulip.The onlything missingfromtheframeisanEmiratesplaneflyingoverhead,but youwouldnthave towaitlongtoseeoneof those

    HOME AWAYROMHOMEfcoursePetrofacan importantclient.hehospitality industryanbe prettycut-throatoweworkhardtoay competitive.lexCherfan,olden TulipHotel

    Petrofacts October2015

    COOLDELIVERY

    Themostcommontype ofshipmentis electricalandengineeringequipmentdestinedfor project sites.RyanHunter,DHL

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    18/27

    |Petrofacts February2014

    BIGPICTURESANTUARIONORTHEAST

    Petrofacts February2014

    Followingmorethantwoyearsof hard work,thePetrofacMexicoteamachieveda milestoneinJuly,indeliveringfirst oilfrom theSantuarioNorthEast fieldinTabasco,southern Mexico.Thedevelopmentwasfirstidentifiedbythetechnicalteaminearly 2013and

    drillingcommencedlaterthatyear.ThefirstwelldrilledSantuario401 wastestedandfoundto be100%oilbearingwithcombinedflowratesofmore than2,500barrelsofoil perday.Threefurtherappraisalwellswere drilled andfoundtobe oilbearing,all ofwhich

    weresubs equentlycompletedas developmentwells. Testingdemonstratedthattheexistingin-fieldpipelineswould,aftersignificantrepair,becapableofsafelycarryingtheadditionalfluids.SantuarioNorthEast isineffectanewfielddiscovered

    ina matureproducingenvironmentandisourclientPEMEXslargestonshorediscoveryinthelastfiveyears.Theinitialfocusison safeproductiobuttheteam islookingathowfurthervaluecanbecreatedinfuture.PhotographbyMartin Varg

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    19/27

    |PetrofactsOctober2015

    OPPORTUNITYSHEADINGDOWNSTREAMargeteddiversificationmakes soundbusinesssense,

    ndin recentyears, Petrofachasmadestridesinto

    edownstreamsector, with successin refining.etrofacts looks athow thestrategyis playing out

    Petrofacts October2015

    Asever,the AnnualReportandAccountsisa signpost:in hisforeword,GroupCEOAymanAsfarisaid thatthe companywassuccessfullycontinuingits businessmodeldiversification.In particular,he reportedthatthe Engineering,Construction,

    Operationsand Maintenance(ECOM)businesshad movedfurtherdownstream,withsomenotablesuccessesintherefiningsector,andthe potential tomakeasimilar moveintopetrochemicals.Of course,this typeof diversification

    makessoundstrategicsense, particularlyina loweroil priceenvironmentwhen,often,refiningcan becomemoreprofitable.It alsohelps that,in severalofPetrofacscoreMiddle Easternmarkets, manyof thenationaloilcompanies areactivelyinvestingintheir refiningcapacity.Buthow doesa companylikePetrofac

    actuallymakethemoves?Itsalong,slowjourney, which we take step-by-step, saysChristopherMcDonald, ExecutiveVicePresident ofECOM, responsibleforbusinessdevelopment.Thestrategyissimple.Wepartner withcompanieswhohavecomplementaryexperience.And,bitbybit,we buildour owncredentials.Inthe MiddleEast,for example,Petrofac

    knowsthe clients,it knowsthe contractors,anditknowshowtodeliverlarge,demandingprojectsin aswelteringdesertclimate.So,it makessensefor Petrofactotie-upwith othercompanieswho have

    deepexperienceof deliveringrefineryprojects,but norecordof workingintheMiddleEast. Thatway,the differententitiescanpursueaprojectthatneitherwouldbeconsideredforon theirindividualmerits.Andthewholebecomesfargreaterthanthesumof theindividualparts.Thisapproachbeganseveral yearsago.

    Thereweresome disappointmentsalongthewaybutin 2015,itgainedrealtraction.Withincrementalprogress,successfirst

    camein December2012, whenPetrofacwasawardedtwo engineering,procurementand construction(EPC)packages, valuedat $1.4billion, forSaudi

    AramcosJazan Refineryand Terminalproject.Bestdescribed asa tankfarm,thisassignmentplayedto Petrofacsexistingexperience,so therewas noneetoenlist aco-venturepartner.But itgavePetrofacan all-importantfoot-in-the-do

    intothe refiningsector.And,with astronemphasisonemploying anddevelopingSaudinationals,it reaffirmedthecompanys commitment tolocal deliver

    Big breakthroughNext, in November2013,camethe bigbreakthrough:a $2.1billionrefineryimprovementprojectfor OmanOilRefineriesandPetroleumIndustriesCompany(ORPIC),awardedon a50/50joint-venture basis to Petrofac andKorea-basedDaelim IndustrialCoLtd.Oneofthe largestoiland gasengineeri

    procurementand constructiondealsevawardedin Oman,this contractincludeanupgradeofan existingfacility,plusthadditionofnewrefiningunits,whichwillthetotalcapacityof theSoharRefinerymorethan 70%.Theprojectismovingonapace.By A

    2015,the teamwas celebratingmore thfivemillionmanhourswithouta singlelotimeincident (LTI).During thesummermonths,theconstructionphase hadcommenced.Andeverythingis ontracktomeet thebruising 36-monthscheduleAnothermajorlandmarkcame in

    February2014.Leadinga three-wayjoint-venture involving Korea-basedSamsungEngineeringCo Ltdand CB&NederlandBV,Petrofacreceivedawardnotification forKuwaitNational PetroleuCompanys(KNPC) CleanFuels ProjecMinaAbdulla (MAB1)refinery.Locatedinsouthern Kuwait,the

    totalvalueofthe contractis$3.7billion.Thescopeofthelumpsumengineeringprocurementand constructioncontracincludestheprovisionof 19newrefiningunitsat MinaAbdulla(some50kmfromKuwaitCity),the upgradeof fiveexistingunitsat Shuaiba(10kmfurthersouth),an

    Belowandleft,construction workcontinuesapaceontheSoharRefineryimprovementprojectinOman

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    20/27

    |PetrofactsOctober2015

    companyinginter-refinerytransferlines.Itisa largelygreenfieldandpartlyownfieldproject, saysprojectdirectorupDasgupta.Anditis afirstforKNPC,ew refineryprojectto internationalandards,which willbring abig increaseto

    eexistingcapacity yetbe morevironmentallyfriendly.

    efiningcredentials

    August2014,justsixmonthsaftertheNPCwin, Petrofacwas ableto celebratetanotherrefining success:a sizablegineering,procurement,constructiondcommissioningcontractfor arefineryckageinthenewRefineryandtrochemicalsIntegratedDevelopmentAPID)projectin Johor,Malaysia.Awardedby PRPCRefinery andCrackernBhd,asubsidiaryofPETRONAS,thismpetitivelytenderedcontract isvaluedmorethan$500million.Itincludesthreephurrecoveryunits, twoaminegenerationunits,two sourwater strippingits,a liquidsulphurstorageunit,andaphursolidificationpackageunit. And,asellas addingto Petrofacsrefiningedentials,it isalso thecompanysfirstajoronshoreprojectin Malaysia.So,movingon fromthese initialccesses,how aboutfuture prospects?espiteuncertaintyover thefutureofitabilityof refining,andover-capacityrossthe globalmarket,manyoperators

    econtinuingto invest,particularlyin theddleEast.Asa recentMcKinseyreporttsit:MajorcrudeexportersintheMiddlestcontinueto addto refiningcapacity,otivatedby anumber offactors.First,suringsecurityof domesticsupplymainsa toppoliticalprioritySecond,ddleEast playersaremotivatedbyaintainingtheir competitivenessin theobalcrude markets.Consequently,Petrofacis seeingaalthypipelineof futureopportunities.d,dependingon theproject, thempanyisgettingto thestagewhereitnpursue opportunitiesand achieve

    pre-qualificationin itsown right.AcrosstheMiddleEast,thereisalsoa

    tendencyfor newrefineryprojects tobecloselyintegratedintopetrochemicalprojects.And,by followingthesamestrategyas inrefining,Petrofacis keen

    todevelopits credentialsin thisrelatedfield.We arein petrochemicalsnowwherewe werein refiningafewyearsago,explainsChristopher.You couldsaywearea coupleof yearsintoa ten-yearjourney.

    Eventhoughthereis ahealthymarketoutthere,Petrofacneedstobeverydisciplinedinits biddingbehaviour.Wecant andwe wontgo aftereverything,hesays. Biddingis anexpensivebusiness.Asinglebidmaycostus US$12or13 million.Soweneedto gothrougha rigorousscreeningprocess.Realistically,c anwewin?Canwewin andmakemoney?And,if so,whatsour differentiator?But,whenitcomesdowntoit,whats

    actuallydifferentabouta refiningorapetrochemicalsproject?In fact,all ofthecomponentsare quitesimilar,saysPaoloBonucci,Vice Presidentandheadof onshorebusinessdevelopmentatECOM.Justlikeanyotheroilandgasfacility,a

    refineryor a petrochemicalsplant ismadeupof piping,machinery, pressurevesselsandvalves.The difference isthat,traditionally,Petrofac hasworkedon what

    I wouldcall horizontalprojects.They arespreadacrossa largearea.Youhave theluxuryof space.Sodesignsdontneedtobeparticularly complicated.Bycontrast,a refineryaswellas a

    petrochemicalproject isa verticalproject.Everythingissqueezedinto asmaller area.Sothedesignsandthe pipeworkbecomethatmuch morecomplex.Thecoreskillsarethesame.But

    youneed somereferenceprojectstoshowthatyou canadaptthemto thedownstreammarket.We arenow atthatstagein refining,andwe areheadingintheexactsamedirection forpetrochemicals.

    EverythingisontrackonOmansSoharRefineryimprovementprojectto meetthebruising36-monthschedule

    Petrofacts October2015

    We areinpetrochemicalsnow wherewe

    were in refininga few years ago.

    You could saywe are a coupleofyearsintoaten-yearjourney

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    21/27

    |Petrofacts June2014 Petrofacts June2014

    Ifyouhavean itemwhichyoutaketoworkeveryday,whichsayssomethingaboutyouandyour work,let us know, [email protected]

    I ALWAYSCARRYMYTIFFINTIN

    SaiN Acharyais thepipingdeputy

    leadengineerbased inMumbai,

    wherelunchtime istaken seriously.Indianlunchboxes,calledtins or

    dhabbas,come inall shapesand

    sizes. Here,Sai tellsus abouthis

    owntin tinrituals.Photographby AtulLoke

    Theflavour ofhome-cookedfoodisunique.Mineispreparedbymy wife:Ipreferlessspicyfoodandsheknowsmytasteverywell.Everyday,I eatsteamedrice,roti, sauteedvegetable,dal(lentil soup),saladand yogurt.

    Cookinginvolvesskill,planning andtherightingredients,andshe managesitall.Onspecialoccasionsorfestivals,I gettoenjoyspecialistsweetdishes too.

    Mytinitselfis aMiltonlunchboxwithitsowncarrystrap;Miltonis averypopularlunchboxmanufacturingcompany.

    Tiffintinsaredeliveredjustin timeforlunch;everyday,a mancalledVikaspicksupthefreshlycookedfoodfrommyhomeanddeliversitto myoffice,supportedbyafully-fledgedlogistics team.In fact,all overMumbai,dhabbawallahs whoareknowntobepunctualanddisciplined useacomplexsystemto getthousandsof these

    lunchboxesto theirdestinationseveryday. Myown lunchboxtravelsto theofficeeachdaybylocaltrain!

    Theeffort ismuch appreciated.Itgives immensesatisfactionandpleasuretohave delicioushome-cookedfoodwhich provides abreakfromwork. Itis alsohealthy,hygienicandnutritious.

    Youknow,thereis asayingthatfoodconnectswiththesoul.I believethataftermanylong hectichours ofworkingeatinga balancedmealnot onlynourishesyourbodyandmind,italsoenhancesyourwork productivity.

    Ido haveonehealthtip:oneshouldnttalkwhilehavingfood.So Ieatmylunchatmyworkstationin silence,accompaniedby thebackgroundchatterofthe latestgossipfromothersin theoffice.

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    22/27

    |Petrofacts October2015

    Accordingto Plato,Youcannot

    conceivethe manywithoutthe

    one.Inthecaseof Petrofacsengineeringcentrein Chennai

    today, thatone isK RSR Krishna.

    Eightyears ago,Krishna

    movedbacktohis studenttownofChennai havingworkedall

    overthe worldfor engineering

    companies,includingPetrofac.

    Hewastaskedwithsettinguptheoperation,and todayit isthe

    singlelargestengineering office

    inSouthern India.

    Theoriginalideatoopenengineeringcentresin India

    camein 2003,explainsKrishna.

    ThefirstofficeinMumbaiwas

    alreadyatcapacity,sohe waschargedwithfindinga second

    siteand Chennaiwaschosen

    inconsultationwiththeteamin

    Sharjah.Imactually fromthe

    neighbouringprovince ofAndhraPradesh,but Istudied

    hereformydegreein

    instrumentationengineering.

    AndI amnowdefinitelyoneofthe longestservinggeneral

    managers,saysKrishna.

    Althoughnotthe oldest

    Theoriginalplanwasfor100people,butKrishnasaysthat

    KRSR KRISHNA

    etrofacsengineeringcentres in Indiaaree powerhouses of its project delivery.

    etrofacts talks totwo ofthe companys

    eneralManagers KR SR Krishna inhennai andPawanKumarin Delhi

    ocompare notesfromopposite endsfthe country. Photographsby RaySmith

    WHENSOUTHMEETSNORTH

    OUBLEVISION thingsstartedto goreally well.Wegotmoreandmorework,

    wemobilisedmoreandmore

    people,andsoon wewere

    deliveringprojectseverywhere.

    Today,there are2,100people,including700working on

    project-contracts.These

    includeprojectand engineering

    managers,engineers,designers,and3D modellers.

    Petrofacs successstory in

    Chennaiisall downtothestaff

    members,whose tremendouscontributionsmake thissuch

    adependable office,

    demonstratingthe cultureand

    valuesof Petrofac,saysKrishna.Buthe canalsorecalla

    timewhenitwasjusthimanda

    fewothers.Whenyourea small

    team,it isveryimportanttoestablishthe rightkindof

    culture,heexplains. Now,we

    areahugeteam,andit isequally

    asimportant.Krishnadescribesa truly

    multi-cultural,multi-lingual,

    multi-religiousoperation.There

    arefour differentlanguagesin

    SouthernIndiaalone;andallthemajorfaithsare represented

    here,he says.Wetryto liveand

    celebrate togetherin an

    inclusiveway.EvencompetitorsinChennairemarkupontheir

    PetrofactsOctober2015

    PAWANKUMARteamspirit, headds proudly.

    Krishnaisequallyproudof the

    rangeof workthatChennai

    doesfor Petrofacand itsclients,

    supportingallfour divisionsof

    ECOMfrom concepttocommissioning.Right now,

    wehavemorethan10projects

    inprogress,hesays.These

    includework inAlgeria, SaudiArabia,Iraq,Oman, theNorth

    Seaand AbuDhabi. Employees

    alsosupport Petrofacsofficesin

    Sharjah,Wokingand Aberdeen.Internationalassignmentsare

    commonin India,and Krishnais

    noexception.He hasworkedin

    Qatar,Kuwait, Malaysia,Oman,theUnited ArabEmirates,and

    evenSiberia.I mhappytomove

    wherethe companywantsme

    togo,heexplains.Infact,oneyear,it wasntjusta questionof

    movingmilesit wasmoving

    fromone extremetoanother.

    Iwentfromminus53degreesinSiberia,to around50degrees

    inSharjah adifferentialof more

    than100,he laughs.Itmight

    notsoundit,butitwas a

    fantasticlife experience.Krishnaisnow looking

    forwardtosharing hisexperiences

    withhis newcolleague, Pawan,

    whomhehasmetat industryeventsinthe past.

    ForPawanKumar,his new

    appointmentas General

    Managerof PetrofacsDelhi

    officerepresentsboth anew

    beginningand a homecoming.Bornandbredinthenorthern

    capitalof NewDelhi, Pawan

    didntremainin hishometown

    forlong.Fromearlyon,I wanted

    tobecome anentrepreneurand

    technocrat,he says,first getting

    adegreeinmechanicalengineeringandlateranMBA.

    Althoughnew toPetrofac,

    Pawanis aveteranofthe

    sector, withalmost 34yearsexperience.He beganhis career

    withEngineersIndia,whichhe

    referstoas themotherorganisationfortheoilandgasindustryin India,stayingthere

    fornearly23 years.He wenton

    toholda seriesof positionsat

    MottMacDonald,FosterWheeler,Dodsaland Essar,

    beforebeingapproachedby

    Petrofactoheadup theDelhi

    EngineeringCentre(DEC).Thecomplexityof theprojects

    thatPetrofactakeson really

    appealedtome,he adds.

    TheDEChasworkedonlargecontractssuch asADCOsgas

    compressionprojectand

    KNPCsClean FuelRefinery

    projectin Kuwait.The latterwas

    aturningpointforthe office.KNPChas broughta revolution

    inthe developmentofparticular

    downstreamprocesses and

    plantdesign, hesays.Weincreasedour numbers;

    wedeveloped oursystems;

    andweprovedthatwe can

    deliverbetterprocesses.Pawanis keentoseethe DEC

    adaptas itgrows. Managing

    anddeliveringcomplex

    processingplantsrequiresthesimplificationand organisation

    ofourprocesses,andIm

    lookingforwardto the

    developmentofcapabilitiesand

    capacities.Today,there are

    600engineers anddesigners,buttheaimis toenhancemanpowerto800bytheend

    ofnext year.

    TheDelhiofficeitselfisin the

    cityof Gurgaon,30km

    south-westofthe capital.Gurgaonis thehappening city

    oftomorrow Indias own

    SiliconValley,says Pawan.

    Heis alsoimpressedbytheatmosphere inthe office.Every

    organisationhas itsown colour,

    buthere itsverylively.People

    arehappy;theyhaveagreat

    dealofownershipfortheir

    projects.It feelslikea proper

    community.

    LikeChennai, theDelhi offi

    hasan impressive programmofsocial events,fromfestival

    picnics.ButPawanis most

    lookingforwardto celebrating

    thefourth anniversaryof theofficeitself,at theendof

    October. Weare invitingour

    familiesin,heexplains.Itwil

    bea wonderfulevent.PawanKumarshares his

    namewithafilmdirector,a

    footballer, andeven a

    professionalwrestler but waskedwhathe doesinhis ow

    sparetime,he laughs.Ihardl

    haveany sparetimetheseda

    ButI lovenature,beingwithm

    family, andmost ofall travellinhe explains,detailingtripstha

    haveincludedMalaysia,

    SingaporeandMadagascar.Aftermorethanadecadeo

    travellingthe worldfor pleasu

    aswellas work,Pawanislookingforwardto returningto

    hishometownafterall these

    years.It is veryexcitingto be

    partofthis,hesays.Iam surPetrofacsvisionfor Indiawill

    helpthe organisationreach n

    heights.I thinkwe haveavery

    brightfutureahead.

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    23/27

    |PetrofactsOctober2015

    People

    Petrofachas its fairshare of globetrotters,andsomehaveworkedin allcornersof theworld.

    JennieSaywell hearsthe travellerstales of

    oneof them,MarkGillett.PhotographbyMarkLehn

    In2001, SeniorConsultantMarkGillett movedfromhisSouthAfrican homelandto

    England.There,threeyearslater,PetrofacsPlantAssetManagementoffered hima job.Andsobegana careerthatwouldsee Markliveandworkacrossall fourregionswherethecompanyoperates.Hisfirstrole forthe

    newly-formedPAMCBMnetteam involvedsettingupconditioningmonitoringprogrammesfor clients.Althoughbasedin England,theinternationalscope ofMarksjob meant that he was posted

    FOURCORNERS

    OFTHEEARTH

    MarkGillettonthe shorelineofhiscurrenthome townofPerth, Australia

    PetrofactsOctober2015

    Ivebeenveryblessedto havebeentoplacesthatmost peoplewill nevergo to,andto seesomeunrealsights

    tosome exotic destinations.Iworked onvarious projectsfromtheNorthSeaall theway

    downto PapuaNewGuinea,hesays.IwassenttoKuwait,notlongafterthewar,withblackenedground andbombed-outbuildings. I wasalsosent toLibya.Marks lastassignment wasin Basra,Iraq.Youstartoffwiththeshockofbeingpickedupatthe airportinanarmouredvehicle, andbeinghandeda bullet-proofvest.Itwas quitean experience!In2007,Markmovedtothe

    PAMMaintenanceIntegritygroup,workingon

    maintenancestrategiesforclients.His firstassignmentwasinAlaska,andwhilehe

    wasmostlybased inAnchorage,the actualprojectwas250milesinsidetheArcticCircle,ina placecalledDeadhorseinPrudhoe Bay.Whatan incredibleplace

    thatwas,Mark recalls.Inwinter,its completelyfrozen.Insummer,the tundraisalllakesand grasslands,teemingwithwildlife.Ive neverbeenonefor photography,butI wassoinspired,Iactuallyboughtacamerathereand then.Thecountrysidewas just

    astonishing,andit wasfullofincredible down-to-earthpeople mostlysporthuntersandfishermen.I thoroughlyenjoyedmyselfthere.Aftertwo yearsMarkleft

    Alaska,with amazingstoriestotell,includingcoming within100metresof amotherpolarbearandhertwocubs.Heremembers:Wewereina

    vehicle,andwheneverabearissighted,thewildlife securitypeoplecordonit off. If thebearisnthungry,itl l justgo tosleepbut ifitshungry,itsakillingmachine.Wehad rangerstellingus,Dontyou daregoanycloser!Markdecidedtorelocateto

    theMiddleEastin 2011,whilethecompanywassettingupanAbuDhabioffice,andfoundhimselftradingone extremetemperaturefor another.WhenI leftAlaska,itwas-50C awhite-out,hesays.WhenI landedin AbuDhabi,itwas50C:a100Cswing!Abu Dhabiwas aninteresting

    moveforMark,whosawit asareal meltingpotof cultures.However,his timethere wasshort-lived:no soonerhad hesettleddownthan theteamwonaprojecton theRumailaoilfieldinIraq.MarkwasmadeProjectManager,and workedthereon a rotationalbasis,

    splittinghistime betweenBasraandhome.Bythe timetheproject wascompleted,Markwas runningthe rotatingequipmentdepartment.Fouryearsafter arrivingin

    AbuDhabi,the startof 2015speltthestartof yetanothernewjourneyfor Mark.ThisJanuary,he acceptedhiscurrentjob inPerth, workingontheINPEX project.Theyrecallingita megaproject,hesays.It involvescombiningthreeverylarge facilitiesinto

    one giantproject.Its absolumassiveforus.INPEXmightbea projecto

    mammothproportions,butMarkfindshis newhomeofPerthto havemoreof apersonalatmosphere.Perthfeelsmorelikea bigtowntothanacityof twomillion,hesays.Itsreally welcomingalaid-backhere;theresamassiveexpatcommunity.Youarewhatyouare,andeveryoneishappy withthat.MarkswifeJanice and

    daughterAlexandra havemovedwith himto AustraliaTheyneverlived anywhereotherthan SouthAfrica befotheyrefindingthisallawfuexciting.Im thoroughlyenjoyingAustralia, hesays,admittingthathe feelsmoresettledwith hisfamily aroun

    him.Itsso nicebeingabletogohomeeverynighttomyfamily.Before, Iwas goingfrohotelto rentalto communalhouse,which isnot alwayseasy,he adds.Aftera decadeof livingin

    differentplacesacrosstheworld,Mark islooking forwatostayinginone place atleast,fora fewyears.Ivedoanenormous amountoftravellingin mylifetime,andliketodolesstravellingnow.veryhappytosaythatIvenogotona planeforfourmonthsnow!However,Mark hasone fin

    destinationin mindonce hisdaughterhascompletedherschooling.Ivebeen veryblessedtohavebeentoplacthatmostpeoplewillnevergto,andtoseesomeunrealsights.ButthenextplaceImmovingtois England,he saIwanttorelocatebacktoLymingtonin theNew Fores

    Ihavea lotoffamilyandfrienthere thatstheplaceIrealcallhome.

    Does Mark deserve the title

    of Petrofacs most prolific

    globetrotter? Do you knowsomeone who has li ved in mo

    places th an Mark? Are you

    thinking of relocating, and

    would like advice fromcolleagues with similar

    experience? Do let us know

    at petrofacts.editorial@

    petrofac.com

  • 7/25/2019 Petro-facts October 2015

    24/27

    People

    |Petrofacts October2015

    nceagain,the competitionineSpringissueof Petrofactsracteddozensof entries.Thecompetitionset youthisgicalchallenge.Youand alleagueneedto exchangeauableitem.However,youvefoundinthe pastthatythingyousendto eachherinsecurelygets stoleninansit.So youagreeto puttheminsidea box,whichcanbeckedwith severalpadlocks.Youeachhavea numberofdlockswiththeir

    correspondingkeys.Unfortunately,neitherofyouhavekeystoanyof theotherspadlocks.Howcanyousendtheitem

    securelyintheboxto yourcolleague,sothattheycanopenit? Rememberthatanythingyousendin anunlockedbox(like akey,oranunlockedpadlock) willgetstolen.Thefirstfiveluckywinners

    whoworkedit out,andeachwonan iPodshuffle,were:

    KashyapMishra fromDelhi;AlecJones fromWoking;VinodMartulefromMumbai;DaveWardfromSouthampton;andRanjith ChandrasekaranfromMumbai.Andthesolution?Youput

    yourvaluableitemin thebox,lockitandretainthekey.Youthensend thepadlockedboxtoyour colleague.Shecannotopenit but she

    putson her lock,retainingthekeytothat,andsendingthebox,now withtwo padlocks,

    backtoyou.Youthenunlock and removeyourown padlock.Theboxremainssecuredwith yourcolleaguespadlock,to whichshehasretainedthekey.Soyoucansafelysendit backtoheragain,andshewillbe abletounlockituponreceiptandremovethevaluable item.Congratulationsto allof our

    winnerswhocameupwiththesolutionand goodlucktoeveryone considering thisissuespuzzle!

    buildinghasa panelof threehtswitches,which arebelledOnandOff.Allofemare currentlyOff.Theomstowhichtheyarewiredealldistant.Onlyoneoftheeeswitchescontrolsthehtin thebasement,whichisongwayaway,andliketheherrooms,cannotbe seenmthe switches.

    Youwantto discoverwhicheofthethreeswitchesntrolsthelightin thesementbutyou onlywantmakeonejourneyinordertonfirmthe answer.Youarealoneinthe building;ucannot dismantlethe

    witchesor traceany wiring.tthereisa way,usingthe

    witches,andwithout visitingyotherrooms, whichwillableyouto gooncetothesementandknow whichonehe threeswitchescontrolslight.Whatdo youdo?

    ryourchancetowinonefiveAppleiPodShuffles,easeemailyour answerpetrofacts.competitionpetrofac.com.Closingdateentries is1 January, 2016.

    anyou solvethisissueslogicpuzzle andwin yourselfa prize?

    WHICHSWITCH?OGICPUZZLE

    JAYDANIELWRIGHT