petition: letter to the media re gmc and dr hadiza bawa-garba · letter to the media re gmc and dr...

Letter to the media re GMC and Dr Hadiza Bawa-GarbaPetition published by Dr David Nicholl on Nov 28, 2017

Background (Preamble):

There has been huge interest (in the BMJ and New Statesman) in the case of Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba who the GMC areseeking erasure from the medical register at the Royal Courts of Justice, The Strand on Thursday December 7th.

In February 2011, Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba a junior paediatric trainee was on duty at the Leicester Royal Infirmary when ayoung patient tragically died of sepsis. Hadiza was devastated at his death.

The Crown Prosecution Service at first told her there was no case, but Hadiza and a nurse were convicted of grossnegligence manslaughter in late 2015. This was despite the fact that there were multiple other failings including IT,nursing, junior and senior staff failings. There were also major systems failures in the hospital. The jury did not hearabout all of these as a legal loophole meant that many improvements made afterwards the prosecution argued could be"excluded ".

We are concerned about the GMCs actions for erasure and aim to get the attached letter published in a newspaperprior to December 7th.

Petition Text:

Sir, We are concerned that the General Medical Council (GMC) is risking a culture of candour in medicine and perpetuatingan injustice by seeking through the High Court the permanent erasure from the medical register of Dr HadizaBawa-Garba. Dr Bawa-Garba, a trainee paediatrician, was convicted in 2015 of negligent manslaughter after the tragic death of JackAdcock from sepsis in 2011. The Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service (MPTS) then had to decide if she was fit to continue to practice. It heard thather clinical practice was generally regarded as excellent, with no other concerns flagged against her, and that she hadopenly addressed the deficiencies which resulted in the child's death. It recommended she could apply to return toservice as a doctor after 12 months suspension which ends this month. The MPTS identified "multiple systemic failures"within the service. The evidence for these failures was not fully examined at the criminal trial and had they been, thiswould almost certainly have reduced her purported culpability.The GMC is now appealing, seeking to have her struck off. We know of no evidence that terminating Dr Bawa-Garba'smedical career will make any patient safer. On the contrary it promotes a climate of defensiveness. In 2001, the joint declaration by the Government and the medical profession recognised that 'honest failure should notbe responded to primarily by blame and retribution, but by learning and by a drive to reduce risk for future patients.' We urge the GMC to recognise that many within and outside medicine are already losing confidence in it and that thiscase could define its future.

PETITION: Letter to the media re GMC and Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba

Powered by GoPetition

http://www.gopetition.com/

Total signatures 786 (Signature comments can be viewed in the Appendix of this document)

# Title FirstName Surname Town/City Region Question 1 Question 2 Comment

786 N/C Mark Prescott Shrewsbury UK SY3 9HQ MB ChB (Dundee)

FRCS FCEM

View

785 N/C Benjamin Stenson Edinburgh UK Consultant

Neonatologist

MD View

784 N/C Andrew Carr Perth Australia GP MbBCh,

MRCGP,FRACGP

View

783 N/C Jonathan Treml Birmingham UK Consultant

Geriatrician and

Medical Examiner

FRCP N/G

782 N/C Elizabeth Draper Melton

Mowbray

UK LE14 2EL PhD N/G

781 N/C Dumisani Ncomanzi Kettering UK Consultant MBChB N/G

780 N/C Indrani Banerjee London UK Consultant

Paediatrician

FRCPCH N/G

779 N/C SWARUPSINH CHAVDA LUTLEY LANE

, HALESOWEN

UK B63 1EZ MBCh B,FRCR N/G

778 N/C Jasia Khan London UK E10 6hb Mbbs N/G

777 N/C Murtuza Khan High Wycombe UK Consultant

Paediatrician

MRCP, FRCPCH N/G

776 N/C Catriona Thompson Peterborough UK Consultant

Emergency Physician

FRCEM N/G

775 N/C Sultan Sabri Croydon UK Solicitor BA (Hons) MA LL.B.

PDLP

View

774 N/C John Dodge Usk UK Retired Professor of

Child Health

CBE, FRCP N/G

773 N/C Thomas Livingston Nottingham UK StR BMBS N/G

772 N/C Jatt Khaira Birmingham UK Stroke Consultant FRCP N/G

771 N/C Aabha Sharma TQ2 7AA UK Chemical Pathologist FRCPath View

770 N/C Laura Brown Manchester UK Clinical Scientist DPhil N/G

769 N/C John Firth Cambridge UK Consultant Physician FRCP N/G

768 N/C Basirat Afinowi Cambridge UK Project manager BSc N/G

767 N/C abid abdulkhaliq Ilford UK Dentist BDS (Hons) N/G

766 N/C Hazra Khansaheb ILFORD UK ig3 9lu FCCA N/G

765 N/C Ashiya Ali London UK Consultant

(paediatrics)

FRCPCH N/G

764 N/C Elliott Cheng London UK ST5 MRCPCH N/G

763 N/C Donal Duffin Banbridge UK BT32 3LT MB MRCP MRCGP N/G

762 N/C Peter Devlin Brighton UK GP FRCGP N/G

761 N/C Eric Watts BRENTWOOD UK CM15 8LH FRCP View

760 N/C Kemi Bako London UK Consultant

Community

Paediatrician

MRCPCH N/G

759 N/C Billy Wilson Wilmslow, UK CT1 Anaesthetics MBChB N/G

758 N/C Chithambaram Veerappan oldham UK ol3 7hr MBBS, EDIC,FFICM N/G

757 N/C Vaseem Ahmed Ilford UK MD MSc N/G

756 N/C Dr Vishnu Pillai Dublin Ireland Senior house officer BMBS N/G

755 N/C Karin Laudin Guisborough UK Consultant

psychiatrist

MRCPsych N/G

754 N/C Amanda Williams London UK Consultant

Paediatrician

MRCPCH N/G





753 N/C Suganya Sabaretnam Luton UK Speciality doctor MBBS, MD N/G

752 N/C Peter Darkin Barnes UK Paediatric SHO MBChB, MSc N/G

751 N/C Jane Green Basildon UK Student nurse Bsc N/G

750 N/C Homera Choudhary Hardwick UK Mother Languages degree N/G

749 N/C Amit Singh Bangor UK GP MRCGP N/G

748 N/C Deborah Bird London UK Consultant

Paediatrician

MB ChB N/G

747 N/C Austin Omijie London UK Doctor MBBS N/G

746 N/C Sudeshna Bhowmik Chester UK Consultant

Paediatrician

MRCPCH N/G

745 N/C Shabeena Maricar Essex UK GP MRCGP N/G

744 N/C John Quin Brighton UK Retired FRCP N/G

743 N/C Luthien Tinuviel London UK - - N/G

742 N/C N N London UK Pharmacist Bsc N/G

741 N/C Leila Smith Cambridge UK Midwife Midwifery N/G

740 N/C Zakariyya Vali Leicester UK LE4 9UD MRCP N/G

739 N/C Saraha Perkin Borehamwood UK WD6 1BZ MBBS N/G

738 N/C Rohin Francis London UK ST7 in cardiology MRCP N/G

737 N/C Sajeda Youssouf London UK Consultant MbChB N/G

736 N/C S Faiz Birmingham UK B20 3BE BA View

735 N/C Muhammad Asif Leiester UK speciality doctor T&O MBBS,MRCS,FRCS View

734 N/C Radu Chirvasuta Hitchin UK Dr MD N/G

733 N/C Jon Bramall St Albans UK Consultant intensivist FRCA N/G

732 N/C David Hanlon Leixlip Ireland Co Kildare MB MICGP N/G

731 N/C Emily Hall Leeds UK Civil Servant Master of Arts N/G

730 N/C Arfy Majeed London UK Chartered

Accountant

FCCA N/G

729 N/C Shumi Islam London UK Teacher MA N/G

728 N/C Nazmin Alim London UK Marketing Llb hons N/G

727 N/C Ayesha Sharieff London UK Gp Mrcgp N/G

726 N/C Najmus Aslam Leicester UK Consultant Leicester View

725 N/C Sapna Ladani Leicester UK Consultant Frcpath N/G

724 N/C Maria Foulds Bradford UK BD10 0TA MBChB hons N/G

723 N/C Geoff Gill Liverpool UK Consultant Physician FRCP View

722 N/C Lucy Jones Sheffield UK Consultant FRCEM N/G

721 N/C Niniola Adetuberu Newcastle

upon Tyne

UK Core trainee,

psychiatry

Mbbs N/G

720 N/C Lisa Davies Liverpool UK Consultant

(respiratory)

BM BCh BA FRCP N/G

719 N/C Christopher O'Callaghan London UK Professor of

Paediatricss

FRCPCH N/G

718 N/C Sean Matheiken London UK Vascular Surgeon MBBS FRCS N/G

717 N/C Sarah Jenkins Glasgow UK Consultant MBChB MRCP

FRCR

N/G

716 N/C Fiona Paterson Troon UK Specialty Dr MbChB View

715 N/C Donal Duffy Dublin Ireland Consultant

Representative

BBS View

714 N/C Asam Ishtiaq Waterford Ireland Consultant FRCSI N/G

713 N/C Philip Abraham Ipswich UK Consultant MD FRCPCH View

712 N/C David Lewis Oxford UK Consultant physician MRCP N/G

711 N/C Merran Thomson London UK Consultant FRCPCH N/G





710 N/C Dave Huyton Okehampton UK Specialist Paramedic

-Critical Care

Pg Cert Crit care N/G

709 N/C Stephen Cusack Cork Ireland Consultant,

Emergency Medicine

FRCSI, FRCEM N/G

708 N/C Dinakar Unnithan Buckingham UK Consultant FRCR View

707 N/C Sam Hartley Northampton UK Consultant grade MRCPCH N/G

706 N/C Nisha Morar London UK Paediatric ST3 Mbbs N/G

705 N/C Peter Oâ€™Brien Coventry UK GP FRCGP N/G

704 N/C Anne Davies LONDON UK NW2 2AP FRCP N/G

703 N/C Wendy Savage London UK Retired Senior

Lecturer & Honorary

Consultant

MBBch Frcog MSc

(public Health Hon

DSc

View

702 N/C Harvey Marcovitch Banbury UK Former MPTS

Tribunal Chair

FRCP FRCPCH N/G

701 N/C Michael Rose London UK Consultant neurology FRCP, MD N/G

700 N/C John Kirwan Bristol UK Retired Consultant

Rheumatologist

MB BS, FRCP N/G

699 N/C Rakesh Ravi London UK Consultant MBBS, FRCPCH N/G

698 N/C Lisa Somers LONDON UK Consultant FRCEM N/G

697 N/C Liliana Risi London UK GP MRCGP N/G

696 N/C Richard Ingram Nottingham UK Medical StR MRCP PhD N/G

695 N/C Gregory Landon Harrow UK HA1 3TL MRCPCH N/G

694 N/C Susan Gilby Whitegate UK medical director Mus.B(hons),

MB.,Ch.B.,FRCA.,FFI

CM

View

693 N/C Katie Knight London UK SpR paediatrics MRCPCH N/G

692 N/C LATA NAIR U UK GP MBBS, MRCGP View

691 N/C Seema Sukhani Luton UK Consultant MBBS N/G

690 N/C Chee-Seng Yee Doncaster UK Consultant

Rheumatologist

FRCP (London) N/G

689 N/C Orod Osanlou West kirby UK Specialist Registrar MRCP N/G

688 N/C Bernadette Rae London UK Advanced Nurse

Practitioner

Masters Degree in

Health Care

View

687 N/C Tim Delaney Dublin Ireland D04 DK10 FPSI N/G

686 N/C Iain Chalmers Oxford UK OX2 6HX DSc, FRCP N/G

685 N/C Arup Chakraborty Milton Keynes UK Consultant in

Intensive Care and

General Medicine

BSc MBBS EDIC

FRCA FFICM FRCP

N/G

684 N/C Julian Bashforth Waterlooville UK GP BSc BM MRCGP N/G

683 N/C Rae Webster Northampton UK Retired Consultant FFICM N/G

682 N/C Helen Moore Birmingham UK Paediatric Registrar MBChB N/G

681 N/C Eleanor Stone Birmingham UK GPST2 MBChB N/G

680 N/C Ashley Woodcock Altrincham UK Consultant physician MD FMedSCi FRCP View

679 N/C Peter Fleming Bristol UK BS2 8EG CBE, FRCPCH N/G

678 N/C Tanzeem Raza Bournemouth UK BH8 9NJ FRCP London FRCP

Edin

N/G

677 N/C Erika Harnik London UK Doctor Mrcpch N/G

676 N/C William Whitehead Barmouth UK GP MA BM BCh MRCGP N/G

675 N/C Alison Gill Leeds UK Consultant MRCP N/G

674 N/C Godwin Oligbu London UK Consultant MRCPCH, MSc View

673 N/C Andrew Bush London UK SW3 6NP FRCPCH View





672 N/C Richard Nicholl London UK Consultant

Paediatrician

MBChB FRCPCH

DCH

View

671 N/C Simon David Taylor-Robinson London UK Consultant

Hepatologist

FRCP N/G

670 N/C Mark Lazarus London UK Consultant

(Rheumatology)

MRCP N/G

669 N/C Arti Maini London UK GP, appraiser,

medical

educationalist

MRCGP MSC Med

Ed

N/G

668 N/C E Dapre London UK JCF Bsc, mres, mbbs N/G

667 N/C Pat Dapre LONDON UK IT Consultant B of IT N/G

666 N/C Lauren Weekes NEWTON

ABBOT

UK TQ13 0LF FRCA N/G

665 N/C Bridget Catterall Bicester UK Nurse BSc View

664 N/C James Tomlinson Sheffield UK Consultant Spinal

Surgeon, Training

Programme Director

FRCS (T&O) N/G

663 N/C Nesta Mackenzie Cobham UK GP MRCGP N/G

662 N/C Yousef Basma London UK SE10 0GW MBBS BSC

MRCPCH

N/G

661 N/C SYED Mehdi Milton Keynes UK Consultant FRCP View

660 N/C Sunitha Ramesh Watford UK GP MRCGP N/G

659 N/C Asha Dev Birmingham UK Consultant Calicut Medical

college

View

658 N/C Matthew Jones Lancaster UK GPST 1 MBBS N/G

657 N/C Jeanne Elven London UK Junior doctor MBBCH N/G

656 N/C Natasha Mir London UK GP MRCPGP N/G

655 N/C Andrew Polkinghorn RINGWOOD UK BH24 1NX BM N/G

654 N/C Clare Andrews London UK Paediatric ST1 MbCHB, BsC N/G

653 N/C Mary Edmondson London UK GP FRCGP N/G

652 N/C Farrah Pervez Walsall UK Gp Mrcgp N/G

651 N/C jameel ahmed Hale UK Staff grade Mbbs N/G

650 N/C Syed Haq London UK Hospital Doctor MRCA View

649 N/C senem sahin london UK Psychiatry SpR MRCPsych N/G

648 N/C Gary Foley London UK Paediatric Spr MRCPCH View

647 N/C Manal Kumar Wirral UK Consultant Frcs N/G

646 N/C Alex Armitage London UK Paediatric Registrar MB ChB N/G

645 N/C Sumi Bisht Hamilton New

Zealand

Paediatrician FRCPCH N/G

644 N/C Muhammad Khokhar Harrow

Middlesex

UK HA3 9JY PhD (London) N/G

643 N/C k george manchester UK Consultant Frcs N/G

642 N/C Sean O'Donnell Liverpool UK Paediatric ST5 MBCHB N/G

641 N/C Gbemisola David-West Reading UK ST3 Obstetrics and

Gynaecolgy

Mbbs N/G

640 N/C Raghu Krishnamurthy Birmingham UK Consultant

Paediatrician

MRCPCH N/G

639 N/C Russell Pryce London UK Neonatal SpR MRCPCH N/G

638 N/C Kunal kalra Woolwich UK Spr DNB N/G

637 N/C Tokunbo Sanwo Hornchurch UK rm11 1nx MRCPCH N/G

636 N/C Tariq Nawaz London UK Registrar

(paediatrics)

MRCPCH, MBBS,

BMedSc

N/G





635 N/C Omar Ahmed Newcastle

upon Tyne

UK Consultant Plastic

Surgeon

FRCSEd (Plast) N/G

634 N/C Niall Downey Newry Northern

Ireland

Airline captain,

Doctor, Patient

Safety trainer.

FRCSI N/G

633 N/C J Kallingal Blackburn UK Consultant MB BS N/G

632 N/C Katrina Crawford Cambridge UK St5 paediatrcs MSC MSC & DIC

IMP MBBS BSC

PGCME FHEA

MRCPCH

N/G

631 N/C Maimoona Afzal TELFORD UK sPR Mbbs N/G

630 N/C A Oommen Milton keynes UK Consultant Mbbs N/G

629 N/C Talha Ghannam Solihull UK B93 9LA BSc N/G

628 N/C Ajo John Smallfield UK Surgeon MBBS, MS, FRCS

Ed, FRCS Eng,

FEBS

N/G

627 N/C Bijil Arackal Chichester UK PO20 1NP Mrcpsych N/G

626 N/C Laura Graley London UK Paediatric registrar BMBS N/G

625 N/C Alison Markwick Plymouth UK Paediatric spr Bm N/G

624 N/C Dr Suad Hirsi-Farah Wolverhampton UK SpR in O&G MRCOG View

623 N/C Frances Ryan Glasgow Scotland Education and youth

worker

MA BSc N/G

622 N/C Justin Joseph Worksop UK GP MBBS, MRCGP,

MSc(SEM), DFFP,

DRCOG, DCH

View

621 N/C Asha Madasseri Reading UK Consultant FRCPCH N/G

620 N/C Indu Anand Birmingham UK Consultant

Community

Paediatrician

MRCPCH N/G

619 N/C Charlotte Alexander London UK SW1P 2QD MA MRCGP N/G

618 N/C Lohita Rilesh Nanda Leicester India SpR FRCA N/G

617 N/C Omar BAJMMAL Leicester UK LE2 4FU Mrcp N/G

616 N/C Michelle Jenner-Oâ€™Brien CAMBRIDGE UK SpR Liverpool N/G

615 N/C Sobath Premaratne Bromsgrove UK Surgery Mbbs. MRCS N/G

614 N/C Sukhpal Gill Sutton coldfield UK GP MRCGP N/G

613 N/C Nadua Audhalj London UK SHO Paediatrician Mbbs N/G

612 N/C Lorna McKerracher Glasgow UK ST6 Paediatric

Trainee

MRCPCH N/G

611 N/C Aisha Janjua Birmingham UK Hospital doctor MBBS N/G

610 N/C Younus Saleem Nottingham UK Consultant Mbbs mrcpsych View

609 N/C Sabrina Jalil Solihull UK B90 3LF MBChB N/G

608 N/C Manish Mishra Carlisle UK Register Carlisle Hospital N/G

607 N/C Elizabeth Calton Streatham UK SW16 2DR MBBS MRCPCH N/G

606 N/C Rafi Khan Perth UK Anaesthetic FRCA View

605 N/C Rameshi Chennagiri Milton Keynes UK Consultant FRCS Tr&Orth N/G

604 N/C Sudeep Damodaran Brundall UK Consultant Frcpch N/G

603 N/C Ildiko Schuller London UK Consultant MRCPCH View

602 N/C Saran Shantikumar Rugby UK SpR Public Health MFPH N/G

601 N/C Wajid Ali Birmingham UK GP MBCHB N/G

600 N/C Himanshu Singh Preston UK Consultant Frcp View

599 N/C R John West Midlands UK Hospital consultant MRCP N/G





598 N/C Linda Walker London Czech

Republic

Consultant

paediatrician

MBBS N/G

597 N/C Tarun Goel Milton Keynes UK MK3 7RW MRCPsych N/G

596 N/C neda zaman birmingham UK B13 9pe Bds N/G

595 N/C Ashwani Kapila Milton keynes UK Consultant Mbbs, mrcpsych View

594 N/C Rakesh Ravi Barking UK Consultant Barts health N/G

593 N/C Ciara Mackey Belfast UK Doctor SpR MB BCh N/G

592 N/C Prakash Gupta Oxford UK Consultant MB BS, MRCP N/G

591 N/C Yusuf Vali Leicester UK Consultant Mbchb N/G

590 N/C Victoria Hendley Stone UK GP Mb BChir N/G

589 N/C Perviz Asaria London UK ST6 Cardiology MBBS N/G

588 N/C Randa Abasaeed Elhag Edgbaston UK Consultant MbChb N/G

587 N/C Farhana Shamim London UK SpR MBBS N/G

586 N/C FERRAH Choudhary Nottingham UK SPR MBChB N/G

585 N/C Ahfiya Alvi Birmingham UK Gp Mbbs N/G

584 N/C AMNA Suliman London UK Paediatrics Mbbs N/G

583 N/C Friya Bhatti Huntingdon UK GP MRCGP N/G

582 N/C Alexis Mackleworth London UK Paediatric doctor MBBS N/G

581 N/C Esinam Doamekpor Stevenage UK SpR Paediatrics MRCPCH N/G

580 N/C Janaki Balasubramaniam London UK GP MRCGP N/G

579 N/C Muhammed Naseem Deira UAE Junior Doctor RAKMHSU N/G

578 N/C Ahmed Aber Sheffield UK SpR/Surgey University of London N/G

577 N/C Anna Rzeskiewicz London UK Paediatrics MRCPCH N/G

576 N/C Ruby Jose Roachford UK SS4 3FJ Mbbs N/G

575 N/C Sanjay S.k Davangere India Gynaecologist MBBS , DGO View

574 N/C Aruj Qayum Barking UK Consultant Mrcpch N/G

573 N/C Bapu Sathyajith London UK Family Physician MRCGP View

572 N/C Dr Ada Gashau London UK Paediatric Registrar MBChB N/G

571 N/C Julie Lord London UK Consultant

Paediatrician

MRCP N/G

570 N/C Gayan De Costa Borehamwood UK StR Chemical

Pathology

MBBS, FRCPATH N/G

569 N/C Jemima Harris London UK Paediatric SpR MRCPCH N/G

568 N/C margaret Atim-oluk london UK se7 8qg MBChB N/G

567 N/C Nadia Shad London UK Trainee mbbs N/G

566 N/C Piyusha Kapila London UK Consultant MBChB View

565 N/C Martin Garcia London UK Paediatric SpR MBBS MRCPCH N/G

564 N/C Frances Copp London UK SHO MBBS BSc N/G

563 N/C Emmama New Oxford UK OX3 8QE FPCC, BA (Oxon),

BMBCh (Oxon)

N/G

562 N/C Gareth Lewis London UK Paediatric Registrar MRCPCH N/G

561 N/C Ellen Wright London UK GP and Chair

Greenwich CCG

MA, MSc, MBBS,

FRCGP, FRCA

N/G

560 N/C Gopalkrishna Sheshappanavar London UK Hospital Doctor -

Specialty Doctor

MBBS, MS

Orthopaedics,

MRCSEd

N/G

559 N/C Jahana Kacheri Leicester UK GP trainee M.B.B.S N/G

558 N/C Faslu Rahman London UK E96FB BE N/G

557 N/C sandra ofori Port Harcourt Nigeria Consultant

(Cardiology)

FWACP N/G

556 N/C Dalbir Sohi London UK Consultant FRCPCH N/G

555 N/C Mohammed Siddiqui Bury UK Cinsultant FRCP N/G





554 N/C Akwasi Osei-Yeboah Dagenham UK Consultant Bsc MBChB

MRCPCH

View

553 N/C Lily Martin London UK Paediatric trainee Bristol N/G

552 N/C Shola Doherty Croydon UK Paediatric doctor MRCPCH N/G

551 N/C Anil Kumar Buckingham UK Consultant Mbbs N/G

550 N/C S Hart London UK - - N/G

549 N/C Padakkara Saju Leeds UK Consultant

Psychiatrist

Mrcpsych N/G

548 N/C Mark Butler London UK ST8 paediatrics MRCPCH N/G

547 N/C sabul hussain london UK gp mbbs N/G

546 N/C Toyin Banjoko London UK Consultant

Paediatrician

MBBS N/G

545 N/C Natasha Thorn London UK Paediatric st4 BMBS N/G

544 N/C Nabil Mahmood Norwich UK Consultant

Radiology

FRCR N/G

543 N/C Neha Malhotra London UK Trust doctor MD Paediatrics N/G

542 N/C Harsha Wickramarachchi Stratford UK Specialty Doctor MBBS N/G

541 N/C Zakia Balghari London UK Consultant Mrcog N/G

540 N/C Jennifer oluku London UK senior house officer mbbs N/G

539 N/C Roshni Pulakkal leicester UK le2 3ap MRCGP N/G

538 N/C Mohamed Ali Kalathingal Oadby UK GP MRCGP N/G

537 N/C Kate Oâ€™Farrell London UK Paediatric registrar MRCPCH N/G

536 N/C Katharine Rogerson London UK Paediatric Trainee BA MBBS N/G

535 N/C Richard Curnock London UK SpR MRCPCH N/G

534 N/C Raghu Prasad Bexley UK Consultant MB BS, MD Paeds,

DNB Paeds,

MNAMS, FAGE,

FRCPCH

N/G

533 N/C Sher Anjum London UK Associate specialist MRCPI View

532 N/C Bejoy Kuttikkate Rochford UK SS4 3FJ Mbbs N/G

531 N/C Huw Llewelyn Carmarthen UK Consultant

Endocrinogist,

General Physician

MD. FRCP N/G

530 N/C Anya Leiva Richmond UK GP MRCGP View

529 N/C Dhruv Rastogi London UK Consultant

(Paediatrics)

MAHE N/G

528 N/C A R Moodambail Enfield UK Consultant FRCPCH View

527 N/C JUNAID RAFI IPSWICH

KESGRAVE

UK IP5 2EZ MBBS,MRCPI,

DFSRH

N/G

526 N/C Alan Shirley Sheffield UK GP MRCGP N/G

525 N/C Anjana Radhakrishnan Milton Keynes UK Consultant FRCR N/G

524 N/C Mohammad Alfayez Glasgow UK Consultant clinical

oncology

MBchB, PhD, MRCP,

FRCR

N/G

523 N/C Srivastava Manoj MK UK Doctor MBBS N/G

522 N/C Narayana Prasad Altrincham UK Consultant FRCS Tr & Orth N/G

521 N/C Riaz Mappilakkandy Leicester UK Consultant Physician FRCP N/G

520 N/C Nasheeda Thevarkad High wycombe UK Hp13 7pg MRCGP N/G

519 N/C Sudheer Sulaiman Stevenage UK Consultant

Psychiatrist

MRCPsych N/G

518 N/C Bipin Patel Milton Keynes UK GP MB BCh MRCP View

517 N/C Arianna Lopes Vieira London UK Paediatric SHO Mbbs N/G

516 N/C Assid Jaleel London UK GP University Degree View





515 N/C Fahmi Faraz lymm England consultant

anaesthesia

mobs N/G

514 N/C Tharayil Suresh Larbert UK Doctor M B B S View

513 N/C Paul Inasu SCARBOROU

GH

UK YO125LB MRCPsych View

512 N/C Shahul Hameed Newcastle

Upon Tyne

UK Consultant Frcs N/G

511 N/C Deepu Abraham Birmingham UK Registrar MRCPCH N/G

510 N/C Kaanthan Jawahar East Leake UK ST3 NIHR Academic

Clinical Fellow

MBBS N/G

509 N/C Rajesh Kumar Padinhare Veettil Belfast UK BT16 2GE MRCP N/G

508 N/C Alka Desai London UK SpR MRCPCH N/G

507 N/C Cassandra Gyamtso Croydon UK CR0 2EL MRCPCH View

506 N/C Gayle Hann Barnet UK Consultant

paediatrician

Mbchb View

505 N/C Ravi Prakash London UK Psychiatry M.B.,B.S. N/G

504 N/C Sabu Anzar Leicester UK Registrar MRCPCH N/G

503 N/C Ceri Murphy London UK Paediatrician BMBS, MRCPCH,

BMEDSCI

N/G

502 N/C Rajendra Chaudhary Urmston UK M41 8SR FRCS Dip-Bar View

501 N/C Nazia Waqas London UK Paediatric doctor Mbbs N/G

500 N/C Firdos Patel London UK E7 9LU Ba N/G

499 N/C Mohammad Hanif Glasgow UK Doctor Glasgow N/G

498 N/C Dr Meena Virdi Glasgow UK Hospital Consulant FRCS View

497 N/C Neeraj Jain High Wycombe UK Consultant FRCPCH N/G

496 N/C Manoj Puthiya Veettil Birmingham UK Doctor FRCS N/G

495 N/C Thushara Stanly Chester UK Consultant /doctor Mrcpsych View

494 N/C Keloth Pradeep Prenton UK CH437XW Md N/G

493 N/C vineet batta milton keynes UK hospital doctor nhs FRCS N/G

492 N/C VIJAY KUDARI LONDON UK SE3 8DR MRCP View

491 N/C Ravi Madhotra Milton Keynes UK Consultant FRCP N/G

490 N/C Andrew Cummin London UK Consultant Physician DM FRCP View

489 N/C Karen Johns Birmingham UK Nurse RGN View

488 N/C A Siddiq Pulakal Mancheste UK consultant FRCP N/G

487 N/C Lesley Kay Hexham UK Consultant FRCP N/G

486 N/C Beena Abdul Buckingham UK Mk18 1 fg Mrcog N/G

485 N/C Cristina Ilea Chigwell UK Consultant MRCPCH N/G

484 N/C Campbell Murdoch Bath UK BA2 0AR MBChB N/G

483 N/C Jane Roberts Chester UK CH3 9ET MRCP N/G

482 N/C Elizabeth Auer Southampton UK Anaesthetist BmBCh oxon N/G

481 N/C S Sahu Orpington UK Consultant psychiatry Mrc psych N/G

480 N/C Helen Salisbury Oxford UK OX2 6QX MRCGP N/G

479 N/C Tariq Aziz Bradford UK Gp MRCGP (2014) N/G

478 N/C Mohammed Arif Moothadeth Newcastle

upon Tyne

UK Consultant in

Occupational

medicine

MFOM N/G

477 N/C Muhammad Mukhtar Cheadle UK Consultant MRCEM View

476 N/C Krish Murthy Liverpool UK Consultant FRACP N/G

475 N/C Basheer Tharayil Birmingham UK Consultant

Paediatrician

FRCPCH N/G

474 N/C Salim Ahammed Thornton Heath UK CR7 7QA Mbbs View

473 N/C Maktoum Abdul Azeez Sutton coldfield UK GP FRCGP N/G





472 N/C Krishna Menon Swansea UK SA3 5DX MRCPsych N/G

471 N/C Chinonye Okwuosa London UK GP Mb ChB, FRCS. N/G

470 N/C Mohammed jamsheed Darlington UK DL3 9PD Mrcp N/G

469 N/C Hira Singh Middlesbrough UK Pharmacist MRPharmS N/G

468 N/C Amal Hashi london UK o&g st2 mbbs View

467 N/C Rajesh Chadda London UK Gp MBBS N/G

466 N/C Vinu Ginimav Guildford UK Area Sales Manager MSc N/G

465 N/C Fasal Kotta Altrincham UK Wa15 0rs Mbbs mrcem N/G

464 N/C Prem Mahadun Manchester UK Conultant

Psychiatrist

Mbbs mrcpsych cct View

463 N/C Joanna Galbraith Chichester UK GP Mrcgp View

462 N/C Camille Gajria London UK GP MRCGP N/G

461 N/C Ramasamyiyer

e

Swaminathan London UK Retired Concultant

chemical pathologist

M.B.B.S; Ph.D;

FRCPath

View

460 N/C Dominika Murgasova Guildford UK Paediatric trainee MD Res MRCPCH N/G

459 N/C Wardah Malik Colchester UK CO4 5JL MBBS N/G

458 N/C Arun Bhaskaran Bridgend UK Senior clinical fellow

(Trauma

&Orthopaedics)

FRCS Tr&Orth N/G

457 N/C Caroline Henry Long Eaton UK ST4 Paeds MRCPCH N/G

456 N/C Cyril Chacko Stoke-On-Trent UK Consultant FRCA,FFICM N/G

455 N/C Janani Devaraja Sheffield UK SpR MRCPCH View

454 N/C Cheryl battersby London UK Paediatric trainee MRCPCH N/G

453 N/C Hilary Towse London UK Paediatric registra MBBS N/G

452 N/C Ameera Abdelrahim Birmingham UK Doctor MBChB N/G

451 N/C Amisha Patel Bicester UK Gp MBCHB N/G

450 N/C Kim Holt London UK Consultant MBChB View

449 N/C Jyothish Govindan Buckingham UK MK181FG M.D. FRCP (UK) N/G

448 N/C Anne-Marie Kelly Altrincham UK Consultant MBchB FRCPath N/G

447 N/C Mayur Patel Bicester UK Consultant BSc, MSc, PhD,

MBBS, MRCP,

FRCPath, PGCert

View

446 N/C Hannah Jacob London UK N8 7nb MRCPCH N/G

445 N/C Sujith N Peterborough UK SAS MRCPsych N/G

444 N/C Tony Whitfield Preston UK Nurse Degree View

443 N/C Jenny Vaughan London UK Consultant

neurologist

FRCP View

442 N/C Pete Deveson Epsom UK GP MRCGP N/G

441 N/C Nicholas Price Bradford UK GP MRCGP N/G

440 N/C Susan Bewley London UK Professor of

Women's Health

FRCOG N/G

439 N/C amit acharya london UK gp trainee mbbs N/G

438 N/C Jonathan Sleath Hereford UK HR2 9HN MRCGP N/G

437 N/C Rosalind Bray London UK Clinical Scientist MSc N/G

436 N/C Rebecca Stead Waterlooville UK Clinical Scientist PhD N/G

435 N/C Susan Brook London UK W13 0LF MRCP N/G

434 N/C Sharon Colyer Sheffield UK Clinical Scientist BSc,MSc N/G

433 N/C Esther Nnadi Essex UK GP MBBS N/G

432 N/C Michael Addison Wilmslow UK SK9 5DE FRCPath N/G

431 N/C Freya Hassall Cardiff UK trainee clinical

scientist

MRes N/G





430 N/C Clodagh Loughrey Belfast UK Consultant Chemical

Pathologist

FRCPath N/G

429 N/C BECKY JONES ashford UK trianee clinical

biochemist

BSc View

428 N/C Judith Strachan Dundee UK Consultant Clinical

Scientist

BSc, FRCPath N/G

427 N/C Mubarak Bidmos Brampton Canada GP MBBS N/G

426 N/C Anitha Vayalakkad Altrincham UK Consultant

Neonatologist

MRCPCH N/G

425 N/C Gwenllian Hughes Cardiff UK GP MBBS N/G

424 N/C Rahee Mapara London UK Junior Doctor (on F3

year)

MBBS N/G

423 N/C Mark Taylor Preston UK Consultant geriatric

medicine

Mrcp View

422 N/C Joe Toner Nottingham UK Retired MB. BS. BSc. FRCP N/G

421 N/C Hawwa Shillingford London UK GP registrar BMBS N/G

420 N/C Jonathan Coates Newcastle UK GP MBBS (Hons) N/G

419 N/C M Akma London UK GP MD N/G

418 N/C S Subramonia Newcastle UK Consultant FRCS N/G

417 N/C Tiba Abid Harrow UK HA1 4QT Keele University

Student

N/G

416 N/C Anupam Gupta Prudhoe UK Specialty trainee

registrar

Mrcpch N/G

415 N/C jeremy luke crawley UK GP MRCGP N/G

414 N/C Sophie Nocton London UK GPST1 MBBS View

413 N/C HUI LU GOH birmingham UK fy2 mbchb N/G

412 N/C Hakeem Yusuf Birmingham UK Lecturer PhD N/G

411 N/C Salman Ashraf Leicester UK LE2 3DN Mrcgp mrchb N/G

410 N/C Gemma Uddin Leicester UK Teacher PGCE N/G

409 N/C William Leach Glasgow Scotland Consultant

Orthopaedic Surgeon

FRCS Glas FRCSEd

Orth

N/G

408 N/C Aman Haque BÃ˜NES Norway 5155 Masters N/G

407 N/C Priya Iyer Glasgow UK Gp Mrcgp N/G

406 N/C Louisa Polak Colchester UK GP BM BCh N/G

405 N/C Bangalore Satish Kent UK Consultant FRCPCH View

404 N/C Prashna Primulapathi Newcastle UK Registrar st6 Paeds MBCHB, dip Paeds N/G

403 N/C Ruth Matthews Leicester UK Medical Statistician MAc. N/G

402 N/C Hafsah Hassan Gwarzo Abuja Nigeria Civil Servant BSc. Biochemistry View

401 N/C Hajer Oun Glasgow UK CT1 MbChb N/G

400 N/C Ian O'Sullivan Cardiff UK Gp MBBCH View

399 N/C Edward Cooper London UK Retired paediatrician FRCP N/G

398 N/C Firdous Syed BIRMINGHAM UK B17 9LZ MRCP N/G

397 N/C Muhammad Kabir Abuja Nigeria Lawyer Masters N/G

396 N/C Angharad Spencer MANCHESTER UK M22 4JW MBChB View

395 N/C Peter Isherwood Birmingham UK Consultant in Critical

Care Medicine &

Anaesthesia

FFICM N/G

394 N/C Jessica Watson Bristol UK GP MRCGP N/G

393 N/C Safiyyah Salihu Cranfield UK mk43 0GA Ma N/G

392 N/C Rahmatu Ahmed Abuja Nigeria Lawyer FICMC View

391 N/C David Levine Penzance UK Consultant Physician

(retired)

FRCP N/G





390 N/C Mohamed R Leicester UK Hospital Doctor MB.ChB, FCAI N/G

389 N/C Huseinat Usman-Folorunsho Sheldon UK B26 3RG Msc View

388 N/C Amanda Kemp Tiverton UK GP registrar MBBCh N/G

387 N/C Jay Ilangaratne East Yorkshire UK Editor www.medical-journal

s.com

View

386 N/C Sarah Tyler Brighton UK ED registrar MRCEM N/G

385 N/C Obedat Olajide MANCHESTER UK M11 2LW Nurse View

384 N/C Hauwa Garba Gombe Nigeria law Enforcement

officer

MA Anti Corruption View

383 N/C Awais Mir Maidenhead UK Gp Mbbs View

382 N/C Samantha Gordon London UK Consultant

ophthalmologist

B.Sc(Hons), MBBS,

FRCOphth

View

381 N/C Abdulazeez Odumade London UK Engineer Bsc N/G

380 N/C Maricel Irwin Chorley UK GP trainee MD N/G

379 N/C Alison Cooke Colchester UK GP MBBS N/G

378 N/C Gavin Shields Stratford-upon-

Avon

UK GP MBChB DCH N/G

377 N/C Eleanor Jones Chislehurst UK Consultant

Emergency Medicine

MBBS BSc FRCEM View

376 N/C Usman Adeyemi Leicester UK LE1 2PA BSc Civil Engineering N/G

375 N/C Rukinder Birk London UK Consultant FRCA View

374 N/C Allison Charnock Manchester UK GP MBChB N/G

373 N/C Lyvia Dabydeen London UK Consultant Paediatric

Neurologist

MRCP N/G

372 N/C Syeda Qureshi Ipswich UK GP Mbbs N/G

371 N/C Aida Jawhari Nottingham UK Consultant physician MBBS, FRCP, PhD View

370 N/C Rashed Akhtar Leicester UK LE5 0TX MRCGP N/G

369 N/C Bilal Bawamia Newcastle

Upon Tyne

UK SpR MRCP N/G

368 N/C Saad Azhar Huddersfield UK Surgery MBChB View

367 N/C Emily Burns Birmingham UK B675AZ MBChB View

366 N/C Amar Karia Coventry UK Obstetrics and

Gynecology trainee

MBBS N/G

365 N/C Merfet Mohammed London UK CT3 Psychiatry MBBS N/G

364 N/C Rebecca Spooner Melksham UK ST5 Psychiatry MRCPsych N/G

363 N/C Naomi Selvadurai Letchworth UK GP Mbbs Mr Gp N/G

362 N/C Nadia Wahid Birmingham UK Gp University degree View

361 N/C Michael Rimmer Warwick UK Doctor MB ChB MRes N/G

360 N/C Nicola Hambridge Leeds UK GP MRCGP (2000) N/G

359 N/C Hauwa Sadiq Kano city Nigeria Medical

Officer(medical

doctor)

Bayero University

Kano

View

358 N/C Mairi Mcguire Motherwell UK ML1 2FL Mbchb Dundee.

MRCP Glasgow

N/G

357 N/C Ramesh Kumar Leeds UK Consultant MD N/G

356 N/C Mairi Bowlerwell Dunfermline UK GP MRCGP N/G

355 N/C Hadya Parinitha Leicester UK GP MBBS, MRCPCH.

MRCGP.

View

354 N/C Muna Nur Sheffield UK Gp Mbchb N/G

353 N/C Khadijah Aliyu Abuja Nigeria Rehabilitation

therapist

University degree N/G

352 N/C Joanna Lang Lincoln UK Social Scientist BA dual Honours N/G





351 N/C Natalia Albu Colchester UK Gp MBBS RCGP View

350 N/C Anonymous Anonymous Croydon UK Doctor MBBS N/G

349 N/C Lola Akintoye Leicester UK Toxicologist PhD N/G

348 N/C Marie Freel Glasgow UK Consultant FRCP N/G

347 N/C Sandia George Newcastle

upon Tyne

UK Specialty trainee in

Paediatrics/Neurodis

ability: Registrar- ST6

MBBS, PG Diploma

Paediatric

Neurodisability

View

346 N/C John Paul Leach Lanarkshire UK Consultant

Neurologist

MD, FRCP (gla)

FRCP (Ed)

View

345 N/C Maria Pan London UK SpR MBBS View

344 N/C Helen Linklater Dorking UK RH4 1HX FRCP N/G

343 N/C Charlotte Mathew Newcastle UK SHO MBBS N/G

342 N/C Torquil Duncan-Brown Lichfield Australia GP MBChB, FRCGP N/G

341 N/C Aisha SADIQ Leicester UK LE2 4DN University degree N/G

340 N/C Elizabeth Dowling Newcastle

Upon Tyne

UK GPST1 MBcHB N/G

339 N/C Richard Rees Cricklewood UK SpR MRCP N/G

338 N/C Shazia Parveen Birmingham UK B95LT Diploma N/G

337 N/C Puskar Bura Bristol UK junior doctor MBBS N/G

336 N/C Hani Shuheibar Manchester UK Consultant MBCHB MRCOG N/G

335 N/C Rajan Kumar Sood Dundee UK Junior Doctor - FY2 MBChB N/G

334 N/C Kim Simpson Durham UK Spr paediatric Mbbs N/G

333 N/C Jenny Hamida Leicester UK Le29ad PGCE N/G

332 N/C Hamid Aboubakar Leicester UK Teacher University Degree View

331 N/C Hauwa Umar Kano Nigeria Development work MBaa N/G

330 N/C Mohamed Naved Leicester UK Consultant FRCS N/G

329 N/C Ammar Ghouri Leicester UK Gp Mrcgp N/G

328 N/C Khadijat Morafa Manchester UK Scientist MSc N/G

327 N/C Ravi Jayaram Chester UK Consultant

paediatrician

FRCPCH N/G

326 N/C Helen Aspey Newcastle UK Consultant Mbbs N/G

325 N/C Haoua Hamid dabo Alfaki leicester UK le3 8ld Phd View

324 N/C Nicola Turner Gerrards Cross UK GP BM N/G

323 N/C Chris Kasp Birmingham UK Consultant Mrcp N/G

322 N/C Fatima Abulfathi Maiduguri Nigeria Senior Registrar

Haematology

MBBS N/G

321 N/C asra Ayub Coventry UK Accountant University of derby N/G

320 N/C Nasba Ayub Coventry UK Teacher University of

Bedfordshire

N/G

319 N/C Syed Rizwan scotland UK Cardiologist MBChB N/G

318 N/C Katrina Clark Epping UK GP MBBS View

317 N/C Kate Herriot Bristol UK Psychiatry Core

Trainee

MBBS N/G

316 N/C Kiran Murva Leicester UK GP MBChB, MRCGP N/G

315 N/C Nadia Afsheen Birmingham UK Consultant MRCP N/G

314 N/C Poppy Richardson Newcastle UK Paediatric junior

doctor

MBBS N/G

313 N/C Richard Lehman Banbury UK GP academic MRCGP N/G

312 N/C S Srinivasan Leicester UK Middle grade FRCS View

311 N/C Shubhechya Shrestha Leicester UK GP MBChB, BSc

physiology, MRCGP

N/G

310 N/C Claire Anderson Newcastle UK SpR MBBS N/G





309 N/C Kanthan Theivendran Ashby-de-la-Zo

uch

UK Consultant (T&O) MBBS, BSc, MRCS,

FRCS(Tr&Orth)

N/G

308 N/C Zaunab Maina-Lukat New Cairo Egypt Lawyer University of

Maiduguri, Borno

State

N/G

307 N/C Mark Turner Preston UK Mark Turner Mb ChB N/G

306 N/C sarah scales newcastle upon

Tyne

UK paediatric sho mbbs N/G

305 N/C Aisling Chew Newcastle

upon Tyne

UK Paediatric teaching

fellow

MBBS N/G

304 N/C Mariama Cole Leicester UK Midwife RGN, RGM N/G

303 N/C M Mahmood Stirchley UK B302ta Bsc N/G

302 N/C Kam Ag London UK Student BEng N/G

301 N/C Laura Lane Newcastle UK Doctor MBBS MRPCH N/G

300 N/C K Akter West Midlands

ds

UK Specialty doctor MBBS N/G

299 N/C Zaharau Isa Abuja Nigeria Accountant MBA N/G

298 N/C Amany Tadrous belfast UK BT9 7GY MRCPCH , MRCPI,

DCH, MBBCh

N/G

297 N/C Wei-Te Ting Newcastle

upon Tyne

UK GPST MBChB N/G

296 N/C Zainab Ibrahim Abuja Nigeria Administrator B.sc biochemistry N/G

295 N/C Jerina Rich Newcastle UK Paediatric trainee MRCPCH View

294 N/C Ugonna Offor Newca Upon

Tyne

UK Paediatric Trainee MBChB N/G

293 N/C Yetunde Sulu London UK Teacher BA (Hons) N/G

292 N/C Tom Altmann Newcastle

upon Tyne

UK Paediatrics Mbbs N/G

291 N/C Narasimha Gadi Basildon UK Consultant MRCP N/G

290 N/C Habiba Ali Newcastle

upon Tyne

UK Paediatric SpR MBBS N/G

289 N/C Neelima Vucha Southend-on-

sea

UK GP MRCGP N/G

288 N/C Nurudeen Binuyo Abuja Nigeria 187 Masters in

Development Studies

View

287 N/C Devina Siaw Manchester UK Ct1 Mbbs N/G

286 N/C Nurudeen Usman Birmingham UK radiographer Bsc N/G

285 N/C Anna Emmott Liverpool UK GP MRCGP N/G

284 N/C Kabir Yusuf London UK IT Consultant MSC. N/G

283 N/C Abu Haneefah Birmingham UK GP MRCGP N/G

282 N/C Elizabeth Pope Didcot UK Junior Doctor Mbbs N/G

281 N/C Rasheeda Dabiri Birmingham UK B17 0RP University degree N/G

280 N/C Hafsah Imran Halifax UK Student Clinical sciences bsc N/G

279 N/C Fatihiya Saad Leicester UK Teacher University degree N/G

278 N/C Taofikat Agbabiaka Broxbourne UK EN10 6SS MSc N/G

277 N/C sahira liaquat birmingham UK b10 9ej BA HONS N/G

276 N/C Ibrahim Hadiza Maiduguri Nigeria Civil servant BSc N/G

275 N/C Lateefah Binuyo Birmingham UK B28 0DH MSc N/G

274 N/C Jannah Leon-Maurice Leicester UK Retired Retired View

273 N/C Adama Ibrahim Wokingham UK Project manager MBA N/G

272 N/C Zaahira Kidy Leicester UK Dietitian Undergraduate

masters

N/G





271 N/C Jakir Ullah Ilford UK Doctor ST3 Mbbs N/G

270 N/C Elizabeth Penny Birmingham UK Clinical Psychologist DClinPsy N/G

269 N/C Hilary Klonin Hull UK Consultant FRCPCH N/G

268 N/C Lateefat Junaid Leicester UK LE4 2BJ Bsc Law View

267 N/C Mona Elfarargy Leicester UK LE2 2EJ Bachelor of

commerce

N/G

266 N/C gerry wheeler Isle of North

Uist

UK gp mbchb drcog mrcgp N/G

265 N/C Sarah Wookey Greater London UK GP MRCPCH View

264 N/C Maryam Marafa Asokoro Nigeria 900231 B. Sc international

studies

View

263 N/C Alice Hodkinson Cambridge UK GP MA, MBBS, MRCGP View

262 N/C Fiaz Farooq Halifax UK GP nMRCGP, MBChB View

261 N/C R Chowdhury Leicester UK Psychologist PhD candidate N/G

260 N/C Mehwesh Qureshi Halifax UK GP MBChB MRCGP View

259 N/C Taiwo Bidmos Leicester UK le1 4ql Bsc Accounting N/G

258 N/C Saada Saad Kent UK Lawyer University degree N/G

257 N/C Seher Qureshi HALIFAX UK Pharmacy technician Bsc Hons N/G

256 N/C Rajnaara Akhtar Leicester UK Lawyer PhD N/G

255 N/C Kavya Mohandas Merseyside UK Consultant MBBS FRCPath N/G

254 N/C Fergus Hamilton Bristol UK Ct2 medicine Mrcp N/G

253 N/C Simon Tobin Southport UK GP FRCGP N/G

252 N/C Rebekah Burrow OXFORDSHIR

E

UK OX2 9FU MSc N/G

251 N/C Jo Wright Bingham UK Nurse Rn 1,15 MSc View

250 N/C Reem Nawari Northampton UK Gp Mbchb N/G

249 N/C Bhimanagouda Patil Darlington UK Consultant MRCP N/G

248 N/C Rubina Akhtar Leicester UK GP MRCGP N/G

247 N/C Robert Tanner Llangollen UK GP BM BCh N/G

246 N/C Nicholas Steel Norwich UK Public Health MBChB N/G

245 N/C ajai tyagi birmingham UK Consultant frcs N/G

244 N/C Sally Higginbottom London UK GP MRCGP N/G

243 N/C Caroline Ward Oxford UK GP BMBS N/G

242 N/C Lesli Davies Rugby UK GP MB ChB N/G

241 N/C Helen Stedeford London UK GP MRCGP N/G

240 N/C Peter English Horsham UK RH12 1XA FFPH N/G

239 N/C Thomas Lavender Middlesbrough UK Consultant physician MRCP N/G

238 N/C Kerry Jeevananthan Angmering UK Spr Mbbs View

237 N/C Farihah Yusuf Newcastle UK SpR MBBS N/G

236 N/C Kashif Bhatti Leeds UK GP BM N/G

235 N/C Julian Treadwell Oxford UK GP MRCGP N/G

234 N/C David Spitzer London UK GP BSc MBBS N/G

233 N/C David Best Tunbridge

Wells

UK Teacher BMus Honours N/G

232 N/C Dr Beena Koshy Vellore India Development

paediatric consultant

M.D.. M.D. research N/G

231 N/C Yusuf Rajbee Morden UK GP MbChB N/G

230 N/C David Drew Sutton Coldfield UK Paediatrician MRCP View

229 N/C Tanya Kumar East Croydon UK Junior doctor Mbchb N/G

228 N/C Aysha Hussain Leicester UK Homemaker Hnd biological

science

N/G





227 N/C Harriet Davies Hove UK Paediatric trainee

ST2

BMBS N/G

226 N/C Anita Annakesavan Leicester UK LE2 4UG MRCS View

225 N/C James Golding Prenton UK Consultant

anaesthetist

MBChB FRCA N/G

224 N/C Anthony Cochrane Liverpool UK Consultant

(Anaesthetics)

FRCA N/G

223 N/C Zohra Qureshi Bishops

Stortford

UK GP MRCGP N/G

222 N/C Bindu Vydianath Birmingham UK Doctor MBBS FRCPATH N/G

221 N/C Ann Burns Sunderland UK GP Mrcgp N/G

220 N/C Caroline Greene Cambridge UK GP MRCGP N/G

219 N/C Ganapathiram Lakshmanan Bournemouth UK Hospital Doctor MRCS View

218 N/C Elizabeth Tomkins Middlesbrough UK Nurse - Matron Bsc hons N/G

217 N/C Arijit Mitra BIRMINGHAM UK Consultant BMEC N/G

216 N/C Malika Javid Coventry UK Consultant MRCP FRCR N/G

215 N/C Sree Jaidev Scarborough UK GP MBBS N/G

214 N/C Krishnamoorthy Narayanan Newcastle UK Consultant Mbbs, MS, FRCS N/G

213 N/C Kerrie Spaul Leicester UK GP MBChB N/G

212 N/C Sadaf Akbar Dagenham UK GP MBBS MRCGP N/G

211 N/C Suresh Pillai Lincoln UK Consultant Surgeon MBBS, MS, DNB,

FRCS

View

210 N/C Makani Purva Hull UK Consultant FFARCS View

209 N/C Sonia Chester London UK GP MBBS N/G

208 N/C Suresh Joseph Newcastle

upon t

UK Consultant

Psychiatrist

FRCPSYCH N/G

207 N/C Jonathan Graham Nottinghamg UK GP BM BS MRCGP N/G

206 N/C Wee Haan Pang Birmingham UK Radiologist MBChB FRCR View

205 N/C Arun Ranjit Liverpool UK Consultant FRCP N/G

204 N/C Rabi Nambi Derby UK Consultant MD N/G

203 N/C Deepthi Jyothish Birmingham UK B17 8AD FRCP N/G

202 N/C neelima sibal Birmingham UK GP MRCGP N/G

201 N/C Sangeeta Tiwary Asian/Asian

British

UK Paediatrics Trainee MBBS, MRCPCH View

200 N/C Antonia Lile Stratford upon

avon

UK GP MbChB View

199 N/C Sanjay Vydianath Birmingham UK B17 8RH Kerala University View

198 N/C Josephine Drew Nottingham UK Paediatrician MRCPCH View

197 N/C Rebecca Roberts Rawtenstall UK Gp Mrcgp N/G

196 N/C Neeta Ray Chaudhuri London UK Consultant MBBS, FRCOphth View

195 N/C Sangeeta Joshi Newcastle UK Consultant FRCPCH N/G

194 N/C Jeanette Clayton Peterborough UK Gp MB ChB N/G

193 N/C Andrea Ling Cardiff UK CF14 9JL MBBCh N/G

192 N/C Emma Valentine Langport UK Registrar MBChB N/G

191 N/C Siobhan Quinn Manchester UK Paediatric St4 MRCPCH View

190 N/C Wasif Razzaq Billingham UK Gp Mbchb N/G

189 N/C Divya Gurudutt Newcastle

Upon Tyne

UK Consultant

(Paediatrics)

MB BS N/G

188 N/C Reena Johal Walsall UK GP Mbchb mrcp drcog

mrcgp

N/G

187 N/C Praveen Kumar peterborough UK Consultant Mrcpsych N/G

186 N/C Mohammed Wakaas Rotherham UK GP Mbchb View





185 N/C Arunachalam Iyer Glasgow UK Consultant FRCS N/G

184 N/C Vandana Surendran Newmarket UK GP MBBS N/G

183 N/C Sunil Nair Wirral India Consultant Physician MBBS, PhD, FRCP View

182 N/C Sam Craik Telford UK CT1 Doctor MBChB N/G

181 N/C Cherian George Market Drayton UK Consultant

Radiologist

FRCR View

180 N/C Kamalpreet Sidhu Castle Eden UK GP MBBS N/G

179 N/C Fleur England Peterborough UK Gp Mbchb hons nmrcgp N/G

178 N/C Chovodath Unnikrishnan Wakefield UK Gp MRCGP N/G

177 N/C Eniang Offiong Leicester UK ST-1 MBBS N/G

176 N/C Rebecca Purkiss Kettering UK Specialty Doctor MBChB N/G

175 N/C Vicky Brice Manchester UK SpR Paediatrics MBChB N/G

174 N/C Manjunath Kambalimath STOCKTON

ON TEES

UK Consultant MBBS DCH

MRCPCH

N/G

173 N/C Sonja Adhiyaman Mold UK GP MRCGP MRCPCH N/G

172 N/C Tina Ramnani Nottingham UK Consultant

Neurologist

BMBS BMedSci N/G

171 N/C Sheetal Purohit Kings Langley UK Gp Mbchb N/G

170 N/C Soni Soumian Stoke on Trent UK Consultant FRCS Edinburgh N/G

169 N/C Mandy Mohamed ahmed Oadby UK Specialty doctor BDS N/G

168 N/C Salil Koyitty veedu Widnes UK Gp Mrcgp N/G

167 N/C Monica Chidgey Abergavenny UK GP MB.BS MRCGP N/G

166 N/C Rose Moore-Moffatt Hove UK GP registrar MBBS N/G

165 N/C Manoj Prahladan Royston UK Academic Mbbs N/G

164 N/C Michael Wild Edinburgh UK SpR MBChB N/G

163 N/C Fiorenza Shepherd London UK Doctor Imperial N/G

162 N/C Abdul Nazeer Moideen Swansea UK Spinal fellow MBBS, FRCS N/G

161 N/C Syeda Imam London UK SHO MBBS, BSc N/G

160 N/C Ayat Ali London UK Doctor Mobs N/G

159 N/C Gopalakrishnan Gopalan Irinjalakuda India 680712 M.S. N/G

158 N/C Madhuri Dasarathi Sunderland UK Consultant MRCPCH N/G

157 N/C Ravi Thyagarajan Portsmouth UK Consultant MBBs N/G

156 N/C Alexandra Stevens Bickington UK Gp spr BMBS N/G

155 N/C T B Leicester UK Consultant MRCP N/G

154 N/C Ameen Shamsudeen Leeds UK Paediatric Mbbs mrcpch pg dip N/G

153 N/C Stephanie Harrison Leicester UK Nurse BSc honours in

nursing

View

152 N/C Heba Abu-Owm London UK GP trainee Medicine MBBS N/G

151 N/C Salim Bicha Altrincham UK General Practitioner MRCGP N/G

150 N/C Tim Wright Edinburgh UK EH7 6TU MBChB View

149 N/C Usha Mohandas LakeMary USA GP MD N/G

148 N/C Sara Maki London UK Doctor Imperial College

London

N/G

147 N/C Tim Leitch Clarendon Australia GP FRACGP N/G

146 N/C Phil Whitaker Bath UK GP BM BS N/G

145 N/C Roya Dabestani Melbourne Australia GP Mrcgp View

144 N/C Arvind Sinha Birmingham UK Consultant Mbbs N/G

143 N/C Mary Jose Nottingham UK Medical Student MBBS N/G

142 N/C Evangelos Mangos London UK Surgeon FRCS (T&O) N/G

141 N/C Daud Afzal Woking UK Medical

representative

Ba Hons N/G

140 N/C Rajesh Gabani Woolwich China Consultant FRCPCH N/G





139 N/C Ruth Kwong London UK Paediatric sho BMBS N/G

138 N/C Rani Sebastian Bristol UK Consultant FRCOphth N/G

137 N/C Sandeep Rondla Coventry UK A&E Spr MBBS N/G

136 N/C Subhan Christudas Chennai India Consultant

Paediatrician

Mrcpch N/G

135 N/C Yoginee Gokool Dumfries UK Junior dotor MBBS N/G

134 N/C Shailini Bahl West Byfleet UK Kt14 6hx Mrcpch N/G

133 N/C Sarah Ajam Coleshill UK GPST3 MBBCh N/G

132 N/C Sulma Gulzar Derby UK GP Mbchb, nMRCGP N/G

131 N/C Tariq AHMAD Cambridge UK Consultant Plastic

Surgeon

FRCS(Plast) N/G

130 N/C Ashok Aralihond Kingston,

London

UK Doctor Frcpch N/G

129 N/C Animesh Singh London UK Consultant Physician MBBS MRCP N/G

128 N/C Beenish Ashraf Stockport UK GP Mbchb View

127 N/C Katie McDowell Glasgow UK FY1 Doctor MBBS View

126 N/C Sian Alexander Cambridge UK Neurology SpR MRCP N/G

125 N/C Lisa Clayton London UK Neurology SpR MRCP N/G

124 N/C Aniket Deshpande Rugby UK Consultant FRCS (Urol) N/G

123 N/C Zeshan Riaz Southampton UK So40 2bn MRCP N/G

122 N/C James Lilleker Manchester UK SpR Neurology MBChB N/G

121 N/C Diana Iskander Ashford UK Paediatric registrar MBBch, MRCPCH N/G

120 N/C Halima Ahmed Bolton UK BL1 4EY University degree N/G

119 N/C Abrar Hussain UXBRIDGE UK Ub8 2jw MRCPsych N/G

118 N/C Shankar Kashyap Gosforth England Consultant FRCS View

117 N/C Martin Samuels Stoke on Trent UK Consultant

Paediatrician

MD FRCPH N/G

116 N/C Isurima Katuwawela Nottinghamshir

e

UK Psychiatrist

(consultant)

MBChB birmingham N/G

115 N/C John Ross Reeth UK GP MRCGP N/G

114 N/C Rhys Thomas Newcastle UK Consultant

Neurologist

BSc MBChB MRCP

MSc PhD

N/G

113 N/C Suhair Shebani Leicester UK Consultant MBBCh MRCPCH

MSC FRCPCH

View

112 N/C Fati Attahiru Abuja Nigeria Development worker Masters N/G

111 N/C Nazia Edathola kottasseri Oadby UK GP MRCGP N/G

110 N/C Rosemarie Richards London UK W6 9HE MBBA BsC RCGP N/G

109 N/C Salini Sumangala Leicester UK Spr Mrcp N/G

108 N/C Nadir Kiddo Leicester UK Trust grade doctor MRCPCH N/G

107 N/C megan lewis Mundesley UK GP MRCGP N/G

106 N/C muhammad akunjee london UK doctor mbbs N/G

105 N/C Indira Natarajan Stone UK St15 0wf Mbbs N/G

104 N/C Muhammad Nadeem Leicester UK Paediatrician MD N/G

103 N/C saud jukaku Edgware UK HA8 5SH Mbbs N/G

102 N/C Ihsan Hamzah Nottingham UK Doctor SpR Mbbch FRCR MRCS N/G

101 N/C Domine McConnell London UK GP MBCHB N/G

100 N/C C Hill Exmouth UK SHO MBChB, BSc (Hons) N/G

99 N/C Maryam T Abuja Nigeria GP MRCGP N/G

98 N/C Mina Endeley Linton in Ouse UK GP MRCGP View

97 N/C Kosi Abdulai Brighton UK GP Trainee MBBChir N/G

96 N/C Catherine McGrath Birmingham UK Rheumatology SpR MRCP View

95 N/C Nadia Yousaf Glasgow UK Doctor Newcastle N/G





94 N/C Mahima Charan Lincoln UK F2 MBChB N/G

93 N/C Lin Pan Leicester UK GP registrar MBchB View

92 N/C Antigoni Koukkoulli Limassol Cyprus Ophthalmologist MBBS FRCOphth

MScMEd

View

91 N/C Sarah Dunne London UK ED Spr MBBS N/G

90 N/C Aneta Filipek Kirkwall UK GP trainee Medical doctor N/G

89 N/C Suzi Armitage Leicester UK Paeds Trainee MRCPCH N/G

88 N/C mohammed ashraf high wycombe UK HP11 2SR mbbs N/G

87 N/C Sonal Kapoor Leicester UK SpR University hospitals

of Leicester

View

86 N/C Anna Maclure Sunderland UK SASG Urologist MRCSEd N/G

85 N/C Emily Lloyd Nottingham UK FY1 Doctor BMBS N/G

84 N/C Peter Ellis Salisbury UK Registrar (emergency

medicine)

BMBS N/G

83 N/C Suzanne Hale Llantrisant UK ST4 Anaesthetist FRCA View

82 N/C Neelam Hassan Cardiff UK Core Trainee BM BCh N/G

81 N/C Arun Kurup Wheaton aston UK Consultant Mbbs mrcp N/G

80 N/C Mushammat Hussain Charlton UK Consultant MBBS N/G

79 N/C Imogen Rygol Truro UK F2 doctor Bmbs N/G

78 N/C Andrew Lawton Edinburgh UK ST5 Psychiatry MRCPsych N/G

77 N/C Lorna Filby Nottingham UK CT anaesthetics MBChB N/G

76 N/C Sarah Graham Leed UK gP MRCGP N/G

75 N/C Naina Emcy Essex UK Consultant MBBS N/G

74 N/C Abimbola Yerimah Telford UK ST1 MBBS N/G

73 N/C Sam Roberts Leeds UK Clinical Leadership

Fellow

MRCP N/G

72 N/C Husain Asgerally Leicester UK LE3 9TH Mbchb N/G

71 N/C Moon-Moon Majumdar Brighton UK Anaesthetic SHO MBBS N/G

70 N/C Rakiya Sambo Gloucester UK Project Managee Masters N/G

69 N/C Preethi Bhishma Leeds UK SpR MBBS N/G

68 N/C Rusha El Sheikh Leicester UK consultant O&G MRCOG N/G

67 N/C S Amin Manchester UK Housewife None N/G

66 N/C IMRAN KHURSHID Bury St

Edmunds

UK Senior Clinical Fellow

EM

MBBS N/G

65 N/C Jonathan Cusack Leicester UK Consultant

neonatologist

MBChB MRCPCH

MMedSci (Clin Ed)

N/G

64 N/C Ram Nagaruru Venkata Lethbridge Canada Pediatric consultant FRCPCH, FRCPC View

63 N/C Melanie Mein Wellington New

Zealand

6022 MRCGP N/G

62 N/C Jagruti Hillhouse Scotland UK Doctor University of London N/G

61 N/C Gemma Matthewman Birmingham UK GP Trainee MB BCh N/G

60 N/C Nitesh Singh Leicester UK ST7 Paediatrics Mrcpch N/G

59 N/C Kamini Yadav Leicester UK Specialist Registrar MBBS, MRCPCH,

PhD.

N/G

58 N/C B S Manchester UK Student . N/G

57 N/C Ejiro Eyaru Essex UK SpR MBBS View

56 N/C David Gendy Stafford UK SpR MBChB N/G

55 N/C Martyn Traves Derby UK Consultant

Anaesthetist

MBChB View

54 N/C Aisha Latif Rochdale UK Teacher Manchester

Universiry

N/G





53 N/C Sukitha Rupasinghe Liverpool UK SpR (General

Surgery)

MBchB. MRCS N/G

52 N/C Luisa Busato Norwich UK GPST MBBS N/G

51 N/C Kishori Kulkarni Leicester UK GP MRCGP N/G

50 N/C Hufsa Tayyab Brighouse UK Gp Leicester N/G

49 N/C Judi Galea London UK A&E registrar MBChB N/G

48 N/C Zak Connor Colchester UK Chemist MChem N/G

47 N/C Bharat Modhwadia London UK GP Leeds N/G

46 N/C Ala Mejaddam stockholm Sweden Registrar Md N/G

45 N/C Liam Hudson Brixton UK Anaesthetist MB BChir N/G

44 N/C Mary Oâ€™Driscoll Birmingham UK Consultant MRCPCH N/G

43 N/C Niharika Tyagi London UK Doctor MRCP N/G

42 N/C Charlotte Rowe Truro UK GP trainee BMBS N/G

41 N/C IQTEDER Uddin Bury St.

Edmunds

UK Spr MRCEM N/G

40 N/C Ademola Olaitan London UK Specialist Registrar MRCP(UK) N/G

39 N/C Muhammad Murtaza Colwyn Bay UK Consultant

Diabetologist

MBBS MRCP View

38 N/C Aaron Dehghan Manchester UK SHO MBBS N/G

37 N/C Sarah Aspland Shrewsbury UK Medical student MBBS 2020 N/G

36 N/C Aysha Ziauddin Milton Keynes UK Gp vts Mrcog N/G

35 N/C Tehmina Parekh Hipperholme UK GP Mbbs N/G

34 N/C PARTHASARA

DHI

RACHAKONDA Southend on

Sea

UK Consultant MRCPCH N/G

33 N/C Arun Kishore Worthing UK Consultant MD N/G

32 N/C Afrah Al- Maliki Richmond UK GP MBCHB MRCGP

DFRSH DPD

View

31 N/C Yen yen Khor KINGSTON UK Gp BM N/G

30 N/C Kashif Aziz Banstead UK GP MBBS N/G

29 N/C Asma Shebani Warwick UK Civil Engineer Coventry university N/G

28 N/C Lubna Khan Leamington UK Housewife Masters degree N/G

27 N/C Sekinat Yusuf Londo UK Trainee doctor Degree N/G

26 N/C Muniba khan SOUTH

CROYDON

UK Cr2 6bt MBChB N/G

25 N/C Bernadette Keating Norwich UK Doctor F3 BMBS N/G

24 N/C Nehal Thanawala Leicester UK SpR MRCPCH N/G

23 N/C Dr Naomi Eastwood Wrexham UK Paediatric registrar

(ST5)

MRCPCH View

22 N/C chris Busby Nottingham UK NG81LF MBBS N/G

21 N/C Adnan Zafar Stockton on

Tees

UK Consultant

Paediatrician

FRCPCH View

20 N/C Rohini Rattihalli Oxford UK Consultant Mrcpch N/G

19 N/C Kinjalben Patel London UK GP Bsc, MBBS, MRCGP,

PGCE

N/G

18 N/C Tejumola Olaoye Birmibgham UK ST4 O&G Mbbs View

17 N/C Julia Eddington Whakatane New

Zealand

GP MBBS BSc N/G

16 N/C Anthony Taylor Romford UK locum SHO BMedSci BMBS N/G

15 N/C Umesh Prabhu ROCHDALE UK OL11 5RF MRCPCH View

14 N/C Toseef Ahmad Cheadle UK Doctor BMBS N/G

13 N/C Pooja Harijan Peterborough UK Paediatric registrar MRCPCH N/G

12 N/C Chelsey Gathercole Colchester UK SHO MBChB N/G





11 N/C Mike Dromey Chester UK CH4 7DR BMBS N/G

10 N/C Subarna Chakravorty London UK Consultant MBBS PhD N/G

9 N/C Sarah Blundell Doncaster UK Paediatric Surgery

ST4

MRCS View

8 N/C Therese Walsh Liverpool UK Anaesthetist spr Frca N/G

7 N/C Aude Gatignol Liverpool UK Medical SpR MD View

6 N/C Christian Harkensee Newcastle

upon Tyne

UK Consultant

paediatrician

MD PhD MSc

FRCPCH

View

5 N/C Michelle Romachney Abergele UK SAS dr Mb ChB N/G

4 N/C John Spencer Newcastle UK GP FRCGP N/G

3 N/C annemarie mitchell Auckland New

Zealand

ITU consultant CICM View

2 N/C Gordon Caldwell Worthing UK Consultant Physician MB BS FRCP

London

View

1 N/C Dr David Nicholl Hagley UK Consultant

Neurologist

FRCP N/G

* N/C - field not collected by the author

* N/G - not given by the signer

* S/C/P - State, County or Province

* Question 1 - Profession (ie GP, Consultant (specialty) and/or grade (eg SpR); Lawyer; Nurse

* Question 2 - University Degree or Qualifications? (FRCP, QC, etc)...just one please!

* View - view comment




Appendix: All signatures comments

786 Mark Prescott Back to signature list

The lessons we learn by our mistakes are usually never forgotten

785 Benjamin Stenson Back to signature list

Strongly in favour of systems improvement and not punishment of trainee doctors unless there is clear evidence of wilfulnegligence or other irresponsible behaviour

784 Andrew Carr Back to signature list

I left the UK because I could see how ineffective this regulator had become in balancing accountability with safetyimprovement. How many more will leave? Appalling.

775 Sultan Sabri Back to signature list

This is a prime example of injustice, depravity and wickedness of extreme right-wing GMC .who should be held toaccount for their actions in this case.

771 Aabha Sharma Back to signature list

Consultant should have acted on the bloods and didn't need a trainee to tell him the significance of a low ph and highlactate.

761 Eric Watts Back to signature list

We need constructive error management looking at all contributory factors

736 S Faiz Back to signature list

Dr Bawa-Garba has accepted the mistakes she made which led to the tragic death of a child. She should not be heldresponsible for the systemic failures of an under-resourced NHS.

735 Muhammad Asif Back to signature list

I always had doubts about this case.In a busy hospital understaffed junior doctors are forced to make decisions withoutproper time to assess patients.There should be a limit to how many patients you can see safely and if you are made todeal with more patients whole management should be jointly responsible with the doctor.

726 Najmus Aslam Back to signature list

Professional concern must be dealt with professionals who understand the Miriad of factors at play . Dr Hadiza is beingmade a scapegoat for a previous poor system which has since been amended. The media has sensationalised a casewhich is tragic but a mistake of systematic errors. Either everyone on duty that night is sentenced accordingly or itappears that race , gender and religious discrimination will win.

723 Geoff Gill Back to signature list

This appears a system rather than personal failure. The GMC should also abide with the 12 month erasure decision.

716 Fiona Paterson Back to signature list




Very concerned that reflective document was used against her in court. This will deter honest discussion.

715 Donal Duffy Back to signature list

To find Dr Bawa-Garba guilty and address the structural and systemic faults is a failure for patients.

713 Philip Abraham Back to signature list

This case raises once again serious questions about GMCs treatment of ethnic minority doctors in UK

708 Dinakar Unnithan Back to signature list

Fairness is paramount

703 Wendy Savage Back to signature list

To strike a good doctor off the register for one honest mistake particularly when there were system failings is wrong Thisdoes not protect the public or recognise the difficulties doctors work under,

694 Susan Gilby Back to signature list

In order to foster a safety culture in the NHS we need to foster openness and honesty recognising human factors andsystem failures.

692 LATA NAIR Back to signature list

It is difficult to comment without knowing how culpable this young doctor isThe GMC is keen to apply the letter of the law in case of foreign doctors. It is good to see the paediatric communitystanding together at a time like this.In general practice where ethnic doctors work alone in deprived areas, it is very difficult to get this range of support. Ihope this landmark case opens the eyes of the nation to the gross injustice meted put to the doctorslike Hadiza

688 Bernadette Rae Back to signature list

This is scape-goating. Ignoring systematic failures of others that they have already corrected is not a representation ofwhat actually happened. Donâ€™t persecute Dr Bawa-Garba.

680 Ashley Woodcock Back to signature list

Return to blame culture will be disastrous for patients and healthcare workers

674 Godwin Oligbu Back to signature list

This is a gross injustice and Iâ€™m beginning to think that there is element of racial discrimination here. This is an errorand not intentionally.

673 Andrew Bush Back to signature list

Totally support this

672 Richard Nicholl Back to signature list

GMC must review how it addresses "honest failure".




A first step might be accepting ,rather than appealing ,decisions made by the Medical Practitioner Tribunal Service."

665 Bridget Catterall Back to signature list

I am also very concerned about the nurse who has already been struck off.

661 SYED Mehdi Back to signature list

She should be offered further traing and not Removed from Register.

659 Asha Dev Back to signature list

Her name should not be erased from GMC please

650 Syed Haq Back to signature list

I support this petition

648 Gary Foley Back to signature list

The GMC must not resort to blame culture when concerns are raised regarding patient safety and system errors areovertly recognised.

624 Dr Suad Hirsi-Farah Back to signature list

No health professional intentionally harms anyone. We all need to learn from tragedies. So address the training needs.

622 Justin Joseph Back to signature list

I m sure there is more civilized way of looking at and solving this problem.

610 Younus Saleem Back to signature list

C

606 Rafi Khan Back to signature list

The GMC should allow Dr Bawa-Garba, to continue to practice under the terms recommended by the MedicalPractitioners Tribunal Service.Please stop criminalising doctors.

603 Ildiko Schuller Back to signature list

A young doctor should be able to be supported and be able to redeem themselves, they will never make the samemistake again.

600 Himanshu Singh Back to signature list

GMC is acting unfairly above the MPTSThere is already dearth of doctors in Acute specialties like ED, obstetrics, Pediatrics, Medicine etc outside of majorhospitals. This will clearly damage the public ultimately.

595 Ashwani Kapila Back to signature list




We want justice and not revenge.

575 Sanjay S.k Back to signature list

Such legal action will have adverse effects on future medical practice and future medical aspirants .

573 Bapu Sathyajith Back to signature list

Junior doctor being crucified for systemic failures. Typical case of target the easiest prey while corrupt sharks hidebehind policies and power. Hypocrisy is thy name GMC ?

566 Piyusha Kapila Back to signature list

I support Dr Bawa-Garba and feel she has been treated unfairly

554 Akwasi Osei-Yeboah Back to signature list

I worked under her as a junior doctor and I can attest she is an excellent clinician.

533 Sher Anjum Back to signature list

We suppprt our colleague

530 Anya Leiva Back to signature list

I am a GP on a career break and it is precisely the fear of something like this happening to me that is deterring me fromreturning to practice. I feel it is impossible not to make mistakes whilst working under the current pressures and resourceconstraints within the NHS.

528 A R Moodambail Back to signature list

Do justice to Dr Bawa-Garba and medical profession

518 Bipin Patel Back to signature list

This injustice must not be allowed to materialise

516 Assid Jaleel Back to signature list

Please reinstate this Drs GMC so she can practice.

514 Tharayil Suresh Back to signature list

A case that deserves support of all doctors

513 Paul Inasu Back to signature list

I believe that the failures of the system should be a key mitigation while considering the allegations against Dr.Bawa-Garba

507 Cassandra Gyamtso Back to signature list

I agree that there was multiple failures in the system processes and communication and not completely one individual's




fault or that at any point the doctor concerned was intent on causing harm.

506 Gayle Hann Back to signature list

In a profession already struggling to keep our trainees, errors should not cause permanent exclusion from the register iftrainees can be shown to have been otherwise meeting all their competencies especially when their are deficiencieswithin the corporate structure

502 Rajendra Chaudhary Back to signature list

The GMC is made of legal robots which lack AI.

498 Dr Meena Virdi Back to signature list

To target a junior Doctor for systems failure is to claim false justice

495 Thushara Stanly Back to signature list

Letâ€™s not penalise junior doctors for their lack of support and supervision in NHS.Its not their fault . When I trained innhs there was plenty of doctors including seniors on the wards . Now itâ€™s less and everyon knows that would affectthe care . Letâ€™s not scapegoat her. Letâ€™s not damage a noble profession .i want my children to become doctorsin future but I am scared for their life and future .

492 VIJAY KUDARI Back to signature list

Racism

490 Andrew Cummin Back to signature list

"Continue to practice" should read "continue to practise"

489 Karen Johns Back to signature list

In a arena where honesty candour and a an assumption of a â€˜blame freeâ€™ culture where does this relentlessuseless victimisation of a doctor fit?

477 Muhammad Mukhtar Back to signature list

Shouldnâ€™t be removed from GMC register

474 Salim Ahammed Back to signature list

Need thorough investigation of any system failure and be fair

468 Amal Hashi Back to signature list

ALL clinicians will remember a mistake in their practise. We see multiple cases of never events/incidents in the nhs EVERYDAY- with sincere regret to those affected.The good however heavily overweighs the bad. Overall her years of clinical practise has been commendable.Its a travesty to remove her from the workforce. We can only learn and better ourselves. Teaching and reflecting from our error is what has improves medical practise.




464 Prem Mahadun Back to signature list

Victimising the victim of the system is not right.

463 Joanna Galbraith Back to signature list

Awful treatment. Address system failures before blaming a human.

461 Ramasamyiyere Swaminathan Back to signature list

It is wrong to victimize this junior doctor , when it is the system which failed.

455 Janani Devaraja Back to signature list

Do not blame one person for the failings of many

450 Kim Holt Back to signature list

The focus on any investigation needs to be on learning. Sometimes individuals are negligent but where there aremultiple systemic issues even the best clinicians might fail. Fairness encourages real learning .

447 Mayur Patel Back to signature list

One person, especially a trainee should not be blamed for this systematic failure.

444 Tony Whitfield Back to signature list

Save the NHS

443 Jenny Vaughan Back to signature list

http://www.manslaughterandhealthcare.org.uk/

429 BECKY JONES Back to signature list

As a trainee biochemist we rely on the support from our line manager. From the BMJ article, it seems that this youngdoctor communicated the abnormal blood gas results to her superior during the handover.

423 Mark Taylor Back to signature list

This will hamper the safety culture many of us are trying to create. Penalising junior doctors who are acutely out of theirdepth, have appropriately asked for help, and are then let down by multiple system failures amounts to cruel andinhuman treatment (this defines torture under ECHR) and will lead to a lack of candour and missed opportunities forlearning/improvement

414 Sophie Nocton Back to signature list

The further the GMC goes with prosecuting individuals, rather than investigating systemic failures, the more rapidlyDoctors will leave medicine in the UK.

405 Bangalore Satish Back to signature list

GMC should realise that doctors are working under extreme pressure. Rather punish an individual, they should help




rectify the system. These tragic errors are bound to happen if GMC continues in its punitive pursuit.

402 Hafsah Hassan Gwarzo Back to signature list

One mistake should not terminate the Doctor's Career. Justice and equality for patients and medical practitioners alike!

400 Ian O'Sullivan Back to signature list

The direction of persecution from the GMC will lead to the collapse of medicine in the UK.

396 Angharad Spencer Back to signature list

A culture of openness and addressing system errors is key to improving patient safety. This case risks reversing allprogress made in this regard.

392 Rahmatu Ahmed Back to signature list

Please allow Hadiza continue her practice.

389 Huseinat Usman-Folorunsho Back to signature list

Justice must prevail

387 Jay Ilangaratne Back to signature list

Law needs changing as to manslaughter by gross negligence: case law does not reflect contribution of system failuresbut designed to target an individual only. A point for Supreme Court to decide.

385 Obedat Olajide Back to signature list

Professional services is to care, God heals. The death of everyone comes from God Almighty alone. No human isperfect, not even the Jury. Please spare Dr. Bawa-Garba of this conviction.

384 Hauwa Garba Back to signature list

We need justice and fairness

383 Awais Mir Back to signature list

This lady has suffered enough and appears to be an otherwise excellent doctor. Please let her get on with her life andget on with treating patients. This could have happened to any of us. Condolences to the boyâ€™s family too, my son died of sepsis in 2013 as well

382 Samantha Gordon Back to signature list

The case for gross negligence manslaughter is non-existent and should be subject to judicial review. That the GMCcontinue to pursue this woman in the face of the MPTS judgement is a disgrace. It cannot be a coincidence that thisdoctor is a black woman and the targetting of black and ethnic minority doctors by the GMC and others must stop.

377 Eleanor Jones Back to signature list

A trainee in a difficult environment can not be used as a scapegoat for the failings of a whole system.




375 Rukinder Birk Back to signature list

When will Management start being held accountable for serious incidents such as this, where failings in managingresources lead to human error and deaths.

371 Aida Jawhari Back to signature list

Persecuting doctors for genuine error, whilst working in a complex often flawed system will only worsen morale,recruitment and retention of doctors and will not improve safety for patients.

368 Saad Azhar Back to signature list

Chronic staff shortages mean that the current workforce are overstretched. By doing the job of potentially two or morepeople there is a higher chance of mistakes being made. Doctors should be supported through this process rather thanscrutinised and shamed publicly.

367 Emily Burns Back to signature list

Deeply concerned for this trainee and nurse, as well as for future patient safety to see what appears to be 'taking downthe vulnerable/easy targets' amongst a string of contributors to this tragic death.

362 Nadia Wahid Back to signature list

There were a catalogue of failings in this case, it's is indeed a great shame that the finger was pointed at one personand not on the trust who failed both the medical Team and the patient

359 Hauwa Sadiq Back to signature list

SirI hope the GMC will look into this letter and

355 Hadya Parinitha Back to signature list

Striking Dr. Bawa-Garba is certainly not in the best interest of GMC, neither is it any form of justice. Changes to avoidsystem failure is the solution rather than individualised blaming. This will restore confidence in professionals, who workvery hard to deliver and also in patients, who put their trust in the healthcare system.

351 Natalia Albu Back to signature list

Not fair not right!

347 Sandia George Back to signature list

This is so utterly tragic and unfair.

346 John Paul Leach Back to signature list

Systems failure should not impel personal blame

345 Maria Pan Back to signature list

shocking to see a reflective piece being used again someone in the court of law when we are being encouraged astrainees to relfect openly and learn from our mistakes and improve this is shockingly encouraging a blane culture




332 Hamid Aboubakar Back to signature list

Since i know Hadija Bawa she is excelent doctor

325 Haoua Hamid dabo Alfaki Back to signature list

Hadiza Bawa has always been an exelent doctor

318 Katrina Clark Back to signature list

An appalling decision by the GMC. Why would any young person want to enter this profession in light of such treatment.

312 S Srinivasan Back to signature list

Please stop scape goating hardworking nurses doctors & healthcare & allied professionals & show some resolve tosolve the real issues...overworked staff.working under challenging circumstances....less resources on the shopfloor inthe name of cost cutting ..surely the plea of so many people signing the petition cannot & should not be ignored & GMCneeds to start living upto its own standards of supporting doctors as per it's tagline! !!

295 Jerina Rich Back to signature list

We are doctors in the making, we are not God. We will make mistakes and fall victims of system failures from time totime. It is what we do with our mistakes that makes us good consultants of the future. What GMC is currently doing, is actually frightening and the fact that I pay a fee every year to this institution, makes me feellike I am sponsoring it, which is disappointing.

288 Nurudeen Binuyo Back to signature list

Supporting the position that the GMC withdraws its legal action against Dr. Bawa-Garba.

274 Jannah Leon-Maurice Back to signature list

As a junior doctor, she canâ€™t be expected to carry the van for those of senior rank and experience. This is cruelvictimisation of a black woman.

268 Lateefat Junaid Back to signature list

The decision by the GMC to appeal the Tribunal's verdict amount to witch-hunting in my humble opinion. This is likethrowing away the baby with the birth water. GMC should be supporting their trainees and members to address thesystemic failures in the NHS for a better and safer practice. The whole system needs a huge overhauling.

265 Sarah Wookey Back to signature list

How can we improve the care we give to patients if we are too frightened to admit to mistakes?And why single out one individual for blame when this event arose from errors in many systems?

264 Maryam Marafa Back to signature list

The GMC should cease scapegoating Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba.

263 Alice Hodkinson Back to signature list

This could happen to any doctor. We all see death and we all sometimes make tragic errors. If we want to provide a




safer service then we need to be able to discuss what went wrong and how to improve it without scapegoats, withoutblame and with openness. While any one of us could be charged and convicted of manslaughter doctors will instinctivelytry to protect themselves so there will not be the openness that we need.

262 Fiaz Farooq Back to signature list

It is not appropriate to deny the public the services of a doctor who helped thousands of people just because they madea mistake.

260 Mehwesh Qureshi Back to signature list

A sincere, hardworking, compassionate doctor cannot be made a scapegoat for the system failing- the system isdangerous and needs to be corrected before other tragedies occur.

251 Jo Wright Back to signature list

Everyone sign this & try to prevent the loss of an amazing doctor

238 Kerry Jeevananthan Back to signature list

The whole process is very unjust in todayâ€™s society and the GMC like a dog with a bone. I really feel for this youngdoctor who is undoubtedly in pieces about the death of this child but also unfairly treated as the â€˜messengerâ€™ ofthe healthcare system failures that the GMC must feel they need to shoot down. This would resolve nothing for futuretrainees. Fix the system, not blame individuals.

230 David Drew Back to signature list

Current systems set doctors up to fail. GMC should support doctors who recognise their errors not perpetuate the blameculture. They are acting against the interests of patients and doctors.

226 Anita Annakesavan Back to signature list

I have left Surgery because I didn't feel the system/ Seniors supported me as a junior doctor. It is the same system stillat work.

219 Ganapathiram Lakshmanan Back to signature list

It is unfortunate that GMC is being vindictive even after excellent feedback from colleagues about this doctor. This is innobody's interest and will have longterm consequences for all stakeholders involved.

211 Suresh Pillai Back to signature list

Please see the bigger picture

210 Makani Purva Back to signature list

We need to be united in supporting

206 Wee Haan Pang Back to signature list

Unacceptable treatment and decision from a union that is meant to fight for the rights of its member and to treat itsmember fair and square




201 Sangeeta Tiwary Back to signature list

Learn not Blame!

200 Antonia Lile Back to signature list

This Dr has not been treated fairly. I request that all the facts and factors contributing to this case are considered I wouldhope that Dr Bawa-Garba is not blamed for factors outside her control working a demanding and failing system.

199 Sanjay Vydianath Back to signature list

Please stop this injustice

198 Josephine Drew Back to signature list

Learn not blame please

196 Neeta Ray Chaudhuri Back to signature list

GMC I believe is institutionally racist and has many more rulings against ethnic minirities

191 Siobhan Quinn Back to signature list

Do not blame the individual for the system failures. The nhs needs to be funded properly if we are to prevent this tragedybeing repeated.

186 Mohammed Wakaas Back to signature list

Unfair to be used as a scapegoat.

183 Sunil Nair Back to signature list

Please Stop scapegoating junior doctors working in acute specialties. Look at the difficult circumstances they work in.We are at further eroding the attraction for acute specialties by these actions.

181 Cherian George Back to signature list

We are human beings and we make mistakes. Erasure from the medical register has to be a well balanced and rightdecision and if not the GMC is being unfair and biased. GMC has to look after the interests of both patients and doctors.

153 Stephanie Harrison Back to signature list

I think this is disgraceful that you are continuing to victimise this dr for the many errors that have been discussed above.Please stop.

150 Tim Wright Back to signature list

It's a disgrace that this caring Doctor is being made a scapegoat for systemic failings caused by chronic underfunding ofthe NHS.

145 Roya Dabestani Back to signature list

Clearly scapegoating a trainee Dr for the failings of the system - disgraceful and it certainly doesnâ€™t encourage me to




work within this system again !

128 Beenish Ashraf Back to signature list

I am absolutely disgusted at how this doctor is being punished and made a example of when there were many otherfailings within the NHS system.

127 Katie McDowell Back to signature list

Absolutely unacceptable that a doctor should be punished for systemic failures and chronic underfunding in the NHS

118 Shankar Kashyap Back to signature list

It's typical of GMC to behave as such. It had done in the past and will continue to do so in the future because of thestatutory powers it has been given and non medical people have taken charge. Read my book :A Kangaroo Court"!!

113 Suhair Shebani Back to signature list

GMC duties to protect guide and retrain doctors and treat them with fairness avoiding heavy handed punshiment thatmight satisfy the media on the short term but will have a long lasting damage to the medical profession This young doctor was an outstanding character a well trained loving and caring doctor she cannot be punished for thesystem failure

98 Mina Endeley Back to signature list

Learning not blame. It is impossible for a single trainee in a hospital to be responsible for this!

96 Catherine McGrath Back to signature list

Shame on you GMC. Judge, just and executioner in one step.

93 Lin Pan Back to signature list

This is against everything I have ever been taught througout my career. It is extremely disheartening to learn that GMCis so determined to find a scapegoat for what is clearly a system failure.

92 Antigoni Koukkoulli Back to signature list

I have worked for the NHS for 13 years and I am disappointed by the unfair treatment this poor doctor has beenreceiving. The GMC is certainly not fit for purpose! Doctors should not be made to pay for it.

87 Sonal Kapoor Back to signature list

Gmc should reconsider its decision as it is affecting all the doctors mentally and no one will ever want to join thisspecialty after this injustice!!

83 Suzanne Hale Back to signature list

Suzanne Hale

64 Ram Nagaruru Venkata Back to signature list

In appropriate for GMC to do this and should support doctors like CPSA in Alberta does. CPSA supports doctors and




helps them to settle

57 Ejiro Eyaru Back to signature list

Please spare this doctor

55 Martyn Traves Back to signature list

Justice must prevail

39 Muhammad Murtaza Back to signature list

this is typical example of scape goating

32 Afrah Al- Maliki Back to signature list

For a junior doctor itâ€™s injustice to give this decision

23 Dr Naomi Eastwood Back to signature list

#thiscouldhavebeenmetoo

21 Adnan Zafar Back to signature list

Hadeeza should not have her name erased from register.

She should be allowed to return to work in supervised settings.

18 Tejumola Olaoye Back to signature list

I believe that this is a witch hunt following a very sad event. This doctor did not set out to harm a patient, and did not doso through the sole daily of her own. Use your energy more appropriate and pursue the government for allowing us towork in such circumstances, due to underfunding and under staffing, that encourages mistakes being made.

15 Umesh Prabhu Back to signature list

No doctor should be punished so severely for systems failure. No doctor should be punished for others mistakes. Nodoctor should be sent to prison when there are systems failures. No junior doctor should be punished for seniors failureto supervise or to protect them.

9 Sarah Blundell Back to signature list

Grossly unfair and inappropriate treatment by the GMC

7 Aude Gatignol Back to signature list

Totally unfair

6 Christian Harkensee Back to signature list

I fully support this letter!

3 annemarie mitchell Back to signature list




there but for the grace of God walks every Doctor who has ever done an on call shift in the under resourced publicsystem.

2 Gordon Caldwell Back to signature list

If the GMC wins this case it will be an injustice to Dr Bawa Garba, the end of Duty of Candour and set patient safetyback 20 years in the UK




petition: letter to the media re gmc and dr hadiza bawa-garba · letter to the media re gmc and dr...

Documents