8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

1/83

@KGFBK IGVUM GJ \VBJT^BVEJDQ BJL E_DOBJ@E

GI AJIGVMB\AGJ IGV \B_ ^UV^GTET

^eev Veyaep Ve~gv|Dgmfajel8 ^obte 2 # ^obte 6

ATKE GI MBJ

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

2/83

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

3/83

@kgfbk Igvumgj \vbjt~bvejdq

bjl Exdobj`egi Ajigvmb|agj igv \bx

^uv~gtet ^eev Veyaept8Atke gi Mbj 6>22

DGMFAJEL8 ^OBTE 2 # ^OBTE 6

Huje 6>22/veiked|aj` |oe ke`bk bjl ve`ukb|gvq ivbmepgvc

bt b| Hbjubvq 6>22!

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

4/83

\oat pgvc at ~ufkatoel gj |oe vet~gjtafaka|q gi |oe Tedve|bvq-@ejevbk gi |oe GEDL*

\oe g~ajagjt ex~vettel bjl bv`umej|t em~kgqel oeveaj lg jg| jedettbvakq veiked|

|oe giiadabk yaept gi |oe GEDL gv gi |oe `gyevjmej|t gi a|t memfev dguj|vaet gv

|ogte gi |oe @kgfbk Igvum gj \vbjt~bvejdq bjl Exdobj`e gi Ajigvmb|agj igv \bx

^uv~gtet*

ATFJ 10?-16-9228 Dgmfajel8 ^obte 2 # ^obte 6+ @kgfbk Igvum gj \vbjt~bvejdq bjl

Exdobj`e gi Ajigvmb|agj igv \bx uv~gtet8 eev Veyaept+ GEDL ^ufkatoaj`*

o||~8''lx*lga*gv`'2>*20?0'10?169>6-ej

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

5/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

\BFKE GI DGJ\EJ\T 4

\bfke gi Dgj|ej|t

Bfgu| |oe @kgfbk Igvum * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 5

Exedu|aye tummbvq * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 0

Aj|vglud|agj * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 1

Ajigvmb|agj bjl me|oglgkg`q utel igv |oe ~eev veyaep gi |oe Atke gi Mbj* * * * * * 1Gyevyaep gi |oe Atke gi Mbj* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 2>@ejevbk ajigvmb|agj gj |oe ke`bk tqt|em bjl |oe |bxb|agj tqt|em * * * * * * * * * * * *22Vedej| leyekg~mej|t * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 24

Dgm~kabjde pa|o |oe T|bjlbvlt * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 25

B* Bybakbfaka|q gi Ajigvmb|agj * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 25

Gyevyaep * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 25B*2* Gpjevtoa~ bjl alej|a|q ajigvmb|agj * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *20B*6* Bddguj|aj` vedgvlt * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 46B*4* Fbjcaj` ajigvmb|agj * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 49

F* Bddett |g Ajigvmb|agj * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

6/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

< \BFKE GI DGJ\EJ\T

Tummbvq gi Le|evmajb|agjt bjl Ibd|gvt Ujlevkqaj` Vedgmmejlb|agjt* * * * 91

Bjjex 28 Huvatlad|agjt Vet~gjte |g |oe Veyaep Ve~gv| * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 04

Bjjex 68 Kat| gi bkk Exdobj`e-gi-Ajigvmb|agj Medobjatmt aj Igvde * * * * * * * * 022

BFGU\ \OE @KGFBK IGVUM 5

Bfgu| |oe @kgfbk Igvum

\oat lgdumej| at dgjialej|abk bjl ~vg~vae|bvq |g GEDL* Bjq ujbu|ogv-atel latdkgtuve+ ute gv lattemajb|agj+ ea|oev pogke gv ~bv|abk+ gi |oat lgdumej|at ~vgoafa|el*

\oe @kgfbk Igvum gj \vbjt~bvejdq bjl Exdobj`e gi Ajigvmb|agj igv \bx

^uv~gtet at |oe muk|akb|evbk ivbmepgvc pa|oaj poado pgvc aj |oe bveb gi |bx|vbjt~bvejdq bjl exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj at dbvvael gu| fq gyev 2>> huvatlad-|agjt+ poado ~bv|ada~b|e aj |oe @kgfbk Igvum gj bj erubk igg|aj`*

\oe @kgfbk Igvum at dobv`el pa|o aj-le~|o mgja|gvaj` bjl ~eev veyaep gi|oe am~kemej|b|agj gi |oe aj|evjb|agjbk t|bjlbvlt gi |vbjt~bvejdq bjl exdobj`egi ajigvmb|agj igv |bx ~uv~gtet* \oete t|bjlbvlt bve ~vambvakq veiked|el aj |oe6>>6 GEDL Mglek B`veemej| gj Exdobj`e gi Ajigvmb|agj gj \bx Mb||evtbjl a|t dgmmej|bvq+ bjl aj Bv|adke 69 gi |oe GEDLMglek \bx Dgjyej|agj gjAjdgme bjl gj Db~a|bkbjl a|t dgmmej|bvq bt u~lb|el aj 6>>

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

8/83

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

9/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

E_EDU\AYE TUMMBVQ 0

Exedu|aye tummbvq

2* \oat ve~gv| tummbvatet |oe ke`bk bjl ve`ukb|gvq ivbmepgvc igv|vbjt~bvejdq bjl exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj aj |oe Atke gi Mbj bt pekk bt ~vbd-|adbk am~kemej|b|agj gi |ob| ivbmepgvc* \oe aj|evjb|agjbk t|bjlbvl poado

at te| gu| aj |oe @kgfbk Igvumt \evmt gi Veievejde |g Mgja|gv bjl Veyaep^vg`vett \gpbvlt \vbjt~bvejdq bjl Exdobj`e gi Ajigvmb|agj+ at dgjdevjelpa|o |oe bybakbfaka|q gi vekeybj| ajigvmb|agj pa|oaj b huvatlad|agj+ |oe dgm~e-|ej| bu|ogva|qt bfaka|q |g `baj |amekq bddett |g |ob| ajigvmb|agj+ bjl aj |uvj+poe|oev |ob| ajigvmb|agj dbj fe eiied|ayekq exdobj`el pa|o a|t exdobj`e giajigvmb|agj ~bv|jevt*

6* \oe ke`bk bjl ve`ukb|gvq ivbmepgvc igv |oe bybakbfaka|q gi ajigvmb-|agj aj |oe Atke gi Mbj at aj ~kbde* Gpjevtoa~ bjl alej|a|q ajigvmb|agj atmbaj|bajel fq vekeybj| ej|a|aet bjl bvvbj`emej|t* Aj blla|agj+ |oat ajigvmb-|agj at tgme|amet iakel pa|o `gyevjmej|bk bu|ogva|aet gv oekl fq tevyade~vgyalevt ~uvtubj| |g bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` vuket* \oe `ejevbk ve`ukb|gvqejyavgjmej| aj |oe Atke gi Mbj at dgm~veoejtaye bjl+ ~bv|adukbvkq igv bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` ~uv~gtet+ bkk mbhgv iajbjdabk ted|gv ajlut|vaet bve tuf-hed| |g bd|aye gyevta`o| leta`jel |g ejtuve |ob| ~vgdettet igv dut|gmev luelaka`ejde bjl |oe mbaj|ejbjde gi b~~vg~vab|e |vbjtbd|agjbk ajigvmb|agj bveigkkgpel*

4* \oe ~gpev gi |oe Atke gi Mbj |bx bu|ogva|aet |g gf|baj ajigvmb|agjigv exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj ~uv~gtet aj |bx mb||evt at dkebv* Ebdo exdobj`egi ajigvmb|agj bvvbj`emej| at fvgu`o| aj|g igvde fq bj gvlev gi \qjpbkl

|ob| ~vgyalet |ob| |oe bvvbj`emej| tobkk obye eiied| jg|pa|ot|bjlaj` bjqg|oev ejbd|mej|+ bjl poado mglaiaet |oe fbtad bddett ~gpevt dgj|bajel aj|oe Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210> |g ejtuve |ob| |oeq b~~kq igv |oe ~uv~gtet gi |oebvvbj`emej|*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

10/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

? E_EDU\AYE TUMMBVQ

dkbam |g |oete exde~|agjt* \oe Atke gi Mbj togukl veyaep a|t ~gkadq ve`bvl-aj` bddett |g ajigvmb|agj oekl fq ke`bk blyatevt+ |bx blyatevt bjl bula|gvtbjl ejtuve |ob| a| at dgm~b|afke pa|o eiied|aye exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj bjlvedgvl bjl dgj|ajue |g mgja|gv veruet|t igv ajigvmb|agj poeve |oete vuket bve

am~kadb|el*

5* \oe Atke gi Mbj obt feej exdobj`aj` ajigvmb|agj aj bddgvlbjde pa|o|oe aj|evjb|agjbk t|bjlbvlt tajde a|t iavt| |bx ajigvmb|agj exdobj`e b`vee-mej|t dbme aj|g igvde aj 6>>9* Bk|ogu`o |oat at b vekb|ayekq togv| ~evagl+ex~evaejde |g lb|e togpt |ob| exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj obt feej eiied|aye bjlex~ela|agut* \oe Atke gi Mbj jgp obt medobjatmt igv |oe exdobj`e gi ajigv-mb|agj aj |bx mb||evt |ob| mee| |oe t|bjlbvl aj igvde pa|o 20 huvatlad|agjt bjlat bd|ayekq ej`b`el aj je`g|ab|agjt igv iuv|oev b`veemej|t* \oe Atke gi Mbjobt bktg exdobj`el ajigvmb|agj pa|o |oe Uja|el Caj`lgm |ovgu`o b lgufke

|bx bvvbj`emej| tajde |oe 215>t /|ogu`o |oe tdg~e gi ajigvmb|agj exdobj`elpbt kama|el! bjl+ aj dvamajbk |bx mb||evt+ obt exdobj`el ajigvmb|agj pa|objq huvatlad|agj /ve`bvlkett gi |oe exat|ejde gi bj aj|evjb|agjbk b`veemej|!|ovgu`o a|t lgmet|ad Dvamajbk Hut|ade Bd|t tajde |oe ebvkq 211>t*

9* \oe ieelfbdc ~vgyalel fq |oe Atke gi Mbjt ajigvmb|agj exdobj`e~bv|jevt at yevq ~gta|aye* \oe ajigvmb|agj veruet|el at ~vgyalel ruadckq bjlexdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj ~bv|jevt bve b~~vedab|aye gi |oe g~ej bjl |vbjt~bvej|vekb|agjtoa~ |oeq obye pa|o |oe Atke gi Mbj dgm~e|ej| bu|ogva|q*

0* \oe dgm~e|ej| bu|ogva|q at aj |oe ~vbd|ade gi ajigvmaj` |oe Iajbjdabk

Dvame Uja| /IDU! gi |oe ibd| |ob| bj Atke gi Mbj |bx~bqev /e*`* bj Atke gi Mbjvedgvl-cee~ev aj ~gttettagj gi ajigvmb|agj |ob| at |oe tufhed| gi bj ajigvmb-|agj exdobj`e veruet|! at |oe tufhed| gi b veruet| aj b dvamajbk dbte* \oe Atkegi Mbj bu|ogva|aet dgjtalev |ob| latdkgtuve |g |oe IDU aj |oete davdumt|bjdetat aj bddgvlbjde pa|o |oe |evmt gi a|t exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj b`veemej|t* A|at ~gttafke+ ogpeyev+ |ob| a|t \AEB ~bv|jevt mbq jg| tobve |oat aj|ev~ve|b|agj*Aj |oete davdumt|bjdet+ bjl |g bygal bjq ujdev|baj|q gv matujlevt|bjlaj` aj|oat ve`bvl+ latdkgtuve |g |oe IDU togukl jg| fe mble pa|ogu| |oe ex~vettpva||ej dgjtej| gi |oe ~bv|jev huvatlad|agj*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

11/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

AJ\VGLUD\AGJ 1

Aj|vglud|agj

Ajigvmb|agj bjl me|oglgkg`q utel igv |oe ~eev veyaep gi |oe Atke gi Mbj

?* \oe bttettmej| gi |oe ke`bk bjl ve`ukb|gvq ivbmepgvc gi |oe Atke giMbj bjl |oe ~vbd|adbk am~kemej|b|agj bjl eiied|ayejett gi |oat ivbmepgvcpbt fbtel gj |oe aj|evjb|agjbk t|bjlbvlt igv |vbjt~bvejdq bjl exdobj`e giajigvmb|agj bt letdvafel aj |oe @kgfbk Igvumt \evmt gi Veievejde+ bjl pbt~ve~bvel utaj` |oe @kgfbk Igvumt Me|oglgkg`q igv ^eev Veyaept bjl Jgj-Memfev Veyaept* \oe bttettmej| pbt fbtel gj |oe kbpt+ ve`ukb|agjt+ bjlexdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj medobjatmt aj igvde gv eiied| bt b| Hbjubvq6>22+g|oev ajigvmb|agj+ ex~kbjb|agjt bjl mb|evabkt tu~~kael fq |oe Atke gi Mbjluvaj` |oe gj-ta|e yata| |ob| |ggc ~kbde gj 2-4 Jgyemfev 6>2>+ bjl ajigvmb-|agj tu~~kael fq ~bv|jev huvatlad|agjt* Luvaj` |oe gj-ta|e yata|+ |oe bttettmej|

|ebm me| pa|o giiadabkt bjl ve~vetej|b|ayet gi |oe vekeybj| Atke gi Mbj ~ufkadb`ejdaet ajdkulaj` |oe Le~bv|mej| gi |oe \vebtuvq+ |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vqbjl |oe Iajbjdabk Tu~evyatagj Dgmmattagj*

1* \oe \evmt gi Veievejde fvebc lgpj |oe t|bjlbvlt gi |vbjt~bvejdqbjl exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj aj|g 2> ettej|abk ekemej|t bjl 42 ejumev-b|el bt~ed|t ujlev |ovee fvgbl db|e`gvaet8 /B! bybakbfaka|q gi ajigvmb|agj3/F! bddett |g ajigvmb|agj3 bjl /D! exdobj`aj` ajigvmb|agj* \oat dgmfajelveyaep bttettet |oe Atke gi Mbjt ke`bk bjl ve`ukb|gvq ivbmepgvc bjl |oeam~kemej|b|agj bjl eiied|ayejett gi |oat ivbmepgvc b`bajt| |oete ekemej|t

bjl ebdo gi |oe ejumevb|el bt~ed|t* Aj vet~ed| gi ebdo ettej|abk ekemej| ble|evmajb|agj at mble ve`bvlaj` |oe Atke gi Mbjt ke`bk bjl ve`ukb|gvq ivbme-pgvc |ob| ea|oev /a! |oe ekemej| at aj ~kbde+ /aa! |oe ekemej| at aj ~kbde fu|dev|baj bt~ed|t gi |oe ke`bk am~kemej|b|agj gi |oe ekemej| jeel am~vgyemej|+gv /aaa! |oe ekemej| at jg| aj ~kbde* \oete le|evmajb|agjt bve bddgm~bjael fqvedgmmejlb|agjt igv am~vgyemej| poeve vekeybj|* Aj blla|agj+ |g veiked| |oe^obte 6 dgm~gjej|+ vedgmmejlb|agjt bve bktg mble dgjdevjaj` |oe Atke giMbjt ~vbd|adbk b~~kadb|agj gi ebdo gi |oe ettej|abk ekemej|t* Bt gu|kajel aj|oe Jg|e gj Bttettmej| Dva|evab+ igkkgpaj` b huvatlad|agjt ^obte 6 veyaep+ bvb|aj` pakk fe b~~kael |g ebdo gi |oe ettej|abk ekemej|t |g veiked| |oe gyevbkk

~gta|agj gi b huvatlad|agj* Ogpeyev |oat vb|aj` pakk gjkq fe ~ufkatoel b| tudo

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

12/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

2> AJ\VGLUD\AGJ

|ame bt b ve~vetej|b|aye tufte| gi ^obte 6 veyaept at dgm~ke|el* \oat ve~gv||oeveigve ajdkulet vedgmmejlb|agjt aj vet~ed| gi |oe Atke gi Mbjt ke`bk bjlve`ukb|gvq ivbmepgvc bjl |oe bd|ubk am~kemej|b|agj gi |oe ettej|abk eke-mej|t+ bt pekk bt b le|evmajb|agj gj |oe ke`bk bjl ve`ukb|gvq ivbmepgvc+ fu|

a| lget jg| ajdkule b vb|aj` gi |oe ekemej|t*

2>* \oe bttettmej| pbt dgjlud|el fq b |ebm poado dgjtat|el gi |oveebttettgvt bjl b ve~vetej|b|aye gi |oe @kgfbk Igvum Tedve|bvab|8 Fvabj M*Obvvaj`|gj+ U*T* Aj|evjbk Veyejue Tevyade3 Ivelevadc T|vbutt+ U*T* Aj|evjbkVeyejue Tevyade3 Bj|ogjq Yekkb Kbuvej|a+ Majat|vq gi Iajbjde+ |oe Edgjgmqbjl Ajyet|mej| /Mbk|b!3 bjl Bjlvep Buevfbdo gi |oe @kgfbk Igvum Tedve|bvab|*

Gyevyaep gi |oe Atke gi Mbj

22* \oe Atke gi Mbj at bj atkbjl pa|o bj bveb gi b~~vgxamb|ekq 506 trubvecakgme|vet+ kgdb|el aj |oe Avato Teb+ bjl at yav|ubkkq erualat|bj| ivgm Avekbjlbjl |oe Uja|el Caj`lgm* \oe ke`bk tqt|em gi |oe Atke gi Mbj at Mbjx kbp*Mbjx kbp lb|et fbdc dej|uvaet3 bjl at ejbd|el bjl blmajat|evel fq \qjpbkl+|oe Atkbjlt ~bvkabmej|+ poado obt feej mee|aj` dgj|ajugutkq tajde 101 BL*B kbv`e ~bv| gi |oe fbtat gi |oe Mbjx kbp bjl ke`bk tqt|em at |oe Ej`kato kbpbjl ke`bk tqt|em+ ajdkulaj` |oe ~vajda~ket gi dgmmgj kbp* \oe Atke gi Mbj atb teki-`gyevjaj` le~ejlejdq gi |oe Fva|ato Dvgpj* A| at jg| ~bv| gi |oe Uja|elCaj`lgm gv |oe Euvg~ebj Ujagj+ bjl at jg| ve~vetej|el aj ea|oev |oe Uja|el

Caj`lgm gv Euvg~ebj ^bvkabmej|t* Uja|el Caj`lgm kbp lget jg| ex|ejl |g|oe Atke gi Mbj pa|ogu| |oe dgjtej| gi \qjpbkl* Rueej Ekabfe|o AA+ veievvel|g gj |oe Atkbjl bktg bt |oe Kgvl gi Mbjj+ at Oebl gi T|b|e* B Kaeu|ejbj|@gyevjgv at |oe Dvgpjt ~evtgjbk ve~vetej|b|aye gj |oe Atkbjl*

26* Aj vekb|agj |g |oe Atke gi Mbj+ |oe Uja|el Caj`lgm at vet~gjtafkeigv |ovee bvebt8 leiejde /igv poado |oe Atke gi Mbj ~bqt b iee!+ aj|evjb|agjbkvekb|agjt+ bjl uk|amb|e `ggl `gyevjbjde /|ob| at+ |oe Uja|el Caj`lgm `gy-evjmej| vetevyet |oe ~gpev |g aj|evyeje laved|kq aj |oe Atkbjlt biibavt ajdev|baj yevq kama|el davdumt|bjdet jbmekq b `vbye fvebclgpj gv ibakuveaj |oe blmajat|vb|agj gi hut|ade gv dayak gvlev!* B t|b|emej| bt vedej|kq btJgyemfev 6>2> fq |oe Uja|el Caj`lgm Majat|vq gi Hut|ade+2 poado ogklt|oe ~gkadq vet~gjtafaka|q igv |oe dgjt|a|u|agjbk vekb|agjtoa~ pa|o |oe Atke giMbj+ ajdkulel |oe igkkgpaj` dgmmej|8 Pe vet~ed| |oe va`o| gi |oe Dvgpj

Le~ejlejdaet |g teki-le|evmajb|agj bjl b`vee |ob| a| pgukl |bce b yevq teva-gut davdumt|bjde ajleel igv |oe UC `gyevjmej| |g dgj|em~kb|e gyevvalaj`|oete ~gpevt* \oe Uja|el Caj`lgmt vgke aj aj|evjb|agjbk vekb|agjt obt~gtel tgme dobkkej`et /e*`* poeve |oe g~evb|agj gi lgmet|ad |bx vuket obye

2* \oe iukk lgdumej| at b| ppp*hut|ade*`gy*uc'`gy-vet~gjte-hut|ade-teked|-dgmma||ee-

dvgpjle~ejlejdaet*~li*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

13/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

AJ\VGLUD\AGJ 22

aj|evjb|agjbk dobvbd|evat|adt!+ bjl gyev |ame+ |oe Atke gi Mbj obt exevdatel`veb|ev dgj|vgk gyev aj|evjb|agjbk |bx mb||evt* \oeve at jg mbt|ev b`veemej|gj ogp |oat pgvct8 vb|oev+ |oe ~vgdett at mble u~ gi b dgmfajb|agj gi ~vbd-|ade+ majat|evabk ke||evt bjl g|oev aj|evjb|agjbk ajt|vumej|t*

24* \oe Atke gi Mbj obt b ~g~ukb|agj6 gi ?> >5? bjl b yevq kgp ujem-~kgqmej| vb|e gi 6*4 ~evdej|* \oe Atke gi Mbj obl b @L^ gi @F^4 6*>4 fakkagj~gujlt aj 6>>0'>? bjl b @L^ ~ev db~a|b gi @F^ 6< 102 ~gujlt* \oe Atkegi Mbj edgjgmq le~ejlt mbajkq gj ajtuvbjde+ fbjcaj`+ iajbjde bjl futa-jett tevyadet+ bt pekk bt ~vgiettagjbk bjl tdaej|aiad tevyadet poado |g`e|oevbddguj| igv mgve |obj 9> ~evdej| gi a|t @L * \oe iajbjdabk tevyadet ted|gva|teki at mble u~ mbajkq gi le~gta|-|bcaj` ajt|a|u|agjt+ iujl tevyade ~vgyalevtbjl ajtuvbjde dgm~bjaet* G|oev mbhgv ted|gvt gi |oe edgjgmq ajdkule mbju-ibd|uvaj`+ ej`ajeevaj`+ dgjt|vud|agj bjl |oe ve|bak ted|gv* Aj |oe kbt| iep qebvt

jep edgjgmad bd|aya|aet obye feej leyekg~el+ tudo bt bavdvbi| ve`at|vb|agjbjl mgt| ta`jaiadbj|kq+ e-`bmaj` bjl g|oev bvebt gi e-dgmmevde*

@ejevbk ajigvmb|agj gj |oe ke`bk tqt|em bjl |oe |bxb|agj tqt|em

22> La`et| gi Edgjgmad bjl Tgdabk T|b|at|adt+ Edgjgmad

Biibavt Layatagj+ Atke gi Mbj \vebtuvq*

4* \oe Atke gi Mbj duvvejdq at |oe ~gujl t|evkaj`*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

14/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

26 AJ\VGLUD\AGJ

oebl gi |oe Ajdgme \bx Layatagj gi |oe Atke gi Mbj @gyevjmej|t \vebtuvqLe~bv|mej|*

29* Atke gi Mbj ajdgme |bx b~~kaet |g fg|o ajlayalubkt bjl dgm~bjaet3

|oeve at jg te~bvb|e tqt|em gi dgv~gvb|agj |bx* Vetalej| ~evtgjt bve |bxel gjpgvklpale ajdgme poake jgj-vetalej| ~evtgjt bve |bxel gjkq gj Atke gi Mbjtguvde ajdgme* B dgm~bjq at vetalej| aj |oe Atke gi Mbj igv |bx ~uv~gtet ai|oe dgm~bjq pbt igvmel ujlev Mbjx kbp gv a|t majl bjl mbjb`emej| bveexevdatel aj |oe Atke gi Mbj* Duvvej|kq+ |oe t|bjlbvl vb|e gi ajdgme |bx igvb vetalej| ajlayalubk at 2> ~evdej| bjl b oa`oev vb|e gi 6> ~evdej| b~~kaet |gajdgme aj exdett gi @F^ 2> 5>> /taj`ke ~evtgj! bjl @F^ 62 >>> /mbvvaeldgu~ke!* Atke gi Mbj |bx kbp bktg ~vgyalet igv ybvagut ~evtgjbk bkkgpbjdetbjl |bx lelud|agjt* Jgj-vetalej| ajlayalubkt bve kabfke |g ajdgme |bx gj|oeav Mbjx tguvde ajdgme exde~| igv ajdgme ebvjel ivgm dev|baj b~~vgyel

tguvdet+ igv exbm~ke Atke gi Mbj fbjc aj|evet|* \oe vb|e igv jgj-vetalej|t atbktg 6> ~evdej|* B |bx db~ b~~kaet aj vet~ed| gi |oe |bx kabfaka|q gi Mbjx veta-lej|t* \oat ~vgyalet igv b vetalej|t |bx kabfaka|q |g fe db~~el b| @F^ 225 >>>*

20* \oe t|bjlbvl ajdgme |bx vb|e igv fg|o vetalej| bjl jgj-vetalej| dgm-~bjaet at > ~evdej|* \oe t|bjlbvl vb|e `ejevbkkq b~~kaet |g bkk igvmt gi ajdgmevedeayel fq bkk dgm~bjaet exde~|8

b* kadejtel fbjct+ poado bve |bxel b| 2> ~evdej| gj ajdgme ivgm |oeavfbjcaj` futajett3 bjl

f* ajdgme levayel ivgm ke||aj` bjl leyekg~mej| gi vebk et|b|e+ majaj`bjl rubvvqaj`+ gi kbjl aj |oe Atke gi Mbj poado at |bxel b| 2> ~evdej|*

2?* Dgm~bjaet bve veruavel |g iake |bx ve|uvjt ve`bvlkett gi |oe ibd| |ob|jg |bx mbq fe gpaj`* \vblaj` dgm~bjaet tufhed| |g Mbjx ajdgme |bx b| |oet|bjlbvl > ~evdej| vb|e dbj eked| |g ~bq |bx b| |oe 2> ~evdej| vb|e*

Ve`ukb|gvq Ejyavgjmej|

21* \oe Atke gi Mbj obt b pale-vebdoaj` ve`ukb|gvq ivbmepgvc |ob| `gyevjta|t iajbjdabk tevyadet ajlut|vq* Futajettet mut| ejevbkkq fe bu|ogvatel bjltu~evyatel fq b `gyevjmej|bk bu|ogva|q+ poado pakk bktg ~vgyale bj|a-mgjeqkbujlevaj` bjl dguj|evaj` |evvgvat| iajbjdaj` gyevta`o| pa|o vet~ed| |g |ob|futajett* Le~gta| |bcevt bt pekk bt |ogte aj |oe ajyet|mej| futajett /tudo btt|gdc fvgcevt+ btte| mbjb`evt bjl iajbjdabk blyatevt! bve veruavel |g fe kadejtelujlev |oe Iajbjdabk Tevyadet Bd| 6>>?+ bjl bve tu~evyatel fq |oe IajbjdabkTu~evyatagj Dgmmattagj /|oe ITD!* \oeve bve 4< kadejtel fbjct aj |oe Atke giMbj+ dgjtat|aj` gi 6> ajdgv~gvb|el aj |oe Atkbjl bjl 2< poado bve fvbjdoet gigyevtebt fbjct* Gi |oe 6> ajdgv~gvb|el fbjct gjkq gje at jg| ~bv| gi b palevfbjcaj` `vgu~* B mbhgva|q gi fbjct bve ~bv| gi Uja|el Caj`lgm `vgu~t bjl|oeve bve bktg fbjct ivgm `vgu~t fbtel aj Avekbjl+ T~baj+ Ivbjde+ Tpa|evkbjl

bjl Tgu|o Bivadb* Atke gi Mbj fbjct obye b le~gta| fbte gi @F^ 56 fakkagj bjl

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

15/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

AJ\VGLUD\AGJ 24

dgkked|aye ajyet|mej| tdoemet mbjb`el aj |oe Atke gi Mbj obye b~~vgxamb|ekq@F^ 54 fakkagj aj iujlt ujlev mbjb`emej|* Dgm~bjq bjl |vut| tevyade ~vg-yalevt bve bktg kadejtel fq |oe ITD* \vut| tevyade ~vgyalevt aj |oe Atke gi Mbjtevyade b~~vgxamb|ekq 6> >>> |vut|t bjl dgm~bjq tevyade ~vgyalevt tevyade

b~~vgxamb|ekq 42 >>> dgm~bjaet* Kaie ajtuvevt+ jgj-kaie ajtuvevt+ ajtuvbjdembjb`evt bjl `ejevbk ajtuvbjde aj|evmelabvaet bve kadejtel ujlev |oeAjtuvbjde

Bd| 6>>?+ bjl bve tu~evyatel fq |oe Ajtuvbjde bjl ^ejtagjt Bu|ogva|q /|oe A B!*

Vedej| leyekg~mej|t

6>* \oe Atke gi Mbj obt g~evb|el mebtuvet eruaybkej| |g |oe EU Laved|ayegj |oe \bxb|agj gi Ajdgme ivgm Tbyaj`t /|oe EUTL! tajde 6>>5 bjl pakk femgyaj` |g iukk bu|gmb|ad exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj ujlev |oe EUTL ivgm

2 Hukq 6>22*

62* BIgujlb|agjt Fakk 6>2> dbme feigve Ke`atkb|aye Dgujdak /|oe u~~evfvbjdo gi \qjpbkl! igv iavt| veblaj` gj |oe 65|o Hbjubvq 6>22 bjl dgj|bajt~vgyatagjt vekb|aj` |g |oe et|bfkatomej| gi igujlb|agjt+ poado bve jg| g|o-evpate ~vgyalel igv ujlev Atke gi Mbj* \oe Fakk veruavet |ob| igujlb|agjtobye ve`at|evel b`ej|t bjl ajdkulet gfka`b|agjt aj vekb|agj |g |oe ogklaj` gigpjevtoa~ bjl bddguj|aj` ajigvmb|agj* \oeIgujlb|agjt Fakk 6>2> vedeayela|t |oavl veblaj` bjl pbt ~bttel b| b ta||aj` gi Ke`atkb|aye Dgujdak oekl gj |oe?|o Iefvubvq 6>22* \oe Fakk |oeveigve jgp ~vgdeelt |g Vgqbk Bttej|*

66* \oe Dgm~bjaet /^vgoafa|agj gi Febvev Tobvet! Fakk/tee ted|agj gjFebvev Tobvet fekgp! vedeayel a|t |oavl veblaj` bjl pbt ~bttel b| b ta||aj`gi Ke`atkb|aye Dgujdak oekl gj |oe 2t| Iefvubvq 6>22 bjl ~vgdeelt |g VgqbkBttej|* \oe eiied| gi |oe ke`atkb|agj at |g ejtuve |ob| bjq exat|aj` dgm~bjaetaj vet~ed| gi poado b febvev tobve at aj attue mut| ejtuve |ob| |oe tobve atdgjyev|el aj|g b ve`at|evel tobve*

64* \oe Atke gi Mbj ta`jel b lgufke |bx bvvbj`emej| /L\B! pa|o Fbovbajgj 4 Iefvubvq 6>22 bjl b \AEB pa|o Ajlab gj < Iefvubvq 6>22*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

16/83

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

17/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 25

Dgm~kabjde pa|o |oe T|bjlbvlt

B* Bybakbfaka|q gi Ajigvmb|agj

Gyevyaep

6

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

18/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

29 DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ

69* Igvea j dgm~bjaet |ob| obye |oeav dej|vbk mbjb`emej| bjl dgj|vgk aj|oe Atke gi Mbj bve vetalej| igv |bx ~uv~gtet aj |oe Atke gi Mbj bjl bve veruavel|g iake bj ajdgme |bx ve|uvj* Poeve |ogte dgm~bjaet obye b ~kbde gi futa-jett aj |oe Atke gi Mbj |oeq bve bktg veruavel |g ve`at|ev pa|o |oe Dgm~bjaet

Ve`at|vq* Ogpeyev+ |oeve at jg veruavemej| |g ~vgyale |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vqpa|o gpjevtoa~ ajigvmb|agj+ bjl |oe |bx ve|uvj pakk gjkq alej|aiq Atke gi Mbjvetalej| gpjevt gi tudo dgm~bjaet* \oeve bve 460 igvea`j dgm~bjaet |ob| bvevetalej| igv |bx ~uv~gtet aj |oe Atke gi Mbj+ bjl aj mbjq dbtet gpjevtoa~ajigvmb|agj pakk fe bybakbfke lue |g |oe b~~kadb|agj gi bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj`dut|gmev lue laka`ejde vuket* Bkk igvea j dgm~bjaet |ob| bve blmajat|evel fqAtke gi Mbj dgv~gvb|e tevyade ~vgyalevt bve tufhed| |g bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj`vuket* \oe dgv~gvb|e tevyade ~vgyalev pgukl obye |g alej|aiq bjl yevaiq |oefejeiadabk gpjevt gi |oe igvea`j dgm~bjaet* Poeve |oe bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj`vuket lg jg| b~~kq+ |oe veruavemej|t |g mbaj|baj gpjevtoa~ ajigvmb|agj pakk`ejevbkkq le~ejl gj |oe kbp gi |oe huvatlad|agj aj poado |oe dgm~bjq at ajdgv-

~gvb|el* Bddgvlaj kq+ ajigvmb|agj gj |oe gpjevt gi igvea`j dgm~bjaet |ob| bvevetalej| igv |bx ~uv~gtet aj |oe Atke gi Mbj mbq jg| bkpbqt fe bybakbfke bjla| at vedgmmejlel |ob| vuket fe ~u| aj ~kbde |g ejtuve |oe bybakbfaka|q gi tudoajigvmb|agj* Ogpeyev+ |oe ajigvmb|agj `b|oevaj` ~gpevt bybakbfke |g |oe Mbjx|bx bu|ogva|aet pakk b~~kq bjl tg bjq ajigvmb|agj |ob| |oe mbjb`emej| gi |oedgm~bjq ogklt dbj fe bddettel igv exdobj e gi ajigvmb|agj ~uv~gtet*

60* ^bv|jevtoa~t |ob| dbvvq gj futajett aj |oe Atke gi Mbj bve veruavel|g alej|aiq |oeav ~bv|jevt poej iakaj` |oeav bjjubk |bx ve|uvj* Kama|el ~bv|-

jevtoa~t mut| ve`at|ev pa|o bjl ~vgyale |oe jbmet gi ebdo ~bv|jev |g |oeDgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq* \oe ~vgyatagj gi |vut| tevyadet at tufhed| |g bj|a-mgjeqkbujlevaj` dut|gmev lue laka`ejde vuket*

6?* \oe dveb|agj gi igujlb|agjt at jg| duvvej|kq ~vgyalel igv ujlev Atkegi Mbj kbp /ogpeyev+ teeVedej| Leyekg~mej|t aj vekb|agj |g igujlb|agjt!*\oeve bve jg g|oev vekeybj| ej|a|aet bjl bvvbj`emej|t aj |oe Atke gi Mbj*

61* \oeve bve b ybvae|q gi ~ejbk|aet ujlev |oe Atke gi Mbjt kbpt |g ejtuve|ob| ajigvmb|agj veruavel |g fe mbaj|bajel at+ aj ibd|+ mbaj|bajel* \oe ~ejbk-|aet b~~ebv |g fe ~vg~gv|agjb|e bjl lattubtaye ejgu`o |g ajtuve dgm~kabjde*Luvaj` |oe gjta|e yata|+ |oe bttettmej| |ebm igujl |ob| Atke gi Mbjt |bxbu|ogva|aet bve bfke |g vet~gjl |g veruet|t igv gpjevtoa~ bjl alej|a|q ajigv-mb|agj igv bkk |q~et gi ke`bk ej|a|aet bjl bvvbj`emej|t* Ajigvmb|agj vedeayelivgm ~bv|jev huvatlad|agjt pa|o bj exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj vekb|agjtoa~ pa|o|oe Atke gi Mbj dgjiavmt |oat*

4>* \oeve at b t|vgj` ve`ukb|gvq medobjatm aj ~kbde poevefq bkk ta`jaiadbj|ajlut|vaet bve tufhed| |g b dkgte gyevta`o| igv dgm~kabjde pa|o |oe ybvae|q gikbpt aj ~kbde aj |oe Atke gi Mbj* \oe ~evtgjjek ej`b`el igv |oete ~uv~gtet bvecjgpkel`ebfke bjl ex~evaejdel* Ta`jaiadbj| eiigv|t bve mble |g kabate dkgtekq

pa|o vedgvl-cee~evt |g ejtuve tqt|emt bve aj ~kbde |ob| mee| |oe veruavemej|t

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

19/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 20

gi Atke gi Mbj ke`atkb|agj* Aj ~bv|adukbv+ |oe Atke gi Mbj |bx bu|ogva|aet mee|pa|o vedgvl-cee~evt |g ex~kbaj |oe veruavemej|t ujlev exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agjmedobjatmt bjl pob| gfka`b|agjt |oete pakk am~gte gj ajlut|vq aj vet~gjlaj`|g veruet|t*

Bddguj|aj` Ajigvmb|agj

42* Bddguj|aj` ajigvmb|agj igv bkk dgm~bjaet+ |vut|t bjl `ejevbk ~bv|jev-toa~t at bybakbfke aj bddgvlbjde pa|o |oe t|bjlbvlt |ovgu`o |oe b~~kadb|agj giajdgme |bx bjl bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` veruavemej|t* Kama|el ~bv|jevtoa~t|ob| lg jg| obye Atke gi Mbj vetalej| ~bv|jevt bjl |ob| lg jg| dbvvq gj b futa-jett aj |oe Atke gi Mbj bve jg| tufhed| |g b t~edaiad veruavemej| |g mbaj|bajbddguj|aj` vedgvlt aj bkk dbtet+ |ogu`o |oeve at b `ejevbk gfka`b|agj igv ~bv|-jevt |g vejlev |vue bddguj|t ujlev ~bv|jevtoa~ kbp* A| at vedgmmejlel |ob||oe Atke gi Mbj kbp ejtuvet |ob| kama|el ~bv|jevtoa~t bve aj bkk dbtet veruavel|g mbaj|baj vekabfke bddguj|aj` vedgvlt+ ajdkulaj` ujlevkqaj` lgdumej|b|agj+igv b| kebt| 5 qebvt*

Fbjcaj` Ajigvmb|agj

46* Fbjcaj` ajigvmb|agj mut| fe mbaj|bajel aj bddgvlbjde pa|o |oe kbptvekb|aj` |g iajbjdabk ajt|a|u|agjt bjl bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` kbpt*

B*2* Gpjevtoa~ bjl alej|a|q ajigvmb|agj

Huvatlad|agjt togukl ejtuve |ob| gpjevtoa~ bjl alej|a|q ajigvmb|agj igv bkk vekeybj|

ej|a|aet bjl bvvbj`emej|t at bybakbfke |g |oeav dgm~e|ej| bu|ogva|aet*

Dgm~bjaet /\gV B*2*2!

\q~et gi Dgm~bjaet

44* B dgm~bjq dbj fe igvmel aj |oe Atke gi Mbj ~uvtubj| |g |oe Dgm~bjaetBd| 2142+ |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 6>>9gv |oeKama|el Kabfaka|q Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2119*\oe ~vgmuk`b|agj gi |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 6>>9obt jg| tu~~kbj|el |oe Dgm~bjaetBd| 2142* ^vgiettagjt aj |oe Atkbjl ~evdeayel |ob| Bd| obl pgvcel pekk+ fu| |ob|a| pbt |gg dumfevtgme+ bt a| veruavel ex|ejtaye iakaj` pa|o |oe Dgm~bjaetVe`at|vq+ tudo bt |vbjtiev gi tobvet+ |oe attuaj` gi mgv|`b`e aj|evet|t+ gv dobj`etaj mbjb`emej|* Igv tmbkkev futajettet |oete eyej|t mbq fe yevq ajiveruej|+ bjl|oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142 at t|akk utel igv |q~adbk |vblaj` dgm~bjaet gv g|oev tmbkkej|ev~vatet*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

20/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

2? DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ

4>9obye iepevveruavemej|t |g iake ajigvmb|agj pa|o |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq |obj dgm~bjaetajdgv~gvb|el ujlev |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142+ bkk tudo dgm~bjaet mut| obye bve`at|evel b`ej| pog bve veruavel |g mbaj|baj |oe tbme ajigvmb|agj*

Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142

45* Ujlev |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142 a| at ~gttafke |g igvm dgm~bjaet kam-a|el fq tobvet gv fq `ubvbj|ee gv ujkama|el dgm~bjaet* Bkk dgm~bjaet igvmel|oeveujlev bve veruavel |g mbaj|baj b ve`at|ev |ob| alej|aiaet |oe jbmet bjlbllvettet gi ebdo memfev bjl |oe lb|e gj poado |oeq fedbme gv debtel |g feb memfev /Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142+ t* 19!*

49* \oe ve`at|ev mut| `ejevbkkq fe ce~| b| |oe dgm~bjqt ve`at|evel giiade*

Poeve a| at ce~| b| tgme g|oev giiade+ |oej |oe kgdb|agj gi |oe ve`at|ev mut| fejg|aiael |g |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq* Aj bkk dbtet+ |oe ve`at|ev mut| fe mbaj-|bajel aj |oe Atke gi Mbj /Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142+ tedt* 19/2B! bjl /2F!!*

40* \oe ve`at|ev mut| fe g~ej igv ajt~ed|agj |g bkk memfevt+ bt pekk bt|g bjq g|oev ~evtgj+ gj ~bqmej| gi b vebtgjbfke iee /Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142+ t*11!* Mgvegyev+ ai bjq ~evtgj veruavet b ~bv| gv dg~q gi |oe ve`at|ev+ a| mut| felekayevel pa|oaj 2> lbqt gi |oe veruet|*

4?* Aj blla|agj |g |oe mbaj|ejbjde gi b tobve ve`at|ev+ eyevq 2142 Bd| dgm-~bjq mut| mbaj|baj dev|baj vedgvlt bjl mbce dev|baj ve|uvjt |g |oe Dgm~bjaet

Ve`at|vq* \oete ve|uvjt bjl le|bakt bve b mb||ev gi ~ufkad vedgvl+ bddettafke |gmemfevt gi |oe ~ufkad ea|oev b| |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq gv gjkaje gj ~bqmej|gi b jgmajbk ~vetdvafel iee* \oetet vedgvlt ajdkule8

Ve`at|ev gi laved|gvt bjl tedve|bvaet /Dgm~bjaet Bd| 21?6+ t* 62!

Ve`at|ev gi dobv`et bjl dg~aet gi eyevq ajt|vumej| dveb|aj` b dobv`e/Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142+ t*01!

Bjjubk ve|uvj /Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142*2>1!3

T~edabk bjl ex|vbgvlajbvq vetgku|agjt gi memfevt /Dgm~bjaet Bd|2142*t* 221!+

Maju|et gi mee|aj`t gi memfevt+ bjl gi laved|gvt /Dgm~bjaet Bd|2142+ t*221!3

Bddguj|t /Dgm~bjaet Bd| 21?6+ t* 2!*

41* B 2142 Bd| dgm~bjq mut| bktg tufma| ve|uvjt /`ejevbkkq pa|oaj 2mgj|o gi |oe dobj`e! bt veruavel fq |oe Bd| |g |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq gj |oegdduvvejde gi dev|baj eyej|t tudo bt b dobj`e aj |oe kgdb|agj gi |oe ve`at|evelgiiade+ bj bk|evb|agj gi tobve db~a|bk gv b dobj`e gi jbme*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

21/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 21

Kama|el Kabfaka|q Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2119

* Kama|el kabfaka|q dgm~bjaet /KKDt! igvmel ujlev |oeKama|el Kabfaka|qDgm~bjaet Bd| 2119/KKD Bd|! mut| mbaj|baj b ve`at|evel giiade bjl obye b

ve`at|evel b`ej| aj |oe Atke gi Mbj b| bkk |amet /KKD Bd|+ tt+ < bjl 5!* Aj gvlev|g igvm |oe KKD+ b ~evtgj vetalej| aj |oe Atke gi Mbj mut| kgl`e |oe bv|adketgi gv`bjatb|agj pa|o |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq+ ajladb|aj` |oe jbme gi |oe ve`-at|evel b`ej| bjl |oe jbmet bjl bllvettet gi |oe memfevt* \oe bv|adket gigv`bjatb|agj mut| fe bmejlel |g veiked| bjq dobj`et aj |oe memfevtoa~ gi|oe dgm~bjq+ bjl |oe bmejlmej| mut| fe jg|aiael |g |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vqpa|oaj 2 mgj|o gi |oe dobj`e /KKD Bd|+ t* 0!* Aj blla|agj+ |oe dgm~bjq mut|iake bj bjjubk ve|uvj pa|o |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq ajladb|aj`+ aj|ev bkab+ bjqdobj`et aj memfevtoa~ /KKD Bd|+ t* 2>!* \oat ajigvmb|agj at g~ej |g ajt~ed-|agj fq |oe ~ufkad /KKD Bd|+ t*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

22/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

6> DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ

>9+ tedt* 51 bjl 96!*

\bx Kbp

! bjl bve |oeveigve veruavel |g

tufma| ajdgme |bx ve|uvjt* \oe ajdgme |bx ve|uvj veruavet latdkgtuve gi gpjev-toa~ ajigvmb|agj gjkq |g |oe ex|ej| gi bjq Mbjx vetalej| aj|evet| aj |oe dgm~bjq*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

23/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 62

dgm~bjq+ bjl |oe jbmet bjl bllvettet gi |oe Atke gi Mbj vetalej| ~evtgjtbu|ogvatel |g bdde~| tevyade gi ~vgdett bjl bjq jg|adet veruavel |g fe tevyelgj |oe dgm~bjq /Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142+ t* 424!* \oeve at jg veruavemej| |g~vgyale ajigvmb|agj gj |oe gpjevt gi |oe dgm~bjq*

52* Dgm~bjaet igvmel ujlev |oe kbpt gi bjg|oev huvatlad|agj |ob| bvembjb`el bjl dgj|vgkkel aj |oe Atke gi Mbj bve dgjtalevel vetalej| igv |bx~uv~gtet+ bjl bve veruavel ujlev |oe Ajdgme \bx Bd|t |g fe ve`at|evel igvajdgme |bx bjl tufma| ajdgme |bx ve|uvjt* Gpjevtoa~ ajigvmb|agj mut| feajdkulel aj bj ajdgme |bx ve|uvj fu| gjkq |g |oe ex|ej| gi bjq Mbjx vetalej|gpjevtoa~ gi |oe dgm~bjq*

56* \oeve bve b~~vgxamb|ekq 26>> igvea`j dgm~bjaet duvvej|kq ve`at|evelaj |oe Atke gi Mbj gi poado 460 bve vetalej| igv |bx ~uv~gtet* Mbjq gi |oeteigvea`j dgm~bjaet bve fvbjdoet gi |vblaj` dgm~bjaet gv iajbjdabk ajt|a|u-|agjt* Mgt| gi |oe igvea j dgm~bjaet |ob| obye bj et|bfkatoel ~kbde gi futa-jett aj |oe Atke gi Mbj pakk ea|oev obye b fbjc bddguj| gv ve`at|evel b`ej| aj|oe Atke gi Mbj gv pakk fe ve`ukb|el /igv exbm~ke+ igvea`j fbjct gv ajtuvbjdedgm~bjaet!+ bjl |out |oeav gpjevtoa~ ajigvmb|agj pakk fe mbaj|bajel ujlevbj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` kbp*

54* Ujlev bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` kbp+ b ~evtgj ~vgyalaj` dgv~gvb|e tev-yadet |g b dgv~gvb|agj at dbvvqaj` gj b vekeybj| futajett bjl at b vekeybj|~evtgj bjl at |oeveigve gfka`b|el |g b~~kq dut|gmev lue laka`ejde vuket/^vgdeelt gi Dvame /Mgjeq Kbujlevaj`! Dgle 6>2>+ t* 6!* \oe Ve`ukb|el

Bd|aya|aet Gvlev 6>>1 leiajet dgv~gvb|e tevyadet bt igkkgpt8

DKBTT < DGV^GVB\E TEVYADET

/4! ^vgyalaj` tevyadet pa|o vet~ed| |g |oe igvmb|agj gi dgm~bjaet*

/

/5! ^vgyalaj` gv bvvbj`aj` igv ~vematet igv ute bt b ve`at|evel giiadeigv b dgm~bjq*

/9! ^vgyalaj` gv bvvbj`aj` igv bddgmmglb|agj bllvett ibdaka|aet igv b

dgm~bjq*

/0! Bd|aj` bt b ve`at|evel b`ej| ujlev |oe Kama|el Kabfaka|q Dgm~bjaetBd| 2119 gv |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 6>>9*

/?! Bd|aj` bt bj giiadev gi b dgm~bjq /ajdkulaj` bt laved|gv gv bk|evjb|elaved|gv+ fu| exdkulaj` bt tedve|bvq+ gi b dgm~bjq!*

/1! Bd|aj` bt tedve|bvq gi b dgm~bjq*

/2>! Bvvbj`aj` igv bjg|oev ~evtgj |g bd| bt bj giiadev gi b dgm~bjq /ajdkul-aj` bd|aj` bt b laved|gv+ bk|evjb|e laved|gv gv tedve|bvq gi b dgm~bjq!*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

24/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

66 DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ

/22! Bd|aj` gv bvvbj`aj` igv bjg|oev ~evtgj |g bd| bt b jgmajee tobve-ogklev gv jgmajee memfev gi b dgm~bjq*

/26! ^vgyalaj` blmajat|vb|agj tevyadet |g b dgm~bjq*

/24! ^vgyalaj` tevyadet pa|o vet~ed| |g |oe igvmb|agj gi ~bv|jevtoa~t*

/2

/25! ^vgyalaj` gv bvvbj`aj` igv bddgmmglb|agj bllvett ibdaka|aet igv b~bv|jevtoa~

52>+ t* 5/6!!+ |g8

b! alej|aiq pog at |oe fejeiadabk gpjev gi |oe b~~kadbj|3

f! |bce vebtgjbfke mebtuvet |g yevaiq |oe alej|a|q gi |ogte ~evtgjt+ utaj`vekeybj| ajigvmb|agj gv lb|b gf|bajel ivgm b vekabfke tguvde3 bjl

d! le|evmaje poe|oev |oe b~~kadbj| at bd|aj` gj feobki gi bjg|oev ~evtgjbjl+ ai tg+ alej|aiq |ob| g|oev ~evtgj+ bjl |bce vebtgjbfke mebtuvet |gyevaiq oat alej|a|q utaj` vekeybj| ajigvmb|agj gv lb|b gf|bajel ivgmb vekabfke tguvde*

55* \oeve mbq jgje|oekett fe davdumt|bjdet poeve ajigvmb|agj pakk jg|

fe bybakbfke ve`bvlaj` |oe jgj-vetalej| gpjevt gi igvea`j ajdgv~gvb|el dgm-~bjaet |ob| bve vetalej| aj |oe Atke gi Mbj igv |bx ~uv~gtet* Ogpeyev+ aj |oetedbtet+ |oe ajigvmb|agj `b|oevaj` ~gpevt bybakbfke |g Mbjx |bx bu|ogva|aetpakk b~~kq /tee ted|agj F*2+ fekgp!*

Jgmajeet

59* \oeve at jg veruavemej| ujlev Atke gi Mbj dgm~bjq kbp vekb|aj` |g|oe ~vgyatagj gi ajigvmb|agj bt |g |oe alej|a|q gi |oe ~evtgj gj pogte feobkib jgmajee ogklt tobvet* Tobvet oekl fq b jgmajee bve dgjtalevel |g fe oeklgj |vut| igv |oe fejeiadabk gpjev gi |oe tobvet* \oat at b fbve |vut| ~gttafkqdveb|el fq ledkbvb|agj gi |vut|* Aj tudo b dbte+ |oat |q~e gi bvvbj`emej| at|vbjt~bvej| igv |bx ~uv~gtet* Poeve layalejlt bve ~bal aj vet~ed| gi |oetobvet |oeq bve `ayej laved|kq |g |oe fejeiadabk gpjev+ bjl |oeve at jg gfka`b-|agj igv |oe jgmajee |g ledkbve gpjevtoa~ gi |oe tobvet gv |oe vedea~| gi |oelayalejlt* Ogpeyev+ b Mbjx vetalej| jgmajee pgukl fe veruavel |g eyalejde|g |oe Bttettgv |oe ~evtgj |g pogm |oe layalejl at ~bal gj |g bjl ~vgyalepva||ej eyalejde gi |oe jgmajee bvvbj`emej| aj gvlev |g tb|atiq |oe Bttettgv|ob| jg kabfaka|q |g ajdgme |bx bvatet |g |oe jgmajee*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

25/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 64

50* \oe Atke gi Mbjt bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` kbpt dgyev |ogte ~evtgjtpog bd| gv bvvbj`e igv bjg|oev ~evtgj |g bd| bt b jgmajee tobveogklev gvjgmajee memfev gi b dgm~bjq /tee latduttagj ujlevIgvea`j Dgm~bjaet+bfgye!* Poeve |oete bd|aya|aet bve ~vgyalel fq pbq gi futajett+ |oej |oe dut-

|gmev lue laka`ejde vuket pakk b~~kq* Poeve b ~evtgj lget jg| ~vgyale |oetetevyadet fq pbq gi futajett+ |oej |oe gfka`b|agjt ve`bvlaj` |oe mbaj|ejbjdegi alej|a|q ajigvmb|agj mbq jg| b~~kq* \oe davdumt|bjdet aj poado b jgma-jee pgukl jg| fe tufhed| |g bjq vedgvl-cee~aj` veruavemej| bve aj bjq eyej|ex|vemekq kama|el+ bjl |g lb|e |oeve obye feej jg veruet|t igv ajigvmb|agjve`bvlaj` jgmajee tobveogklevt* \oe eiied| gi |oat gj exdobj`e gi ajigvmb-|agj aj ~vbd|ade togukl fe mgja|gvel fq |oe Atke gi Mbj gj bj gj`gaj` fbtat*

Febvev tobvet /\gV B*2*6!

5?* \oe attubjde gi febvev tobvet at ~vgoafa|el fq |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd|2142 bjl |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 6>>9* A| at jg|el |ob| |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142gjkq ~vgoafa|t |oe attubjde gi febvev tobvet ivgm 6>>>< a| at jedettbvq igv ogklevt |g dgjyev||oete tobvet |g jgmajb|aye tobvet aj gvlev |g exevdate |oeav va`o|t bt tobve-ogklevt /e*`* yg|aj` va`o|t+ va`o| |g vedeaye layalejlt!*

51* \oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq ve~gv|t |ob| gjkq 22 bjl at duvvej|kq bpba|aj`Vgqbk Bttej| /teeVedej| Leyekg~mej|t bfgye!*

^bv|jevtoa~t /\gV B*2*4!

9>* @ejevbk ~bv|jevtoa~t bjl kama|el ~bv|jevtoa~t dbj fe igvmel aj |oe Atkegi Mbj+ poado bve `gyevjel fq |oe^bv|jevtoa~ Bd| 21>1 bjl |oe dgmmgj kbp* B~bv|jevtoa~ at leiajel bt |oe vekb|agjtoa~ poado tuftat|t fe|peej ~evtgjt dbvvq-aj` gj b futajett aj dgmmgj pa|o b yaep |g ~vgia| /^bv|jevtoa~ Bd| 21>1+ t* 1+ tedt*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

26/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

6< DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ

96* Aj blla|agj |g |oe veruavemej|t ujlev ~bv|jevtoa~ kbp+ |oe |bx kbpb~~kaet |g ~bv|jevtoa~t /poe|oev igvmel ujlev Atke gi Mbj kbp gv g|oevpate!|ob| ea|oev levaye ajdgme |ob| at kabfke |g |bx aj |oe Atke gi Mbj gv pa|o vet~ed||g poado gje gv mgve ~bv|jevt at vetalej| aj |oe Atke gi Mbj* Aj |oete dbtet+

|oe ~bv|jevtoa~ a|teki at jg| kabfke |g ajdgme |bx+ fu| ebdo ~bv|jev at kabfke |g~bq ajdgme |bx b| |oe b~~vg~vab|e vb|e aj vet~ed| gi oat gv oev pogke ajdgme+ajdkulaj` |oe tobve gi |oe ~vgia|t gi bjq ~bv|jevtoa~* Aj gvlev |g lg |oat+ajdgme bjl lelud|agjt bve dgm~u|el b| |oe ~bv|jevtoa~ keyek bjl |oej bkkg-db|el |g |oe ~bv|jevt* Bddgvlaj`kq+ b ~bv|jevtoa~ |bx ve|uvj |ob| mbcet tudodbkdukb|agjt mut| fe iakel+ bjl |oat ajdkulet |oe jbme gi ebdo ~bv|jev bjl |oetobve gi ~vgia|t |g poado |oe ~bv|jev at ej|a|kel /Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210>+ t* 94!*

\vut|t /\gV B*2*

94* \vut|t obye feej vedg`jatel aj |oe t|b|u|e kbp gi |oe Atke gi Mbj igvmbjq qebvt bjl |oe |vut| dgjde~| at jgp pekk et|bfkatoel aj |oe Atkbjl* \oe~vajda~ket gi |vut| kbp bjl erua|q bt leyekg~el aj Ej`kbjl bve b~~kael bjlvedg`jatel fq |oe dguv|t aj |oe Atke gi Mbj ajtgibv bt |oeq bve jg| dgj|vbvq|g bjq kgdbk t|b|u|e gv ~vedelej|* \vut|t bve u|akatel igv mbjq bjl ybvagut~uv~gtet bjl ~kbq b uteiuk vgke aj dgmmevdabk bjl ~vayb|e dkaej| ta|ub|agjt*\oe ettej|abk dobvbd|evat|ad gi b |vut| at |ob| a| at b ke`bk vekb|agjtoa~ dveb|elfq b ~evtgj+ |oe te||kgv+ poej btte|t obye feej ~kbdel ujlev |oe dgj|vgk gi b|vut|ee igv |oe fejeia| gi b fejeiadabvq gv igv b t~edaiael ~uv~gte*

92>+ t* 6!* Bvekeybj| futajett ajdkulet |vut| tevyadet* \oe Ve`ukb|el Bd|aya|aet Gvlev6>>1 leiajet |vut| tevyadet bt igkkgpt8

DKBTT 5 \VUT\ TEVYADET

Ve`ukb|el bd|aya|aet

/2! Bd|aj` bt tgke |vut|ee aj vekb|agj |g bj ex~vett |vut|*

/6! Bd|aj` bt |vut|ee /g|oev |obj tgke |vut|ee! aj vekb|agj |g bj ex~vett|vut|*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

27/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 65

/4! ^vgyalaj` |vut| blmajat|vb|agj tevyadet aj vekb|agj |g bj ex~vett |vut|*

/

/5! Bd|aj` bt b ~vg|ed|gv aj vekb|agj |g bj ex~vett |vut| /|ob| at+ b ~evtgjg|oev |obj b |vut|ee pog+ bt |oe ogklev gi bj giiade dveb|el fq gvujlev |oe |evmt gi |oe |vut|+ at bu|ogvatel gv veruavel |g ~bv|ada~b|eaj |oe blmajat|vb|agj gi |oe |vut|!*

/9! Bd|aj` bt bj ejigvdev /pa|oaj |oe mebjaj` gi |oe ^uv~gte \vut|t Bd|2119! aj vekb|agj |g b ~uv~gte |vut|*

99* Poeve |oe dut|gmev lue laka`ejde veruavemej|t b~~kq+ |oe |vut| tev-yade ~vgyalev at gfka`b|el |g alej|aiq |oe te||kgv bjl bjq cjgpj fejeiadabvq gi|oe |vut| /^vgdeelt gi Dvame /Mgjeq Kbujlevaj`! Dgle 6>2>+ t* 5/4!/d! bjl

/l!!* \oe fejeiadabvaet |ob| mut| fe alej|aiael bve jg| kama|el fq bjq ~evdej|-b`e aj|evet|* \oe leiaja|agj gi |vut| tevyadet lget jg| lat|aj`uato fe|peej|vut|t igvmel ujlev Atke gi Mbj kbp gv |vut|t igvmel ujlev igvea`j kbp*

90* Aj |oe Atke gi Mbj+ |oe ~vgyatagj gi |vut| tevyadet at bktg b ve`ukb|elbd|aya|q poado mebjt |ob| |ogte ~evtgjt dgjlud|aj` |oat bd|aya|q fq pbq gifutajett mut| `ejevbkkq ogkl b kadejde attuel fq |oe ITD* \oeve bve 261kadejtel |vut| tevyade ~vgyalevt aj |oe Atke gi Mbj+ tevyaj` b~~vgxamb|ekq6> >>> |vut|t* \oe ITD+ aj a|t tu~evyatgvq vgke+ dgjlud|t gj-ta|e yata|t |gbttett dgm~kabjde pa|o bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` bjl dguj|evaj` |oe iajbjdaj`gi |evvgvatm vuket+ ajdkulaj` dut|gmev alej|aiadb|agj ~vgdeluvet+ |oe mbaj|e-

jbjde gi ajigvmb|agj gj |oe tguvde gi iujlt bjl tguvde gi pebk|o+ bjl vedgvl-cee~aj` gfka`b|agjt /tee fekgp+ ujlev Ve`ukb|gvq Ivbmepgvc!*

9?* Ujlev Atke gi Mbj |bx kbp |vut|eet gi |vut|t |ob| obye Atke gi Mbjfejeiadabvaet gv |ob| ebvj ajdgme ivgm tguvdet aj |oe Atke gi Mbj pakk feveruavel |g iake b |bx ve|uvj* Ogpeyev+ poeve b |vut| obt jg Atke gi Mbjfejeiadabvq bjl jg Atke gi Mbj tguvde ajdgme |oej |oeve pakk fe jg Atke giMbj |bx kabfaka|q bjl jg gfka`b|agj |g iake b |bx ve|uvj+ eyej ai |oe |vut| obt b|vut|ee vetalej| aj |oe Atke gi Mbj bjl ai a|t btte|t bve mbjb`el aj |oe Atke giMbj* Gi|ej+ |vut|eet pakk teec dkebvbjde ivgm |oe |bx bu|ogva|aet |g et|bfkato

|ob| |oeve at jg kabfaka|q |g |bx aj |oe Atke gi Mbj*|vut|t obye tgu`o| dkebvbjde dev|aiadb|et*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

28/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

69 DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ

91* Poeve b ~evtgj lget jg| ~vgyale |vut| tevyadet fq pbq gi futajett+|oej |oe gfka`b|agjt ve`bvlaj` |oe mbaj|ejbjde gi alej|a|q ajigvmb|agj ujlevbj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` kbpt mbq jg| b~~kq+ ogpeyev+ |oe dgmmgj kbp pakkveruave |ob| |oe |vut|ee fe bfke |g alej|aiq |oe fejeiadabvaet+ bjl |oe te||kgv

pakk |q~adbkkq fe alej|aiael fq |oe |vut| leel* B |vut|ee mut| b| bkk |amet febfke |g ~vgyale b fejeiadabvq pa|o ajigvmb|agj dgjdevjaj` |oe g~evb|agjgi |oe |vut| /tee ted|agj B*6+ fekgp!* \oat pakk ajdkule jg| gjkq bddguj|aj`ajigvmb|agj fu| g|oev |vut| lgdumej|t+ tudo bt |oe |vut| leel bjl lgdumej|tvekb|aj` |g |vbjtievt gi ~vg~ev|q mble fq b te||kgv* \oat obt jg| ~veyej|el |oeeiied|aye exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj+ bjl |oe eiied| gi |oat gj EGA aj ~vbd|adetogukl fe mgja|gvel fq |oe Atke gi Mbj gj bj gj`gaj` fbtat* A| at bktg dgj-deaybfke |ob| b |vut| dgukl fe dveb|el poado obt jg dgjjed|agj pa|o |oe Atke giMbj g|oev |obj |ob| |oe te||kgv doggtet |ob| |oe |vut| pakk fe `gyevjel fq |oekbpt gi |oe Atke gi Mbj* Aj |ob| eyej| |oeve mbq fe jg ajigvmb|agj bfgu| |oe|vut| bybakbfke aj |oe Atke gi Mbj*

Igujlb|agjt /\gV B*2*5!

0>* A| at jg| duvvej|kq ~gttafke |g igvm igujlb|agjt ujlev Atke gi Mbj kbp/teeVedej| Leyekg~mej|t aj vekb|agj |g igujlb|agjt!*

Ejigvdemej| ~vgyatagjt |g ejtuve bybakbfaka|q gi ajigvmb|agj/\gV B*2*9!

Dgm~bjaet

02* Igv dgm~bjaet igvmel ujlev |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142+ ibakuve |gmbaj|baj |oe ve`at|ev gi memfevt /ajdkulaj` |oe veruavemej| |g cee~ a| u~ |glb|e! dbvvaet b ~ejbk|q gi b iaje jg| exdeelaj` @F^ 5>>> gj tummbvq dgj-yad|agj+ bjl b iaje pa|ogu| kama| aj dbtet gi dgjyad|agj gj ajigvmb|agj /teeDgm~bjaet Bd| 2142+ tedt* 19/6!+ 44>!* \oat tbme ~ejbk|q b~~kaet |g bj b`ej|pog mbaj|bajt |oe ve`at|ev gj feobki gi |oe dgm~bjq /Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142+t* 11B!* B iaje gi @F^ 5>>> bktg b~~kaet aj |oe dbte gi b ibakuve |g lekayev b

dg~q gv ~gv|agj gi |oe ve`at|ev gj veruet| /Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142+ ted* 11/4!!*06* Aj vet~ed| gi dgm~bjaet igvmel ujlev |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 6>>9+ibakuve |g mbaj|baj |oe ve`at|ev gi memfevt at tufhed| |g b iaje jg| exdeelaj`@F^ 5>>> /Dgm~bjaet Bd| 6>>9+ tedt* 96+ 0? bjl 664!*

04* Poeve bj KKD ibakt |g ~vgyale |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq pa|o a|tbjjubk ve|uvj /poado mut| ajladb|e |oe jbmet bjl bllvettet gi |oe duvvej|memfevt!+ |oe KKD at `uak|q gi bj giiejde bjl kabfke |g b iaje jg| exdeel-aj` @F^ 5>>> bjl |oe KKD at leemel |g fe leiujd| /KKD Bd|+ t* 2>/4!!*\oe tbme tbjd|agj b~~kaet poeve |oe KKD ibakt |g jg|aiq |oe Dgm~bjaet

Ve`at|vq gi b dobj`e aj a|t ve`at|evel b`ej| /KKD Bd|+ 1/6!!+ pog pakk fe

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

29/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 60

veruavel |g mbaj|baj ajigvmb|agj gj |oe memfevt gi |oe KKD aj bddgvlbjdepa|o dut|gmev lue laka`ejde vuket* Ai |oe ve`at|evel b`ej| at aj fvebdo gi |oebj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` kbpt |oat at b dvamajbk giiejde |ob| at kabfke+ gj tum-mbvq dgjyad|agj+ |g b dut|glq |evm jg| exdeelaj` tax mgj|ot gv |g b iaje jg|

exdeelaj` @F^ 5>>>+ gv |g fg|o+ gv gj dgjyad|agj gj ajigvmb|agj+ |g dut|glqjg| exdeelaj` |pg qebvt gv |g b iaje+ gv |g fg|o /^vgdeelt gi Dvame /MgjeqKbujlevaj`! Dgle 6>2>+ ~bvb*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

30/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

6? DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ

Ve`ukb|gvq Ivbmepgvc

00* \oeve at ka||ke eyalejde gi |oe ute gi ejigvdemej| mebtuvet+ poe|oev|oe am~gta|agj gi iajet gv dvamajbk ~vgtedu|agj gi |ogte pog dgj|vbyeje |oe

ybvagut kbpt* Ogpeyev+ |oeve b~~ebvt |g fe dkgte gyevta`o| gi bkk ve`ukb|elfutajettet /a*e* dgv~gvb|e bjl |vut| tevyade ~vgyalevt+ iajbjdabk ajt|a|u|agjt+|oe ajtuvbjde ted|gv bjl ajyet|mej| iujlt! igv bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` ~uv-~gtet+ poado `g |ovgu`o b |ogvgu`o gj-ta|e veyaep eyevq gje |g |ovee qebvtle~ejlaj` gj |oeav vatc ~vgiake* \oeve at dkgte dgmmujadb|agj fe|peej |oeve`ukb|gvq fglaet bjl ajlut|vq+ bjl |oeve at bj eiigv| |g pgvc |ovgu`o ta|u-b|agjt poeve |oeve bve dgjdevjt |ob| dgj|vgkt |g mee| vuket bve jg| aj ~kbde*Gyevbkk+ |oe oa`o t|bjlbvl gi ve`ukb|agj aj |oe Atke gi Mbj at pekk ej|vejdoel*

0?* \oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq at ~bv| gi Le~bv|mej| gi Edgjgmad Leyekg~-

mej| bjl at vet~gjtafke igv mbaj|bajaj` tax laiievej| ve`at|vaet dgm~bjaetigvmel ujlev |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142+ Dgm~bjaet Bd| 6>>9+ dgm~bjaetigvmel ujlev |oeKama|el Kabfaka|q Dgm~bjaet Bd| 6>>9+ ve`at|vq gi futajettjbmet+ ve`at|vq gi kama|el ~bv|jevtoa~t+ bjl |oe ve`at|ev gi igvea`j dgm~b-jaet |ob| obye et|bfkatoel b ~kbde gi futajett aj |oe Atke gi Mbj* Igv bkk gi|oe ej|a|aet ve`at|evel pa|o |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq+ lgdumej|t bve ~ufkadvedgvl bjl dbj fe tebvdoel* Tajde 6>>>+ lgdumej|b|agj igv eyevq ve`at|evelej|a|q obt feej tdbjjel bjl ~u| gj kaje* \oat ajdkulet lattgkyel dgm~bjaet*Lgdumej|b|agj |ob| lb|et ivgm ~vagv |g 6>>> bve bybakbfke aj |oe bvdoayet* \oedgm~e|ej| bu|ogva|q ejdguvb`et exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj ~bv|jevt |g dgjlud|

|oeav gpj tebvdoet poeve ajigvmb|agj at ~ufkadkq bybakbfke*01* \oeve bve b~~vgxamb|ekq 42 0>> Atke gi Mbj dgm~bjaet duvvej|kqve`at|evel pa|o |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq* \oete bve dgm~vatel gi 69 >>>dgm~bjaet igvmel ujlev |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142+ 5 5>> dgm~bjaet igvmelujlev |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 6>>9+ bjl 6>> KKDt* Aj blla|agj+ |oeve bve b~~vgxa-mb|ekq 26>> igvea j dgm~bjaet ve`at|evel pa|o |oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq* A| att|bjlbvl ~vbd|ade |g dvgtt-veievejde iakaj`t pa|o ~vagv ajigvmb|agj |g ejtuvedgjtat|ejdq+ igv exbm~ke+ pa|o vet~ed| |g ajigvmb|agj ve`bvlaj` |oe alej|a|qgi |oe ve`at|evel b`ej| gv kgdb|agj gi |oe ve`at|evel giiade* Ejigvdemej|~vgdeluvet bve igv |oe mgt| ~bv| kama|el |g |oe am~gta|agj gi kb|e iakaj` ieet*B~~vgxamb|ekq ?> ~evdej| gi dgm~bjaet bve mbjb`el'blmajat|evel fq b dkbtt< kadejde ogklev pog at dobv`el pa|o ejtuvaj` dgm~kabjde pa|o bj|a-mgjeqkbujlevaj` bjl g|oev vuket bjl at tu~evyatel fq |oe Iajbjdabk Tu~evyatagjDgmmattagj /latduttel fekgp!* \oe matve~vetej|b|agj gi dgm~bjaet bt Mbjxdgm~bjaet+ gv utaj` jbmet |ob| `aye |oe ajladb|agj |ob| |oeq bve ej`b`el aj bve`ukb|el ajlut|vq /tudo bt fbjcaj` gv ajtuvbjde! poeve |oat at jg| |oe dbte+ at|bcej yevq tevagutkq fq Mbjx bu|ogva|aet bjl b jumfev gi jg|adet bve attuelebdo qebv pbvjaj` ajyet|gvt gi tudo bd|aya|q*

?>* \oe Dgm~bjaet Ve`at|vq ajt|a|u|et t|vace gii ~vgdeluvet poeve b

dgm~bjq ibakt |g iukiak a|t t|b|u|gvq veruavemej|t+ igv exbm~ke poeve a| ibakt |g

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

31/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 61

tufma| bj bjjubk ve|uvj gv mbaj|baj b ve`at|evel giiade+ bjl g|oev dgm~bjaetb~~kq igv lattgku|agj* Poeve b dgm~bjq ibakt |g iake bj bjjubk ve|uvj+ |oej biavt| jg|ade at tej| |g |oe dgm~bjq poevefq a| obt |pg mgj|ot |g vemelq |oeibakuve* Poeve |oe dgm~bjq lget jg| vet~gjl+ |oej b tedgjl jg|ade at tej|

bjl bj bjjgujdemej| at ~kbdel aj |oe kgdbk ~b~ev* Ai jg vet~gjte at vedeayel|g |oat tedgjl jg|ade bi|ev |pg mgj|ot |oej |oe dgm~bjq at t|vudc gii*B~~vgxamb|ekq 2> dgm~bjaet bve t|vudc gii ebdo qebv*

Dgv~gvb|e bjl \vut| Tevyade ^vgyalevt

?2* Bkk dgv~gvb|e bjl |vut| tevyade ~vgyalevt /DT^t'\T^t! bve tu~ev-yatel fq |oe ITD+ gyevteej fq b |ebm gi 1 ~vgiettagjbkt pog bve dobv`elpa|o ejtuvaj` dgm~kabjde pa|o bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` vuket bt pekk bt g|oevve`ukb|agjt dgyevaj` DT^t'\T^t* \oeve bve b~~vgxamb|ekq 6>> iavmt |ob| bvekadejtel bt dgv~gvb|e gv |vut| tevyade ~vgyalevt+ mgt| gi poado ogkl kadejtetigv fg|o bd|aya|aet* DT '\T^ iavmt em~kgq b~~vgxamb|ekq 6>>> ~eg~ke aj |oeAtke gi Mbj+ pa|o b |q~adbk iavm em~kgqaj` 5-2> ~evtgjt*

?6* \oe iavmt aj |oe Atke gi Mbj |ejl |g fe iukk-tevyade+ |ob| at |oeq bvejg| hut| ajygkyel aj gje bt~ed| gi dgv~gvb|e gv |vut| tevyadet tudo bt dgm~bjqigvmb|agj gv bd|aj` bt ve`at|evel b`ej|* Ajleel+ |oe dumukb|aye eiied| gi bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` ve`ukb|agjt+ kadejtaj` veruavemej|t bjl dgm~kabjde dgt|t`ejevbkkq ~uto iavmt |g ~vgyale iukk tevyade* Mgvegyev+ |oe ITD ajladb|et |ob|a|t kadejtaj` ~gkadq ibyguvt b iukk tevyade b~~vgbdo*

?4* Ebdo iavm at veruavel |g ~vgyale bj bjjubk dgm~kabjde ve|uvj ta`jelujlev ~ejbk|aet gi ~evhuvq* \oe ITD veyaept |oe bjjubk ve~gv|aj` lgdumej|tbjl dgjlud|t gj-ta|e yata|t gi ebdo iavm* Gj-ta|e tu~evyatagj at lgje gj b4-qebv dqdke iavmt |ob| ~gte b oa`oev vatc igv mgjeq-kbujlevaj` gv |evvgvat|iajbjdaj` bd|aya|aet bve tufhed| |g bjjubk yata|t+ poake kgpev-vatc iavmt bveyata|el gjde eyevq |ovee qebvt* Mgt| gi |oe dgv~gvb|e bjl |vut| tevyade ~vg-yalevt bve melaum |g kgp vatc* Dgv~gvb|e bjl |vut| tevyade ~vgyalevt bve bktgye||el |g togp |oe ~evtgjjek bve ia| bjl ~vg~ev+ poado ajdkule veievejdet bjl~gkade doedct* \oe ceq ~evtgjt gi DT^t bjl \T^t /bt pekk bt g|oev kadejde-

ogklevt ceq ~evtgjt! bve ye||el |g ejtuve |oeq bve ia| bjl ~vg~ev |g ujlev|bce|oeav vgket* Ia|jett bjl ~vg~vae|q ajdkulet dgm~e|ejdq+ aj|e`va|q bjl tgkyejdq*Ceq ~evtgjt bve leiajel aj ted|agj

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

32/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

4> DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ

bjl |oe ajigvmb|agj ~vgyalel aj |oe ruet|agjjbave* Ejigvdemej| mebtuvet dbjajdkule veygcaj` kadejte bjl latrubkaiadb|agj gi laved|gvt bjl |oete gdduvaj b objliuk gi dbtet eyevq qebv ogpeyev |oe |ejlejdq at |g pgvc |ovgu`oattuet pa|o |oe iavm dgjdevjel |g ejtuve dgm~kabjde pa|o ve`ukb|gvq bjl

t|b|u|gvq gfka`b|agjt*

Ajtuvbjde

?5* \oe ajtuvbjde ted|gv aj |oe Atke gi Mbj at tufhed| |g |oe gyevta o| gi|oe Ajtuvbjde bjl ^ejtagjt Bu|ogva|q /A^B!+ poado at et|bfkatoel ~uvtubj||g |oeAjtuvbjde Bd| 6>>?* \oe `vgu~ objlkaj` gyevta`o| dgjtat|t gi 2< t|biimemfevt pog bve ~vgiettagjbkkq rubkaiael aj bddguj|bjdq+ kbp+ ajtuvbjde+bjl `ejevbkkq obye ex~evaejde pgvcaj` aj |oe ajtuvbjde ajlut|vq* Aj blla-|agj+ |oe A^B obt bddett |g ex|evjbk ex~ev|ate+ igv exbm~ke ke`bk+ bddguj|aj`gv bd|ubvabk tevyadet aj ~bv|adukbv dbtet*

?9* \oe ajtuvbjde futajett pbt iavt| et|bfkatoel aj |oe ebvkq 21?>t bjldgjtat|t gi fg|o kaie bjl jgj-kaie ajtuvevt* \oe mbaj bt~ed| gi |oat at db~|ayeajtuvbjde+ poado fe`bj pa|o b tmbkk jumfev gi iavmt ~vgyalaj` ajtuvbjde |g~bvej| dgm~bjaet aj |oe Uja|el Caj`lgm bjl poado obt `vgpj |g bfgu| 25>dgm~bjaet |glbq* Db~|aye ajtuvbjde dgm~bjaet ujlev|bce b vekb|ayekq tmbkkygkume gi |vbjtbd|agjt+ fu| bddguj| igv b kbv`e tobve gi |oe mbvce| fq mgje-|bvq ybkue* Ve`bvlaj` kaie ajtuvbjde+ |oeve bve b tmbkkev jumfev gi iavmt+ fu||oat futajett at mgve kbfguv aj|ejtaye bjl tg |oe dgm~bjaet |ejl |g fe kbv`ev*

\oeve bve 25 bd|aye kaie ajtuvbjde dgm~bjaet poado em~kgq bfgu| 6>>>~eg~ke* \oe kbv`et| taj`ke kaie ajtuvbjde dgm~bjq aj |oe Atke gi Mbj em~kgqtb~~vgxamb|ekq 45> ~eg~ke* Fq dgj|vbt|+ |oe 25> gv tg db~|aye ajtuvevt em~kgqbfgu| 25>-6>> ~eg~ke* Tajde |oete dgm~bjaet+ aj gvlev |g fe kadejtel+ mut|lg futajett aj |oe Atke gi Mbj |oeq pakk `ejevbkkq oave bj ajtuvbjde mbjb`ev*Ajtuvbjde mbjb`evt mut| |oemtekyet fe kadejtel+ bjl |oeve bve bfgu| 0 mbj-b`evt aj |oe Atke gi Mbj |ob| bddguj| igv |oe mbhgva|q gi |oat futajett*

?0* Tu~evyatagj gi |oe ajtuvbjde ajlut|vq at b dgmfajb|agj gi bjjubkve~gv|aj` gfka`b|agjt ~kut b ~vg`vbm gi gj-ta|e yata|t* Bkk ajtuvbjde dgm~bjaet

bve veruavel |g ~vgyale le|bakel iajbjdabk ve|uvjt bjjubkkq* Ajlayalubk davdum-t|bjdet |oej le|evmaje |oe tdg~e+ iveruejdq bjl jb|uve gi |oe gj-ta|e yata|*\oe gj-ta|e ~vg`vbm pbt aj|vgludel aj 6>>2+ b| poado |ame |oe igdut pbt gjbj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` vatct+ ~bv|adukbvkq aj |oe kaie ajtuvbjde ted|gv* Aj blla-|agj |g dgm~kabjde pa|o bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` vuket+ |oeve at ajlut|vq t~edaiadve`ukb|agj ujlev |oeAjtuvbjde Bd| 6>>?+ bt pekk bt fajlaj` `ualbjde*

??* ^ve~bvb|agj igv gj-ta|e yata|t dgmmejdet 9 mgj|ot ~vagv |g yata|+poeve |oe |ebm memfevt /6 ~vgiettagjbkt ~kut b tu~evyatgv!+ veyaept vatct bjlattuet igv |ob| ~bv|adukbv ajtuvev bjl dgjtalev eyej|t aj |oe ~vagv 26-2? mgj|ot/igv exbm~ke+ ~bqmej|t mble bjl jep futajett bdruavel!* B ruet|agjjbave

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

33/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 42

at |oej leyekg~el+ dgjtat|aj` gi t|bjlbvl ~kut ajlayalubkatel ruet|agjt* \oeaj|ej|agj at |g igdut |oe attuet |g fe vbatel luvaj` |oe yata| bjl alej|aiq ~ve-datekq poado ajlayalubkt togukl fe aj|evyaepel* Ve`bvlkett gi |oe |q~e giajtuvbjde dgm~bjq+ dgm~kabjde pa|o bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` vuket at |q~adbkkq

b igdut+ vedg`jataj` |ob| vatct gj |oe db~|aye tale bve kett ~vgjgujdel* Igv bkbv`e ajtuvbjde dgm~bjq |oe gj-ta|e yata| `ejevbkkq |bcet 4-< lbqt3 igv tmbkkdgm~bjaet b yata| kbt| ~evob~t 6 lbqt* \oe yata| pakk veyaep t~edaiad |vbjtbd-|agjt+ kg`t+ bjl tbm~ke iaket*

?1* Aj blla|agj |g igvmbk gj-ta|e yata|t+ |oeve bve bktg bl ogd yata|t igv~bv|adukbv ~uv~gtet* \oete mbq fe gj yevq togv| jg|ade igkkgpaj` b dgm~kbaj|vedeayel ivgm |oe ~ufkad gv b veruet| ivgm bjg|oev ve`ukb|gvq fglq*

1>* \oe em~obtat ve`bvlaj` ejigvdemej| igv |oe A^B at |g pgvc pa|okadejteet |g alej|aiq attuet poeve am~vgyemej| at jeelel* Poeve bj attueat jg| iujlbmej|bk |oej a|t b~~vgbdo at |g pgvc pa|o |oe dgm~bjq |g vemelq|oeav ~vgdeluvet* B dbte ajygkyaj` tevagut yagkb|agj pa|o Atke gi Mbj kbp aj|oat bveb obt jg| bvatej aj kbt| 4 gv < qebvt* Aj b kbv`e dbte b jumfev gi qebvtb`g |oeve pbt b tqt|emad ibakuve aj |oe dgj|vgk tqt|em b| gje dgm~bjq+ |oeA^B em~kgqel bj ex|evjbk bula|gv |g ~vglude b ve~gv| poado kel |g pogketbkedobj`et aj |oe dgm~bjqt b~~vgbdo* \oe A^B |bcet b dgkkbfgvb|aye b~~vgbdopa|o ajlut|vq+ fu| bttev|t b dkebv layalaj` kaje fe|peej ve`ukb|gv bjl futajett*

Le|evmajb|agj bjl ibd|gvt ujlevkqaj` vedgmmejlb|agjt

Le|evmajb|agj

\oe ekemej| at aj ~kbde

Ibd|gvt ujlevkqaj`

vedgmmejlb|agjt

Vedgmmejlb|agjt

Ajigvmb|agj ve`bvlaj` |oe gpjevtoa~

gi igvea`j dgm~bjaet |ob| bve

vetalej| igv |bx ~uv~gtet aj |oe Atke

gi Mbj mbq+ ujlev dev|baj kama|el

davdumt|bjdet+ jg| fe bybakbfke*

Poeve igvea`j dgm~bjaet bve vetalej|

igv |bx ~uv~gtet aj |oe Atke gi Mbj

vuket togukl fe aj ~kbde |g ejtuve

|oe bybakbfaka|q gi ajigvmb|agj gj |oe

dgj|vgkkaj` gpjevt gi tudo dgm~bjaet*

Vb|aj`

\g fe dgm~ke|el gjde b ve~vetej|b|aye tufte| gi ^obte 6 veyaept obye

feej dgm~ke|el*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

34/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

46 DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ

B*6* Bddguj|aj` vedgvlt

Huvatlad|agjt togukl ejtuve |ob| vekabfke bddguj|aj` vedgvlt bve ce~| igv bkk vekeybj|

ej|a|aet bjl bvvbj`emej|t*

@ejevbk veruavemej|t /\gV B*6*2!

12* \oe veruavemej|t igv dgm~bjaet |g mbaj|baj bddguj|aj` vedgvltujlev dgm~bjq kbp bve tamakbv aj |oe |ovee vekeybj| Bd|t+ bjl ~vgyale |ob|bddguj|aj` vedgvlt mut| /a! dgvved|kq ex~kbaj bkk |vbjtbd|agjt+ /aa! ejbfke |oeiajbjdabk ~gta|agj gi |oe dgm~bjq |g fe le|evmajel pa|o vebtgjbfke bdduvbdqb| bjq |ame+ bjl /aaa! bkkgp iajbjdabk t|b|emej|t |g fe ~ve~bvel /Dgm~bjaetBd| 21?6+ t* 2 /igv dgm~bjaet igvmel ujlev |oe Dgm~bjaet Bd| 2142!+Dgm~bjaet Bd| 6>>9+ t* ?>+ bjlKama|el Kabfaka|q Dgm~bjaet Bd| 211+ t* 96D!* \oat veruave-mej| b~~kaet ve`bvlkett gi |oe ibd| |ob| |oe t|bjlbvl ajdgme |bx vb|e igv fg|ovetalej| bjl jgj-vetalej| dgm~bjaet at > ~evdej|*

16* ^bv|jevt bve fgujl |g vejlev |vue bddguj|t bjl iukk ajigvmb|agj gibkk |oaj`t biied|aj` |oe ~bv|jevtoa~ |g bjq ~bv|jev gv oat ke`bk ve~vetej|b-|ayet /^bv|jevtoa~ Bd| 21>1+ t* 4>!* Aj blla|agj+ |oe |bx kbp veruavet |ob| bkk

~bv|jevtoa~t /poe|oev igvmel ujlev Atke gi Mbj kbp gv g|oevpate! |ob| ea|oevlevaye ~vgia|t ivgm futajett dbvvael gj aj |oe Atke gi Mbj gv poado obye gjegv mgve ~bv|jevt vetalej| aj |oe Atke gi Mbj mut| iake b |bx ve|uvj /Ajdgme\bx Bd| 210>+ t* 94!* \oe gfka b|agj |g iake b ve|uvj |va``evt |oe veruavemej||g mbaj|baj tudo vedgvlt bt mbq fe jedettbvq igv mbcaj` b |vue+ dgvved| bjldgm~ke|e ve|uvj /Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210>+ t* ?>B!* Mgvegyev+ bjq ~evtgj |ob|at gfka`el |g ~ve~bve b ve|uvj dbj fq jg|ade fe veruavel |g ~ve~bve /gv obye~ve~bvel! tudo bddguj|t bt |oe jg|ade mbq veruave bjl lekayev tudo bddguj|tpa|oaj tudo vebtgjbfke ~evagl bt mbq fe t~edaiael /Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210>+ t*96F!* \oe jg|ade mbq veruave |oe bddguj|t |g fe dev|aiael gv bula|el*

\oe veruavemej| |g mbaj|baj bddguj|aj` vedgvlt at bj aj|e`vbk ~bv| gi ted-|agjt ?>B bjl ted|agj 96D /poado ~vgyalet igv |oe attuaj` gi jg|adet veruavaj`bddguj|t |g fe ~ve~bvel bjl ~vgludel |g |oe Bttettgv!* \oe ~ejbk|q igv jgj-dgm~kabjde ujlev Ted|agj ?>B at b iaje jg| exdeelaj` @F^ 2> >>> bjl ujlevted|agj 96D b iaje gi u~ |g @F^ 5 >>> gv 9 mgj|ot aj leibuk| /t*96F/

14* Poeve b kama|el ~bv|jevtoa~ igvmel ujlev Mbjx kbp obt jg ~bv|jevt|ob| bve vetalej| aj |oe Atke gi Mbj jgv bjq Mbjx tguvde ajdgme+ |oeve mbq

fe jg |bx ve~gv|aj` veruavemej|t ~kbdel gj a|* Ogpeyev+ kama|el ~bv|jevtoa~tbve veruavel |g obye b ~kbde gi futajett aj |oe Atke gi Mbj+ poado pgukl ea|oev

mebj |ob| a| at tufhed| |g |bx kbp /tajde a| at dbvvqaj` gj futajett aj |oe Atke gi

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

35/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 44

Mbj! gv+ ai a| at feaj` ~vgyalel b ~kbde gi futajett |ovgu`o b tevyade ~vgyalev/tudo bt b ve`at|evel giiade!+ |oej |oat pgukl dgjt|a|u|e b dgv~gvb|e tevyadebjl bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` vuket pgukl b~~kq*

12>+ t* 29+ bktg tee `ualbjde vuket aj vet~ed| gi vedgvl-cee~aj` veruave-mej|t letdvafel aj ted|agj B*4+ fekgp!* /Ibakuve |g mbaj|baj tudo vedgvlt attufhed| |g |oe ~ejbk|aet letdvafel aj ted|agj B*2*9+ bfgye*! Ogpeyev+ poeve|oe tevyade ~vgyalev at mevekq ~vgyalaj`+ igv exbm~ke+ b ve`at|evel giiade igv|oe ~bv|jevtoa~+ |oete vedgvlt pgukl gjkq vekb|e |g |ogte |vbjtbd|agjt vekb|aj`

|g |oe mbaj|ejbjde gi |oe ve`at|evel giiade+ bjl jg| jedettbvakq |g bjq g|oevbd|aya|aet gv |vbjtbd|agjt ujlev|bcej fq |oe ~bv|jevtoa~* Aj tudo b dbte+ |oevembq fe jg veruavemej| |g mbaj|baj bddguj|aj` vedgvlt* Dgjteruej|kq+ |oeveat jg t~edaiad veruavemej| |g mbaj|baj bddguj|aj` vedgvlt igv kama|el ~bv|jev-toa~t aj bkk dbtet*

15* Igv |vut|t+ b |vut|ee gv bjq ~evtgj blmajat|evaj` btte|t gj feobki gi|oe |vut| pakk fe tufhed| |g |oe vedgvl-cee~aj` veruavemej|t ~uvtubj| |g bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` veruavemej|t bt letdvafel bfgye* Aj blla|agj+ t~edaiad`ualbjde obt feej ~ufkatoel |ob| b~~kaet |g |vut| tevyade ~vgyalevt ~uvtubj|

|g poado |oeq bve ex~ed|el |g ejtuve |ob| |oe |vut| ~vg~ev|q at dkebvkq btdev-|bajel+ bjl a|t ybkue bjl jb|uve bve ujlevt|ggl* Gj bj gj-`gaj` fbtat |vut|tevyade ~vgyalevt togukl mbaj|baj8

Gva`ajbk |vut| lgdumej|t+ ajdkulaj` tuftalabvq lgdumej|t+ poadotogukl fe oekl aj tbie dut|glq*

Maju|e fggc |g vedgvl |oe ledatagjt gi |oe |vut|ee*

Le|bakt gi |oe btte|t oekl aj |vut| bjl bjq kabfaka|aet ajduvvel bt|vut|ee*

Bddguj|t bjl |bx vedgvlt*

Dg~aet gi vekeybj| dgvvet~gjlejde*

Le|bakt gi te||kgv+ fejeiadabk gfhed|t bjl ~vg|ed|gv+ ajdkulaj` iukk DLLbt b~~vg~vab|e aj bddgvlbjde pa|o bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` ke`atkb|agj*

Bjq ke`bk bjl |bxb|agj blyade |bcej*

Poake |oe `ualbjde lget jg| obye igvde gi kbp+ a| at jg|el |ob| |oe kbp lget~vgyale |ob| b dguv| dbj+ aj le|evmajaj` poe|oev b ~evtgj obt dgm~kael pa|o |oevedgvl-cee~aj` veruavemej|t am~gtel fq |oe bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` kbp+ |bce

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

36/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

4< DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ

aj|g bddguj| bjq vekeybj| tu~evyatgvq gv ve`ukb|gvq `ualbjde poado b~~kaet |g|ob| ~evtgj bjl poado at `ayej fq b dgm~e|ej| bu|ogva|q /^vgdeelt gi Dvame/Mgjeq Kbujlevaj`! Dgle 6>2>+ t* +t* ?>B/1+ t* 4>!+ am~kaet b lu|q |g tuft|bj|ab|e tudo bddguj|t fqmebjt gi tu~~gv|aj` lgdumej|t tudo bt dgj|vbd|t+ ajygadet bjl vedea~|t*

10* Aj bjq dbte poeve |oe |vut|ee at bd|aj` fq pbq gi futajett+ gv |oebtte|t gi |oe |vut|t bve feaj` mbjb`el fq b tevyade ~vgyalev+ bj|a-mgjeq kbuj-

levaj` vuket b~~kq |g |oe tevyade ~vgyalev* Aj |ob| dbte+ |oe tevyade ~vgyalevpakk fe veruavel |g mbaj|baj b vedgvl gi bkk |vbjtbd|agjt dbvvael gu| aj |oe

5* Kepaj gj \vut|t 20|o Ela|agj+ ~* 9603 Ujlevoakk bjl Obq|gj Kbp gi \vut|t bjl \vut|eet+

25|o Ela|agj+ ~* 950* \vut|eet mut| fe veblq |g dbute |oe bddguj|t gi |oe |vut| ~vg~ev|q

|g fe exbmajel gv bula|el fq bj ajle~ejlej| bddguj|bj| bjl mut| igv |ob| ~uv~gte ~vg-

lude tudo ygudoevt bjl `aye tudo ajigvmb|agj |g oam bt oe mbq veruave* \oe \vut|ee

mut| bkkgp b fejeiadabvq |g ajt~ed| |oe |vut| bddguj|t bjl bkk lgdumej|t vekb|aj` |g |oe

|vut|* TeeObktfuvqt Kbpt gi Ej`kbjlYgk

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

37/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 45

dguvte gi |oe futajett+ ajdkulaj` bddguj| iaket bjl futajett dgvvet~gjlejde+bjl tudo g|oev vedgvlt bt bve tuiiadaej| |g ~evma| vedgjt|vud|agj gi ajlayalubk|vbjtbd|agjt /^vgdeelt gi Dvame /Mgjeq Kbujlevaj`! Dgle 6>2>+ t* 29!* Igv|vut|t aj vet~ed| gi poado |oe |vut|ee at jg| tufhed| |g bj|a-mgjeq kbujlev-

aj` kbpt+ |oeve bve `ejevbk gfka`b|agjt ujlev |oe dgmmgj kbp |g fe bfke |gbddguj| |g |oe fejeiadabvaet+ poado bt t|b|el bfgye veruavet |ob| |oe |vut|eembaj|baj dkebv bjl lat|ajd| bddguj|t* \oat veruavet |ob| |oe |vut|ee togukl feaj b ~gta|agj |g tuft|bj|ab|e bjq |vbjtbd|agjt vekb|aj` |g |vut| btte|t fq mebjtgi tu~~gv|aj` lgdumej|t tudo bt dgj|vbd|t+ ajygadet bjl vedea~|t*

Lgdumej| ve|ej|agj /\gV B*6*4 bjl B*6*

1?* \oe lgdumej| ve|ej|agj ~evagl ujlev |oe |bx kbp at 9 qebvt bjl |oatb~~kaet |g bkk dgm~bjaet /Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210>+ ted* 96D! bjl ~bv|jevtoa~tveruavel |g iake b |bx ve|uvj /Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210>+ t* ?>B/6!/f!!*

11* Igv |vut|t bjl ~bv|jevtoa~t |ob| bve jg| g|oevpate tufhed| |g b ~ve-tdvafel ve|ej|agj ~evagl+ |oe dgmmgj kbp vuket am~kq b veruavemej| |g mbaj-|baj vedgvlt+ fu| lget jg| t~edaiq b ~evagl* B |vut|ee gv ~bv|jev mbq fe veruavel|g bddguj| |g b fejeiadabvq gv ~bv|jev /bt |oe dbte mbq fe! b| bjq |ame luvaj`|oe ~evtgjt |vut|eetoa~ gv |evm bt ~bv|jev+ bjl |oat ~evagl pgukl ex|ejl |g|oe ex~avq gi bjq ~vetdva~|agj ~evagl igv bd|agjt b`bajt| |oe |vut|ee gv ~bv|jev+poado at `ejevbkkq 9 qebvt ivgm |oe lb|e |oe dbute gi bd|agj bddvuel /Kama|b|agjBd| 21?< /bt bmejlel!+ t* 6!* \oat mbq fe |bcej |g mebj |ob| tudo vedgvlt

togukl fe ve|bajel igv b| kebt| |oe luvb|agj gi |oe |vut|eetoa~ gv ~bv|jevtoa~ ~kut9 qebvt* Poeve bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` vuket b~~kq+ lgdumej|t mut| fe ce~| igvb| kebt| 5 qebvt /^vgdeelt gi Dvame /Mgjeq Kbujlevaj`! Dgle 6>2>+ t* 20!*

Le|evmajb|agj bjl ibd|gvt ujlevkqaj` vedgmmejlb|agjt

Le|evmajb|agj

\oe ekemej| at aj ~kbde*

Ibd|gvt ujlevkqaj`

vedgmmejlb|agjt

Vedgmmejlb|agjt

Kama|el ~bv|jevtoa~t bve jg| tufhed|

|g b t~edaiad veruavemej| |g mbaj|baj

bddguj|aj` vedgvlt aj bkk dbtet*

Atke gi Mbj kbp togukl ejtuve |ob|

kama|el ~bv|jevtoa~t bve aj bkk dbtet

veruavel |g mbaj|baj vekabfke bddguj|-

aj` vedgvlt+ ajdkulaj` ujlevkqaj`

lgdumej|b|agj+ igv b| kebt| 5 qebvt*

Vb|aj`

\g fe dgm~ke|el gjde b ve~vetej|b|aye tufte| gi ^obte 6 veyaept obye

feej dgm~ke|el*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

38/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

49 DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ

B*4* Fbjcaj` ajigvmb|agj

Fbjcaj` ajigvmb|agj togukl fe bybakbfke igv bkk bddguj|-ogklevt*

Vedgvl-cee~aj` veruavemej|t /\gV B*4* 2!

2>>* \oe Atke gi Mbjt bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` kbpt b~~kq |g ~evtgjt dbvvq-aj` gj |oe igkkgpaj` bd|aya|aet /^vgdeelt gi Dvame /Mgjeq Kbujlevaj`! Dgle6>2>+ Tdoeluke 2!8

Bjq bd|aya|q dbvvael gj igv |oe ~uv~gte gi vbataj` mgjeq bu|ogvatel|g fe fgvvgpel ujlev |oeAtke gi Mbj Kgbjt Bd| 210>? bjl Dkbtt 6 gi Tdoeluke 2 |g |oe Ve`ukb|el Bd|aya|aet

Gvlev 6>>1 bt ai |oe exdkutagjt dgj|bajel pa|oaj |oe Gvlev gv |oeIajbjdabk Tevyadet /Exem~|agjt! Ve`ukb|agjt 6>>1 obl jg| feej mble*

Futajett dbvvael fq b tgdae|q ve`at|evel bt b dvela| ujagj pa|oaj |oemebjaj` gi |oe Dvela| Ujagjt Bd| 2114*

Le~gta| |bcaj` pa|oaj |oe mebjaj` gi ted|agj 4 gi |oe Iajbjdabk TevyadetBd| 6>>? bjl Dkbtt 2 gi Tdoeluke 2 |g |oe Ve`ukb|el Bd|aya|aet Gvlev6>>1 a`jgvaj` bjq exdkutagjt igv |ob| dkbtt dgj|bajel pa|oaj |oe Gvlevgv |oeIajbjdabk Tevyadet /Exem~|agjt! Ve`ukb|agjt 6>>1 obl jg| feejmble*

Bjq bd|aya|q dbvvael gj igv |oe ~uv~gte gi vbataj` mgjeq fq b kgdbkbu|ogva|q*

\oe futajett gi b fuvebu le dobj`e*

\oe futajett gi |oe ^gt| Giiade aj vet~ed| gi bjq bd|aya|q ujlev|bcejgj feobki gi |oe Jb|agjbk Tbyaj`t Fbjc*

Bjq bd|aya|q ajygkyaj` mgjeq /ajdkulaj` bjq ve~vetej|b|agj gi mgj-e|bvq ybkue! |vbjtmattagj tevyadet gv doerue ejdbtomej| ibdaka|aet*

\oe ~vgyatagj gi tbie dut|glq ibdaka|aet igv dbto gv karual teduva|aet gjfeobki gi g|oev ~evtgjt*

Kejlaj` ajdkulaj`+ fu| jg| kama|el |g+ dgjtumev dvela|+ mgv|`b`edvela| ibd|gvaj` bjl |oe iajbjde gi dgmmevdabk |vbjtbd|agjt*

Iajbjdabk kebtaj` bvvbj`emej|t aj vet~ed| gi ~vglud|t g|oev |objdgjtumev ~vglud|t*

Bjq futajett ajygkyaj` |oe attuaj` bjl mbjb`aj` gi mebjt gi ~bqmej|/ajdkulaj` fu| jg| kama|el |g dvela| bjl lefa| dbvlt+ doeruet+ |vbyekevt

doeruet+ mgjeq gvlevt+ fbjcevt lvbi|t bjl eked|vgjad mgjeq!*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

39/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 40

\oe futajett gi ~vgyalaj` iajbjdabk `ubvbj|eet bjl dgmma|mej|t*

Blmajat|evaj` gv mbjb`aj` mgjeq gj feobki gi g|oev ~evtgjt*

2>2* Dgjteruej|kq+ fbjct bjl g|oev iajbjdabk ajt|a|u|agjt bve dgyevelfq |oe dut|gmev lue laka`ejde bjl vedgvl-cee~aj` veruavemej|t gi |oe Atkegi Mbjt bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` kbpt* \oat ajdkulet alej|aiqaj` dkaej|t bjlmbaj|bajaj` vedgvlt gi bkk |vbjtbd|agjt ujlev|bcej gj |oe dkaej|t feobki/^vgdeelt gi Dvame /Mgjeq Kbujlevaj`! Dgle 6>2>+ tedt* 9+ 1+ 29! poe|oevaj vet~ed| gi bj gj-`gaj` vekb|agjtoa~ gv b gje-gii |vbjtbd|agj* \oe ITD obt~ve~bvel b objlfggc |ob| ekbfgvb|et gj |oe |q~et gi |vbjtbd|agjt vedgvlt|ob| mut| fe mbaj|bajel aj gvlev |g tb|atiq |oe t|b|u|gvq veruavemej|t+ poadogu|kajet |ob| aj eyevq dbte |vbjtbd|agj vedgvlt mut| dgj|baj /BMK'DI\Objlfggc+ t* ?*6!8

b! le|bakt gi |oe dut|gmev gv dguj|ev~bv|q+ ajdkulaj` bddguj| le|bakt3

f! |oe jb|uve gi |oe |vbjtbd|agj3 bjl

d! le|bakt gi |oe |vbjtbd|agj*

2>6* \oe objlfggc iuv|oev t|b|et |ob| b kadejte ogklev mut| ejtuve |ob| btb|atibd|gvq bula| |vbak dbj fe et|bfkatoel igv BMK'DI\ ~uv~gtet bjl |ob| biajbjdabk ~vgiake gi b tut~ed|el bddguj| gv dkaej| dgm~bjq dbj fe et|bfkatoel/BMK'DI\ Objlfggc+ t* ?*6*2!* \g tb|atiq |oete veruavemej|t+ |oe igkkgpaj`blla|agjbk ajigvmb|agj mut| fe tgu`o| bt b~~vg~vab|e /fbtel gj vatc!+ bjl

|vbjtbd|agj vedgvlt ve|bajel gi8b! |oe ygkume gi iujlt ikgpaj` |ovgu`o |oe bddguj|'|uvjgyev gi dkaej|

dgm~bjq3

f! |oe gva`aj gi |oe iujlt3

d! |oe igvm aj poado |oe iujlt peve giievel gv pa|olvbpj+ a*e* dbto+doerue+ e|d*3

l! |oe alej|a|q gi |oe ~evtgj ujlev|bcaj` |oe |vbjtbd|agj3

e! |oe let|ajb|agj gi |oe iujlt3

i! |oe igvm gi ajt|vud|agj bjl bu|ogva|q3

`! |oe jbme bjl bllvett /gv alej|aiadb|agj dgle! gi |oe dguj|ev ~bv|q3

o! |oe teduva|q lebk| aj+ ajdkulaj` ~vade bjl tae3

a! poe|oev |oe |vbjtbd|agj pbt b ~uvdobte gv b tbke3

h! |oe bddguj| le|bakt ivgm poado |oe iujlt peve ~bal /ajdkulaj`+ aj |oedbte gi doeruet+ fbjc jbme+ tgv| dgle+ bddguj| jumfev bjl jbme gibddguj| ogklev!3

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

40/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

4? DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ

c! |oe igvm bjl let|ajb|agj gi ~bqmej| mble fq |oe futajett |g |oedut|gmev3

k! poe|oev |oe ajyet|mej|t peve oekl aj tbie dut|glq fq |oe futajett gv

tej| |g |oe dut|gmev gv |g oat'oev gvlev bjl+ ai tg+ |g pob| jbme bjlbllvett3

m! bd|aya|aet gi |oe dkaej| dgm~bjq3 bjl

j! bjq kbv`e a|em'exde~|agj ve~gv|t dveb|el aj |oe dguvte gi |vbjtbd|agjmgja|gvaj`*

2>4* Poake |oe objlfggc at `ualbjde |ob| lget jg| obye |oe igvde gi kbpbjl tg at jg| t|vad|kq fajlaj` gj iajbjdabk ajt|a|u|agjt+ |oe ITD mbaj|bajt |ob|aj ~vbd|ade |oe keyek gi le|bak aj |oe objlfggc tevyet bt b tbie obvfguv igv

iajbjdabk ajt|a|u|agjt* Mgvegyev+ |oe dguv|t dbj |bce jg|ade gi |oe `ualbjdeattuel fq |oe Ve`ukb|gvq bu|ogva|q /^vgdeelt gi Dvame /Mgjeq Kbujlevaj`!Dgle 6>2>+ ted* 2>+ t* >>+ gv |g fg|o3 bjl

/f! gj dgjyad|agj gj ajigvmb|agj |g dut|glq jg| exdeelaj` 6 qebvt gv |gb iaje+ gv |g fg|o*

2>5* Aj blla|agj+ ibakuve fq b fbjc |g mbaj|baj fbjcaj` ajigvmb|agj+ btb fvebdo gi |oe BMK Dgle+ at b dgj|vbyej|agj gi ted|agj >? |oevefqbkkgpaj` |oe Dgmmattagj |g |bce ve`ukb|gvq bd|agj b`bajt| |oe fbjc* Aj |oete

davdumt|bjdet |oe Dgmmattagj dbj bktg |bce bd|agj b`bajt| |oe ajlayalubktajygkyel*

Ve`ukb|gvq Ejyavgjmej|

2>9* B |ebm gi < ajlayalubkt pa|oaj |oe ITD at leladb|el |g |oe ve`ukb|gvqtu~evyatagj gi |oe fbjcaj` ajlut|vq aj |oe Atke gi Mbj* \oeve bve 4< fbjctlgaj` futajett aj |oe Atke gi Mbj* B vbj`e gi ajt|a|u|agjt at ve~vetej|el+ ivgmkbv`e fbjcaj` `vgu~t |g tmbkk kgdbk tbyaj`t fbjct* \oe ajlut|vq em~kgqtb~~vgxamb|ekq 60>> ~eg~ke* Poake le~gta|t obye `vgpj gyev |oe ~bt| ledble+

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

41/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BYBAKBFAKA\Q GI AJIGVMB\AGJ 41

|oe jumfev gi fbjcaj` kadejtet obye veludel |ovgu`o mev`evt bjl dgj-tgkalb|agjt* \oe kadejtaj` vuket ve`bvlaj` fbjct peve veigvmel aj 211? pa|o|oe aj|vglud|agj gi b jep fbjcaj` kbp bjl dgle* \oete vuket peve iuv|oevu~lb|el aj 6>>? pa|o |oe aj|vglud|agjIajbjdabk Tevyadet Bd| 6>>?*

2>0* Gyevta`o| gi |oe fbjcaj` ajlut|vq at dgjlud|el aj b tamakbv ibtoagj |g|ob| letdvafel aj vet~ed| gi DT^t'\T^t+ dgjtat|ej| pa|o |oe ITDt ~ufkatoel`ualbjde* \oat ajdkulet b dgmfajb|agj gi bjjubk ve~gv|aj` gj dgm~kabjdemebtuvet bkgj` pa|o b dqdke gi gj-ta|e yata|t |g ejtuve dgm~kabjde* \oet|bjlbvlt |ob| b~~kq |g fvbjdoet bve tgmepob| laiievej| aj |evmt gi karuala|qveruavemej|t bjl igvea`j exdobj`e vuket+ fu| vedgvl-cee~aj` veruavemej|tbjl dut|gmev lue laka`ejde vuket bve alej|adbk poe|oev |oeq b~~kq |g Atke giMbj fbjct gv fvbjdoet gi igvea`j fbjct*

2>?* Tu~evyatagj gi fbjct at letc fbtel dgu~kel pa|o gj-ta|e yata|t*Gj-ta|e yata|t igv bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` ~uv~gtet obye feej |bcaj` ~kbdetajde 211? bjl aj 6>>1-6>2> le|bakel veyaept obye feej ujlev|bcej aj dgj-jed|agj pa|o |oe aj|vglud|agj gi |oe Iajbjdabk Tevyadet Bd| 6>>?* Gj-ta|eyata|t pakk tufteruej|kq fe dgjlud|el gj b 2 |g 4-qebv dqdke+ le~ejlaj` gjkeyek gi vatc* Ve`bvlkett gi vatc+ |oeve at bj bjjubk mee|aj` pa|o ebdo fbjc|g latdutt dgm~kabjde pa|o bj|a-mgjeq kbujlevaj` vuket bjl ebdo fbjc mut|dgm~ke|e bj bjjubk dgm~kabjde ve~gv|* ^bv|adukbv bvebt gi igdut pa|oaj |oeajlut|vq obye feej |oe ~vgdeluvet bvgujl aj|vgludel futajett bjl |oe mgja-|gvaj` gi bddguj|t* \oe ITD ve~gv|t exdekkej| dgmmujadb|agj pa|o fbjct gj

ogp |oeq dgm~kq pa|o ve`ukb|gvq veruavemej|t bjl |oeve at jg ajladb|agj |ob||oeve at bjq leiadaejdq aj |oe mbaj|ejbjde gi fbjc vedgvlt*

Le|evmajb|agj bjl ibd|gvt ujlevkqaj` vedgmmejlb|agjt

Le|evmajb|agj

\oe ekemej| at aj ~kbde*

Vb|aj`

\g fe dgm~ke|el gjde b ve~vetej|b|aye tufte| gi ^obte 6 veyaept obye

feej dgm~ke|el*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

42/83

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

43/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BDDETT \G AJIGVMB\AGJ 1* B ybvae|q gi ajigvmb|agj mbq fe jeelel aj b |bx ejruavq bjl huvatlad-|agjt togukl obye |oe bu|ogva|q |g gf|baj bkk tudo ajigvmb|agj* \oat ajdkuletajigvmb|agj oekl fq fbjct bjl g|oev iajbjdabk ajt|a|u|agjt bt pekk bt ajigvmb-|agj dgjdevjaj` |oe gpjevtoa~ gi dgm~bjaet gv |oe alej|a|q gi aj|evet| ogklevtaj g|oev ~evtgjt gv ej|a|aet+ tudo bt ~bv|jevtoa~t bjl |vut|t+ bt pekk bt bddguj|-aj` ajigvmb|agj aj vet~ed| gi bkk tudo ej|a|aet* \oat ted|agj gi |oe ve~gv|exbmajet poe|oev |oe Atke gi Mbjt ke`bk bjl ve`ukb|gvq ivbmepgvc `ayet|oe bu|ogva|aet bddett ~gpevt |ob| dgyev bkk vekeybj| ~eg~ke bjl ajigvmb|agj+bjl poe|oev va`o|t bjl tbie`ubvlt bve dgm~b|afke pa|o eiied|aye exdobj`e giajigvmb|agj* A| bktg bttettet |oe eiied|ayejett gi |oat ivbmepgvc aj ~vbd|ade*

22>* \oe ~gpev gi |oe Atke gi Mbj |bx bu|ogva|aet |g gf|baj ajigvmb|agj igvexdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj ~uv~gtet aj |bx mb||evt at dkebv* Ebdo exdobj`e gi ajigv-mb|agj bvvbj`emej| at fvgu`o| aj|g igvde fq bj gvlev gi \qjpbkl |ob| ~vgyalet|ob| |oe bvvbj`emej| tobkk obye eiied| jg|pa|ot|bjlaj` bjq g|oev ejbd|mej|+ bjlpoado mglaiaet |oe fbtad bddett ~gpevt dgj|bajel aj |oe Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210>|g ejtuve |ob| |oeq b~~kq igv |oe ~uv~gtet gi |oe bvvbj`emej|* Aj blla|agj |g |oe

~gpevt bybakbfke |g |oe |bx bu|ogva|aet ujlev |oe |bx kbp+ veruet|t igv ajigvmb|agjaj |bx mb||evt dbj bktg fe dobjjekkel |ovgu`o |oe B||gvjeq-@ejevbk aj dvamajbkdbtet eyej aj |oe bftejde gi bj exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj bvvbj`emej|*

222* Bu|ogva|aet obye tuiiadaej| ~gpev |g dgm~ek ~vglud|agj gi ajigvmb-|agj+ ajdkulaj`+ aj b~~vg~vab|e dbtet+ tebvdo bjl teauve poeve |oeve bve veb-tgjbfke `vgujlt igv tut~ed|aj` |ob| bj giiejde ajygkyaj` ivbul aj dgjjed|agjpa|o gv aj vekb|agj |g ajdgme |bx at feaj`+ obt feej gv at bfgu| |g fe dgmma|-|el* Aj ~vbd|ade+ |oe |bx bu|ogva|aet obye jg| obl |g vetgv| |g tudo ~gpevt+ btbkk veruet|t igv ajigvmb|agj obye feej ~vgdettel pa|ogu| bjq gfhed|agj fq |oe~evtgj aj ~gttettagj gi |oe ajigvmb|agj*

226* \oeve bve kama|b|agjt gj |oe bddett |g ajigvmb|agj lue |g exde~|agjt|ob| b~~kq aj |oe dbte gi ke`bk ~vayake`e+ |oe dgjialej|abk dgmmujadb|agjt

gi b |bx blyatev+ gv |ob| vekb|e |g |oe pgvc gi bj bula|gv* Aj ~vbd|ade+ |oete

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

44/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

5G gi |oe Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210>* \oete ~gpevtbkkgp |oe Bttettgv |g gf|baj lgdumej|bvq ajigvmb|agj ivgm bjq ~evtgj pa|ovet~ed| |g |ob| ~evtgjt kabfaka|q |g |bx gv ivgm bjq g|oev ~evtgj aj vet~ed| gib |bx~bqevt kabfaka|q* \oe ~gpevt+ bt |oeq bve lvbi|el igv lgmet|ad ~uv~gtet+lg jg| dgj|em~kb|e gf|bajaj` ajigvmb|agj igv |oe ~uv~gte gi iukiakkaj` bj

exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj veruet|* \oe Atke gi Mbj obt bllvettel |oat attue fqveyataj` |oete ~gpevt t~edaiadbkkq igv |oe ~uv~gte gi ebdo exdobj`e gi ajigvmb-|agj bvvbj`emej| ej|evel aj|g* \oete ~gpevt bve mglaiael |g bkkgp igv bddett|g ajigvmb|agj aj vet~gjte |g b veruet| igv ajigvmb|agj ujlev b lgufke |bxbvvbj`emej| /L\B! gv |bx ajigvmb|agj exdobj`e b`veemej| /\AEB! fq mebjtgi bj gvlev ujlev t* 21 gi |oeAjdgme \bx Bd| 6>>4 /igv \AEBt! gv ujlev t* 5< gi|oeAjdgme \bx Bd| 210> /igvL\Bt!* Poeve bj gvlev obt feej mble+ |oej |oebvvbj`emej| tobkk obye eiied| jg|pa|ot|bjlaj` bjq|oaj` aj bjq ejbd|mej|*

225* Gvlevt obye feej mble aj vet~ed| gi bkk L\Bt bjl \AEBt ej|evelaj|g fq |oe Atke gi Mbj* \oe gvlevt ~vgyale igv mglaiadb|agjt |g |oe dgj|ej| gi

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

45/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BDDETT \G AJIGVMB\AGJ 5D |g 2>5G gi |oeAjdgme \bx Bd| 210>+ |g t~edaiq |ob| jg|adet igv|oe ~vglud|agj gi ajigvmb|agj mbq fe mble fq |oe Bttettgv poeve |oe Bttettgvfekaeyet a| |g fe jedettbvq igv |oe ~uv~gte gi vet~gjlaj` |g b veruet| mble fq|oe dgj|vbd|aj` ~bv|q aj bddgvlbjde pa|o |oe b~~kadbfke bvvbj`emej|t* Aj blla-

|agj+ |oe leiaja|agjt gi |bx bjl |bx~bqev bve mglaiael tudo |ob| kabfaka|q igv|bx ujlev |oe dgj|vbd|aj` ~bv|qt kbpt at vekeybj| igv |oe ~uv~gte gi exevdataj`|oe Bttettgvt ~gpevt ujlev |oeAjdgme \bx Bd| 210>*

229* Lgdumej|bvq ajigvmb|agj mebjt bjq t|b|emej|+ ibd|+ vedgvl gv lgdu-mej| aj bjq igvm /Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210>+ t* 2>5G!* \oe tdg~e gi |oat leiaja|agj

~vgyalet |oe dgm~e|ej| bu|ogva|q |oe ~gpev |g ~u| ruet|agjt |g b ~evtgj poejveruet|el fq bj exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj ~bv|jev* \oeve bve ~ejbk|aet igv ibak-uve |g dgm~kq gv igv ~vgyalaj` ajigvmb|agj |ob| at jg| |vue* /Ajdgme \bx Bd|210>+ ted* 2>5G!*

220* Aj vekb|agj |g dvamajbk |bx mb||evt /poado ajdkulet |bxet gi bjq cajl!ajigvmb|agj dbj bktg fe gf|bajel bjl ~vgyalel ujlev |oe Dvamajbk Hut|adeBd|t /DHB! 211> bjl 2112*

22?* Ted|agj 6< DHB 211> ~vgyalet igv |oe B||gvjeq @ejevbk+ aj bjq dbteaj poado a| b~~ebvt |g oam gj vebtgjbfke `vgujlt |ob| |oeve at b tut~ed|elgiiejde ajygkyaj` tevagut gv dgm~kex ivbul+ poeveyev dgmma||el+ |g attue bjg|ade veruavaj` bjq ~evtgj pogm oe obt vebtgjbfke `vgujl |g fekaeye obtvekeybj| ajigvmb|agj |g ~vglude lgdumej|t poado b~~ebv |g oam |g fe vek-eybj| |g |oe ajyet|a`b|agj gv bjq lgdumej|t gi b t~edaiael dkbtt poado b~~ebv

|g oam |g tg vekb|e* Veruet|t igv bttat|bjde ujlev |oat ted|agj dbj fe mble fqbjq ~evtgj pog obt dgjlud| gi b dvamajbk ajyet|a`b|agj aj bjg|oev dguj|vqpoado ajdkulet |oe ~gkade gv |bxb|agj bu|ogva|aet*

221* Ted|agj 62 DHB 2112 /bt tuft|a|u|el fq Tdoeluke 9 gi |oe^vgdeelt giDvame Bd| 6>>?! ~vgyalet |ob| poeve |oe B||gvjeq @ejevbk vedeayet b veruet|igv bttat|bjde ivgm b dguv|+ |vafujbk gv ~vgtedu|aj` bu|ogva|q aj bjg|oev dguj-|vq gv |evva|gvq gv ivgm bjq g|oev vekeybj| bu|ogva|q aj gf|bajaj` eyalejde aj|oe Atkbjl aj dgjjed|agj pa|o dvamajbk ~vgdeelaj`t gv b dvamajbk ajyet|a`b-|agj gv blmajat|vb|aye ~vgdeelaj`t /bt leiajel! gv bj ajyet|a`b|agj aj|g bj bd|

~ujatobfke aj tudo ~vgdeelaj`t |oe B||gvjeq @ejevbk mbq b~~kq |g |oe Oa`oFbakaii /Tummbvq Dguv|! |g vedeaye tudo eyalejde bt mbq fe b~~vg~vab|e igv|oe ~uv~gtet gi `ayaj` eiied| |g |oe veruet|*

26>* Ai a| b~~ebvt |g |oe B||gvjeq @ejevbk |ob| |oe veruet| igv bttat|bjdevekb|et |g b iatdbk giiejde aj vet~ed| gi poado ~vgdeelaj`t obye jg| qe| feejajt|a|u|el+ |oe B||gvjeq @ejevbk mbq jg| bvvbj`e igv |oe eyalejde |g fe tggf|bajel ujkett

b! |oe veruet| at ivgm b dguj|vq gv |evva|gvq poado at b memfev gi |oeDgmmgjpebk|o gv at mble ~uvtubj| |g b |veb|q |g poado |oe Uja|el

Caj`lgm at b ~bv|q bjl ex|ejlt |g |oe Atkbjl3 gv

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

46/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

pakk jg| bkkgp |oat*Ogpeyev+ |oe Dvamajbk Hut|ade Bd|t 211> bjl 2112 bkkgp igv |et|amgjq |g fe|bcej feigve b hul`e+ bjl b veruet| ujlev |ogte bd|t dbj fe mble aj dbtet gi |bxivbul poe|oev gv jg| bj exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj bvvbj`emej| at aj eiied|* \oeB||gvjeq-@ejevbkt giiade aj |oe Atke gi Mbj vedeayel mgve |obj 1> veruet|tigv ajigvmb|agj aj 6>>1 ivgm b ybvae|q gi dguj|vaet ujlev |oe Dvamajbk Hut|adeBd| 211> bjl 2112+ bjl obye |pg iukk-|ame kbpqevt leladb|el |g objlkaj` tudoveruet|t* A| at am~gv|bj| |g jg|e |ob| |oeve at jg jedetta|q |ob| veruet|t igv ajigv-mb|agj aj dvamajbk |bx mb||evt mut| fe ~vgdettel ujlev |oe Dvamajbk Hut|ade

Bd|t+ bt exdobj`e aj |oete mb||evt dbj bktg fe ~vgdettel ujlev b \AEB gv L\B*

266* \oe bddett ~gpevt aj |oe Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210> letdvafel bfgye lgjg| b~~kq |g ~evtgjbk vedgvlt+ hguvjbkat|ad mb|evabk gv a|emt tufhed| |g ke`bk

~vayake`e /Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210>+ t* 2>5@!* Hguvjbkat|ad mb|evabk at bjq mb|evabkdveb|el igv hguvjbkat|ad ~uv~gtet+ poevebt ~evtgjbk vedgvlt veiev `ejevbkkq|g meladbk vedgvlt /Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210>+ t* 2>5G+ bt leiajel aj |oe ^gkade

^gpevt bjl ^vgdeluvet Bd| 211?!* \oe |evm a|emt tufhed| |g ke`bk ~vayake`eat leiajel bt /Ajdgme \bx Bd| 210>+ t* 2>5G+^gkade ^gpevt bjl ^vgdeluvetBd| 211?+ t* 24!8

/2! Tufhed| |g tufted|agj /6!+ aj |oat Bd| a|emt tufhed| |g ke`bk ~vayake`emebjt

/b! dgmmujadb|agjt fe|peej b ~vgiettagjbk ke`bk blyatev bjl oatdkaej| gv bjq ~evtgj ve~vetej|aj` oat dkaej| mble aj dgjjed|agjpa|o |oe `ayaj` gi ke`bk blyade |g |oe dkaej|3

/f! dgmmujadb|agjt fe|peej b ~vgiettagjbk ke`bk blyatev bjl oatdkaej| gv bjq ~evtgj ve~vetej|aj` oat dkaej| gv fe|peej tudo bjblyatev gv oat dkaej| gv bjq tudo ve~vetej|b|aye bjl bjq g|oev~evtgj mble aj dgjjed|agj pa|o gv aj dgj|em~kb|agj gi ke`bk~vgdeelaj`t bjl igv |oe ~uv~gtet gi tudo ~vgdeelaj`t3 bjl

/d! a|emt ejdkgtel pa|o gv veievvel |g aj tudo dgmmujadb|agjt bjlmble

/a! aj dgjjed|agj pa|o |oe `ayaj` gi ke`bk blyade3 gv

/aa! aj dgjjed|agj pa|o gv aj dgj|em~kb|agj gi ke`bk ~vgdeelaj`tbjl igv |oe ~uv~gtet gi tudo ~vgdeelaj`t+ poej |oeq bve aj|oe ~gttettagj gi b ~evtgj pog at ej|a|kel |g ~gttettagj gi|oem*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

47/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

DGM^KABJDE PA\O \OE T\BJLBVLT8 BDDETT \G AJIGVMB\AGJ ~vgyalet |ob| b jg|ade ujlev ted|agj 2>5L/6! gi |ob|Bd|8

b! lget jg| gfka`e b ~evtgj pog obt feej b~~gaj|el bt bj bula|gv igv |oe~uv~gtet gi bjq ejbd|mej| |g lekayev gv mbce bybakbfke lgdumej|tpoado bve oat ~vg~ev|q bjl peve dveb|el fq oam gv gj oat feobki igvgv aj dgjjed|agj pa|o |oe ~evigvmbjde gi oat iujd|agjt ujlev |ob|ejbd|mej|+ bjl

f! lget jg| gfka`e b |bx blyatev |g lekayev gv mbce bybakbfke lgdumej|tpoado bve oat ~vg~ev|q bjl dgjtat| gi vekeybj| dgmmujadb|agjt*

8/6/2019 Peer Review Report Combined: Phase 1 + Phase 2 Isle of Man

48/83

^EEV VEYAEP VE^GV\ DGMFAJEL ^OBTE 2 BJL ^OBTE 6 VE^GV\ ATKE GI MBJ GEDL 6>22

+ t* 2>5@/6!!*

260* Pa|o vet~ed| |g |oe kama|b|agj gj bddett |g ajigvmb|agj oekl fq |bxblyatevt+ Atke gi Mbj bu|ogva|aet em~obtate |ob| |oat b~~kaet gjkq |g |oe blyadegi |oe |bx blyatev+ bjl jg| |g bjq |vbjtbd|agj lgdumej| exedu|el gj |oe dka-ej|t feobki* Igv exbm~ke+ ai |oe |bx blyatev peve |g exedu|e b |vbjtbd|agj gjfeobki gi |oe dkaej|+ |oe |vbjtbd|agj lgdumej|t |oemtekyet /tudo bt dgm~bjqigvmb|agj lgdumej|t! pgukl jg| fe dgyevel fq |oe exde~|agj* Tamakbvkq+ ai

|oe |bx blyatev peve dobv`el pa|o mbaj|bajaj` b tobve ve`at|ev aj vet~ed| gib dgm~bjq gpjel fq |oe dkaej|+ |oe ve`at|ev a|teki pgukl jg| dgjt|a|u|e b vek-eybj| dgmmujadb|agj*

26?* \oeve bve kama|b|agjt gj |oe bddett |g ajigvmb|agj lue |g exde~|agjt|ob| b~~kq aj |oe dbte gi ke`bk ~vayake`e+ |oe dgjialej|abk dgmmujadb|agjt gi b|bx blyatev+ gv |ob| vekb|e |g |oe pgvc gi bj bula|gv* Aj ~vbd|ade+ |oete exde~-|agjt obye jeyev feej ajygcel |g ~veyej| |oe |bx bu|ogva|aet ivgm gf|bajaj`ajigvmb|agj igv |oe ~uv~gtet gi bj exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj veruet|+ bjl+ ai|oeq lal bvate+ |oe Atke gi Mbj bu|ogva|aet pakk bu|oej|adb|e |oe ybkala|q gi bjq

dkbam |g |oete exde~|agjt* \oe Atke gi Mbj togukl veyaep a|t ~gkadq ve`bvlaj`bddett |g ajigvmb|agj oekl fq ke`bk blyatevt+ |bx blyatevt bjl bula|gvt bjlejtuve |ob| a| at dgm~b|afke pa|o eiied|aye exdobj`e gi ajigvmb|agj* \oe Atkegi Mbj bu|ogva|aet mbaj|baj b ve`at|ev utel |g vedgvl bkk exde~|agjt |g lat-dkgtuve+ poado pgukl alej|aiq bjq dbtet vbatel fq vedgvl cee~evt dgjdevjaj`dgmmujadb|agjt tufhed| |g ke`bk ~vayake`e+ dgjialej|abk dgmmujadb|agjt gi b|bx blyatev+ gv |ob| vekb|e |g |oe pgvc gi bj bula|gv* \oe Atke gi Mbj bu|ogva-|aet togukl ajdkule aj |oat ve`at|ev bj bjbkqtat gi |oe eiied| |ob| |oe exde~|agj|g latdkgtuve obt aj ebdo dbte gj |oe EGA Uja|t bfaka|q |g vet~gjl |g |oevekeybj| veruet|+ e*`* poe|oev |oat obt biied|el a|t bfaka|q |g ~vgyale |oe ajigv-

mb|agj veruet|el aj pogke gv aj ~bv|*

Gf|bajaj` Ajigvmb|agj aj ^vbd|ade

261* \oe Le~u|q Bttettgv gi \bxet at |oe g~evb|agjbk mbjb`ev igv ajigv-mb|agj exdobj`e* B| iavt| ajt|bjde+ bjq veruet| |ob| at mble ~uvtubj| |g b\AEB gv L\B at veyaepel fq |oe Le~u|q Bttettgv |g`e|oev pa|o b kbpqevivgm |oe B||gvjeq-@ejevbkt giiade |g le|evmaje poe|oev |oe ajigvm