educational forum in obstetrics gynaecology of ranzcog/fnu cmnhs educational forum in obstetrics and...
TRANSCRIPT
College of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences
The Royal Australian and New ZealandCollege of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists
24-29 June 2012 | Lautoka, Fiji
FNU and RANZCOG are pleased to acknowledge the support and involvement from the following bodies:
final report
College of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences
educational forum in obstetrics gynaecology
The Royal Australian and New ZealandCollege of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
1
CONTENTS
Page
Acknowledgements
Message from the Chairman, Organising Committee
2
4
Seminar ‘Evidence Based Updates in Clinical Obstetrics and
Gynaecology Practice’
5
Inaugural meeting of the Fiji Obstetrics and Gynaecology Society (FOGS)
10
Educational Forum Dinner
11
RANZCOG/PSRH Emergency Obstetrics and Neonatal Care Workshop
12
RANZCOG/ASCCP Colposcopy Workshop
16
RANZOG/PSRH Pacific Obstetrics and Gynaecology Ultrasound Workshop
19
RANZCOG/FOFH Laparoscopy Training workshop
21
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
2
Acknowledgements
On behalf of the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists
(RANZCOG) and the Fiji National University College of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences (FNU
CMNHS) we have pleasure in presenting the Report of the inaugural RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational
Forum in Obstetrics and Gynaecology, held in Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012.
The forum comprised a seminar and clinical workshop program bringing together, for the first time, local
and international specialists in obstetrics and gynaecology, for an interesting, innovative and interactive
learning experience for O&G postgraduate trainees, specialist obstetrician gynaecologists, and other
reproductive health workers from Fiji and other PICs.
Simultaneously, the forum was a unique opportunity designed to initiate networking and develop closer
liaisons in the region, and a number of suggestions were forthcoming about ways that the Pacific can
interact more with Asian, Australian and New Zealand colleagues through the network of Obstetrics and
Gynaecology societies in the Oceania region.
A necessary element to hosting a meeting of this size is significant funding to enable the event to
proceed. RANZCOG and FNU CMNHS would therefore like to express their sincere appreciation to the
following bodies:
• AusAID, through the Strengthening Specialist Clinical Services in the Pacific project
• UNFPA
• Asia Oceania Federation of Obstetrics and Gynaecology (AOFOG)
• Australian Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology (ASCCP)
• Friends of Fiji Health (FOFH)
• Pacific Society for Reproductive Health (PSRH)
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
3
The other equally important element in hosting the 2012 Educational Forum in O&G was the personal
commitment to delivery of a high quality educational program, with associated social and logistical
aspects, provided by the organising committee, facilitators, lecturers and staff manning the various
facilities used during the week-long forum.
Special acknowledgement is made of:
Educational Forum – Seminar and Workshop Organisers
Professor Rajat Gyaneshwar Chief Local Organiser FNU CMNHS
Dr Amanda Noovao-Hill Second in Charge FNU CMNHS
Ms Carmel Walker Senior Coordinator RANZCOG
Ms Vinau Savu Project Officer FNU CMNHS
Dr Miriam O’Connor Emergency Obstetrics Workshop Leader
Matron Emma Deloi Emergency Obstetrics Workshop Local Organiser
Dr Jeffrey Tan Colposcopy Workshop Leader
Dr Virisila Sema Colposcopy Workshop Local Organiser
Professor Peter Stone Pacific O&G Ultrasound Workshop Leader
Dr Amanda Noovao-Hill Pacific O&G Ultrasound Workshop Local organiser
Dr Sunil Pillay Laparoscopic Surgery Workshop Leader
Dr Jimi Taria Laparoscopic Surgery Workshop Local Organiser
Dr Luisa Cikamatana-Rauto Medical Superintendent Lautoka Hospital
We are confident that the joint inaugural RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics and
Gynaecology in Lautoka has been a significant step forward in partnerships between Fiji, the Pacific and
regional bodies concerned with maternal and child health.
We hope the momentum generated by the event will continue with fervour.
Professor Ian Rouse Dr Rupert Sherwood
Dean, College of Medicine Nursing and President, The Royal Australian and
Health Sciences, Fiji National University New Zealand College of Obstetricians and
Gynaecologists
July 2012
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
4
Message from the Chairman, Organising Committee
For the first time in 2012, RANZCOG and FNU CMNHS joined together to provide an Educational Forum
in Obstetrics and Gynaecology, over the period 23 June to 29 June. The forum comprised a one-day
Seminar, held at the Tanoa Waterfront Hotel, followed by four concurrent workshops held at Lautoka
Hospital over the following week.
The timing of the Educational Forum was planned to coincide with a visit by a significant number of
internationally renowned specialist obstetricians and gynaecologists, visiting Lautoka for the 2012
Council meeting of the Asia & Oceania Federation of Obstetrics and Gynaecology (AOFOG). This
provided the opportunity for a number of visiting AOFOG representatives to join with RANZCOG and
FNU CMNHS lecturers as speakers and facilitators for the seminar and workshop program the following
week. The report of the various components of the forum is contained in this report.
On behalf of the Organising Committee, may I express our sincere appreciation to all who contributed to
the success of the Seminar and Workshop program - as participants, facilitators, organisers, supporters,
donors, hospital staff and friends.
We were thrilled at the enthusiasm and goodwill amongst colleagues, as we work towards our common
goal in the provision of quality care for women and their families in the Pacific.
Professor Rajat Gyaneshwar
Chief Local Organiser
Professor of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, FNU CMNHS
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
5
Seminar ‘Evidence Based Updates in Clinical Obstetrics and Gynaecology Practice’
1. Seminar Organisers
Professor Rajat Gyaneshwar Chief Local Organiser FNU CMNHS
Dr Amanda Noovao-Hill Second in Charge FNU CMNHS
Ms Carmel Walker Senior Coordinator RANZCOG
Ms Vinau Savu Project Officer FNU CMNHS
2. Report of the Seminar Organiser, Professor Rajat Gyaneshwar
The seminar ‘Evidence Based Updates in Clinical Obstetrics and Gynaecology Practice’ was a
central feature of the educational form. This was the event at which all participants came
together for a lecture program delivered by local and international speakers, on a range of key
areas relevant to O&G practice. The seminar was attended by approximately 100 participants,
comprising O&G trainees and specialists from Fiji and surrounding Pacific island countries (PICs),
and O&G specialists representing AOFOG, the Pacific Society for Reproductive Health (PSRH) and
the Australian Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology (ASCCP) as well as RANZCOG and
FNU CMNHS.
Contributors to the seminar program were as follows:
Professor Yu-Shih Yang President AOFOG Taiwan
Professor Ian Rouse Dean, FNU CMNHS
Suva Fiji
Dr Alec Ekeroma President, PSRH
New Zealand
Dr Wame Baravilala Adviser in Reproductive Health
UNFPA Pacific Sub-Regional Office
Suva Fiji
Dr James Fong Head of O&G, CWMH Suva Fiji
Dr Kenneth Clark Chairman, RANZCOG Asia Pacific
Committee
New Zealand
Dr Rupert Sherwood President, RANZCOG Australia
Dr Shanti Raman Senior Research Fellow and
Community Paediatrician/ Human
Resources for Health Knowledge
Hub @ UNSW
Australia
Dr Swaran Naidu Specialist Obstetrician/
Gynaecologist
Lautoka Fiji
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
6
Dr Rekha Joseph Specialist Obstetrician
Gynaecologist
Chennai India
Dr Jaydeep Tank Chairman Reproductive
Endocrinology Committee AOFOG
Mumbai India
Professor PC Ho Immediate Past President, AOFOG Hong Kong
Dr Rohana Haththotuwa Deputy Secretary-General, AOFOG Sri Lanka
Dr Sunil Pillay Specialist Obstetrician
Gynaecologist
New Zealand
Dr Pushpa Nusair Specialist Obstetrician
Gynaecologist
Suva Fiji
Professor Walfrido Sumpaico Secretary-General, AOFOG Philippines
Dr P.K Shah Council Member (India) Mumbai India
Dr Amanda Noovao-Hill Specialist Obstetrician
Gynaecologist
Lautoka Fiji
Dr Rajendra Kumar Specialist Obstetrician
Gynaecologist
New Zealand
Dr Kurian Joseph President-Elect, AOFOG
Chennai India
Dr Jeffrey Tan Specialist Obstetrician
Gynaecologist
Australia
Dr Digby Ngan Kee Specialist Obstetrician
Gynaecologist
New Zealand
Dr Ravi Chandran Treasurer, AOFOG Malaysia
The target audience for the program was the postgraduates in O&G and current O&G specialists
in Fiji and those who had completed their MMed in Fiji and returned to their own Pacific Island
countries (PICs). These participants were given central seating in the seminar so that it was
clear to them that they were the target group for the lectures.
The program was developed as four sessions:
• Session 1: Professional Development
• Session 2: Reproductive Endocrinology
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
7
• Session 3: Intrapartum Care
• Session 4: Gynaecology
After an overview of challenges in maternal and reproductive health in the Pacific by leading
local obstetrician gynaecologist, Dr James Fong, the first session utilised the expertise of
RANZCOG experts and what Australian and New Zealand Colleges can do to support
professionalism in the Pacific.
Sessions 2-4 focussed on clinical areas, with the lecture topics chosen to complement the FNU
CMNHS O&G curriculum, providing updates on key areas relevant to clinical O&G practice, and
utilising the expertise of a number of leading international speakers on these topics.
At the conclusion of each session was a panel discussion with experts who had provided the
lectures, to answer questions or raise queries about local issues relevant to the lectures.
An electronic responder system was used during several of the presentations, to encourage
participation from all students, in a de-identified way, and this was successful. It was felt that
the electronic responder system facility could be further explored by faculty at the medical
school, as a useful tool for teachers to identify areas to focus on in situations where students
may be shy in revealing what areas they need further help with, or in fact unable to identify
gaps in knowledge.
The powerpoint presentations from each speaker were made available on the RANZCOG
website for seminar participants to download.
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
8
2. Evaluation of the seminar
Evaluation forms were completed by 38 Fijian and Pacific O&G trainees and specialists.
Level of satisfaction
Respondents reported the following level of satisfaction regarding the seminar and its content:
Registration process Satisfied 52% Very satisfied 48%
Training materials Satisfied 48% Very satisfied 52%
Speakers/presenters Satisfied 29% Very satisfied 61%
Training facilities Satisfied 65% Very satisfied 34%
Appropriate and informative training sessions Agree 50% Strongly agree 50%
Well organised training Agree 48% Strongly agree 52%
Satisfactory training location Agree 50% Strongly agree 50%
Supportive and helpful training staff Agree 68% Strongly agree 32%
Additional comments
Alternative venue:
Suva or Nadi as possible alternate venue
Topics suggested for future seminars:
A wide range of topics were suggested for future seminars and these will be noted by the
organising committee.
Areas most enjoyed by participants:
The areas that participants liked the most were particular topics, the mix of speakers from
different backgrounds, and the fact that the presentations were evidence-based.
Areas least enjoyed by participants:
A variety of comments included absence of midwifery participation and lack of time after each
speaker for questions and comments.
Improvements for next seminar:
A range of suggestions were made including more frequent seminars of this type, more use of
the responder system, more case scenarios and better food.
Relevancy of the seminar to practice:
100% of respondents reported Yes to the following questions.
Will the seminar assist current clinical practice?
Was training relevant?
Would you recommend this seminar?
Rating of the seminar to other training of this type previously attended:
Very good 55% Excellent 45%
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
9
In addition to feedback from Fijian and Pacific participants, comments on the seminar were
sought from the perspective of the visiting specialists from the Asian region (AOFOG
representatives). These comments commended the efforts of the local organisers and venue. It
was felt that the topics were appropriately selected with good response and interactions by
delegates. It was suggested that future seminars be needs based with more time for interaction
at the end of each talk. The use of the responder system was commended and it was felt that
more seminars of this type should be conducted using local faculty and faculty from adjacent
countries. The presentation ‘Challenges in Maternal Health in the Pacific’ was of interest to
visiting O&G specialists from the Asian region.
Dr James Fong, Head of O&G at Colonial War Memorial Hospital, Suva, present on ‘Challenges in Maternal Health in the Pacfific’
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
10
Inaugural meeting of the Fiji Obstetrics and Gynaecology Society (FOGS)
Immediately following the seminar, the inaugural meeting of the Fiji O&G Society (FOGS) was held at the
Tanoa Waterfront Hotel, taking advantage of the number of interested persons present who would be
potential members for FOGS. At the FOGS meeting the FOGS Constitution was adopted, with the
following office bearers declared elected:
President Dr Swaran Naidu
Vice President Dr James Fong
Secretary/Treasurer Dr Amanda Noovao-Hill
General Members Dr Kelera Sakumeli
Dr Vasitia Cati
At the Seminar Dinner the official launch of FOGS was delivered by the President of Fiji. Dr Naidu then
addressed the dinner gathering and introduced the member of the FOGS Executive.
Dr Rey de los Reyes, (President Philippine Society of O&G), Dr Kelera Sakumeli, Dr Alec Ekeroma (Presdient PSRH), Dr James Fong, Dr Rupert
Sherwood (President RANZCOG), Dr Swaran Naidu (President FOGS), the Honourable Ratu Epeli Nailatikau President of Fiji, Dr Vasitia Cati,
Dr Amanda Noovao-Hill, Dr Kenneth Clark, Dr Yu-Shih Yang (President AOFOG), Dr PK Shah.
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
11
Educational Forum Dinner
A Dinner was held on Sunday 24 June, hosted by FNU CMNHS and RANZCOG, attended by 130 guests. Dr
Wame Baravilala presided as Master of Ceremony for the event.
The special guest at the dinner was His Excellency the President of Fiji, Ratu Epeli Nailatikau, who
delivered an impressive address demonstrating his commitment to the women of Fiji, and the
involvement of men in supporting their wife’s pregnancy and childbirth and their ongoing role in
education and raising of their children. The President of Fiji then officially launched FOGS. It is noted
that the President has agreed to be the Patron of FOGS and this level of support is encouraging and
exciting for the Society’s Board and its members.
An address was given by the newly elected President FOGs, Dr Swaran Naidu, reporting the intention of
the new society to build a cohesive and progressive entity to support O&G and reproductive health
workers. Dr Naidu thanked partner organisations for their current and future support and interest in
FOGS and she introduced the members of the Executive Committee.
Dr Alec Ekeroma, President of PSRH, confirmed the ongoing interest of PSRH in all matters concerning
the O&G and reproductive workforce with the common aim of improving reproductive, neonatal and
perinatal health in the Pacific through the Pacific workforce.
The speech by the RANZCOG President, Dr Rupert Sherwood, encapsulated RANZCOG’s commitment to
Fiji and the Pacific, and its intention to build on current partnerships across the region and expand
existing programs of educational support and opportunity in collaboration with these partners in a
multidisciplinary approach to addressing maternal health and MDG4 and 5 targets.
An impressive address was provided by the Dean of the FNU CMNHS, Professor Ian Rouse, concerning
the potential for further development of positive partnerships in the region with existing and new
partners. At the same time, Professor Rouse commended the O&G and reproductive health workforce
currently serving Fiji, with commitment and dedication to the women and their families which comprise
the fabric of Fijian society. Dean Rouse then formally announced the appointment of Dr Sunil Pillay as
Adjunct Associate Professor of Obstetrics and Gynaecology to the FNU CMNHS.
In the address by the AOFOG President, Professor Yu-Shih Yang thanked the hosts for the educational
forum, RANZCOG and FNU CMNHS. On behalf of AOFOG member societies, he announced a number of
new initiatives from AOFOG member societies to support professional development and networking for
Pacific O&G specialists from Fiji and other PICs. These interactions will be explored and discussed
further over coming months.
MC, Dr Baravailala, opens the dinner The President of Fiji addresses the Dinner Prof Rouse, Dr Pillay, Prof Gyaneshwar
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
12
RANZCOG/PSRH Emergency Obstetrics and Neonatal Care Workshop, 25-27 June 2012
1. Workshop Faculty
Dr Miriam O’Connor Course Director
Dr Shyam Desai Chairman, Maternal and Perinatal Health Care Committee AOFOG
Dr Alec Ekeroma President PSRH, Consultant Obstetrician Gynaecologist Auckland
Sr Aliote Galuvakadua CWMH (Educator/facilitator with Fiji EmONC training course)
Sr Sera Witherow Nauqe CWMH (Educator/facilitator with Fiji EmONC training course)
Sr Kathy Gapirongo Midwifery educator, Honiara, Solomon Islands
Organisers:
Sr Emma Diloi
Dr Amanda Noovao-Hill
Prof Rajat Gyaneshwar
Ms Vinau Savu
Ms Carmel Walker
Local Host Organiser (Matron, Labour Ward, Lautoka Hospital)
O&G Specialist Lautoka
Chief Local Organiser
FNU CMNHS
RANZCOG
2. Report of the Course Director, Dr Miriam O’Connor
The evaluation of the Emergency Obstetrics and Neonatal Care (EONC) workshop reveals, on the
whole, that the course was well-received by all, and some very reasonable suggestions have
been made. There was no pre- and post- participant assessment given the time constraints (we
normally include options for pre-quiz and post-quiz + assessment at 2 Skills Stations in the PNG
PEmOC course for hospital staff.....but there is no evidence that this sort-term evaluation of
improvement in knowledge and hands-on skills translates into improved services at the facility
level unless the class-room based learning is tied to clinical attachments for several weeks to
address individual Learning Objectives). However, program managers always love pre-and post-
tests....and they do have value to the facilitators in terms of pinpointing what has been well
taught and learned and where they might focus efforts to improve delivery/translation.
I suspect that learning objectives for the big hospital staff versus rural facility staff are
somewhat different and it would be preferable to provide ‘whole-of-site’ training for each
setting or at least, for staff from the same level of facility. The original intention had been to
provide a tertiary referral centre PEmOC for staff of Lautoka Hospital (all cadres working in
Labour Ward) but there were other courses being run for the Medical Officers and, of course,
someone had to do the clinical work!). Some of the demonstrations (eg how to successfully
perform an informative speculum and vaginal examination on the anxious patient) were perhaps
a bit boring for the hospital staff....but the rural workers seemed very glad to have had this
addressed. I know there were times when we elaborated on some ‘basics’ for the benefit of the
rural staff that must have seen repetitive to the hospital staff.......but they seemed to handle it
with good and patient grace!
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
13
I sought informal feedback from Srs Aliote and Sera, co-facilitators from CWMH:
• I asked if there was anything that was at variance with what they have been teaching to
date and was reassured to hear that this is not the case
• They felt that the session on Epidemiology of Maternal Mortality and Morbidity was of value
and a good scene-setter
• They very much appreciated the inclusion of a variety of videos to break up the teaching
sessions and have requested copies (which I shall send to both Sr Aliote and Prof.
Gyaneshwar who might copy and distribute to those participants who were interested).
• They found the PPH ‘staging’ classification and Estimating Blood Loss session very valuable
and would like to incorporate it locally
• They agree that sessions on retained placenta with Skills Stations on AMTSL, physiological
management of the 3rd
stage and manual removal of the placenta (using ModelMed® uterus
and placenta being cognizant of the recommendations for care and use..... these
mannequins are NOT easy to maintain in a tropical environment and they require
supervised use at all times.....so easy to rupture the cervix or uterus.....just like the real
thing!)
They suggested that future PEmOC courses for the Fiji context might include:
• More drills for nurses and include a drill on eclampsia Completely agree it would have been
ideal to run more but the facilitators had not worked together before....which I think is
almost essential for a satisfactory learning experience for the participants.
• More partogram scenarios.....which seem to have been enjoyed and valuable to the
participants this time (we did 3-4). This should be part of Essential Obstetric Care course,
rather than Emergency Obstetrics Care.....perhaps the one course (Essential) should be a pre-
requisite for the other (Emergency).
• More time spent ‘getting the dates right’ and using the obstetric calendars in creative
scenarios....without recourse do ‘doing a scan’ (generally included and emphasised in an
Essential Obstetrics Care course but I always offer it in PEmOC as well as PEOC if they want
it).
• Some may want the opportunity to practice maternal BALS in a Skills Station (even tho’ it
has almost zero success in the obstetric patient) which was not included in this course in the
interests of time and it’s low value in PIC obstetrics
• The 4th
stage.....of value but they want more than just the Golden Hour, with emphasis on
prevention and early identification of potential problems
� maybe the first 6 hrs then
� the first 24 hrs
I accept this is much needed but have included it in an Essential Obstetrics Care course for
staff of the more rural facilities rather than one on Obstetric Emergencies.....form follows
function.
• they were keen to include more on Antenatal care and the Birth Plan/Delivery Planning +
Danger Signs (pre and post-natally for mother and newborn) Again, not usually a part of
EmOC, but rather EOC
• Suggested including a PPH or Eclampsia Puzzle as a Skills Station and run race between 4 or
5 groups (1 facilitator for each group) Sounds great fun to me and I shall correspond with
Aliote and Sera to hear more about this.
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
14
• Add a pre-test and post-test....points for and against doing this in an abbreviated time
frame.
I have no doubt that each PIC will gradually establish their own versions of EmONC training (and
might consider EOC training as a pre-requisite for PEmOC training), picking and choosing various
aspects of the various courses available which can then be appropriately transcribed for local
context and need. Gaps will be detected and products developed to fill those gaps. I feel
confident that RANZCOG/PSRH would be pleased to have PEmOC used in such a way, and I am
sure the PNG RHTU will be content to share resources and ideas with colleagues and institutions
across the Pacific as it moves through a Phased development and implementation with a well-
resourced, strong and dynamic monitoring and evaluation framework so that we identify
opportunities for improved quality as we go.
I think there may be value in developing a Knowledge Bank/Clearing House of a variety Sexual
and Reproductive Health training materials and references, including EmONC training materials
(such as will be done by the PNG Reproductive Health Training Unit, RHTU....a public-private
partnership between PNG’s National Department of Health, AusAID and the Oil Search Health
Foundation) in order to catalogue and make available for dissemination S&RH training materials
of interest to and appropriate for Pacific use. I feel confident that the PNG RHTU would be
happy to make some of these things available using a ‘cloud’ vehicle such as dropbox
(www.dropbox.com ) or via our website which is currently in development even though putting
it all on an open website has some limitations that should be recognised and acknowledged.
These might include:
1. Books
1.1. hard copy or at least, information re source agencies and costs
1.2. e-resource books
1.2.1. free (provide copies or at least website addresses where they can be downloaded)
1.2.2. for purchase
2. e-journals
3. List of website links relevant to S&RH training eg the WHO Reproductive Health Library at
www.who.int/rhl; JPHIEGO; K4Health; Guttmacher Institute and ....many others
4. Interactive training CR-roms
5. Miscellaneous video presentations available online or through a variety of agencies, and
some that will be developed for specific settings by UN agencies, NGOs, training institutions,
private media organizations etc
6. Banks of assessment questions and ‘perfect’ answers
7. Banks of Skills Stations scenarios that might be adapted/varied for local use
There will be more good ideas in due course. I hope people will share their good ideas with the
folks at PSRH and RANZCOG’s APC who can act to disseminate ideas for development by those
who are willing to take up the mantle.
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
15
3. Evaluation of the workshop
Evaluation forms were completed by 18 participants who attended the workshop.
Level of satisfaction
Respondents reported the following level of satisfaction regarding the workshop and its
content:
Registration process Satisfied 55% Very satisfied 45%
Training materials Satisfied 50% Very satisfied 50%
Speakers/presenters Dissatisfied 6%* Satisfied 33% Very satisfied 67%
Training facilities Dissatisfied 6%* Satisfied 33% Very satisfied 61%
Appropriate and informative training sessions Agree 50% Strongly agree 50%
Well organised training Disagree 7%* Agree 55% Strongly agree 38%
Satisfactory training location Disagree 7%* Agree 50% Strongly agree 50%
Supportive and helpful training staff Agree 38% Strongly agree 62%
*This respondent indicated they would prefer local facilitators and venue
Additional comments
Areas most enjoyed by participants:
The areas that participants liked the most were refreshing/updating basic knowledge,
interactivity of participants, and both the presentations and practical sessions.
Areas least enjoyed by participants:
Some responders felt that the room was too small and the practical sessions too short.
Improvements for next seminar:
A range of suggestions were made including extending the workshop to cover more topics.
Relevancy of the seminar to practice:
100% of respondents reported Yes to the following questions.
Will the seminar assist current clinical practice?
Was training relevant?
Would you recommend this seminar?
Rating of the seminar to other training of this type previously attended:
Very good 61% Excellent 39%
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
16
RANZCOG/ASCCP Colposcopy Workshop, 25-27 June 2012
1. Workshop Faculty
Dr Jeffrey Tan Course Director, Gynaecologist , Melbourne
Dr Ai Ling Tan Gynaecologist, New Zealand
Dr Kerryn Ireland-Jenkins Pathologist, Melbourne
Organisers
Dr Virisila Sema
Dr Amanda Noovao-Hill
Prof Rajat Gyaneshwar
Ms Vinau Savu
Ms Carmel Walker
Local Host Organiser, O&G Diplomate Lautoka Hospital
O&G Specialist Lautoka
Chief Local Organiser
FNU CMNHS
RANZCOG
2. Report of the Course Director, Dr Jeffrey Tan
Preparation:
The RANZCOG/ASCCP Colposcopy Workshop was funded by a donation from ASCCP and this was
well acknowledged by RANZCOG and the FNU CMNHS.
Prior to the event, a significant amount of effort went into organising the workshop and
equipment required. It would be worthwhile to have a standard operating protocol so all
aspects of the organisation of the workshop can be methodically checked to ensure minimum
glitches.
Workshop:
Setting: Video facilities from the colposcope are vital for the workshop. A list of equipment,
instruments, spare ‘parts’ , for example bulbs, disposables and supplies should be prepared to
avoid last-minute frantic maintenance prior to the workshop. The ideal setting would be two
separate rooms with video outlets. This would provide for privacy for patients and one-on-one
teaching in one room, and discussion and instruction by a second facilitator with other students
in the other room. There would still need to be some form of communication link between the
examining colposcopist and the instructor.
Faculty:
Two gynaecologists and a pathologist for a 3-day workshop is the ideal situation.
Attendees:
Six O&G trainees were designated for the intensive training, however others were keen to have
hands-on practice, so the intensive training did not eventuate. Future workshop will need firm
direction as to whether the facilitators are directed to train up to three people intensively or
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
17
whether more candidates get experience with hands-on colposcopy. A course can have
unlimited numbers but a workshop will need to be restricted in numbers of attendees.
Workshop program:
It is appropriate to start with two hours of early morning lectures, but once the teacher and
trainee start seeing patients, the amount of time required per patient varies. There was a day
when we had 12 patients to see, and that took up the rest of the day, without opportunity for
late afternoon lectures and discussion. This last session of the day (at least 1 hour) is important
and serves as a de-brief as well.
Conclusion:
Overall, the attendees showed an average to good knowledge of colposcopy and management
of screened abnormalities. This is partly shown by their performance in ‘quiz’ sessions applying
the keypad polling system. The majority could do with more hands-on colposcopy training.
The range of equipment and accessories, eg biopsy forceps and disposables, is limited. There is
a need for support on pathways to sourcing equipment and supplies, including at times,
donated supplies, to ensure smooth function of colposcopy services.
Notwithstanding the above suggestions for organisational improvements for future workshops,
feedback during and following the conclusion of the course indicated that the workshop was
well received by the trainees, who were keen to receive further upskilling in their colposcopy
and pathology skills.
Comment:
The Pacific nations need an effective cervical cancer prevention program. There is a need to
document what efforts have been made from within and from outside assistance in this area
with a view to compiling a report looking at possible programs to assist the nations individually
and collectively in areas of screening, management of screened abnormalities and HPV
vaccination.
3. Evaluation of the workshop
Evaluation forms were completed by 10 participants, specifically nominated for the course.
Level of satisfaction
Respondents reported the following level of satisfaction regarding the workshop:
Registration process Satisfied 60% Very satisfied 40%
Training materials Satisfied 30% Very satisfied 70%
Speakers/presenters Satisfied 30% Very satisfied 70%
Training facilities Satisfied 50% Very satisfied 50%
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
18
Appropriate and informative training sessions Agree 30% Strongly agree 70%
Well organised training Agree 48% Strongly agree 52%
Satisfactory training location Agree 50% Strongly agree 50%
Supportive and helpful training staff Agree 50% Strongly agree 50%
Additional comments
Areas most enjoyed by participants:
The areas that participants liked the most were the opportunity to do practical colposcopy one-
on-one with the trainer, the use of the TV screen set up for live teaching, and for those with
existing skills, the chance to build on those skills.
Areas least enjoyed by participants:
One participant queried the logistics of walking around from place to place, another felt the
afternoon sessions were a bit rushed, and one participant mentioned the delayed start of the
course due to equipment failure.
Relevancy of the seminar to practice:
100% of respondents reported Yes to the following questions.
Will the seminar assist current clinical practice?
Was training relevant?
Would you recommend this seminar?
Overall comments
Respondents were very positive about the workshop overall. One respondent suggested
ongoing training support through the use of videoconferencing facilities between the experts
and the local Fijians for this and other workshops.
Rating of the seminar to other training of this type previously attended:
Very good 30% Excellent 70%
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
19
RANZOG/PSRH Pacific Obstetrics and Gynaecology Ultrasound Workshop, 25-28 June 2012
1. Workshop Faculty
Prof Peter Stone Course Leader, Maternal-Fetal Medicine Subspecialist, Auckland
Dr Peter van Der Weijer Gynaecologist Auckland
Ms Cathy Sorensen Ultrasonographer, Auckland
Dr Kwok Yin Leung O&G Specialist, Hong Kong, visiting AOFOG facilitator
Organisers
Dr Amanda Noovao-Hill
Prof Rajat Gyaneshwar
Ms Vinau Savu
Ms Carmel Walker
Local Host Organiser (O&G Specialist Lautoka)
Chief Local Organiser
FNU CMNHS
RANZCOG
2. Report from Course Director, Professor Peter Stone
This was a highly successful, educational and enjoyable course. The organisers wish to sincerely
thank the local team both in Obstetrics and Gynaecology and Radiology for making available
facilities and arranging for women to come and have scans. The Fiji National University staff also
deserve thanks for much of the administrative organisation. It always is a pleasure to work with
friendly, enthusiastic Pacific people who are striving to learn and improve care.
The teachers are highly motivated to continue with such courses and include more one on one
teaching and retain the current format for those who are beginner scanners.
A particularly successful feature of the course was the clinical and ultrasound interactions with
combined lectures given by the clinicians and the sonographer. This showed the important
working relationship that develops between imaging and the outcome for the patient. The
concept of ultrasound as a tool for the clinician to use to enhance care is an important one as
ultrasound is expensive and is a technology which needs to be used wisely. Frequently, the
teachers were asking “what is the question?” or “how will ultrasound help?”.
The teachers would like the participants to work through the course book and DVD and to
obtain as much scanning experience as possible, not to hurry and really see in the image, what
ultrasound can offer when used appropriately.
As always the feedback was useful and the teachers are already working on different course
design to meet the needs of a wide range of people.
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
20
3. Evaluation of the workshop
Evaluation forms were completed by 19 Fijian and Pacific O&G trainees and specialists.
Level of satisfaction
Respondents reported the following level of satisfaction regarding the workshop and its
content:
Registration process Satisfied 42% Very satisfied 58%
Training materials Satisfied 15% Very satisfied 85%
Speakers/presenters Satisfied 30% Very satisfied 70%
Training facilities Satisfied 42% Very satisfied 58%
Appropriate and informative training sessions Agree 50% Strongly agree 50%
Well organised training Agree 58% Strongly agree 42%
Satisfactory training location Disagree 6% Agree 63% Strongly agree 31%
Supportive and helpful training staff Agree 42% Strongly agree 58%
Additional comments:
Alternative venue:
One respondent felt that the location for the scanning was too crowded and the room too small.
Areas most enjoyed by participants:
The areas that participants liked the most covered both the lectures and the practical sessions.
Areas least enjoyed by participants:
Several respondents would have liked more time for scanning, and one commented on the
overcrowded room.
Improvements for next workshop:
One respondent suggested that materials be provided well before the workshop for pre-reading.
The other suggestions related to more time being allowed for practical scanning sessions. One
visiting PIC participant requested that other practitioners from other islands be included in
future workshops. It was requested that the next course be run for one week.
Relevancy of the seminar to practice:
100% of respondents reported Yes to the following questions.
Will the seminar assist current clinical practice?
Was training relevant?
Would you recommend this seminar?
Other comments
Respondents felt that the workshop was generally well organised and relevant to practice.
Follow up workshops were requested.
Rating of the seminar to other training of this type previously attended:
Average 10%, Very good 25% Excellent 65%
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
21
RANZCOG/FOFH Laparoscopy Training workshop, 25-29 June 2012
1. Workshop Faculty
Dr Sunil Pillay Course Director, Gynaecologist Auckland
Dr Rajendra Kumar Gynaecologist Auckland
Dr Shiu Kumar Gynaecologist Auckland
Dr Kurian Joseph Gynaecologist, Chennai India (visiting AOFOG Councillor)
Dr Fong Yoke Fai Gynaecologist , Singapore (visiting AOFOG Councillor)
Dr Rekha Joseph Gynaecologist, Chennai India
Dr Nirupama Samaraweera Anaesthetist, Auckland New Zealand
Mr Brian Thomas Theatre Nurse, Auckland
Ms Vuki Nabete Theatre Nurse, Auckland
Ms Seruwaia Kolibagsoga Theatre Nurse, Auckland
Organisers
Dr Jimi Taria Local Host Organiser (Head of O&G Lautoka Hospital)
Dr Amanda Noovao-Hill O&G Specialist Lautoka
Prof Rajat Gyaneshwar Chief Local Organiser
Ms Vinau Savu FNU CMNHS
Ms Carmel Walker RANZCOG
2. Report from the Course Director – Dr Sunil Pillay
The joint RANZCOG/Friends of Fiji Health Laparoscopy/Endoscopy surgical workshop held as
part of the RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS educational forum is part of the introduction of laparoscopic
surgery to medical staff responsible for gynaecological surgery in Fiji, using a new laparoscopic
tower provided by Olympus. This training represents the introduction of minimally invasive
surgery. The program is being undertaken in a staged way by Friends of Fiji Health with a
number of supporting sponsors based in New Zealand: Johnson & Johnson, Olympus, Big Green
Surgical Co, 3M, REM Systems and Brightside Hospital.
For this course, expertise was provided by visiting senior laparoscopic surgeons representing the
Asia Oceania Federation of O&G (AOFOG). This level of experience and input was valued by the
‘regular’ faculty and participants.
The course comprised a one-day lecture and demonstration program focussing on safety and
care of the endoscopic equipment, held on Saturday 23 June, followed by practical sessions in
theatre during the week 25-29 June 2012. Attendance at the day program was compulsory for
those intending to attend the hands-on course. The lecture day was attended by 13
gynaecological surgeons, and approximately 14 theatre nurses. The program provided them
with a good understanding of care of the equipment and safety issues, electrosurgical principles,
entry techniques, anaesthetic considerations and selection of appropriate cases for endoscopic
surgery.
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
22
The hands-on course was attended by two general surgeons, eight gynaecologists practicing at
senior level, and three recently graduated gynaecologists. A number of other trainees,
gynaecologists and theatre nurses were invited to observe in theatre. The selection of doctors
for the hands-on training was based on the ‘train the trainer’ model, so that senior
gynaecologists were given the opportunity for this intensive training which they can then
introduce to their junior staff over time at Lautoka, Labasa and Colonial War Memorial
Hospitals.
Cases were selected by the Head of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, in consultation with the course
leader, Dr Pillay. Of the ten trainees identified for intensive training, all had at least three days
of training. Trainees took part in four operations per day such as diagnostic laparoscopy and
tubal sterilisation, and observed more complicated procedures.
Both during the surgery and during the break times, the trainees discussed issues with the
trainers and they appeared to increase in confidence as they undertook the procedures
themselves. Some surgeons will need additional experience and this will be continued with
future visits by members of FOFH over the coming year. The next training visit is organised for a
week in September when Dr Pillay will provide further training to the heads of O&G from
CWM, Labasa and Lautoka Hospitals.
3. Evaluation of the Workshop
Evaluation forms were completed by 7 participants.
Level of satisfaction
Respondents reported the following level of satisfaction regarding the seminar and its content:
Registration process Satisfied 42% Very satisfied 58%
Training materials Satisfied 28% Very satisfied 72%
Speakers/presenters Satisfied 58% Very satisfied 42%
Training facilities Satisfied 23% Very satisfied 72%
Appropriate and informative training sessions Agree 58% Strongly agree 42%
Well organised training Agree 58% Strongly agree 42%
Satisfactory training location Agree 58% Strongly agree 42%
Supportive and helpful training staff Agree 14% Strongly agree 86%
Additional comments
Areas most enjoyed by participants:
The areas that participants liked the most were the hands-on experience with experienced
surgeons. One respondent referred to applying the latest evidence based practice to different
Report of RANZCOG/FNU CMNHS Educational Forum in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, Lautoka Fiji, 23-29 June 2012
23
clinical scenarios, and also the learning opportunity during the pre-op rounds with Dr Pillay
especially in regard to selection of cases for laparoscopic surgery.
Areas least enjoyed by participants:
One respondent felt that the intended training schedule had not been followed so some
trainees missed out.
Improvements for next workshop:
It was suggested that the training be more focussed with fewer participants.
Other comments
One respondent advised that a laparoscopy tower is needed in Labasa if they are to put into
practice what they learn in this training. All other comments were positive and appreciative.
Relevancy of the seminar to practice:
100% of respondents reported Yes to the following questions.
Will the seminar assist current clinical practice?
Was training relevant?
Would you recommend this seminar?
Rating of the seminar to other training of this type previously attended:
Average 14% Very good14% Excellent 72%