pdf vol 05 no 03 197-236 private engel

40
 PRIVATE LAW  A Constitutional Framework for Private Governance  By Christoph Engel I. Introdu ction ................................................................................................................................................ 198 II. Privat e versu s p ublic gover nance......................................................................................................... 202 1. Disputes and confl icts....... ................................................................................................................. 202 2. Constitutional protection from governmental interference into private regulation in the interest of the addres sees .................................................................................... 204 a) Protected rights......................................................................................................................... 205 b) Legitimate aims......................................................................................................................... 209 c) Condu cive ...................................................................................................................................... 213 d) Least intrusiv e................ ................................................................................................................ 213 e) Not overl y onerou s ....................................................................................................................... 214 f) Solutio ns ......................................................................................................................................... 218 3. Other disputes between private regulators and government ...................................................... 219 a) Conf licts in private regulat ory bodies........................................................................................ 219 b) Conflicts between competing private regulators ...................................................................... 221 c) Competition between private and public regulation ............................................................... 222 4. Disputes between addressees and government............................................................................. 223 a) Protection from public intervention into private regulation ................................................... 224 b) Call for protection against private regula tion ........................................................................... 225 5. Disputes between beneficiaries and government .......................................................................... 228 a) Protection from public intervention into private regulation ................................................... 228 b) Call for effective priva te regul ation ............................................................................................ 229 III. Private gover nance without law ...................................................................................................... 229 1. Normative advantages of governance by law................................................................................ 230 2. Constitutional status of govern ance by law ................................................................................... 231 IV. Conclusion: From pure private to hybrid regulation .................................................................... 233 I am indebted to Adrienne Héritier, Florian Becker, Tanja Börzel and Peer Zumbansen for helpful comments, and to Darrell Arnold for the linguistic trimming of the paper.  

Upload: my-n

Post on 10-Apr-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 1/40

Page 2: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 2/40

Page 3: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 3/40

Page 4: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 4/40

Page 5: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 5/40

Page 6: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 6/40

Page 7: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 7/40

Page 8: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 8/40

Page 9: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 9/40

Page 10: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 10/40

Page 11: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 11/40

Page 12: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 12/40

Page 13: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 13/40

Page 14: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 14/40

Page 15: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 15/40

Page 16: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 16/40

Page 17: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 17/40

Page 18: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 18/40

Page 19: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 19/40

Page 20: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 20/40

Page 21: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 21/40

Page 22: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 22/40

Page 23: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 23/40

Page 24: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 24/40

Page 25: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 25/40

Page 26: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 26/40

Page 27: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 27/40

Page 28: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 28/40

Page 29: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 29/40

Page 30: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 30/40

Page 31: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 31/40

Page 32: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 32/40

Page 33: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 33/40

Page 34: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 34/40

Page 35: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 35/40

Page 36: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 36/40

Page 37: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 37/40

Page 38: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 38/40

Page 39: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 39/40

Page 40: PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

8/8/2019 PDF Vol 05 No 03 197-236 Private Engel

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pdf-vol-05-no-03-197-236-private-engel 40/40