participatory governance: decision making and committee ... › associations › faculty... ·...

1

Participatory Governance:

Decision Making and Committee Roles in

Effective Institutional Planning

September 2017 DRAFT

Cabrillo College Governance Manual - 2017 2

Participatory Governance: Decision Making and Committee Roles in Effective Institutional Planning

Contents Purpose and Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 5

Foundations of Institutional Planning and Participatory Governance Committee Goals ................................ 6

Our Mission [Proposed Update] .................................................................................................................. 6

Vision Statement [Update in Process] ......................................................................................................... 6

Values ........................................................................................................................................................... 6

Core Four Competencies .............................................................................................................................. 7

Accreditation ................................................................................................................................................ 7

CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES MISSION STATEMENT ...................................................................... 7

ACCJC STANDARD I ....................................................................................................................................... 8

The Philosophy of Institutional Planning ......................................................................................................... 9

The Philosophy of Participatory Governance Decision Making at Cabrillo College ....................................... 10

We are guided by: ...................................................................................................................................... 10

Tools for participatory governance decision-making: .................................................................................. 10

Decision-Making for Participatory Governance Committees: ................................................................... 11

Behaviors Beneficial to the Participatory Governance Process: ................................................................ 11

Evaluating Governance Processes ............................................................................................................. 12

Role and Responsibility for Governance ........................................................................................................ 13

Faculty Participation: ................................................................................................................................. 13

Operational Planning ............................................................................................................................. 13

Participatory Governance ...................................................................................................................... 13

Collective Bargaining .............................................................................................................................. 13

Collective Bargaining: Legal Provisions .................................................................................................. 13

Classified Staff Participation: ..................................................................................................................... 14



Collective Bargaining .............................................................................................................................. 14


Confidentials – Meet and Confer Group: ................................................................................................... 14

Student Participation: ............................................................................................................................ 15


Administrator Participation: ...................................................................................................................... 14



Meet and Confer .................................................................................................................................... 15

Board of Trustees: ...................................................................................................................................... 15

Operational and Policy Planning ............................................................................................................ 16


Structures for Participation ............................................................................................................................ 17

Participatory Governance Groups ............................................................................................................. 17

Participatory Governance Committee ................................................................................................... 17

Subcommittee ........................................................................................................................................ 17

Operational Groups ................................................................................................................................... 17

Council .................................................................................................................................................... 17

Task Force .............................................................................................................................................. 17

Advisory Group ...................................................................................................................................... 17

Decision Making Process ................................................................................................................................ 19

Participatory Governance Committee Initiatives and Reporting ................................................................... 21

Timeline...................................................................................................................................................... 21

Participatory Governance Committee Member Roles and Responsibilities .................................................. 22

Appendices .................................................................................................................................................... 23

Glossary of Common Acronyms and Miscellaneous Abbreviations ............................................................... 23

Governance Related Education Code ............................................................................................................ 29

§53200 BARCLAYS CALIFORNIA CODE OF REGULATIONS Title 5 ............................................................... 29

HISTORY ................................................................................................................................................. 30

§51023.5 BARCLAYS CALIFORNIA CODE OF REGULATIONS Title 5 ............................................................ 30

§51023.7 BARCLAYS CALIFORNIA CODE OF REGULATIONS Title 5 ............................................................ 32

HISTORY ................................................................................................................................................. 33

College Policies on Participation in Local Decision Making ........................................................................... 34

BP 2510 Participation in Local Decision Making ........................................................................................ 34

AP 2510 Participation in Local Decision Making ........................................................................................ 34

Selected Data Resources ................................................................................................................................ 40


Cabrillo Integrated Planning and Resource Request Process ........................................................................ 41

Component and Constituency Diagrams ....................................................................................................... 42

President’s Component ............................................................................................................................. 42

Student Services Component ..................................................................................................................... 42

Administrative Services Component .......................................................................................................... 43

Instruction Component .............................................................................................................................. 43

Faculty Senate Groups ............................................................................................................................... 44

Student Senate Groups .............................................................................................................................. 44

Bargaining Groups ...................................................................................................................................... 45

Administration Constituency Primary Councils ......................................................................................... 45

Committee List ............................................................................................................................................... 46

Governance Committee Feedback Surveys ................................................................................................... 48

Member Survey .......................................................................................................................................... 49

Chair Survey ............................................................................................................................................... 52


Purpose and Introduction In 1988, the California Legislature and the Governor approved AB 1725 directing the California

Community College Board of Governors to develop regulations designed to:

…ensure faculty, staff, and students (have) the opportunity to express their opinions at the campus

level, and to ensure that these opinions are given every reasonable consideration, and the right to

participate effectively in district and college governance, and the right of academic senates to

assume primary responsibility for making recommendations in the areas of curriculum and

academic standards (70900.5).

Upon direction from the Legislature, the California Community College Board of Governors adopted

Title 5 regulations to implement AB 1725. For faculty, these regulations are contained in §51023 and

again in §53201 specifically for Academic Senates. Regulations pertaining to classified staff are found

in §51023.5 and those pertaining to students are under §51023.7. The Board of Governors then

directed each community college district Board of Trustees to adopt local policies and procedures to

implement these Title 5 regulations.

The Cabrillo College Board of Trustees policies supporting the Title 5 regulations are contained in Board

Policy 2510: Participation in Local Decision-Making (See Appendix).

The purpose of the Participatory Governance: Decision Making and Committee Roles in Effective

Institutional Planning is to collect, document, and present the major college policies, procedures, and

committees related to governance in planning and decision-making. The document serves as a convenient

guide for the college community and as a resource for newly hired employees as they consider their role

in active institutional planning and effectiveness outcomes. This handbook is reviewed and updated by the

College Planning Committee (CPC) on a regular basis of at least every three years.

At Cabrillo College, participatory governance is grounded in the inclusion of faculty, staff, students, and

administrators in the decision-making processes. The inclusion of all constituent groups and varying

viewpoints promotes effective collaboration in college planning. The Faculty Senate, the Associated

Students of Cabrillo College (ASCC) Student Senate, Administrative Council representatives, Confidentials,

and the collective bargaining units for Classified Staff and Faculty are all present at the highest governance

council, the CPC. Consistent and effective communication among constituent representatives and their

respective constituent bodies is critical for successful decision-making. Membership on any participatory

governance committee assumes regular communication with constituent bodies either through a

written or oral report. For ease of reporting, a constituency report out template is provided in the

Appendix (pending).


Foundations of Institutional Planning and Participatory Governance

Committee Goals

BP 1200 District Mission, Vision and Values

Board Approved 5.20.2015

Reference: ACCJC Standard I.A

Using the college's governance and decision-making processes, the mission, vision and core values are

reviewed on a regular basis and revised as necessary.

Our Mission [Proposed Update] Cabrillo College connects students to pathways that impart the relevant skills and knowledge to propel

them from where they are to where they aspire to be. With an emphasis on quality and equity, Cabrillo

empowers students to be effective communicators, critical thinkers, and responsible world citizens.

Vision Statement [Update in Process] Cabrillo College is passionate about developing critical thinking, honing oral and written communication,

and enhancing global awareness, while cultivating personal and professional responsibility in our students.

Exploration, innovation, creativity, and implementation of a variety of teaching methods, including

technology literacy, are hallmarks of our approach to learning. We help students of varying skill levels

achieve their potential, and consider everyone in the college part of a community of learners who are

treated with dignity and respect. Cabrillo College supports a climate of diversity, self-empowerment, and

sustainability, with a strong sense of social justice.

As an integral part of Santa Cruz County, Cabrillo College is an accessible gateway to prosperity that

provides education for all, supporting the local economy and improving economic vitality. We serve

students who have goals of transfer, career preparation, basic skills, personal fulfillment, and retraining

through an inclusive and effective learning environment. Students will leave with greater knowledge and a

richer expectation of themselves.

Values Learning

We provide an excellent and safe learning environment that enhances a student’s experience in the

accumulation of knowledge, the sharing of ideas and the celebration of achievement both within the

classroom and throughout the college’s community of learners.

Student Focus

We commit to creating the best educational environment for students, providing quality programs and

services that promote their diverse and evolving needs as they progress toward their individual

educational goals.

http://www.boarddocs.com/ca/cabrillo/Board.nsf/goto?open&id=A2FW2483432A


Collaboration

We believe in the open exchange of ideas that is nurtured through respect, trust, and consideration of

differences, demonstrated by our shared commitment to the mission of Cabrillo College.

Esteem

We strive to hold each member of the Cabrillo community in esteem, based on the far-reaching potential

of each individual, the diverse and often unrecognized journeys and achievements of each person, and the

fundamental dignity of each human being.

Equity

Student Equity at Cabrillo College is the commitment to cultivate an inclusive teaching and learning

environment by providing equitable support, access, and opportunities for success emphasizing

historically underrepresented and emerging student populations.

Core Four Competencies To achieve our mission, the Cabrillo College community works together to help students master our four

college competencies. The Core 4 represent the major skills that all students need to succeed in

completing their degree pattern. The college is committed to fulfilling this promise: When our students

have met the requirement for the A.A or A.S. degree or have completed the general education sequence,

they will be competent in:

Communication: Reading, Writing, Listening, Speaking, and/or Conversing

Critical Thinking and Information Competency: Analysis, Computation, Research, Problem Solving

Global Awareness: An appreciation of Scientific Processes, Global Systems and Civics, and Artistic

Variety

Personal Responsibility and Professional Development: Self-Management and Self- Awareness,

Social and Physical Wellness, Workplace Skills

Accreditation The Western Association of Schools and Colleges, the recognized local agency that is affiliated with the

Federation of Regional Accrediting Commissions of Higher Education, accredit Cabrillo College. The College

adheres to the institutional standards set forth by the Accreditation Commission for Community and

Junior Colleges, and has been approved by the Board of Governors of the California Community

Colleges and the California State Department of Education. The College is also approved by the

California Department of Education for the training of veterans under the provisions of the G.I. Bill of

Regulations. The College is a member of the Community College League of California. Designated

courses are accepted on a transfer basis by the University of California, the California State

University system, and by private four-year colleges and universities. Review and evaluation of the College

Mission Statement, Academic Quality, Institutional Effectiveness, and Institutional Integrity will be

included in the triennial revision of the college mission statement and this handbook.

CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES MISSION STATEMENT Per California Education Code 66010.4. (a)

1. The California Community Colleges shall, as a primary mission, offer academic and vocational

instruction at the lower division level for both younger and older students, including those

persons returning to school. Public community colleges shall offer instruction through but not


beyond the second year of college. These institutions may grant the associate in arts and the

associate in science degree.

2. In addition to the primary mission of academic and vocational instruction, the community colleges

shall offer instruction and courses to achieve all of the following:

a. The provision of remedial instruction for those in need of it and, in conjunction with the

school districts, instruction in English as a second language, adult noncredit instruction,

and support services which help students succeed at the postsecondary level are

reaffirmed and supported as essential and important functions of the community colleges.

b. The provision of adult noncredit education curricula in areas defined as being in the

state's interest is an essential and important function of the community colleges.

c. The provision of community services courses and programs is an authorized function of

the community colleges so long as their provision is compatible with an institution's ability

to meet its obligations in its primary missions.

3. A primary mission of the California Community Colleges is to advance California's economic

growth and global competitiveness through education, training, and services that contribute to

continuous work force improvement.

4. The community colleges may conduct to the extent that state funding is provided, institutional

research concerning student learning and retention as is needed to facilitate their educational

missions.

ACCJC STANDARD I The institution demonstrates strong commitment to a mission that emphasizes student learning and

student achievement. Using analysis of qualitative and qualitative data, the institution continuously and

systematically evaluates, plans, implements, and improves the quality of educational programs and

services. The institution demonstrates integrity in all policies, actions, and communication. The

administration, faculty, staff, and governing board members act honestly, ethically, and fairly in the

performance of their duties.

1. The mission describes the institution’s broad educational purposes, its intended student

population, the types of degrees and other credentials it offers, and its commitment to student

learning and student achievement. (ER 6)

2. The institution uses data to determine how effectively it is accomplishing its mission, and whether

the mission directs institutional priorities in meeting the educational needs of students.

3. The institution’s programs and services are aligned with its mission. The mission guides

institutional decision-making, planning, and resource allocation and informs institutional goals for

student learning and achievement.

4. The institution articulates its mission in a widely published statement approved by the governing

board. The mission statement is periodically reviewed and updated as necessary. (ER 6)


The Philosophy of Institutional Planning BP3250, Accreditation Standard IB, Title V §§51008, 51010, 51027, 53003, 54220, 55250, 55400 et seq.,

56270 et seq.

Included in participatory governance committee goals are the following plans, including but not limited to:

Plan

Primary Participatory Governance Committee

where applicable

Strategic Plan College Planning Committee (CPC)

Facilities Plan Facilities Planning Committee (FPC)

Sustainability Plan Sustainability Subcommittee of FPC

Emergency Response Plan Safety Subcommittee of FPC

Technology Plan Technology Committee (TC)

Education Master Plan College Planning Committee (CPC)

BSI/Equity/SSSP Integrated Planning Student Equity and Success Committee (IIC)

Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) Plan Professional Development Committee (PDC)

Program Plans All

Transfer Center Plan (required by law) None

Extended Opportunities Programs and Services

(EOPS) Plan (required by law)

None

The President/Superintendent ensures that the District has and implements a broad based,

comprehensive, systematic, and integrated system of planning that involves appropriate segments of the

college community and is supported by Institutional Effectiveness research (BP3250).

Systematic planning at Cabrillo College is led by our participatory governance committees using

constituent input and feedback.

https://www.cabrillo.edu/services/pro/strategicPlanning/docs/CabrilloStrategicPlan2014to2019.pdf

http://www.cabrillo.edu/services/pro/masterPlan/cabrillo_fmp_final.pdf

http://cabrillo.edu/associations/facultysenate/handouts/160920/CabrilloSustainabilityPlan_081116.pdf

https://www.cabrillo.edu/internal/emergency/

https://www.cabrillo.edu/services/pro/accred/pdf/ITTP.pdf

http://www.cabrillo.edu/services/pro/masterPlan/Cabrillo_Report_final.pdf

https://www.cabrillo.edu/services/equity/main.html

http://www.cabrillo.edu/services/hr/documents/CabrilloEEOPlanFALL2017FINALDRAFT.pdf

https://www.cabrillo.edu/services/instruction/ProgramPlans.html

https://www.cabrillo.edu/services/studserv/documents/CounselingProgramPlanwithSLOattachments2016.pdf

https://www.cabrillo.edu/services/studserv/documents/EOPSCAREProgramReviewFINAL.pdf


The Philosophy of Participatory Governance Decision Making at Cabrillo

College BP2430, BP2510 Education Code §§70902(d), 72400; Accreditation Standard IV.B.1.j:IV.B.2

ACCJC Accreditation Standard IV, Leadership and Governance indicates the institution recognizes and uses

the contributions of leadership throughout the organization for promoting student success, sustaining

academic quality, integrity, fiscal stability, and continuous improvement of the institution. Governance

roles are defined in policy and are designed to facilitate decisions that support student learning programs

and services and improve institutional effectiveness, while acknowledging the designated responsibilities

of the governing board and the chief executive officer. Through established governance structures,

processes, and practices, the governing board, administrators, faculty, staff, and students work together

for the good of the institution.

Cabrillo College encourages collegial rapport among all stakeholders while students, our primary

stakeholders, and their success is our key focus. Within participatory governance committees, the process

is to work with others in making decisions that are in the best interest of the college rather than just one

constituency or one individual. The institution is lifted by perspective-sharing within the bigger picture.

We are guided by: A perspective of larger institutional planning

All participants taking responsibility for relaying and sharing information as well as providing

constituent feedback to the committee on which participants serve

Providing expertise from constituencies but deciding from a college perspective

Gathering information as part of the decision-making process

Trusting the intent of the committee participant

Acknowledging competing interests but working for the good of the college as a whole

Tools for participatory governance decision-making: All Master Planning documents of the college including but not limited to:

Educational Master Plan

Cabrillo Connects Strategic Plan

Facilities Master Plan

Technology Plan

Distance Education Plan

Student Success and Support Plan

Student Equity Plan


Data from the college or outside entities including but not limited to:

Program data

Population/demographic data

Institutional data

Economic vitality data

Budget data

K-12 / California Partnership for Achieving Student Success (CalPASS) data

Bay Area Community College Consortium (BACCC) regional data

Other county, other regional, statewide, and national data, as appropriate

There are three foundational premises to inform and clarify the use of data within the collegial

decision making process:

Belief that the data/information are trustworthy, reliable, accessible and transparent to the

college.

Agreement that additional data may be required and requested as part of the process.

Understanding that data may need explanation and review as part of the decision-making

process.

Decision-Making for Participatory Governance Committees: We agree that adequate time and review be spent on decisions as needed and appropriate.

Whenever possible consensus will be the desired approach. Participants will use the thumbs

up/thumbs down approach with a sideways thumb for those who can ‘live with the decision’.

When a participant ‘lives with the decision’ it implies an appropriate timeline for evaluation

and review of the process (to be decided by the committee). Committees may request a

formal vote be taken for specific items.

We agree that when conflict arises, a vote may be taken as part of the process but not until

reasonable avenues for consensus has been attempted.

We agree that all decisions and recommendations go to the president as advisory; should the

president disagree with the decision / recommendation, a written response will be provided

to the committee.

Behaviors Beneficial to the Participatory Governance Process: Listening for understanding: strive to explain the opposing position or idea

Clarifying and summation of ideas or positions – checking for understanding

Encouraging all to participate

Encouraging the greater good

Upholding/maintaining an institution wide perspective

Maintaining respectful dialogue/respectful rapport

Having fun


Evaluating Governance Processes

Governance processes will be reviewed on a regular basis as outlined in the table below found in the Institutional Effectiveness Committee web site (http://www.cabrillo.edu/services/pro/ie/index.html).

Task Primary Responsible Party(ies) Time

Review progress on strategic plan goals

Institutional Effectiveness Committee, College Planning Council

Annually each spring. Full plan update every 5 years

Survey primary governance committee members to assess committee and facilitator effectiveness for overall decision making

Planning and Research administers survey

Spring term every three years (2015, 2018, 2021, etc.)

Evaluate college mission and vision statements via surveys, forums, and task force activities

President’s Office, Planning and Research

Every three years (2014, 2017, 2020, etc.)

Update Governance Manual President’s Office, College Planning Council

Every three years (2014, 2017, 2020, etc.)

Evaluate resource allocation process by analyzing input from participants via request form and committee dialogue

Institutional Effectiveness Committee

Late fall after each allocation cycle

Evaluate program review and assessment results and process by analyzing program plan content, input from participants, and committee dialogue

Assessment Review Committee, Institutional Effectiveness Committee, Administrative Services Council, Administrator Council, Council of Instructional Planning, Instructional Council, Student Services Council

Ongoing and annually after each planning cycle; late spring for Instruction and late fall for all other areas

http://www.cabrillo.edu/services/pro/ie/index.html


Role and Responsibility for Governance

Faculty Participation:

Operational Planning

There is operational consistency for all faculty. Faculty work with their Program Chairs and Deans on

matters concerning curriculum and classroom operations. Faculty work together with administrators to

determine the most effective methods to meet the needs of students, personnel, and the college.

Participatory Governance

The Faculty Senate is responsible for formal recommendations regarding academic and professional

matters (See Appendix: California Administrative Code Title 5 §53201, Cabrillo Board Policy 2510). The

Faculty Senate Executive Board consists of an elected president, and an appointed Vice President,

Secretary, and Treasurer. The Division Senators are comprised of two faculty elected from each of the

five instructional divisions, plus one each from Counseling, Counseling and Educational Support Services,

and the Library. The Watsonville Representative is a voting member. Senator-at-Large seats rotate every

other year and are filled by election. Non-voting seats are held by a Student Senate Representative,

the Student Learning Outcomes Assessment Coordinator, the Cabrillo College Federation of Teachers

Liaison, the Cabrillo Classified Employee Union Liaison, and the Vice President of Instruction.

The Faculty Senate is also responsible for appointing faculty to college and district standing

committees, peer review teams, and various college and district ad hoc committees. In addition, the

Faculty Senate provides input into the prioritization process for new planning and resource requests

through their appointments to the core department/division/council and/or Senate group and the College

Planning Committee (CPC). The Senate president meets regularly with the College President and Vice

President of Instruction and the Dean of Research, Planning, & Institutional Effectiveness to ensure

college-wide faculty concerns are communicated and discussed. Faculty Senate meetings are open

and all faculty are encouraged to communicate regularly with their representatives and to participate in

Senate sponsored events, activities, and meetings. Senate minutes are posted on their website. Faculty

representatives on participatory governance committees will report back to Faculty Senate on a consistent

basis.

Collective Bargaining

The Cabrillo College Federation of Teachers (CCFT) is the collective bargaining representative for all

Cabrillo College faculty. CCFT often appoints representatives to committees and groups that deal

primarily with employee contracts and benefit information and issues. Questions or concerns

regarding faculty working conditions should be directed to CCFT representatives.

Collective Bargaining: Legal Provisions

Decision-making policies and implementation cannot detract from negotiated agreements on wages and

working conditions. Faculty Senate and bargaining representative may establish agreements as to

consulting, collaborating, sharing or delegating (Title 5 §53204). The exclusive bargaining agent shall

consult with the faculty senate prior to engaging in bargaining on: Faculty Evaluation (Ed Code §87663),

http://cabrillo.edu/associations/facultysenate/minutes.html


Tenure (Ed Code §87610.6) and Faculty Service Areas (Ed Code §87743.2). CCFT representatives on

participatory governance committees will report back to CCFT on a consistent basis.

Classified Staff Participation:


Classified staff have the responsibility and opportunity to participate in decision-making across the

college. At the operational level, classified staff collaborate with other staff, administrators, faculty, and

students within and across their departments, programs, and service areas to determine the most

effective ways to meet the needs of the students, personnel, and the college. Different units have varying

processes for how operational decisions are made and staff are encouraged to check with their

supervisors, governance, and/or bargaining unit leaders for more detailed information.


Recommendations and opinions of staff are given every reasonable consideration. The classified staff

appoints representatives to various college committees through the collective bargaining unit, Cabrillo

Classified Employee Union (CCEU). Classified staff shared governance participation is defined by Title 5 and

Board Policies and Administrative Procedures. Classified staff provide input into the prioritization for new

planning and resource requests through their appointments to core mission workgroups and the CPC.

Classified staff are encouraged to communicate regularly through their representatives and are

encouraged to participate in meetings, events, and other college wide activities. CCEU representatives on

participatory governance committees will report back to CCEU on a consistent basis.


Classified staff have one collective bargaining unit that represents all classified employees on work related

conditions. Questions or concerns regarding working conditions should be directed to the CCEU

representatives. CCEU appoints representatives to shared governance committees and groups that deal

with all aspects of college decision making, especially those that affect employee contracts, working

conditions, and benefit information.

Confidentials – Meet and Confer Group: “Confidential Employee” is an employee of the District who, in the regular course of his/her duties, has

access to confidential information that contributes to the development of management proposals and

decisions with respect to employer-employee relations (Government Code §3540.1(c)). As such, they are

not a bargaining unit, but rather a meet and confer unit. This component has a representative presence on

the CPC and selected shared governance committees. Confidential representatives on participatory

governance committees report to the Confidential group on a consistent basis.

Administrator Participation:


Administrators participate in decision-making processes in a variety of ways. In their local areas of

responsibility, they are responsible for seeking faculty, staff, and student input to improve programs and

services, as well as working with their direct supervisors and appropriate committees and work groups to

represent the ideas and issues of their areas. Managers are responsible for facilitating department and

unit program reviews and plans by faculty and staff, as well as for facilitating division or service area


meetings where faculty and staff work together to prioritize any requests for college-wide resources

coming from their academic or service areas.

All Deans, Vice Presidents, and select managers with broader campus responsibilities serve on the Admin

Council, which meets monthly. When needed, managers provide formal input on governance issues to the

college president.

The Instructional Deans have a monthly meeting with the Vice President of Instruction and the Director of

Planning & Research to problem solve and discuss operational issues such as providing curriculum support

to faculty, program compliance and regulatory changes, enrollment management, and coordinating

overlapping programs and services.

The President’s Cabinet meets weekly and includes the President and all Vice Presidents, and the Director

of Planning & Research as needed. The President’s Cabinet is responsible for discussing overall college

operational issues and making recommendations to the President based on input from their areas.


Administrators are appointed to serve on a variety of Cabrillo College and District ad hoc and standing

committees by the college president. The administrators provide input to the prioritization process for

new planning and resource requests through their appointments to the core mission workgroups and the

CPC. In addition, administrators have a responsibility to solicit opinions from faculty, staff, and students in

affected areas, as well as give those opinions reasonable consideration before final decisions are made

that affect those individuals. Administrator representatives on participatory governance committees will

report back to Administrators on a consistent basis.

Meet and Confer

Administrators who are directors, deans, and vice presidents are represented by the meet and confer

group, Administrative Benefits Committee (ABC). Questions and concerns regarding working conditions

should be directed to ABC representatives.

Student Participation: The Associated Students of Cabrillo College (ASCC) Student Senate is responsible for representing all

students to the college president, Faculty Senate, and college standing committees (Cabrillo Board Policy

2150, California Administrative Code Title 5 §51023.7). The ASCC Student Senate appoints eligible students

to serve on a number of college standing committees, including the CPC, and the Assessment Review

Committee, among others. All Cabrillo students are represented on the Cabrillo Board of Trustees by a

Student Trustee with an advisory vote (Cabrillo Board Policy 2150). The ASCC President or his or her

designee is a member of the CPC.

Each Cabrillo student has specific rights and responsibilities as a student enrolled in the college, which are

defined by the Students Rights and Responsibility Handbook. All students are encouraged to make their

voice heard by voting or participating in student elections and student clubs, by bringing issues to the

attention of the ASCC Student Senate, or by contributing their opinions to occasional college surveys

regarding student satisfaction with the college and specific departments and services.


Students participate in decision-making processes in a variety of ways. The ASCC Student Senate meets

regularly and appoints student representatives to governance groups and committees within the college.

The ASCC Student Senate provides input to the prioritization process for new planning and resource


requests through their appointments to the Student Learning Outcomes Committee, the Facilities Planning

and Advisory Committee, and the CPC. Students have a responsibility to gather information from these

meetings and to disseminate this information and collect feedback from their student peers. Student

representatives on participatory governance committees will report back to Student Senate on a

consistent basis.

Board of Trustees:

Operational and Policy Planning

The Governing Board is responsible for making formal decisions regarding academic and professional

matters. This is done through the implementation of Board Policy. Board policy is the voice of the

Governing Board and defines the general goals and acceptable practices for the operation of the District. It

implements federal and state laws and regulations. The Governing Board, through policy, delegates

authority to the Superintendent/President to administer the District. The Superintendent/President and

District employees are responsible to reasonably interpret Board policy as well as other relevant laws and

regulations that govern the District.


In administering District policies, the Superintendent/President shall be guided by the knowledge that the

Governing Board values an open interchange of ideas among all employees of the District. Nothing herein

shall be interpreted as intended to interrupt the free and open flow of ideas and assistance among

personnel at every level.


Structures for Participation

Participatory Governance Groups CPC must approve all Participatory Governance Groups.

Participatory Governance Committee

Committee that meets on a regular basis, consisting of constituent representatives designated or selected

to act in an advisory capacity to College Planning Committee (CPC). The charge of Cabrillo College

governance committees is to communicate ideas, concerns, goal completions and recommendations

through dialogue between the committee, CPC, and their constituents. These committees serve as vital

components to college planning and goal setting.

Subcommittee

A permanent sub group convened by a standing committee or council designated to consider specific

subjects in detail for recommendations back to the standing committee or council. The chair or one

representative must be a member of the committee or council to which it reports. Other members need

not be members of the committee to which it reports.

Operational Groups

Council

Standing council intended to consider all matters pertaining to procedural issues as defined by the role of

the members, (e.g., Council of Instructional Planning) and assisting with college operations needs.

Task Force

A constituency or operations represented group specifically convened by and reporting to a committee or

to the President (or President’s designee) to address a special college-wide subject/issue. The Task Force

meets until the subject/issue is resolved whereupon the group disbands.

Advisory Group

A working group of individuals with specialized expertise that provides input and advice to an operational

unit or group of units but does not make binding decisions (example EOPS Advisory Group).


Decision Making Process All ideas or proposed changes that have a District wide impact will move through the Participatory

Governance process via appropriate committees. Final recommendations and decisions move through

the governance process to the College Planning Committee (CPC). CPC considers the recommendations

and provides and final recommendation to the President. Should the President disagree with a

governance recommendation, it is incumbent upon the President to state in writing the rationale.

Recommendations that require Governing Board approval will move forward as action items to the

board agenda. Informational recommendations may also be given to the Board as an information

agenda item or report.

1. Propose action.

2. Relevant governance committee(s) will discuss and evaluate the proposed action through

inclusive dialogue and may request additional data or wish to confer with other committees,

councils, etc.

3. A formal recommendation may move forward to CPC to discuss and evaluate through inclusive

dialogue. The committee chair or designee(s) forwarding the recommendation is expected to

introduce the written recommendation to CPC in person. Should the chair or designee be

unavailable, the recommendation must be accompanied by a written summary of committee

feedback and rationale for the recommendation. Any recommendation moving forward must be

provided in time to allow for sufficient dialogue, data and information request fulfillment, and

other consultation.

4. CPC will provide feedback and any requested changes to the proposing committee. This will be

documented through minutes and communicated to the committee chair by the President in

writing. This may require returning to Step 1 or 2 as appropriate.

5. CPC makes final recommendation to President. The President can ask for additional information

and if s/he does not accept recommendation the rationale must be stated in writing.

6. President presents recommendation as action item to Governing Board to discuss and evaluate

and may request additional information or consult with others as appropriate. Should the

Governing Board not accept the recommendation their rationale should be clearly reflected in the

minutes.

7. After adoption the action item is implemented. The implementation task is typically assigned to

an employee, office, service, and/or department.

8. After implementation, the action should be assessed or evaluated for effectiveness and informing

future action proposals to complete the cycle of Planning, Implementation, and Evaluation. The

means and method of the evaluation depend on the action item and should be defined when

developing the action item. For example, an action item to implement a process change to

improve student outcomes should contain a specific numeric goal and timeline.


Participatory Governance Committee Initiatives and Reporting As a representative of students, faculty, classified, confidential or administrator, collective thoughts and

voices are a vital part of providing a holistic recommendation for college planning. Institutional planning

for 2017-2018 includes the following strategic focus areas for Cabrillo:

Guided Pathways

Accreditation

Integrated Planning (Initiative)

Facilities/Technology Planning (Bond)

Institutional Effectiveness Planning Initiative (IEPI)

Goals assigned to the committee will be based on these focus areas. The committee may wish to

carryover goals from last year as well.

Timeline Month Task

August Participatory Governance workshop held to identify committee goals for current year

derived from the Strategic Plan and other institutional foci.

September End of year report from prior year reviewed by the Institutional Effectiveness

committee for comment and recommendations back to CPC.

October End of year report from prior year provided to Governing Board as action item

May End of year report for current year on status of committee goals and an assessment of

issues the committee would like addressed in the next year by any committee or unit

and the committee’s recommendations for changing the description or composition of

the committee if any.

June Final committee reports for current year provided to CPC and a summary is added to

the aggregate end of year report.


Participatory Governance Committee Member Roles and Responsibilities Attend all meetings or send substitute as needed

Come prepared to participate and carry concerns from constituent group

Read agendas and materials in advance of the meeting

Report back to constituent group or other interest committees any items discussed and actions taken.

Listen respectfully and actively contribute.

In addition, Committee Chairs:

Schedule regular meetings

Post agendas 72 business hours ahead of meeting

Monitor attendance

Compile minutes

Facilitate respectful and inclusive dialogue


Appendices Glossary of Common Acronyms and Miscellaneous Abbreviations

Acronym/ Abbreviation Definition / Description

AA Associate in Arts degree AA-T Associates in Arts for Transfer AB540 CA State law that allowed students meeting certain criteria to pay resident tuition rates

AB1725 Assembly Bill 1725 is landmark legislation that provides new direction and support for the community college. The bill's reforms fall into eight areas: Mission; Governance; Finance; New Programs and Services; Affirmative Action; Employment Policies; Accountability; Conditions and Appropriation for Reform.

ABC Administrative Benefits Council

ACCESS In cooperation with UCSC, an academic bridge program for community college students interested in pursuing a career in research science. Its mission is to provide students with opportunities to acquire knowledge and skills that will increase their transfer eligibility and academic success, and lead to greater diversity among university undergraduates in the biomedical sciences. The program focuses on students whose academic goals and potential have been affected by disadvantageous circumstances and/or students who belong to groups with below-average UC enrollment rates. (not an acronym)

ACE Academy for College Excellence (formerly known as DBA, Digital Bridge Academy) (Student Learning Community)

ACHRO/EEO Statewide Association of Chief Human Resources Officers/Equal Employment EEO Officers

ACCT Accounting (Instructional Program)

ADA Americans with Disabilities Act - A federal act which mandates full accessibility for students and employees with disabilities

ADAPT Adaptive Physical Education (instructional Program)

A&R Admissions and Records Office

ADT Associate Degree for Transfer

AEBG Adult Education Block Grant

AGS Alpha Gamma Sigma (campus club - Student Honor Society)

AH Art History (Instructional Program)

ALH Allied Health (Instructional Program)

AMAP Accelerated Medical Assisting Program (Student Learning Community)

AMC Administrators/Managers Council

ANTHR Anthropology (Instructional Program)

AP Accounts Payable (in Business Office)

AP Art Photography (Instructional Program)

AP Administrative Procedure (found in current Cabrillo Policy Manual)

AP Advanced Placement (high school)

ARC Assessment Review Committee (officially OARC)

ART Art-Studio (Instructional Program)

AS Associate in Science degree



AS-T Associates in Science for Transfer

ASC Accessibility Support Center (formerly DSPS)

ASCC Associated Students of Cabrillo College

ASCCC Academic Senate for the California Community Colleges. The statewide organization representing the faculty on matters of educational policy. Local academic senates also have rights and responsibilities related to local district governance.

ASL American Sign Language (Instructional Program)

ASTRO Astronomy (Instructional Program)

ATH Athletics (Instructional Program)

AUO Administrative Unit Outcomes (measures what administrative unit does for others) as opposed to SLO (student learning outcomes)

BBP Blood-borne pathogens

BBS Bilingual/Bicultural Studies (Instructional Program)

BELA Business, English, and Language Arts Division

BIO Biology (Instructional Program)

BOG Board of Governors. Appointed by the Governor, the Board establishes policy for the California Community Colleges

BOGW Board of Governors fee waiver (waives the unit enrollment fee at Community Colleges for California residents, including high school students, so that the cost of enrollment is not a barrier. Eligibility is based on financial need.)

BP Board Policy (found in Cabrillo Policy Manual)

BSO Business Services Office

BUS Business (Instructional Program)

CAHM Culinary Arts and Hospitality Management (Instructional Program)

CABT Computer Applications/Business Technology (Instructional Program)

CAP Cabrillo Advancement Program (Student Learning Community)

CBO Chief Business Officer (aka Vice President of Administrative Services)

CCEU Cabrillo Classified Employees Union (certified May 1, 2007)

CCFT Cabrillo College Federation of Teachers (faculty union)

CEM Construction and Energy Management (Instructional Program)

CEO Chief Executive Officer (aka President/Superintendent)

CFRA California Family Rights Act

CG Counseling and Guidance

CHAC Cabrillo Hispanic Affairs Council

CHEM Chemistry (Instructional Program)

CIO Chief Instructional Officer (aka, Vice President of Instruction)

CIP Council for Instructional Planning

CIS Computer and Information Systems (Instructional Program)

CJ Criminal Justice (Instructional Program)

COLA Cost of Living Adjustment

COMM Communication Studies (Instructional Program)

CPC College Planning Committee

CS Computer Science (Instructional Program)

CSSO Chief Student Services Officer (aka Vice President of Student Services)

CTC Computer Technology Center

CTE Career Technical Education



CWEE Cooperative Work Experience Education

DACA Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals

DANCE Dance (Instructional Program)

DAS Division Accounting Specialist

DC Department Chair

DE Distance Education

DH Dental Hygiene (Instructional Program)

DM Digital Media (Instructional Program)

DMAG Data Management Advisory Group

DMCP Digital Management Career Preparation (Instructional Program related to ACE)

DSPS Disabled Student Program and Services (former name)

ECE Early Childhood Education (Instructional Program)

ECON Economics (Instructional Program)

EDUC Education (Instructional Program)

EEOC Equal Employment Opportunity Commission

EMP Educational Master Plan

ENGL English (Instructional Program)

ENGR Engineering (Instructional Program)

EOPS Extended Opportunity Program and Services - a categorically funded program for colleges and programs serving disadvantaged students

ES Environmental Science (Instructional Program)

ESL English as a Second Language (Instructional Program)

ETECH Engineering Technology (Instructional Program)

FA Financial Aid

FAFSA Free Application for Federal Student Aid

Flex Flexible faculty schedule (annually 9 days of faculty staff development)

FMP Facilities Master Plan

FPC Facilities Planning Committee

FPPO Facilities Planning and Plant Operations (formerly M&O)

FR French (Instructional Program)

FSA Faculty Service Area (used for faculty layoff and reassignment purposes defined in CCFT contract)

FT Fire Technology (Instructional Program)

FTEF Full-Time Equivalent Faculty

FTES Full-Time Equivalent Student

GE Gainful Employment (Federal reporting requirement)

GE General Education

GEOG Geography (Instructional Program)

GEOL Geology (Instructional Program)

G-MUG Grant Managers User Group

GO Grants Office

GOAL Greater Opportunity for Adult Learning (formerly AEBG)

GP Guided Pathways

GPA Grade point average

GRMN German (Instructional Program)



HASS Human Arts and Social Sciences Division

HAWK Health, Athletics, Wellness and Kinesiology Division

HIST History (Instructional Program)

HONRS Honors (Instructional Program)

HORT Horticulture (Instructional Program), also name of building/location

HR Human Resources department

HS Health Science (Instructional Program)

HSERV Human Services (Instructional Program)

IA Instructional Assistant (classified position)

IAC Instructional Administrator Council

IC Instruction Council

IDA Instructional Division Assistant (classified position)

IEC Institutional Effectiveness Committee

ILC Integrated Learning Center (location: Watsonville Campus)

IGETC Intersegmental General Education Transfer Curriculum

IPA Instructional Procedures Analyst

IT Information Technology (formerly CR, Computer Resources)

ITAL Italian (Instructional Program)

JAPAN Japanese (Instructional Program)

JOURN Journalism (Instructional Program)

KIN Kinesiology (Instructional Program) (formerly PE)

LIBR Library (instructional Program), also name of building/location

LRC Learning Resources Center

LS Learning Skills

MA Medical Assisting (Instructional Program)

MATH Mathematics (Instructional Program)

MESA Math, Engineering, and Science Achievement program (Student Learning Community)

METEO Meteorology (Instructional Program)

MLC Math Learning Center

MQs Minimum Qualifications. Replaces California Community College credentials for state-defined academic qualifications related to faculty hiring

MUS Music (Instructional Program)

N Nursing (Instructional Program)

NAS Natural and Applied Sciences Division

OARC Outcomes Assessment Review Committee (aka ARC)

OCEAN Oceanography (Instructional Program)

PCN Position Control Number (budget-related position number)

PCTE Perkins Career and Technical Education Act

PDA Professional Development Activity

PERS Public Employees' Retirement System

PHILO Philosophy (Instructional Program)

PHYS Physics (Instructional Program)

PIE Program Improvement and Effectiveness

PIO Public Information Officer

PO Purchase Order



PR Purchase Requisition

PRO Planning and Research Office

PS Political Science (Instructional Program)

PSYCH Psychology (Instructional Program)

RE Real Estate (Instructional Program)

READ Reading (Instructional Program)

RT Radiologic Technology (Instructional Program)

SAS Senior Accounting Specialist (classified position)

SBDC Small Business Development Center

SDLC Stroke and Disability Learning Center (also known as the Stroke Center)

SESAG Student Equity and Success Advisory Group

SEP Student Educational Plan

SESSC Student Equity and Success Steering Committee

SLO Student Learning Outcomes (measures knowledge, skills, abilities and attitudes students gain)

SLS Sign Language Studies (Instructional Program, now ALS)

SOC Sociology (Instructional Program)

SPAN Spanish (Instructional Program)

SPECS (Scholars Program for Engineering College Students) Cluster term for departments working together in the HASS Division

SPED Special Education (Instructional Program)

SQL Structured Query Language

SSCT Student Support & Care Team

SSSP Student Success and Support Programs

STEAM Science, Technology, Engineering, Art, and Mathematics

STEM Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

STRS State Teachers' Retirement System

SWP Strong Workforce Program

TA Teaching Assistant

TA Theater Arts (Instructional Program)

TAC Technology Advisory Committee (now TC)

TAG Transfer Admission Guarantees

TC Technology Committee (formerly Technology Advisory Committee)

TLC Teaching and Learning Center

TUs Teaching Units

UCSC University of California, Santa Cruz

VAPA Visual, Applied and Performing Arts Division

VATEA Vocational Applied Teacher Education Act

VP Vice President

VPAS Vice President, Administrative Services (aka CBO and formerly Vice President of Business Services)

VPI Vice President, Instruction (aka CIO)

VPSS Vice President, Student Services (aka CSSO)

VTEA Vocational-Technical Education Act (Perkins)

W Welding (Instructional Program)



WS Women’s Studies (Instructional Program)

WSCH Weekly Student Contact Hours


Governance Related Education Code

§53200 BARCLAYS CALIFORNIA CODE OF REGULATIONS Title 5 Barclays Official California Code of Regulations

Title 5. Education

Division 6. California Community Colleges

Chapter 4. Employees

Subchapter 2. Certificated Positions

Article 2. Academic Senates

§53200. Definitions. For the purpose of this Subchapter:

a. “Faculty” means those employees of a community college district who are employed in positions

that are not designated as supervisory or management for the purposes of Article 5

(commencing with §3540) of Chapter 10.7 of Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code, and

for which minimum qualifications for hire are specified by the Board of Governors.

b. “Academic senate,” “faculty council,” and “faculty senate” means an organization formed in

accordance with the provisions of this Subchapter whose primary function, as the

representative of the faculty, is to make recommendations to the administration of a college

and to the governing board of a district with respect to academic and professional matters. For

purposes of this Subchapter, reference to the term “academic senate” also constitutes

reference to “faculty council” or “faculty senate.”

c. “Academic and professional matters” means the following policy development and

implementation matters:

1. curriculum, including establishing prerequisites and placing courses within disciplines;

2. degree and certificate requirements;

3. grading policies;

4. educational program development;

5. standards or policies regarding student preparation and success;

6. district and college governance structures, as related to faculty roles;

7. faculty roles and involvement in accreditation processes,

including self-study and annual reports;

8. policies for faculty professional development activities;

9. processes for program review;

10. processes for institutional planning and budget development; and

11. other academic and professional matters as are mutually agreed upon between the

governing board and the academic senate.

d. “Consult collegially” means that the district governing board shall develop policies on academic

and professional matters through either or both of the following methods, according to its own

discretion:

1. relying primarily upon the advice and judgment of the academic senate; or

2. agreeing that the district governing board, or such representatives as it may designate, and

the representatives of the academic senate shall have the obligation to reach mutual agreement


by written resolution, regulation, or policy of the governing board effectuating such

recommendations.

Note: Authority cited: §§66700 and 70901, Education Code. Reference: §§70901 and 70902, Education

Code.

HISTORY

1. Amendment of NOTE filed 11-4-77; effective thirtieth day thereafter (Register 77, No. 45).

2. Amendment of NOTE filed 4-27-83; effective thirtieth day thereafter (Register 83, No. 18).

3. Amendment filed 10-30-90 with Secretary of State by Board of Governors, California Community

Colleges; operative 11-30-90 (Register 90, No. 49). Submitted to OAL for printing only pursuant

to Education Code §70901.5(b).

4. Relocation of article 2 heading filed 5-15-93; operative 6-4-93 (Register 93, No. 25).

5. Amendment filed 9-6-94; operative 10-6-94. Submitted to OAL for printing only pursuant to

Education Code §70901.5 (Register 94, No. 38).

§51023.5 BARCLAYS CALIFORNIA CODE OF REGULATIONS Title 5 Barclays Official California Code of Regulations

Title 5. Education


Chapter 2. Community College Standards

Subchapter 1. Minimum Conditions

§51023.5. Staff.

a. The governing board of a community college district shall adopt policies and procedures that

provide district and college staff the opportunity to participate effectively in district and college

governance. At minimum, these policies and procedures shall include the following:

1. Definitions or categories of positions or groups of positions other than faculty that

compose the staff of the district and its college(s) that, for the purposes of this section, the

governing board is required by law to recognize or chooses to recognize pursuant to legal

authority. In addition, for the purposes of this section, management and non-management

positions or groups of positions shall be separately defined or categorized.

2. Participation structures and procedures for the staff positions defined or categorized.

3. In performing the requirements of subsections (a)(1) and (2), the governing board or its

designees shall consult with the representatives of existing staff councils, committees, employee

organizations, and other such bodies. Where no groups or structures for participation exist that

provide representation for the purposes of this section for particular groups of staff, the

governing board or its designees, shall broadly inform all staff of the policies and procedures

being developed, invite the participation of staff, and provide opportunities for staff to express

their views.

4. Staff shall be provided with opportunities to participate in the formulation and

development of district and college policies and procedures, and in those processes for jointly


developing recommendations for action by the governing board, that the governing board

reasonably determines, in consultation with staff, have or will have a significant effect on staff.

5. Except in unforeseeable, emergency situations, the governing board shall not take action

on matters significantly affecting staff until it has provided staff an opportunity to participate in

the formulation and development of those matters through appropriate structures and

procedures as determined by the governing board in accordance with the provisions of this

Section.

6. The policies and procedures of the governing board shall ensure that the recommendations

and opinions of staff are given every reasonable consideration.

7. When a college or district task force, committee, or other governance group, is used to

consult with staff regarding implementation of this section or to deal with other issues which

have been determined to significantly affect staff pursuant to subdivision (a)(4), the

appointment of staff representatives shall be made as follows:

i. The exclusive representative shall appoint representatives for the respective bargaining

unit employees, unless the exclusive representative and the governing board mutually agree

in a memorandum of understanding to an alternative appointment process.

ii. Where a group of employees is not represented by an exclusive agent, the appointment

of a representative of such employees on any task force, committee or governance group

shall be made by, or in consultation with, any other councils, committees, employee

organizations, or other staff groups that the governing board has officially recognized in its

policies and procedures for staff participation.

iii. When the task force, committee or governance group will deal with issues outside the

scope of collective bargaining, any other council, committee or staff group, other than an

exclusive agent, that the governing board has officially recognized in its policies and

procedures for staff participation may be allowed to designate an additional representative.

These organizations shall not receive release time, rights, or representation on such task

forces, committees, or other governance groups exceeding that offered to the exclusive

representative of classified employees.

iv. In all cases, representatives shall be selected from the category that they represent.

b. In developing and carrying out policies and procedures pursuant to subsection (a), the district

governing board shall ensure that its actions do not dominate or interfere with the formation or

administration of any employee organization, or contribute financial or other support to it, or in

any way encourage employees to join any organization in preference to another. In addition, in

order to comply with Government Code §§3540, et seq., such procedures for staff participation

shall not intrude on matters within the scope of representation under section 3543.2 of the

Government Code. Governing boards shall not interfere with the exercise of employee rights to

form, join, and participate in the activities of employee organizations of their own choosing for

the purpose of representation on all matters of employer-employee relations. Nothing in this

section shall be construed to impinge upon or detract from any negotiations or negotiated

agreements between exclusive representatives and district governing boards. It is the intent of

the Board of Governors to respect lawful agreements between staff and exclusive


representatives as to how they will consult, collaborate, share, or delegate among themselves

the responsibilities that are or may be delegated to staff pursuant to these regulations.

c. Nothing in this section shall be construed to impinge upon the policies and procedures

governing the participation rights of faculty and students pursuant to §§53200- 53204, and

§51023.7, respectively.

d. The governing board of a community college district shall comply substantially with the

provisions of this section.

Note: Authority cited: §70901, Education Code. Reference: §§70901, 70901.2 and 70902, Education

Code; and §§3540 et seq., Government Code.

§51023.7 BARCLAYS CALIFORNIA CODE OF REGULATIONS Title 5 Barclays Official California Code of Regulations

Title 5. Education


Chapter 2. Community College Standards

Subchapter 1. Minimum Conditions

§51023.7. Students.

a. The governing board of a community college district shall adopt policies and procedures that

provide students the opportunity to participate effectively in district and college governance.

Among other matters, said policies and procedures shall include the following:

1. Students shall be provided an opportunity to participate in formulation and

development of district and college policies and procedures that have or will have a significant

effect on students. This right includes the opportunity to participate in processes for jointly

developing recommendations to the governing board regarding such policies and procedures.

2. Except in unforeseeable, emergency situations, the governing board shall not take

action on a matter having a significant effect on students until it has provided students with an

opportunity to participate in the formulation of the policy or procedure or the joint

development of recommendations regarding the action.

3. Governing board procedures shall ensure that at the district and college levels,

recommendations and positions developed by students are given every reasonable

consideration.

4. For the purpose of this Section, the governing board shall recognize each associated

student organization or its equivalent within the district as provided by Education Code §76060,

as the representative body of the students to offer opinions and to make recommendations to

the administration of a college and to the governing board of a district with regard to district

and college policies and procedures that have or will have a significant effect on students. The

selection of student representatives to serve on college or district committees, task forces, or

other governance groups shall be made, after consultation with designated parties, by the

appropriate officially recognized associated student organization(s) within the district.


b. For the purposes of this Section, district and college policies and procedures that have or will

have a “significant effect on students” includes the following:

1. grading policies;

2. codes of student conduct;

3. academic disciplinary policies;

4. curriculum development;

5. courses or programs which should be initiated or discontinued;

6. processes for institutional planning and budget development;

7. standards and policies regarding student preparation and success;

8. student services planning and development;

9. student fees within the authority of the district to adopt; and

10. any other district and college policy, procedure, or related matter that the district

governing board determines will have a significant effect on students.

c. The governing board shall give reasonable consideration to recommendations and positions

developed by students regarding district and college policies and procedures pertaining to the

hiring and evaluation of faculty, administration, and staff.

d. Nothing in this Section shall be construed to impinge upon the due process rights of faculty, nor

to detract from any negotiations or negotiated agreements between collective bargaining

agents and district governing boards. It is the intent of the Board of Governors to respect

agreements between academic senates and collective bargaining agents as to how they will

consult, collaborate, share or delegate among themselves the responsibilities that are or may be

delegated to academic senates pursuant to the regulations on academic senates contained in

§§53200-53206.

e. The governing board of a community college district shall comply substantially with policies and

procedures adopted in accordance with this Section.

Note: Authority cited: §§66700 and 70901(b)(1)(E), Education Code. Reference: §§70901 (b)(1)(E),

70902(b)(7) and 76060, Education Code.

HISTORY

1. New section filed 3-12-91 by Board of Governors of California Community Colleges with the

Secretary of State operative 4-5-91. Submitted to OAL for printing only pursuant to Education

Code §70901.5(b), (Register 91, No. 23).

2. Editorial correction of printing error in subsection (b) and HISTORY 1. (Register 91, No. 43).

3. Amendment of subsections (a)(1), (a)(3), (a)(5), (a)(7), (b), (c) and (d) filed 9-6-94; operative 10-

6-94. Submitted to OAL for printing only pursuant to Education Code §70901.5 (Register 94, No. 38).

4. Amendment of section and Note filed 5-16-2003; operative 6-15-2003. Submitted to OAL for

printing only pursuant to Education Code §70901.5 (Register 2003, No. 27).


College Policies on Participation in Local Decision Making BP 2510 Participation in Local Decision Making

The Board is the ultimate decision-maker in those areas assigned to it by state and federal laws and

regulations. In executing that responsibility, the Board is committed to its obligation to ensure that

appropriate members of the District participate in developing recommended policies for Board action

and administrative procedures for Superintendent/President action under which the District is governed

and administered.

Each of the following shall participate as required by law in the decision-making processes of the

District:

Faculty Senate(s) (Title 5 Sections 53200-53206)

The Board or its designees will consult collegially with the Faculty Senate, as duly constituted with

respect to academic and professional matters, as defined by law. Procedures to implement this section

are developed collegially with the Faculty Senate.

Staff (Title 5 Section 51023.5)

Staff shall be provided with opportunities to participate in the formulation and development of District

policies and procedures that have a significant effect on staff. The opinions and recommendations of

the classified group will be given every reasonable consideration.

Students (Title 5 Section 51023.7)

The Associated Students shall be given an opportunity to participate effectively in the formulation and

development of district policies and procedures that have a significant effect on students, as defined by

law. The recommendations and positions of the Associated Students will be given every reasonable

consideration. The selection of student representatives to serve on District committees or task forces

shall be made after consultation with the Associated Students.

Except for unforeseeable emergency situations, the Board shall not take any action on matters subject

to this policy until the appropriate constituent group or groups have been provided the opportunity to

participate.

Nothing in this policy will be construed to interfere with the formation or administration of employee

organizations or with the exercise of rights guaranteed under the Educational Employment Relations

Act, Government Code Sections 3540 et seq.

See Administrative Procedure AP2510.

http://www.boarddocs.com/ca/cabrillo/Board.nsf/goto?open&id=A2LMNU5C1D27

AP 2510 Participation in Local Decision Making Faculty Participation


http://www.boarddocs.com/ca/cabrillo/Board.nsf/goto?open&id=A2LMNU5C1D27


There is operational consistency for all faculty. Faculty work with their Department Chairs and Deans on

matters concerning curriculum and classroom operations. Faculty work together with administrators to

determine the most effective methods to meet the needs of students, personnel, and the college.

Shared Governance

The Faculty Senate is responsible for formal recommendations regarding academic and professional

matters (See Appendix: California Administrative Code Title 5 Section 53201, Cabrillo Board Policy 2130).

The Faculty Senate Executive Board consists of an elected president, and an appointed Vice President,

Secretary, and Treasurer. The Division Senators are comprised of two faculty elected from each of the

five instructional divisions, plus one each from Counseling, Counseling and Educational Support Services,

and the Library. The Watsonville Representative is a voting member. Senator-at-Large seats rotate every

other year and are filled by election. Non-voting seats are held by a Student Senate Representative, the

Student Learning Outcomes Assessment Coordinator, the Cabrillo College Federation of Teachers

Liaison, the Cabrillo Classified Employee Union Liaison, and the Vice President of Instruction.

The Faculty Senate is also responsible for appointing faculty to college and district standing committees,

peer review teams, and various college and district ad hoc committees. In addition, the Faculty Senate

provides input into the prioritization process for new planning and resource requests through their

appointments to the core mission workgroups and the College Planning Council. The Senate president

meets regularly with the College President and Vice President of Instruction and the Director of Planning

& Research to ensure college-wide faculty concerns are communicated and discussed. Faculty Senate

meetings are open and all faculty are encouraged to communicate regularly with their representatives

and to participate in Senate sponsored events, activities, and meetings. Senate minutes are posted on

their website: http://cabrillo.edu/associations/facultysenate/minutes.html

Legally Defined Areas of Participation in Title 5 And Other Codes

Academic Senate

For the purposes of this Section, the term "academic and professional matters" means the following

policy development and implementation matters:

1. curriculum, including establishing prerequisites and placing courses within disciplines

2. degree and certificate requirements

3. grading policies

4. educational program development

5. standards or policies regarding student preparation and success

6. district and college governance structures, as related to faculty roles

7. faculty roles and involvement in accreditation processes, including self-study and annual reports

8. policies for faculty professional development activities

9. process for program review

10. process for institutional planning and budget development

http://cabrillo.edu/associations/facultysenate/minutes.html


11. other academic and professional matters as are mutually agreed upon between the governing board

and the academic senate

Other code sections that legally require participation by faculty:

1. Education Code Section 66450 - distribution of academic presentations

2. Education Code Section 87458 - administrative retreat rights

3. Education Code Section 87359 - equivalencies to minimum qualifications

4. Education Code Section 87360 - faculty hiring

5. Education Code Section 87663 - faculty evaluation

6. Education Code Section 87610.6 1 - faculty tenure

7. Education Code Section 87743.2 - faculty service areas

8. Title 5,Section 55022 - curriculum committees

9. Title 5, Section 53204 - academic senate/union agreements


The Cabrillo College Federation of Teachers (CCFT) is the collective bargaining representative for all

Cabrillo College faculty. CCFT often appoints representatives to committees and groups that deal

primarily with employee contracts and benefit information and issues. Questions or concerns regarding

faculty working conditions should be directed to CCFT representatives.

Collective Bargaining: Legal Provisions

Decision-making policies and implementation cannot detract from negotiated agreements on wages and

working conditions. Faculty senate and bargaining representative may establish agreements as to

consulting, collaborating, sharing or delegating (Title 5 §53204). The exclusive bargaining agent shall

consult with the faculty senate prior to engaging in bargaining on: Faculty Evaluation (Ed Code §87663),

Tenure (Ed Code §87610.6) and Faculty Service Areas (Ed Code §87743.2).

Staff Participation


Classified staff have the responsibility and opportunity to participate in decision-making across the

college. At the operational level, classified staff collaborate with other staff, administrators, faculty, and

students within and across their departments, programs, and service areas to determine the most

effective ways to meet the needs of the students, personnel, and the college. Different units have

varying processes for how operational decisions are made and staff are encouraged to check with their

supervisors, governance, and/or bargaining unit leaders for more detailed information.

Shared Governance

Recommendations and opinions of staff are given every reasonable consideration. The classified staff

appoints representatives to various college committees through the collective bargaining unit,

(CCEU). Classified staff shared governance participation is defined by Title 5 and Board Policies and


Administrative Procedures. Classified staff provide input into the prioritization for new planning and

resource requests through their appointments to core mission workgroups and the College Planning

Council. Classified staff are encouraged to communicate regularly through their representatives and are

encouraged to participate in meetings, events, and other college wide activities.


Classified staff have one collective bargaining unit that represents all classified employees on work

related conditions. Questions or concerns regarding working conditions should be directed to the

Cabrillo Classified Employee Union (CCEU) representatives. CCEU appoints representatives to shared

governance committees and groups that deal with all aspects of college decision making, especially

those that affect employee contracts, working conditions, and benefit information.

Confidentials – Meet and Confer Group

“Confidential Employee” is an employee of the District who, in the regular course of his/her duties, has

access to confidential information that contributes to the development of management proposals and

decisions with respect to employer-employee relations (Government Code Section 3540.1(c)). As such,

they are not a bargaining unit, but rather a meet and confer unit. This component has a representative

presence on the CPC and selected shared governance committees.

Student Participation

The Associated Students of Cabrillo College (ASCC) Student Senate is responsible for representing all

students to the college president, Faculty Senate, and college standing committees (Cabrillo Board

Policy 2150, California Administrative Code Title 5 Section 51023.7). The ASCC Student Senate appoints

eligible students to serve on a number of college standing committees, including the College Planning

Council, and the Assessment Review Committee, among others. All Cabrillo students are represented on

the Cabrillo Board of Trustees by a Student Trustee with an advisory vote (Cabrillo Board Policy 2150).

The ASCC President or his or her designee is a member of the College Planning Council.

Each Cabrillo student has specific rights and responsibilities as a student enrolled in the college, which

are defined by the Students Rights and Responsibility Handbook. All students are encouraged to make

their voice heard by voting or participating in student elections and student clubs, by bringing issues to

the attention of the ASCC Student Senate, or by contributing their opinions to occasional college surveys

regarding student satisfaction with the college and specific departments and services.

Shared Governance

Students participate in decision-making processes in a variety of ways. The ASCC Student Senate meets

regularly and appoints student representatives to governance groups and committees within the

college. The ASCC Student Senate provides input to the prioritization process for new planning and

resource requests through their appointments to the Student Learning Outcomes Committee, the

Facilities Planning and Advisory Committee, and the College Planning Council. Students have a

responsibility to gather information from these meetings and to disseminate this information and collect

feedback from their student peers.

Students (Education Code Section 51023.7)


Students shall be provided with opportunities to participate in the formulation and development of

Board Policies and Administrative Procedures, and in those processes for jointly developing

recommendations for action by the Board of Trustees, that the Board reasonably determines, in

consultation with staff, have or will have a significant effect on students. Including:

1. grading policies

2. codes of student conduct

3. academic disciplinary policies

4. curriculum development

5. courses or programs which should be initiated or discontinued

6. processes for institutional planning and budget development

7. standards and policies regarding student preparation and success

8. student services planning and development

9. student fees within the authority of the District to adopt

10. any other Board Policy, Administrative Procedure or related matter that the district Board of

Trustees determines will have significant effect on students.

Administrator Participation


Administrators participate in decision-making processes in a variety of ways. In their local areas of

responsibility, they are responsible for seeking faculty, staff, and student input to improve programs and

services, as well as working with their direct supervisors and appropriate committees and work groups

to represent the ideas and issues of their areas. Managers are responsible for facilitating department

and unit program reviews and plans by faculty and staff, as well as for facilitating division or service area

meetings where faculty and staff work together to prioritize any requests for college-wide resources

coming from their academic or service areas.

All Deans, Vice Presidents, and select managers with broader campus responsibilities serve on the

Admin Council, which meets monthly. When needed, managers provide formal input on governance

issues to the college president.

The Instructional Deans have a monthly meeting with the Vice President of Instruction and the Director

of Planning & Research to problem solve and discuss operational issues such as providing curriculum

support to faculty, program compliance and regulatory changes, enrollment management, and

coordinating overlapping programs and services.

The President’s Cabinet meets weekly and includes the President and all the Vice Presidents, and the

Director of Planning & Research as needed. The President’s Cabinet is responsible for discussing overall

college operational issues and making recommendations to the President based on input from their

areas.

Shared Governance


Administrators are appointed to serve on a variety of Cabrillo College and District ad hoc and standing

committees by the college president. The administrators provide input to the prioritization process for

new planning and resource requests through their appointments to the core mission workgroups and

the College Planning Council. In addition, administrators have a responsibility to solicit opinions from

faculty, staff, and students in affected areas, as well as give those opinions reasonable consideration

before final decisions are made that affect those individuals.

Meet and Confer

Administrators who are directors, deans, and vice presidents are represented by the meet and confer

group, Administrative Benefits Committee (ABC). Questions and concerns regarding working conditions

should be directed to ABC representatives.

Board of Trustees

Operational and Policy Planning

The Governing Board is responsible for making formal decisions regarding academic and professional

matters. This is done through the implementation of Board Policy. Board policy is the voice of the

Governing Board and defines the general goals and acceptable practices for the operation of the District.

It implements federal and state laws and regulations. The Governing Board, through policy, delegates

authority to the Superintendent/President to administer the District. The Superintendent/President and

District employees are responsible to reasonably interpret Board policy as well as other relevant laws

and regulations that govern the District.

Shared Governance

In administering District policies, the Superintendent/President shall be guided by the knowledge that

the Governing Board values an open interchange of ideas among all employees of the District. Nothing

herein shall be interpreted as intended to interrupt the free and open flow of ideas and assistance

among personnel at every level.

http://www.boarddocs.com/ca/cabrillo/Board.nsf/goto?open&id=A2LMS75C99F1

http://www.boarddocs.com/ca/cabrillo/Board.nsf/goto?open&id=A2LMS75C99F1


Selected Data Resources Planning and Research

o FACT Book

o Education Data Sources List

College Accreditation Site

Accreditation Standards

Budget & Benefits Information Center

Community College League of California Fast Facts

Educational Master Plan

Fiscal Data Abstract

Program Planning Page

Strategic Plan Page

http://cabrillo.edu/services/pro/

http://www.cabrillo.edu/services/pro/factbook/

http://cabrillo.edu/services/pro/Educational%20Data%20Sources%20October%202014.pdf

http://www.cabrillo.edu/services/pro/accred/index.html

https://accjc.org/eligibility-requirements-standards-policies/

http://www.cabrillo.edu/internal/adminservices/budgetcenter/

http://ccleague.org/files/public/Publications/FF2017%5B1%5D.pdf

http://www.cabrillo.edu/services/pro/masterPlan/

http://extranet.cccco.edu/Divisions/FinanceFacilities/FiscalStandardsandAccountibilityUnit/FiscalStandards/FiscalDataAbstract.aspx

http://www.cabrillo.edu/services/pro/programPlanning/

http://www.cabrillo.edu/services/pro/strategicPlanning/


Cabrillo Integrated Planning and Resource Request Process


Component and Constituency Diagrams

President’s Component

Student Services Component


Administrative Services Component

Instruction Component


Faculty Senate Groups

Student Senate Groups


Bargaining Groups

Administration Constituency Primary Councils


Committee List Name Acronym Type Parent Administrator Benefits Council ABC Bargaining Non-cabinet

member managers

Academic Council AC Operational Faculty Senate Administrator Council Admin Operational President

Administrative Services Council ASC Operational VPAS ASC Advisory Group (Formerly Disabled Student Program and Services)

ASCAG Advisory ASC

Associated Students of Cabrillo College (Student Senate)*

ASCC Governance Students

Basic Skills Advisory Council BSAC Advisory Instruction

Cabrillo Classified Employee Union CCEU Bargaining Classified Staff

Cabrillo College Federation of Teachers CCFT Bargaining Faculty Cabrillo Hispanic Affairs Council CHAC Other Other

Classification Study Committee CSC Bargaining HR/CCEU Classified Employees Professional Growth Committee

CEPGC Bargaining HR/CCEU

College Planning Committee CPC Governance President

Confidential Employee Group CEG Bargaining Confidential employees

Council on Instructional Planning CIP Operational Instruction

Curriculum Committee* CC Governance Faculty Senate Data Management Advisory Group DMAG Advisory Administrator

Council Distance Education Committee DEC Operational Instruction

Education Centers Advisory Group ECAG Advisory Instruction Emergency Preparedness Committee EPC Operational FPAC

Equal Employment Opportunity EEO Task Force HR Extended Opportunity Programs and Services Advisory Group

EOPSAG Advisory EOPS

Facilities Planning Committee FPC Governance CPC

Faculty Grant Committee FGC Operational Faculty Senate

Faculty Prioritization FP Operational Faculty Senate Faculty Senate* FS Governance Faculty

Flex Committee FC Governance PD


Name Acronym Type Parent

Greater Opportunity for Adult Learning GOAL Advisory President Grant Managers User Group G-MUG Advisory Grants/BSO

Health Benefits Committee HBC Operational VPAS Institutional Effectiveness Committee IEC Governance CPC

Instructional Administrative Council IAC Operational VPI

Instructional Council IC Operational VPI Outcomes Assessment Review Committee OARC Governance CPC

Sabbatical Leave Review Board SLRB Governance Faculty Senate Professional Development Committee PD Governance CPC Safety and Emergency Preparedness Group SEPG Governance FPC Sustainability and Climate Planning Group SCPG Governance FPC

Student Discipline Hearings Committee SDHC Operational Dean of Students Student Equity and Success Advisory Group SESAG Advisory SESSC Student Equity and Success Steering Committee SESSC Governance CPC

Student Health Services Advisory Group SHSAG Operational VPSS Student Services Council SSC Operational VPSS

Student Support and Conference Team SSCT Operational Dean of Students

Technology Committee Tech Governance CPC Transfer Center Advisory Group TCAG Advisory Counseling

* Brown Act applicable committees


Committee Report Out Template


Governance Committee Feedback Surveys

Member Survey


Chair Survey

participatory governance: decision making and committee ... › associations › faculty... ·...

Documents