part 1 - analysis of historical significance: historic...

Phase II: Analysis of Historically Significant City Buildings, Newton, Massachusetts Cabot Elementary School DRAFT 3/23/2012

PART 1 - Analysis of Historical Significance: Historic Images!!

!Figure 1: Cabot School circa 1929 (Source: MACRIS)

DiNisco Design PARTNERSHIP

Cabot School

Working GroupMeeting

May 23, 2016

Concept Diagram

ADMIN. ADMIN.

PREVIOUSLY PROPOSED CURRENT PROPOSED

Circulation Diagrams

KITC

HENCAFETERIA

PUBLIC

SERV

ICE

MAIN CORRIDOR

BLUE

ZON

E&

PARK

ING

KITC

HENCAFETERIA

PUBLIC

SERV

ICE

MAIN CORRIDOR

BLUE

ZON

E&

PARK

ING

KITC

HEN

CAFE

TERI

A

PUBLIC

SERV

ICE

MAIN CORRIDOR

BLUE

ZON

E&

PARK

ING

KITC

HEN

CAFETERIA

PUBL

IC

SERV

ICE

MAIN CORRIDOR

BLUE

ZON

E&

PARK

ING

DIAGRAM 1 DIAGRAM 2

DIAGRAM 3 DIAGRAM 4

Site Plan Concepts

VANS

13 CARS

15 C

ARS

BUSES

SERVICE

BUSES

SERVICE

15 C

ARS

13 CARS

7 CARS

9 CA

RS

BUSES

SERVICESERVICE

15 C

ARS

10 CARS

VANS

SERVICE

BUSES

SERVICE

CONCEPT 1 CONCEPT 2

CONCEPT 3

N 0 10050

!"#$

%$&'( !"#$

#)*($ %+* ,'-+%+.

/.&

&0!'1

"

"

1%2# 3'*4

*53

* *!#+6 (0+!#!7*8

"*

!*

#(*#+

#(*#+

!#+6'1#

First Floor Second Floor

Third Floor

Renovation Addition | A.2 (Old A.3)

DiNisco Design PartnershipLimited

a r c h i t e c t s a n d p l a n n e r s

CABOT ELEMENTARY SCHOOLNewton, MA

LEGEND

CLASSROOM

SPECIAL EDUCATION

LIBRARY

ART/MUSIC

STAGE

GYMNASIUM

KITCHEN/CAFETERIA

ADMINISTRATION

BUILDING SERVICES

16 April 2015

FIRST FLOOR

SECOND FLOOR

THIRD FLOOR

N

GYMNASIUM

OT/PTADMINISTRATION NURSE

Renovation / Addition | Floor Plans

STGG.OFF CL-1 CL-1 CL-1 CL-1

P.A. P.A.S SS B.O.

CL-K CL-K CL-K CL-K

CUST/SERV

TT

KITCHENTT

CAFETERIA PP

CUST/SERV

MUSIC

STAG

E

UPPERGYMNASIUM

CL-2 CL-2

CL-2CL-2P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

SPED SPED

ARTEXTNDDAY

CL-3

CL-3 CL-3

P.A.

P.A.

S

SS B.O.

B.O.

CL-3

CL-5 CL-5

CL-5CL-5P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

CL-4 CL-4

P.A. SB.O.P.A. SS

CL-4

SPED LIBRARY

ROOF

ROOF

ROOF

0 4020

SOLAR ORIENTATION

EQUINO

XES

SUMMER

SOLSTICE

WINTER

SOLSTICE

DESIGN CHARACTERISTICS

• Variations within each schemewill be studied

• Core / Academics organizedvertically

• Gym can be zoned off• Kindergarden & 1st Grade on

ground floor• Academics on three floors• Limited floor-to-floor

heights due to salvage of1929 building

* Variations within scheme will be studied• Core program located on ground floor• Kindergarten on upper level• Academic on two floors• Gym cannot be zoned off• Cafeteria / Library ceiling heights low• Service area undersized• Dimensionally tight on site

N 0 4020

FIRST FLOOR SECOND FLOOR

THIRD FLOOR

Original Concept




LEGEND

CLASSROOM

SPECIAL EDUCATION

LIBRARY

ART/MUSIC

STAGE

GYMNASIUM

KITCHEN/CAFETERIA

ADMINISTRATION

BUILDING SERVICES

16 April 2015

FIRST FLOOR

SECOND FLOOR

THIRD FLOOR

N

GYMNASIUM




P.A. P.A.S SS B.O.

CL-K CL-K CL-K CL-K

CUST/SERV

TT

KITCHENTT

CAFETERIA PP

CUST/SERV

MUSIC

STAG

E

UPPERGYMNASIUM

CL-2 CL-2

CL-2CL-2P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

SPED SPED

ARTEXTNDDAY

CL-3

CL-3 CL-3

P.A.

P.A.

S

SS B.O.

B.O.

CL-3

CL-5 CL-5

CL-5CL-5P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

CL-4 CL-4

P.A. SB.O.P.A. SS

CL-4

SPED LIBRARY

ROOF

ROOF

ROOF

0 4020

SOLAR ORIENTATION

EQUINO

XES

SUMMER

SOLSTICE

WINTER

SOLSTICE







N 0 4020


THIRD FLOOR

Concept A.1




LEGEND

CLASSROOM

SPECIAL EDUCATION

LIBRARY

ART/MUSIC

STAGE

GYMNASIUM

KITCHEN/CAFETERIA

ADMINISTRATION

BUILDING SERVICES

16 April 2015

FIRST FLOOR

SECOND FLOOR

THIRD FLOOR

N

GYMNASIUM




P.A. P.A.S SS B.O.

CL-K CL-K CL-K CL-K

CUST/SERV

TT

KITCHENTT

CAFETERIA PP

CUST/SERV

MUSIC

STAG

E

UPPERGYMNASIUM

CL-2 CL-2

CL-2CL-2P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

SPED SPED

ARTEXTNDDAY

CL-3

CL-3 CL-3

P.A.

P.A.

S

SS B.O.

B.O.

CL-3

CL-5 CL-5

CL-5CL-5P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

CL-4 CL-4

P.A. SB.O.P.A. SS

CL-4

SPED LIBRARY

ROOF

ROOF

ROOF

0 4020

SOLAR ORIENTATION

EQUINO

XES

SUMMER

SOLSTICE

WINTER

SOLSTICE







N 0 4020


THIRD FLOOR

Concept A.2




LEGEND

CLASSROOM

SPECIAL EDUCATION

LIBRARY

ART/MUSIC

STAGE

GYMNASIUM

KITCHEN/CAFETERIA

ADMINISTRATION

BUILDING SERVICES

16 April 2015

FIRST FLOOR

SECOND FLOOR

THIRD FLOOR

N

GYMNASIUM




P.A. P.A.S SS B.O.

CL-K CL-K CL-K CL-K

CUST/SERV

TT

KITCHENTT

CAFETERIA PP

CUST/SERV

MUSIC

STAG

E

UPPERGYMNASIUM

CL-2 CL-2

CL-2CL-2P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

SPED SPED

ARTEXTNDDAY

CL-3

CL-3 CL-3

P.A.

P.A.

S

SS B.O.

B.O.

CL-3

CL-5 CL-5

CL-5CL-5P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

CL-4 CL-4

P.A. SB.O.P.A. SS

CL-4

SPED LIBRARY

ROOF

ROOF

ROOF

0 4020

SOLAR ORIENTATION

EQUINO

XES

SUMMER

SOLSTICE

WINTER

SOLSTICE







N 0 4020


THIRD FLOOR

Concept A.3




LEGEND

CLASSROOM

SPECIAL EDUCATION

LIBRARY

ART/MUSIC

STAGE

GYMNASIUM

KITCHEN/CAFETERIA

ADMINISTRATION

BUILDING SERVICES

16 April 2015

FIRST FLOOR

SECOND FLOOR

THIRD FLOOR

N

GYMNASIUM




P.A. P.A.S SS B.O.

CL-K CL-K CL-K CL-K

CUST/SERV

TT

KITCHENTT

CAFETERIA PP

CUST/SERV

MUSIC

STAG

E

UPPERGYMNASIUM

CL-2 CL-2

CL-2CL-2P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

SPED SPED

ARTEXTNDDAY

CL-3

CL-3 CL-3

P.A.

P.A.

S

SS B.O.

B.O.

CL-3

CL-5 CL-5

CL-5CL-5P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

CL-4 CL-4

P.A. SB.O.P.A. SS

CL-4

SPED LIBRARY

ROOF

ROOF

ROOF

0 4020

SOLAR ORIENTATION

EQUINO

XES

SUMMER

SOLSTICE

WINTER

SOLSTICE







N 0 4020


THIRD FLOOR

Concept A.4




LEGEND

CLASSROOM

SPECIAL EDUCATION

LIBRARY

ART/MUSIC

STAGE

GYMNASIUM

KITCHEN/CAFETERIA

ADMINISTRATION

BUILDING SERVICES

16 April 2015

FIRST FLOOR

SECOND FLOOR

THIRD FLOOR

N

GYMNASIUM




P.A. P.A.S SS B.O.

CL-K CL-K CL-K CL-K

CUST/SERV

TT

KITCHENTT

CAFETERIA PP

CUST/SERV

MUSIC

STAG

E

UPPERGYMNASIUM

CL-2 CL-2

CL-2CL-2P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

SPED SPED

ARTEXTNDDAY

CL-3

CL-3 CL-3

P.A.

P.A.

S

SS B.O.

B.O.

CL-3

CL-5 CL-5

CL-5CL-5P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

CL-4 CL-4

P.A. SB.O.P.A. SS

CL-4

SPED LIBRARY

ROOF

ROOF

ROOF

0 4020

SOLAR ORIENTATION

EQUINO

XES

SUMMER

SOLSTICE

WINTER

SOLSTICE







N 0 4020


THIRD FLOOR

Concept B.1




LEGEND

CLASSROOM

SPECIAL EDUCATION

LIBRARY

ART/MUSIC

STAGE

GYMNASIUM

KITCHEN/CAFETERIA

ADMINISTRATION

BUILDING SERVICES

16 April 2015

FIRST FLOOR

SECOND FLOOR

THIRD FLOOR

N

GYMNASIUM




P.A. P.A.S SS B.O.

CL-K CL-K CL-K CL-K

CUST/SERV

TT

KITCHENTT

CAFETERIA PP

CUST/SERV

MUSIC

STAG

E

UPPERGYMNASIUM

CL-2 CL-2

CL-2CL-2P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

SPED SPED

ARTEXTNDDAY

CL-3

CL-3 CL-3

P.A.

P.A.

S

SS B.O.

B.O.

CL-3

CL-5 CL-5

CL-5CL-5P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

CL-4 CL-4

P.A. SB.O.P.A. SS

CL-4

SPED LIBRARY

ROOF

ROOF

ROOF

0 4020

SOLAR ORIENTATION

EQUINO

XES

SUMMER

SOLSTICE

WINTER

SOLSTICE







N 0 4020


THIRD FLOOR

Concept B.2




LEGEND

CLASSROOM

SPECIAL EDUCATION

LIBRARY

ART/MUSIC

STAGE

GYMNASIUM

KITCHEN/CAFETERIA

ADMINISTRATION

BUILDING SERVICES

16 April 2015

FIRST FLOOR

SECOND FLOOR

THIRD FLOOR

N

GYMNASIUM




P.A. P.A.S SS B.O.

CL-K CL-K CL-K CL-K

CUST/SERV

TT

KITCHENTT

CAFETERIA PP

CUST/SERV

MUSIC

STAG

E

UPPERGYMNASIUM

CL-2 CL-2

CL-2CL-2P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

SPED SPED

ARTEXTNDDAY

CL-3

CL-3 CL-3

P.A.

P.A.

S

SS B.O.

B.O.

CL-3

CL-5 CL-5

CL-5CL-5P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

CL-4 CL-4

P.A. SB.O.P.A. SS

CL-4

SPED LIBRARY

ROOF

ROOF

ROOF

0 4020

SOLAR ORIENTATION

EQUINO

XES

SUMMER

SOLSTICE

WINTER

SOLSTICE







Concept B.3




LEGEND

CLASSROOM

SPECIAL EDUCATION

LIBRARY

ART/MUSIC

STAGE

GYMNASIUM

KITCHEN/CAFETERIA

ADMINISTRATION

BUILDING SERVICES

16 April 2015

FIRST FLOOR

SECOND FLOOR

THIRD FLOOR

N

GYMNASIUM




P.A. P.A.S SS B.O.

CL-K CL-K CL-K CL-K

CUST/SERV

TT

KITCHENTT

CAFETERIA PP

CUST/SERV

MUSIC

STAG

E

UPPERGYMNASIUM

CL-2 CL-2

CL-2CL-2P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

SPED SPED

ARTEXTNDDAY

CL-3

CL-3 CL-3

P.A.

P.A.

S

SS B.O.

B.O.

CL-3

CL-5 CL-5

CL-5CL-5P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

CL-4 CL-4

P.A. SB.O.P.A. SS

CL-4

SPED LIBRARY

ROOF

ROOF

ROOF

0 4020

SOLAR ORIENTATION

EQUINO

XES

SUMMER

SOLSTICE

WINTER

SOLSTICE







N 0 4020


THIRD FLOOR

N 0 4020


THIRD FLOOR

Concept B.4




LEGEND

CLASSROOM

SPECIAL EDUCATION

LIBRARY

ART/MUSIC

STAGE

GYMNASIUM

KITCHEN/CAFETERIA

ADMINISTRATION

BUILDING SERVICES

16 April 2015

FIRST FLOOR

SECOND FLOOR

THIRD FLOOR

N

GYMNASIUM




P.A. P.A.S SS B.O.

CL-K CL-K CL-K CL-K

CUST/SERV

TT

KITCHENTT

CAFETERIA PP

CUST/SERV

MUSIC

STAG

E

UPPERGYMNASIUM

CL-2 CL-2

CL-2CL-2P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

SPED SPED

ARTEXTNDDAY

CL-3

CL-3 CL-3

P.A.

P.A.

S

SS B.O.

B.O.

CL-3

CL-5 CL-5

CL-5CL-5P.A.

P.A.B.O.

SPEDL.C.

SPEDCLRM

STT.WK

T.LNG

TT

CL-4 CL-4

P.A. SB.O.P.A. SS

CL-4

SPED LIBRARY

ROOF

ROOF

ROOF

0 4020

SOLAR ORIENTATION

EQUINO

XES

SUMMER

SOLSTICE

WINTER

SOLSTICE







A Series Summary

CONCEPT A.1 CONCEPT A.2

CONCEPT A.3 CONCEPT A.4

B Series Summary

CONCEPT B.1 CONCEPT B.2

CONCEPT B.3 CONCEPT B.4

Footprint Comparison

+/- 58'

+/- 3

8'

+/- 5

9'

15'-6

"@

1ST

FLO

OR

@ U

PPER

FLO

ORS

+/- 2

1'+/

- 3'

+/- 58'

+/- 1

9'+/

- 71'

+/- 58'

EXISTING CONDITIONS PREVIOUSLY PROPOSED CURRENT PROPOSED

PARK PROPERTY LINE

BRIDGES AVE.

EASEMENT

PARK PROPERTY LINE

EASEMENT

PARK PROPERTY LINE

EASEMENT

PARKVIEW AVE.

BRIDGES AVE.

PARKVIEW AVE.

BRIDGES AVE.

PARKVIEW AVE.

part 1 - analysis of historical significance: historic...

Documents