paper 2 - amazon web servicessmartfuse.s3.amazonaws.com/.../2017/10/english-lang… · ·...
TRANSCRIPT
English Language
Paper 2
Writers’ Viewpoints and Perspectives
Exam Guide
Name:_____________________
Class:______________________
Reading Source A and Source B
Read both sources first. Read
them carefully and stay focused.
Read them both again. This time:
Highlight interesting/powerful words and
phrases.
Annotate any devices or techniques that
you spot.
Remember: Q1-4 are reading questions. It is
important that you read and understand both
sources. Visualise what you are reading.
15
minutes
Question 1: True or False?
Success Criteria: Read the question very carefully
Focus on the specified source and lines
Read the statements very carefully
Give four answers
Shade the box
Top Tips:
If struggling, eliminate the ones you know are definitely
incorrect.
Make sure that the meaning of the statement is the same
as the meaning of the source- sometimes they will try
and trick you with vocabulary.
4 minutes
Question 2: Summarise…
Underline what the question is asking you to do.
What is it asking you to summarise?
Identify at least two differences/similarities.
Write a paragraph about each
difference/similarity (depending on what the
question is asking you to do).
Structure each paragraph like this:
A key difference is……
In Source A it states ‘……’
Which implies that…
Whereas in Source B it states ‘……’
Which suggests that……
Difference/
Similarity
Quote(s) from
Source A
Inference
Quote(s) from
Source B
Inference
Question 2: Example Answer
A key difference is the girls’ clothing. In source A
the girl’s clothes are more expensive as she
wears ’gold encrusted buttons’ and has a ‘lace
collar’ suggesting that she has excess money to
spend on unnecessary luxuries. Whereas in
Source B the girl’s clothing is more basic, as she
wears a ‘torn cotton t-shirt’ and ‘plimsolls’,
implying that appearance is not as important to
her, just functionality.
Another key difference is their attitude
towards education. In Source A, the girl is less
concerned about education as she ‘has a mound of
disorganised and incomplete assignments’ and she
‘laughs off’ warnings from her butler, implying that
due to her lavish lifestyle, she sees education as
unnecessary because she already has everything she
wants. Whereas in Source B the girl prioritises her
education more as she ‘meticulously timetables her
homework’ and there are ‘mountains of drafted and
redrafted essays’ on her floor, suggesting that she is
more determined to succeed, perhaps because unlike
the girl in Source A, she has to work harder in order
to succeed and has more determination.
Top Tips:
Use comparatives to show the difference: more, less, richer, poorer, smarter, colder….
To gain the highest marks, you must give perceptive
inferences: what does the language actually suggest?
Include multiple, short and snappy quotations from both
sources.
Difference/
Similarity
Quote(s) from
Source A
Inference
Quote(s) from
Source B
Inference
Question 3: Language Analysis
Underline the key words in the question: source,
line numbers, focus.
Pick at least 4 language features (powerful
words/phrases, devices, sentence forms).
Choose wisely, as you will have limited time.
12
minutes
Question 3: Success Criteria:
Explore a range of techniques
Use subject terminology
Use precise/relevant quotations to support ideas
Explain effects of language in detail.
Write about each language feature you have identified
using the following writing frames:
The author writes, “…”
A technique used here is….
This shows….This makes the
reader feel…
Quote
Technique
Effect
The writer uses (insert
technique)to describe the ___
For example, “…”.
The (insert ST) “…” has
connotations of… This
suggests/makes the reader…
This idea is developed by…
Technique
Quote
Effect Zoom in
Connotations
More ST
Link to another
quote/
technique
Top Tip: Use these phrases to explain the
effects of the language:
• This creates the
impression…
• This makes the reader feel…
• …has connotations of ….
• This paints a picture…
• This emphasises the …
• This highlights…..
Top Tip:
Consider the
connotations of
words when you
explain the effect
Question 3: Example Answers
Grade 4:
The writer describes the coal tip as a
‘killer with a rotten heart’. This
personification makes the reader feel that
the tip is like a murderer that is creeping up on the
children in the school. The writer also uses the
phrase ‘inching ominously’. This adverb makes the
reader realise that the tip is creeping up to them.
Grade 9:
The writer makes effective use of
personification to single out coal tip
number 7 as a ‘killer with a rotten heart’.
Here, the emotive adjective ‘rotten’ creates
the impression of a malevolent being. This is
because ‘rotten’ can have several
connotations, but all of them are negative. For
example, it makes a link for the reader with
decay, death, but just as importantly, is
suggestive of evil intent. It is as if it sets out
to deliberately kill the children. This is further
added to by a verb phrase ‘inching ominously’ which
suggests on- going movement, slow, imperceptible but
inevitable and the adverb, ‘ominously’ forewarns of
the disaster to come. The writer appears to draw on
conventions of the horror genre to pull the reader
into his account – it has a clear villain and set of
victims.
Technique
Quote
Effect Zoom in
Connotations
More ST
Link to
another
quote/
technique
Quote
Technique
Effect
Question 4: Comparison
Success Criteria:
Make POINTS about the writer’s
viewpoint
Give EVIDENCE to prove this
Identify the METHODS/DEVICES the
writer is using.
EXPLAIN what this shows about the
writer’s view/intentions
COMPARE with the other source.
16 minutes
Question 4- Quick Plan:
What is the viewpoint of each writer? What does each
writer think/feel/believe, etc? Make a quick plan:
Source A: Writer’s
Viewpoint
Source B: Writer’s
Viewpoint
He believes….
He thinks….
He believes….
He thinks….
Now make a quick plan for comparing:
What’s different or similar about the writers’ views?
What’s different/similar about their methods /devices?
Question 4: Suggested writing frame
In source A the writer’s viewpoint is….
For example it says ‘……’
The writer uses (method/subject term/ device)
which suggests….
Clearly the writer is showing/trying to….
By contrast, in Source B the writer’s viewpoint is
different/similar because….
For example it says ‘……’
The writer uses (method/subject term/ device) which suggests…
Clearly the writer is showing/trying to….
This is different/similar to source A because…
Comparative Connectives Connectives to show similarity
Similarly
Equally
Likewise
As with
Like
In the same way
Both
Connectives to show difference
Whereas
On the other hand
Instead of
Alternatively
Unlike
However
In contrast
Top Tip:
Try to include more than one quotation to support your point.
Explain all quotations.
Really zoom in on the quotation.
Remember subject terminology.
Use comparatives and connectives to compare the sources/writers
Viewpoint
Quote
Effect Zoom in
Connotations
ST/Methods
Compare
Question 4:Getting Grades 6-9
To get the higher marks, you need to:
Compare viewpoints and compare the methods
Identify if/why the viewpoint of the writer
changes in a source
Insert more comparative phrases and
connectives as you go to compare the
sources/writers.
Comment on advanced methods: sarcasm, tone,
etc.
Use regular short snappy quotations to support
your ideas.
Explain how the perspective (when or where they
are writing) impacts on their viewpoint.
Top Tip:
Choose quotations/views/methods from both sources that you
can easily compare. E.g. In Source A the writer uses anthropomorphism by referring to the
elephant using the proper noun ‘Annie’, implying that he wants the reader
to recognise her human qualities and emotions. Similarly, in Source B the
writer uses the pronoun ‘he’ to refer to the rat, but this time implying
that he feels guilt for what he is about to do.
Question 4: Example Answers
Grade 3-4
In source A, the writer is shocked and saddened by what
happened. He describes the events as a ‘disaster’ and gives
the impression that the village is a dark and dangerous place.
In comparison, in source B the writer is worried about more
serious earthquakes happening in the future. One method he
uses is a rhetorical question when he asks: ‘who can say what
strange trial ... may await us?’ suggesting this kind of
disaster or worse might happen again.
Grade 8-9
The writer of source A seems dispassionate at first as he
paints the picture of gloomy, isolated Aberfan as it lies ‘tucked away’ from sight
and mind. The verb ‘tucked’ is more usually associated with being tucked up in
bed and tends to have more positive connotations of safety and warmth. But
here, the writer uses it differently, perhaps to imply complacency. He
reinforces this view when he creates the sense of a malevolent ‘killer’ stalking
its victims. He sees this disaster as ‘cruel’ and a ‘shame’ on ‘God and man’. This
time, the emotive connotations of ‘shame’ link with God to suggest a biblical
connection as with the shaming of sinners. In contrast, the writer of Source B
mocks the idea of the earthquake, which seems so minor it was hardly noticed in
London. One method he uses is exaggeration where he describes the incident
out of all proportion, with the Midlands for example, where it merely ‘broke
crockery’. The reference to broken crockery is hardly momentous yet through
it, the writer cleverly understates the threat at this point, something he
escalates later in his report when he asks the rhetorical question: ‘who can say
what strange trial ... may await us?’ Here the reference to ‘trial’ reveals the
writer’s view of the potential dangers a future earthquake might bring. Just as
a defendant is put on trial for life, so he seems to imply that next time a similar
earthquake might lead to loss of lives and so should be taken more seriously.
Perhaps the writer of source B is able to use a more sarcastic, mocking tone
because it was a superficial disaster; whereas in Source A a more mournful tone
is used because lives were lost and the writer believes that this kind of disaster
shouldn’t occur in the twenty-first century.
Viewpoint
Quote
Effect
Zoom in
Connotations
ST/Methods
Compare
Question 5: Point of view writing.
Read the question and underline the:
Form
Audience
Purpose
Statement
10 minutes: Create a spider diagram of ideas. Surround your
ideas with examples/reasons.
Top Tip:
Number your ideas. Each idea will become a paragraph.
Try to think carefully about the order of your ideas; try to get
each paragraph to flow on logically to the next one.
Group similar ideas into one paragraph.
10 minutes
planning
35 minutes
writing
Once you have decided what each paragraph will be about,
and the order you will write them in, you are ready to
begin.
Success Criteria:
AO5 - Content
Make sure you communicate ideas clearly
Use a range of language devices appropriately
Match the tone, register and style of your writing to the
purpose, audience and form.
Use a range of sophisticated vocabulary.
AO5 - Organisation
Ensure ideas are relevant and engaging
Use paragraphs accurately (TiPToP)
Link ideas/paragraphs
Use a range of discourse markers
Use a variety of structural features – for example: a hook; a one
sentence paragraph; a conclusion
AO6 – Technical Accuracy
Use ambitious vocabulary throughout
Use a range of punctuation accurately
e.g. . , ; : ? ! “” - … ()
Use a range of sentence forms
e.g. Simple/Compound/Complex
Accurately spell a range of vocabulary including more complex
words
Use Standard English - i.e. avoid informal language and slang.
There are a range of forms that you might be asked
to write in:
Letter
Article
Text for a speech
Text for a leaflet
Essay
The exam board gives the following instructions for
each form:
Question 5: Writing an introduction:
Remember that this is the first thing that the examiner
reads, and so it needs to have instant impact on them.
Recipe for intro:
Hook the reader with persuasive devices
Establish your viewpoint (do you agree or disagree?)
Clearly explain what the topic or issue is about
For example:
How did you get here today? Bicycle? Run? Or, like billions of others across the globe,
did you jump into a gas guzzler which belched out noxious fumes? It concerns me that
the majority of you would admit to the latter; so many of us opt for convenience over
the environment. I believe that it is up to our generation to make the change.
You are then ready to write your other paragraphs using your
plan. There are a range of ways that you can structure your
paragraphs.
Option 1: OREO Paragraphs
Opinion: In my opinion, we damage the
environment using transport.
Reason: I think this because the petrol used by
vehicles damages the environment and atmosphere.
Example: This is clearly shown by how many people
drove a car into work today. Just imagine all of those
toxic gasses floating up into the atmosphere.
Opinion: It is certain to me that this needs to
change.
Phrases for giving your
opinion:
In my opinion…
I believe that….
It is certain to me that….
It’s my firm belief that….
Phrases for giving your
reason:
My reason for believing this
is….
I think this because….
Some people think this
because….
Phrases for giving
examples:
For example, …..
Just imagine….
To prove this….
This is clearly shown by….
Option 2: Perfect Paragraphs
1. Start with clear, topic sentence to introduce your point.
2. Use evidence/research to support your point.
3. Explain specific benefit/disadvantage based on the evidence.
4. Use imagery to make your point even clearer.
5. Finish by using a call to action (asking the reader to do something)
Or…A rhetorical question (to leave a point in the reader’s mind)
6. LINK to next paragraph
E.g.
The benefits of a traffic free zone outside school are clear. Recent research has shown that once cars are banned, up to 70% of parents walk with their children to school’ (UK Gov., 2012). This would be incredibly beneficial to our children’s health. Instead of schools full of obese, wheezing, unhealthy children a simple daily walk could create a generation that is healthy, fit and alert. This is why I am asking you to contact our local council and ask them to create a ‘Traffic Free Zone’ outside our school; the benefits would be immeasurable.
Top Tip:
Make your writing unique- the examiner will read hundreds so
it’s important that you show creativity with your approach.
Fully develop your ideas. Use imperatives to make your
reader imagine a scenario, use personal experience or real-life
examples to illustrate your point of view.
Question 5: The conclusion:
Avoid just summarising points already made
What do you want the reader to do/ think/
believe/consider as a result of your writing?
What needs to happen next? What might happen if
you are ignored?
Make some kind of link back to the start.
End with something thought-provoking.
Remember: you must use a range of connectives to link
and sequence your ideas:
You may also find the following discourse markers useful
for linking and developing your ideas:
Remember to use a range of devices in your writing. The
following may be particularly useful:
Personal Pronouns
E.g. Can we really afford to ignore the damage we are doing to our planet? Our
Home?
Imperative Verbs
E.g. Stop throwing rubbish away; recycle your waste and save our planet.
Alliteration
E.g. Careless consumers continuously throw cardboard and other recyclables
into the bin.
Facts
E.g. The amount of pollution we release into the atmosphere is growing every
year.
Opinions
E.g. Personally, I think that it is totally unacceptable.
Rhetorical questions
E.g. Can we justify having lights on when we are not in a room?
Repetition
E.g. Pollution surrounds our homes; it surrounds our schools; it’s slowly, but
surely, surrounding our planet.
Emotive Language
E.g. Our planet is dying under the weight of this suffocating pollution.
Statistics
E.g. 90% of our rubbish could have been recycled.
Simile:
E.g. Due to our carelessness, the icecaps are melting like ice creams on a hot
summer’s day.
List of Three:
E.g. Make a change: pick up litter, recycle your waste and take shorter
showers.
Top Tip:
There are a whole range of devices you can use: metaphors,
sarcasm, humour, juxtaposition, plosives, sibilance,
onomatopoeia, personification…. What’s important is that you
select devices to achieve specific effects.
It’s important that you use a range of punctuation
in your writing.
Full stop . indicates that a sentence has finished
Comma , indicates a slight pause in a sentence,
separates clauses in a complex sentence
and items in a list Question
mark ? goes at the end of a question
Exclamation mark !
goes at the end of a dramatic sentence to
show surprise or shock
Apostrophe ‘ shows that letter(s) have been left out or
indicates possession Speech
marks “” indicate direct speech, the exact words
spoken or being quoted
Colon : introduces a list, a statement or a quote in
a sentence
Semicolon ; separates two sentences that are related
and of equal importance Dash /
hyphen - separates extra information from the main
clause by holding words apart
Brackets ( ) can be used like dashes, they separate off
extra information from the main clause
Ellipsis … to show a passage of time, to hook the
reader in and create suspense
Mark Scheme for Q5
Grade 7-9:
AO5: Content: compelling, convincing, complex ideas.
Devices: a range of devices for specific effects
Structure: varied, inventive, engaging
Organization: fluent paragraphs, variety of integrated discourse markers
AO6: Sentence separation: consistently accurate
Punctuation: wide range, high level of accuracy
Sentence forms: types and lengths used for effect
Spelling: high level of accuracy
Vocabulary: ambitious and extensive
Grade 5-6:
AO5: Content: consistently clear, engaging
Devices: a range of devices used for effect
Structure: engaging, developed
Organization: linked paragraphs, connecting words/phrases
AO6: Sentence separation: mostly secure and accurate
Punctuation: wide range, mostly successfully
Sentence forms: variety used for effect
Spelling: generally accurate
Vocabulary: increasingly sophisticated
Grade 3-4:
AO5: Content: mostly successful, developed, some control and relevant ideas
Devices: Some devices are used for effect
Structure: Uses paragraphs
Organization: linked ideas, some connectives
AO6: Sentence separation: mostly secure, sometimes accurate
Punctuation: Some control of a range
Sentence Forms: attempts a variety of sentence lengths and structures
Spelling: Some accurate spelling of complex words
Vocabulary: A range, varied
Grade 1-2
AO5: Content: simple and limited ideas
Devices: Simple vocabulary and devices
Structure: Random paragraphs
Organization: Some basic connectives
AO6: Sentence separation: sometimes accurate
Punctuation: Some accurate full stops & capital letters
Sentence forms: simple range
Spelling: accurate spelling of basic words
Vocabulary: simple