page 1 of 14 evaluation report for the tender of …

14
Page 1 of 14 EVALUATION REPORT FOR THE TENDER OF SUPPLY OF LAB EQUIPMENT FOR CENTRAL LAB UNDE THE APPROVED PC-1 (TENDER NO. UE/PC-1/TENDER 2020-21/05) Tender No. UE/PC-1/Tender 2020-21/05 for Supply of Lab Equipment for Central Lab was advertised on Newspapers and on the website of PPRA Punjab as per Rule No.12 (2) of PPRA Rules 2014. The Bids of following bidders were opened on 29-04-2021as per provisions of Rule (30) of PPRA Rules 2014: 1 Professional Systems (1) 12 Lab Chem Scientific (12) 2 SU Enterprises (2) 13 Science Emporium (13) 3 AGBL(3) 14 Scientific Traders (14) 4 Kamstec International (4) 15 Pakistan Hospital(15) 5 Analytical Measuring System(5) 16 Marshal Trading Corporation (16) 6 Sentron Asia International (6) 17 Max Tech Corporation (17) 7 Innovative Scientific Solution (7) 18 Key Scientific Corporation (18) 8 HA Shah(8) 19 Rays Technologies (19) 9 Ayub Brothers(9) 20 New Chemical Centre (20) 10 Innovative Power Engineering (10) 21 Shalimar Scientific (21) 11 CNA International (11) Bids of above-mentioned bidders were evaluated, as per Rule (32) of PPRA, through Eligibility and Technical Evaluation Criteria given at clause No.13, 14, 15 and 16 of the published Tender Document. After Evaluation bids of following bidders were rejected: Rejection of Bid for Lot#1 Name Status Reason of Rejection Sentron Asia International (6) Rejected Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document, as the bidder managed to get 42 marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification were 45. Innovative Scientific Solution (7) Rejected Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document, as the bidder managed to get 43 marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification were 45. Rejection of Bids (LOT#2) Name Status Reason of Rejection (LOT#2) Science Imporium(13) Rejected Did not qualify for the Lot, All Supply Order attached were with rates erased and no list of Technical Personnel with Qualification was attached. Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document, as the bidder managed to get 10 marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification were 35.

Upload: others

Post on 27-Jan-2022

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1 of 14

EVALUATION REPORT FOR THE TENDER OF SUPPLY OF LAB EQUIPMENT FOR CENTRAL LAB

UNDE THE APPROVED PC-1 (TENDER NO. UE/PC-1/TENDER 2020-21/05)

Tender No. UE/PC-1/Tender 2020-21/05 for Supply of Lab Equipment for Central

Lab was advert ised on Newspapers and on the website of PPRA Punjab as per Rule

No.12 (2) of PPRA Rules 2014.

The Bids of following bidders were opened on 29-04-2021as per provisions of Rule (30) of PPRA Rules

2014:

1 Professional Systems (1) 12 Lab Chem Scientific (12)

2 SU Enterprises (2) 13 Science Emporium (13)

3 AGBL(3) 14 Scientific Traders (14)

4 Kamstec International (4) 15 Pakistan Hospital(15)

5 Analytical Measuring System(5) 16 Marshal Trading Corporation (16)

6 Sentron Asia International (6) 17 Max Tech Corporation (17)

7 Innovative Scientific Solution (7) 18 Key Scientific Corporation (18)

8 HA Shah(8) 19 Rays Technologies (19)

9 Ayub Brothers(9) 20 New Chemical Centre (20)

10 Innovative Power Engineering (10) 21 Shalimar Scientific (21)

11 CNA International (11)

Bids of above-mentioned bidders were evaluated, as per Rule (32) of PPRA, through

El ig ibi l ity and Technical Evaluat ion Cr iter ia given at clause No.13, 14, 15 and 16 of

the published Tender Document . After Evaluat ion bids of fol lowing bidders were

rejected:

Rejection of Bid for Lot#1

Name Status Reason of Rejection

Sentron Asia International (6)

Rejected Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document, as the bidder managed to get 42 marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification were 45.

Innovative Scientific Solution (7)

Rejected Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document, as the bidder managed to get 43 marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification were 45.

Rejection of Bids (LOT#2) Name Status Reason of Rejection (LOT#2)

Science Imporium(13)

Rejected

Did not qualify for the Lot, All Supply Order attached were with rates erased and no list of Technical Personnel with Qualification was attached. Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document, as the bidder managed to get 10 marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification were 35.

Page 2 of 14

AGBL Pakistan(3) Rejected Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document, as the bidder managed to get 21marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification were 35.

Rejection of Bids (LOT#2) Name Status Reason of Rejection (LOT#3)

Scientific Traders (14)

Rejected The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (the failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria)

The Evaluat ion Report was s igned by the Chairman and the members of the

Committee. After Evaluation, the Purchase Committee rejected/accepted the ids wih

details g iven below:

Lot No. 1

S# Item Name QTY Bidder's Detail

Reason of Rejection (LOT#1) Name Brand Status

1

High Pressure Liquid

Chromatography HPLC

1

SU Enterprises (2)

LC6000 SeriesScion

Instruement- Germany

Rejected Technically not approved Bidder nothing is mentioned in his offer what he is providing to end user. As per tender doc.

H.A. Shah & Sons (8)

G7111AAgilent

Technologies-USA

Rejected

Technically not approved Quoted model by Agilent has the delay volume of 800 – 1100 μL, dependent on back pressure; measured with water at 1 mL/min (water/caffeine tracer) which does not fulfil minimum requirement as rendered. Bidder didn’t quote Thermostatic column compartment with both heating & Cooling option.

Kamstec International(4)

E2695 XC Alliance

Waters- USA Accepted

2 Mass

Spectrometer (GC-MS)

1

Kamstec International(4)

Hybrid Xevo MMS(1766001481 Waters-

USA

Accepted

H.A. Shah & Sons (8)

G7082BW Agilent

Technologies-USA

Rejected

Quoted Agilent single Quad GCMS (which is not hybrid system) Instead of Hybrid system or GCMSMS & LCMSMS. Quoted system is not according to tender specifications. Not compatible with HPLC.

3

Scanning Electron

Microscope (SEM)

1

Professional System Pvt Ltd(1)

CUBE-2 Emcrafts

Co.Ltd Accepted

Innovative Power Engineering (10)

CX-200P Coxem Korea

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 13.5 of Tender Document)

4 X-Ray Diffracto

meter (XRD) 1

SU Enterprises(2)

TD-3500 Dangdong

Tondda Science and Technology

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 13.5 of Tender Document)

Sentron Asia International (6)

CDX-6 Theta X-Ray

Spectrolab-UK

Rejected

Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document as the bidder managed to get 42 marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification were 45.

Page 3 of 14

5

AC/DC Hall Effect

Measurement System / Hall Effect DX-100

1

Innovative Scientific Solution (7)

DX-100 XiamenDexin

g Magent Tech-China

Rejected

Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document as the bidder managed to get 43 marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification were 45.

Sentron Asia International (6)

DX-100 XiamenDexin

g Magent Tech-China

Rejected

Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document as the bidder managed to get 42 marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification was 45.

Innovative Power Engineering (10)

DX-100 XiamenDexin

g Magent Tech-China

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 13.5 of Tender Document)

6 Atomic Force Microscope

1

Professional System Pvt Ltd (1)

XE7 Park Systems

Accepted

Kamstec International(4)

C 3000 Nanosurf AG-Switzerland

Accepted

7 Atomic

Absorption 1

SU Enterprises (2)

500FG-PC PG Instruement-

UK Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 13.5 of Tender Document)

Analytical Measuring System

Pvt Ltd (5)

PinAAcle 900H System

N3200071 PerkinElmer-

Singapore

Accepted

Rays Technologies (19)

NovAA 800D AnalytikJena

Germany Rejected

Rays Technologies Offered Analytik Jena AA 800 D and Alternate Offer Contraa 800D. (Bidder

could quote only one Mode/Brand/Make of one item under clause NO. 2.2 of the Tender

Document)

Kamstec International(4)

Savanta AA CBC Scientific

- Australia Accepted

Sentron Asia International (6)

S44990 Spectrolab-

UK Rejected

Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document as the bidder managed to get 42 marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification was 45.

8 DNA Sequencer 1

H.A. Shah & Sons (8)

A35644 Agilent

Technologies-USA

Accepted

Analytical Measuring System

Pvt Ltd (5)

GenomeLab GeXP from

ABSciex Accepted

Page 4 of 14

Lot No. 2 S# Item Name Qty

Bidder's Detail Reason of Rejection (LOT#2)

Name Brand Status

1 Eppendorf Centrifuge

1

SU Enterprises(2) Universal 320

R Hettich-Germany

Rejected Technically not approved (Details in the Document attached)

M Ayub Brothers (9) GT4R

Benchtop Thermofisher

Rejected Technically not approved (Details in the Document attached)

Key Scientific Corporation (18)

Z326K Hermle Germany

Rejected Technically not approved (Details in the Document attached)

H.A. Shah & Sons (8)

5428000619, 5430R

Eppendorf Germany, AG

Accepted

CNA International (11)

5430 Eppendorf / Thomas USA

Rejected Technically not approved (Details in the Document attached)

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

SH-FU-4MS SH Scientific

USA Rejected

Technically not approved (Details in the Document attached)

2 Elemental Analyzer

1

Maxtech Corporation (17)

UNICUBEGermany

Accepted

Rays Technologies (19)

Multi EA 5100 AnalyticalJena, Germany

Accepted

3 Freezer (-80C) 1

SU Enterprises(2) ULUF P610GG

Arctiko-Denmark

Accepted

H.A. Shah & Sons (8)

U9430-0001 innova U535 Eppendorf Brunswick

Germany AG

Accepted

Pakistan Hospital (15)

FDE40086FV Thermo Scientific

Forma FDE Series USA

Accepted

M Ayub Brothers (9) Thermofisher Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment, (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 14.5 of Tender Document)

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

LUF-D24 Labtron-UK

Accepted

Sentron Asia International (6)

BDF-86V588 Biobase-

China Rejected

The quoted brand is not Equivalent to required brands of EU/USA or Japan Origin

CNA International (11)

DF-600 Ildam -Turkey

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment, (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 14.5 of Tender Document)

Key Scientific Corporation (18)

MDF-U55V Panasonic

/PHCbi Japan Accepted

AGBL Pakistan (3) DF-590 Nuve-

Turkey Rejected

Did not qualify for the Lot, The bidder managed to get only 21 marks against the minimum requirement of 35 marks for qualification.

Page 5 of 14

4 Filtration Unit with Suction

1

M Ayub Brothers (9) 10287097

Thermofisher Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment, (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 14.5 of Tender Document)

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

Pobel-Spaing Accepted

5 FTIR

Spectrometer 1

SU Enterprises(2) FTIR-7800 PG Instruement-

UK Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment, (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 14.5 of Tender Document)Only One Supply Order was attached)

Sentron Asia International (6)

S70-530 Spectrolab-

UK Accepted

CNA International (11)

7800 Lambda-Australia

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment, (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 14.5 of Tender Document)

Kamstec International(4)

Alpha-P Bruker-

Germany Accepted

H.A. Shah & Sons (8)

Cary 630, KBR Opyion Agilent

Technologies USA

Rejected

As per tender documents Spectral measurements range is 7800 cm-1 to 350 cm-1 But bidder offered KBr 6300–350 cm-1. Which is below than required: N ratios of up to 20,000:1 . Bidder quoted 9,600:1 with KBR.

6 IR Gas Analyzer 1

SU Enterprises(2) TOQK-1000 TOP Cloud Agri China

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment, (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 14.5 of Tender Document)Authorization Certificate was not attached

Rays Technologies (19)

ADC Bioscientific

England Accepted

Sentron Asia International (6)

Gasboard -3100P Hubei Cubic-Ruiyi

Instrument -China

Rejected The quoted brand is not Equivalent to required brands of EU/USA or Japan Origin

7 Box Muffle

Furnace (Up to 1800 C)

1

SU Enterprises(2) XG3-18

Hobersal-Spain

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment, (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 14.5 of Tender Document)

M Ayub Brothers (9) 15501092

Thermofisher Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment, (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 14.5 of Tender Document)

Rays Technologies (19)

XSB-6-6-9-1 MM-F01-H Thermcraft

USA

Accepted

Sentron Asia International (6)

LX800MF Labdex-UK

Accepted

CNA International (11)

BF51314C Lindbrg

Thomas- USA Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment, (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 14.5 of Tender Document)( Only One Supply Order was attached)

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

SH-FU-4MS SH Scientific

USA Accepted

Page 6 of 14

8

UV/Visible Double Beam

Spectrophotometer

1

SU Enterprises(2) T80+ PG

Instruement-UK

Rejected Wavelength Range is not according to tender doc.

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

DB-20S Dynamica,

England Rejected Wavelength Range is not according to tender doc.

M Ayub Brothers (9) 15840002

Thermofisher Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment, (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 14.5 of Tender Document)The quoted model did not meet the given Specification

9 Germanium

detector 1 No Bidder Quoted the Item

10

Portable ChlorophyII Flourometer Along with accessories

1

SU Enterprises(2) TYS-BTOP Cloud Agri

China Rejected

Did not Provide the Authorization Certificate and the quoted model

Rays Technologies (19)

OS-30p+ ADC Bioscientific

England Accepted

11

Incubator with 5% CO2 and

humidity (Large size)

1

SU Enterprises(2) H3550-45-E Benchmark

USA Rejected Capacity Did not Meet as per BOQs

H.A. Shah & Sons (8)

Galaxy 48 R Eppendorf

New Brunswick

Germany, AG

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment, (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 14.5 of Tender Document)

Science Imporium(13)

ICO50 MED Memmert-Germany

Rejected

Did not qualify for the Lot, All Supply Order attached were with rates erased and no list of Technical Personnel with Qualification was attached. Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document, as the bidder managed to get 10 marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification were 35.

AGBL Pakistan(3) EC 160 Nuve-

Turkey Rejected

Bid was rejected under Clause No. 19.2.5 of the Tender Document, as the bidder managed to get 21marks whereas the minimum Marks required for Qualification were 35.

Sentron Asia International (6)

LX100AJI Labdex-UK

Accepted

M Ayub Brothers (9) 15713395

Thermofisher Rejected Co 2 Concentration required 0-20% Not Oxygen

Rays Technologies (19)

ICO-50med Memmert Germany

Accepted

12 Stirred

fermenter 1

Pakistan Hospital (15)

Jupiter 10 (D/H 1:3.0) Solaris Italy

Rejected Support only microbial culture Single jacket (required is double jacket)

Rays Technologies (19)

Minifors 2, Infors

HTSwitzerland

Rejected The Bidder did not Provide Authorization Certificate( Mandatory Requirement in the Evaluation Criteria

Page 7 of 14

Lot No. 3 S# Item Name QTY

Bidder's Detail Status Reason of Rejection (LOT#3)

Name Brand

1

Digital melting

point apparatus

UK

2

SU Enterprises(2) M3000 Kruss -

Germany Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

M Ayub Brothers (9) 11446618

Thermofisher Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

DMP600, 710 A&E Lab UK

Accepted

Sentron Asia International (6)

DMP-600A&E Lab UK

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Scientific Traders (14)

India Rejected

The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (Eligibility Criteria) and Stability of Balance not good

2 Distillation

Plant Germany

1

SU Enterprises(2) WSB/4 Hamilon-

UK Accepted

M Ayub Brothers (9) 12068990

Thermofisher Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Rays Technologies (19)

IM-50 Germany Malaysia

Accepted

Sentron Asia International (6)

W4000 Astuart-UK

Accepted

Scientific Traders (14)

Favorite 4-L Malaysia

Rejected

The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (Eligibility Criteria) and Stability of Balance not good

New Chemical Centre (20)

Favorite 4-LMalaysia

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

Biobase -China Rejected The quoted model (China made) is not equivalent to given requirement in terms of quality

3 Electric Balance

Germany 2

SU Enterprises(2) PA4202 Ohaus-

USA Accepted

Innovative Scientific Solution (7)

JNB5003G Jonlab-China

Rejected Stability of Balance not good

CNA International (11)

PCE-CS 1000N/PCE Germany

Accepted

Scientific Traders (14)

Jt3003 China Rejected

The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (Eligibility Criteria) and Stability of Balance not good

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

JJ300AG&G Germany

Accepted

Sentron Asia International (6)

GA-220G2 Gram-Spain

Accepted

M Ayub Brothers (9) 15989345

Thermofisher Accepted

Science Emporium (13)

PLE 4200-2N Kern and Sohn

Germany Accepted

Page 8 of 14

New Chemical Centre (20)

AS220R2 Radwag

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

4

Fume Hoods PPR Surface

with LED display

2

CNA International (11)

Local Made Rejected Surface not mentioned and dimension do not match with the BOQs

Lab Chem Scientific (12)

Local Made Rejected Literature of fume hood and Two Stage Regulator UK not provided,

Marshal Trading Corporation (16)

Local Made PPR Surface

Rejected Literature of fume hood and Two Stage Regulator UK not provided,

New Chemical Centre (20)

Local Made Rejected Dimension do not match with the BOQs

Sentron Asia International (6)

Local Made Accepted

Scientific Traders (14)

2x2ft Large China

Rejected

The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (eligibility Criteria) and dimension do not match with the BOQs

Key Scientific Corporation (18)

Cupboard Hood-1200 China

Accepted

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

FH1200 Biobase, China

Accepted

5

Hot Plates with

Magnetic Stirrer

2

SU Enterprises(2) RTH-340 Robus

Tchnology Accepted

Sentron Asia International (6)

SH-4 A&E Lab UK

Accepted

M Ayub Brothers (9) 15303538Therm

ofisher Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Lab Chem Scientific (12)

China Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Rays Technologies (19)

AREC,X With PT1000

ProbeItaly Accepted

AGBL Pakistan (3) MSH-300

BioSan-Lathvia Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Innovative Scientific Solution (7)

HSC-19T Jonlab-China

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

CNA International (11)

SH4C ILDAM Rejected Required watts 1000 but bidder offered600 watt is not as per tender doc.

Scientific Traders (14)

Digital 85-2 China

Rejected

The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (eligibility Criteria) China hot plate is not stable.

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

MSH-20A Witeg, Germany

Accepted

Page 9 of 14

6 Soxhlet

Apparatus 1

M Ayub Brothers (9) K292010-

0000Thermofisher

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Scientific Traders (14)

China Rejected The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (eligibility Criteria

Lab Chem Scientific (12)

Pyrex Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

EAM9202-3 Korea

Accepted

7 Spin Coater 1

Sentron Asia International (6)

MTI Corporation Accepted

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

EZ4 China Rejected Required Diameter 5" Offered 4"

Scientific Traders (14)

EZ4 China Rejected

The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (eligibility Criteria) and Required Diameter 5" Offered 4"

8 Ultraheat Sonicator

1

SU Enterprises(2) J.P Selectra-

Spain Accepted

M Ayub Brothers (9) 10562372

Thermofisher Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Lab Chem Scientific (12)

China Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Sentron Asia International (6)

D6 GT Sonic Ultrsoons HD

Cat# 30008665 Accepted

CNA International China Rejected Chinese Sonicater is not acceptable. Not stable.

Scientific Traders (14)

FSF-020S China Rejected

The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (Eligibility Criteria) Chinese Sonicater is not acceptable. Not stable.

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

China Rejected Chinese Sonicater is not acceptable. Not stable.

9

Analytical Balance (0.0001-200)gm

Germany

1

SU Enterprises(2) RTH-340 Robus

Tchnology Accepted

Innovative Scientific Solution (7)

JAB2204N Jonlab-China

Rejected Not Stable

CNA International (11)

BSA2245 Sartorious

Accepted

Science Emporium (13)

ABS 220-4N Kern and Sohn

Germany Accepted

Rays Technologies (19)

ATY-224 Shimadzu, Japan

Accepted

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

JJ224BF G&G Germany

Accepted

Sentron Asia International (6)

GA-220G2 Gram-Spain

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

M Ayub Brothers (9) 15917500

Thermofisher Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Page 10 of 14

CNA International (11)

BSA2245 Startorius

Accepted

Scientific Traders (14)

FA 2004 China Rejected The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (Eligibility Criteria

New Chemical Centre (20)

AS220R2 Radwag

Rejected Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment

10

Fume Hoods PPR surface

with LED display

1

Sentron Asia International (6)

Local Made Accepted

Lab Chem Scientific (12)

Local Made Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Marshal Trading Corporation (16)

Local Made Rejected Literature of fume hood and Two Stage Regulator UK not provided,

New Chemical Centre (20)

Local Made Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

CNA International (11)

Oosh/Roshnico Rejected Surface not mentioned and dimension do not match with the BOQs

Scientific Traders (14)

2x2ft Medium Rejected

The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (Eligibility Criteria) Surface not mentioned and dimension do not match with the BOQs

Key Scientific Corporation (18)

Cupboard Hood-1200 China

Accepted

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

FH1200 Biobase, China

Accepted

11

Hot Plates with

Magnetic Stirrer

1

SU Enterprises(2) RTH-340 Robus

Tchnology Accepted

Sentron Asia International (6)

SH-4 A&E Lab UK

Rejected Watts are not as per BOQ

M Ayub Brothers (9) Thermofisher Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Lab Chem Scientific (12)

Scilogex USA Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Rays Technologies (19)

AREC,X With PT1000 Probe

Italy Accepted

AGBL Pakistan (3) MSH-300

BioSan-Lathvia Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Innovative Scientific Solution (7)

HSC-19T Jonlab-China

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

CNA International (11)

SH4C ILDAM Rejected Watts are not as per BOQ

Scientific Traders (14)

85-2China Rejected The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (eligibility Criteria)

Page 11 of 14

12 Kjeldahl

Apparatus 1

SU Enterprises(2) S2 Behr-Germany

Accepted

Scientific Traders (14)

India Rejected The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (eligibility Criteria)

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

YDS-10 China Accepted

Lab Chem Scientific (12)

China Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Rays Technologies (19)

UDK-129 Italy Accepted

Sentron Asia International (6)

A&E Lab UK Accepted

13 Liquid N2

cylinder UK 1

Sentron Asia International (6)

Tedpella -USA Accepted

Scientific Traders (14)

YDS-10 China Rejected

The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (Eligibility Criteria) Chinese Sonicater is not acceptable.. Chinese cylinder is not acceptable

M Ayub Brothers (9) 10318543

Thermofisher Accepted

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

YDS- Chaina Rejected Chinese Brand is not acceptable and not as per given requirement

14 pH meter

USA 1

SU Enterprises(2) Starter 3100-F

Ohaus-USA Accepted

CNA International (11)

ILD-TS-6 HANNA Accepted

Scientific Traders (14)

PHS-25C China Rejected

The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (Eligibility Criteria) Chinese Sonicater is not acceptable.

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

MW-150 Milwaukee,

Europe Accepted

M Ayub Brothers (9) 12870633

Thermofisher Accepted

Science Emporium (13)

PB10-C Sartorius Germany

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

New Chemical Centre (20)

PH700 Apera Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Page 12 of 14

15 Soxhlet

Apparatus 1

M Ayub Brothers (9) 12694823Therm

ofisher Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Scientific Traders (14)

China Rejected

The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (eligibility Criteria) Chinese Sonicater is not acceptable.

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

KM-ME2Lab Heat, Germany

Accepted

Lab Chem Scientific (12)

Pyrex Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

New Chemical Centre (20)

200RASX Quickfit

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

16 Vortex 1

SU Enterprises(2) MX-S DLAB-USA Accepted

M Ayub Brothers (9) 15786959

Thermofisher Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment

Scientific Traders (14)

XH-C China Rejected

The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician (eligibility Criteria) Chinese Sonicater is not acceptable.

New Chemical Centre (20)

2X41R, 13284769 Fisher

Brand Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

AGBL Pakistan (3) V-1 Plus BioSan-

Lathvia Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Lab Chem Scientific (12)

China Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Rays Technologies (19)

Wizard Italy Accepted

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

MX-S SCILOGEX-USA

Accepted

17 Water Bath Thermostat Digital USA

1

SU Enterprises(2) WB10

Polyscience-USA Accepted

Sentron Asia International (6)

WB1LH Accepted

Science Emporium (13)

WNB-Memmert Germany

Accepted

Rays Technologies (19)

Alpha Germany Accepted

AGBL Pakistan (3) NB-( Nuve-

Turkey Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria

CNA International (11)

ILD-TS-6 ILDAM Accepted

Scientific Traders (14)

HH-S6 China Rejected The bid was rejected under clause No. 19.2.2 of the Tender Document because the bidder Did not have any qualified Technician

New Chemical Centre (20)

11386661 Fisher Brand

Rejected

Did not Provide Two Supply Orders, received in past, of Quoted Equipment (failed to meet the Eligibility Criteria given at Clause No. 15.4 of Tender Document)

Page 13 of 14

The Financial Bids of Qualified Bidders were publicly opened as per provision of Rule 30(2) of PPRA Rules

2014. The required amount of Bid Security was checked and was found as per

requirements give in the Tender Document.

After evaluation of financial bids, the committee declared that the bids were in order. The

Committee decided not to include the rates of items, rejected on the basis of

nonconformance of specif icat ions, in the Comparative Statement.

The Purchase Committee also rejected the items which the bidders quoted in PKR on CIF basis and in

Foreign Currency on FOR (PKR) basis. The Comparative Statement was prepared, checked and signed by

the Purchase Committee. Purchase Committee proposed, under Rule (55) of PPRA Rules 2014, that the

contract may be awarded to the bidders on the basis of lowest Evaluated Rates (Item wise). The

Committee prioritized the items on the basis of their need and recommended to place the order of

following items:

LOT#1 (CIF)

S S# in PC-1

Item Name QTY Bidder's Detail

Currency Unit Rate

without Tax Total Amount without Tax Name Brand

2 26 Mass Spectrometer

(GC-MS) 1

Kamstec International(4)

Hybrid Xevo MMS(1766001481

Waters- USA USD $ 160,350.00 160,350.00

3 30 Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM)

1 Professional System

Pvt Ltd(1) CUBE-2 Emcrafts Co.Ltd USD $ 109,350.00 109,350.00

6 48 Atomic Force Microscope

1 Professional System

Pvt Ltd (1) XE7 Park Systems USD $ 48,000.00 48,000.00

7 56 Atomic Absorption 1 Analytical

Measuring System Pvt Ltd (5)

PinAAcle 900H System N3200071 PerkinElmer-

Singapore USD $ 57,427.00 57,427.00

LOT#2 (CIF)

S# S# in PC-1

Item Name QTY Bidder's Detail

Currency Unit Rate without

Tax

Total Amount without Tax Name Brand

1 3 Eppendorf Centrifuge

1 H.A. Shah & Sons

(8)

5428000619, 5430R Eppendorf Germany,

AG EURO 7,505.00

EURO 7,505*1.18 = USD $ 8,855.90

2 5 Elemental Analyzer 1 Maxtech

Corporation (17) UNICUBEGermany EURO 54,803.00

EURO 54,803*1.18 = USD $ 64,667.54

3 7 Freezer (-80C) 1 Pakistan

Hospital (15)

FDE40086FV Thermo Scientific Forma FDE

Series USA USD $ 10,900.00 10,900.00

5 17 FTIR Spectrometer 1 Kamstec

International(4) Alpha-P Bruker-

Germany EURO 26,522.00

EURO 26,522*1.18 = USD $ 31,295.96

6 24 IR Gas Analyzer 1 Rays

Technologies (19)

ADC Bioscientific England

GBP £ 28,995.00 GBP £ 28,995*1.38 =

USD $ 40,013.10

10 53

Portable ChlorophyII

Flourometer Along with accessories

1 Rays

Technologies (19)

OS-30p+ ADC Bioscientific England

GBP £ 4,000.00 GBP £ 4,000*1.38 =

USD $ 5,520.00

Page 14 of 14

11 70 Incubator with 5% CO2 and humidity

(Large size) 1

Sentron Asia International (6)

LX100AJI Labdex-UK USD $ 9,520.00 9,520.00

LOT#3 (FOR)

S# S# in PC-1

Item Name QTY Bidder's Detail Unit Rate

with GST Total Amount

with GST Name Brand

1 9 Digital melting point

apparatus UK 2

Shalimar Scientific Stores (21)

DMP600, 710 A&E Lab UK 125,000.00 250,000.00

2 11 Distillation Plant

Germany 1

Sentron Asia International (6)

W4000 Astuart-UK 190,000.00 190,000.00

3 13 Electric Balance Germany 2 Shalimar Scientific

Stores (21) JJ300AG&G Germany 36,500.00 73,000.00

4 18 Fume Hoods PPR Surface

with LED display 2

Sentron Asia International (6)

Local Made 295,000.00 590,000.00

5 21 Hot Plates with Magnetic

Stirrer 2 SU Enterprises(2) RTH-340 Robus Tchnology 48,000.00 96,000.00

6 32 Soxhlet Apparatus 1 Shalimar Scientific

Stores (21) EAM9202-3 Korea 195,000.00 195,000.00

7 33 Spin Coater 1 Sentron Asia

International (6) MTI Corporation 180,000.00 180,000.00

8 36 Ultraheat Sonicator 1 Sentron Asia

International (6) D6 GT Sonic Ultrsoons HD

Cat# 30008665 140,000.00 140,000.00

9 55 Analytical Balance (0.0001-200)gm

Germany 1

Science Emporium (13)

ABS 220-4N Kern and Sohn Germany

99,450.00 99,450.00

10 65 Fume Hoods PPR surface

with LED display 1

Sentron Asia International (6)

Local Made 295,000.00 295,000.00

11 68 Hot Plates with Magnetic

Stirrer 1 SU Enterprises(2) RTH-340 Robus Tchnology 48,000.00 48,000.00

12 71 Kjeldahl Apparatus 1 Shalimar Scientific

Stores (21) YDS-10 China 695,000.00 695,000.00

13 73 Liquid N2 cylinder UK 1 M Ayub Brothers (9) 10318543 Thermofisher 425,000.00 425,000.00

14 76 pH meter USA 1 Shalimar Scientific

Stores (21) MW-150 Milwaukee,

Europe 63,000.00 63,000.00

15 80 Soxhlet Apparatus 1 Shalimar Scientific

Stores (21) KM-ME2Lab Heat, Germany 139,000.00 139,000.00

17 85 Water Bath Thermostat

Digital USA 1

Sentron Asia International (6)

WB1LH 90,000.00 90,000.00

The report ends here.