Philippine ANALYST June 2016

71

INFRASTRUCTURE

INFRASTRUCTURE

P10-Bn Cargo Rail Line proposedThe cargo project is the first unsolicited proposal submitted for consideration to the newly installed Rodrigo Duterte Administration. Once approved, the railway line is expected to be completed within 2 years.

The Cargo Train Project proposed by MRail Inc. (MRail), a subsidiary of Manila Electric Co. (MERALCO), is seen as the solution to the long standing issue of congestion

in Metro Manila seaports and the roads leading to and from the ports which are now often clogged with cargo trucks. The proposal was first submitted to Aquino’s administration but its evaluation and approval was delayed partly due to the previous administration’s aversion to unsolicited project proposals and partly due to right of way (ROW) issues. In a bid to close more private-public-partnership (PPP) projects prior to stepping down, the Aquino administration finally gave approval on April 28, a few days away from the May 9 Presidential Election. With the election ban in place, the project was again given pause until a new government took office.

With the newly installed Duterte Administration, talks between Philippine National Railways (PNR) and MRail have resumed and its approval is being fast-tracked. “[We have support from] the new administration. We are just sorting out a few items which they want included in the project. We have indications that in the first 100 days[ all of these will be addressed] and then we can have a signing, “ shared MRail President and Chief Executive Officer Ferdinand Inacay in a media briefing.

The multi-billion peso project (see Project Details of MRail's Cargo Train Project) is a revival of ICTSI’s similar operations that carried freight to and from MICT to ICTSI-owned LGICT in Calamba, Laguna. This cargo line service ran

from December 1997 until it was suspended in 2003. At that time, ICTSI found that keeping the railway line operational was too expensive due to the deteriorating condition of the existing PNR tracks which prevented trains from running at a desired speed (it still took 4 hours for the cargo to travel end-to-end thus reducing its economic benefits) and the cleaning of garbage thrown by squatters living near the tracks at the passing cargo trains were costing the company P2 million per year.

But the growing issue of congestion in Manila ports which was further aggravated by an imposition of a truck ban on Manila

The cargo railway project is seen as a solution to the growing issue of port congestion in Manila.

Philippine ANALYST June 2016

72 INFRASTRUCTURE

INFRASTRUCTURE

City streets in 2014 had urged ICTSI to find a partner – MRail – and offer to the Philippine government the proposal to revive the cargo rail line in 2015. A study conducted by the government think-tank, Philippine Institute for Development Studies (PIDS), estimated that the Manila Port congestion was costing the country at least P44 billion annually. The 2015 PIDS study also identified the Manila Port to Laguna Corridor as the most viable option for the initial cargo railway line, with a recommendation to extend the line to Clark and Subic and build a seamless multi-modal transport in the Subic-Clark-Manila-Batangas

h The cargo train line is a 57-kilomer cargo rail system.

h A non-exclusive Track Usage Agreement (TUE) between the PNR and MRail was already signed in January 2015, which will ensure that there will be no interference in the PNR commuter service plying the Tutuban to Alabang route.

h MRail will build tracks inside the Manila International Container Terminal (MICT) inside the Manila port area to connect to the Tutuban Station in the existing PNR line.

h MRail will operate a freight train service on the existing PNR tracks that will run 24 hours daily, with a minimum of 8 round trips per day, with an average daily container transfer of 600 TEUs from the Laguna Gateway Inland Container Terminal (LGICT) to MICT, and vice versa.

h MRail plans to spend P900 million to acquire 3 cargo trains and P300 million to construct tracks to connect MICT to Tutuban Station of PNR. PNR meanwhile has set aside P300 million to build new tracks exclusive for the cargo train.

h The project will be undertaken in 3 phases: Phase 1, at a cost of P2.7 billion, will cover the cost of 8 locomotives, 120 flat wagons, and construction of depots and tracks inside the ports and will connect Manila Port to Calamba, Laguna; Phase 2 and Phase 3, will cost P7.3 billion and will connect the Manila Port to Clark and Subic.

h It will take 2 years to implement Phase 1 of the project. It will also take 24 months before the trains could be delivered. Hence, if the proponent starts in 1Q17, the freight rail service can be operational by 2018.

h Once the proposed cargo line is operational, it is expected to reduce the number of trucks on the road by at least 200 trucks per day.

h MRail, a subsidiary of Manila Electric Co. (MERALCO), has partnered with Enrique Razon, Jr.’s International Container Terminal Services, Inc. (ICTSI) for the cargo rail project.

Corridor connecting all 4 major seaports and trading routes. The implementation of a container rail service is among

the priority projects declared by new Transportation Secretary Arthur Tugade, which he said he will approve within his first 100 days in office. Specifically, Secretary Tugade wants a 500 kilometer railway that would link Subic and Clark Freeport Zones to Metro Manila’s seaports and airports. Over the longer term, Secretary Tugade shared that he wanted all cargo to move across the country via railway or roll-on/roll-off (RO-RO) shipping.

project details of mrail's cargo train project

Philippine ANALYST June 2016

73INFRASTRUCTURE

INFRASTRUCTURE

NLEX-SLEX Connector Road undergoes Swiss Challenge

After a delay of 6 years, the P23.2 billion North Luzon Expressway (NLEX) – South Luzon Expressway (SLEX) Connector Road project is now undergoing Swiss Challenge – the next step for any unsolicited proposal submitted by the private sector to the government, and the final step prior to project award.

Under the private-public-partnership (PPP) scheme in the Philippines, any unsolicited proposal to develop an infrastructure project will have to undergo “Swiss Challenge.” A Swiss Challenge is a globally accepted procurement procedure wherein an unsolicited bid for a project is open to other parties or competitors who will match or exceed the offer of the original proponent. After competitive bids are submitted, the original proponent is then given the opportunity to submit a counter-proposal matching or exceeding the competitors’ offer. As of writing, no comparative proposals were submitted to the Philippine government to counter the original proponent’s, Metro Pacific Tollways Development Corporation (MPTDC), offer. With no other takers for the NLEX-SLEX connector road project, the award and signing of the project contract is expected to happen in the 4Q16.

The multi-billion pesos project involves the construction, operation and maintenance of an 8-kilometer, 4-lane elevated expressway over the Philippine National Railway (PNR) Line between Circumferential Road 3 in Caloocan City and Metro Manila Skyway Stage 3 that will link NLEX and SLEX (see NLEX-SLEX Connector Road Project Map). The project will have at least 2 interchanges and 2 tolling plazas. MPTDC operates NLEX while San Miguel and Indonesian-based Citra Group operate SLEX. When MPTDC first submitted the project proposal in 2010, the initial cost of the entire project was at P18 billion. The years of delay and changes in the original project design had bloated the cost to P23.2 billion - of this amount P15.74 billion will be allocated for actual construction and P7.46 billion will allocated to right-of-way (ROW) acquisitions.

MPTDC and its parent company, Metro Pacific Investment Corp. (MPIC) has, for the past years, expressed its frustration over the delays faced by the NLEX-SLEX connector project. When MPTDC first submitted the proposal in 2010, under the then Macapagal-Arroyo administration, they were given positive feedback and were told of a quick approval from the National Economic Development Authority (NEDA), but changes in leadership halted discussions.

The succeeding administration under Nonoy Aquino was less accommodating to the MPIC group, and unsolicited proposals, in particular. The project went “under review” during the Aquinio

No one submitted a counter-proposal, as a default, MPTDC will be awarded the project.

nlex-slex connector road project map

Philippine ANALYST June 2016

74 INFRASTRUCTURE

INFRASTRUCTURE

administration and it took 2 years to complete mostly because the Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) and the Department of Transportation and Communications (DOTC), the 2 government agencies in-charge of implementing the project, were in disagreement about several of the project details and the appropriate project structure. When finally NEDA green-lighted the project in 2012, it was again halted because the government had to decide whether it will subject the project under Swiss Challenge. The project eventually found its way to the Department of Justice (DOJ) in 2015, which made a decision that the NLEX-SLEX Connector Road Project will have to go through Swiss Challenge as per the dictates of the private-public-partnership (PPP) law governing unsolicited projects. NEDA gave its approval for the amended Swiss Challenge terms of the project in December 2015. It took another 6 months for the government to prepare all the papers to get the Swiss Challenge for the NLEX-SLEX Connector Road Project underway.

With no other challenger to MPTDC’s current proposal, the DPWH is looking to start preparations on the resolution that would award the NLEX-SLEX Connector Road Project to MPTDC, after which a contract with the original proponent is expected

to be signed in November 2016. For their part, MPTDC shared that they will start drawing up the detailed engineering design already, a process that they expect to complete by the 1Q17. ROW acquisitions will also commence and is expected to be completed by 3Q17. Construction of the project will be finished by June 2020. The concession period granted to MPTDC will run for 35 years.

The project is expected to decongest traffic in Metro Manila by providing trucks with an alternative route and give better access to Manila ports as well as the Ninoy Aquino International Airport (NAIA) and Clark International Airport. It will reduce the travel time from SLEX to NLEX to just 15 to 20 minutes from the current 1.5 to 2 hours, and those coming from Clark via NLEX heading to Laguna will see their travel time cut to 1 hour and 40 minutes from the current 3 hours.

The project spent 2 years “under review,” and another 3 years waiting for the government to decide whether it has to go through Swiss Challenge.

Philippine ANALYST June 2016

75INFRASTRUCTURE

INFRASTRUCTURE

STATUS OF BIG TICKET INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS IN THE PIPELINEAS OF JUNE 2016

PROJECT TITLE IMPLEMENTING AGENCY

FUNDING SOURCE

CIVIL WORKS TIMEFRAME PROJECT COST STATUS / ISSUES

ROADS/BRIDGES

Camarines Sur Expressway DPWH PPP TBD P2.25 billion On-going revision of project plan

Laguna LakeshoreExpressway Dike DPWH PPP TBD P122.8 billion Failed Bidding

NLEx-SLEx ConnectorRoad DPWH PPP 2016-2022 P23.2 billion

Undergoing a Swiss Chalenge

DPWH finalizing agreements with TRB regarding interconnection for MMSS3 and NLEX.

Southeast Metro ManilaExpressway (C6) DPWH PPP 2016-2019 TBD

TRB issued Notice to Proceed of the Project on June 27 and received by CITI on June 28

Status of Final Engineering Design Drawings and Parcellary Plans:

• Section 1A: Approved by TRB; Section 1B: Submittal to TRB June 30 and under process for approval

• Section 2: For submittal to TRB for approval 1st week of July 2016

• Section 3, 4, 5 & 6: Review by the Independent Consultant is 90% complete

RAILWAYS

MRT-3 Rehabilitation DOTr PPP TBD TBD

Metro Pacific Investments Corp. Chairman Manuel Pangilinan said the company was open to reviving its proposal for the improvement of the MRT-3 with the new administration

LRT Line 6 DOTr PPP TBD P65.1 billion For Submission of PQ documents on 9 September 2016

AIRPORTS

Davao InternationalAirport Upgrade DOTr PPP TBD P40.6 billion

DOTr currently reviewing the project

Six firms identified as project prospects to pre- qualify and bid

Submission of qualification documents postponed to August 10-17 as requested by prospective bidders

UTILITIES

Davao Sasa PortModernization DOTr, PPA PPP TBD P18.99 billion DOTr currently reviewing the project

850-MW Sucat ThermalPower Plant DOE PPP TBD TBD

PSALM approved another auction

Privatization of the decommissioned Sucat plant is scheduled in September 2016

OTHER PROJECTS

Civil Registry System Information Technology Project Phase 2

PSA PPP TBD P1.6 billion Bidding process starts

Philippine ANALYST June 2016

76 INFRASTRUCTURE

INFRASTRUCTURE

STATUS OF ON-GOING BIG TICKET INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS AS OF JUNE 2016

PROJECT TITLE IMPLEMENTING AGENCY

FUNDING SOURCE

CIVIL WORKS TIMEFRAME PROJECT COST STATUS / ISSUES

ROADS/BRIDGES

Metro Manila SkywayStage 3 TRB PPP 2015-2018 P37.43 billion

Overall progress for all sections is calculated at12.157%

NLEx Harbor Link DPWH PPP

Segment 8.2:2017-2019

Segment 10:2014-2017

P 15.4 billion(Segments8.2 and 10)

Segment 8.2:Detailed Engineering Design (DED) was completed and submitted to TRB for approval

Segment 10:Project accomplishment rate is at 29%

SLEx Expressway TollRoad 4 TRB PPP 2016 - 2017

(1st section) P13.1 billion

DPWH Legal Service recommended TRB to immediate ly execute the Draft Memorandum of Agreement between DPWH and TRB for DPWH to provide personnel and funding assistance for the acquisition of the ROW of the toll road project

TPLEx DPWH PPP 2010-2017 P24.4 billion

Section 1:Substantially completed

Section 2: 95.78 % completed (lots), 19.48 % completed (improvements), 100 % completed (trees)

Section 3:Construction is ongoing; Urdaneta City to Binalonan substantially completed

AIRPORTS

Mactan-Cebu International Airport Passenger Terminal Building

DOTr PPP 2016-2018 P17.5 billion Project accomplishment rate is at 23.25%

RAILWAYS

LRT 1 CaviteExtension DOTr PPP 2016 - 2021 P64.9 billion

Ongoing soft renovation and upgrades of LRT Line 1’s existing system and other pre-construction activities

ACRONYMS

DOE Department of Energy

DOTr Department of Transportation

DPWH Department of Public Works and Highways

LRT Light Rail Transit

MMSS3 Metro Manila Skyway Stage 3

MRT Metro Rail Transit

MW Megawatt

NAIA Ninoy Aquino International Airport

ROW Right of Way

PPA Philippine Ports Authority

PQ Pre-qualification

PSALM Power Sector Assets and Liabilities Management Corp.

SLEX South Luzon Expressway

TBD To be determined

TRB Toll Regulatory Board