overview of mutual funds and financial sector development
TRANSCRIPT
1
Overview of Mutual Funds andFinancial Sector Development
Mike Lubrano, IFC
NBFI Video Conference28 February - 1 March 2001
Washington DC
2
Introduction and overview
• The role of investment funds• How they work; structures• The scale of the funds market• How they developed internationally
3
What is an investment fund?• Entity publicly offering shares or
units• Invests the money attracted mainly in
publicly offered securities• Manages money as a single pooled
portfolio• Investors have no control over
portfolio decisions
4
What Investment Funds are Not
• Risk taking intermediaries• Banks / Quasi-banks• Captive Finance Subsidiaries• Instant Liquidity Generators• Alter Egos
5
What funds do: intermediate
Savers: individuals, companies, governments
Intermediaries: banks; insurance, pension and investment funds
Brokers, dealers
Markets
Primary dealers, investment banks
Borrowers: governments, companies, individuals
moneybondssharesloans
6
What funds do for investors
• Diversify risk• Reduce costs• Offer professional management• Protect investors: highly transparent• Increase savings choice
– Can be base for personal pensions• More flexible than contractual savings• Lower cost than contractual savings
7
What funds do for economies
• Mobilize savings• Widen and deepen capital markets• Balance foreign capital flows• Provide longer term financing• Pressure for risk reduction, improved
performance• Create demand for
– innovation, new products (derivatives)– better infrastructure– better disclosure– corporate governance
8
How Funds Work
Investor Fund Issuers
Gains from sales of Assets
Distributions Dividends;Interest
MoneyMoney
FundShares
Securities
9
Key Players and Their Roles• Sponsor - creates fund• Portfolio manager – chooses assets• Administration – operates fund• Custody – safekeeps assets• Marketing – sells the fund to investors• Oversight – checks the fund operates
legally and in the interests of investors
10
One Common Approach
Fund
Management Company
Auditor
Regulator
Custodian
safekeeps assets
operates regulates
audits
regulates
11
Legal Structures of Funds
CustodianManagementCompany
UnitsContractual
TrusteeTrusteeUnitsTrust
CustodianDirectorsSharesCompany
Safekeepingof assets
Responsibleto Investors
IssueStructure
12
Types of FundsType Capital Issuance Trading
Open end Variable Continuous At NAV viamanagementcompany
Closed end Fixed One off At marketprice onexchange
Interval Variable One off /periodic
On exchange /periodicredemptions
Open end/Exchangetraded
Variable Continuous On exchange /alsoredeemable
13
Open versus closed
Issue A15.0%
Issue B15.0%
Issue C15.0%
Issue D10.0%
Issue E10.0%
Issue F10.0%
Issue G10.0%
Issue H10.0%
Cash5.0%
Issue A15.0%
Issue B15.0%
Issue C15.0%
Issue E10.0%
Issue F10.0%
Issue G10.0%
|ssue H10.0%
Issue I10.0%
Cash5.0%
14
Open end funds need liquidmarkets
• Constantly buy and sell assets to meetpurchases and sales of fund shares orunits
• Must be able to value assets correctly toset a correct price on shares or units
• Can present problem in emerging markets• Closed ended funds suit illiquid markets
better
15
Significance of open ended funds(Source: BIS 1998)
618415As % ofmarketcap
1634946As % ofGDP
UKFranceJapanUSAs atend1996
16
Size of open end fund markets:End 1998 (source: ICI, Cadogan)
7,3825,766US1,680297UK
13,442202Korea4,344359Japan
721.4Hungary6,335621France1053.4Chile
Number offunds
Value of funds- $ billion
Country
17
% ownership of mutual funds byincome groups in the US
(source: ICI)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
< $25,000$25,000 - 34,999$35,000 - $49,999$50,000 - $74,999$75,000 - $99,999>$100,000
18
How funds developedinternationally
Spontaneously• First fund enabled
the investor ofmodest means toaccess adiversifiedportfolio: 1868 inthe UK
Artificially• Created to serve
specific need – eg– Assist privatisation– Bypass poor
banking system– Kick start stock
markets– Retail government
bonds
19
FeaturesSpontaneous• More sustainable
since develop oncemarkets andexpertise exist
• Market unregulatedat start
Artificial• Less sustainable
unless consistenteffort made: often pre-date markets soexpertise lacking andoperation hindered
• Market often poorlyregulated at start
20
Outcomes – not dissimilarSpontaneous• Scandals occur so
regulation isintroduced
• New scandals occur• Regulation and
markets are improved• Examples: US
Investment CompaniesAct 1940, UK FinancialServices Act 1986
Artificial• Scandals occur eg
Czech PrivatisationFunds, Korea, Mexico
• Regulation andmarkets are improved
• Or market fails todevelop
21
Candidates for Regulation
• Funds (securities regulator)• Fund management company (securities
regulator)• Custodian or trustee (securities
regulator and banking regulator – oftenbanks)
• Fund salespeople (securities regulator)• Auditor (professional ethics – additional
standards may be needed)
22
Measures & ObjectivesRegulatory Measure Anti-
competitiveBehavior
MarketMisconduct
AsymmetricInformation
SystemicInstability
Competition RegulationAntitrust/competition policy ✓✓✓✓
Market Conduct RegulationDisclosure standards (assets;fees) ✓✓✓✓
Comparable presentation of results ✓✓✓✓
Marketing/advertising rules (KYC rules) ✓✓✓✓ ✓ ✓✓✓
Valuation (NAV at MTM) ✓✓✓✓ ??(Korea)Limits on permitted activities ✓✓✓✓
(conflict of interest; self-dealing)Limit basis for calculating fees ✓✓✓✓ ??(Korea)Prudential RegulationLicensing; fit and proper ✓✓✓✓ ✓ ✓✓✓ ??(Korea)Legal separation; segreg. of assets ✓✓✓✓ ✓ ✓✓✓ ??(Korea)[Minimum capital requirements] ✓✓✓✓ ✓ ✓✓✓ ??(Korea)Legal investment ✓✓✓✓ ??(Korea)Liquidity requirements ✓✓✓✓ ??(Korea)Leverage limitations ✓✓✓✓ ??(Korea)Diversification -concentration limits ✓✓✓✓ ??(Korea)Private oversight (custodians, audit) ✓✓✓✓ ??(Korea)Redundant RegulationsFee Caps ??[Minimum Capital Requirement] ??(Korea)
23
To make funds work, you need:• Sufficient demand (savings)• Adequate supply of quality assets• Appropriate legal framework• Competent regulatory body with
sufficient resources• Capacity to effectively enforce law• Distribution channels
24
.. And ..• Competent fund operators with
sufficient capital• Operational infrastructure
(exchanges, custody, brokerage,etc)
• Reliable money transmission• Appropriate accounting standards• Neutral or beneficial tax• Efficient disclosure mechanisms
25
If you don’t have some or all of these…• Does the political will exist to create
them?It should, because:• Funds mobilize savings, deepening
markets• Savings finance corporate and
government borrowing• Domestic savings reduce impact of
foreign flows• Use for private pension provisionNeed political stability: long haul
26
Where to start?
• Training all those relevant to tasks• Create strategy with tasks - clear
leadership and accountability• Create legal, regulatory framework, fiscal
and accounting framework• Create regulatory body• Brief potential fund managers, custodians,
etc. on opportunities