organizational framework for organ donation and tissue donation … · 2017. 8. 16. · organ...
TRANSCRIPT
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
JANUARy 2015
CONTRIBUTORS
Working groupLouis Beaulieu, Transplant Québec Gilles Beaupré, Héma-QuébecSuzanne Boivin, CSSS Richelieu-Yamaska Michel Carrier, Transplant QuébecLouis Couture, CHU de Québec (has since changed positions)Annick Lavoie, ACMDPQLucie Raymond, AQESSSHugues Villeneuve, Transplant Québec
With the collaboration of Denis Ouellet and Andréanne Trottierof the Direction de la biovigilance et de la biologie médicale, MSSS
Also consultedLyne Beauregard, CSSS Richelieu-Yamaska Mélissa Foucault, CSSS Richelieu-Yamaska Corinne Lajoie, CSSS Richelieu-Yamaska
PRODUCTION
Written by Louis Beaulieu, Executive Director, Transplant QuébecGilles Beaupré, Human Tissue Procurement Manager, Héma-Québec Annick Lavoie, Executive Director, ACMDPQLucie Raymond, Service Organization Advisor, AQESSS
With the collaboration of Sonia Amziane, Attorney, AQESSS, Brigitte Junius, Head of Communications and Public Relations, Transplant Québec, and Laurent-Paul Ménard, Director, Public Relations, Héma-Québec
French editing Rédaction Frédéric Desjardins inc.
Copy editing, graphic design and DTP Guénette + Delisle design et communication
English translation Anglocom
Revision James Cookson et Karin Montin, s.e.n.c.
DISTRIBUTION
Association québécoise d’établissements de santé et de services sociaux et autres 505 De Maisonneuve Boulevard West, Suite 400Montreal, Quebec H3A 3C2Telephone: 514-842-4861
© Association québécoise d’établissements de santé et de services sociauxLegal deposit – Q1 2015Bibliothèque et Archives nationales du Québec Library and Archives CanadaISBN 978-2-89636-206-6 (print) ISBN 978-2-89636-203-5 (PDF)
This document is available from the following websites: www.acmdp.qc.cawww.aqesss.qc.cawww.hema-quebec.qc.cawww.transplantquebec.ca
Excerpts may be reproduced for non-commercial use, provided that credit is given. Any partial reproduction must stay true to the original.
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
1
FOREWORD
After death, a single donor can
•Saveasmanyas8livesbydonatingorgans •Give20-oddpeopleabetterqualityoflifebydonatingtissues
Theorganandtissuedonationprocessesrequireabest-effortsapproach.Bysteppinguptheseeffortsandimprovingandstreamliningthewayservicesareorganized,wecansavemorelivesandhelpmorepeoplegetoffdialysisandrecovertheirfullpotential.Wecanalsoachievesignificantsavingsforthehealth-caresystemandsocietyasawholewitheverysuccessfulorgantransplantandtissuegraft.
LedbyAQESSSandTransplantQuébec,ourfourorganizationsjoinedforcestoproducetheStandardizedOrganDonationProcedureandStandardizedTissueDonationProcedurein2012,oneyearafternewpro- visions in theActRespectingHealthServicesandSocialServices (ARHSSS)came intoeffect.Withanamendmenttosection204.1,theActreaffirmedtheneedforeveryestablishmenttohavesuchproceduresinplace.
Over time, itbecameclear thatdevelopinganorganizational framework fororgandonationand tissue donationservicesforestablishmentsandcouncilsofphysicians,dentists,andpharmacistswasnotonlyagoodidea,butessential.TheMinistèredelaSantéetdesServicessociaux[ministryofhealthandsocialservices,MSSS]joinedourworkinggroup.
ThisframeworkisalsoaconcreteresponsetotheMSSS’s2004report,Les dons et greffes d’organes et de tissus au Québec – Plan d’action[organandtissuedonationsandtransplantsinQuebec:actionplan]. Itspurposeistoprovideacriticalvisionoforgandonationandtissuedonation,eachofwhichhasitsownspecialrequirements.Theframeworkindicateshowservicescanbemoreefficientlyorganizedbothincasesofdeceaseddonorsandpotentialdonorsfacingimminentdeath,assetoutintheARHSSS.
Theendgoaloftheseeffortsistoincreasethenumberoftransplantsandgraftsand,asaresult,savelives,reducewaitingtimes,andhelppatientsregaintheirhealth,whilealsogeneratingsavingsforthehealth-caresystem.
Association des conseils des médecins, dentistes et pharmaciens du Québec
Association québécoise d’établissements de santé et de services sociaux Héma-Québec
Transplant Québec
2
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
n summARy 5
n AuDIEncE 8
n OBJEcTIVEs 9
n VALuEs 10
n BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn 11
n ORGAn DOnATIOn 12
n CURRENTORGANDONATIONSITUATION(ASOFDECEMBER31,2013) 14– Dataonorgandonation 14– Characteristicsofpatientsonthewaitinglist 17– Characteristicsoftransplantrecipients 18– Economicissues 18
n TIssuE DOnATIOn 20
n CURRENTTISSUEDONATIONSITUATION(ASOFMARCH31,2014) 20– Eyetissues 21– Othertissues(heartvalves,skin,bone,andtendons) 22– Tissuetransplants 23
n LEGIsLATIVE FRAmEWORK 24
n GuIDInG PRIncIPLEs 27
n ORGAnIZATIOnAL ARRAnGEmEnTs 28
n mAnAGEmEnT cOmmITmEnT 28
n mAnAGEmEnT TEAm’s ROLEs AnD REsPOnsIBILITIEs 29
n TRAININGOFCLINICALTEAMS 29
n ORGANANDTISSUEDONATIONCOMMITTEE 30– Compositionandoperation 30
n FOLLOW-UPANDFEEDBACKMECHANISMS 31
n sPEcIAL POInTs TO TAKE InTO AccOunT 32
n ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs 33
n ROLEs AnD REsPOnsIBILITIEs OF VARIOus PLAyERs 33
n ORGAnIZATIOn OF sERVIcEs 35
n EMERGENCYSERVICES(ANDOTHERCAREUNITS) 35
n INTENSIVECARE(INCLUDINGTHEHEARTANDNEONATOLOGYUNITS) 35
n DIAGNOSTICSERVICES 36
n MEDICALSERVICES 36
n PHARMACYDEPARTMENT 36
n OPERATINGROOM 36
n INTERESTABLISHMENTTRANSFERS 37
n MEDICALRECORDS 37
n CLINICALETHICSCOMMITTEE 37
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
3
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
n TRAnsPLAnT QuÉBEc suPPORT TO EsTABLIsHmEnTs 38
n MISSION,VALUESANDSTRATEGICPRIORITIESOFTRANSPLANTQUÉBEC 38
n SUPPORTPROGRAMFORORGANDONATIONDEVELOPMENTINQUEBECHOSPITALS 38
n ORGANDONATIONCOORDINATIONPROGRAMINQUEBECHOSPITALS 39
n ORGANDONATIONLIAISONANDRESOURCENURSES 40
n MEDICALMANAGEMENT 40
n TRAINING 40
n DOCUMENTATIONAVAILABLETOHEALTHPROFESSIONALSANDESTABLISHMENTS 42– TransplantQuébecwebsite 42– StandardizedOrganDonationProcedure 43– Standardizedorgandonationprocedureflowchart 43– OrganDonorandTissueDonor(OTD)binder 44– Donationprocesschecklist 44– Guidelines,policies,protocols,proceduresandforms 44
n PERFORMANCEINDICATORS 45
n ADVISORYCOMMITTEES 48
n SUPPORTFORESTABLISHMENTORGANANDTISSUEDONATIONACCREDITATION
(DECEASEDDONORS) 48
n COMMUNICATIONS 49
n FINANCIALSUPPORTFORDONORIDENTIFICATIONANDORGANPROCUREMENT 49
n ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs 50
n ORGAnIZATIOn OF sERVIcEs 50
n RESPONSIBILITIESOFDEPARTMENTS 50
n CLINICALSERVICES 50
n MEDICALBIOLOGYSERVICES 54
n MORGUEANDPATHOLOGYLABS 54
n ADMISSIONSANDMEDICALRECORDS 54
n OPERATINGROOM 55
n HÉmA-QuÉBEc suPPORT FOR EsTABLIsHmEnTs 56
n MISSION,VALUESANDSTRATEGICPRIORITIESOFHÉMA-QUÉBEC 56
n HOSPITALDEVELOPMENTPROGRAM 57
n TISSUEDONATIONCOORDINATIONPROGRAMINQUEBECHOSPITALS 57
n AWARENESSPLAN 57– Classificationofestablishments 58
n SUPPORT 60
n TRAINING 60
n DOCUMENTATIONAVAILABLETOHEALTHPROFESSIONALSANDESTABLISHMENTS 60– Héma-Québecwebsite 60– StandardizedTissueDonationProcedure 60– Standardizedtissuedonationprocedureflowchart 60– Quickreferencecard 61– A Legacy of Life guide 61– Posters 61
n PERFORMANCEINDICATORS 62
n PREREQuIsITEs FOR succEss 63
n cOncLusIOn 64
previous view
4
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
n APPEnDIXEs 65
n APPEnDIX 1 65
n DISTINCTIONBETWEENNDDANDDCD 65
n APPEnDIX 2 66
n ORGANPROCUREMENTCENTRESANDORGANTRANSPLANTATIONCENTRES 66– Organprocurementcentres 66– Organtransplantationcentresandprograms 66– Establishmentsofferinglivingdonorprograms 66– Pediatricestablishmentsofferinglivingdonorprograms 66
n APPEnDIX 3 67
n ORGANDONATIONPROGRESSREPORT–ADDITIONALINFORMATION 67– Factsaboutorgandonors 67– PatientsonthewaitinglistandtransplantrecipientsinQuebec,byregion 67
n APPEnDIX 4 68
n TRANSPLANTQUÉBECSUPPORTFORESTABLISHMENTS–ADDITIONALINFORMATION 68– TransplantQuébecadvisorycommittees 68– Communicationsandpublicrelations 68
n FINANCIALSUPPORT–USEFULDEFINITIONS 68
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
5
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
summARy
Theorganizational framework fororgandonationandtissuedonationservices isa referencedocument intendedforallhealthandsocialservicesestablishments,ineveryregionofQuebec,operatingahospitalwithamissiontoofferdiagnosticservicesaswellasgeneralmedicalandspecializedcare. Itsaimisto facilitate their operations by providing a structured approach aimed at developingmore effective and betterperformingorgandonationandtissuedonationservicesinordertobettermeettheneedsofpatientswaitingforanorganortissuetransplant.
Theframeworkisintendedprimarilyforestablishmentdirectors,managers,andmembersoftheCouncilofPhysicians,Dentists,andPharmacists(CPDP).Itpresentsthewinningconditionsforestablishingtheproperprocessandimplementingthemeanstosupportclinicalteamsintheirorgandonationandtissuedonationactivities.Itisareferencedocumentintendedforallplayersandparticularlyforphysicians,nurses,andrespiratorytherapists.
Firstitisessentialtostatethatthereareparticularitiesspecifictoorgandonation,andthesameistruefortissuedonation.Consequently,adaptedandspecificorganizationalarrangementsmustsupporttheimple-mentationof theproperpractices. Indeed,only1.4%ofpatientswhodie inhospitalarepotentialorgandonors,whichwouldhaverepresentedamaximumof344donorsin2009,ifalltheconditionsweremetineveryinstance.Bycontrast,some50%ofpeoplewhodiearepotentialtissuedonors,whichwouldamount,intheory,tomorethan30,000donorsperyear.Thismajordiscrepancyintermsofvolumeaswellasotherparticularitieshighlightstheneedforseparateapproachestoorgandonationandtissuedonation,inspiteofthefactthatanumberofconsiderationsaresimilar.
The framework targetsseveralobjectives thatwillhelp to improveoutcomesandperformanceand lead tobetteridentificationandreferralsoforgandonorsandtissuedonors.Theconsolidationoftheestablish-mentcultureoforgandonationandtissuedonationalsoaimstoachieveamoreeffectiveorganizationofservicesincompliancewithlegalobligationsandresponsibilitiestothepopulationserved.Therolesandresponsibilities of eachplayer are thereforepresented, including thoseof the establishment, TransplantQuébecfororgandonation,andHéma-Québecfortissuedonation.
Inordertoguidetheplayerswhoworktogethertostructureservicesmoreeffectively,theframeworkalsopresentsthevaluesassociatedwiththeachievementoforganandtissuedonationandtransplantation.Thus,thesystem’sultimateobjectivesaretosavelives(e.g.,ofpatientswaitingforaheart,liverorlung),improvequalityoflife(e.g.,ofpatientswaitingforakidney,corneaorothertissue),supportgrievingfamilies,andpromotetheexpressionofsocialsolidarity.Playersareguidedbythecorevaluesoffreeandinformedconsent,freeanduniversalcare,equityandanonymity.
Agreatdealofbackgroundinformationispresentedonthecurrentsituationregardingorgandonationandtissuedonation,includinginformationondonation,patientsonthewaitinglist,transplantrecipients,andfinancialconsiderations.
Intheareaoforgandonation,whiletheyear2013demonstratedthatitispossible,throughacollective effort, tosurpassthefigureof20donorspermillion inhabitants (dpmi)and,consequently, toachievea significant increase in the number of transplant recipients, together with a corresponding decrease in thelengthofthewaitinglist,thesegainscannotbetakenforgranted.Infact,theresultshaveremainedstableoverthelast10years(andbelowtheresultsobservedin2013).Québeccanobviouslydobetter.
previous view
6
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
summARy
Thedataontissuedonation,meanwhile,indicatethatsignificantprogresshasbeenachieved,particularlyintermsofthenumberofcorneatransplants.Thishasasignificantimpact,inthatitreducesthenumberofpatientsonwaitinglists.Theneedforheart,skin,andbonetissue,aswellastendons,issogreat,however,thatconstantvigilanceisrequiredfromallstakeholders.
Theframeworkestablisheslinkstolegislation,regulations,andnormativeaspectsthatlendstructuretoorgandonationandtissuedonationprocedures,clearlysettingouttheobligationsofestablishmentsand,morespecifically,thoseofdirectorsofprofessionalservices(DPSs).
Inordertodirecttheactionsofestablishments,fiveguidingprinciplesaresetout.By emphasizing collabo- ration and coordination, these principles highlight the necessity of recognizing the shared responsi-bility and interdependence of establishments and organizations in order to ensure that organ dona-tions and tissue donations are carried out.Basedontherolesofeachestablishmentandthenatureoftheiractivities,theframeworkalsounderscorestheimportanceofensuringtheaccessibilityandavailabilityofservicesandresources,sharingknowledge,andsupportingresearch(withhelpfromTransplantQuébecandHéma-Québec),withtheobjectiveofimplementingbestpractices.
Attheheartofthisorganizationalframework,specificproceduresaresetoutfororgandonation(includingsupportfromTransplantQuébec)andtissuedonation(includingsupportfromHéma-Québec).Thisimpor-tantsection
• Explainsthecommitment,rolesandresponsibilitiesofthemanagementteam• Reiteratestherespectiveproceduresfororgandonationandtissuedonation• Emphasizesthecrucialnatureofformingclinicalteams• Specifiestherolesandresponsibilitiesoftheorganandtissuedonationcommittee,aswellasitscom- position
Inregardtoorgandonation,theimportanceofeachplayerinthesuccessofthedonationandtransplanta- tionchainisreiterated,specifying(dependingonwhethertheestablishmentisanidentification,procurementortransplantationcentre)theresourcesthattheestablishmentmustmobilizeandtheactionsitmustperformateachstageinthechain.Theframeworkthenexplainstherolesandcontributionsofeachdepartmentconcerned:emergencyservices,intensivecare(includingtheheartandneonatologyunits),diagnosticser-vices,medicalservices,pharmacy,andoperatingroom.Alsohighlightedisthenecessityofensuringtimelyandeffectiveinterestablishmenttransferseachtimetheyarerequired,andconsultationoftheclinicalethicscommitteewhereappropriate.ThesectionconcludeswithapresentationbyTransplantQuébecexplainingitsmission,roles,andprograms:trainingandsupportinthedevelopmentoforgandonation;coordinationofthedonationprocess;therespectiverolesoftheliaisonandresourcenursesandthemedicalmanage-mentteam;andsupportfortheaccreditationofestablishments.Inaddition,completedetailsareprovided onthedocumentationavailable tohealthprofessionalsandestablishments:TransplantQuébecwebsite;standardizedorgandonationprocedure;OrganandTissueDonorbinder;donationprocesschecklist;guides,policies,protocols,procedures,andforms.Informationonsupportforcommunicationsactivitiesinestab- lishmentsisalsoprovided,togetherwithdetailsonthefinancialsupportavailablefordonoridentificationandorganprocurement.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
7
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
summARy
Inregardtotissuedonation,theframeworkexplainsthenatureofthecollaborationrequestedfromclinicalservices,medicalbiologyservices(laboratories,pathology),admissions,medicalrecords,andoperatingroomsinestablishments,specifyingtheirrolesandexpectedcontributions,andlistingthestepstofollow,aswellasanswerstofrequentlyaskedquestions.ThesectionconcludeswithapresentationbyHéma-Québecexplainingitsmissionandcommitment,itsrolesandresponsibilitieswithrespecttotissuedonation,andtheimplementationofbestpractices.Thecoordinationprogramfortissuedonationinhospitalsispresented,togetherwiththeawarenessplanframingthepromotional,trainingandrecognitionactivities,basedontheclassificationofestablishments(targetedcentres,Category1,orCategory2centres)establishedinaccor-dancewiththevolumeofpotentialdonorsandthestrategiesdeployedinsupportofthisplan.Finally,docu- mentationissuggestedtohealthprofessionalsandestablishments(Héma-Québecwebsite,standardizedtissuedonationprocedure,quickreferencecard,guide,andposters).
Toroundouttheorganizationalframework,conditionsofsuccessareidentified:
• Thedevelopmentofatruecultureoforganandtissuedonationineachestablishment,reflectedinaformalcommitmentbytheboardofdirectorsandseniordirectorsoftheCPDP,andexpressedinstrongleader- shipbytheentiremanagementteam,medicalteamsandmanagers
• Propertrainingofphysiciansandclinicalstaffonhiring,andthedevelopmentandmaintenanceofcom- petencieswiththeobjectiveofconsolidatingbestpractices
• Therecognitionofinterdependenciesbetweenidentification,procurement,andtransplantationestablish-ments,andtheestablishmentofeffectivecoordinationmechanisms
• Theorganizationofcommunicationsactivitiesforallstaffattheestablishmentandthepublic• ActivecollaborationwithTransplantQuébecandHéma-Québec• Poolingofexpertiseandsupportforresearch
Thecommitmentofestablishments,directors,managers,physicians,clinicalteams,CPDPs,andorganandtissuedonationcommitteeswillmakeitpossibletoimproveorgandonationandtissuedonationoutcomes.Indoingso,eachwillplayadirectpart inensuringthatpatientsonthewaiting list receivemoretimelytransplants,whilegeneratingsavingsforthehealth-caresystem.
previous view
8
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
AuDIEncE
Thisorganizationalframeworkfororgandonationandtissuedonationservicesisprimarilyintendedfor directorsandmanagersofQuebecestablishmentswithgeneralorspecializedcaremissions.Itprovidesinformationtohelpthemcreateoptimumconditionsforimplementingprocessesandresourcestosupportclinicalteamsintheirorganandtissuedonationactivities.
Theframeworkwillalsobeofinteresttopotentialstakeholdersintheorganandtissuedonationprocesses,in- cludingphysicians,nursesandrespiratorytherapists,departmentheads,andmedicalprogramco-managers.Councilsofphysicians,dentists,andpharmacists(CPDPs)andestablishmentorganandtissuedonationcommitteesalsoplayakeyrole,asdootherhealth-careandsocialservicesprofessionals,suchasphar- macists,socialworkers,andnutritionists,aswellasspiritualcareadvisors.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
9
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
OBJEcTIVEs
Thisframeworkhasanumberofobjectives, includingbetter identificationandreferralofpotentialorgandonorstoTransplantQuébecandpotentialtissuedonorstoHéma-Québecinordertoincreasethenumberoforganandtissuetransplantscarriedout.Theseobjectivesareasfollows:
• Strengthentheorganandtissuedonationculturewithinestablishmentstoactivelycontributetothecol- lectiveefforttosavelivesandimprovethequalityoflifeofpeoplewaitingforanorganortissuetransplant, wherevertheymaybe• Supportestablishmentsinorganizingorganandtissuedonationservicesaccordingtotheirstatus(for organs,anidentification,procurementortransplantationcentre;fortissues,atargetcentre,Category1 centreorCategory2centre)• Allowfortheidentificationandreferralofpotentialorganandtissuedonorswithinestablishments• Helpdirectorsofprofessionalservices(DPSs)performtheirdutieswithrespecttoorganandtissue donation• Clarifyanddefinetherolesandresponsibilitiesofestablishments,ofTransplantQuébecfororgandonation andofHéma-Québecfortissuedonation• Bolsterprocurementanddonormanagementinestablishmentsthatcarryouttheseactivitiesfororgan donation
Organizationalproceduresandproposedmechanismstoaidinachievingtheseobjectivesmusttakeintoaccounttheuniquenatureoforgandonationandtissuedonationsothatservicesareoptimallydeliveredinbothcases.
previous view
10
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
VALuEs
Thereareanumberofvaluesunderpinningorganandtissuedonationandtransplantation.Thesevaluesguideestablishmentsinternally,intheirinteractionswithpatientsandfamilies,andintheiractivitiesinthebroadercommunityandsocietyasawhole.
Thevaluesoftheorganandtissuedonationandtransplantsystemareasfollows:
•Savelives•Improvequalityoflife•Supportfamiliesinmourning•Promotesocialsolidarity
Thesevaluesseektogivedueweighttoallimportantfactorsintheprocess.Thus
•Thepatient’sconsenttothedonationisvoluntary.•Familyandlovedonesagreefreely.•Theconsenttoorganortissuedonationrespectsthewishesmadeexplicitlyknownbythepatient(the donor).•Thedonationconsentisinkeepingwiththedonor’svalues,suchassharing,socialsolidarity,mutual assistanceandgenerosity.•Thedesireofdonors’familiestohonortheirlovedones’decisiontodonateorgansortissuesafterdeath isrespected.•Treatmentisatalltimesfair.•Thedonationisfree.•Thedonationisanonymous.
Withregardtoorgantransplantationandtissuegrafting,relatedconsiderationscontributeto
•Fairallocation•Anonymityand•Greatereffortstoincreaseorganandtissuedonation
Ineveryinstance,allpossiblemeasuresaretakentoprovideclearandinspirationalguidancetothestaffwhomakethedecisionsandperformthetasksinvolvedinthedonationandthegraftingortransplantationprocess.Nothingislefttochance,soastoearnthepublic’strust,andespeciallythetrustofdonors,griev- ingfamilies,andpatientswaitingforanorganortissuetransplantorgraft.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
11
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn
Formattersrelatedtoorgandonation:Transplant Québec
Formattersrelatedtotissuedonation:Héma-Québec
GraphicreproducedwiththegenerouspermissionoftheKidneyFoundationofCanada
Theneedsfororganandtissuedonationaregreatandestablishmentsmustactivelycontributetomeetingthem.Tobeabletooffertherightservices,wemustallbeonthesamepageintermsofwhatthoseneedsentail.Therearealsofundamentaldifferencesbetweenorgandonationandtissuedonation.Thisorganiza-tionalframeworktakesthosedifferencesintoaccount.
Afterdeath,patientscansavemanylivesbydonatingtheirhearts,lungs,livers(whichcanbedividedinhalfandtransplantedtotworecipients),pancreasesandbowelsandcanimproveotherpeople’squalityoflifeandlifeexpectancybydonatingtheirkidneys.Fromthetimetheyareremoved,organscanbepreservedforvaryingperiods(e.g.,fourhoursfortheheart,sixtoeighthoursforthelungs,andabout15hoursforthekidneys),dependingontheirresistancetocoldischemia.
Tissuepreservationtimesalsovary.Sometissues,suchaseyetissue,mustbetransplantedwithin14daysofprocurement.Othertissues,suchasskin,heartvalves,tendons,andbone,maybepreservedforuptofiveyearsusingcontrolledfreezingandcryopreservation.
previous view
12
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn – ORGAn DOnATIOn
8,116,133
7,304,520
3,652,260
31,755
445
165
Quebec’s population as of January 1, 2013. (Source: Bilan démographique du Québec, 2014 edition)
90% of adult Quebecers say they are in favour of organ and tissue donation.(Source: 2009 Impact Recherche survey)
Half of all Quebecers claim to have given their express consent to being organ donors. (Source: 2009 Impact Recherche survey)
Number of deaths in Quebec hospitals, all causes. (Source: CMQ, 2010)
1.4% of deaths in hospitals meet organ donation criteria.
Number of donors in 2013, for a rate of 20.2 donors per million inhabitants.
Source: Transplant Québec
In 2013,165 donors = 20.2 dpmi (donors per million inhabitants): Transplant Québec’s all-time high
1AccordingtoTransplantQuébecdata,therewere1,047patientsawaitingatransplantasofDecember31,2013,and1,250onthe samedatein2012.Overthepastdecade,thenumberofdeceaseddonorshasfluctuatedbetween119(2010)and165(2013). In2013therewere165deceaseddonors,comparedwith120in2012.
ORGAn DOnATIOn
Responding to the needs of patients awaiting organ transplants
Thenumberofpatientswaitingfororgantransplantshasincreasedsteadilyoverthepasttenyears,exceptfor2013when,forthefirsttimeineightyears,thewaitinglistactuallyshrankandthenumberofdonorsspiked.1Yetthenumberofdonorshasremainedstableoverthesameperiod,despitebesteffortsevery daybyphysicians,attendingteams,andTransplantQuébec.Progressisn’tjustpossible—it’snecessaryanditmustbesystem-wide. Thisdecade-oldimbalancehasseriousrepercussionsonthehealthofpatientsawaitingtransplants.Theiroverallconditiondeteriorates, theywithdrawsociallyand,all toooften, theydieaneedlesslyprematuredeath.Butestablishmentsdohavesolutionswithintheirreach.TheymustjoinforcestobetteraddresstheneedsofpeopleonwaitinglistsalloverQuebec.(SeeAppendix3,underPatientsonthewaitinglistandtransplantrecipientsinQuebec,byregion,p.67.) Theseeffortsmustfirstbedeployedlocally,bynetworkingwithotherestablishments,withthegoalofin-creasingthenumberoforgandonorsandtransplants.Theywillalsohaveapositiveimpactontheservicesthatmany patients need. For one,more andmore patientswill be able to stop dialysis treatment. Foranother,patientswaiting foranorganother thanakidneywillbe transplantedfaster,offeringtheaddedbenefitoffreeingupvaluablehumanandfinancialresourcesinclinicalintervention.
Organization of services
ORGAn
DOnATIOn: EVERyOnE’s
REsPOnsIBILITy.
BEcAusE
EVERy
cOnsEnT
cOunTs.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
13
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn – ORGAn DOnATIOn
Potentialorgandonorsprimarilycomefromcriticalcareunits.Identificationofapotentialdonorsetsthedonationprocessinmotion.Thenextstepisreferral.Theentireorgandonationprocessisusuallycompletedin24to48hours.
Foranorgandonationtocometopass,certainconditionsmustbemettomaintainthehemodynamicstabilityof thedonorsotheorganscanberemovedandtransportedto transplantationcentres.AnunidentifieddonorwhoisnotrecommendedtoTransplantQuébeccanhavedisastrousconsequencesfornumerousrecipients. It’samatterof lifeanddeath forpatientsawaiting the transplantofavital organinatransplantationcentre.Consideringthelimitednumberoforgandonorsoverall—justover300potentialdonorsperyearinQuebecifallconditionsaremetineveryinstance—itisparamountthatalldonorsbeidentifiedandreferred.
Transplantrecipientshaveagoodchanceofsurvivalor,forkidneytransplants,ofnothavingtoreturntodialysis.
• 70%to80%ofheart,liver,orlungtransplantpatientsliveforatleastanotherfiveyears.• 80%ofkidneytransplantpatientsstillhavetheirgraftafterfiveyears.
Living donation
Whilesomeoftheconsiderationsdealtwithherecouldalsohaveapositiveimpactonlivingorgandonation,thisorganizationalframeworkdoesnotaddressthatformofdonation.
Itisimportanttonote,however,thattheoutcomesforlivingdonationinQuebec,especiallyforkidneys(butalso,lessoften,liverlobes),arewellabovetheCanadianaverageandhavebeenforanumberofyears.In2013,therewere16.8livingdonorspermillioninhabitants(549kidneystransplanted)forCanada,butonly6.7dpmi(53kidneysandtwoliverlobestransplanted)forQuebec.
Workstillneedstobedoneonlivingdonationsinclosecooperationwithexistinglivingdonationprograms,andaguidebookshouldbedevelopedforhealth-careestablishments.
ORGAn DOnORs
ARE A RARE
BREED: FEWER
THAn 1.4% OF
PEOPLE WHO DIE
In A HOsPITAL
cAn DOnATE.
previous view
14
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn – ORGAn DOnATIOn
cuRREnT ORGAn DOnATIOn sITuATIOn (As OF DEcEmBER 31, 2013)
Data on organ donation
Forseveralyears,theCollègedesmédecinsduQuébec(CMQ)hasbeenconductingexternalindependentauditsontheoverallperformanceofthetransplantanddonationsystem,withdirectsupportfromindividualmedicalrecordsdepartments.
Themostrecentstudyavailable,Les donneurs potentiels d’organes dans les hôpitaux du Québec – Années 2000 à 2010[PotentialOrganDonorsinQuebec-BasedHospitalsfrom2000to2010],revealstwofindings:
• Thenumberofpotentialdonors isvastlydifferentfromthenumberofactualdonors.Accordingtothe CMQ’sestimate,therecouldhavebeen269to432donorsannuallybetween2000and2009(depending ontheyear)if all conditions had been met in every instance.• In2009therewere138deceaseddonors,whiletheCMQestimatedtherecouldhavebeenasmanyas 344:thisfigurerepresentsanadjustedsuccessrateof75%,includinganestimated432potentialeligible donorswith a neurological determinationof death (NDD) and20donors after cardiocirculatorydeath (DCD)forallofQuebec.2
number of deceased and potential donors in Quebec, 2000–2009
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
Deceased donorsPotential donors (if all conditions were met in every instance)
Data source: Organ Donors in Quebec-Based Hospitals in 2009, CMQ
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
348
135
324
136
269
125
315
142
292
136
356
136
401
139
410
140
430
151
432
138
2AccordingtotheCMQstudy,344donorswouldhavegeneratedarateof40.5dpmi,with1,290organspotentiallyprocured.The internationalbenchmarkis75%.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
15
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn – ORGAn DOnATIOn
Donor identification
AccordingtotheCMQstudy,theidentificationratesinQuebechavevariedbetween66%(2000)and88%(2003),whilethetargetis100%.
Identification rates of potential donors in Quebec, 2000–2009
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
66%72% 75%
88%84% 85%
79% 78% 79% 82%
Data source: Organ Donors in Quebec-Based Hospitals in 2009, CMQ
Donor referral
Thenumberofdeceasedorgandonors(withalowof119in2010andahighof165in2013)andpatientswhowereabletoreceiveatransplant(withalowof360in2010andahighof503in2013)hasremainedstablesince2004,whilethenumberofpatientswaitingforanorganwentupnearly60%,risingfrom872 in2004to1,250in2012anddroppingto1,047in2013.
From2004to2013,thenumberofreferralstoTransplantQuébecfromhealth-careestablishmentsneverexceeded541,fluctuatingbetween388(2010)and541(2013).The2009CMQstudysetsthetheoreticalpotentialatover800accordingtothedefinitionofapotentialdonor—apersonofanyagewithseverebraindamagewhoisintubatedandonmechanicalventilation.Thebenchmarktargetis100%.
number of patients on the waiting list, recommended potential donors, transplant recipients, and deceased organ donors in Quebec, 2004–2013
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
2007 2008 2009 2010
Transplant recipientsRecommended potential donorsPatients on the waiting list
Deceased organ donors
418430403
432469423
1,1061,159
1,202
140 151 138
360
1,241
119
2011
384
1,264
137
2012 2013
364
388 414466
1,250
120
503
541
1,047
165
2004
380
872
136
2005
362
1,009
136
2006
399
449 456 439
1,040
139
Source: Transplant Québec
previous view
16
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn – ORGAn DOnATIOn
Withrespecttothereasonsforreferralrefusalsin2013,overonethird(37%)wereduetofamilies’refusal togivetheirconsenttoorgandonation,whilemedicalreasons(medicalandsocialhistory,medicalcondi-tions,unconfirmedbraindeath,hemodynamicinstability,etc.)accountedfornearlytwothirds(63%).
In2013,thedonationratepermillioninhabitantsexceeded20forthefirsttimeever(20.2),whilethelow was14.9in2012.ThecountrieswiththehighestdonationratesincludeFrance(25),theUnitedStates(26)andSpain(35).
Rates of deceased donors per million inhabitants in Quebec, canada, spain, the u.s., and France, 2012 and 2013
0
10
20
30
40
5
15
25
35
2012 2013
Quebec Canada Spain U.S. France
15.4
20.2
35.2
26.224.5
15.514.9
34.7
25.724.3
Source: Transplant Québec
Family consent to donate
AccordingtothesameCMQstudy,thefamilyconsentratesforallofQuebecrangefrom56%(2007and2009)to76%(2002),whilethetargetis80%.
Therearethreemainreasonsfamiliesrefuseconsent:
• Thepotentialdonordidnotgiveclearwrittenconsentorthefamilyisunawareoftheirlovedone’swishes.• Theorgandonationapproachwasnotfollowedproperly.Atwo-prongedapproach(firstannouncingthe irreversibleprognosisandthenproposingtheoptionoforgandonation)ispreferableinthesesituations.• Delaysentailedbythedonation,whichcanbecometaxingforafamilyincrisis.
Donationafterdeathrequirescarefulattention,anapproachtailoredtopotentialdonorsandtheir familiesandasensitivitytosocialandculturalfactors.
Becausefamiliesfacedwithasuddentragedyareinshock,theymustbetoldofthediagnosistactfullyandwithcompassion.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
17
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn – ORGAn DOnATIOn
Number of organs per donor
Between2007and2013,theaveragenumberoforganstransplantedperdonorinQuebecrangedfrom3.4to3.8forNDDdonorsandfrom3.2to3.6foralldonors,thatis,thosegivenanNDDdiagnosisandthosewhodonatedafteraDCD.Thetargetsare3.75organsperdonor forNDDand2.75perdonor forDCD.Theseoutcomesdemonstratetheimportanceofperforminganadequateassessmentandoptimumdonormaintenance,twoprerequisitestomaximizingthenumberoforgansperdonor.(SeeAppendix1,DistinctionbetweenNDDandDCD,p.65.)
mean number of organs transplanted by donor in Quebec, 2007–2013
3.03.13.23.33.43.53.63.73.83.94.0
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
3.43.4 3.43.5
3.6 3.63.7 3.7
3.6 3.6*
3.8
3.53.4
3.2
Source: Transplant Québec
Mean number of organs per donor (NDD)Mean number of organs per donor (NDD and DCD) *Including 14 DCD for 31 organs transplanted
characteristics of patients on the waiting list
• Thelikelihoodsomeonewillneedanorgantransplantduringtheirlifetimegreatlyexceedstheiroddsof becominganorgandonorafterdeath.Dependingontheirage,men’soddsofneedingatransplantmay beasmuchassixtimeshigherthantheiroddsofbecominganorgandonor.Forwomen,theratioisfour toone.3
•Nearlythreequartersofthepatientsonthetransplantwaitinglistneedakidney.Thesepatientsareon dialysis.•In2013,38patientsdiedwhileonthewaitinglist.Ofthatnumber,anestimated20%diedforareason notdirectlyrelatedtotheirneedforatransplant.Therewere69suchdeathsin2012and59in2011.
number of patients on the waiting list by organ type, 2012 and 2013
ORGAn TyPE numBER OF PATIEnTs WAITInG
2012 2013
Heart 60 46
Lung 107 87
Liver 118 100
Pancreas 14 15
Kidney 923 782
Combinationoforgans4 28 17
Total 1,250 1,047
Source:TransplantQuébec
3S.D.Shemie,L.Hornby,J.Chandler,P.Nickerson&J.Burkell,Lifetimeprobabilitiesofneedinganorgantransplantversus donatinganorganafterdeath,American Journal of Transplantation,2011;11:2085–2092.4Combinationoforgansmeanskidney/pancreas,heart/lungandothercombinations.
previous view
18
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn – ORGAn DOnATIOn
characteristics of transplant recipients
•Theaveragetransplantrecipientin2013wasnearly50yearsold.• From2008to2013,thenumberoftransplantrecipientsrangedfrom360(2010)to503(2013).
number of transplant recipients by organ type, 2012 and 2013
ORGAn TyPE numBER OF TRAnsPLAnT REcIPIEnTs
2012 2013
Heart 39 46
Lung 33 52
Liver 89 125
Pancreas 3 2
Kidney 187 265
Combinationoforgans5 13 13
Total 364 503
Source:TransplantQuébec
Economic issues
AccordingtotheDecember2012studybytheInstitutnationald’excellenceensantéetenservicessociauxduQuébec(INESSS)entitledAnalyse d’impact budgétaire d’une augmentation de la transplantation rénale au Québec[budgetimpactanalysisofincreasingkidneytransplantationinQuebec],basedontheassump-tionsmade,an increase in the number of deceased and living donors could save the health-care system substantial amounts of money—as much as $20 million over 10 years.Accordingtoanotherstudy,publishedinNovember2012byProfessorYvesRabeau,6basedonthesameassumptions,over $50 million could be saved over a 10-year period (for 1,000 transplants in 10 years), given that nearly half of all kidney transplant recipients return to work.ThefiguresgoevenhigherwhenyouaddinalltransplantsinQuebec.
• Kidneytransplantsaddvalue,specificallyintermsoftheeconomy(dialysis),thepatient,thepatient’s family,andsocietyasawhole.
–Oneyearofdialysis foronepatientcostsbetween$60,000 (basecost)and$80,000, ifallpotential associatedcostsareincluded. –Onekidneytransplantcansave$40,000tonearly$55,000peryearperpatient(variesbysource).
5Combinationoforgansmeanskidney/pancreas,heart/lung,andothercombinations.6 The Economics of Kidney Failure,YvesRabeauPhD,forTheKidneyFoundationofCanada–QuebecBranch,November2012.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
19
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn – ORGAn DOnATIOn
“Becauseitimprovesthechancesofsurvivalandthequalityoflifeofthepersonwithkidneyfailure,kidneytransplantationisrecognizedworldwideasthemostcost-effectivetreatment.”7
—JuanRobertoIglesias,MD,MSc,PresidentandCEOoftheINESSS
“Theuseofgraftsislimitedbythenumberofavailableorgansandthelowernumberoflivingdonors,comparedwiththeexperienceobservedelsewhere;this gives rise to the need to further promote organ donation.”8
“Althoughthedifferentmeasuresdesignedtooptimizethemanagementofdeceased-donorkidneys,topromoteconsenttoorganremovalupondeathandtoincreasethenumberoflivingdonorsrequirefunds, this investmentwillbequicklyoffsetby thesavings resulting fromtheadditional transplantsperformedeachyear.”9
7 Analyse d’impact budgétaire d’une augmentation de la transplantation rénale au Québec [BudgetImpactAnalysisofIncreasing KidneyTransplantationinQuébec],Institutnationald’excellenceensantéetservicessociaux,December2012.8Ibid.,p.52.9Ibid.,p.52.
previous view
20
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn – TIssuE DOnATIOn
0
2,000
2004-20052003-2004
103
2005-2006
202
2006-2007
240
2007-2008
318
2008-2009
311
2009-2010
821
2010-2011
1,187
2011-2012
1,583
2012-2013
1,571
2013-2014
1,926 1,917
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
1,600
1,800
Source: Héma-Québec
TIssuE DOnATIOn
cuRREnT TIssuE DOnATIOn sITuATIOn(As OF mARcH 31, 2014)
High demand
Familieswhohaveconsentedtotissuedonationareunanimousinsayingthatthedonationgavemeaningtotheirlovedone’sdeathand,insomecases,evenhelpedtheminthegrievingprocess.A large percent- age of Quebec’s population claims to be in favour of donation and expects health-care professionals to bring the subject up when the time comes.Whenfamiliesareinshockfollowingthedeathofalovedone,theyareunlikelytotaketheinitiativethemselvestosuggestmakingadonation,soit isuptothe health-careprovidertoraisethematterifdonationispossible.
Patientsawaitingtissuegraftsarecountingondonorgenerosity.Itisthedutyofhealth-careprofessionals toidentifypotentialdonorsandmakereferralstoHéma-Québecsothatthisvaluabledonationcanbecar-riedoutaccordingtothecriteriasetoutintheStandardizedTissueDonationProcedure.
Althoughpotentialdonorreferralsareincreasingyearoveryear,thedemandfortissueissohighthatthesituationrequiresconstantvigilanceonthepartofallstakeholders.
number of potential donor referrals, 2003–2014
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
21
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn – TIssuE DOnATIOn
Eye tissues
Héma-Québec acts as the sole distributor of eye tissue acrossQuebec. In concrete terms, thismeans corneal surgeons identify the needand specify the typeof tissue required for the scheduled surgery. Héma-Québecisresponsibleformakingtherequestedproductavailablebythetimerequired.
number of donors (eye tissue), 2008–2014
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
2008-2009 2009-2010 2010-2011 2011-2012 2012-2013
Source: Héma-Québec
225
491
704 722 713
2013-2014
649
TheQuebecwaitinglistforcorneatransplantshasbeencutbymorethanhalfsince2011.Intwoyears,itdroppedfrom704to328.ThisprogresswasduetoanewprocurementprocessandcooperationwithoureyebankpartnersinMontrealandQuebecCity.
Patients awaiting cornea transplants, 2011–2013
numBER OF PATIEnTs On WAITInG LIsT sHORTEnInG OF WAITInG LIsTs (%) As OF As OF As OF As OF 4/30/2012 TO 2/8/2011 TO 2/8/2011 11/1/2011 4/30/2012 3/20/2013 3/20/2013 3/20/2013
Montreal* 506 380 360 207 ▼43% ▼ 59%
CUO-QC** 198 156 131 121 ▼ 8% ▼ 39%
Total 704 536 491 328 ▼ 33% ▼ 53%
*Montreal:QuebecEyeBankinMontreal**CUO-QC:Centreuniversitaired’ophtalmologieduCHUdeQuébec,HôpitalSaint-Sacrementsite
previous view
22
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn – TIssuE DOnATIOn
Other tissues (heart valves, skin, bone, and tendons)
AlthoughHéma-QuébecisQuebec’sonlydistributorofeyetissue,suchisnotthecaseforothertypesoftissue.Whetherforheartvalves,skin,tendons,orbonetissue,hospitalscanuseanysuppliertomeettheirneeds.Héma-Québec’smission,itshouldbenoted,istoefficientlymeettheneedsoftheQuebecpopula-tionforoptimal-qualityhumantissues.
number of donors (heart valves, skin, bone, and tendons), 2004–2014
Héma-Québecmakesanongoingeffort topromotethevariousproductsandservices itprovidesto theprovince’shospitalsand ispleased that therehasbeenasteady,marked increase indemand forgraftsalongwithahighrateofusersatisfaction.
Theuseofhumantissueforgraftinghasgrownsteadily inrecentyears.Theemergenceofnewsurgicaltechniques,anagingpopulation,andnewtherapeuticindicationsforcertaintypesoftissuegraftsarejustafewofthefactorsthathavecontributedtothisgrowth.
Distribution of tissues by Héma-Québec, 2007–2014
0
50
100
150
200
250
2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 2009-2010 2010-2011 2011-2012 2012-2013
69
98
124
164 162
202
162174 175
2013-2014
215
Source: Héma-Québec
0
4,500
4,000
3,500
3,000
2,500
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
2007-2008 2008-2009 2009-2010 2010-2011 2011-2012 2012-2013 2013-2014
Source: Héma-Québec
Linear (Series 1)Series 1
737
1,604 1,712
2,732 2,802
3,369
3,895
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
23
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
BAcKGROunD AnD cuRREnT sITuATIOn – TIssuE DOnATIOn
Tissue transplants
Inanallograft,orallogeneictransplant,apatientreceivesagraftoftissuefromanotherperson.
Inmostcases,thepurposeofthetissuetransplantistoimproverecipients’qualityoflife,althoughinthecaseofheartorskintissue,itmaywellhelpsavetheirlife.
Allograftsarelife-changingforthousandsofpatients.Someexamplesofallograftsareprovidedbelow, accordingtosurgicalspecialization.
Eye allograft.Eyetissueisremovedfromadeceaseddonor,evaluatedandpreservedforvaryingperiods(14daystooneyear).Eyetissuetransplantscanbeusedtotreatavarietyofpathologicalconditions,suchasthese:
• Keratoconusandbullouskeratopathy–Corneareplacement•Cornealperforation–Useofapartofthecorneaorawholecornea•Glaucoma(surgery)–Valveimplantthatmustbecoveredbyasclera•Pterygiumoraneyetumour(ablation)–Useoflamellae(frozentissue)torebuildtheeyesurface
cardiac allograft.Theaorticorpulmonicvalvesandtheirrespectivearteriesareremovedfromadeceaseddonor,processedandcryogenicallypreservedforuptofiveyears.Allograftsareimplantedtocorrectcertaincongenitalheartdefects:
•SomeformsoftetralogyofFallot•Completetranspositionofthegreatarteries(TGA)withventricularseptaldefect(VSD)andsubpulmonary stenosisorpulmonaryatresia(Rastelliprocedure)•Severepulmonaryvalvestenosis•Aorticvalvestenosis
skin allograft.Skinallograftsareremovedfromadeceaseddonor,processedandcryogenicallypreservedforuptofiveyears.
Skinallograftscanbeusedtotreat
•Severeburns–Thegraftservesasatemporarydressingtoreducefluid lossandasabarrieragainst infection•Otherconditions(e.g.,toxicepidermalnecrolysis)
Bone or tendon allograft.Boneandtendonallograftsareremovedfromadeceaseddonor,processedandcryogenicallypreservedforuptofiveyears.Theycanbeusedfor
•Hiprevisionsurgery•Kneerevisionsurgery•Replacementofamassivebonesegmentincertainosteosarcomacancercases•Replacementofatendonaftertrauma
previous view
24
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
LEGIsLATIVE FRAmEWORK
AnActtoFacilitateOrganandTissueDonation(SQ2010,c.38)enteredintoeffectonFebruary28,2011,amendingthefollowingthreeacts:
1.ActRespectingLabourStandards(CQLR,c.N-1.1)2.ActRespectingtheRégiedel’AssuranceMaladieduQuébec(CQLR,c.R-5)3.ActRespectingHealthServicesandSocialServices(CQLR,c.S-4.2)
ThisdocumentdoesnotaddresstheActRespectingLabourStandardsortheActRespectingtheRégiedel’AssuranceMaladieduQuébecbecausetheydonotapplytothedirectorsofprofessionalservices(DPSs)athealth-careestablishmentsandbecausethisframeworkonlycoversdonationondeath,whetherimmi-nentorrecent.
CertainprovisionsoftheCivilCodeofQuébec(CQLR,c.C-1991)applytoorganandtissuedonation.Thesewill bediscussedbelow.Thepotential donor’s consent canbe recordedwith theRégiede l’Assurance MaladieduQuébec(RAMQ),whichmustmaintainaregistry(since2011),orwithanotarywhomustinformtheChambredesNotairesduQuébec,whichhasalsomaintainedaconsentandrefusalregistrysince2005.Potentialdonorsmayalsoindicatetheirconsentonthebackoftheirhealthinsurancecardbysigninganddatingthestickerandaffixingitinthespaceprovided.
Nomatterwhatoptiontheychoose,potentialdonorsmayrevoketheirconsentwithouthavingtoprovideareason.Ifadonorhaschosenmorethanoneoption,theonemademostrecentlymustbeused.Intheeventpotentialdonors’wishesareunknownandtheyareunabletogivetheirconsent,alternativeconsentmay beobtainedfromapersonindicatedinarticle15oftheCivilCodeofQuébec,providedtheorderofprioritysetoutinthatarticleisfollowed.
Section204.1oftheARHSSSdefinesthedonoridentificationandreferralresponsibilitiesofDPSsofestab- lishmentsthatoperategeneralandspecializedhospitals(GSHs).Subjecttoconsentbythepotentialdonororsomeone representing thepotentialdonor, thesection imposes theobligation tosendany required medical informationaboutthepotentialdonorandtheorgansortissuesthatmayberemoved,asappli-cable,toTransplantQuébec(organs)orHéma-Québec(tissues).Moreover,theestablishmentmusthaveanorganortissuedonationprocedurefortheDPStofollow.EstablishmentsshouldrefertotheStandardizedOrganDonationProcedureandStandardTissueDonationProcedure thatweredevelopedbyorganandtissuedonationpartners.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
25
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
LEGIsLATIVE FRAmEWORK
n Act Respecting Health services and social services, cQLR, c. s-4.2
AsPEcTs OF THE LAW
Diligent identification and referral of potential donors in situations of imminent or recent death
Verification of consent for organ or tissue removal
communication of medical information
Family support
WORDInG
Wheninformedoftheimminentorrecentdeath ofapotentialorganortissuedonor,thedirector ofprofessionalservicesofaninstitutionoperating ageneralandspecializedhospitalshalldiligently:
verify,withoneoftheorganizationsthatcoordinateorganortissuedonationsandaredesignatedbytheMinisterundersection2.0.11oftheActrespectingtheRégiedel’assurancemaladieduQuébec(ChapterR-5),whetherthepotentialdonor’sconsentforthepost-mortemremovaloforgansortissuesisrecordedintheconsentregistriesestablishedbytheOrdreprofessionneldesnotairesduQuébecandtheRégiedel’assurancemaladieduQuébec,inordertodeterminethedonor’slastwishesexpressedinthisregardinaccordancewiththeCivilCode;and
sendtosuchanorganization,iftheconsenthasbeengiven,anynecessarymedicalinformationconcerningthepotentialdonorandtheorgans ortissuesthatmayberemoved.
sTAKEHOLDERs
GsH • DPS • Physicians •Health-careprofessionals
•Transplant Québec(organdonation)10
•Héma-Québec(tissuedonation) •RAmQ(registry) •chambre des notaires du Québec (registry)
GsH • DPS • Physicians •Health-careprofessionals •Medicalrecords •Transplant Québec(organdonation) •Héma-Québec(tissuedonation)
GsH • Careteam •Organdonationliaisonnurseor resourcenurse(whereapplicable) •clinical coordinator/advisor with Transplant Québec (organdonation) –tosupportteams •coordinator with Héma-Québec (tissuedonation)
sEcTIOn
204.1
(1)
(2)
10TransplantQuébecandHéma-QuébecaredesignatedbyOrderoftheMinisterofHealthandSocialServicesconcerningthelist oforganizationsensuringthecoordinationoforganortissuedonations,M.O.2011004: www.ramq.gouv.qc.ca/SiteCollectionDocuments/citoyens/en/autres/arrete-ministeriel-don-organes-en.pdf
previous view
26
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
LEGIsLATIVE FRAmEWORK
n civil code of Québec, cQLR, c. c-1991
AsPEcTs OF THE LAW
consent given by
– Adult – minor 14 or over– Holder of parental authority (minor under age 14)
consent given by a third party
Attestation of death and removal of donations or tissues
AsPEcTs OF THE LAW
cause of death
•not established by the physician
•As a result of negligence•In obscure or violent circumstances
WORDInG
Apersonoffullageoraminor14yearsofageorovermay,formedicalorscientificpurposes,givehisbodyorauthorizetheremovaloforgansortissuestherefrom.Aminorunder14yearsofagemayalsodosowiththeconsentofthepersonhavingparentalauthorityorofhistutor.Thesewishesareexpressedverballybeforetwowitnesses,orinwriting,andmayberevokedinthesamemanner.Thewishesexpressedshallbefollowed,unlessthereisacompellingreasonnottodoso.
Apartofthebodyofadeceasedpersonmayberemoved,ifthewishesofthedeceasedarenotknownorcannotbepresumed,withtheconsentofthepersonwhowasorwouldhavebeenqualifiedtogiveconsenttocare.Consentisnotrequiredwheretwophysiciansattestinwritingtotheimpossibilityofobtainingitinduetime,theurgencyoftheoperationandtheserioushopeofsavingahumanlifeorofimprovingitsqualitytoanappreciabledegree.
Nopartofthebodymayberemovedbeforethedeathofthedonorisattestedbytwophysicianswhodonotparticipateeitherintheremovalorinthetransplantation.
WORDInG
Everyphysicianwhocertifiesadeathforwhichheisunabletoestablishtheprobablecausesorwhichappearstohimtohaveoccurredasaresultofnegligenceorinobscureorviolentcircumstancesshallimmediatelynotifyacoronerorpeaceofficer.
sTAKEHOLDERs
•Adult•minor 14orover•Holder of parental authority (minorunderage14)•GsH•RAmQ(registry)•chambre des notaires du Québec (registry)
If the wishes of the deceased are not known,hisorherlegalrepresentativeasdefinedinart.15oftheCCQ
In the absence of a representative,aperson,byorderofpriority,identifiedinart.15oftheCCQ
In emergency situations,twophysi-cians
Twophysicianswhodonotparticipateintheremovalortransplantation
sTAKEHOLDERs
• Physician•Coroner• Peaceofficer•Transplant Québec(organdonation)•Héma-Québec(tissuedonation)
Underthissection,anestablishmentmaynotproceedwithremovinganorganortissuefromadeceasedpersonuntilthecoronerhasauthorizedit,subjecttoconsentobtainedaccordingtotheprovisionsoftheCivilCode(the deceased person having given consent while alive, or in the absence of such consent, a legal representative, and if no legal representative has been appointed, a person, by order of prior- ity, identified in article 15 of the civil code).
sEcTIOn
43
44
45
sEcTIOn
34
n Act Respecting the Determination of the causes and circumstances of Death, cQLR, c. R-0.2
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
27
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
GuIDInG PRIncIPLEs
Anumberofprinciplesstemmingdirectlyfromthevaluessetoutabovemayproveuseful inguidingtheactionsofhealth-careestablishmentsandproviders:
•Consultandcooperatewithotherstakeholderstopromoteanincreaseinorganandtissuedonations tomeetdemand.
•Acknowledgethesharedresponsibilityandinterdependencebetweendifferentorganizationsinvolvedinvariousorganandtissuedonationprocessesandensurecoordinationandcommunicationbetweenpart-ners.
•Makesureservicesandresourcesareaccessibleandavailablewhenneededintheorganandtissuedonationprocesses.
•Recognizetheroleofeachestablishmentaccordingtothenatureofitsactivities,inlinewiththepopu- lationitserves.11
•Fosterknowledgesharingbetweendonationorganizationsandestablishmentsandsupportresearch inthefieldwiththesupportofTransplantQuébecorHéma-Québecforthepurposeofdevelopingand implementingbestpractices.
11Organdonationactivitiesarediscussedbelowseparatelyforidentification,procurementandtransplantationcentres.Fortissue donation,eachestablishmentmaybeconsideredapotentialprocurementcentre.
previous view
28
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOnAL ARRAnGEmEnTs
Establishmentsmustsupportclinical teams inofferingrequiredorganandtissuedonationservices. It isimportantthatmanagementadoptanorganizationalvisionandculturepromotingorganandtissuedonationtoguidedecisionmakingonhowservicesaretobeorganizedwithintheestablishment.Acommitmenttoorganandtissuedonationfromalllevelsofmanagementtogetherwiththeactiveinvolvementofphysiciansandotherhealth-careprofessionalswillhelpfostersuchanorganizationalculture.
EstablishmentsmustalsomeetAccreditationCanadastandardsforsafe,high-qualitycareandservices.MonitoringandevaluatingoutcomesoftheorganandtissuedonationprocesseswillallowthenecessaryadjustmentstoreachQuebec’sorganandtissuedonationtargets.Tothatend,itishighlydesirablethatoutcomesshouldbemonitoredbyclinicalteamsdirectly,alongwithmanagementteamsandboardsof directors.
Theorganizationalpoliciestobefollowedwithinestablishmentstosupporttheorganandtissuedonationprocessesaresetoutbelow.Somearesimilarwhileotherspresentseveraldifferences.
mAnAGEmEnT cOmmITmEnT
•Adoptacommonandsharedvisionwithintheestablishmentsothatclinicalteamsbegintakingorgan andtissuedonationconcernsintoaccountasamatterofcourse.
•Developanorganizationalculturethatpromotesorganandtissuedonation.•AlignactionswithSafetyofHumanCells,TissuesandOrgans forTransplantationRegulationsand AccreditationCanadastandardsfordonationortransplantation,asapplicable.
•Incorporate theorganand tissuedonationvisionandculture intodecisionsabout theorganizationofservices.
•Ensureengagementfromclinical,medicalandadministrativeteamsinorganandtissuedonation.•Monitororganandtissuedonationoutcomesusingacontinuousimprovementapproachtoqualityandclinicalandorganizationalperformancemeasurement.
•Buildpartnershipswithorganandtissuedonationorganizationsandwithotherestablishmentswhen required.
•Craftanorganandtissuedonationcommunicationplanthatincorporatesthefollowing:
– AnawarenesscampaigntargetingemployeesandphysiciansincooperationwithTransplantQuébec andHéma-Québectoencourageregistrationwithconsentregistries –Increasedawarenessamongclinicalstaff –Providinginformationabouttheorganandtissuedonationtoolsthatareavailable –Localandregionalawarenessandeducationinitiativesondonation,transplantationandgrafting
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
29
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOnAL ARRAnGEmEnTs
mAnAGEmEnT TEAm’s ROLEs AnD REsPOnsIBILITIEs
Themanagement teamassumessharedresponsibility for theestablishment’sorganandtissuedonationactivitiesandforfactoringthemintohowservicesareorganized.
TheARHSSSassignsspecificresponsibilitiestotheDPS,whomustbesupportedbythemanagementteam.
TheDPS’sspecificresponsibilitiesincludethefollowing:
•Ensuringtheapplicationofsection204.1oftheARHSSSaccordingtotheorgandonationprocedureandtissuedonationprocedure(SeeLegislativeframework,p.24.)
•Ensuringtheproperfunctioningoftheorganandtissuedonationcommitteeincooperationwiththees-tablishment’sotherdivisions
•WorkinconjunctionwiththeCPDPinitsroleinassessingthequalityofprocedures
Establishmentsmustimplementmechanismsandallocatethenecessaryresourcestosupportorganandtissuedonationactivitiesatalllevels.Identifyingoneormoreproponentswithintheestablishmentwillmakeiteasiertomonitortheseactivities.Thesearesomeofthekeymeasurestobeimplementedfirst:
•Applicationoftheorgandonationprocedureandtissuedonationprocedure•Trainingofclinicalandmedicalteams,especiallythoseworkingwithincriticalcareunits•Formationofanorganandtissuedonationcommittee•Useofmonitoringandfeedbackmechanismswithaneyetowardcontinuousimprovement,withthehelpoftherecordsdepartment
OrganandtissuedonationpoliciesandproceduresaredesignedtosupporttheDPSandclinicalteamsintheireffortstoidentifyasmanypotentialdonorsaspossible,aswellasinthefollowingsteps:referraltotheappropriatedesignatedorganization,communicationofthediagnosisandprognosistothefamily,proposalofthedonationoption,assessmentandeligibilityofthedonorandremovaloftheorgansortissues.
Themanagement teammustdisseminate theseprocedures andensure they are followedbyall clinicalteamsconcerned.
TRAInInG OF cLInIcAL TEAms
The training of clinical teams is key to achieving desired organ and tissue donation outcomes.Themanagementteammustthereforeplanappropriatetrainingactivitiestosupporttheminthisregard. It is alsoimportanttoensurenewemployeesaretrainedwhentheyarehired.Thisappliestoallcriticalcarestaff(e.g.,nurses,respiratorytherapists,physicians,socialworkersandspiritualcareadvisors).
Continuoustrainingactivitiesmustbeplannedtoensurethatorganandtissuedonationknowledgeby clinicalteamsisuptodate.
TransplantQuébecandHéma-Québeccancontributeactively to these trainingactivities inavarietyofways.Establishmentscancontacttheseorganizationsforsupportandassistance.
previous view
30
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOnAL ARRAnGEmEnTs
ORGAn AnD TIssuE DOnATIOn cOmmITTEE
Organand tissuedonationcommitteesplayakey role inensuring theadvancementofdonationwithin establishments.
ThespecificresponsibilitiesofDPSsaresetoutintheARHSSS.DPSscannotbeexpectedtoknowfromdaytodayoratanygiventimehowthingsstandintermsofidentifyingpotentialorganandtissuedonors,referralstoTransplantQuébecorHéma-Québec,donormaintenanceandorganandtissueprocurement.ThispointstotheneedforaninterdisciplinaryorganandtissuedonationcommitteetosupporttheDPS andmanagementteaminperformingtheirduties.
EveryestablishmentshouldthereforehaveanorganandtissuedonationcommitteethatreportsdirectlytotheDPSoradesignatedrepresentative.Dependingoncircumstancesandspecificneeds,thecommittee’sresponsibilitiesmaybedelegatedtoanotherexistingcommitteerelatedtocriticalcare(emergency,inten-sivecare,heartunits),giventhenatureoforganandtissuedonationactivities.Thecommittee’smaindutiesareto
•Promoteorganandtissuedonationwithintheestablishment•Promotethetrainingofhospitalstaff,especiallydoctors,nursesandrespiratorytherapistsworkingincriticalcare
•Monitorandevaluatetheprofessionalactivities thataffectsteps in theorgandonationprocedureandtissuedonationprocedure
•Analyzeperformanceandqualityindicatordata•Makerecommendationstoresolveproblemsthataffectstepsintheorgandonationprocedureandtissuedonationprocedure,specificallybysuggestingwaystooptimizetheprocessandmakeongoingimprove- ments
•Produceanorganandtissuedonationprogressreportatleastonceayearformanagementlistingkeychallengesandsettingoutappropriaterecommendations
•Ensurerecommendationsareimplementedandevaluatetheresults
composition and operation
Inadditionto theDPSordesignatedrepresentative, thecommitteeshould includeprofessionalsworking inthecriticalcaredepartmentswheremostofthepotentialorganandtissuedonorsarelocated.Amem- berof theexecutiveboardof theCPDPshouldalso jointhecommittee. It isalsorecommendedthat theTransplantQuébecclinicalcoordinator/advisor,aHéma-Québecrepresentativeand,whereapplicable,anorganandtissuedonationliaisonnurseorresourcenurseactivelyparticipateonthecommitteetoprovideasmuchsupportaspossible.Anarchivistmayalsohelpthecommitteeinitsworkasneeded.
Thenumberofcommitteemembersandmeetingsmayvarybyestablishmentaccordingtothevolumeandnatureoforganandtissuedonationneeds.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
31
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOnAL ARRAnGEmEnTs
FOLLOW-uP AnD FEEDBAcK mEcHAnIsms
Toensurecontinuousimprovement,itisimportanttohavemonitoringandfeedbackmechanismsinplacetomeasureoutcomesandmakeanynecessarychanges.Establishmentsmustalso takecare tooffer qualityservices thatmeetstandardsofexcellence. In this regard theymustmeetAccreditationCanadastandardsfororganandtissuedonation.
AccreditationCanadarecognizestheimportanceofproperlyorganizingservicestoachievethebestpos-sible results inorgandonationand tissuedonation.Organand tissuedonation standards fordeceaseddonorshavebeencoveredbytheAccreditationCanadaprogramsince2010.Theapplicablestandardsareasfollows:
•OrganandTissueDonationStandardsforDeceasedDonors•CriticalCare(Standard8)•EmergencyDepartment(Standard9)•OrganandTissueTransplantStandards
TransplantQuébecofferssupportservicestoguideestablishmentsthroughtheaccreditationprocess. It hasalsodevelopeda referencedocument,Soutien et accompagnement des établissements de santé et de services sociaux du Québec relativement aux normes d’Agrément Canada[supportandassistanceforQuebechealthandsocialserviceagencieswithrespecttoAccreditationCanadastandards].
Onthetissuedonationside,Héma-Québeccanprovideinformationonregulatoryrequirementssoestab- lishmentscanbesuretheyconformtoAccreditationCanada’sstandards.
Furthermore,establishmentsmusthaveaccesstocompilationtoolstomeasureandevaluateoutcomes.Dashboardsareusefulformonitoringoutcomesandsupportingthedonationcommitteeandmanagementteamwithregardtoorganandtissuedonationorganizationalmatters.Annualprogressreportsfortheboardofdirectorsarealsorecommended.
TransplantQuébecoperatesaninformationsystemtodocumentorgandonationactivities,specificallythroughtheorgandonationqualityindicatorsproject.Pilotprojectsinseveralestablishmentshavedemon- strateditsworth.Theinformationsystemprovidesestablishmentswithquickinformationonorgandonationoutcomesintheirareasotheycanevaluatetheirperformanceandadjusttheirstrategiesaccordingly.
previous view
32
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
sPEcIAL POInTs TO TAKE InTO AccOunT
Theservicesavailableandhowtheyaredeliveredarenotthesamefororgandonationandtissuedonation.Establishmentsmustthereforeconsiderthespecificcharacteristicsofeachdonationtypeandadaptser-vicesaccordingly.
Theinformationbelowlistspointstoconsiderinorganandtissuedonation.Thatwayclinicalteamscanfollowclearguidelineswheninteractingwithpatientsandtheirfamiliesinsituationsofimminentorrecentdeath.
Inaddition,bothTransplantQuébecandHéma-Québecsupportestablishmentsbyguidingthemthroughthecontinuumofcaretobeprovidedinorganandtissuedonationactivities.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
33
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
Arangeofservicesmustbeaccessibleandavailablewithintheidentifyingestablishment,usuallyinclosecooperationwithasecondestablishment(theprocurementcentre)andpotentiallyathird(thetransplanta-tioncentre).Forasuccessfulorgandonationprocess,servicesmustbeorganizedsoastotakethefol-lowingspecialfactorsintoaccount:
•Thelimitednumberofannualdonorsoverallandperestablishment•Howdonorsareidentifiedandmaintained•Howtheorgandonationproposalispresentedtothefamily•Timelyaccesstoabedinintensivecare•Timelyaccesstotheoperatingroom,oftenaftercoordinatingmultiplesurgicalteamsfromanumberofspecialties
•Trainingofattendingteamsincriticalcareunits(onhiring,duringonboardinginanewdepartment,andaspartofcontinuoustraining)
Facts on the organ donation process
•Theprocessvariesintermsoflength(duetotheunexpectednatureoforgandonation,whichusually occursintheemergencyroomorintensivecare),occurswhenthefamilyisinastateofshock,and requirestheinvolvementofalargernumberofpeople.•Whenanorganisdonatedafterdeath,100to150peopleareinvolved.•Organdonationcanhappenanytime,24/7.•Detailedlogisticalproceduresmustbefollowedtoensuresuccess.•Thenumberofdonorsmayvaryfrom0to10inasingleweekforallofQuebec.•Tendonorscanresultin30to40transplants,requiring40to50intensivecarebedsplusoperating roomsforallthesecases.
ROLEs AnD REsPOnsIBILITIEs OF VARIOus PLAyERs
Organ donation and transplantation chain
Routine training of critical care staff(ER and intensive care)
+ awareness/educational activities for staff and the public
DONATION CHAIN TRANSPLANTATION CHAIN
Eligibility
Follow-up with patient on the waiting list
Access to the transplant
Follow-up with recipientFormation of an organ donation committee
Identi�cation and referral of the potential donor
Communication with the family and consent
Organ allocation
Removal
Organ distribution
Post-donation follow-up
Communication and donor maintenanceand organ preservation
Source: Transplant Québec
previous view
34
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
Theorgandonationandtransplantationchainisonlyasstrongasitsweakestlink.Ongoingmobilizationofstakeholderswillfacilitateeffortsrequiredatalllevels.ThisrequiresthatestablishmentsmakeaconcertedeffortwithTransplantQuébectoensuretheyarefulfillingtheirresponsibilitieseverytimeitisrequired,fromidentificationtoorganremoval,andforeverydonor.
Itisalsoimportanttosupporttheorganizationofservicesattheregionalandinterregionallevels.Itmaybenecessarytoestablishcorridorsofservice inordertopoolresources.Factorstoconsider inorganizing organtransplantserviceswillbecoveredinfurtherdetailgiventhespecificnatureoftransplantactivities.Onlyeightestablishmentswithhighlyspecificprogramsareaffected.
Anumberofcommunitypartnersandassociationsarealsoinvolvedintheorgandonationprocess.
cEnTRE By AcTIVITy TyPE
Identification centres
Activities in the donation chain may be carried out by the identification or procurement centre, or by both at the same time
Procurement centres
All procurement centres are identification centres
Transplantation centres
As a general rule, transplantation centres are identification and procurement centres
cOmmEnTs
Centreswithanemergencyroomandtheabilitytoofferintensivecare
CurrentlyonlyahandfulofestablishmentsinQuebecremoveorgans.
ForDCDcases,TransplantQuébecmayperformtheremovalinanestablishmentwithwhichithasanagreement.
ThenumberoftransplantprogramsinQuébecisasfollows:
-7forthekidneys (including2pediatric programs)- 3fortheheart- 2fortheliver(pediatric)- 1forthelungs
sTEPs In THE ORGAn DOnATIOn AnDTRAnsPLAnTATIOn cHAIn
• Identificationofpotential organdonor• Referralofpotential organdonorto TransplantQuébec• communicationof diagnosis/prognosis tofamily• Proposal oftheorgan donationoption• Donorevaluation and maintenance
Inadditiontothestepssetoutabove:
• Organremoval and preservation
Inadditiontothestepssetoutabove:
• Evaluation of eligibility ofpatientonatransplant waitinglist• Transplantation•Follow-up withrecipient
n centres by activity type and establishment categories as they relate to the steps in the organ donation chain
EsTABLIsHmEnT cATEGORIEs
Allestablishmentswhosemissionsinvolvegeneralandspecializedcare
PRAcTIcEs PRAcTIcEs RELATED TO RELATED TO nDD AnD DcD TO DcD OnLy
Establishments thatcanproceed accordingly
(SeeApp.2,p.66.)
(SeeApp.2,p.66.)
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
35
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF sERVIcEs
Organizationofservicesmustbetakenintoaccountaccordingtotypeofactivityandestablishmentcate-gory.Thepointstoconsiderwillvarydependingonwhethertheestablishmentisapotentialdonoridenti- ficationcentre,procurementcentreortransplantationcentre.Thisframeworkcoversdonoridentification,referralandmaintenance,andorganprocurementfortheseestablishments.Inaddition,theDCDprotocol issetoutsothatestablishmentsthatdonotcurrentlyperformorganremovalcanevaluatetheimpacts associatedwiththatparticularactivity.
Organ donation requires working in partnership and poses a networking challenge.Establishmentsmusttherefore identify partners and specify corridors of service and coordination processes andproceduresnecessaryfortheproperconductofactivitiesincooperationwithTransplantQuébec.
EmERGEncy sERVIcEs (AnD OTHER cARE unITs)
•Followorgandonationprocedures,particularlyforidentification,referralandfamilycommunication.•Afteridentifyingapotentialdonor,verifythedonor’seligibilitywithTransplantQuébecbeforetransferringthedonortotheestablishment’sintensivecareunit.
•Makesurephysiciansandclinicalteamshaveaccesstoequipment(e.g.,respirators).•Maintainthehemodynamicstabilityofthepotentialdonor.•Takethenecessarystepsinorganizingthedonation:applicableclinicalexaminationswithintherequiredtimeframes,transferringthepatienttoanotherestablishmentifneeded,etc.
•Facilitateandsupporttheseactivities.•Supportthefamilythroughouttheprocessandavoidproposingthedonationoptionintheemergencyroomwheneverpossible.
InTEnsIVE cARE (IncLuDInG THE HEART AnD nEOnATOLOGy unITs)
•Followallstepsintheorgandonationprocess.•Makesurethepotentialdonorisadmittedtointensivecare(accesstoabedandtoequipmentsuchas arespirator).
•Maintainthehemodynamicstabilityofthepotentialdonor.•Takethenecessarystepsinorganizingthedonation:applicableclinicalexaminationswithintherequiredtimeframes,transferringthepatienttoanotherestablishmentifneeded,etc.
•Declarebraindeathaccordingtocurrentprotocols.•Performclinicalexamstoconfirmneurologicaldeathordonationaftercardiocirculatorydetermination ofdeath,takingintoaccounttheprovisionsofarticle45oftheCivilCodeofQuébec.(SeeLegislativeframework,p.26.)
•Helpevaluatethedonorandthequalityoftheorgans.•Seetoitthatthefamilyissupportedthroughouttheprocess.
previous view
36
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
DIAGnOsTIc sERVIcEs
•Performtherequiredanalysesandexaminationsquickly:laboratories(serologyandvirologyinparticular),pathology (biopsy),medical imaging (general radiography, tomodensitometry,angiography,coronary angiography,ultrasound,etc.)andhistocompatibilitylaboratory.
•Ensureaccesstootherdiagnosticserviceswhenrequired(electrophysiology,etc.).
Ifadiagnosticserviceisnotavailableorifitcannotbeperformedinanestablishment,theexaminationwillbedoneattheprocurementcentre.
mEDIcAL sERVIcEs
•Takeintoaccountthemedicalspecialtiesbroughtintoplayinthedonationprocessandassesstheim-pactsontheirclinicalpractice(imaging,pathology,surgery,neurology,cardiology,pulmonology,etc.).
•Encouragephysicianstogetinvolvedintheorgandonationprocess: –Sendtherequiredinformationontheorgandonationprocesstothephysiciansworkingintheestab- lishmentwhomaybebroughtinatvarioustimesintheprocess.
–Supportandencouragephysicianandresidenttraining. –Encouragephysicianparticipationontheorganandtissuedonationcommittee.•Ensure that theCPDPcontrols andproperly assesses thequality of themedical andpharmaceuticalproceduresinvolvedintheorgandonationprocess.
•Forprocurementcentresonly,grantprivilegestophysiciansfromotherestablishmentsorprovinces.
PHARmAcy DEPARTmEnT
•Supportmedicalteamsandclinicsinmaintainingdonorsandduringorgan(heartandlung)recruitmentproceduresintermsofpharmaceuticalservicesandcare,withtheaimofachievingoptimalorganfunc-tiontoincreasethenumberoftransplantations.
OPERATInG ROOm
•Maketheoperatingroomavailablefororganremovalonaflexiblebasis,takingintoaccounttheavail- abilityofrooms,clinicalteamsandprocurementphysicians.
•AssessthespecificimpactsassociatedwithDCD(deathofthepatientintheoperatingroomwhentreat-mentorend-of-lifecare isstopped,withthefamilyusually inattendance)andtakethemintoaccountwhenimplementingthisservice.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
37
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
InTEREsTABLIsHmEnT TRAnsFERs
•Promotecollaborationbetweenestablishments,primarilythoseofferingspecializedneurology,neuro- surgeryandtraumatologyservicesandtheestablishmentsthatdonot.Itisimportanttokeepthenumberof transfers for organdonationpurposes to aminimumand remember their impact on lovedones.TransplantQuébecseekstooptimizedonormovementinordertominimizethenumberofpatienttrans-fersinthedonationprocess.
Forexample,whenapatientmeetstheidentificationcriteriaandmustbetransferredtoanotherestab- lishmentforaspecialtyconsultation,itisrecommendedthatthepatientremainattheestablishmentheorshehasbeentransferredto,eveniftreatmentisnotpossible,whenthepatientislikelytobeapotentialorgandonor.Thedonationprocesscanthuscontinueatthatestablishment.Suchmethodsavoidpoint-lesstransfersandreducetheinconvenienceandcost.Ifapatientneedstoreturntotheoriginalestab- lishment(e.g.,patient’sdeath,organdonation ineligibilityorthefamily’swish),TransplantQuébeccanprovidefinancialaidforthetransfer,ifneeded.(SeeAppendix4,underFinancialsupport,p.68.)
•Proceedasprearrangedwiththeestablishmentsinvolved,especiallyasconcernsdonormanagement(aspectsofdonormaintenanceororganprocurement).
•Schedulethestaffneededtotransferthedonor(intubatedpatient)toaprocurementcentre.Fororganremoval,ensurethedonoristransferredtotheprocurementcentreselectedbyTransplantQuébec.
mEDIcAL REcORDs
•Discloseinformationfromtherecordasneeded.•HelpcollectdatafortheTransplantQuébecperformanceindicators,primarilybyreviewingtherecords ofpeoplewhodiedincriticalcareunits,inordertoprovideinformationthatcanbeusedwhenassessingthequalityoftheestablishment’sorgandonationprocess.
•Serveonthedonationcommitteeatleastonceayearorasneeded.
cLInIcAL ETHIcs cOmmITTEE
•Assistwiththeimplementationoforgandonationpracticesintheestablishment,asneeded.•Helptoclarifytheethicalaspectsoforgandonationandserviceorganization.
Manyorgandonorsarealsotissuedonors.Insuchcases,theorgandonationprocedureapplies,andTransplantQuébectransfersanorgandonorwhoispotentiallyalsoatissuedonortoHéma-Québec,whichtakeschargeofthetissuedonationprocess.
previous view
38
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
TRAnsPLAnT QuÉBEc suPPORT TO EsTABLIsHmEnTs
mIssIOn, VALuEs AnD sTRATEGIc PRIORITIEs OF TRAnsPLAnT QuÉBEc
TransplantQuébecisthesoleorganizationinchargeofcoordinatingorgandonationafterdeathinQuebec.ItreportstotheMinisterofHealthandSocialServices.
Transplant Québec’s mission
InsupportofQuebecers’collectiveefforttosavelivesandimprovethehealthofpeopleindesperateneedoforgans,TransplantQuébec
•Coordinatestheorgandonationprocessleadingtotransplantation,ensuringthegreatestpossible availabilityofqualitydonororgans.•Ensuresthatorgansareallocatedfairly,basedonstringentethicalandclinicalcriteria.•Helpsimproveclinicalpracticesininstitutionalsettingsbyholdinghospitaltraininganddevelopment activitiesandparticipatingindonation-andtransplant-relatedteachingandresearchactivities.•Actsasacatalysttocreateinterdependencieswithinthedonation/transplantationsystemandserves asafacilitatortaskedwithfosteringdiscussionandmobilizingstakeholders.•Promotespro-donation,pro-transplantationvaluesofsolidarityamongthegeneralpublic,health-care professionalsandestablishmentsconcerned.
TransplantQuébecisactivelyengagedsothatthegreatestnumberofQuebecerswaitingfororganscanreceivetransplants.
suPPORT PROGRAm FOR ORGAn DOnATIOn DEVELOPmEnT In QuEBEc HOsPITALs
AspartofTransplantQuébec’shospitaldevelopmentprogram,eachestablishmentofferingcriticalcareservicesisassignedaTransplantQuébecclinicalcoordinator/advisor,whocanhelptheinstitutiondevelopandimplementorgandonationbestpractices.
ORGAn
DOnATIOn: TOGETHER
FOR LIFE
QuALITy
sAFETy
TRAnsPAREncy
FAIRnEss
cOLLABORATIOn
cOnsuLTATIOn
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
39
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
Roles and responsibilities of the clinical coordinator/advisor
•MaintaintiesbetweentheestablishmentandTransplantQuébec•Provideassistancetocreateandsupportanorgandonationcommittee•Helpupdatereferencematerials•Helpdispenseorgandonationtrainingaccordingtoidentifiedneeds•Cooperatewiththeestablishment’smedicalrecordsdepartmenttocollectqualityindicatorinformation,inaccordancewiththeStandardizedOrganDonationProcedure
•Helporganizeorgandonationawarenessandeducationalactivities•Serveasanorgandonationresourceperson•ProvidesupportduringtheAccreditationCanadaprocess
Formoreinformation TransplantQuébecHospitalDevelopmentandEducationDepartment Telephone:1-855-373-1414.Press7tohearthemessageandthenpress2.
ORGAn DOnATIOn cOORDInATIOn PROGRAm In QuEBEc HOsPITALs
A teamofclinicalcoordinator/advisorsavailable24/7alsocoordinates theorgandonationprocess.Theentireprovinceisservedby20clinicalcoordinator/advisorsbasedinMontrealandQuebecCity.
Theclinicalcoordinator/advisoractsasaclinicaladvisorandprovides thesupportcare teamsneed. Incollaborationwithphysiciansandallotherprofessionals,theclinicalcoordinator/advisorisinvolvedateachstageoftheorgandonationprocess:
•Identificationofthepotentialorgandonor•Referralofthepotentialdonor•Managementandmonitoringofthedonor•Discussionswiththefamily•Assessmentandacceptanceofthedonor•Donortransfertoaprocurementcentre•Assessmentoftransplantorgans•Organallocation•Organremovalandpreservation•Organandmedicalteamtransport•Follow-upwithstakeholders,includingthedonor’sfamily
Additionally,theTransplantQuébecclinicalcoordinator/advisoroverseesthemaster listofpatientswait- ing fora transplantaccording to the rulesestablishedby theorganization,aswellas thepost-donationfollow-upfordonorrecords.
Formoreinformation TransplantQuébecClinicalServices Telephone:1-855-373-1414.Press7tohearthemessage,press4andthenpress2.
previous view
40
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
ORGAn DOnATIOn LIAIsOn AnD REsOuRcE nuRsEs
Sixteenestablishmentswithanannualpotentialof8to20donorshaveadedicatedtissueandorgandona-tionteammadeupofliaisonandresourcenurses.
Theorganandtissuedonationliaisonnurse12andresourcenurse13organizeorgandonationsincooperationwiththeorganandtissuedonationcommittee,oftenunderthedirectionoftheestablishment’sprofessionalservices.Theyplanandorganizetrainingforhealth-careprofessionalstoincreasethenumberofreferralsandthefamilyconsentratebyidentifyingandreferringdonorstoTransplantQuébecearlyintheprocess.
Theyactasresourcepeopleforthestakeholdersinasharedinterventionmodelateverystageoftheorgandonationprocess.Theirroleincludesallofthefollowing:
•Meetwiththemedicalteamtodecideonhowtoapproachthegrievingfamily•Ensurebestpracticesarefollowedwhentheorgandonationoptionispresented•Offerthegrievingfamilyongoingsupport•Answerthefamily’squestionsincollaborationwiththeattendingteam
Formoreinformation TransplantQuébecHospitalDevelopmentandEducationDepartment Telephone:1-855-373-1414.Press7tohearthemessageandthenpress2.
mEDIcAL mAnAGEmEnT
TransplantQuébec’soperationsaresupportedbythemedicalmanagementteam,whichismadeupofsixphysicians,includingthemedicaldirectorandthedeputymedicaldirector.Together,theyformtheon-callmedicalteamthatisavailable24/7to
•Makenecessarymedicaldecisions•Guidetheclinicalaspectofcoordination•Actasthego-toresourcepeopleforphysiciansworkinginestablishments•Speakatinformationortrainingactivities•Helpdevelopandreviseorganizationalprocesses,policiesandprocedures
TRAInInG
Currently,Quebechealth-careandsocialservicesprofessionalsreceiveverylimitedpreliminarytraininginorgandonation.Itisimportanttomaintainandprovideorgandonationtrainingforcriticalcaredepartmentprofessionals(physicians,nursesandrespiratorytherapists)ateachestablishment,especiallyduringorien-tationsessions.
12OrganandtissueanddonationliaisonnursesareTransplantQuébecemployeeswhoworkinanestablishment.In2013there werefourliaisonnursesbasedateightestablishments(10sites)whosharedround-the-clockdutyfortheMontreal,Montérégie andLavalareas.13Organandtissuedonationresourcenursesareemployedbytheestablishmentswheretheywork.Underthehospitalmanage- mentprogramadministeredbyTransplantQuébec,halfoftheirsalariesispaidbyTransplantQuébecandtheotherhalfbythe establishment.In2013therewere15resourcenursesat10establishments(19sites)throughoutQuebec.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
41
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
TransplantQuébecanditsteamofclinicalcoordinator/advisors(whoareallnurses),organdonationliaisonnursesandphysiciansofferawidevarietyof trainingactivities forhealth-careandsocialservicespro- fessionals,especiallythoseworkingincriticalcare.
AnumberoftrainingsessionsbyTransplantQuébecareaccreditedbyeducationalinstitutionsorprofes- sionalorganizationsandentitleparticipantstotrainingcredits.
Thesetrainingsessionscoverthefollowing:
•Theorgandonationprocess,aswellastherolesandresponsibilitiesofhealth-careprofessionals•Maintainingthehemodynamicstabilityoforgandonors•Breakingbadnewsandproposingtheorgandonationoption
Examplesofaccreditedtraining
•Standardizedorgandonationprocedure(1to1.5hours)•Approachingandsupportingthefamilyinorgandonationsituations(13hours)•Maintainingthehemodynamicstabilityoforgandonors(1hour)•Discussingandsuggestingorgandonation(1hour)
Examplesofnon-accreditedtraining
•OrgandonationinQuebec(presentationforprofessionals,3hours)•OrgandonationinQuebec(presentationforthegeneralpublic,1hour)
TransplantQuébecoffersaccreditedonlinetrainingonitswebsite.Thistraining,developedincollaborationwiththeQuebecSocietyofIntensivists,isintendedforphysicians,nursesandrespiratorytherapists,espe-ciallythoseworkingincriticalcareunits.
Bytheendofthistraining,theparticipantswillknowthekeystagesintheStandardizedOrganDonationProcedureandhaveabetterunderstandingofhow important it is toactivelyparticipate in thedonationprocess.Participantswillbeableto
•Identifytheirrolesintheorgantransplantationanddonationchain•IdentifypotentialorgandonorsandreferthemtoTransplantQuébec
Onceparticipantshaveviewedthetrainingmaterialandpassedthetest,theyareentitledtoatraining credit.
TransplantQuébecalsooffers training in the formof talksatmanyCEGEPsanduniversitiesaspartof preliminarytrainingprogramsinnursing,respiratorytherapyandmedicine.
Organ donation saves lives!
Your work is important, thank you for your commitment!
Online learning on organ donation*Learning credit – free
www.transplantquebec.ca/professionnels/formationenligne
*French version only
previous view
42
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
DOcumEnTATIOn AVAILABLE TO HEALTH PROFEssIOnALs AnD EsTABLIsHmEnTs
TransplantQuébecprovidesallhealth-careandsocialservicesprofessionalswhoworkincriticalcarewithreferencematerialsthatwalkthemthroughtheprocess,fromidentifyingpotentialorgandonorstoorganremoval.Herearesomeexamples:
•TransplantQuébecwebsite•StandardizedOrganDonationProcedure•Standardizedorgandonationprocedureflowchart•OrganandTissueDonor(OTD)binder•Donationprocesschecklist•Guides,policies,protocols,procedures,andforms,includingtheadultandpediatricdonormanagement guidelines
Formoreinformation Clinicalcoordinator/advisorfortheestablishmentor TransplantQuébec’sHospitalDevelopmentandEducationDepartment Telephone:1-855-373-1414.Press7tohearthemessageandthenpress2.
Transplant Québec website
TheTransplantQuébecwebsite,especially theHealthProfessionalssection,providesawealthofusefulinformation.Thesection isdedicatedentirely toprofessionals in institutionalsettingsand isdesignedtoexplaintheorgandonationprocessandsimplifytheirwork.
www.transplantquebec.ca
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
43
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
standardized Organ Donation Procedure
Versionforhospitalswithdedicatedorgandonationpersonnel
PROCÉDURE TYPE POUR LE DON D’ORGANES
PROCÉDURE TYPE POUR LE DON DE TISSUS
EN RELATION AVEC L’ARTICLE 204.1 DE LA LOI SUR LES SERVICES DE SANTÉ ET LES SERVICES SOCIAUX
MARS 2012
Centre hospitalier avec personnel dédié en don d’organes
Versionforhospitalswithoutdedicatedorgandonationpersonnel
PROCÉDURE TYPE POUR LE DON D’ORGANES
PROCÉDURE TYPE POUR LE DON DE TISSUS
EN RELATION AVEC L’ARTICLE 204.1 DE LA LOI SUR LES SERVICES DE SANTÉ ET LES SERVICES SOCIAUX
MARS 2012
Centre hospitalier sans personnel dédié en don d’organes
Thepurposeof thisprocedure is tosupportorganandtissuedonation inestablishmentswithaviewtobetteridentificationandmoresystematicreferralsofpotentialorgandonors.Bothversions(withandwithoutdedicatedorgandonationpersonnel)areintendedprimarilyforDPSs,membersoforganandtissuedona- tioncommitteesandcriticalcareprofessionals.Theproceduregoesalongwaytofacilitatingtheirwork,whilealso improvingoutcomes in theestablishmentandensuringservicesmeetAccreditationCanada’snew(deceaseddonor)organdonationstandards.
standardized organ donation procedure flow chart
Versionforhospitalswithdedicatedorgandonationpersonnel
© Transplant Québec 2012
STANDARDIZED ORGAN DONATION PROCEDURE IN REFERENCE TO ARTICLE 204.1 (LSSSS)
Patient with a prognosis of impending death
Hospital with a liaison/resource nurse assigned to organ donation
DO NOT OFFER THE OPTION OFDONATION TO THE FAMILYBEFORESTEP 4
End of the referral to Transplant Québec
ACTIVE MEDICAL TREATMENT
The patient satisfies the criteria for being a potential organ donor: • A person of any age • Has experienced a severe neurological insult (post-resuscitation, cerebral anoxia, CVA, cerebral haemorrhage, encephalopathy, traumatic brain injury, Glasgow score < 5 ...) • Requires mechanical ventilation
Depending on the situation, a decision is made to continue or stop active medical treatment
Diagnosis of neurological determination of death (NDD)Potential donor (NDD)
Severe and irreversible prognosisConsider withdrawing life-sustaining therapy (WLST)Potential donor for donation after cardiocirculatory death (DCD)
The patient’scondition improves
Contact the liaison/resource nurse of your hospital to verify the donor’s eligibility
When the organ donor is also a tissue donor, Transplant Québecwill communicatewith Héma-Quebec.
Yes
IDENTIFICATION
REFERRAL
PRIOR TO OFFERING THE OPTION OF ORGAN DONATION TO THE FAMILY
The liaison/resource nurse assigned to organ donation contacts Transplant Québec
to verify the patient’s inscription in the registries of the RAMQ andthe Chambre des notaires du Québec
COMMUNICATIONOF DIAGNOSIS / PROGNOSIS
Announce and explain the poor and irreversible prognosis
Discuss withdrawing life-sustaining therapies (WLST)
Provide the time necessary to absorb the information
Ensure that the family understands the prognosisBe prepared to repeat the information as often as needed
• Provide a quiet and private space
• Be empathic and attentive to the family’s needs
• Ensure that family support personnel are present
• Use of visual aids (i.e. brain scan)
OFFER / TEAM APPROACH
PRESENT THE OPTION OF ORGAN AND TISSUE DONATIONAsk the family to respond based on the KNOWN expressed wishes of the patient as indicated by • the inscription(s) in the RAMQ and the Chambre des notaires du Québec registries OR • the signature on the back of the health insurance card OR • a prior verbal consentOR if the wishes are NOT KNOWN, have the family decide by considering the person’s values and beliefs
Offer to involve the Transplant Québec coordinator to answer any questions the family might have
Ascertain the family’s decision
Allow sufficient time for a period of reflection Be attentive to the family’s needs, answer questions and address concerns
Reference tools: www.transplantquebec.ca and the following documents (available upon request at [email protected]): Trousse Pensez don (can be found in the intensive care units and the emergency departments) and pocket size donor guideline card
Communicate the family’s decision to Transplant Québec
Consent Refusal
CONTINUE DONOR MANAGEMENT Provide all available information concerning the donor to the Transplant Québec coordinator
Begin the donor evaluation and eligibility phase in collaboration with the medical team and the Transplant Québec coordinator
NDD
Continue to providefamily support
End-of-life care
DCD
Diagnosis of neurological determination of death completed by 2 physicians
Transfer to the operating room*
Organ procurement
Transfer to the operating room
WLST and end-of-life care
Diagnosis of death by cardiocirculatory criteria completed by 2 physicians
Organ procurement
Death does not occur
Continue end-of-life care
* For hospitals that do not carry out procurements: Depending on the situation, the donor will be transferred to a procurement center as soon as possible.
1
2
3
4
5EVALUATION, ELIGIBILITY ANDPROCUREMENT
No
Continuation of active medical treatment
Depending on thesituation, continue or stop medical treatment
With the collaboration of
Versionforhospitalswithoutdedicatedorgandonationpersonnel
© Transplant Québec 2012
STANDARDIZED ORGAN DONATION PROCEDURE IN REFERENCE TO ARTICLE 204.1 (LSSSS)
Patient with a prognosis of impending death
Hospital without a liaison/resource nurse assigned to organ donation
DO NOT OFFER THE OPTION OFDONATION TO THE FAMILYBEFORESTEP 4
End of the referral to Transplant Québec
ACTIVE MEDICAL TREATMENT
The patient satisfies the criteria for being a potential organ donor: • A person of any age • Has experienced a severe neurological insult (post-resuscitation, cerebral anoxia, CVA, cerebral haemorrhage, encephalopathy, traumatic brain injury, Glasgow score < 5 ...) • Requires mechanical ventilation
Depending on the situation, a decision is made to continue or stop active medical treatment
Diagnosis of neurological determination of death (NDD)Potential donor (NDD)
Severe and irreversible prognosisConsider withdrawing life-sustaining therapy (WLST)Potential donor for donation after cardiocirculatory death (DCD)
The patient’scondition improves
ContactTransplant Québec to verify the potential donor’s eligibility
1 888 366-7338 option 1
When the organ donor is also a tissue donor, Transplant Québecwill communicatewith Héma-Quebec.
Yes
IDENTIFICATION
REFERRAL
PRIOR TO OFFERING THE OPTION OF ORGAN DONATION TO THE FAMILY
Contact Transplant Québec: 1 888 366-7338, option 1to verify the patient’s inscription in the registries of the RAMQ andthe Chambre des notaires du Québec
COMMUNICATIONOF DIAGNOSIS / PROGNOSIS
Announce and explain the poor and irreversible prognosis
Discuss withdrawing life-sustaining therapies (WLST)
Provide the time necessary to absorb the information
Ensure that the family understands the prognosisBe prepared to repeat the information as often as needed
• Provide a quiet and private space
• Be empathic and attentive to the family’s needs
• Ensure that family support personnel are present
• Use of visual aids (i.e. brain scan)
OFFER / TEAM APPROACH
PRESENT THE OPTION OF ORGAN AND TISSUE DONATIONAsk the family to respond based on the KNOWN expressed wishes of the patient as indicated by • the inscription(s) in the RAMQ and the Chambre des notaires du Québec registries OR • the signature on the back of the health insurance card OR • a prior verbal consentOR if the wishes are NOT KNOWN, have the family decide by considering the person’s values and beliefs
Offer to involve the Transplant Québec coordinator to answer any questions the family might have
Ascertain the family’s decision
Allow sufficient time for a period of reflection Be attentive to the family’s needs, answer questions and address concerns
Reference tools: www.transplantquebec.ca and the following documents (available upon request at [email protected]): Trousse Pensez don (can be found in the intensive care units and the emergency departments) and pocket size donor guideline card
Communicate the family’s decision to Transplant Québec
Consent Refusal
CONTINUE DONOR MANAGEMENT Provide all available information concerning the donor to the Transplant Québec coordinator
Begin the donor evaluation and eligibility phase in collaboration with the medical team and the Transplant Québec coordinator
NDD
Continue to providefamily support
End-of-life care
DCD
Diagnosis of neurological determination of death completed by 2 physicians
Transfer to the operating room*
Organ procurement
Transfer to the operating room
WLST and end-of-life care
Diagnosis of death by cardiocirculatory criteria completed by 2 physicians
Organ procurement
Death does not occur
Continue end-of-life care
* For hospitals that do not carry out procurements: Depending on the situation, the donor will be transferred to a procurement center as soon as possible.
1
2
3
4
5EVALUATION, ELIGIBILITY ANDPROCUREMENT
No
Continuation of active medical treatment
Depending on thesituation, continue or stop medical treatment
With the collaboration of
previous view
44
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
Organ Donor and Tissue Donor (OTD) binder
TheOrganandTissueDonorbinderguidesthecareteamthrougheverystageoftheorgandonationprocess.Thebinderhasbeendistributedtoallhospitalsandmustbeavailableinallcriticalcaredepartments.Itcon-tainssevenchaptersonthefollowingtopics:
•Identificationofpotentialorgandonors•Supportingandapproachinggrievingfamilies•Neurologicaldeterminationofdeath(NDD)anddonationaftercardio- circulatorydeath(DCD)•Consentforms•Assessmentandmanagementofpotentialdonors•Donortransfertoaprocurementcentre•ActtoFacilitateOrganandTissueDonation,inforcesinceFebruary 2011
Criticalcareteamsdonothavetoworryaboutupdatingthistoolbecausethisistheresponsibilityofeachestablishment’sclinicalcoordinator/advisor.
Donation process checklist
Thispocket referenceguidescriticalcareprofessionals through theor-gandonationprocess.ThechecklistisbasedontheStandardizedOrgan DonationProcedure. Itprovidesagreatdealofvaluable informationontheorgandonationprocess.
Copiesofthechecklistareavailablefromtheestablishment’sTransplantQuébec clinical coordinator/advisor or the hospital development andeducationdepartment.
Guidelines, policies, protocols, procedures and forms
TransplantQuébecprovidesnumerousguides,policies,protocols, andprocedures forphysiciansand health-careprofessionals.Forinstance,theHealthProfessionalssectionoftheorganization’swebsitein-cludesthefollowingresources:
•OrganDonorAssessmentandManagementGuidelines–Adults•Protocolederecrutementcardiaqueetpulmonaire [cardiacandpulmonaryrecruitmentprotocol]•OrganDonorAssessmentandManagementGuidelines–Pediatrics•Protocoletypedestinéaudond’organesaprèsdécèscardiocirculatoire(DDC) [standardizedprotocolfordonationaftercardiocirculatorydeath]
TheorgandonationclinicalproceduresandformsarealsoavailableontheTransplantQuébecwebsiteatwww.transplantquebec.ca/en/professionnels.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
45
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
PERFORmAncE InDIcATORs
Organization chart with organ donation quality indicators
Critical care staff- Physicians- Nurses- Respiratory therapists
DPS
Organ and tissuedonation committee
+Transplant Québec
clinical coordinator/advisor
Hospital generalmanagement
Transplant QuébecAnalyze �les upon receipt
Medical recordsStudy records and forms
of people who diedin critical care units
Quality indicator report - Identi�cation rate - Referral rate - Consent rate - Number of organs per donor - Action plan
Action planExample: Training withemergency department
staff
Assessment reporton the records included
in the study
Source: Transplant Québec
FourkeyperformanceindicatorssetoutanddescribedintheStandardizedOrganDonationProcedureareusedtomonitororgandonationintheestablishment.
n Establishment with dedicated organ donation personnel
Theseindicatorsfromtheorgandonationquality indicator (ODQI)systemareavailablefromtheorgandonationliaisonorresourcenursesworkingattheestablishmentandareobtainedthroughtheretrospec-tivestudyoftherecordsofpeoplewhodiedprimarilyintheestablishment’scriticalcaredepartments.
n Establishment without dedicated organ donation personnel
TheODQIsystemisavailabletoprovidequalityindicatorsfirsttoestablishmentswithoutdedicatedorgandonationstaff.
Withtheparticipationoftherecordsdepartmentofestablishmentswithgeneralandspecializedcaremis-sions,thenewsystemdrawsontheorgandonationworkCMQhasconductedformorethan10years.
Health-careprofessionals,DPSsandorganandtissuedonationcommitteeswillfindthedataveryuseful inassessingprogress inorgandonationsand,asneeded,developingactionplans toaddress identifiedproblems.
previous view
46
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
Thefour(4)performanceindicatorsareasfollows:
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
47
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
previous view
48
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
ADVIsORy cOmmITTEEs
TransplantQuébechasanumberofadvisorybodies,includingamedicalscientificadvisorycommitteeandorgan-specificsubcommitteesthatactivelyparticipateinallocationprocedureandcriteriadevelopment, aswellasotheractivities.Physiciansandtransplantsurgeonsininstitutionalsettingsalsocontributeto thiswork.TransplantQuébec’sethicscommitteemakesrecommendationsonanumberofissuesrelated to theorganization’smission, insupportofQuebec’s transplantanddonationsystem. (SeeAppendix4,underTransplantQuébecadvisorycommittees,p.68.)
suPPORT FOR EsTABLIsHmEnT ORGAn AnD TIssuE DOnATIOn AccREDITATIOn (DEcEAsED DOnORs)
SinceApril2010TransplantQuébechasofferedestablishmentshelpwithorganandtissuedonationaccreditationfordeceaseddonors.Itsdocu-mentSoutien et accompagnement des établissements de santé et de ser- vices sociaux du Québec[supportandassistanceforQuebechealth-careandsocialservicesestablishments]goesoverAccreditationCanada’sstandardsfor
•Organandtissuedonation(deceaseddonors)•Intensivecaredepartments(Standard8)•Emergencyrooms(Standard9)
Inconcreteterms,TransplantQuébeccan
•AnswerpartnerqueriesconcerningHealthCanada’sSafetyofHumanCells,TissuesandOrgansforTransplantationRegulationsandtheAccreditationCanadastandards
•Helpdevelopstandardizeddocumentsforvariousaspectsofstandards (policies,standardizedproce-duresandothertools)
•AssistinpreparingdocumentationdescribinghowrolesandresponsibilitiessetoutinthestandardsaresharedbetweenestablishmentsandTransplantQuébecorotherparties,includinglaboratories,withaviewtosigningrequiredagreements
•Supportgroupeffortstopromotetheimplementationofbestpracticesandadapttoolsincooperationwiththeestablishments
TransplantQuébec can also help establishmentswith livingdonor donationprogramsensure their pro-cessesarecompliantwithHealthCanada’sSafetyofHumanCells,TissuesandOrgansforTransplantationRegulations.(SeeAppendix2,underEstablishmentsofferinglivingdonorprograms,p.66.)
TransplantQuébeccanalsoact as anadvisorwithin its fieldof competence, supportinghospitalswith general and specialized caremissions that offer organ transplantation services subject toAccreditationCanada’sQmentumProgramOrganandTissueTransplantStandards.(SeeAppendix2,underOrgantrans- plantationcentresandprograms,p.66.)
Les normes sur le don d’organes et de tissus (donneurs décédés)Services des urgences (Norme 9)Services de soins intensifs (Norme 8)
SOUTIEN ET ACCOMPAGNEMENT DES ÉTABLISSEMENTS DE SANTÉ ET DE SERVICES SOCIAUX DU QUÉBEC RELATIVEMENT AUX NORMES D’AGRÉMENT CANADA
Novembre 2012
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
49
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF ORGAn DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
Under themandate it received fromMSSS in 2010, TransplantQuébecmay contact establishments to informthemofitsnewresponsibilitiesandofferthemsupport.However,TransplantQuébecmustinterveneonlyasrequiredtomeetneedsexpressedbyestablishments.
Formoreinformation TransplantQuébecComplianceandQualityDepartment Telephone:1-855-373-1414.Press7tohearthemessageandthenpress7.
cOmmunIcATIOns
Establishments are urged to organize informational and educational activities on organ donation andtransplantation—topicsinwhichthepublichasshownagreatdealofinterest—particularlyregardingthosewaitingfortransplantsorrecipients,theirfamiliesanddonors’families.Themedia,especiallyatthelocalandregionallevels,oftentakeaninterestintheseissues.
EstablishmentsoftenworkwithTransplantQuébeconcommunicationsandpublicrelationsactivitiesinthecommunity.
TransplantQuébec’scommunicationsandpublicrelationsdepartmentwillprovideasmuchassistanceas itcanwithcommunicationsactivitiesininstitutionalandpublicsettings.
TransplantQuébecalreadyorganizesandsupportsanumberofcommunicationsandpublicrelationsinitia-tivespromotingorgandonationtothegeneralpublicandspecifictargetaudiences,particularlyhealth-careandsocialservicesprofessionals,youngerandolderpeople,andsoonculturalcommunitiesaswell.(SeeAppendix4,underCommunicationsandpublicrelations,p.68.)
Formoreinformation TransplantQuébecCommunicationsandPublicRelationsDepartment Telephone:1-855-373-1414.Press7tohearthemessageandthenpress3.
FInAncIAL suPPORT FOR DOnOR IDEnTIFIcATIOn AnD ORGAn PROcuREmEnT
TransplantQuébecmanagesanorgandonationfundforthecostsincurredfordeceaseddonors.Thepro-gramprovidesfixedsumsfortheestablishment’sidentificationandprocurementcentresandcoverstravelcosts for teams, transportationcosts forprocuredorgansand for returning thebody,andcertainblood testsinaccordancewithTransplantQuébec’sIdentificationandPaymentPolicyforOrganDonationfromDeceasedDonors.(SeeAppendix4,underFinancialsupport,p.68.)
previous view
50
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF sERVIcEs
Héma-Québeclookstogeneralandspecializedhospitalsandtheirvariousdepartmentstoensureidenti- ficationand referralof allpotential tissuedonors.Afterapotential tissuedonorhasbeen referred, the Héma-Québeccoordinatortakeschargeofthedonationprocessandtriestominimizetheimpactonmed-icalpersonnel.However,thecooperationofthefollowingdepartmentsisessentialforasuccessfuldonation:
•Clinicalservices•Medicalbiology(laboratory)services,includingpathology(pathologylabandmorgue)•Admissions•Medicalrecords•Operatingroom
REsPOnsIBILITIEs OF DEPARTmEnTs
•Identifypotentialtissuedonors•ContacttheHéma-QuébeccoordinatorondutytochecktheRAMQandChambredesnotairesduQuébecconsentregistries
•Facilitateandsupporttheseactivities
cLInIcAL sERVIcEs
MedicalstaffareresponsibleforidentifyingandreferringpotentialtissuedonorsaccordingtothecriteriasetoutintheStandardizedTissueDonationProcedure–RecentPatientDeath.Recentdeathmeansacardio-pulmonarydeathwithout life supportthatmayleadtoahumantissuedonation.
n If consent is recorded in the registries
•Medical records
Ifconsenthasbeengiven,additionalinformationonthedeceased’smedicalhistorywillberequiredsotheHéma-Québeccoordinatorcanperformaproperassessmentofthepotentialdonor’ssuitability.Hos-pitalmedicalstaffmustbeinformedandprovidetheinformation.
•Communication with the family
Generally,thefamilyandHéma-Québecspeakbyphone.TheHéma-Québeccoordinatorisresponsibleforexplainingthetissuedonationprocess.Ifthefamilywantstoleavethehospitalbeforespeakingto thecoordinator,medicalstaffmustobtain thephonenumberwhere the familycanbe reachedwithin anhourofleaving.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
51
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
n If consent is not noted in the registries or the back of the health insurance card has not been signed
DonationmustbesuggestedtothefamilyandsupportfromtheHéma-Québeccoordinatormustbeoffered.Ifthefamilyconsentstotissuedonationorhasquestionsaboutthedonationprocess,themedicalprofes-sionalactsasthelinkbetweenthecoordinatorandthefamily.Oncethecoordinatorhasbeeninformedofthesituation,heorshewillbeabletotakeoverand
•Givethefamilytheusualexplanations•Receiveconsentfortissueremoval•Fillinthedonoreligibilityquestionnaire•Handleformalitiesforthetransferofthedonor’sbodytothefuneralhome
n How are tissues procured?
•Unlikeorgans,humantissuescanberetrievedforseveralhoursafterbloodcirculationsstops.•Thedonor’sbodyistreatedwithcareandrespectbyateamofprofessionalsspecializingintissuepro- curement.Procurementisdoneinspeciallydesignedfacilities,inaHéma-Québecestablishment,orinahospitaloperatingroom,accordingtostringentproceduresandincompliancewithHealthCanadaandvariousrecognizedregulatoryagencystandards.
n When does the tissue donation process begin?
•Thedonoreligibilityprocessbeginsassoonasconsenttotissuedonationisobtained.Ideally,removalshouldbedoneasquicklyaspossibleafterdeathtomaximizethequalityoftheprocuredtissues.
n Are screening tests performed during tissue donation?
•Bloodiscollectedtodeterminethedonor’sserologicalprofileandensuretherecipient’ssafety.
n What is the age limit to be a tissue donor?
Theagecriteriondependsontissuetype:
•Cardiactissue–Birthto60years•Skinandbonetissue–15to70years•Tendons–15to60years•Eyetissue–2to85years
previous view
52
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
n What about confidentiality?
•Theresultsofserologicalanalysesremainconfidential,butaresenttothepublichealthagencyifanoti-fiablediseaseispresent.
•All information obtained during the donor eligibility process is protected by law.14 Allmedical record assessment information remains strictly confidential and is used only to determine the eligibility of a potentialdonor.
•Iftissueremovaldoesnottakeplaceorthetissuesarenotusedfortransplantationbecauseofinforma- tioninmedicalorhospitalrecords,informationcannotbedisclosedduetolawsprotectingthemedicalinformationofdeceasedpersons.
•Someretrievedtissuesmaybesenttoanexternallaboratorytobeprocessedandconserved(QuebeceyebankinMontrealandCentreuniversitaired’ophtalmologieduCHUdeQuébec,HôpitalSaint-Sacrementsite).
•Thecoronercanasktotakebloodsamplesforanalysisorrequestcopiesofcertaindocuments.•Ifthedonor’sbodyisautopsiedaftertissueremoval,thepathologistmayrequestcopiesofcertaindocu-ments.
n What happens to the tissues after they are removed?
•Bacteriologicaltestsareperformedonremovedtissuesinordertoensureasafe,optimumqualitygraftforthepotentialrecipient.Tissuesareprocessedandconserved(freezingorcryopreservation,dependingonthetypeoftissue)untiltheyaregrafted.
•Tissuesintendedfortransplantcanbeconservedforalongtimewithoutanydeteriorationorchangeinquality.However,theproperconservationmethodsmustbeused.Certaintissuescanthereforebekeptforuptofiveyears.However,withtheever-growingneedfortransplanttissues,theyarerarelykeptsolong.
n How many people can receive a transplant from a single tissue donation?
Dependingonthetypeofremovalandthequalityofthetissuesremoved,atissuedonorcanhelpupto 20recipients.Althoughitcansavelivesjustlikeorgandonationdoes,inmostcases,thepurposeofhumantissuedonationisabovealltomaintainorimprovequalityoflife.Aheartvalvedonationcannotonlyhelppatients return to leadingnormal lives,butalso incertaincaseseliminate theneed formorecomplex surgery.Andbonetissuedonationsallowrecipientstomaintainornoticeablyimprovetheirmobility.
n can a potential tissue donor be excluded under certain circumstances?
Currentlythereisstillalackofknowledgeabouttissuedonation,leadingtoshortagesinpotentialdonorsidentifiedandreferredtoHéma-Québec.Sometypicalscenariosaredescribedbelow.
• The donor’s medical history is complicated “Theoreticallythetissuedonor’sclinicalpicturedoesnotappeartosatisfythedonationrequirements.” ItisbettertoreferthepotentialdonortoHéma-Québecratherthanrefusetoohastily.Thepotentialdonormustbeexcludedautomaticallyifoneofthediagnoseslistedinsection1ofthetissuedonationproce-durehasbeenmade.
14ActRespectingAccesstoDocumentsHeldbyPublicBodiesandtheProtectionofPersonalInformation,CQLR.,c.A-2.1. (www2.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/dynamicSearch/telecharge.php?type=2&file=/A_2_1/A2_1_A.html)
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
53
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
•The potential tissue donor is not on a respirator Humantissuedonationdiffersfromorgandonationinanumberofways.Oneimportantdistinctionisthattissueslikebones,heartvalves,skin,tendons,andeyetissuesaremuchlesscomplexstructuresthanorgansliketheheartandkidneys.Unlikeorgans,tissuescanbedeprivedofoxygenforacertainperiodoftimewithouttheirqualitybeingaffected.Itisthereforepossibletoremovethemevenafterthedonor’sbloodhasstoppedcirculating.However,removalneedstotakeplaceassoonaspossibletoavoidthedeteriorationofsomemorefragiletissues.
•The potential donor is in cardiorespiratory arrest and his or her pulse does not resume Deathmustbecertified.Thetissuedonornolongerhasaheartbeat.
•The potential donor was found dead, rigor mortis has set in and the time of death is unknown Rigormortis is not a reason to exclude a potential tissue donor. TheHéma-Québec coordinatorwill determinewiththefamilymembers,thecoronerora lawenforcementofficer, ifappropriate,whenthedeceasedwaslastseenalive.Thistimewillbeusedasthetimeofdeath.
•The potential donor is under the guardianship of a public trustee Apotentialdonorwhoisundertheguardianshipofapublictrusteecanbeatissuedonor.TheHéma- Québeccoordinatorwillcontactthetrusteeandconducttheusualchecks:
–Presenceorlackofconsent –Authorizationfromthetrustee –Presenceorabsenceofapersonwho is familiarwith thedeceased’ssocialandmedicalhistory to completetheeligibilityquestionnaire
•The potential donor is known to have MRSA15 or VRE16
ApotentialdonorwhoisknowntohaveMRSAorVREbutdoesnotshowsignsofanactiveinfectionatdeathcanundergotissueremoval.TheHéma-Québeccoordinatorhasaccesstoadonorassessmentmanualandwillconsulthisorhermedicaldirector,whenappropriate.
•No family comes to the hospital ThepotentialtissuedonorisrecommendedtoHéma-Québecwhetherthedeceased’sfamilyispresent ornot.TheHéma-Québeccoordinatorwillconduct theusualchecks in theexisting registriesand, ifconsenthasbeengiven,maycontactthefamilytoexplainthedonationprocess.
•The case comes from a coroner Toooftenstill,medicalstaffincorrectlybelievethatacasefromacoronercannotendintissuedonation.Fortraumaticdeathoradeathinvestigatedbythecoroner,theHéma-Québeccoordinatormustconducttheusualcheckswiththecoroner,whomayrequestanautopsyorcertainassessmentsthatwillshed lightonthecauseofdeath.Generally,tissueremovalispossible,andthecoronercomestoanagreementwithHéma-Québeconhowtoproceed.
• An autopsy is required This type of scenario does not prevent tissue removal at all. After the referral toHéma-Québec andconsent for tissue removalhasbeenobtained, theHéma-Québeccoordinatorwill give the family theusualexplanationsandmakeanyrequiredarrangementswiththepathologistonrecord.
15Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus. 16Vancomycin-resistant enterococci.
previous view
54
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
mEDIcAL BIOLOGy sERVIcEs
Medicalbiology(laboratory)servicescanbecalleduponinthefollowingsituations:
n Availability of a blood sample.Foreachdonor,theHéma-Québeccoordinatorneedstocalculatetheplasmadilution.Ifthedonorishemodiluted,theHéma-Québecrepresentativewillcontactthelaboratorytofindoutwhetherapre-infusion/pre-transfusionsampleisavailable.Ifasampleisavailable,itmayberequiredfortheprescribedserologicalanalyses.Theseanalysesarecontractedouttoanoutsidelabo- ratory.
n Blood bank.Fromtimetotime,theHéma-Québeccoordinatormayspeaktoapersonatthehospitalbloodbanktoobtaintheexactvolumesofthetransfusionsadministeredtothedonorinordertocalcu- latetheplasmadilution.
mORGuE AnD PATHOLOGy LABs
Apathologylabisusedforthefollowingsteps:
•Comprehensivephysicalexaminationofthedonor•Preparationofthedonorforremoval(shavingthesurgicalsite,preoperativewashingofthedonor)•Removalofeyetissues.Thistypeofremovalgenerallytakesplaceinthesettingfromwhichthereferraloriginates.Theremovalcanbedoneinthedeceased’sroomorinthepathologylab,dependingonavail- ability.Notethatthisdoesnotapplytoothertypesoftissues.Toensureoptimumasepsiscontrol,theremoval of tissues such as skin, bone tissues, tendons and the heart for valvesmust bedone in an operatingroomoraHéma-Québecestablishment.
ADmIssIOns AnD mEDIcAL REcORDs
Thehospital’sadmissionsormedicalrecordsservicesmaybecalleduponforthereasonssetoutbelow.
n medical record assessment
AHéma-Québecstaffmemberwillneedtoassesstheeligibilityofatissuedonorwhohasbeenrecom-mendedandforwhomdonationconsenthasbeenobtained.Todothis,thestaffmemberwillgodirectly totheestablishmentfromwhichthereferralcameorwillaskforcertainmedicalrecordstobefaxed.
•On-site record assessment by a Héma-Québec staff member TheHéma-Québeccoordinatorwillmakesurethatthedonor’smedicalrecordisavailableandwilldirecthisorhercolleaguetothedepartmentinquestion(e.g.,admissions,records,careunit).Photocopiesofcertaindocumentswillbemadeandappendedtothedonor’seligibilityfile.
•Off-site record assessment TheHéma-Québeccoordinatorfrequentlycontactsthemedicalrecordsdepartmenttoobtaincopiesofdocuments in thedeceased’smedical records.Thedocumentationmustbe faxed to thenumber thecoordinatorgivesthedepartment,incompliancewiththeinformationdisclosurerulesforpatientrecords.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
55
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
n Transfer of the body to the Héma-Québec establishment or a procurement centre
Eye tissuesareusually removedat theestablishmentwhere thedeathhasoccurred.Forother typesof tissues,thedonor’sbodyistransferredtoaHéma-Québecestablishment.Familiesmustgivepriorconsentforbodytransfers.Thisformalityiswidelyaccepted.TheHéma-Québeccoordinatorinformstheestablish-ment’sadmissionsdepartmentthatafuneralhomeistakingthedonor’sbodyandhandlingthetransfer.Afterthetissueremoval,thebodywillusuallybesenttothefuneralhomeselectedbythefamilyortotheestablishmentperformingtheautopsy,ifapplicable.NotethatthecostsassociatedwithmovingthebodyarecoveredbyHéma-Québec.
n Review of the deceased’s records in relation to the number of potential tissue donations
Héma-Québeccanaskforthemedicalrecordsdepartment’scooperationinobtainingdataonthenumberofpotentialdonorsintheestablishment.
OPERATInG ROOm
Héma-QuébechasagreementswithanumberofestablishmentstouseanoperatingroominsituationswherethefamilyrefusestoallowthebodytobetransferredtoaHéma-Québecestablishment.
•Theprocurementteamusestheoperatingroomwithoutcallingontheservicesofhospitalstafforusinghospital equipment. TheHéma-Québec coordinator comes to an agreementwith the operating roommanagertosettheremovaltimeanddecidewhichroomwillbeused.
•Thetissuesareremovedaccordingtotheplannedoperatingscheduleortheavailabilityoftheroom.
IfthereisnoagreementbetweentheestablishmentandHéma-Québec,thecoordinatorwillspeakto hospitalmanagementtoseewhetheranoperatingroomcanbeused.
previous view
56
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
HÉmA-QuÉBEc suPPORT FOR EsTABLIsHmEnTs
mIssIOn, VALuEs AnD sTRATEGIc PRIORITIEs OF HÉmA-QuÉBEc
Héma-Québecistheorganizationresponsibleforcollecting,processinganddistributinghumantissuesinQuebec.InOctober2001,theMinisterofHealthandSocialServicesauthorizedHéma-Québectoexpanditsmissiontocoverhumantissues.Atthesametime,theministerrecognizedHéma-Québec’sexpertise inhumantissueprocessinganddistributionandauthorizedittotakethenecessarystepstocarryoutits newmission.
Withthisnewmandate,Héma-Québecreformulateditsmissiontoincorporateitsnewresponsibilities.
Héma-Québec’smissionistoefficientlymeettheneedsoftheQuebecpopulationforsafe,optimal- qualitybloodandbloodproducts,humantissues,cordblood,mother’smilk,andcellularproducts;todevelopandprovideexpertise and specialized, innovative services in the fieldof humanbiologicalproducts.
Asinthecaseofbloodproducts,Héma-Québecappliesthehigheststandardsandusesthelatesttech- nologiesinordertoensureasafeandadequatesupplyofhumantissue.ItscommitmentistoensurethattransplantphysiciansinQuebechospitalshaveaccesstosafeproductsforhumantissuetransplants.
Héma-QuébecisbetterknownforitsroleasthesolemanagerofQuebec’sbloodsupply,buthasalsoactedasthesupplierofhumantissuesfortransplantsinceDecember2001.Inadditiontotheremovalofeyetissuefor corneal transplants, the organization provides hospitalswith skin grafts, heart valves andmusculo- skeletaltissuesuchastendonsandbones.Quebecthushasanorganizationsupplyingsafe,highqualityhumantissueforrecipients.
Héma-Québec’sbusinessdevelopmentrepresentativesareavailabletopublicizethehumantissueprod-uctsandservicesHéma-Québecoffersandsupporthealth-careprofessionalswhowouldlikemoreinfor-mationonanyoperationalaspects,fromidentifyinggraftstoreportingadversereactions.
Formoreinformation Héma-QuébecBusinessDevelopmentManager Telephone:514-832-5000,ext.385
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
57
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
HOsPITAL DEVELOPmEnT PROGRAm
AspartofHéma-Québec’shospitaldevelopmentprogram,allestablishmentsareentitledtosupportandassistance toensure theydevelopand implement tissuedonationbestpractices. In that regard,Héma- Québec’srolesandresponsibilitiesareasfollows:
•MaintaintiesbetweentheestablishmentandTransplantQuébec•Provideassistancetocreateandsupportanorgandonationcommittee•Helpupdatereferencematerials•Helpdispensetissuedonationtrainingaccordingtoidentifiedneeds•Helporganizetissuedonationawarenessandeducationalactivities•Serveasatissuedonationresource•ProvidesupportduringtheAccreditationCanadaprocess
Formoreinformation Héma-QuébecProcurementDepartment Telephone:418-780-4362,ext.2271
TIssuE DOnATIOn cOORDInATIOn PROGRAm In QuEBEc HOsPITALs
InQuebec,coordinationoftissuedonationishandledbyHéma-Québec’steamofcoordinators,whoareavailable24/7.
Theon-callcoordinatorhandlespotentialdonorreferralsand isable toguidemedicalstaff throughallstagesoftissuedonation:
•Identificationofthepotentialtissuedonor•ReferralofthepotentialdonortoHéma-Québec•Discussionswiththefamily•Assessmentandacceptanceoftissuedonor•Donortransfer•Follow-upwithstakeholders,includingthedonor’sfamily
AWAREnEss PLAn
Generalandspecializedcareestablishmentshaveperformedareviewoftheirdeathrecordsinrecentyearsanddiscoveredthatnearly50%ofdeathscouldhaveresultedintissuedonation.Inlightofthegreatnum- ber of potential donors,Héma-Québechasdevelopeda strategy aimedat concentrating its awareness effortsinafewtargetedhospitals.
Thisplansuggestspromotional,training,andrecognitionactivitiesformedicalstaffbasedontheestab- lishment’sclassification.Thoseestablishmentswhosenamesdonotappearinanycategorycancontact Héma-Québecforinformationontheprocess.
previous view
58
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
classification of establishments
•Targetcentres•Category1centres•Category2centres
n Target centres
IntheQuebecCityandMontrealareas,14hospitalsweretargetedbasedoneorallofthefollowingcriteria:
• ProximitytoHéma-Québecfacilities• VolumeofreferralstoHéma-Québec• Management’swillingnesstofosteratissuedonationcultureinthefacility
Planned activities
• Quarterlyvisitstocareunits(day,eveningandnight)• Monthlycallstomedicalstaff(day,eveningandnight)• Trainingdays–Customizedorbasedonidentifiedneeds• Recognitionactivitiesformedicalstaff–Eachquarter,Héma-Québeccelebratesthecontributionofthosewhohavereferredpotentialtissuedonors
List of target establishments (14 centres)
montreal and other areas
- HôpitalMaisonneuve-Rosemont- HôpitalduSacré-CœurdeMontréal- CSSSdeLaval,HôpitaldelaCité-de-la-Santésite- CHUM,HôpitalNotre-Damesite- CSSSduCœur-de-l’Île,HôpitalJean-Talonsite- CSSSduSuddeLanaudière, HôpitalPierre-LeGardeursite- CSSSd’AhuntsicetMontréal-Nord, HôpitalFleurysite
Quebec city and chaudière-Appalaches areas
- CHUdeQuébec,Hôpitaldel’Enfant-Jésussite- Institutuniversitairedecardiologie etdepneumologiedeQuébec- CSSSAlphonse-Desjardins,Hôtel-DieudeLévissite- CHUdeQuébec,HôpitalSaint-Françoisd’Assisesite- CHUdeQuébec,CHULsite- CHUdeQuébec,HôpitalduSaint-Sacrementsite- CSSSdeBeauce,HôpitaldeSaint-Georgessite
n category 1 centres (8 centres)
Planned activities
• Monthlycallstomedicalstaff(day,eveningandnight)• Trainingdays–Customizedorbasedonidentifiedneeds• Recognitionactivitiesformedicalstaff(annually)–Eachyear,Héma-Québeccelebratesthecontribution ofmedicalstaffwhohavereferredpotentialtissuedonors
List of Category 1 establishments
montreal and montérégie areas
- CSSSdeSaint-Jérôme, HôpitalrégionaldeSaint-Jérômesite- CSSSChamplain—Charles-LeMoyne, HôpitalCharles-LeMoynesite- CSSSPierre-Boucher,HôpitalPierre-Bouchersite- CHUM,HôpitalSaint-Lucsite
Quebec city and other areas
- CHUdeQuébec,Hôtel-DieudeQuébecsite- MaisonMichel-Sarrazin- CSSSdelarégiondeThetford, HôpitaldeThetfordMinessite- CHUS,HôpitalFleurimontand Hôtel-DieudeSherbrookesites
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
59
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
n category 2 centres (20 centres)
Planned activities
• Monthlycallstomedicalstaff(day,eveningandnight)• Trainingdays–Customizedorbasedonidentifiedneeds
List of Category 2 establishments
n Other suggested methods
• Toensurereferralofalltissuedonorsintheestablishment
– DistributionofTissueDonationposterstoallcareunits(nursingstation,familyrooms) – Standardizationofpost-mortemdocumentation – Awarenessactivitiesfordepartmentheadandmedicalstaff
• Topromotecollaborativemethods
– DesignationofaresourcepersonatHéma-Québectofollowupwiththepersoninchargeoforganand tissuedonation – Personalizedfollow-upwiththemedicalstaffintheeventofareferralandafterwardifnecessary – Recognitionofmedicalstaffthroughadhocactivities
• Topromoteoutcomemeasurementandensurecontinuousqualityimprovement
– Maintenanceofadepartmentalstatisticsregistry – Maintenanceofahospitalstatisticsregistry – Developmentofperformanceindicators
• To support and assist the clinical and administrative teamshandling organ and tissuedonations in establishments
– Héma-Québectraining – Distributionofdocumentation –Visitstopatientcareunits
montreal and other areas
- CSSSRichelieu-Yamaska, HôpitalHonoré-Merciersite- CSSSPierre-DeSaurel,Hôtel-DieudeSorelsite- MUHC,MontrealGeneralHospitalsite- CSSSJardins-Roussillon,HôpitalAnna-Labergesite- CHUSainte-Justine- MontrealHeartInstitute- CSSSHaut-Richelieu-Rouville, HôpitalduHaut-Richelieusite- MUHC,RoyalVictoriaHospitalsite- CHUM,Hôtel-DieudeMontréalsite- JewishGeneralHospital- Maisondesoinspalliatifs(Saint-Jean-sur-Richelieu)- MUHC,MontrealNeurologicalHospitalsite- CSSSduSud-Ouest–Verdun,HôpitaldeVerdunsite
Quebec city and other areas
- CSSSdeQuébec-Nord, HôpitalSainte-Anne-de-Beauprésite- CSSSdeChicoutimi,HôpitaldeChicoutimisite- CSSSdeJonquière,HôpitaldeJonquièresite- CSSSdeRimouski-Neigette, HôpitalrégionaldeRimouskisite- CSSSdeLac-Saint-Jean-Est,Hôpitald’Almasite- CSSSduNorddeLanaudière, HôpitaldeJoliettesite- CSSSduSuroît,HôpitalduSuroîtsite
previous view
60
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
suPPORT
Acoordinatorisavailable24/7ontheorganandtissuedonorreferrallineat1-888-366-7338,option2.
TRAInInG
Héma-Québecrepresentativesmakethemselvesavailabletoexplaintheprocessforidentifyingandrefer-ringpotential tissuedonors.Training iscompletely freeandequipsprofessionals for thisaspectof theirwork.
Formoreinformation Héma-QuébecProcurementManager Telephone:418-780-4362,ext.2271
DOcumEnTATIOn AVAILABLE TO HEALTH PROFEssIOnALs AnD EsTABLIsHmEnTs
Héma-QuébecprovidesQuebecestablishmentswithspeciallydesigned tools thatsimplifyand facilitateidentificationandreferral.
Héma-Québec website
VisittheHumanTissuessectionoftheHéma-Québecwebsite:www.hema-quebec.qc.ca
standardized Tissue standardized tissue donation Donation Procedure procedure flow chart
PROCÉDURE TYPE POUR LE DON D’ORGANES
PROCÉDURE TYPE POUR LE DON DE TISSUS
EN RELATION AVEC L’ARTICLE 204.1 DE LA LOI SUR LES SERVICES DE SANTÉ ET LES SERVICES SOCIAUX
MARS 2012
Centre hospitalier sans personnel dédié en don d’organes
ThispublicationisavailableontheHéma-Québecwebsite
NE PAS OFFRIR L’OPTION DU DON ÀLA FAMILLE AVANT L’ÉTAPE 3
Prise en charge du processus par Héma-Québec, incluant l’enregistrement d’un consentement téléphonique avec la famille
• VIH-VHB-VHC • Infection systémique active et non traitée • Cancer sanguin (lymphome, leucémie, maladie de Hodgkin) • Alzheimer, Parkinson, démence d’étiologie inconnue
PRÉSENCE D’UN CONSENTEMENT
Colliger : • Formulaire AH 224 • Formulaire SP3 (Déclaration de décès) • Formulaires de transport ambulancier (AS-810 et AS-803P) • Notes au dossier du donneur (48 dernières heures) • Résultats de laboratoire (culture, hémoculture)
ABSENCE D’UN CONSENTEMENT
Présenter l’option du don à la famille et le soutien par un coordonnateur d’Héma-Québec
Consentement Refus
Non Oui
Communiquer avec Héma-Québec :
1 888 366-7338, option 2
Fin de laréférence àHéma-Québec
Fin de laréférence àHéma-Québec
Transmettre les informations médicales nécessaires à Héma-Québec pour la quali�cation du donneur
Réfrigérer le corps (le plus rapidement possible)
1 DONNEUR POTENTIEL DE TISSUS
Personne de 85 ans et moins, vérifier si présence de :
AVANT D’OFFRIR L’OPTION DU DON À LA FAMILLE
■ Vérifier si la carte d’assurance maladie est signée
■ Communiquer avec Héma-Québec :
1 888 366-7338, option 2 Transmettre les informations suivantes : • Nom • Date de naissance • Numéro d’assurance maladie
Héma-Québec fera la véri�cation de la présence d’un consentement aux registres des consentements au don d’organes et de tissus de la Chambre des notaires du Québec (CNQ) ou de la Régie de l’assurance maladie du Québec (RAMQ).
3
2
IDENTIFICATION
RÉFÉRENCE
APPROCHE
4QUALIFICATIONDU DONNEUR ET PRISE EN CHARGE
PROCÉDURE TYPE POUR LE DON DE TISSUS EN RELATION AVEC L’ARTICLE 204.1 (LSSSS)
Patient en mort récente
Outils de référence : www.hema-quebec.qc.ca, section Hôpitaux - Tissus humains Publication Un héritage pour la vie et af�ches disponibles sur le site Web
ThispublicationisavailableontheHéma-Québecwebsite
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
61
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
Quick reference card
Medicalstaffreceiveaquickreferencecardlistingtissuedonoreligibilitycriteria.
A Legacy of Life guide
Whenapersondieswithoutmakingknownhisorherdesiretodonateorgansortissues,thedecisionfallstothefamily.A Legacy of Life is intendedforthose families. Ithelps themconsider the requestandmakeaninformeddecision.
Posters
Aseriesofposterswith short personal accounts fromamedical professional, adonor’s family anda recipient’sfamilystressestheimportanceoftissuedonationinhospitalsettings.
Thispublication isavailableontheHéma-Québecwebsite.
previous view
62
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
ORGAnIZATIOn OF TIssuE DOnATIOn sERVIcEs
PERFORmAncE InDIcATORs
Totracktissuedonationinestablishments,theStandardizedTissueDonationProcedurehasthreeper- formanceindicators.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
63
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
PREREQuIsITEs FOR succEss
Thereareseveralprerequisitestoimprovedorganandtissuedonationperformanceandoutcomes:
•A formalcommitmentby theboardofdirectors,generalmanagement,and theCouncilofPhysicians,Dentists,andPharmacistsingeneralandspecializedcareestablishmentswitharealcultureoforganandtissuedonationtopromotingdonationforthebenefitofpatientsonwaitinglistsandofthecommunity asawhole
•Strongleadershipfromthewholemanagementteam,activelysupportedbythegeneraldirectorandthedirectorofprofessionalservices,withtheparticipationofmedicalteamsandcriticalcareunitmanagers,aswellasadulymandateddonationcommitteethatisactivelysupportedbytheestablishment
•Sufficientorganandtissuedonationtrainingforphysiciansandclinicalstaff,withprioritygiventonursesand respiratory therapistsworking incritical care—firstwhen theyarehired,duringdepartmentalon- boarding,andthenthroughcontinuingprofessionaldevelopmentandskillsmaintenance
•Acommitmenttointroducingbestpracticesfororganandtissuedonation,aswellasoptimalorganizationofservices,includingregular,ongoinganalysisoftheestablishment’soutcomesandperformance
•Recognitionoftheinterdependenciesbetweenidentification,procurement,andtransplantationcentresandestablishmentofthemechanismsneededtoensurecoordinationofdonorservicesateverystage oftheprocessatthelocal,regional,andinterregionallevels
•Communicationsactivities, includingawareness trainingandeducational initiativesdirectedat institu- tionalmanagers,physicians,andstaff,aswellasthecommunityandthegeneralpublic
•ClosecooperationwithTransplantQuébecandHéma-Québectocarryoutorganortissuedonationsfortransplantsorgrafts
•Poolingofexpertiseandsupportforresearch
previous view
64
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
cOncLusIOn
Thisorganizationalframeworkfororgandonationandtissuedonationservicesconstitutesaseriouseffortto guide establishments to better structure donation activities and improve outcomes locally and inter- dependentlywithotherestablishments. Improving theperformanceof individualestablishmentsand theentirenetworkwillrequireafirmcommitmentfromboardsofdirectorsandmanagementtodevelopingagenuinedonationculture.Carewillbeneededandsufficientresourceswillhavetobeprovidedinordertoorganizeorganandtissuedonationactivitiesinlinewitheachestablishment’sresponsibilities.Theestab- lishmentwillneedtotakelocalspecificitiesthatapplytoorganandtissuedonationintoaccount.
Ongoingeffortdedicatedtotraining,improvementofpractices,ongoingresultsassessment,clearcoordi-nation,andcontinuedteamengagementwillberequiredtoimproveperformanceandhelpestablishmentsmeetaccreditationrequirements.ClosecooperationwithTransplantQuébecandHéma-Québecwillalso beakeytosuccess.Indoingthis,establishmentswillagainshowtheircommitmenttoservingtheircom-munitiesandfulfillingaresponsibilitytothepublic.
Collectively,wewillbetteraddresstheneedsofwaitingpatientswhilehonouringthewishesofmillionsofQuebecerswhohaveagreedtodonationaftertheirdeaths.Theseeffortswillsavelivesandimprovethequalityoflifeofthousandsofpeople.Byactivelytakingonthissocialresponsibility,generalandspecializedcareestablishmentswillhelptosavethelivesofpeoplewaitingforhearts,lungs,andlivers.Theywillalsomakeskingraftspossibleforpeoplewithsevereburnsandeyetissuegraftstorestorepeople’ssight.Andtheywillenablemanytostopdialysistreatment,generatingsubstantialsavingslocallyandforthesystemasawhole.Thebenefitsforindividuals,families,andsocietyasawholewillbenumerous.
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
65
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
APPEnDIXEs
APPEnDIX 1
DIsTIncTIOn BETWEEn nDD AnD DcD
Source:TransplantQuébec
Formore informationaboutdefinitions, identificationandeligibility, visit theTransplantQuébecwebsite:transplantquebec.ca/en/identification-and-eligibility
nEuROLOGIcAL DETERmInATIOn OF DEATH (nDD)
91.5% of donors in 2013
MeetstheNDDcriteria
Vitalfunctionsartificiallymaintained(removalwillcausecirculationtostop)
Potentialremovalof8organs(heart,lungs,liver[potentialbipartition],pancreas)
▼
▼
▼
▼
▼
▼
DOnATIOn AFTER cARDIOcIRcuLATORy DEATH (DcD)
8.5% of donors in 2013
Noneurologicaldeathandwithdrawaloflife-sustainingtherapy(LST),regardlessoforgandonation
LSTwithdrawninacontrolledenvironment(operatingroom)
Deathdeclaredfiveminutesaftercardiacarrest
Potentialremovalof6organs(kidneys,liver,lungs,pancreas)
previous view
66
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
APPEnDIXEs
Organ procurement centres
InQuebec,ninehealthandsocial servicesestablishmentsat 12sitesaredesignatedasprocurementcentres:
• Centrehospitalierdel’UniversitédeMontréal(CHUM)– HôpitalNotre-DameandHôpitalSaint-Luc•McGillUniversityHealthCentre(MUHC)– RoyalVictoriaHospital,MontrealChildren’sHospital andMontrealGeneralHospital•CHUSainte-Justine•HôpitalMaisonneuve-Rosemont•HôpitalduSacré-CœurdeMontréal•CentrehospitalieruniversitairedeSherbrooke(CHUS)•CHUdeQuébec•CSSSdeChicoutimi•CSSSLesEskersdel’Abitibi
Removalcanalsooccurinothergeneralandspecializedcareestablishmentswhereapotentialorgandonorhasbeeniden- tified,particularlyaftercardiocirculatorydeath.
Organ transplantation centres and programs
InQuebec,eightestablishmentsofferorgantransplantationprogramsat10sites
n Centrehospitalierdel’UniversitédeMontréal(CHUM)– HôpitalNotre-Dame• Lungtransplants•Heart-lungtransplants•Kidneytransplants(includinglivingdonors)•Pancreastransplants
n Centrehospitalierdel’UniversitédeMontréal(CHUM)– HôpitalSaint-Luc• Livertransplants(includinglivingdonors)
n McGillUniversityHealthCentre(MUHC)– RoyalVictoriaHospital• Hearttransplants•Heart-lungtransplants•Livertransplants•Pancreastransplants•Kidneytransplants(includinglivingdonors)
n McGillUniversityHealthCentre(MUHC)– MontrealChildren’sHospital• Hearttransplants•Kidneytransplants(includinglivingdonors)
n HôpitalMaisonneuve-Rosemont• Kidneytransplants(includinglivingdonors)
n CHUSainte-Justine• Hearttransplants•Livertransplants(includinglivingdonors)•Kidneytransplants(includinglivingdonors)
n MontrealHeartInstitute• Hearttransplants
n CentrehospitalieruniversitairedeSherbrooke(CHUS)– HôpitalFleurimont• Kidneytransplants(includinglivingdonors)
n CHUdeQuébec–Hôtel-DieudeQuébec• Kidneytransplants(includinglivingdonors)
n Institutuniversitairedecardiologieetdepneumologie deQuébec• Hearttransplants
Establishments offering living donor programs
• CHUdeQuébec–Hôtel-DieudeQuébec(kidney)•CHUS(kidney)•MUHC–RoyalVictoriaHospital(kidney)•HôpitalMaisonneuve-Rosemont(kidney)•CHUM–HôpitalNotre-Dame(kidney)•CHUM–HôpitalSaint-Luc(liver)
Pediatric establishments offeringliving donor programs
• CHUSainte-Justine(kidney)•MUHC–MontrealChildren’sHospital(kidney)
APPEnDIX 2
ORGAn PROcuREmEnT cEnTREs AnD ORGAn TRAnsPLAnTATIOn cEnTREs
previous view
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES
67
TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
APPEnDIXEs
Patients on the waiting list and transplant recipients in Quebec, by region, 2013
TOTAL (ALL ORGAns) KIDnEy
PATIEnTs On TRAnsPLAnT PATIEnTs On TRAnsPLAnT WAITInG LIsT REcIPIEnTs WAITInG LIsT REcIPIEnTs
ADmInIsTRATIVE REGIOn POPuLATIOn % OF (n=1,047) % (n=503) % (n=782) % (n=265) %By REGIOn* QuEBEc
POPuLATIOn
01Bas-Saint-Laurent 199,834 2 % 23 2.2 % 7 1.4 % 18 2.3 % 5 1.9 %
02Saguenay–Lac-Saint-Jean 273,009 3 % 26 2.5 % 18 3.6 % 15 1.9 % 7 2.6 %
03CapitaleNationale 707,984 9 % 76 7.3 % 36 7.2 % 45 5.8 % 14 5.3 %
04-17Mauricie–Centre-du-Québec** 498,274 6 % 38 3.6 % 19 3.8 % 33 4.2 % 6 2.3 %
05Estrie 315,487 4 % 37 3.5 % 14 2.8 % 29 3.7 % 11 4.2 %
06Montréal 1,981,672 25 % 360 34.4 % 162 32.2 % 284 36.3 % 95 35.8 %
07Outaouais 372,329 5 % 39 3.7 % 21 4.2 % 24 3.1 % 12 4.5 %
08Abitibi-Témiscamingue 146,753 2 % 14 1.3 % 9 1.8 % 14 1.8 % 5 1.9 %
09Côte-Nord 95,647 1 % 13 1.2 % 2 0.4 % 9 1.2 % 1 0.4 %
10Nord-du-Québec 42,993 1 % 9 0.9 % 3 0.6 % 7 0.9 % 1 0.4 %
11Gaspésie–Îles-delaMadeleine 92,536 1 % 10 1.0 % 5 1.0 % 8 1.0 % 1 0.4 %
12Chaudière-Appalaches 408,188 5 % 30 2.9 % 12 2.4 % 23 2.9 % 10 3.8 %
13Laval 409,718 5 % 57 5.4 % 27 5.4 % 47 6.0 % 10 3.8 %
14Lanaudière 476,941 6 % 39 3.7 % 21 4.2 % 32 4.1 % 10 3.8 %
15Laurentides 563,139 7 % 63 6.0 % 23 4.6 % 47 6.0 % 14 5.3 %
16Montérégie 1,470,252 18 % 175 16.7 % 100 19.9 % 125 16.0 % 53 20.0 %
OutsideQuebecorinformationnotsentbyhospitalfortheregion 38 3.6 % 24 4.8 % 22 2.8 % 10 3.8 %
Total 8,054,756 100 % 1,047 100 % 503 100 % 782 100 % 265 *** 100 %
*Source:StatisticsCanada,adaptedbyInstitutdelastatistiqueduQuébec,February6,2013.**Centre-du-Québecisregion17,butthedatahavebeencombinedwithregion04.***Kidneyanddoublekidneytransplant.
Facts about organ donors
• Potentialorgandonorsareararebreed,accountingforonlyabout1.4%ofpatientswhodieinhospital.
•Adeceasedpotentialdonorwhoisnotidentifiedcanresult inthedeathsofseveralpeople.
•Adeceasedpersoncandonatehisorherheart,liver,lungs,kidneys,pancreas,andintestines.
•Thecauseofdeathfororgandonorsisassociatedwith –Acerebrovascularaccident(CVA)(50%) – Headtrauma(25%) –Cerebralanoxiaorothercause(25%)•Organ donors come from all walks of life and all cultures.Eachdonorisassessedatthetimeofdonation,regardless ofsex,sexualorientation,ethnicorigin,orreligion.
•Organdonorsare foundthroughout theprovinceandatallestablishments,rangingfromonetoseveraldonorsperyear.
• InQuebec,theoldestdeceasedorgandonorwas88yearsold and the youngest, barely 48 hours old. A76-year-old donorsavedfivelives.
•Theaveragedonorin2012was50.1yearsold.In10years,theaveragedonoragehas increasedbysixyears from44 tojustover50.
•Organdonationoftengivesdonors’familiesacertainsenseofcomfortandgivesmeaningtotheworkofmedicalstaff.
•A livingorgandonorcangiveonekidney,a lobe fromthe liver,andoccasionallyalobefromalung.
Patients on the waiting list and transplant recipients in Quebec, by region
Thetablebelowshowsthe2013statisticsforallorgansandjustkidneys,expressedinabsolutenumbersofpeopleandinpercentagesoftheQuebecpopulation.
APPEnDIX 3
ORGAn DOnATIOn PROGREss REPORT – ADDITIOnAL InFORmATIOn
previous view
68
ORGANIZATIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR ORGAN DONATION AND TISSUE DONATION SERVICES TABLE OF cOnTEnTs
APPEnDIXEs
Transplant Québec advisory committees
The medical scientific advisory committee consists of 11physiciansfromeachhospitalcentre,universityinstitute,oruniversity-affiliated hospital centre performing transplants orinvolved in transplantation, anduniversity-affiliatedhospitalcentreinvolvedinorgandonation,aswellasthemedicaldirectorofTransplantQuébec.Thecommitteeistaskedwithreviewingandstandardizingmedicalandscientificstandardsandrecom-mendingtotheboardofdirectorspoliciesandproceduresforidentifyingandmanagingdonors,andorganremovalandallo-cation.
Thiscommitteeisassistedbythreesubcommittees(chest,liver,andkidney-pancreas)madeupof representatives fromeachtransplantprogramandonerepresentativeforQuebec’shisto-compatibility laboratories.Theprimary roleof thesesubcom-mittees is to propose state-of-the-art allocation proceduresthattakescientificandmedicaldataintoconsideration.
Theethics committeehaseightmembers.Itspurposeistopromoteethicalreflectionwithintheorganizationontheethicalissuesraisedbyorgandonationandbythepoliciesandproce-duresassociatedwithorganallocation.Thecommitteeregularlyprovidesadvicetotheboardofdirectors,towhichitreports.
FInAncIAL suPPORT – usEFuL DEFInITIOns
• Accepted but not used donor – Deceaseddonorforwhomthe
assessmentandorgandonation processwasinitiatedbutwho,for medicalorotherreasons,couldnot continuetotheorganprocurement stage
• Accepted, retrieved from an invalidated donor – Deceaseddonor
whoisinvalidatedintheoperating roomandfromwhomnoorganswere removedortransplanted
Formoreinformation,refertoTransplantQuébec’sidentificationandpaymentpolicyfororgandonationfromdeceaseddonors.
• Identification centre –Establishment (hospital)thatrecommendedanorgan donorwhowasacceptedbyTransplant Québec
• Procurement centre –Establishment (hospital)whereallstepsleadingupto andincludingorganprocurementtake place
• Accepted organ donor – Deceased donorwho,afteranassessmentbya TransplantQuébecclinicalcoordinator/ advisor,meetsthemedicolegaland logisticalcriteriafororgandonation
• Accepted and used donor – Deceased donorfromwhomatleastoneorgan hasbeentransplanted
APPEnDIX 4
TRAnsPLAnT QuÉBEc suPPORT FOR EsTABLIsHmEnTs – ADDITIOnAL InFORmATIOn
Thefollowingfixedsumsarepaidtoestablishments:
n Identificationcentres• $1,000foreachorgandonoraccepted byTransplantQuébec(sinceMay17, 2013;previously$500)
n Procurementcentres• $7,000foreachorgandonoraccepted andused(sinceMay17,2013; previously$4,500)• $1,000foreachorgandonoraccepted, retrievedfromandinvalidated
TransplantQuébecpaysthesesumstoeachestablishmentannuallyinthesummerfollowingthefiscalyear.
communications and public relations
Activitiesareorganizedthroughouttheyear,including
•Comparisonofstatisticsforthecalendaryearwiththoseof thepreviousyear(mid-February)•NationalOrganandTissueDonationWeek(lastfullweekin April)•WorldOrganDonationandTransplantationDay(mid-October)
AdditionallyTransplantQuébecregularlypublishestheliaisonnewsletterAu cœur du don to informconcernedparties andpartners of initiatives in establishments and communities, aswellastrainingactivitiesandtheavailabilityofnewtools.Thenewsletter can be downloaded from the TransplantQuébecwebsitetransplantquebec.ca/en/publications.
Thewebsiteprovidesawealthofinformation,includingstatis-tics.It isareferencesourceforthepublicandmedia,aswell asprofessionals.
Theorganization’sannualreport isalsoavaluablesourceofinformation on donation inQuebec, year by year. Annual re-portsforrecentyearscanbeviewedattransplantquebec.ca/en/annual-reports.
Formoreinformation,contactTransplantQuébec’scommuni-cationsandpublicrelationsDepartment.
previous view