operation management in baby memorial hospital
DESCRIPTION
How a hospital works,,TRANSCRIPT
DERRICK VIJAYAN (015)
G ANANDKUMAR (017)
MOLUCHANG AO (031)
SABIR SALAM (041)
SABITH SALIM (042)
SHETH KALP CHETAN (047)
SUSMIT DANDAPAT (056)
TULASI PRABHAKARBABU (057)
Operations Management Project
PROCESS FLOW ANALYSIS AT BABY MEMORIAL HOSPITAL
Guide: Prof. Sanjay Jharkaria
Group 4, Section A
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 2
Contents
Introduction ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..………. 2
BMH facilities…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 4
Departments ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 4
Laboratory facilities ……………………………………………………………………………………………………... 4
Operation Theatre .…………………………………………………………………………………………………….... 5
BMH Academy ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 6
Community services ……………………………………………………………………………………..……………… 6
Organization Structure ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 7
Major departments …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 8
Layout ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 11
Treatment Flow ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 14
Process flow and calculation ……………………………………………………………………………………………….…… 17
Front desk and Reception …………………………………………………………………………………....…….. 17
Cash Counter ……………………………………………………..………………………………………………..…….. 18
Departments …………………………………………………….……………………………………….……..………… 19
Pharmacy …………………………………………………………..……………………………………………………….. 21
Recommendations ………………………………………………………..…………………………………………………………. 23
BMH Layout ……………………………………………………..…………………………………………………………. 23
Front desk and reception ………………………………..…………………………………………………………… 23
Cash Counter …………………………………………………..………………………………………………………….. 24
Departments …………………………………………………………………………………………………..…………… 25
Pharmacy ………………………………………………………………………………………………………..…………… 26
SAP Analysis and LAP synthesis …………………………………………………………………………………..……………. 28
References ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 30
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 3
Introduction
Baby Memorial Hospital is one of the leading multi specialty hospitals in Kerala. Baby
Memorial Hospital (BMH) is located in Indira Gandhi Road, Calicut which is pretty much the
heart of Kozhikode. It is in proximity of bypass road and the Main bus station thus very
convenient to patients from near and far.
The hospital was named in memory of Late. Mr. K.C. Varghese (lovingly called 'Baby'), father
of Dr. K.G. Alexander, MD, the Founder Chairman. Dr K.G. Alexander combined his
formidable spirit of entrepreneurship and a deep rooted commitment to ethical patient care
to forge the foundation of this hospital. From humble beginnings in 1987, the hospital is now
acknowledged by one and all as one of the best apical care institutions in Kerala. BMH has
received various recognitions for its quality work. BMH is an NABH accredited ISO 9001:2000
and 14001:2004 accredited hospital.
Started with 56 beds in rented premises, BMH today has its own eleven-storied building with
more than 450 beds. It has all the Medical and Surgical specialties and super-specialties,
headed by highly qualified and experienced doctors, most of whom are retired professors
and heads of departments of various Medical Colleges in Kerala. A team of 100 doctors &
750 medical, Nursing, Para medical and Administrative staff work together here. This
remarkable growth has been achieved in such a short span of time mainly due to the highly
professional treatment and excellent nursing care ensured by the management. The hospital
has an enviable reputation for its ethical and honest medical practices which also attracts the
patients.
BMH is on the fast track for modernization. State-of-the-art facilities for all the departments
are constantly installed resulting in achieving a high level of sophistication. The Operation
Theatre Complex has 14 fully equipped, international class operation theatres, which is the
only one of its kind in the region. The stainless steel wall cladding, anti-static flooring and
laminar flow air-conditioning system with micro filters ensure zero percent post-operative
infection rates. There are separate, fully fledged ICUs for medical, cardiology, neurology,
neurosurgery, neonatology, post-transplant and other post-operative and gynaecology and
obstetrics cases with a total of 92 beds as well as a 24 hour Accident and Trauma Care Unit.
BMH ranks amongst the top multi-specialty, tertiary care, referral hospitals in Kerala.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 4
BMH Facilities
DEPARTMENTS The college at present has 29 departments and is set to add more in future
1. Anaesthesiology and critical care. 2. Cardiology. 3. Cardio thoracic care. 4. Child & Adolescent guidance. 5. Dental. 6. Dermatology. 7. ENT & Audiology. 8. Gastroenterology. 9. General Vascular & Laparoscopic Surgery. 10. Gynaecology & Obstetrics. 11. Internal Medicine. 12. Medical Oncology. 13. Nephrology. 14. Neurology. 15. Neurosurgery. 16. Ophthalmology. 17. Orthopaedics. 18. Paediatrics & Neonatology. 19. Paediatric surgery. 20. Plastic, Reconstructive & Micro vascular Surgery. 21. Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation. 22. Radio Diagnosis & Imaging. 23. Respiratory Medicine. 24. Reproductive Medicine & Laparoscopic Surgery. 25. Urology & Transplant Surgery. 26. Psychological Medicine. 27. Cosmetology. 28. Dental & Maxillo facial surgery. 29. Accident & Emergency unit.
LABORATORY SERVICES BMH has one of the most reliable lab services in Kerala. Their facilities includes-
1. Fully automated Biochemistry Analyzer.
2. Blood gas analyzer (ABG).
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 5
3. Coagulation Profile Analyzer.
4. Automatic Cell Counter.
5. Electrolyte Analyzer.
6. Elisa reader.
7. Modern Histopathology and Microbiology labs.
8. Blood Bank.
Operation theatre
The operation theatre of BMH is equipped with:
1. Fourteen operating rooms. 2. Stainless steel wall cladding. 3. Zero percent post operative infection. 4. Antistatic flooring. 5. Laminar flow air conditioning system with hepa filters. 6. Equipped with world class Multi-parameter Invasive and Non-invasive Monitors,
Operating Tables, Anaesthesia Ventilators, Diathermies, C-arm Image intensifiers, Infusion Pumps etc.
7. A well equipped 20-bedded surgical ICU with most modern resuscitative facilities.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 6
BMH Academy BMH also runs an academy which provides add on to the hospital management. The
students also get world class facilities and exposure to all types of patients. The various
courses that are available in BMH are:-
Post graduate course – DNB for Doctors
Currently offering in Urology, Anaesthesiology, General Medicine,
Orthopaedics & Paediatrics
Soon to offer Plastic Surgery, Neurology, Obstetrics &Gynaecology.
Baby Memorial College of Nursing
Stared in the year 2002
affiliated to University of Calicut,
Recognized by Kerala Nurses' and Midwives' Council.
Recognized by the Indian Nursing Council, New Delhi.
Has 4 year B. Sc nursing and 2 year M. Sc Nursing
Baby Memorial School Of Nursing
Established in 1995
Recognized by the Kerala Nursing Council & Indian Nursing Council.
3.5 year Diploma course in General Nursing & Midwives
Helpers for Hospital and Nursing Home Course
Course Conducted by JAN SHIKSHAN SANSTHAN.
6 Month course with internship.
Anaesthesia Assistants course
CME programmes
Community Services
The hospital also does community services like free plastic surgery, medical camps,
medical checkup, Epilepsy treatment, Cardiac surgery screening camp etc.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 7
Organization Structure
Chairman and Managing Director
Dr. K. G. Alexander
Medical Director
Prof. T.P.Joseph
Medical Superintendent
Dr.Shaji Thomas John
Diretor Academic Studies
Prof.P.V.Ramana
Exeutive Director
Mrs. Anitha Alexander
General Mananger
Mr.P.V.Rajendr
Dy.Medical Superintendent
Dr.P.K.Inderjit
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 8
Major Departments
CMO
ANAESTHESIOLOGY AND CRITICAL CARE 9
CARDIOLOGY 5
CARDIO THORACIC SURGERY 3
CHILD AND ADOLESCENT GUIDANCE 1
DENTAL 3
DERMATOLOGY 2
ENT & AUDIOLOGY 5
GASTROENTEROLOGY 4
GENERAL,VASCULAR AND LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY 5
GYNAECOLOGY AND OBSTETRICS 11
INTERNAL MEDICINE 9
MEDICAL ONCOLOGY 1
NEPHROLOGY 3
NEUROLOGY 5
NEUROSURGERY 3
OPHTHALMOLOGY 2
ORTHOPEDICS 7
PAEDIATRICS AND NEONATOLOGY 5
PAEDIATRICS SURGERY 3
PLASTIC,RECONSTRUCTIVE AND MICRO-VASCULAR SURGERY 5
PHYSICAL MEDICINE AND REHABILITATION 7
RADIO DIAGNOSIS AND IMAGING 2
RESPIRATORY MEDICINE 3
REPRODUCTIVE MEDICINE AND LAPROSCOPIC SURGERY 3
UROLOGY AND TRANSPLANT SURGERY 3
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 9
Departments and number of available doctors
Paediatrics & Neonatology Baby Memorial hospital is in fact the first ‘Baby Friendly Hospital’ in Malabar. It is in
level III, 15 Bedded Neonatal ICU with incubators, radiant warmers, advanced Neonatal
ventilators for managing extreme premature neonates. It also has Facilities for the
management of babies with low birth weight, respiratory distress syndrome, hyaline
membrane disease, congenital cardiac anomalies, metabolic problems in neonates, single &
double surface phototherapy for the management of neonatal jaundice; baby clinic with free
immunization services, rehabilitation facilities for children with special needs, special clinic
for children with Down’s syndrome, Epilepsy clinic for children & an Adolescent care clinic for
older children. The hospital also ensures that the medical staff is available 24x7.
Cardiology This department has a state-of-the-art 12 bedded Intensive Coronary Care Unit (ICCU)
with ultra-modern resuscitative devices, external pacemaker, multi parameter monitors,
computerized central monitoring system etc. Temporary & permanent cardiac pacemaker
implantations are regularly performed. Colour Doppler Echocardiography having Tissue
harmonic imaging, colour kinesis & acoustic quantification, Burdick computerized tread mill
stress testing, Holter monitoring recorders & analyzing. It also boasts the first Multi-plane
Trans Oesophageal Echo (TOE) facility of its kind in North Kerala.
Neurology
Baby memorial hospital has a dedicated, 10 bedded Neurology ICU with the
latest monitoring equipments. Testing facilities include digital EEG with brain mapping,
video EEG, EMG and Nerve Conduction studies. Special clinics for epilepsy, movement
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 10
disorders & neuromuscular disorders, behavioral neurology are also available. Neuro-
radiology facilities like spiral CT & 4-vessel Angiogram are one of the best in Kerala.
Gynaecology & Obstetrics
Baby Memorial hospital conducts maximum number of deliveries in the private sector
in North Kerala. They have treatment for all gynecological disorders and specialists in dealing
with high Risk Pregnancy. They have facilities for treatment for both male & female
infertility as well as laparoscopic hysterectomy and ovarian surgeries. The department is
headed by a retired Medical college professor and has 10 specialists.
Internal Medicine
Baby Memorial Hospital is a regional centre of excellence for the treatment of all
medical disorders. A fully fledged Intensive Care Unit & Respiratory Care Unit is available,
and is equipped with sophisticated Ventilators and Multi parameter Monitors. A large
number of critically ill patients are successfully managed by a team of dedicated doctors.
ENT & Audiology Outpatient procedures like otoendoscopy, diagnostic nasal endoscopy, vertigo
management with practical repositioning manoeuvre, removal of foreign bodies of ear and
nose are often of top quality. Aetiological Services done includes pure tone eudiometry,
BERA, Speech and voice evaluation and voice therapy.
Operative procedures performed include micro ear surgeries, nasal surgeries, surgeries of
pharynx, video endoscopic and micro laryngeal procedures, partial and total larynxgectomies
as well as Head & Neck Surgeries.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 11
Layout
BMH is a 480-bed hospital with about 10
ICUs and 14 operation theatres set in about 11-
floors. The hospital consists of a number of
different functionalities such as front desk,
Pharmacy, outpatient areas, in-patient areas,
Emergency care, other specialty services,
laboratory and diagnostic equipments,
Administration, Staff areas, Food and other services etc. An efficient layout should b e aimed at
providing following features:
Provide optimal functional adjacencies. These adjacencies should be based on a detailed
functional program which describes the hospital's intended operations from the
standpoint of patients, staff, and supplies.
Make efficient use of space by locating support spaces so that they may be shared
by adjacent functional areas, and by making prudent use of multi- purpose
spaces.
Provide a well organized and efficient logistics system including elevators.
Promote staff efficiency by minimizing distance of necessary travel between frequently
used spaces.
Increase the comfort of patients by placing mostly accessed functionalities in easily
reachable locations.
At BMH the OP area and emergency care unit is located at the ground floor itself, which
provides sudden action in case of emergencies and contain majority of crowd coming to
OP areas to the ground floor itself. A detailed layout of ground floor is provided in the
next page. From the layout we can see most of the essential functionalities such
pharmacy, labs, canteen services etc are provided at the ground floor itself and are
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 12
placed at optimum locations. Analysis of location various functionalities are as following.
Out-patient: The functionalities required by out-patients such as Registration
counter, cash-payment, majority of consulting rooms, Laboratory, waiting areas
etc are optimally located around a central activity centre. This minimizes the
distance to be travelled between various functionalities.
Registration desk: Enquiry cum new registration and cash-payment cum ID issue
desks are separately located yet nearer in order to prevent over-crowding in front
of a single desk. Also the medical records and accounts departments are optimally
placed just behind the cash-payment cum ID issue desk to decrease transfer
times.
Pharmacy: It is separated from the general crowd area and is located towards the
exit so that the patients can buy the prescribed medicines before they leave the
hospital hassle free.
Emergency Care: It is located separated from the general areas. It has a separate
entrance and is attached with an ambulance bay. Hence emergency situations can
be handled effectively with high priority
Consulting Rooms: Majority of the consulting rooms are provided in the ground
floor itself with the exception of few departments. An improvement can be done
in this regard. The waiting areas are provided commonly to different departments
which provide efficient use of the limited available space.
Canteen: It is also provided in the ground floor at the back to separate the crowd.
It can be entered both from inside and out-side.
Administration: Administrative wing is again located at the ground floor. Though
it is placed optimally behind the accounts department, using up the limited space
in the ground floor for admin, which doesn’t directly come in contact with the
patient, is not properly justified.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 13
Legend
1. Pharmacy
2. Gynec Dept
3. Lift & Stairs to IP areas
4. Reception/New Registration
5. Cash/ID issue/Old Registration
6. Medical Records Department
7. Accounts Department
8. Laboratory
9. Lift 2
10. Administration area
11. Stairs and Lift to Theatres
12. To Consulting Rooms
13. Emergency Handling Area
14. GM’s Room
15. Ambulance Bay
16. Canteen
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 14
Treatment Process
1. New Registration: Done at enquiry cum new Registration counter. There are two people
at this counter. They give Details regarding the required department number and
availability of the doctors.
2. Cash Payment: Done at cash counters opposite to new registration counter. There are
four counters at this desk. There will be a registration fee for new patients and
consulting fee for all patients.
3. ID issue: After Payment, the patient is issued an ID card from the same counter. ID card
has the following details.
i. Patients Name
ii. Patient ID no.
iii. Date
iv. Department Name/Number
v. Doctors name
4. Old Patients: Old patients can directly go the cash counters and after registering their ID
no. and payment if required, they can go to their previously allotted departments.
5. Consulting: A file containing detail of each department is forwarded to the concerned
dept, where he is to be treated. Average waiting before consulting time is about 20-30
minutes, which at present can go upto 1 hour during peak hours. Patients are generally
handled by junior doctors. Only major cases are handled by senior doctors.
6. Post-Consultation: After consultation,
a. Some cases maybe recommended for In-patient. There will be another
registration process at the previously mentioned counter and patient will be
allotted respective room after payment of cash deposit.
b. Some patients will have to take tests from laboratory and meet the doctor again
the same day with the results. No registration is required again in this case.
c. Some patients will have to meet the doctor again at a later time. The patient can
book an appointment in advance in this case.
7. Pharmacy: Patients can buy the prescribed medicines at the pharmacy. Process at
pharmacy is explained separately.
Emergency Handling
A separate area is available for emergency handling. An ambulance bay is attached to it
and it has got a separate entrance. Process here is slightly different. The registration process is
relaxed and quick here. Patients will be directly carried to required departments with high
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 15
priority and there will be no waiting time. A detailed and proper registration process similar to
ordinary patients will be done at a later stage.
Process Flow Chart
Old Patient Emergency Care
Patient Arrival
New
Registration
Cash payment
and Id Issue
Consulting of
Doctors
Laboratory
Pharmacy
Exit
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 16
Process Flow Analysis and Capacity Calculation
Operational analysis of various departments is done to calculate the capacity and to find any
bottlenecks if any. Then by the analysis of the present and future demand, we can optimize the
process flow and thereby the capacity of the department.
Front desk and Reception
Time taken to meet the receptionist = 75 seconds
New patients coming per day peak hours = 1200 to 1400
I.e. approx 1300
Peak Hours
Assuming 80 % of them come during peak hours
Total number of patients during peak hour =0.80 X 1300
=1040 patients.
No: of receptionist = 2
Peak hour shift = 10 hours (8:30 am – 6:30 pm)
No of man hours =20
Maximum patients serviced = 20 X 3600/ 75
=960 patients.
Clearly, there is over utilization during peak hours (108.33 % of full capacity).
Off peak hours
Of the remaining i.e. during non-peak hours
No: of patients = Total no: of patients’ coming- no of patients coming during peak hours
= 1300 – 1040
=240 patients.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 17
No of receptionist = 1
Non peak hour shift = 14 hours
No: of Man hours = 14
Maximum no: of patients that can be serviced = 14 X 3600/75 = 672 patients.
I.e. it works at 35.71% of full capacity at this shift.
No need for improvement or change during this time.
Cash Counter
This section has 5 persons. They collect the slip; which is forwarded from the receptionist via,
the patients themselves. Depending upon the availability of doctors / choice of the patients;
they issue an Id which contains details of the patient as well as the name of the doctor. A
moving staff (usually an assistant periodically takes the file and forward to the concerned
department). Since and existing customer already have an Id card; servicing them takes less
time
Time taken to service a new patient = 3 minute
Time taken to service an old patient = 1 minute
During Peak Hours:
No of Receptionist = 5
Peak hour shift = 10 hours
Total man hours = 50 hours
No of new patients coming = 1040 (refer previous page)
Assuming the number of old patients are about 30% of new patients;
No of old patients = 0.30 X 1020
=306 = approx. 300 old patients.
Time taken to service new patients =1020 X 3 minutes
=3060 minutes =51 hours
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 18
Time taken to service new patients = 300 X 1 minute
=5 hours
Total service time = 56 hours.
Working at 112% of full capacity.
During non peak hours:
No: of cashiers =2
Non peak hour shift = 14 hours
Total man hours = 28
No of new patients = 240
No: of old patients =0.30 X 240= 72
Time to serve new patients = 240 X 3/60 hours
= 12 hours.
Time to serve old patients = 72 X 1/ 60 hours
=1.2 hours
Total service time = 13.2 hours
I.e. it works at about 47.14% of full capacity.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 19
Departments The patients after registering go to their respective departments where they consult their
respective doctors. The servicing time per patient differs from departments to departments and
also among patients. However, for analysis purpose, we take the average time to service a
patient in a particular department called Average Servicing Time (AST).
The number of doctors, both senior and junior, varies according to the demand for that
particular department. The shift time for senior doctors are 4 hours, while it is 8 hours for
junior doctors. Sometimes, junior doctors assist senior doctors also.
The distribution of patients and the capacity of that particular department are calculated
below.
Analysis
Paediatrics
No. of patients arriving during peak hours: 63
Max. Service capacity: 86
Running at 73% of full capacity. Therefore no change needed
No. of patients arriving during Off peak hours: 12
Max. Service capacity: 51
Running at 23% of full capacity. This process is seriously underutilized.
No. of Doctors
Doctor hours
Patients arrival
Capacity
Department Junior Senior Total hours Peak
Off peak
AST (min)
Peak hours
Other hours Peak
Off peak
Pediatrics 3 2 32 20 12 14 63 12 86 51
Cardiology 2 3 28 20 8 18 75 15 67 27
Neurology 3 2 32 20 12 16 36 9 75 45
Gynecology 6 5 68 52 16 35 85 20 89 27
Internal Medicine 5 4 56 56 0 10 410 0 336 0
ENT 3 2 32 24 8 20 55 10 72 24
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 20
Cardiology
No. of patients arriving during peak hours: 75
Max. Service capacity: 67
Needs improvement since this department is running at 112% of full capacity.
No. of patients arriving during Off peak hours: 15
Max. Service capacity: 27
Running at 55% of full capacity. Therefore no improvement needed.
Neurology
No. of patients arriving during peak hours: 36
Max. Service capacity: 75
This indicates under utilization (48% of full capacity)
No. of patients arriving during Off peak hours: 9
Max. Service capacity: 45
This indicates under utilization (20% of full capacity)
Gynaecology
No. of patients arriving during peak hours: 85
Max. Service capacity: 89
The demand is close to capacity ( 96% of full capacity). Some improvements needed.
No. of patients arriving during Off peak hours: 20
Max. Service capacity: 27
Running at 74% of full capacity. Therefore no improvement needed.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 21
Internal Medicine
No. of patients arriving during peak hours: 410
Max. Service capacity: 336
Seriously over utilized – running at 122% of full capacity.
ENT No. of patients arriving during peak hours: 55
Max. Service capacity: 72
Running at 76% of full capacity. Therefore no change needed.
No. of patients arriving during Off peak hours: 10
Max. Service capacity: 24
Running at 42% of full capacity Therefore no improvement needed.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 22
Pharmacy
The pharmacy is located at the ground floor near the main entrance/ exit. So it’s convenient for
people coming from outside to get medicines easily. There is only one entrance; which is
located perpendicular to the main entrance. Also it is adjacent to the Gynaecology &obstetrics
department as well as operation theatre. This makes it easy for the pregnant ladies to get
medicines without much difficulty. Besides medicines, injections and anaesthesia needed for
surgeries are obtained without any delay.
It has 5 pharmacists and one of them also acts as cashier.
The layout is as shown:
Key: C: Cashier cum pharmacist
S1-S4: Other pharmacists.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 23
The Time taken for each customer to enter and exit the pharmacy were noted and tabulated as
shown below. (Time was noted only till the 5 customers had completed the shopping)
Customer no
Time entered(sec)
Time left(sec) Time spent in Pharmacy
1 0 173 173
2 34 272 238
3 197 443 246
4 312 508 196
5 345 - -
6 363 546 183
7 452 -
Calculation: Time for 5 customers to finish shopping = 546 sec
Average time for serving one customer = 546/5
= 108 sec.
Average time spent by a customer in pharmacy = (173+238+246+196+183)/5
=207.2 sec
So a patient spends half of the time waiting to be serviced. So there is a need for improvement.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 24
Recommendations
BMH Layout
Here the administration wing is not an essential part in the ground floor, while providing all out
patient consulting rooms in the ground floor itself will greatly ease the effort for patients. So we
suggest re-locating the admin Area to a higher floor and Bring down the consulting rooms in the
higher floors to the area previously used up by the administration wing.
Front desk and reception
So we conclude that the reception is working in full force during peak hours. There may be a
bottle neck; but the employees try to work hard; so as to eliminate the bottle neck. However
there are chances that this may affect their performance & may cause error in forwarding the
type of department needed. Still by experience the receptionists of Baby memorial Hospital are
never heard of misdirecting patients. Even then, hiring another employee will eliminate the
bottleneck.
Cash Counter
At peak hour shift cashiers work is worth 56 hours; even though they themselves have only 50
hours to spend; and during non peak hours they work only at 47.14% of full capacity. One way
of tackling this issue would be appointing an additional cashier. Another way would be using
online registration. This would reduce the rush at reception & cash counter; by approx 5- 10 %
(as seen in some hospitals which have implemented it). Mobile registration too could be
effective; as more people have mobile phones than internet in this part of world. At non peak
time cashiers and receptionists work very less than their full capacity. This could be avoided by
reducing the no: of receptionist to 1. But that may increase the load on him.
Another suggestion is to scrap the reception system at non-peak and appoint 2 cashiers; who
do both the job of cashier and receptionist.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 25
Feasibility calculation of such a system:
Total man hours available at cash counter during non- peak time = 28 hours (from previous
calculations)
Time required for doing cashier’s part of job during non peak hours = 13.2 hours
Time required for doing receptionist’s part of job during non- peak hours = no: of patients X
mean service time = 240 X 75/ 3600
=5 hours
Total time to do both operations = 18.2 hours
Hence this set up will work at 65.2% of full load capacity & eliminate the need of a person at
the reception.
Departments
Cardiology
Currently there is over utilization during peak hours since the patients are around 75 and the
capacity is only 67. We can see that the servicing time of one customer is about 18 minutes or
3.33 customers per hour.
So additional hours to be added = 8/3.33 = 2.4 hours.
If 3 hours are added,
Current capacity will become 77 current demand is 75.
So demand can be satisfied for the time being. Since there are 3 senior doctors, increasing their
shift by 1 hour will increase the servicing capacity by the required three hours.
Again this solution is only temporary and in the long run, they may have to hire at least one
junior doctor which will increase the servicing capacity by 3.33* 8 = 26.6 patients/shift
Neurology
Neurology is seriously underutilized with most of the capacity wasted. During peak hours the
difference in capacity is about 39 patients and during off peak hours it is about 36 patients.
Average servicing time = 16 minutes.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 26
Therefore during peak hours 39*16/60 = 10.4 hours are wasted and during off peak hours,
36*16/60= 9.6 hours are wasted. This wastage can be reduced by reducing the shift time of
senior doctors, who are generally more expensive. In the meantime, the hospital should take
steps to increase its patient inflow and when the capacity increases, they can increase the shift
time back to normal.
Gynaecology
Currently, the gynaecology department is on the verge of full capacity with an average of 85
customers during peak hours and full capacity of 89 customers. By the current trend, the
number of patients is expected to increase and soon they will have to have additional doctor
hours.
Since there are 11 doctors in this department, this additional demand can be satisfied by giving
over time work to doctors on a shift basis so that every doctor will have to do overtime of 4
hours a week, extra.
Therefore increase of doctor hours in one week= 44
Increase of doctor hours in 1 day = 44/7 = 6.3 hours/day
Increase in servicing capacity per day = 6.3 *60/35 = 10.8
Then the current capacity will become 100 during peak hours which will be enough for the time
being.
Internal Medicine
This department faces the most serious over utilization with 410 patients visiting and capacity
of only about 336.
The difference in capacity = 410 – 336 = 74 patients per day
Average servicing time = 10 min
Therefore extra hours needed = 74*10/60 = 12.33 hours.
These 12.33 hours can be gained by hiring 2 junior doctors by whom the department can gain
additional 3.66 hours for future increase which will increase the total capacity to 94 patients
during peak hours.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 27
Pharmacy
In pharmacy, most of the time is spent by patients waiting to be serviced. So, we feel that since
at most of the time there are 3 or 4 customers in the pharmacy (even during peak times the
maximum we noted was 7), there is no need of 5 pharmacists. 3 pharmacists are needed at non
peak hours and 5 pharmacists are needed at peak hours. Also we noted that there is a bottle
neck at the cash counter. This also blocks the easy entry of customers into the pharmacy, as the
cashier is seated near the entrance.
We propose a new layout. The layout is similar; except some minor changes. We plan to
convert one more pharmacist into cashier cum servicing during peak hours, thus having 2
cashiers during peak hours. During non peak hours we may have only one cashier cum
pharmacist and 2 other pharmacists.
Another point to be noted is the position of the main cashier who works during peak hour as
well as non peak hour. He is to be seated away from the entrance. Since most of the patients
buy medicines while leaving the hospital; we propose a new exit at the right most corner of the
shop. This will also be helpful for the customers as they can exit directly from the pharmacy.
Key:
C- cashier/ pharmacist, S - Other Salesman
(P)- working only during peak hours
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 28
SAP analysis and LAP synthesis
The development of new ideas and the development in Information Technology in
recent years have large impacts on organizations. The success or failure of many
business ventures is determined by the implementation of these new ideas in the form of e-
commerce and e-business. Also in health services there is an increase in integration of
Information Technology and there is a need to make this shift across all levels of
health care services. Hospitals have begun to rely on e-commerce based operations to
procure medicines and equipments and also for providing advance reservations for patients.
As SAP LAP Analysis is used in Organizations to adapt new technologies, we have used the SAP-
LAP framework for the implementation of web based advance reservation for existing patients.
Situation Baby Memorial Hospital is one of the leading multi specialty hospitals in Kerala, located
in the heart of Kozhikode.
BNH has won several awards and is an ISO 9001:2000 accredited organization.
BMH is a 480 bedded multi specialty hospital with more than 100 doctors in various
departments.
More than 1000 outdoor patients are serviced in a day.
Around 29 departments with well equipped facilities.
Actors Top Management who takes decisions in various functions.
Over 100 well experienced doctors who services the patients
Over 300 supporting staffs including nurses, pharmacists and attenders
Administration staff responsible for the smooth functioning of the hospital and takes
care of various operational strategies and various transactions,
Process A registration portal is to be incorporated into the current BMH website.
Existing users are given a user id and password so that they can log on to the portal.
Through the portal they can reserve for consulting a particular doctor, view schedules of
doctors and get updates on reservation status and changes in the schedules.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 29
In the long term, the hospital can implement an e-payment facility by which new
patients can pay the registration charges and register and also existing patients to pay
their medical fees.
Learning Implementation of website registration can possibly result in cost reduction.
Ease of use for patients since they don’t have to go in person to register and directly go
to their department for consulting.
Less crowding in front desk means there is no over utilization in the registration counter
which can considerably reduce the servicing time.
Action Top management should take necessary actions to implement the online registration
portal
Take stringent quality checks in the new software for registration allocation.
Conduct periodic maintenance and trouble shooting on the portal
Make patients aware of the new facility which will surely go well with young customers.
Commitment in part of administration and front desk operators.
Performance The online registration portal improves the utilization of front desk and reception.
Less cost is incurred in maintaining the website than the front desk.
Less bottleneck in the reception means that the reserve capacity of the registration
process increases, which can further increase the patient inflow possibly without any
problems.
Reservation known in advance means that the hospital reservation can plan their
schedule in advance and add shifts if needed.
Can learn the trends in patient distribution in various departments and allocate
resources accordingly.
Operations Management Project
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode Page 30
References
Information from the patients, administrative and medical staffs collected
during our field survey.
BMH website - http://www.babymhospital.org/
http://www.babymhospital.org/specialities.php
http://www.babymhospital.org/center.php
Operations Management for competitive Change- Richard B Chase, F Robert Jacobs, Nicholas J
Aquilano, Nitin K Agarwal
Prof. Sanjay Jharkaria Class Lecture notes
SAP-LAP Models, Global Journal of Flexible Systems Management, Apr-Jun 2001