open access and the changing nature of scholarly publishing anton angelo research data co-ordinator...
TRANSCRIPT
Open access and the changing nature of scholarly publishing
Anton Angelo Research Data Co-ordinator
Peter Lund Manager, Research Support
UC Library
Agenda
• Changing landscape of scholarly publishing• Open access – gold and green• Finding open access journals• UC Research Repository• Making data visible• Article impact metrics
Where are you publishing now?
Have you had
something published?
Where did you get it accepted?
How did you find
out where to submit
it?
Changing landscape
Scholarly Publishing
Serials Crisis
Finch report
PLOS / ArXiv
/Institutional repositories
Funders mandates
Benefits of Open Access
• Satisfies the requirements of research funders requiring open access publication, such as Marsden, UK Research Councils, the NIH, Wellcome Trust and many others - see SHERPA/JULIET. NZ National Science Challenges also require open data.
• Bigger impact - potential for greatly increased dissemination and citation advantage
• Ameliorates the effects of the serials crisis?• More equitable impact – access is for all, not just those who
can afford journal subscriptions.• Supports technology transfer of UC research to the community
and to business
Citation advantage of OASize of OA citation advantage when found (and where explicitly stated by discipline)
% increase in citations with Open Access
Physics/astronomy 170 to 580
Mathematics 35 to 91
Biology -5 to 36
Electrical engineering 51
Computer science 157
Political science 86
Philosophy 45
Medicine 300 to 450
Communications studies (IT) 200
Agricultural sciences 200 to 600
Alma Swan (2010) The Open Access citation advantage: studies and results to date - ePrints Soton. Retrieved May 6, 2013, from http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/268516/
Who pays?
Gold
• Journal Articles• Payment from author
(research grant, or centrally funded?)
• Predatory publishing?• Double Dipping?
Green
• Articles, Theses, Data…
• Funded from institution?
• Rigorous review?
Article Processing ChargesFee paid before publication
Main publishers • PLOS, BioMedCentral, Hindawi, PeerJ
Average cost of APCs $US300-3000
No centralised fund
Hybrid • Some Articles are OA
Full OA• Entire journal is Open Access – free to the reader
Predatory Publishing
Cold Calling
•Journal may not exist•Relies on a bit of flattery and ego
Impersonation
•Science Q•Q Science
Highjacking
•Sylwan (Polish)•Sylwan (English)
‘Hybrid’ leads to Double Dipping
Author Submits paper to publisher
Author pays Article Processing Charge (US$300-US$3000) to publisher
Publisher reviews and publishes Article Open Access in Journal
Publisher charges Library a subscription for journal
Finding open access journals:Ulrichs Web
What it does• Contains listings of 300,000 currently published journals,
newsletters, and annuals, as well as discontinued publications. It also contains complete names and addresses of journal publishers.
Limitations• Use to find Publisher, Abstracting and
Indexing databases
Demonstration
• Chemistry
Green route: UC Research Repository
• Over 3 million item downloads to date• 2nd biggest IR in NZ
3,220
4,326
Preprints of PBRF Research
Theses
Most Popular ItemsAuthor Date Title D/loads Date addedLloyd, Caleb Charles 2009 A Low Temperature Differential Stirling Engine for Power Generation. Thesis
for Master of Engineering, University of Canterbury. Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering.
33,648 Oct 2009
Lohmeyer, Martin 2008 The Diaoyu / Senkaku Islands Dispute. Thesis for Master of Law, University of Canterbury. Law.
27,468 Jul 2010
Pawlowski, Ilona Paulina
2007 Sex in Women's Magazine Advertising An analysis of the degree of sexuality in women's magazine advertising across age demographics and women's responses.. Thesis for Master of Arts, University of Canterbury. Political Science and Communication.
22,255 Sep 2008
Head, Lyndsay Fay 2006 Land, authority and the forgetting of being in early colonial Maori history. Thesis for Doctor of Philosophy, University of Canterbury. Maori and Indigenous Studies.
20,103 Sep 2008
Ember, Adrienna 2008 Enlarged Europe, shrinking relations? the impacts of Hungary's EU membership on the development of bilateral relations between New Zealand and Hungary. Thesis for Doctor of Philosophy, University of Canterbury. Thesis for Master of Arts, University of Canterbury. European Studies.
19,623 Sep 2008
Haslett, David Stuart 2007 Riding at the Margins: International Media and the Construction of a Generic Outlaw Biker Identity in the South Island of New Zealand, circa 1950 - 1975.. Thesis for Master of Arts, University of Canterbury. Sociology and Anthropology.
19,193 Sep 2008
van Berkel, Haley Kathryn
2009 The Relationship Between Personality, Coping Styles and Stress, Anxiety and Depression. Thesis for Master of Science, University of Canterbury. Psychology.
18,860 Jul 2009
Thomas Thistlewood
Rule, K. (1994). UC Research Repository: Thomas Thistlewood and women slaves. Retrieved November 25, 2013, from http://ir.canterbury.ac.nz/handle/10092/4674
International mandates
• ROARMAP - list of universities with an institutional mandate• 222 universities internationally have institutional mandates• (Including: Imperial College, Edinburgh, Nottingham, MIT, QUT, Princeton, Trinity
College Dublin, Waikato...)
Mandatory deposit of research
Increase deposit rates
• Opt out rather than opt in to the UC Research Repository.
• ~12% of PBRF eligible items are currently deposited.
Already exists for theses
• Including embargos for sensitive research
Commitment to open access
• Ensures publicly funded research becomes publically available• Funders (Marsden, National Health and Medical Research Council,
Australian Research Council) increasingly require OA.• OA material more widely cited
Making you and your data more visible
Dryad•Biomedical Data•Small Fee•dryaddata.org
Figshare•Figures, slides•Free•figshare.com
ORCiD•Identify Yourself•Free•orcid.org
ImpactScholarly• 1
7 Million Potential Viewers
Public• 3
Billion Potential Viewers
Industry• R
esearch & Development
Government• P
ublic Policy
Impact
Pat Loria http://www.slideshare.net/patloria/pat-loria-altmetrics-oar-2013
Examples of Altmetrics Services
Plumanalytics.com
Impactstory.orgAltmetrics.org
FacebookGIT
SCOPUS
Google Scholar
Questions?
For more information consult the Scholarly Communication subject guide http://
canterbury.libguides.com/scholarlyor contact your liaison librarian.
References
• Eysenbach, G. (2006). Citation Advantage of Open Access Articles. PLoS Biol, 4(5), e157. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.0040157
• Shorley, M. and Jubb, M. (2013) The Future of Scholarly Communication. London: Facet
• Swan, A. (n.d.). The Open Access citation advantage: Studies and results to date. ePrints Soton. Retrieved May 6, 2013, from http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/268516/
3rd party ‘repositories’
ArXivPhysical sciences archive – preprint repository
http://arxiv.org/
PLoSReviewed ‘journal’
http://www.plosone.org/
Research GateCommercial research repository
https://www.researchgate.net/home.Home.html
Impact StoryArticle Level Metrics – Impact beyond scholarly citations
http://impactstory.org/