on wed, jan 16, 2019 at 10:10 am peti secretariat
TRANSCRIPT
-_..,._.,..._...,,_-_-_--:.-:..-:::...-:.-::..-::..-::..-=..-·_·--=-·;._,.,,- .:.":: ·---- .. -._-__,,.~..,,..,-,.-----,.--,-,--..,,.... ,....__,.....,_.,,... --,.,-~:--_-:_-_-_-_-_ . ....,... ... """···,-- __ """··-·.----.·-,-· ---···----. --,-. ~.- ... - ..... ---···---· ··• .. ,. ·---------········ -- -- - - . - --; i
From: Sent To: Subject:
16 January 2019 12:40 PETI Secretariat Re: 21/03/2019 - EP Hearing on Climate Change Denial - preliminary check of availability
Dear Secretariat,
Thank you for reaching out. I can confirm that I would b·e available on 21 March, assuming that travel to. Brussels can be covere.d
Many" thanks,
On Wed, Jan 16, 2019 at 10:10 AM PETI Secretariat <[email protected]:eu> wrote:
Dear:-.,
In the European Parliament, the Committee on Petitions is organising a hearing on Climate Change Denial. . '
In order to start organising, we would kindly like to check your availability on the date of 21 March in the morning (Brussels). ' · ·
! · As the selection of the speakers is the fi~al decision of the Members of the Committee, kindly note that this · email is not to be considered as an invitation for the hearing yet.
"
As the secretariat, we only check in advance the possible availability of potential speakers, in order to support a further smooth organisation. ·
Thank 'you for your understanding and for informing us informally already on your availability on the date ' of the scheduled Hearing.
Best regards,
~~~ ///,.,...,.~-~---- ...... (~- ! . Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions
European Parliament Directorate-General for Internal Policies of the· Union Directorate for Citizens' Rights and
.I Constitutional Affairs Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions
1
I.Ji'IIIU @ t ? fi llli.,
~,---=====---- .... - .... -_- __ ,..._- ., __ ._- "'" - ..,... - __ --- ~ . .....,..__,,__=·· --------· -.- .. -~·,-,·-·· -~----. .. . ... . . . .. . .. . . . ·, •••••• ··----·-·- ••• -· .w ---·······----- -----------·· ······~-~---·-··-----··············--······--- ······---·· -·--- ---···---·· .. ·······-·-·-··-·····- --· ~----~-
-------------------- From: Sent: To: Subject:
18 January 2019 PETI Secretariat Re: 21/03/2019 - EP Hearing on Climate Change Denial - preliminary check of availability
Dears,
Y es, I can confirm my availability on 21st of March.
All the best,
i. ~:tlll,it t.':<";fk'c•" ·\-.. Ham, 18.01.2019 r. B 13:06 "tJ. PETI Secretariat <[email protected]> nanaca:
Dear-.
In the ~~ament, the Committee on Petitions is organising a hearing on Climate Change Denial.
In order to start organising, we would kindly like to check your availability on the date of 21 March in the morning (Brussels). •
As the selection of the speakers is the final decision of the Members of the Committee, kindly note that this email is not to be considered as an invitation for the hearing yet.
As the secretariat, we only check in advance .the possible availability of potential speakers, in order to support a further smooth organisation.
Thank you for your understanding and for informing us informally already on your availability on the date of the scheduled Hearing.
Best regards,
Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions
European Parliament Directorate-General for Internal Policies of the Union Directorate for Citizens' Rights and Constitutional Affairs Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions
www.europarl.europa.eu -
. ' I. i
1
,., 1111
-• Ill Ill fl
From: Sent: To: Subject: 21/03/2019 - EP Hearing on
availability
Dear-- Dear~
ln the European Parliament, the Committee on Petitions is organising a hearing on Climate Change Denial. ln order to start organising; we would kindly like to check your availability on the date of 21 March in the morning (Brussels). • · · ~t%,.., <$?,¾"<,nh,. '~'. ..
I
As the selection of the speakers is the final decislon of the Members of the Committee, kindly note that this email is_ not-to be considered as an invitation for the hearing yet. As the secretariat wé only check in advance the possible availabilltv of potential speakers, inorder to support a fûrther~~~}ganisation. . . · · . .
Thank,y.ou or your understanding and for informing us informally already on your availability on the date of the · scheduled Hearing. . ' .
Best regards,
~-~ ((«{:_~~,, ~- Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions
f
,-
European Parliament Directorate-General for Internal Policies of the
Union Directorate for Citizens' Rights and Constitutional
Affairs Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions
www.eurOparl.europa.eu
1
._illlf i lill'.IIRa
Ji
From: Sent: To: Subject: ea 1ng on Climate Change Denial - preliminary check of
availability
Dear
ln the European parliament, the Committee on Petitions is organising a hearing on Climate Change Denial. ln order to start organising, we would kindly like to check your availability on the date of 21 March in the morning (Brussels).
As the ·selection of the speakers is the final _decision of the Members of the Committee, kindly notè that this email is not to be.considered as an invitation for the hearing yet. . · As the secretariat, we only check in advance the possible availability of potential speakers, in order tosupport a further smooth organisation.
Thank you for your understanding and for informing us informally already on your availability on thé date of the scheduled Hearing., ·
Best regards,
~-~ ((CR~~\,'\.' ~- Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions
European Parliament Directorate-General for Internal Poliçies of the
Union Directorate for Citizens' Rights and Constitutional
Affairs Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions
www.europarl.europa.eu
1
•1911 llltUIIUIMMII r • r•
J
From: Sent: To: Subject:
ary PETI Sècretariat Re: 21/03/2019 - EP Hearing on Climate Change Denial - preliminary check of availability ·
Dear Sir/Madam,
thank you for consider-me as a potential participant in this event; ' /1- .r,:
. 'ufîfortunately
Sincerely
. and thus cannot attend.
. "Depa rt.merrt of Civil Engineering and Architecture, School of Engineering Leading Research Scientist, Head of Wave E~gineering Laboratory Department of Cybernetics, School of Science, T·'u•
i • .•
Dear ln the European Parliament, thé Committee on Petitions is organising a hearing on Climate Change Denial. ln order to start organising, we would kindly like to check your avallability on the date of 21 March in the morning (Brussels). As_ the selection of the speakers is the final decision of the Members of the Committee, kindly note
· " that this email is not to be considered as an invitation for the hearing yet. As the secretarlat, we only check in advance the possible availability of potential speakers, in order to support a-further smooth organisation. Thank you for your understanding and for informing us informally already on vouravallabtlitv on the date of the scheduled Hearing. Best regards,
,g~ J(,((f-~,,, \~- Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions
European Parliament Directorate-General for Internal Policies of the
· Union Directorate for Citizens' Rights and Constitutional Affairs Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions
1
I l.
DilfRfflRWJJUltW 1
·--.,..._--,,----,,,,,.. -·--·--·-···-·····- ----·-···-·.
a
From: Sent: To: Subject:
16 January 201 PETI Secretariat Re: 21/03/201~ - EP Hearing on Climate Change Denial - preliminary check of availability
Hello and thank you for asking! lt looks like I cannot make it because I need to be back Sorry for· this and all the best! - On 16.01.19 14:39, PETI Secretariat wrote:
· Dear ln the European Parliament, the Committee on Petitions is organising a hearing on Climate Change Denial.
·· '~~4W,etde#.to s;tam: organlsing, we would kindly like to check your availability on the date of 21 March in the morning [Brussels]. · As the selection of the speakers is the final decision of the Members of the Committee, kindly note that this email is not to be considered as an invitation for the hearing yet. As the secretariat, we only check in advance the possible availability of potential speakers, in order to support a further smooth organlsatlon, · • · Thank you for your understanding and for informing us informally already on your availability on the .
. . date of the scheduled Hearing. Best regards,
-'¼~ {((fr-~~,, ~-- Secretariat of t~~·t!~i'ttî~e on Petitions
European Parliament Directorate-General for Internal Policies of the Union
Directorate for Citizens' Rights and Constitutional · Affairs
Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions·
www.europarl.europa.eu
Estonian University of Life Sciences. Kreutzwaldi 1, 51014 Tartu Estonia
bh!_t!_tpp_ê,s,!_: L/L/t:t:_w~i t!_t!_e~r.:.,:- c~o~mcg_,11 li■■- ... wordpress.com/
http://www.akadeemia.ee/en/membershi / members
Center of Excellence in Environmental Adaptation (ENVIRON) http://environ.emu.ee
Center of Excellence in Global Change (EcolChange) http://ecoic~ange.emu.ee
Stress-Induced Plant'.-Volatiles in Biosphere-Atmosphere System (SIP-VOL+, ERC-AdG) http://cordis.europa.eu/projects/rcn/106468 en.html
Biology, Controls and Models of J'ree .Volatile Organic Compound Emissions http://www.springer.com/life+~ciences/forestry/book/978-94-007-6605-1
1
¥ , 1 .1111 11111 I 1•
------~=== ------------------- . From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:
18 January 2019 18:55 PETI Secretariat
Re: 21/03/2019 - EP con erence - Climate Change Denial
Dear Sirs, I am delighted and honoured to he consulted as a possible speaker on such a crucial aspect of the enviromental communication, and declare
'\trnyî~Î~vailability. , w ,· Best regards,
~-·h}.~·,
PETI Secretariat <[email protected]> ha scritto:
:Dear~
::;>Dea~ > . > > ln the European Parliament, the CommlUee on Petitions is organising > a hearing on Climate Change Denial. · > ln order to start organising, we would kindly like to check your > availability on the date of 21 March in the morning (Brussels). > > As the selection of the speakers is the final decision of thè > Members of the Committee, kindly note that this email is not to be > considered as an invitation for the hearing yet. > As the secretariat, we only check in advance the possible > availability of potential speakers, in order to support a further > smooth organisation. .,.,,., ,.,, ·•''~>"<t>-i~,,-.,.,,,-,w,,.
'>~. "i•Y
> > Thank you for your understanding and for informing us informally > already on your availability on 'the date of the scheduled Hearing.
> > Best regards, > > Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions > > > [cid:[email protected]] > > > Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions > > > > European Parliament > > Directorate-Gen~ral for Internal Policies of the Union
,I! ••
,. From: Sent: To: Subject:
anuary 2019 23:44 PËTI Secreta~iat ' Re: 21/03/2019 - EP Hearing on Climate Change Denial - preliminary check of availability
Dear Secretariat,
Y es I am· available! Would be happy to participate if invited. Thank you for considering me.
Sincerely, · ....
On Jan 18, 2019, at 4: 18 AM, PETI Secretariat <peti-se<[email protected]> wrote:
Dear~ ln the European Parliament, the Committee on Petitions is organising a hearing on Climate Change Denial. · . · · · · ln order to start organising, we would kindly-like to check 'your availability on the date of 21 March
. in the morning (Brussels). As the selection of the speakers is the final decision of the Members of the Committee, kindly note that this email is not to be considered as an invitation for the hearing yet. As the secretariat, we only check in advance the possible availability of potential speakers, in order to support a further smooth organisation. · Thank you for your understanding and for informing us informally already on your avallabllltv on the date of the scheduled Hearing. · · Best regards,
Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions
European Parliament Directorate-General for Internal Policies of the Union Directorate for Citizens' Rights and Constitutional Affairs Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions
1
, •IP! L flJW! .!
.... ,u., -·····-------- -- ----- ---~
I
-----····- ·--~
From: Sent: To: Subject:
24 January 2019 11 :20
Re: [AJSPI] 21(03-EP Hearing-Climate Change Denial-check avail
Bonjour madame, '
~e cette proposition, malheureusement
.,~inc~~~ e'3r'ciialernent ~-
à cette date (I will be
Le jeu. 24 janv. 2019 à 11:01, ~=~~~=~a-~e~u-> a écrit :
Bonjour: J £ , _· . Bl I 11 I li- @europarl.europa .• sa envoyé un· message en utilisant votre formulaire de contact personnel (https://www.ajspi.com/ itact) sur AJSPI. Si vous ne souhaitez pas recevoir ces courriels, vous pouvez modifier vos paramètres ici.: ht s://www.a·s i.co t. Message: De~ the European Parliament, the Committee on Petitions is organising a hearing on Climate Change Denial. ln order to start organising, we would kindly like to check your availability on the date of 21 March in the morning (Brussels). As the selection of the speakers -~I decision of the Members of_the Committee, kindly note that this email is Ilot to be considered as an invitation.for the hearing yet. As the secretariat we only check in advance.the possible· availability of potential speakers, in order to support a further smooth organisation. Thank you or your· understanding and for informing us informally already on your availability on the date of the scheduled Hearing. _Best regards, Tue Secretariat of the Committee on Petitions - [email protected]
I
I !
1
Ji I urn ut■,_.._,
rt
...... .. ILI '!T'l''" a■■ .. LC 1 1 • I ' I a
7 a
[lpone1icKH napnaMeHr Parlamcnto Europeo Evropskf parlamenl Europa•Parlam•ntet Europilsches Parlament Euroopa Parlament Eupt,Jnoli<6 Ko1vopoo~10 European Parliament Parlementeuro"'tn Parlai mint na hEorpa Europsklparlamenl Parlament• europco Elropas Parlaments Europos Parlamentas Eur6pal Parlament Parlament Ewropew EUJD!lff l Parlement ,Parlame_nt Europtjskl Parlernento Europeu Parlamffl tul Eurajlt an, Eurdpskyparlament !vropskl parlamenl £uroopan parlamenltl Ell/DJ!¾pl!l lamentet.
D 302021 11 :02.2019
Bruxelles, PvP/kk[JPOL-COM-PETI D(2019}4302]
Invitation to Public Hearing on Climate Change Denial " 21 March 2019 .
DearM~
The Committee on Petitions (PETI) of the European Parliament jointly with the · ... t½P, on, Envhiom~blic Health and ,~ ~ety (ENVI), will organise .a ~ç~in,g title~ ''.f · Hearin on Climate Chang_e Deni~!", =. 10:30 tGMt~ ¥~atclh2,019 m the European Parliament m Brussels (Rue Wiertz ·,. ,,m::·. .. . . . -~-'.~:;;:w . i -~,--
-On this occasion, I have the pleasure to invite you to participate in the abovementioned hearing as an expert to share your views ~d experience and to present information 9n this topic. The allocated time for each presentation is 15 minutes and we kindly ask you to respect this limit. .The question and answer session with Members of the European
· Parliament will follow the experts' presentations. A copy -of the preliminary draft programme of the event, is enclosed for your perusal, providing a summary indication concerning your contribution: and describes also the generalbackground of the Hearing.
\,~ ~ I
On request, the European Parliament will reimburse your travel expenses in accordance with the Rules on Publio Hearings. The rules, regulations and forms are also enclosed in this letter. Among others, a prerequisite to reimburse your travel expenses is to inform us whether you will be travelling from/to a place other than your private address or place of work, failing to do so will render reimbursement impossible.
You are kindly asked to comply with the registration ;requirements mentioned in Article . 7 of the Rules on Public Hearings, which is described in more detail on the· homepage of the Transparency Registry. The direct link to this information page is: https://bit.ly/2DJPWGH.
5273 GEN
Upon your arrival, you will be welcomed in the Atrium Welcome Point 30-45 minutes before the start of the hearing. I would like to kindly ask you to inform us· whether you
. · require any special assistance during your visit· in the European Parliament.
Moreover, in order to make ·the hearing a success and use the available time wisely, it would optimise the flow of the information supplied to the Members of the European Parliament and facilitate the work of interpreters during the hearing, if you could· share a short English version of your presentation 01· speaking points. It is also useful to specify in advan~e if ~o~ ":'Îsh to use È2fiJl111!!rhat is the original language of your presentation with the PET! Sec1"mr1 ·~ a1 • . .
I would also liketo draw your attention to the fact that, unless you oblect in.writing, your CV will be published on the PETf Committee website among the other supporting. documents for the hearing. It will be deleted one year later. In addition, if you agree; ·· your speech will also be published on the PETI Committee website.
Further details will be provided to you by the PETI Secretariat- they will contact you' · · over the phone - to ensure-a: smooth proceeding. You can.also contact the Secretariat · yourself on +32 (0)2-28 42 111, e-mail address: petl..:[email protected].
We look :forward to welcoming you o~ the day of the hearing . ..- : v~•. •, • • ,
Yours. sincerely,
Cecilia Wikström Chair of the Committee on Petitions
Annexes: , Draft programme . • Information and forms for reimbursement of expenses
Eaponei1cKM napnaMeMT Parlamenio Europeo Evropsky parla ment Europa-Parlamente! Europalsches Pa~ameÎlt Euroopa Parlament EupwnaîK<i Koivo~o~A,o European Parliament Parlement européen Parlalmlnt na hEorpa Europskl par lament Par lamento eùrepeo Elropas Parlaments Ellropos Parlamentas Europa! Parlament Pârlament Ewropcw Europees Parlement Parlament Europe)skl Parlamento Europeu Parlarnentul European Eur6psky parlament Evropskl parlament Evroopan parlamenttl. Europaparlamentet ·
Bruxelles, PvP/kk[JPOL~COM-PETI D(2019)4287]
D.302018. 11.02.2019
Subject: . . .
Invitation to Public Hearing on Climate Changé Denial - 21 March 2019
Dear~ . .,,._,. ~«-:,>: .@:❖~:«-•·• w' -~••"❖ • • • • .•:❖::&;-::ire,. • ~ •
The~~etlUoïiS~T iaM European Parliament jointly with the Committee on · · · Safety (ENVI), will organise a public hearing titled
tngon otë · ange Denial", from 10:30 to 12:30 on 21 March 2019 in the pr~mises of the European Parliament in Brussels (Rue Wiertz 60). · ·
. On this occasion, I have the-pleasure to invite.you to participate in the abovementioned hearing as an expert to share your views and experience and to present information on this topic. The
. allocated time for each presentation is 15 minutes and we kindly ask you to respect this limit. The question and answer session withMembers of the European Parliament will follow the experts' presentations. A copy of the preliminary draft programme of the event, is enclosed for · your perusal, providing a summary indication concerning your contribution, and describes also . the general background of the Hearing. · ·
On request, the European Parliament will reimburse 'your travel expenses in accordan~e with the Rules ·on Public Hearings. The rules, regulations and forms are also enclosed in this· letter, Among others, a prerequisite to reimburse your travel expenses is to provide us an offer from a travel agency quoting the travel itinerary and its expenses, failing to do so will render reimbursement impossible.
You are kindly asked to comply with the registration requirements mentioned in, Article 7 of the Rules. on Public Hearings, which is described in 'more detail on the homepage of the. Transparency Registry. The direct Iink to this information p~ge is; https://bit.ly/2DJPWGH.
Upon your arrival, you will be welcomed in the Atrium Welcome Point 30-45 minutes before the start of the hearing. I would like to kindly ask you· to inform us whether you require any .special assistance during your visit in the European Parliament.
Moreover, in order to make the hearing a success .and use the available time wisely, it would optimise the flow of the information supplied to the Members of the European Parliament and
. .
5273 GEN
---····-·-·-·····--····-·················-···--·····-·
facilitate the work of interpreters\during the hearing, if you could share a short English version of your presentation or speaking points. It is also useful to specify in advance if you wish to use Powe;rPoint and what Is the original language of your presentation with the PETI Secretariat (by e-mail). ·
I would also like to draw your attention to the fact that, unless you object in writing,' your CV · will be published on the PETI Committee website among the other supporting documents for the hearing. It will be deleted one year later. In addition, if you agree, your speech will also be published on the PETI Com,;Yif ■ifù- . Further details will be provided to you by the PETI Secretariat - they will contact .You over the phone - to ensure a smooth proceeding. You can also contact the Secretariat yourself on +32. (0)2~28 42 111, e-mail address: [email protected].
We look forward to welcoming you on theday of the hearing.
Yours sincerely,
Cecilia Wikström . Chair of the Committee on Petitions
Annexes: • . Draft programme • Information .and forms for reimbursement of expenses
Io
I
I - ! I
. . ·······--·--·--- .... _
. .
European Parliament 2014-2019
Committee on the Environment; Public Health and Food Safety Committee on Petitions
PE;Tl_ OJ(2019).XXXXX
·FIRST. DRAFT-PROGRAMME
IolntHeartng · I,
· "Climate Change Denial"
Thursday 21 'March 2019, 10.30 to 12.;J0
Euro pean Parliament, Brussels . . . ' ' ~ . '
XX building· . .
Roo:rn:XX
OJ\l 143029EN.doc~
Ururèd in cliv1?.rsity
PE616.565v0l--O0 .
. EN
·I I
.. , .... , ·"" --------·-·····
Background
. The Committee on Petitions received petition No 0900/2016 by F.K. (Austrian) on behalf of Food & Water Europe, bearing 732 signatures on taking action against a multinational oil company for climate change. The petitioner would like the European Parliament to take action against a multinational oil company for its climate change denial. The petitioner informed the Committee on Petition about an ongoing investigation in the United States.on the same issue.
. The petitioner also listed the adverse effects of climate change and its denial on environment, . public health, agriculture, water sources, tourism, energy policy or transport policy.
. .
Pending the petition additional information was provided; referring to positions of scientists assessingdi_ß considerable impact of specific industrial activities. on climate change and on the
· other hand; the expensive misinformation campaigns of industrial lobbyists to circulate the· · opposite views. These mechanisms possibly prevent governments, investors and individuals to change politics, from reducing critical industrial activities at an earlier stage.
. . I 'I. ?
The European Union is bound by the Paris Agreement adopted. by the Pàrties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change at the-Zl st Conference of Parties to the UNFCCC in December 2015. ·
Coordinators ofboth the ENVI a:n_d PET{ Committee decided to organise this Hearing, targeting the different aspects of Climate Change Denial and its dynamics 'among different actors in· · society. . , : ,·
l ; . l
'
' . î I . i .
Documents/link_s provided:
"petition and additional documents received;
" Paris Agreement [https://unfocc.int/process-aùd-meetings/the-paris-agreement/the-paris agreement]
- 24th Conference. of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate · Change Climate - Katowice; Poland, 2-14 December 2018 [bttps://unfccc.int/katowice and· https://cop24.gov.pl/J · ·
- European Parliament resolution of25 October 2018 on the 2018 UN ClimateChange Conference in Katowice, Poland (COP24) · [http://www.europar1.eûropa.eu/sides/getDoc,do?pubRef=-//EP/trEXT+TA+P8-TA-2018- 0430+0+DOC+XML+V0//EN] .
PE616.565v01--00 2/5 OJ\1 l 43029EN.docx
E.N
l I I
I i
--·--···-~----- --- . '
Order of business
WELCOME
10:30 ---10:35 Ms Cecilia WIKSTRÖM, Chair of the Committee on Petitions
l .
FIRST PANEL" Climate Change Denial" general overview
10::35 .:..11:1s (40 minutes)
10:35 -10:50 Mr.Christian Hgenhofer, CEPS, Senter Fellow; Head-of Energy and Climate programme~ Director of Energy Climate House · . .
deneràl introduction on climate change challenges and Climate Change Denial in different aspects of society
· 10:50-11:05
11:05 -11:15
Ms Stella Schaller, Project manager Study on climate change denial by ADELPID . . .
Oyemêw of climate change denial in politics, baséd on a studyscheduled for publication in Eebruary 2019 by-Adelphi · · . . . Q&Asession
SECOND.PANEL~ Climate Change Denial ,
Communlcatlon techniq~ies and misinformation 11:15 -12:25 (70 minutes]
11:15 -11:30 Geoffrey Supran, Harvard University, co-author of the Environmental · · Research · Letter "Assessing Exxonlvlobll's climate · change communlcations (1977-20:1-4)'! Communication techniques used by private companies to mislead the public on the effects of certain industrial acttvittesor: (he climate
. .
11:30-11:45 Georgi Stefanov, Chief climate & energy expert, "Climate Change and Green Economy''-manager programme manager, WWF·Bulgaria.
Campàigning techniques and information sharing by other relevant actors - ' in society ·
OJ\1143029EN.docx 315" PE616.565v01--00
EN
.. --· ····-···----·---·· ·-·--·---· .. -- ..... -----··•·· ---·-·-·- --·-·-- - ~
11:45 -12:00
12:00 - 12:25
Darren Woods, Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive Officer of Exxon Mobil Corporation · ·
Q&Asession
CONCLUDING REMARKS 12:25 -12:30, ., MsA4iua~Ioana VA.LEAN, Chair of the Committee onthe Environment,
i,,'.t Public Health and Food Safety
! !
-!
i i ' ,-
PE616.565v01-00 4/5 OJ\1143029EN.docx
EN
--··--·-'-----~-··--··· ·•· -••,----- ---------, ··-· ·-·------·· ..... ···--------·-------·-·.-------·. ·--·-·-----·-··---·---------- --- -----·· :·--·----- -····----j . .. . i
' I I
. !
ADDITIONAL INFORl\fATiON
Administrator for ENVI secretariat·
Office:
Phone:+
ill [europar].europa.eu
Offite: ·g· . .Phone: + · ·
it£@ . • Office: fl k Phone:
a euro arl.euro a.e · •~uroparl .europa .eu·
1 Theprocesslng of personal data is subject to Regulation (Ee) No 45/2001of 18 December 2001 (OJ.L 812.1.2001, ~~. '
0J\l 143029EN.docx 5/5 PE616.565v01-00
EN j'
LEGAL ENTITY . · INDIVIDUAL
NAME 111·11· I 1111 1111.l I I I I I •i I I I I .I I l·I I j FiRST NAME . I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I . I I I 'I I I I I I I I I I I
ADDRESS$treet [. l. I 111 I- I I I 11 I I I I I I I I I I J I I I I I I Number [ I I ! I I I l I I · · Postcode!. I I · I I I I 1 ! I I I
Town I City f I l I I 1 · 1 I I I I I I j· I I I l .I l I I I I I I I I Cou~tryDJ VAT·N° [1 ! l 1 ! 111.! :.j I l(lfthîsft~ldiscompleted;pleaseattrlch~rtofflclalVATdocument)
PHONE f I I I I I I I l I l I I - FAX1 I I I I I I I I l I I . I I I I . E-MAIL
A laglble photocopy of the Identity card or passport must be provided ·
. · NAME li I 11111 î1~0~~~~~~ 111111 I 11 ris rs • (The name under which the account has been ope.neg} · ·
. l I I- I I I I r LI ·1 I I I I I I T I I I I I I I trJ?1 IM& . . ~~ BANK,-,-,r-r-1 · . till l■a 1
IBA~ I LI I 1..1.....,..· ..1-,-.I ~I 1- ·1 I .fl I I 1-11 I I I 11 I I.LI..I I I I 1.J !tllßlli litJ (Obligatory, If the IBAN Co .t where your bank Is establ/shed) ~~ . · ' · •rnt::11 I , If SWl~T ~ODE {BIC) · · · · · 111 1■ 11111WiUJ •• • -
ACCOUNT NUMBER (Natlonàl Formàt, if /BA . st)
:BANKNAME f .i1r.-1Î-l11111 lfl 11-1 j·j 1111 ! ,··11 I' I I I I I 1- 11 I I I I I I I I I l 1 · I I l -I
AD.DRgss Street I I l I I I I I I j· I I. I I 1· I I ·I 1-1 I I I I Numbér· I I · I I ·I I I I I I Postcode!
Town I City I I I I I· i- I I I I I I I I I· I I I~ I I I I I I
Î~·-,q 'I a· r I 1.1 I
BANK STAMP,:!-. SIGN~TURE_QF BANIS DATE+ SIGNATURE OF ACCOUNT Ho"LDER . ,
REPRESENIATIVE * : : (Obilgatory) .. . .
• It Is preferable to attach a copy of recent bank statement Please note that the bank statement has ' to provide ~I the Information listed above under 'ACCOUNT NAME' and 'BANK'. ln this case, the ' stamp of the bank and the signature of the bank's I certify that the Information provided Is true and representative are not reaulred. accurate.
I I .I I .I 11 I ·I I ·I I I Ill
· I I I - I· Country[IJ
E11ropean Parliament
Déclaration sur l'honneur
Le/la soussigné/ e) déclare, par la présente, sur l'honneur avoir utilisé sa voiture personnelle lors de la réunion de la commission spécifiée ci-après :
N dl' rt/nétiti .. . . . . om e expe pétitionnaire _ T ..
~~ .
' S'estrendu(e) de ~ _. _. :·--···· ..
Daté de l'audition publique : _ , ' ... . , ' . . ......
Commission des Pétitions w '"~- .
Fait à· .. ,t. ;,t, . _. i;. )' '~ •
Le ..... .1 ..... 1 ...... signature de· l'intéressé( e)
Declaration of Honour
~-- (({f(~' ~- European·Parlfament
· I, the undersigned, hereby declare on my 'honour that I travelled· by private car' to. attend the· committee meeting/hearing referred to below:
Naine of expert/petitioner ; ; : .- : ~ , ..
Date of hearing/meeting .. '. ." : : .- .
Committee on Petitions • • • • • • • • • I Travelledfrom : to. ..
Signature of expert/Petitioner
I I
- From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:
05 February 2019 16:01
European Parliament - Joint ENVI-PETI Public Hearing on Climate Change denial
Dear--
I am contacting you to explore your availability and interest in participate as a speaker to a Joint Public Hearing organised by the PETI and ENVI Committee of the European parliament on Climate Change denial.
} '
The ,event will be held at the European Parliament on 21 March 2019 from 10:30 to 12:30.
I would appreciate a quick reply so that the draft programme of the hearing can be finalised. We will of course circulate it to you together with any other relevant info in case you will be available. We can further discuss at the phone about the purpose and object of this event.
Best regards,
ENVI Secretariat
1·
r I ! '
, ...... :v.,, • • ,11 as,
.. :ilfff·•
; I; : I -mp I
---------------------- From: Sent: To: Subject:
adelphi.de> 06 February 2019 09:40
Follow VP Flag: # Flag Status:
AW;.JointPEThEN\fl Public hearing on Climate change denial - 21 march 2019 - 10:00-12:30 INVITE 27-02 Study Launch Convenient Truths report - adelphi BRUSSELS.PDF
Follow up Flagged
w,.rarr ·œ■t®
Dear~
thanks for your email and tnvltlngus to participate in the panel discussion on 21 March.
As discussed, our Managing Director, Alexander Carius, would be available to join the 'meeting from 10.30 to 12.30. {Alexander Çarius - [email protected])
I am attaching the invitation for our breakfast event in Brussels on 27 February, where the study will officially be
launched. \/',/,,e hope you or.1spme of your colleagues can attend. lt would also be a nice opportunity to exchange on the topic and follow-up activities. T,heJinvite will~lso becirculated via Jo Leinen's office.
Kind regards,
~
, • • , ••• .,.,,..... ' - ~--- ., ~---··· ••• • • .. .,. ·-----·,._._._ ,w ~ , , .
Phone:+ Fax: +49 (30) 89 000 68 - 10 Mail: Web: https://www.adelphi.de
Twitter.com/adelphi_berlin • · Linkedin.com/company/adelphi-berlin
-~~-~f:~~o~._co,~/a_d,~lph_i.d~ . ----··· ·-··--·--·---· . ~~P.~~ adelphi research gemeinnützige GmbH Alt-Moabit 91, 10559 Berlin
Geschäftsführer:
Sitz: Berlin, AG Charlottenburg HRB 81753; UST ID: DE 813281567
Von: europarl.europa.eu] Gesendet: Dienstag, 5. Februar 2019 15:47 An:···••- adelphi Betreff: Joint PETI-ENVI Public hearinq on Climate change denial - 21 march 2019 - 10:00-12:30
1
Dear... " ·-f.ffl~illffl:\jfdlri
As promised this Is my email address and in the object you have the details of the public hearing. .
. . • • lfllll ■ ill a 8 I will circulate to you the draft programme and othêr instructions in the next weeks.
Please let me know who will present the study for Adelphi.
Many thanks - European Parliament ENVI Secretariat
· Lli 111111
•1m1r m111 n• • • ;__a,nr 11 1
I lllihf1 • INJt • !Rtfll I P
I ,
2
From: Sent: To: ,, /ffl'<•= f-HM,~'$ .
Subject: •~·#~''' ~ ;R£_:,PÖssit--i.Uiilil!rf$!Mit~ ❖-. ate Change denial on 2Ù.19
Attachme=~:w~.,;,~( .. :;..,, .. ;. t~,~~~~;.:.;~;~~~;=~~~~;;.~~~~~ . ~¥~~§.{::::~.,•·~ --~ -· ~..,- · ,::: ·,❖.: ,· ~-❖~-~ >. -~' '· '' \~:- ❖\,..,, é•.(:·❖:::::..:r~-}J?.tw .. ~-,,'' -~·' -i ~'-:'.;:,J;:-:.it~~At=Ù'O,,
' ~- ·':~:- ?"~t~· ~-!~>">~'i/ .~ :::;.~#
Bonjour,
Voici la pétition a l'origine de l'audition. Pourriez-vous me donner votre adresse (de travail) pour l'insérer dans l'invitation officielle qu'on va vous envoyer
(par mailJ? , •4ii'll:HU •• 1111,llfü!! w
Merci d'avance, è;l rr · ?n11 IIIIIIUII JI.,
- • 11111 111 T p,_.
from a Sent: 18 February 2019 14:37 To:' Subject: RE: Possible participation to a Public hearing on Climate Change denial on 21.3.19 at the European Parliament
I think I missed your call, sorry. I called you back but there Is the voice mail. I'm in the office now
From:£ Sent: 18 February 2019 12:01 To: Subject: Ré: Possible participation to a Public hearing on Climate Change denial on 21.3.19 at the European Parliament
a - [email protected]>
Y es, could I call you after 2pm ?
Le 18/02/19 à 11:53, Good morning, When would you be available for a quick talk by phone? This afternoon? Thanks # lfilintaiiWii- '
From: Sent: 15 February 2019 13:17 To: Subject: Re: Possible participation to a Public hearing on Climate Change denial on 21.3.19 at the European Parliament
Yes, possible in theory, but TBD on Monday. please send the draft programme
1
Cordialement, Best regards, Met vriendelijke groeten,
f •(tter
I- :;. I . I I : .'. ii
I
dt u: ::~z d ' Ii ) - ht
l'écopsychologie: un couple hors norme")
Le 15 févr. 2019 à 12:40, a v,europarl.europa.eu> a écrit :
Dear WG If I ns•
I am contacting you informally to explore your availability and interest in participate as jlJ!Pea1$:er to ~. ·". Joint Public Hearing organised by the ffl! Plfffl i~!ferW' iC Committee of the EuropewiJi•Q! 91.,Qimate Change denial. The evenl4ifrßhM& iP&MMoßMMi a Parliament on 21 March 2019 from 10:30 to 12:30.
Mr Egenhofer that we also contacted gave me your name and I know you recently came for a similar event on the SDGs.
programme of the hearin •e~ e programme of the hearing and of course-we can further discuss at the phone on Monday about the purpose and object of this event.
Best regards,
ENVI Secretariat
2
From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:
Attachments:
19 February 2019 13:59
,,_ FW: URGENT ATTENTION PLS: FW: European Parliament - Joint ENVI-PETI Public Hearing on.Climate Change denial Draft Programme_Climate Change Denial_PETI-ENVl.docx
Dear~ -.i@•nn■r I'm writing you following below mail to my colleague phone earlier this morning. 4 JI I , I was unable to approach you earlier. I just tried to contact you via phone to seek some more information on this Joint ENVI-PET! Public hearing. I will try later again, but alternatively you could. always contàct me on my mobile on:
which I understood you had contacted by ·--·11··.
Yours sincerely,
Is this .the future of.b-iofùels? ' We're researching algae to help reduœ C01 emissions.
.· Learn more•~ aigu>>
Elf(onMc · Ener!
Follow ExxonMobil in Europe on Twitter: twitter.com/exxonmobil_eu Visit ExxonMobil's Energy Factor, an online resource covering the cutting-edge technology and innovations that are helping to meet tomorrow's energy needs.. ·
Exxo.nMobil Petroleum & Chemical b.v.b.;'.:0
,Hermeslaan 2, B-1831 Machelen - Belgium EU Transparency Register No: 0745650927-75 . Registered office: Polderdijkweg, 2030 Antwerp; VAT BE 0416.375.270 --RPR Antwerp; BoA Antwerp EUR 685- 6691011-19 This communication may contain privileged or proprietary information. The information is intended only for the use of the addressee(s). If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any use, disclosure, or copying ·of the information lsprohiblted. If you are not an intended recipient; please notify the sender immediately
From: europarl.europa.eu] Sent: Tuesday, February 19, 2019 10:.20 AM . T Subject: European Parliament - Joint ENVI-PETI Public Hearing on Climate Change denial
I
Dear Ü
1
As anticipated this morning by phone, I am contacting vou to explore the availability and interest of a representattve . of Exxon Mobil in participating' as a speaker to a Joint Public Hearing organised by the PETI Jlll!IIN,.Ul■d!lMiiliitJ' the European parliament on Climate Change denial.
r1v11 • •• •••11••1••11 • 1111, 111111111 n•1tT1s The event will be 6l! tr t Ml lJrobeaf ßJ flt £i!ilJ,.uch 2019 from 10:30 to 12:30.
"S 11111■ ilk Please find attached the draft programme. • 111 111 JJ! • - . I would appreciate a quick reply so that the draft programme of the hearlng can be finalised.
We can further discuss at the phone any detail you deem relevant.
Best regards,
11112 ENVI Secretariat
il: I I a11 n■
I I L 2
~---------------- From: Sent: To: Subject:
exxonmobil.ci 25 February 2019 17:38
RE: URGENT /\JTçNTIÖN PLS: FW: European Parliament - Joint ENVI-PET! Public Hearing on Climate Change denial
Follow Up Flag: Flag Status:
Follow up , Flagged
Dear ß ,. I,
I trie~ to call you this afternoon aboutJhe upcoming Joint ENVI-PETI Public Hearing on March 21. As we were not able to talk over the phone, please note that, while we appreciate your inquiry into Exxon Mobil's availability and Interest in participating in the Hearing, we are unfortunately constrained from participating because of ongoing climate-change related litigation in the United States. As I'm sure you can understand, it is important to ensure that public commentary does not prejudice those proceeding-•■iT fflll li li ;:;1..1u:wau1
I would like to underscore our respect for the pivotal role the ENV~ßft'i'hf$!atpl,éjldfWG!lt~WU!l'' Parliament, and thank you for understanding the sensitivity of our current situation. ·.
Best Regards, ' • ! ,, I
~in E.urope on Twitter: tw:~~~~~':TutJ411!11 tllll,lil!BIMI . Visit ExxonMobil's Energy Factor. an online resource covering the cutting-edge technb""iMll■liULl;,ns that are helping to meet tomorrow's energy needs.
fi;grr1 ExxonMobil Petroleum & Chemical b.v.b.a., Hermeslaan 2, B-1831 Machelen - Belgium EU Transparency Register No: 0745650927-75 tlli illl d@ltm1'£¾W't.V,•'1\~».;~~, Registered office: Polderdijkweg, 2030 Antwerp; VAT BE 0416.375.270 ~ RPR Antwerp; BoAAntwerp EUR 685- 6691011-19 This communication may contain privileged or proprietary information. The information is intended only for the use of the addressee(s). If you are not the intended rectplent, you are hereby notified that any use, disclosure, or copying of the information is prohibited. If you are not an intended recipient, please notify the sender immediately
' From:flll Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 2:12 PM
!:~~ectrRE: URGelJT/ATTENTION PLS: FVy: 1:tît'6pean Parliament -Joint ENVI-PETI Pu~•mltlJ!l!l·.mge denial . . U lrfllffl'ॠ·' . .. i ... 11lfJ!II
Dear.~
Unfortùnâfëly l'lh still not able to give you an answer, but still hope tö give it by COB today as w.e had agreed.
1
Best, nikolaas .. ,n1•-, Ut JidM\ffi@■
Tel +32 2 239 3147 Follow ExxonMobil in Europe on Twitter: twitter.com/exxonmobil_eu Visit ExxonMobil's Energy Factor. an online resource covering the cutting-edge teçhnology and innovations that are helping to meet tomorrow's energy needs.
ExxonMobil Petroleum & Chemical b.v.b.a., Hermeslaan 2, 8~1831 Machelen - Belgium . EU Transparency Register No: 0745650927-75 •m1 ··;'.iii • Registered office: Polderdijkweg, 2030 Antwerp; VAT BE 0416.375.270 - RPR Antwerp; BoA Antwerp EUR 685- 6691011-19 This communication may contain privileged or proprietary information. The information is intended only for the use of the addressee{s). If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notiMed that any use, disclosure, or copying of thelnformatlon is prohibited. If you are not an intended recipient, please notify the sender imme~iately
From: i1ÏIÏlliil @eur~~arl.europ~.eu] Sent: Monday,·February 25, 2019 2:04 PM To: a I I @exxonmobil.com> Subject: Re: URGENT ATTENTION PLS: FW: European Parliament - Joint ENVI-PETI Public Hearing· on Climate Change denial ·
Hello,
I was wondering if you already have an answer concerning the participation of Exxon to the public hearing {as we're. meeting our Chair at 15:00 and it would have been good to update her). Thanks! ·
On 19 Feb 2019, at 13:59, @exxonmobil.com;> wro $]X,'- li ]IF Dear
I'm writing yöu following below mail to my colleagu , which I understood you had contacted by phone earlier this morning.
I was unable to.approach you earlier. I just tried to contact you via phone to seek some more information on this Joint ENVI-PETI Public hearing. I will try later again, but alternatlvelv you could always contact me on my mobile on:
Yours sincerely, •--atRflPŒ■r
•Btfflii•llMk 1• ,,..
2
Ill __ ,- _
· , .:{*-'r.-,v ~ From: Sent: To: Subject:.
l ••· 01 March 2019 11 :28
RE: Possible'participation to a Pub,~~~te Change denial on 21.3.19 at the European Parliament
IINli~~'-t
Hello,
, Coordinators confirmed you as a speaker on Wednesday. You will receive shortly the official invitation with the most updated programme of the hearing. ·
As requested, here you find the study launched on Wednesday by Adelphi: https://www.adelphi.de/en/[email protected] !Nib 1 1 ·11111C ~w~m:· Mlltlt
Best regards,
From: Sent: 18 February 2019 16:42 To: Sub~ect: Re: Possible participati fi Î f~~~Mf@ijf;on Climate Change denial on 21.3.19 at the E_uropean Parliament · ··", ·
■ WC? J f ' . '.1 I I di 11 & t ~P P QQJf}t D t I ffbilliêrl I •;
.-.JWitlkl'imti!tW!!:tjtdt'MMI mid' '·•»"Université càtholique de Louvain (UCL)
Earth and Life Institute (ELI) ~im.rt£ t1mllU: Georges Lemaître Centre for Earth and Climate Research (TECLIM) Place Louis Pasteur 3, (bte L4·.03.08) · B-1348 Louvain-la-Neuve Belgium
E-mail t ] @i1clouvaîn.be 9Pf CJ1dimate.be is a valid alias) Tel: • î I ■] (les courriels sont préférés; e-mail is preferred) Web: www.climate.be/vanyp, vvww.ipcc.ch, www.uclouvain.be/envi and www.cfdd.be Acknowledgement: The support given by the Walloon Government to the "Walloon Platform for IPCC" i~ gratefully ackn~wle<lg9ti .. V#Midt Remerciements: Le soutien ac~a~ffarre wallon à la "Plateforme Wallonne pour le GIEC" est très apprécié. (Voir e-GIEC.be)
·~4"~S%; ~~.;@$f1it .. ':-.~t':::··:(.:}~·
Le 18/02/19 '~ ,, .
Merci d'avance,
J'N kllrMl'liiillll I ..
. . :.:¥.?.K.4U U ltilill.U ..... L .. Il, ... J. Jl ill From. Sent: 18 February 2019 14:37 To: Subject: RE: Possible participation to a Public hearing on Climate Change denial on 21.3.19.at the European Parliament·
I think I mîssed your call, sorry. I called vouback but there is the voice mail. I'm in the office now ·
From: E ' I Q douvain.be> Sent: 18-February 201912:01 To: C '. f a t l · I' §)europarl.europa.eu> Subject: Re: Possible participation to a Public hearing on Climate Change :df'll I denial on 21.3.19 at the European Parliamènt
-~l.Uöt!Mfê!$EJ 111 a Y es, could I call you àfter 2pm ?
Le 18/02/19 à 11:53, a écrit: Good morning, When would you be available for a quick talk by phone? This afternoon? ~J'fïitllü:(fA!tW-.!fAr~..,,.. ·
em••t11ÏtJÎ~~IMiiAkiWffif#~ftN¼YV~~.11u_,_.fflllltl!IIIM.ft till . .. :;~1#%~:;;.;_;~;~~-M~ffl · P Mt
From: Sent: 15 February 2019 13:17 To Subject: Re: Possible participation to a Public hearing on Climate Change denial on 21.3.19 at the European Parliament ·
. Yes, possible in theory, but TBD on Monday. JWIHlllend the draft prWIIINMl lfl 11111111 --
. A UU dk h• Cordialement, Best regards, Met vriendelïke oeten,
bbl&
. . . '. 1 ,:::;p: rs t:
2
Le 15 févr. 2019 à 12:40, a li ii f'mroparl.europa.eu> a écrit:
Dear Mr
I am contacting you informally to explore your availability and interest in participate as a speaker to a Joint Public Hearing organised by the PETI and ENVI Committee of the European parliament on Climate Change' denial. The event will be held at the European Parliament on 21 March 2019 from 10:30 to 12:30.
that we also contacted gave me your name and I know you recently came for a similar event on the ·SDGs.
I would appreciate a quick reply so that the draft programme of the hearing can be finalised. If you are theoretically available I can circulate to you the draft
~ programme of the hearing and of course · we can further discuss at the phone on, Monday about the purpose and object of this event. · '
Best regards,
ENVI Secretariat
3
..... ,111&