of'the - veritaszimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/first report... · 4 "2 c ci...

29
% t, s -i:. S tr C O IND S E S S g OhI - tr X G]I]IT i\T PA$RX,XA1\Atr N]il F'NR.ST R.EPOR.T OF'THE T'X]IEIWAT'NC COI\{MNT'T'EE @I\ II\DNGENIS,ATNO]N.AiND EMPOWER.MENT' ON T'HE OFER,{T'TOINS OF'' TT{E COIWM{JNINT'Y SHARE OWNER.SHW T'R.{JST'S.AhID EN4PLOYtrE SF{AR]T OWhIER.SE]I{P SCHEIWES Ft'esepsted to Ffir{isrpeetat Febrt,saryt 2015 (s"c E, 20x5) DISTRIBUTED BY VERITAS e-mail: [email protected]; website: www.veritaszim.net Veritas makes every effort to ensure the provision of reliable information, but cannot take legal responsibility for information supplied.

Upload: others

Post on 11-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

%t,

s -i:.

S tr C O IND S E S S g OhI - tr X G]I]IT i\T PA$RX,XA1\Atr N]il

F'NR.ST R.EPOR.T

OF'THE T'X]IEIWAT'NC COI\{MNT'T'EE @I\ II\DNGENIS,ATNO]N.AiND EMPOWER.MENT'

ON T'HE OFER,{T'TOINS OF'' TT{E COIWM{JNINT'Y SHARE OWNER.SHW T'R.{JST'S.AhID

EN4PLOYtrE SF{AR]T OWhIER.SE]I{P SCHEIWES

Ft'esepsted to Ffir{isrpeetat Febrt,saryt 2015

(s"c E, 20x5)

DISTRIBUTED BY VERITAS e-mail: [email protected]; website: www.veritaszim.net

Veritas makes every effort to ensure the provision of reliable information, but cannot take legal responsibility for information supplied.

Page 2: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

@RDERED nN TtrRIWS OF'ST.ANDINTG OR.DER No.153:

1. At the commencement of every session, ihere shall be as many committees to be designated

accoidiirg to government poilfolios as the Standing Rules and Orders Committee may deem fit.

2. It shall be tire function of sucli coinmittees to examine expenditure administration and policy of

government departments and other inatters falling Lrnder their jurisdictions as Parliament may, by

resolution determine.

3. The members of such coinmittees shall be appointed by the Standing Rules and Orders

Committee, froin one or both Houses of Farliament, and such appointments shall take into

account the expressed interests or expertise of the Members and Senators and the political and

gender composition of Parliament.

TEFd]\{S CF' R.EF'trR.ENCE

Subject to these Standing Orders, a Thematic Cornmittee shall-

(i) It shall be the function of such Commiffees to examine government policies which fall under or

relate to the designated theme or themes, and other matters falling under their jurisdictions as the

Standing Rules and Orders Committee may determine;

Page 3: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

Oir Tnr-rr s Cray, i7 Ootob er 201s,

cn Standing Rules and Crclers

Committee on Indigenisation ancl

Ficn. Sen" Bhebe MHon. Sen. Chief Chitanga C.F

F{on. Sen" Chizema C.F

F{on. Sen. Chief Danclawa T"h4

F{cn. Sen. Goto R.F{on. Sen" Juba A.FIon. Sen. Mabugu F.EF{on. Sen. Mahofa S.ts

FIon. Sen. Vlaluleke C.F{on. Sen" Chief MarczvaFIon. Sen. Mashavakure J*{.

F{on. Sen. h4atiirira A.Hon. Sen. Mavhunga hzi.

Hon. Sen. Mlotshwa S.

F{on. Sen. h4uchihwa R..

Hon. Sen. MupfumiraP.Hon. Sen" lrldlovu J.

Hon. Sen" Chief NembireF{on. Sen. Chief NyamukohoF{on. Sen" Chief }*lyangazonke V.lrlF{on. Sen. I{yathi R.

F{on. Sen. Sibanda W.FIon. Sen" Tawengwa C.Z

h/iadaiir Fresideni of the Senate anncunced that the Cornmittee

rrcminatect tire following members to serve on the ThemaLte

Empo\ryerment:

F{ot'p," Sew" Cfsazerfra{E to he Cfauarpers,om

Page 4: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

1. O INTR.OD{JCT'ION

i.l Uirder indigenisation and empoweilnent, govemment focuses on broad based economicempowerment to ensure the majority of Zimbabweans are integrated into the n'lain streameconomy and that they become drivers and beneficiaries of the economic activities in thecolmry.

1.2 Some of the vehicles that are being used to achieve broad based economic empowerment are:Community Share Ownership Trusts (CSOT), Employee Share Ownership Schemes (ESOS,Direct Equity Participation, Procurement and Youth Development Fund among others.

1.3 Pursuant to its oversight role over the executive, the Thematic Committee on Indigenisationand Empowerment resolved to undertake an inquiry into the operations of the Community ShareOwnership Trusts and Employee Share Ownership Schemes in order to assess the progress madetowards the implementation of these schemes in accordance with the requirements of theindigenisation law. This report is a summary of the Committee's findings, observations andrecommendations on the same.

2.0 OE.TECTXVES

The objectives of the enquiry were:

2.1To understand the operations of both the Community Share Ownership Trus'is and EmployeeShare Ownership Schemes.

2.2 To assess the extent to which the programmes have been implemented

2.3 To appreciate challenges that may be hindering the implementation of these schemes.

2.4 To recommend strategies that may enhance the successful achievemeni of indigenisation andempowerment.

3.0 Vf,ETFIODOX-OGY

To gather information on the implementation of the Community Share Ownership Trusts andEmployee Share Ownership Schemes, the Committee held oral evidence meetings and receivedwritten submissions on the same.

3.X. Ona[ Evidemce Sessions

3.1.1 On behalf of the Permanent Secretary for the Ministry of Youth, Indigenisation andEconomic Empowerment, Mr. Sigobodhla, the Director of Indigenisation and Empowerment inthe ministry, unpacked the Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment Act [14:33]. This was

4

Page 5: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

clone in order to enhance the Commitiee's understanding of tlie indigenisation and empowerment

legislative framervork.

3.1.2The National indigenisaiion and Economic Empoweiment Board, Chief Executive Officei',

Mr. Gwatiringa briefed the Committee on the achievements and challenges that the Board is

faced with in various sectors in as far as the implementation of the indigenisation prograrnmes is

concerned.

3.1.3 The Committee received oral evidence on the operations of the follcwing six Community

Share Cwnership Trusts:

i, Bindura Community Share Ownership Trust

ii. \4hondoro-Ngezi-Chegutu-ZvimbaCommunityShareOwnershipTrustiii. Uzumba-Maramba-PfungweCommunityShareOwnershipTrustiv. Gwanda Community Share Ownership Trustv. Umguza Community Share Ownership Trustvi. Bikita Community Share Ownership Trust

3.1.4 The Committee also received oral evidence on the operating modalities of the Employee

Share Ownership Schemes of the following three companies: Meikles Limited, Schweppes

Zimbabwe Limited and Delta Coqporation (Pvt.) Limited.

3.1.5 In addition, the Committee received written submissions from all the witnesses that

appeared before it to give oral evidence on Community Share Ownership Trusts and Employee

Share Ownership Schemes.

4"CIT'F{E COV{iWlTT'trtr F-INDI]qGS

4" X. XND EGtrNNSATSON GEhIER.AT, C CV{PLNAIqCE

4.1.1 As of February 2014,theNational Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment Board (NIEEB) had

processed the following indigenisation plans subrnitted by cornpanies in different sectot's of the economy:

ivlining-464

Finance and Tourism-zl8

Vlanufbcturing-40X

Other-376,bringing the tctal to I 459"

4.L2 Cballenges encountered in pursuing compliance include a misunderstanding of the

programme, resistance by some companies, intransigence, avoidance and politicisation of the

economic prografilme.

Page 6: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK

4.2.1 The Community Share Ownership Trust is established in terms of Section 148 of the

General Indigenisation Regulations of 2010 and registered by the Registrar of Deeds.

4.2.2 This scheme is a govemment initiative under the indigenisation programme aimed at

ensuring that communities have shares in companies that exploit natural resources in their areas

and use the proceeds from the shareholding to fund developrnental projects in their communities.

4.2.3 Foreign-owned mining companies operating in Zimbabwe are compelled to dispose of 5I%

shareholding to locals and at least 10% of this equity is seeded towards Community Share

Ownership Trusts which are reserved for the local community in which the firm operates.

4.2.4 The pledge is a donation to the trust in order to enable it to start functioning. It is also

important to note that advance dividend was also accepted as initial capital to kick start the

activities of the Trusts. The seed capital amounts have been given by businesses according to the

capacity of such businesses. However, there is no legal instrument to enforce pledges, hence the

Ministry of Youth, Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment and the board rely on persuasion

or the good will of the companies to ensure that the companies honour their pledges'

4.3 COMPLIAI{CE

4.3.1 Not all Community Share Ownership Trusts have received seed crtpital. Only those with

operating and compliant companies exploiting their natural resources have received seed capital.

By March 2014,only 16 Community Share Ownership Trusts out of the 61 that were registered

throughout the country were operational as some companies were yet to pay seed capital. A total

of USD116.4 million was pledged to the trusts by several companies across the country and of

that, about USD30 million was paid to the Trusts by March 2014.

43.2 ENNDUR.A COMM{JN{TV SH,{R,E OWNER.SE{NP TR.{JST

FredaRebecca Gold Mine pledged US$10 million to Bindura Community Share Ovrnership

Trust. The arrangement is that FredaRebecca Gold Mine will disburse US$l million per year to

the Bindura Community Share Ownership Trust for a period of 10 years. As at March 2014,thecompany had disbursed US$l million towards seed capital and an additional US$l million

through an advance facility, (see annexure I).

Page 7: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

4.3"3 MT{ONDOR.O-NGEZX.CIq:EGUTU.ZVNMBA COMMUNNT'V ST{,AR.E OWNER.SE{XF

TR.{.]ST'

Zimplats plege<i US$10 million to Mhondoi'o-Ngezi-Chegutu-Zvimba Coinmunity Share

ownership Trust and had disbursed the whole amount as at March 2014. The US$10 million was

to be shared equally among the three disti"icts which are Mhondoro-Ngezi, Chegutu and ZvrmbaThe Pan African mines are among companies that are rel.uctant in terms of compl.iance, (see

annexure 2).

43.4A2\JndB.A-M,ARAMts.A.PF'{J]NGWE COMMUINNT'V SHAR.E OWNER.SHNP T'R.E]ST

Larfage pledged US$1 million to Uzumba-Maramba-Pfungwe Community Share ownershipTrust. The agreement is that Larfage will disburse the money in thlee installments of US$333

000.00. As at April2014 the company had disbursed US$326 000.00. Other companies operating

in this community but are not compliant include; Rocklink, Sulleage Gold Mines, Natural Stone,

Black Granite, Ground Rock Gold Mining and Light Weight Gold Mining, (see annexure 3).

4.3"5 GW,ANDA COMMU}{ITV SX{AR.E OWI\ER.SHW T'RUST'

Gwanda Community Share Ownership Trust had four qualifying companies that made pledges

as follows: (i) Blanket Mine-US$l million and disbursed the whole amount plus US$4 millionadvance dividend loan. (ii) Pretoria Portland Cement-Us$l.5 million and disbursed US$1.4million, the remaining US$100 000.00 was being held by the company pending subscriptionagreement certificate from the National Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment Board. (iii)Farvic Mine-US$180 000.00 and disbursed US$30 000.00 (iv) Jessi Mine-US$500 000.00,and disbursed US$250 000.00 as at April 2014. Vumbachikwe Mine had not complied with the

indigenisation law, (see annexture 4).

4.3. 6 UlW GWZA COIWMIUNST'V SF{AR.E GWIVER.SF{XP T'Nq.{JST"

Pretoria Portland Cement pledged US$1.5 million to Umguza Community Share OwnershipTrust and had disbursed US$l 399 700.00 as at April2014. The outstanding amount of US$ 100

300.00 was to be disbursed upon the finalisation of subscription agreement documents, (see

annexure 5).

4.3.7 EIKNT.A COMM{JNNT'V SH.AR,E OWNtrR.SE{NF T'R.{JST'

Bikita Minerals made a pledge of US$ 1 million to Bikita Community Share Ovmership Tru-st anci

had disbursed US$50 000.00 as at April 2014. Other non-compliant companies that are operatingin the area are Bayrich MineA[an-Jiang African Resources and the Consenrancy, (see annexure6).

Page 8: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

4.3.E Of the six Community Share Ownership Trusts that appeared before the Comrnittee, onlyGwanda Community Share Ownership Tiust had received, in addition to their seed capital,dividend arising tiom their 10% shareholding in Blanket Mine. Bikita Community Share

Ownership Trust received the ieast amount of US$50 000.00 towards seed capital compared tothe other five ihat aooeared before the Committee.

4.4 F'NN.AINCE

4.4.1 Section 17 of the Act provides for the imposition of "one or more levies on any private orpublic company and any other business operatin g in Zimbabwe" for the funding of the Nationalindigenisation and Economic Empowerment Board's mandate.

4.4.2 Though National Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment Board made proposals and

submissions on the levies, it still does not have the Statutory Instrument to collect the levy.

Hence, the Board depends on fiscal budgetary allocations since inception with the result that the

programme has been grossly underfunded.In2014 national budget, National Indigenisation and

Economic Empowerment Board was allocated [ISD2.6 nai]liore against its request for USD X0

million.

4.4.3 The provision of financial assistance to business start-ups, rehabilitation and expansion as

well as management buyouts has been adversely affected by the perennial lack of financialresources. Thus, the National Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment Board has been

redirecting some of the loan applications for business start-ups to financial institutions such as

CABS and STANBIC, but has no power to approve on who should get and who should not.

4.5 .ATTATNMENT OF' TF{E 1O% S}I,AR.EX{OLBTI{G

4.5.1 Of the six Community Share Ownership Trusts that appeared before the Committee, onlyone Community Share Ownership Trust namely Gwanda had attained the 10% sharehoiding withBlanket Mine and has a member who sits on the board.

I

4.6 VOUTH EMPOWER.MEIVT'IN T'HE COMMUNITY SHAR.E OWNER.SE{NF T'R.UST'S

4.6.I Community Share Ownership Trusts are required to ensure that all infrastructuredevelopment projects engage youth through providing jobs. However, there remains a gap inCommunity Share Ownership Schemes to effectively address youth socio-economic needs.

According to the written submission from the National Indigenisation and EconomicEmpowerment Board, as of March 2014, Zvishavane Community Share Ownership Trust was

the only Trust that was proactive in ensuring that youth in the local communities of Zvishavanewere employed.

4.6.2 Circular Jt{o. 1 of 2A13 of the h{inistry or" Youth,Empowerment outlines that a quota be set aside, such that at

Av

Xndigenisation and Econcmicleast 10% cf the budget for all

Page 9: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

Community Share Ournership Trusts is for yor-rth einpowerment programmes. Cnly twoCommunity Share Ownership Trusts oi-it of the 6 that appeared before the Committee hadcomplied with this requirement. These are Eindura-US$i00 000.00 and Gwancla-US$250000.00.

4.7 EMPX,OVEE SH.AR.E OWNtrR.SFNNF SCF{EME tr.trG,AT, F'R,AVIEWOR.K

4.7.1 The Employee Share Ownership Scheme is established in terms of Section 14A of theGeneral indigenisation R.egulations of 2010. The regulation provides that at least 5%shareholding in a company shall be considered as compliance by a company establishing anEmployee Share Ownership Scheme. The purpose of this scheme is to ensure broad basedeconomic empowerment by ensuring that the workers participate by way of having direct equityparticipation in the companies they are woiking for. It was envisaged that this will indirectly leadto the increase in productivity levels in the companies anci low employee turnovers in companiesthat have implemented the scheme as employees derive job satisfaction and thus resulting instable employment.

4.7.2 It is important to note that Employee Share Ownership Schemes are only established bymeans of moral persuasion. Companies have a legal leverage not to implement Employee ShareOwnership Schemes especially when they have used other entities to achieve full indigenisation.

4.E CON4PI,N^ANCE

4.8.1 Meikles Limited had not empowered its employees through the Employee ShareOwnership Scheme. The Company borrowed US$1.4 million from the Pensions Fund of itsworkers to establish the Employee Share Ownership Scheme. The Committee was also informedthat govemment owed Meikles Limited US$90 million. Of this amount, the Reserve Bank ofZimbabwe had given Treasury Bills worth of US$49 million to Meikles Limited as at August20t4.

4.8.2 Schweppes Zimbabwe is performing very well business wise. However, employees gotUS$240.00 as dividends for the years 2010 and 2011, thereafter, they did not get them due to theUS$12.1 million outstanding balance of the US17,5 million loan that the company had borrowedfrom the local banks as capital injection. Employees expressed dissatisfaction over the groupcertificate that they own compared to individual certificates that the middle management of 6people have.

4.8.3 Delta has issued a total of 120 million shares to staff under the share schemes since 2009but has no control on how the employees deal with the shares they would have acquired throughthe Employee Share Ownership Scheme, resulting in most of them prefening to sell the sharesfor cash to fund their personal needs.

4.8.4 The tax legislation regards the capital gain arising from the share schemes as taxableincome which is subject to Pay As You Earn.

Page 10: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

4.8.5 When Zimbabweans buy shares froin the foreigners in existing companies, this amounts todisinvestment by the foreigners and money leaves Zi";nbabwe within 7 days of the transaction;the end result is capital flight.

4.8.6 Non-managerial employees received sha:es for iree vrhile managerial employees boughtshares through the Share Option Schemes.

4.8.7 Deltahas 2 employee share schemes namely:

I{a) The Share Participation Schteme (established in 1990). The employees have since received anet of US$150.00 each per year in dividends in the last few years. The Scheme has about 14

million shares cunently valued at US$20 million and has 2 45A participants.

1,(h) Empowerment Scheme- 20 million Delta shares were allocated to permanent employees inGrade E and below in 2008 with.each getting 5000 shares. The scheme matured in September2013 and the bulk of the employees opted to cash in. A total of 14 million shares were sold forUS$18 million with each getting a pay-out of about US$5 800.

(2) Share Option Scheme-Managerial employees participate in this scheme. They are offered topurchase a given number of shares at a price fixed on the grant date. The employee can walkaway from the arrangement if the prices are not attractive. The Share Price is oniy payable onmaturity after a minimum vesting period of 3 years. Currently, PAYE is payable on the discountoffered by the company arising from the share options or the capital gain over the vesting period.

4.10.8 Delta also empowers sorghum and barley farmers through contract farming which it fundsto the tune of US$60 million per annurn.

5.0. COMMNT'TEE OBSER.V.{TNONS

The Committee observed that:

5.1 The Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment programme is grossly underfundedresulting in some empowerment programmes e.g youth and women empowelment programmes,failing to take off. ,

5.2 The coilection of levy is the only legal source of funding available to the NationalIndigenisation and Economic Empowerment Board, but does not have the Statutory Instrumentto do so.

5.3 Some legislative and bureaucratic issues are hindering the smooth implementation of theindigenisation programme. These include among others:

(a) Lack of clarity on the Indigenisation and Economic Empowetment Act;

(b) the misinterpretation of the Act and regulations by the majority of people in thecounffy;

10

Page 11: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

(c) the dispai'ity betureen the Incligenisa-iion Aci a:nd other larvs. For instance, theh4inistry of Youth, Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment has to rely onother Ministries io ensure compliance, e.g. the Vlinistry has to get the Ministry ofhrdustry and Cominerce to assist them in as tar as canceling licenses withZimbabrve trnvestment Authority is concerned; and

(d) the delays by the Ministry of Youth, Indigenisation and Economic Empowermentin processing the subscription agreement documents that ensures the attainment ofthe L0% shareholding by the Comrni-inity Share Ovmership Trusts.

5.4 The apparent reluctance of most companies to allocate value to employees and to honourtheir pledges is a clear indication of the limits of the Act in dealing with broad basedempowerrnent.

5.5 There is communication breakdown between the lMinistry of Youth, Indigenisation andEconomic Empowerment and the Ministry of Mines and Mining Development in terms ofdisseminating information regarding the mining companies ihat are operating in the country.

5.6 Sitting allowances and other related allowances of the Community Share Ownership Trustsboard members are not standardised.

5.7 Faihire by some companies to declare dividends due to debts that they need to offset first.

5.8 Lack of understanding of the Employee Share Ownership Schemes by the employees.

5,9 Lack of trust between the employees and management.

5.10 Employees cease to benefit from the Employee Share Ownership Trusts upon retirement,death or when one resigns.

5.11 Zimbabwe Institute of Public Administration and Manasement trainins courses areexpensive.

5.12 Non-compliance by the qualifying companies e.g Pan African Mines, Rock Link, BayrichMineA{an- Jiang African Resources among others.

5.13 Poor investment portfolios as in the case of Gwanda Community Share Ownership Schemewhich had its US$2 million locked in MetBank due to liquidity challenges.

5.14 Capital flight negatively impacts on the successful implementation of the indigenizationprogramme.

11

Page 12: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

6.O R.EC CIMME i\F,,,A.T'NONS

The Cornmittee recominends that:

6.1 Govemment must allocate adequate funds and disburse it timeously to the National

Indigenisation and Economic Empowermen.i Board in every nationai budget to enable it

discharge its mandate.

6.2 Government must pu-t in place the Statutory Instrument that enables the National

Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment Board to collect levies by June 2015.

6.3 Government must ensure that the misconception or misinterpretation of the indigenisation

and economic empowerment is cleared immediately to allay fears to enable all concerned

stakeholders to particiPate.

6.4 Government must immediately come up with a piece of legislation that requires companies to

contribute a certain percentage towards the seed capital of the Community Share Ownership

Trusts; and which also gives powers to see that the requirement is enforceable by June 2015.

6.5 Government must come up with another piece of legislation that provides for the application

of punitive measures to those who fail to meet the requirements; this also applies to Employee

Share Ownership Schemes by June 2015'

6.6 Effective information dissemination by the Ministry of Mines and Mining Development to

the Ministry of youth, Indigenisation and Economic Empowennent on all the mining companies

that are operating in all the provinces in the country, is paramount to ensuring total participation

by these companies in the indigenisation and empowelment programme.

6.7 Ministry of youth, Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment must standardise the sittings,

sitting allowances and other related allowances of the Community Share Ownership Trusts of

board members.

6.8 Ministry of Youth, Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment must expedite the processing

of subscription agreement documents to ensure the attainment of the 10% shareholding by the

Community Share Ownership Trusts 2015.

6.9 Effective comlnunication in companies is vital to ensuring that employees understand the

Employee Share Ownership Trusts and are kept abreast with developments in the company in

order to avoid mistrusts and misunderstandings between the management and the employees.

d.10 Companies in every sector of the economy should, where they are profitable, declare

dividends to Employee Share Ownership Trusts for employees to benefit from the proceeds of

the companies that they are working for'

x.2

Page 13: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

6.11 The N4inistry of Youth, Indigenisation and Economic Empowermeirt should consider

institutions oiher than ZIFAM tlrat will offer the t-rair'ing courses of the Community Share

Ownership Truist board inembers ai a reasona.ble cosi.

6.12 Ca:paeity building foi'the Coiamunity Share Ownerstrip Trusi board meinbers should be an

on-going process.

5.13 There is need for government to strike a balance between orming business and creating new

value and attracting foreign direct inrrestment io address tli.e issue of capital flight.

In conclusion, the Committee notes with concern the failure by Farliament to provide funds forthe Committee to undertake fact -finding visits to some of these Communi'ty Share Ornmership

Trusts. The Commiftee therefore, urges Farliament to put more effort in the provision of funds

for Committees activities.

.7 -ll.f

Page 14: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

€ *'

bh-

+

V)

'| e-

F'

A

{ E

'*'

sHc

' a

tH

4r-.

-

P-i

vo-

{F

)CI

Lnn (D

A€E

H

FJ

Rl

-T

lse

H.

F

Fr

f/r\

@ t

rT#.

;+4

&6

Ft

\\eE

=l

6

A

(tle

\E

r'

E.C

A

Ea

!.R

ff'

5.6

5'E

FS

H+ \€

Ft

z,r

-\

gJ

CI* Hta

C'

CD

cD a

-N

)c)

(.,J

N)

wet

rA

AR

q\t/

\u

w

trar

ue!*

ie

e =

,(n

E#p

g=q\

+

L\;=

j :.d

.e.

i F

*G

atF

e1

Rq

tJ"

wE

Fkr

eB

F

\ R k s s e{ R R \ G h* oo \ B Fi

h \ Rd e e k \J F

} \ a Fq) e{ G k ftA R.

Rd fr e \ re e k RA a

sHi

("i

Fr.

,/T

\ '

qFx

H

X c

t8,Y

Vr-

-.

\ ts

CD

..+

?3F

&

&s

g E

g's

g 3

+€

& F

.E

aF

.5

(a

Fr

a €.

(a=

EE

e ^.

R,

F<

(,

g R

H 8

d"(a

aE'

\r

lE.

Fd

e.H

N

FrJ

nol

J.

!+

F+

.r

CD

(D C) o t\1

F=

# A

wu

8,ffi

FoF

F€

Fd

@

FE

lc

s€ HE

'(a

6q

0aR

S 5

g*r

ur-

(+

-.

- -

)*.

.;\

F'.v

E H

gT

';r

=

'(D

oL\ og

rflH F

/1 t*r

tr CA

cg) 6 c8)

rh ,9 F(

WH v

'-L--

)F

dfg{

Rr< Yl<

E}r

hd(.

re &

"-C

v)

t4l

S{H

5S€r

q;€H

#6

H-E

-g tr

El€

€ o=

+=

F+

5 -

x r

n e;

I g

I E€s

as=

$A=

fiEE

\ =

a-

==

E

.?

*.gF

D g

FD

a- *

6ei

Eit'

;7

t"6q

(u

ct

)Ln

=

.:p(e

1F

=

H

Sqe

sg

6ci

i o5

=v)

?a

mF

g€|

'{ Avv ao (a

tr x 6 '4F"{

FE

,

@ F4

d v Fe

fiE S

E &

FE

fu E

E i

A:i

ge6

e =

8 =

E n

H 6

.7.',

E H

€g 9

.;?

=E

6 $

ot C

D T

:68

E 3

eFO

xt

lHF

ari

lE.

FH

E

H

N)-

ao,=

\v o

=

o=

rq

or-

t)

Fr.

V

4 C

D !

i

F

s rr

=

F.;

?D v-

&

H

;d F F }{ F ,^ f' (a A Ffa

ts€d

o

(a t! \J F F x Vt

@ *#s

(-F

n'

l F

Fr

!'-?

yl

F.

I\J

c'

+i\

'r c-

f S

D\J

d-

.r

.+

n]O

-F5l

fi."'c

Foc

uopS

F;n

1 a

Osf

. C

D +

5r

'-+

sw H

3'

H(-

*)

i-a,n

(*

vL/

CD

CD

%*F

S6s

X F

dH.

FqF sxE

e@ F#

'cq

tsod F

€,+

6q€

F4)

E e'1

F |4 F-,

A F w)

F FE

gel

',F

oF

#F

. ch @ F )Edd

qE 3

3 s$

5Y'ia

cDA

wo-

='o

-q

F g

e fi

+ 5

q E

5;'

6.jj

2. (?

| 6:

ig(

tA:i

eD c

tX

i cD

r-F

O

X

L/

t.lo

*6ts

-4

ct 6 rH ,-

) S

A

(n frrt

rE

F s F:t

eH !d OE v1 4 F

fd F., @ F \d \J Rq

H Ft

Iq LJr{

tr!t WT

IJE

4o

+cD

Fn'

a td

a\

.\ ts

lf/

\r

!L,

Fr

^Am

1.J.

. \

., -|

. \

|

V)

ND

+T

le+

Yl

6E .,

'fo*

YE

tJX

(J

rA

11A

,Y

-Od.

15

;'=.

n'4X

ruas

.Hg

AcD

vr

Ln

.O(-

+V

)

FE

?.E w

ry Vkoe e F

"+ (a & >d

fd 6. fF @ F1 6 p ts'F

-nfl F

l

H H

G b F{ ts H; \' R h q F

q

g E

6 F

:*

36 F

qa#

=,5

F

q L

r s

cD i

6 a

A $

'}{

d-,

-;--

. -5+

;q':h

=aa

fg8-

il€s3

8-€F

:tX

Es5

Fts

ra68

HE

l; R

'c P

?,6

' H c

{E

a-3

=B

Xsr

D=

F4*

qdq

b- E

'dJ.

2'. F

3 E

=r

s s:

o*

5 I

i 5

e a

AR

+: ,s

"-b

Ho_

a+5'

HE

s u*

8-qg

rf,

ilcD

pD

g'

\ d

OU

)CtF

i

tr'

Fd

FE

d,q € R

iF

*t)r

{1a

o 6 @ (A

z @ e0 Fs{

d

cg) F"

(A (a @ (t)

(a E F"( l-, 6 !*d i".,

N h"{

oo w Frr

I \ B (\ F{{ R Rf a b Q b G. H

Page 15: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

4WR

F<

&

h.

qe.

iwc#

idd

Fd.

F

sE<

I&e

Fd

\d

H

fuS

gF

ogu

Hc

eF

F5"

Ho4

H (

n $-

\is

-uF

r \./

\?

.l ,r

\)"

4P

)/,\ 6.8

EA

tb

cD

3Fr

,F.

VL,

F

-I

fD

'\aH

ryrt

a

N

N)

!t C

D n

1 c-

r I

a)

r.

P

{ n

g3'O

a

I

F 3

H'F

i [ #

'3" F

E_ q

b'H

- 5

F' 3

1

i;PE

F;3

36F

dE

6qB

Fr*

ts85

$1 s

iA F

En

;l*gF

F{=

=P

a-

?*s

HG

6gR

gHcD

o

5\lr'

O

O

(D

O-

tH)

E e

gfE

gt S

--fif

fE H

Ff

B-'i

gF&

837r

+H

=ep

#$l€

g*tr

*'i'F

*af;E

ae&

igE

E'

30

fi 34

A

E"g

gF

e'

vr

5Et

.. (u

F

J (J

)

#3di

rf;#

EF

arF

EX

p

1:b

6 cD

X "

I 5

(D F

r 6

(e Y

'fi

Fgx

e fi

= *F

6;i e

7IIF

IIqF

S6|

-t);

:d(2

^.'-f

H6E

Y"F

.D f

ieS

v,H

.SF

H

1 .?

B;i+

;.,n

Tq6

F

6F _+ +

= ;

\Y 6

L+4

e^E

't'.

FH

oq H

. P

n'H

oa s

\v*t

EfIJ

OC

D

Eq{

co:

+5V

)r-

t a

f-:

L1'\

rJ-r

Va

[=.

CD

UJ

;J ' '€

) F

+ -

@ 5

=\JV

)

=C

Irc)

qJO

C

D.g

bA

a. =a

H("

-S5

'.r\

=

(^r

\-tiY cp

K

IJ+

!-

F-

l-l fJ

Page 16: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

|.z-*

I

t-'+

X -FD

O)

; (n

i--

+\J

V H

#.

f"+

;H (U

t-)

LnC

I\J

/ A

\.

l-v (- F a- 'd. t'+

w. o

*a-*

;aF

DX

o

5rr

e.-f

\v

6

CD

=;r

nl

s(e

6+qc

Dr

" s

* oq

(J=

=3o

)/^

-^

>

-)

J

FX

H I

Page 17: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

H

|=<

i-=

dN

\=/L

@@

FJ

ff\A

d'

F\

&\g

\q

\ rr

' b

6.'tu

F (aF

<S

}=

sFa

ni"9

@ F+

bs

E.H

Xer

pw

v \-

/of

)A

+\r

' )^

.o

\j,F

8-ct

4E

I\)

N3

\.J

&38

H6'

E S

. g

F*

fu

6 F

5

vdfg

l.v n"(a

gr€

=

"=

.6

eN

F

T

Fq.

e

l.-t> (t)

tJ CD Fl a B c)

N \ RI \ s ,i. i: tr{

t\ \ G t\J 6a h\ s A \ G} s \ s ,I tr f\ .\l Y. n s (s (J

li} R R El

(t{

14 tu q blo

\E I R' s t\d

F4

..$)

| I

HI

I

iJI

I

a"i

i

+-_

1N

- I

I X

t{d

,e\

|

Di

ygl

zt

6 R

Ii

rso

Fd

i

-rr

FF

ri H

.tri

5l

ffi E

'l@

i ca

6q

irl rl ll i rl

__._

]___

_r

_i

- I

EI

\-l (t) I

tr i

@ |

F

I

i-ri

giol

@

|

)-f

I F

+4

|

Ftl

vl _ill

Q

Ial

E'i

re i

Xi

rDi

rlti l*l

ll

.E-+

l

=B

-€5q 8'

., cd

'l.)n C

D \;

CD

rj Ff4

AC

D n F.r

.r

l- -+

-p\J

;-r

Q- <

g€"€

p

gs

= H

P'

=-

!{

--t

=

F1

(P

'_l

isr

flr

tso

F=

h&tl

E

Fds

;FF

.(ad g =

.6 E

'TF

FH

'@ t

" F

'qH

gF

#@

o).t.

l4

E>

AA

lRV

-$)

a

A.\

O-

r-f

HH

gBF

HC

'x-

b"*

F'a

5oq

uo

r-.+

'CD

o' E

tr V)

(& @ e"ts

(t)

'fgD

F]

g A

->rj

H F(e

sra

Fi

F-S

.+ ),

r .

|..r.

A

FC

I aU

)\l rA

.,

^ \t)

Xc+ :'{ 5

Ycr

tT

\ rd

Fr

\v

.l

IEA

H

\J\E

l \J

€F3

F\

\dV pd

ftw

)EF

5 6 H F4 w @ Fry

{p F

*$.

,at v tse

gt*,

g5il

FB

-H*S

g':t

l F

F\r

.!-F

v)i-r

|v)

3H s

: H

ol

a?

CI *H

E 3

=l

S,j

(A C

u-

=i

-,/r

tH % H

n gl

a

F.a

ie"J

a

cfN

$,E

3 $

Sq

i I

EE

3;+

gsi

*if,

trrf

q,o?

lY

'5

CD

+=

>-+

.F+

r #

ino

|-{

. '

hr

i (+

,5.=

:_J-

ql

H.<

\ c

\odg

l 6'

5 5@

i

$q

Nr(

'l tu

e-';

I

i#.,

\]o@

= E

s p

.ffi

g s'

Erg

\$ss

ij^

HsP

gf.-

r lJ

O

F

DS

+E

J F

It.J

{ O

-o.

\ F

$(,

(A

ffi$F

ill*r

l ps

3? F

l -

F'a

d'F

F:€

fr 6

F?

tF l.

* lE

F F

tg."

s i

I F

@2

Eit;

FR

R*E

FV

) =

gbJ-

FF

qA

i gf-

t ,a A+

.'d

8-

:s'

H

l5

.o

a.

r ,id

l

+ E

I >

z,

cD c

fl 2

eo

;6I

ffi g

X*i

8w

(y

Y

i F

{cD

lli

E3

(Di

ot-

-4.4

I

E4

F'

-' F

J

"nF

r er

Ssi

C)

;dl

FI

__-l

a\1

t-.

. l-f

'{-.

A.1

.

rcF

CIC

\JJ

5(D

F()

.-

FC

CD

Oe+

o E

LEIiJ

F

tsr-

+ C

D F

Di-d

F

J.>

) fDx

(v lE*r

% *

FdP

'd S

O

i*i.

ry

id$

rl|F

\'@)

&eH

ry

..O F

4P

e\

gF

f@i#

/ E

FE

t. F

dF

66e

e6,

'o

FD

fi:./)

FF

A.

t-

);C

D

'Jv) ct

)

gH 3',€

/h

(-F

\ Y

F

-.

\-/

t-i

tJ

irr

lqqS

IH

CD

(Dll- IA |

\J

rr.

)-:..

lq

(A

i4

r-+

' I

lL-.

. 5

ffiI

ctt

rD il

;'l@

c)

'! E i-,

n|

\,/

\ .,'

l

iPa)

EI

>-.

n

,'r)

i55H

I 'F

io l- oq

'+IH

SR

tr(e

F,

lEd

c\r

' d.

pi+

!Q|

Fdo

.|4A

4F

# ;6

tro1

\d \

d (a rG\

v F4

ets

llryI

dw € tr r bi ,a

\ V € Aq

adt

F<

P f? & CA

I I IrJ

lcu ti

Page 18: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

4ffin

Fq

(d

Rq

e{

Fd

lsW

F

Eo

EE

dg

@

\d

H f

uSt<

" F

dc

f?F

E<

R

ld

eV

Fsd

rq 0

a

H()

#.X

u)

s)--

FR

@A

V

\/ 't

A.

F

L-J-

i

-. 6'E

5ar

6 o,

# fs

p^'

vL.

' H

o A

.\f_

.1

irrA vt

|_

i

-?,

EiC

). f

r O

-E

4 e*

CD

'1f

nE-E

cD ea

.€.s

a. x

B36

='

s F

.o 6

5.d

?'a

gSsg

-gF

"Fs

E

11)

='

F

u) r

il rl.

\''p

4'

\./

-f

rD

;i i*

*

ilg'-f

:E'il

-.

t';F

ts

7,*.

F

Hi

LJ

-f

,.t1

5 *'

;

s.-t

s E

s'

+6

+'=

. e,

g"

H q

ilH'E

F

F H

', S

A

(aE

trE

'kF

Fa

\Y

r*

F'

Fl

H)

Ft.

nt:@

,h

Er

n(l/

A

q F

HP

'W

flE

l€.

+(g

)

CD

LJ ;J CD

H F+

r€gi

6g\./

F

r 'r

_.-!

:j

5c)=

R}

": s

FF

r;€

3F

i ?u

'- ;P

5

- c

H-F

sx 8

;i-,9

-3a

5 G

R

=

6'v

) 'U

;

Sr=

.H

I H

g

-\

F+

.\ iJ

t.

OY

'

(DO

q r-

j-t

v

t-r- ilX

E.-

?-F

'qJ$

))r 5E

xJH

F.e

='

5 s.

H 5

'rA

\-,

cJ)

\'rl\1

rd

.

FD

F.*

pD (vt-

) \J

H

vt

o-iJ

:Uln

-

f -

gl o

ct

Y.'!

1 r.

E5

0 C

) c

r.'*

r d

5 ;d

cD

F

D $

H

. F

f (Y

/r

\ iJ

F

:'' '.=

.6

[i X

X 5

F'5

urH

q€

54\

='

E

6FT

a-F

.i

#F*

{ d

o s

* 5'

E';

sr^

\r .

tt )r

ri.

=

* s)

a

:+

. F

) F

ir a

f,,

.rt

c+

-;

3e?F

r+F

Ailf

g;en

aeD

il€

.Ul?

l.

fr-.

.

F"t

15

3'

FD

;

t-f

(^)

liu)

H r*J

CD

0a FD iJ FD

CD ?

HA

A\H

H

;J

(Y

a*-

;J

-J.-

tC

D15

F:iC

DC

DC

D Y

C

D

s.Ji

F.

UY

(\

.\-)

/i

ts

-')oa

H50

'qv)

X C

).ig

cr g

oo

- !D

FD

.r

. F

D O

O

- V

)

?i;=

*=

i=gc

3'

CD

@

P

7 \J

F

J'+

,{r-

!,3{B

Ii

;.,P

*T:

T E

A oa

XE

EH

$FH

Ats

LI i,

'5 S

. 3 '

b-av

'cD

5C;J

-

Oa

H)

r-r-

+'

H

cra

Tgq

n F€

Fg A,'l

F F_

F.d o FT

la OE fD v2 I v 6 w F, 6 !'t F"4 (r)

(t)

F F @ (a

-hl

a-'

{r

!-d

E;J vt\

(9

FF

{v

\-,

FJ. er

A -. \,,

/(-

t .4

|J.

\/

5cD

oa8

}JJ

-\J

F+

)

n1V

PA

\ F8!

Fie

.a6E

s.r

J'-.

a.

5HH

HH

ilA

- tf

nD.\J

h

c"n

td. r-+

aq8+

FS

l.-

+

\J

,7 7

s)

o)_

ry r

y ct

sl

5 r-

?

nE

c.n

I

fre6

5iF

,:IgF

3s-n

Hg

HE

[tsIA

*H5X

EE

EH

Bw

YF

F{K

gsT

!'F*g

gFH

dCI3

HIa

HH

&E

;a*

O-

v )-

*-

r^'

(y

-.

JF

+

[5

7^'

.--+

A

- O

- =

')

vl

F-r

- '€

(-

l' ,ti

l

5cD

6

HrE

if6

Page 19: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

FI

e\q

I

wi

@l

tsdi

Hi

@l €?

i€l @

lI

Arl

Pl

Fj<

|

wl

ler

I

+--

*1

I

trd

biN

W@

@6q

eF

.ew

) td

e FC Rq

Fg €+ @e

F!4

@

pF$.

't oa

tr&

agq*

H"

N)X

Q

-L&

=F

XN

)-t\)

Fq=

{ wu

gtr

(g)

nclE

rdo

?H

F€

HF

dc sq F-E

'ca

6q

H ni'

oa CD

N \ € \ FJ s ?{ Fr

h \ G kr 9o Fq

c\r

R h \ \A € s HI \ ri \ e{ B trb s Rd I +{ q F

{'t\ \ R

I

sq .€ h fr s' \ I FI \ $ F}

tr t\ \ R}

R{.

rRil E b s.

.F

rd \ A \J .td t k tEl

N 3 !4 b Eil \, F

{R A

aF

tl

# P Fd

F{

Fd n w (e F E €-+

Fc

F !Ec

V2 6 A w

E T

;$3H

FC

O7

C

=,_

,r @

6: E

rFH

3 s

fi5

5=65

'-3

E=

U-,

5 l$

55*f

,951

t' F

e3:

'l N

.'!F

v)

5 g

u)

H F

;5F

f 6"

eH

'x)

x5

?xC

O *

''15

X

r., -

tJ

ld

(9

Fdf

i &8

#gE

.#;E

3 c

lS6

d a-

: cn

o.

SgE

H'3

FF

5

Fr.

YE

€ a

(>

=F

na.A

=(t

) !i

I g FD w FJ

oa CD H

?dH

id

uJ

F4

g,€

A

w'

( 1,

, F

h.F

txrd

. \t

i.i

etpc

aH A 6 H i=

d

tsS

Hfi

ES

AS

+S

g$F

$ rc

s tr

3 ff

=E

*E E

#$ F

s d

g [3

iA$F

-:H

: g

s$a€

gF $

;:f u

: F

s a

$ L$

g,n

s'$1

FA

EfB

$+H

s-a1

3fH

grL

sFB

-53e

sF

St E

ISe

FB

a 5

og'

.?

?g g

E

(Y .n

FZ

,(t

) G

)qs fD

{A

(af

V)

u//

H F.{ w CD H w

CD

=L

t.B

6*L}

Jct

)

o\)

t.-K n1

;J

>)- CD

X(e

i4a

l-r

.1"

*;v)

F

ryF

D;J i^ )4

.

9D H

q9ox

Av

iJ(d

dl-.

tH

CD

tJ '

:dt-

1 w

ni l.lJ

lr(n

F

D c'+

CD n.

<,

I-'

CD

l); q (e

l-{ '^-) e N |4 Fl

6 E (g)

Fd \t r @ A # aaA

uV @ A &t

F{ ^) F! r F

o4 H 'qH (a)

A F Fdc CA F+

v Ca H F

{ (a @ ,B v4

I I l-

Page 20: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

F=

={

b:J

XE

/!F

o

€ca

G"r

g o

€+6F

=A

E

#o\d

'..

Fca

+-

V(e

ffiD

sR

€+l!J

} F

oA (9

\d

F.{

F

.{.F

g

\# Fb

n F=

?El

=<

@R

qts

# e

e:s

@F

3M

.'

'd

Fq \_ e l# Frd

e

(A)

€+.

Ft

Fc e €"+ \

$SH

A il

trE

TF

H $

FH

trq

3#E

gff*

FP

3 E

A;-

.6 6

's 6

5'g

[;

6 E

'g- E

's"

*6 H

H E

n 6

oF

a .,

EE

"3 x

3 E

n 2

'TI

HE

gIid

fH F

H#p

6A-F

tri3

+=

E i

cy c

, F

; =

='=

'=

-r

v, e

= a

--#s

I X

Hgf

toF

SH

i &H

F-\

'E'*

)e

v E

" e

< A.q c# F5

D4!

t e

e.t

sd,

FE

IF

Ed fr A (e we

Fl< F#

g€€

F=

gRq=

=E

o &

v d

=

-r

--

w

"a d

E'*

-\

}i tg

)

e" e

+ w

)F

s.

(A(g

) w

Fd.

G

ryH

=6"

fD

i'*ts

qHg

\, 'J

Es.

ti"A

Oq

F€

€-t

/q,

Al

V

\E/

FrA

# \d

(&E F

tE

DF

E{

!# ts,

#\ \l/ !E{

# \# &

g.*F

S6s

FS

H

dPA

r!4c FqH sxE

6O wH

lEl

.dg4 6E

eF

dt

ry(e

,a\

tsrla

V

F=

+.

se i+

EE

. aF{

lAt

ld*o

e (a br/

FS €+ Fda

dts

d @

I w V)

|..Q (t. FD F.t

CD Ft

tr l€c w € 6.q

.J F'

|d t" t? (a

I I i t-_

i I

H.g

",€

.u€

5 sF

a.S

tF3s

ii E

Fx

*F:S

E"6

tsg.

f; x

.*.*

,3 g

. F

3 5

gq1t

s[(v

SF

6:e

-+-+

6

6i"D

s F

o A

**

n\

ldo

I

6p*r

-+t-

.

Effi

3H

=-H

CD

:sF

}{R

5o

\v u

+

O-

O r

-+ .\

.E

f;-r5

tsi-

F+

C

D

q-r.

r-.

i-i

O)

t+i=

.X

'o

5(y

r=

AC

Drln

.'+

I5

F'r'

tcD

L;', o l-. tJ

i;H ae EJH ')

ct CD

oa*r

go -q

a)

gJO

U)(

4tr

4l

h lr.

\-

-{;-

\Y

..-

+

7a

=

ld

;-i-

V)

\J

F-

FD

XV

'' O

v HA

C)*

qJC

D (

u o

'{r+ iJ

Hv

\-,

co (+ F

-t

Page 21: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

ren

\-t

-4

lF:l

a)N

t

i:]gr

E

< €

FF

{\J

itv

l

lE

o F

\d

-_-s

)its4

F\R

qA

iFJi

#dq-

r f,f

r I

Fot

F

:ddo

e

!-+

A

I

F=

{ F

s{

doH

r.'/!

F@

P;a

H F

l6q

sa

q\v

fi\

{

(v

I

HI

F1\

\ |

|.-r

-\"

I\i,

\J

i

CD

F.II

BA

\la

i.J./.

I

,d

l

a* O CI u)'

WE

il-H

'g*E

&\t

!d

tEr

Pq

i=J

HO

@#|

. ts

rle

e.:Y

A

q r.

*F

E{

Ww

@

s (a

A \-l

FE

F,

e.q

F F# r ED rq F 0q G (a

n(-F

lv

-

\J

H

cgF

Dx

4ia

A

rY

). t

lr hr

o

l--

Hl-t

F

.. 5

'v

IJ

F€F

sd

w ,

:. cD

i^

v ri'

:i

s0.-

,J

C

t bD

Uv

(-

a.1\

- H

. \y

>,id

|n ()d

= H)

5 R

u a.

I

\ -

l-r

l-TI'A

)At IxE

XE

'H

EgX

He=

.+d5

-1.'

(9

fro

{-

(-r-

A

rfn

at

r id

F

F

e\v

\y

i^

H

A-

CI

XF

\t)

1v (DIf

XC

D(9

Page 22: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

*,

H*=

-_l

tuV

L

I

&,

&,

\y

\d

e"E F9 e F

*d,@ 6.

.\w F

{il# e *"

i

6E FC (a €-+

F3

Rq w + |se A 14 @

K N) tu

,%\4

/ ru

Effi

FE

lo

PF

4 F

ed@

Fel

o 8€ ffig'

(&)

6e

lt HH v.

\J

f-fl

b-l

ng \I;Jt.-

a n CD (+ >dr o

K:*

43

E'tn

HC

D3:

{;,,

SC

D 5

'$5 iJ

. t'-

F

'

Lr

>-(

?CI6

@@

si

L \ F$ \ d N ?t Fr{ R \ G q aa fr = € RJ \r s $ e) s- \ \i F) \ \. Fi

R R \ ha Fq.

rRt. -q U

1 t a \ rs R \d, \ FA G 3 q B-

LSs

a

Eq \' (\

l €\.

a4 F*

-' t't

r-

a

t4

a /'-

. r

tA

. 14

r

DD

5

X

S

?'Lr

-

i -

v --

i'*--

{ fT

J

=*H

F5:

.zF

4o;'8

';4H

-\e€

I5 8

,fr.=

? 5

0* g

k =

J'-o

-oC

D

oo-'c

i

=7r

K &

s S

SsE

s A

1 3

F{

X =

XE

'-'-;

v-

-}J'

:\

s 1.

3 T

= T

g F

g F

F.

FF

I \y -F

o

' -

t F

D.n

Ea!

'HN

{C=

J.d*

Fp.

Crir

\-{

(-{

\-i

FT

ws

wo;

'E F

I S H

_E_*

AF

E=

: H

IE#

ffiV

ffi-

?.8

6 S

:,3tr

;rF

.-.r

o(,jH

-o -

t|Jp

uf C

I c>

6'F

=

.6

Z, F

eLc

D,D

o i

S F

;F

R'

EF

Es!

-EG

FE

sF

E?f

r3+

#+3

t4

lr\/i

J\J}

-{ FT

56

5 w

U. ;F

*;gH

gF

o c'

o€

+

=6'

b.

h cD

O

Fn.

.+

Aa5

._

(D

kd 'r-J

f"d ts F'

Fr,

a l* (t)

F1*

1 vF (D A * 6A tD i" ry F B E F

JA d (g

)

A 4 F!!s rg)

4 \J ed Fd

F3 (t)

ED

+.&

/

FF

{

F Flt

H w A +'*

"/rg

)

4 H i# A G{

@ =+ F9

FF

.tA

tA ts

qH

E H

f il&

F*e

E tu

3e

Fbg

b,c

F

'! -_

4 H

5,il

f; sE

.d n

.g F

gE

Eqf

ffi*=

H$g

adE

g*a

oStH

pFtr

\'/=

'F $H

HA

H.:H

.1 8

ts

d s

H.F

H'

ExF

:F

e E

AgH

Bg.

qrg

.c

FJ

+ifo

A

N

) 3'

otr

2,ca

@ HR gw F

4 H H (D r< F!,

€5 €

Ejg

6-F

g H

ir*

sgT

ef,5

it#E

dsF

{Ys

,_,F

.'_$E

"$fr

3H8

H-

H .A

'E ;

A-Y

H 6

aC

D ?EE

t;s a

rO

-:..n

5

e np

-

HE

F'f

? $*

FE

fE

t$f;t

rEilE

9.€

il$:

AE

H E

H +

sBE

gaH

'esE

nri E

::tit

?E

h'c *

o s

o {;

; $

* $

H_ F

; fi

gfiil

+L*

pEl 3f

i$m

i'

e'+

c-

l''

(DC

D3r

j0(

DC

DO rd

(Dep

U)

;J o-I I L

Page 23: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

s€tr

HP

R

i -T

P

€e

6'4€

"Ktr

-bfu

6 E

g

\-Jd

F

+-

V

n'(a

#

6r"*

gi

="6

ftF1

H4 -\

€ -

n A

- J-

,;;

-"

uev

)-F

a.

(.+

o =

.9.

Fr)

rt'

O

=o F6

a..{

€CD q6

F4W

nry

eae.

lai

lE

' F

d F

d6

FiE

aH

! F

d \d

5 &

sia

o E

o e

FE

{ R

rd

op

w

;rrd

.

6q 6

q

Nnl H iA

€€R

PC

) V

l (l)

5-c_

5'H

o p_t

l' g

5F

i PH

1rll

'LJ

L/

CD

Ft

F-i

*..t

V)L

F3E

PS

o =

d.a=

"F

"q&

t? t

r F

s

ER

;Fra

(t

) A

% =

.6 g

'qH

5rd

. ;

t:ca@

r-F

Fsp

e

\f)

5F H

w 7

.Ys9

5fr

:.=A

(Y

A

FE

detE

{ E

d e

E5e

:@A

. !-

. -

(Y

Ar'

F#

!d

tBF

d ;#

+ (a

gEru

€Ft

A

/ql

\J

\J

tun

w)g

F5 6 F

F{

F{

fE f0 F @ + A bt ta41

%*F

66R

FT

rd

SA

'

ld.

lL@

g

FS

HF

d F

r€F

d.

HF

+6q

eH

?

8g2E

gf8"

8€zH

6EE

23

; g

H c

) tr

F r

FD

re

x-q

R *

grj

t ?

r'g

3 g€

=

Fr 5

= H

.x iJ

g H

,8 s

s?aE

asE

*3+

FfiE

LHsq

A*

eEE

H+

5:6E

=8d

5tg:

uav'

H\l!

6

, 8-

F

v'! F

().<

CD

3 H

Ss

to\

t A

t

ts

i--.:

l-vF

f5

5 F

r u)

cD tr

; E

Uq

sq H

rFX

I

r-iA

n'b

i-5n

>)

a-x

F q

o(,

?

(-F

O-

9. o

:t'

fFD

trv) lq

l o

\dd pt

siF

st

Fd

r'a

||4

AP *g

q (g)

,a\ \r' l4t

e Fqd

FJ

A

t.tH

*'iJ

A/h

\./

\v

.-+

SE

A

' lr.-t

14

\Joo F1

u) *& "o c

f'(<

tr Far

fF

# A v 4 Ai

H Fqt f., O $ ct)

9*'q

F ti

JF

+ u

) cD

SE

'{e+

^ a)

6H

If.

\./

\l

-1

V)

E;<

^6,

\'/ Y

ii

i-{ ')\-

,C

D

fats

Hgo

I I I I I

F ca (g) o + (a

KP

P

f-.

HiJ =

'NtJ

i-.

poa

R It4d

,d Rq

H 16 |d G |4 ,- 0q fD (a

6' q

H g

bcr

0-[

,' O

='

c E

'CD

tr a

?E'E

PC

I IJ

q =

aqC

D!d

PF

r-+

+F

C

I g

'ot'D

'- qXF

='E

iacr

DiiC

I(r

oa T

o.=

Page 24: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

()

7 ry

l I

o-'|H

|J

iJ

4 iJ

H7\

r-,

qJ

\v

=.

=C

I*a

6FD

Eo- '

CD

().

=fi(

-,)

6o=

"1

V)

CD

c"+

(t

) \,

FA

.

ft86#

dqF

8g€F

s,2

=3E

r, e

<^F

B E

.g:ig

.oE

EF

fa-r

rHtiF

=ad

i]5

?,H

E?H

€ffts

: 3A

?gI

sdF

dgiq

."nA

H*

'5F

5+cD

5'

r8

6 cD

ctsa

if fr

=

F

qF {q

gg.E

-its=

ilFd€

FH

<*F

E F

F?

=E

H ?

**H

'tr

S .+

$.9

E =

g f S

i I H

Hqe F3

Ta-

AS

aF

p-o-

Ff

A-c

>

I$6

o 6

r-cD

E'fr

5g

3$ g

r-+ 6c

' fr

a a

rl- ll ii i_1_

Page 25: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

N k t. \ trri s P(

Fr

h \ (\ (.t

ta tr{

=o\\) trl

0q Gr

q f.l R k- ft s' h s FI \ \i s F{

R \ RA .$. h 3* q fr Q \ F

I (\ \ 6 s -R.

tsQ

n \" a er q Fril

ry F FI

F*

tsd

t*d w 6 Fs

Fne

V2

'!tt

\dl

E F5 (a @ A F6d H ^-

)F R F

d A frdd @)

@ w e.ts

Ec

Frd

tsE

l c

(g)

(D rA i'-

(g)

L-A

-

t^) \o \o { ,^

t

cD F

*rn

g ts

i6

fi dE

'-- F

c.n

d F

grgT

E;3

p n

E.x

anE

sF$f

fiH

B R

H€

CD

O-

a H

. C

D

5 u)

F

|:+4

)=-*

NL ms

qeffi

I=61

e

Hce

d4f

bbr

c(k

ai

trE

c@ eg

9F

EI

o ;*

At

U ,= =:1

bA

r

H V @ a (9 ,Fl k

vt*

F-t

hl

() 5o NJ

H-

\/ tf,

.

N)

F.i {

FS

E g

Fdo

F

E

fA

@ F

5#.;+

F+

T&

@

F*

\-A

}:e

A.

lc

'+LJ

r F

qL

p

#'(a

E

5.H

e

5.6

5'A

FlH

GE

+\ \O

Ft

15 o

- o-

8,6

{ n

g z

s *

EE

g=sH

bBF

flx"

S g

,-r

E g,

* f"

S "

* +

Eira

nf+

5fiff

i;S

gqH

.FH

qg

sfv

rets

F4

Aq/

frJ

frffi

Fld

c W

Fd

Fnd

FE

J ts

* .

8q'

KF

'(a

) 6q

Ffr o

g€€

F.

=-s

X E

se.

g e*

' t E.

E"-

R;F

EE

ro i

!)

4-

ft

R =

.6 g,

Fy

F

FH

'@ a

F'

sse AI<

ld

dF

F E

6qru

ery

F\

,ar

\d

\./

e*O

ch#

Ft

@ E H @ fE{

|qa A v F4

%*

Sas

X F

dH.

k€g

eSB

rqtD

FE

6 ln

fF

-4.

!.,

5 et

'6E

€F

+f

e F

q4r-

\/F

o{

Fd

tsdl Qr

.e w!

(9

A

=H

;i+ tdd

(Al6

El

A @ tsd

!€J

a cf

a

I

tr o

d tr

u)

E--

X e

Ei/\

nr

5

n t.,

;l-uF

o 6 sH

g\-

/4

CD

a

d(A

F

IA

\ f-

c-l.

5 id

oa C:r

fD

ry(e

A,

Fct

.\./

dr

s+ fd

F'

a F

qlr''

\}-T *oq (a V F

46 F

leH m

tr7,

(n@

CA

rh

oli gtr

F.{ H w o F!€

F fE+

'.

FH

tqfe

f$sk

$F=

EE

5E3r

*iS

ddgE

HS

qsd

f\r

i#3E

HE

1g

- \'

c-f

Fi-t

-

{ s0 CD FJ H & CD ()

F'

F-'c F*d A v € Aq

idt

F{ ts, e @ (A

xF'€

EjH

;*H

gHti

a3E

]#8-

=fr

7r;=

sdQ

H58

" f-

i5$c

Poa

Ts

F) H

g '

1*

F, o

d 7

5 E

H I

i*F

oa

6'

q'-:

i.X6 s'

€'

€ 3

g ?

= =

Fv)

O

4

+n

a $f

; H

c-..H

,K

(e

T8

='

F?P

FH

oa

3

U)

v2 LA ;^,

FtF

{^) €d Fd

F{

d dn fr (n ts?{ Y

Fs- fD A l* OE o f\ F

tr (8)

(h fD e"+

(a

E"3

I in

sfl:*

HF

Do-

o,- A

F(

U

F)

trr

;,+o-

cD x

+

nDg6

g14

F

.. H

-1.

r+

iln6

:

u(n

y'F

+

---l-

---

Page 26: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

wn

eRq

FE

lnd€

F#

icc

trJ

Rq

Frd

o 6

F{

lrd o

P

,4.

0Eq

F4

Fl

At

Fh:

Fdo }{ @ FE

E Fd

OE

n1

r-+

|

-b+ H

d€;-

oHF

V)C

I-=

' ^

tr4

\J

=w

'-l d

F{

H\

Fl (D

Ytd

'

)

3FD -

\rt

d(D F

t(a

n \l FqF @ Rq

w Fd

I.d CI

FI

,d OE @ (a

I R s

s, a

H "

G" gg

$ gq

+ g

$ gg

[g;E

$pgt

fE;H

{3.

l-r g

A F

; q

a ifi

g S

g 6

F E

s! b

-E |J

silfE

sEs[

$H$1

$alli

E.F

F ;

H eg

A \/

;. $

:sfi

F g

i L

+.?

i r

tr

H F

.; u

g 6'

[-__

FF

.-\

ra

\./

Fd.

l--.

).-a

)J.

F

)-)

oa *

=.

/1\

,)

vr\Y

J

c.+

F(D

Fr' a sD

v t

rf,P

'-{F

Jq

i"\P

. l.4

a"C

I { CD

rrt

\^J

tsi )-{

X5X l-a bJ

A;-

.+

V F4

il.iJ

(+

FJ.

co

p x

FD

0'a

A

f-t

\v

!98-

PdT

.;J

A osJ

CD

rtP

5'I I I I i I

_-1_

_

WH

PP

FF

*09

F"

\l/

bd

F.

H

L'

€+.

5Rep

g.

W.

A.

\ l,

Aq

fE€d

F.{

}a

dF

d ts

d€+ (&

* F

- H

'F B

eE

K "i

r5

B- it

*q E

i?- n

H =

'P

FD

H=

'X$=

n0H

F+

3F*e

ER

HH

F 6

H 8

.F F

tr E

3 ii

=.(

)+O

Fgd

r,6

+6

iA '

€ e-

+a'

5 q

q r

FP

l. -

cD

Xc+

c'+

F0

I i--

-'---

| -

Page 27: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

CI

sa cD

*ggF

EF

€yss

# af

tTgE

g ;[*

gie

$$g

ilEF

BE

*5tH

[i fIf

F[$

E?H

il[i I

Fr

3F'a

sFF

"FF

;.F $

* gg

u *i

uFfiF

u[*

I I L.--

-.

Page 28: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

W

b=ql

VL &s

@tr

P'F

A \d F#

w RC e F:g t'd A F.r

*{

H N fD \rv W

s(a €4 ry F

.qF e"

tsF

TA w F

<@

HF

\O

FJ a-

t\.,

Fr

F1

Ft

)-J

F-

;\. \,

)lr

}--g

Ai-1 UO

\f-#

tu

i"v ts

unt^

)

d R

q ""

5 IE

c

6"q€

.9S

fu

o

Fx

6-- x

'(& fr

7 &

o*"

s 5-

* gH

E'

#6'ry

,FF

r+

.6{

' g

E

'.!d o

I *F

XaX

i-J

r.+

'Y

7A

!.+

-e3-

F

l. C

D

3"C

rO)

(-

(-t-

k=a

gCD

4

d a-

6A

(D15 C

D n

&3E

FS

7,

E

A

lq

F;F

F--

=-

g= 6i

6' *

E'

a-3;

FF

E.

V)

E{

ftg=

.5 g

'3F

FH

'@ a

F"

spe

\E

Fw

L \ F} \ FA tr X R h \ h. q aa w F{" R. s R

d R \ s F} \ s G}

R h \ s F{

o.R b R

*R

d = G s ? \ RA G \ tri 3. -R. Cn

(1- s c\ \ \l F

I ft

E e F FI

Yd

A !*r

(t>

F?r

{ vF

_ fD A F oq o A !# H '-L) e Fd ts{

|d 6. F# (a A t-q

Fo (t)

'EF

\J F |nd

F1

(g)

@ n & f'4 F F.

Fd

F. (a @ A #

I w r\ o H CA - (t)

@ l< iJ U)

@ (.rl

/1

tslr*

|Ivl ryl

Frl

\tl ot fql

FI

F5

l

@l

Faf

I

F{l pl ol !4

1

dl elI

vl 4lI

--J trl

r*ts

Ie+

lR

qlel F

.. i

fE(

IY

lF

{ I

FaI

pl @l

Hi

Fdl

e+l

vl F4i

6e Ar

w A v {- w (A -" V @ F-a

w s

(& FF

fs,

Aq

w E @ F v ldd A w F.d

.F

4 d 6A

Fa

Fd

FV

FE

{ E

EI

Qc

.€@

x'F

5x,d

. w

iie Fid

(a

FF

Ed

fj @ F<

H

C)o

FD

t*'r

o +

=

L?'u

3 .-

+ O

-X

FD

rA

t-

-\'

\t)

,J

d

=i.c

D d

6

=('+

l-.

. }.

] ts

'

5 \J

-', g

d"fr

d =

. r

FD

6'

:]FH

V)

/*n

V)

. \v

ar

\ )

Hu3

5:-

trG

)\-

/ d-

s9 a

i.E

rc .F{

'BJd*0

e ct)

V 4 F} )+ Y @

w9s

9 S

Foa

q '

Fa+

=t-

?sS

SlJ

. O

- F

D Q

_ F

r( 1

*i

(d

0D u

)

gq8

H g

a qE

fr s

53;*

F6t

s=.q

='n

D ;+

,5 E

w o

l<

x O

-,+

OA

|-

. 1.

..,

-)S

it

="

t+ l

-( F

ir /n

=P

-;5

q*9

g o

r<

l;5

tr 3

r-+

+

V

Y

Ft

f-r

r 5

r6F

',

"E A

gX

f F

"J;

eH o

da6

q s

fi g

'q'c

rv)E

rX

=9

g +

H-

).}/

=.X

o-

o =

'a

.*

e-+

r}

(n

{ f

gq?

pHee

..FD

gg-

(\1

CD

!i

r-+

F

J*

w x

3H

:\YH

IJC

D5

A

C),

-f

c

^ C

D O

-f

E.o

Fts

Ol

F+

);J

H.

i- -r

. eD

F0

-a-J

g

5.C

D

6?a

-

l---

I I I

r) 'n

| -

n)

Irh

\

r;d

:-.u

)FY

=@ H' o

'\fi

PH

h=,Q

\../

( J

OC

I I

t-1

nlH

la-

;J CD

U)

F@ LA

g)

e5H

croo

3. (A 6€ !JF

Jb

=F

'.C

ICD

|d^

ld

--\

n1F

l '-i

l-

)-

L) t.+L-

J a

AC

DV

5p

€\-

./ n

FD

f_h n\'

,

a8

a'a

F#A w A

*/ffi

#C

A

ic!d

. G

dd

Ed}

dF

=e

Fd

c

sq 8F'

(& 6

Q

iHhK

fo5i

; 'r'

q'cD

cD c

6'5

X=

D)

E b

7 +

,l2

J)

ar g

wiJ

i. 6' H 0a

Bry

e F F< F A & (a

tr CA

CA (D s (t)

qs_l

Page 29: OF'THE - VeritasZimveritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/First Report... · 4 "2 C CI IVSMUNXTV S H,A[TE, OWI\ER.S]I{IP T'RUSII X,EG ST.,AT'XVE, F.RAMEWG RK 4.2.1 The Community Share

,JH

,@.

-J

Vd

\-1

F:q

fgE

Aq

Aild

FP

F

rdo

Ffi

do

@

\E/

HA

e'q

TJi

'".JJ

F9

i"<o

Ee

€XF

{ fq

E

cF

'!o9A

6q 0

E id

o!5r

5r*)

iJ

{:

F.

rD o

f|\

n.r'

\Y

,)

.F\

f-y

H'\;

Jt)(

Av)

'*

@ a

-; g

g9D

)

cDl-t >

) F

?1

+-.

;a

Y Ft

FD

ld

@E

SE

"Ft3

' se

&(9

!d

F

d.F

4 bJ

(+

Fee

o@

ff'&

F4p

v r=

ae6

+\

(e

5 -€

q

FJ

Z.

\l;

r-f

)A

A\F

F

iH g

H-6

H=

oH+

,=

;--a

( sts.

F6F

H.'

-|

(D

r-r

FD

('...r

(+

,-

F

<C

D

CD

i-f

+

p-.

cD *

9.

1v$J

CD

TT

=o

(9

n H iJ Rq

Bls

) !d o E !d 6q o (a

EE

gHqS

:i a.

Fni

-rf,F

FD

OA

FF

K

I

ktH

3*

g5'

q3'tE

(}r-

+.r

=gH

-Tfr

\ H

f-

.Y

. p

Hg

- s)

-H

(f)

H u

)@

f-

'@

(Jr

(>:-

. O

" >

-\-

-l lJ

. \J

H\-

/ P

\J

.H

CD ,-t