nyu computer science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

31

Upload: others

Post on 31-Aug-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

������������ ����������������������������������� !�" ��$#%��&�'�"���(�) ��"*,+-��.��!�"������ ��0/

132$46587:9:;.9:<>=?46@A�584CB69:D(<E1FHGJI�KMLONPI$LMQRI,S"TNPU$V6WYX

Z GJU&X(NPI[L�\]I�KMLMQ^L_U�LMW`GPVbacNPL_d&WfegNPLMQihYNPj�k[hlQ^WYI�hlWmKnEWfoqprGJX�s tEI�Q^uJWfX(KMQ^L8vwyx%z|{X�GyNJ}~o.N%vJ�&w%L_d���GyGJX

nEWfoqprGJX�s���nEWYo�prGJX�s�x%�J�J�J�$��tHk[�j�NPU$V6WYXY��hYKY��I[v�U���Wm}~U�E��X�Q^j��J�$��x%�J�$x

�����8�M���>�?�� 4]=�<%B��RD(4C;�=��C9:D(<>=?7f��46D(�l4�=?;.;.9�<%��9:B�=r;E58�6 �Dm¡mD(7:D(�l@r�6 >=?��9:<f�C58<>¡YB��6Db�RDl46;�=?7:9£¢¤5��C %5r¡Y58¥(5¤7£Dl�%;.5¤<f�

D��%�%46Dl�(4]=�;.BP�^46D(;¦��46D(§�7£5¤;¦B6�P5_¨]9�©ª¨8=?�69:D(<%BM«�¬�9:¥(58<��C %5�4C5_¨]58<Y��5®­ªDl46�$�6D�¯�=�4]¡YBy�C %5°¡m58B69:�(<D��>=±¨]D(;E;.D(<�%46Dl�6D(��@Y�%9:<%�B6@YBC�658;³²i´�2�µ�¶&�RD(4��6 %5b·¸¡%=b�%46Dl�(4]=�;.;E9:<%��7¹=�<��(º>=?�(5(»l�64]=�<%B��RD(4C;�=��C9:D(<�B6@YBC�658;EB�;�=M@§>5465_¨]Dl<%B69¹¡Y5¤465_¡E=�B$�>DlB6BC9£§�7£5�¨]Dl;.�PD(<%58<Y�CByD��J�%4CD(�6Dl��@Y�%9:<%��BC@fBC�658;EB_« �  %9:B$�>=��P584$5]¼>=�;E9£<�58B[=?<>¡r5¤¥(=�7:º>=��C58B�6 %4C585"=����%46DY=(¨C %58B±�6D�64�=?<%B��^D(46;0=��C9£Dl<>=�7��%46Dl�(4�=?;.;E9£<��>½¾ �  %5�¿�º%<%9¹¨C À´�Á62��%46DMÂ]5_¨]��²�´�D(;E�%º%�65¤4�Ã6=�9¹¡Y5_¡J»PÁ�<Y�6º�9£�C9:D(<YÃ��(º%9¹¡Y5M¡Ä2$46Dl�(4]=�;.;E9:<%�(¶�¨®D(<%BC9£BC�6BrD?�!=B6�64CD(<%�l7:@���@Y�>5M¡J»�¯�9¹¡Y5®ÃiBC�>5_¨®�646º�;Å7¹=�<%�lº>=��l50¯�9£�C gº%BC584�Ã6¡Y5]©><�5_¡¦=�7:�(5¤§%4�=?9ƨE��@Y�P58BÄ=�<>¡g=ÇB658;E9�Ã=�º%�CD(;�=?�69¹¨��64]=�<%B��RD(4C;�=?�69:D(<�BC@fBC�658;È�6 P=���465MÉ(º�9£4C58B�º�B6584±�(º%9¹¡%=?<>¨]5(«

¾,Ê @�¨]D(<Y�64]=�BC�_»Ë6·±7£�lD(4C9£�C %;.9¹¨]BM» ÌÄ�6 %50¯�D(4CÍ�D(<g=�7:�(5¤§%4�=?9ƨ)B6�P5_¨]9�©ª¨8=?�69:D(<�Dl469:�(9:<>=?�69:<%�0�R4CD(;�Á6Î�Á62Ï ¬ÑÐ%«:Ò(»¤9:By=��%º%465&�>58<P¨]9:7ÓÃ6=�<P¡lÃi�P=��P584[=?�%�%46DY=(¨C r�CD��64�=?<%B��^D(46;0=��C9£Dl<>=�7M�%4CD(�(4]=�;E;.9Ó<��>«%Á��J��46D�¥Y9¹¡Y58B="¨]Dl<>¨]9:B65l»>º�<%9��RD(4C;-;0=��C %58;�=?�69¹¨8=?7%<%D(�]=��C9£Dl<�=?<>¡E9£<P¨]7:º>¡Y58B�¯�D(4CÍ.D(<E<%D(<P¡Y58�65¤46;.9:<%9:BC;Ô«

¾,Õ ·¸2 � µg² Õ Dl§>584C�.·«�2$=�9:�(5lÖ B � 4]=�<%B��RD(4C;�=��C9:D(<�µY@YB6�C58;�¶9:B.=H�Rº�7£7:@�;E5_¨C >=�<%9¹¨8=?7�B6@YB6�C58;×�6 P=���64�=?<%B��^D(46;EB� %9:�( mÃi7:58¥l587>BC�>5M¨]9�©ª¨8=��C9:D(<%B��CD�´�¨]D%¡Y5(« �  %5�BC�>5M¨]9�©ª¨8=��C9:D(<%B�=?465��(9:¥(5¤<�9£<0=±�Rº%<P¨]�69:D(<P=�7B6º%§%BC58��D?�~µ%Ø ��Ù =�º%�l;.58<Y�65M¡�¯�9:�6 E©%¼%5_¡lÃ��PD(9:<Y��D(�P584�=?�69:D(<%BM«Î�9:46BC�_»l¯�5�¡Y58B]¨]469:§P5�5_=l¨C �B6@YB6�C58;Ú9£<�¡Y58�]=�9:7%=�<>¡b %9:�( �7£9:�l f��9:<f�C58465¤B6�69:<%�±�R5M=��6º�4658BM«�Û�5®¼m�M»(¯�5�58B6�]=�§%7:9:B6 

=±�R4�=?;.58¯�D(4CÍrD��[¨®D(;.;ED(<"¨®469:�6584C9¹=r§Y@¯� %9¹¨6 EB6º>¨C 0¡Y9�­ª584C58<Y���64]=�<%B��RD(4C;�=��C9:D(<>=?7fBC@YB6�65¤;.B�¨8=�<E§>5±58¥(=�7:ºYÃ=��65M¡J«�Î�9:<>=�7:7:@Y»(¯�5��>Dl9£<Y��Dlº%��¨]D(;E;.Dl<r�R5M=��6º�4658B�=�<>¡0¡Y9�­J584658<P¨]58BrD?�[�6 �5r�6 %4C585B6@YB6�C58;.B�=?<>¡0¨]D(;E�>=�4C5�6 %58;`«

Ü]Ý�Þ(ßlßYà_á�â�ã]äEåÓæ.ßYç8á�â�è�éâ�ê(ã�ë�ãCì¹ã]æ(í�ã�î�älï_ç¤æ(ð]ã]ä�ñ$ã]í�ã8ç8á�ðCê�òóá�à8ô�ã]ð�â�í�î�õMã�ælð]é(ö8÷^æ�ì¹àMá�øùç¤â^åÓàMæ�Ý?é�í�â�ã]ø¸í�úJã]ðCê(æ(à¤ûÓàMõ_é0ü&ýùð]ãÞ(ælä(ã]á�â�ê(ã�ü&ýrð]ã�à8ì[þ�ç]ï_ç®ûªñ$ã]í�ã8ç8á�ðCê�ð]à_æ�â�á6ç¤ð]â°þ�ÿ_ÿMÿ��������Mÿ�������� �®ÿ

Page 2: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

� ����������������� ���!�

"�#�$&%&#�')(*(,+.-/%0+21�'�3 $&(*46587 9,:�'&1�;=<>52')#?%&7@4/#?$&%&# ')(A1�')#�7CBD+FE�3 G65.:H:?$I4/#?$/B6GJ3 7&K&')-JBL$&-J3 7H4/#�$MB6GJ3 7NB,:�O/7QP�')#?7$)RS:?7Q-TG/-/#?7 5F+2')U65.7�'V-JB,7 9M4W7Q-J1�+.X&7Y:?$Y(A'Z+8-6:�'>+.-[$&#�+.(T4/#�$ZXD7&\^]_O/7�`Q1�$)RS:�ab')#?7b3 #�+21�+21?cL#?7Q(A'>+.-J1@')-,+.(T4J$D#?:�')-6:+21?1�G/7d+.-�1�$VR�:�ab')#?707Q-/%)+.-/7Q7Q#�+.-/%J\@ef5g'V#?%&7Y')(T$&G/-6:�$)R�#?7N1�7N')# 3?OTOJ'D1�UJ7Q7Q-h%D$)+.-/%�$&-T:�$�$)X&7Q#�3 $&(*7b:?O6+21H3 #�+21�+21Qij -k$&-/7,OJ')-JB=K�'h3 $D-J1�+2B67Q#�')U65.7A4W$&#?:�+.$&-l$)R0:?O/7,a0$&#?;hOJ'&1dRS$M3 GJ1m7NBl$&-TnQo&p q,r&sFt.uQt2v6wl')-JBxr&y{zSoDq�rDzSt2v6wl:?O/71�$)RS:�ab')#?7�B67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:Y4/#?$/3 7N1?1Q<=$&-l:?O/7L$&:?O/7Q#IOJ')-JB=KW|}p�o&zSo&zS~�|}t�v{w�OJ'&1IUW7Q7Q-l4/#?$&(T$&:�7NB�'&1I'[(T7Q:?O/$/Bh$)R$&U/:�'Z+8-6+.-/%*+.-6R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-�')UW$&G/:�',4/#�$&U65.7Q(�UW7 R�$&#�7Y+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�+.-/%[+8:_+8-l',4/#?$/B6GJ3 :�+.$&-h52')-/%DGJ')%&7&\

]�#�'&BD+.:�+.$&-J'Z5�5.P&K 4/#?$&%D#�')(A1dOJ'>X&7�UW7Q7Q-kX&7Q#�+F�J7NBf�Q�?|/�Np t2q,�>vJzSr&s�sF~AU6P�3�O/$6${1�+.-/%�'*-{G/(,UW7Q#�$)R�+.-/4/G/:,:?7N1�:3Q'&1�7N1�K�#?G/-/-6+.-/%l:?O/7T4/#?$D%&#�')(�K ')-JBl7QX)'>5.GJ'):�+.-/%l:?O/7T#?7N1�G65.:�1�\�]_O/7T4/#?$&U65.7Q(�a0+.:?Ok:?O6+21,')4/4/#?$6'&3?O�+21L:?OJ'):+.:�3Q')-�-/7QX&7Q#*R�$&#�(A'>5F5.P�4/#?$)X&7�:?O/7k3 $&#?#?7N3 :?-/7N1�1T$)R�:�O/7�4/#�$&%&#�')(�\�]0O/7Q#?7�(,+.%&O6:�'>5.a_'>P/1TUW7k3Q'&1�7N1*-/$&:3Q')4/:?G/#�7NBTU6PT:?O/7I:?7N1�:bB/'):�'�\H�0p�o&zSo&zS~�|}t�v{w['):?:?7Q(T4/: 1�:?$,3Q'):�3�OA7Q#?#�$&#�1H'V:C')-[7N')#�5.Ph'�1�:�'V%&7b$)R�:�O/7�4/#?$D%&#�')(B67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:N\

��o&p q,r&sb�>�Np t �0��r&zSt�o&vWKH$&-f:?O/7�$D:?O/7Q#TOJ')-JB=K@+21h')-�r&vJr&sF~)zSt���4/#?$/3 7N1?1*:?OJ'):AB67 �J-/7N1*+.-�(A'):�O/7Q(A'):�+23Q'>5:?7Q#?([1HadOJ'):0+.:b(T7N')-J1CR�$&#I'�4/#�$&%&#�')(�:?$*UJ7�3 $D#?#?7N3 :NK6%)+.X&7Q-�',(['):?O/7Q(A'):m+g3Q'Z5�B67 �J-6+.:�+.$&-l$)R�:?O/7Y4/#?$D%&#�')(T�(,+.-/%[52')-/%&GJ')%D7�GJ1�7NB=K�')-JB�',RS$&#?(['>5^1�4W7N3�+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-k$)RH:?O/7L4/#?$&U65.7Q(�UJ7 +.-/%l1�$)5.X&7NB=\��d$)a07QX&7Q#NK/:?O/7!R�$D#?(A'>5X&7Q#�+F�}3Q'):m+8$D-�$)R 52')#?%&7Y4/#?$D%&#�')(A1@OJ'&1_:?G/#?-/7NBh$DG/:C:�$TUJ7!+8(*4/#�'&3 :�+23Q'>5\

�@Pl3 $&-{:�#�'&1�:NKW:?O/7T:�#�')-J1�RS$&#?(A'V:�+.$&-J'>5^')4/4/#�${'&3�O���1�7Q7h��"0�{�& >¡ RS$&#�')-l7 9J3 7 5�5.7Q-6:T1�G/#?X&7QPW¢0+21�'�£Q~ZvWz�¤{�NzSt��$&#I��o&v�£¥zSp y6�NzSt��N�I$&-/7&\ e¦4/#?$&%D#�')(�+210B67Q#�+.X&7NB,RS#?$&(�'Y4/#?$DU6587Q(§1�4W7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-hU6PA1�GJ3Q3 7N1?1�+.X&7Y')4/465F+23Q'):�+.$&-h$)R3 $&#?#�7N3 :?-/7N1?1��S4/#?7N1m7Q#?X&+.-/%L:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-J1�:?OJ'):�587N'DB,:?$Y'Y3 $&#?#?7N3 : +.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-*$)R}:?O/704/#?$DU6587Q(�\�e�;&7QP4J$V+8-6:I+21b:�O/7Ap��NyD£¥r6¨Qt�s�t�zS~Y$)RH:�#�')-J1�RS$&#?(A'V:�+.$&-h#?G65.7N1Q<=$&-J3 7,'T#?G65.7L+21b4/#�$ZXD7Q-�3 $&#?#�7N3 :NK/+.:Y3Q')-�UW7,GJ1�7NBl')%{'>+.-+FR©'V4/465�+23Q')U65.7T:�$�:�O/7Y4J')#?:�+23 G652')#Y1�+.:?GJ'):�+.$&-�\Hª}+8U/# ')#�+.7N1b$VR^;6-/$)ab-h:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J1@3Q')-hUJ7L7N1�:�')U65F+21�O/7NB=<='&1:?O/7I5F+.U/#�')#�+.7N1I%&#�$ZaLK{:�O/7Y-{G/(,UJ7Q#d$)R^-/7Qa�4/#?$6$)R1H#�7N«&G6+.#?7NB¬+.-�:?O/7�B67QXD7 58$D4/(T7Q-{:I$)RH',4/#?$&%D#�')(§B67N3 #?7N'&1�7N1�\

eI-�'DB6XZ')-6:�')%&7L$)RH:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J'Z5�4/#?$&%&# ')(T(,+.-/%*+g1I:�O/7�:�+.%&O6:�3 $&G/465F+.-/%�$)RH4/#?$D%&#�')(�B67QXD7 58$D4/(T7Q-{:')-JBlXD7Q#�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-�\Te�3 $&(T465.7Q:?7[4/#?$&%&# ')(­3 $D-J1�+21�:�1Y$VRC:?O/7A1m4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-�K :?O/7,�J-J'Z5C7 9/7N3 G/:�')U65.7T4/#?$&%D#�')(�K')-JB�:?O/7T3 $&(T465.7Q:?7*O6+g1m:?$&#?P�$)RH+.-6:?7Q#?(T7NBD+2'):?7*:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-J1Q\Y]0O6+21IO6+21�:?$&#�P�1�7Q#?XD7N1Y'&1Y'T4/#�$&%&#�')(�B6$/3 �G/(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-�K=1�+.-J3 7L+.:�3Q')4/:?G/#?7N1I'>5F5�+2B67N'&1Y'V-JB�B67N3�+21�+.$&-J1Y#�7 587QX)')-6:IR�$&#d:?O/7�4/#?$D%&#�')(�\bª�'):?7Q#I(T$MBD+F�}3Q'):m+8$D-+21!R®'&3�+F5F+.:�'):?7NB¯UJ7N3Q'VGJ1�7T+.:T3 $&#?#�7N1�4J$&-JB/1!:?$�1m:?7Q4/46+.-/%�UJ'D3?;�+.-�:�O/7AB67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:T')-JB�RS$)5F58$)a0+.-/%k')-k$D:?O/7Q#U/#�')-J3�O�'):�'°4J$)+.-6:�abO/7Q#�7�'TB67N3�+21�+.$&-la_'D1H(['&B67&\

]_O/7T:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J'>5�4J')#�'DBD+8%D(±5.7N'>X&7N1L'[5.$&:�$VR_#�${$&(²R�$D#�')G/:?$D(A'):�+.$&-�<�:?O/7A4/#�$&%&#�')(*(T7Q#�3Q')-kUW7#?7 5F+.7QX&7NBf$)RY:?7NBD+.$&GJ1T: '&1�;/1,:?OJ'):A3 $D(T7hG/4³B6G/#�+.-/%´4/#?$D%&#�')(µB67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:h1�GJ3?O�'&1,#?7Qad#�+.:�+.-/%�4/#?$D%&#�')(46+.7N3 7N1QK6X&7Q#�+FRSP&+.-/%T')4/465F+23Q')U6+F5�+�:�Ph3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&-J10$VR}:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J1�K)#?7QX&+.7Qa0+.-/%,:?O/7�B67QXD7 58$D4/(T7Q-{:0O6+21�:?$D#?P,7Q:�3)\�d$Za07QX&7Q#>K&+.(T4W$&#?:�'V-{:�B67N1�+8%D-�B67N3�+21�+.$&-J1Y')#?7Y%D7Q-/7Q#�'>5F5.P[587 RS:b:?$*:?O/7Y4/#?$&%&# ')(T(T7Q#N\

¶_7N3 7Q-{:�5.P&K&'I3 $&-J1�+2B67Q#�')U65.707 ·�$&#?:�OJ'D1=UJ7Q7Q-,(A'&B67@:?$)ab')#�B/1W:?O/7HB67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:�$)RJ'b3 $&(T(*$&-�4/#?$D:?$&:�P{46+.-/%1�P/1�:?7Q(¸�?¹C"_�JK}1�7Q7h�FºY')UJ�&�>¡S¢@R�$D#�:?O/7Le»B/'*52')-/%DGJ')%&7&\Ie»1Y'°RSG/:?G/#?7,%&${'>5KWa07�a0$&G652B¬5�+.;&7*:?$A7 9/465.$&#?7,O/$)a'¯:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-J'>5»3 $D(T4J$&-/7Q-6:�3Q')-�UJ7�+.-J3 $&#?4W$&#�'):�7NBf+.-{:?$´1�GJ3�O¦'x4/#?$&:?$&:�P646+.-/%�7Q-6X&+.#?$D-/(T7Q-{:>\¼]0O/7:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J'Z5©1�P/1�:?7Q(�3 $&G652BkUW7AGJ1m7NBk:?$�'Z+gB¯#?7Q4652'&3�+.-/%l46+.7N3 7N1,$)Rb:?O/7T4/#?$D:?$&:�P{4W7,U{Pl(T$&#�7T7 E�3�+.7Q-{:46+.7N3 7N1I$&U/:�'>+.-/7NB[U6Ph:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(,+.-/%�+.-6:?$A',: ')#?%&7Q:@52')-/%&GJ')%D7&\

½�#?$&(¾:?O6+21Y4W7Q#�1�4J7N3 :m+8XD7&K�a07,:�');D7�'hB67Q:�'>+F5.7NB¿58$6$&;l'):�1�7QX&7Q#�'Z5©')4/4/#�${'&3�O/7N1I:?$h:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J'>5 4/#?$&�%&#�'V(T(,+.-/%L+8-h:�O/7Y-/7 9M:0:?O/#?7Q7Y1�7N3 :�+.$&-J1�K/7Q(T4/OJ'&1�+.À +.-/%[#?7 5.7QXZ')-6:0RS7N'):?G/#?7N1Q\ Á�-h:?O/7I52'&1�:b1�7N3 :�+.$&-�K/a07I4/#?7N1�7Q-6:'!R�# ')(T7Qa0$&#?;L$)R^3 $&(T(*$&-�3 #m+8:�7Q#�+2'YRS$&#0:?O/7Y3 $&(T4J')#m+g1m$&-A$VR�:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J'>5}1mPM1�:�7Q(A1Q\�½�+.-J'>5F58P&K�aC7Y')4/465.P:?O/7N1�7�3 #m+8:�7Q#�+2'T:?$*:?O/7�1�P/1�:?7Q(A10G/-JB67Q#Y3 $&-J1�+2B67Q#�'V:�+.$&-�\

 Ã�Ä,Å¸Æ �T�T���©ÄÈǦ�=É Ê�ËTËT���IÌb�©Ä

]0O/7l¹HÁ�"Í4/#?$DÎ�7N3 :Lab'&1,3 #?7N'):?7NBxa0+.:?O´:�O/7A%&$6'>5b$)R�4/#?$/B6GJ3�+.-/%Ï')-¯+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:?7NB�1�$VR�:�ab')#?7AB67QXD7 58$D4/(T7Q-{:1�P/1�:?7Q(¸GJ1�+.-/%�:�O/7A:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-J'>5H4J')#�'&BD+.%&(�\l¹HÁ�"�1�:�'V-JB/1YRS$&#h`>¹H$&(T4/G/:�7Q#?�'>+2B67NB=K Á-6:?G6+.:�+.$&-/�S%&G6+2B67NB

Ð

Page 3: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

"�#�$&%&#�')(*(,+.-/%{c/\�]0O/7[4/#?$DÎ�7N3 :,3 $&-J1�+21�:�1L$)Rb:�a0$�3 $&(T4W$&-/7Q-6:�1QiT]0O/7[a0+2B67Q�1�4J7N3 :�#?G/(µ4/#?$&%D#�')(T(,+.-/%¬5g'V-/�%&GJ')%D7,¹HÁ�"©�ª����0Ñ��&ÒD'N¡�KJ')-JB[:?O/7L4/#?$&%&#�'V(T�S:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-A1mPM1�:�7Q(�¹HÁ�"©�������0Ñ �6ÓZ')¡�\H]0O/7�GJ1m7Q#b$)R0¹HÁ�"©���£�|M� �Nt �C�Q£H',4/#�$&U65.7Q(§+.-k¹@Á�"��ªx')-JBlÔ&�>p�t��N��£_'��O/$&4J7 RSG65F5.P�7 E�3�+.7Q-6:Q¢�t�qb|=s��>q,�NvJzSrDzSt2o&v*$)R�:?O/7Y4/#?$&U65.7Q(�\

e¾Õ�t2ÔD�QÖ£�|M� �NzSp y6q±sFr&v{wDy{r>w&�!+g1L'h1�+.-/%)5.7TRS$&#?(['>5�52')-/%&GJ')%&7*abO6+23?Ol+.-J3�5.GJB67N1T1�4W7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-�3 $&-J1�:�#?GJ3 :�1QK+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-h3 $&-J1�:?#�GJ3 :�1QK&')-JBT'V-{P!+8-6:?7Q#?(*7NBD+g'V:?7»3 $D-J1�:?#?GJ3 :�1 -/7Q7NB67NB°RS$&#�4/#?$&%&# ')(×B67QXD7 58$D4/(T7Q-{:>\H]0O/7GJ1�7T$VRC1�GJ3?Ox'*5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7,(A');D7N1d+8:Y7N'D1�P�:?$[RS$&#?(,G652'):?7,4/#?$D%&#�')(¾:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J1I'&1_58$/3Q'>5K�3 $&#?#?7N3 :�-/7N1?1��4/#?7N1�7Q#�X&+.-/%JKY1�$&G/# 3 7Q�S:?$&�1�$&G/# 3 7�:�#�')-J1�RS$&#?(A'V:�+.$&-J1T$D-Ø'´3 $D(T(T$&-¦1�7Q(A'V-{:�+23�UJ'&1�+21Q\Ù¹HÁ�"��ª�+21h'f£Q�Q¤{�>q,�sFr&v{wDy{r>w&�NK_+\07&\.K�'¯52')-/%&GJ'V%&7la0+.:?O/$&G/:�'¿�/9M7NB¦1m7Q:h$)R�UJ'&1�+23kB/'): 'k:�P64J7N1Q\¼]_O6+g1[([');&7N1*+.:h4J${1�1�+.U6587x:?$(A')-6+.4/G652'):?7L4/#?$&%&# ')(§1?3?O/7Q(*7N1babO6+23�O�3Q')-[52'):�7Q#�UW7I+8-J1m:�')-6:�+2'):?7NB�'D10-/7Q7NB67NB=\

]_O/7_1mPM1�:�7Q(�¹HÁ�"©���Y+21H')-,+.-6:?7Q#�'&3 :m+8XD7�1�P/1�:?7Q(ÍabO/${1m7C4/G/#�4J${1�7d+21�:?$Y'&1?1�+g1m:H:?O/704/#?$&%D#�')(T(T7Q# +.-A3�5.7Q#�+23Q'>5a0$&#?;k')-JBl$D:?O/7Q#�:�'D1�;M1!:?OJ'):,3Q')-kUJ7h')G/:?$D(A'):?7NB=\[Á:,4W7Q#�R�$D#?(A1Y#�$&G/:�+.-/7A: '&1�;k1�GJ3�O�'&1Y;D7Q7Q46+8-/%¯:?#�'&3�;�$)RXZ'V#�+.$&GJ1,X&7Q#�1�+8$D-J1�$VR»'�4/#?$&%&#�'V(�K�')-JB¯+.:�4/#�$ZXD+2B67N1T'�(T7N3�OJ')-6+21�(�RS$&#,4J7Q#�RS$&#?(,+.-/%l:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J1�\�Á�-'&B/BD+.:�+.$&-�K�+.:bO/7 5.4J1b:?O/7YGJ1m7Q#bX&7Q#�+FRSPA:?O/7Y')4/465F+23Q')U6+F5F+2:�P�$)RH'L:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-T:?$['�4W$&#?:�+.$&-h$VR^:?O/7I4/#?$&%D#�')(�\Á:�'Z5g1m$h(A'>+.-{: '>+.-J1Y'*5�+.U/#�'V#?P�$)R0:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-�#?G65.7N1Y')-JBl'&1?1�+21�:�1d+.-�1m7N')#�3�O6+8-/%h:�O/7�5F+.U/#�')#�P&\�ÚI7N3�+21�+.$&-J1QKO/$)a07QX&7Q#NK/')#?7�'>5.ab'>PM1@(A'DB67�U6PA:?O/7YGJ1m7Q#N</O/7�$D#_1mO/7�1�G/4/465F+.7N1I:?O/7I+.-{:�G6+8:m+8$D-�\

Á�:�+21©+.-{:?7Q#�7N1�:�+.-/%�:?$L-/$&:?7b:�OJ'):�:?O/7L¹HÁ�"x1�P/1�:?7Q(¼ab'&1�B67QXD7 58$D4J7NB[GJ1�+.-/%,7 9�'D3 :�5.PT:?O/7Y¹HÁ�"k(*7Q:?O/$MB6$V58$D%&P&\½�+.#�1�:NK�'�R�$&#�(A'>5C1�4W7N3�+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-´$)RY¹HÁ�"©����ab'&1!ab#�+.:?:?7Q-�K abO6+23�Ok+.-J3�5.GJB67N1['[5.$&%)+23Q'>5�3Q'>523 G65.GJ1LRS$&#�4/#?$D%&#�')(:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J1�\�]0O/7Q-�K6'I4/#?$&:?$&:�P64J70$)R=:?O/7�1�P/1�:?7Q(Íab'&1�B67Q#�+.X&7NB°RS#?$&(�:?O/7�1�4W7N3�+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-hGJ1�+.-/%�4/#?$D%&#�')(:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J1�\»]_O/7°1mPM1�:�7Q(�OJ'&1I-/$D:YP&7Q:�#�7N'&3?O/7NB¬+.:�1»�J-J'>5©1m:�'):?7&<=:?O/7Q#�7 R�$&#�7�4J'V#?:�1d$)R�+.:�1YB67N1?3 #�+.4/:�+.$&-UJ7 5.$)a�#?7 R�7Q#d:?$,:?O/7�1�4W7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-l#�'):?O/7Q#0:?OJ'V-h:?O/7Y+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:?7NBl1�P/1�:?7Q(�\

½�$&#b'TB67Q:�'>+F5F5.7NB�7QXZ'>5.GJ'):�+.$&-l$)R�:?O/7,¹HÁ�"´4/#?$DÎ�7N3 :I1�7Q7T�ÜÛ¦Ý6�{�6ÓQ¡\

Þ�ßà á�âHã�ä�åHæ)ç&ã=è é[êVë*ì>ä]0O/7�4/G/#?4J${1m7�$)RT¹HÁ�"����¯+g1*:?O/7�:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-J'>5bB67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:h$)R»4/#�$&%&#�')(í1?3?O/7Q(*7N1Q\³]_O6+g1*+.-J3�5.GJB67N1(A')-6+.4/G652'):�+.$&-�$)RH'&3 :?GJ'>5=4/#?$&%&#�'V(A1QK/B67Q#�+.XZ'):m+8$D-�$)R�-/7Qaî:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-T#?G65.7N1da0+.:?O6+.-�:?O/7Y1�P/1�:?7Q(�K6:?# ')-J1��RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-A$)RH'>5.%&7QU/#�'Z+g3!:�P{4W7N1b')-JBh:�P64J7�1?3�O/7Q(T7N1QKW')-JBhX&7Q#m+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-�$)R�')4/465F+g3Q'VU6+�5F+2:�Pl3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&-J1Q\

]�#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-L#?G65.7N1 +.-h¹HÁ�"�3 $&-J1�+g1m:�$)R}:?O/#�7Q7_3 $D(T4J$&-/7Q-6:�1Qi�+.-/4/G/:H:�7Q(T4652'):?7&K&$DG/:?4/G/:�:?7Q(T4652'):?7&K6')-JB')4/465F+23Q')U6+F5F+2:�P¿3 $D-JBD+8:m+8$D-�\�]0O/7!+.-/4/G/:�')-JB�$&G/:?4/G/:I:?7Q(T4652'):�7N1Y')#?7Y|=p�o w&p�r&qÙ£¥��¤{�Nq,��£¥KW4J${1�1�+.U658P�+.-J3�5.GJBD+.-/%� o&vJzS���Zz�|Mr&p�r&q,�>zS�Np�£¥K=abO6+23�Ok'>5F58$)aÍ:?O/7LGJ1�7Q#Y:?$[(A')#?;[RS#�')%D(T7Q-{: ')#?P[:?7Q#?(A1!��� o&vJzS���Zz�£ ¢C'&1d#?7Q4652'&3 7N')U65.7&\�e:�P{46+23Q'>5I#?G65.7&K�RS$&#,7 9�'V(T465.7&K07 9M4/#?7N1�1�7N1,:?O/7�BD+21�:?#m+8U/G/:m+8XD+.:�P´$)R�:?O/7�3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&-J'Z5»7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-´$)X&7Q#,X)')#?PD+8-/%3 $&-6:?7 9/:�1Qi

���ðï.ñ�ò�ó)ô=õJö�÷îõ/ø2ù�õ�ú�û�¡ü

ï.ñlò�ó)ô}õWö´����÷d¡=õMø�ùQõ����8ú»¡Wûýd-JB67Q#�:?O6+210#�G6587&KW:?O/7�3 $/B67YRS#�')%&(*7Q-{:

�­iFþÿï.ñ*���Ï °ó)ô}õWö��Tõ/ø2ù�õ Ð û+21b:�#�')-J1�RS$&#?(T7NB*:?$

ï.ñ*���� °ó)ô}õWö´�­i8þ��Tõ/ø2ù�õ���iFþ Ð û��Á-T'&B/BD+.:�+.$&-*:?$»1mGJ3?O,#?G65.7N1QK6¹HÁ�"l4/#?$)XD+gB67N1�'d(T7Q:�'Z5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7©R�$&#0zSp�r&v/£�nQo&p�q,r&zSt�o&v[�Q��|}p��Q£ £¥t�o&v/£QKQabO6+23�OA'>5F5.$)a�1:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J'Z5�'>5.%&$&#m+8:�O/(A10:?$TUW7�7 9/4/#?7N1?1�7NB�1�+.(,+F52')#�5.P�:?$,#?7Q%DG65g'V#�7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1�\

]_O/7�:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-I#?G65.7N1�')#?7�$&#?%6')-6+.ÀQ7NB�'&1�wD�NvW�Np�r&zSt��N�@£¥�>z�£¥K¥+®\>7&\.K)'b1�(A'Z5�5J1�7Q:�$VRM4W$Za07Q#�RSG65{7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:�')#?P:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J1 :�OJ'):C3Q')-[UJ7IGJ1�7NB[:?$,3 $&-J1�:?#�GJ3 :H-/7Qa�#?G65.7N1Q\H]0O/7IUJ'&1�+23I#?G65.7N1©+.-J3�5.GJB67�%&7Q-/7Q#�'Z5}4/#�+.-J3�+.465.7N1��1�GJ3�O�'&1LG/-6RS$)52B=K�R�$)52BW¢�K©:?O/7AB67 �J-6+.:�+.$&-J'>5�#�G6587N1L$)Rb:?O/7*52')-/%&GJ')%D7&K^'V-JBk:?O/7['>9{+.$&([1�')-JB¿+.-6R�7Q#?7Q-J3 7h#�G6587N1

 

Page 4: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

$)R�:?O/7�4/#?7NB67 �J-/7NB�:�P64J7N1Q\�½/G/#?:?O/7Q#�(T$&#?7&Kb1�$D(T7hRS#?7N«DG/7Q-{:�5.PfGJ1�7NB�B67Q#�+.X&7NBf#?G65.7N1QK�'&1*a07 5F5!'&1[1�:�'V-JB/')#�B+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-l:?7N3�O/-6+2«&G/7N1»R�$&#I1�$&(T7,')UJ1�:?#�'D3 :C:�P64J7N1QK=')#?7,'>XZ'>+F52')U65.7&\L¹HÁ�"©����'>5F5.$)a�1b:�O/7�GJ1�7Q#Y:?$[B67 �J-/7-/7Qa¦:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-A#?G65.7N1I')-JBh(['>+.-{:�'Z+8-[5F+.U/#�')#m+87N1I$VR^#?G65.7N1Q\

¹@Á�"����h#?7N3 $D#�B/1b:�O/7�adO/$)5.7°B67QXD7 58$D4/(T7Q-{:Y$VRC'T4/#?$D%&#�')(ÙR�#�$&(�'[1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-�\LÁ:�'Z5�5.$)a�1d:?O/7,GJ1�7Q#Y:?$U/#?$)a�1�7I:?O/#?$DG/%&Oh:?O/7�B67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:NK/UJ'D3?;6:?#�'&3�;A')-JBh3 $D-{:�+.-6G/7�a0+.:?O�'V-/$&:?O/7Q#04/#?$&%&# ')(�X&7Q#�1�+.$&-�K/#�7Q:?G/#?-h:?$4/#?7QXD+.$&GJ1TB67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:A1�:�7Q4J1�7Q: 3)\k]0O/7�1�P/1�:?7Q(µ'&1?1�+21�: 1�:�O/7AGJ1�7Q#°+8-´:�O/7�1�7 5.7N3 :�+.$&-�')-JBx')4/465F+g3Q'V:�+.$&-�$)R:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-�#?G65.7N1Q\Leb5F5H:?O6+21Y3Q'>5F521IRS$&#�'[1�$&4/O6+21�:�+23Q'):?7NB�+8-6:?7Q#�'D3 :�+.X&7TGJ1�7Q#Y7Q-6X&+.#?$D-/(T7Q-{:Y$D-�:�$&4�$)R0:?O/71�P/1�:?7Q(�3 $D#?7&\�]0O6+21b7Q-6X&+.#?$D-/(T7Q-{:I(A');D7N1HGJ1m7�$)R R®'D3�+�5F+.:�+.7N1Y1�GJ3�O�'&10%&# ')4/O6+23�1?3 #?7Q7Q-J1�K/a0+.-JB6$)a�1QKJ')-JB[(°+g3 7&K')-JBh'>5F5.$)a�1d:?O/7YGJ1�7Q#b:?$*4J7Q#�RS$&#?(�'Z5�5 :?O/7�1�P/1�:?7Q(�RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1I3 $&-{XD7Q-6+87Q-6:�5.P&\

]_O/7Q#?7A')#?7T1�7QXD7Q#�'>5�52')-/%&GJ')%D7N1I+.-{XD$)5.X&7NBl+.-k:�O/7AB67N1�+.%&-x$)R�¹HÁ�"����J\�e»1!:?O/7�o{¨�¥� �NzIsFr&v{wDy{rNwD�NK=:?O/7°5g'V-/�%&GJ')%D7IR�$&#dRS$&#?(,G652'):�+.-/%T4/#?$&%D#�')(�1?3�O/7Q(T7N1QK=')-�'>5.%&7QU/# '>+23Q'>5F58PkB67 �J-/7NB¬52')-/%&GJ')%D7Y+21Y'&1?1�G/(*7NB=\b¹HÁ�"��ªxab'&1B67N1�+.%&-/7NB¯7N1�4J7N3�+2'>5F5.P´:?$�1�7Q#�X&7T:?O6+21Y4/G/#�4J${1�7&\h]�#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-k'>5.%&$&#�+.:?O/([1�')#?7LRS$&#?(,G652'):?7NB�+.-´'h1�4J7N3�+2'>5(T7Q:�'Z5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7&K)abO6+23�O�3 $D-J1�+21�:�1�$VR�3 $&-J1�:�#?GJ3 :�1�1�+.(,+F52')#0:?$Y#?7Q%&G652')#@7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J1QKD$ZXD7Q#�:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-�#�G6587N1'&1LB67N1?3 #�+.UJ7NBf')UJ$)X&7&\�]_O6+g1!52')-/%&GJ'V%&7T+21T1mG/4/4J${1�7NB¯:?$�UJ7[52'):?7Q#,#?7Q4652'&3 7NBxU6Pk'�1�+8(*46587�'V4/465�+23Q'):m+8XD7[5g'V-/�%&GJ')%D7&\b½�+8-J'Z5�5.P&K�:?O/7Y52')-/%&GJ'V%&7LR�$&#d7Q-J')U65F+8-/%l3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&-J1I$)RH:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-h#?G65.7N1Y3 $&-J1�+21�:�1d$)RH4/#?7NBD+23Q'):?7N1$)X&7Q#0:?7Q#?(A1_$)R^:�O/7Y$&U/Î�7N3 :052')-/%&GJ')%&7&\d$&:?7I:?OJ'):I¹HÁ�"����,+21L�Q�ZzS�>v/£Qt�¨�sF�Ha0+.:?Oh#�7N1�4J7N3 :b:�$�:�O/7Y:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-*5�+.U/#�'V#�+.7N1QKJ$DU/Î�7N3 :@52')-/%&GJ'V%&7�')-JBGJ1�7Q#b7Q-6XD+8#�$&-/(T7Q-6:N\@�)+8-J3 7*¹HÁ�"©���,+210UJ7 +.-/%[GJ1�7NB*R�$D#�+.:�10$)ab-hB67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:NK6+.:@+2107QX&7Q-h4J$61?1�+.U65.7�:?$T3�OJ')-/%&7:?O/7!+8(*46587Q(*7Q-{:�'V:�+.$&-�5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7,U6Ph%&$)+.-/%AUJ'D3?;[:?$[:?O/7�1�: ')%&7YUJ7 RS$&#?7!�/9{+.-/%h:?O/7!52')-/%&GJ')%&7&K=')-JB�3?OJ')-/%V+8-/%:?$A',BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-6:b52')-/%&GJ'V%&7&\

Þ�ßSÞ á�âHã��� ������� ���ã éAê&ëTì��Á-h$D#�B67Q#0:?$�'&3Q3 $D(T(T$/B/'):?7�'!RSG65�5 XZ')#�+.7Q:�PT$)R 4/#?$&%&#�'V(T(,+.-/%�1�:�PD5.7N1QK6:?O/7�¹@Á�"x%&#?$DG/4�3 $&-J3 7 +.X&7NB¬:?O/7I-/$&:�+.$&-$)R^'La0+2B67Q�1�4W7N3 :?#?G/(Ù52')-/%&GJ')%&7&K/',1�+.-/%)5.7Y52')-/%DGJ')%&7Y4/#?$)XD+gBD+.-/%A'Z5�5�:?O/7�1m:�PD5.7N1@#?7N«&G6+.#?7NB=KMR�#?$D( 1m4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-5.7QX&7 5HB6$Zad-A:?$°+8(*46587Q(*7Q-{:�'V:�+.$&-�587QXD7 5®\d¹HÁ�"��ª¯OJ'&10:?O/7IRS$)5F5.$Za_+8-/%h3 $&(T4W$&-/7Q-6:�1Qi

� \0eb5.%&7QU/#�'Z+g3L$&#�'VUJ1�:?#�'&3 :IB/'):�'*:�P64J7N1�\»]@P64J7N1I4/#?$)XD+2B67�:�O/7�(*7N')-J10RS$&#Y1�4J7N3�+FRSP&+.-/%lUJ'&1�+23L$&U/Î�7N3 :�1I')-JB$&4J7Q#�'V:�+.$&-J10$&-h:?O/$61�7Y$&U/Î�7N3 :�1Q\�]0O/7QP�B67Q:?7Q#�(,+.-/7�:?O/7�')4/465F+23Q'):�+.$&-�RS$&#b:?O/7I52')-/%DGJ')%&7&\

Ð \b]0O/7b1?3?O/7Q(*7052')-/%&GJ')%&7&\�]0O6+21^5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7@+21�:?O/70O/7N')#�:�$)R�¹HÁ�"©�ª�')-JB°4/#?$)X&+2B67N1 :?O/7b(*7N')-J1�R�$D#�ab#m+8:m+8-/%1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-J1[')-JB´'>5.%&$D#�+.:?O/(A1Q\xÁ:°+g1*1�:?#?GJ3 :?G/#�7NBxO6+87Q# ')#�3�O6+g3Q'Z5�5.P�a0+.:?Ox5.7QX&7 521°R�#?$D( 1m4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-:?O/#?$&G/%&Ol')4/465F+23Q'):�+.$&-�K�4/#�$M3 7NB6G/#?7[B6$Zad-�:�$�3 $&-6:?#?$V5®\Y]0O/7T1�4W7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-l5.7QX&7 5�+21�3Q'Z5�5.7NB��)�Np vJ�>sJ')-JB3 $&-J1�+21�:�10$VR^7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1d$)X&7Q#0:?O/7YUJ'&1�+23!:�P64J7N1�\

 �\b"�#?$&%D#�')(A1Q\ "�#?$D%&#�')(A1@3 $&-/-/7N3 :b:?O/7d�J#�1�:d:�a0$L4J')#?:�1@$)R�:�O/7b52')-/%&GJ'V%&7&\�e�4/#?$&%&#�'V(Í+21b'L�J-6+.:?7�1�7Q:0$)R3 $&(T4J$D-/7Q-{:�1�K{adO6+g3�O[(A'>PTUJ7I:�P{4W7N1QK/3 $&(T4/G/:�'):m+8$D-�1�:�#?GJ3 :?G/#?7N1QK6(T$/B6G65.7N10$&#bB67QXD+g3 7N1�\0¹H$&(T4/G/: '):�+.$&-1�:?#?GJ3 :?G/#�7N1QKJ(*$MB6G65.7N1Y')-JB�B67QX&+23 7N1�'V#?7Y+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-J1!$)R�:?O/7,UJ'&1�+23,B/'):�',:�P64J7N1IG/-JB67Q#�5.PD+8-/%�:?O/71?3?O/7Q(*7I5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7&\

]_O/7,52')-/%&GJ')%&7°+g1LB67 �J-/7NB¯R�$D#?(A'>5F5.P&\Ted5.%&7QU/#�'>+23[B/'):�'h:�P64J7N1L')#?7TB67 �J-/7NBk:�O/#?$&G/%&O�'Z58%D7QU/#�'>+23A1m7Q(A')-/�:�+23Q1Q\ j -65.Px:?O/7T;&7Q#�-/7 5C$)Rb:?O/7h1?3�O/7Q(T7T52')-/%DGJ')%&7,+21,B67 �J-/7NBx:?O/#?$&G/%DOk:?#�'&BD+.:�+.$&-J'Z5_B67Q-/$&:�'V:�+.$&-J'>5_1m7Q(A')-/�:�+23Q1Y�F�&:�$/Ó&Ó&KFº�$D#QÓ��Q¡�\^]_O/7�'&B/BD+.:�+.$&-J'>5�5.7QX&7 521I')#?7�B67 �J-/7NB[+.-h:?7Q#�(A10$)R�:�O/7Y4/#?7QX&+.$&GJ1C587QXD7 5g1dU6P�zSp�r&v�£2nQo&p q�rVÖzSt�o&vJr&s�£¥�>q�rDvJzSt��Q£Q\

¹@Á�"��ª¬OJ'&1�')-A'VUJ1�:?#�'&3 :H1mP{-6:�'>9�K)O/7Q-J3 7b+.:�1 7 9/:?7Q#?-J'Z5}#?7Q4/#?7N1m7Q-{:�'V:�+.$&-L+g1��J7 96+.U6587&\0]0O/7052')-/%DGJ')%&7b3Q')-TUW7#?7Q4/#?7N1m7Q-{:?7NB*U6PA')-[e»ª º j ª=��5F+.;&7Y$&#b"�'&1?3Q'>5.��5F+.;&7YXZ'V#�+2')-{:>K&$&#@7QX&7Q-AU6PA',ª=Á��{"���5F+.;&7�$&#0"�#?$V58$D%&��5F+8;D7�X)')#�+2')-6:NKB67Q4J7Q-JBD+.-/%�$&-�abOJ'):[:?O/7l4J')#?:m+g3 G652')#l')4/465F+23Q'):�+.$&-�3Q'>5F521[RS$&#N\ eb5F5�:?OJ'):*+21h#?7N«DG6+.#?7NBf+21h')-¦')4/4/#?$D4/#�+2'):?74J')#�1m7Q#��NG/-/4J')#�1m7Q#N\

Page 5: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

j :�O/7Q#�-/$&: ')U65.7C3�OJ')#�'&3 :?7Q#m+g1m:�+23Q1�$)R=¹HÁ�"��ªh')#?7=nQy6s2s6zS~�|}t2v6w&K6q,oNÔ&y6sFr&p�t�zS~)K)4/#?$)X&+2B67NBLU6P�'>5.%&7QU/#�'>+23�:�P64J7N1�$&-:?O/7�1�4W7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-h5.7QX&7 5�')-JB[U{P[3 $&(T4/G/:�'):m+8$D-�1�:?#?GJ3 :?G/#�7N1QK6(T$MB6G65.7N1b'V-JBhB67QX&+23 7N1!�(T$/B6G6587N1_a0+.:?O[+.-{:?7Q#�-J'>51�:�'V:?7)¢�$&-h:?O/7I+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-�5.7QX&7 5K}'V-JBlvJo&vWÔ&�NzS�>p�q,t�vJtg£¥q,\

Á�:�+21©-/$&:^1mG/#?4/#�+21�+.-/%�:?OJ'V:^1�$D(T7H(T$/B67Q#?-,4/#?$&:�$&:�P{46+.-/%I52')-/%&GJ')%D7N1�')#�7_B67N1�+8%D-/7NBT1�+.(,+F52')#�5.P}<DRS$&# 7 9�')(*46587&K:?O/7�4/#?$&:?$&:�P646+.-/%l52')-/%&GJ')%&7lºI#�+FEA-��ðÚ Ñ ���>¡K03 G/#?#?7Q-6:�5.P´G/-JB67Q#�B67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:h'): d7Qa"!�$&#?;´ýb-6+.X&7Q# 1�+.:�P&K1�OJ')#�7N1T1�7QX&7Q#�'Z5�;&7QP¯R�7N'):�G/#?7N1,a0+.:?Oî¹HÁ�"©�ª�iH1�:?#�$&-/%k:�P{46+.-/%JK@GJ1�7Q#?�B67 �J-/7NB�'>5.%&7QU/# '>+23�B/'V:�'�:�P64J7N1�Kb')-JB´'52'>P&7Q#?7NBh1�7Q(A'V-{:�+23Q1Q\

Û¯7Ya0+F5�5�-/$)a�7 9�')(°+8-/7L:?O/7�:�O/#?7Q7�3 $&(T4W$&-/7Q-{: 10$)R0¹HÁ�"©�ªl+.-�B67Q: '>+F5®\

Þ�ß$# %�&0æ)ç�'( *)6ç�+, =ç� �á,å�-IãJæÁ-*4/#?$&%&#�'V(A1�3 7Q#�:�'>+.-L+gB67Q-6:�+F�J7Q#�10')#?7@GJ1�7NBLRS$&# $&U/Î�7N3 :H1�7Q:�1@��1�$D#?:�1 ¢�K¥R�$&#�7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:�1 $)R=:?O/7N1�7b1�7Q:�1@��3 $&-J1�:�')-6:�1 ¢ K')-JB»R�$&#�R�G/-J3 :�+.$&-J1 $D4J7Q#�'):m+8-/%I$&-Y:?O/7Q( �$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-J1¥¢�\��@7 RS$&#?7Ha07�%)+.X&70')-Y+.-6:?7Q#?4/#?7Q: '):�+.$&-�:�$b:?O/7N1�701�P{(,UW$)521QKa07�')#?7bB67N'>5F+.-/%Ta0+.:?O*4/#?$&%&#�'V(¼1?3?O/7Q(*7N1Q\�]0O/7b4/G/#?4W${1�7I$)R�')UJ1m:?#�'&3 :�:�P64J7N1 +21@:?$Y%)+.X&7I')-,+.-{:�7Q#?4/#?7Q:�'):m+8$D-TU{P4/#?7N1�7Q-6:�+.-/%�:�O/7_1m$&#?:�1QK)3 $&-J1�: ')-{: 1�')-JBL$&4J7Q#�'V:�+.$&-J1 a0+.:?OT:?O/7 +.# RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5F+.:�PA')-JBLU{P,1�:�'):m+8-/%Y:�O/7C4/#�$&4J7Q#?:m+87N1+.-hRS$&#?(�$)RH'>96+8$D(A1I�S52'>a�1 ¢�\ eIUJ1�:?#�'D3 :b:�P{4W7N10(A'>PAUW7�3 $&-J1�:?#�GJ3 :?7NBhO6+.7Q#�')# 3?O6+23Q'>5F5.P&\

eI-�')UJ1�:�#�'&3 :0:�P{4W7&K/U/#�+.7.�JP�3Q'>5F5.7NB�:�P64J7&KJ3 $D-J1�+21�:�10$)R�:�a0$�(['>+.-�4J')#?: 1Qi/ ]0O/7[£¥tFw&vWr&zSy{p��>K=abO6+23?O¯+21�'*5F+21�:�$)Rb1�P6(�UW$)521YabO/$61�7,(T7N')-6+.-/%h+21�1m4J7N3�+F�J7NBka_+8:�O6+8-x:?O/7T:�P64J7&\10H'&3�O1�P{(,UW$)5�+21�'D1?1�$/3�+g'V:?7NBha0+.:?Ok'T1m4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-k$VR�+8: 1b;D+.-JBk��1�$&#?:0$&#Y3Q')#?#�+.7Q#Y1�7Q:b$)RC'V-�')UJ1�:�#�'&3 :b:�P64J7)¢�i�&P{(,UJ$V5g1!RS$&#�1m$&#?:�1Y')#�7A%)+.X&7Q-´'&1L'):?:?#�+.U/G/:?7N1!:?O/7[;&7QP{a0$&# Bkù�2�3Nó&K�1�P6(,UJ$)521!RS$&#�3 $&-J1m:�')-6:Y7 587Q(*7Q-{:�1:?O/7 +.#»1�$D#?:NKJ')-JB¬$&4J7Q# '):�+.$&-k1�P6(�UW$)521�'V#?7�%)+.X&7Q-�:?O/7 +.#IR�G/-J3 :m+8$D-J'>5F+8:�P&\Ie¼1�G/UJ1�7Q:I$)RH:?O/7N1m7�1�P6(,UJ$)521_+g1(A'&B67YXD+g1�+8U65.7T:�$T:?O/7Y$&G/:�1�+gB67,U6PA:�O/7AsFt.£Qz�o�n,��o&v�£¥zSt�zSy6�NvJz�£@$)R^:�O/7�:�P{4W7&\b�&P6(,UJ$)521d-/$&:b(A'DB67�XD+g1�+8U65.7')#?7b3Q'>5F5.7NBh¤{t�Ô&Ô&�>v�1�P6(,UJ$)521Q\H]_O/7_1�+8%D-J'):?G/#?7�B67Q:�7Q#?(,+.-/7N1H'd52')-/%&GJ'V%&7b$)R=aC7 5F5.��RS$&#?(T7NBhzS�>p�qL£0�SRS$&#?(T7NBR�#?$D( :�O/7�3 $&-J1�:�')-6:�10U6Ph')4/465.P&+.-/%[:?O/7�$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-J1¥¢HabO6+23?O�(A'>PA'>521�$A3 $D-{:�'Z+8-¬R�#�7Q7I+gB67Q-6:�+F�J7Q#�1Q\

/ ]0O/7�3 $)5F5.7N3 :�+.$&-k$VR�s�rDÕ £¥KWabO6+23?Ok1�4W7N3�+FR�P�:?O/7,4/#?$&4J7Q#�:�+.7N1I$)R^:�O/7°1mP{(,UJ$V5g1�\�]0O/7!5g'>a�1I')#?7!�J#�1�:?�S$D#�B67Q#58$D%)+230RS$&#?(,G652'&1@U/G6+F58:_R�#?$D(¼7N«DGJ'):�+.$&-J10')-JB°+8-/7N«DGJ'>5F+.:�+.7N1�'V-JB,5.$&%)+23Q'>5�$&4W7Q#�'):?$D#�1540K76CK98³K(:¦K{'V-JBT$)R:?O/7�«&GJ'V-{:�+F�J7Q#�1<;�K�=JK/$)X&7Q#b1�$D#?:�1@$)R�:?O/7Y:�P{4W7&\

]0O/7T(*7N')-6+.-/%�$)RC'¬:�P64J7T]î+21�B67 �J-/7NB¯:?$[UJ7T:�O/7A3�52'&1?1Y$VRC'>5F5C:?7Q#?(*�S%&7Q-/7Q#�'):?7NB�(T$/B67 521Y$)Rb]Y\*d$&:?7,:?OJ')::?O/7Q#?7L(,+.%&O6:�UW7�(A')-6PhBD+�·�7Q#?7Q-6:I(T$MB67 521dRS$&#�'*:�P{4W7�]YK/$D#b:?O/7Q#?7L(,+.%&O{:IUJ7L$&-65.Ph$&-/7&K=B67Q4J7Q-JBD+.-/%�$&-�:?O/74J')#?:m+g3 G652')#Y1�7Q:b$VR�52'>a�1b1�G/4/465F+.7NB=\

½�$&#07 9�'V(T465.7&KJ:?O/7IRS$)5F5.$)a0+.-/%A:�P64J7�1�4W7N3�+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-kB67N1?3 #�+.UJ7N1d+.-6:?7Q%&7Q#Y')#�+.:?O/(T7Q:�+23I(T$/B6G65.$� �ió?>A@ õCB,D5E, GFH 2*I�J�KQuQ�Np�oLK>o&vJ�(KNzSÕ�oMKQ£�y6���di

ù�2�3Nó H 2NI�J�KH 2*I�J�u¥�>p�oMKNo&vW�OK>zSÕ�oLKñQP öNRVóT� H 2NI�J�¢ H 2*I�Jh£Qy{� �

øTS(UAù H 2*IAJ¬�VK>~Aiu¥�>p�oXWþ oDvJ�(Ku¥�>p�oXWþ zSÕ�oMKo&vJ�YWþ zSÕ�oMK£¥y6� �&�?uQ�Np�o�¢�þ�oDvJ�(K£¥y6� �&��oDvJ�D¢�þ�zSÕ�oLK£¥y6� �&��zSÕ�o�¢�þ¦uQ�Np�o

õJö*I�2Wñbó.>A@ õÒ

Page 6: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

Á:�OJ'D1�:?O/7@X&+21�+.U65.7Y3 $&-J1�:�+.:?G/7Q-6:�1 H 2*I�J�K)uQ�Np�oMKNo&vW�OK>zSÕ�o�')-JB°£¥y6���6K>abO/7Q#?7Iu¥�>p�oLKNoDvJ�0')-JB[zSÕ�o�')#?703 $&-J1�:�')-6:�1$)RH1�$&#?: H 2NI�J�K6')-JBl£Qy6���I+21b'�R�G/-J3 :�+.$&-�:�');D+.-/%A$&-/7 H 2*IAJ*4J')#�')(*7Q:?7Q#�')-JB[#?7Q:�G/#?-6+.-/%�' H 2*IAJ�\

e�:�P{4W7�]�(A'>PhB67Q4J7Q-JBh$D-�$&:?O/7Q#0:�P64J7N1_+8-�:?O/#?7Q7Yab'>PM1�ió.>A@ õ�ï®öNRDøZP�ùNï[2�ö�\�e´:�P64J7H]x3Q')-YUJ70(A'DB67H'NX)'>+F52')U65.7CU6P�')-I+.-J1�:�'V-{:�+2'):m+8$D-�K)4J${1?1�+8U65.PLa0+.:?O�#?7Q-J'V(,+.-/%JKNGJ1�+8-/%

')-TïSö*R&ø]PNI�õ�3�52')GJ1m7&\0�&GJ3?O[')-,+.-J1�:�')-6:�+2'):�+.$&-*+21�7N«DG6+.XZ'>5.7Q-6:b:?$Y:?O/7b:�7 9M:?GJ'Z5}1�G/UJ1�:�+.:?G/:�+.$&-[$)R=:?O/7bUJ$/B6P$)R�]��a0+.:?Oh3 $&-J1�+21�:�7Q-{:@#?7Q-J')(,+.-/%/¢�<6:?O/7Q#�7b+21@-/$�4/#?$D:?7N3 :�+.$&-[$&-T:?O/7I(T$/B67 5g1@$)R�]Y\&Á�-J1�:�')-6:�+2'):�+.$&-J1@')#?71�+.(T465.P�'T1�O/$&#?:�OJ')-JB[-/$&:�'):m+8$D-[R�$&#0:�P64J7�UW$MBD+.7N1Q<W:?O/7QP[OJ'>X&7Y-/$,+.-JB67Q4J7Q-JB67Q-6:�1�7Q([')-{:m+g3Q1�\^ SJùQõ�ó.>A@ õ/ù�\Ie¼:�P64J7T(['NPhGJ1m7A')-/$&:?O/7Q#>KH` 4/#�+.(,+.:�+.X&7Nch:�P64J7,U6P�(T7N')-J1I$VR_' ^ SJùQõ7I_2�öÏ3�52')GJ1�7&\,Á�-k:?O6+213Q'&1�7&K�:�O/7T4/#�+.(,+.:�+.X&7[:�P64J7°+g1L4/#?$D:?7N3 :?7NBk')%6'>+.-J1�:Y(T$/BD+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-J1L$)Rb:?O/7A3Q')#?#m+87Q#,1�7Q:�1!$)RH+.:�1!(T$MB67 521Q\]0O6+21*+g1�3Q'>5F5.7NB�¤{t��Np�r&p��Q¤{~�|=p���£¥�>p��>r&zSt�o&v´')-JBf%&GJ')#�')-6:?7Q7N1*+.-JB67Q4J7Q-JB67Q-6:�+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-{: ')U6+F5�+.:�P¦$)R,:?O/74/#�+.(,+.:�+.X&7Y:�P{4W7&\H]0O/7Y:�P{4W7N1@(T7Q-{:m+8$D-/7NB*+8-h:�O/7 ^ SJù�õ`I�2�ö¿3�52')GJ1�7�1mO/$&G652B[UJ7Y:?O/$&G/%DO{:0$)R^'D1H4J'V#?:H$)R:?O/7Y-/7Qa¦:�P{4W7&\

ó.>A@ õa@bSL3cS H õ6óQõ`3)ù�\b]@P64J701�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-J1 (['NPdUJ7H4J'V#�')(T7Q:?#m+8ÀQ7NB=\�]0O/7@4J')#�')(*7Q:?7Q#�1=3Q')-�UW7C1�$D#?:�1�P{(,UW$)521QK3 $&-J1�:�')-6:�1�P6(,UJ$)521QK=')-JB�$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-l1�P{(,UW$)521Q\�]0O/7QPl')#?7�'):�:?#�+.U/G/:?7NB¬+.-�:�O/7�1?')(*7�ab'>P�'&1da0+.:?O6+.-k'1�+.%&-J'):?G/#?7&\¬�&GJ3?Ox:�P{4W7A1�4W7N3�+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-J1T')#?7[3Q'>5F587NB�zS~�|/�[£¥��¤{�Nq,�Q£I$&#�wD�NvW�Np t2�[zS~�|M�Q£Q\A]_O/7QPk(A'>P�UW7+8-J1m:�')-6:�+2'):?7NB[UJ$D:?O[+.- ^ SJùQõ7Id2�ö¿3�52')GJ1m7N1�')-JB�ïSö*R&ø]PNI�õ�3�52')GJ1�7N1Q\BloNÔ&��£C')#?7�'*1�O/$&#?:?OJ'V-JB[-/$&:�'):�+.$&-[RS$&#�3 7Q#�:�'>+.-�:�P64J7N1b')-JB¬:�P{4W7�1?3?O/7Q(*7N1babO6+23�O�')#�7IR�#?7N«DG/7Q-6:�5.PhGJ1�7NB=\e�$MB67N1,')#�7A1�P6-{:�'D3 :�+23Q'>5F58P¯+.-{:�#?$MB6GJ3 7NBxU6Px�4J$61?1�+.U65.P�#?7N3 G/# 1�+.X&7)¢Y(T$MB67hB67N3�52')#�'):m+8$D-J1Q\k]0O/7h1�7Q(A')-6:�+23Q1Y$)R

(T$/B67TB67N3�5g'V#�'):�+.$&-J1»+g1!7 9M4652'>+.-/7NB¯U{P¬+.-J1�:�')-6:�+2'):�+.$&-k$VRH:?O/7T'&1?1�$/3�+2'):?7NBl:�P64J7N1Q<=:?O6GJ1I#?7N3 G/#�1�+8XD7T(T$/B67N1Y')#?77 9/465g'Z+8-/7NB¬+.-�'*1�:?#�'>+.%&O6:�RS$&#?ab')#�B°(A')-/-/7Q#N\H]_O/7Q#?7�')#�7Y:�a0$LUJ'&1�+23Y;D+.-JB/1b$)R�(T$/B67�B67N3�52')#�'V:�+.$&-J1QiùfP H \@e�1�G/( +21C',BD+21�Î�$)+.-{:0G/-6+.$&-[$)R�'I�J-6+.:?7Y-6G/(,UJ7Q#0$)R�XZ')#m+g'V-{:�1@')-JB[3 $&(T7N1�a_+8:�O�3 $&-J1m:?#?GJ3 :?$&# 1QK)4/#?$&Î�7N3 �

:�+.$&-J1QK/')-JB*UJ$6$)5.7N')-�:?7N1m:�RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1QK/abO6+23�O[+.-JBD+g3Q'V:?7�abO/7Q:�O/7Q#�')-*+8-6:?7Q-JB67NB¬4/#?$&Î�7N3 :�+.$&-[aC$DG65gB*PD+87 52B'TB67 �J-/7NBh#?7N1mG658:>\@�3g2*I�PNRVó�\Ye�4/#?$MB6GJ3 :L+21�'��J-6+.:?7&K O/7Q:?7Q#?$&%&7Q-/7Q$DGJ1Y:?G/465.7&\he�4/#?$/B6GJ3 :�OJ'&1L'�3 $&-J1m:?#?GJ3 :?$&#IRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-´')-JB3 $&(T4J$D-/7Q-{:�1m7 587N3 :�$&#0RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1Q\

½�$&#Y4/#�'&3 :m+g3Q'Z5H4/G/#?4J${1m7N1QK :?O/7T4/#?$&%D#�')(T(,+.-/%�1�P/1�:?7Q(¾RS$&#L:?O/7L5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7A1mO/$&G652Bk4/#?$)XD+2B67�'h3 $)5F5.7N3 :�+.$&-$)R@|}p���Ô&�®�CvW��ÔhzS~�|M��£A'&1Y'[UJ'&1�+21»R�$&#IRSG/#?:?O/7Q#L4/#?$&%&# ')(T(,+.-/%h'&3 :�+.X&+.:�+.7N1Q\[]@P{46+23Q'>5b1�:�')-JB/')# B�:�P64J7N1»+8-J3�5.GJB67UJ$6$)5.7N')-kX)'>5.G/7N1QK�+.-{:?7Q%D7Q#�1QK=�J-6+.:?7[1�7Q:�1Y')-JBl(,G65.:�+21�7Q:�1�K=�J-6+.:?7[(A')4/46+.-/%{1QK 1�7N«&G/7Q-J3 7N1�K�:�#?7Q7N1QK=4J$V+8-6:?7Q#�1L')-JB4J$V+8-6:?7Q#Y1�:?#?GJ3 :�G/#?7N1Q\

Þ�ß$h á�âHã�ä�)6âHã=èÍãi�j ����k�� ��^ãdl�m,é[ê&ëTì��Ûk7�a0+F5�5Y4/#?7N1�7Q-6:[:?O/7�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-6:�1�:�PD5.7h5.7QX&7 521[$)RY:?O/7�1?3�O/7Q(T7¬5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7l')-JB´%)+.X&7h7 9J')(T465.7N1Q\�½/$&#*(T${1�:7 9J')(T465.7N1QKWaC7Ya_+�5F5�GJ1m7�')-heYª º j ª���5�+.;&7,#?7Q4/#�7N1�7Q-{: '):�+.$&-�\

nVoqp�oZr s ô=õ�t�u�@A3>õ/ùNùNï[2�ö,v�S=öVwbPVS7wWõkñx2�3 v�2Lw=ï$RCS=ö*Izy�P öNR)óNï[2�ö�SJø�{|3g2MwV3cS H�H ï®öVweI-�7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-�B67Q-/$&:?7N1I$&U�Î�7N3 :�1d$)Rb'A3 7Q#?: '>+.-k;&+.-JBx��7&\J%J\gK}'h1�$D#?:�$VRC')-k'>5.%&7QU/#�'>+23,:�P64J7)¢�\�½�G/-JB/')(T7Q-6:�'>57 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1b'V#?7�:�O/7�:?7Q#�(A1@$ZXD7Q#HUJ'&1�+23I$&U�Î�7N3 :0')-JB[$&4J7Q# '):�+.$&-h1�P{(,UW$)521H$VR^')-[G/-JB67Q#�5.P&+.-/%h'>5.%&7QU/#�'>+23I:�P{4W7&<:?O/7N1�7T1�P6(,UJ$)521!OJ'NXD7�:?$hUW7�+.-6:?7Q#?4/#?7Q:�7NB�+.-�1�$&(T7L(T$/B67 5H$)RC:?OJ'V:�:�P64J7&\ j :?O/7Q#Y7 9�'V(T465.7N1Y$)RH7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1RS$)5F58$)a�i

}�P�SL3fI�õ7I~t�u�@A3>õ/ùNùNï[2�ö�ù o ]0O/7�%&GJ'V#�B67NB[7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-�OJ'D10:?O/7IRS$)5F58$)a0+.-/%*R�$D#?(�i�

Page 7: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

ï.ñ*ú��Ió)ô=õWöd���L�¡A\N\>\?� ¡�ú5�Tó)ô=õJöd�k�,û]0O/7lw&y6r&p�Ô)£�ú5��')#?7�UJ$6$)5.7N')-�7 9M4/#?7N1�1�+.$&-J1QK�'V-JB´:?O/7�����')#?7�7 9M4/#?7N1�1�+.$&-J1[$)RY:?O/7k1?')(T7h-/$&-/��RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5;D+8-JB H \�]0O/7l%&GJ')#�B67NB 7 9M4/#?7N1�1�+.$&-�+21[-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#?(°+8-6+21�:m+g3)Kd+.:�1[X)'>5.G/7l+21[$&-/7l$)R�:?O/7�� � RS$&#AadO6+g3�O�:?O/73 $&#?#�7N1�4J$&-JBD+.-/%´ú5�0+21L:?#?G/7&\�]_O/7�1�7Q:,$)Rb4W${1?1�+.U65.7hXZ'>5.G/7N1L+21,3Q'>5F5.7NB�¨�p�� r&Ô&z�¤6\hÁSR�-/$D-/7A$)RI:?O/7hú5�0+21�:�#?G/7&K:?O/7[XZ'>5.G/7h$)Rb:?O/7[%&GJ')# B67NBk7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1!+21,-/$&:,B67 �J-/7NB=\lÁSR�:�O/7AU/#?7N'DB6:?O�3 $&-6:�'>+.-J1L$&-65.P�$D-/7TXZ'>5.G/7&K@:?O/77 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-¬+g1I3Q'>5F5.7NBxÔ&�NzS�>p�q,t�vJr&zS�>K/$&:?O/7Q#?a_+g1m7I+8:_+g1I3Q'>5F5.7NBxvJo&vWÔ&�NzS�>p�q,t�vJr&zS�>\

Á®RCú�+21IB67Q:?7Q#?(,+.-J'):?7&K�:?O/7Y%&GJ')#�B67NB[7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-ï.ñ*ú×ó)ô=õWöd���L�¡���ú�ó)ô}õWöd���dû

+21�1m7Q(A')-6:�+23Q'>5F58P[+2B67Q-6:�+23Q'>5�:?$T:?O/7T� o&vJÔDt2zSt�o&vJrDs}���?|}p���£�£Qt2oDvï.ñ*ú×ó)ô=õWöd���dõMø�ùQõC���dû

eÙ%&GJ')#�B67NB¯7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-´a0+.:?O´3 $&-J1�:�'V-{:�5.Pk:�#?G/7A%DGJ')#�B/1,B67N1?3 #�+.UJ7N1*')-Ï'V#?U6+.:?#�')#?Px3?O/$)+23 7hUW7Q:�a07Q7Q-x:?O/7U/#�')-J3�O/7N1Q\[Á: 1YU/#?7N'&B6:�Ol+21Y:?O/7TG/-6+.$&-´$VRC:?O/7TU/#�7N'&B6:?Ok$)R�����'V-JBk:?O/7*U/#?7N'&B6:?Ok$VR����N\¬�&GJ3?O´'h%DGJ')#�B67NB7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-�(A'>PAUW7�')U/U/#?7QXD+g'V:?7NBhU6P

�Q���L�¡�����¢?K')-f7 9M4/#?7N1�1�+.$&-³3Q'>5F5.7NB¯�CvWt2zS�l�Q¤6o&t2� �N\�]0O/7[�J-6+.:?7k3�O/$)+23 7�OJ'D1,:?O/7hRS$)5F5.$)a0+.-/%�4/#?$D4J7Q#?:�Pxa0+.:?O�#?7N1m4J7N3 :h:?$:?O/7T')4/465F+23Q'):�+.$&-x$)R_'*RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-hn i»]_O/7T7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J10n��?�Q���*�¡5���>¢?¢b')-JBx�gn��Q����¢�� ¡=n��Q���>¢?¢0OJ'NXD7�:�O/7°1�')(T7U/#?7N'&B6:�O�\H]0O6+21bO/$V5gB/1d1�+.-J3 7�a07YOJ'>X&7Y3Q'>5F5.�SU{P6�SXZ'>5.G/7A'V-JBh3Q'>5F58�S:m+8(*7°3�O/$)+23 7�1m7Q(A')-6:�+23Q1Q\H]�$A'>X&$)+2Bh1�7Q(A')-6:�+234/#?$&U65.7Q(A1�K/a07�B6$A-/$&:b'>5F5.$)a�:�O/7Y-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#?(,+.-6+21�:�+23,3�O/$)+23 7�UJ7Q:�a07Q7Q-�O6+.%&O/7Q#��S$&#�B67Q#dR�G/-J3 :�+.$&-J1�\

y�P�ö*R)óNï[2�ö�� ^ ù�óg3cSLR)óNïT2�ödS=öNI~�X@�@�ø�ï$R�S/óNïT2�ö o eI-�r{¨¥£¥zSp�r&�>zSt2o&vL+21I',4J')#�'V(T7Q:?7Q#�+.ÀQ7NBh7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-�<6+.:b+210$)R:?O/7IRS$&#?(

� H �d���fK>\N\>\�K H �,�g�/¢53�iY�abO/7Q#?7,:?O/7[�c�C')#?7L|MrDp�rDq��>zS�Np�£�$)RH;D+.-JB/1 H �^')-JB�(A'>Ph$/3Q3 G/#IR�#?7Q7L+.-k:?O/7,7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-���\YÁ®R�nl+21�1�GJ3�Ok')-')UJ1�:�#�'&3 :�+.$&-�K6:?O/7Q-�:?O/7Tr |&|}sFt���rDzSt2o&v*$)R=n�:?$,7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1���� $)RH')4/4/#?$&4/#�+2'):�7Y;&+.-JB/1d+2107 9/4/#?7N1?1�7NB¬U{P

n��Q���cKN\>\N\QK����6¢?�]_O/7IR�G/-J3 :�+.$&-J'Z5�+.:�Pl�;D+.-JBW¢C$)R R +g1d%)+.X&7Q-hU6PñQP öNR)ó,� H �.KN\>\N\QK H �)¢�3(�

Û¯7H(A'>PY#?7N1�:�#�+23 :�:?O/7CB6$&(['>+.-�$VR�')#?%DG/(T7Q-{: 1=U{PL4/G/:?:�+.-/%�')-,')4/4/#?$&4/#�+2'):�7»rV£�£Q�Np zSt2oDv�UW7QO6+.-JBT:?O/7©R�$D#?(A'>54J')#�'V(T7Q:?7Q#@5F+g1m:NK}'D1@+.-

�?öVS/óTrMKQö�S/ó�¨!i�r�� ¨V¢0öVS/ó,ihr�� ¨��Á®R^:�O/7�'&1?1m7Q#?:�+.$&-[+21b-/$D:»1?'V:�+21��J7NB[RS$&#b:?O/7�'D3 :?GJ'>5�4J')# ')(T7Q:?7Q#�1�K{:�O/7�#?7N1�G65.:I$)R�:?O/7�')4/465F+23Q'):�+.$&-�+21dG/-JB67Q�

�J-/7NB=\d$&:?7I:?OJ'):0:?O/7I52')-/%DGJ')%&7I+21@RSG65�5.P¬R�G/-J3 :�+.$&-J'Z5®<MR�G/-J3 :�+.$&-J1d(A'>PT$/3Q3 G/#�'&104J'V#�')(T7Q:?7Q# 1C'V-JBh'&1@#?7N1�G65.:�10$)RRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1Q\A]_O/7Q#?7A')#?7*:�a0$h1�:�')-JB/'V#�B�O6+8%DO/7Q#?�S$&#�B67Q#,$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-J1Qi»R�G/-J3 :�+.$&-x3 $&(T4J$61�+.:�+.$&-��A'V-JB�R�G/-J3 :m+8$D-:?G/465F+.-/%l��'&1©+.-�½�"_¢�\

ybï[uA@�2}ï®öJóNù�S=öNIG�Tõ7R(P*3)ùNï[2�ö o e R�G/-J3 :�+.$&-´(['NPlUW7�B67 �J-/7NB´'&1,'[�/9/4J$)+.-6:T$)R»'¬RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5b7N«&GJ'V:�+.$&-�\Ûk7LOJ'NXD7�:?O/7L�/9/4J$)+.-6:Y$&4J7Q#�'V:?$&#��¸abO6+23?O�+21Y')4/465F+.7NBl:?$h'T4J'>+.#�3 $&-J1�+g1m:�+.-/%h$)RC',RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-�+2B67Q-{:m+��J7Q#,')-JB')-�'VUJ1�:?#�'&3 :m+8$D-�a_+8:�O�'[RS#?7Q7,$M3Q3 G/#�#?7Q-J3 7A$VR_:�OJ'):I+2B67Q-{:�+F�J7Q#N\h]0O/7[')4/465F+g3Q'V:�+.$&-�$VRC:?O/7,�/9/4J$V+8-6:,$&4J7Q# '):?$&#%)+.X&7N1L:?O/7T(°+8-6+.(A'Z5d1m$)5.G/:�+.$&-�$VR_:�O/7�3 $&#�#?7N1�4J$D-JBD+8-/%�RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5b7N«DGJ'):�+.$&-�\l¹H$D-J1�+2B67Q#NK�R�$&#L7 9�'V(T465.7&K�:?O/7RS$)5F58$)a0+.-/%hB67 �J-6+.:�+.$&-l$)R^:�O/7IR®'&3 :�$&#�+2'>5i

Ó

Page 8: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

�x�§n i¬�?öVS/óTv�¢bö�S/ó�iïgñhv±þ��,ó)ô}õWö �õ/ø2ù�õ�v��¯n���v�� � ¢û

¢�d7Q#?7&K>nh+210-/$&:0;{-/$)ab-[$&G/:�1�+gB67Y$VR�:�O/7I�/9M4W$)+.-{:b7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-�')-JBA3Q'V-/-/$&:0UJ7YGJ1�7NBh'&10'!RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-[+2B67Q-{:�+F�J7Q#N\d$&:?7Y:�OJ'):�����nxi�÷Y¢0#?7NB6GJ3 7N1I:?$[÷î+8: 1�7 5FRC+FRH:?O/7Q#�7�+21d-/$[R�#�7Q7�$/3Q3 G/#?#?7Q-J3 7,$)R�nl+.-k÷�\I½/G/#?:?O/7Q#�(T$&#?7&K:?O/7I�/9/4J$)+.-6:�$D4J7Q#�'):�$&#b%&7Q-/7Q#�'Z5�+.ÀQ7N1d:?$A1�P/1�:?7Q([1H$VR�RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5�7N«&GJ'V:�+.$&-J1Q\

�[õ/ùgR�3)ï�@�óNï[�=õ�� 2�ö�ù�óg3�P*R)óNù o ÁSR0�¦+21�'[��¤{r&p�r&�NzS�>p�tg£QzSt2�I4/#?7NBD+23Q'):?7&K�:?O/7Q-�:?O/7Y$DU/Î�7N3 :I1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-ó)ôVS/ó 3*�hi[���?�W¢

B67Q-/$&:?7N1_:?O/7�G/-6+2«DG/7T�h$)R�;&+.-JB�3!RS$&#0abO6+23?O¯���?�W¢HO/$)52B/1Q\0]0O6+21@RS$&#?(�+21I3Q'>5F587NB¯Ô&�Q£Q�Np t |}zSt2oDvJ\Á®RC�î+210-/$&:�'T3�OJ')#�'D3 :?7Q#�+21�:�+23Y4/#�7NBD+g3Q'V:?7&K/a07Y(A'>P�1m:�+F5�5 ab#�+.:?7ù�2 H õ 3*��i¬���?�W¢?�

�d7Q#?7Y:?O/7�U/#�7N'&B6:?Oh$)R�:?O6+21Y� o&qd|}p��Q¤{�>v/£Qt2�>����¤{o&t����IB67Q4J7Q-JB/1d$&-k�,\Û¯7Y(A'>P,R�$D#?(�1�7Q:�1_U{P�£¥�>zH� o&qd|}p��Q¤{�>v/£Qt2oDvJi¡ H �hih�����J¢Q¢

B67Q-/$&:?7N1�:?O/701�7Q:�$)RJ'>5F5M$DU/Î�7N3 : 1=$)R/;&+.-JB H :�OJ'):�1?'):m+g1�R�P,�L�?�J¢�\ ��Ûk7H(A'>PY'>521�$I7Q-{G/(T7Q# '):?7H1�7Q:�1�<)7Q-{G/(T7Q# '):�+.$&-3Q')-hUW7�XD+87Qa07NB�'&1b'T3 $&(*4/#?7QO/7Q-J1�+.$&-=¢�\0^9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J10(A'>P[UJ7�«DGJ')-6:�+F�J7NBhGJ1�+.-/%[:?O/7Ty{vWt2�>�Np�£¥rDs*£Ny6r&vJzSt �C�>p�;^K6:?O/7[�Q�)t.£QzS�NvWzSt2r&s�£>y{r&vWzSt �0�Np5=h')-JB:?O/7[y{vWt$£>y{�[�Q�)t.£QzS�NvWzSt2r&sb£Ny6r&vJzSt �C�>p�=O�)\�¤bGJ')-{:m+��J7NB¿7 9M4/#?7N1�1�+.$&-J1IOJ'>X&7�UW${$)5.7N')-l#?7N1mG658: 1�')-JBl')#�7�:�P{46+23Q'>5F5.PGJ1�7NB�+8-l3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&-J'>5�7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J1Q\

nVoqp�o�n s ô=õ�y�P�ø�ø��X@�@ ø2ï�RfS/óNï[�}õ�v�S=öVwbPVS7wWõ]0O6+21_587QXD7 5�$)R�:?O/7I52')-/%&GJ')%&7L4/#?$)X&+2B67N1@R'&3�+F5F+.:�+.7N1IRS$&#0:?O/7�B67N3�52')#�'V:�+.$&-�$)R $&U/Î�7N3 :�1b')-JB*RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1Q\

¥ ^V¦ õ`RVó§�[õ7R&ø[SL3cS/óNïT2�ö�ù o Ûk7I(A'>P,%)+.X&7�$DU/Î�7N3 : 1�-J')(T7N1@U6PT(T7N')-J1@$)R�'T� o&s2sF� �NzSt��N�Yo{¨�¥� �Nz�ÔD���>s�rDp�rDzSt2o&vW<&a07ab#�+.:?7

� H �d���fK>\N\>\�K H �,�g�/¢¨F �Q���gK>\N\N\©K����6¢')-JB*+.-6:?#?$/B6GJ3 7�:�O/7To{¨��Q���>zHt�Ô&�NvWzSt �0�Np�£b�g��\H½/$D#»v¸þ � K/:?O/7Y4J')#?7Q-6:?O/7N1�7N1I')#?7I$&(,+.:?:�7NB=</a07�1�+.(T465.P�ab#�+.:?7

H �ªF �«�Û¯7Y(A'>P�p��Q£QzSp�t��Nz=$&U�Î�7N3 :�B67N3�52')# '):�+.$&-J1_+8-l',1�+.(,+F5g'V#Ya_'>PA'D1@R�G/-J3 :m+8$D-�4J')#�'V(T7Q:?7Q#�1Q</3 $&-J1�+gB67Q#I7&\/%J\gK�?öVS/óTrMKQö�S/ó�¨!i�r�� ¨V¢dF � � �9KQÓ&¢?�I'):?G/# '>5F58P&KWB67N3�5g'V#�'):�+.$&-J1d(A'>PT$/3Q3 G/#»1�7N«DG/7Q-6:�+2'>5F58P&\

y�P�ö*R)óNï[2�ö¬�[õ`RDøTSL3cS/óNï[2�ö�ù o ÁSR H +21T'¬RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-´;D+8-JB¯+.-�')-�$DU/Î�7N3 :TB67N3�52')#�'V:�+.$&-�K�a07AOJ'>X&7h'¬R�G/-J3 :m+8$D-B67N3�52')#�'):m+8$D-h+.-�­/�3Q'>523 G65.GJ1Y1�:�P&5.7,�Q�î+21�')-�'VUJ1�:?#�'&3 :m+8$D-[+8-�:?O6+21b3Q'&1�7)¢ \

½�G/-J3 :�+.$&-J1d(A'>PTUJ7,B67N3�5g'V#?7NB[+.-�:�O/7�eYª º j ªx1�:�P&5.7YU6PAad#�+.:�+.-/%

Page 9: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

ñQP öNR)ó0n®F � H �J¢�3�iY�1�]0O6+21�+21WÎ�GJ1m:H')-�')U/U/#�7QX&+2'):�+.$&-°R�$&# 3 $&-{XD7Q-6+87Q-J3 7&\d�)+.(,+F52')#�5.P&K/'bG/-J')#�PY�/9/4J$)+.-6:�$&4J7Q#�'V:?$&# (A'>PYUJ7b1�G/4/4/#?7N1?1m7NBU6PA#?7Q4652'&3�+.-/%

ñQP öNR)ó,� H ¢A3dn¯F �x��n�i¬� H �W¢<3LiY��¢U6PA:?O/7Y:�#�'&BD+.:�+.$&-J'>5�eYª º j ª=�1�:�P&5.7,ab'>PT$)RHB67N3�5g'V#�+.-/%�',#�7N3 G/#�1�+.X&7YRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-�i

ñQP öNR)ó0n®F � H �J¢�3�iY�1KnVoqp�o J s ô=õ�{ 3c2*R)õ7I�P*3cSJø�v�S=öVwbPVS7wWõ]0O6+21_587QXD7 5�$)R0¹HÁ�"©�ª�3 $&-6:�'>+.-J1b3 $D-J1�:?#?GJ3 :�1d1�GJ3?Ol'&1@XZ')#m+g'VU6587N1�K�'&1?1�+.%&-/(T7Q-6:�1b'V-JB[4/#?$M3 7NB6G/#�7N1Q\

° SL3)ï[S ^ øgõ/ù�S=ö*I,�hù>ùNï[w�ö H õWöJóNù o �)+.(,+F52')#b:?$Y:�O/7b$&U/Î�7N3 :HB67N3�52')#�'):�+.$&-�K6a070(A'>P�B67N3�52')#?7Y',�NrDp�t�r{¨QsF�>K&abO6+23�O(A'>PTUW7Y+.-6+.:�+2'>5F+8ÀQ7)B=i�7SL3 H �±i8þ±�1�

Û¯7�'&1?1�+.%&-�',X)'>5.G/7�:?$[',XZ')#m+g'VU6587,GJ1�+.-/%T:�O/7Ar)£ £¥tFw&vWq,�NvJz £QzSr&zS�>q��>vJz�­iFþ �

a0+.:?O�:?O/7�1�7Q(A')-6:�+23Q10$)R�XZ'V#�+2')U65.7N1�'&1!p��>y&£Qr{¨�s��d$&U/Î�7N3 :@+gB67Q-6:�+F�J7Q#�1Q\²H'V#�+2')U65.7N1�3Q')-hUW7�B67N3�52')#?7NBl')-JB*+.-6+.:�+2'>5F+.ÀQ7NB�3 $V5�5.7N3 :�+.X&7 5.P&K�'&1C+8-�x�7SL3Tï®öJóAt.KQ�7SL3Tï®öJó5�W¢�iFþ �� 7K©�/¢?K

')-JB[:?O/7 +.#IXZ'>5.G/7N1d(A'>PAUW7�3�OJ')-/%&7NB[U6P�'¬��o&s�sF���>zSt2�>��r)£ £Qt�wDvJq,�NvWzSK{7&\�%J\.K��t?K]�J¢�i8þ �?ÓOK �  6¢?�

�&: '):?7Q(T7Q-6:�10')#?7�1�7Q4J'V#�'):?7NB[GJ1�+.-/%k`)<�c/\

{ 3c2*R)õ7I�P*3>õMù o "©#?$M3 7NB6G/#�7N1�')#?7xBD+�·�7Q#?7Q-6:hRS#?$&(íRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1�+8-�:?OJ'):[:?O/7QP¦B6$�-/$D:hP&+.7 52B�' #?7N1�G65.:N\�Á�-¹HÁ�"��ª�K�7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-J1A')#�7�1�:?#�+23 :�5.P�BD+21�:�+.-/%&G6+21�O/7NBfRS#?$&(µ1�: '):?7Q(T7Q-6:�1L:?$k;&7Q7Q4´:�O/7�3 $)5F587N3 :m+8$D-³$VR»4/#?$D%&#�')(:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J1d(A')-J'V%&7N')U65.7&\A�d7Q-J3 7T:?O/7Q#?7[')#?7,$&-65.Pk4/G/#?7T4/#�$M3 7NB6G/#?7N1�\A"�#�$M3 7NB6G/#?7N1!7 +.:?O/7Q#�7 9/465F+g3�+.:�5.P3�OJ')-/%&7�R�$D#?(A'>5YXZ')#m+g'VU6587¯4J')#�')(T7Q:�7Q#�1[$&#*+8(*465�+23�+.:�5.P�(T$MBD+FRSP�-/$&-65.$M3Q'>5�X)')#�+2')U65.7N1¯��1�G/4/4/#?7N1�1�7NB�XZ'V#�+2')U65.74J')#�'V(T7Q:?7Q#�1 ¢ \�0©X&7Q#?P[4/#?$/3 7NB6G/#?7�3Q'>5F5^3Q'V-hUJ7�#�7NB6GJ3 7NBh:?$A'V-�'&1?1�+.%&-/(T7Q-6:b:?$*:?O/7YXZ')#m+g'VU6587,4J')# ')(T7Q:?7Q#�1�\

"©#?$/3 7NB6G/#?7N1b')#?7�B67N3�52')#�7NB�'D1�+.-�:?O/7YRS$)5F5.$Za_+8-/%[7 9J')(T465.7&i@A3c2*Rhr)£ £¥tFw&vWzSÕ�o�F �x�7SL3[ï®öJóAt�¢^iWt�iFþ Ð K')-JBh')#�7�3Q'>5F587NB¬+.-�'¬��r&s�s=£QzSr&zS�Nq,�>vJzSK/'&1@+.-�7SL3Aï®öJó1�}<MRfSJø2ødr)£ £¥tFw&vWzSÕ�o/�Q�W¢?�]�$�'NXD$)+2BT'>5F+2'&1�+.-/%JKD+.:�+21�#?7N«DG6+.#?7NB*:?OJ'): -/$�:�a0$��7 9/465F+23�+8:d$&# +.(T465F+g3�+.:Q¢@XZ')#�+2')U65.7I4J')#�')(*7Q:?7Q#�1 $)R�'I4/#?$M3 7NB6G/#�7(A'>PTUW7�'&1?1m$M3�+2'):?7NB¬a0+.:?Oh:?O/7,1?')(T7IXZ')#m+g'VU6587&\

nVoqp�oqp s ô=õ�� 2�öWóg3g2=øT³´2�3ZïgõWöJóQõ`I¨v�S=ö�w*P�S7wJõ]0O6+21L4J')#?:L$)RY¹HÁ�"©�ª³3 $D-J1�+21�:�1Y$VR_:�O/7�3 $&-6:?#?$V58���J$)a�3 $&-J1�:?#?GJ3 : 1Y1�GJ3?O´'&1!:?O/7AGJ1mGJ'>5»t�zS�Np�r&zSt�o&vx£QzSr&zS�Nq,�NvWz�£�xUhô�ï�ø.õ¬58$6$&4�K�I*2¿58$6$&4la0+.:?O�7 9M465F+23�+.:°øgõ(SO�=õh1�:�'):?7Q(*7Q-{:0+.-k:�O/7Y5.${$D4�UW$MB6PW¢�\dÁ:Y'>521�$�3 $&-6:�'>+.-J1�sFr{¨��Nsð£b')-JBwL2Wó�2k1�:�'):?7Q(*7Q-{:�1�\

Page 10: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

nVoqp�o�µ {�SL3cSJø2øgõ/ø��|2�ö�ùQóg3�PNRVóNù¹HÁ�"��ªx'>5F58$)a�1C5�+.(,+.:?7NB¬4J')#�'>5F5.7 5F+21�(¾+.-�:?O/7IRS$&#?(�$)R�:?O/7Y4J')#�'Z5�5.7 5^3 $D(T4J${1�+8:m+8$D-�$)R�U65.$/3?;/1Q\d¹H#�+.:�+23Q'>5�#�7Q%)+.$&-J1(A'>PTUW7�3 $&-J1�:�#?GJ3 :?7NBhGJ1�+8-/%[:?O/7IRS$)5F5.$Za_+8-/%*RS$&#?(�iSOU1SJïgóhòÍó)ô}õWö���õJö*IbU«SJïgó�KabO/7Q#?7hò�+21b'*3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&-�K}'V-JBl��+21b:�O/7�3 #�+.:�+23Q'>5^#�7Q%)+.$&-�\

Þ�ßZ¶ ëY'Olb��'( è�渷���é[êVë*ì��¹H$&(*4/G/:�'):�+.$&-l1�:?#?GJ3 :?G/#�7N1QK=(T$/B6G6587N1�K�')-JBlB67QX&+23 7N1Y4/#�$ZXD+2B67,+.-{:�7Q#?4/#?7Q:�'):m+8$D-J1b$)R0:?O/7�'Z58%D7QU/#�'>+23,:�P{4W7N1I:?OJ'):G/-JB67Q#�5.Px:?O/7�1�3?O/7Q(T7*52')-/%&GJ')%D7&\k]0O/7QP�3Q')-xUJ7[%&#?$&G/4W7NBk:�$&%&7Q:?O/7Q#T'&1*��o&qd|/o&vJ�>vJz�£Y$)R�'¬|}p�o�w&p�r&q,\l]0O/74/#?$&%D#�')( +21b7 9/7N3 G/:?7NBhU6P*+8-6X&$&;D+.-/%A7 9/7N3 G/:�')U65.7LX&+21�+.U65.7A3 $&-J1�:m+8:�G/7Q-{:�1_$)R�+.:�1d3 $&(T4J$D-/7Q-{:�1�\

� 2 H @�P}ó�S/óNï[2�ö�¹}óg3�P*R)ófP*3Nõ/ù o e � o&qd|}y6zSr&zSt2oDv¦£QzSp�y6�NzSy6p��h+21�'´3 $)5F587N3 :m+8$D-�$)RTB67N3�52')#�'):�+.$&-J1�R�$D#�1�$D#?:�1QK$&U/Î�7N3 :�1QK�'V-JBhRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1!:?OJ'):�')#?7,(A'DB67°'>X)'>+F5g'VU6587[:?$h:?O/7,$&G/: 1�+2B67&\[¹H$&(T4/G/:�'V:�+.$&-k1�:?#?GJ3 :?G/#�7N1b4/#?$)XD+2B67A'(T7N')-J1CR�$&#_+8(*46587Q(*7Q-{:�+.-/%h:�P64J7N1Q\H]_O/7�B67N3�5g'V#�'):�+.$&-�$)R©'*3 $&(T4/G/:�'):m+8$D-�1�:?#?GJ3 :?G/#�7YOJ'&10:?O/7IRS$&#?(

ùQóg3�PNRVófPN3>õkò�º»F½¼ � o&v/£QzSt�zSy{�>vJz�£�¾E<�fK>\N\>\QK�E�¿õJö*Id2Wñ�ù�óg3�P*R)ófP*3>õ

]_O/7�sFt.£Qz�omn»� o&v/£QzSt�zSy{�>vJz�£�3 $&#?#�7N1�4J$&-JB/1@:?$L:?OJ'):�$)R�'!:�P64J7&<D+.:C3 $D-J1�+21�:�1@$)R�1�P6(�UW$)521 RS$&#C1m$&#?:�1QK&3 $D-J1�:�')-6:�1QK')-JBLRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1@XD+g1�+8U65.7Y:?$L:?O/7b$&G/: 1�+2B67&\0�)+.-J3 7»3 $&(*4/G/:�'):�+.$&-A1m:?#?GJ3 :?G/#?7N1@')#?70+.-6:?7Q-JB67NB['&1 +.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-J1RS$&#H:�P64J7N1QKD4/#?$M3 7NB6G/#�7b+2B67Q-6:�+F�J7Q#�10(,GJ1�:H-/$D:C')4/4W7N')#�+.-h:?O/705F+21�:0$)R�3 $&-J1�:m+8:�G/7Q-{:�1�\H¹@$&(T4/G/:�'):m+8$D-A1�:?#?GJ3 :�G/#?7N1(A'>PTUW7�4J')#�'V(T7Q:?7Q#�+.ÀQ7NB�'V-JB[:?O{GJ1_GJ1�7NB�'&1L`�+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-{: '):�+.$&-�1�3?O/7Q(T7N1�c/\

]_O/7¬¨�oNÔD~1E � K>\N\>\QK�E ¿ $)RH:?O/7T1�:?#?GJ3 :�G/#?7,4/#?$)X&+2B67N1YB67 �J-6+.:�+.$&-J1,'):d587N'D1�:IR�$D#�:?O/7T3 $&-J1m:�+.:?G/7Q-{: 1Q<WR�G/#�:?O/7Q#` O6+2B/B67Q-Jc¯7Q-{:�+.:�+.7N1,(['NP¯UJ7�B67 �J-/7NBÏR�$D#�+.-6:?7Q#?-J'>5bGJ1�7&\´]0O/7h;D+.-JB/1T$VR»B67 �J-6+.:�+.$&-J1T:�OJ'):,(A'>P�')4/4J7N'V#,+.-1�:?#�GJ3 :?G/#?7N1@+.-J3�5.GJB67&i

/ +8-J1m:�')-6:�+2'):�+.$&-J10$)R�:�P{4W7N1QK/:�P64J7�1?3�O/7Q(T7N1QK=��4J')#�')(T7Q:�7Q#�+.ÀQ7NBW¢C1�:?#?GJ3 :�G/#?7N1QKJ')-JB[(*$MB6G65.7N1/ B67N3�5g'V#�'):�+.$&-J1d$)R�(T$/B67N1QK6RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1QKW$&U/Î�7N3 :�1QK/')-JB[4/#�$M3 7NB6G/#?7N1Ia_+8:�O/$&G/:b%)5.$&UJ'>5 XZ')#�+2')U65.7N1]_O/7IR�$)5F5.$)a0+.-/%A7 9J')(T465.7!+�5F5.GJ1�:?# '):?7N1dO/$Za�',:�P{4W71Àj�1Á[ú�D�D5Â�(,+.%&O{:dUJ7Y+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:?7NB=iùQóg3�PNRVófPN3>õhú�D�D5Â�ÃQB��kªF ö}õ(U ^ 2�2}ø©KNzSp y{�(KSnQr&sð£Q�OK>r&vJÔ*K>o&p(KQvJo&z iH 2*I�õlö}õ(U ^ 2�2}ø�F n¥r&sð£Q�ÅÄ°zSp�y6�OK

ñQP öNRVóAr&vWÔªF �?ö=õ(U ^ 2�2}ø@�VK>~/¢bö=õ(U ^ 2�2}ø�iïgñ[�Aþ�zSp�y6�Y4³~,þ�zSp�y6�,ó)ô}õWö�zSp y{�,õ/ø2ù�õ�nQr&sð£Q�Yû�K

ñQP öNRVóAo&pGF �?ö=õ(U ^ 2�2}ø0��KN~�¢Cö=õ(U ^ 2�2}ø�iïgñ[�Aþ¯n¥r&sð£Q�¸4�~*þknQr&sð£¥�Ló)ô=õJö[n¥rDs�£Q�LõMø�ùQõlzSp�y6�,û�K

ñQP öNRVóAvJoDz�F �?ö}õ(U ^ 2�2}ø_�J¢bö=õ(U ^ 2�2}ø�iïgñ[�Aþ�zSp�y6�,ó)ô}õWöhnQr&sð£¥�Yõ/ø�ùQõkzSp y{�Lû

õJö*Id2Wñ»ù�óg3�P*R)ófP*3>õe§3 $&(*4/G/:�'):�+.$&-�1m:?#?GJ3 :?G/#?7*+21,3Q'>5F587NB´'¿£¥~)vWzSr&�NzSt���rDs2sF~h� o&p�p�� �Nz +.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):m+8$D-´$)R�'h:�P{4W7,+FR�:?O/7[7 5.7Q�

(T7Q-6:�1�$VR�:�O/7�#?7N1m4J7N3 :�+.X&7Y3 $&-J1�:�+.:?G/7Q-6:@5F+g1m:�1@:?$&%&7Q:?O/7Q#@a0+.:?O[:?O/7 +.#_1m$&#?:�1�')-JB°RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5F+.:�+.7N1�3 $)+.-J3�+2B67,��'>RS:?7Q#3 $&-J1�+21�:�7Q-{: #?7Q-J')(,+.-/%/¢ \�e�1mP{-6:�'&3 :�+23Q'>5F5.P�3 $D#?#?7N3 :�+8(*46587Q(*7Q-{:�'V:�+.$&-T$)RJ'b:�P64J7@+21�3Q'Z5�5.7NB[£Q�Nq,r&vWzSt2� r&s�sF~�� o&p p�� �Nz+FRH:?O/7I+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-�4/#?$)X&+2B67N1I',(T$/B67 5�$)R�:?O/7Y:�P{4W7&\

� �

Page 11: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

ÆÇ2*I�P�øgõMùYS=ö*I_�[õ(��ï$RVõMù o B�o>Ô&y{sF��£_')-JBxÔ&�>�Nt�����£_'V#?7�1�+.(,+F52')#Y:?$h3 $&(T4/G/: '):�+.$&-�1m:?#?GJ3 :?G/#?7N1�KJ7 9J3 7Q4/:Y:?OJ')::?O/7QP[(A'>PA'>521�$T7 9/4J$D#?:b4/#?$/3 7NB6G/#?7N1Q\HÚI7QXD+23 7N1b(['NP&KD+.-�'&B/BD+.:�+.$&-�K=3 $&-6:�'>+.-�B67 �J-6+.:�+.$&-J1I$)R�O6+2B/B67Q-lXZ')#m+g'VU6587N1abO6+23�O�3Q')-lUJ7T([')-6+.4/G65g'V:?7NBl:?O/#?$DG/%&Ol:?O/7,4/#?$M3 7NB6G/#�7N1Y4/#?$)XD+gB67NB=\LeI-�7 9J')(T465.7,RS$&#Y'[(T$/B6G6587*aC$DG65gB�UW7'T3 $)5F5.7N3 :�+.$&-l$)R�4/#?$/3 7NB6G/#?7N1b([')-6+.4/G65g'V:�+.-/%�'T1�:�'&3�;[%)+.X&7Q-�'&1d',4J')#�')(*7Q:?7Q#N\ j -/7,3 $&G652B[+.(A')%)+.-/7,'AB67QXD+23 7abO6+23�O¿1mG/4/465�+.7N1L1�+.(,+F5g'V#IR�G/-J3 :�+.$&-J1�K=U/G/:�OJ'&1d:?O/7,1�:�'&3�;�'D1�')-¬+.-{:?7Q#�-J'>5�XZ'V#�+2')U65.7A'&3Q3 7N1?1�+.U65.7T$&-65.Ph:?O/#�$&G/%&O:?O/7Y4/#?$/3 7NB6G/#?7N1Q\

È ÊÊÉ?ËI��� �?� Ä¸Ì �?��Í�Î ÌI� ÊÊÉ?ËIÅ�Ï*��ÌI���§Ê�ËTËT����Ìb�©Ä

]0O/7[eb5.%&$D#�+.:?O/(,+23Q1T%D#?$&G/4f�Á�½ Á�"�Û¦º Ð \ � ¢d+g1°(T$&:�+.XZ'V:?7NBkU6Pk:?O/7h3 $&-6X&+23 :�+.$&-f:?OJ'):,'�%D#?7N'):�B67N'Z5_$VR�:?O/7'&3 :�+.XD+.:�+.7N1b$)R�'>5.%&$D#�+.:?O/(,+23�B67QX&7 5.$&4/(*7Q-{:�1mO/$&G652Bh')-JBA3Q'V-hUJ7Y4J7Q#mR�$&#�(T7NB,+.-l'�1�+8(°+�52')#da_'>PT'&1@(A'):�O/7Q(A'):�+.�3Q'>5�'&3 :�+.XD+.:�+.7N1Q\C]_O/7Y%&#?$&G/4[+21bB67QX&7 5.$&46+.-/%�'!52')-/%&GJ')%D7IR�$&#�`Q'Z58%D$&#�+.:?O/(,+23Y7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-J1?c,a0+.:?Oh:?O/7I+2B67N'*:?OJ'):'>5.%&$&#m+8:�O/(A1H')#�7�B67QX&7 5.$&4J7NB*U6P�([')-6+.4/G65g'V:�+.-/%A1�GJ3�OT7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J1I�Ðe�7Q7N�& 6KÐe�7Q7N�f�/K��0Ñ��DÒ)U�K��0Ñ��MÓNU/¡\�]0O/7b;&7QP4J$V+8-6:Y+21!:?OJ'):�:�O/7�52')-/%DGJ')%&7A1�O/$DG65gB¯UJ7['hG/-6+FR�$D#?(�RS#�')(T7Qa0$&#�;h#�'):?O/7Q#Y:?OJ'V-�'hG/-6+.$&-k$VRd'h1m4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-52')-/%&GJ')%D7A')-JBl')-�+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-{: '):�+.$&-¯5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7&id+.:�(,GJ1�:YUW7T4J${1�1�+.U6587[:?$hXD+.7Qa '>5F5H7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1L'&1Y1�4J7N3�+F�J�3Q'):�+.$&-J1�K}'>5.:?O/$DG/%&O�-/$&:Y'>5F5�7 9M4/#?7N1�1�+.$&-J1I-/7Q7NBh:?$h1�G/%&%D7N1�:�')-¬+8(*46587Q(*7Q-{:�'V:�+.$&-�\Y]0O/7Y52')-/%&GJ'V%&7�1�O/$DG65gB�UW73 $&(T4J'V#�')U65.7Y:?$�:�O/7b52')-/%&GJ'V%&7YGJ1�7NB*U{PT(['):?O/7Q(A'):m+g3�+2')-J1�K/a0+.:?O[-/$&:�'):�+.$&-J1@:?OJ'V:H%)+.X&7�',3 $&-6X&7Q-6+.7Q-{:0ab'>PT:?$7 9/4/#?7N1?1�3 $D-J3 7Q4/:�1�')-JB�R®'&3�+F5F+.:�'):?7[#?7N'&1m$&-6+.-/%J\h¹�5.7N')#m58P&K�'¬-6+g3 7h'>5.%&7QU/#�'Z+g3[1�:?#�GJ3 :?G/#?7L+21�'[4/#�7Q#?7N«&G6+21�+.:?7[RS$&#$&U/:�'Z+8-6+.-/%*+.-{:?7Q#�7N1�:�+.-/%h#?7N1�G65.:�1QKW1�+.-J3 7�$D:?O/7Q#?a0+21�7&KW-/$T%&7Q-/7Q#�'Z5�52'NaI1�3Q')-�UJ7L7 9M4/#?7N1�1�7NB=K}'V-JBh7N'&3�O�1�:?7Q4�OJ'&1:?$TUW7YX&7Q#�+F�J7NBl'>RS#?7N1�O�\

Á�:[+21*+8(*4J$&#?: ')-{:[:?$´-/$&:�7�:?OJ'):h:�O/7¿1m4J7N3�+F�}3l-/$&:�'V:�+.$&-J'>5�3 $&-{XD7Q-{:�+.$&-J1[GJ1m7NB¦1�O/$&G652B�UW7�%V+8XD7Q-�5F+8:�:�5.7a07 +.%&O{:>\b]0O/7Y+2B67N'°+g1I:�$,�J-JBh:?O/7L#�+.%&O6:�UJ'>52')-J3 7,UW7Q:�a07Q7Q-�#?7N'&B/')U6+F5F+.:�P&K=:�7Q#�1�7Q-/7N1?1QKW')-JB�B67Q4W7Q-JB/')U6+F5�+�:�P&\IÁ�-$&G/#04/#?7N1�7Q-6:�'):m+8$D-h$)R�:?O/7IRS#�')(T7Qa0$&#�;}KDaC7Y:�#?PT:?$,GJ1�7�'h`Q3 $&-6X&7Q-6:�+.$&-J'>52c/K/1�7 5FRS�S7 9M4652')-J'):�$&#?Ph-/$&:�'V:�+.$&-AGJ1�+8-/%4J')#?7Q-6:?O/7N1�7N1_$&-65.Ph:?$A'>X&$)+2Bh')(,U6+.%&G6+.:�+.7N1Q\

#@ßà ä�ç�'7��)6ç(��'{ãWæ½�+.#�1�:b$VR©'>5F5K=a07Y-/7Q7NB�:?$AB67 �J-/7�1m$&(T7�$DU/Î�7N3 : 10:?$Ta0$&#?;*$&-�\b�&G/4/4W${1�7YE +g1I'[B6$&(A'>+.-�KW7&\/%J\.K/-6G/(,UJ7Q#�1_$&#UJ$6$)5.7N')-J1Q\@Ûk7�B67 �J-/7,',-/7Qa×B6$D(A'>+.-º`Ñ þ_EÓÒ½º7ÑÕÔÖº`Ñ×K:?O/7kB6$&(A'Z+8-�$)R¸E,�1�:?#�GJ3 :?G/#?7N1QK07N'&3�O�$)R�abO6+23�O�+21[7 +8:�O/7Q#�')-�7 587Q(*7Q-{:h$)R¸Eí$&#h3 $&-J1�:?#?GJ3 :�7NBxRS#?$&(í:�a0$E,�1�:?#?GJ3 :?G/#�7N1Q\

]�$�'D3 :?GJ'>5F5.P�U/G6+F52B~E,�1�:?#?GJ3 :�G/#?7N1QK�a07TGJ1�7�'V-³t�v��Q���>zSt2oDv�o |/�Np�r&zSt�o&v�Ø�')-JBx'x��o&v�£¥zSp y6�NzSt�o&v´o |M�>p�r&zSt2oDvÙ \bÁ®R�r[+21�'V-�7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:Y$)R�EhKW:?O/7Q-iØ�r�1m:�')-JB/1@RS$&#I:?O/7�3 $&#�#?7N1�4J$D-JBD+8-/%h7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:Y$)R5º`ÑI\0Ûk7,1�OJ'>5F5^ad#�+.:?7�Ør+.-J1�:?7N'&B[$VR�Ø�rJ\@ÁSRH�h')-JBl~T')#?7|E,�1�:?#?GJ3 :?G/#�7N1QK6:?O/7Q-l� Ù ~TB67Q-/$&:�7N10:?O/7|E��1�:�#?GJ3 :?G/#?7Y3 $&-J1�:?#�GJ3 :?7NB*R�#�$&(§�')-JBl~W\�º7Ñx+210:?O/7Y1�7Q:0$)R^'Z5�5�1�:?#?GJ3 :?G/#�7N1H:�OJ'):C3Q')-hUW7YU/G6+F58:_R�#?$D(ÓE U{PA'!�J-6+.:?7L-{G/(,UJ7Q#0$)R�+8-)Î�7N3 :�+.$&-J1I')-JB3 $&-J1�:�#?GJ3 :�+.$&-J1Q\

Û¯7�3Q')-[+.-{:?#�$MB6GJ3 7,')-kt2ÔD�NvJzSt�zS~[�NsF�Nq,�NvWzJU6P[#?7NB67 �J-6+.-/%º Ñ þ_EÓÒ ¡ �(¢¸Ò½º Ñ ÔÚº Ñ')-JB*+.(T4W${1�+.-/%h:?O/7Tt�Ô&�NvWzSt2zS~TsFr&Õ

� Ù � þ�� Ù �¾þ �V�d$)a¦a07�OJ'>X&7,'[#?7N'&1�$&-J'VU6587,1�:�')#�:�+.-/%A4W$)+.-{:NK�1�+8-J3 7*aC7,3Q')-�$DU/:�'>+.-�R®')(°+�5F+2')#�1�:�#?GJ3 :?G/#?7N1dU{P¬+.(T4J${1�+8-/%$&:?O/7Q#I'>5.%&7QU/#�'>+23I52'>a�1Q\ j R^4J')#�:�+23 G65g'V#b+.-6:?7Q#?7N1�:�'V#?7Y:?O/7I52'>a�10$)Rbr)£ £¥o>�Nt�r&zSt2�>t2zS~)i

�&�

Page 12: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

� Ù � ~ Ù u/¢�þ¦�?� Ù ~�¢ Ù uLK$)Rb��oDq�q,y6zSr&zSt��Nt�zS~Zi

� Ù ~*þ�~ Ù �VK')-JB[$)Rbt�Ô&�Nqd|MoDzS�NvJ�>~)i

� Ù �[þ¦���Á:L+21!+.-{:?7Q#�7N1�:�+.-/%l:?$�-/$&:�7T:?OJ'):La0+.:?O�7N'D3?Ox-/7Qa 5g'>a aC7*%&7Q:T')-/$&:?O/7Q#!R®')(°+�5F+2')#TB/'):�'�1�:?#?GJ3 :�G/#?7&i�a07[%&7Q:NK1�GJ3Q3 7N1?1�+8XD7 58P&Kds�tg£Qz�£?Ûbq,y{sFzStgÖ£Q�Nz�£Tr&vWÔh£Q�Nz�£Q\T½/$&#�1�7Q: 1QK�Ø�+21Y:?O/7°R�G/-J3 :�+.$&-�riÜÝ ¡ r9¢{K Ù +21!:?O/7A1�7Q:YG/-6+.$&-¨ÞHK')-JBX�L+21d:?O/7Y7Q(T4/:�Ph1�7Q:N\#@ßSÞ ß� �æ�·Z)¨àa-IãL'( =ç�·Zl��HæÛk7Ya0+F5F5�GJ1�7�:?O/7IRS$)5F5.$)a0+.-/%T5.7Q(T(A'°:?$AB67QX&7 5.$&4¬R�G/#?:�O/7Q#b#?7N1�G65.:�1Qi

v�õ H�H SXJ oZr�á?â ö*I�P*R)óNï[2�özv©õ H¨H S�ãCÂ��>z n¼r&vJÔkw�¨?�lzSÕ�o[nQy{vW�NzSt�o&v/£hÔ&�®�CvJ� Ôxo&v¨º`Ñ×Û�£Qr&zStg£2nQ~)t2v6w�z�¤6�nQo&s2sFo&Õ�t�v{w[� o&vJÔDt2zSt�o&v/£gäå tçæ[nè�°þ³w��å t�tçæ[néØr[þ³wêØrMÛHr&vJÔå t�t�tçæ[n��hþ³w¿��r&vWÔbn�~,þ�w�~lr)£�t�vJÔDy{�>zSt2o&v�¤{~�|/o&z�¤{�Q£Qtg£�t2qd|}sFt��Q£�n �?� Ù ~�¢Hþ³wW�?� Ù ~/¢ë�¤{�>vYnlþ³w*ì{ 3c2�2Jñ o �@PT+.-JB6GJ3 :�+.$&-l$&-h:?O/7�3 $D(T465.7 9{+.:�P�$)R :?O/7YRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-�'V#?%&G/(T7Q-6:N\d$&:?7I:?OJ'):d:?O/7I�J#�1�:b4J'V#?:b$)R�:�O/7Y5.7Q(T(A'T3Q'V-hUJ7�$D(,+.:?:?7NB[+FR5º Ñ B6$67N10-/$&:bOJ'>X&7�')-[+2B67Q-6:�+.:�P&\

ª�7Q:bGJ1@+.-{:�#?$MB6GJ3 7L:?O/7YRS$)5F5.$)a0+.-/%AUJ'&1�+g3!$&4J7Q# '):�+.$&-J1Qi

ÆÇSL@ o ]0O/7H$D4J7Q#�'):�$&#��C')4/465F+.7N1�'@R�G/-J3 :m+8$D-�:?$b7N'D3?OA` (*7Q(�UW7Q#�cI�7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:�')#�P�3 $&(T4J$D-/7Q-{:Q¢W$)R{+.:�1�')#?%&G/(T7Q-6:NK')-JB[:?O/7Y#�7N1�G65.:b+21b'T1m:?#?GJ3 :?G/#?7I$)R�:?O/7IRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-�X)'>5.G/7N1b$&U/: '>+.-/7NB=\�ÁSR=n�+21b'�R�G/-J3 :�+.$&-�KW:?O/7Q-,n��,1�:�')-JB/1@RS$&#:?O/7IRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-�1�'):�+21�RSP&+.-/%�S+S¢Ln��«�,þ~��S+F+S¢,n���Ør¾þ~ØJn´rJK�S+F+F+S¢,n��T�?� Ù ~/¢fþkn��T� Ù n��A~J\ybï�ø.óQõ73 o ]0O/7Y$D4J7Q#�'):�$&#jí,:�'V;&7N10',4/#?7NBD+23Q'):?7!|¯'V-JBh'T1�:?#?GJ3 :�G/#?7,��')-JB[#?7Q:?G/#?-J1d:?O/7�1�:�#?GJ3 :?G/#?7Y$)RH3 $&(T4W$&�-/7Q-6:�10$)R0�h:?OJ'):b1?'):�+21�RSP*|^\ |�íT1�:�')-JB/1CR�$&#d:?O/7IR�G/-J3 :m+8$D-�1?'):m+g1�R�PD+.-/%�S+S¢*|èí¸�Lþz��S+F+S¢[|èí�Ør*þÅî Ør +FR | r� $&:�O/7Q#?a0+21�7

�S+F+F+S¢[|èí[�?� Ù ~�¢�þ¦�S|èí��J¢ Ù �S|èíh~�¢�NÐ

Page 13: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

�*õ`I�PNRVõ o Á®R�Ò�+21b'LU6+8-J'V#?PA$D4J7Q#�'):m+8$D-T+.-iEhKM'V-JBh�*+g1C+8-iº7ÑbK6:?O/7Q-iÒ�ï,�A#�7Q:?G/#?-J1@:?O/7YXZ'Z58G/7Y$DU/:�'>+.-/7NB[U{P+.-J1�7Q#?:�+.-/%CÒ�UW7Q:�a07Q7Q-�'&B>Î?'&3 7Q-6:�3 $&(T4W$&-/7Q-6:�10$)R0�}\5Ò|ïY+210:?O/7!R�G/-J3 :�+.$&-l1?'):�+21�RSPD+8-/%�S+S¢*+�R5Ò�OJ'D1b')-[+2B67Q-{:m+8:�Ph7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:��,1�GJ3�O�:?OJ'V:»�YÒ¼r[þ�r�Ò¼�Lþ�rWK/:?O/7Q-�Ò�ï��Lþ��6K�S+F+S¢iÒ�ï�ØrTþ�rJK=')-JB�S+F+F+S¢iÒ�ïT�?� Ù ~/¢�þ¦�©Ò�ïT�J¢�Ò �QÒ�ïA~�¢�\¹�5.7N')#�5.P&KbÒ¦(,GJ1�:bUJ7,'&1?1�$/3�+2'):�+.X&7IRS$&#�Ò�ï�:�$TUJ7LG/-6+g«DG/7&\d$)a�:?OJ'):,a07AOJ'>X&7�1�$D(T7AUJ'D1�+23[$&4J7Q#�'V:�+.$&-J1QK@aC7�3Q'V-kRS$&#?(,G652'):?7�'¬RS7Qa�52'NaI1Q\�½�+.#�1�:>K5��BD+21�:?#�+.U/G/:?7N1:?O/#?$DG/%&O Ù <6RS$&#�'>5F5^1�:�#?GJ3 :?G/#?7N1I�h')-JBk~*a07YOJ'NXD7

n��T�?� Ù ~/¢@þ¦�.n��*�J¢ Ù �.n��A~�¢?��&7N3 $&-JB=Kb��BD+21�:?#�+.U/G/:?7N1dUJ'&3�;{ab')# B/1H:�O/#?$&G/%&O[RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5^3 $D(T4J${1�+8:m+8$D-�i

�.n���wW¢��Íþî�.n,�)¢��*��wC�)¢?�½/G/#�:?O/7Q#?(T$&#�7&K&+FR�n�+21@+.-)Î�7N3 :�+.X&7,a0+.:?O[+.-6X&7Q#�1�7dnAð � K/:�O/7Q-

�.n��&¢ ð � þ¦�.n ð � �&¢?�Ûk7YOJ'>X&7�1�$D(T7Y#?G65.7N10+.-6X&$)5.XD+8-/%Xí/\H½�+F5.:?7Q#�+.-/%*+21�3 $&(*(�G/: '):�+.X&7&i

|èíX£¸í[�[þ飸íL|�í[�V�|èí�+g1I')-[+2B67Q(T4W$&:?7Q-6:�$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-�KM+®\�7&\.K

|èíL|�í[�Aþ |èí[���½�+.-J'>5F5.P&K=:?O/7IR�$V5�5.$)a0+.-/%h3 $&(T(,G/:�'):�+.XD+.:�P*#?7 52'):�+.$&-�O/$V5gB/1dUJ7Q:�a07Q7Q-���')-JBCí6i

|èíIn��*�hþkn��T�S|��bn ¢�í��V�]0O/7Y4/#?$6$)R10$)R�:?O/7N1�7I52'>a�1b')#�7�1�:?#�'>+.%&O6:�RS$&#?ab')#�B*')4/465F+g3Q'V:�+.$&-J1I$)R�:?O/7I+.-JB6GJ3 :�+.$&-�587Q(*(A'/\

#@ß$# ñdl©èÅl èzl�'�-dâ�·Sæ6è³æe¾O/$&(T$&(T$D#?4/O6+21�(�+21T7N1�1�7Q-{:m+g'Z5�5.P�'h5F+.-/7N')#h$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-´a_+8:�O�#?7N1�4W7N3 :T:?$ Ù \ e§RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-¦¤x+21T'lO/$D(T$&�(T$&#�4/O6+g1m(�+.-_º`Ñ�òóÝ º`ÑMô*+�R�:�O/7Q#?7h7 9{+21�: 1T')-�'&1?1m$M3�+2'):�+.X&7h$D4J7Q#�'):�$&#YÒ�a0+.:?Ox+2B67Q-6:�+.:�P´7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:��k1�GJ3�O:?OJ'):�S+S¢�¤ó�Lþ���')-JB�S+F+S¢l¤J�?� Ù ~/¢@þ¦¤��iÒ ¤¿~

ÁSR0¤��L+21b-/$D:�B67 �J-/7NB=KJ:�O/7Q-iÒ�-/7Q7NBh-/$D:bOJ'>X&7�')-[+2B67Q-{:m+8:�Ph7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:N\d$&:?7Y:�OJ'):b:?O6+21d%)+.X&7N1b')-l'>5.%&7QU/#�'>+23IRS$&#?(,G652'):�+.$&-�$)R�:?O/7A`QÚd+.X&+2B67T')-JB¿¹H$&-J«DG/7Q#�c,4J')#�'DBD+8%D(�</4J')#?:!�S+F+�¢:?7 5F521YGJ1!:?OJ'):I:?$�3 $&-J«DG/7Q#�'h3 $&(T4J$DG/-JBk1�:?#?GJ3 :�G/#?7[uJK=aC7T3Q')-kBD+.XD+gB67*+.:Y+.-k:�a0$T4J')#?: 1L�¿')-JBx~WK�3 $&-J«DG/7Q#:?O/7N1�7Y4J'V#?:�1QKJ'V-JBh3 $&(,U6+8-/7L:?O/7Y#?7N1�G65.:�1�\

Á�:@+g1@a0$&#?:�O{abO6+F5.7Y:?$L7 9�')(°+8-/7YO/$D(T$&(T$&#�4/O6+g1m(A1QK/1�+.-J3 7Y:?O/7QPT#?7Q4/#�7N1�7Q-{:b'L%&7Q-/7Q#�'Z5�3�52'&1?10$VR�$D4J7Q#�'):m+8$D-J1QK$)RYabO6+23?O¯n_��')-JB¨Ò�ïl')#?7�1�4W7N3�+g'Z5!3Q'&1m7N1Q\´�HP´3 $&(,U6+.-6+.-/%´:?O/7Q(�+.-�:?O/7[RS$&#?(í�QÒ�ïD¢«�¯�.n_�&¢�K0'>5F5»1�GJ3�OO/$&(T$D(T$&#?4/O6+21�(A1d3Q')-hUJ7L7 9M4/#?7N1�1�7NB=\C]_O6+g1I3Q')-hUW7�1�:�'V:?7NB,+.-¬R�$&#�(§$)RH')-/$&:?O/7Q#@5.7Q(T(A'/i

�  

Page 14: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

v�õ H�H SXJ o�n�á?õ 2 H 2 H 2�3�@©ô�ï2ù H v�õ H�H S�ãA÷Øn¥y6vJ�>zSt2o&v¿¤Ïtg£�r[¤{oDq�oDq�oDpS|J¤6t.£Qq±t öͤ�þÍ�QÒ�ï)¢��h�.n��)¢nQo&pY£Qo&q,�,o |M�>p�rDzSo&p�Ò�r&vJÔInQy{vW�NzSt�o&vYn�ì{ 3c2�2Jñ o ]0O/7A` $&-65.P*+FR¥c,4J')#?:b3Q')-hUW7�1�O/$)ab-[GJ1�+.-/%[:?O/7�BD+21�:?#�+.U/G/:�+.X&7L52'>a�1@RS$&#��!'V-JBiï&KJ')-JB[:?O/7A`�+�RQc,4J')#?:+21�'V-�')4/465F+g3Q'V:�+.$&-l$)R�:?O/7!+8-JB6GJ3 :m+8$D-�5.7Q(T(['/\

Û¯7�3Q')-lB67Q#�+.X&7T1�7QX&7Q#�'>5�GJ1�7 RSG65�+2B67Q-6:�+.:�+.7N1�'&1I'[3 $&-J1�7N«DG/7Q-J3 7T$)R�:?O/7T�b$&(*$&(T$&#?4/O6+21�(�ª=7Q(T(['/\�]0O/7QP%&7Q-/7Q#�'Z5�+.ÀQ7,:?O/7�BD+21�:?#m+8U/G/:m+8XD7�52'>a�10$VR��&KLíT'V-JBCï{\v�õ H�H SXJ o J á �Y2 H SJïSöd¹�UAïgógRDô�ï®öVwbã,Â��>zQnQy{vW�NzSt�o&v@nAÛ=o |M�>p�rDzSt2o&v�£�Ò¦r&vWÔ�÷�£Qr&zSt.£�nQ~=n�� r1Ò�¨)¢�þ¦�gn�r/¢�÷��.n�¨V¢r&vWÔbndÒ�ï��°þ_÷�ï��Lìë�¤{�>vYnd�[�QÒ�ï&¢�þ¦�Q÷�ï)¢��&�.nd�)¢�ì{ 3c2�2Jñ o ª=7Q:�w[þ¯n��T�QÒ�ï&¢0')-JBh')4/465.Ph:?O/7�O/$D(T$&(T$&#�4/O6+g1m(�5.7Q(T(A'/\

v�õ H�H SXJ oqp¨á { 3c2 H 2JóNï[2�ö�ã���o&p[r&pQ¨Qt�zSp�r&p�~LnQy{vW�NzSt�o&vhnbÛ0|}p���Ô&t�� r&zS�,|Ír&vJÔkrV£�£QoN�>t2r&zSt��N�ho¥|M�Np�r&zSoDpYÒ±Õ��¤{r&�>��äá �g³Q@�3g2 H 2WóNïT2�öAãl�.n��&¢��A� Ù ïD¢�þ¦� Ù ï&¢��A���.n,�D¢Q�)¢á íf³Q@�3g2 H 2WóNïT2�öAãl�S|,í6¢��A� Ù ïZ¢@þ¦� Ù ï)¢��A�?�®|�íM¢Q�)¢á ïg³Q@�3g2 H 2WóNïT2�öAãl�QÒ�ï&¢��[� Ù ï)¢Hþ¦�QÒ�ï)¢��A���QÒ�ï&¢Q�)¢�ì{ 3c2�2Jñ o Ûk7!�J#�1�:I4/#?$)X&7¸�Q�S4/#?$&(*$&:�+.$&-�'V-JB�ï>�S4/#?$&(T$&:m+8$D-�U6Ph:?O/7�O/$&(*$&(T$&#?4/O6+21�(Ù5.7Q(T(A'/\IÛk7L:?O/7Q-lGJ1�7:?O/7N1�7Y#�7N1�G65.:�1b:�$A1�O/$)aÇ�N�S4/#?$&(T$D:�+.$&-�\d$&:?7�:?OJ'):T7N'D3?O�$)R�:?O/7N1m7�52'>a�1[3 $&#?#?7N1m4J$&-JB/1[:?$´'¯abO/$)5.7k1�7Q:A$VR�4/#?$&%&#�'V(µ:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J1Q\�]0O/74/#?$&(*$&:�+.$&-�52'NaI1Y1?'>P�:?OJ'):Y# '):?O/7Q#Y:?OJ')-¯(A')4/46+.-/%JK�#�7NB6GJ3�+8-/%l$&#I�/5.:?7Q#m+8-/%�$)X&7Q#Y$&-/7,52')#?%D7°1m:?#?GJ3 :?G/#?7&K�$&-/73Q')-�BD+.XD+gB67�:?O/7�1�:?#�GJ3 :?G/#?7*+8-6:?$�1m(A'>5F5.7Q#T$&-/7N1QK@(A')4x#?7NB6GJ3 7�$D#��/5.:?7Q#*7N'&3?O´$VR�:?O/7N1�7&K0')-JBx3 $&(,U6+8-/7�:?O/7#?7N1�G65.:�1�\

#@ß$h äHãLøSãM)6ç�·Zl��eI-�+.(T4J$&#�:�')-6:�3�5g'D1?1h$)R,$&4J7Q# '):�+.$&-J1h')#?7x£Q�NsF� �NzSt�o&v¦o |/�Np�r&zSt�o&v/£QKbabO6+23�O�1�7 5.7N3 :�$D-/7k$&G/:h$)R,:�a0$xXZ'>5.G/7N1Q\e¬+.-6+8(,G/(�')-JB[(A'>96+.(,G/(­')#�7»1�GJ3�O�$D4J7Q#�'):m+8$D-J1Qi

ÆÍï®ö�ï H P Hdù ÆÇS7u�ï H P H o rCú�¨L1�7 5.7N3 :�1d:?O/7�1�(A'Z5�5.7Q#I$)RbrA')-JBx¨&K/')-JB¯r�ûA¨L1�7 5.7N3 :�1d:?O/7Y52')#?%D7Q#N\Á®R�a07Y-/$)a³ad#�+.:?7 ú�ï��*R�$D#_1m$&(T7Y1�:?#?GJ3 :?G/#�7��=K/a07�%&7Q:d:?O/7»1m(A'>5F5.7N1�:�3 $&(T4W$&-/7Q-6:b$)RH�=\�e�4/#�$&U65.7Q(�3Q')-

')#�+21�7L+FRY�lþé�/\ �hB6$67N1I-/$&:»3 $D-{:�'Z+8-k')-6P�3 $D(T4J$&-/7Q-6:�1QK=O/7Q-J3 7óú�ïg�*+g1IG/-JB67 �J-/7NB=\T]_O6+g1L3Q')-lUJ7L�/9/7NBlU{P+.-{:�#?$MB6GJ3�+.-/%�'!�C�>zSt2zSt�o&yD£��NrDs�y6�|ü�\Y�&GJ3�Ok'TB6$&(A'>+.-l7 9/:?7Q-J1�+.$&-k3Q')-�B6# '&1�:�+23Q'>5F5.P�1�+.(T465F+FRSP¿'V-�'>5.%&$&#m+8:�O/(,+237 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-�K61�+.-J3 7b+.:�#?7NB6GJ3 7N1©:?O/70-{G/(,UJ7Q#@$)R}1�4W7N3�+g'Z5�3Q'&1�7N1 :�$YUJ7�3 $&-J1�+gB67Q#�7NB=\H�b$)a07QX&7Q#NK�+.:H(A'>PI+.-6:?#?$/B6GJ3 7+.-J3 $&-J1�+21�:?7Q-J3�+.7N10a_+8:�O�'&B/BD+.:�+.$&-J'Z5J52'>a�1 $&#Ha_+8:�O,52'NaI1 +.-{XD$)5.X&+.-/%,$&:?O/7Q#�$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-J1©$&-T:?O/7IB6$&(A'>+.-�\�]�$L%)+.X&7')-h7 9J')(T465.7�$VR^:?O/7Y4W${1?1�+.U65.7L+.-J3 $&-J1�+21�:?7Q-J3�+.7N1QK 3 $&-J1�+2B67Q#�:�O/7Y$&4J7Q#�'V:�+.$&-i¼ B67 �J-/7NB�U6P

r�¼ ¨!þ¦rL�]0O6+21Y1�7 5.7N3 :�+.$&-l$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-¬+g1Y'D1?1�$/3�+g'V:�+.X&7&K}1�+8-J3 7[��rC¼ ¨)¢�¼ �,þÍri¼ �¥¨1¼ �D¢HþÍrJ\I]0O/7YRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-�¼dï1�7 5.7N3 :�1,:�O/7T�J#�1m:�7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:T$)R�'¬5F+21�:h�$&#L:?O/7*587 RS:?(T$61�:,7 587Q(*7Q-{:T$VR»'h:?#�7Q7)¢�\�b$)a�3 $&-J1�+2B67Q#X¼�ïg�/K©abO/7Q#?7�¬+21,:?O/7[7Q(T4/:�Pl5F+g1m:N\�]0O/7Q-f�Q¼¨ï��M¢«¼ rfþ­rWKC1�+8-J3 7i¼¨ïg�h+21,:�O/7T+2B67Q-6:�+.:�Px7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:T$)R ¼�\k�@G/:,RS#?$&(:?O/7�B67 �J-6+.:�+.$&-f$)R«¼�K@a07A;6-/$)a�:?OJ'):[�Q¼�ïg�6¢1¼ r´þ¯¼¨ïg�/\��d7Q-J3 7�rfþ¯¼dïf�hRS$&#T')#?U6+.:?# ')#?P�rJ\´]0O/74/#?$&U65.7Q(�')#�+21�7N1Y1�+.-J3 7T:?O/7L52'>a§ri¼ ¨*þ¼r�'Z58#�7N'&B6Ph+.-6X&$)5.X&7N1Y:�O/7�+2B67Q-6:�+.:�P�7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:�$)R�¼�KW+8-�R'&3 :NK=7N'&3�O7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:Y+21Y'[#�+.%&O6:I+gB67Q-6:�+.:�P�7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:�$)R�¼�\�]�$h#?7N1�$)5.X&7,:?O6+21d+.-J3 $&-J1�+21�:?7Q-J3 P&K©aC7,3Q')-l7 +.:?O/7Q#�#?7N1m:?#�+23 :Y:?O/7

� �

Page 15: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

52'>a×ró¼ ¨!þ�r,:�$�rCWþ�¼�ïg�/K6$&#@GJ1�71¼dï��,'&1H'L#�+.%&O6:@+2B67Q-{:�+.:�P[$&-65.P&\�Û�O6+g3�O�1�$)5.G/:�+.$&-[+21@UJ7Q:�:?7Q#bB67Q4J7Q-JB/1$&-h:?O/7Y4J'V#?:�+23 G652')#»'V4/465�+23Q'):m+8$D-�\el')-6Ph4/#?$&%D#�')(T(,+.-/%h4/#?$DU6587Q([1�3Q')-kUW7,RS$&#?(,G652'):?7NBl'&1I$&4/:�+.(,+.ÀN'):m+8$D-k4/#?$&U65.7Q(A1Qi»�J-JBl:?O/7A1�(['>5F587N1m:NK52')#?%&7N1m:�$&#H3?O/7N'V4J7N1�:©+8-[1�$&(T7b%V+8XD7Q-A3�52'&1?1 $)R�XZ'Z58G/7N1�\0�&GJ3?O*4/#?$&U65.7Q(A1H3Q'V-TUJ7�1m4J7N3�+F�J7NBTGJ1�+8-/%,:?O/7@RS$)5F5.$Za_+8-/%$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-�i

¥¸@�óNï H ï[ý&õ o Á®R}nh+21b'!RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-�K�róú?þ�¨Y1�7 5.7N3 :�107 +.:?O/7Q#LrA$D#!¨!'&3Q3 $&#�BD+.-/%T:?$,abO6+23�O[+21b1�(A'>5F5.7Q#NK)nxrA$D#�n´¨&\]0O/7TB67 �J-6+.:�+.$&-k$)R�ûQþT+21Y')-J'Z58$D%&$&GJ1QK�+.:�1�7 5.7N3 :�1Trh$D#°¨,B67Q4W7Q-JBD+8-/%l$&-labO6+23�O�+g1I%D#?7N'):?7Q#NKDn�r�$&#Hn³¨D\IÛk7OJ'>X&7

r�ú þ ¨!þÅî r*+�R=n´rXÿlnϨ¨I+FR�n�r��¿nϨ&\

Û�OJ'):�OJ'V4/4J7Q-J1!+.-�:?O/7[3Q'&1�7Yn¦rxþ¦n¦¨���ÁSRHn¯+21�'V-l+.-)Î�7N3 :�+.X&7[RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-�K :?O/7Q-�rkþ�¨&K�')-JBla07T#�7Q:?G/#?-:?OJ'):YX)'>5.G/7&\A�d$)aC7QXD7Q#NKW+.-�'*5.$&:�$)Rb3Q'&1�7N1!:?O/7LR�G/-J3 :�+.$&-�nk+21!-/$&:I+.-)Î�7N3 :�+.X&7&\[]0O/7Q-l+.:�([');&7N1I-/$�1m7Q-J1�7T:?$1?'>P�`�5.7Q:Arèú?þk¨,UJ7�z�¤{�Y7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:Y+.-l:?O/7A1�7Q: ¡ rLK)¨f¢T(°+8-6+.(,+.À +.-/%[n�c�KW+8-J1m:?7N'&B�a07°1mO/$&G652Bk1?'>P�`�5.7Q:Ariú.þ¿¨UJ7¯£¥oDq��[7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:T+.-�:?O/7l1�7Q: ¡ rMKZ¨�¢�(,+.-6+.(,+.À +8-/%¯n�c�\³]0O6GJ1óú þx3 $&-6:�'>+.-J1A1m$&(T7h-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#�(,+.-6+g1m(�\¦Á�-B67QX&7 5.$&46+.-/%�1�$V58G/:m+8$D-J1,:?$�$D4/:�+.(,+.ÀN'):�+.$&-x4/#?$&U65.7Q(A1QK +21!+21,B67N1�+.#�')U65.7�:?$l'>5F5.$Za�-/$&-JB67Q:�7Q#?(,+.-6+21�(�KH1�+.-J3 7ha07')#?7Y-/$D:b-/$&#?(A'Z5�5.P*+.-{:?7Q#�7N1�:?7NB[+.-l')-{P[$&:?O/7Q#d4/#?$&4J7Q#�:�P[$)R�:?O/7Y#?7N1�G65.:b:�OJ')-�:?OJ'V:H+.:b(°+8-6+.(,+.ÀQ7N1_n�\

#@ßZ¶ �dl����0ã�çVãM'/è½·���·Sæ6èÁ-[:?O/70RS$)5F5.$)a0+.-/%JK6aC7da0+F5�5�7 9J')(,+.-/7I-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#?(,+.-6+21�(�+.-[(T$&#?7IB67Q:�'>+F5\�e»10'!(A'):?:?7Q#�$VR}R'&3 :NK):�O/7�(T7Q(,UW7Q#�1$)R=:?O/70eb5.%&$&#m+8:�O/(,+23Q1�%&#?$DG/4�OJ'>X&70BD+F·�7Q#�7Q-{:@X&+.7Qa�1�'&1 :�$�abOJ'V:�7 9�'&3 :�')4/4/#?$6'&3?O,:?$I-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#�(,+.-6+g1m( 1mO/$&G652BUJ7L:�');&7Q-�\ Ûk7,BD+21?3 GJ1?1d:?O/#?7Q7Y4J$61?1�+.U65.7°'V4/4/#?${'&3�O/7N1Y�Ðe�7Q7N�& 6K��0Ñ��&Ò)U6¡\

j -/7�4W${1?1�+.U6+F5F+.:�PL+21�'>X&$)+2BD+.-/%I7 9M465F+23�+.:�-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#?(,+.-6+21�(¼')-JBY'Z5�5.$)a0+.-/%IG/-JB67Q#?�1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):m+8$D-T$&-65.PY:?O/#?$&G/%DO1�7Q:Y3 $&-J1�:?#�GJ3 :�+.$&-�\YÁ-l:?O6+21Y')4/4/#�${'&3�O�K=$&-/7LR�$&#�(�G652'):�7N1b:?O/7,1�7Q:Y$)RC'>5F5C1�$V58G/:m+8$D-J1I:?$�'*4/#?$&U65.7Q(�K ')-JB�:?O/7Q-1�7 5.7N3 :�1Y'*4J')#?:�+23 G652')#Y(T7Q(,UW7Q#�$)RH:�O6+g1Y1m7Q:bU{Pl1�$&(T7!R�G/#�:?O/7Q#»1m:?7Q4�\�]0O/7L(A'>+.-k'&B6XZ'V-{:�'V%&7Y$)RH:?O6+21I(T7Q:?O/$/B+21L:?OJ'):Y:?O/7A1m7Q(A')-6:�+23Q1�$VRC:?O/7T7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-k52')-/%&GJ'V%&7T+21L1�+.(T465.7Q#N\ j -x:?O/7T$&:?O/7Q#LOJ')-JB=K :?O/7T$&U�Î�7N3 :�1L')-JBRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1*+.-�3 $&-J1�+2B67Q#�'):m+8$D-³UW7N3 $&(T7k(*$&#?7�3 $D(T465F+g3Q'V:?7NB=<I+.-J1�:?7N'&BØ$)R�7N«&GJ'Z5�+.:�P�4/#�7NBD+g3Q'V:?7N1[+.:[UJ7N3 $&(T7N1-/7N3 7N1?1?'V#?PA:�$T%&$T:?$T1�7Q:d(T7Q(,UJ7Q#�1�O6+.4�\

eY1�'�1�7N3 $&-JB¯4J${1�1�+.U6+�5F+.:�P&KHa07A3Q'V-Ï'>5F5.$)a 'l3�O/$)+23 7A$&4W7Q#�'):?$D#T� ¡�+.-{:�$�:�O/7T-/$&:�'):m+8$D-�K�U/G/:!5.7Q:�+.:T'>5.ab'>PM1B67Q-/$&:?7T1�$D(T7�B67 �J-6+.:?7&K=U/G/:YG/-J1�4W7N3�+F�J7NB=K�$&4W7Q#�'):?$&#>\�]0O/7L$&-65.P�4/#?$&4W7Q#?:�Ph$)R�� ¡ $&-/7�(A'>P�'&1�1�G/(T7Y+21I:?OJ'V:�� ¡+21�1m7 587N3 :m+8XD7&\�e�$&#?7I4/#?7N3�+21�7 5.P&K

r�� ¡H¨!þ¦£Q�Ns���rMKZ¨V¢RS$&#H1�$&(T7I1�7 5.7N3 :�+.$&-TRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-�£¥�>sJadO6+g3�O,+21@:?$YUJ7Y1�4W7N3�+��J7NB*52'):�7Q#N\�]0O6+21�(T$/B67 5J+21H1m7Q(A')-6:�+23Q'>5F58P[1�+.(T465.7&K/U/G/:-/$&:?7L:?OJ'):�'Z5�5HBD+F·�7Q#?7Q-{:I$/3Q3 G/#?#?7Q-J3 7N1I$)Rb� ¡�(,GJ1�:dUJ7,UJ$&G/-JB�:?$*:?O/7�1?'V(T7T£Q�Ns�\H�d7Q-J3 7T3 7Q#?:�'>+.-�K�5g'>a�1dabO6+23�O1�7Q7Q(§$DU{XD+.$&GJ1b(['NP[3 $&-{:�#�'&BD+23 :b7N'&3�O�$&:�O/7Q#N\�½/$&#0+.-J1�: ')-J3 7&K/:?O/7!5g'>a�1

r�� ¡H¨!þר*� ¡�r3Q')-/-/$&:dUJ7�X)'>5F+2B�:�$&%&7Q:?O/7Q#0a0+.:?O

n���rl� ¡C¨V¢�þ¦�.n�r�¢»� ¡ �.n�¨)¢.�]�$A1�7Q7Y:?O6+21QK=3?O/$61�70n�K�rh')-JBk¨L1�GJ3�O�:?OJ'):YriWþ ¨�KSnxrTþרL')-JBLn�¨Iþ�rW\

]_O/7h:?O6+.#�B�')4/4/#?${'&3�Ox+21T:�$kOJ'>X&7�')-´$D4J7Q#�'):�$&#�� ¡�B67Q-/$&:m+8-/%�'V#?U6+.:?#�')#?P´3�O/$)+23 7&\¦]0O/7hRS$)5F5.$Za_+8-/%¯52'>a�1+.-{XD$)5.X&+.-/%l� ¡�')#?7�B67N1�+.#�'VU6587&K=U/G/:d(�G/:�GJ'>5F58P[+.-J3 $&(*4J'):�+.U65.7&i

� Ò

Page 16: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

�S+S¢[e a07 5F5.�B67 �J-/7NB´-/$&:m+8$D-�$)R�'¬#?7.�J7 9{+.X&7&K©:?#�')-J1�+.:�+.X&7[#?7 �J-/7Q(T7Q-6:,$&4J7Q# '):�+.$&-´�Q8f¢»1�GJ3�Ok:?OJ'V:�'>5F5�3 $&-/�1�:?#?GJ3 :�10')#�7Y(T$&-/$&:?$D-6+g3Ia_+8:�O�#?7N1�4W7N3 :�:�$ 8�\

�S+F+S¢�]0O/7Y4/#?$&4W7Q#?:�PA:?OJ'V:��i8ÿ~,+F·´�¿�¡@~Tþ¦�=\�S+F+F+S¢�]0O/7,52'>a�1L:?OJ'):T� ¡�+21,3 $&(T(,G/:�'V:�+.X&7&K�'&1?1�$/3�+2'):�+.X&7A')-JB¿+2B67Q(T4J$D:?7Q-{:><H-/$&:�7T:?OJ'):L:?O6+21QK :?$&%&7Q:?O/7Q#La0+.:?O

�S+F+�¢ K)+.(T465F+.7N1H#�7.�J7 9{+.XD+8:�PT')-JBL:?#�'V-J1�+.:�+.X&+.:�P,$)RA8�K)abO/7Q#�7N'&1@�S+F+S¢�:?$&%D7Q:?O/7Q#�a0+.:?O,#?7.�J7 96+8XD+.:�P�$VRA8±a0$&G652B+8(*4658P[+2B67Q(T4W$&:?7Q-J3 7,$)Rb� ¡S\

�S+.XJ¢h]0O/7I52'Na �¿� ¡@~X8È�=K/abO6+23�O�a0$&G652B*R�$V5�5.$)aîR�#?$D(��®+�+S¢b')-JB��S+F+F+S¢�\�XW¢A]0O/7Y#?7N«DG6+8#�7Q(T7Q-{:d$)R^#�7 R�7Q#?7Q-6:�+2'>5�:?#�'V-J1�4J')#?7Q-J3 P&K/adO6+g3�O[+21�3�5.${1m7 58Ph#�7 5g'V:?7NB[:?$,:?O/7�«DG/7N1�:�+.$&-�adO/7Q:?O/7Q#

��� ¡H~|�´�k�¡�~Tþz��\�b$D:?7�:�OJ'):b:?O/7�1�7N3 $D-JB�')4/4/#?$6'&3?O�'VUJ$)X&7Y;&7Q7Q4J10:�O6+g1d4/#?$&4W7Q#?:�P&\�X&+S¢h]0O/7b52'>akn �?��� ¡ ~/¢Hþî�.nl�J¢b� ¡��.nk~�¢�K6$&#H:?O/7Ia07N');&7Q#�n��?��� ¡�~/¢k8 �.nl�W¢_� ¡ �.nk~�¢�\�b$&:�7b:?OJ'):@:?O/7b52'):�:?7Q#

aC$DG65gB*RS$)5F5.$)a¦RS#?$&(¾�S+S¢C')-JB��®+�+S¢�\��X&+F+S¢�]0O/7I52'Na �?�i8È~/¢�4f�?��8 u/¢�+.(T465F+.7N1L�i8 ��~�� ¡©u/¢�K&abO6+23�OlaC$DG65gB*RS$)5F5.$)a�R�#�$&(��S+F+S¢_'V-JB��S+F+�+S¢�\�X&+F+F+S¢�]0O/7b52'>a~;k�hi nk��8 w¬�[+.(T465F+87N1©n�8 w=\H]_O/7Y$&:?O/7Q#bBD+.#?7N3 :�+.$&-�a0$&G652B°R�$V5�5.$)a�RS#?$&(�(T$&-/$D:?$&-6+23�+.:�P

$)R�8³\

Û¯7�3Q')-h1�O/$)a´:?OJ'):H:�O/7N1�7b52'>a�1@')#?7b(,G/:?GJ'>5F5.P,+.-J3 $&(T4J'V:�+.U6587&KW7QX&7Q-,+FR�:�O/7»BD+FE�3 G65.:@52'Na��XW¢=+210B6#?$&4/4J7NB=\d$&:?70:?OJ'V:b� ¡$ïD�°1�: ')-JB/1 RS$&#H')-�`Q')#�U6+8:�#�')#?P/cY3?O/$V+g3 7_R�#?$D(Í:?O/7�1�:?#�GJ3 :?G/#?7I�}\�Á�-T4J')#?:m+g3 G652')#>K}� ¡�ï��YB67N1�3 #�+.UJ7N13�O/${${1�+8-/%¬R�#�$&(±')-l7Q(T4/:�P�1�:�#?GJ3 :?G/#?7&\,Û�OJ'):�B6$67N1T� ¡Zïg�¬(T7N')-���Á�:�(T7N')-J1I:�OJ'):Y-/$�3�O/$)+23 7,+21Y4W${1?1�+.U65.7&K +\7&\.K�+8:,B67Q-/$&:?7N1L:?O/7TG/-J1�'):�+21��}')U65.7h1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-�\¬Á-x4J')#?:�+23 G652')#NK0� ¡Zïg��1�'):�+21��J7N1TrW� ¡�� ¡]ï���þ¾rJK (T7N')-6+.-/%l:?OJ'):OJ'>X&+.-/%T:�O/7�3�O/$)+23 7�UJ7Q:�a07Q7Q-�` -/$&:�O6+8-/%6cT')-JB�`�1�$&(T7Q:?O6+.-/%{c�K{a07Y(,GJ1�:�3�O/$6${1�7A`Q1�$D(T7Q:?O6+.-/%{c/\

#@ß�� äHã=è½ ���ç�·Z)/æed5�5b7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1L7Q-J3 $&G/-6:?7Q#?7NBx1�$¬R®')#,')#?7A'Z58%D$&#�+.:?O/(A1»+8-x:?O/7h1�7Q-J1�7[:?OJ'):Ya07h3 $&G652BkU/G6+F52B´'h(A'D3?O6+.-/7h:?$'&3 :?GJ'Z5�5.P´7 9/7N3 G/:?7�:�O/7Q(�\�Á�-�(A'V-{P´3Q'&1�7N1QK@O/$)a07QX&7Q#NK@aC7�'V#?7[+.-{:?7Q#�7N1�:?7NBx+.-fUJ7 +.-/%�')U65.7�:?$x1�4J7N3�+FRSP´$&G/#4/#?$&U65.7Q(§# '):?O/7Q#H:�OJ')-A%V+8XD+.-/%A'L(T7Q:?O/$/BT$VR^1�$)5.XD+8-/%,:?O/7I4/#?$&U65.7Q(�K�7N1�4J7N3�+2'>5F5.Ph+FR�a07YB6$�-/$D:CPD7Q:H;6-/$Za¦1�GJ3�O'L(T7Q:?O/$/B=\ Ûk7�a_+�5F5^'Z5�5.$)a¦1�GJ3�O¿` G/-/7 9/7N3 G/:�')U65.7Nc,7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-J1b1�$�:�OJ'):0aC7I')#?7Y')U65.7�:?$,OJ'>X&7b:�O/7»3 $&(*46587Q:�7B67Q#�+.XZ'V:�+.$&-�K/RS#?$&(Ù:?O/7I+.-6+8:m+g'Z5C�SRS$&#?(['>5S¢©1m4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-l:?$T:�O/7I�J-J'>5^'>5.%&$&#m+8:�O/(�+.-�$D-/7YG/-6+��J7NB¬RS#�')(T7Qa0$&#�;}\

Á�-,:?O/7@R�$)5F5.$)a0+.-/%JK&a07@%)+.X&7b'I4J${1?1�+8U65.7�'V4/4/#?${'&3�O,:?$�:�O/7_1m7Q(A')-6:�+23Q1 $)R}'>5.%&$&#�+.:?O/(°+g3_7 9M4/#?7N1�1�+.$&-J10�Ðe�7Q7N�& >¡��� Ñ �&Ò)U/¡\ ª=7Q:[1�:�')-JB!RS$&# :?O/7b1�7Q:�$)R}'>5.%&$&#m+8:�O/(,+2307 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J1Q\�Û¯7_'D1?1�G/(T7@:?OJ'):�*+g1©#?7N3 G/#�1�+.X&7&K6')-JBL:?OJ'):´3 $&-6:�'>+.-J1Y'*#?7N3 G/#�1�+.X&7T1�G/UJ1�7Q: �î$)RH7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1I:�OJ'):»'V#?7L+gB67Q-6:�+F�J7NB¯a0+.:?OlXZ'>5.G/7N1L�7&\=%J\gK^`>Ó)cT$&#T`c­k�li� Ù Ð cM¢�\�Á�-{:?G6+.:�+.X&7 5.P&KWa07»3Q')-*+.-{:�7Q#?4/#?7Q:�')-[7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-k�I+.-�l'&1Y`Q1�4W7N3�+FR�PD+.-/%{cT$D-/7&K{$D#H(T$&#�7&K{$D#H4J$61?1�+.U65.P-/$JK=7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:�1Y$VR��I\YÛk7TB67 �J-/7T:?O/7,U/#?7N'DB6:?O�R�G/-J3 :�+.$&-��b���D¢b:?$hUJ7,:?O/7[1�7Q: ¡ ����� Äh�h`Q1�4W7N3�+��J7N1�cl�7¢{\j -x:?O/7T$&:?O/7Q#LOJ')-JB=K a07A3Q')-¯+8-6:?7Q#?4/#�7Q:A��'&1L'�` : '&1�;/c[:?$[�J-JB�1m$&(T7T7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:,$)R���\h]0OJ'V:�:�'&1m;�(,+.%&O6:OJ'>X&7�1�7QXD7Q#�'>5}1�$)5.G/:�+.$&-J1@$&#@UJ7d+.(T4J${1�1�+.U6587&\0ÚI7 �J-/7,�18 ���/:?$�(T7N'V-�i�:�O/7b:�'&1�;h�Y3Q')-TUW7»1m$)5.X&7NBTU6PT1�$)5.XD+8-/%:?O/7h:�'D1�;³� � \�]0O/7�#?7 �J-/7Q(T7Q-6:T#?7 52'):�+.$&- 8 +21A'¯1�G/UJ1�7Q:T$)R ¨Ô��\fÛk7�3Q')-´:?O6+.-/;´$)R18 'D1�` (A'>PkUW7:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(T7NBh:�${c/\�]_O/7�#�7 �J-/7Q(T7Q-{:Y#�7 5g'V:�+.$&-l+21I#?7.�J7 96+8XD7A')-JB�:?#�')-J1�+8:m+8XD7&\�Á�-{:�7Q#?4/#?7Q:�+.-/%�')-l7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-��'&1,'�1m4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-f$)R�XZ'Z58G/7N1�+8-��IK a07Aa0$&G652B¯7 9M4W7N3 :��h:?$l1�4J7N3�+FRSP�'h%)+.X&7Q-¦������abO/7Q-/7QX&7Q#��i8 �J\¹H$&-6X&7Q#�1m7 58P&K�+FR»�����b���D¢�K=:?O/7Q-���+g1L'h1�$)5.G/:�+.$&-k$VRC:?O/7,:�'&1m;��6K�1�$ha07�OJ'>X&7h�C8 �J\LÛk7A3 $&-J3�5.GJB67[:?OJ'):�b� �&¢@þ ¡ �����»Ä,�Y8È�7¢6\

Û¯7�a0$&G652B¬5�+.;&7,:?$h3�OJ')#�'&3 :?7Q#m+8ÀQ7Y8í+.-l:?7Q#?(A1d$)R���\IeÍ#?7N«DG6+.#?7Q(T7Q-6:IR�$D#��ó8 � � +21Y3 7Q#?:�'Z+8-65.P��b���D¢� �b� �!��¢�\I�HG/:I:?O/7Q-�K�R�$D#»')-6Pk�6K��ó8 � ¡�ï���KJabO6+23�O�+g1IG/-/#�7N'&1�$&-J')U65.7,G/-65.7N1?1,�*þ¼�¡Zïg�/\�]0O6+21I%)+.X&7N1d#�+21�7,:?$[:?O/71�7N3 $&-JB�#?7N«DG6+.#?7Q(T7Q-6:�:?OJ'V:�� ¡�ï��°+21�'*#?7Q4652'&3 7Q(T7Q-6:IR�$&#,�T$D-658P�+FR»�*þ � ¡�ï���\»�d$)a07QX&7Q#NKW:?O6+21I#?7N«&G6+.#?7Q(*7Q-{:Y$)R

�g�

Page 17: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

` 4/#?7N1m7Q#?XZ'):m+8$D-�$VRCB67 �J-/7NB6-/7N1?1?ch3 $&(T465F+23Q'):?7N1!:?O/7�:�#�')-J1�RS$&#?(A'V:�+.$&-h#?G65.7N1Q\Ie�-l'>5.:?7Q#?-J'):m+8XD7°'V4/4/#?${'&3�Oh+21I:?$'&3Q3 7Q4/: :?O/70XZ'>5F+2BD+.:�P�$VR���8 � ¡�ï���KN;&7Q7Q46+.-/%I+.-T(,+.-JBL:?OJ'):�8²B6$67N1�-/$&:�7 9J'&3 :�5.PL(T7N')-�`¥(A'>P�UW7C#�7Q465g'D3 7NB,U{P/c/\Á-¯:?O6+21�')4/4/#?$6'&3?O�K=a07,a0$&G652Bk3�O/7N3?;¬R�$&#Y4/#�7N1�7Q#?XZ'V:�+.$&-k$)RbB67 �J-/7NB6-/7N1?1!+8-JBD+.XD+2B6GJ'>5F58PxRS$&#I:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J1+.-{XD$)5.X&+.-/%C8³\d$&:?7,:?OJ'V:Y:?O/7T(T7N')-6+.-/%�$)Rj8 'V-JBl:?O/7AB67Q#�+.X)'):�+.$&-x$)RHRSG/#?:?O/7Q#L#?7 �J-/7Q(T7Q-6:�#?G65.7N1LO6+.%&O65.P�B67Q4J7Q-JB¯$&-:?O/7�3�O/${1�7Q-l')4/4/#?${'&3�Oh:?$,-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#�(,+.-6+g1m(�\

#@ß#" %�-5-5øZ·Z)7 =ç�·xl��¼ç�l_��·Sæ)ç&æ�)+.-J3 7b:?O/7d�S�J-6+.:?7)¢^sFtg£¥zV+21�'IB/'):�'I1�:?#?GJ3 :�G/#?7Ha0+.:?OL(A')-6PI+.(T4J$&#�:�')-6:^')4/465F+23Q'):�+.$&-J1�K&a07Ha0$&G652BI5F+.;&7b:�$b7 9�'V(,+.-/71�$&(*7�1�4J7N3�+2'>5F+.ÀQ7NB�5F+21�:Y$&4J7Q# '):�+.$&-J1Y���©+.#�� � ¡\�½/$&#05F+21�:�1�K�Ø�+21d:?O/7IR�G/-J3 :m+8$D-Ïr ÜÝ �.rD¡K Ù +g1d:?O/7T� o&vJ� r&zS�>vJr&zSt�o&v$ KJ'V-JBX�L+210:?O/7�7Q(*4/:�P*5F+21�:��6¡\v�õWö�wJó)ô o ]0O/7b5.7Q-/%&:�Oh$)R�'Y5F+21�:0+21@:?O/7I-{G/(,UW7Q#C$VR�7 5.7Q(T7Q-{: 1@+.:_3 $D-{:�'Z+8-J1�\�Û¯7»B67Q-/$&:�7�:?O6+210$D4J7Q#�'):m+8$D-AU6P�%?\�hï�3Nõ7R)óQõ7Ié�*õ7I�P*R)óNï[2�ö o Ûk7,-/$Zaî+.-{:�#?$MB6GJ3 7*:�a0$T-/7QaÍ#�7NB6GJ3 :�+.$&-k$&4W7Q#�'):?$&# 1babO6+23�Ok')#?7T3�5.${1�7 5.Pl#?7 52'):?7NB:?$Xï6\¸WÝÈ�®587 RS:?�S#?7NB6GJ3 7)¢�'V-JBdW& �#�+.%&O6:?�S#?7NB6GJ3 7)¢07N'&3�O�:�');D7�:?O/#?7Q7,')#?%&G/(*7Q-{:�1�KJ')-JBh$D4J7Q#�'):�$&# Ò�K=')-¬+8-6+.:�+2'>5XZ'Z58G/7[�T')-JBh'L5F+21�:L�}\0]0O/7QP�3Q'V-hUJ7�B67N1�3 #�+.UJ7NB�U{P

�QÒ¸W& �&¢ �.rg�fKNrc�gK>\N\N\©KNrf�)¡=þ�rg�|Ò ��rg�|ÒÍ�('�'!'���r��XÒ �D¢?¢?¢

�QÒ¸WÝ��&¢ �.rg�fKNrc�gK>\N\N\©KNrf�)¡=þ¦�?��� Ò rc�Q¢�Ò�rg�>¢)'�'!'´Ò¼r��L�Û�O{PxB6$ka07A-/7Q7NB :�a0$�(T$&#?7h#?7NB6GJ3 :m+8$D-´$&4J7Q#�'V:?$&#�1*��]_O/7Q#?7�')#?7[:�aC$�(A'>+.-�')-J1�a07Q#�1°:?$l:?O6+21T«&G/7N1m:�+.$&-�\½�+.#�1�:NK6:?O/7�BD+.#?7N3 :�7NBh#?7NB6GJ3 :�+.$&-J1I3Q')-hUW7�1�7Q7Q-�'&1C+8(*46587Q(*7Q-{:�'V:�+.$&-J1b$VR�:?O/7Y$&4W7Q#�'):?$&#�ïY+.-habO6+23�O�:?O/7Y$D#�B67Q#$)R�7QXZ'>5.GJ'):m+8$D-h+21�1m7N«&G/7Q-6:�+2'>5\b¹@7Q#?:�'>+.-65.P&K/+FR5Ò¦+21I'&1?1�$/3�+2'):�+.X&7�')-JB[OJ'&1_+2B67Q-{:m+8:�P[7 5.7Q(T7Q-{:,�6K/:?O/7Q-Ò�ïYþ¦�QÒ¸W& �D¢�þ¦�QÒ¸WÝ��&¢.�

]_O/7�1�7N3 $&-JBl')-J1maC7Q#d+21I:?OJ'):b([')-{Ph(*$&#?7YRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1Y3Q')-lUW7°B67N1�3 #�+.UJ7NBlU6P�BD+.#?7N3 :?7NBl#?7NB6GJ3 :m+8$D-J1I:?OJ')-U6P¸ï{\ ½/G/#?:?O/7Q#�(T$&#?7&K&'>5.:?O/$DG/%&O,7QX&7Q#?P�O/$D(T$&(T$&#�4/O6+g1m(¼3Q')-,UJ7b7 9/4/#?7N1?1�7NB*'&1�'b#�7NB6GJ3 :�+.$&-�K6(A')-6PIR�G/-J3 :�+.$&-J1abO6+23�O�')#?7Y-/$D:bO/$&(T$&(*$&#?4/O6+21�(A1b3Q'V-hUJ7�B67N1�3 #�+.UJ7NBl'&1bBD+.#?7N3 :?7NB¬#?7NB6GJ3 :�+.$&-J1Q\

j UJ1m7Q#?X&7Y:?OJ'):daC7�3Q'V-�3?OJ')# '&3 :?7Q#�+.ÀQ7YUJ$D:?OhRS$&#?(A1@$)RHBD+.#?7N3 :?7NB¬#?7NB6GJ3 :�+.$&-�#�7N3 G/#�1�+.X&7 5.P&K=a07YOJ'NXD7�QÒ¸W& �&¢��6¡�þ �

�QÒ¸W& �&¢����.r&¡ $ �J¢ þ r�Ò �QÒ¸W& �D¢?�')-JB

�QÒ¸WÝ��&¢��6¡�þ ��QÒ¸WÝ��&¢��?� $ �gr&¡S¢ þ �QÒ¸W& �D¢?�iÒ¼r

Ûk7A1m7Q7T:?OJ'):XW& 4/#�$M3 7N1?1m7N1I5F+21�:�1!R�#�$&(�#�+.%&O6:Y:?$[5.7 R�:NK ')-JB~WÝ RS#?$&(¾5.7 RS:,:?$h#�+.%&O6:N\,Á-�1m$&(T7A1�7Q-J1m7&K�#�+.%&O6:?�#?7NB6GJ3 :�+.$&-�3 $D#?#?7N1�4W$&-JB/1@:?$Ap�� �Ny6p?£Qt2oDvJK{'V-JB,5.7 RS:?�S#?7NB6GJ3 :�+.$&-l3 $&#?#?7N1�4W$&-JB/1@:?$At�zS�Np�r&zSt�o&vW\^]�$,(A');&7d:?O6+21H(*$&#?73�5.7N')#NK/a07Y%)+.X&7,')-�'>5.:?7Q#?-J'V:�+.X&7Y#?7N3 G/#�1�+.X&7,B67N1?3 #�+.4/:�+.$&-l$)R 5.7 R�:?�S#�7NB6GJ3 :�+.$&-�i

�QÒ¸WÝ��&¢��6¡�þ ��QÒ¸WÝ��&¢����.r&¡ $ �J¢ þ �QÒ¸WÝ���� Ò r�¢?¢?���

]0O/7Y7N«DG6+.XZ'>5.7Q-J3 7T$)R�:?O/7Y:�a0$TB67 �J-6+8:m+8$D-J1Y3Q')-�UW7Y7N'&1�+F5.P�X&7Q#�+F�J7NB¬U{P*+.-JB6GJ3 :�+.$&-�\

� Ó

Page 18: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

d$&:?7Y:�OJ'):�'>5.:?O/$&G/%DO�W& 'V-JBdWݵ5.$6$&;�1�+.(,+F52')#NK=:?O/7Q#�7�(A'>P[UJ7�'*U6+.%�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3 7L+.-�7 E�3�+.7Q-J3 PlUJ7Q:�a07Q7Q-:?O/7Q(�K&B67Q4W7Q-JBD+.-/%T$&-,:?O/7�')4/465F+23Q'):�+.$&-�\_º�7Q-/7Q#�'>5F5.P&K6abO/7Q-T4/#?$/3 7N1?1�+.-/%!5�+21�: 1 RS#?$&(î587 RS:H:�$Y#�+.%&O{:>K&'>5F5J7 587Q(*7Q-{:�1$)R0:?O/7L5�+21�:,OJ'>X&7,:?$hUW7A3 $&-J1�+2B67Q#?7NBlUW7 R�$D#?7T:?O/7T#�7N1�G65.:�3Q')-lUJ7*#?7Q:?G/#?-/7NB=\T�d$)aC7QXD7Q#NK=-/$&:�'>5F5H#�+.%&O6:?�S:?$&��5.7 RS:3 $&(T4/G/: '):�+.$&-J1,(,GJ1�:T-/7N3 7N1�1?')#�+F5.P³1�: ')#?:,4/#?$/3 7N1?1�+.-/%Ï'V:�:�O/7�#�+.%&O6:T7Q-JB´$VR»:?O/7[5F+21�:N\�¶07Q:?G/#�-6+8-/%�'¿#?7N1�G65.:a0+.:?O/$&G/:I7QXZ'Z58GJ'V:�+.-/%�')#?%DG/(T7Q-{: 10abO/${1�7,X)'>5.G/7N1Y')#?7�-/$D:�-/7Q7NB67NB�+21d;{-/$)ab-l'&1Ls�rVu¥~[�N�>r&sFy{r&zSt�o&vW\Y¹H$&-J1�+gB67Q#RS$&#b7 9J')(T465.7�:?O/7IRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-¯�Q¼_W& �D¢�K6abO6+23?Ol1�7 5.7N3 :�1d:?O/7Y�J#�1m:C7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:I$)R©'�5�+21�:>\

�Q¼_W& �&¢ � � \>\N\ � ���)¡Jþ � ¼´�Q¼_W& �D¢�� Ð \N\>\ � ���)¡=þ�\>\N\Dþ � K1�$L:?O/7�7QX)'>5.GJ'):�+.$&-h:?7Q#�(,+.-J'):?7N10'>RS:?7Q#H$&-/7I1�:?7Q4�K/')-JB*aC7IB6$�-/$D:�5.${$D;A'):H:�O/7�#?7N1m:H$)R�:?O/7d5F+g1m:N\ j -h:?O/7b$D:?O/7Q#OJ')-JB=K=�©¼_WÝ �6¢H'>5.ab'>PM10#�7Q:?G/#?-J1��/K6U/G/:NK�GJ1�+.-/%A:?O/7,1�7N3 $&-JB[#?7N3 G/# 1�+.X&7�B67 �J-6+.:�+.$&-l$)R�WÝ�K

�Q¼_WÝ,�6¢�� � K Ð K  )¡6þ�\N\>\&þz�9�U/G/:0+.-�:�O6+g1d7QXZ'Z58GJ'V:�+.$&-�KJ:�O/7�3 $&(T465.7Q:?7Y5F+21�:d+21b:?# 'NXD7Q#�1�7NB*UJ7 RS$&#?7�:�O/7Y#?7N1�G65.:b+210#�7Q:?G/#?-/7NB=\

yb2V3 H SJøk�hï,+0õ`3>õWöJóNïTS/óNï[2�ö o ]�$�3 $D-J3�58GJB67[:?O6+21�1m7N3 :�+.$&-�K=a07�a0$&G652B�5F+.;&7T:�$h%)+.X&7T')-�+gB67N'¬$)RCO/$)aîR�$D#?(A'>5BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-{:m+g'V:�+.$&-h��"�'>+2� � K�"�-Y� Ð Kð"�'>+2� � ¡&�J:�1�+.-{:�$�:?O/7@eb5.%&$D#�+.:?O/(,+23Q1�R�# ')(T7Qa0$&#?;�� e�7Q7Q¡�\�Á-,(A'V-{PY')4/465F+23Q'):�+.$&-J1a07Yab')-{:0:?$*7QXZ'>5.GJ'):?7,')-h7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-�$)R^:�O/7IR�$&#�(

n��?�QÒ¸WÝ��D¢��.rg�fK>rg�cKN\N\>\QKNr��Z¡$&#b7QXD7Q-

n*�{�.rg�fK>rg��Ò¼rg�fKN\>\N\QK��QÒ«WÝ��&¢ �.rg�cKNrg�cKN\>\N\QK>rf�&¡.¡x�Ûk7Ya0$&G652B*5F+.;&7�:?$T3 $&(*4/G/:?7�1�GJ3�O�'LXZ'>5.G/7!+8-J3 #�7Q(T7Q-{: '>5F58P&KW+\/7&\gKJ�®R�$&#0:?O/7I�J# 1�:07 9M4/#?7N1�1�+.$&-=¢H+.-h:?O/7IRS$&#?(�$)R

�Q÷¸WÝ´�.n´�&¢?¢ �.rg�cKNrg�cKN\>\N\QK>rf�Z¡��Ûk7�3Q')-lB6$A1�$TU6P*�J-JBD+8-/%h')-h$&4W7Q#�'):?$D#�÷�1�GJ3�O�:?OJ'):

n��?�iÒ¼r/¢@þ¦�.nx�J¢�÷¼rMK1�+.-J3 7bn��&�QÒ¸WÝ��D¢C1?'V:�+21��J7N1b:�O/7Y#?7N3 G/#�1�+.X&7L7N«&GJ'):m+8$D-J1

�.n*�D�QÒ¸WÝ��&¢�¢��/¡¸þ n´��.n*�&�QÒ¸WÝ��D¢?¢?��� $ r�¢ þ ���.n*�)�QÒ¸Wݳ�D¢?¢?�W¢�÷ rMK

abO6+23�O¿'V#?7�'>521�$�1m$)5.X&7NBhU6P�÷¸WÝf�.nÏ�D¢�\Ied58:�O/$&G/%&Ok1�GJ3�O�')-l$&4W7Q#�'):?$&#�÷ 3Q'V-/-/$&:�-/7N3 7N1�1?')#�+F5.PlUJ7LR�$DG/-JBhRS$&#'>5F5Jnk')-JBCÒ�KD+.:d+g1I'>5.ab'>PM1@4J$61?1�+.U65.7�:�$,�J-JB[$&-/7YRS$&#I�.n�KNt�Ô=¢�K6B67 �J-/7NB�U6P

~X÷Íu,þ¦�.n��/. � ~XÒÍu/¢.K(. � ~XÒ¼u/¢.�ÁSR��.n�K�+2BW¢�3Q')-TUW7�3 $&(T4/G/:?7NB°7 E�3�+.7Q-{:�5.P&K6:?O/7Q-A1m$�3Q')-In�þ0.M�>�.nAK�+2BW¢�KDabO/7Q#?71.��=#?7Q:?G/#�-J1 :?O/70+.�S:?OA3 $&(*4J$&-/7Q-6:$)RH',:?G/465.7&\

� �

Page 19: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

2 Ã�Ä,Å43 ÊÙÉ�Ã65µÃl��ÌI�1Í)7>����Ì Ì0� ���Y��Ì�É�É�����Ë���Ì�Ì Ì ���«Ë45981ÍJ��Å×̶0eY"H]I���ð"�'>+2� � ¡H+21,'l1�P/1�:?7Q(¸R�$D#�:�O/7TRSG65F58Px(T7N3�OJ')-6+23Q'>5�:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-k$)R�4/#?$DU6587Q(í1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-J1*:?$7 E�3�+.7Q-6:�¶0e�e 3 $/B67&\¦¶0eY"H]I�´GJ1�7N1[1�:?7Q46a0+21�7�#�7 �J-/7Q(T7Q-{:[U6PÏ1�GJ3Q3 7N1�1�+.X&7k')4/465F+g3Q'V:�+.$&-¦$)R�3 $&#?#?7N3 :�-/7N1?1��4/#?7N1�7Q#�X&+.-/%[:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-J1@:?$T')G/:?$&(['):?7I4/#?$&%&#�'V( B67N1�+8%D-�KJX&7Q#m+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-�K}'V-JBh')-J'>5.PM1�+g1�\

]_O/7Y+.-/4/G/:I52')-/%&GJ')%&7LRS$&#b:?O/7T¶0eY"H]»��3 $&(T46+F5.7Q#Y+21!�7¤ Ù K�')-k')UJ1�:?# '&3 :0RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5H1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-¿5g'V-/�%&GJ')%D7�UJ'&1�7NB¿$&-h�J-6+.:?7A1m7Q:Y:?O/7Q$&#?P&K=abO6+23�Ok3Q')-lUJ7A1�O/$)ab-l:?$[7 9/4/#?7N1?1Y')-6P�4J')#�:�+2'>5^#�7N3 G/#�1�+.X&7LR�G/-J3 :m+8$D-l+.-'L�H�)��ÔVÖ.|MoDt2vWz�vWo&p�q,r&s6nQo&p q,\h�7¤ Ù +g1!7N1?1�7Q-6:�+2'>5F5.PÏ'*RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5b1�G/UJ1�7Q:�$VR»�O0@]bª¦�8�{ÚYÚL�{� � ¡H')G/%&(T7Q-6:?7NBa0+.:?O¬�/9M7NB6�S4W$)+.-{:I$&4J7Q# '):�+.$&-J1Q\H]_O/7�3 $&(T46+F5.7Q#I4/#?$MB6GJ3 7N1I1�7N«DG/7Q-{:m+g'Z5^¶0e�eµ3 $MB67!+.-�:?O/7,¹´52')-/%DGJ')%&7&\

¶_e»"@]I�hGJ1�7N1�1�7QXD7Q#�'>5�:?7N3?O/-6+2«DG/7N1Y:?$h4/#�$MB6GJ3 7T7 Eh3�+87Q-6:Y:�')#�%&7Q:»3 $/B67TabO6+23�O�3 $&#?#�7N1�4J$&-JB�:?$�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-6:4/OJ'&1�7N1*$)RY:?O/7�3 $&(T46+F5.7Q#N\¦]0O/7¬�J#�1�:T4/OJ'D1�7�$)RY:?O/7l3 $&(T46+F5.7Q#h:?#�')-J1�52'):�7N1,7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J1°R�#?$D(��/9M7NB6�S4W$)+.-{:-/$&#?(['>5HRS$&#?(¾+.-6:?$k')-³t�zS�Np�r&zSt��N�I�@�Z� Ô)Ö.|/o&t�vJz�n¥o&p q,\�]0O/7[-/7 9M:,4/OJ'&1m7�')4/465F+.7N1I�0vJt�zS�hÔ&t öI�Np��NvW�Nt�v{w,:?$�:?O/73 $/B67&\H]0O/7d�J-J'>5}4/OJ'&1m7�4W7Q#�R�$D#?(A1IÔ&r&zSr*£¥zSp y6�NzSy6p��!£¥�>sF���>zSt2o&v»R�$&#0'�¶0e�ex\/]0O/7»3 $D(T46+F587Q#_+g1@U6+2'&1�7NB[:�$Zab')# B/1%&#?7Q7NB6Ph1�:?# '):?7Q%)+.7N1Q\

Á�-A'&B/BD+.:�+.$&-[:?$Y:?O/7�3 $D(T46+F587Q#>KJ¶0eY"H]I��4/#�$ZXD+2B67N1H1�7QXD7Q#�'>5}$D:?O/7Q# R�G/-J3 :m+8$D-J1C1mGJ3?OA'D1 (A'>+.-{: '>+.-6+8-/%,:?# ')-J1��RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-T5F+.U/#�')#�+.7N1QK=4J'V#�1�+.-/%7�NG/-/4J')# 1�+.-/%A7Q:�3)\©e�4/#?$D:?$&:�P{4W7�$VR^:?O/7,1�P/1�:?7Q(�ab'&1@+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:?7NB¬+8-¯�O0H]bª©\

]_O/7�¶0e»"@]I�A(*7Q:?O/$MB6$V58$D%&P�'>+.(A10:?$*UJ7�4/# '&3 :�+23Q'>5KJ7Q(*4/OJ'&1�+.ÀQ7N1�'VG/:?$&(A'):m+8$D-�KJ')-JB*RS$M3 GJ1�7N1d$&-�'T1mG/U/�3�52'&1?1!$)R�B67Q:?7Q#?(,+.-J'):?7&K :?# '&3 :�')U65.7T4/#?$DU6587Q([1Y:?OJ'):,3 $&(T4/G/:?7°�J-6+8:�7�1�7Q: 1Q\A]0O6+21L1�G/U}3�52'&1?1,3Q')4/:�G/#?7N1�'¬a0+2B67XZ'V#�+.7Q:�P[$)R�4/#?$&U65.7Q(A1I')#�+21�+.-/%*+8-�4/#�'&3 :�+23 7&\

Û¯7Ya0+F5�5HBD+21?3 GJ1?1d:?O/7I52')-/%&GJ')%D7T�7¤ Ù 'V-JB[:?O/7Y:?7N3�O/-6+g«DG/7N1IGJ1�7NB�+8-�:?O/7Y:?O/#?7Q7Y4/OJ'D1�7N1b$VR©3 $&(*46+�52'):m+8$D-�\

h@ßà á�âHã�ä�-IãL)7·;:�)7 =ç�·Zl��¬�� ������� ���ãfä=<?>�7¤ Ù ��"@���6Ó&KF¹0"H�&�>¡W+21b'LX&7Q#?P6�SO6+8%DO/��587QXD7 5�RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5�4/#?$&U65.7Q(�1m4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-�52')-/%&GJ')%D7&\�Á�:0+21b'!R�G/-J3 :m+8$D-J'>51�G/UJ1�7Q:@$)R��O0H]bª©K{3 $&-J1�+21�:m+8-/%,$)R=7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J1@$)X&7Q#�UJ$6$)5.7N')-h')-JB,+.-6:?7Q%&7Q#0B/'):�'I:�P{4W7N1H')-JB°�J-6+.:?7Q�1�7Q:@7 9M4/#?7N1m�1�+.$&-J1QK�7Q-/OJ')-J3 7NB¯a0+.:?O��/9M7NB6�S4W$)+.-{:,7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1Q\[�7¤ Ù 4/#?$)X&+2B67N1IRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-�'VUJ1�:?#�'&3 :m+8$D-�\�]0O/7[1�7Q(A')-6:�+23Q1$)R��7¤ Ù +210B67 �J-/7NB[$&4J7Q#�'V:�+.$&-J'>5F5.P,+.-h:?7Q#?(A1©$)R�'I5.$)aC7Q#���587QXD7 5}+.(T4W7Q#�'):�+.X&7Y1�7Q:?�S:�O/7Q$&#?7Q:�+23d(A'&3�O6+8-/7I52')-/%DGJ')%&7��1�7Q7Y: ')U65.7N1 ¢�\e�${1m:��7¤ Ù 7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J1,3 $&-6RS$&#?(�:?$ha07 5F5.�S;{-/$)ab-x(A'):?O/7Q(['):�+23Q'>5H-/$&:�'V:�+.$&-J1QK=a0+.:?Ox:?O/7,7 9�3 7Q4/:m+8$D-�$)R(A')4J1�\AÛ¯7A#?7Q%6')#�Bk'¬(A')4´'&1�'��J-6+8:�7�1�7Q:L$)R�$&# B67Q#?7NBl4J'>+.#�1L:?OJ'):L(A')4J1L'�B6$&(A'Z+8-´1�7Q:L:?$�'¬#�')-/%&7h1�7Q:N\]0O6GJ1QKH'�(A')4´3Q')-xUJ7�1�+.-/%)5.7Q�SX)'>5.G/7NB�$D#�(,G65.:�+.�SXZ'Z58G/7NB=\´½�G/-J3 :�+.$&-´#?7Q:?#�+.7QX)'>50+g1*B67Q-/$&:?7NBxU6P�wW�?�J¢ K�adO6+�5.7(,G65.:�+.�SXZ'>5.G/7NBl(A'V4h#?7Q:?#�+.7QXZ'Z5�+21�B67Q-/$&:�7NB[U{Phw ¡ �L¢6\

�7¤ Ù 7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-J1T')-JB¿58$)a07Q#?��5.7QX&7 5»3 $D-J1�:?#?GJ3 :�1L')#?7hB67N1?3 #�+.UJ7NB +.-´:?O/7[:�')U65.7N1,UW7 58$)a�K@')-JBk:�O/7 +8#¬£¥�>z�Öz�¤{� o&p��NzSt��l��o&qd|}sF���Zt�zS~,+21T%V+8XD7Q-�\�]0O/7�3 $&(T465.7 96+.:�P´(*7N'&1�G/#?7�3Q')-´UW7�UJ'&1m7NBx$&-´7 E�3�+.7Q-{:[OJ'&1�O/�S: ')U65.7[+8(*�465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-J1*$)R»1�7Q: 1T')-JB´([')4J1Q\xÛk7�'&1?1mG/(T7h:?OJ'):T'k1�+.-/%)5.7�OJ'&1�O�$D4J7Q#�'):m+8$D-´$&-�'kB/'):�'¬+.:?7Q(ía0+.:?OG/-6+.:?�1�4J'&3 7�1m:?$&#�')%D7b:�');&7N1©G/-6+.:b:�+.(T7&K/')-JB*:?OJ'):C1m7N')#�3�O6+8-/%,:?O/#�$&G/%&Oh'�1�7Q:0:�');D7N1�:�+.(T7I4/#?$&4W$&#?:�+.$&-J'>5�:?$L:?O/73Q')#�BD+.-J'>5F+.:�Ph$)R�:?O/7�1�7Q:N\�Á�-�:?O/7Y: ')U65.7N1QK65.7Q:A@Í')-JBêë�UJ7,')-{Ph1�:?$D#?7NBh1�7Q:�1QK/')-JB�5.7Q:�whUW7�',(A')4�\

]_O/7�1�G/U652')-/%&GJ')%&7l�7¤¸�?�7¤ Ù a0+.:?O/$&G/:°�/9M7NB6�S4W$)+.-{:[7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J1 ¢�ab'&1,1�O/$)ab-´:�$�OJ'>X&7�'V:�5.7N'&1m:T:?O/77 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.X&7[4J$)a07Q#�$)R�¶07 52'):m+8$D-J'>5beb5.%&7QU/#�'�\�]�$l7 9/4/#?7N1?1!:?#�')-J1�+.:�+.X&7h3�5.${1�G/#?7&K©aC7*-/7Q7NBk:?$l'&B/B¯:?O/7Y�H�)��ÔVÖ|MoDt2vWzH�Q��|}p��Q£ £¥t�o&v�£�vky�{CB�DFEW�?��¢H')-JBC}Xy�{CB�D G0����¢H�®R�$&#@5.7N'&1�:I')-JB[%&#?7N'):�7N1�:@�/9M7NB[4W$)+.-{:NK�#?7N1�4J7N3 :m+8XD7 58PW¢b:?$:?O/7Y7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1_+.-�:?O/7L:�')U65.7N1Q\

Á�-�'&B/BD+.:�+.$&-�KWaC7�'Z5�5.$)aÍ1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-J1I7 +.:?O/7Q#I%)+.X&7Q-[+.-h�/9/7NB6�S4J$V+8-6:Y-/$&#?(['>5=R�$&#�(�KD+®\�7&\.Kó)ô}õ�@Íi(º�H6@ ÄI@¦þ¦�L�!@�¢ H ï®ö�ï H ïTý6ïSö�w�@«Kó)ô}õ�@Íi�@6H�ú ÄJ@�þî���!@L¢ H S7u�ï H ïTý6ïSö�w�@«K

$&#0+.-�:?O/7Y(T$&#?7Y%D7Q-/7Q#�'>5=R�$D#?(ó)ô}õ�@Íi(º�H6@ ÄLK���@�¢ H ï®ö�ï H ï[ý{ï®öVw�@1Kó)ô}õ�@Íi�@6H�ú ÄMK���@�¢ H S7u�ï H ï[ý{ï®öVwN@«�

� �

Page 20: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

0^9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-�� j 4W7Q#�'):�+.$&- ÚI7 �J-6+8:m+8$D- ¹@$&(T465.7 9{+.:�P@�iFþ ¡ ¢ '&1?1�+.%&-h7Q(T4/:�Ph1�7Q: j � � ¢@ÇUAïgó)ôkiFþ¦� 1�7Q:b7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:»'&B/BD+.:�+.$&- j � � ¢@ÍøgõMù>ùYiFþ¦� 1�7Q:b7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:»B67 5.7Q:�+.$&- j � � ¢����@ 1�7Q:b(T7Q(,UJ7Q# 1�O6+.4�:?7N1�: j � � ¢O @ ')#?U6+.:?#�')#�PA3?O/$V+g3 7 j � � ¢=h����@ :?7N1�:@R�$D#b7Q(T4/:�P�1m7Q:ba0+.:?O j � � ¢

')#?U6+.:?#�')#�PA'&1?1�+.%&-/(*7Q-{:b:�$h�w ¡ �L¢ +8([')%&7�1�7Q:b$VRC�[G/-JB67Q#»w j � � ¢wW���J¢ ~JK6+FRHw ¡ �L¢Lþ ¡ ~7¢ j � � ¢

P �G/-JB67 �J-/7NBW¢�KW$&:?O/7Q#?a_+g1m7w ¡ �L¢�iFþ ¡ ¢ (A');&7d+.(A')%&7,1�7Q:b7Q(T4/:�P j � � ¢w ¡ �L¢ UAïgó)ôkiFþ�~ '&B/B[7 5.7Q(T7Q-{:I:?$,+.(A'V%&7�1�7Q: j � � ¢w ¡ �L¢�øgõMù>ùYiFþ�~ B67 587Q:�7�7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:bRS#?$&( +.(A')%&7,1�7Q: j � � ¢~J��w ¡ �L¢ +8([')%&7�1�7Q:b(*7Q(�UW7Q#�1�O6+.4�:�7N1�: j � � ¢wW���J¢HiFþ P #?7Q(T$)X&7L�ARS#?$&("Ib2 H SJïSö�w j � � ¢wW���J¢HiFþ¦u (A');&7YwW�?�J¢@þ¦u j � � ¢Ib2 H SJïSö�w 7 587Q(*7Q-{:�1da0+.:?Oh-/$&-/7Q(*4/:�Phw6��+.(A')%&7 j � � ¢��ñx2V3°�I�Q@�¢ 7 9M7N3 G/:?7,�©58$/3�;TRS$&#b7N'&3�O j �R%!@��03 ${1�:Q���©5.$/3?;W�?�J¢�¢?¢

�©58$/3�;J�?�W¢ 7 587Q(*7Q-{:L�T+.-�'*3 $&4{P[$)R9@õWö*I´ñx2�3

]�'VU6587 � i�0^587Q(*7Q-{:�'V#?P��7¤�$&4J7Q# '):�+.$&-J1

0 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-�� j 4J7Q#�'V:�+.$&- ÚI7 �J-6+.:�+.$&- ¹H$&(T465.7 96+.:�P3cS=öVwWõ�w 1�7Q:d$)R©'Z5�5�+8([')%&7N10G/-JB67Q#Yw j �S%�wW¢%!@ 1�7Q:I3Q')#�BD+.-J'>5F+.:�P j �S%!@L¢w=�#@I¡ +.(A')%D7Y$)RT@ÍG/-JB67Q#Iw j �S%!@L¢¡ ����@ ÄUKl�?�J¢Q¢ 1�7Q:_R�$&#�(T7Q# j �S%!@¨�C3 ${1�: �SKl�?�W¢?¢?¢¡ 7)�?�W¢Ci6����@|¢ 1�7Q:_R�$&#�(T7Q# j �S%!@¨�C3 ${1�: �7)���J¢?¢?¢@NV�ë 1�7Q:_+8-6:?7Q#�1m7N3 :�+.$&- j �S%!@L¢@~�½ë 1�7Q:IBD+�·�7Q#?7Q-J3 7 j �S%!@L¢@¨Þ�ë 1�7Q:dG/-6+8$D- j �S%!@ Ù %�ëI¢=�����@ ÄUKl�?�J¢ 7 96+21�:?7Q-6:�+2'>5©«DGJ')-6:�+F�J7Q# j �S%!@¨�C3 ${1�: �SKl�?�W¢?¢?¢;�����@ ÄUKl�?�J¢ G/-6+.X&7Q#�1�'>5^«DGJ')-{:m+��J7Q# j �S%!@¨�C3 ${1�: �SKl�?�W¢?¢?¢@ÇÔ_ë 3Q')#�:?7N1�+2')-h4/#?$/B6GJ3 : j �S%!@¨�1%�ëI¢(,+.-*ïW@ (,+.-6+.(,G/(�X)'>5.G/7L+8-N@ j �S%!@L¢@ÍiFþ�ë 3 $&46Ph1�7Q:Xë�:?$T1�7Q:�@ j �S%!@L¢

] ')U65.7 Ð i�b$D-/7 587Q(*7Q-{:�'V#?Pl�7¤¦$&4J7Q# '):�+.$&-J1

Ð �

Page 21: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

]0O/7N1�7[1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-J1,')#�7�')-k7 9/:?7Q-J1�+.$&-¯$)Rb�7¤ Ù <�¶0e»"@]I��:?#m+87N1I:�$h:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(Ù:?O/7Q(±:?$*�/9/7NB6�S4J$)+.-6:�7 9/�4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-J1Q\

ed5.:?O/$&G/%&O��7¤ Ù +21[]�G/#m+8-/%D�3 $&(T465.7Q:?7&K@+.:,+21,4/#�'&3 :m+g3Q'Z5_:�$�RS$/3 GJ1,(A'>+.-65.P´$&-´:?#�'D3 :�')U65.7A4/#�$&U65.7Q(A1T7 9/�4/#?7N1?1m7NBhU6P�',O6+.%&O65.Ph#?7N1m:?#�+23 :?7NB�1mG/UJ1�7Q:b$)R0�7¤ Ù \h@ßSÞ X ·;YHãW�@ì¥ë1l�·���ç�á�'O ��Hæ�m©lA'�èz =ç�·Zl��©æºb+.X&7Q-l'T1�4W7N3�+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-l$)R�:?O/7!R�$&#�(

ó)ô}õ�@Íi(ºZH6@ ÄUKl�!@L¢ H ï®ö�ï H ïTý6ïSö�w�@1K¶0eY"H]I�[:?#�+.7N10:?$*#?7Qab#�+.:?7Y:?O/7Y7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-?Kl�!@L¢�+.-k')-h7N«DGJ'):�+.$&-J'>5�R�$&#�(

@¦þ¦�L�!@�¢.�Ûk7�')#�7�-/$)af5.${$&;D+.-/%TRS$&#b'!�/9M7NB[4W$)+.-{:d$)RH��\©Û�+.:?O[:?O/7�1�4W7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-�+.-h:?O6+21@R�$D#?(�KD+.:0+2107N'&1�+.7Q#b:?$T3�O/7N3?;:?O/7,3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&-J1I$)RH:?O/7I�/9/7NB6�S4J$)+.-6:�:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-J1H(*7N3?OJ')-6+23Q'>5F5.P&\Y]�$[#?7Qab#m+8:�7�Kl�!@L¢�+.-�')-�7N«&GJ'):m+8$D-J'>5RS$&#?(�K�¶0eY"H]I�lGJ1�7N1,'�G/-6+FR�$&#�(,5.Pk:?7Q#?(,+.-J'):m+8-/%fp��>Õ�p�t�zS�[£Q~N£QzS�Nq,K abO/${1m7�3 G/#?#�7Q-{:L+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-x+21,'&BO/$/3,U/G/:�3Q')4/:?G/#?7N1Y'[-6G/(,UJ7Q#Y$)R@R�#�7N«&G/7Q-6:�5.Pl$M3Q3 G/#?#m+8-/%�4/#?$&U65.7Q(A1Q\LÁSRb:?O/7T3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&-J1L$)RH:�O/7,�/9M7NB6�S4W$)+.-{::?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J103Q')-/-/$D:bUJ7LX&7Q#�+F�J7NB=K/:?O/7,3 $&(T46+F52'):�+.$&-�:�7Q#?(,+.-J'):?7N1Q\

Û�O/7Q-/7QX&7Q#IXZ'V#�+.$&GJ1�3 $D-JBD+8:m+8$D-J1I$&-k¤l�(T$D-/$&:?$&-/7&K6+.-(�}'):m+8$D-J')#?P�'):�º0K/+\W7&\.K=¤W�QºH¢1[ ºH¢�KJ'V#?7�1?'V:�+21��J7NB=K:?O/7�1�4W7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-

ó)ô}õ���i6�6H~º ÄL¤W�?��¢�þî� H ï®ö�ï H ï[ý{ï®öVwl�+21ba07 5F5.�B67 �J-/7NBl')-JB�3Q')-hUW7Y+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:?7NB�GJ1�+.-/%A:�O/7IR�$)5F5.$)a0+.-/%T+.(T4W7Q#�'):�+.X&7,3 $MB67&K

��iFþ~º��Rf2�öM�}õ73cwJõW¢

�×i8þ³¤W�?��¢õJö*IH<

abO6+23�O�3 $&-6X&7Q#?%&7N1d'>R�:�7Q#_'��J-6+8:�7�-6G/(�UW7Q#�$VR©1�:�7Q4J1Q\�]0O/7�')-J'Z58$D%TO/$)52B/10RS$&#0:?O/7�B6GJ'>5�1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-ó)ô}õ���i6�6H�ú ÄL¤W�?��¢@þ¦� H S7u ï H ï[ý{ï®öVwl�1�

�&GJ3�O´')-l+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-x(A'>PlUJ7*+8-/7 Eh3�+87Q-6:,RS$&#�:�a0$h#?7N'&1m$&-J1Q\h½�+.#�1�:NK�:?O/7T-/7Qa§')4/4/#?$>96+8(['):�+.$&-k$)R��+21A3 $D(T465.7Q:?7 5.P´#?7N3 $&(T4/G/:?7NB´'V-JB´3 $&46+.7NB�'):,7N'&3�Ox+.:?7Q#�'):�+.$&-�K0'>5.:?O/$&G/%DOx+8:*(,+.%&O{:[BD+�·�7Q#T$D-658P�1�5�+.%&O6:�5.PRS#?$&(Ù+8: 1Y4/#?7QXD+.$&GJ1YX)'>5.G/7&\[�&7N3 $&-JB=K�B67Q4W7Q-JBD+8-/%l$&-l:?O/7,4J')#�:�+23 G65g'V#T¤}K�:?O/7L+.:?7Q#�'):�+.X&7[1�:?7Q4l(A'>PhUJ7TU6+2'&1m7NB:?$)ab')#�B/1�'!4J')#?:�+23 G652')#b1�7N')#�3�Oh1�:?#�'):�7Q%&P}<):�O6+g10'>521�$,(A'V;&7N1�:?O/7Y')-J'>5.P/1�+210BD+�Eh3 G658:>\HÛk7daC$DG65gB°5F+.;&7Y:?$Y+.:?7Q# '):?7-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#�(,+.-6+g1m:�+23Q'>5F58P�+.-�'°a_'>PT:�OJ'):�'>5F5.$)a�10GJ1d:?$,:�');&7�'&B6X)')-6:�')%&7I$)R�$&-65.P�1�5F+8%DO{:�3�OJ')-/%&7N1d$)RH�,\

¹0'>+�'V-JB�"�'Z+8%D7»�8¹C"H�&�>¡JB67QX&7 5.$&4W7NBT'I:?O/7Q$&#�PYRS$&#��/9/7NB6�S4J$V+8-6:b3 $&(T4/G/:�'V:�+.$&-J1 abO6+23?O°+g1 XD7Q#?P�%&7Q-/7Q# '>5}')-JB')4/465F+.7N1�:?$Y4J'V#?:�+2'>5F5.P�$D#�B67Q#?7NB,1�7Q:�1 ')-JB,1�7Q(,+F52'):?:�+23 7N1Q\©Ûk70#?7N1�:?#�+23 :�$&G/# 1�7 5.X&7N1 :?$Y4/#?7N1�7Q-6:�+.-/%�')4/465F+23Q'):�+.$&-J1@:?$3 $)5F5.7N3 :�+.$&-J1�$VR}1�7Q:�1QK)abO6+23�OT')#?7�52'):�:�+23 7N1Q\�]0O6+21�#?7N1�:�#�+23 :�+.$&-�(A'V;&7N1�1m7Q-J1�7b1�+.-J3 7b:?O/7C1m7Q: +g1 $D-/7H$)RJ:?O/7b1�+.(T465.7N1�:')-JB¬(T${1�:0a0+2B67 5.PlGJ1�7NB�B/'): ',:�P{4W7N1QKJ')-JB¬:?O/7YUJ'&1�+23,1�7Q:b$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-J1_RS#?7N«&G/7Q-6:�5.P�1?'):m+g1�R�P[:?O/7�3 $D-JBD+8:m+8$D-J1b$)R:?O/7Y:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-J1Q\

Á�-,:?O/7 +.#�4J')4J7Q#I�F¹C"H�D�N¡�KN:?O/7QP,B67QX&7 5.$&4A')-T'>5.%&7QU/# '>+23b')4/4/#?${'D3?OL:?$�-/$D-JB67Q:?7Q#?(,+.-6+21�:�+23_+8:�7Q#�'):�+.$&-L+.-,�/9/7NB6�4J$V+8-6:b3 $&(T4/G/:�'V:�+.$&-�\ e¦4J')#?:�+2'>5WR�G/-J3 :m+8$D-I\×+g103Q'>5F5.7NBh'[Õ�o&p©�N£Q�NzDn¥y6vJ�>zSt2o&v!+FR]\[�!@1KQ�L¢=+21H7 +.:?O/7Q#0G/-JB67 �J-/7NB$&#Y7Q(T4/:�P�+FR�')-JBl$&-65.P�+FR^@_H���\,e 4J')#?:�+2'>5F5.P�B67 �J-/7NB¿R�G/-J3 :m+8$D-Z`°+21�3Q'Z5�5.7NBx')-�t�vJ�>p��>q,�NvJzWnQy{vW�NzSt�o&v[+FR`D�?�«K�u/¢=+2107 +.:?O/7Q#bG/-JB67 �J-/7NBh$D#�`D�?�1KQu/¢a[Ø��\�]0O/7Y:�a0$YRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1�'V#?7»1�'>+2B[:?$,UJ70nQ��r)£QtS¨QsF�H#�7 5g'V:�+.X&7Y:?$[¤T+FR')-¬+8-J3 #�7Q(T7Q-{:I$)R�º´a0+.:?O6+.-l:?O/7�a0$&#�;M1�7Q:I1�:?#�+23 :�5.P[+.-J3 #?7N'&1�7N1|º´U/G/:I-/$&:bUW7QP&$&-JB�º®Þ n��QºH¢�\0Ûf+.:?O6+.-l:?O6+21RS#�')(T7Qa0$&#?;=K&:�O/7YRS$)5F58$)a0+.-/%[:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-A3Q'V-�UJ7L4/#?$)X&7NB[3 $&#?#?7N3 :Ni

Ð/�

Page 22: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

��iFþ±vky�{ B�D�b �.n�¢ü

��iFþ"Á�<�xUhô�ï2øgõ�=�uL��\��.n�����¢?K���¢?¢

�×i8þQ`D�?�1KQu/¢�<õJö*I

Û�O/7Q:?O/7Q#L:?O/7T%&7Q-/7Q# '):?7NBk3 $/B67T+21L7 E�3�+.7Q-6:°B67Q4W7Q-JB/1,$&-k:�O/7A3?O/$V+g3 7[$)R�\±'V-JB�`6\[Á:!+g1L7N'&1mP�:�$[�J-JB1�GJ3�OhRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1@RS$&#�',4W$)aC7Q# 1�7Q:YëØ')-JB�'L(T$&-/$&:?$D-/7IR�G/-J3 :�+.$&-*n�U6Ph3?O/$6${1�+.-/%

\[�!@1KQ��¢�þ î ¡ ¢ +FR @6H��¡ @ ¢ $&:?O/7Q#�a0+21�7&K}'V-JB`D�?�«K�u/¢±þ ��Þ�uL�

]0O/7Y:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-T5.7N'&B/1d:?$T:?O/7YGJ1mGJ'>5�+.:?7Q#�'):m+8$D-��iFþ"Á�<�xUhô�ï2øgõ�n �?�L¢]c��L¢

�×i8þ�n �?�L¢�<õJö*I

ÁSRIaC7[3?O/$6${1�7�\[�!@1KQ�L¢�þd@½���§')-JB�`D�?�«K�u/¢�þ¾� U[ï.ó)ô¦uJK�a07A%&7Q:L:?O/7,RS$)5F5.$Za_+8-/%¯-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#?(,+.-6+21�:�+23+.:?7Q#�'):m+8$D-�i

��iFþ"Á�<�xUhô�ï2øgõ�=�uL�,n �?�L¢N�x�L¢

�éUAïgó)ôkiFþ¦uJ<õJö*I

Á�:@+g1_4J${1?1�+8U65.7L:?$,#?7 �J-/7Y:?O/7YUJ'&1�+23I:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-T:?$�3 $D(T4/G/:?7I�/9/7NB[4J$)+.-6:�1@RS$&#0XZ')#�+.$&GJ1CR�G/-J3 :�+.$&-J1^n�\ýd-JB67Q#»3 7Q#?: '>+.-�3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&-J1QK�R�$&#d7 9�')(*46587&KDn��Qº@¢C')-JBCº Þ¼n �QºH¢�OJ'>X&7Y:?O/7�1?'V(T7I�/9M7NB¬4J$)+.-6:NKJ1�$*:?OJ'):

��iFþ±vky�{CB�D�b¬�Qº¯ÞÍn �QºH¢.K�ºH¢ü

��iFþ"Á�<�xUhô�ï2øgõ�=�uL��\��.n�����¢?K���¢?¢

�×i8þQ`D�?�1KQu/¢�<õJö*I

]0O/7�:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-´3Q')-�'>521�$xUJ7�#�7 �J-/7NB´a0+.:?Of#?7N1�4J7N3 :[:?$�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-6:AG/-JB67Q#m58PD+.-/%�B/'):�'l:�P64J7N1[1�GJ3�O�'&1B67N3 $&(T4W${1?')U65.7d52'):?:�+23 7N1Q\�]0O/7b:�O/7Q$&#?P�3Q'V-�UW7b%&7Q-/7Q#�'Z5�+.ÀQ7NB*:?$�B67N'>5Ja0+.:?O[1�PM1m:?7Q(A1�$)RJ�/9/7NB6�S4J$)+.-6:07N«&GJ'):m+8$D-J1Q\

]_O/7�3 $/B67�%D7Q-/7Q#�'):?7NB¬U{Ph$&G/#d:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-J10(,+.%&O6:Y1�:�+F5F5HUJ7Y+.-/7 E�3�+.7Q-6:NK�1�+8-J3 7,:?O/7,3 $&(T4/G/:�'V:�+.$&-�$)R\[�.n��?��¢?K���¢�3 $&G652B UJ7h7 9/4J7Q-J1�+.X&7l')-JB¯+21,4J7Q#�RS$&#?(*7NBxa0+.:?O´7N'&3�Ox+8:�7Q#�'):�+.$&-�\x]0O/7�1?')(T7h(°+8%DO{:,O/$)52BxRS$&#:?O/7T'&1?1�+8%D-/(T7Q-{:,��iFþe`D�?�«K�u/¢�\0Ûk7,a0$&G652B¬5�+.;&7*:?$�'V4/4658P[�0vJt�zS�TÔ&t ö��Np��NvW�Nt�v{w!:?$T+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:L�/9M7NB6�S4W$)+.-{:3 $&(T4/G/: '):�+.$&-J10(T$D#?7Y7 E�3�+.7Q-{:m58P&\

h@ß$# X ·���·�ç&ã_+�·;f�ãL'6ã���)7·�����Ht�vJt�zS��ÔDt ö��>p��NvJ�>t2v6wT��"�'Z+g� � Kð"�-Y� Ð K�"�'>+2� � ¡�+21�'*:?7N3�O/-6+g«DG/7,GJ1�7NB�:?$A'>X&$)+2B¬#?7N3 $&(T4/G/:�'V:�+.$&-J1b$VR^7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1$)R�:?O/7IRS$&#?(

Ð&Ð

Page 23: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

n��?���fK>\N\>\�K��g�/¢')-JB[#?7Q4652'&3 7,:?O/7Q(Ùa0+.:?O[5.7N1?1b7 9/4J7Q-J1�+8XD7�+.-J3 #?7Q(*7Q-{:�'Z5^3 $&(T4/G/:�'V:�+.$&-J1Q\

Û¯7�3Q')-�'>X&$)+2Bh1�GJ3�O�#?7N3 $&(*4/G/:�'):�+.$&-J10U6P[(A'>+.-{: '>+.-6+8-/%[:?O/7I+.-6XZ')#�+2')-6:��þkn��?���fK>\N\N\´K��g�/¢'):0:?O/7Y4/#?$D%&#�')( 4J$)+.-6:�abO/7Q#�7�:?O/70n¬+g1d7QXZ'Z58GJ'V:?7NB=</:?O6+21b'>5F5.$)a�10GJ10:�$�#�7Q465g'D3 7�:?O/7�3 $&(*4/G/:�'):�+.$&-[$)RJnla0+.:?O+.:�1b1�:�$&#?7NB[XZ'Z58G/7Y�,\H]0OJ'):@+21QKWaC7

� \Y�Q£QzSr{¨QsFtg£�¤b:?O/7d+.-{X)')#�+2')-6:0U{PT7QX)'>5.GJ'):�+.-/%Yn[+.-{:�$ �¦$D-T7Q-{:�#?PT:?$L:?O/7b4/#?$&%D#�')(¼#�7Q%)+.$&-AadO/7Q#?7�:�O/7�X)'>5.G/7$)RJn�+g1d-/7Q7NB67NB=<

Ð \0G/4}B/'):?7i��a0+.:?O6+.-f:?OJ'):,4/#?$&%&# ')(�#?7Q%)+.$&-�adO/7Q-/7QX&7Q#A')-6P�$VR»:?O/7h4J'V#�')(T7Q:?7Q# 1T���fKN\>\N\QK��g�l$)RCn�')#?7(T$MBD+F�J7NB=<�:�O6+g1!G/4}B/'):�7A3 $MB67°+g1L3Q'>5F5.7NB�Ô&t öI�Np��NvW���T� oNÔD�IR�$D#1� a0+.:?O¯#?7N1�4J7N3 :L:?$h:?O/7T(*$MBD+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-J1Ô)���fK>\N\N\´K>Ô)�g�J<

 �\0#?7Q4652'&3 7�a0+.:?O6+.-�:?O/7�4/#?$D%&#�')(�#?7Q%)+.$&-�'Z5�5 $M3Q3 G/#?#�7Q-J3 7N1b$)R=n �?���cKN\>\N\QK��g�6¢HU{PC��\]_O6+g1!:?7N3�O/-6+g«DG/7[+21�3Q'>5F5.7NB��CvWt2zS�[Ô&t ö��Np��>vJ�Nt�v{wDK�'[%&7Q-/7Q#�'>5F+.ÀN'):�+.$&-´$VR_1�:?#�7Q-/%&:?Ok#?7NB6GJ3 :m+8$D-�\ j R�3 $&G/# 1�7&K

�J-6+.:?7�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3�+.-/%x+21Ta0$&#�:?O{adO6+�5.7�$&-65.Pk+FR�:?O/7l3 G/(�G652'):m+8XD7�3 ${1�:*$)R�7 9/7N3 G/:�+.-/%´:?O/7�BD+F·�7Q#�7Q-J3 7¿3 $/B67hRS$&#7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-Y��a0+.:?O6+.-,:?O/704/#?$&%D#�')(�'>RS:?7Q#��J-6+.:?7bBD+�·�7Q#?7Q-J3�+.-/%!+g1�'V4/465�+.7NBL+21�5.7N1?1 :?OJ'V-�:�O/7C3 ${1�: $)RJ#?7Q4W7N'):?7NBD5.P7QXZ'Z58GJ'V:�+.-/%�nî+.-¦:?O/7k$&#m+8%V+8-J'Z5�4/#?$&%D#�')(�\¼]_O/7l+2B67N'´+21¬:?$´#?7N3 $&%&-6+.ÀQ7k:�O/${1�7l7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J1�:?OJ'):�3Q')-�UW7(A'>+.-6:�'>+.-/7NB!+.-/7 9M4W7Q-J1�+.X&7 5.PA'&1W+.-6XZ')#�+2')-6:�1Q\�¶0eY"H]»�!1m:?$&#?7N1�'C�J-6+8:�7_3 $V5�5.7N3 :�+.$&-*$)R��>sF�Nq,�NvWzSr&p�~IÔ&t ö��Np��>vJzSt�r{¨QsF��Q��|}p��Q£ £¥t�o&v�£C')-JB[:?O/7 +.#Y'&1?1�$/3�+2'):?7NB[U65.$M3�;/1b$)RHBD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3 7�3 $/B67�%&GJ'V#�')-6:?7Q7NB[:?$,UJ7!+8-/7 9/4J7Q-J1�+8XD7&\

Û�O/7Q-/7QX&7Q#Y')-�7 9M4/#?7N1�1�+.$&-k3Q')-lUJ7,#?7N3 $&%&-6+.ÀQ7NBl'&1dUJ7 +.-/%�3 $D(T4J${1m7NBh$)RH7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:�')#?PlBD+F·�7Q#�7Q-{:�+2')U65.7T7 9/�4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-J1QK):?O/7Q-I�J-6+.:?7bBD+F·�7Q#�7Q-J3�+8-/%�3Q'V-YUJ7C'V4/465�+.7NB=\@Á-L$&#�B67Q#�:?$d7 9M4W${1�7�O6+2B/B67Q-T7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:�')#?PYBD+F·�7Q#�7Q-{:�+2')U65.77 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1L')-JBl:?$h(A'V;&7,:?O/7A3 $/B67T(T$&#?7,#?7Q%DG65g'V#NK�7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1,')#�7�4652'&3 7NB¿+.-{:�$�'h-/$&#?(['>5�RS$&#?(�GJ1�+8-/%')-/$&:�O/7Q#�#?7Qad#�+.:?7T1�PM1m:?7Q(�\Y]0O6+21I#?7Qab#�+.:?7T1�P/1�:?7Q(�4W7Q#�RS$&#?(A1I'TX)')#�+.7Q:�P�$)R0(,+.-/$&#�1�P6(,UJ$)5F+23L(A')-6+.4/G652'):�+.$&-J11�GJ3�O�'&1@:?G/#�-6+8-/%h1�7Q:�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3 7,')-JB[+.-6:?7Q#�1�7N3 :�+.$&-¬+.-{:?$*7N«&G6+.XZ'Z587Q-6:�1�7Q:0RS$&#?(*7Q#�1Q\

]_O/7�BD+�·�7Q#?7Q-J3 7,3 $MB67IRS$&#b',(T$/BD+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-xÔ)�A%&7Q-/7Q# '>5F58P�3 $D-J1�+21�:�10$)RH'L46+.7N3 7�$)RH3 $MB67YUW7 R�$D#?7Y:?O/7Y(T$/BD+.��}3Q'):�+.$&-�K/3Q'>5F5.7NB*|}p�� Ô&t öI�Np��NvW���I��o>Ô&�NK6')-JB['Y46+.7N3 7�'>RS:?7Q#H:?O/7I(T$/BD+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-�K/3Q'>5F5.7NB[|MoV£¥zSÔ&t ö��>p��>vJ� ��� oNÔD�N\ Ûk7ab#�+.:?7�g ð ÿ Ô)���¼'V-JB�g Ñ ÿ¼Ô)���YK�#?7N1�4W7N3 :�+.X&7 5.P&\A]0O/7T4/#�7NBD+�·�7Q#?7Q-J3 7[')-JBl4J$61�:�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3 7A3 $/B67TU65.$M3�;M13Q')-h(T$/BD+FR�Ph$D-658Ph:�O/7YXZ')#�+2')U65.7Y�×'V-JB[5.$M3Q'Z5�XZ')#m+g'VU6587N1�\�d$&:?7Y:?OJ'V:C:�O/7�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3 7�3 $/B67Y+21d-/$&:0G/-6+g«DG/7&\

Á�:=+21=+.-6:?7Q#?7N1�:m+8-/%I:?$�3 $D-J1�+2B67Q#^3 $)5F5.7N3 :�+.$&-J1 $)R/7N«DGJ'>5F+8:m+87N1k���dþkn �fK>\N\>\QK��ihbþkn*hVK�+.-�abO6+23�O,7N'&3?OY7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-n#jTB67Q4J7Q-JB/1L$&-65.Pl$&-lXZ')#�+2')U65.7N1*� � K>\N\>\�K�� � ')-JB�� � K>\N\>\QK���j ð � \,½/$D#Y:?O/7,4/G/#?4J${1m7T$)RC7 Eh3�+87Q-J3 P&K a07Ta0$&G652B5F+.;&7A:�$A(A'Z+8-6:�'>+.-�'V-JBl7 9M465.$)+.:,'>5F5H$)RC:?O/7N1m7T7N«&GJ'Z5�+.:�+.7N1,'&1d+.-6XZ')#�+2')-6:�1!a0+.:?O6+.-Ï'[4/#?$D%&#�')(¾#?7Q%)+.$&-´úT\,]0O/7Ô&t ö��Np��>vJzSt�r&sN$VR����fKN\>\N\QK���h0a0+.:?OA#�7N1�4J7N3 :@:?$Tú�+210B67Q-/$&:?7NB,U6PAg ¡ ���gK>\N\N\´K���hg¢1ÿ�ú6�Y\�Á:©+g1@$&U/: '>+.-/7NB,RS#?$&(úÍU{P[#?7N3 G/#�1�+8XD7 58P�'V4/4658PD+.-/%h:?O/7IRS$)5F58$)a0+.-/%[:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J1Qi

� \b¶07Q4652'&3 7�7N'&3�O�(*$MBD+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-xÔ)�h$M3Q3 G/#�#�+.-/%T+.-kúÍa0+.:?O

g ¡ � � KN\>\N\QK�� h ¢ ÿNg ð � � ÿ¦Ô)��� Ô)��g Ñ � � ÿ¦Ô)���9��KabO/7Q#?7,-/$h-/7Qa¼$/3Q3 G/#?#?7Q-J3 7N1!$)R�n �,')#�7�+.-6:?#?$/B6GJ3 7NBla0+.:?O6+.-x:?O/7TBD+�·�7Q#?7Q-J3 7[3 $MB67,RS$&#Y:?O/7,#?7Q(['>+.-6+8-/%+8-6XZ'V#�+2')-{: 15���cKN\>\N\QK���h)K{')-JBT'Z5�5J$/3Q3 G/#?#?7Q-J3 7N1@$)R6n �03Q')-,UW7�#?7Q4652'&3 7NB°U{PY���>\ Ûk7�3Q'>5F5����@:?O/7Yq,t2vWt2q,r&st2vW�Nr&p t2rDvJz�R�$&#d:?O/7�BD+F·�7Q#�7Q-{:�+2'>5�g ¡ ���cKN\>\N\´K��ihg¢1ÿ¦Ô)���Y\

Ð \b¶07Q4652'&3 7�'>5F5�$M3Q3 G/#�#?7Q-J3 7N1b$VR}n#jIU{Ph:?O/7�3 $D#?#?7N1�4W$&-JBD+.-/%���jYa0+.:?O6+.-�:?O/7Y#�7N1�:b$)R0úÐ  

Page 24: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

]_O6+g1@%)+.X&7N1_GJ1H:�O/7Y%&7Q-/7Q#�'>5��Q¤{r&t�vlp�y6sF�Q£�RS$&#03 $)5F587N3 :m+8XD7�4/#?7NBD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3 7�'V-JBT4W${1�:�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3 7�3 $/B67YU65.$M3�;/1QKabO/7Q#?71���I(,GJ1�:bUJ7L(,+.-6+.(A'>5�+.-6XZ')#�+2')-6:Ni

g ð ¡ ���gK>\N\N\©K���hc¢ ÿ¦Ô)��� þ g ¡ ���gK>\N\>\QK��ihg¢«ÿNg ð ����ÿ¦ÔV�I�9�g ð�¡ ���gK>\N\>\QK��ihg¢ ÿ¦Ô)���

')-JBg Ñ ¡ � � K>\N\N\©K�� h ¢ ÿ¦Ô)��� þ g Ñ ¡ � � K>\N\>\QK�� h ¢ ÿ¦Ô)���

g ¡ ���gK>\N\>\QK��ihg¢«ÿNg Ñ ����ÿ¦ÔV�I�9�Ç�e¬+.-6+.(A'>5�+.-6XZ')#m+g'V-{:�1I3Q')-hUW7YRS$&G/-JBhU6PA7 9J')(,+.-6+.-/%[:?O/7TÔ&r&zSrhÔ&�m|M�>vJÔ&�>vJ�N~*Ô&rNwIRS$&#�nQ�fKN\>\N\´KSn*h&\Á�-T$&#�B67Q#�:�$�B67Q:?7Q#?(,+.-/7IabO/7Q:?O/7Q#��J-6+.:?7IBD+�·�7Q#?7Q-J3�+.-/%T'&3 :?GJ'Z5�5.P,+.(T4/#�$ZXD7N1 :?O/7b4J7Q#mR�$&#�(A')-J3 7b$)R=:?O/7�3 $/B67&K

:?O/7,1�7Q:?�S:?O/7Q$&#�7Q:�+23�3 ${1�:I$)R�:?O/7�#�7N1�G65.:�+.-/%h4/#?$&%&#�'V(�+21�B67Q:?7Q#�(,+.-/7NB�¨?�®n¥oDp��I')4/465.P&+.-/%�')-6Ph:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J1�\]0O6+21d£¥~)vWzSr&�NzSt��H')-J'>5.P/1�+21 +.-6X&$)5.X&7N1@:?O/#?7Q7�3 $D(T4J$&-/7Q-6:�1Qi :?O/7I3 ${1�:�$)R�7N1�:�'VU65�+21�O6+.-/%,:?O/70+.-6XZ')#m+g'V-{:�1@UW7 R�$&#�7b:?O/73 $/B67�U65.$/3?;=KW:?O/7T3 ${1�:b$)RH(['>+.-{:�'Z+8-6+.-/%h:?O/7Q(¾a0+.:?O6+.-k:?O/7LU65.$M3�;}K=')-JB�:?O/7L#?7Q(A'>+.-6+.-/%�3 ${1�:�1�\b]0O/7�3 $&-J3 7Q4/:$)R�� o&vJzSt�vJy6t2zS~!+21!+8-6:?#?$/B6GJ3 7NB¯:?$�')#?%&G/7[')UJ$&G/:L:?O/7A3 ${1m:�1Y$)R0(A'>+.-6:�'>+.-6+.-/%�+.-6XZ')#m+g'V-{:�1�\�º=zSp�o&v{wl� o&vJzSt�vJy6t�zS~(T7N')-J1I:�OJ'):�:�O/7�a0$&# 1�:�3Q'&1�7T3 ${1m:�$)R0#?7Q7N1�:�'VU65�+21�O6+.-/%l')-�+8-6XZ'V#�+2')-{:�'ZR�:?7Q#�'[1�+.-/%)5.7T4J')# ')(T7Q:?7Q#d+21Y(T$/BD+F�J7NB+21TUW$&G/-JB67NBfU{P�'¯3 $&-J1�:�')-6:N\�Áh��r��¿� o&vWzSt2vWy{t�zS~h(T7N')-J1°:?OJ'):T:?O/7l3 G/(,G65g'V:�+.X&7k3 ${1�:T$)RY(A'>+.-6:�'>+.-6+.-/%�')-+.-{X)')#�+2')-6:Y#?7 52'):�+.X&7,:?$h'>5F5^(*$MBD+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-J1!:?$[:?O/7�4J')# ')(T7Q:?7Q#d+21IUJ$&G/-JB67NBlU6Ph:?O/7T3 ${1�:I$)RH7N1�: ')U65F+g1mO6+8-/%�:?O/7+.-{X)')#�+2')-6:,4658GJ1L:?O/7*-{G/(,UJ7Q#L$)Rb(T$/BD+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-J1L:?$�:?O/7*4J')#�')(T7Q:�7Q#N\h¹H7Q#�:�'>+.-�3 $&-6:�+.-{G6+.:�Pl4/#?$&4W7Q#?:�+.7N1LO/$)52BRS$&#b:?O/7,3 $&(T4J$61�+.:�+.$&-l$)R©3 $D-{:�+.-6G/$&GJ1dRSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1Q\0ed58:�O/$&G/%&Ol:?O/7�3 $D-J3 7Q4/:�$)RH3 $&-6:�+.-{G6+.:�P�O/7 5.4J1I$&-65.P[+.-l:?O/73Q'&1�7Y$VR�5F+.-/7N')#Y3 $&(T465.7 9{+.:�P&K�+8:Y3Q')-hUW7�%&7Q-/7Q#�'Z5�+.ÀQ7NB�:?$T')#?U6+.:?# ')#?P[4J$)5.P6-/$&(,+2'>5H3 $&(T465.7 9{+.:�+.7N1Q\

�&$D(T7�'&B/BD+.:�+.$&-J'>5�:?7N3�O/-6+g«DG/7N1Y3Q')-hUW7�GJ1�7NB¬:?$A1�4W7Q7NB�G/4�:?O/7�3 $/B67�$&U/:�'Z+8-/7NB�'>RS:?7Q#0�J-6+.:?7�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3�+.-/%U6P�'T3 $D-J1�:�')-6:@R®'&3 :�$&#Ni

/ e 3 $)5F5.7N3 :�+.$&-x$)RH+.-6XZ')#�+2')-6:�1L3Q')-k7N'&1�+F5.PlUJ7T7N1m:�')U65F+21�O/7NBl+.-�'[-J'Z+8XD7Tab'NP�U{Pl1�7Q4J')#�'V:?7 5.Ph+.-6+.:�+2'>5F+8À +�-/%7N'&3?O�����\b¶0e»"@]I�hGJ1�7N1I'h£QzSp���r&qLÖg|}p�oN� �Q£ £¥t�v{wI:?7N3�O/-6+2«&G/7,:?$*7 E�3�+.7Q-{:�5.Pl7N1�:�'VU65�+21�Ok1�7QXD7Q#�'>5�(,G/:?GJ'>5F5.PB67Q4J7Q-JB67Q-6:b+.-6XZ')#�+2')-6:�1_+.-hRS7Qa¦4J'&1?1�7N1�\H]0O6+21b%V+8XD7N1b'T3 $&-J1�: ')-{:���R®'&3 :�$&#C1�4W7Q7NB6G/4�\

/ ¹H7Q#?:�'>+.-�3 $V5�5.7N3 :�+.$&-J1�$)R,+.-6XZ')#�+2')-6:�1�3Q')-¦UJ7x7N1�:�'VU65�+21�O/7NBî+.-�RS7Qa07Q#h5.$6$&4J1hGJ1�+.-/%�:�a0$´$&:?O/7Q#[5.${$D4/�3 $&(,U6+8-6+.-/%[:?7N3�O/-6+g«DG/7N1Y3Q'>5F5.7NBk�>�Np zSt2� r&s/')-JB�¤{o&p tgu¥o&vWzSr&s)nQy&£Qt�o&vJ\

/ ½�+8-6+.:?7TBD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3�+.-/%JK�1�:?#�7N')(,+.-/%�'V-JB[RSGJ1�+.$&-�+8-J3 #�7N'&1�7TB/'):�'L+.-JB67Q4W7Q-JB67Q-J3 7�')-JB¬4J${1�1�+.U658P�+.-6:?#?$/B6GJ3 7GJ1�7 5.7N1?1Y3 $MB67&\�k�£Q�NsF�Q£ £�Ö���o>Ô&���>sFt2q,t�vJr&zSt�o&v,+21dGJ1�7NB�:?$A'&3�O6+.7QX&7�'V-/$&:?O/7Q#Y3 $&-J1�:�')-6:?��R'&3 :?$&#b1�4W7Q7NB6G/4�')::?O/7Y7Q-JBh$)R�:?O/7I�J-6+.:?7Q�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3�+.-/%�4/OJ'&1m7&\

h@ß$h +� =ç� =ìNä�ç�'9��)6ç(��'6ã�äHãLøSãM)6ç�·Zl��]0O/7Y3 $MB67I$&U/:�'Z+8-/7NB['>RS:?7Q#H:�O/70�J#�1�:0')-JBA1m7N3 $&-JBT4/OJ'D1�7N1@$)R�3 $&(T46+F52'):�+.$&-h1�:�+F5F5�GJ1m7N1C1m7Q:�1H')-JB*(A')4J1@'&1�UJ'D1�+23B/'):�'¿:�P64J7N1�<0+.:�1,4W7Q#�R�$D#?(A')-J3 7¬+g1[')-J'>5.P6ÀQ7NBx+.-�:�7Q#?(A1,$)RY:?O/7l1�7Q:?�S:?O/7Q$&#�7Q:�+23�3 $&(T465.7 96+.:�P´(*7N'&1�G/#?7&\�]0O/7:?O6+.#�B¬4/OJ'&1�7Y$)R�:�O/7�3 $&(T46+F5.7Q#NK/adO/${1�7I+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-�+210-/$&:bPD7Q:_3 $D(T465.7Q:?7&K/+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�1d:?O/7N1�7�1�7Q: 1b')-JB(A')4J1dGJ1�+.-/%h3 $&-{XD7Q-{:�+.$&-J'Z5©1�:�$&#�')%&7Y1�:?#�GJ3 :?G/#?7N1d$&-�'hy6vJt nQo&p�qLÖ���o)£Qz0£Q�?£>y{�>vJzSt�r&sWlC÷�B �ð"H�I�6ÓQ¡\b]0O/7�¶_e�e3 $/B67�%&7Q-/7Q# '):?7NBL+21�%DGJ')#�')-6:?7Q7NB,:?$Y7 9/7N3 G/:?7Ia0+.:?OT:?O/7I1?')(T7ba0$&# 1�:?�3Q'&1�70'&1�P6(T4/:?$&:m+g3d1�4J'&3 7�')-JB°:�+.(T7»¶_e�e3 $&(T465.7 96+.:�+.7N1Y'&10:?O/7�1�7Q:��S:?O/7Q$&#?7Q:�+23L3 $&(T465.7 9{+.:�+.7N1Y'&1_:?O/7�1�7Q:?�S(A'D3?O6+.-/7�3 $/B67&\

]_O6+g1C5g'D1�:�3 $&(T46+F52'):�+.$&-l4/OJ'&1m7�3 $&-J1�+21�:�1d$)R�:?O/7IR�$V5�5.$)a0+.-/%[:�a0$T1�:?7Q4J1�i

� \0eb5F5�-/$&-/�S7 5.7Q(T7Q-{: ')#?P�1�7Q:?�S:�O/7Q$&#?7Q:�+23Y$D4J7Q#�'):m+8$D-J10+.-�:�O/7�4/#?$&%D#�')(�')#�7I+8(*46587Q(*7Q-{:?7NB�+8-�:?7Q#?(A1d$)R�:?O/77 587Q(*7Q-{:�'V#?P�$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-J1�1mO/$Zad-�+.-T:�O/7C: ')U65.7&\^]_O/7C#�7N1�G65.:�+.-/%�4/#?$&%D#�')(î+g1@1?'>+2BL:?$IUJ70+.-h£Q�Nz�Ö�q�rD�Q¤{t�vJ��Ö��o>Ô&�AvWo&p q�rDs/nQo&p�q,\[]0O6+21�1�:?7Q4¿+g1,1�:�#�'>+.%&O6:�R�$D#?ab')#�Bh')-JBkB6$67N1Y-/$D:�3�OJ')-/%&7T:?O/7[3 $&(T465.7 9{+.:�Pl$)Rb:?O/73 $MB67&\

Ð �

Page 25: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

Ð \0Ûk7b:?#?PL:?$I+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:b7N'&3�OT7 5.7Q(T7Q-{: ')#?PT1�7Q:�$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-*+.-T:?7Q#?(A1©$)R�3 $D-{X&7Q-6:�+.$&-J'>5�¶0e�e¾$&4J7Q#�'V:�+.$&-J11�GJ3?O[:?OJ'):@:?O/7Y'&1�P6(T4/:?$&:�+23da0$&#�1�:?�3Q'D1�7b:�+.(T7Y')-JBh1�4J'&3 7Y3 $&(T465.7 96+.:�+.7N1b$&-[:?O/7Y¶0e�e±')#?7Y'&1©%&${$/B['&1:?O/7�1�7Q:?�S:?O/7Q$D#?7Q:�+23Y3 $&(T465.7 96+8:m+87N1�\

]_O/7N1�7h4J7Q#�RS$&#?([')-J3 7�$&U�Î�7N3 :�+.X&7N1*3Q')-/-/$&:h'>5.a_'>P/1LUJ7�'D3?O6+.7QX&7NB=\�Á�-�:?OJ'):[3Q'&1�7&K@:?O/7�3 $&(*46+�5.7Q#ha0$&G652B')4/465.PhO/7QG/#�+21�:�+23Q1Y1�GJ3�O�'&10#�7Q4/#?7N1�7Q-6:�+.-/%�1�7Q: 1b'&10OJ'&1mOh:�')U65.7N10$&#�1m7N')#�3�Oh:?#?7Q7N1Q\

¶_e»"@]I�Y:?#�+.7N1�:?$�'>X&$V+gB,3 ${1m:�5.P�3 $&46P�$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-J1@')-JBLO6+2B/B67Q-�3 ${1m:�1 $)R}%6')#?UJ')%&703 $)5F5.7N3 :�+.$&-AU6PL+.(T4J${1�+8-/%XZ'V#�+.$&GJ1�� o |}~*r&�No&t�Ô&r&vW���I')-JBlÔ&� r&s�s�o>��rDzSt2o&vl� o&vJÔDt2zSt�o&v/£Q\

ÚI7Q4W7Q-JBD+.-/%´$&-�:?O/7�;&+.-JBf$)R�$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-J1*#?7N«DG6+.#?7NB R�$&#[7N'&3�O¦£QzSo&p���Ô¯£Q�NzI�(A'V4J1A')#�7�1�:?$&#?7NBf'&1[1�7Q:�1 ¢+.-¦:?O/7l4/#?$&%D#�')(�KI¶0e»"@]I�³3�O/${$61�7N1h')-¦')4/4/#?$&4/#m+g'V:?7l+.-{:�7Q#?-J'>5�#?7Q4/#?7N1m7Q-{:�'V:�+.$&-fR�$&#h:�OJ'):�1m7Q:N\ " $61?1�+.U65.7#?7Q4/#?7N1m7Q-{:�'V:�+.$&-J1b')#?7&i

/ y{v=¨?r)£Q� Ô»1m7Q:NKJ',B6$&G/U65.P{��5F+.-/;&7NB¿5F+g1m:�a0+.:?Oh4W$)+.-{:�7Q#�1b:�$�:�O/7Y�J#�1�:b')-JB�52'&1�:05F+21�:Y3 7 5�5<

/ s�o>��rDsZ1�7Q:>KM3 $D-J1�+21�:�+.-/%T$)R�'L:�')U65.7I$)R�'>5F5�4W${1?1�+.U65.7�X)'>5.G/7N10$)R�:?O/7Y1�7Q:NK63Q'>5F587NBx¨?rV£¥�>K&4J$V+8-6:?7Q#�1©5F+.-/;&+.-/%[:?O/7:�')U65.7Y7 5.7Q(T7Q-{: 1�3 G/#?#�7Q-{:�5.P[+.-�:�O/7�1�7Q:NKJ')-JB[4W$)+.-{:�7Q#�1b:�$�:�O/7Y�J#�1�:b')-JB�52'&1�:b7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:N<

/ £|/r&p?£Q�,1�7Q:NKH'lB6$&G/U65.P6��5�+.-/;&7NB 5F+21�:TabO/7Q#�7A7N'&3�O´3 7 5�5I4J$)+.-6:�1,:?$�:?O/7�3 $&#?#?7N1m4J$&-JBD+.-/%k7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:,+.-´:?O/7UJ'&1�7Y:�')U65.7L$)R^'L5.$/3Q'>5©1m7Q:N\

]_O/7�¶0eY"H]I��B/'V:�')�1�:?#�GJ3 :?G/#?7b1�7 5.7N3 :�+.$&-[4/OJ'&1�7Y3Q')-TUJ7dX&+.7Qa07NBA'D1�'YO6+.%&O65.PA3 $&-J1�:�#�'>+.-/7NBTX)')#�+2')-6:�$)R�:?O/7�O0H]dª�B/'): ')�1�:?#?GJ3 :�G/#?7»1m7 587N3 :m+8$D-¿3 $D(T4J$&-/7Q-6:N\m ÊÙ� Ǧ��Ì ËTÌb��Ì0� �Sn»Åpo?nbÌ�ÉQ��Ì0� ���!�]0O/7h:?O/#�7Q7�')4/4/#�${'&3�O/7N1�:�$�:�#�')-J1�RS$&#?(A'V:�+.$&-J'>5C4/#�$&%&#�')(*(,+.-/%�a07hOJ'>X&7A4/#�7N1�7Q-{:�7NB´3Q')-/-/$&:,UJ7�3 $&(*4J')#?7NB7N'&1�+F5.P&\[Á-k:�O6+g1,1�7N3 :m+8$D-�K�a07,�J#�1�:Y4/#�7N1�7Q-{:,'*R�# ')(T7Qa0$&#?;�$)R_3 $&(*(T$&-�3 #�+.:?7Q#m+g'¬U{PlabO6+23�Ok:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-1�P/1�:?7Q(A1d3Q')-hUJ7L7QXZ'>5.GJ'):?7NB=\0]0O/7Q-�aC7Y3 $&(T4J'V#?7Y:?O/7�:�O/#?7Q7�1�P/1�:?7Q(A10a_+8:�Oh#?7N1�4J7N3 :I:?$,:?O/7N1�7,3 #�+.:?7Q#�+2'/\

¶�ßà é�'(·�ç&ãL'(·Z ém©lA'�qCr* *ø��� =ç�·����×á�'( ��Hæ�mQl�'�èz =ç�·Zl���ä�åHæ)ç&ã=èÍæÛk7Y%&#�$&G/4h$&G/#�3 #�+.:?7Q#m+g'°+.-�%&7Q-/7Q# '>5^3 #�+.:?7Q#�+2'/KW1�PM1m:?7Q(�'&1�4W7N3 :�1QKJ'V-JB*5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7,'&1�4J7N3 : 1Q\

µVoZrMoZr }AõWö=õ`3cSJø×�«3)ï.óQõ73)ïTS2 ^�¦ õ`R)óNï[�=õV\Y]0O/7,4/#�+.(A'V#�+.P�%D${'>5�$)RH(*${1�:I:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-�1�P/1�:?7Q(A1_+21I:?O/7Tw&�>vJ�Np�r&s�£QyQ|&|/o&p z=n¥oDpb|=p�o w&p�r&qq�o>Ô&t �C� r&zSt2oDvVì�]0O6+21*+.-J3�5.GJB67N1h:?O/7xo |}zSt�q�tguQr&zSt2oDv¦$)R�3 $&-6:?#?$)5»1m:?#?GJ3 :?G/#?7N1�KH:?O/7xt2qd|}sF�>q��>vJzSr&zSt�o&v�$)RB/'):�'�1m:?#?GJ3 :?G/#?7N1�K&:?O/7Y'&B/')4/:�+.$&-[$)R�%V+8XD7Q-A4/#?$D%&#�')(A1©:?$�4J'V#?:�+23 G652')#b1�:�P&5.7N1@$)R�4/#?$D%&#�')(T(°+8-/%WK{')-JB*:?O/7w&�NvW�Np�r&zSt�o&vl$)RH-/7QaÍ:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-h#?G65.7N1Q\Y½/G/#?:?O/7Q#Y%D${'>521�'V#?7Y|}p�o w&p�r&q¾£Q~ZvWz�¤{�Q£Qtg£?Û=:?O/7TB67Q#�+.XZ'):m+8$D-$)R�'!4/#?$&%&#�'V(ÍRS#?$&(¼'�1m4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-�K6|=p�o w&p�r&q�r&Ô&r¥|}zSt2oDvh:?$�4J'V#?:�+23 G652')#07Q-{XD+.#?$&-/(T7Q-6:�1�$D#�52')-/%&GJ')%D7N1QK|}p�o�w&p�r&qÙÔ&�Q£Q�Np tÜ|=zSt2o&v9Û�'V-JB���B67NB6GJ3 :�+.$&-/�S$&#�+.7Q-6:?7NBW¢��N�>p�t �C� r&zSt�o&vVì@�3g2 ^ øgõ H Ib2 H SJï®ö�\beI-x+8(*4J$&#?: ')-{:,3 #�+.:?7Q#�+.$&-x+21,:?O/7[4/#?$&U65.7Q( B6$D(A'>+.-�'h:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-�1�P/1�:?7Q(µ3Q')-OJ')-JBD5.7&\H�&$D(T7b1�PM1m:?7Q(A1=#?7N1m:?#�+23 :�:�O/7 +8#�4/#�$&U65.7Q(¼B6$&(A'>+.-,:?$b4/#?$)XD+2B67_'dO6+.%&O/7Q#HB67Q%&#?7Q7@$)R}')G/:?$D(A'):�+.$&-�\j :?O/7Q#�10OJ')-JBD5.7T'*a0+2B67�#�')-/%D7Y$)RH4/#?$&U65.7Q(A1dU/G/:�#�7N«&G6+.#?7L:?OJ'):b:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-J1HUW7�1�7 5.7N3 :?7NB�U6Ph:?O/7GJ1�7Q#N\

õ(u�óQõJö�ùNï ^ ï2ø�ï.ó.>�\,�&7QXD7Q#�'>5�4J')#?:�1d$)RC'*:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-�1�P/1�:?7Q(A1d(A'>PhUJ7h���ZzS�Nv�£¥tS¨QsF�tsH:?O/7Y5F+.U/#�')#�P�$)RH:?# ')-J1��R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-l#?G65.7N1Y(['NPlUW7T7 9M:�7Q-JB67NB=K�$D#�'[-/7Qa§1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):m+8$D-�$&#L4/#?$&%&# ')(T(,+.-/%[52')-/%&GJ')%D7T(A'>P�UW7+8-J3 $D#?4J$&# '):?7NB=\

Ð Ò

Page 26: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

µVoZrMo�n ¹�>�ùQóQõ H �hùg@ õ7R)óNù2V3cwMS=ö�ï[ý�S/óNï[2�ö~S=öNIfó.>A@ õMù§2Jñbóg3cS=ö�ùQñx2�3 H S/óNï[2�ö�ù�\je�${1m:�1�PM1m:?7Q(A1L4/#?$)X&+2B67h'[|}p�� Ô&�S�0vJ� Ôl��o&s�sF���>zSt2oDv�o�nzSp�rDv/£�n¥o&p q,r&zSt�o&v�p�y6sF�Q£.Û�abO6+23�O³(['NP¯52'):?7Q#[UJ7l7 9/:?7Q-JB67NB=\�]0O/7Q#�7�')#?7�:�aC$x3 $&-{:�#�')#?Pk(*7Q:?O/$MB/1*RS$&#(A'>+.-{: '>+.-6+8-/%h:�O/7I5�+.U/#�'V#?P�$)R�:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J1_$)R^:�O/7�1�P/1�:?7Q(�i@:?O/7[��r&zSrDs�o w[r |&|}p�oNrD�Q¤�')-JB¬:?O/7�wD�Nv�Ö�Np�r&zSt��N�[£Q�NzIr |&|}p�oNrD�Q¤`ì�e�3Q'V:�'>5.$&%h+21,'[52')#�%&7�3 $V5�5.7N3 :�+.$&-f$)R�B6$&(A'>+.-/�1�4W7N3�+F�}3h;6-/$Za_587NB6%D7&\ j -x:?O/7$&:?O/7Q#�OJ')-JB=K6'Y%&7Q-/7Q#�'V:�+.X&7�1�7Q: +21H'L1�(A'>5F5}1�7Q:@$)R}4W$)aC7Q#mR�G65J7 5.7Q(T7Q-6:�')#?P,#?G65.7N1QKDRS#?$&(ÍabO6+23�O�'DB/BD+8:m+8$D-J'>5#?G65.7N1�3Q')-hUW7�B67Q#�+.X&7NB=\0¶07N3 7Q-6:�5.P&KJ:�O/7Q#?7�1�7Q7Q(A1d:?$,OJ'>X&7YUJ7Q7Q-l',:?7Q-JB67Q-J3 Ph:?$)ab')#�B/1@:?O/7I52'):?:�7Q#N\

ñx2�3 H 2Jñdóg3gS=ö�ùQñ�2V3 H S/óNï[2�ö,3�P�ø.õ/ù�\IÁ�-�%D7Q-/7Q#�'>5K=:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-�#?G65.7N1Y3 $&-J1�+21�:Y$)R�+.-/4/G/:Y:?7Q(T4652'):�7&K=$&G/:?�4/G/:Y:?7Q(T4652'):?7&K ')-JBl')4/465F+g3Q'VU6+�5F+2:�P�3 $D-JBD+8:m+8$D-�\T]0O/7,+.-/4/G/:�')-JB¿$&G/:?4/G/:Y:?7Q(T4652'):�7N1I(A'>P�UJ7*#?7 52'):?7NBU{Px�?£>y{t��Nr&sF�>vJ� �T$&#TÔ&��£¥� �NvWÔ&r&vW���fì�¶0G65.7N1L(A'>P�UW7T|=p�o>��� Ô&y6p�r&s0��'>5.%&$D#�+.:?O/(,+23>¢�$&#,£Q�Q¤6�Nq,r&zSt���ìT]@P646+.�3Q'>5F58P&KW4/#?$/3 7NB6G/#�'>5�#?G65.7N1�'V#?7YGJ1�7NB�'D1�wDs�o6¨?r&s�#?G65.7N1QKWabO/7Q#?7N'&1b1�3?O/7Q(A'V:�+23Y#?G65.7N1Y')#?7TsFo>��r&s�sF~,r |&|}sFt���r{¨�sF�p��®�CvW�Nq,�NvWz�p y{sF��£�ì

óg3cS=ö�ù�ñx2�3 H S/óNïT2�ö,@A3c2*R)õ/ùNù1S=ö*I H õ7RDôVS=ö�ïTý�S/óNïT2�ö�\L�&P/1�:?7Q(A1!(A'>P�UW7TRSG65F5.Pk(A')-6GJ'>5K�1�7Q(,+.�')G/:?$&(['):�+23)K$&#=RSG65�5.PT')G/:?$D(A'):�+23)\�e´([')-{GJ'Z5�1�P/1�:?7Q(î+21 4/#�'&3 :�+23Q'>5/$&-65.PY+.-T3 $&-/-/7N3 :�+.$&-,a0+.:?O,4W$Za07Q#�RSG65{:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A')�:�+.$&-h#?G65.7N1Q\d�&7Q(,+.�')G/:?$&(A'V:�+23Y1�PM1m:?7Q(A10(A'>PT#�7N«&G6+.#?7LGJ1�7Q#�'&1?1�+g1m:�')-J3 7Y$&-�3 7Q#?: '>+.-�K/OJ')#�B[:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A')�:�+.$&-J1Q\H½�G65�5.Pl')G/:?$&(A'V:�+23Y1�PM1m:?7Q(A1@$)RS:?7Q-h#?7N1�:?#m+g3 :I:?O/7Y4/#?$DU6587Q(�B6$&(A'Z+8-l')-JBh')4/465.P�B6$&(A'Z+8-/�1m4J7N3�+F�}3O/7QG/#�+21�:�+23Q1Q\

ù�> ùQóQõ H ùfP*@A@�2�3Nó�\L�H7N1�+gB67N1I:�O/7�1�P/1�:?7Q(�3 $&(T4W$&-/7Q-{:I:?OJ'):YB67N'>521Ia0+.:?O�:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-J1QKJ'[1�P/1�:?7Q(¾(A'>P4/#?$)X&+2B67IR'&3�+F5�+.:�+.7N1dRS$&#b4/#?7Q:�:�P64/#�+.-6:�+.-/%h�$)RS:?7Q-*+8-l3 $&-/-/7N3 :�+.$&-�a0+.:?O�4J')# 1�+.-/%A')-JB[G/-/4J')#?:m+8-/%�¢C')-JB[RS$&#B6$M3 G/(T7Q-6:�'):m+8$D-�$)R�:?O/7�B67QXD7 58$D4/(T7Q-{:I4/#?$/3 7N1?1!�#�')-/%)+.-/%*R�#�$&(�5.$)ab��5.7QX&7 5^UW${$D;{;&7Q7Q46+.-/%h:?$*U/#?$)a�1�+.-/%:?O/7�B67N3�+21�+.$&-l:?#?7Q7Y#?7Q4/#?7N1m7Q-{:�+.-/%[:?O/7�B67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:IO6+g1m:?$&#Q¢�\

µVoZrMo J v�S=ö�w*P�S7wJõ��hùg@ õ7R)óNùùg@ õ7R&ï8û�R�S/óNïT2�özS=ö*Ifó�SL3gwWõ{ó[øTS=ö�w*P�S7wJõ/ù�\�]_O/7_3�O/$)+23 7b$)R/52')-/%DGJ')%&7N1 GJ1�7NB!+21�3�5.${1�7 5.P,#?7 52'):?7NBL:?$I:?O/704/#?$&U/�

587Q(µB6$&(['>+.-�$)RY'h:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-x1�PM1m:?7Q(�\he�1mPM1�:�7Q( (['NPl4/#?$)XD+2B67�1�7Q4J'V#�'):?7h£�|M� �Nt �C� r&zSt�o&v´')-JBzSr&pSw&�Nz_52')-/%&GJ')%&7N1�K=$&#»'Z5�5.$)aÍ:?O/7,B67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:�$)RH4/#?$D%&#�')(A1da0+.:?O6+.-�'[1�+.-/%)5.7&K�a0+2B67Q�1�4W7N3 :?#?G/(²5g'V-/�%&GJ')%&7&\�Á-´:?O/7[RS$&#?(*7Q#�3Q'&1�7&K©:?O/7�1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):m+8$D-´52')-/%&GJ')%D7T+21,$)RS:?7Q-´'�X&7Q#?P6�SO6+8%DO/��587QXD7 5!B67N1?3 #m+84/:m+8XD75g'V-/%&GJ')%&7&KH'V-JBk:?O/7[:�')#�%&7Q:Y52')-/%&GJ'V%&7�'l3 $&-6X&7Q-6:�+.$&-J'>5b4/#?$&%D#�')(T(,+.-/%¬5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7&K�adO/7Q#?7N'&1,'�a0+2B67Q�1�4J7N3 :?#�G/(±52')-/%DGJ')%&7A'&3Q3 $D(T$MB/'V:?7N1�'>5F5@587QXD7 5g1°$)Rb4/#?$&%&#�'V(T(,+.-/%hRS#?$&( �-/$&-/�S7 9/7N3 G/:�')U65.7)¢�1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q')�:�+.$&-J1YB6$)ab-l:?$h4/#?$&%&# ')(A1Q\,�&P/1�:?7Q([1I(A'>PhGJ1�7A'[:?O6+.#�B�52')-/%DGJ')%&7LR�$D#IR�$&#�(�G652'):m+8-/%kzSp�r&v�£2nQo&p q,r&zSt2oDvp�y6sF�Q£Y$&#�zSp�r&v�£2nQo&p q�rDzSt2o&vlr&sÜwDo&p�t�z�¤{qL£gìIbS/ó�S�ó.>A@ õ/ù�\beI%{'>+.-�K=:?O/7L#�')-/%&7L$)RCB/'):�'*:�P{4W7N1b$V·�7Q#�7NBhU6P�'A1�P/1�:?7Q(Ù+21d5F+8-/;D7NBl:?$,+.:�1I4/#?$DU6587Q(±B6$D(A'>+.-�\]�#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-h1�P/1�:?7Q(A1_(A'>PAOJ'>X&7,'L�/9M7NB�1�7Q:I$)R©B/'V:�',:�P{4W7N1QK/7&\W%J\.K/1�7Q:�1I')-JB¬(A')4J1QK/$D#�1�G/4/4J$D#?:GJ1�7Q#?�B67 �J-/7NBl'>5.%&7QU/#�'>+23LB/'):�'L:�P{4W7N1Q\

ö�2�ö*I�õ6óQõ`3 H ïSö�ï2ù H \�d$&-JB67Q:?7Q#�(,+.-6+g1m(¾+g1d')-[+.(T4J$&#�:�')-6:�'&1�4W7N3 :�$)R�',:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-h1�P/1�:?7Q(�\�Á�:�'>5F5.$)a�1:?O/7�4/#?$D%&#�')(T(*7Q#�:?$h'>X&$)+2Bh$)X&7Q#��1�4J7N3�+FRSP&+.-/%�'[4/#�$&U65.7Q(�<�:?O6+21I(A'>Ph;&7Q7Q4l4J'):�OJ1b:?$h')-l7 E�3�+.7Q-6:I+8(*�46587Q(*7Q-{:�'V:�+.$&-A$D4J7Q-�\5b$&-JB67Q:�7Q#?(,+.-6+21�(§(A'>P,UJ7Y7 9/465F+g3�+.:d+.-[R�$&#�(¼$)R^'*�Q¤{oDt2� ��o |/�Np�r&zSo&p©Û=$&#�+.(T465F+23�+.:+8-¬R�$D#?(�$)R_rDp¥¨�t2zSp�r&p ~T£Q�NsF� �NzSt�o&v7Û/7&\/%W\.KDR�#?$D(�'T1�7Q:N\

H S/ó)ô=õ H S/óNï$RfSJø@ù�2bP�ö*I�ö=õ/ùNù�\IÚI7Q4J7Q-JBD+.-/%[$&-[+.:�104/#?$&U65.7Q(�B6$D(A'>+.-�KJ'L:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-A1mPM1�:�7Q( (['NP[B67Q�4J7Q-JB[$&-�3 7Q#?: '>+.-A(A'V:?O/7Q(A'):�+23Q'>5�(T7Q:�O/$MB/1Q\©Á:@+21bB67N1�+.#�')U65.7YRS$&#0:?O/7N1�7Y(*7Q:?O/$MB/1@:?$,UW7�1�G/4/4J$&#�:?7NB[U{P'T1�$&G/-JB[:?O/7Q$D#?7Q:�+23Q'>5�UJ'&1�+g1�\

��

Page 27: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

¶�ßSÞ àa&�u&ãM)6ç�·;r�ã_ ����¼ëY'(lA&5øSã=è +�l�èé b·��]0O/7I%&${'>5=$)R�:?O/7L¹HÁ�"´1�PM1m:?7Q(Í+210:?$,B67N'>5�a0+.:?O[%&7Q-/7Q#�'>5�4/#?$&%D#�')(T(,+.-/%L4/#?$&U65.7Q(A1b')-JB*:?$T1�G/4/4W$&#?:0:?O/7IGJ1�7Q#'&1I(,GJ3�O¿'D1b4W${1?1�+.U65.7T+.-k(*7N3?OJ')-6+.ÀN')U65.7[:�'&1�;/1Q\Y]0O/7Q#?7°+g1I-/$[+.-6:?7Q-6:Y:?$A(*7N3?OJ')-6+.ÀQ7h')-6P�B67N3�+g1�+8$D-J1�B6G/#m+8-/%:?O/7T:�#�')-J1�RS$&#?(A'V:�+.$&-l4/#?$M3 7N1�1Q\l¹HÁ�"�+21,1�$�%D7Q-/7Q#�'>5C:�OJ'):I+.:�1L$&U/Î�7N3 :Y52')-/%&GJ')%D7&KH¹@Á�"��ª©K�B6$67N1�-/$D:�3 $&-6:�'>+.-')-6Ph4/#?7NB67 �J-/7NBkB/'): 'T:�P64J7N1Q\Ied5�5CB/'V:�'T:�P64J7N1Y')#�7�GJ1�7Q#?�B67 �J-/7NB=<�1�$D(T7�:�P64J7TB67 �J-6+.:�+.$&-J1Y(,+.%&O6:IUJ7,RS$&G/-JB+.-�'T1m:�')-JB/')#�B*5F+.U/#�')#�P&\

]_O/7�ed5.%&$&#�+.:?O/(,+23Q1b'V4/4/#?${'&3�OA:�#�+.7N1H:�$�4/G/:b4/#?$D%&#�')(T(°+8-/%!+.-{:?$T'L(A'):�O/7Q(A'):�+23Q'>5WR�#�'V(T7Qa0$&#?;,UJ'&1�7NB*$&-RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-�')4/465F+23Q'):�+.$&-�\´Û�O6+F5.7�'l(A'V:?O/7Q(A'):�+23�+2')-´(A'V-6+84/G652'):�7N1LR�$D#?(,G65g'D1QKH'�4/#?$&%&# ')(T(T7Q#,(A')-6+.4/G652'):?7N14/#?$&%D#�')(A1^+8-h:�O/7�1?')(T7Iab'NP&KD7 +.:?O/7Q#bGJ1�+.-/%T;6-/$)ab-A:�#�')-J1�RS$&#?(A'V:�+.$&-J1�$&#04/#?$)XD+.-/%T-/7Qa�#?7N1�G65.:�1Q\�Á�:0+210'�4/G/#�74J7Q-J3�+F5.�')-JB6�S4J')4W7N#�')4/4/#�${'&3�O�K/-/$A')G/:?$D(A'):�+.$&-[:�');&7N1@4652'&3 7&\0]0O6+21b1�7Q:�1_eb5.%&$&#m+8:�O/(,+23Q1�')4J'V#?:@R�#?$D( :�O/7Y:�a0$$&:?O/7Q#I')4/4/#?${'&3�O/7N1QK6abO6+23�O�1�:?#�$&-/%)5.PA7Q(*4/OJ'&1�+.ÀQ7T1�PM1m:?7Q(�1�G/4/4W$&#?:N\

¶_e»"@]I��+210(*$&#?7I4/#�')%&(A'V:�+23Q'>5F58P[$&#�+.7Q-6:?7NB=\�Á�:�1@4/#?$&U65.7Q(�B6$&(A'Z+8-[+210#�7N1�:?#�+23 :?7NB*:?$L�/9M7NB6�S4W$)+.-{:d7 9M4/#?7N1m�1�+.$&-J1!$ZXD7Q#Y4J$)a07Q#�1�7Q:I52'):?:�+23 7N1QK abO6+23�Ol+.:�')G/:�$&(A'):�+23Q'>5F5.Pk3 $&(T46+F5.7N1,:?$h7 E�3�+.7Q-6:NK�$VR�:?7Q-¿5�+.-/7N')#��S:�+.(T7T+.(T465.7Q�(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-J1�\H¶0eY"H]I�A'>521�$°R�$/3 GJ1�7N1d$&-h7N'&1�P[#?G/-6:�+.(T7�')-J'Z58P/1�+21d$)R�:?O/7,3 $MB67I+.:I4/#?$MB6GJ3 7N1�\

¶�ß$# qCY�ç&ã��Hæ�·Z&5·ZøZ·®çQå¹HÁ�"����[+21I7 9M:?7Q-J1�+8U65.7,+.-�1m7QX&7Q#�'>5�#�7N1�4J7N3 :�1�\�]0O/7�$DU/Î�7N3 :d52')-/%&GJ')%D7�+21I-/$&:d�/9/7NB=<W+8:�3Q'V-�UW7,#?7Q4652'&3 7NB=K�$&#d+.:3Q')-kUW7h7 9M:�7Q-JB67NBkU6P�+8-6:?#?$/B6GJ3�+.-/%k-/7Qa 3 $D-J1�:?#?GJ3 :�1!U{P¯:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-l:?$h%)+.X&7Q-x$&-/7N1Q\�]_O/7,5F+8U/# ')#?Pk$)R:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-[#?G65.7N1I3Q')-hUJ7L7 9M:?7Q-JB67NB=\

�)+.-J3 7hed5.%&$&#�+.:?O/(,+23Q1L+21,'h(['):?O/7Q(A'):m+g3Q'Z5HRS#�')(T7Qa0$&#?;=K=+.:T3Q')-kUW7h7 9M:�7Q-JB67NB�')#�U6+8:�#�')#�+F5.P&\�b7Qa :�P{4W7N1QK$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-J1QKW')-JB[:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J103Q')-hUW7�'&B/B67NB=\

eY1�'¬%&7Q-/7Q#�'>5F+.ÀN'):�+.$&-x$)R�1�7Q:�1L')-JB¯(A')4J1QK©¹C'>+C')-JBx"�'>+.%&7A3 $&-J1�+gB67Q#L�/9/7NB6�S4J$)+.-6:T:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J1dRS$&#')UJ1�:�#�'&3 :0RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1YB67 �J-/7NB�$&-h52'):�:�+23 7Q�S:?O/7Q$&#?7Q:�+23,B/'):�'°:�P64J7N1�\b½�+8-6+.:?7TBD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3�+.-/%h+21IB67 �J-/7NB�'VUJ1�:?#�'&3 :m58PRS$&#�')-6P�B/'):�'[:�P64J7&\[]0O/7T#?7Qab#m+8:�7°1mPM1�:�7Q(A1I+.-�¶0eY"H]»��3Q')-kUW7T7 9M:�7Q-JB67NBk:?$�3 $)X&7Q#�'DB/BD+8:m+8$D-J'>5C4/#?$DU6587Q(1�4W7N3�+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-J1Y')-JBhBD+F·�7Q#?7Q-{:m+g'VU6587,7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1�\�d7Qa¦:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J103Q')-hUW7�'&B/B67NB�'&10a07 5F5\

¶�ß$h á�'( ��Hæ�mQl�'/è_ =ç�·Zl��~�j·Z&5'( *'O·SãWæ, ����6v ��øSãWæÁ-�%&7Q-/7Q#�'>5K/:�#�')-J1�RS$&#?(A'V:�+.$&-T#?G65.7N1I3 $&-J1�+21�:b$)R +.-/4/G/:�:�7Q(T4652'):?7&K/$&G/:�4/G/:b:?7Q(T4652'):?7&KW')-JBh')4/465F+23Q')U6+F5�+.:�Pk3 $&-/�BD+.:�+.$&-�\

Á�-�¹@Á�" KD+8-/4/G/:I')-JBT$DG/:?4/G/:0:?7Q(T4652'):?7N10')#?7d4/#?$&%&#�'V( 1?3�O/7Q(T7N10')-JB*(A'>P,+.-J3�58GJB67,3 $&-6:?7 9M:@4J')#�')(*7Q:?7Q#�1Q\]0O/7L#?G65.7N1Y')#?7�$D#?%{')-6+.ÀQ7NBl'&1I'T%&7Q-/7Q# '):�+.X&7�1m7Q:NK/+\W7&\.K='A1�(['>5F5©1�7Q:I$)RH4W$Za07Q#�RSG65�#?G65.7N1IabO6+23�Ol(A'>PAUW7�GJ1m7NB+.-l:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-[7 9M4/#?7N1�1�+.$&-J1Q\�]_O/7°1m7Q:b$)RH#?G65.7N1d+21b7 9/:?7Q-J1�+.U65.7&K�4/#�$&U65.7Q(T�1�4J7N3�+F�}3[')-JB[RS#?7N«DG/7Q-{:m58PhGJ1m7NB#?G65.7N1d(A'>PTUJ7,'&B/B67NB=\

]�#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J1^+8-hed5.%&$&#�+.:?O/(°+g3Q1I')#?7I#?G65.7N1@RS$&#0:?O/7Y(A')-6+.4/G652'):�+.$&-�$)R^')4/465F+23Q'):�+.X&7L7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J1Q\0]0O/7#?G65.7N1[OJ'>X&7h:?O/7ó�}'NXD$&#T$)RY(A'):?O/7Q(['):�+23Q'>5b+2B67Q-6:�+.:�+.7N1Q\�eb5.%&$&#m+8:�O/(,+23Q1[:?#�+.7N1T:�$k;&7Q7Q4�#�G6587N1h'D1,%&7Q-/7Q#�'>5Y'&14J$61?1�+.U65.7°'V-JBh'NXD$)+2Bh')4/465F+g3Q'VU6+�5F+2:�Pl3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&-J1Q\

¶_e»"@]I��GJ1m7N1TBD+F·�7Q#�7Q-{:,;D+8-JB/1°$)R�:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J1Y'V:�:�O/7AX)')#�+.$&GJ1L4/OJ'&1�7N1,$VRd3 $D(T46+F5g'V:�+.$&-�\�½�+F9/7NB6�4J$V+8-6:�7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+8$D-J1�'V-JB�1m7Q:�7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1L')#?7T:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(T7NB¬:?$�')4/4/#?$&4/#m+g'V:?7T-/$&#?(['>5�R�$D#?(A1dGJ1�+.-/%�#�7Qab#�+.:?71�P/1�:?7Q(A1�\ j :?O/7Q#L:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-J1d5.7N'&B�RS#?$&(�')4/465F+g3Q'V:�+.X&7A:�$h+.:?7Q#�'):m+8XD7,R�$D#?(�K�')-JB¯:?$�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-{:m+g'Z5HRS$&#?(�\]0O/7Y#?G65.7N1I')#?7I+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:?7NB¬+.-h52')#?%&7�3Q'V:�'>5.$&%{1Q\

]_O/70R�$D#?(¼$)R=:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-,#?G65.7N1@OJ'&1�:�$�B6$�a_+8:�OA:?O/7d7 9M:?7Q-6:H$VR�(*7N3?OJ')-6+.ÀN'):m+8$D-�'L1�PM1m:?7Q(¼4/#?$)XD+2B67N1Q\�)+.-J3 7Yeb5.%&$D#�+.:?O/(,+23Q10+21@-/$&-/�')G/:�$&(A'):�+23)KD+.:�1@#?G65.7N1b')#?7d;&7Q4/:b'&1@%&7Q-/7Q#�'>5�'&1@4J${1?1�+8U65.7&K/:�O{GJ1@(A');D+.-/%L+8:d7N'&1�+.7Q#RS$&#Y:?O/7,GJ1�7Q#Y:?$h(A'V-6+84/G652'):�7T7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J1�'V-JB�R�$D#?(,G65g'D1Q\ e�$&#?7T1�4W7N3�+��}3*#?G65.7N1Ya_+8:�O�3 $&(T465F+23Q'):?7NBk'V4/465�+.�3Q')U6+F5F+.:�P�3 $D-JBD+8:m+8$D-J1�'&1©+.-k¹@Á�"��ª¿$&#�¶0eY"H]I�A3Q'Z5�5�R�$&#07 9/:?7Q-J1�+.X&7�1�P/1�:?7Q(¾1�G/4/4J$&#�:H+.-¬�J-JBD+8-/%h')4/4/#?$D4/#�+2'):?7#?G65.7N1I')-JBh3?O/7N3�;D+8-/%h3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&-J1Q\

Ð Ó

Page 28: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

¶�ßZ¶ w§ãL)6â� ���·#x7 =ç�·xl�� ���� ä^åHæVçVã�è ä���-5-�lA'Dç½/#�$&(�'I1�$)RS:�ab')#�7�7Q-/%)+.-/7Q7Q#�+.-/%Y4W$)+.-{:�$)R/XD+87QaLK>+8:�+21=+.(T4W$&#?:�'V-{: :?OJ'):�'d1�PM1m:?7Q(×'VG/:?$&(A'):�7^'&1�(A')-6PdR�G/-J3 :�+.$&-J1'&104W${1?1�+.U65.7T')-JB*5.7N'>X&7�:?$,:?O/7Y4/#�$&%&#�')(*(T7Q#0$&-65.Ph:�'&1�;/1@abO6+23?Ol#?7N«DG6+.#?7Y+.-6:?G6+.:�+.$&-�\

¹@Á�"f:?#�+.7N1d:?$A4/#�$ZXD+2B67�7 9J'&3 :�5.P�:�O6+g1�\Y¹HÁ�"����A;D7Q7Q4J1I:?#�'&3�;A$VRH:?O/7�3 $&(*46587Q:�7°B67QXD7 58$D4/(T7Q-{:YO6+21�:�$&#?Ph$)RH'4/#?$&%D#�')(�\*Á:T'&1?1�+21�: 1Y:?O/7TGJ1m7Q#Y+.-´X&7Q#�+FRSP&+.-/%k')4/465F+23Q')U6+F5�+.:�P�3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&-J1,$VRC:?#�'V-J1�R�$D#?(A'):�+.$&-J1Y'V-JBk#?7Qad#�+.:?7N14/#?$&%D#�')(�46+.7N3 7N1Y'>R�:�7Q#_'V4/4658PD+.-/%h:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J1Q\

ed5.%&$&#�+.:?O/(°+g3Q1�KJ$&-�:?O/7�$D:?O/7Q#�OJ'V-JB=KJ4/#?$)XD+2B67N1I-/$A(T7N3�OJ')-6+.ÀN'):�+.$&-�\Iý�1�+8-/%[:?O/7Leb5.%&$&#m+8:�O/(,+23Q1Y(T7Q:?O/$/B6�$)5.$&%&Ph3Q')-hUW7�3 $&(T4J'V#?7NB[:?$A',(['):?O/7Q(A'):m+g3�+2')-zyð10a0$&#?;TabO/7Q-l1�+.(T465F+FR�PD+.-/%�')#�+.:?O/(T7Q:�+23»R�$&#�(�G652'&1�\

�@PhB67N'>5F+.-/%ha0+.:?O�(T$D#?7�1�4J7N3�+F�}3,4/#�$&U65.7Q(A1QK=¶0e»"@]I�T+21I')U65.7�:?$[3 $&(T46+F5.7�RSG65F5.P�')G/:?$D(A'):�+23Q'>5F5.P�'T1�4W7N3 �+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-k:�$�')-l7 E�3�+.7Q-{:!+8(*46587Q(*7Q-{:�'V:�+.$&-�\TÁ�-k7N'&3�O¿3 $D(T46+F5g'V:�+.$&-k4/OJ'&1�7&K�4/#?$&%&# ')(�46+.7N3 7N1,')#?7,#?7Qad#�+.:?:?7Q-(T7N3�OJ')-6+23Q'>5F5.P&\

]_O/7Q#?7I+21�',:�#�'&B67Q$)·lUJ7Q:�a07Q7Q-�%&7Q-/7Q#�'Z5�+.:�P�')-JB¬(T7N3?OJ'V-6+8ÀN'V:�+.$&-�\C�@Ph#?7N1m:?#�+23 :�+.-/%T:?O/7L4/#?$&U65.7Q(­B6$D(A'>+.-�K1�4W7N3�+��}3L;6-/$)a05.7NB6%&7�3Q')-hUW7Y+.-J3 $&#?4W$&#�'):�7NB[+.-{:�$T:?O/7�1�P/1�:?7Q(�'V-JB[GJ1�7NBh:?$[')G/:?$&(A'V:?7»B67N1�+8%D-�B67N3�+21�+.$&-J1Q\

¶�ß�� ä�-�ãM)7·;:�)7 =ç�·Zl�� ���� á� *'��^ã�ça�� ������� ���ãJæ¹HÁ�"��ª�K):?O/7b1�: ')-JB/')#�BL$&U/Î�7N3 :�5g'V-/%&GJ')%&70$)R ¹HÁ�" K>+21�'Ia0+2B67Q�1�4J7N3 :�#?G/(Í52')-/%&GJ'V%&704/#?$)X&+2BD+.-/%�3 $&-J1m:?#?GJ3 :�1�RS#?$&(1�4W7N3�+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-´5.7QX&7 5�B6$)ab-k:?$l3 $&-6:?#?$)5.�S$&#�+.7Q-6:?7NB¯5.7QX&7 5\k�)+.-J3 7¯¹HÁ�"©�ª´+21,'l1?3�O/7Q(T7T52')-/%DGJ')%&7[abO/${1�7hB/'):�':�P{4W7N1�3Q')-¯UJ7h'&B/')4/:?7NBl:�$�:?O/7T4/#�$&U65.7Q( UW7 +.-/%¿1m$)5.X&7NB=K�+8:!+21YRSG65F5.Pk%&7Q-/7Q#�'>5\ j -/7[1�O/$&G652Bx-/$&:?7,:?OJ'):L:?O/7$&U/Î�7N3 :052')-/%&GJ'V%&7I+.-k¹HÁ�"x+21b-/$D:0�/9M7NB=<W')-{Ph'>5.%&7QU/#�'Z+g3Q'Z5�5.PlB67 �J-/7NBh52')-/%DGJ')%&7Y(A'>P[UJ7�GJ1m7NB=\

]_O/7Yeb5.%&$&#m+8:�O/(,+23Q1d5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7,3 $&-J1�+21�:�10$VR©')4/465F+23Q'):�+.X&7,7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1I$)X&7Q#bB/'): ',$&U/Î�7N3 :�1b')-JB�R�G/-J3 :m+8$D-J1Q\d7Qa³$DU/Î�7N3 : 1C'V-JBT$&4W7Q#�'):�+.$&-J1@(A'>PTUW7�B67 �J-/7NB*+.-h:?7Q#?(A1@$)R�%V+8XD7Q-A$&-/7N1@GJ1�+.-/%T7N«DGJ'>5F+.:�+.7N1Q\b½/G/-J3 :m+8$D-J10(A'>PUJ7L4J$)5.P6(T$&#?4/O6+23)\

¶_e»"@]I�ABD+21�:�+.-/%&G6+21�O/7N1IUJ7Q:�a07Q7Q-�1�4W7N3�+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-�5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7�')-JB[: ')#?%&7Q:@52')-/%&GJ')%D7&\H"�#?$DU6587Q([1b')#?7Y1�4J7N3�+.��J7NB¬+.-k�7¤ Ù K�'[�O0@]bª=��5F+.;&7,RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5 5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7La0+.:?Oh�/9/7NB6�S4J$)+.-6:Y7 9M4/#�7N1?1�+.$&-J1Q\I]0O/7�¶0eY"H]»�¬3 $D(T46+F587Q#4/#?$/B6GJ3 7N1,¶0e�e 3 $MB67&\[Á�-{:?7Q#�(T7NBD+2'):?7h1�:?7Q4J1LGJ1�7h�7¤ Ù +.-´abO6+23?O´B67N1?3 #�+.4/:�+.X&7�3 $&-J1m:?#?GJ3 :�1IOJ'>X&7TUW7Q7Q-´#?7Q�4652'&3 7NBhU6P[+.:?7Q#�'):m+8XD7Y$&-/7N1Q\

Á�-�'h1�P/1�:?7Q(±1�GJ3�O�'&1Y¶_e»"@]I�JK�abO6+23�OlRSG65�5.Pk(*7N3?OJ')-6+23Q'>5F5.P´3 $&(T46+F5.7N1�'h1m4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-x:?$�'[4/#?$&%D#�')(�K+.:,+21T'�%&$6$MB¿+2B67N'k:?$�OJ'>X&7�1m7Q4J')#�'):?7h1�4W7N3�+��}3Q'V:�+.$&-¦')-JBk: ')#?%&7Q:L52')-/%&GJ')%D7N1Q\lÁ-î¹HÁ�"Í')-JBxed5.%&$&#�+.:?O/(°+g3Q1B67N1�+.%&-lB67N3�+g1�+8$D-J1�')#�7�(A'DB67YU{PT:�O/7YGJ1�7Q#N\0ºI#�'&B6GJ'>5F5.P&K/4J')#?: 1H$VR�:?O/7Y4/#?$&%D#�')( 'V#?7�#�7Q465g'D3 7NBhU6PT5.$)a07Q#?��5.7QX&7 53 $&-J1�:�#?GJ3 :�1�'&1 a07b')4/4/#?${'D3?OT')-L+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-�K6abO6+F5.7�$D:?O/7Q#�4J')#?:�1 #�7Q(A'>+.-TG/-J3�OJ')-/%&7NB=\ e¦1�+.-/%)5.7�$&U�Î�7N3 :52')-/%&GJ')%D7�'>5F58$)a�1IBD+F·�7Q#?7Q-{:I1�:�')%&7N1_$)R�:?O/7,B67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:b:?$A3 $67 9{+21�:d+.-�$&-/7Y4/#�$&%&#�')(�\

¶�ß#" +� =ç� ³á°å�-�ãWæ¹HÁ�"Í'>5F58$)a�1°:?O/7AGJ1m7Q#�:�$¿1m4J7N3�+FR�P´')-6P�'>5.%&7QU/#�'Z+g3[:�P64J7[U{Px1�:�'):�+.-/%�+.:�1L$&U/Î�7N3 :�1,')-JB¯$&4J7Q#�'V:�+.$&-J1T')-JB¯:?O/74/#?$&4W7Q#?:�+.7N1Y:�OJ'):YO/$)52BlUJ7Q:�a07Q7Q-k:?O/7Q(�\[�&GJ3?O�'�1�4J7N3�+F�}3Q'):m+8$D-k+21Y7 ·�7N3 :�+.X&7*$&-65.P�+FRb:?O/7TGJ1m7Q#NK=+.-�'&B/BD+.:�+.$&-�K+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�1,'h(T$/B67 5C$)Rb:?O/7*:�P64J7&K�+\�7&\gK�7 9/465�+23�+.:�5.P´4/#?$&%D#�')(A1I:?O/7*$&4J7Q#�'V:�+.$&-J1,1�GJ3?O¯:?OJ'):�:�O/7A1�4J7N3�+F�J7NB4/#?$&4W7Q#?:�+.7N1dO/$)52B=\C]@P64J7N10(A'>PTUW7�3 $&(,U6+.-/7NB�O6+.7Q#�')#�3�O6+23Q'>5F58P&\

e�1�+.(,+F52')#k3 $&-J3 7Q4/:h+21hGJ1m7NB�U{Pf:?O/7ked5.%&$&#�+.:?O/(,+23Q1�%&#?$DG/4�\ ]@P64J7N1�'V#?7kB67 �J-/7NB¦U6P³1�4W7N3�+FR�PD+.-/%�+.:�1$&U/Î�7N3 :�1QK�$&4J7Q#�'V:�+.$&-J1QK�')-JB�5g'>a�1�\bed58%D$&#�+.:?O/(,+23Q1YB6$67N1b-/$&:I#?7N«DG6+.#?7,:�P64J7N1I:�$TUJ7L+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:?7NB=K=+.:I#?7N«&G6+.#?7N1:?O/7,7 96+g1m:?7Q-J3 7T$)Rb'[:?7Q#?(T�S%&7Q-/7Q# '):?7NBh(*$MB67 5H$)Rb'T:�P64J7&\Le¼:�P64J7,O6+.7Q#�')#�3�O{Pl3Q')-lUJ7,RS$&#?(*7NB�'DB/BD+8-/%h(*$&#?752'>a�10:?$A'L%)+.X&7Q-�:�P{4W7&\

¶_e»"@]I��GJ1�7N1@1�7Q:�1H'V-JB,(A')4J1@'&1HB/'): 'I:�P64J7N1�\�el')-6P,4/#�'&3 :�+23Q'>5J4/#�$&U65.7Q(A103Q')-TUJ7dRS$&#?(,G652'):?7NBL+.-[:?7Q#?(A1$)RH1�7Q:�1QK�(A')4J1QK/')-JB��/9M7NB6�S4W$)+.-{:Y7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1�\C]0O6+21d#?7N1�:?#m+g3 :m+8$D-h(A');&7N1@+.:I4J${1�1�+.U6587,:?$*4/#?$)X&+2B67�'VG/:?$&(A'):m+g3+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:�'):�+.$&-�$)R^:�O/7�B/'):�'L:�P64J7N1Q\

Ð �

Page 29: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

¶�ß�{ �dl����0ã�çVãM'/è½·���·Sæ6è¹HÁ�"��ªî4/#?$)X&+2B67N1[')-�')#?U6+.:?#�'V#?P{���J-6+.:?7Q�3�O/$)+23 7l$&4J7Q# '):?$&#,abO6+23�O³')4/465F+.7N1[:?$´�-/$D-/��R�G/-J3 :�+.$&-J'Z5�¢,XZ'Z58G/7N1�\³]�$'>X&$)+2B,1�7Q(A')-6:�+230BD+FE�3 G65.:�+.7N1QK6�J-6+.:?7�3�O/$)+23 7bUJ7Q:�a07Q7Q-,RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J1 +21 -/$&:�4W7Q#?(,+.:?:?7NB=\@]0O/7b'&B/BD+.:�+.$&-J'>5�3 $D(T4/#?7Q�O/7Q-J1�+.X&7Q�3�O/$)+23 7,7 9M4/#?7N1�1�+.$&-l-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#?(,+.-6+21�:�+23Q'>5F5.Pk3?O/$6${1�7N1d1�$&(T7Y$&U�Î�7N3 :0:?OJ'):I1?'):�+21��J7N1b'°4/#?7NBD+23Q'):?7&\

]_O/7Yeb5.%&$&#m+8:�O/(,+23Q1b%&#�$&G/4hOJ'&10-/$&:dP&7Q:�B67N3�+2B67NB�abO/7Q:?O/7Q#I:?$T'>5F58$)aÍ')-h7 9/465�+23�+.:�3�O/$)+23 7�$&4W7Q#�'):?$&#d$&#b:?$'>5F5.$)aÍ-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#?(,+.-6+21�(²+8-JBD+.#?7N3 :m58P¯:?O/#?$&G/%&Ok1�7Q:Y3 $&-J1�:�#?GJ3 :�+.$&-l$&-65.P&\�Á�:I+21d5�+.;&7 5.Pk:�OJ'):»'[3�O/$)+23 7T$&4J7Q# '):?$&#a0+F5F5CUW7,+.-J3 $&#?4J$D#�'):?7NB�+.-k:�O/7�52')-/%DGJ')%&7&\T]0O6+21�3�O/$)+23 7T$&4W7Q#�'):?$D#»3 $&G652B¯UJ7A'V-¿'V#?U6+.:?#�')#?P6�3�O/$)+23 7T$&4J7Q# '):?$&#'&1@+.-¯¹HÁ�"©�ªk$&#b')-�$&4J7Q# '):?$&#0:?OJ'):bB67Q-/$&:�7N1�1�$D(T7�B67 �J-6+.:?7&KJU/G/:dG/-J1�4J7N3�+F�J7NB=K�1m7 587N3 :m+8$D-�$&4W7Q#�'):?$&#>\

Á�-k¶0e»"@]I�JK=-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#�(,+.-6+g1m(±+21I7 9/4/#?7N1?1�7NB¿:?O/#?$&G/%&Ok')#�U6+8:�#�')#?P�1�7 5.7N3 :�+.$&-¯RS#?$&(�'h1�7Q:»'V-JBk')#?U6+.:?#�'V#?P1�7N')# 3?Oh:?O/#�$&G/%&O�'T1�7Q:>\^]_O6+g1I'>X&$)+2B/10#?7N1m:?#�+23 :�+.-/%A:�O/7Y$&#�B67Q#0+.-�adO6+g3�O�:�O/7�1�$)5.G/:�+.$&-�1m7Q:0+21b%&7Q-/7Q# '):?7NB=\

]_O/7H'&B6XZ')-6:�')%D7H$)RJ'>X&$)+2BD+.-/%�7 9/465F+g3�+.:@-/$&-JB67Q:?7Q#?(,+.-6+21�(�+21 'b1�+.(T465.7Q#H1�7Q(A')-6:�+23Q1�$)RM:�O/7H$&U/Î�7N3 :=52')-/%&GJ'V%&7&\�d$Za07QX&7Q#>K@R�G/-J3 :�+.$&-¦')-JBf$&U�Î�7N3 :hB67 �J-6+.:�+.$&-J1�-/7Q7NB�:�$�UW7k7 9M:�7Q-JB67NB�UW7QP&$&-JB�7N«DGJ'):�+.$&-J'Z5»4/#?7NBD+23Q'):�7N1h:?$%&7Q-/7Q#�'Z5�1�7Q:�(T7Q(,UW7Q#�1�O6+.4�4/#�7NBD+g3Q'V:?7N1Q\�ª�7Q:?:�+.-/%�:?O/7k3?O/$)+23 7x$&4J7Q# '):?$&#�B67Q-/$&:�7�'�B67 �J-6+.:?7&KYG/-J1m4J7N3�+F�J7NB1�7 5.7N3 :�+.$&-h$&4W7Q#�'):?$D#C'>521�$,#?7N1�G65.:�1©+.-�1�+.(T465.7Q#�1�7Q([')-{:m+g3Q1�K{U/G/:b3 7Q#?: '>+.-T52'>a�1d�7&\&%W\.K{3 $&(*(�G/: '):�+.X&+.:�PW¢�(A'>P,-/$5.$&-/%&7Q#bUW7�X)'>5F+gB=\0Û¯7YUJ7 5F+.7QX&7,:?OJ'):b:?O/7Y:�O6+8# B�')4/4/#?$6'&3?O�KD+\/7&\.KW'>5F58$)a0+.-/%h')-�')#?U6+.:?# ')#?P6�3?O/$)+23 7L$&4J7Q#�'V:?$&#NKV+g1(T$&#�7»')4/4/#�$&4/#�+2'):?7&K6UJ7N3Q'VGJ1�7�$&-/7Y3Q')-�B67QX&7 5.$&4�',1�P/1�:?7Q(�$)R�B67N1�+.#�')U65.7�4/#?$D4J7Q#?:�+.7N10$VR�:?O/7�3�O/$)+23 7Y$&4J7Q#�'V:?$&#N\�&7Q(A')-6:�+23h4/#�$&U65.7Q(A1h3Q')-�UW7�'>X&$)+2B67NB U{P´#?7N1m:?#�+23 :�+.-/%�:�O/7�3�O/$)+23 7�$D4J7Q#�'):�$&#T:?$�'x3�O/$)+23 7�UJ7Q:�a07Q7Q-�-/$&-/�RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5�X)'>5.G/7N1Q\

¶�ß�| w" =ç6â©ã�èÅ =ç�·Z)7 *ø!ä�l��5���×�HãJæ&æ]0O/7�¹HÁ�" %&#?$&G/4¯(A'&B67�'hU6+.%k7 ·�$&#�:�:?$l4/G/:,:?O/7 +.#Ta0$&#?;l$&-´'l1�$)5F+2Bx(A'):?O/7Q(A'V:�+23Q'>5CUJ'&1�+g1�\k"�')#?:�$VR�:?O/7'&3 :�+.XD+.:�+.7N1I+.-k:?O/7*¹HÁ�"�4/#�$&Î�7N3 :�ab'&1d:?O/7TB67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:�$)RH:�#�')-J1�RS$&#?(A'V:�+.$&-J'>5^1�7Q([')-{:m+g3Q1dRS$&#L¹HÁ�"©�ª´')-JBl'5.$&%)+23Q'>5b3Q'>523 G658GJ1L$)R04/#?$&%&# ')(�:�#�')-J1�RS$&#?(A'V:�+.$&-J10RS$&#L¹HÁ�"©���J\�Á�-�'&B/BD+.:�+.$&-�K�:�O/7T%&#?$&G/4�RS$&#?(A'Z5�5.PlB67QX&7 5.$&4J7NB:?O/7Y7 96+21�:�+.-/%A4/#�$&:?$&:�P64J7Y$)R0¹HÁ�"©���TGJ1�+.-/%A:�O/7T¹HÁ�"´(T7Q:?O/$/B6$)5.$&%&P&\el'):�O/7Q(A'):�+23Q'>5J1�$&G/-JB6-/7N1?1©+21H'V-,+.(T4J$&#�:�')-6: +g1�1�G/7b+.-[:?O/7ba0$&#?;Y$VR�:�O/7beb5.%&$D#�+.:?O/(,+23Q1@%&#?$&G/4�\�eb5.:?O/$&G/%DO3 7Q#?:�'Z+8-[B67N3�+g1�+8$D-J1C'VUJ$&G/:�-/$&-JB67Q:�7Q#?(,+.-6+21�( ')-JB*1�7Q(A')-6:�+23Q1 OJ'>X&70-/$&:�P&7Q:�UJ7Q7Q-*(A'&B67&K):?O/7QPT')#?7b3 $&-J1�+gB67Q#�7NB:?$TUW7YX&7Q#?P*+.(T4J$&#�:�')-6:N\

]_O/7h:?O/7Q$&#�+.7N1*G/-JB67Q#�5.P&+.-/%�¶0eY"H]I�JK^+®\@7&\.K �J-6+.:?7kBD+F·�7Q#?7Q-J3�+.-/%Ï'V-JBx�/9/7NB6�S4J$)+.-6:A:?O/7Q$D#?PkRS$&#,52'):�:�+23 7N1QKOJ'>X&7IUJ7Q7Q-�B67QXD7 58$D4J7NB¬R�$D#?(A'>5F5.P&\�eY1@R®'V#_'D1H:�O/7�1�PM1m:?7Q(�+.:�1�7 5FR�%&${7N1�K/:?O/7I7Q(T4/OJ'&1�+21_+g1_(T$&#?7Y$&-[4/#�')%D(A'):�+23+21?1�G/7N1d:?OJ')-h$&-[RS$&#?(['>5F+8:�P&\

¶�ßà�} é�l���)7ø��Hæ�·Zl��Á: +21�BD+FE�3 G65.:H:�$�3 $&(T4J')#�7_1mGJ3?OTBD+F·�7Q#?7Q-{:�')4/4/#?$6'&3?O/7N1 :�$b:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J'>564/#?$&%&#�'V(T(,+.-/%J\�eI-,7QXZ'>5.GJ'):m+8$D-a0$&G652B[O6+.%&O65.P�B67Q4J7Q-JBh$D-AabOJ'V:Ca07Ia0$&G652B[7N1�:�')U65F+21�O�'&1@:?O/7Y%&$6'>5}$)R :?O/7Y:?#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J'>5J(*7Q:?O/$MB6$V58$D%&P&\ÁSR0a07�ab')-6:b:?$hB67QX&7 5.$&4k'T(A'V:?O/7Q(A'):�+23Q'>5HBD+21?3�+.465F+8-/7h$VRH4/#?$&%&#�'V(T(,+.-/%,+.-JB67Q4J7Q-JB67Q-6:,$)RH4/#�')%&(['):�+23I+21?1�G/7N11�GJ3�OT'&1=52')#�%&7b1?3Q'>5.704/#?$&%&#�'V(T(,+.-/%JK>:?O/7bBD+8#�7N3 :�+.$&-A3�O/${1�7Q-,U{PY:�O/7Ced5.%&$&#�+.:?O/(°+g3Q1 %D#?$&G/4T1�7Q7Q(A1 ')4/4/#?$&4/#m+g'V:?7&\ÁSR?K/$&-[:?O/7Y$&:�O/7Q#COJ'V-JB=K/a07Y;{-/$)a�:?OJ'):0a07»'V#?7�B67N'>5F+.-/%A(A'Z+8-65.Pha0+.:?O�'L#?7N1m:?#�+23 :?7NBh3�52'&1?10$VR�4/#?$&U65.7Q(A1d:?OJ'):a07bab')-6:�:?$Y:?#?7N'): +.-h'I4/#�')%&(['):�+23)K&(T7N3�OJ')-6+.ÀQ7NB[ab'>P&K):?O/7�¶0eY"H]I�,')4/4/#?${'&3�O,+21@a07 5�5.�1�G6+.:?7NB=\d¹H$&-J1�+gB67Q#m+8-/%')%{'Z+8-�$&G/#[+.-6+.:�+2'>5T(T$&:m+8X)'):�+.$&-�Kd4/#?$)X&+2BD+.-/%¦'x:?#�')-J1�RS$&#?(['):�+.$&-J'>5»3 $D(T4J$&-/7Q-6:h$)RT'x%&7Q-/7Q#�'>5�4/#?$D:?$&:�P{46+.-/%1�P/1�:?7Q(�K6a07IaC$DG65gB*5.$6$&;*R�$&#b',1�P/1�:?7Q(�abO6+23�OhUJ$&:?OhOJ'D1C'°%&7Q-/7Q#�'>5�4/#?$&U65.7Q(�B6$D(A'>+.-�')-JB[$)·�7Q#�1©7 9M:?7Q-J1�+8XD71�P/1�:?7Q(Í1�G/4/4J$D#?:H'&1�R®')# '&1 :?O/7HGJ1m7Q#�7Q-{XD+.#?$&-/(T7Q-6:�+21�3 $&-J3 7Q#�-/7NB=\�Ûk7@R�7Q7 5/:?OJ'): :?O/7d¹HÁ�"l%D#?$&G/4Y+21�R'&3�+.-/%Y:?O/7#�+.%&O6:»BD+.#?7N3 :m+8$D-�'&1_R®')#I'&1b:�O/7°B67N1m%)+.-�$VRH:?O/7�a0+2B67Q�1�4W7N3 :?#?G/(²5g'V-/%&GJ')%&7T')-JB¬:?O/7�:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-�1�PM1m:?7Q(%&$67N1Q\��d$)aC7QXD7Q#NKJ4/# ')%&(A'):m+g3!+21?1�G/7N1L1�O/$&G652BlUW7�%V+8XD7Q-k(T$&#?7,a07 +.%&O6:N<=:?O/7T1�P/1�:?7Q(±1�O/$&G652Bl4/#�$ZXD+2B67T'*5g'V#?%&75F+.U/#�')#?P´$)RIRS#?7N«&G/7Q-6:�5.P´GJ1�7NBf1�:�')-JB/')# B´B/'):�'l:�P64J7N1QKb'k3 $D(,R�$D#?:�')U65.7l�S+.(T465.7Q(T7Q-6:?7NBW¢,GJ1�7Q#A7Q-6XD+8#�$&-/(T7Q-6:NK

Ð �

Page 30: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

R�3)ï.óQõ73)ïT2�ö � â { �hø[wL2�3Zïgó)ô H ï�R&ù �Y�X{ s ¹o{¨��Q� �NzSt��N�Q£ %&7Q-/7Q#�'>5 4/#?$&%&#�'V(T(,+.-/% (A'V:?O/7Q(A'):�+23Q'>5=RS#�')(T7Qa0$&#�; 1mG/4J7Q#�3 $&(*46+�5.7Q#Ô&o&q,r&t�v %&7Q-/7Q#�'>5 RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5 �/9/4J$)+.-6:�7 9/4/#?7N1?1�+.$&-J1�Q�)zS�Nv/£QtS¨Qt�s�t�zS~ 52')-/%DGJ')%&7N1QK/#�G6587N1 G/-/#�7N1�:?#�+23 :?7NB #?G65.7N1zSp�r&v/£�n¥oDp�q,r&zSt�o&v/£ %D7Q-/7Q#�'):�+.X&7,1�7Q: (A')-6GJ'>5 3Q'):�'>5.$&%p�y6sF�Q£ +.-/4/G/:NKW$&G/:?4/G/:NKW3 $&-JBD+.:�+.$&- %&7Q-/7Q#�'>5 #�7Qab#�+.:?7Y#?G65.7N1q,����¤{r&vJtguQr&zSt2oDv 1m7Q(,+.�')G/:?$&(A'V:�+23 -/$&-/7 ')G/:?$D(A'):�+23£¥~>£QzS�Nq £QyQ|&|/o&p z 5�+.(,+.:?7NB -/$&-/7 7 9/:?7Q-J1�+.X&7sFr&v{wDy{rNwD�Q£ a0+2B67Q�1�4W7N3 :?#?G/(�K�1?3�O/7Q(T7N1 RSG/-J3 :�+.$&-J'>5 �O0H]bª¿a0+.:?Oh�/9/4J$)+.-6:�1zS~�|M�Q£ ')UJ1�:�#�'&3 :NK6'>5.%&7QU/#�'>+23 'Z58%D7QU/#�'>+23 1�7Q:�1b')-JB¬(A')4J1vJo&vWÔ&�NzS�>p�q,t�vJtg£¥q 'V#?U6+.:?#�')#?Ph3�O/$)+23 7 XZ')#�+.$&GJ1 1m7 587N3 :m+8$D-�RS#?$&(§1�7Q:

] ')U65.7� /i�0©XZ'>5.GJ'):m+8$D-�$)RH]�# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-��&P/1�:?7Q(A1»� j X&7Q#?XD+.7QaY¢')-JBT'»5F+8U/# ')#?PT$)R�')G/:�$&(A'):?7NBL:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-J1�1�GJ3?O['&1 +.-h¶0e»"@]I�YRS$&#C3 7Q#�:�'>+.-Ta07 5F58�SG/-JB67Q# 1�:?$6$MB[4/#?$DU6587Q(B6$&(A'Z+8-J1�\

�XR�~ ö�27UAø.õ7Ibw H õWö/óNùÁ�a0$&G652BL5F+.;&7b:?$I:?OJ')-/;,¶0$&UW7Q#?:HÚI7Qab')#�RS$&# +.-6+.:�+2'>5�1mG/%&%&7N1�:�+.$&-J1�'V-JB�%DG6+gB/'V-J3 7b:?O/#?$&G/%DO/$&G/:�:�O/7_1mG/#?X&7QP=<{�@$&U"�'>+.%&7LRS$&#�X)'>5.GJ')U65.7A3 $&(T(*7Q-{:�1d$&-l:?O/7,4J')4W7Q#N<�')-JB¬(,PhRS#�+.7Q-JB/1Y')-JB¬R�7 5F5.$)a 1�:?GJB67Q-6:�1I½/#�'V-J3 $lº»'&1�4W7Q#?$&-6+')-JBXel')#�3 $[" 7 5�5.7Q%&#m+8-6+ RS$&#b:?O/7 +.#b(T$D#�'>5�1�G/4/4J$D#?:N\3¼Å=7NÅ0��Åd���HÅ5Í��� Ñ �&Ò&')¡�½0\�ª�\H�0')G/7Q#*7Q:A'>5\Gë�¤{�XBly{vWt2��¤k�Cp�o´�Q� �Nz,ò�Ã?��ì��Wo&sFy{q,�óÃ�ä1ë�¤{��Áht�Ô&�Cº&|/���>zSp�y6q®Â�r&v{wDy{r>w&�

ò�Ã?�@ÖxÂ�K{XD$)5.G/(T7 � �& L$)R5Â����>zSy{p���ÀYo&zS��£�t2vxòHo&qd|}y6zS�Np�º}�>t2�>vJ� �N\��&4/#m+8-/%D7Q#?�Z²�7Q#�52')%JK=�@7Q#�5F+8-�K � �&�&Ò/\���0Ñ �&Ò)U/¡�¶@+23�OJ')#�Bl�©+8# Bh7Q:�'>5\�eÍ3 $&(T(*$&-hUJ'&1�+21@RS$&#�'>5.%&$D#�+.:?O/(,+23�1�4W7N3�+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-k')-JBhB67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:N\@Á�½ Á�"

Û¦º Ð \ � Û¯$&#?;D+8-/%[4J')4W7Q#be»¶�-I� /K � �&�&Ò/\��� Ñ �6ÓZ')¡�½0\�ª�\H�0')G/7Q#*7Q:°'Z5®\Gë�¤6�XB�y6vJt��Q¤x�Cp�o´�Q� �Nz,ò�Ã?��ìC�JoDs�y6q,�XÃQÃ�ä1ë�¤6�h�Cp�o w&p�r&qÕëJp�r&v/£�n¥oDp�q,r&zSt�o&vº}~>£QzS�Nq�ò�Ã?�@Öxº=KNX&$V58G/(*7 Ð �& I$)RAÂ�� �NzSy6p��5À»oDzS�Q£bt2v�òHo&qd|}y6zS�Np׺}�>t2�>vJ� �N\ �&4/#�+.-/%&7Q#��Z²�7Q#�52')%JK/�@7Q#�5F+8-�K

� �&�6Ó6\���0Ñ �6ÓNU/¡�¶@+23�OJ')#�B �J\��©+.#�B�7Q:�'Z5®\¾]0a0$´7 9M7Q# 3�+g1m7N1hRS$&G/-JBf+.-�' UJ$6$&;�$&-¦'>5.%&$&#�+.:?O/(°+g3Q1�\�Á�-�ª�')(,UW7Q#?:e�7Q7Q#?:?7Q-J1QK=7NBD+.:?$&#>K��Cp�o w&p�r&qʺ&|M� �Nt �C� r&zSt�o&vlr&vJÔ�ëJp�r&v/£�n¥oDp�q,r&zSt�o&vJ\�0 521�7QXD+.7Q#T�{3�+.7Q-J3 7h"�G/U65F+21�O/7Q#�1

�I\ç²�\���b$D#?:?O/��d$)5F5g'V-JBW¢�K � �&�MÓ{\���©+.#�� � ¡�¶@+23?OJ'V#�B,�J\N�©+.#�B=\ eI-Y+.-{:�#?$MB6GJ3 :m+8$D-�:?$b:�O/7�:?O/7Q$&#?PI$)R65�+21�: 1Q\�]�7N3?O/-6+23Q'>5J#�7Q4J$&#?:>K j 9{RS$&#�BYýd-6+.X&7Q#�1�+.:�P

¹H$&(T4/G/:m+8-/%[ª�')UJ$D#�'):?$&#�P&\J"�#?$D%&#�')(T(°+8-/%T¶07N1m7N')#�3�Olº�#?$&G/4�K � �&� � \�F¹C"@�&�)¡�Ý>+2')ÀQO/7Q-´¹C'Z+^')-JBl¶0$&UW7Q#?:�"�'>+.%&7&\�"©#?$&%&# ')(§ÚI7Q#�+.XZ'):�+.$&-¯U{P�½�+F9/7NB6�" $)+.-{:,¹H$D(T4/G/:�'):�+.$&-�\b]�7N3�O/�

-6+23Q'>5H#?7Q4J$D#?:NKWÁ��5e ¶_7N1�7N')#�3�O�Úd+.XD+g1�+8$D-�K�]Y\=Ý/\WÛ�'):�1�$D-�¶07N1�7N'V#�3?Ox¹H7Q-6:?7Q#NK � �&�D�/\b]�$�'V4/4J7N')#d+.-#?7QXD+g1m7NB[RS$&#?(�+.-�º=�Nt��NvW���Yo�nL�Cp�o�wDp�r&q,q�t�v{wD\

��Ú Ñ ���)¡�¶Y\bÚI7Qab')#T7Q:�'>5\Ͷ07 RS7Q#?7Q-J3 7k(A'V-{GJ'>5IRS$&#A:�O/7�ºI#�+FEA-�4/#�$&:?$&:�P646+8-/%x52')-/%DGJ')%&7&\�Á-�4/#?$&%D#?7N1?1QKÚI7N3 7Q(,UJ7Q# � �����/\

 ��

Page 31: NYU Computer Science · 2015. 11. 18. · #+.4/:+.$&-\

�FºY')UJ�&�)¡Lº»')U/#m+87 5KI¶Y\b��7NBD+8:�$&#Q¢�\�ÚI#�'>RS:,#?7Q4J$&#�:A$&-´#�7N«&G6+.#?7Q(T7Q-6:�1*RS$&#A'k3 $D(T(T$&-f4/#?$&:?$&:�P646+.-/%�1�P/1�:?7Q(�Kb$)X&7Q(,UW7Q# � �&�&��\H¹@$&(T(T$&-h"�#�$&:?$&:�P646+8-/%,Ûk$D#?;&+.-/%hºI#?$&G/4�\�FºI$&#QÓ��)¡ie¬+g3�OJ')7 5�Ý/\d¹�\dº�$&# B6$&-�\ ë�¤{�iEY�NvWo&zSr&zSt�o&vJr&s×EY�Q£Q�Np tÜ|}zSt�o&v¦omn��Cp�o w&p�r&q,q,t2v6w�Â�r&v{wDy{rNwD�Q£gì0÷YvÃ�vJzSp�o>Ô&y{�>zSt2oDvJ\@�&4/#�+.-/%&7Q#?�Z²�7Q#�52')%WKVd7Qaé!�$D#?;}K � �MÓ��/\�Ðe�7Q7Q¡ ª�')(,UJ7Q#�:je�7Q7Q#?:?7Q-J1Q\H½�$&#?(A'Z5�BD+F·�7Q#?7Q-6:�+2'):�+.$&-�\/eÍ4J'V%&7IR�#�$&(§',UJ$6$&;[$&-�'>5.%&$D#�+.:?O/(,+23Q1Q\�Ðe�7Q7N�& )¡,ª�')(,UJ7Q#�: e�7Q7Q#�:?7Q-J1Q\Leb5.%&$&#m+8:�O/(,+23Q1Q\�]�$)a_'V#�B/1b4/#�$&%&#�')(*(,+.-/%�'&1Y'[(A'):?O/7Q(['):�+23Q'>5H'&3 :�+.X&+.:�P=\�Á�-B�r&z�¤6�Nq,r&zSt��Q£�rDvJÔ�òHo&qd|}y6zS�Np�º=�Nt��NvW���fìW�Cp�oN�fì@ò ÁYÃ�º}~)qd|Nì.KMb$)X&7Q(,UJ7Q# � �D�& /\�Ðe�7Q7N�f�&¡,ª�')(,UJ7Q#�:�e�7Q7Q#?:?7Q-J1�\H�&$D(T7H(T$D#?7H7 9J')(T465.7N1 $)R}'>5.%&$D#�+.:?O/(,+230B67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:�1Q\ Á�½ Á�"lÛ¦º Ð \ � Ûk$&#?;6�

+.-/%A4J')4W7Q#beYÚY"���Ó{K � �&�f�J\��"�'>+2� � ¡�¶0$&UW7Q#?:A"�'>+.%&7&\ ��oDp�q,r&s�E»t ö��Np��>vJzSt�r&zSt2oDvVì@÷��0p�o w&p�r&q º}~)vWz�¤{�Q£Qt.£�ëJ����¤{vJt�£Ny6�N\lýje�Á�¶07N1m7N')#�3�O

"�#?7N1�1QK/eI-/-he�#?UW$&#NKLe¬+23�O6+8%6')-�K � �&� � \��"�'>+2� � ¡�¶0$&UW7Q#?:»"�'Z+8%D7&\^"©#?$&%&# ')(T(,+.-/%Ta0+.:?O[+.-6XZ')#m+g'V-{:�1�\5ÃQ���k�~º}o�nQzSÕ�r&p��NK � �&� � \��"@���6Ó>¡�¶0$&UW7Q#?:�"�'>+.%&7[')-JBk½/#m+8:�À��d7Q-/%)5.7 +.-�\�e�7N3?OJ')-6+23Q'>50:?#�')-J1�5g'V:�+.$&-k$)Rb1�7Q:�:?O/7Q$D#?7Q:�+23,4/#?$&U65.7Q(µ1�4W7N3 �

+F�}3Q'):�+.$&-J1°+8-6:?$k7 Eh3�+87Q-6:h¶0e�eÿ3 $/B67�� e�3Q'&1�7l1�:?GJB6P&\N�MoDy{p vJr&sdo�nXº}~)qT¨?oDs�t��kò@o&qd|}y{zSrDzSt2o&vWK�x�/¢�i Ð �6Ó�� Ð   Ð K � �&�MÓ{\

��"i-Y� Ð ¡§¶0$&UW7Q#?:�"�'Z+8%D7�')-JBf�&OJ'>P&7�-I${7Q-6+.%J\�½�+.-6+.:?7kBD+�·�7Q#?7Q-J3�+.-/%´$)RY3 $&(T4/G/:�')U65.7�7 9M4/#?7N1�1�+.$&-J1Q\�÷,ò�BëJp�r&v/£Qr&�NzSt�o&v�£�o&v��Cp�o�wDp�r&q,q�t�v{w Â�r&v6w&y6rNw&��£»r&vWÔ¸º=~>£¥zS�>q�£QK(�/�� 6¢ iç�O� Ð �(�{Òf�JK)Ý)G65.P � �D� Ð \��"_�{�& )¡ ��\�"�'V#?:�1?3�O�')-JBl¶Y\ �&:�7 +8-6U/#��G/%&%D7Q-�\T"�#?$&%D#�')(§:?# ')-J1�RS$&#?(A'):m+8$D-�1�P/1�:?7Q(A1�\hòHo&qd|}y6zSt2v6wXº=y{p �N�>~>£¥K

� Ò6�� M¢�i � ����� Ð   � K6�&7Q4/:?7Q(,UJ7Q# � �&�D /\�F�{ÚYÚL�{� � ¡»Ý/\@�{3�O{ab')#�:?À&K�¶Y\�ÚI7Qa_'V#NKA0d\�ÚIG/U6+.-J1�;6P&KC')-JB�0b\©�{3?O/$D-{UW7Q#?%J\¯�Cp�o�wDp�rDq�q,t�v{wlÕ�t�z�¤�º}�>z�£�ä*÷YvÃ�vJzSp�o>Ô&y{�>zSt2oDv�zSo ºL�|ë*Â�\��&4/#�+.-/%&7Q#?�Z²�7Q#m5g'V%JK � �&� � \�F�&:?$�Ó&ÓN¡§Ý)${1�7Q4/O�0b\��&:�$ZP&\ EY�NvJoDzSr&zSt2oDvJr&s�º}�Nq,r&vWzSt2��£�äaë�¤{�Yº}� o&zSz�Ö�º}zSp�r&�Q¤6�N~T÷_|&|}p�oNr&��¤kzSo��0p�o�w&p�r&q,q,t�v{wÂ�r&v{wDy{rNwD�Cë�¤{� o&p�~)\�]0O/71e�Á�]¦"�#�7N1?1QKW¹C')(,U/#�+2B6%&7&KLel'&1�1?'&3�O{GJ1�7Q:�:�1QK � �6Ó&Ó6\�ÜÛ¦Ý6�{�6Ó>¡�¶Y\/Ý/\/Û�'):�#?$JK{Ú,\7ex\/Ý)$&O/-J1�$D-�KM'V-JBh¶Y\Lex\W�&(A')U6P&\^]�#�')-J1�R�$&#�(A'):�+.$&-J'>5=4/#?$&%&# ')(§B67QX&7 5.$&4/(T7Q-6:Ni

e�-�7 9�'V(,+.-J'):�+.$&-h$)R�:?O/7 e�G/-6+23?Ox¹HÁ�"�')4/4/#?$6'&3?O�\�]0O/71e�Á�]b¶�0عH$&#?4W$&#�'):m+8$D-�K`el')# 3?O � �D�6Ó{\

  �