numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...welcome to the 8th european...

46
Welcome to the 8 th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures Stefano Morlacchi Politecnico di Milano

Upload: others

Post on 22-May-2021

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Welcome to the 8th

European Bifurcation Club

12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona

Numerical models

of single- and double-

stenting procedures

Stefano Morlacchi

Politecnico di Milano

Page 2: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Stenting procedures in bifurcations

Page 3: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Stenting procedures in bifurcations

Lower clinical

outcomes

Technical

complexities

CBL are still an

open challenge

Improvement of the current state-of-the-art

Page 4: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Numerical methods

Numerical

methods

Advantages:

- Assessment of biomechanical quantities: arterial stress,

wall shear stress, deformations.

- Comparative evaluation of different techniques.

- Optimization of the current devices and design of new

concepts.

Page 5: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Numerical methods

Clinical

studies

In vitro

experiments

Numerical

methods

Advantages:

- Assessment of biomechanical quantities: arterial stress,

wall shear stress, deformations.

- Comparative evaluation of different techniques.

- Optimization of the current devices and design of new

concepts.

Page 6: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Numerical methods

Clinical

studies

In vitro

experiments

Numerical

methods

Advantages:

- Assessment of biomechanical quantities: arterial stress,

wall shear stress, deformations.

- Comparative evaluation of different techniques.

- Optimization of the current devices and design of new

concepts.

Page 7: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Aim of this work

Virtual simulation of

stenting procedures in

coronary bifurcations.

Page 8: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Aim of this work

Virtual simulation of

stenting procedures in

coronary bifurcations.

Fluid dynamics

model of the

hemodynamic field.

Page 9: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Structural simulations

Morlacchi et al. “Sequential structural and fluid dynamic numerical

simulations of a stented bifurcated coronary artery”

Journal of Biomechanical Engineering 133(12):121010.

Page 10: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Structural simulations

Page 11: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Fluid dynamic simulations

Chiastra C et al. “Computational fluid dynamics of stented coronary bifurcations

studied with a hybrid discretization method”

European Journal of Mechanics - B/Fluids. 2012; 35:76–84.

INLET

OUTLET SB

30%

OUTLET MB

70 %

Flow rate

85 ml/min

Page 12: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Fluid dynamic simulations

Chiastra C et al. “Computational fluid dynamics

of stented coronary bifurcations studied with a

hybrid discretization method”

European Journal of Mechanics - B/Fluids. 2012;

35:76–84.

INLET

OUTLET SB

30%

OUTLET MB

70 %

Volume flow rate

85 ml/min

Page 13: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Stenting procedures in bifurcations

Provisional SB stenting

0 0.115 0.23

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

Page 14: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Stenting procedures in bifurcations

Culotte technique Provisional SB stenting

0 0.115 0.23

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

0 0.115 0.23

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

Page 15: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Stenting procedures in bifurcations

Simultaneous Kissing Stents

0 0.115 0.23

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

Page 16: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Stenting procedures in bifurcations

Crush technique Simultaneous Kissing Stents

0 0.115 0.23

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

0 0.115 0.23

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

Page 17: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Stenting procedures in bifurcations

T-stenting

0 0.115 0.23

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

Page 18: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Stenting procedures in bifurcations

T-stenting with

protrusion

T-stenting

0 0.115 0.23

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

0 0.115 0.23

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

Page 19: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Stresses in the devices Bulk-flow quantities

Near wall quantities

PSB CULOTTE Low WSS Area

STRUT

MALAPPOSITIONS

0.95

0.83

Arterial stresses and stent

configurations

Biomechanical quantities

Page 20: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Stresses in the devices Bulk-flow quantities

Near wall quantities

PSB CULOTTE Low WSS Area

STRUT

MALAPPOSITIONS

0.95

0.83

Arterial stresses and stent

configurations

Biomechanical quantities

Page 21: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Stresses in the devices Bulk-flow quantities

Near wall quantities

PSB CULOTTE Low WSS Area

STRUT

MALAPPOSITIONS

0.95

0.83

Arterial stresses and stent

configurations

Biomechanical quantities

Page 22: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Stresses in the devices Bulk-flow quantities

Near wall quantities

PSB CULOTTE Low WSS Area

STRUT

MALAPPOSITIONS

0.95

0.83

Arterial stresses and stent

configurations

Biomechanical quantities

Page 23: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Some examples

Strut malappositions in the SKS tecnhique.

Single- and double- stenting techniques.

Influence of procedural errors: stent protrusion in

the MB within the T-stenting technique.

Page 24: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Some examples

Strut malappositions in the SKS tecnhique.

Single- and double- stenting techniques.

Influence of procedural errors: stent protrusion in

the MB within the T-stenting technique.

Page 25: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Single- and double- procedures

PSB CULOTTE CRUSH

Page 26: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Single- and double- procedures

PSB CULOTTE CRUSH

Page 27: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Single- and double- procedures

PSB CULOTTE CRUSH

Page 28: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Single- and double- procedures

PSB CULOTTE CRUSH

0 0.23

Velocity [m/s]

Low velocities Low velocities

Page 29: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Single- and double- procedures

0 0.5

WSS [Pa]

PSB CULOTTE CRUSH

0 0.23

Velocity [m/s]

Low WSS Area Low WSS Area

Low velocities Low velocities

Page 30: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Some examples

Strut malappositions in the SKS tecnhique.

Single- and double- stenting techniques.

Influence of procedural errors: stent protrusion in

the MB within the T-stenting technique.

Page 31: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Effects of stent protrusion

T-stenting

with protrusion

T-stenting

Page 32: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Effects of stent protrusion

T-stenting

with protrusion

T-stenting

-0.05 0 0.05

Viscous shear stress [Pa]

Page 33: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Some examples

Strut malappositions in the SKS tecnhique.

Influence of procedural errors: stent protrusion in

the MB within the T-stenting technique.

Single- and double- stenting techniques.

Page 34: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Effects of strut malappositions C

UL

OT

TE

S

KS

0 0.125 0.25

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

0 0.125 0.25

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

LOW FLOW REGION

LOW FLOW REGION

Page 35: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Effects of strut malappositions C

UL

OT

TE

S

KS

0 0.125 0.25

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

0 0.125 0.25

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

NO STRUTS

NO STRUTS

Page 36: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Effects of strut malappositions

0 120 240

Max principal stress [kPa]

CU

LO

TT

E

SK

S

0 0.125 0.25

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

0 0.125 0.25

Velocity magnitude [m/s]

HIGH STRESS – ?NO DRUG?

Page 37: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Conclusions

Implementation of a sequential virtual model of

different stenting procedures for coronary

bifurcation lesions.

Application of the sequential model to assess both

structural and hemodynamic variables.

Comparisons among different single- or double-

stenting techniques.

Page 38: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Conclusions

Implementation of a sequential virtual model of

different stenting procedures for coronary

bifurcation lesions.

Application of the sequential model to assess both

structural and hemodynamic variables.

Comparisons among different single- or double-

stenting techniques.

Page 39: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Conclusions

Implementation of a sequential virtual model of

different stenting procedures for coronary

bifurcation lesions.

Application of the sequential model to assess both

structural and hemodynamic variables.

Comparisons among different single- or double-

stenting techniques.

Page 40: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Further developments

Image-based simulations of clinical cases.

In collaboration with Universitat Pomepeu Fabra, Barcelona.

CTA + CCA

3D model

Page 41: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Further developments

Validation of fluid dynamic fields with in-vitro tests.

In collaboration with Dr. Francesco Burzotta, Roma

and Prof. Vlachos, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, USA.

PIV Imaging Bench test Flow measurement

Page 42: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Further developments

Drug elution numerical models.

In collaboration with prof. Paolo Zunino, University of Pittsburgh,

and Elena Cutrì, Mox, Politecnico di Milano.

EBC presentation by Prof. Gabriele Dubini.

Page 43: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Acknowledgements

Politecnico di Milano

Prof. Francesco Migliavacca

Prof. Gabriele Dubini

Dr. Elena Cutrì

Ing. Claudio Chiastra

Ing. Sebastian Colleoni

University of Pittsburgh

Prof. Paolo Zunino

Page 44: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

THANK YOU FOR THE ATTENTION

Page 45: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Validation of structural results

COMPARISON WITH IN VITRO EXPANSION BY ORMISTON ET AL.

Page 46: Numerical models of single- and double- stenting procedures...Welcome to the 8th European Bifurcation Club 12-13 October 2012 - Barcelona Numerical models of single- and double-stenting

Validation of structural results

COMPARISON WITH IN VITRO EXPANSION BY SCHULTZ ET AL. 2009

In vitro

expansion Virtual

simulation